Hubbry Logo
The Game ChangersThe Game ChangersMain
Open search
The Game Changers
Community hub
The Game Changers
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The Game Changers
The Game Changers
The Game Changers
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Game Changers
A large muscular arm, with green tinted veins.
Official release poster
Directed byLouie Psihoyos
Written byMark Monroe
Joseph Pace
Produced byJoseph Pace
James Wilks
StarringJames Wilks
Scott Jurek
Patrik Baboumian
Production
companies
Oceanic Preservation Society
Refuel Productions
Diamond Docs
The Djinn Foundation
Release date
  • January 19, 2018 (2018-01-19)
Running time
86 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Box office$897,992[1]

The Game Changers is a 2018 American documentary film about vegan athletes who follow plant-based diets.[2][3][4]

Release

[edit]

The Game Changers debuted at the Sundance Film Festival in January 2018, with a second edit released worldwide for a one-day screening in September 2019.[3] The film has over a dozen executive producers, including James Cameron, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Pamela Anderson, Steve Bellamy, Rip Esselstyn, Jackie Chan and Brendan Brazier.[4][5]

Synopsis

[edit]

James Wilks is a mixed martial artist and self defense instructor. Having suffered an injury he used his downtime to explore the effects of plant-based diets on health, recovery, and athletic performance. He first explores the vegetarian diet of Roman gladiators before interviewing athletes such as Scott Jurek, Patrik Baboumian, Bryant Jennings, and Derrick Morgan (along with his wife, the plant-based chef Charity Morgan) who attribute their success to a plant-based diet.

Comments follow from Scott Stoll, a physician for the USA Olympic team, who argues that animal based protein impedes recovery and athletic performance due to certain inflammatory molecules and inflammatory mediators. He contrasts this with plant-based proteins that, he argues, promote gut microbial diversity, reduce inflammation, and optimize recovery and athletic performance. The film dramatizes a comparison of postprandial effects of meals consisting of animal- versus plant-based foods, purporting to show that those who ate meat showed reduced penile function and indications of endothelial dysfunction that could disrupt athletic performance. In an interview, Professor of Epidemiology and Nutrition, Walter Willett, argues that there is accumulating evidence showing that high consumption of protein from dairy sources is related to a higher risk of prostate cancer.

The next scenes criticize the meat and dairy industry for what Perry Mason, Executive Officer of the Cook County Department of Public Health, calls tactics out of the tobacco industry playbook where public relations firms such as Exponent hire researchers to create doubt to counteract public health messages. Doctor of preventative medicine David Katz says despite the appearance of confusion in the media, there is global consensus that a healthy diet is a plant-food rich diet.

A further indictment of animal agriculture comes from Bob Bailey, Research Director of Energy, Environment, and Resources at Chatham House, who says that while three quarters of all agricultural land are used for livestock production such food sources provide 34% of the protein and 18% of the calories worldwide. Animal agriculture is charged with being a main driver of deforestation and is implicated in habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity. Other scientists in the film mention other environmental impacts of animal farming including carbon dioxide emissions, the overuse of fresh water, and water pollution. Professor of Food Policy, Tim Lang, makes a closing argument that reducing meat and dairy consumption and increasing plant consumption will improve both public health and environmental health.

Having recovered from his injury, Wilks is shown teaching self defense with an additional component, what he terms "internal defense", saying that with his understanding of the benefits of plant-based diets he now has the tools to protect more lives than ever before.

[edit]
In order of appearance

Reception

[edit]

On Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 67% based on reviews from 9 critics.[7] It received overall positive reviews by viewers,[8] but was criticized by some nutrition, fitness, and science communication professionals.[9][10][11] It has been credited with influencing some viewers to shift their dietary habits towards more plant-based options,[12][13][14] an impact that has been dubbed the "Game Changers effect".[15] Actor Dolph Lundgren and CEO of Greggs, Roger Whiteside said they decided to follow a vegan diet after watching it.[16][17]

VegNews ranked the film as one of the best vegan documentaries to watch in 2024.[18] Viewing the film is accredited as an approved activity for continuing medical education (CME) credits by the Defense Health Agency,[19] and the American College of Lifestyle Medicine offers CME credits for watching the film and passing an online quiz based on it.[20][21]

The documentary was criticized by some professionals in fitness, nutrition, and science communication.[11][22] For example, sports nutrition expert Asker Jeukendrup said, "Game Changers ticks almost all the boxes of pseudoscience, and none of the boxes of science"[10] while Joe Schwarcz, director of the McGill University Office for Science and Society complained, "There is good science to be had for promoting a plant-based diet, but this film strays too much into pseudoscience for my appetite." Schwarcz criticized the film, saying "the feats of the athletes in The Game Changers cannot be considered to be proof of the benefits of a vegan diet for athletic performance." According to Schwarcz, the evidence presented "is quite flimsy", the filmmakers indulge in confirmation bias and data dredging, and "some of the research cited on behalf of veganism is funded by the organic or avocado industries."[9]

