Hubbry Logo
Scott CarneyScott CarneyMain
Open search
Scott Carney
Community hub
Scott Carney
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Scott Carney
Scott Carney
Scott Carney
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Scott Carney (born July 9, 1978) is an American investigative journalist, author and anthropologist. He is the author of five books: The Red Market, The Enlightenment Trap, What Doesn't Kill Us, The Wedge, and The Vortex. Carney contributes stories on a variety of medical, technological and ethical issues to Wired, Mother Jones, Playboy, Foreign Policy, Men's Journal, and National Public Radio.[1][2][3][4][5]

Key Information

Carney was the first American journalist to write about "Iceman" Wim Hof in a 2014 article in Playboy.[6] The book that came out of that research, What Doesn't Kill Us, spent two months on the New York Times bestseller list in 2017.[7] His 2020 book, The Wedge, explores the core concepts of the Wim Hof Method and applies them to a wide array of physical training.[8]

He reported from Chennai, India, between 2006 and 2009. In 2015 he founded the Denver-based media company Foxtopus Ink, which produces audio books, video courses and podcasts. In 2018 Foxtopus Ink released the first season of the podcast Wild Thing on the search for bigfoot.[9]

Carney holds a number of academic and professional appointments including as a contributing editor at Wired, a senior fellow at the Schuster Institute for Investigative Journalism at Brandeis University, and as a judge for the Payne Award for Ethics in Journalism.[10] He graduated from Kenyon College in 2000 and dropped out of a Ph.D. in anthropology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison in order to pursue journalism.

Works

[edit]

The Red Market

[edit]

Carney coined the phrase "the red market" to describe a broad category of economic transactions around the human body. Drawing on the concepts black markets, white markets and gray markets he suggests that commerce in body parts is separate because bodies are not commodities in a strict sense. Instead, commerce in human bodies needs to account for the ineffable quality of life and creates a lifelong debt between the provider and receiver of the flesh. Straight commerce in human bodies disguises the supply chain and reduces a human life to its meat value. Carney calls for "radical transparency" in the red market supply chain in order to protect its humanness.

The book, The Red Market traces the rise, fall, and resurgence of this multibillion-dollar underground organ trade through history, from early medical study and modern universities to poverty-ravaged Eurasian villages and high-tech Western labs; from body snatchers and surrogate mothers to skeleton dealers and the poor who sell body parts to survive. While local and international law enforcement have cracked down on the market, advances in science have increased the demand for human tissue—ligaments, kidneys, even rented space in women's wombs—leaving little room to consider the ethical dilemmas inherent in the flesh-and-blood trade.[11]

The Enlightenment Trap

[edit]

The Enlightenment Trap examines the unusual circumstances around the death of Ian Thorson while on a meditation retreat in the mountains of Arizona. The book uses Thorson's story as a springboard to understanding the path that Tibetan Buddhism took to get to the United States and analyzes the often conflicted relationship that Americans have with the concept of enlightenment.[12] Carney recounts the story of the death of his former student Emily O'Conner who took her life on a meditation retreat in India in 2006.[13] Thorson was a follower of the controversial Buddhist guru Michael Roach who teaches a version of Buddhism that closely aligns with the Christian Gospel of Prosperity.[14] Carney's book is based in part on his article in Playboy, "Death and Madness on Diamond Mountain".[15] The book was originally published under the title A Death on Diamond Mountain and was re-released in 2016 under a new title.[16][17]

What Doesn't Kill Us

[edit]

In 2011 Carney travelled to meet Dutch fitness guru Wim Hof in Poland on an assignment from Playboy with the intention of exposing him as a charlatan.[18] Hof claimed to be able to teach a meditation technique that would allow people to consciously control their body temperature and immune systems.[19] The claims were similar to those made by Michael Roach.[20] After a week studying the method, however, Carney "had to reevaluate everything he thought about gurus".[21] Within a week he learned how to perform similar feats as Hof, including hiking up a snow covered mountain wearing just a bathing suit. His book, What Doesn't Kill Us, continues the journey by linking evolutionary theory and environmental conditioning with the Wim Hof Method. He interviews US Army scientists who are trying to find ways to make soldiers more effective in extreme environments, the founders of the outdoor workout movement the November Project, legendary surfer Laird Hamilton and endurance runner Brian MacKenzie. Carney ends his journey by climbing up to the top of Mount Kilimanjaro, most of the way, wearing just a bathing suit.

Carney has since revised his position on Wim Hof after discovering 19 deaths-by-drowning related to people practicing the Wim Hof Method in water and passing out from shallow-water blackout.[22] Carney attributes the deaths to people following Wim Hof's instructions on various official training courses and YouTube videos that depict Hof hyperventilating in water in apparent contradiction to Hof's own official warnings. The Dutch newspaper de Volkskrant independently verified his claims.[23][24]

The Wedge

[edit]

"The most comfortable way to think about the Wedge is that it's a choice to separate stimulus from response",[25] by which Carney means using the conscious action of the mind to interrupt the automatic physical reactions of the body. Carney suggests that all living things use the wedge to navigate the hard problem of consciousness through sensation. Every sensation offers an opportunity for choice, and thus choice is the fundamental unit of consciousness. Carney draws on the work of neuroscientist Andrew Huberman at Stanford to explain how fear and anxiety offer opportunities to use the Wedge and proceeds to put his own body under various sorts of environmental stresses—saunas, throwing kettlebells, MDMA therapy, flotation tanks, breathwork and ayahuasca—to test the concept for himself.[25] The book received favorable coverage on Here and Now, Men's Journal, Kirkus and Outside.[8][26][27][28]

