Hubbry Logo
Henry PlummerHenry PlummerMain
Open search
Henry Plummer
Community hub
Henry Plummer
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Henry Plummer
Henry Plummer
Henry Plummer
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Henry Plummer (c. 1832–January 10, 1864) was a prospector, lawman, and outlaw in the American West in the 1850s and 1860s, who was known to have killed several men. He was elected sheriff of what was then Bannack, Idaho Territory, in 1863 and served until 1864, during which period he was accused of being the leader of a "road agent" gang of outlaws known as the "Innocents," who preyed on shipments from what was then Virginia City, Idaho Territory to other areas. In response some leaders in Virginia City formed the Vigilance Committee of Alder Gulch and began to take action against Plummer's gang, gaining confessions from a couple of men they arrested in early January 1864. On January 10, 1864, Plummer and two associates were arrested in Bannack by a company of the vigilantes and summarily hanged. Plummer was given a posthumous trial in 1993 which led to a mistrial. The jury was split 6–6.

Key Information

Early years

[edit]

Plummer was born William Henry Handy Plumer in about 1832 in Addison, Maine, the last of six children in a family whose ancestors had first settled in Maine in 1634, when it was still a part of the Massachusetts Bay Colony. His father died while Henry was in his teens. In 1852, at age 19, Plummer headed west to the gold fields of California. He changed the spelling of his surname to Plummer after moving west.[1] His mining venture went well: within two years he owned a mine, a ranch, and a bakery in Nevada City. In 1856, Plummer was elected sheriff and city manager. Supporters suggested that he should run for state representative as a Democrat. However, the party was divided, and without its full support, he lost.

Becoming an outlaw

[edit]

On September 26, 1857, Plummer shot and killed John Vedder. As city marshal of Nevada City, California, Plummer had been providing protection of Lucy Vedder, John's wife, who was seeking to escape from her abusive husband. Plummer claimed he was acting in self-defense in the incident, but was convicted of second-degree murder. He won an appeal for a retrial and was convicted again and sentenced to ten years in San Quentin.[2] But in August 1859, supporters wrote to the governor seeking a pardon based on his alleged good character and civic performance. The governor granted the pardon because of Plummer's poor health as a result of tuberculosis, which was incurable at the time.

In 1861, Plummer tried to carry out a citizen's arrest of William Riley, who had escaped from San Quentin; in the attempt, Riley was killed. Plummer turned himself in to the police, who accepted that the killing was justified. Fearing that his prison record would prevent a fair trial, they allowed Plummer to leave the state.

Life of a criminal

[edit]

Plummer headed to Washington Territory where gold had been discovered. There he became involved in a dispute that ended in a gunfight won by Plummer. He decided to leave the West and return to Maine.

On the way back east, waiting for a steamboat to reach Fort Benton, Montana, on the Missouri River, Plummer was approached by James Vail. He was recruiting volunteers to help protect his family from Indian attacks at the mission station he was attempting to start in Sun River, Montana. No passage home being available, Plummer accepted, along with Jack Cleveland, a horse dealer who had known Plummer in California.

While at the mission, both Plummer and Cleveland fell in love with Vail's attractive sister-in-law, Electa Bryan; Plummer asked her to marry him and she agreed. As gold had recently been discovered in nearby Bannack, Montana, Plummer decided to go there to try to earn enough money to support them both. Cleveland followed him. In January 1863, Cleveland, nursing his jealousy, forced Plummer into a fight and was killed. The altercation took place in a crowded saloon, and observers agreed that Plummer had killed his foe in self-defense. Plummer was viewed very favorably by most town residents, and in May he was elected sheriff of Bannack.

The Vigilantes

[edit]
See also: Montana Vigilantes

Between October and December 1863, the rate of robberies and murders in and around Alder Gulch increased significantly, and the citizens of Virginia City grew increasingly suspicious of Plummer and his associates. Notable criminal acts by alleged members of the Plummer gang included:

  • On October 13, 1863, Lloyd Magruder was killed by road agent Chris Lowrie. Magruder was an Idaho merchant leaving Virginia City with $12,000 in gold dust from goods he had sold there. Several of the men he hired to accompany him back to Lewiston, Idaho, were criminals. Four other men in his party were also murdered in camp—Charlie Allen, Robert Chalmers, Horace Chalmers and William Phillips—by Lowrie, Doc Howard, Jem Romaine and William Page.[3]
  • On October 26, 1863, the Peabody and Caldwell's stage was robbed between the Rattlesnake Ranch and Bannack by two road agents believed to be Frank Parish and George Ives. Bill Bunton, the owner of the Rattlesnake Ranch who joined the stage at the ranch, was also complicit in the robbery. The road agents netted $2,800 in gold from the passengers and threatened them all with death if they talked about the robbery.[3]
  • On November 13, 1863, a teenaged Henry Tilden was hired by Wilbur Sanders and Sidney Edgerton to locate and corral some horses owned by the two men. Near Horse Prairie, Tilden was confronted by three armed road agents. He was carrying very little money and was allowed to depart unmolested, but was warned that if he talked about whom he had seen, he would be killed. He told Hattie Sanders, Wilbur's wife, and Sidney Edgerton that he had recognized one of the road agents as Sheriff Henry Plummer. Although Tilden's account was dismissed because of general respect for Plummer, suspicion in the region increased that Plummer was the leader of a gang of road agents.[3]
  • On November 22, 1863, the A.J. Oliver stage was robbed on its way from Virginia City to Bannack by road agents George Ives, "Whiskey Bill" Graves, and Bob Zachary. The robbery netted less than $1,000 in gold and treasury notes. One of the victims, Leroy Southmayd, reported the robbery and identified the road agents to Sheriff Plummer. Members of Plummer's gang confronted Southmayd on his return trip to Virginia City, but Southmayd was cunning enough to avoid injury or death.[3]
  • In November 1863, Conrad Kohrs traveled to Bannack from Deer Lodge, Montana, with $5,000 in gold dust to buy cattle. After talking with Sheriff Plummer in Bannack, Kohrs worried about the risk of robbery on his return to Deer Lodge. While his group was camped overnight, his associates found road agents George Ives and "Dutch John" Wagner surveying the camp and armed with shotguns. A day or two later, Kohrs was riding on horseback to Deer Lodge when Ives and Wagner gave chase. As Kohrs's horse proved the faster, Kohrs evaded confrontation and reached the safety of Deer Lodge.[3]
  • In early December 1863, a three-wagon freight outfit organized by Milton S. Moody was going from Virginia City to Salt Lake City. Among the seven passengers was John Bozeman. It was carrying $80,000 in gold dust and $1,500 in treasury notes. While the outfit was camped on Blacktail Deer Creek, Wagner and Steve Marshland entered the camp, armed and ready to rob the pack train. Members of the camp had armed themselves well, and Wagner and Marshland were able to escape by claiming they were just looking for lost horses. Two days later, Wagner and Marshland were both wounded in an unsuccessful attempt to rob the train as it crossed the Continental Divide at Rock Creek.[3]
  • On December 8, 1863, Anton Holter, who was taking oxen to sell in Virginia City, survived an attempted robbery and murder. When Ives and Aleck Carter, whom Holter recognized, discovered Holter was not carrying any significant wealth, they tried to shoot him. He avoided being shot and escaped into the brush.[3]