The journal of the Hungarian Dietetic Association Új DIÉTA (New Diet) criticized the film, calling it "pseudoscience rather than real science" and "propaganda for veganism". The journal criticized the film for "one-sided research" and claims lacking in scientific basis, saying "The Game Changers only includes research that is conducive to the message they want to convey, that a vegan (plant based) diet is better in all respects than a diet containing animal-derived foods." The journal opined that it is "of paramount importance" that a documentary of this type approach the topic with scientific rigor, but "instead, the filmmakers placed more emphasis (on) eliciting emotional impact than the proper scientific background."[23] Mail & Guardian writer Luke Feltham similarly criticized the documentarian's claims of neutral presentation of facts, calling the film "an hour-and-a-half advertisement for vegan living".[24]

Some generally supportive reviewers also took issue with the movie's portrayal of masculinity especially as it adopts some stereotypical arguments regarding virility and the traditionally assumed connections between masculinity and strength.[25][26][27][28]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Game Changers

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a 2018 documentary film that advocates for plant-based diets as superior for athletic performance, recovery, and overall health, centering on mixed martial artist James Wilks's personal investigation into optimal nutrition following an injury. Directed by Louie Psihoyos and produced by Wilks among others, the film features interviews with vegan athletes such as ultramarathoner Scott Jurek and strongman Patrik Baboumian, alongside endorsements from figures like Arnold Schwarzenegger and James Cameron, who argue that animal products hinder endurance and promote inflammation. Key claims include enhanced blood flow and erection quality after plant-based meals compared to meat-heavy ones, demonstrated via small-scale experiments, and historical examples of gladiators purportedly thriving on barley-based diets. While the documentary highlights successful plant-based athletes and some evidence for reduced cardiovascular risks with such diets, it has drawn criticism for relying on anecdotal evidence, extrapolating from underpowered studies involving few participants, and omitting robust data showing comparable or superior outcomes for omnivorous athletes in strength and power sports. Reviews from nutrition experts note that although plant-based eating can support high performance when nutrient needs are met, the film's assertion of universal superiority lacks causal substantiation from large-scale, controlled trials and ignores confounders like training volume and genetics.

Production

Development and Premise

James Wilks, a former UFC fighter and producer of the documentary, sustained severe bilateral knee injuries in 2011 that sidelined him from training and prompted an extensive personal investigation into optimal nutrition for athletic recovery. During this period, Wilks examined dietary approaches, initially focusing on high-protein animal-based regimens common among athletes, but gradually shifted toward plant-based options after reviewing scientific studies and historical examples, such as analyses of ancient gladiators' diets. His self-reported improvements in endurance and strength from adopting a vegan diet during recovery formed the basis for the film's central narrative. Filming for The Game Changers began in , shortly after Wilks' injuries, as he sought to document his findings and interview athletes and experts endorsing plant-based eating for performance advantages. Wilks collaborated with director , known for the Oscar-winning The Cove, to structure the project as a investigative journey challenging conventional views on protein sources and in sports. Executive producers including and joined to amplify the production's reach, with Cameron contributing based on his own advocacy for plant-based diets and Schwarzenegger providing credibility from his background despite initial skepticism. The premise centers on Wilks' assertion, derived from his post-injury experimentation and review of select studies, that plant-based diets confer superior benefits for athletic recovery, strength, and overall health compared to omnivorous ones reliant on animal products. This framework frames as an exposé on purported myths about meat's necessity for elite performance, drawing from Wilks' narrative of transformative personal evidence rather than comprehensive meta-analyses.

Key Personnel and Funding

served as the primary producer and on-screen narrator of The Game Changers, drawing from his background as a former UFC mixed martial artist who retired in 2012 after sustaining a double knee injury in 2011, which led him to investigate plant-based diets for recovery and performance. , who adopted during this period, framed the film's premise around his personal quest for evidence supporting meat-free nutrition among elite athletes. The director, , is an Academy Award-winning filmmaker best known for The Cove (2009), a exposing dolphin hunting practices with an emphasis on and environmental advocacy. Executive producers included , a prominent filmmaker who transitioned to in 2012 and has since promoted plant-based eating through investments exceeding $140 million in alternative proteins, alongside his wife . Other notable executive producers, such as , , , and , brought visibility from sports and entertainment, many of whom have publicly endorsed reduced consumption for health or ethical reasons. Funding details for the film remain largely undisclosed, with production supported primarily through the resources and networks of its vegan-aligned executive producers rather than traditional studio backing or contributions from and industry sources. This reflects motivations tied to environmental, ethical, and for plant-based diets, as evidenced by Cameron's concurrent financial stakes in vegan ventures, potentially influencing the selection of narrative elements favoring such perspectives. No peer-reviewed disclosures or financial reports specify exact budgets or donor breakdowns, underscoring the project's roots in -driven initiative over neutral .