The Vortex

[edit]

In 1970 the Great Bhola Cyclone killed 500,000 people in East Pakistan and set off a series of cataclysmic events that almost culminated in nuclear war between the United States and USSR. Scott Carney and Jason Miklian tell the story of The Vortex through the eyes of cyclone survivors, two genocidal presidents (Richard Nixon and Yahya Khan), a soccer star turned soldier and mutineer Hafiz Uddin Ahmad, and American aid worker and a weatherman from Miami who tried to avert disaster. The Vortex received largely favorable reviews in The Washington Post and NPR for linking the effects of climate change to armed conflict.[29][30] The Vortex was included on the long-list of finalists for the 2023 Carnegie Medal for excellence in nonfiction.[31]

Awards

[edit]

Carney won the 2010 Payne Award for Ethics in Journalism for his story "Meet the Parents".[32] In 2008, he was selected as a finalist for the Livingston Award for International Journalism for an article titled "The Bone Factory".[33] He was also a finalist for the same award in 2010 for this story "Cash on Delivery" about surrogate pregnancies in India.[34] He has been nominated for the Daniel Pearl Award from the South Asian Journalists Association three times. The Red Market won the 2012 Clarion Award for best non-fiction book. The Vortex was included on the long-list of finalists for the 2023 Carnegie Medal for excellence in nonfiction.[31]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Scott Carney

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Scott Carney is an American investigative journalist and anthropologist whose work combines narrative non-fiction with ethnographic methods to uncover hidden aspects of human exploitation, physiological adaptation, and the risks of unverified wellness practices. Based in Denver, Colorado, he has contributed to outlets such as Wired, where he served as a contributing editor, and published in Mother Jones, Playboy, and Foreign Policy. Carney holds a master's degree in anthropology from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and has conducted extensive fieldwork in South Asia, where he speaks Hindi. His investigative reporting earned the 2010 Payne Award for in for "," which exposed an international kidnapping-to-adoption ring. Carney's books include The Red Market, detailing the global trade in human organs, tissues, and children; What Doesn't Kill Us, a New York Times bestseller exploring evolutionary adaptations to extreme cold through Dutch athlete 's methods; and The Enlightenment Trap, which investigates deaths and psychological harms linked to intensive retreats. Other works, such as The Wedge on human choice in physiological control and The Vortex on the 1970 Bhola Cyclone's geopolitical aftermath, highlight his range from to historical disasters. Carney has critiqued overhyped health trends, including later revelations on dangers in the empire, such as participant deaths and legal actions, reflecting his commitment to empirical scrutiny over promotional narratives.

Early life and education

Childhood and formative influences

Scott Carney was born on July 9, 1978, in . Public details about his family background and specific childhood experiences remain limited, with Carney himself providing scant self-reported accounts beyond a general emphasis on personal drive toward exploration. Carney has described an enduring interest in leading an adventurous life from an early age, which drew him toward as a field promising opportunities for immersive experiences and discovery. This curiosity about and adaptability, rather than structured ideological frameworks, shaped his formative perspective, prompting him to seek paths that allowed direct engagement with real-world phenomena over abstract theorizing. These early inclinations toward empirical into human limits and societal dynamics foreshadowed his shift from potential academic pursuits to fieldwork-driven reporting, prioritizing firsthand of systemic issues like exploitation and resilience over conventional narratives.

Academic background

Carney graduated from in 2000 with a . He subsequently enrolled in the anthropology program at the of Wisconsin-Madison, earning a in in 2005. His graduate coursework included training in ethnographic methods, which emphasize and immersive fieldwork to gather empirical data on social practices and cultural systems. Carney advanced to doctoral studies in at the same institution but discontinued the Ph.D. program prior to completing his dissertation, opting instead for a career in . This academic foundation in anthropology provided tools for rigorous, on-the-ground investigation, prioritizing direct evidence over abstracted theories and enabling analysis of human behaviors in unregulated or marginal environments through systematic observation and narrative documentation. Such methods foster causal insights derived from verifiable patterns, as opposed to ideologically filtered interpretations, by focusing on observable incentives and structural constraints shaping individual actions.