At the time Bannack and Virginia City were part of a remote region of the Idaho Territory; there was no formal law enforcement or justice system for the area. Some residents suspected that Plummer's road agent gang was responsible for numerous robberies, attempted robberies, murders and attempted murders in and around Alder Gulch in October–December 1863. From December 19 to 21, 1863, a public trial was held in Virginia City by a miners' court for Ives, the suspected murderer of Nicholas Tiebolt, a young Dutch immigrant. Hundreds of miners from around the area attended the three-day outdoor trial. George Ives was prosecuted by Wilbur F. Sanders, convicted, and hanged on December 21, 1863.[4]

On December 23, 1863, two days after the Ives trial, leading citizens of Virginia City and Bannack formed the Vigilance Committee of Alder Gulch in Virginia City. They included five Virginia City residents, led by Sanders.[5] Between January 4 and February 3, 1864, the vigilantes arrested and summarily executed at least 20 alleged members of Plummer's gang. Shortly after its formation, the Vigilance Committee dispatched a posse of men to search for Carter, Graves, and Bunton, known associates of Ives. The posse was led by Captain James Williams, the man who had investigated the Tiebolt murder. Near the Rattlesnake Ranch on the Ruby River, the posse located Erastus "Red" Yeager and George Brown, both suspected road agents. While traveling under guard back to Virginia City, Yeager made a complete confession, naming the majority of the road agents in Plummer's gang, and Henry Plummer. The posse found Yeager and Brown guilty and hanged them from a tree on the Lorrain's Ranch on the Ruby River.[6]

On January 6, 1864, vigilante Captain Nick Wall and Ben Peabody captured Wagner on the Salt Lake City trail. The vigilantes transported Wagner to Bannack, where he was hanged on January 11, 1864. By this time, Yeager's confession had mobilized vigilantes against Plummer and his key associates, deputies Buck Stinson and Ned Ray. Plummer, Stinson, and Ray were arrested on the morning of January 10, 1864, and summarily hanged. The two youngest members of the gang were said to be spared. One was sent back to Bannack to tell the rest to get out of the area, and the other was sent ahead to Lewiston to warn gang members to leave that town. (Lewiston was the connection from the territory to the world, as it had river steamboats that traveled to the coast at Astoria, Oregon, via the Snake and Columbia rivers.) Plummer was known to have traveled to Lewiston during the time when he was an elected official in Bannack. The hotel registry records with his signature during this period have been preserved. The large-scale robberies of gold shipments by gangs ended with Plummer's and the alleged gang members' deaths. Gang member Clubfoot George was hanged at about the same time with Plummer.

Posthumous trial

[edit]

Plummer was given a posthumous trial in 1993 which led to a mistrial. The jury was split 6–6.[7]

On May 7, 1993, a posthumous trial (Montana’s Twin Bridges Public Schools initiated the event) was held in the Virginia City, Mont., courthouse. The 12 registered voters on the jury were split 6-6 on the verdict, which led Judge Barbara Brook to declare a mistrial. Had Plummer been alive he would have been freed and not tried again.[7]

[edit]
  • Francis M. Thompson's 1914 article in The Massachusetts Magazine (Vol. VI, No. 4 - pages 159-190) describes his relationship with Plummer and presents some of the details of the case, from a personal view of being a mercantile owner in Bannack during that period. In 2004, the Montana Historical Society gathered Thompson's memoirs into a book, A Tenderfoot in Montana.
  • Ernest Haycox's 1942 historical novel Alder Gulch depicts Plummer as handsome and well-spoken, but a cold and calculating murderer and thief without conscience. He portrays the vigilantes as justified but equally remorseless, as they conducted their lynching executions by slow strangulation hangings.
  • Il passato di Carson [The Past of Carson], a storyline in the Italian comics series "Tex" (nos. 407 to 409, September to November, 1994), is loosely based upon the real story of the "Innocents" and features a character, Raymond Clemmons, inspired by Plummer.
  • Henry Plummer appears in a fictional portrayal in the 2013 video game, Call of Juarez: Gunslinger. The game depicts him radically different to his real-life counterpart, as still being alive sometime after 1881, according to the protagonist, and is appropriately depicted as an older man. Though unlike other historical discrepancies mentioned by characters in the game, this is never touched upon.