Filming Process

Filming for The Game Changers commenced in 2011, initiated by producer following a double knee injury that prompted his exploration of dietary impacts on recovery and . The production extended over several years, culminating in that aligned with a compressed documentary timeline ahead of its January premiere. Cinematographer John Behrens led shoots across five countries, adapting to diverse environments including UFC events, elite athlete training facilities, and laboratory settings to capture real-time action and scientific demonstrations. To maintain flexibility in unpredictable scenarios, Behrens employed a multi-camera rig—typically two to three units—allowing simultaneous coverage of dynamic sequences such as sports and physiological tests, which minimized disruptions in high-stakes athletic contexts. The process incorporated staged dramatic reenactments to illustrate historical claims, such as ancient gladiatorial diets, blending archival-inspired visuals with modern production techniques for narrative emphasis. Controlled experiments, including vascular response tests using beetroot juice, were filmed in clinical environments to document physiological effects under observation, prioritizing authentic data capture over scripted staging. Logistical challenges arose from the film's modest , necessitating rapid adaptability to international travel, variable in training arenas, and coordination with high-profile athletes' schedules, often requiring on-the-fly adjustments without extensive support. Wilks' background as a UFC fighter facilitated access to MMA events and sessions, enabling embedded filming that integrated with broader athlete interviews, though this extended the overall production into a multi-phase effort likened by collaborators to an endurance bout.

Content Overview

Synopsis


The Game Changers (2018) centers on , an elite trainer and winner of , whose severe knee injury sustained during training leads him to reevaluate the impact of diet on recovery and athletic performance. Motivated by this personal setback, Wilks undertakes a worldwide investigation into nutrition, particularly plant-based diets, interviewing scientists, physicians, and high-level athletes while documenting his own dietary transition to . The narrative progresses chronologically through Wilks' quest, interweaving his experiences with controlled experiments—such as post-meal erection monitoring on athletes to assess blood flow—and testimonials from vegan competitors demonstrating feats like lifts by and records by . These segments build from individual recovery anecdotes to broader examples of plant-based success in sports, incorporating historical references to gladiators and ancient warriors purportedly thriving on vegetable-heavy regimens. The film employs dramatic reenactments, celebrity appearances including , and provocative visuals to underscore its progression toward advocating a societal pivot from animal-derived foods, framing plant-based eating as a pathway to enhanced , strength, and overall without delving into opposing dietary evidence. The documentary profiles a selection of athletes adhering to plant-based diets to underscore the feasibility of in elite sports. Ultra-marathoner , who set a record for the fastest traversal of the 2,189-mile in 46 days during 2015 while vegan, is interviewed to exemplify performance. UFC fighter appears preparing a vegan meal ahead of his 2016 bout against , where he competed effectively on such a regimen. Patrik Baboumian, who achieved feats like carrying 1,224 pounds in a walk in 2013 as a vegan, represents . Cyclist Dotsie Bausch, 2012 Olympic team pursuit silver medalist and vegan, and NFL defensive end , who adopted plant-based eating in 2015, illustrate applications in speed and contact sports. Bodybuilder Nimai Delgado and former NFL lineman David Carter, weighing over 300 pounds while vegan, are featured to address muscle-building and power positions. The athletes span disciplines like ultrarunning, , strongman events, , and , positioning vegan diets as viable across varied physical demands, though sports such as and wrestling—where omnivorous diets prevail among top competitors—are absent from the lineup. Contributing experts include urologist Dr. Aaron Spitz, who examines dietary influences on erectile function through athlete demonstrations. Biological anthropologist Christina Warinner interprets stable from 2014 excavations of gladiator remains in , , revealing elevated C3 plant signatures (89-100% plant-derived carbon) consistent with , , and as staples, framed in the film as evidence of ancient fighters' plant-based sustenance. Cardiologist Dr. Caldwell B. Esselstyn Jr., advocate of low-fat plant diets for cardiovascular health, and others like Dr. James Loomis provide physiological endorsements aligned with the vegan performance narrative.

Core Claims

Performance and Recovery Benefits

The documentary presents plant-based diets as enhancing athletic performance through improved flow and reduced physiological hindrance from animal products. It features an experiment conducted by vascular specialist Vogel, in which measurements of flow were taken in athletes before and after consuming either a plant-based meal or a meat-based meal; the plant-based meal resulted in sustained and clearer arterial imaging, while the meat-based meal showed temporary and fat globules impeding circulation, purportedly leading to "clogging" that diminishes oxygen delivery to muscles during exertion. Film segments highlight testimonials from elite athletes attributing superior endurance and output to , such as ultramarathoner and player , who reported outperforming expectations in competitions after adopting plant-based eating; Morgan specifically noted decreased post-training soreness and swelling compared to his prior omnivorous regimen. The narrative contrasts these with claims that meat consumption exacerbates fatigue in omnivorous competitors during prolonged events, positioning plant-fueled athletes as having an edge in real-world scenarios like marathons and combat sports. On recovery, the film asserts that avoiding animal-derived foods minimizes , accelerating muscle repair and reducing downtime; it cites accounts of faster resolution of delayed-onset muscle soreness (DOMS) and joint pain, alongside purported mechanisms like compounds promoting microbial diversity in the gut to optimize healing processes. These benefits are linked to overall efficiency gains, with examples including extended career for vegan strongmen and triathletes who maintain peak condition without the recovery lags associated with meat-heavy diets.

