Hubbry Logo
Edgar MorinEdgar MorinMain
Open search
Edgar Morin
Community hub
Edgar Morin
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Edgar Morin
Edgar Morin
Edgar Morin
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Edgar Morin (/mɔːˈræn/; French: [ɛdɡaʁ mɔʁɛ̃]; né Nahoum; born 8 July 1921) is a French philosopher and sociologist of the theory of information who has been recognized for his work on complexity and "complex thought" (pensée complexe),[9] and for his scholarly contributions to such diverse fields as media studies, politics, sociology, visual anthropology, ecology, education, and systems biology. He holds two bachelors, one in history and geography and one in law,[10] and never did a Ph.D.[10] Though less well known in the anglophone world due to the limited availability of English translations of his over 60 books, Morin is renowned in the French-speaking world, Europe, and Latin America.[11]

Key Information

During his academic career, he was primarily associated with the École des hautes études en sciences sociales (EHESS) in Paris.

Biography

[edit]

Edgar was born on July 8, 1921 as Edgar Nahoum, to Vidal Nahoum and Louna Beressi. They were Greek Jews from Salonica (Thessaloniki) of distant Italian ancestry. They moved to Marseille[12] and later to Paris. While he is of Sephardic Jewish origin, his family was secular and non-practicing for three generations.[13][14] His mother died when he was ten years old.[15]

In 1936, during the Spanish Civil War, Morin joined the libertarian socialist organization Solidarité Internationale Antifasciste.[16] Two years later, he joined the pacifist anti-fascist, left-wing Parti Frontiste.[17][18] When the Nazi Germans invaded France in 1940, Morin assisted refugees and joined the French Resistance.[19] He left Paris to the "free zone" Toulouse, where he continued to study law at the Toulouse Capitole University.[20] He joined the French Communist Party in 1941. He then joined Michel Cailliau's MRPGD (Mouvement de Résistance des Pronniers de Guerre et Déportés), which was a resistance movement against the German occupation of France. As a member of the French Resistance, he adopted the pseudonym Morin after a miscommunication during a meeting of resistance fighters in Toulouse, when he introduced himself Edgar Manin, in reference to Malraux's character in La Condition humaine. They misheard him as "Morin," and the name stuck.[21]

The MRPGD later merged into François Mitterrand's MNPGD (Mouvement national des prisonniers de guerre et déportés). Morin later became attaché to the staff of the 1st French Army in Germany (1945), then head of the "Propaganda" office in the French Military Government (1946). At the Liberation, he wrote L'An zéro de l'Allemagne (Germany's Year Zero), in which he described the mental state of the defeated people of Germany as being in a state of "somnambulism", in the grip of a "state of depression," hunger, and rumors.

In 1945, Morin married Irène "Violette" Chapellaubeau and they lived in Landau, where he served as a lieutenant in the French Occupation army in Germany.[22] The couple had two children, sociologist Irène Nahoum-Léothaud and anthropologist Véronique Nahoum-Grappe.

In 1946, he returned to Paris and gave up his military career to pursue his activities with the Communist Party. In 1948 and 1949, he wrote for the arts and entertainment section of the Patriote Résistant. Other literary contributions in this year include the Communist Party leader Maurice Thorez inviting him to write for the weekly Les Lettres Françaises, and Morin connecting the philosopher Martin Heidegger with the journal Fontaine to write a review. Due to his critical posture, his relationship with the party gradually deteriorated until he was expelled in 1951 after he published an article in L'Observateur politique, économique et littéraire. In the same year, he was admitted to the National Center of Scientific Research (CNRS) with the support of Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Vladimir Jankélévitch.

In 1955, Morin was one of the four leaders of the Comité contre la guerre d'Algérie (Committee against the Algerian War) and he defended Algerian politician Messali Hadj. Unlike Jean-Paul Sartre, André Breton, Guy Debord and his friends Marguerite Duras and Dionys Mascolo, he did not sign the Declaration on the Right to Insubordination in the Algerian War, known as the "Manifesto of 121", published in September 1960 in the journal Vérité-Liberté. Believing that the urgent need was to avoid the installation of dictatorships in France and Algeria, he joined Claude Lefort, Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Roland Barthes in instead calling for urgent negotiations. In 1954, Morin co-founded and directed the magazine Arguments [fr], which ran until 1962.

In 1959 his book Autocritique was published. The book was a sustained reflection on his adherence to, and subsequent exit from, the Communist Party, focusing on the dangers of ideology and self-deception.

Edgar Morin at a colloquium in Rio de Janeiro, 1972.

In 1960, Morin travelled extensively in Latin America, visiting Brazil, Chile, Bolivia, Peru and Mexico. He returned to France, where he published L'Esprit du Temps, a work on popular culture. That same year, French sociologist Georges Friedmann brought him and Roland Barthes together to create a Centre for the Study of Mass Communication that, after several name changes, became the Edgar Morin Centre of the EHESS, Paris.[23] Also in 1960 Morin and Jean Rouch coauthored the film Chronique d'un été, an early example of cinéma vérité and direct cinema.

Beginning in 1965, Morin became involved in a large multidisciplinary project, financed by the Délégation Générale à la Recherche Scientifique et Technologique in Plozévet. This project culminated in La Métamorphose de Plodémet (1967), which was an ethnology of contemporary French society about the commune of Plozévet (in Finistère), where he stayed for almost a year. In 1968, Morin became the center of a controversy after the publication of his study, as local inhabitants felt betrayed by his work and denounced inaccuracies that he published. Morin attempted to clarify his intentions and answered critics on the Canadian television show Le Sel de la semaine, and it was agreed that the inhabitants misinterpreted his sociological jargon, and he likewise misinterpreted their cultural references and jokes.[24][25]

In 1968, Morin replaced the incumbent professor of philosophy, Henri Lefebvre, at the University of Nanterre. He became involved in the student revolts that began to emerge in France. In May 1968 he wrote a series of articles for Le Monde that tried to understand what he called "The Student Commune." He followed the student revolt closely and wrote a second series of articles in Le Monde called "The Revolution without a Face," as well as coauthoring Mai 68: La brèche with Cornelius Castoriadis and Claude Lefort.[26]

In 1969, Morin spent a year at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in La Jolla, California. Jonas Salk invited him under the recommendation of Jacques Monod and John Hunt, with the sole imposed condition of learning. It was there, in this "breeding ground for Nobel Prizes" that he familiarized himself with systems theory. He read Henri Laborit, James Watson, Stéphane Lupasco, Bronowski, and was introduced to the thought of Gregory Bateson and the "new problematic in ecology".[27]

In 1970, he married Johanne Harrelle, but the relationship did not last; after their divorce in 1980, they remained friends until her death in 1994. In 1982, he married Edwige Lannegrace, who was his lifelong partner until her death in 2008.[28]

In the 1972 international colloquium L'Unité de l'Homme, which he co-organized with Jacques Monod and Massimo Piatelli-Palmarini, Morin aimed to bridge different disciplinary perspectives on human nature.[29] His communication "Le Paradigme perdu: la nature humaine," became a book the following year.

In 1983 he published De la nature de l’URSS, which deepened his analysis of Soviet communism and anticipated the perestroika of Mikhail Gorbachev.

In 2002 Morin participated in the creation of the International Ethical, Scientific and Political Collegium. Also that year, he made a trip to Iran with Dariush Shayegan. In June 2002, Morin published a widely-discussed op-ed with Sami Naïr and Danièle Sallenave in Le Monde entitled "Israël-Palestine: le cancer," where they argued that the suffering of the Jewish people had allowed Israel to become an oppressor of the Palestinian people.[30] The authors were sued for "racial defamation and apology for terrorist acts" by France-Israël et Avocats sans frontières, but were ultimately acquitted by the court of cassation, which recognized the article as falling under the freedom of expression.[31][32]

Following a meeting at a music festival in Fez, Morocco, in 2009, Morin became close with sociology professor Sabah Abouessalam. The couple married in 2012.[33] In 2013, the couple tried to rehabilitate an ecological farm in the Marrakech region owned by his family; they were inspired by the agro-ecology of Pierre Rabhi.[34] They also collaborated on the text, La rencontre improbable et nécessaire (Presses de la Renaissance, 2013), and in 2020 on Changeons de voie - Les leçons du coronavirus (Denoël, 2020).

In 2013, he supported Chief Raoni in his fight against the Belo Monte dam in Brazil. Raoni, intellectuals, lawyers and politicians launched a moral tribunal for crimes against nature and the future of humanity during the Rio+20 Conference. In the same year, Morin and twelve other intellectuals joined the platform published by the European citizens' initiative End Ecocide in Europe.[35] In 2019, he declared in an article in Liberation.fr that money's power is at the origin of ecological degradation.[36]

At the age of 101, Morin worked on a translation of 32 of his essays alongside sociologist Amy Heath-Carpentier in the book The Challenge of Complexity: Essays by Edgar Morin, which included a few that were translated into English for the first time.[37]

Polycrisis and complex thought

[edit]

After leaving the Communist Party in 1951, Morin's work moved toward a new "politics of civilization," which calls for the transformation of the human species into humanity and places the solidarity between people as a fundamental goal.

