Hubbry Logo
Apparitional experienceApparitional experienceMain
Open search
Apparitional experience
Community hub
Apparitional experience
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Apparitional experience
Apparitional experience
Apparitional experience
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Part of a series on the
Paranormal
Main articles
Skepticism
Parapsychology
Related

In parapsychology, an apparitional experience is an anomalous experience characterized by the apparent perception of either a living being or an inanimate object without there being any material stimulus for such a perception.

In academic discussion, the term "apparitional experience" is preferred to the term "ghost" because:

  1. The term ghost implies that some element of the human being survives death and, at least under certain circumstances, can make itself perceptible to living human beings. There are other competing explanations of apparitional experiences.
  2. Firsthand accounts of apparitional experiences differ in many respects from their fictional counterparts in literary or traditional ghost stories and films (see below).
  3. The content of apparitional experiences includes living beings, both human and animal, and even inanimate objects.[1]

History

[edit]

Attempts to apply modern scientific or investigative standards to the study of apparitional experiences began with the work of Edmund Gurney, Frederic W. H. Myers and Frank Podmore,[2] who were leading figures in the early years of the Society for Psychical Research (founded in 1882). Their motive, as with most of the early work of the Society,[3] was to provide evidence for human survival after death. For this reason they had a particular interest in what are known as "crisis cases". These are cases in which a person reports having a hallucinatory experience, visual or otherwise, which apparently represents someone at a distance; this experience subsequently being considered to have coincided with that person's death, or a significant life event of some kind. If the temporal coincidence of the crisis and the distant apparitional experience cannot be explained by any conventional means, then in parapsychology the presumption is made that some as yet unknown form of communication, such as telepathy (a term coined by Myers[4]) has taken place.[citation needed]

While it may be said that the work of Gurney and his colleagues failed to provide convincing evidence for either telepathy or survival of death, the large collection of firsthand written accounts which resulted from their methods may nevertheless be regarded as providing a valuable body of data concerning the phenomenology of hallucinations in the sane.

A later discussion of apparitional experiences was that of G. N. M. Tyrrell,[5] also a leading member of the Society for Psychical Research of his day. He accepted the hallucinatory character of the experience, pointing out that it is virtually unknown for firsthand accounts to claim that apparitional figures leave any of the normal physical effects, such as footprints in snow, that one would expect of a real person.[6] He develops the idea that the apparition may be a way for the unconscious part of the mind to bring to consciousness information that has been paranormally acquired – in crisis cases, for example. He introduces an evocative metaphor of a mental "stage-carpenter",[7] behind the scenes in the unconscious part of the mind, and constructing the quasi-perceptual experience that eventually appears on the stage of consciousness, so that it embodies paranormal information in a symbolic way, a person drowning at a distance appearing soaked in water, for example.

The study and discussion of apparitions developed in a different direction in the 1970s, with the work of Celia Green and Charles McCreery.[8] They were not primarily interested in the question of whether apparitions could shed any light on the existence or otherwise of telepathy, or in the survival question; instead they were concerned to analyse a large number of cases with a view to providing a taxonomy of the different types of experience, viewed simply as a type of anomalous perceptual experience or hallucination.

One of the points that was highlighted by their work was point (2) listed above, namely that "real-life" accounts of apparitional experiences differ markedly from the traditional or literary ghost story. These are some of the more notable differences, at least as indicated by their own collection of 1800 firsthand accounts:

  • Subjects of apparitional experiences are by no means always frightened by the experience; indeed they may find them soothing or reassuring at times of crisis or ongoing stress in their lives.[9]
  • Spontaneous apparitional experiences tend to happen in humdrum or everyday surroundings, and under conditions of low central nervous system arousal, most often in the subject's own home – while doing housework, for example. By contrast, subjects who visit reputedly haunted locations in hopes of "seeing a ghost" are more often than not disappointed.[10]
  • Apparitions tend to be reported as appearing solid and not transparent; indeed they may be so realistic in a variety of ways as to deceive the percipient as to their hallucinatory nature; in some cases the subject only achieves insight after the experience has ended.[11]
  • It is unusual for an apparitional figure to engage in any verbal interaction with the percipient; this is consistent with the finding that the majority of such experiences only involve one sense (most commonly the visual).[12]

Psychological implications

[edit]

Psychological theories of perception

[edit]