Physiological and Health Arguments

The Game Changers asserts that meat consumption triggers acute , with a single animal-based meal causing arteries to constrict by up to 40% within two hours and thickening blood to impair flow, as shown in an experiment with players where post-meal serum from meat eaters appeared cloudy compared to plant-based alternatives. This vascular response is attributed to pro-inflammatory elements in animal products, including endotoxins and N-oxide (TMAO), which purportedly raise by 70% after consuming a and contribute to tissue damage over time. The documentary links these mechanisms to , citing a demonstration involving where young men exhibited poorer blood flow and after a meat-heavy versus a vegan one, framing it as evidence of meat's role in compromising nitric oxide-dependent essential for sexual and circulatory . Broader claims extend to chronic conditions, positing that animal protein elevates cardiovascular mortality by 8% per 10% of calories derived from it, boosts overall heart disease risk by 61% relative to low intake, and heightens cancer mortality over 400-fold in high-animal-protein diets, primarily via sustained and absent in plant-dominant . Plant nitrates from sources like beets and are promoted as superior for sustaining through production, enabling better oxygen delivery and endothelial integrity than pathways associated with animal foods. On protein adequacy, the film contends that contain all essential and deliver 70% excess beyond requirements in vegan diets, equating their utility to animal sources for bodily repair while avoiding ; it largely overlooks disparities in digestibility (e.g., lower PDCAAS scores for most ) and density, insisting varied intake meets needs without animal contributions.

Historical and Broader Societal Claims

The documentary asserts that ancient Roman gladiators followed a mostly to build their physique and withstand combat injuries, citing a isotopic analysis of skeletal remains from the gladiator cemetery that revealed high levels of carbon and consistent with and consumption rather than . This evidence is presented as supporting their hordearii ("barley men"), implying gladiators derived strength from grains and beans as a vegan-like regimen designed for fat padding and endurance. On environmental grounds, the film argues that animal agriculture imposes severe ecological burdens, consuming 83% of global farmland, 27% of freshwater resources, and contributing 15% of worldwide , while also accelerating , , and water contamination. These claims frame meat production as resource-intensive and inefficient compared to plant-based alternatives, positioning dietary shifts toward as essential for mitigating and preserving ecosystems. Beyond athletics, The Game Changers promotes a cultural reevaluation of meat's dominance in society, depicting it as entrenched in outdated tropes and ethical oversights, with endorsements from figures like and urging viewers to reject animal products for moral, planetary, and virility reasons. The narrative implies plant-based diets confer ethical superiority by decoupling human achievement from animal exploitation, advocating for widespread adoption to dismantle " " in favor of sustainable, compassionate norms.

Scientific Scrutiny

Analysis of Cited Evidence

The documentary cites several small-scale trials on supplementation from juice to support claims of enhanced and recovery, such as a 2009 study by Bailey et al. demonstrating reduced oxygen uptake during submaximal exercise in 8 recreationally active men after consuming 500 ml of juice daily for 6 days. This intervention isolated the vasodilatory effects of dietary nitrates, yet the film's to broad vegan diet superiority overlooks the trial's limited sample size, short duration, and lack of direct comparison to omnivorous diets with equivalent nitrates from other sources, rendering generalizability tenuous for elite athletic contexts. Similarly, a referenced by Lansley et al. on 9 trained cyclists found that beetroot juice enabled 16% greater distance covered in a cycling , attributing benefits to improved efficiency via nitric oxide pathways. However, with such constrained participant numbers and no long-term dietary adherence assessment, these findings cannot reliably underpin causal assertions about plant-based regimens outperforming mixed diets, as nitrates occur in various and the effects may not scale to diverse populations or sustained training loads. The film draws on associative evidence from high-profile vegan athletes, such as ultrarunner or strongman , implying dietary causation for their achievements without accounting for uncontrolled variables like superior genetics, optimized training volumes, or toward outliers. These narratives rely on post hoc correlations rather than randomized designs isolating diet from confounders, failing to demonstrate that plant-based nutrition uniquely drives performance over factors like total energy intake or periodized programming common across elite competitors. In presenting correlations between plant-inclusive diets and health outcomes—like lower —the documentary infers causation without disentangling mediators such as incidental caloric restriction or elevated density from fiber-rich plants, which independently influence biomarkers irrespective of exclusion. Empirical scrutiny reveals these links often stem from holistic patterns in adherents, not inherent antagonism from consumption when macronutrients and calories are matched, underscoring a disconnect between observed associations and verified mechanistic .