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Henry Plummer

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Henry Plummer (1832 – January 10, 1864) was an American prospector and lawman who served as the elected sheriff of Bannack, Montana Territory, from May 1863 until his summary execution by the Montana Vigilance Committee, which accused him of masterminding a gang of road agents responsible for numerous robberies and murders during the territory's gold rush era. Born in Washington County, Maine, to a family of sea captains, Plummer migrated to California in 1851 amid the Gold Rush, where he worked in mining, ranching, and briefly as town marshal of Nevada City before being convicted of second-degree murder in 1857—a sentence from which he was pardoned in 1859 due to health concerns and community skepticism of his guilt. Arriving in Bannack in 1863, he quickly gained popularity through his charisma and promises to curb lawlessness, winning election as sheriff and constructing the territory's first jail, yet his tenure coincided with escalating violence against miners and travelers. Plummer's defining controversy arose from vigilante allegations that he led "The Innocents," a purported network of bandits executing ambushes and holdups, with claims of over 100 victims though documented incidents were far fewer and profitable hauls minimal. Lacking a formal or such as recovered stolen goods or victim bodies, his rested on confessions extracted under duress from captured associates like Erastus Yeager, amid a broader campaign by elite miners that hanged at least 21 men to impose order in the lawless . While early accounts sympathetic to the , such as editor Thomas Dimsdale's 1866 narrative, portrayed Plummer as a cold-blooded chief with a premeditated criminal empire, subsequent historical analysis has emphasized evidentiary discrepancies, coerced testimonies, and possible driven by social and political motives among the territory's Republican-leaning business class, fostering enduring debate over whether he was a corrupt or an unjustly lynched public servant.

Early Life

Family Background and Upbringing

Henry Plummer was born in 1832 in , the youngest of seven children to William Jeremiah Plummer and Elizabeth Handy Plummer. His family traced its roots to early settlers in the region, arriving as part of the expansion in the 1630s. The Plummers maintained a longstanding tradition in maritime professions, with Plummer's father, an older brother, and a brother-in-law all serving as sea captains engaged in coastal trade. Young Henry was initially groomed to follow this path, reflecting the family's economic reliance on seafaring amid the opportunities and risks of 19th-century commerce. However, Plummer's slight build and contraction of rendered him unsuitable for the physical demands of life at sea, derailing his prospective career in the family trade. This health affliction, combined with financial hardships following his father's death during his teenage years, prompted him to seek opportunities elsewhere. At age 19, in 1852, he departed for the , marking the end of his eastern upbringing.

Initial Ventures Westward

At the age of 19, in 1852, Plummer left his family home in , to join the , driven by reports of vast mineral wealth in the Sierra Nevada foothills. He departed amid the peak of gold fever that had drawn tens of thousands eastward migrants since the 1848 discovery at , seeking fortune through prospecting rather than continuing in his family's maritime traditions, which were curtailed by his health issues including possible . Plummer's transcontinental journey began by sea, routing through to shorten the overland Pacific crossing, a common but perilous shortcut involving river travel, mule trains, and disease risks in the . The voyage from ports to , followed by transit to the Pacific side and steamer to , spanned approximately 24 days, culminating in his arrival in by late April 1852. This path avoided the grueling wagon trains of the or Trails, which claimed thousands from exhaustion, , and conflict, though 's fever-ridden swamps posed their own hazards. Upon reaching , Plummer proceeded northeast to Nevada City, a burgeoning mining hub in the region, where he invested in a , a mine, and initially a bakery to support his efforts. His early mining claims yielded sufficient returns within two years to expand holdings, including a combination and saloon, establishing a foothold in the transient economy of placer camps where stampeders traded labor for gold dust amid rudimentary and volatile markets. These ventures capitalized on the rush's infrastructure boom, though success hinged on placer deposits' finitude and competition from hydraulic methods emerging in the .

Career in California

Role as a Lawman

In 1855, Henry Plummer was appointed deputy sheriff under David Johnson in , a bustling mining community in Nevada County. The following year, at age 24, he was elected to succeed Johnson as city marshal, reflecting local confidence in his abilities to enforce order amid the frontier's volatility. Plummer was reelected to the marshal position, demonstrating sustained public support in a town prone to saloon brawls, theft, and disputes over mining claims. As , Plummer maintained a reputation for efficiency in upholding , including protecting vulnerable residents such as saloon workers from abuse, which involved direct intervention in violent incidents. His tenure aligned with Democratic Party affiliations, leading to a nomination for state assemblyman, where he was narrowly defeated. These roles positioned him as a key figure in Nevada City's rudimentary , tasked with arresting offenders and quelling disturbances without a formal police force beyond deputies.

Criminal Conviction and Imprisonment

In September 1857, while serving as city marshal of , Henry Plummer shot and killed John Vedder during a confrontation on the street. Plummer had been providing protection to Vedder's wife, , from her husband's reported abuse, though accounts also allege Plummer was romantically involved with her, escalating tensions when Vedder confronted him. Plummer maintained that he acted in after Vedder drew a first, but witnesses disputed this, leading to his and a highly publicized . The case drew significant attention, with Plummer appealing the initial verdict to the California Supreme Court twice before a final conviction for second-degree murder. On February 22, 1859, he was sentenced to ten years' imprisonment at San Quentin State Prison. Supporters, including fellow law enforcement officers, petitioned for leniency, emphasizing Plummer's prior service as a deputy sheriff and arguing the killing occurred in the line of duty amid self-defense circumstances. Plummer entered San Quentin on the day of sentencing but served only a short term, as his health rapidly declined from contracted during under poor conditions. In August 1859, following further petitions to Governor John W. highlighting his illness and good character, Plummer received an early release on , effectively a conditioned on leaving . Historical analyses note disputes over the conviction's fairness, with some contemporaries and later accounts questioning witness reliability and suggesting vigilante-like pressures influenced the outcome, though the judicial record stands as a formal second-degree finding.