Apparitional experiences have relevance to psychological theories of perception, and in particular to the distinction between top-down and bottom-up approaches (cf. article on Top-down and bottom-up design). Top-down theories, such as that of Richard Langton Gregory, who conceives of perception as a process whereby the brain makes a series of hypotheses about the external world,[13] stress the importance of central factors such as memory and expectation in determining the phenomenological content of perception; while the bottom-up approach, exemplified by the work of James J. Gibson, emphasises the role of the external sensory stimulus.[14]

Apparitional experiences would seem to lend support to the importance of central factors, since they represent a form of quasi-perceptual experience in which the role of external stimuli is minimal or possibly non-existent, while the experience nevertheless continues to be phenomenologically indistinguishable from normal perception, at least in some cases.[15]

Schizotypy

[edit]

The interest of apparitional experiences to psychology has acquired an added dimension in recent years with the development of the concept of schizotypy or psychosis-proneness.[16] This is conceived of as a dimension of personality,[17] continuously distributed throughout the normal population, and analogous to the dimensions of extraversion or neuroticism. As long as mental illness is regarded under the disease model, according to which a person either does or does not 'have' schizophrenia or manic depression, just as a person either does or does not have syphilis or tuberculosis, then to talk of the occurrence of an apparitional or hallucinatory experience in a normal person is either an oxymoron, or to be taken as an indication of latent or incipient psychosis. If, on the contrary, a dimensional view of the matter is taken, it becomes easier to conceive of how normal people, more or less high on the putative schizotypy dimension, might be more or less prone to anomalous perceptual experiences, without their ever tipping over into psychosis.[18]

Green and McCreery's identification of a class of what they called 'reassuring apparitions'[9] is of particular interest in this regard, as it suggests that the experiencing of hallucinations may even have an adaptive effect in certain subjects, making them better able to cope with adverse life events. This would fit with the model of schizotypy as essentially a normal dimension of personality, and might help to explain why the proneness to anomalous perceptual experiences has apparently not been 'weeded out' by the process of natural selection.

Philosophical implications

[edit]

Direct realism

[edit]

Apparitional experiences also have implications for the philosophy of perception. The occurrence of hallucinations, that is, perceptual experiences 'having the character of sense perception, but without relevant or adequate sensory stimulation [...]',[19] have long been one of the standard objections to the philosophical theory of direct realism. According to this theory we are in some sense in direct contact with the external world when we seem to be perceiving it, and not merely in direct contact with some mediating representation in our mind, such as a sense-datum or an image, which may or may not correspond to external reality. The psychologist J.J. Gibson, referred to above, became an advocate of the philosophical theory of direct realism.[20]

Hallucinatory experiences reported by sane people do not pose any new problem in principle for the theory of direct realism, other than that posed already by the more widely discussed hallucinations reported by people in a state of psychosis or under other abnormal conditions such as sensory deprivation. They pose the problem in a particularly stark way, for the following reasons:

Scepticism about the status of verbal reports

[edit]

In the case of hallucinations reported to have occurred in pathological or abnormal states there is some scope for uncertainty about the accuracy, or even the meaning, of the percipient's verbal report. Horowitz,[21] for example, summarising his experience of questioning patients with chronic schizophrenia about their visual experiences during painting sessions, wrote:

'It was necessary to persist beyond initial verbal descriptions of their hallucinations, and insist that the patient describe and draw what he had seen. Initial descriptions of "vicious snakes" might then be drawn and redescribed as wavy lines. "Two armies struggling over my soul" arose from the subjective experience of seeing moving sets of dots. "Spiders" might be reduced, when the patient stated and drew what he actually saw, to a few radiating lines. In drawings of their hallucinations patients could often distinguish between those forms which duplicated what they saw with their eyes from those forms which were what they "made out of it".'[22]

Such difficulties of interpretation are much less obvious in the case of written reports by ostensibly normal subjects, in good health and not medicated at the time of the experience.

Extreme realism of the experience

[edit]

At least some of the apparitional experiences reported by normal subjects appear to mimic normal perception to such a degree that the subject is deceived into thinking that what they are experiencing actually is normal perception. Similar close mimicking of normal perception is reported by some of the subjects of a lucid dream[23] and out-of-body experiences,[24] which therefore pose similar problems for the theory of direct realism.

Representationalism

[edit]

Apparitional experiences appear prima facie more compatible with the philosophical theory of representationalism. According to this theory, the immediate objects of experience when we are perceiving the world normally are representations of the world, rather than the world itself. These representations have been variously called sense-data or images. In the case of an apparitional experience one might say that the subject is aware of sense-data or images which happen not to correspond to, or represent, the external world in the normal way.