Journalistic career

Early reporting in India

Carney relocated to , , in 2006, where he began freelance investigative reporting on the country's underground markets in human tissues and adoption networks. As a contributor to Wired and other outlets, his early fieldwork focused on direct of illicit supply chains driven by global demand, often obscured by legal prohibitions and institutional narratives portraying transactions as consensual or regulated. In , Carney exposed India's bone trade, tracing how rural grave robbers exhumed corpses from villages in and supplied skeletons to schools worldwide, including in the United States and , for as little as $300 per full set despite international bans on such exports. His reporting highlighted causal dynamics where poverty in remote areas met demand from anatomy labs unwilling to source ethically, with smugglers exploiting lax enforcement of India's Anatomy Act to ship an estimated thousands of skeletons annually. Similarly, in a series on kidney trafficking, Carney documented how impoverished donors in Tamil Nadu villages sold organs for $1,000–$2,000 to brokers catering to wealthy recipients in and elsewhere, revealing how anti-trafficking laws inadvertently drove the market underground while failing to address economic desperation as the root supply factor. Carney's 2009 Mother Jones investigation "Meet the Parents" detailed adoption scandals, centering on the 1999 kidnapping of a boy named Subash from Chennai's slum, who was sold for 10,000 rupees to the Malaysian orphanage before international placement, potentially in the U.S. Midwest. The piece uncovered networks involving corrupt s that facilitated at least 165 s from 1991 to 2003, generating $250,000 in fees while falsifying documents to meet Western demand, where adoptive parents paid up to $14,000 per child amid a global shortage of infants. On-the-ground interviews with biological parents, traffickers, and orphanage officials debunked claims of voluntary relinquishment, demonstrating how profit incentives—unmitigated by ineffective oversight under India's laws or the Convention—sustained child abductions from slums to supply foreign agencies. This reporting earned Carney the 2010 Payne Award for Ethics in Journalism, recognizing his personal involvement in reuniting families and persistent pursuit of hundreds of cases despite resistance from adoption intermediaries.

Key investigations into human exploitation

Carney's investigations into the global trade in human organs revealed a clandestine network operating in countries like and , where prohibitions on compensated channeled demand into black markets rife with and . In undercover reporting, he documented brokers arranging kidney sales for as little as $1,000 to desperate sellers, often poor laborers transported across borders to undergo in unregulated clinics, with recipients paying up to $100,000 through intermediaries. These exposés highlighted how legal bans, intended to prevent exploitation, instead empowered criminal elements to control supply chains, resulting in higher risks of infection and death for donors without improving access for patients. His probe into India's bone trade, detailed in a 2008 Wired article, exposed factories in processing smuggled human skeletons for , sourcing remains from rural grave robbers who exhumed bodies for $3–$5 each amid a shortage of legal cadavers. Carney traced the supply from grieving families in remote villages to exporters shipping thousands of skeletons annually to U.S. and European universities, underscoring institutional complicity as buyers overlooked origins to meet demand. This underground persisted due to export bans and ethical restrictions on , fostering a market where incentivized over consensual alternatives. Investigations into blood and plasma collection uncovered "blood farms" in rural , where middlemen paid villagers pennies per liter—often under duress or —before reselling to pharmaceutical firms at markups exceeding 1,000%. Carney's fieldwork revealed donors suffering repeated extractions leading to , with bans on paid donation driving operations into hidden camps rather than regulated centers, amplifying health risks without curbing . In parallel reporting on child trafficking, Carney's 2009 Mother Jones piece examined overseas adoption fraud in , detailing a case where a was allegedly kidnapped from his parents in and rerouted through falsified documents to a U.S. family for $20,000 in fees. Through ethnographic immersion, he mapped causal links from —where staff fabricated relinquishment papers amid poverty-driven abandonments—to international agencies profiting from quotas, arguing that Hague Convention loopholes and domestic bans on private adoptions perpetuated illicit pipelines over transparent . Similar patterns emerged in his scrutiny of surrogacy commodification, as in a 2010 exposé on clinics implanting up to five embryos in low-income women for $5,000–$7,000 payouts, with mandatory C-sections and confinement exacerbating exploitation under India's permissive regulations that lured foreign clients while local bans on surrogacy elsewhere funneled women into unregulated hubs. These works critiqued hospitals and NGOs for covert profiteering, yet emphasized individual agency in poverty-fueled participation, advocating empirical scrutiny over ideological prohibitions that distort markets into coercive shadows.

Coverage of extreme physiology and pseudoscience

In 2014, Carney published "The Iceman Cometh" in Playboy, marking him as the first U.S. to profile Dutch extreme athlete , known for feats like climbing without thermal clothing and enduring extreme cold through breathwork and mindset techniques. Initially approaching the story with toward Hof's claims of voluntary control over the , Carney trained under Hof in , experiencing elevated body temperature and reduced inflammation during controlled experiments, which aligned with a 2014 Dutch clinical trial demonstrating Hof's method could modulate immune responses via hyperventilation-induced . However, Carney's reporting highlighted biological limits, noting that while acute stressors like cold exposure might trigger adaptive responses, Hof's promotion risked ignoring dangers and lacked robust long-term evidence beyond small-scale studies. Carney's work expanded to probe hormesis—the principle that sublethal doses of environmental stressors, such as cold, heat, or hypoxia, can induce cellular adaptations conferring resilience, rooted in evolutionary biology where ancestral humans faced variable climates. In investigations, he tested these claims empirically, documenting personal physiological shifts like improved vascular function from repeated cold plunges, but cautioned against pseudoscientific overreach in the wellness sector, where unregulated protocols often prioritize anecdotal testimonials over randomized controlled trials. For instance, Carney scrutinized breathwork's purported suppression of inflammation, affirming short-term epinephrine surges but emphasizing risks of hyperoxia-induced oxidative stress or drownings in unsupervised water-based sessions, as evidenced by multiple fatalities linked to extreme variants. By 2023–2024, Carney turned to dissecting influencers, critiquing neuroscientist for promoting unverified interventions like blue-light-blocking glasses tied to sponsorships, arguing such claims veer into by conflating preliminary rodent data with human outcomes absent large-scale validation. Similarly, in analyzing physician Peter Attia's advocacy for tracking devices and anti-aging regimens, Carney highlighted conflicts of interest, such as Attia's 2023 against Oura Ring alleging $1.3 million in unpaid equity for promotional work, underscoring how charisma and affiliate revenue often eclipse empirical scrutiny of metrics like for prediction. Carney advocated prioritizing causal mechanisms—verifiable dose-response curves from stressors—over hype, warning that the biohacking industry's $4.5 billion valuation in 2023 fuels narratives detached from physiological realism.

