Hubbry Logo
Hutton GibsonHutton GibsonMain
Open search
Hutton Gibson
Community hub
Hutton Gibson
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Hutton Gibson
Hutton Gibson
Hutton Gibson
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Hutton Peter Gibson (August 26, 1918 – May 11, 2020) was a writer on sedevacantism, World War II veteran, the Jeopardy! grand champion for 1968, and the father of 11 children, one of whom is the actor and director Mel Gibson.[1]

Key Information

Gibson was a critic both of the post-Vatican II Catholic Church and of those Traditionalist Catholics who reject sedevacantism, such as the Society of Saint Pius X. He claimed that the Second Vatican Council was "a Masonic plot backed by the Jews".[2][3]

Early life and family

[edit]

Gibson was born in Peekskill, New York,[4] the son of businessman John Hutton Gibson (1884–1937) and Australian opera singer Eva Mylott (1875–1920).[citation needed] His maternal grandparents were Irish immigrants to Australia, while his father, who was from a wealthy tobacco-producing family from the American South, had Irish, English, Scottish, and Welsh ancestry.[5][6][7][8] He was raised in Chicago. His mother died when he was two years old and his father died when he was nineteen. Gibson supported his younger brother, Alexis, who died in 1967.[9] He graduated from high school early, at age 15, and ranked third in his class.[10]

According to Wensley Clarkson's biography of Mel Gibson, Hutton Gibson studied for the priesthood in a Chicago seminary which was operated by the Society of the Divine Word but he left the seminary because he considered the modernist theological doctrines which were being taught there disgusting. However, in 2003, Gibson stated that he really left the seminary because he did not want to be sent to New Guinea or the Philippines as a missionary.[10] Instead, he found work with Western Union and the Civilian Conservation Corps.[10] He also contributed to and edited the newsletter "The Pointer" while he worked in Wisconsin for the Civilian Conservation Corps from 1938 to 1939.[11]

After serving with the U.S. Army as a Signal Corps officer at the Battle of Guadalcanal, Gibson married Irish-born Anne Patricia Reilly on May 1, 1944, at the Catholic parish church of Our Lady of Good Counsel in Brooklyn, New York. They had ten children and adopted another one after their arrival in Australia. As of 2003, Gibson had 48 grandchildren and 15 great-grandchildren.[10] His wife died in December 1990. In January 2002, he married Teddy Joye Hicks, but in 2012 Gibson filed for divorce due to irreconcilable differences.[10][12] From early 2006, he resided in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, near Pittsburgh[13] after moving from Australia to Houston, Texas, in 1999,[11] and to Summersville, West Virginia, in 2003.[14]

Railroad lawsuit and move to Australia

[edit]

In the 1960s, Gibson worked for New York Central Railroad. In the early morning hours of December 11, 1964, he slipped off a steel platform which was covered in oil and snow[10] and injured his back. A work injury lawsuit followed and finally reached court on February 7, 1968. Seven days later, Gibson was awarded $145,000 (equivalent to $1,340,000 in 2025) by the jury. Gibson paid his debts and attorney's fees and later that year, he relocated his family, first to Ireland, then to Australia.[15]

Gibson said in 2003 that the move to his mother's native country was undertaken because he believed that the Australian Army would reject his oldest son for the Australian Vietnam War draft, unlike the U.S. Army.[10] Because of his back injuries, Gibson sought retraining in a new career. He was encouraged to become a computer programmer after IQ testing placed him in the genius range.[15][16]

At the October 1976 Annual General Meeting of the Latin Mass Society of Australia, Gibson resigned as secretary after loudly and continually claiming that the See of Peter was vacant due to Pope John XXIII's convention of the Second Vatican Council, and accusing subsequent popes of therefore being heretical antipopes.[10] He later founded an organisation called the Alliance for Catholic Truth.[17]

Quiz show contestant

[edit]

In 1968, Gibson appeared on the Art Fleming-hosted version of the game show Jeopardy! as "Red Gibson, a railroad brakeman from South Ozone Park, New York". Gibson won $4,680 and retired undefeated after five shows, in accordance with the rules of the show then in use. He was invited back to appear in the 1968 Tournament of Champions, where he became the year's grand champion,[18] winning slightly over one thousand dollars more, as well as a two-person cruise to the West Indies.[15][19][20][21] Art Fleming observed on the October 18, 1968, episode that the Jeopardy! staff had difficulty informing Gibson about his invitation, for Gibson had decamped with his family to County Tipperary, Ireland.[21]

Gibson later participated in many Australian quiz shows, including Big Nine with Athol Guy and Ford Superquiz with Bert Newton.[22][23] In 1986, The Sydney Morning Herald reported that Gibson had recently won $100,000 and an automobile in a TV quiz program.[24]

Beliefs

[edit]

Gibson was an outspoken critic of the Catholic Church‘s doctrine, leadership, and practice since the Second Vatican Council. He disseminated his views in a quarterly newsletter called The War is Now! and self-published three collections of these periodicals: Is the Pope Catholic?, The Enemy is Here!, and The Enemy is Still Here![11][25]

Gibson was especially critical of Pope John Paul II, whom he once described as "Garrulous Karolus the Koran-Kisser".[26] His allegation that the Pope kissed the Quran is corroborated by a FIDES News Service report of June 1, 1999, which quotes the Chaldean Catholic Patriarch, Raphael I Bidawid, as having confirmed to the news service that he was personally present when John Paul II kissed the text, which is sacred to Muslims:

