Hubbry Logo
X-class submarineX-class submarineMain
Open search
X-class submarine
Community hub
X-class submarine
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
X-class submarine
X-class submarine
X-class submarine
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Class overview
NameX class
Operators Royal Navy
Preceded byV class
Succeeded byXE class
SubclassesX3, X4, X5-10, X20-25, XT
Completed20
Lost7 (5 scuttled, 1 foundered, 1 collision)
Preserved1
General characteristics (X class)
Typemidget submarine
Displacement
  • 27 tons surfaced
  • 30 tons submerged
Length51.25 ft (15.62 m)
Beam5.75 ft (1.75 m)
Draught5.3 ft (1.60 m)
Propulsion
  • Single shaft; 1 × Gardner 4LK[1] 4-cyl diesel engine, 42 hp (31.3 kW) at 1,800 rpm
  • 1 × Keith Blackman electric motor, 30 hp (22.3 kW) at 1,650 rpm
Speed
  • 6.5 knots (12.0 km/h) surfaced
  • 5.5 knots (10.2 km/h) submerged
Range
  • 500 nmi (926 km) surfaced
  • 82 nmi (151.8 km) @2 knots (2 mph; 4 km/h) submerged
Test depth300 ft (91.5 m)
Complement4
Armament2 × 4,400 lb detachable amatol charges

The X class was a World War II midget submarine class built for the Royal Navy during 1943–44. It was substantially larger than the original Chariot manned torpedo.

Known individually as X-Craft, the vessels were designed to be towed to their intended area of operations by a full-size "mother" submarine – usually one of the T class or S class – with a passage crew on board, the operational crew being transferred from the towing submarine to the X-Craft by dinghy when the operational area was reached, and the passage crew returning with the dinghy to the towing submarine. Once the attack was over, the X-Craft would rendezvous with the towing submarine and then be towed home.

Range was limited primarily by the endurance and determination of their crews, but was thought to be up to 14 days in the craft or 1,000 nmi (1,900 km), after suitable training. Actual range of the X-Craft itself was 600 nmi (1,100 km) surfaced and 80 nmi (150 km) at 2 knots (3.7 km/h) submerged.[2]

Specification

[edit]

The craft was about 51 ft (16 m) long, 5.5 ft (1.7 m) maximum diameter and displaced 27 long tons (27 t) surfaced and 30 long tons (30 t) submerged. Propulsion was by a 4-cylinder Gardner 4LK[1] 42 hp diesel engine, converted from a type used in London buses and a 30 hp electric motor, giving a maximum surface speed of 6.5 knots (12.0 km/h; 7.5 mph) and a submerged speed of about one third of that.[2] The crew initially numbered three – commander, pilot and ERA (Engine Room Artificer, i.e. engineer), but soon a specialist diver was added, for whom an airlock, known as a "wet and dry" compartment, was provided. The ERA, usually a Navy Chief Petty Officer, operated and maintained the machinery in the vessel.

The weapons on the "X-Craft" were two side-cargoes – explosive charges held on opposite sides of the hull with two tons of amatol in each. The intention was to drop these on the sea bed underneath the target and then escape. The charges were detonated by a time fuse.[2] The craft were fitted with electromagnetic field generators to mask their inherent magnetic field to avoid detection by anti-submarine detectors on the sea bed and also with sonar and a periscope.[2]

Service

[edit]

A number of development craft were built before it was felt that a feasible weapon had been produced. The first operational craft was X3 (or HM S/M X.3), launched on the night of 15 March 1942. Training with the craft began in September 1942, with X4 arriving in October. In December 1942 and January 1943, six of the "5-10" class began to arrive, identical externally but with a completely reworked interior.

These operations were part of a longer series of frogman operations; see human torpedo.

The operational base and training establishment was HMS Varbel at the former Kyles Hydro Hotel at Port Bannatyne on the Isle of Bute in the Firth of Clyde, Scotland.

Major operations

[edit]
X25 underway

Their first deployment was Operation Source in September, 1943, an attempt to neutralise the heavy German warships based at Kåfjord, Nordkapp in Northern Norway. Six X-Craft were used but only two successfully laid charges (under the German battleship Tirpitz). Two were lost while being towed to Norway; X8 began taking water and was scuttled, and X9 sank with her crew after the towline parted. Only X6 and X7, commanded by Lieutenant Donald Cameron and Lieutenant Godfrey Place respectively, were successful in placing their charges although their crews were captured (there is some evidence that X5 also placed her charges;[3] X10 also penetrated the anchorage but was unable to attack and the crew were picked up by another submarine). Tirpitz was badly damaged, crippled, and out of action until May 1944; it was destroyed on 12 November 1944 by Avro Lancaster bombers during Operation Catechism in Tromsø, Norway.[4]

For this action, Cameron and Place were awarded the Victoria Cross, whilst Robert Aitken, Richard Haddon Kendall, and John Thornton Lorimer received the Distinguished Service Order and Edmund Goddard the Conspicuous Gallantry Medal.[5] The commander of X8, John Elliott Smart, was appointed a Member of the Order of the British Empire (MBE).[6] There was a possibility that X5 had also successfully planted explosive side charges before being destroyed, but this was never conclusively proven; its commander Henty-Creer was not awarded a medal, but was mentioned in dispatches.[7][4]

The lost boats were replaced early in 1944 with X20 to X25 and six training-only craft.