Literary works

The Red Market (2011)

The Red Market: On the Trail of the World's Organ Brokers, Bone Thieves, Blood Farmers, and Child Traffickers, published in June 2011 by William Morrow, examines the global illicit trade in human bodies, organs, tissues, and reproductive services, which Carney terms the "red market." Drawing from three years of fieldwork, the book contends that international bans on compensated —such as those enforced under the 1980s-era National Organ Transplant Act in the U.S. and similar global prohibitions—artificially suppress supply amid rising demand from aging populations and medical advances, thereby spawning predatory black markets valued in billions of dollars annually. Carney argues that these restrictions, intended to prevent exploitation, instead incentivize , , and by driving transactions underground, where vulnerable populations bear the costs without regulatory protections. Carney's narrative traces ethnographic investigations across , , the , and other regions, documenting brokers facilitating kidney sales from impoverished donors in Indian villages like those in , where sellers received as little as $1,000 while intermediaries profited far more; bone thieves desecrating graves in India for skeletal remains exported to U.S. medical schools; and "blood farms" in extracting plasma from paid donors under hazardous conditions. He exposes child trafficking networks blending illegal adoptions with organ harvesting risks, and operations in India treating women as commodified vessels for wealthy clients, often leading to health complications for donors and ethical violations. These accounts, grounded in direct interviews and site visits, illustrate a shadow economy where human parts fetch prices like $160,000 for a full-body breakdown into transplantable components, far exceeding legal donation values. The book critiques guidelines and national policies for prioritizing ethical absolutism over pragmatic demand management, citing evidence that bans correlate with higher coercion rates—such as post-1990s Indian cases where donors faced after sales—without reducing overall trade volumes, estimated to supply 10% of global transplants illicitly. Carney advocates reconsidering prohibitions through regulated compensation models to align incentives with and safety, positing that legal markets could diminish exploitation by formalizing supply chains. While praised for illuminating causal distortions in , the work faced accusations of in its vivid portrayals, though these are countered by the verifiability of cases via Carney's on-the-ground sourcing and alignment with independent reports on donor in regulated versus banned systems. The publication heightened public discourse on organ shortages, influencing policy debates toward harm-reduction approaches over outright bans.

The Enlightenment Trap (2013)

In his 2013 book, Carney investigates the fatal consequences of extreme spiritual pursuits within a Western adaptation of , centering on the 2012 death of Ian Thorson during a retreat at Diamond Mountain University in . Thorson, a 38-year-old devotee, succumbed to and after being expelled from a three-year silent retreat for rule violations, retreating to an isolated cave where his body was later found emaciated and mummified. The retreat was led by Geshe Michael Roach, an American-born teacher who blended traditional Gelugpa practices with entrepreneurial self-improvement techniques, charging participants fees for courses promising accelerated enlightenment through isolation, tantric visualization, and vow-bound austerities. Carney traces the causal chain from Roach's hype—rooted in unorthodox interpretations like karmic business success and secret tantric partnerships—to profit-oriented excesses that disregarded physiological limits. reports confirmed Thorson's death resulted from untreated and exposure, not transcendent attainment, while survivor testimonies detailed hallucinations, psychoses, and a prior incident linked to meditation-induced breakdowns among followers. Neurological evidence cited by Carney highlights how prolonged intensive can disrupt brain function, inducing or dissociation, underscoring pseudoscientific overreach in commodified enlightenment schemes. This parallels cases like Ray's 2009 Sedona sweat lodge, where three participants died from during a paid ritual adapting Native American traditions, with Ray convicted of for ignoring medical distress in pursuit of "spiritual warrior" breakthroughs. The work critiques the "enlightenment trap," where seekers, lured by gurus' authority and promises of rapid nirvana, prioritize mystical narratives over empirical realities like hydration needs or risks, fostering environments of unchecked excess. Carney employs first-hand documents from Thorson, ex-acolyte interviews revealing sexualized rituals and claims, and Roach's own writings to demonstrate how Diamond Mountain evolved into a for-profit entity—generating revenue via retreats and online courses—diverging from Himalayan roots into a hazardous American hybrid. No criminal liability ensued for Roach or associate Christie McNally, despite their roles in directing Thorson to the cave, exposing regulatory voids in the spiritual industry where participant waivers shield leaders from accountability for foreseeable harms. Reception praised Carney for illuminating guru-led causal failures over cultural excuses, with empirical data countering relativist defenses that frame deaths as voluntary or traditional. Critics, including some , argued the book overemphasizes Western distortions while downplaying safe orthodox practices, yet death tolls from Roach's programs—including Thorson's and reported psychoses—affirm the need for of adaptations amplifying dangers for profit. The analysis prioritizes verifiable physiology and accountability, revealing how untested extremes, hyped for enrollment, precipitate tragedy absent rigorous oversight.