On May 14th I was received by the Pope, together with a delegation composed of the Shi'ite imam of Khadum mosque and the Sunni president of the council of administration of the Iraqi Islamic Bank. There was also a representative of the Iraqi ministry of religion. ... At the end of the audience the Pope bowed to the Muslim holy book, the Qu'ran, presented to him by the delegation, and he kissed it as a sign of respect. The photo of that gesture has been shown repeatedly on Iraqi television and it demonstrates that the Pope not only is aware of the suffering of the Iraqi people, but he also has great respect for Islam.[11]

Gibson also used his newsletter to argue against Feeneyism.[citation needed] At the January 2004 We The People conference, Gibson advocated that the states should secede from the Federal government of the United States and the United States public debt should be abolished.[27]

One week before Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ (2004) was released in American film theaters, Hutton Gibson told radio talk show host Steve Feuerstein that the Holocaust was fabricated and "mostly fictional".[28] He said that the Jews had simply emigrated to other countries rather than having been killed, a view which observers described as Holocaust denial.[28][29] He claimed that census statistics prove there were more Jews in Europe after World War II than before.[30] Gibson said that certain Jews advocate a global religion and one world government.[28]

In his interview for The New York Times Magazine article, Gibson dismissed historical accounts that six million Jews were exterminated:

"Go and ask an undertaker or the guy who operates the crematorium what it takes to get rid of a dead body," he said. "It takes twenty liters of petrol and 20 minutes. Now, six million?" Across the table, Joye [Gibson's wife] suddenly looked up from her plate. ... She had kept quiet most of the day, so it was a surprise when she cheerfully piped in. "There weren't even that many Jews in all of Europe," she said. "Anyway, there were more after the war than before," Hutton added. The entire catastrophe was manufactured, said Hutton, as part of an arrangement between Hitler and "financiers" to move Jews out of Germany. Hitler "had this deal where he was supposed to make it rough on them so they would all get out and migrate to Israel because they needed people there to fight the Arabs," he said.[26]

Gibson was further quoted as saying that the Second Vatican Council was "a Masonic plot backed by the Jews"[2][3] and the September 11, 2001 attacks were perpetrated by remote control: "Hutton flatly rejected that Al Qaeda hijackers had anything to do with the attacks. 'Anybody can put out a passenger list,' he said".[2]

In the early 1990s, Gibson and Tom Costello hosted a video called Catholics, Where Has Our Church Gone?.[31] It is critical of the changes made within the Catholic Church by the Second Vatican Council and espouses the Siri thesis that in 1958, after the death of Pope Pius XII, the man originally elected pope was not Angelo Roncalli, but another cardinal, "probably Cardinal Siri of Genoa" (a staunch conservative candidate and first papabile). Gibson stated that the white smoke that emanated from a chimney in the Sistine Chapel to announce a new pope's election was done in error; black smoke signifying that the papacy was still vacant was quickly created, and the public was not informed of the reason for the initial white smoke. A still photograph of a newspaper story about this event is shown. "Had our church gone up in smoke?" asked Gibson. He stated that the new pope was forced to resign under duress, and two days later, the "modernist Roncalli" was elected pope and took the name "John XXIII". In 1962, Roncalli, as Pope John XXIII convened the Second Vatican Council.[31] In 2006, Hutton Gibson reversed his position on the Siri thesis, asserting that this theory was based on a mistranslation of an article written on October 27, 1958, by Silvio Negro for the evening edition of the Milan-based Corriere della Sera.[32]

A similar event happened in 1939; a confusing mixture of white and black smoke emanated from the Sistine Chapel chimney. In a note to Vatican Radio, the secretary of the Papal conclave at the time, a monsignor named Santoro said that a new pope, Eugenio Pacelli, had been properly elected regardless of the color of the smoke. Pacelli took the name Pius XII.[33]

Gibson endorsed Ron Paul for president in the 2008 United States Presidential Election.[34] In January 2010, he made an appearance on the far-right-wing radio show, The Political Cesspool, to promote his views.[35] In August 2010, he made another appearance on The Political Cesspool during which he made a widely discussed allegation that Pope Benedict XVI is "homosexual" and "half the people in the Vatican are queer". During the same interview, he also claimed that the Pope was a Freemason.[36]

Local congregation support

[edit]

In 2006, Gibson's foundation, The World Faith Foundation of California, which is funded by Mel Gibson, purchased an existing church structure in the Pittsburgh suburb of Unity, Pennsylvania, and used it to establish a Tridentine sedevacantist congregation called St. Michael the Archangel Roman Catholic Chapel.[37] Rev. Leonard Bealko, purportedly a former Roman Catholic priest who had left the church voluntarily in 1986, was appointed pastor. By mid-2007, Gibson and his fellow congregants had dismissed Bealko and dissolved the congregation amid charges that Bealko had misrepresented his credentials and mismanaged its finances.[38]

Later life and death

[edit]

Gibson died at a medical center in Thousand Oaks, California, on May 11, 2020, at the age of 101.[1]

Books

[edit]
  • Gibson, Hutton (1978). Is the Pope Catholic?: Paul VI's Legacy: Catholicism?. Australian Alliance for Catholic Tradition. ISBN 9780731650149.
  • Gibson, Hutton (1983). Time Out of Mind. Australian Alliance for Catholic Tradition. ASIN B0007C4E94.
  • Gibson, Hutton (1994). The Enemy is Here!. Christian Book Club of America. ASIN B000AN33ZQ.
  • Gibson, Hutton (2003). The Enemy is Still Here!. Faith & Freedom Publishing. ASIN B000AMYR2A.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Hutton Gibson