Submarines X20 to X25 were dispatched to Bergen, Norway. On 15 April 1944, in Operation Guidance X24 attacked the Laksevåg floating dock. X22 was intended for the mission, but had been accidentally rammed during training and sunk with all hands. X24 made the approach and escaped successfully, but the charges were placed under Bärenfels, a 7,569-gross register ton (GRT) merchant vessel alongside the dock; the ship was sunk but the dock suffered only minor damage. On 11 September the operation was repeated by X24; this time she succeeded in sinking the dock.[8]

A hand-held, hydraulically powered, net cutter of the type used by X boat divers to cut through torpedo nets protecting harbours

X-Craft were involved in the preparatory work for Overlord. Operation Postage Able was planned to take surveys of the landing beaches with X20, commanded by Lt KR Hudspeth, spending four days off the French coast. Periscope reconnaissance of the shoreline and echo-soundings were performed during daytime. Each night, X20 would approach the beach and 2 divers would swim ashore. Soil samples were collected in condoms. The divers went ashore on two nights to survey the beaches at Vierville-sur-Mer, Moulins St Laurent and Colleville-sur-Mer in what became the American Omaha Beach. On the third night, they were due to go ashore off the Orne Estuary (Sword Beach), but by this stage fatigue (the crew and divers had been living on little more than benzedrine tablets) and the worsening weather caused Hudspeth to shorten the operation, returning to Dolphin on 21 January 1944. Hudspeth received a bar to his DSC.

X20 and X23, each with a crew of five, acted as navigational beacons to help the D-Day invasion fleet land on the correct beaches (Operation Gambit), as part of the Combined Operations Pilotage Parties (COPP). The craft were also equipped with a radio beacon and echo sounder to help direct Canadian and British ships to the suitable positions on Sword and Juno beaches. Oxygen bottles on both craft enabled the crews to remain submerged for extended periods during this operation, 64 hours of the 76 total hours at sea.[9][2]

Legacy

[edit]

The only remaining intact example of an X-Craft, X24, was transferred from HMS Dolphin, where she had been on display since 1981, to the Royal Navy Submarine Museum nearby in 1987.[10] Operations continued in the Far East with the revised XE class submarines.

X-craft and crews

[edit]
The engine of X24
  • X3 – unofficially named Piker 1, was lost on 4 November 1942 in Loch Striven due to a leaking engine valve. All crew escaped by utilizing their Davis Submerged Escape Apparatus.[11]
  • X5 – unofficially named Platypus,[12] commanded by Lt. Henty-Creer RNVR (also the operation's commander),[13] crew S-Lt. Nelson, Midshipman Malcolm, and ERA Mortiboys; passage crew Lt Terry-Lloyd (commanding), L/S Element, Stoker Garrity.[14] Henty-Creer, Nelson, Malcolm, and Mortiboys were killed in the attack, though X5's exact fate is unknown.[14]
  • X6 – named Piker II,[13] commanded by Lt. Donald Cameron, crew Lt. J. T. Lorimer, S-Lt. R. Kendall, and ERA Goddard; passage crew Lt Wilson (commanding), Leading Seaman McGregor, Stoker Oxley.[13] Cameron earned a VC, Lorimer and Kendall DSOs, Goddard a Conspicuous Gallantry Medal.[13]
  • X7 – unofficially named Pdinichthys,[15] commanded by Lt. Basil C. G. Place, crew S-Lt. R. Aitken, Lt. Whittam, and ERA Whitley; passage crew Lt Philip (commanding), Leading Seaman J. Magennis, Stoker Luck.[13] Vessel was scuttled immediately following the Tirpitz attack, but only Place escaped before she sank. Aitken escaped from the bottom of the fjord, but Whittam and Whitley were unable to escape before their air gave out. Place also earned a VC, Aitken a DSO, while Philip earned an MBE;[16]
  • X8 – unofficially named Expectant, commanded by Lt. McFarlane RAN[13] (Lt. Smart was passage crew commander)
  • X9 – unofficially named Pluto,[17] commanded by Lt. EA Kearon RNVR; AH Harte (Able Seaman) and GH Hollet (Stoker). Foundered on 16 September 1942 while under tow from the Syrtis.
  • X10 – unofficially named Excalibur,[18] commanded by Lt. Hudspeth RANVR[13]

The depot ship for X craft was HMS Bonaventure.[19]

Builders

[edit]
The remains of an XT-class craft on the beach at Aberlady Bay, east of Edinburgh, in 2008. The bow is to the left, the stern to the right. From left to right can be seen the wet and dry chamber hatch, the "conning tower" (the periscopes penetrated the hull through the "eye" shape) and the secondary hatch.

The numbering sequence of the X class began with X3 because the designations X1 and X2 had already been used previously – X1 had been a one-off submarine cruiser design from the 1920s while X2 had been assigned to a captured Italian submarine.

  • Prototypes
  • X5-type
    • X5 – built by Vickers Armstrong, Barrow-in-Furness, used in Operation Source, sunk Altenfjord, 22 September 1943
    • X6 – built by Vickers, used in Operation Source, scuttled Altenfjord, 22 September 1943
    • X7 – built by Vickers, used in Operation Source, scuttled Altenfjord, 22 September 1943, salved 1976 for museum restoration
    • X8 – built by Vickers, used in Operation Source, scuttled in North Sea, 17 September 1943
    • X9 – built by Vickers, used in Operation Source, foundered under tow in North Sea, 16 September 1943 with all hands[20]
    • X10 – built by Vickers, used in Operation Source, scuttled in North Sea 3 October 1943
  • X20-type
    • X20 – built by Broadbent, Huddersfield, used in Operation Postage Able (surveying Normandy beaches prior to invasion) and on Operation Gambit
    • X21 – built by Broadbent
    • X22 – built by Markham & Co., Chesterfield, collided with HMS Syrtis and lost with all hands while training, 7 February 1944
    • X23 – built by Markham, used on Operation Gambit, sold 1945
    • X24 – built by Marshall, Gainsborough, used on Operation Guidance (attacking Laksevåg floating dock at Bergen 15 April 1944) when the merchant ship Barenfels alongside the dock was sunk; the dock was attacked and sunk on Operation Heckle on 11 September 1944, again by X24 which was hulked 1945
    • X25 – built by Marshall, sold 1945
  • Training craft
    • XT1 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945
    • XT2 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945
    • XT3 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945
    • XT4 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945
    • XT5 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945
    • XT6 – built by Vickers, scrapped 1945

Surviving examples

[edit]
The interior of X24

In the media

[edit]

This type of midget submarine was portrayed in the 1955 war film, Above Us the Waves, featuring John Mills, which was based on both Operation Source and the earlier Chariot attacks on the Tirpitz.