What Doesn't Kill Us (2017)

What Doesn't Kill Us examines how controlled exposure to environmental stressors such as extreme cold and high altitude can enhance human physiological resilience by reactivating dormant adaptive mechanisms evolved over millennia. Published in January 2017 by Rodale Books, the work draws on Carney's initial skepticism toward Dutch extreme athlete Wim Hof's methods, which combine breathing, mindset focus, and cold immersion to purportedly influence autonomic responses. Carney, who began investigating Hof in 2011 to expose , underwent intensive training—including ice baths in subzero conditions and ascents to altitudes exceeding 5,000 meters in the —ultimately documenting measurable physiological changes in himself, such as improved cold tolerance and reduced inflammation markers. Central to the book is the principle of , where sub-lethal doses of stress—unlike overwhelming extremes that cause harm—trigger adaptive responses that fortify the body against future challenges. Carney details laboratory evidence, including studies showing exposure activates (), a metabolically active fat type that generates heat through uncoupled respiration, thereby burning calories from white fat stores and improving metabolic efficiency. For instance, he references research demonstrating BAT recruitment in adults via repeated stimuli, correlating with elevated norepinephrine levels and enhanced vascular function, rather than relying solely on Hof's anecdotal feats like Everest in shorts. This approach debunks claims of miraculous invincibility, emphasizing instead incremental, evidence-based conditioning grounded in , such as Neanderthal adaptations to via BAT proliferation. The narrative interweaves Carney's personal trials—enduring -30°C plunges and hypoxia simulations—with scientific validation from fields like , highlighting how modern comforts have atrophied these capacities, leading to vulnerabilities like metabolic disorders. Achieving New York Times bestseller status, the book was lauded for its empirical rigor and accessible fusion of firsthand experimentation with peer-reviewed data, as in NPR's assessment of its practical insights into body-environment interactions. Critics, however, noted Carney's arc from debunker to proponent risked overstating Hof's techniques without fully addressing risks like hyperventilation-induced blackouts, though the text cautions against unsupervised extremes and prioritizes lab-corroborated benefits over hype.

The Wedge (2022)

The Wedge: Evolution, Consciousness, Stress, and the Key to Human Resilience is a 2020 book by Scott Carney, self-published through his imprint Foxtopus Ink, in which he proposes that humans can exert voluntary control over involuntary physiological processes by exploiting a conceptual "wedge" between external stimuli and automatic biological responses. Carney, drawing on his background in and , argues that this intervention allows individuals to reprogram stress responses, enhancing resilience beyond what genetic provides alone. The core idea posits that modern comforts have insulated people from adaptive stresses, leading to heightened vulnerability to anxiety, autoimmune disorders, and environmental shocks, which can be countered through deliberate disruptions to . The "" refers specifically to the momentary gap where conscious awareness can interrupt autonomic reactions, such as those governed by the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems, enabling techniques like controlled to alter blood pH and sensitivity, thereby reducing neurotic responses to perceived threats. Carney substantiates this with physiological evidence, noting how practices that induce acute stress—such as ice baths or breathwork—can recalibrate the body's set points for tolerance, as demonstrated in experiments where participants voluntarily influenced markers previously thought uncontrollable. He contrasts this with evolutionary baselines, asserting that while favors incremental genetic changes over generations, the wedge permits rapid phenotypic adaptation within lifetimes, effectively accelerating human capability without relying on pharmaceuticals or unproven supplements. Carney illustrates the thesis through personal and observed case studies, including his use of cold immersion to resolve chronic inflammation and autoimmune symptoms, and collaborations with figures like ultrarunner , who applied wedge techniques to endure extreme endurance events like the World's Toughest Mudder. Other examples encompass global ethnographic explorations, such as Latvian sauna rituals for heat acclimation and Amazonian ceremonies for sensory rewiring, which he frames as culturally validated methods to access flow states and override fear-based defaults. These practices, Carney contends, foster a causal chain from individual agency to broader societal robustness, emphasizing empirical self-experimentation over institutionalized interventions. While acknowledging risks like overexertion, he prioritizes data from controlled trials showing measurable gains in endurance and mental acuity, critiquing over-reliance on comfort-driven lifestyles as a deviation from humanity's adaptive heritage.

The Vortex (2023)