Settlement in Montana Territory

Arrival and Involvement in Gold Mining

Henry Plummer arrived in the newly established mining camp of , in October 1862, drawn by reports of a major gold strike along Grasshopper Creek earlier that year. The discovery, made on July 28, 1862, by prospector John White and his party, sparked a rush that quickly transformed the remote area into a bustling settlement with thousands of miners seeking placer gold deposits. Plummer, recently released from imprisonment in , traveled from the Pacific Coast states to capitalize on the opportunities in this frontier goldfield, where yields from simple panning and sluicing operations could reach substantial amounts in the initial months. Upon arrival, Plummer engaged directly in and claims, staking interests in local deposits amid the camp's chaotic early growth. He acquired part ownership in the Dakota Lode, one of Bannack's first hard-rock mines, formally located on August 3, 1863. This vein, situated 500 feet above Grasshopper Creek, represented a shift from surface to more capital-intensive lode operations requiring tunneling and machinery, though initial extractions proved rich in gold ore. Plummer's involvement extended to multiple claims and stakes across the district, allowing him to amass a modest fortune from mining yields before transitioning to other roles in the . These activities positioned him as a stakeholder in Bannack's economic boom, where gold production in 1862–1863 alone exceeded $5 million in unrefined dust and nuggets from the creek gravels.

Election to Sheriff of Bannack

In the spring of 1863, Henry Plummer, leveraging his reputation from prior service as a sheriff and city in mining towns, positioned himself as a candidate for in the burgeoning gold camp of Bannack, then part of . The community, composed largely of miners seeking order amid rapid growth following the 1862 gold discoveries, favored Plummer's charisma, eloquence, and claimed experience over other contenders. His campaign emphasized restoring stability to the isolated settlement, where informal miners' courts had previously handled disputes but proved inadequate for escalating violence and theft. The election occurred on May 24, 1863, with Plummer defeating Jefferson Durley by securing 307 votes out of 544 cast, establishing him as of Bannack and the surrounding mining districts. This vote reflected the miners' courts' transition to formalized governance under territorial oversight, though Bannack lacked a robust legal , relying on elected officials like Plummer, B.B. Burchett, and Coroner J.M. Castner. Prior to the ballot, Plummer had engaged in a public shooting altercation with Hank Crawford over a disputed claim, which he survived, enhancing his image as a decisive figure capable of handling confrontations. Plummer's victory margin underscored his appeal in a transient population estimated at several thousand, drawn by placer yields exceeding $10 million that year, yet vulnerable to opportunistic without established policing. Historical accounts from vigilante-era testimonies and territorial records portray the election as a pragmatic choice for a man presenting himself as reformed and competent, untainted by local scandals at the time, though later revelations questioned the sincerity of his public persona.

Context of Crime in Bannack

Rise of Road Agents and the Innocents

The discovery of gold at Grasshopper Creek on July 28, 1862, rapidly transformed Bannack into a bustling mining camp, attracting thousands of prospectors and creating a lawless environment ripe for criminal exploitation. With minimal formal law enforcement and isolated trails connecting Bannack to supply routes and later to the richer strikes in Alder Gulch—discovered on May 26, 1863—the roads became perilous for travelers carrying gold dust, shipments, and personal wealth. Road agents, highwaymen who ambushed stages, pack trains, and individuals, began operating in earnest during the summer and fall of 1863 as traffic intensified following the Alder Gulch boom, which drew an estimated 10,000 miners to the region and generated millions in gold output. Early documented incidents included the February 1863 murder and robbery of prospector George Evans by Jack Cleveland near Bannack, and the October 1863 holdup of the Peabody & Caldwell stagecoach near Rattlesnake Ranch, where George Ives and Frank Parish seized approximately $2,800 in gold at gunpoint. The term "Innocents" emerged in contemporary accounts to describe an alleged cadre of these road agents, purportedly a loosely affiliated group of dozens—or even over 100—outlaws who denied guilt with the phrase "I am innocent," serving as a among members. Vigilante chronicler Thomas J. Dimsdale, a participant in the subsequent justice efforts, depicted the Innocents as a structured with assigned roles, spies tracking targets, and operations coordinated from ranches like , enabling frequent strikes such as the November robbery of the mail coach by Ives, Bill , and Bob Zachary, netting $500 in gold and notes. Further crimes attributed to them included the murder of Tbalt by Ives near Spring in late 1863 and the slaying of merchant Dillingham in Virginia City in June 1863 by Buck Stinson and associates. However, Dimsdale's narrative, written to vindicate extralegal actions, has been critiqued by historians for exaggeration; analysis of primary sources like Granville Stuart's and period newspapers reveals only a handful of verified profitable robberies—three totaling about $3,500—suggesting isolated opportunists rather than a monolithic terrorizing the with over 100 killings as later claimed. This perception of escalating threat, fueled by real but sporadic amid the frontier's and economic desperation, eroded public confidence in elected officials and precipitated demands for self-organized by late 1863. While robberies preyed on the gold economy's vulnerabilities, scholarly review indicates vigilante lore amplified the Innocents' cohesion to portray a dire , potentially overlooking individual motives and the absence of pre-vigilante prosecutions for many alleged acts.

Economic and Social Pressures in Frontier Mining Camps

The discovery of in Grasshopper Creek on July 28, 1862, triggered a rapid influx of prospectors to Bannack, swelling the population to over 400 individuals by October 1862 and exceeding 10,000 by late spring 1863, predominantly transient males drawn by the promise of quick wealth. This economic boom fueled a economy reliant on rudimentary tools and labor-intensive washing techniques, yielding high-purity (99-99.5%) but exposing miners to volatile yields as surface deposits diminished, compelling deeper claims and hydraulic methods that demanded substantial water infrastructure like ditches. Isolation exacerbated economic strains, as supplies arrived via arduous overland freighting from distant points like or the , inflating prices for essentials—flour could cost $100 per hundredweight—and fostering dependency on credit and informal exchanges amid scarce banking or facilities. Socially, the camp's overwhelming male demographic—few families or women initially—eroded stabilizing norms, with saloons, halls, and brothels proliferating as primary outlets for idleness and vice in a setting of crude tents and cabins lacking established governance. surged, with approximately 100 recorded in 1863 alone, driven by interpersonal disputes over claims, alcohol-fueled brawls, and opportunistic theft targeting gold carriers on rudimentary trails. The absence of formal territorial authority until Montana's organization in 1864, coupled with portable wealth in dust form, incentivized "road agents" to prey on shipments and travelers, as the high value-to-weight ratio of gold minimized risks for robbers while formal lagged behind the boom's chaos. These pressures compounded in a feedback loop: economic desperation from claim exhaustion and inflated living costs bred resentment and mobility, while social atomization—exacerbated by ethnic diversity among miners from , the East, and —hindered communal trust, elevating self-armament and extralegal resolutions over institutional order. Though some camps evolved toward family-oriented stability by , with schools emerging (Bannack's first in September 1863), the initial frontier volatility prioritized survival over restraint, setting conditions for widespread predation until vigilante interventions imposed control.