An X-class submarine – marked as "X2" – features in the 1959 film The Giant Behemoth (a.k.a. Behemoth the Sea Monster).

This class of submarine was later featured in the 1968 movie Submarine X-1 starring James Caan as a Canadian Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve officer who after losing his submarine and fifty crew members in a battle with a German ship during World War II, gets a second chance training crews to take part in a raid using midget subs.

A 1976 Douglas Reeman novel, Surface with Daring, features a fictionalized account of X-class midget submarines, especially XE-16 and its crew, performing several highly secret operations in occupied Europe.[22]

A 2006 Alexander Fullerton novel, The Gatecrashers, features a fictionalized account of X-class midget submarines, including X-12 piloted by one of the protagonists, that lays explosive charges to damage the Tirpitz.[23]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Bibliography

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

X-class submarine

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The X-class submarines were a class of midget submarines developed and built for the Royal Navy during the Second World War, designed for covert missions to attack enemy warships by attaching large explosive charges to their hulls using divers. These compact vessels measured approximately 51 feet in length and 5 feet 9 inches in beam, displaced 27 tons, and were typically crewed by four personnel—a commanding officer, first lieutenant, diver, and engine room artificer—operating in extremely confined conditions with no standing room. Powered by a 42-horsepower diesel engine for surfaced operations and a 30-horsepower electric motor when submerged, they achieved maximum speeds of 6 knots on the surface and 5 knots underwater, with an endurance of about 82 miles submerged, necessitating towing by larger "mother" submarines such as S-class or T-class vessels to reach distant targets. Armament consisted of two 2-ton amatol charges placed via side-hatches, supplemented by limpet mines for smaller sabotage tasks, and they had a maximum dive depth of 300 feet. Conceived in 1942 amid the need to neutralize German capital ships like the battleship Tirpitz that posed threats to Allied convoys, the X-class originated from prototypes developed by Commander C.C. Varley, with production beginning at yards including Vickers-Armstrongs and others. A total of 20 X-craft were constructed between 1942 and 1945, though early prototypes (X-3 and X-4) were lost during training, and the operational fleet included units like X-5 through X-10 and later X-20 through X-25. Their most notable success came during Operation Source in September 1943, when six X-craft—towed to Altenfjord, Norway—penetrated defenses to damage Tirpitz severely, rendering her inoperable for months and earning the crews the Victoria Cross and other honors, despite heavy losses including all six submarines and their crews, with 9 killed and 6 captured. In 1944, X-craft shifted to support roles for the invasion, participating in Operation Gambit where X-20 and marked and Juno beaches with lights and beacons, conducted hydrographic surveys, and cleared obstacles, arriving offshore on June 4 after weather delays and guiding Allied forces with minimal casualties. Earlier missions, such as Operation Postage Able in January 1944, used X-20 for beach surveys off , highlighting their versatility beyond direct attacks. Post-war, most X-craft were scrapped by 1946, but X-24 survives as a museum exhibit, underscoring their legacy as innovative tools of that punched above their weight in strategic impact.

Development and Design

Background and Conception

The development of the X-class midget submarines originated from British pre-war and early wartime experiments with compact underwater attack vehicles, notably the , which entered service in as a response to Italian successes. The , operated by a two-man crew in diving suits, suffered from severe limitations in range and payload, with an endurance of just 7 to 8 hours at 2.9 knots and a detachable warhead carrying only 600 pounds of explosive, making it unsuitable for extended missions or targets far from launch points. These shortcomings prompted the Royal Navy to pursue a more advanced capable of being towed by conventional submarines to operational areas, allowing penetration of heavily defended harbors and fjords to target anchored enemy warships. The primary strategic impetus was the persistent threat from the German Kriegsmarine's heavy surface units, particularly the battleship Tirpitz, which tied down British naval resources in northern waters by lurking in secure Norwegian anchorages beyond the reach of standard attacks. This towed design addressed the need for stealthy, long-range delivery of larger charges without exposing larger vessels to risk. Conception of the X-class was driven by key naval figures, including Admiral Sir Max Horton, who inspired the initiative based on his World War I submarine experience, Lt. Commander G. P. Sladen, and Commander Cromwell Varley, a pioneering advocate for midget submarines who oversaw early design work at his Varley Marine firm. In 1942, the Admiralty established a dedicated midget submarine program to scale up these concepts into operational weapons, transitioning from human torpedoes to self-contained submersibles with a four-man crew for improved control and endurance. Prototypes X3 and X4 underwent successful sea trials off the Scottish coast in October 1942, demonstrating the feasibility of the design for harbor penetration and mine-laying, which led to Admiralty approval for production of the first operational batch (X5 through X10) later that year. These trials confirmed the X-craft's ability to overcome the Chariot's range constraints through towing, paving the way for deployment against high-value targets by mid-1943.

Specifications

The X-class submarines, also known as X-craft, measured 51 feet in length, with a beam of 5 feet 9 inches (1.75 m) and a draught of 5 feet. Their displacement was 27 tons when surfaced and 30 tons when submerged, reflecting their compact design optimized for covert penetration of enemy harbors. Propulsion was provided by a single Gardner four-cylinder delivering 42 shaft horsepower for surface operations, augmented by a Keith Blackman electric motor delivering 30 horsepower for submerged running, driving a single propeller shaft. This configuration enabled maximum speeds of 6 knots on the surface and 5 knots submerged, with an operational range of 500 nautical miles surfaced or 82 nautical miles submerged at 2 knots. Armament consisted solely of two externally mounted, detachable charges each containing 4,400 pounds of amatol explosive, positioned along the hull sides for placement beneath targets; the craft carried no torpedoes. These were intended for strategic strikes against heavily defended surface vessels such as the German battleship Tirpitz. The crew comprised four members: a skipper (commanding officer), first lieutenant (typically handling navigation and diving), third hand (serving as diver and assistant), and engine room artificer (responsible for machinery). They operated in a confined, wet interior space, enduring harsh conditions with limited room for movement, equipped only with a periscope for observation and hydroplanes for depth control. The hull was constructed from riveted steel plates in a single-hull configuration, incorporating main tanks for submergence and specialized fittings at the bow and to facilitate towing by larger "mother" submarines over long distances.