is a 2022 book co-authored by Scott Carney and Jason Miklian, published by Ecco, an imprint of . The narrative centers on the Great Bhola Cyclone of November 12–13, 1970, which struck (present-day ) and remains the deadliest on record, with death toll estimates ranging from 300,000 to 500,000. The book details how the cyclone's devastation exposed deep fissures in Pakistan's bifurcated state, amplifying ethnic and political tensions between East and West Pakistan. The Pakistani government's delayed and inadequate response under President —characterized by minimal relief efforts and poor communication—inflamed Bengali grievances, eroding central authority. This failure contributed to the Awami League's landslide victory in the December 1970 general elections, where secured a majority but was denied power transfer, sparking protests and civil disobedience. Carney and Miklian chronicle the ensuing 1971 , initiated by on March 25, 1971, a brutal military crackdown by West Pakistani forces that resulted in widespread atrocities against Bengali civilians, intellectuals, and , often described as with hundreds of thousands killed. The conflict displaced 10 million refugees into , prompting Indian military intervention in December 1971, which decisively defeated Pakistani forces and led to Bangladesh's independence on December 16, 1971. The authors weave in Cold War geopolitics, highlighting U.S. President and Henry Kissinger's support for to counter and court , including the dispatch of the USS Enterprise task force, while the backed , bringing superpowers perilously close to nuclear confrontation. Narrated through perspectives of figures like survivors Mohammed Hai and Hafiz Uddin Ahmad, missionaries Jon and Candy Rhode, and leaders and , the book employs exhaustive research to depict cycles of corruption, resilience, and human agency amid natural and man-made disasters. Critics praised The Vortex for its riveting, multi-perspective storytelling and relevance to contemporary climate vulnerabilities, noting how the cyclone's intensity—fueled by warm Bay of Bengal waters—foreshadows amplified storm risks under global warming. The work underscores empirical causal chains from environmental catastrophe to societal upheaval, avoiding unsubstantiated conspiracy while grounding claims in archival and eyewitness accounts, though some reviewers observed the narrative's intensity peaks early in the storm's depiction before broadening to war. Carney's journalistic approach links this historical vortex to broader patterns of policy failures exacerbating chaos, echoing his prior explorations of human limits in extreme conditions.

Awards and recognition

Journalism awards

In 2010, Scott Carney was awarded the Ancil Payne Award for Ethics in by the School of and Communication for his article "Meet the Parents: The Dark Side of Overseas ," published in March 2009. The piece detailed the abduction of a child in and his subsequent placement in a U.S. adoption, revealing systemic failures and illicit networks in international practices that prioritized demand over verifiable origins. This recognition underscored Carney's commitment to ethical reporting amid moral complexities, including navigating complicit officials and adoptive families while prioritizing evidence of exploitation. Carney has also been a multiple finalist for the Livingston Awards for International Reporting, which honor investigative work by journalists under 35, reflecting acclaim for his fieldwork in high-risk environments such as organ trafficking routes and unregulated medical practices in . These accolades affirm the rigor of his on-the-ground investigations, which often challenge institutional narratives around global human exploitation by relying on direct sourcing and causal tracing of illicit supply chains. What Doesn't Kill Us attained New York Times bestseller status upon its 2017 release, signaling widespread reader interest in Carney's analysis of human physiological adaptation and its implications for debunking unsubstantiated extreme wellness methodologies. The Red Market received the 2012 Clarion Award for best book, honoring its rigorous documentation of illicit markets in human organs, tissues, and services. These distinctions highlight Carney's influence in scrutinizing exploitative bio-markets and pseudoscientific trends through evidence-based narrative nonfiction, though no major literary prizes have been documented for his subsequent works such as The Wedge or The Vortex.

Reception and influence

Impact on bioethics and markets

Carney's investigative work in The Red Market (2011) illuminated the causal mechanisms underlying illicit body economies, demonstrating how global prohibitions on compensated organ donation create persistent shortages that incentivize trafficking. In India, for instance, following the 1994 Transplantation of Human Organs Act banning paid sales, underground networks proliferated, transforming slums into "organ farms" where impoverished donors underwent unregulated procedures, often resulting in severe health complications and coercion. Carney's case studies, including brokers exploiting post-tsunami refugees in 2004, provided empirical evidence that bans fail to eliminate demand—estimated at over 100,000 kidneys annually worldwide—but instead exacerbate harms by removing legal protections and driving prices higher, with black-market kidneys fetching $1,000–$10,000 per procedure. This analysis has informed discourse by challenging pietistic regulatory approaches, advocating instead for grounded in observed outcomes, such as piloting regulated incentives to increase supply and reduce exploitation. Carney's documentation influenced arguments for reforms, as seen in citations within reviews proposing compensation models akin to Iran's , where paid since 1988 have nearly eliminated waiting lists and curtailed trafficking, contrasting with pre-reform black-market persistence elsewhere. His emphasis on data—e.g., India's post-ban surge in illegal transplants from 500 reported cases in 2007 to thousands annually—advanced in ethics literature, rebutting claims that market-oriented views romanticize by highlighting verifiable pre- and post-ban escalations in donor morbidity. In broader markets, Carney's exposure of intertwined trades in organs, bones, and blood—valued at billions globally—prompted scrutiny of international frameworks, contributing to reforms like the Council of Europe's anti-trafficking convention, which acknowledges supply restrictions as drivers of illicit flows. While some bioethicists critiqued his work for underemphasizing ethical risks, subsequent studies citing The Red Market validated its predictions, showing sustained trafficking in banned jurisdictions versus supply stabilization in incentive-based ones. Carney's investigative work has emphasized empirical scrutiny of extreme environmental conditioning practices, such as those popularized by , by conducting personal experiments to assess physiological responses rather than accepting anecdotal claims. In his 2017 book What Doesn't Kill Us, Carney initially sought to debunk Hof's assertions of voluntary control over the through cold exposure and techniques but found evidence of adaptive benefits, including enhanced brown fat activation and tolerance to , akin to where controlled stressors yield resilience gains. However, he countered hype by documenting risks, reporting 13 fatalities linked to unsupervised Wim Hof Method sessions involving breath holds and cold immersion as of 2023, attributing many to hypoxic blackouts from overzealous application without medical oversight. A prominent case involved a 2022 $67 million lawsuit against Hof alleging his online breathing protocols contributed to a 17-year-old's during pool practice, highlighting how profit-driven workshops can amplify dangers when participants bypass incremental self-testing. Carney advocates grounding wellness fads in through individual experimentation, urging practitioners to monitor personal biomarkers like and lactate thresholds instead of deferring to influencers. His approach critiques guru-led deference by demonstrating how techniques like deliberate can induce and fainting if not calibrated, yet offer verifiable autonomic shifts when titrated safely, as evidenced by his own showing temporary immune modulation via reduced inflammation markers post-exposure. This method promotes causal realism, prioritizing replicable outcomes over unverified promises, such as Hof's claims of curing chronic diseases without randomized trial support. In recent analyses, Carney has extended to trends, critiquing influencers for selective data presentation that overlooks confounders like and baselines. A 2025 investigation into Athletic Greens (AG1) exposed unsubstantiated efficacy claims in a $100 monthly supplement marketed by figures like , favoring self-monitored dietary interventions over proprietary blends lacking longitudinal evidence. Similarly, his 2024 examinations of protocols from highlighted cherry-picked animal studies extrapolated to humans without accounting for metabolic variances, reinforcing empirical self-experimentation—tracking metrics like length or personally—to discern genuine extensions in healthspan from commercial . Carney's efforts have influenced discourse by shifting focus to falsifiable gains, such as measurable endurance improvements from cold therapy, while exposing profit motives in unproven extensions like extreme or nootropics, encouraging users to prioritize adaptive biology over trend-driven excess.