Plummer's Tenure as Sheriff

Official Duties and Public Perception

Henry Plummer was elected of Bannack on May 24, 1863, receiving the majority of 554 votes cast in the district's for key justice positions, including , , and . In this frontier setting lacking formal territorial government, his responsibilities encompassed maintaining public order, investigating crimes such as robberies and murders, apprehending suspects, and enforcing executions where deemed necessary by local miners' courts. Plummer appointed deputies including D.H. Dillingham as , along with Ned Ray, Buck Stinson, and Jack Gallagher, to assist in patrolling the volatile gold camp and surrounding trails prone to highway robberies. A notable action during his tenure occurred in August 1863, when Plummer arrested Peter Horen for the murder of Lawrence Keeley and oversaw Horen's execution by on August 25, constructing the scaffold himself as part of the proceedings under rudimentary local justice mechanisms. Over approximately 14 months, records indicate investigations into 11 reported robberies and multiple deaths, including 13 white victims and 5 Native American deaths, though effective resolutions remained elusive amid the rising tide of road agent activities, such as the October 25, 1863, robbery of the Peabody and Caldwell . Public perception of Plummer at the outset was favorable, reflected in his electoral victory and descriptions of his charismatic demeanor, eloquence, and equitable treatment of citizens regardless of , which earned him support in Bannack's diverse . Contemporary accounts, however, reveal emerging suspicions by late 1863, fueled by persistent unsolved crimes and rumors of his associations with unsavory figures, though these were not yet substantiated publicly; pro-vigilante sources like Thomas Dimsdale's writings, influenced by Republican interests, later retroactively emphasized his duplicity, portraying him as ruling with coercive authority despite his maintained facade of legitimacy.

Allegations of Corruption and Leadership of Criminal Elements

During his tenure as of Bannack from May 1863 to January 1864, Henry Plummer faced accusations of shielding road agents—highway robbers preying on gold shipments between Bannack and Virginia City—and personally orchestrating their operations as leader of a known as the Innocents. Informants, including confessed road agent Erastus "" Yeager, alleged that Plummer directed a network of 20 to 30 men using passwords like "Innocents" and hand signals to coordinate ambushes, with Plummer receiving a cut of the proceeds from robberies totaling around $3,500 in documented cases. These claims, drawn from vigilante interrogations, portrayed Plummer as complicit in murders such as the October 1863 killing of prospector Jason Moore, where members allegedly acted on Plummer's intelligence about Moore's gold dust. Plummer's appointments of deputies like Buck Stinson—a known associate accused of multiple killings—and Ned Ray fueled suspicions of corruption, as these men were later hanged alongside him on January 10, 1864, for road agent ties. Contemporary accounts, such as those in Thomas Dimsdale's 1866 The Vigilantes of Montana, asserted Plummer's oversight enabled over 100 deaths, though verified murders numbered only 13 among white victims and 5 among Native Americans during the period. Critics of Plummer highlighted his inaction on high-profile crimes, including the failure to pursue suspects in the December 1863 robbery of a City-bound party, which vigilantes attributed to his protective role. However, the evidentiary basis for these allegations relies heavily on confessions extracted under vigilante pressure, lacking independent corroboration such as recovered loot or eyewitness accounts directly implicating Plummer in robberies. Dimsdale's narrative, written by a vigilante sympathizer and publisher of the Montana Post, has been critiqued for exaggeration to legitimize extrajudicial actions, with modern analyses noting only sporadic, uncoordinated thefts rather than a sophisticated syndicate under Plummer's command. Revisionist historians like R.E. Mather and F.E. Boswell argue the charges may stem from political opposition to Plummer's Southern sympathies amid Civil War tensions, pointing to the absence of a "" like gang rosters or hidden caches despite searches. Crime rates did decline post-execution, but this correlation does not conclusively prove causation, as vigilante hangings targeted multiple suspects regardless of Plummer's involvement.

Vigilante Response

Formation of the Vigilance Committee

The discovery of prospector Nicholas Tibolt's frozen body on December 8, 1863, near Alder Gulch, with evidence of robbery and murder, intensified public outrage over the road agent epidemic plaguing Bannack and Virginia City. George Ives, a member of the Innocents , was arrested on and subjected to a miners' in Nevada City from December 19 to 21, where witnesses implicated him in Tibolt's killing and other crimes. The trial devolved amid allegations of and by associates of Henry Plummer, resulting in an inconclusive verdict that highlighted the fragility of without formal territorial courts. On , 1863, an group of approximately 100 armed citizens seized Ives from his guards and hanged him near Nevada City, marking the vigilantes' inaugural execution and demonstrating community resolve to bypass perceived corrupt legal processes. This action, occurring without immediate reprisal from Plummer's forces, catalyzed the formal organization of the of Alder Gulch two days later, on December 23, 1863, during a secret meeting of leading merchants and miners in Virginia City. The initial cadre numbered around 27 men, who drafted and signed an oath pledging mutual aid to suppress crime, with Paris S. Pfouts elected as president, Wilbur F. Sanders as , and James Williams as . The committee rapidly expanded, enlisting over 1,000 members across Bannack, Virginia City, and Nevada City within weeks, organized into secretive cells identified by numbers rather than names to enhance and . Key early participants included John X. Beidler, Nathaniel P. Langford, and scouts who gathered intelligence on road agents, driven by empirical evidence of over 100 unsolved murders and robberies since the 1862 Bannack gold strike. The formation reflected causal pressures of the mining frontier—rapid population influx without established —where economic incentives for predation outweighed risks under Plummer's lax tenure, as documented in contemporaneous accounts by Montana Post editor Thomas J. Dimsdale, a committee sympathizer whose reporting, while partisan, aligns with multiple survivor testimonies.