Construction

Builders

The construction of the X-class submarines was distributed among several British engineering firms and shipyards to accelerate production while maintaining operational secrecy during . The primary builders included Vickers-Armstrong at , an established naval shipyard experienced in submarine construction; Markham & Co. in Chesterfield, an ironworks and engineering company; and Thomas Broadbent & Sons in , a machinery manufacturer. The prototypes X3 and X4 were built by Commander C.C. Varley and his team. These firms were selected to diversify production away from congested naval facilities, with a total of 20 boats ultimately produced across prototypes, operational craft, and trainers. Contracts for the operational X-craft were awarded primarily in , following the successful prototyping phase, to meet urgent wartime demands for . Vickers-Armstrong received the initial major allocation in late , building twelve boats including the first batch of six operational craft (X5 through X10) and six training craft (XT1 through XT6) at their yard, which were completed and ready for use by September . Markham & Co. was contracted to construct two boats, X22 and , with X23 launched in December ; Thomas Broadbent & Sons handled allocations such as X20 and X21, with X20 launched in November . Additional operational craft X24 and X25 were built by Marshall Sons & Co. in Gainsborough. This distribution allowed for parallel assembly, though exact allocations varied to balance workload. The builders faced significant challenges due to the project's high , which required compartmentalized work and restricted information sharing even among workers. Non-naval firms like Markham and Broadbent had to adapt their civilian engineering facilities—originally geared toward industrial machinery rather than marine vessels—for precision assembly, involving modifications to workshops for handling classified components like pressure hulls and systems. These adaptations, combined with wartime material shortages and the need for rapid scaling, tested the firms' capabilities but ensured the fleet's timely delivery for key operations.

Production and Commissioning

The production of the X-class submarines encompassed 20 vessels completed during , comprising the prototypes X3 and X4, the operational craft X5 through X10 and X20 through X25, and six additional training-only submarines of the XT class; no major losses occurred during construction. Following successful trials with the X3 and X4 prototypes, which informed design refinements for improved handling and reliability, full-scale production ramped up in late 1942 to mid-1943, enabling rapid output under wartime pressures. The initial batch of six operational submarines (X5–X10) was constructed starting in December 1942, achieving readiness by mid-1943, while the subsequent six (X20–X25) and training craft followed in 1943–1944 to replace losses and support expanded roles. To ensure secrecy and mitigate risks from aerial bombing, manufacturing was dispersed across secure, inland facilities rather than traditional coastal shipyards, with components produced by specialized firms and assembled under strict codenames like "X-craft" to obscure their purpose. at handled the first operational series (X5–X10) and the XT training series, leveraging their expertise in for efficient assembly of the 30-ton, single-compartment hulls equipped with Gardner diesel engines and electric motors. The later series (X20–X25) shifted to inland builders including Thomas Broadbent & Sons in , Markham & Co. in Chesterfield, and Marshall Sons & Co. in Gainsborough, allowing parallel production and quicker integration of modifications such as enhanced buoyancy controls derived from prototype testing. This decentralized approach facilitated the completion of the fleet within approximately 18 months, prioritizing speed and concealment over centralized oversight. Commissioning began in September 1943 for the first operational boats, marking their entry into service amid heightened secrecy; for instance, X5 was commissioned on 9 September 1943, followed shortly by X6 on 16 September and others in the series by month's end. Ceremonies were subdued to maintain operational security, often limited to small gatherings at bases like Faslane on the Clyde, where launches doubled as informal commissionings—X20, later named Exemplar, was launched and commissioned on 1 by Marjorie Warwick, daughter of a naval , while X23 followed on 13 December 1943, initially under the codename P32 before receiving its X designation. Post-commissioning, each submarine received initial fittings tailored to midget operations, including two detachable 2-ton charges, echo sounders, gyro compasses, and provisions for a four-man crew, before integration with larger "mother" submarines for towing to deployment zones due to their limited endurance.

Operational History

Training and Preparation

The training establishment for X-class midget submarine crews was HMS Varbel, a shore base at the former Kyles Hydro Hotel in Port Bannatyne on the Isle of Bute, , established in as headquarters for the 12th Submarine Flotilla. This facility coordinated all preparation for X-craft operations, including intelligence gathering and crew readiness, in the secure waters of the . Selection for X-craft service began in early 1942 with an appeal for volunteers from the Royal Navy submarine branch, emphasizing hazardous special duties. Candidates underwent rigorous physical and psychological screening to ensure resilience under extreme stress, with those meeting standards posted to HMS Varbel by August 1942 for specialized instruction. The typical crew of four—a , (often handling ), and two engine room personnel—required in all roles to maximize operational flexibility. Training regimens at HMS Varbel lasted several months, commencing with September 1942 trials of prototype craft like X3 and X4, and intensifying through 1943 as production models arrived. Exercises in adjacent Loch Striven emphasized simulated towing by larger submarines, harbor penetration drills under cover of darkness, and endurance tests involving prolonged submersion—often 16 to 18 hours—to build proficiency in oxygen management and escape procedures. Crews practiced beach reconnaissance markings and diver lockout operations using the craft's wet-and-dry chamber, adapting to the 27-ton vessel's limited surfaced range of about 500 nautical miles and submerged endurance of approximately 82 miles at 2.5 knots. Early challenges included adapting to the craft's harsh interior, where constant dampness from leaks and flooding during dives soaked , , and , exacerbating during multi-day exercises. posed a significant psychological hurdle in the confined 51-foot hull, with some trainees experiencing hallucinations from CO2 buildup or oxygen imbalances, leading to and disrupted sleep. These conditions contributed to changes, as seen in incidents where interpersonal conflicts or mishaps prompted reassignments, though the program ultimately produced highly skilled teams by late 1943.