Edgar Morin is the originator of the concept of polycrisis, a situation where multiple crises—environmental, social, economic, and political—are interconnected and amplify one another's impacts. To address this, Morin developed a framework called complex thought (pensée complexe) that goes beyond reductionism by integrating various dimensions of reality.

Polycrisis

[edit]

The term polycrisis, first introduced by Edgar Morin, describes a situation in which multiple crises—environmental, social, economic, and political—are interconnected, amplifying each other’s impacts. This concept is deeply rooted in Morin's work, particularly in Terre-Patrie[38] (1993) (Homeland Earth: A Manifesto for the New Millennium[39], 1999), where he explores how the global ecological crisis is inseparable from broader systemic issues such as inequality, governance failures, and cultural fragmentation.

  • Key principles:
    • Crises are not isolated but interact dynamically, creating feedback loops (Terre-Patrie[38][39], 1993; La Méthode,[40][41] Tome 1, 1977).
    • Solutions to one crisis can exacerbate others, requiring integrated and systemic responses.

For more details, see the dedicated Polycrisis page.

Complex thought

[edit]

Morin's complex thought (pensée complexe) forms the foundation of his intellectual contributions. It is a paradigm that seeks to transcend reductionism by integrating multiple dimensions of reality.

  • Core principles:
    • Dialogical thinking: Reconciling contradictions, such as order and chaos, unity and diversity.
    • Hologrammatic principle: Each part of a system contains the whole in some way.
    • Recursive organization: Feedback loops between systems and their components.

The paradigm of complexity

[edit]

Morin’s paradigm of complexity offers a methodological and epistemological shift in approaching knowledge. He advocates for connecting disciplines to address real-world problems, such as the polycrisis.

  • Application areas:
    • Climate change and sustainability.
    • Education reform.
    • Governance in times of uncertainty.

Auto-eco-re-organization

[edit]

This concept emphasizes the self-organizing capacity of systems, coupled with their interaction with their environment (eco) and their ability to reorganize in response to challenges (re-organization). It is particularly relevant in understanding ecological systems and human societies.

  • Examples:
    • Ecosystem resilience in the face of climate change.
    • Societal adaptation during global crises.

Reliance

[edit]

Morin identifies reliance — the human capacity to create and maintain meaningful connections—as essential for addressing complex problems. This concept underscores the importance of solidarity and cooperation in a fragmented world.

Metamorphosis

[edit]

In contrast to revolution, Morin proposes metamorphosis as a framework for understanding profound but gradual transformations in societies. This idea reflects his optimism for a potential transition to more sustainable and equitable systems.

Chaosmos

[edit]

A synthesis of chaos and cosmos, this concept highlights the interplay between disorder and order in complex systems. It is a central idea in Morin’s reflections on systems theory and ecology.

The reform of thinking

[edit]

Morin emphasizes the need for a reform of thought to address the challenges of the polycrisis. He advocates for education that fosters:

  • Interdisciplinary knowledge.
  • Critical thinking.
  • Awareness of uncertainty and interconnectedness.

These principles are extensively explored and applied across various domains in Morin's six-volume magnum opus, La Méthode.

Recognition and legacy

[edit]

Morin did not embrace the French postmodern or poststructuralist movements, instead pursuing his own research agenda. As a result, US academics did not transport his theories into disciplinary discourses in same fashion as they did Foucault's, Derrida's and Galinon-Mélénec's. However, Morin's work spans scholarly and popular literature, and he has appeared on the cover of multiple publications including Sciences Humaines[42] and a special issue of Le Monde.[43]

In addition to being the UNESCO Chair of Complex Thought, Morin is known as a founder of transdisciplinarity. As of 2013 he holds honorary doctorates in a variety of social science fields from 21 universities: Messina, Geneva, Milan, Bergamo, Thessaloniki, La Paz, Odense, Perugia, Cosenza, Palermo, Nuevo León, Université Laval in Québec, Brussels, Barcelona, Guadalajara, Valencia, Vera Cruz, Santiago, the Catholic University of Porto Alegre, the Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, and Candido Mendes University in Rio de Janeiro.[44]

Several academic institutions have been named in his honor, with research centers based on his transdisciplinary methods and philosophy. These include transdisciplinary methods and philosophy.[44][45]

Morin is the subject of several biographies as well as documentary films and TV shows, including the 2015 documentary Edgar Morin, chronique d'un regard, co-directed by Olivier Bohler and Céline Gailleurd.

His 100th birthday in 2021 was celebrated in France, Italy, and Latin America, and several collections of essays were published in his honour.[45][47]

His work has been influential in southern Europe, Latin America, Francophone Africa, and more recently China and Japan.[45] Morin's work has become increasingly accessible to the English-speaking world, notably with the 2022 publication of The Challenge of Complexity: Essays by Edgar Morin, which compiled 32 essays, including some that were translated into English for the first time. Morin worked on this collection with sociologist Amy Heath-Carpentier at the age of 101.[37]

Morin was elevated to the dignity of Knight Grand Cross of the Legion of Honour, in the Honours List of Bastille Day 2021 by French President Emmanuel Macron.[45]

Honours

[edit]
Ribbon bar Country Honour
France Grand Cross of the National Order of the Legion of Honour
France Grand officier of the National Order of Merit
France Commander of the Ordre des Arts et des Lettres
PRT Order of Saint James of the Sword - Grand Cross BAR Portugal Gran Cross of the Military Order of Saint James of the Sword
Order of Lifesaving (Morocco) Morocco Commander of the Order of Intellectual Merit
Spain Officier of the Order of Civil Merit