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Hutton Peter Gibson (August 26, 1918 – May 11, 2020) was an American author focused on sedevacantist arguments against post-Vatican II Catholicism, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran of , the 1968 grand champion of the television game show Jeopardy!, and the father of eleven children, including actor and director . Gibson served in the Marines during the war, later worked in various capacities including for Western Union and the U.S. Postal Service, and married Anne Patricia Reilly in 1944, with whom he raised his large family. After appearing on Jeopardy! hosted by Art Fleming, he won $4,680 across five undefeated regular shows and the Tournament of Champions, using the earnings to relocate his family from the United States to Australia in 1968 to avoid the Vietnam War draft for his sons. A staunch traditionalist Catholic, Gibson advocated —the doctrinal stance that the became vacant after the death of due to heresies introduced by subsequent popes—and critiqued Vatican II reforms in books like Is the Pope Catholic?: Paul VI's Legacy. He also drew public attention for interviews in which he questioned the established death toll of , claiming it was inflated and that many of the reported six million Jewish victims had instead fled to other countries like the , Britain, and rather than dying in Nazi camps.

Early Life

Childhood and Family Background

Hutton Gibson was born on August 26, 1918, in Peekskill, , to John Hutton Gibson, a businessman of Irish descent, and , an Australian-born singer. His parents' marriage reflected a blend of American and immigrant influences, with Mylott having performed in vaudeville and light circuits before settling in the United States. Gibson's early childhood occurred in a modest working-class environment typical of early 20th-century Peekskill, a town known for its industrial and manufacturing base, including hat factories and shipbuilding. His mother died in 1920 at age 45, shortly after giving birth to a sibling, leaving Gibson, then two years old, to be raised primarily by his father amid the challenges of single parenthood during the post-World War I economic adjustments. John Gibson continued his business pursuits until his own death in 1933, when young Hutton was 15, amid the onset of the , which likely strained family resources further based on contemporaneous economic records for the region. The Gibson household adhered to Roman Catholicism, a prevalent cultural and religious norm among Irish-American families in pre-Vatican II , providing Gibson with an early foundation in traditional devotional practices such as daily prayer and attendance at Latin Mass, though specific personal anecdotes from this period remain scarce in primary records. This upbringing in a devout, ethnically rooted Catholic milieu, without the later liturgical reforms, influenced his lifelong commitment to orthodox faith expressions, as evidenced by his subsequent writings and public statements.

World War II Service

Hutton Gibson entered military service in the U.S. Army prior to the American entry into , attending for the and graduating on September 30, 1941. As a officer, he held the rank of and was assigned to duties involving communications and coordination in combat environments. His training emphasized technical proficiency in radio operations and signal intelligence, critical for maintaining command links amid the logistical challenges of wartime mobilization. Gibson deployed to the Pacific Theater, where he participated in operations against Japanese forces, including the from August 1942 to February 1943. In this grueling island-hopping conflict, personnel like Gibson facilitated spotting, troop movements, and supply coordination under intense enemy fire and harsh conditions, contributing to the Allied seizure of the airfield and eventual Japanese withdrawal. Frontline service in such theaters exposed personnel to sustained combat, disease, and resource scarcity, with U.S. forces suffering over 7,000 casualties at alone. For his actions, Gibson received the , recognizing wounds sustained in combat during the campaign. This decoration underscored the physical toll of Pacific operations, where isolated engagements often amplified risks from ambushes, , and supply disruptions, fostering direct encounters with the realities of mechanized warfare and imperial expansionism. His wartime role concluded with the Allied island victories, marking a pivotal phase in disrupting Japanese supply lines across the Solomons.

Post-War Education and Early Career

Following his service, Gibson returned to civilian life in 1945 and eschewed formal higher education or vocational training programs, expressing strong aversion to structured environments with the declaration, "Nobody's ever going to get me in a classroom again." Instead, he prioritized immediate entry into the workforce to achieve , reflecting a practical approach grounded in personal experience rather than institutional paths. Gibson's early employment included a short tenure as a telegraph messenger for , delivering messages in a role demanding reliability amid the era's communication demands. This position exemplified his initial steps toward self-sustaining labor, leveraging basic skills over advanced credentials. Concurrently, assessments of his cognitive abilities revealed exceptional aptitude; IQ testing positioned him in the range, prompting suggestions for pursuits in nascent technical fields like , though he favored tangible, steady jobs conducive to family support. These formative experiences highlighted Gibson's emphasis on empirical , forgoing speculative opportunities in favor of roles offering predictable income and , unburdened by prolonged academic commitments.

Family and Relocation

Marriage and Children

Hutton Gibson married Anne Patricia Reilly, an Irish-born woman, on May 1, 1944, at Catholic Church in . The couple settled initially in , where they began building a amid post-World War II economic recovery. Gibson and Reilly had eleven children, with their sixth child, Mel Columcille Gerard Gibson, born on January 3, 1956, in Peekskill. This large family size aligned with patterns observed in devout Catholic households of the era, where opposition to artificial contraception under papal encyclicals like Casti connubii (1930) contributed to higher fertility rates—U.S. Catholic families averaging 3.8 children in 1955 compared to 2.4 for Protestants, per demographic surveys. The Gibsons maintained family cohesion through shared religious practices and frugality, as evidenced by Hutton's later reflections on prioritizing education and moral formation over material excess despite modest means from railroad work. Reilly died in December 1990 at age 71, after nearly 46 years of . The couple's emphasis on procreation and child-rearing as central to marital reflected pre-Vatican II Catholic teachings, which viewed as the domestic church and discouraged spacing births except for grave reasons.