Major Operations

The primary combat operations conducted by X-class submarines were high-risk attacks on key Axis naval assets in , aimed at disrupting German heavy surface units and infrastructure supporting operations. The most significant of these was , launched in 1943 to neutralize the battleship Tirpitz in Altenfjord, , which threatened Allied convoys to the [Soviet Union](/page/Soviet Union). Six X-craft—X5, X6, X7, X8, X9, and X10—were towed over 1,000 miles from by larger submarines, including HMS Truculent for X6, departing on 11 . En route, X9 was lost on 16 when its tow parted from HMS Syrtis in the , with the passage crew perishing, and X8 was scuttled on 18 by HMS Sea Nymph after mechanical failures aborted its mission against the cruiser Lützow. On 22 September, the remaining X-craft slipped their tows and navigated defended waters to approach their targets, with X5, X6, and X7 assigned to Tirpitz; X10 to the battleship Scharnhorst. X5 vanished during the penetration, likely sunk by German gunfire and depth charges with no survivors. X6, commanded by Lieutenant Donald Cameron, evaded the anti-submarine nets by following a Norwegian coaster's wake, grounded briefly under the target, and successfully placed its two 2-ton charges beneath Tirpitz's hull despite gyrocompass failures and hull damage. X7, under Lieutenant Basil Place, became entangled in the nets but freed itself to lay its charges nearby before being attacked and scuttled; two crew members escaped, while two were trapped and lost. X10, facing heavy defenses, could not close on Scharnhorst and was later scuttled on 3 October during return tow by HMS Stubborn. The charges detonated at approximately 08:12, inflicting severe damage on Tirpitz, including ruptured fuel tanks, flooded engine rooms, and a 2-degree list, rendering her inoperable for six months until April 1944. All six X-craft were ultimately lost, with 29 personnel lost overall. For their leadership, Cameron and Place were awarded the Victoria Cross; additional Distinguished Service Orders went to supporting officers like Third Hand John Lorimer of X7. A subsequent major operation involving X-craft was Guidance in April 1944, targeting shipping repair facilities in harbor, , to hinder maintenance. X24, towed by HMS Sceptre and commanded by Max Shean, penetrated the 30-mile mined undetected on 11-15 . Mistaking the 8,100-ton German supply ship Barenfels for the primary target of the Laksevåg floating dock, X24 placed and detonated its charges, sinking the vessel and causing secondary damage to nearby . The crew safely withdrew and was recovered, with Shean and his team recognized for gallantry through Distinguished Service Orders. This action demonstrated the X-craft's precision strike capability against defended ports, complementing broader coordination efforts.

Minor Operations and Support Roles

In addition to their primary roles in high-risk assaults, X-class submarines conducted several reconnaissance and support missions that provided critical intelligence and navigational aid for larger Allied operations. One key effort was Operation Postage Able in January 1944, during which HMS X20, commanded by Lieutenant K. R. Hudspeth, departed on January 17 to survey the coastline ahead of the D-Day invasion. The crew, including hydrographic experts from the Combined Operations Pilotage Parties (COPP), positioned the submarine at periscope depth off , where they conducted echo soundings, observed German defenses through the , and dispatched divers to collect soil samples from the beach to assess its load-bearing capacity for tanks and vehicles. This five-day submerged operation, enduring harsh conditions with limited air and food, yielded vital data on beach gradients and obstacles, which informed invasion planning and was relayed back to Allied command upon X20's return to on January 21. Building on this preparatory work, X20 and HMS X23 played supportive roles in Operation Gambit, part of the broader D-Day landings on June 6, 1944. Towed into position and arriving offshore on 4 June 1944 after weather delays, both submarines lay on the seabed for several days before surfacing at approximately 4:45 a.m. to activate navigation beacons, flashing lights signaling "D" every 40 seconds, and radio transmitters to guide the invasion fleet toward Sword and Juno beaches from three miles offshore. X20 specifically marked the eastern limit of Juno Beach, ensuring accurate landings for Canadian and British forces, while X23 supported the western approaches to Sword Beach; both vessels operated submerged for up to 72 hours, providing real-time hydrographic updates via echo sounders to minimize navigational errors amid poor visibility and strong currents. These low-intensity marking duties contrasted with direct combat, highlighting the X-class's utility in precision support that contributed to the orderly deployment of over 150,000 troops on the first day. Other reconnaissance activities extended the X-class's contributions beyond the Normandy focus. Following the April 1944 Operation Guidance, in which HMS X24 mistakenly targeted a ship instead of the intended Laksevåg floating dock in Harbor, the returned in September 1944 for a follow-up mission as part of Operation Heckle that included surveys of harbor defenses and shipping movements to confirm target viability before placing mines successfully on the dock. Additionally, some training exercises in 1944 were adapted for gathering, such as shallow-water dives off the British coast that doubled as opportunities to test stealth approaches and gather data on tidal patterns relevant to ongoing European operations. These minor operations were not without risks, as demonstrated by incidents during transit preparations. En route to the September 1943 , HMS X9 foundered on September 16 after its tow rope from HMS Syrtis parted in heavy weather, causing the to plunge uncontrollably; all four crew members— E. Kearon, J. Harte, Artificer F. Hollet, and W. Brown—were lost at sea, underscoring the hazards of even non-combat support transits.