The philosophical implications of hallucinatory experiences in the sane are discussed by McCreery.[25] He argues that they provide empirical support for the theory of representationalism rather than direct realism.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Apparitional experience

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
An apparitional experience is an anomalous sensory perception of a figure, typically a person or animal—whether living or deceased—that is not physically present and lies beyond the percipient's normal range of sensory input. These experiences, often termed apparitions, have been documented across cultures and historical periods, with systematic investigation beginning in the late through organizations like the . In parapsychological research, apparitions are classified into types such as crisis apparitions (occurring near the time of a significant event like ), posthumous apparitions (of the deceased), and recurrent apparitions (repeated sightings in specific locations). Surveys indicate that 10% to 27% of the general population report having had such experiences, with higher rates (up to 30%-35%) for after-death communications among bereaved individuals. Visual perceptions dominate, comprising about 84% of reports, while auditory (37%), tactile (18%), and other sensory modalities occur less frequently; many experiences are collective, involving multiple witnesses in 33% to 56% of cases. These phenomena frequently arise in contexts of bereavement, emotional distress, or near-death situations, and are often described as comforting or informative rather than frightening. Explanatory models range from psychological factors like grief-induced hallucinations to environmental influences such as or electromagnetic fields, though parapsychologists emphasize potential veridical elements—accurate details unknowable by normal means—as evidence for or survival after . Despite ongoing debate, apparitional experiences remain a focal point for interdisciplinary study in , , and anomalous cognition.

Definition and Characteristics

Core Definition

An apparitional experience is characterized as an anomalous sensory involving the apparent manifestation of a figure or object—such as a deceased , spirit, or animal—that lacks any corresponding physical presence in the environment. These experiences are predominantly visual, manifesting as clear sightings of forms or ethereal entities, though they may also incorporate auditory components, like whispers or footsteps, or tactile sensations, such as a fleeting touch. In parapsychological literature, this is delineated as a quasi-perceptual event where the percipient senses the presence of something ostensibly external, yet unverifiable through ordinary sensory verification. Unlike typical hallucinations, which often arise from identifiable physiological or psychological triggers such as substance use, neurological disorders, or mental illness, apparitional experiences occur in the absence of such evident causes, positioning them as unexplained perceptual anomalies within everyday contexts. Hallucinations are broadly defined as sensory impressions without external stimuli, but apparitions are distinguished by their spontaneous onset in otherwise normal states of and their specific thematic focus on absent figures, often evoking a of otherworldliness rather than mere distortion. This differentiation underscores the anomalous nature of apparitions, which resist reduction to standard psychopathological models without additional etiological factors. The term "apparition" originates from the Latin verb apparere, meaning "to appear" or "to come into sight," entering as appāritiō to denote an or manifestation; by the , it appeared in via , initially in religious contexts, and evolved by the to specifically signify ghostly or sightings in usage. This linguistic shift reflects a cultural progression from neutral appearances to phenomena, aligning with historical accounts of otherworldly encounters. Key characteristics of apparitional experiences include their vivid realism, often indistinguishable from ordinary perceptions; profound emotional , which can range from comforting reassurance to intense or ; and transient duration, typically spanning mere seconds to a few minutes before fading. These attributes contribute to the experiences' memorability and their frequent interpretation as significant, non-ordinary events by those who report them.

Types and Features

Apparitional experiences are classified into several distinct types based on their timing, the status of the apparitional figure, and the involvement of witnesses, as outlined in early systematic investigations. Crisis apparitions occur in connection with moments of acute distress or peril to the agent, such as imminent or severe injury, often manifesting to a percipient at or near the exact time of the event. Posthumous apparitions involve figures of deceased individuals appearing after their , typically within hours or days, and may convey or reassurance related to the passing. Collective apparitions are those simultaneously perceived by multiple independent witnesses, providing corroboration and occurring in various settings, including shared crises or posthumous visitations. Reciprocal apparitions feature mutual perceptions between the agent and percipient, where both parties experience sensory impressions of one another, often in pre-arranged or emotionally charged scenarios. These experiences predominantly involve visual perceptions, with figures appearing as translucent, luminous, or solid forms dressed in familiar attire, though auditory elements such as voices calling names or uttering words are also common. Less frequently, olfactory sensations like scents associated with the figure or kinesthetic impressions such as touches or pressures occur, and certain apparitions are triggered by environmental factors, including specific locations reputed as haunted sites. Most apparitional experiences are transient, one-off events lasting from seconds to under five minutes, with the figure often fading abruptly or dissolving. Recurrent cases are uncommon but can be linked to ongoing personal trauma or , manifesting repeatedly over days or weeks in susceptible individuals. Demographic patterns from large-scale surveys indicate that such experiences are reported more frequently by women than men, with affirmative rates of approximately 12% among respondents compared to 7.8% among males in a sample of over 17,000 individuals. They are particularly prevalent in contexts of bereavement, where about 8% of cases involve over a recent or anxiety about a dying relative.