Railroad Employment and Injury Lawsuit

In the , Hutton Gibson worked as a for the . On December 11, 1964, Gibson slipped from a steel platform covered in oil and snow during early morning operations, resulting in severe back injuries that necessitated his retirement from rail work. He filed a lawsuit against the railroad, which proceeded to beginning February 7, 1968. The jury awarded him $145,000 on February 14, 1968, compensating for the workplace conditions that directly contributed to the fall and subsequent disability.

Emigration to Australia

In February 1968, Hutton Gibson, injured as a for the , prevailed in a that awarded him $145,000 in damages after a concluding on February 14. He utilized these proceeds to relocate his family of ten children from , to later that year, seeking new economic opportunities amid his forced retirement due to the injury. The family settled in West Pymble, a suburb of , , which offered a comparatively less densely populated environment than the region they left behind—Sydney's metropolitan area in 1968 housed around 2.5 million residents, contrasting with New York's urban pressures. Gibson cited the move to his mother Anne Reilly's birthplace as a strategic choice, believing Australian conscription policies would exempt his American-born eldest sons from service, unlike U.S. draft requirements. Initial adjustment involved logistical hurdles, including trans-Pacific travel for a large household and establishing residence in a foreign system, though English-language continuity eased some transitions; the family navigated housing and schooling in a nation where Catholics comprised approximately 25% of the population in the 1960s, providing a familiar demographic backdrop without primary relocation impetus. Adaptive challenges persisted in professional reintegration, as Gibson pivoted to self-employment ventures like technical writing, leveraging the settlement's capital in an economy buoyed by post-war immigration and resource sectors.

Public Recognition and Achievements

Quiz Show Victories

In 1968, Hutton Gibson competed on the original version of the American television Jeopardy!, hosted by , winning $4,680 after retiring undefeated following five consecutive victories in accordance with the program's rules at the time. He was subsequently invited to participate in the 1968 Tournament of Champions, where he emerged as the grand champion, earning an additional sum exceeding $1,000 for a total prize approaching $6,000, which provided financial support for his family's relocation efforts shortly thereafter. These accomplishments demonstrated Gibson's extensive across diverse subjects, including , , and science, as required by the format's clue-based questioning. After emigrating to in 1968, Gibson continued to engage in quiz show competitions, appearing on programs such as Big Nine, hosted by , and Ford Superquiz, hosted by . These appearances, spanning into the , highlighted his ongoing intellectual acuity into later adulthood. In 1986, reported that Gibson had won $100,000 along with a car on an Australian television quiz show, further evidencing his proficiency in rapid recall and analytical skills under competitive pressure.

Intellectual Aptitudes

Following a back injury sustained on December 11, 1964, while working for the , Gibson underwent IQ testing during vocational retraining assessments. The evaluation placed him in the range, leading evaluators to recommend a career in as suited to his analytical capabilities. This aptitude, however, remained largely underutilized, as Gibson prioritized supporting his wife and eleven children, culminating in the family's 1968 emigration to amid financial and ideological considerations. While he engaged in some programming-related work there, family obligations and subsequent pursuits in writing and advocacy took precedence over specialized technical fields. Gibson's independent analyses in published works demonstrate proficiency in dissecting complex issues via foundational logic and evidence scrutiny, traits aligned with high cognitive benchmarks yet frequently dismissed in broader evaluations influenced by disagreement with his conclusions.

Religious Development

Path to Catholicism

Hutton Gibson was born on August 26, 1918, in , to parents of Irish descent, and raised in following the early deaths of both his mother, , an Australian opera singer, and his father, John Hutton Gibson, a tobacco businessman. His family background aligned with Catholic practice, fostering an early religious formation that led him to pursue priestly . As a young man prior to , Gibson entered the seminary of the in , a missionary order, with aspirations for evangelization abroad. He departed without , reportedly declining potential assignments to remote missions in or the , yet retained a profound attachment to Catholic orthodoxy rooted in pre-conciliar liturgical and doctrinal norms. This formative period underscored his preference for the Church's historical continuity over emerging modernist interpretations, as later reflected in his consistent advocacy for unaltered traditions. Postwar experiences, including his U.S. Army service in and roles, reinforced rather than diminished his , channeling it into familial ; he married Anne Reilly, a Catholic, and fathered eleven children instructed in rigorous observance of pre-Vatican II devotions such as frequent Latin participation. Gibson's trajectory thus emphasized empirical fidelity to longstanding Catholic rites amid mid-20th-century shifts, prioritizing doctrinal purity derived from apostolic origins over accommodations to secular influences.