Individual X-craft and Crews

List of X-craft

The X-class midget submarines, developed for covert operations during , included two prototypes for trials, twelve operational boats divided into two batches (X5–X10 for initial missions and X20–X25 for later campaigns), and six training variants (XT1–XT6). A total of seven X-craft were lost during the war: five scuttled or sunk during operations, one due to collision, and one that foundered en route. The following table provides an inventory of all X-craft, detailing their builders, commission dates where recorded, key assignments, and fates, based on naval records and historical accounts.
BoatBuilderCommission DateMajor Operations/AssignmentsFate
X3Varley Marine, HambleOctober 1942Prototype trials and developmentScuttled after trials in 1943; later used briefly for training before disposal
X4Portsmouth DockyardOctober 1942Prototype trials and developmentScrapped post-war after serving as a trials and training boat
X5Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessDecember 1942Operation Source (target: Tirpitz, September 1943)Lost without trace during penetration of Altenfjord, Norway, on 22 September 1943; presumed foundered or destroyed
X6Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessDecember 1942Operation Source (target: Tirpitz, September 1943)Charges laid successfully, damaging Tirpitz; scuttled after mission on 22 September 1943 in Altenfjord; crew rescued
X7Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessDecember 1942Operation Source (target: Tirpitz, September 1943)Charges laid successfully, damaging Tirpitz; scuttled after mission on 22 September 1943 in Altenfjord; partial crew loss
X8Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessDecember 1942Operation Source (target: Lützow, September 1943)Scuttled en route on 18 September 1943 in Norwegian Sea after tow parted and mission abandoned; crew rescued
X9Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessJanuary 1943Operation Source (target: Scharnhorst, September 1943)Lost en route on 16 September 1943 in Norwegian Sea after failing to surface; tow parted, all crew lost
X10Vickers-Armstrong, Barrow-in-FurnessJanuary 1943Operation Source (target: Scharnhorst, September 1943)Mission failed; scuttled on 3 October 1943 in Norwegian Sea due to gale after tow broke; crew rescued
X20 (Exemplar)Broadbent's, Huddersfield1 November 1943Operation Postage Able (Normandy reconnaissance, January 1944); Operation Gambit (D-Day pilotage, June 1944)Placed in UNDEX trials at Rosyth post-war; scrapped
X21Broadbent's, HuddersfieldDecember 1943Training and reserve duties; reallocated from pilotage rolesPlaced in UNDEX trials at Rosyth post-war; scrapped
X22 (Exploit)Markham & Co., Chesterfield1 November 1943Training for Combined Operations Pilotage Parties (COPP) at Loch StrivenSunk in collision with HMS Syrtis on 7 February 1944 in Pentland Firth during towing exercises; crew survived
X23 (Xiphias)Markham & Co., Chesterfield13 December 1943Operation Gambit (D-Day pilotage, June 1944)Placed in UNDEX trials at Rosyth post-war; scrapped
X24 (Pike)Marshall, Sons & Co. Ltd., GainsboroughFebruary 1944Attacks on German shipping in Bergen fjords (April and September 1944)Preserved post-war; now on display at the Royal Navy Submarine Museum, Gosport
X25Marshall's, GainsboroughMarch 1944Reserve and training duties; no combat assignmentsPlaced in UNDEX trials at Rosyth post-war; scrapped
XT1Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1943Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war
XT2Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1943Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war
XT3Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1943Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war
XT4Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1943Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war
XT5Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1944Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war
XT6Vickers-Armstrongs, Barrow-in-Furness1944Training for anti-submarine warfare exercisesScrapped post-war

Notable Crew Members

Lieutenant Donald Cameron, a officer, commanded the X6 during in September 1943, where he successfully penetrated the defenses of the in Altenfjord, , placing mines that severely damaged the vessel and kept it out of action for months. For his leadership in navigating the submarine through anti-torpedo nets and anti-submarine defenses under extreme conditions, Cameron was awarded the , one of only four submariners to receive this honor during . Lieutenant Basil Charles Godfrey Place commanded X7 in the same operation, guiding his craft into the Tirpitz's anchorage despite being trapped in nets, and ensuring the mines were placed before the crew's capture by German forces. Place received the for his determination and skill, which contributed to the mission's partial success despite X7's loss. Engine Room Artificer Edmund Goddard, serving as on X6, played a critical role in maintaining control and positioning during the attack, earning the for his composure amid the chaos of confined maneuvering and enemy detection risks. Lieutenant Kenneth Robert Hudspeth, an Australian serving in the Royal Australian Naval Volunteer Reserve, commanded X20 during Operation Gambit in 1944, positioning the submarine off beaches to mark landing sites and provide navigational guidance for the D-Day invasion fleet at and Juno sectors. Hudspeth's prior experience in and his steady handling of the X-craft in rough Channel waters under threat of German patrols earned him a Bar to his Distinguished Service Cross. X-class crews operated in intensely confined conditions, with each submarine accommodating just four men in a 51-foot vessel where space was so limited that crew members could barely move without coordination; the directed navigation and attack, the managed and chart work, the engine room artificer handled propulsion and mechanical systems, and the served as diver and , often performing dual roles during dives or emergencies. This tight-knit dynamic fostered exceptional teamwork but also amplified physical and psychological strains, contributing to the overall loss of approximately 40 personnel across training accidents and operations throughout the war. Post-war, many X-class crew members transitioned to varied and roles while advocating for submariner welfare; Cameron continued submarine service until 1954, including commands on HMS Stoic and HMS Solent, before entering business, while Place rose to rear-admiral, serving in staff positions and as Director of Naval Recruitment until retirement in 1972. Hudspeth returned to teaching in , obtaining a and contributing to education until his death in 2000, and Goddard worked in engineering while preserving accounts of service.