Historical Perspectives

Ancient and Pre-Modern Accounts

Apparitional experiences appear in some of the earliest recorded Mesopotamian literature, such as the , composed around 2100 BCE, where the shade of rises from the underworld to converse with about the , providing one of the oldest depictions of a ghostly apparition summoned through ritual descent. In ancient , Plato's dialogues from the 4th century BCE, including the and , describe shades or souls in the underworld as ethereal figures encountered during philosophical reflections on death and immortality, portraying them as diminished remnants of the living seeking judgment or reunion. Roman accounts from the 1st century CE, such as Pliny the Younger's letter to Licinius Sura (Epistulae 7.27), recount a haunted house plagued by the apparition of a rattling chain-wearing that predicts death, illustrating early classical narratives of spirits as omens tied to unrested souls. During the medieval period, Christian hagiographies from the frequently documented visions of saints or demons as apparitional encounters, such as in the lives of holy figures where spectral demons tempted ascetics or saints appeared to guide the faithful, emphasizing through these manifestations. In Islamic traditions, hadiths from the 7th to 9th centuries describe as invisible beings capable of apparitional sightings, with authentic narrations in and recounting instances where appeared in human or animal forms to interact with prophets or believers, often as tests of or bearers of messages. Pre-modern preserved apparitional experiences in oral and early written traditions across cultures, including Celtic tales of apparitions like the in Irish lore, documented from the 14th century onward in medieval and sagas as a wailing female spirit foretelling death to specific families. Among Indigenous American peoples, oral traditions recount spirit walks or ghostly encounters, such as ancestral spirits appearing in visions during rituals to offer guidance or warn of dangers, varying by tribe but commonly integrated into narratives of connection between the living and the deceased. These ancient and pre-modern accounts framed apparitional experiences as omens of impending events, divine or messages, and evidence of an , profoundly shaping societal practices like elaborate to appease restless shades in Mesopotamian and Greek contexts, or exorcism rituals to expel demonic apparitions in Christian and Islamic traditions.

Modern Investigations

The (SPR) was founded in 1882 in the to systematically investigate claims of phenomena, including apparitional experiences, through empirical methods. In 1886, SPR members Edmund Gurney, , and Frank Podmore published Phantasms of the Living, a seminal two-volume work that compiled and analyzed over 700 cases of apparitions gathered via a of spontaneous experiences reported by witnesses. This effort marked an early shift toward organized documentation, emphasizing veridical details such as apparitions conveying accurate information unknown to the percipient. Gurney and Myers classified apparitions into two primary categories: telepathic apparitions, arising from the mental influence of a living agent (often during a ), and independent apparitions, which occur without such influence and may suggest postmortem . This framework influenced subsequent research by prioritizing the timing, content, and collective perception of sightings to assess evidential value. In 1953, G. N. M. Tyrrell refined these ideas in his book Apparitions, proposing a typology that included apparitions (linked to immediate threats or deaths), retrocognitive apparitions (depicting past events), experimental apparitions (evoked in controlled settings), and recurrent apparitions (repeated in specific locations). Tyrrell's model, based on SPR case files, highlighted the role of "idea-patterns" in shaping perceptual experiences while maintaining a focus on verifiable elements like unrecognized figures providing factual insights. In the United States, the (ASPR) was established in 1885 as the first organization dedicated to similar inquiries, conducting parallel collections of apparition reports and cross-referencing them with SPR data. By the mid-20th century, researchers like extended this tradition; in a 1995 analysis published in the Journal of Scientific Exploration, he examined six modern cases where apparitions displayed veridical features, such as identifying deceased individuals through details inaccessible to the witnesses beforehand. Stevenson's work underscored persistent patterns, including auditory and visual components, in apparitions tied to emotional crises. Methodological approaches evolved from initial reliance on anecdotal questionnaires to more rigorous techniques, including structured interviews, witness corroboration, and on-site environmental evaluations. For instance, during the , SPR investigators like and conducted extended probes at sites of reported hauntings, such as the Enfield case (1977–1979), employing audio recordings, photographic documentation, and systematic monitoring of physical conditions to distinguish apparitional claims from other disturbances. These efforts aimed to enhance reliability by integrating multidisciplinary tools, though challenges in replicating spontaneous events persisted.