Key Investigations and Informant Testimonies

The Vigilance Committee's investigations gained momentum after the public trial and execution of George Ives for the murder of Nicholas Tbalt on December 21, 1863, prompting systematic interrogations of suspected road agents to uncover the gang's leadership and operations. Captives were questioned at length, often yielding detailed confessions under the threat of execution, which vigilantes viewed as reliable due to the informants' insider knowledge and the consistency across testimonies. These accounts directly implicated Henry Plummer as the organizing force behind the Innocents, a network responsible for an estimated 102 murders and numerous robberies between 1863 and 1864. A turning point occurred with the capture of Erastus "Red" Yager in the Stinkingwater Valley in early January 1864. Interrogated at Dempsey's Ranch, Yager confessed to membership in Plummer's gang, naming Plummer as chief, Bill Bunton as deputy leader, and associates including George Ives, Buck Stinson, and Ned Ray. He revealed operational details such as the password "Innocents," a distinctive used to identify members, and Plummer's oversight of robberies like the Walla Walla Express holdup. Yager's testimony, corroborated by physical evidence from prior crimes, prompted immediate mobilization against Plummer's inner circle; Yager was executed by hanging on January 4, 1864. Earlier probes into specific crimes bolstered the case against Plummer. In June 1863, during the arrest of Haze Lyons for the October 1863 murder of prosecutor Jason W. Dillingham in Virginia City, Lyons confessed to acting on Plummer's direct orders to eliminate Dillingham, who had threatened to expose road agent activities through his legal inquiries. Lyons falsely implicated Bannack citizens to deflect blame but confirmed Plummer's central role; he was hanged alongside Stinson, Plummer's deputy, for the killing. Similarly, , wounded and captured after a mid-1863 attempt to rob Milton Moody's train, admitted under questioning to participating in the heist alongside Steve Marshland, with Plummer coordinating the effort; recovered stolen goods, including , a , and firearms, aligned with Wagner's account, which echoed Yager's on structure. Wagner was executed in Bannack in January 1864. Supporting testimonies from victims and peripheral witnesses added layers to the vigilantes' dossier. Henry Tilden reported being robbed between Horse Prairie and Bannack by three men, explicitly identifying Plummer as one; this occurred shortly before Plummer's on January 10, 1864. Hank Crawford recounted Plummer's threats and involvement in the 1863 of Jack , highlighting Plummer's pattern of threats. Leroy Southmayd identified Ives and others in the November 1863 Salt Lake robbery, with Plummer attempting to mislead investigators by shifting blame. These elements, drawn from interrogations rather than formal trials, converged to justify the simultaneous arrests of Plummer, Stinson, and Ray in Bannack on January 10, 1864, though critics later noted the reliance on deathbed confessions potentially coerced by vigilante pressure.

Arrest, Execution, and Immediate Aftermath

Capture and Interrogation

On the evening of , , members of the arrested Henry Plummer in Bannack City, , while he was undressing at his residence; his pistol was broken and rendered unusable during the apprehension. Simultaneously, his associates Buck Stinson and Ned Ray—both deputy sheriffs—were captured: Stinson at Toland's establishment, where he was prevented from drawing his weapon, and Ray while lying on a gambling table. The vigilantes, including figures such as Neil Howie and John Fetherstun, noted that the trio's horses had been brought into town, suggesting preparations to flee. No formal occurred, but during the arrests, Plummer pleaded for , offering to leave the immediately or submit to a , and confessed to involvement in numerous murders and other crimes while begging for time to pray or arrange his affairs. Stinson and Ray responded with verbal resistance and curses, while Ray later penned a statement acknowledging the justice of his impending sentence, admitting participation in a during which he was wounded and his companion killed, though denying certain specifics. These admissions, extracted amid the chaos of capture on a bitterly cold evening, aligned with prior informant testimonies implicating Plummer as the road agent leader, such as Haze Lyons' earlier claim that Plummer had ordered a . The captures formed part of a coordinated operation targeting the alleged Innocents gang, with Plummer, Stinson, and Ray confined briefly in a adjacent to the before being conveyed to the gallows at Hangman's Gulch, approximately 300 yards from —a structure Plummer himself had overseen building for a prior execution. Contemporary accounts, primarily from vigilante sympathizer Thomas J. Dimsdale, portray these events as amid frontier lawlessness, though the lack of documented procedural questioning underscores the extrajudicial nature of the proceedings.

Hanging and Confessions at the Gallows

On , 1864, members of the arrested Henry Plummer at his residence in Bannack while he was undressing, breaking his pistol in the process; Buck Stinson was captured at Toland's saloon, and Ned Ray was seized from a gaming table. The trio, identified as key figures in the road agent operations with Plummer as and the others as his deputies, were marched to Hangman's Gulch and executed on a Plummer had previously ordered constructed for a murderer's hanging. No formal occurred, as the vigilantes deemed the evidence from prior informant testimonies, including those implicating Plummer in murders like that of Jason W. Moore, sufficient for summary justice. The executions proceeded in sequence without delay. Ned Ray was hanged first and cursed profusely as the was applied, struggling until his fingers were forcibly removed from the rope. Buck Stinson followed, blaspheming and commenting on Ray's death as the knot slipped, resulting in a prolonged strangulation rather than an instant drop. Plummer, hanged last, reportedly confessed to numerous murders and other crimes committed under his leadership of the road agents, pleading for mercy with the words, "I am too wicked to die," and requesting a proper drop, which the vigilantes granted, leading to his swift death by neck breakage. These gallows statements, as recorded by vigilante sympathizer Thomas J. Dimsdale in his 1866 account, provided the committee with further details on the gang's operations, though Plummer's has faced in later analyses for potential or amid the condemned man's desperation. No written record of Plummer's full confession survives independently, but it aligned with earlier admissions from executed associates like Erastus "Red" Yeager, who had named Plummer as the gang's chief before his own hanging on December 31, 1863. The rapid executions, witnessed by a crowd in Bannack, marked the vigilantes' decisive strike against the alleged criminal leadership, contributing to a temporary cessation of road agent activities in the region.