Legacy

Operational Impact

The X-class midget submarines played a pivotal role in neutralizing the , significantly altering the strategic balance in the North Atlantic. During in September 1943, X-7 successfully placed its two 2-ton explosive charges under the battleship in Altenfjord, (X-6 was rammed before fully placing its charges), causing severe damage including the displacement of four main turrets, a gash in the hull allowing 500 tons of water ingress, and rendering the engines and propellers inoperable. This attack kept Tirpitz out of commission for six months until April 1944, effectively bottling up the German surface fleet in northern waters and preventing it from threatening Allied convoys to the . As a result, the Royal Navy could reallocate capital ships from defensive convoy duties to offensive operations elsewhere, freeing substantial resources for the broader war effort. The economic burden on was considerable, requiring extensive repairs and diverting industrial capacity amid wartime shortages. In preparation for the D-Day invasion, X-class submarines provided critical reconnaissance that mitigated risks during Operation Overlord. X-20 conducted surveys of Normandy beaches in early 1944 as part of Operation Postage Able, mapping obstacles, gradients, and defenses at Omaha Beach (with attempts at Sword Beach), contributing to overall intelligence for Gold, Sword, Utah, Omaha, and Juno beaches, while X-20 and X-23 served as navigational beacons during the landings on June 6, 1944, under Operation Gambit. Towed to positions off Sword and Juno beaches, these submarines used radio and light signals to guide the invasion fleet, ensuring precise troop deployments despite rough seas and enemy fire. This accurate intelligence reduced uncertainties about beach suitability and underwater hazards, contributing to lower casualties on the British and Canadian sectors and facilitating the rapid establishment of beachheads essential to the invasion's success. The successes of the X-class directly influenced the development of the XE-class submarines, extending the doctrine to the Pacific theater. Building on lessons from European operations, the Royal Navy commissioned 12 improved XE-class boats in , optimized for tropical waters with enhanced range, larger capacity, and better crew accommodations for extended missions. These vessels were towed by larger submarines to target Japanese-held ports, conducting like severing undersea cables and attacking anchored ships in Harbour in 1945. This transition demonstrated the versatility of midget submarines beyond European fjords, validating their role in asymmetric . Despite the high risks, the operational gains from X-class submarines outweighed their losses, shaping post-war naval innovations. Of the 27 X-class boats built, seven were lost during the war, with approximately 20 crew members killed, primarily in hazardous missions like where extreme conditions and enemy defenses claimed lives. However, these sacrifices yielded disproportionate strategic benefits, including the immobilization of major German assets and vital support for Allied invasions. The X-class's proven effectiveness inspired Cold War-era programs, such as the U.S. Navy's X-1 (commissioned 1955), which tested advanced propulsion for harbor defense and , drawing directly from British X-craft designs loaned post-war. This legacy underscored the enduring value of small, stealthy submersibles in modern .

Surviving Examples

HMS X24, the sole intact surviving example of an X-class midget submarine, is preserved and displayed at the Royal Navy Submarine Museum in , . Following its post-war decommissioning, X24 was relocated to HMS Dolphin (the Royal Navy's submarine school) around 1960 for storage under shelter amid uncertainties over its disposal. Surveys conducted in 1970 and 1971 led to a decision in 1972 to restore it as a memorial; it was transported to Dockyard in February 1973 for full restoration before returning to HMS Dolphin for display. The submarine, which participated in operations against German shipping in during , remains open to the public as a key exhibit, allowing visitors to explore its cramped interior and learn about its historical role. No other complete X-class hulls exist, though relics from HMS X7—lost during the 1943 attack on the German battleship Tirpitz in Kåfjord, Norway—have been recovered from the seafloor. The bow and battery sections were relocated in 1976 from 160 feet of water in the fjord and raised, confirming their identity through artifacts such as instruments and crew items now held in collections. Preservation of X24 is supported by its designation on the National Historic Ships register (number 1843), recognizing its significance as a rare World War II artifact. Ongoing maintenance, including a 2017 redisplay with enhanced audiovisual elements in a dedicated gallery, addresses corrosion and display logistics, though the museum—a charity—relies on public funding and donations to sustain conservation amid rising costs for historic vessel care as of 2025. In contrast, no XE-class submarines (the Pacific-adapted successors to the X-class) survive intact, but related exhibits such as detailed plans and scale models are preserved at institutions like the in Greenwich.

Cultural Depictions

Films and Literature

The X-class submarines, particularly their role in against the German battleship Tirpitz, have been portrayed in several British war films that emphasize the daring and claustrophobic nature of operations. The 1955 film Above Us the Waves, directed by , dramatizes the 1943 attack, with portraying the fictional Commander George Fraser, leading a team based on the historical X-7 mission in penetrating Norwegian fjords to place mines on the Tirpitz. The film blends elements of attacks with X-craft missions, highlighting the technical challenges and human endurance involved, though it composites multiple real events for narrative flow. Similarly, Submarine X-1 (1968), directed by William A. Graham and starring as Lt. Commander Richard Bolton, depicts a fictionalized squadron training for and executing a raid on a German battleship in a Norwegian fjord, drawing inspiration from the X-class's real-world exploits during . In literature, the X-class has inspired both non-fiction accounts and limited fictional works that capture the submarines' innovative design and high-risk missions. The seminal non-fiction book Above Us the Waves: The Story of Midget Submarines and Human Torpedoes (1956) by C.E.T. Warren and James Benson provides a detailed firsthand narrative of the development and deployment of X-craft, based on declassified records and crew interviews, serving as the basis for the 1955 of the same name. More recent non-fiction, such as Keith Hall's X3 to X54: The History of the British Midget Submarine (2023), traces the full evolution of the X-class from prototypes to postwar analysis, incorporating veteran testimonies and archival photos to underscore their strategic impact. Fictional depictions are rarer, but elements of midget submarine tension appear in Alistair MacLean's HMS Ulysses (1955), where the psychological strain of confined naval operations echoes X-craft experiences, though the novel primarily focuses on Arctic convoy duties aboard a . Documentaries have offered more factual explorations, often focusing on crew stories and archaeological remnants. The BBC's Timewatch episode "Lost Heroes of the Tirpitz" (2004) investigates the raid through diver expeditions to wreck sites and interviews with survivors' families, revealing the human cost, with 9 British personnel killed and 6 captured during the raid. Modern podcasts, such as the Society for Nautical Research's The Mariner's Mirror Podcast episode "The WW2 Midget Submarines of Aberlady Bay" (2021), examine surviving X-craft wrecks off using archaeological surveys, providing audio insights into training accidents and preservation efforts. These portrayals frequently balance heroism with the grim realities of X-class service, but accuracy varies; films like Above Us the Waves and condense timelines, alter crew dynamics, and heighten dramatic tension for cinematic effect, diverging from historical records where navigation errors and mechanical failures played larger roles than depicted. and documentaries, by contrast, adhere closer to verified accounts from naval archives, emphasizing the submarines' role in neutralizing threats without aerial support.