Books

[edit]
  • 1946 : L'An zéro de l'Allemagne, Paris, Éditions de la Cité Universelle.
  • 1947 : Allemagne notre souci, Paris, Éditions Hier et Aujourd'hui.
  • 1948 : Une cornerie, Paris, Éditions Nagel.
  • 1948 : L'Homme et la Mort, Paris, Éditions Corrêa.
  • 1956 : Le Cinéma ou l'homme imaginaire, Paris, Éditions de Minuit.
  • 1957 : Les Stars, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1959 : Autocritique, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1962 : L'esprit du temps. Essai sur la culture de masse, Paris, Grasset-Fasquelle.
  • 1967 : Commune en France. La métamorphose de Plodémet, Paris, Fayard. Translated to English by A. M. Sheridan-Smith as The red and the white: report from a French village, New York : Pantheon Books, 1970.
  • 1968 : Mai 68, La Brèche, Paris, Fayard.
  • 1969 : La Rumeur d'Orléans, Paris, Le Seuil. Translated to English by Peter Green as Rumour in Orléans, New York : Pantheon Books, 1971.
  • 1969 : Introduction à une politique de l'homme, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1969 : Le vif du sujet, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1970 : Journal de Californie, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1973 : Le Paradigme perdu : la nature humaine, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1975: La bureaucratie (collected work), Paris, Union générale d'éditions
  • 1974 : L'unité de l'homme, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1977 : La Méthode, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1977: "The Noise and the Message". New York: Telos Press.
  • 1981 : Pour sortir du XXe siècle, Paris, Nathan.
  • 1982 : Science avec conscience, Paris, Fayard.
  • 1983 : De la nature de l’URSS, Paris, Fayard.
  • 1984 : Le Rose et le noir, Paris, Galilée.
  • 1984: New York: la ville de villes, Paris, Galilée.
  • 1984 : Sociologie, Paris, Fayard.
  • 1987 : Penser l'Europe, Paris, Gallimard.
  • 1988 : Mais..., Paris, Édition Neo/Soco Invest.
  • 1989 : Vidal et les siens, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1990 : Introduction à la pensée complexe, Paris, ESF.[48]
  • 1991: Un nouveau commencement (with Bocchi Gianluca and Mauro Ceruti)
  • 1993 : Terre-Patrie, Paris, Le Seuil. (with Anne-Brigitte Kern)
  • 1994 : Mes démons, Paris, Stock.
  • 1994: La complexité humaine (as editor)
  • 1995 : Les Fratricides : Yougoslavie-Bosnie (1991-1995), Paris, Édition Arléa.
  • 1995 : Une année sisyphe, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1997 : Comprendre la complexité dans les organisations de soins, Paris, ASPEPS.
  • 1997 : Une politique de civilisation, Paris, Arléa, Paris.
  • 1997 : Amour, Poésie, Sagesse, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1999 : L'Intelligence de la complexité, Paris, L'Harmattan.
  • 1999 : Relier les connaissances, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 1999 : Une tête bien faite : Repenser la réforme, réformer la pensée, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 2000 : Les Sept Savoirs nécessaires à l'éducation du futur, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 2000: Nul ne connaît le jour qui naîtra (interviews with Edmond Blattchen)
  • 2000 : Dialogue sur la nature humaine, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2001 : Journal de Plozévet, Bretagne, 1965, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2002 : Dialogue sur la connaissance. Entretiens avec des lycéens, Paris, La Tour d'Aigues.
  • 2002 : Pour une politique de civilisation, Paris, Arléa.
  • 2003 : La Violence du monde, Paris, Édition du Félin.
  • 2003 : Éduquer pour l’ère planétaire, la pensée complexe comme méthode d’apprentissage dans l’erreur et l’incertitude humaine, Paris, Balland.
  • 2003 : Université, quel avenir ?, Paris, Éditions Charles Léopold Mayer.
  • 2003 : Les Enfants du ciel : entre vide, lumière, matière, Paris, Odile Jacob.
  • 2004 : Pour entrer dans le XXIe siècle, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 2005 : Culture et Barbarie européennes, Paris, Bayard.
  • 2006 : Itinérance, Paris, Arléa.
  • 2006 : Le Monde moderne et la question juive, Paris, Le Seuil.
  • 2006: Pour un nouvel imaginaire politique (with Mireille Delmas-Marty and René Passet)
  • 2007 : L'An I de l'ère écologique, Paris, Tallandier. (with Nicolas Hulot)
  • 2007 : Où va le monde ?, Paris, L'Herne.
  • 2007 : Vers l'abîme, Paris, L'Herne.
  • 2008 : Mon chemin, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2008 : Vive la politique ?, Grenoble, Forum Libération de Grenoble.
  • 2009 : Crises, Paris, CNRS.
  • 2009: Au-delà du développement. Pour une politique de l'humanité? (as editor)
  • 2009 : La Pensée tourbillonnaire, Paris, Éditions Germina.
  • 2009 : Edwige, l'inséparable, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2010 : Pour et contre Marx, Paris, Temps présent.
  • 2010 : Ma gauche, Paris, Éditions François Bourin.
  • 2010 : Comment vivre en temps de crise ?, Paris, Bayard.
  • 2011 : La Voie : pour l'avenir de l'humanité, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2011: Le philosophe indiscipliné, Paris, Le Monde, Hors série
  • 2011: Rendre la terre habitable (with Peter Sloterdijk)
  • 2011 : Conversation pour l'avenir, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2011 : Dialogue sur la connaissance : Entretiens avec des lycéens, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2011 : Mes philosophes, Paris, Germina.
  • 2011 : Le Chemin de l'espérance, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2012 : La France est une et multiculturelle. Lettre aux citoyens de France, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2012: Le Monde n'a plus de Temps à perdre (with members of the Collegium International)
  • 2012: Dialogue sur la politique: la gauche et la crise (with François Hollande)
  • 2013 : Mon Paris, ma mémoire, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2013 : La rencontre improbable et nécessaire (with Sabah Abouessalam), Paris, Presses De La Renaissance.
  • 2014 : Notre Europe : Décomposition ou métamorphose, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2014 : Au péril des idées, Paris, Presses du Châtelet. (with Tariq Ramadan)
  • 2014 : Enseigner à vivre. Manifeste pour changer l’éducation, Paris, Actes Sud-Play Bac Éditions.
  • 2015 : Avant, pendant, après le 11 janvier, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2015 : Impliquons-nous ! Dialogue pour le siècle, Paris, Actes Sud.
  • 2015 : Penser global : L'humain et son univers, Paris, Robert Laffont.
  • 2015 : Qui est Daech ? Paris, Éditions Philippe Rey. (with Régis Debray, Tahar Ben Jelloun, Michel Onfray, Olivier Weber, Jean-Christophe Rufin et Gilles Kepel)
  • 2016 : Pour l'esthétique, Paris, Robert Laffont.
  • 2016 : Pour une crisologie, Paris, L'Herne.
  • 2016 : Ecologiser l'Homme, Paris, Lemieux Éditeur.
  • 2017 : Connaissance, Ignorance, Mystère, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2017 : L’Île de Luna, Paris, Actes sud.
  • 2017 : L'Urgence et l'Essentiel, Paris, Éditions Don Quichotte. (with Tariq Ramadan)
  • 2017 : Le temps est venu de changer de civilisation, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2017: Ce que fut le communisme , Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2017 : Où est passé le peuple de gauche ?, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2018 : Pour résister à la régression, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2018 : Le Cinéma : Un art de la complexité, Paris, Nouveau Monde Éditions.
  • 2018: Poésies du métropolitain, Paris, Descartes & Cie.
  • 2019 : La Fraternité, pourquoi ?, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2019 : Chronique d'un été, Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2019 : Les souvenirs viennent à ma rencontre, Paris, Fayard.
  • 2019: La Marseillaise , Paris, L'Aube
  • 2020 : Quelle école voulons-nous ? La Passion du savoir (with Jean-Michel Blanquer), Paris, Éditions Odile Jacob.
  • 2020 : Sur la crise : Pour une crisologie suivi de Où va le monde ?, Paris, Éditions Flammarion, coll. Champs.
  • 2020 : Changeons de voie : Les leçons du coronavirus (in collaboration with Sabah Abouessalam), Paris, Éditions Denoël.[49]
  • 2020 : L'entrée dans l'ère écolgique, Paris, L'Aube.[50]
  • 2021 : Frères d’âme, entretien avec Pierre Rabhi under questions of Denis Lafay. Paris, L'Aube.
  • 2021 : Leçons d’un siècle de vie, Paris, Édfitions Denoël.
  • 2022 : Réveillons-nous !, Paris, Éditions Denoël.
  • 2022 : The Challenge of Complexity: Essays by Edgar Morin, Edited by Amy Heath-Carpentier, Liverpool, Liverpool University Press.
  • 2023: De guerre en guerre: De 1940 à l'Ukraine , La Tour-d'Aigues/impr. en Bulgarie, Éditions de l'Aube, 99 p. (ISBN 978-2-8159-5460-0).
  • 2023: Encore un moment...: Textes personnels, politiques, sociologiques, philosophiques et littéraires, Paris, Denoël, (ISBN 978-22-07178-30-0)
  • 2023: Mon ennemi c'est la haine (with Véronique Châter and Jean-Claude Perrier)
  • 2024 : Cheminer vers l'essentiel, Albin Michel
  • 2025 : Y a-t-il des leçons de l'Histoire?, Denoël

Films

[edit]
  • 1961 : Chronique d'un été, co-created with Jean Rouch.
  • 1964 : L'Heure de la vérité d'Henri Calef, with Maurice Clavel et Henri Calef.
  • 1966 : Un certain regard. Le cinéma vérité, d'Edgar Morin, by Alexis Klémentieff and Jacques Prayer.
  • 2004 : Regard sur Edgar, entretiens thématiques accordés à Samuel Thomas.
  • 2008 : Edgar Morin, un penseur planétaire. A documentary about Morin by Jeanne Mascolo de Filippis, coll. Empreintes.
  • 2009 : Nous resterons sur Terre, environmental film created by Olivier Bourgeois et Pierre Barougier.
  • 2010: Regards sur le sport [under the direction of Benjamin Pichery and François L’Yvonnet), Paris, Le Pommier / INSEP ; Réédition revue et augmentée : Le sport porte en lui le tout de la société, Paris, Cherche-Midi / INSEP 2020, (ISBN 978-2749165134))
  • 2014 : Edgar Morin, chronique d'un regard. Created by Céline Gailleurd et Olivier Bohler.
  • 2017 : Enseignez à vivre ! – Edgar Morin et l’éducation innovante, by Abraham Ségal.

Conferences

[edit]
  • 2005, "Restricted complexity, general complexity".[51]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Edgar Morin

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Edgar Morin (born Edgar Nahoum; 8 July 1921) is a French philosopher and sociologist renowned for pioneering pensée complexe (complex thought), an epistemological approach that integrates uncertainty, feedback loops, and the irreducible interconnections of phenomena, countering the fragmentation inherent in specialized disciplines. Born in Paris to a Sephardic Jewish family, he adopted the surname Morin while participating in the French Resistance against Nazi occupation during World War II, where he engaged in clandestine activities including aiding refugees and disseminating anti-fascist propaganda. His seminal multi-volume work La Méthode (1977–2006), comprising six books that elucidate principles of organization amid disorder, self-production, and dialogic relations, forms the cornerstone of his contributions to transdisciplinary inquiry across sociology, anthropology, and systems theory. Morin has critiqued ideological dogmas, including those of Marxism and technocratic modernity, advocating instead for an ecology of action that fosters resilience in facing global challenges like polycrises. In recognition of his intellectual legacy, he was elevated to Grand Cross of the Legion of Honour in 2021 and has received honorary doctorates from over two dozen universities worldwide, continuing to publish into his 100s.