Methodological Flaws and Cherry-Picking

The documentary selectively interprets archaeological evidence on ancient gladiators' diets, citing elevated strontium levels in bones as proof of a plant-based regimen while omitting the study's indication of a high-carbohydrate intake primarily from barley and legumes for caloric density, not ideological veganism, and evidence from other analyses showing occasional animal protein consumption in at least two examined individuals. This cherry-picking frames gladiators as proto-vegans to bolster modern claims, disregarding the context of resource availability in the Roman Empire rather than deliberate exclusion of meat for performance reasons. The film emphasizes anecdotal successes of a handful of elite vegan athletes, such as ultrarunner or NFL player David Carter, but neglects the empirical reality that the overwhelming majority of top performers in high-stakes competitions like the Olympics and rely on omnivorous diets including products. For instance, comprehensive reviews of athletic nutrition find no population-level dominance of vegans among medalists or professional leagues, with vegan adherents remaining a tiny fraction—estimated at under 1% in cohorts—despite widespread access to plant-based options, underscoring in highlighting outliers over aggregate data. Furthermore, the presentation bypasses foundational physiological adaptations from , where omnivory facilitated survival through efficient absorption of bioavailable nutrients like iron from —absorbed at rates up to 15-35% versus 2-20% for non-heme plant sources—and , which is absent in unfortified plant foods and essential for neurological function and formation, requiring supplementation or animal-derived intake to prevent deficiencies observed in unsupplemented vegans. This omission prioritizes confirmatory modern examples over causal evidence of dietary flexibility shaped by scavenging and , as evidenced by isotopic analysis of hominid remains showing consistent food integration over millions of years.

Counter-Evidence from Empirical Studies

A 2022 review in Nutrition highlighted that plant-based diets pose challenges for muscle hypertrophy in resistance-trained athletes due to lower protein digestibility, incomplete essential amino acid profiles, and suboptimal leucine content, which fails to maximally stimulate muscle protein synthesis (MPS) without larger portions or fortification. Similarly, research in the Journal of Nutrition demonstrated that plant proteins such as soy and wheat elicit significantly lower postprandial MPS rates compared to animal sources like whey, milk, or beef, attributing this to inferior anabolic signaling from reduced leucine availability.08849-6/fulltext) These findings indicate no inherent superiority of vegan protein sources for athletic muscle building, with animal proteins providing more efficient leucine thresholds (typically 2-3 g per meal) for maximal MPS activation. Longitudinal and comparative studies on athletes reveal that omnivorous diets maintain high without the gaps common in unsupplemented vegan regimens, such as deficiencies in and long-chain omega-3 fatty acids (EPA/DHA). Vegans exhibit baseline levels 20-30% lower than omnivores, impairing phosphocreatine resynthesis and anaerobic capacity in high-intensity efforts, with supplementation required to match omnivorous . Omega-3 deficits in plant-based diets, stemming from inefficient algal conversion to EPA/DHA, correlate with elevated and suboptimal recovery, though direct performance decrements vary by supplementation adherence. A 2023 narrative review in Current Developments in Nutrition concluded that vegan diets do not enhance athletic , , or recovery beyond well-formulated omnivorous alternatives, emphasizing equivalent outcomes at best when vegan intakes are meticulously optimized. Regarding vascular claims, acute post-meal reductions in flow after consumption are transient, resolving within hours and not predictive of chronic in omnivores; population data from cohort studies link balanced -inclusive diets (e.g., Mediterranean patterns) to preserved erectile function when adjusted for confounders like and . Case studies of carnivore-adapted athletes report sustained or improved metrics in strength, , and recovery, with no observed vascular impairments, challenging assertions of long-term harm from foods. Overall, meta-analyses of protein interventions find no significant edge for over sources in lean or strength gains among trained individuals, underscoring equivalence rather than vegan superiority.

Reception and Debates

Initial Media and Audience Response

Upon its premiere on September 16, 2019, The Game Changers elicited a range of media responses, with several outlets highlighting its motivational appeal and endorsements despite acknowledging its advocacy slant. Variety described the film as delivering "88 minutes of fast stats, slick and testimony all aimed to debunk the 'real men eat ' mentality," praising its energetic presentation. noted its emphasis on "profiling athletes whose amazing strength and endurance derive entirely from plant-based diets," framing it as an engaging showcase of elite performers. Aggregator recorded a 67% approval rating from nine critic reviews, reflecting tempered enthusiasm for its persuasive style over rigorous analysis. Audience reactions were similarly divided, with strong support from plant-based advocates who reported inspiration for dietary changes. Viewers on platforms like rated it 7.8 out of 10 based on over 22,000 submissions, often citing its eye-opening portrayal of vegan athletes as transformative. Testimonials from vegan communities emphasized shifts toward plant-based eating, with some crediting appearances by figures like for broadening appeal to traditionally meat-centric demographics. Conversely, skeptics dismissed it as overt , labeling it "propaganda" that overstated benefits through selective anecdotes, as seen in contemporaneous forum discussions. The film's limited theatrical run yielded modest returns of approximately $898,000 worldwide, including $740,000 domestically, constraining initial cinema exposure. However, its Netflix distribution propelled broader accessibility, generating over 1.5 billion website impressions reported by filmmakers shortly after launch, underscoring streaming's role in amplifying viewer engagement.