Evidence and Debates on Guilt

Contemporary Claims of Criminal Involvement

Contemporary claims against Henry Plummer primarily emanated from confessions by captured road agents and identifications during the Vigilance Committee's investigations in late 1863 and early 1864. These assertions portrayed Plummer, as of Bannack, as the organizational head of a known as the "Innocents," which orchestrated at least 11 documented robberies and multiple murders targeting miners, stagecoaches, and travelers between Bannack and Virginia City. The 's activities, including the October 1863 robbery of the Peabody & Caldwell coach and the November 1863 holdup of the Walla Walla Express yielding approximately $2,800 in gold dust, were attributed to Plummer's direction, with deputies like Buck Stinson and Ned Ray allegedly serving as enforcers under his protection. Key testimonies included that of Erastus "Red" Yeager, a suspected road agent arrested in December , who confessed before his execution that Plummer was the chief of the band, naming associates such as Charley Reeves and providing details of the group's structure and operations. Similarly, Haze Lyons, during related to the unspecified of James Dillingham, admitted that Plummer had ordered the killing, executed by Lyons, Stinson, and George Ives. Witness Henry Tilden reported in November that Plummer personally participated in a against him between Horse Prairie and Bannack, recognizing Plummer's distinctive and red coat lining despite occurring in darkness and snow. These accounts, gathered amid the gang's estimated 102 killings—though contemporary tallies focused on confirmed white victims numbering around 13—fueled the vigilantes' case, with informants expressing greater fear of reprisal from surviving comrades than from execution itself. Plummer's arrest on January 10, 1864, followed revelations from these confessions and a failed rescue attempt he allegedly led during George Ives' December 1863 trial, as testified by Nevada City saloon keeper Clinton. At the gallows in Bannack City, Plummer reportedly confessed to numerous murders and robberies, including prior involvement in California crimes such as the 1856-1857 killing of a German named Vedder, before his hanging alongside Stinson and Ray. These claims were compiled by Thomas J. Dimsdale, editor of the Montana Post during the events, in his 1866 narrative The Vigilantes of Montana, derived from 1865 newspaper serials and direct vigilante reports; however, as a proponent of the committee, Dimsdale's documentation reflects their viewpoint without adversarial cross-examination.

Posthumous Scrutiny and Challenges to Evidence

Following Plummer's execution on January 10, 1864, initial accounts, such as those in Thomas Dimsdale's 1866 book The Vigilantes of Montana, portrayed him as the leader of the road agents based largely on vigilante testimonies and gallows confessions, but these have faced increasing scrutiny for lacking corroborative physical evidence. Historians in the late 20th century began questioning the reliability of such sources, noting that confessions from condemned men like Jack Gallagher and others were often extracted under duress or offered in desperate bids for clemency, with no independent documentation linking Plummer directly to specific robberies or murders in the Bannack-Virginia City area. A notable effort at reassessment occurred on May 7, 1993, when Montana's Twin Bridges Public Schools organized a posthumous in the Virginia City courthouse, simulating Plummer's case with historical records and expert witnesses; the jury deadlocked at 6-6, resulting in a mistrial that underscored unresolved evidentiary ambiguities. Research over the subsequent decades has highlighted the circumstantial nature of the accusations, including Plummer's prior in —which involved a killing pardoned by residents—and potential political rivalries between Bannack (where he was elected ) and the vigilante stronghold of Virginia City, suggesting his hanging may have served to consolidate power among the extralegal committee rather than purely address crime. Scholars have pointed to the absence of tangible proof, such as stolen goods traced to Plummer or eyewitness accounts beyond hearsay, arguing that narratives amplified rumors amid chaos to justify summary justice. Some analyses propose the road agent organization, if it existed under centralized leadership, might have been exaggerated or misattributed, with Plummer possibly framed by electoral opponents who viewed his Democratic affiliations and independent as threats. Despite these challenges, no conclusive has emerged, and debates persist, with proponents of guilt citing patterns of unsolved crimes correlating to his tenure, though without forensic or documentary substantiation beyond contemporary suspicions. The case illustrates broader tensions in between oral traditions and demands for empirical verification.

Long-Term Legacy

The execution of Henry Plummer on , 1864, by the of Alder Gulch exemplified the extralegal measures taken in 's gold camps amid a complete absence of formal judicial authority, as miners' courts lacked enforcement power against entrenched criminal networks. This event, part of a broader campaign that hanged approximately 22 men between December 1863 and February 1864, temporarily restored order by eliminating suspected road agents, thereby creating conditions conducive to the imposition of structured legal governance. The committee's bylaws, which authorized only without appeal, underscored the perceived necessity of decisive action in a vacuum where federal oversight was delayed until Montana Territory's formal organization on May 26, 1864. In the immediate aftermath, leaders transitioned their efforts toward provisional institutions, establishing a "People's Court" in February 1864 under figures like Hezekiah L. Hosmer, who later became the territory's first chief justice, bridging extralegal with emerging territorial . The Plummer affair highlighted systemic failures in miners' tribunals, which relied on community consensus but faltered against organized depredations, pressuring incoming federal appointees—such as Governor Sidney Edgerton, whose brother Wilbur Fisk Sanders co-led the —to prioritize judicial infrastructure. By December 1864, Hosmer convened Montana's inaugural federal court session in Virginia City's dining hall, initiating codified proceedings that supplanted informal precedents with statutory frameworks for criminal trials and property disputes. Longer-term, suppression of Plummer's alleged network influenced Montana's territorial , convened in 1866, to enact laws fortifying oversight, protections, and rapid judicial responses tailored to economies, reflecting a synthesis of frontier self-reliance with federal . While some contemporaries, including chronicler Thomas Dimsdale, praised the committee's role in enabling lawful settlement, later analyses note that unchecked risked politicized abuses, prompting constitutional provisions upon statehood in 1889 that emphasized elected judiciaries to curtail future committees. This evolution marked a causal shift from reactive mob justice to institutionalized enforcement, though debates persist over whether Plummer's guilt warranted such precipitous action absent .