Early Life and Formative Influences

Childhood and Family Background

Edgar Nahoum, later known as Edgar Morin, was born on July 8, 1921, in to Sephardic Jewish parents of origin. His family had emigrated from the Greek city of Salonica () to before settling in , where they maintained a secular , with no religious practice for three generations. His father, Vidal Nahoum, was a merchant whose life reflected the migratory patterns of fleeing instability in the and early 20th-century . Morin's mother died when he was ten years old, an event that profoundly influenced his early emotional development amid the family's modest circumstances in interwar . Raised in a culturally assimilated yet ethnically conscious household, young Nahoum experienced the vibrancy of Parisian life, including early exposure to cinema, which later informed his intellectual interests, though his family's secularism distanced them from traditional Jewish communal structures.

Education and Early Intellectual Encounters

Edgar Morin earned his baccalauréat in philosophy in 1939, marking the start of his higher education amid escalating European tensions. That year, he enrolled at the Sorbonne, studying philosophy—which then incorporated sociology and psychology—alongside history, geography, political science, and law, with the ambition of forging a synthetic "humanology" uniting these fields to comprehend human phenomena holistically. As war disrupted Parisian academia, Morin relocated to the unoccupied zone in 1940, continuing his multidisciplinary pursuits, including law, at the University of Toulouse. In his formative years, intellectual stirrings arose from confronting political upheavals like Hitler's ascent and the Moscow show trials, prompting engagement with Immanuel Kant's triad of critical inquiries: what can I know, what ought I to believe, and what may I hope? Morin gravitated toward for its capacity to bridge disciplines, inspired by Karl Marx's fusion of scientific, economic, historical, and political analysis, and later drew on Hegel's to navigate contradictions in human inquiry.

Resistance and Post-War Trajectory

World War II Involvement and Name Adoption

Following the German invasion of in May 1940, Edgar Nahoum, born to a Sephardic Jewish family, left at age 19 for in the unoccupied zone. There, he aided Jewish refugees fleeing and soon engaged with underground networks opposing the Nazi occupation and Vichy collaborationist regime. In 1941, Nahoum adopted the Edgar Morin as a for his clandestine work in the Resistance, a practice common among fighters to protect identities amid threats; he retained it permanently after the Liberation. His activities aligned with the communist-leaning faction of the Resistance, reflecting early Marxist sympathies formed in , where he also affiliated with the . As a Resistance operative, Morin contributed to efforts undermining Axis control, including propaganda distribution and logistical support, though detailed personal exploits remain sparsely recorded in contemporaneous accounts. This period marked his transition from student to committed antifascist, shaped by the existential risks faced by Jews under Vichy anti-Semitic statutes, which stripped citizenship from many naturalized or foreign-born individuals like his family. His wartime experiences, blending personal survival with ideological action, later informed his critiques of totalitarianism.

Communist Affiliation and Break

During , Edgar Morin, originally named Edgar Nahoum, joined the (PCF) clandestinely in 1943 while participating in the Resistance against Nazi occupation. As a "permanent" militant, he operated in the Mouvement de résistance des prisonniers de guerre et des déportés (MRPGD), organizing networks in as a "sous-marin" agent and later contributing to efforts in the Paris committee after its fusion with other movements. After the war, Morin continued his PCF activities in , collaborating with communist publications such as Lettres françaises and Patriote résistant as an editor, and authoring works like L’Allemagne, notre souci in 1947, which reflected party-aligned concerns about post-war Europe. His involvement aligned with the PCF's emphasis on and Soviet solidarity, though he adopted the pseudonym "Morin" from his Resistance days, which became his . Doubts emerged amid the PCF's rigid adherence to Stalinist orthodoxy, particularly following the creation of the in 1947, the Tito-Stalin split and Yugoslav affair in 1948, and the Rajk show trial in 1949, which signaled a "second Stalinist glaciation" and prompted Morin's internal rupture with the party's line by 1949. He ceased active militancy thereafter, leading to growing tensions with PCF leadership over his refusal to endorse Soviet policies uncritically. Morin was formally expelled from the PCF in 1951, amid a period of disengagement exacerbated by these events, marking the end of his direct affiliation with the party. In the ensuing years, he co-founded the review Arguments in 1956 alongside other intellectuals dissenting from orthodox communism, fostering critical debate on without fully abandoning leftist ideals. His break culminated in the 1959 publication of Autocritique, a reflective essay analyzing his six-year adherence to , the generational delusions that sustained it despite evident contradictions like Soviet purges, and the psychological and ideological mechanisms—such as the allure of clandestine adventure and anti-fascist fervor—that blinded him and peers to the regime's realities. In the book, Morin dissected 's failure to transcend bourgeois alienation, framing his exit not as mere disillusionment but as a necessary reckoning with its totalitarian deviations from emancipatory promises.

Professional Career

Journalistic and Sociological Roles

Morin entered the field of sociology in 1950 upon securing a research position at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), France's primary public research institution, where he focused on empirical analysis of contemporary social dynamics. His approach emphasized a "sociology of the present," involving on-site observation of pivotal social events to uncover underlying patterns in human behavior and societal structures, diverging from purely theoretical frameworks prevalent in mid-20th-century French academia. At CNRS, Morin explored intersections of culture and society, producing works such as Les Stars (1957), which dissected the mass-mediated phenomenon of celebrity in cinema as a modern myth-making process, and Commune en France (1967), a field study of rural community life in Plodémet, Brittany, highlighting economic stagnation and cultural resilience amid post-war modernization. These contributions positioned him as a pioneer in cultural sociology, integrating ethnographic methods with broader critiques of reductionist social theories. Parallel to his sociological research, Morin pursued journalistic endeavors that amplified his interdisciplinary insights. In 1956, he co-founded Arguments, a quarterly review published by Éditions de Minuit, alongside intellectuals like and Dionys Mascolo, aiming to foster critical Marxist thought amid following Nikita Khrushchev's 1956 speech. As editor from 1957 to 1963, Morin curated issues that blended , , and cultural analysis, challenging dogmatic while advocating for openness to , , and Third World perspectives; the journal ran for 42 issues before ceasing amid financial and ideological strains. This role exemplified his non-conformist , prioritizing intellectual rigor over partisan alignment, and extended his influence into public discourse on topics like and political myths. Morin's dual roles converged in his advocacy for holistic methodologies, as seen in his CNRS-directed projects on communication and knowledge, including contributions to cinema vérité techniques and media sociology during the . By the late , he had risen to directorial positions at CNRS, overseeing interdisciplinary teams that applied sociological lenses to , , and global interdependence, though his emphasis on often clashed with prevailing structuralist paradigms in French social sciences. His journalistic output, including essays in outlets like , sustained this trajectory, offering empirically grounded critiques of societal trends without succumbing to ideological conformity.

Academic Positions and Institutional Ties

Morin commenced his formal research career at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) in 1950, securing a position as a sociologist following studies in , , and . His appointment was confirmed in 1951, enabling independent sociological inquiries amid post-war intellectual reconstruction. By the early , this role positioned him to explore emerging fields like mass culture and cinema under CNRS auspices. In 1977, Morin ascended to Research Director at the CNRS, a senior rank he held until in 1993 at age 72, after which he retained emeritus status as a senior researcher. This trajectory underscored his institutional embedding within France's premier public research body, where he directed projects on , , and without traditional university lecturing duties. Morin's ties extended to transdisciplinary units under CNRS and the École des Hautes Études en Sciences Sociales (EHESS). In 1973, he co-directed the Centre d'Études Transdisciplinaires Sociologie, Anthropologie, Sémiologie (CETSAS) with Georges Friedmann and , fostering interdisciplinary analysis of social phenomena. By 1983, he co-led the successor Centre d'Études Transdisciplinaires Sociologie, Anthropologie, Politique (CETSAP) alongside , evolving into the Centre d'Études Transdisciplinaires Sociologie, Anthropologie, Histoire (CETSAH), later renamed the Centre Edgar Morin in his honor as a CNRS-EHESS joint unit (UMR 8177). These affiliations facilitated his paradigm of complexity through collaborative, non-reductionist frameworks. Additionally, Morin chaired the scientific board of the Institut des Sciences de la Communication du CNRS (ISCC) into his later years, influencing and . His CNRS-centric career, spanning over four decades, prioritized research autonomy over pedagogical roles, aligning with his critique of siloed academic disciplines.