Criticisms from Nutrition Experts

Layne Norton, a nutritional sciences PhD and competitive powerlifter, published a detailed scientific of The Game Changers in November 2019, arguing that the documentary frequently misrepresents cited studies to support its claims of vegan superiority for athletic performance and health. For instance, the film asserts that consumption increases cancer risk by approximately 20%, but Norton notes this figure derives from observational data prone to factors like lifestyle differences, and the cited actually shows relative risks closer to 1.17-1.22 for , not establishing causation or superiority of plant-based diets. He further critiques the film's portrayal of plant proteins as equivalent to animal sources, emphasizing that plant proteins generally have lower digestibility and incomplete profiles, requiring higher intakes—up to 30-50% more—to achieve similar muscle protein synthesis rates as demonstrated in controlled feeding studies. Nutrition experts have highlighted the film's reliance on small-sample, non-generalizable experiments as pseudoscientific, such as a pilot study with just five vegan and five omnivorous participants measuring post-meal blood viscosity, which Norton describes as lacking statistical power and controls for variables like hydration or recent meals. Similarly, the documentary's erection experiment with athletes (n=6 per group) is dismissed as anecdotal and uncontrolled, ignoring larger randomized controlled trials (RCTs) showing no consistent edge for vegan diets; for example, a 2019 review of endurance athletes found mixed-diet groups with adequate protein matching or outperforming vegans in recovery metrics without the film's claimed inflammatory reductions. The broader expert consensus, as articulated in evidence-based reviews, holds that while vegan diets can support athletic performance when meticulously planned, they do not demonstrate empirical superiority over balanced omnivorous diets incorporating lean meats, and they carry risks of nutrient deficiencies like , heme iron, and long-chain omega-3s, necessitating supplementation that undermines the film's narrative of inherent "purity." RCTs, such as those comparing high-protein omnivorous to vegan interventions in resistance-trained individuals, reveal equivalent gains in strength and lean mass when total protein and calories are equated, contradicting claims of physiological advantages from plant-only nutrition. Potential detriments from lower of calcium and in unsupplemented vegan diets further illustrate that viability does not equate to optimality, per analyses of longitudinal cohort data.

Notable Public Confrontations

In November 2019, nutritionist Chris Kresser appeared on podcast episode #1389, where he critiqued The Game Changers for methodological shortcomings, including the omission of data on high-performing athletes following meat-inclusive diets, such as competitors and runners who thrive on animal-based . Kresser argued that the film selectively highlighted vegan outliers while ignoring counterexamples, such as ultramarathoner Zach Bitter's success on a high-fat, animal-protein regimen, attributing this to an agenda-driven narrative rather than comprehensive evidence. This led to a high-profile debate on December 5, 2019, during The Joe Rogan Experience episode #1393, featuring Kresser alongside James Wilks, the film's producer and protagonist. Wilks defended the documentary's emphasis on plant-based performance advantages, clarifying that it did not claim ancient Roman gladiators were strictly vegan but rather followed a predominantly grain-and-legume diet evidenced by high strontium levels in bone analysis from Ephesus excavations. However, Kresser and host Joe Rogan pressed on evidential gaps, noting that isotopic studies indicate gladiators consumed animal products alongside plants for caloric density, and that the film's portrayal exaggerated exclusivity to bolster modern vegan advocacy without addressing potential nutrient deficiencies in such historical contexts. The podcast exchanges amplified online scrutiny, with multiple YouTube fact-checking videos emerging in late 2019 that dissected the film's claims, such as a October 23 analysis by Nutrition Made Simple highlighting misrepresented studies on blood flow and endurance, and a December 1 breakdown by Sapien Labs critiquing over 150 cited references for context omission. These public rebuttals, viewed millions of times collectively, underscored disputes over cherry-picked athlete anecdotes versus broader empirical patterns of dietary success across omnivorous and plant-based practitioners.

Impact and Legacy

Influence on Public Perception and Diets

Following its premiere on October 16, 2018, The Game Changers correlated with a temporary surge in public interest in s, as evidenced by data showing spikes in searches for terms like "plant-based diet" and "vegan athletes" during late 2018 and early 2019. A 2021 analysis of search volume attributed this uptick directly to the film's release, alongside similar documentaries, noting peaks exceeding baseline interest by factors of 2-3 times in the immediate post-release period. U.S. plant-based food retail sales reached $3.3 billion in 2018, reflecting a 20% year-over-year growth, with early 2019 data indicating accelerated demand for alternatives like plant-based meats, though broader market trends predated the film. The documentary contributed to visibility for plant-based eating among celebrities and athletes, particularly influencing UFC figures like producer , who adopted post-injury and promoted it via the film. Fighters such as , featured for his pre-existing vegan diet, gained renewed attention, and isolated cases like reducing animal products to 10% of intake were linked anecdotally to plant-based advocacy around 2019-2020. However, no sustained shift occurred among elite athletes; UFC champions and top performers, including and in later career phases, predominantly maintained omnivorous regimens, with vegan adoption remaining marginal (under 5% of roster based on public disclosures). Public backlash to the film's claims fostered counter-narratives, amplifying searches and discussions on balanced diets incorporating meat; for "" and "meat benefits for athletes" rose concurrently from onward, coinciding with widespread online debunkings. This skepticism curbed long-term dietary conversions, as national surveys post-2018 showed vegan identification stabilizing at 1-3% of U.S. adults without acceleration attributable to the film, amid ongoing omnivorous preferences in athletic communities.