Historical Reassessments and Scholarly Views

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, historical narratives of Henry Plummer's execution predominantly echoed the vigilantes' perspective, as chronicled in Thomas J. Dimsdale's 1866 account The Vigilantes of Montana, which depicted Plummer as the cunning head of a road agent gang responsible for over 100 murders and robberies, drawing on testimonies from informants and confessions. Dimsdale, a editor and vigilante sympathizer, framed the committee's actions as necessary amid lawlessness, influencing subsequent retellings that accepted Plummer's culpability without independent verification. Mid-20th-century scholarship introduced skepticism, highlighting evidentiary weaknesses such as the absence of direct forensic links between Plummer and specific crimes, reliance on coerced admissions from subordinates like Jack Gallagher and , and potential political motivations tied to Plummer's election as sheriff in 1863 over vigilante-aligned candidates. Biographer J.W. Dykins, in Henry Plummer (2000), cataloged Plummer's documented prior killings in —five in by 1859—but questioned whether these substantiated leadership of Montana's "Innocents" gang, noting no stolen goods were recovered from him and that crime persisted post-execution. Revisionist works in the late , including R.E. Mather and F.E. Boswell's Hanging the Sheriff (), systematically challenged the vigilante narrative by cross-referencing contemporary records, arguing Plummer was scapegoated amid anti-authority sentiment and unsubstantiated rumors amplified by figures like Wilbur Sanders, leader with territorial ambitions. These analyses emphasized systemic biases in primary sources, such as Dimsdale's omission of conflicting affidavits and the vigilantes' extrajudicial hangings of at least 21 men without trials, suggesting Plummer's ouster served to consolidate power for the committee's mining and political interests. Contemporary historians remain divided, with traditionalists citing Plummer's associations with known outlaws like Cyrus Skinner and the temporal correlation between his tenure and heightened road agent activity as circumstantial proof of complicity. Skeptics, however, underscore the lack of surviving manifests or eyewitness accounts tying Plummer to robberies, interpreting the episode as emblematic of overreach in , where unsubstantiated claims justified summary executions to deter chaos. Recent reassessments, informed by archival digitization, portray Plummer as a flawed but reform-minded lawman whose ambiguous past invited projection of collective fears, perpetuating debate over whether his guilt was fabricated or merely unproven. No consensus has emerged, as physical evidence remains elusive, leaving scholarly views contingent on interpretations of testimonial reliability and contextual incentives.

References

  1. https://www.historynet.com/henry-plummer/
  2. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1026&context=etd
  3. https://montanacowboyfame.org/inductees/2008/10/sheriff-henry-plummer
  4. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/68146/68146-h/68146-h.htm
  5. https://www.geni.com/people/Sheriff-Henry-Plummer/6000000051874834191
  6. https://southwestmt.com/blog/infamous-characters-henry-plummer-part-1/
  7. https://www.facebook.com/NPClwNFs/posts/160-years-ago-today-legendary-outlaw-henry-plummer-executed-onthisday-in-1864-he/772082668293493/
  8. https://www.distinctlymontana.com/give-me-high-drop-boys-frontier-justice-and-ghost-henry-plummer
  9. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/mt-henryplummer/
  10. https://www.facebook.com/groups/NorthIdahoHistory/posts/7646273002068799/
  11. https://www.bangordailynews.com/2021/09/30/news/down-east/this-down-east-man-struck-gold-in-california-before-being-hanged-as-a-wild-west-outlaw/
  12. https://www.idahomagazine.com/article/plummer-spotlight/
  13. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/we-henryplummer-hough/
  14. https://spartacus-educational.com/WWplummerH.htm
  15. https://nbcmontana.com/news/montana-moment/bannack-heart-of-the-wild-west-spurred-birth-of-montana-territory
  16. https://ia800206.us.archive.org/35/items/vigilantesofmon00dims/vigilantesofmon00dims.pdf
  17. https://southwestmt.com/blog/henry-plummer-part-2/
  18. https://www.umt.edu/this-is-montana/columns/stories/gold-western-montana.php
  19. https://www.facebook.com/bannackassociation/posts/may-24-1863-henry-plummer-after-his-shooting-scrape-with-hank-crawford-had-condu/4361398173904542/
  20. https://southwestmt.com/blog/the-road-agents/
  21. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/mt-bannack/
  22. https://npshistory.com/publications/nhl/theme-studies/mining-frontier.pdf
  23. https://www.oldprisons.com/montanas-first-jail-is-in-bannack-the-town-that-hanged-its-sheriff/
  24. https://d.lib.msu.edu/etd/50811
  25. https://www.historynet.com/the-mysterious-henry-plummer/
  26. https://ahgp.org/mt/organization_of_vigilantes.html
  27. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/64135/pg64135-images.html
  28. https://the406life.com/henry-plummer-outlaw-or-victim/
  29. https://ahgp.org/mt/montana_days_of_outlaws_vigilantes_miners_courts.html
  30. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/montana-vigilantes/
  31. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1d8h9zp
  32. https://www.clevelandcivilwarroundtable.com/gold-greed-and-a-vacuum-of-law/
  33. https://mhs.mt.gov/education/StoriesOfTheLand/Part2/Chapter6/Ch6Educators/vigilantes
  34. https://sites.lib.jmu.edu/lynchingmarkers/mt1864186701/
  35. https://petticoatsandpistols.com/2014/02/18/montana-vigilantes/
  36. http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/68146
  37. https://www.oupress.com/9780806113791/the-vigilantes-of-montana/
  38. https://www.nebraskapress.unl.edu/bison-original/9780803279896/henry-plummer/
  39. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2355728
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.