Philosophical Foundations

Shift from Marxism to Complexity

Edgar Morin, initially drawn to Marxism during his involvement in the French Resistance, joined the French Communist Party (PCF) in 1941 and remained active until his expulsion in 1951 due to his increasingly critical stance toward the party's Stalinist orthodoxy. His break was precipitated by disagreements over the PCF's uncritical support for Soviet policies, including the Korean War, and his publication of articles questioning dogmatic interpretations of Marxist theory, which the party viewed as deviationist. This expulsion marked the end of his organizational ties to communism, though he continued to engage with Marxist ideas selectively, critiquing their reduction of social phenomena to economic determinism and class conflict alone. In the years following his departure from the PCF, Morin co-founded the journal Arguments in 1956 alongside former communists like and Kostas Axelos, providing a platform for heterodox critiques of and ideological rigidity from both Stalinist and capitalist perspectives. Through Arguments, which ran until 1962, he explored the failures of Marxist orthodoxy to account for human complexity, irrationality, and cultural dimensions, drawing on emerging fields like and while rejecting their own simplifications. In his 1959 autobiographical work Autocritique, Morin reflected on his decade-long adherence to the party as a form of intellectual self-deception, attributing it to the allure of certainty amid post-war chaos but emphasizing the need for self-examination over dogmatic adherence. This period laid the groundwork for his rejection of Marxism's as insufficiently equipped to handle uncertainty, feedback loops, and emergent properties in social systems. Morin's transition accelerated in the 1960s and 1970s through engagement with scientific advancements in , , and , which highlighted and non-linear dynamics—concepts antithetical to Marxism's linear historical . Influenced by thinkers like and , he began articulating a "paradigm of complexity" that prioritized relational wholes over isolated parts, critiquing both Marxist and classical science's . By 1977, with the publication of the first volume of La Méthode (La Nature de l'Utopie), Morin formalized this shift, proposing a dialogic that integrates order and disorder, unity and diversity, as a corrective to ideological and scientific simplifications. Subsequent volumes, culminating in 2004, expanded this into a comprehensive framework for understanding reality's inherent uncertainty and interdependence, positioning complexity not as relativism but as a rigorous alternative to deterministic worldviews. This evolution reflected Morin's commitment to , informed by empirical observations of systemic crises that Marxism failed to predict or explain adequately.

Critique of Reductionist Thinking

Morin identifies as a foundational flaw in classical scientific paradigms, characterized by the of complex phenomena into elementary, isolated components, which abstracts and mutilates the underlying by disregarding emergent properties and interconnections. This approach, rooted in Cartesian and extended through disciplines like physics and , prioritizes simplicity and predictability, often reducing to mechanical aggregates devoid of or feedback loops. In works such as his "From the Concept of System to the of ," Morin argues that such dissolves phenomena into abstractions, failing to account for how interactions generate beyond mere summation. Equally problematic, Morin contends, is the disjunctive principle inherent in reductionist thought, which enforces rigid separations—between parts and wholes, subject and object, or disciplines—fostering fragmented knowledge that obscures systemic wholeness. For instance, disciplinary silos in academia, such as those dividing from , produce contradictory theories by isolating variables, ignoring overlaps and contextual dependencies. He critiques this as a form of amputation, where the quest for certainty expunges the of reality, including irreversible processes introduced by since the 19th century, which undermine deterministic universal laws. Morin extends his critique to holistic alternatives, viewing them as another variant of that simplifies by subsuming parts into an undifferentiated whole, thereby neglecting internal antagonisms and multiplicities. Instead, he advocates a relation that reconciles oppositions—such as —through recursive , where systems both produce and are produced by their elements, as seen in self-organizing processes in and . This perspective reveals that wholes may be "less than the sum of their parts" due to constraining norms and interactions that limit individual expressions, challenging the additive logic of traditional analysis. Central to Morin's framework in La Méthode (volumes published from 1977 to 2004), this rejection of underpins complex thought, which demands meta-recognition of the observer's role and embraces as essential to understanding open, evolving systems. By privileging empirical interconnections over isolated causation, Morin's approach aims to restore a fuller apprehension of phenomena, applicable across sciences and , without succumbing to vague .

Core Concepts in Complex Thought

Paradigm of Complexity

The of complexity, developed by Edgar Morin in works such as La Méthode and elaborated in his 1992 essay, constitutes a foundational framework for understanding through the integration of apparent contradictions rather than their resolution via simplification. It posits that must account for the interplay of , and , rejecting the classical scientific tendency to isolate elements and impose disjunctive logic. Unlike reductionist paradigms that dissect phenomena into independent parts, Morin's approach views systems as generative entities where arises from recursive interactions and environmental embedding, informing theories across disciplines without subsuming them into a totalizing . Central to this paradigm are three intelligibility principles: the dialogic, recursivity, and hologrammatic. The dialogic principle addresses the coexistence of complementary yet antagonistic notions, such as unity and multiplicity or autonomy and dependence, which cannot be reconciled hierarchically but must be held in tension to reveal dynamic processes; for instance, Morin notes that "the whole is greater than the sum of the parts" while also being "less than the sum," highlighting irreducible tensions. Recursivity, or organizational recursion, describes circular causal loops where a system generates its own components, which in turn regenerate the system, as seen in self-eco-organization processes involving feedback from environment to entity and vice versa. The hologrammatic principle extends this by asserting that the whole is reflected in the parts and the parts in the whole, enabling nested complexities where no level is fully autonomous. This paradigm diverges from general by transcending mere connectivity—such as part-whole relations or order-disorder binaries—toward a generative logic that incorporates as inherent, where systems resist definitive closure due to interlocking and unpredictable interactions. Morin argues that classical paradigms "condemn us to uncertain thought, riddled with gaps, without absolute certainty," yet this condition fosters a reflexive essential for addressing real-world phenomena like biological or . In practice, it demands abandoning the illusion of total knowledge, promoting instead a method that links micro- and macro-scales without mutilating , as evidenced in applications to fields like and .

Polycrisis and Systemic Interdependence

Morin's conceptualization of polycrisis emerged in the late as a framework to describe the entanglement of multiple, interdependent global challenges that defy isolated analysis or resolution. Coined alongside Anne Brigitte Kern in their 1999 manifesto Homeland Earth: A Manifesto for the New Millennium, the term denotes not merely a multiplicity of crises—such as , economic instability, and social fragmentation—but their "complex intersolidarity," where problems reinforce and amplify one another through feedback loops and emergent properties. Morin argued that this polycrisis constitutes an anthropological rupture, wherein humanity confronts its inability to unify fragmented and actions amid accelerating systemic disruptions, as evidenced by his 2024 reflection that it represents a crisis of "humanity being unable to become Humanity." Central to understanding polycrisis is Morin's emphasis on systemic interdependence, a principle rooted in his broader paradigm of complex thought, which critiques classical for its mechanistic tendencies and instead posits reality as a web of reciprocal influences, uncertainties, and . In works like Method: Towards a Study of Humankind, Morin illustrates how phenomena exhibit "systemic Y" structures—unities that both integrate and antagonize their components—leading to interdependence where disturbances in one domain (e.g., ecological) propagate unpredictably across others (e.g., geopolitical). This interdependence manifests empirically in events like the intersecting with climate stressors, amplifying vulnerabilities through non-linear causal chains that traditional linear models fail to capture. Morin warns that ignoring such linkages fosters , exacerbating polycrisis by treating symptoms in silos rather than addressing root entanglements. To navigate polycrisis, Morin advocates a "complex rationality" that integrates systemic interdependence via principles, fostering awareness of both unity and diversity in human-ecological systems. This approach, detailed in his elaboration on complex thought, calls for meta-cognition to recognize how global interdependencies—such as fragilities exposed by the —demand holistic strategies over fragmented interventions. Empirical support for this view appears in analyses of crisis cascades, where, for instance, and inequality form vicious cycles that systemic models alone overlook without complexity's emphasis on and . Critics, however, note that Morin's framework risks descriptive vagueness without falsifiable metrics, though its predictive utility in foreseeing entangled crises like those post-2020 underscores its causal realism.

Dialogic and Homo Complexus Principles

Morin's dialogic principle posits that complex phenomena cannot be understood through simple opposition or separation of contradictory elements but require recognizing their simultaneous complementarity and antagonism within a unified . This , articulated in his of , enables the rational integration of dualities—such as , unity and multiplicity—that traditional reductionist thinking forces apart. For instance, Morin applies it to phenomena like , where and dependence coexist, fertilizing each other rather than negating one another, as detailed in his methodological writings on complex thought. The counters binary logics by maintaining duality at the core of unity, avoiding both simplistic synthesis and irresolvable conflict, and has been employed in analyses of social systems, , and . Closely intertwined with the dialogic approach is Morin's conception of Homo complexus, which redefines the human species as an irreducible ensemble of biological, psychic, cultural, social, and historical dimensions, rejecting unidimensional reductions like pure rationality or instinct. Introduced prominently in his educational framework, Seven Complex Lessons in Education for the Future (1999), Homo complexus emphasizes humanity's "unidual" nature—simultaneously sapiens (wise) and demens (mad), individual and collective, mortal and capable of transcendence—demanding a holistic understanding that embraces uncertainty and interdependence. This view critiques anthropocentric simplifications in Western thought, advocating instead for self-knowledge of human complexity as essential for navigating existential risks, such as those arising from technological power and ecological fragility. Morin argues that recognizing Homo complexus fosters ethical responsibility, as humans must confront their own paradoxical capacities for creation and destruction without illusory mastery. Together, these principles underpin Morin's broader critique of classical and , promoting a "complex rationality" that dialogically links the one and the multiple in . The principle operationalizes the Homo complexus by revealing how human traits—reason and passion, and —interact dynamically, informing applications in fields like and where partial views lead to policy failures. While praised for transcending dichotomies, this framework has drawn scrutiny for potentially blurring analytical precision in favor of interpretive openness, though Morin maintains its necessity for addressing real-world polycrises.