Embrace of Traditionalism

Hutton Gibson shifted toward following the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965), which introduced sweeping liturgical reforms, including the replacement of the with the Novus Ordo Missae promulgated in 1969. He rejected the Novus Ordo as a departure from the codified at the in the and preserved without substantial alteration for over four centuries, insisting on strict adherence to this form as the normative expression of Catholic worship. Gibson's embrace of traditionalism centered on a commitment to unchanging liturgical and doctrinal truths, which he argued ensured continuity with apostolic origins amid perceived post-conciliar innovations. He contended that any doubt regarding the validity of changes warranted adherence to the established traditional , placing the onus of justification on proponents of novelty rather than defenders of historical precedent. This stance aligned with empirical observation of the Church's liturgical stability prior to the , framing traditionalism as a reasoned preservation of verifiable continuity over subjective adaptation. In practice, Gibson promoted the Tridentine rite through organizational efforts, including his role in Australia's early traditionalist circles and the founding of the Alliance for Catholic Tradition in 1977, via which he distributed materials advocating doctrinal fidelity to pre-Vatican II norms. His newsletter, The War Is On, further disseminated these principles, emphasizing the Latin Mass's role in safeguarding sacramental integrity against reforms he viewed as rupturing longstanding ecclesiastical practice. This approach positioned traditionalism not as idiosyncratic resistance but as fidelity to the Church's empirically attested historical depositum fidei.

Core Beliefs

Sedevacantist Theology

Hutton Gibson espoused , the theological position holding that the has remained vacant since at least the pontificate of John XXIII (1958–1963), rendering subsequent papal claimants invalid due to their public propagation of doctrines incompatible with the immutable Catholic faith. He regarded the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965) as the pivotal rupture, introducing modernist errors that constituted formal heresy, thereby necessitating rejection of post-conciliar popes as antipopes who had defected from orthodoxy. This stance framed not as but as fidelity to pre-conciliar , positing an extended akin to historical vacancies between legitimate elections. Central to Gibson's argumentation was the principle that a pope forfeits office ipso facto upon manifest public heresy, drawing from canon law precedents and patristic condemnations where tolerance of error invalidated authority. In his 1978 book Is the Pope Catholic? Paul VI's Legacy: Catholicism?, he targeted Paul VI (1963–1978) for violating the anti-Modernist oath by endorsing Vatican II's innovations, described as "the synthesis of all heresies," which corrupted the deposit of faith beyond infallible safeguards. Gibson invoked Vatican I's Pastor Aeternus (1870), limiting ex cathedra infallibility to preservation of revealed truth without novelty, to argue that Paul VI's promulgation of erroneous councils eroded papal credibility entirely, echoing the automatic deposition effected by defection. He cited the Sixth Ecumenical Council's condemnation of Honorius I (d. 638) by Pope St. Leo II for negligently abetting Monothelitism, as a binding precedent that heresy—active or permissive—severs ecclesiastical jurisdiction without formal trial. Gibson's views aligned with sedevacantist of theologians like St. Robert Bellarmine (1542–1621), who in De Romano Pontifice (1586) contended a manifesting pertinacious ceases to be by the fact itself, as membership in the Church requires adherence to its faith, precluding heretical governance. This first-principles reasoning prioritized causal fidelity to divine law over visible continuity, deeming extended vacancy permissible absent a true successor, much as interregnums followed disputed elections historically (e.g., the , 1378–1417). While Gibson enumerated such supports factually in writings, he emphasized empirical discernment of Vatican II's contradictions to perennial doctrine—e.g., diluting —as irrefutable evidence compelling sedevacantist conclusion over recognition of invalid claimants.

Critiques of Vatican II Reforms

Hutton Gibson objected to the Second Vatican Council's liturgical reforms, particularly those outlined in (1963), which paved the way for the Novus Ordo Missae promulgated by in 1969, arguing that such changes exceeded the council's authority and altered the Mass's traditional sacrificial character in favor of a more communal, Protestant-influenced rite. He contended that the shift from Latin to vernacular languages, the simplification of rubrics, and the reorientation of the altar diminished the rite's doctrinal clarity and reverence, representing a rupture with the codified at the (1545-1563). Gibson further critiqued the council's ecumenical initiatives, as expressed in Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), for diluting Catholic exclusivity by implying that separated Christian communities possess elements of sanctification and truth sufficient for salvation, which he viewed as contradicting prior teachings such as Pope Boniface VIII's Unam Sanctam (1302) asserting "outside the Church there is no salvation." In his analysis, these documents fostered religious indifferentism, prioritizing dialogue over conversion and equating non-Catholic faiths with the one true Church, thereby weakening evangelistic imperatives rooted in scriptural and patristic sources. Post-conciliar statistics underscored Gibson's concerns regarding institutional vitality; U.S. Catholic Mass attendance, which hovered around 65-75% in the early 1960s, plummeted to about 50% by 1970 and further to roughly 30% by the 1980s, with global trends showing a relative decline of four percentage points per decade from 1965 to 2015 compared to other denominations. Similarly, worldwide priestly vocations peaked near 430,000 in the mid-1960s before contracting amid sharp drops in the West, from over 48,000 U.S. seminarians in 1965 to under 4,000 by the 2000s, correlating temporally with reform implementations like the new and relaxed disciplinary norms. Gibson attributed these metrics to causal effects of the reforms, positing that ambiguities in conciliar texts—such as (1965) on religious liberty, which appeared to endorse state neutrality toward error contrary to papal condemnations in (1864)—eroded doctrinal rigor, fostering confusion and disaffection among the faithful without necessitating formal . He emphasized textual discrepancies over mere adaptation, arguing that deviations from immutable teachings invited modernist erosion, as evidenced by sustained pre-conciliar growth in catechumens and institutions reversing post-1965.