Commercial and Cultural Ramifications

The documentary's release prompted commercial extensions, including producer ' launch of FȲTA, a plant-based brand utilizing upcycled ingredients, in June 2023 to target athletes seeking performance enhancements aligned with the film's thesis. Its availability from September 2019 onward facilitated broader vegan advocacy, with the official site offering plant-based recipes and meal plans as promotional tools. These efforts leveraged celebrity endorsements from figures like and to market vegan-aligned products, though without verifiable data on direct sales uplift attributable solely to the film. Culturally, The Game Changers fueled polarized discourse on dietary extremism, prompting rebuttals that emphasized human omnivorous adaptations—evident in showing meat consumption's role in cognitive and physiological development—over rigid plant-only prescriptions. Critics, including nutrition researchers, decried its narrative framing as prioritizing over empirical breadth, reinforcing perceptions of as vehicles for ideological influence rather than dispassionate inquiry. This backlash underscored skepticism toward veganism's universality for high-performance demands, without translating into institutional dietary overhauls or policy reforms in guidelines.

Ongoing Scientific Consensus

Subsequent following the 2018 release of The Game Changers has reinforced that vegan diets, while viable for athletic when meticulously planned, confer no unique advantages over omnivorous diets for achieving peak outcomes in strength, , or . A 2024 in the Journal of the International Society of analyzed randomized controlled trials and found no significant differences in metrics or muscle adaptations between balanced vegan and omnivorous groups, provided total energy and protein intakes were equated. Similarly, a 2025 published in Sports Medicine - Open examined muscular strength across plant-based and omnivorous diets, concluding that plant-based approaches do not compromise strength gains, underscoring equivalence rather than superiority. These findings align with broader empirical data from controlled studies, which prioritize matched macronutrient protocols over anecdotal endorsements. In domains like , animal-derived proteins offer practical edges in digestibility and profiles, though vegan alternatives can approximate results with higher volumes or fortification. Reviews highlight that leucine-rich animal sources trigger more efficient muscle protein synthesis via superior , potentially aiding in resistance training without the need for excessive plant protein intake. A 2025 critical review across , strength, and domains noted that while vegan diets meet needs when protein targets are hit—often requiring 20-30% more intake due to lower digestibility scores—omnivorous diets facilitate this with fewer logistical hurdles. Empirical modeling of real-world adherence shows omnivores consistently achieve higher quality without supplementation reliance. Vegan diets exhibit persistent nutrient gaps in bioavailability for key micronutrients like iron, zinc, and vitamin B12, necessitating routine supplementation to match the absorption efficiencies of mixed diets. Studies demonstrate that plant-based iron and zinc have 2-5 times lower bioavailability due to phytate inhibitors, leading to higher deficiency risks in unsupplemented vegans despite adequate intake volumes. Causal analyses of absorption kinetics reveal that heme iron from animal sources provides 15-35% uptake rates versus 2-20% for non-heme plant forms, favoring omnivorous patterns for sustained performance without exogenous aids. Long-term cohort data confirm vegans require targeted interventions to avert subclinical deficits impacting recovery and oxygen transport. The film's advocacy-driven narrative has since served as a in prioritizing verifiable randomized controlled trials over celebrity testimonials, with consensus emphasizing individualized, evidence-based over dogmatic restrictions. Post-2018 syntheses stress that while supports elite athletics in select cases, omnivorous flexibility better accommodates diverse physiological needs without inherent trade-offs. This shift underscores causal realism in dietetics, where and empirical outcomes guide recommendations absent a universal vegan imperative for optimization.