Political and Ethical Dimensions

Politics of Civilization

Edgar Morin's conception of a "politics of " emerges as a response to what he identifies as a profound in modern Western , characterized by , social fragmentation, and the failure to deliver widespread despite material advances. In his 2002 book Pour une politique de civilisation, Morin argues that traditional , focused on and state mechanisms, inadequately addresses these interconnected challenges, necessitating a broader civilizational shift toward , ethical renewal, and ecological awareness. This framework builds on his earlier collaboration with Sami Naïr in Une politique de civilisation (1997), which laid groundwork for transcending narrow ideological programs in favor of a "path" (voie) oriented toward human and planetary regeneration. Central to Morin's proposal are four principal pillars designed to foster a moral and practical reorientation of society. First, a politics of solidarity emphasizes mutual aid networks, such as establishing "Maisons de Solidarité" to respond to everyday moral emergencies and revive cooperative economies, drawing on the observation that approximately 10% of the population exhibits inherent altruism capable of seeding broader change. Second, enhancing quality of life prioritizes ecological sustainability and "affective participation" through convivial practices, including proposals like reducing the workweek to 30 hours to strengthen family and community bonds. Third, a policy of re-sourcing aims to reconnect individuals with local and natural resources, countering alienation from technocratic systems. Fourth, re-moralization seeks to cultivate virtues like forgiveness and responsibility, integrating ethical dimensions into governance to combat cynicism and individualism. These elements are not presented as a rigid blueprint but as interdependent strategies within complex thought, recognizing feedback loops between human behavior, society, and the biosphere. Morin links this politics to addressing the "polycrisis"—a term he introduced in 1999 to denote the entangled nature of ecological, economic, political, and existential threats—advocating for an "integral ecology" that unites environmental, social, and cultural reforms. In works like Seven Complex Lessons in Education for the Future (1999), he extends these ideas to education, urging the cultivation of "Earth identity" and planetary citizenship to underpin a civilized homeland, where politics serves humanity's shared fate amid globalization's unifying yet divisive forces. By 2011, in La Voie: Pour l'avenir de l'humanité, Morin frames it within broader political thought, emphasizing democracy's role in mutual societal-individual control and the rejection of reductive development models in favor of multidimensional civilizational progress. This approach critiques the dominance of growth-oriented paradigms, proposing instead a metamorphosis toward interdependence, humility in facing uncertainty, and a humanism that dissents from destructiveness through creative, dialogic engagement.

Views on Totalitarianism and Secularism

Edgar Morin's critique of emerged from his direct engagement with , which he joined in the 1940s as a Resistance fighter and intellectual drawn to Marxist analysis of society and history. By 1959, disillusioned by the Hungarian uprising of 1956 and the party's denial of Stalinist crimes, he published Autocritique, a rigorous self-examination of the psychological mechanisms—such as myth-making and belief distortion—that sustained his adherence to communist dogma despite of repression and terror. In this work, Morin differentiated genuine , as a tool for , from the coercive self-accusations imposed in totalitarian regimes, which serve to reinforce ideological rather than foster truth-seeking. The fall of communist regimes in in prompted Morin to frame these events as an "anti-totalitarian ," distinct from a straightforward shift to , as it fundamentally eroded the monopolistic control over truth and reality characteristic of such systems. In his 1991 analysis, he argued that , whether fascist or communist, operates through a fusion of absolute and state power, suppressing and in favor of a singular, enforced —often pseudo-scientific or quasi-messianic. This , per Morin, exposed the fragility of totalitarian structures when confronted with internal contradictions and human agency, though he cautioned it did not automatically yield stable democratic outcomes without addressing deeper cultural and cognitive reforms. On , Morin positioned himself as a "radical unbeliever" and firm advocate of laïcité, France's constitutional , proposing a model of a "unified, indivisible, secular and multicultural republic" to balance neutrality with pluralism. He viewed religions as human inventions that, like ideologies, acquire autonomous power over their creators, potentially fostering dogmatism akin to totalitarian certainty. Critiquing atheistic regimes such as the for futile attempts to eradicate religion—evident in the persistence of Orthodox Christianity despite decades of suppression—Morin rejected both theocratic absolutism and militant secular purges, favoring instead a complex approach that recognizes belief's enduring role in human uncertainty without granting it political dominance. In democracies, he contrasted totalitarian claims to divine or higher truths with fluid, provisional knowledge emerging from citizen dialogue and tolerance of dissent.

Criticisms and Debates

Philosophical Objections: Vagueness and Relativism

Critics of Edgar Morin's paradigm of complexity argue that its core principles, such as the dialogic principle and the embrace of uncertainty, introduce excessive vagueness by eschewing precise definitions and reductionist clarity in favor of holistic interconnections. This approach, which Morin outlines in works like Method: Towards a Study of Humankind (1977–2004), resists breaking phenomena into discrete, analyzable parts, resulting in concepts that lack operational specificity and testable boundaries. For example, the notion of "complexus"—a unity of —is presented as inherently aporetic, which detractors claim renders it more metaphorical than analytically robust, akin to vague holistic paradigms dismissed as "ineffectual feel-good nostrums" rather than rigorous intellectual frameworks. This vagueness extends to methodological implications, where Morin's rejection of classical logic's law of non-contradiction in favor of "metap paradigms" prioritizing complementarity over disjunction is seen to erode philosophical precision. Opponents, particularly from analytic traditions, contend that such flexibility allows for interpretive latitude that borders on , complicating falsification and empirical validation; without clear criteria for distinguishing signal from noise in complex systems, the risks conflating insightful with unfalsifiable generality. Philosophical objections further intensify on , with Morin's integration of into epistemic processes—emphasizing that emerges from subjective-systemic interactions—accused of promoting epistemic . By foregrounding and the ineradicable role of , the framework is critiqued for implying that truths are provisional and observer-dependent, potentially equating all perspectives in a equilibrium without hierarchical adjudication based on . González (2020) explicitly identifies this as a flaw, arguing that Morin's succumbs to epistemic , where supplants and objective standards dissolve into multifaceted interpretations. Such critiques warn that this undermines causal realism, as relativistic tendencies could prioritize coherence over verifiable mechanisms, echoing broader postmodern risks of intellectual without anchoring in empirical invariants.

Political Critiques: Residual Leftism and Alarmism

Critics have argued that, despite Edgar Morin's break with the in 1951 following his autocritique of in Autocritique (1959), his intellectual framework retains residual leftist elements, particularly in its persistent skepticism toward liberal individualism and market-driven systems. This manifests in his advocacy for a "politics of " emphasizing global interdependence and responsibility, which some conservative commentators interpret as echoing Marxist internationalism while downplaying national sovereignty and cultural particularities. For instance, in a 2025 , Guillaume Lelong contends that Morin's vision of a "patrie de " overlooks deeper and identitarian realities, prioritizing abstract planetary unity in a manner akin to outdated leftist . Similarly, a Fondapol study frames Morin's paradigm of complexity as a contemporary that subtly advances supranational models, critiquing reductionist but aligning with progressive calls for systemic overhaul over pragmatic national reforms. Morin's self-identification as remaining "de gauche" reinforces these perceptions, as he has affirmed in interviews continuing to hold political positions aligned with left-wing , distinct from official parties but rooted in emancipation-oriented thought. This residual orientation is evident in his co-authored appeals, such as the 2004 "Méditerranéens, unissons-nous!" , which urged transnational against perceived neoliberal excesses, drawing fire from right-leaning critics for idealizing without addressing integration challenges empirically demonstrated in European migration data post-2015. Such views, while informed by his historical engagement with leftist during the (1936–1939), are faulted for insufficiently reckoning with causal failures of collectivist experiments, like the Soviet Union's collapse in 1991, which Morin analyzed but did not fully disavow in ideological terms. On alarmism, detractors highlight Morin's early environmental prognostications and crisis theorizing as overly pessimistic, fostering a narrative of inevitable polycrisis without proportionate empirical validation. Historian Adam Tooze has characterized Morin as a "classic 1970s environmental alarmist," linking his warnings of ecological and societal breakdown—articulated in works like La Méthode (1977–2004)—to era-specific fears that underestimated technological adaptations and human resilience. Critics of the polycrisis concept, which Morin helped popularize through terms like "crise multiple" in the 1970s and formalized later, argue it amplifies interconnected threats (e.g., climate, inequality) into a vague, self-reinforcing doom loop, as seen in post-2008 analyses where predicted systemic collapses failed to materialize amid GDP recoveries in major economies like the EU (averaging 1.5–2% annual growth 2010–2019). This approach, while dialogic in principle, is accused of causal overreach, attributing polycrises to inherent modern flaws rather than disaggregable policy errors, thereby promoting precautionary paralysis over evidence-based mitigation.