Other Media

The X-class submarines have been depicted in several television documentaries focusing on naval operations. In the 2009 series , episode 7 ("Turning the Tide") describes the deployment of six British X-craft into Norwegian fjords during in September 1943, aimed at targeting the German battleship Tirpitz. The 1973 ITV series includes a brief segment on tactics in later episodes covering wartime naval operations, touching on innovative British involving small submersibles like the X-class. In video games, the X-class appears through community modifications in submarine simulation titles. The Silent Hunter series, particularly versions 3 and 4 (released 2005 and 2007), features user-created mods enabling play as British X-craft, including work-in-progress add-ons for missions simulating harbor penetrations and limpet mine attacks, as discussed in dedicated forums for the game's community. Strategy games like Hearts of Iron IV (2016) incorporate X-class elements via total conversion mods that expand naval tech trees to include midget submarines for special forces operations, though these are unofficial extensions rather than core content. Modern digital media has revived interest in the X-class through online platforms. YouTube channel Drachinifel, in its 2019 video "Midget Submarines of WW2 - Small and Possibly Deadly?", provides an in-depth analysis of the British X-class, highlighting their diesel-electric propulsion adapted from bus engines, two-ton charge capacity, and key roles in the Tirpitz raid and D-Day reconnaissance. The podcast We Have Ways of Making You Talk, hosted by Al Murray and James Holland, covers midget submarines including the X-class in episode 25 ("Nazi Drugs and Midget Subs," 2019), discussing their tactical innovations alongside Axis counterparts. In 2025, the podcast released a video episode exploring the surviving X-24 submarine at the National Museum of the Royal Navy. As of November 2025, no dedicated VR simulations of X-class operations exist, but general WWII submarine VR titles like IronWolf VR (2017) offer analogous immersive experiences in midget sub scenarios. Online exhibits, such as the National Museum of the Royal Navy's digital resources on X-24 (the sole surviving example), have been updated for the 80th anniversary of Operation Source, featuring interactive timelines of X-craft missions.

References

  1. https://rnsubs.co.uk/index.php?PageID=794
  2. https://www.coppsurvey.uk/xcraft
  3. https://www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofBritain/D-Day-X-Craft/
  4. https://www.nmrn.org.uk/visit-us/submarine-museum/x24
  5. https://rnsubs.co.uk/articles/service/chariots.html
  6. https://ww2db.com/ship_spec.php?ship_id=1820
  7. http://coastkid.blogspot.com/2012/01/ww2-xt-class-submarine-wrecks-aberlady.html
  8. https://www.marinetechnologynews.com/blogs/x-craft-midget-submarines-700371
  9. https://rnsubs.co.uk/index.php?PageID=1242
  10. https://rnsubs.co.uk/boats/subs/x-craft.html
  11. https://www.militaryfactory.com/ships/detail.php?ship_id=HMS-Xclass-Xcraft
  12. https://rnsubs.co.uk/index.php?PageID=1186
  13. https://kirkheatonhistorygroup.co.uk/thomas-broadbents-d-day-submarine-x-20/
  14. https://theddaystory.com/markers/hms-varbel-ii-12th-submarine-flotilla-headquarters-argyll-and-bute/
  15. https://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/80009605
  16. https://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/80009739
  17. https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1947/april/life-midget-submarine
  18. https://www.coppsurvey.uk/latest-news/x-craft-training
  19. https://www.naval-history.net/WW2CampaignsBritishSubs2.htm
  20. https://www.defensemedianetwork.com/stories/operation-source-the-british-midget-submarine-attack-on-the-tirpitz/
  21. https://www.naval-history.net/WW2aBritishLosses05SS.htm
  22. https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/1963/march/british-submarine-operations-world-war-ii
  23. https://www.facebook.com/NatMuseumRN/posts/on-the-morning-of-9-april-1944-midget-submarine-x24-in-tow-behind-the-s-class-su/836708568483299/
  24. https://www.worldnavalships.com/forums/thread.php?threadid=6569
  25. https://www.historynet.com/dday-secret-submarines/
  26. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cv28w27r8ddo
  27. https://codenames.info/operation/heckle/
  28. https://www.jalopnik.com/how-the-royal-navys-x-class-midget-subs-helped-make-d-d-1709530716/
  29. http://www.bute-at-war.org/gallery/lostmidgets.pdf
  30. https://rnsubs.co.uk/index.php?PageID=809
  31. https://www.maritimequest.com/warship_directory/great_britain/submarines/pages/x_craft/x24_data.htm
  32. https://www.worldnavalships.com/directory/shipinfo.php?ShipID=3744
  33. https://vcgca.org/our-people/profile/1469/Donald-CAMERON
  34. https://www.royalnavy.mod.uk/news/2020/july/31/200731-75th-anniversary-of-the-last-vcs-won-by-submariners
  35. https://www.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/rmgc-object-14427
  36. https://www.noonans.co.uk/news-and-events/latest-news/346/
  37. https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/hudspeth-kenneth-robert--ken-32457
  38. https://navyhistory.au/occasional-paper-46-lieutenant-kenneth-robert-hudspeth-dsc-ranvr/
  39. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4gldy71njjo
  40. https://rnsubs.co.uk/crew/vc-winners/cameron.html
  41. https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/taking-out-the-tirpitz/
  42. https://www.usni.org/magazines/naval-history-magazine/2023/august/smallest-boat
  43. https://naval-encyclopedia.com/cold-war/us/ss-x1.php
  44. https://www.nationalhistoricships.org.uk/register/1843/x24
  45. https://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/30004580
  46. https://www.rmg.co.uk/collections/objects/rmgc-object-1195458
  47. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0047797/
  48. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0063655/
  49. https://thehistorypress.co.uk/publication/x3-to-x54/
  50. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0078sgc
  51. https://snr.org.uk/the-mariners-mirror-podcast/the-ww2-midget-submarines-of-aberlady-bay/
  52. https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/wwtwo/tirpitz_heroes_01.shtml
  53. https://subslikescript.com/series/World_War_II_in_Colour-2069688/season-1/episode-7-Turning_the_Tide
  54. https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=201595
  55. https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=731921386
  56. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zt1O8RIX9pw
  57. https://podcasts.apple.com/mt/podcast/25-nazi-drugs-and-midget-subs/id1457552694?i=1000447307071
  58. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JenyGGG98VY
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.