Psychological and Neurological Explanations

Perceptual Theories

Perceptual theories posit that apparitional experiences arise from errors in and cognitive interpretation rather than external entities. These explanations emphasize how the constructs perceptions from ambiguous or incomplete sensory input, often under conditions that impair normal perceptual accuracy. Such theories frame apparitions as illusions generated by the interaction of environmental cues, physiological states, and psychological expectations, aligning with broader understandings of hallucinations and misperceptions in . The misperception hypothesis highlights mechanisms like , where random patterns in the environment are misinterpreted as meaningful forms, such as faces or figures, particularly in low-light settings that reduce visual clarity. For instance, shadows or reflections in dimly lit rooms can trigger the perception of humanoid shapes due to the brain's tendency to impose familiar structures on ambiguous stimuli. Similarly, autoscopy involves illusory visions of one's own body or a double, often linked to disruptions in self-perception during stress or , mimicking apparitional encounters by creating a sense of an externalized self-presence. These processes are exacerbated in suboptimal conditions, where sensory noise leads to false positives in . Expectation and priming further contribute by shaping perceptual thresholds, where prior beliefs about a location—such as its reputation for hauntings—induce hypervigilance and bias toward interpreting neutral stimuli as anomalous. Cultural narratives about haunted sites can prime individuals to anticipate apparitions, lowering the threshold for detecting patterns and increasing false alarms in sensory processing. Studies of environmental factors in reputedly haunted buildings show that architectural features like uneven lighting or confined spaces heighten arousal, promoting hypervigilant states that amplify misperceptions of ordinary sounds or movements as ghostly. Neurological theories focus on brain activity, particularly in the , where transient electrical disturbances can evoke vivid, apparition-like experiences. Michael Persinger's research proposed that microseizures or stimulated activity in temporal lobe structures generate religious or mystical visions, including sensed presences or figures, by altering interhemispheric communication. His "God Helmet" experiments in the 1990s applied weak magnetic fields to the temporal lobes, inducing reports of sensed presences or out-of-body sensations in some participants, supporting the idea that such experiences stem from endogenous neural patterns rather than external input, although independent replication attempts have largely failed. Sensory deprivation and emotional states like also elevate susceptibility to anomalous perceptions by disrupting normal sensory integration. Research from the 1960s on isolation tanks demonstrated that prolonged reduction of external stimuli leads to spontaneous hallucinations, including visual apparitions, as the compensates by generating internal imagery. In bereavement, disrupts sensorimotor expectations, prompting misperceptions of the deceased through heightened pattern-seeking in ambiguous cues, such as familiar scents or shadows, which the attributes to an absent loved one. These effects underscore how deprivation or emotional distress can mimic apparitional encounters via altered perceptual processing. Research indicates that individuals with elevated schizotypy, a dimension characterized by unusual perceptual experiences and magical thinking, exhibit greater proneness to apparitional experiences. High scores on measures such as the Launay-Slade Hallucination Scale (LSHS), which assesses predisposition to -like events including visual apparitions, reliably predict such reports in non-clinical populations. This correlation is particularly linked to the schizotypal trait of openness to fantasy, as demonstrated in early studies by Thalbourne, where was associated with increased anomalous perceptual events like apparitions. Apparitional experiences also show associations with certain mental health contexts, though these do not imply inherent . In bereavement, for instance, approximately 47% of widows and widowers reported sensory encounters with their deceased , often visual or auditory apparitions, providing emotional comfort without distress. Similar experiences occur in , where hypnagogic or hypnopompic hallucinations manifest as apparitional figures, interpreted as ghostly presences in cultural narratives. Among individuals with (PTSD), hallucinations including visual apparitions are reported at elevated rates, potentially tied to trauma re-experiencing. Personality traits further modulate susceptibility to apparitional experiences. The absorption trait, measured by the Tellegen Absorption Scale, identifies individuals prone to immersive imaginative states, who are more likely to report vivid, apparition-like perceptions. In non-clinical populations, such experiences often involve low levels of pathological dissociation, aligning instead with benign imaginative absorption rather than detachment or depersonalization. Demographically, apparitional reports are more frequent among those in creative professions and under stress, as evidenced in analyses linking to imaginative vocations and situational pressures across over 1,000 cases.