Empirical and Methodological Shortcomings

Critics of Edgar Morin's paradigm of complexity contend that it suffers from insufficient empirical grounding, rendering it difficult to subject to rigorous testing or validation within established scientific frameworks. Unlike reductionist approaches that generate specific, falsifiable hypotheses amenable to experimental verification, Morin's emphasis on irreducible interconnections and emergent properties often prioritizes interpretive synthesis over quantifiable and . This leads to challenges in operationalizing his concepts for empirical studies, as the paradigm discourages disaggregation of phenomena into testable components, potentially limiting its utility in fields requiring predictive models or . Methodologically, Morin's framework has been faulted for its inherent , which hampers systematic application in and execution. While advocating a "method of methods" that integrates multiple disciplinary perspectives, the absence of precise protocols for , , or error correction results in a loose structure ill-suited for replicable investigations. Scholars note that this vagueness can foster subjective interpretations under the guise of holistic understanding, complicating and inter-researcher consistency, particularly in social sciences where empirical rigor demands clear delineations between observation, inference, and speculation. Furthermore, the paradigm's preferential treatment of holistic over reductionist analysis is seen as undermining empirical depth, as it risks glossing over granular mechanisms essential for causal realism. By critiquing as overly simplistic while offering no compensatory tools for dissecting complex systems into analyzable parts, Morin's approach may inadvertently promote explanatory breadth at the expense of precision, thereby weakening its capacity to address real-world problems through evidence-based interventions. This tension highlights a broader methodological shortfall: the difficulty in balancing complexity's embrace of with the demands of scientific accountability.

Major Works

The Method Series

La Méthode (English: Method), Edgar Morin's magnum opus, comprises six volumes published by Éditions du Seuil from 1977 to 2004, forming a systematic exposition of his of complex thought. This series seeks to transcend disciplinary fragmentation and by proposing a meta-method for comprehending reality's inherent , where phenomena exhibit irreducible interconnections, uncertainties, and emergent properties across physical, biological, cognitive, social, and ethical domains. Morin argues that traditional scientific and philosophical approaches, by isolating elements and prioritizing certainty, fail to capture the dynamic unity of , necessitating instead a "" that embraces contradictions and recursive loops without resolving them into simplistic dualisms. The series unfolds progressively, beginning with foundational ontological inquiries and culminating in ethical imperatives. Volume 1, La Nature de la nature (1977), examines physical systems, highlighting , irreversibility via the second law of thermodynamics, and the limitations of classical determinism in and precursors. It posits nature not as a static but as a integrating creation and destruction. Volume 2, La Vie de la vie (1980), extends this to , analyzing life's , evolution's blind yet inventive character, and the of individuality amid systemic interdependence, critiquing both and mechanist views. Volume 3, La Connaissance de la connaissance (1986), shifts to epistemology, dissecting the observational subject's entanglement with the observed object, the aporias of certainty in scientific knowledge, and the need for a reflexive, self-critical cognition that incorporates error, illusion, and context. Morin introduces the "noosphere" concept, linking knowledge production to cultural and historical ecosystems. Volume 4, Les Idées: Habitat, vie, organisation, fonctionnement (1991), explores ideas as living entities within ideational habitats, their reproduction through belief systems, and their role in organizing human thought beyond mere rationality, drawing on linguistics, mythology, and ideology critiques. The final volumes address human dimensions: Volume 5, L'Humanité de l'humanité: L'identité humaine (2001), investigates homo complexus—the multifaceted human identity—integrating biological, cultural, and historical strata, with emphasis on death-awareness, , and societal bonds as sources of both unity and fragmentation. Volume 6, Éthique (2004), derives an of from prior analyses, advocating a "politics of the " that fosters planetary responsibility amid globalization's risks, without prescriptive dogmas but through dialogic solidarity and acceptance of . Throughout, Morin employs loops of , where each volume informs and revises the others, embodying the method's recursive nature.

Other Key Publications and Essays

Morin's sociological inquiries into culture and mass media began with Les Stars (1957), which analyzed the phenomenon of cinema celebrities as modern myths fulfilling psychological and religious needs in society. In Le Cinéma ou l'homme imaginaire (1958), he explored film's role in shaping collective imagination and human identity through visual narratives. These works established his approach to cultural phenomena as interconnected systems blending individual psychology, social dynamics, and technological influence. Autocritique (1959) marked a pivotal personal and political reflection, detailing Morin's rupture with the after the 1956 Soviet revelations, critiquing ideological dogmatism and his own prior adherence through introspective analysis. Expanding on social rumors and , La Rumeur d'Orléans (1969), co-authored with a team of researchers, dissected a 1969 French scandal involving unfounded claims of child trafficking by Jewish merchants, revealing mechanisms of rumor , xenophobia, and media amplification in provincial settings. In Le Paradigme perdu: Qu'est-ce que la nature humaine? (1973), Morin challenged reductionist views of by integrating biological, cultural, and historical dimensions, arguing for a holistic to overcome the nature-culture . Later, Terre-Patrie (1993), co-written with Anne-Brigitte Kern, advocated recognizing as a shared amid , emphasizing interdependence and the risks of polycrisis from environmental and social disruptions. Collections of essays further disseminated his ideas on complexity outside systematic treatises. On Complexity (2007 edition of earlier writings) applied complexity principles to , organization , and human sciences, critiquing linear in favor of emergent, processes. The Challenge of Complexity (2022), compiling over 30 essays spanning decades, addresses themes from production to global , underscoring the need for reflexive, multidisciplinary thinking in addressing contemporary uncertainties.

Recognition and Enduring Impact

Honors and Awards

Edgar Morin has been honored with several high-level French distinctions for his intellectual contributions. He received the initially in 1983, was promoted to Commandeur on January 16, 2002, at the Hôtel de Ville de , and later elevated to Grand officier before achieving the dignity of in the July 14, 2021, promotion decreed by President . In 2012, he was promoted to Grand officier of the by President . Internationally, Morin was awarded the Nonino Prize as "Master of Our Time" in 2004. In April 2024, he received the Prize from the Human Futures Foundation for exemplifying "wisdom in action" as a "good ancestor." He has also been recognized with the Distinguished and Outstanding Lifetime Achievement Award from the World Complexity Science Academy and honors from the Bertalanffy Center for the Study of Systems Science. Morin holds more than 30 honorary doctorates from universities across over 20 countries, spanning fields such as , , and . These recognitions underscore his influence in promoting complex thought and globally.

Intellectual Legacy and Recent Contributions

Edgar Morin's intellectual legacy is epitomized by his paradigm of "complex thought" (pensée complexe), which posits that reality cannot be fully grasped through reductionist or disjunctive scientific methods but requires embracing uncertainty, interdependence, and recursive processes across disciplines. Developed over decades, this approach critiques the fragmentation of knowledge in modernity and advocates for a dialogic epistemology where unity and diversity, order and disorder, interact dynamically. His six-volume La Méthode series (1977–2004) systematizes these ideas, influencing in social sciences, ecology, and by highlighting and feedback in human societies. Morin's early works on and , such as The Red and the White (1959) and The Stars (1957), laid groundwork for analyzing cultural phenomena through , extending to critiques of ideological simplifications in and media. This legacy has permeated diverse fields, from in Homeland Earth (1993), co-authored with Anne-Brigitte Kern, urging planetary citizenship amid , to contemporary applications in addressing "polycrises"—interlinked crises like pandemics and climate instability—that demand non-linear thinking over linear predictions. UNESCO's 2021 centenary tribute underscored his role in fostering global intellectual dialogue on complexity, with tributes noting his transcendence of disciplinary boundaries in , , and . Scholars credit Morin with bridging , open , and to human and society, influencing recursive models in and organizational studies. In recent contributions, Morin, at age 103 as of 2024, remains engaged, publishing the autobiographical novel L'Année a perdu son printemps on June 5, 2024, which intertwines personal reflections on loss with broader historical and existential themes amid global upheavals. A 2023 interview at age 101 revealed his ongoing emphasis on life's vital force countering mortality, while applying complex thought to warn against oversimplified responses to ecological and social disruptions. His framework continues to inform analyses of interconnected global challenges, as seen in 2024 discussions linking complexity to historical human migrations and cultural exchanges, reinforcing calls for adaptive, holistic governance. Despite advanced age, Morin's persistent output, including endorsements of open societies and European unity, sustains his impact on rethinking knowledge for an era of uncertainty.