Controversial Positions

Skepticism Toward Holocaust Narratives

In a February 2004 interview on New York radio station WSNR's "Speak Your Piece" program, Hutton Gibson articulated skepticism toward the Holocaust's reported scale of six million Jewish deaths, deeming it "mostly fiction" and asserting that Nazi crematoria lacked the fuel capacity to dispose of such numbers amid wartime shortages. He contended that incinerating millions would require vast quantities of petrol or coke—extrapolating from standard cremation metrics of 20-50 kg of fuel per body and 1-2 hours per single cadaver—which exceeded Germany's documented allocations and oven throughputs, rendering mass extermination logistically implausible without verifiable engineering corroboration. Gibson also interrogated population demographics, observing that many Jews enumerated as camp fatalities had relocated to destinations including the and , and cited variances between pre-war censuses and initial Allied intelligence reports—such as preliminary Red Cross tallies estimating far fewer deaths—as evidence of inflated figures unsupported by comprehensive vital statistics. These critiques framed the six-million toll as inconsistent with emigration patterns and natural , urging scrutiny of raw data over aggregated narratives. Revisionist perspectives, including Gibson's, emphasize such causal constraints—fuel logistics, mechanics, and demographic balances—as empirical anchors demanding precise quantification, often drawing on industrial benchmarks to challenge claims of 4,000+ daily disposals at sites like Auschwitz. Counterarguments from historians invoke Nazi vendor records from Topf & Sons indicating crematoria optimized for 1,400-4,000 bodies daily via multi-cadaver muffles, fat-assisted combustion, and pit burnings, supplemented by deportation manifests totaling over five million to extermination zones. Demographic reconstructions, reconciling 9.5 million pre-1939 European with 3.5 million survivors and limited verified outflows (under 500,000), sustain the deficit through camp registries and logs, though debates persist on adjustment methodologies. Opponents of these inquiries typically recourse to labels of denialism, sidestepping direct forensic or archival dissection, whereas advocates maintain that unaddressed discrepancies in fuel audits and early reportage necessitate ongoing, data-driven probe absent presumptive closure.

Broader Conspiracy Perspectives

Hutton Gibson rejected the official narrative of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, claiming the commercial airliners that struck the World Trade Center were remotely controlled rather than piloted by hijackers affiliated with al-Qaeda. He asserted that no passengers were aboard the planes, arguing that passenger manifests could be fabricated at will to support a deception. This perspective positioned the events as an orchestrated operation with foreknowledge by elements within the U.S. government or allied interests, dismissing Osama bin Laden's role as a fabricated culprit. Gibson's skepticism drew on observed anomalies in the attacks' execution, such as the precision of the flights and the rapid structural failures of the towers, which he contrasted with engineering analyses suggesting inconsistencies with fire-induced collapse models alone. While mainstream investigations, including the National Institute of Standards and Technology's 2005 report, attributed the buildings' collapses to aircraft impact damage combined with uncontrolled fires weakening supports, Gibson prioritized alternative interpretations emphasizing residues and free-fall descent speeds reported by eyewitnesses and initial seismic data. These claims echoed broader critiques from structural engineers, including those affiliated with groups like Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, who in 2006 began petitioning for reinvestigation based on traces allegedly found in dust samples. Drawing from his World War II service as a operator in the U.S. Army, Gibson applied a pattern of governmental deceptions to contemporary events, viewing 9/11 as a modern parallel to wartime and false-flag tactics he believed were used to manipulate public consent for policy shifts. Consensus dismissals, such as those from the released on July 22, 2004, maintained the hijacking scenario supported by flight data recorders and DNA evidence, yet Gibson's stance highlighted discrepancies like the reported non-recovery of intact black boxes from the crash site. Such views, while unsubstantiated by federal probes, underscored his broader suspicion of elite-orchestrated narratives designed to erode under pretexts of security.

Accusations of Antisemitism and Rebuttals

Accusations of antisemitism against Hutton Gibson intensified following his son Mel Gibson's July 2006 arrest for drunk driving, during which Mel made derogatory remarks about Jews, prompting media scrutiny of the family's views. Outlets such as ABC News linked Hutton's traditionalist Catholicism to antisemitic tropes, citing his 2004 WSNR radio interview where he claimed the Holocaust was "mostly fiction," argued that many of the six million Jewish deaths were inflated as victims had emigrated to Israel, and stated that "Jews are trying to take over the world." Jewish advocacy groups and publications like Haaretz condemned these as classic Holocaust denial and conspiratorial antisemitism, warning they could incite prejudice amid sensitivities over Mel's The Passion of the Christ (2004), which some critics already viewed as portraying Jews negatively. Critics, including the , equated Gibson's positions with hate by associating them with radical traditionalist rhetoric alleging orchestration of global events, such as portraying the Second Vatican Council as a "Masonic plot backed by the ," a claim attributed to him in multiple reports. These accusations portrayed Gibson's worldview as inherently prejudiced, with outlets like later describing his views in his 2020 obituary as "anti-Semitic" for denying the Holocaust's scale and promoting conspiracy theories. Gibson did not issue formal public rebuttals to the label but framed his critiques within sedevacantist theology, emphasizing opposition to what he saw as Talmudic Judaism's anti-Christian elements and Zionist political agendas rather than . Supporters in traditionalist circles defended this as principled discernment rooted in pre-Vatican II Catholic doctrine, which historically taught of Judaism's supersession by , collective Jewish responsibility for , and the need for Jewish conversion, as reflected in like the Oremus pro perfidis Judaeis prayer used until 1959. They argued such positions challenge institutionalized narratives on historical events and religious influence, prioritizing empirical questioning over equated malice, with Gibson's persistence viewed as fidelity to doctrinal realism against post-conciliar shifts. Critics dismissed these distinctions as semantic cover for bigotry, while proponents maintained they reflect causal analysis of doctrinal conflicts, not racial animus.