Criticisms and debates

Carney's evolving perspective on the Method has drawn accusations of inconsistency from proponents of the technique. In a 2011 article, Carney initially portrayed Hof as a potentially fraudulent "dare-devil ice guru," questioning the scientific validity of his claims about controlling the through breathing and cold exposure. However, after training with Hof and summiting Kilimanjaro in shorts in 28 hours—a feat typically requiring five days—Carney's 2017 book What Doesn't Kill Us argued that deliberate exposure to environmental stressors like cold and hypoxia could activate latent human evolutionary adaptations for resilience, partially validating aspects of the method. By 2023, Carney shifted to sharp criticism in his blog post "The Rise and Fall of the Empire," citing 13 deaths linked to unsupervised breathing exercises, including shallow-water blackouts, and a $67 million filed in 2022 by the family of a 17-year-old girl who drowned during a pool session guided by Hof's Innerfire . He has since documented 31 such fatalities based on news reports and direct contacts, emphasizing risks of hyperventilation-induced hypoxia. Supporters of Hof, including some in online communities, have labeled later work as flip-flopping driven by personal grievances or sensationalism, pointing to his early endorsement as evidence of the method's merits before alleged fallout with Innerfire instructors. Hof's camp has responded by attributing drownings to user error rather than inherent flaws, with a 2023 court denial of dismissal in the lawsuit underscoring ongoing legal scrutiny but not resolving causation debates. defends his position with autopsy data and expert input on hypoxic blackouts, arguing that early hype overlooked contraindications like unsupervised water practice, though a 2025 Journal review notes his reservations stem from contradictory promotional videos by Hof rather than outright rejection. Critics of Carney's broader exposés, such as The Red Market (2011), have occasionally questioned the vividness of his accounts of global organ trafficking and body as prioritizing narrative drama over comprehensive analysis, with a New York Times review observing his India-centric focus limits global scope. Carney counters such claims by grounding reports in on-site investigations and verifiable cases, like sales in slums, without fabricating elements. No major ethical lapses or personal scandals have been substantiated against him, and his in later works acknowledges initial over-optimism about biohacking trends before prioritizing empirical risks over ideological defenses of markets or therapies.