References

  1. https://news.cnrs.fr/articles/edgar-morin-turns-100-and-continues-his-journey
  2. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8832048/
  3. https://www.ciup.fr/en/chaises/prendre-position-the-chair-of-fraternity/
  4. https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20240605-french-philospher-publishes-novel-at-the-the-age-of-102
  5. https://www.seuil.com/ouvrage/la-methode-i-et-ii-edgar-morin/9782020968720
  6. https://news.cnrs.fr/articles/edgar-morin-in-praise-of-complex-thought
  7. https://www.connexionfrance.com/news/hero-sailor-jean-le-cam-among-frances-july-14-honours-list/422047
  8. https://www.wise-qatar.org/biography/edgar-morin/
  9. https://en.geneastar.org/genealogy/morinedgar/edgar-morin
  10. https://www.aspr.ac.at/en/education-training/aspr-campaigns/homeland-earth/homeland-earth/edgar-morin
  11. https://somatosphere.com/2023/edgar-morins-lecons-dun-siecle-de-vie.html/
  12. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3692098-vidal-and-his-family
  13. https://www.amazon.com/Vidal-His-Family-Sephardic-Twentieth/dp/1845192745
  14. https://europeanfamilytherapy.eu/edgar-morin/
  15. https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/morin-edgar
  16. https://lhumaine.numerev.com/articles/revue-2/2926-edgar-morin
  17. https://unesco.delegfrance.org/Edgar-Morin-la-construction-d-une-pensee-visionnaire-Sabah-Abouessalam
  18. https://shs.cairn.info/revue-geographie-economie-societe-2010-1-page-111?lang=fr
  19. https://metode.org/issues/entrevista-monografic-revistes/edgar-morin-3.html
  20. https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=2008012509395185
  21. https://archive.mcxapc.org/docs/apc/0901montuori.pdf
  22. https://maitron.fr/morin-edgar-ne-nahoum-david-simon-edgar/
  23. https://www.dbnl.org/tekst/oltm003ongr01_01/oltm003ongr01_01_0060.php
  24. https://www.iulm.it/en/iulm/riconoscimenti/lauree-ad-honorem/laurea-edgar-morin
  25. https://www.persee.fr/doc/rfsp_0035-2950_1984_num_34_1_394112
  26. https://shs.cairn.info/article/E_HERM_060_0073?lang=en
  27. https://mondediplo.com/Edgar-Morin
  28. https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2006/book-reviews/edgar_morin/
  29. https://courier.unesco.org/en/articles/new-way-thinking
  30. https://www.africine.org/structure/centre-edgar-morin-ex-cetsah/5605
  31. https://hal.science/CEM
  32. https://www.uv.es/uvweb/college/en/university/academic-institutional-events/honoris-causa-doctors/honoris-causa-doctors-21st-century/date-investiture/ceremony-naming-edgar-morin-doctor-honoris-causa-1285852457837/Honoris.html?id=1285878744992
  33. https://uranos.ch/research/references/Morin_1992/morin-paradigm-of-complexity.pdf
  34. https://schoolofnomedia.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/MorinOn_Complexity_Foreword.pdf
  35. https://omarmeriwani.com/philosophy/edgar-morins-paradigm-of-complexity/
  36. https://medium.com/secondary-experience/complex-thinking-for-a-complex-world-about-reductionism-disjunction-and-systemism-by-edgar-morin-b90472bb76fd
  37. https://psychaanalyse.com/pdf/MORIN_INTRODUCTION_A_LA_PENSEE_COMPLEXE_1990.pdf
  38. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/372042447_The_Paradigm_of_Complexity_in_Edgar_Morin_and_the_Latourian_Epistemology_An_Attempt_to_Approach
  39. https://digitalcommons.ciis.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1007&context=cejournal
  40. https://cascadeinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/What-is-a-global-polycrisis-version-1.1-27April2022.pdf
  41. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/global-sustainability/article/global-polycrisis-the-causal-mechanisms-of-crisis-entanglement/06F0F8F3B993A221971151E3CB054B5E
  42. https://www.lemonde.fr/en/opinion/article/2024/01/24/edgar-morin-faced-with-the-polycrisis-humanity-is-going-through-the-first-resistance-is-that-of-the-spirit_6460205_23.html
  43. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/260603130_Edgar_Morin_and_Complex_Thought
  44. https://thetricontinental.org/newsletterissue/polycrisis-and-capitalism/
  45. https://journals.isss.org/index.php/proceedings57th/article/download/2078/726
  46. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12171050/
  47. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/00187267221139457
  48. http://www.ideassonline.org/public/pdf/Sevencomplexlessonsineducation.pdf
  49. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000123074
  50. https://shs.cairn.info/journal-communications-2022-1-page-221?lang=en
  51. https://www.redalyc.org/journal/2738/273862538023/html/
  52. https://www.amazon.fr/Pour-politique-civilisation-Edgar-Morin/dp/2869595808
  53. https://www.amazon.fr/Une-politique-civilisation-Edgar-Morin/dp/2869593228
  54. https://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Edgar_Morin_on_Civilizational_Politics
  55. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/renewed-humanism-required-to-meet-global-challenges-by-edgar-morin-and-claudio-pedretti-2025-09
  56. https://integral-review.org/issues/vol_7_no_2_nguyen_review_of_morin.pdf
  57. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/072551369103000102
  58. https://www.gene.eu/edgar-morin
  59. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383952631_The_Emergence_of_Edgar_Morin%27s_Complex_Thinking
  60. https://www.scielo.br/j/aabc/a/nnJSJtbswhQQDkm3CMyR8gJ/
  61. https://journal.emergentpublications.com/Article/c5d4d003-5e2c-4744-b50c-d270b76ff1cf/jats
  62. https://www.marianne.net/agora/tribunes-libres/guillaume-lelong-lhistoire-accelere-et-semble-donner-tort-a-edgar-morin
  63. https://www.fondapol.org/etude/complexite-critique-dune-ideologie-contemporaine/
  64. http://isias.info/spip.php?article1334
  65. https://www.weforum.org/stories/2023/03/polycrisis-adam-tooze-historian-explains/
  66. https://medium.com/edge-of-collapse/a-cascade-of-failures-the-polycrisis-defined-a55a578a97d7
  67. https://journals.library.ualberta.ca/complicity/index.php/complicity/article/view/20398
  68. https://www.litencyc.com/php/sworks.php?rec=true&UID=34686
  69. https://monoskop.org/images/a/ad/Morin_Edgar_Method_vol_1_The_Nature_of_Nature.pdf
  70. https://www.iemed.org/publication/towards-ecologised-thought-interview-with-edgar-morin/
  71. https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/1017EC70FB25BDF95B1D679F0C9AFC14/S0010417524000136a.pdf/return_to_orleans_racism_rumor_and_social_scientists_in_1960s_france.pdf
  72. https://www.sudoc.fr/026146169
  73. https://www.changinghands.com/book/9781789761658
  74. https://edgarmorinmultiversidad.org/index.php/biografia-oficial/reconocimientos/34-comandador-de-la-legion-de-honor.html
  75. https://www.lefigaro.fr/demain/societe/legion-d-honneur-edgar-morin-distingue-dans-la-promotion-du-14-juillet-20210714
  76. https://lelab.europe1.fr/jeanne-moreau-et-edgar-morin-faits-grands-officiers-de-l-ordre-national-du-merite-par-francois-hollande-5761
  77. https://www.leparisien.fr/laparisienne/people/jeanne-moreau-et-edgar-morin-promus-a-l-ordre-du-merite-15-11-2012-2323633.php
  78. https://www.grappanonino.it/en/news/nonino-prize-forty-fifth-year-on-may-7th-2022/
  79. https://myfox8.com/business/press-releases/ein-presswire/703124155/edgar-morin-receives-the-jonas-salk-prize-from-the-human-futures-foundation-on-anniversary-of-the-salk-polio-vaccine/
  80. https://www.wcsaglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Morin-rispBIS.pdf
  81. https://www.bcsss.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Edgar-Morin.pdf
  82. https://www.trobadescamus.com/2022/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/CA20_Ficha-ganador_II-Premi_Edgar_eng.pdf
  83. https://wise-qatar.org/biography/edgar-morin/
  84. https://globalstudies.wustl.edu/news/faculty-book-launch-challenge-complexity-essays-edgar-morin
  85. https://www.academia.edu/4074758/COMPLEX_THOUGHT_An_Overview_of_Edgar_Morin_s_Intellectual_Journey
  86. https://www.fairobserver.com/region/europe/peter-isackson-edgar-morin-french-philosopher-philosophy-culture-news-37824/
  87. https://www.unesco.org/archives/multimedia/document-5321-eng-2
  88. https://english.elpais.com/culture/2023-05-05/philosopher-edgar-morin-at-the-age-of-101-whenever-im-possessed-by-the-force-of-life-the-specter-of-death-recedes.html
  89. https://illuminem.com/illuminemvoices/bridging-worlds-the-silk-road-of-ideas-and-edgar-morins-vision-of-complex-humanity
  90. https://premio.grappanonino.it/en/winner/edgar-morin/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.