References

  1. https://gamechangersmovie.com/
  2. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/game-changers-review
  3. https://biolayne.com/articles/research/the-game-changers-review-a-scientific-analysis/
  4. https://dieteticallyspeaking.com/an-evidence-based-review-of-the-game-changers/
  5. https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/1506838/2020/01/03/tuf-champ-james-wilks-finds-second-life-and-controversy-as-plant-based-diet-advocate/
  6. https://rakyourlife.substack.com/p/james-wilks-is-on-a-mission-to-change
  7. https://www.forbes.com/sites/douglasyu/2023/06/22/the-game-changers-producer-james-wilks-launches-upcycled-sports-nutrition-company-fyta-ahead-of-vegan-documentarys-2025-sequel/
  8. https://www.dvidshub.net/news/312117/former-ufc-fighter-shares-plant-based-diet-benefits-with-509th-medical-group
  9. https://theunconventionalists.com/episode/133
  10. https://www.cnn.com/2019/12/18/sport/game-changers-documentary-james-wilks-spt-intl
  11. https://liannephillipson.com/movie-giveaway/
  12. https://www.airforcemedicine.af.mil/News/Display/Article/1817793/the-game-changers/
  13. https://greensportsblog.com/game-changers-movie-review/
  14. https://plantbasednews.org/news/celebrities/james-cameron-vegan/
  15. https://lancengym.medium.com/is-game-changers-funded-by-impossible-foods-or-beyond-meat-d9f323133350
  16. https://rippedbody.com/game-changers/
  17. https://www.vogue.com/article/the-game-changers-plant-based-diets-vegan-meat-sundance-film-festival
  18. https://filmmakermagazine.com/104649-i-always-had-two-to-three-cameras-rigged-dp-john-behrens-on-the-game-changers/
  19. https://alaricthebarbarian.substack.com/p/toward-a-reconstruction-of-gladiator
  20. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7455754/plotsummary/
  21. https://ilovegoodsugar.com/blogs/faqs/what-is-the-movie-the-game-changers-summary
  22. https://www.netflix.com/title/81157840
  23. https://www.menshealth.com/entertainment/a29890574/joe-rogan-experience-chris-kresser-game-changers-study/
  24. https://gamechangersmovie.com/cast/
  25. https://omdfortheplanet.com/blog/plant-powered-elite-athletes/
  26. https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2019/11/the-game-changers-11-record-breaking-plant-based-athletes-601566
  27. https://gamechangersmovie.com/the-film/
  28. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F66Sv2xNoxY
  29. https://gamechangersmovie.com/benefits/maximizing-performance/the-plant-based-advantage/
  30. https://kellyjonesnutrition.com/the-game-changers-review/
  31. https://www.greenqueen.com.hk/why-the-game-changers-is-such-a-game-changer-plant-based-netflix/
  32. https://nutritionfp.com/blog/takeaways-from-the-game-changers/
  33. https://gamechangersmovie.com/benefits/optimizing-health/
  34. https://gamechangersmovie.com/food/protein/
  35. https://gamechangersmovie.com/the-bigger-picture/
  36. https://elementnutri.com/myth-busting/the-game-changers-debunked/
  37. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10334161/
  38. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10105836/
  39. https://www.aleph2020.org/human-health/humans-are-adapted-to-meat-fat
  40. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0899900725000607
  41. https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1113/EP092016
  42. https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/17/1/95
  43. https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12970-017-0192-9
  44. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7666422/
  45. https://journalofexerciseandnutrition.com/index.php/JEN/article/view/173
  46. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7926405/
  47. https://variety.com/2018/film/reviews/the-game-changers-review-1202721601/
  48. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-reviews/game-changers-1080643/
  49. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/the_game_changers
  50. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7455754/
  51. https://mediaimpactfunders.org/the-game-changers-planting-the-seeds-of-veganism-one-meat-eating-dude-at-a-time/
  52. https://www.reddit.com/r/netflix/comments/dzv1r2/the_game_changers_is_the_worst_documentary_ive/
  53. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7455754/faq/
  54. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/02/game-changers-puts-muscle-behind-its-message-at-law-school/
  55. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7613518/
  56. https://chriskresser.com/debunking-the-game-changers-joe-rogan/
  57. https://podcastnotes.org/joe-rogan-experience/chris-kresser-joe-rogan-game-changers-vegan-diet/
  58. https://jrelibrary.com/1393-james-wilks-chris-kresser-the-game-changers-debate/
  59. https://biolayne.com/articles/research/the-game-changers-debate-james-wilks-vs-chris-kresser-on-the-joe-rogan-experience/
  60. https://chriskresser.com/reflections-on-the-game-changers-debate/
  61. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QB0aieRNJs0
  62. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aIrHWtFvJIM
  63. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8971697/
  64. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35370517/
  65. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/395668293_Documentary_films_can_increase_public_interest_in_plant-based_diets_in_the_USA
  66. https://plantbasedfoods.org/2018-plant-based-foods-retail-sales-data
  67. https://www.facebook.com/groups/worldcarnivoretribe/posts/629739871119994/
  68. https://ketogenic.com/debunking-the-game-changers/
  69. https://www.secondnature.io/us/guides/lifestyle/media-commentary/game-changers-response
  70. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15502783.2024.2413961
  71. https://sportsmedicine-open.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40798-025-00852-7
  72. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40215782/
  73. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/391833566_Plant-Based_Diets_and_Athletic_Performance_A_Critical_Review_of_Evidence_Across_Endurance_Strength_and_Hypertrophy_Domains
  74. https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/83/7/e2063/7921515
  75. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07853890.2024.2389295
  76. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10516628/
  77. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8746448/
  78. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acsomega.4c07560
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.