References

  1. https://www.scottcarney.com/about
  2. https://www.scottcarney.com/books
  3. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-wim-hof-empire
  4. https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/7210762.Scott_Carney
  5. https://drdianehamilton.com/what-doesnt-kill-us-with-scott-carney-and-cultivating-leadership-together-with-glain-roberts-mccabe/
  6. https://www.osmosis.org/podcast/pushing-past-perceived-limits-scott-carney-journalist
  7. https://www.linkedin.com/in/scottcarney
  8. https://irisnrc.wisc.edu/staff/carney-scott/
  9. https://www.bookbrowse.com/biographies/index.cfm/author_number/3650/scott-carney
  10. https://www.wired.com/2007/11/ff-bones/
  11. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/10863697
  12. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/03/meet-parents-dark-side-overseas-adoption/
  13. https://www.motherjones.com/criminal-justice/2010/04/payne-ethics-award-scott-carney-india-adoption/
  14. https://www.npr.org/2011/06/10/136931615/blood-bones-and-organs-the-gruesome-red-market
  15. https://www.npr.org/2011/06/02/136885472/foreign-policy-strict-laws-perpetuate-organ-theft
  16. https://www.scottcarney.com/articles
  17. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/04/surrogacy-tourism-india-nayna-patel/
  18. https://www.scottcarney.com/article/the-iceman-cometh
  19. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog/tag/wim%2Bhof
  20. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog/tag/Breathwork
  21. https://ypo.vhx.tv/videos/ypo-live-wellness-wednesday-what-doesn-t-kill-us-with-scott-carney
  22. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog/andrew-huberman-is-lying-to-you
  23. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/49-y-tu-peter-attia/id1675685319?i=1000662390340
  24. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/scottcarney_follow-the-money-peter-attias-lawsuit-against-activity-7191104052468842496-429G
  25. https://www.harpercollins.com/products/the-red-market-scott-carney
  26. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304066504576347703687111960
  27. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/136931615
  28. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/17/books/the-red-market-by-scott-carney-on-human-parts-trafficking-review.html
  29. https://www.seattletimes.com/entertainment/books/the-red-market-scott-carneys-expos-of-the-worldwide-traffic-in-blood-and-body-parts/
  30. https://globalcomment.com/red-market-by-scott-carney/
  31. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9555687-the-red-market
  32. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12202555/
  33. https://www.scottcarney.com/article/death-and-madness-at-diamond-mountain
  34. https://www.amazon.com/Death-Diamond-Mountain-Obsession-Enlightenment/dp/1592408613
  35. https://www.npr.org/2015/03/29/395849232/understanding-the-dark-side-of-enlightenment-on-diamond-mountain
  36. https://info-buddhism.com/geshe_michael_roach-Death-and-Madness-at-Diamond-Mountain.html
  37. https://matthewremski.com/wordpress/spiritualized-narcissism-as-trauma-response-a-review-of-and-meditation-on-a-death-on-diamond-mountain-by-scott-carney/
  38. https://www.elephantjournal.com/2012/05/psychosis-stabbing-secrecy-and-death-at-a-neo-buddhist-university-in-arizona/
  39. https://www.shelf-awareness.com/readers/2015-03-20/scott_carney:_when_spiritual_practice_turns_deadly.html
  40. https://abcnews.go.com/US/james-ray-found-guilty-negligent-homicide-arizona-sweat/story?id=13908037
  41. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/october-8/self-help-gurus-sweat-lodge-ceremony-turns-deadly
  42. https://www.scottcarney.com/the-enlightenment-trap
  43. https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/sex-and-death-on-the-road-to-nirvana-86995/
  44. https://macleans.ca/culture/books/sex-and-death-on-a-doomed-search-for-enlightenment/
  45. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/scott-carney/a-death-on-diamond-mountain/
  46. https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/1dlxh9t/cult_leader_geshe_michael_roach/
  47. https://www.salon.com/2015/03/15/when_buddhism_goes_bad_how_a_yoga_and_meditation_retreat_turned_cult_like_and_deadly/
  48. https://www.npr.org/2017/01/08/508765671/what-doesnt-kill-us-invites-practical-medical-benefits
  49. https://www.scottcarney.com/what-doesnt-kill-us
  50. https://www.amazon.com/What-Doesnt-Kill-Environmental-Conditioning/dp/1623366909
  51. https://www.shortform.com/pdf/what-doesnt-kill-us-pdf-scott-carney
  52. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/scott-carney/what-doesnt-kill-us-freezing/
  53. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/592234/what-doesnt-kill-us-by-scott-carney-foreword-by-wim-hof/
  54. https://www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/what-doesnt-kill-us-review-freeze-your-enthusiasm-5bd2d9f5
  55. https://www.scottcarney.com/the-wedge
  56. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/scott-carney/the-wedge-evolution-consciousness-stress-and-the-k/
  57. https://www.harpercollins.com/products/the-vortex-scott-carneyjason-miklian
  58. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/scott-carney/the-vortex/
  59. https://www.scottcarney.com/the-vortex
  60. https://journalism.uoregon.edu/past-ancil-payne-award-winners
  61. https://roborman.com/stimulus/107-the-power-of-lightly-held-beliefs-with-scott-carney/
  62. https://www.aevitascreative.com/client/scott-carney
  63. https://cqpress.sagepub.com/cqresearcher/report/organ-trafficking-cqrglobal20110719
  64. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/368336916_Organ_Sales
  65. https://fightslaverynow.org/why-fight-there-are-27-million-reasons/otherformsoftrafficking/organ-removal/
  66. https://pure.au.dk/portal/files/306850740/Albertsen_Organ_Markets.pdf
  67. https://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1183&context=chapman-law-review
  68. https://cqpress.sagepub.com/cqresearcher/report/organ-trafficking-cqresrre20220624
  69. https://cbhd.org/cbhd-resources/trading-in-organs-ipads-cash-or-a-kidney
  70. https://www.amazon.com/What-Doesnt-Kill-Environmental-Conditioning/dp/1635652413
  71. https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/exploration-survival/wim-hof-california-lawsuit/
  72. https://www.outsideonline.com/podcast/scott-carney-podcast-interview/
  73. https://fortune.com/2025/01/24/ag1-athletic-greens-supplements-green-powder-bryan-johnson/
  74. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog
  75. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/269-on-science-with-anne-sophi-282226755/episode/2-scott-carney-on-andrew-huberman-285639721/
  76. https://www.livescience.com/health/gambling-with-your-life-experts-weigh-in-on-dangers-of-the-wim-hof-method
  77. https://www.reddit.com/r/BecomingTheIceman/comments/1aw1zkz/curious_if_anyone_knows_what_the_deal_is_with/
  78. https://www.scottcarney.com/blog/wim-hofs-court-case-takes-a-turn
  79. https://www.scottcarney.com/the-red-market
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.