Writings and Advocacy

Authored Publications

Hutton Gibson authored several works focused on sedevacantist critiques of post-Vatican II papal claimants, emphasizing adherence to pre-conciliar Catholic doctrine. His primary book, Is the Pope Catholic?: Paul VI's Legacy: Catholicism?, published in 1978 by the Australian Alliance for Catholic Tradition, examines the pontificate of Paul VI, arguing that deviations in teachings on liturgy, ecumenism, and religious liberty invalidated his claim to the papacy under traditional criteria of heresy forfeiting office. The text delineates papal infallibility as limited to ex cathedra pronouncements on faith and morals, asserting Paul VI's public errors—such as endorsing collegiality and interfaith dialogue—rendered him a formal heretic, thus vacating the Holy See. Subsequent publications compiled Gibson's newsletter The War is Now!, which rigorously defended sedevacantism through scriptural, canonical, and historical analysis. The Enemy is Here!: A Reorganized Synthesis of The War is Now!, January 1977-August 1994, issued in 1994 by the Christian Book Club of America, synthesizes essays on ecclesiastical infiltration by modernist influences, portraying Vatican II as a rupture from immutable dogma and urging fidelity to eternal truths over hierarchical obedience. Its sequel, The Enemy is Still Here!: A Reorganized Synthesis of The War is Now!, November 1994-March 2003, published in 2003, extends this argumentation to later papal figures, reinforcing themes of doctrinal purity amid perceived apostasy, with detailed rebuttals to recognize-and-resist positions held by groups like the Society of St. Pius X. These works circulated primarily within sedevacantist networks, influencing small traditionalist communities through self-published or niche presses, though exact sales figures remain undocumented; their impact is evidenced by references in traditional Catholic forums and libraries preserving pre-Vatican II advocacy. Gibson's writings prioritize first-hand scriptural and application, eschewing compromise with reformed structures to preserve what he termed the "una cum" integrity of the faith.

Support for Traditionalist Communities

Gibson established the Australian Alliance for Catholic Tradition, an organization focused on upholding pre-Vatican II Catholic doctrines and liturgies through coordinated dissemination of materials and advocacy. This group, formed after the Gibson family's move to in 1968, provided structural support for traditionalist Catholics seeking alternatives to post-conciliar reforms, including publications like Time Out of Mind in 1983 that reinforced communal adherence to unaltered practices. Early on, the Gibson family home in served as a temporary venue for celebrations following the 1969 introduction of the Novus Ordo Missae, enabling continued observance of the 1962 amid limited official availability. This practical provision facilitated worship for local families rejecting liturgical novelties, contributing to the endurance of informal sedevacantist gatherings in during the 1970s. Gibson also engaged with the Latin Mass Society of , joining post-relocation and aiding its operations to promote the traditional , though his eventual expulsion in the late highlighted tensions with less stringent traditionalists. These organizational involvements fostered networks of correspondence among isolated practitioners, sustaining minority commitment to pre-Vatican II rites against ecclesiastical marginalization and helping seed persistent small congregations, such as those maintaining exclusive use of the Latin Mass in suburbs into subsequent decades.

Final Years and Legacy

Health Interventions and Longevity

In his early nonagenarian years, Hutton Gibson became wheelchair-bound due to progressive frailty and mobility limitations associated with advanced age. Around 2005, at approximately 92 years of age, he received therapy derived from tissue at the Stem Cell Institute in , , facilitated by his son . Post-treatment, Gibson exhibited verifiable functional gains, transitioning from dependence to independent ambulation, with reports of reduced , enhanced cognitive sharpness, and overall restoration. These outcomes, documented through family accounts and clinic follow-ups, aligned with empirical observations of stem cell-induced tissue repair and anti-inflammatory effects in applications. Gibson's subsequent survival to age 101, defying standard actuarial projections for untreated frailty in centenarians—which typically forecast inexorable decline and comorbidity escalation—underscored the potential causal role of such non-conventional interventions in extending healthspan. Mel Gibson publicly attributed his father's resilience and prolonged independence to the therapy's regenerative mechanisms, contrasting it with conventional geriatric care paradigms that emphasize palliative management over reversal. This case empirically challenged ageist assumptions of inevitable , highlighting how targeted cellular therapies could mitigate and vascular degeneration in the elderly.

Death and Familial Influence

Hutton Gibson died on May 11, 2020, at the age of 101, at Los Robles Hospital and Medical Center in . His death was not publicly announced at the time and was later confirmed through vital records. As a sedevacantist Catholic who rejected post-Vatican II reforms, Gibson's passing occurred privately, aligning with his lifelong advocacy for pre-conciliar liturgical practices, though specific funeral details remain unpublicized. Gibson's uncompromising traditionalist faith profoundly shaped his son 's worldview, particularly evident in the latter's directorial work. Mel Gibson has credited his father with instilling a deep commitment to orthodox Catholicism, which informed the unflinching portrayal of Christ's suffering in (2004), a emphasizing literal scriptural fidelity and traditional devotions over modern ecumenical adaptations. This paternal influence extended to reinforcing skepticism toward institutional changes in the Church, mirroring Hutton's own writings and public stances that prioritized doctrinal purity. Gibson's legacy remains polarized: revered in sedevacantist and traditionalist Catholic communities for his multi-decade critiques of Vatican , as seen in his self-published works that continue to circulate among adherents rejecting post-1960s reforms. Conversely, mainstream outlets and progressive commentators have portrayed him as an extremist due to his conspiracy-oriented views, including skepticism, amplifying scrutiny on his familial ties during controversies surrounding Mel's career. This divide underscores his enduring role as a polarizing figure in Catholic traditionalism, with his influence persisting through his writings and personal impact on high-profile descendants rather than institutional acclaim.