Philosophical Implications

Direct Realism

Direct realism, also known as , posits that perceptual experiences involve a direct acquaintance with ordinary objects in the external world, without the mediation of mental intermediaries such as sense-data or representations. This view, defended by philosopher in his 1962 work Sense and Sensibilia, argues against indirect theories by emphasizing that in veridical perception, one perceives the world as it is, unfiltered by internal constructs. Austin critiques sense-datum theories, maintaining that ordinary perception provides immediate access to material objects, challenging the notion that illusions or errors require positing non-physical intermediaries. Apparitional experiences pose significant challenges to direct realism, particularly through reports of veridical apparitions—cases where the perceived figure conveys accurate unknown to the witness at the time. For instance, in parapsychological investigations, witnesses have described apparitions revealing precise details about distant events or deceased individuals, suggesting the involvement of non-physical entities that undermine the reliability of sensory access to a purely material . Such cases imply that may not always track physical objects directly, as the experiences occur without corresponding external stimuli, forcing direct realists to confront the possibility of unmediated encounters with the non-material. Skeptics of apparitional reports within a direct realist framework highlight the unreliability of verbal accounts, attributing them to memory confabulation akin to the demonstrated in . Elizabeth Loftus's 1970s studies showed how post-event can distort eyewitness memories, leading to fabricated details in recollections of events. Applied to ghost sightings, this effect suggests that apparitional narratives may arise from or cultural expectations contaminating initial perceptions, rather than direct sensory contact with anomalous entities, thus preserving direct realism by questioning the evidential weight of such testimonies. Proponents of an "extreme" form of direct realism counter that the vividness of apparitional experiences indicates a literal presence, yet the absence of —such as measurable traces or corroborative artifacts—fuels ongoing debates about interpretive overreach. This perspective argues that the phenomenological intensity of sightings aligns with unmediated , but without empirical verification, it risks conflating subjective immediacy with objective reality, prompting critiques that direct realism inadequately accounts for hallucination-like phenomena.

Representationalism

Representationalism in the posits that all perceptual , including apparitions, consist of brain-constructed representations whose content determines their phenomenal character. According to this view, perceptions are not direct encounters with external objects but intentional states where the mind represents the world through mind-dependent content, such as properties and relations inferred by cognitive processes. Michael Tye's intentionalist account, for instance, argues that the qualitative feel of an arises from what it represents, whether veridical or not, emphasizing that representational content is constitutive of itself. Applied to apparitional experiences, representationalism interprets these as internally generated simulations that misfire due to memory recall, expectation, or imaginative processes, rather than external stimuli. Such experiences resemble dream-like intrusions into , where the produces vivid representations without corresponding sensory input, leading to the of an external presence. This framework aligns with the idea that hallucinations, including apparitions, share the same representational structure as veridical perceptions but lack accurate causal grounding in the environment. Philosophical support for this application draws from dual-component theories distinguishing intentional content (what the experience is about) from phenomenal content (how it feels), allowing apparitions to seem realistically present despite their internal origin. argues that while intentional content can be non-veridical, the phenomenal aspect retains a representational structure that accounts for the subjective immediacy of such experiences. This explains why apparitions feel as "real" as ordinary perceptions, as the brain's representational mechanisms do not differentiate sharply between sourced and unsourced content. Critiques of representationalism highlight its difficulty in explaining collective veridical apparitions, where multiple independent witnesses report identical, accurate details of events or figures not physically present, challenging the notion of purely internal simulations. Such cases suggest possibilities beyond localized brain processes.

Cultural and Parapsychological Contexts

Role in Folklore and Religion

Apparitional experiences have long been integrated into as manifestations of unresolved souls or ancestral presences, shaping narratives that explain the liminal space between . In European traditions, legend, emerging in medieval accounts from the 12th and 13th centuries, depicts a spectral procession of ghostly hunters led by figures like or demonic entities, often interpreted as damned or restless souls pursuing the living as punishment for earthly transgressions. Similarly, in African Zulu , amadlozi—ancestral spirits—are believed to appear in visitations to guide or warn descendants, maintaining familial bonds and influencing daily decisions through dreams or direct encounters, as documented in historical ethnographies of Zulu society. In religious contexts, apparitions serve as divine or interventions, reinforcing doctrinal beliefs about the . Within , the 1917 apparitions of the Virgin Mary at , , culminated in the on October 13, witnessed by an estimated 70,000 people, who reported seeing the sun dance and change colors, interpreted as a call for repentance and validation of eternal life through Marian devotion. In , bhoot—restless spirits of the prematurely deceased—are described in ancient texts like the as wandering entities causing misfortune unless appeased through rituals, embodying unresolved karma and the cycle of rebirth. Buddhist traditions, particularly in Tibetan lore, portray or as tormented beings in one of the six realms of samsara, driven by insatiable greed from past lives, appearing to remind practitioners of attachment's perils and the need for compassion. These experiences fulfill multiple functions across cultures, acting as moral warnings against vice, validations of continuity, and shamanic guides for spiritual journeys. Ghostly encounters in often caution against behaviors like Sabbath-breaking or greed, as seen in tales where participants face eternal unrest, while in shamanic practices, spirits provide counsel during rituals to navigate crises or heal communities. Such apparitions influence religious rituals, notably Mexico's , which originated in the as a syncretic blend of indigenous Mesoamerican beliefs and Spanish Catholic , where families construct ofrendas to welcome returning ancestral spirits, ensuring their safe passage and affirming familial ties beyond death. Cross-culturally, apparitional beliefs exhibit widespread patterns tied to animistic worldviews, with anthropological studies from the indicating that explanations for phenomena like or misfortune, including spirit sightings, appear in over 80% of sampled societies, underscoring their role in addressing existential uncertainties.

Contemporary and Beliefs

In the and , the (SPR) continued to document spontaneous apparitional experiences through case collections and surveys, building on historical efforts to identify veridical elements where apparitions conveyed information later verified as accurate. Analyses of contemporary reports have highlighted patterns in crisis apparitions, suggesting potential psi-mediated perception in some cases. A 2018 meta-analysis by Etzel Cardeña reviewed experimental evidence for parapsychological phenomena, finding statistically significant effects across 108 studies with an overall of 0.20, which some parapsychologists extend to support broader psi influences potentially relevant to apparitions. Neuroimaging studies in the 2020s have explored the mechanisms underlying -related visions, often interpreted as apparitions by experiencers. on complicated has shown neural correlates, including involvement in processing stimuli, which may contribute to the emotional intensity and realism of experiences involving deceased loved ones. These findings align with broader parapsychological inquiries into how bereavement triggers that mimic apparitional encounters. Parapsychologists have advanced the survival hypothesis, positing that some apparitions represent discarnate consciousness persisting after death. Bruce Greyson's 2021 book After synthesizes decades of near-death experience (NDE) data, linking apparition-like visions during NDEs—such as encounters with deceased relatives conveying veridical information—to evidence for postmortem survival, with over 1,000 cases analyzed showing consistent themes of non-physical awareness. Critiques of fraudulent claims have employed digital forensic analysis, such as pixel anomaly detection in purported ghost photographs, to identify manipulations, emphasizing rigorous verification in parapsychological research. Public beliefs in apparitions and ghosts have remained stable or slightly increased in the , influenced by media portrayals. A 2021 Ipsos poll found 36% of Americans believe in ghosts, up from 32% in Gallup's 2005 survey, with younger demographics showing higher endorsement rates; as of 2023, a Gallup poll reported 41% belief among Americans. Ghost-hunting shows, proliferating since the early with series like Ghost Hunters (2004-2016), have boosted perceptions of scientific legitimacy, as a 2012 study demonstrated that framing paranormal investigations as evidence-based increases viewer belief. Globally, the 2020s have seen a surge in apparitional reports facilitated by , with ghost-detection apps like GhostTube and EVP Radar downloaded millions of times, correlating with increased user-submitted encounters. In , apparitions are increasingly interpreted through quantum theories, such as entanglement suggesting interconnected beyond physical , as explored in works blending physics with to frame ghosts as energy imprints in the quantum field.