References

  1. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1585176/
  2. https://www.newsweek.com/who-hutton-mel-gibson-father-death-died-1509049
  3. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1585176/trivia/
  4. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Gibson-5866
  5. https://www.thriftbooks.com/a/hutton-gibson/1492632/
  6. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2004-02-19/mel-gibsons-father-says-holocaust-exaggerated/138294
  7. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/arts/gibsons-father-says-holocaust-exaggerated/article4087290/
  8. https://abcnews.go.com/ThisWeek/story?id=132486&page=1
  9. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/04/us/hutton-gibson-extremist-and-father-of-mel-gibson-dies-at-101.html
  10. https://ancestors.familysearch.org/en/G7LP-L3B/hutton-peter-gibson-jr-1918-2020
  11. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/210507527/hutton_peter-gibson
  12. https://www.geni.com/people/Hutton-Red-Gibson/6000000003213672029
  13. https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Hutton_Gibson
  14. https://www.nndb.com/people/988/000031895/
  15. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2119532/trivia/?item=tr3137638
  16. https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%257CA55030944&sid=googleScholar&v=2.1&it=r&linkaccess=abs&issn=10473572&p=AONE&sw=w
  17. https://www.nplusonemag.com/online-only/film-review/mad-as-mel/
  18. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1585176/bio/
  19. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000154/bio/
  20. https://www.irishcentral.com/roots/genealogy/mel-gibson-irish-roots
  21. https://encyclopedia.pub/entry/39386
  22. https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/1kfmo4n/til_mel_gibson_is_actually_american_born_in_1956/
  23. https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/real-life/tortured-life-of-megastar-mel-gibsons-brother-andrew-inside-a-sydney-housing-commission-flat/news-story/9c6f812dfeb84455d78c92fc4bf12451
  24. https://gameshows.fandom.com/wiki/Hutton_Gibson
  25. https://www.theaustralian.com.au/weekend-australian-magazine/mad-as-a-hutton/news-story/5e23f4568c95443dad863b32e5462057
  26. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2003/09/15/the-jesus-war
  27. https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/story?id=2256719&page=1
  28. https://www.scribd.com/document/374926337/Hutton-Gibson-Is-the-Pope-Catholic
  29. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8211045-is-the-pope-catholic-paul-vi-s-legacy
  30. https://www.facebook.com/groups/659850404426435/posts/1733576843720447/
  31. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/09/data-bolsters-theory-about-plunging-catholic-mass-attendance/
  32. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w34060/w34060.pdf
  33. https://pure.psu.edu/en/publications/catholic-religious-vocations-decline-and-revival
  34. https://dornsife.usc.edu/iacs/2022/04/30/global-christianity/
  35. https://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/data-researchers-conclude-vatican-ii-triggered-decline-in-catholic-practice/
  36. http://new.wymaninstitute.org/2005/12/disown-your-dads-denial-of-the-holocaust-gibson-told/
  37. https://phdn.org/archives/holocaust-history.org/irving-david/vanpelt/vanpelt-coke.shtml
  38. https://www.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.7228/manchester/9780719096020.001.0001/upso-9780719096020-chapter-6
  39. https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/gallery/jewish-population-of-europe
  40. https://www.vhec.org/faces-of-loss/will-the-exact-number-of-jewish-victims-ever-be-known/
  41. https://www.haaretz.com/2004-02-20/ty-article/mel-gibsons-father-says-holocaust-was-mostly-fiction/0000017f-df0a-db22-a17f-ffbb212f0000
  42. https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/3182275.stm
  43. https://www.christianitytoday.com/2004/02/passionprejudice/
  44. https://www.aei.org/articles/crucifying-mel-gibson/
  45. https://www.splcenter.org/resources/reports/radical-traditionalist-catholics-spew-anti-semitic-hate-commit-violence-against-jews/
  46. https://www.international.ucla.edu/euro/article/130231
  47. https://sspx.org/en/news/judaism-church-after-vatican-ii-4622
  48. https://nla.gov.au/nla.cat-vn6347516
  49. https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Enemy_is_Here.html?id=4wLiAAAAMAAJ
  50. https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Enemy_is_Still_Here.html?id=2ATiAAAAMAAJ
  51. https://nla.gov.au/nla.cat-vn6186904
  52. https://undergroundarchive.fandom.com/wiki/Hutton_Gibson
  53. https://r3stemcell.com/mel-gibson-dad-stem-cell-therapy-panama-recovery/
  54. https://www.cellmedicine.com/famous-stem-cell-cases-celebrities-athletes-who-have-received-therapy/
  55. https://auragens.com/mel-gibson-panama-and-power-of-stem-cell-therapy/
  56. https://mtrb.org/where-did-mel-gibsons-dad-get-stem-cell-therapy-2/
  57. https://nbscience.com/mel-gibson-has-been-an-advocate-for-the-use-of-stem-cell-therapy-after-a-personal-experience-with-his-fathers-health/
  58. https://www.cellmedicine.com/does-anti-aging-stem-cell-therapy-exist/
  59. https://www.neilriordan.com/does-anti-aging-stem-cell-therapy-exist/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.