References

  1. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283087634_%27Do_Ghosts_Exist%27_A_summary_of_parapsychological_research_into_apparitional_experience
  2. https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/wp-content/uploads/sites/360/2017/09/Six-Modern-Apparitional-Experiences-Stevenson-JSE-1995.pdf
  3. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/19349637.2025.2500324
  4. https://www.academia.edu/564376/Apparitional_Experiences_A_Primer_on_Parapsychological_Research_and_Perspectives
  5. https://www.aiprinc.org/apparitions/
  6. https://psi-encyclopedia.spr.ac.uk/articles/ghosts-and-apparitions-psi-research-overview
  7. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/apparition
  8. https://www.etymonline.com/word/appear
  9. https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/jnp.13.4.515
  10. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/psychological-medicine/article/varieties-of-felt-presence-three-surveys-of-presence-phenomena-and-their-relations-to-psychopathology/C7DD60644076559D5685D51226693E5D
  11. https://ia601502.us.archive.org/35/items/phantasmsoflivin001gurn/phantasmsoflivin001gurn.pdf
  12. https://iapsop.com/archive/materials/spr_proceedings/spr_proceedings_v10_1894.pdf
  13. https://omnika.org/texts/107
  14. https://www.jstor.org/stable/20522292
  15. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/230691784_Phantom_Past_Indigenous_Presence_Native_Ghosts_in_North_American_Culture_and_History
  16. https://isac.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/uploads/shared/docs/misc_gilgamesh.pdf
  17. https://www.spr.ac.uk/about/our-history
  18. https://books.google.com/books/about/Phantasms_of_the_Living.html?id=BoIDiafA9ToC
  19. http://www.aspr.com/who.htm
  20. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-020-01364-7
  21. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3032659/
  22. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4482736/
  23. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7304295/
  24. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.2466/pms.1983.57.3f.1255
  25. https://journals.lww.com/jonmd/fulltext/2002/08000/experimental_facilitation_of_the_sensed_presence_.8.aspx
  26. https://www.bps.org.uk/psychologist/neuroscience-soul
  27. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4354964/
  28. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11097-021-09759-6
  29. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2215001325000265
  30. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237230606_Seeing_and_feeling_ghosts_Absorption_fantasy_proneness_and_healthy_schizotypy_as_predictors_of_crisis_apparition_experiences
  31. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1799198/
  32. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10487786/
  33. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10658640/
  34. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8364205/
  35. https://www.sdu.dk/da/resources/net/~/~/media/9C791D2DCB6D43D8B3BAF17639484A8F.pdf
  36. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/254151742_The_muse_in_the_machine_Creativity_anomalous_experiences_and_mental_health
  37. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/perception-problem/
  38. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3748455
  39. https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/wp-content/uploads/sites/360/2017/09/The-Contributions-of-Apparitions-to-the-Evidence-for-Survival_-Ian-Stevenson-1982.pdf
  40. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0957154X14562756
  41. https://www.ingentaconnect.com/contentone/imp/jcs/2003/00000010/F0020006/art00009
  42. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3213001/
  43. https://www.ianbphillips.com/uploads/2/2/9/4/22946642/naive_realism_the_slightest_philosophy_and_the_slighest_science_--_french_and_phillips_--_final_draft_feb_21.pdf
  44. https://direct.mit.edu/books/monograph/4729/Ten-Problems-of-ConsciousnessA-Representational
  45. https://philarchive.org/archive/DESVAH
  46. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/227717917_Representationalism_and_the_argument_from_hallucination
  47. https://consc.net/papers/representation.pdf
  48. https://sites.pitt.edu/~dash/huntsman.html
  49. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/creation-of-the-zulu-kingdom-18151828/zulu-voices-zulu-meanings-ancestors-praises-and-history/79523197F25392244724A8096F80E242
  50. https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000626_message-fatima_en.html
  51. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4381323/
  52. https://www.lionsroar.com/buddhism/hungry-ghosts/
  53. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt46nwn8
  54. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/top-ten-day-of-dead-mexico
  55. https://www.bps.org.uk/research-digest/ghosts-and-gaps-supernatural-beliefs-fill-similar-unknowns-across-cultures
  56. https://www.spr.ac.uk/8-spontaneous-apparitions-and-ndes
  57. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29792448/
  58. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325352351_The_Experimental_Evidence_for_Parapsychological_Phenomena_A_Review
  59. https://www.mdpi.com/2077-0383/9/3/851
  60. https://skepticalinquirer.org/2020/06/so-you-have-a-ghost-in-your-photo/
  61. https://www.ipsos.com/en-us/news-polls/belief-in-ghosts-2021
  62. https://news.gallup.com/poll/16915/three-four-americans-believe-paranormal.aspx
  63. https://news.gallup.com/poll/509654/americans-belief-paranormal-phenomena-new-high.aspx
  64. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/10/121024141633.htm
  65. https://www.whistleout.com/CellPhones/Guides/best-ghost-hunting-apps
  66. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/gh-realghosts/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.