Hubbry Logo
BakarwalBakarwalMain
Open search
Bakarwal
Community hub
Bakarwal
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Bakarwal
Bakarwal
Bakarwal
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Bakarwal (also spelled Bakkarwal, or Bakerwal) are a nomadic Muslim ethnic group and a sub-group of the larger Gujjar community.[2][3] They primarily inhabit the Indian Union Territories of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh, where they have been listed as a Scheduled Tribe since 1991.[4][5][6] The Gujjar-Bakarwal are among the largest Muslim tribal communities in the region and constitute the third-largest ethnic group in the Indian-administered part of Jammu and Kashmir.[7][8][9][2]

Key Information

The Bakarwal are traditionally pastoral nomads, known for seasonally migrating with their livestock in search of suitable grazing pastures.[2] Their annual transhumance involves moving between high-altitude meadows in the summer and lower-altitude areas during the winter. They were officially enumerated as a distinct group for the first time during the 2001 Census of India.[2]

They inhabit a vast area stretching from the Pir Panjal Range to Zanskar, located in the Himalayan mountains of India .[10][11][12] Their seasonal migration patterns encompass regions such as Suru Valley and Kargil in Ladakh, and they traverse the Pir Panjal and Banihal passes during their transhumance.[12] This extensive migration route underscores their deep-rooted connection to the diverse terrains and climates of the Himalayan region.[12]

History and origin

[edit]

Bakarwals and Gujjars are often grouped together as a single social and ethnic community due to their shared ancestry, language, religion, and cultural practices.[2][13] Both groups speak dialects of Gojri, practice Islam, and follow similar customs in terms of dress, food, and social organization.[2][12][13] As a result, they are frequently treated as a unified tribal category in official classifications and government records, particularly in the context of their Scheduled Tribe status in Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh.

The Bakarwal community is not limited to India; they are also found in Azad Kashmir, Pakistan. Significant populations of Bakarwals reside in some areas of Azad Jammu and Kashmir. These areas serve as important seasonal and permanent settlements for the community, reflecting their traditional patterns of transhumance and pastoralism.[6]

Despite these commonalities, Gujjars and Bakarwals are often distinguished by their traditional modes of livelihood.[2][12][13] Bakarwals are primarily a nomadic pastoralist group who migrate seasonally with their herds of sheep and goats in search of grazing pastures in the Himalayan highlands during summer and lower-altitude regions in winter.[13]

One view suggests that the Bakarwals emerged in the twentieth century as a mix of Gujjars, Awans, and others from present-day Hazara, Pakistan.[14] However, this view is not recognized by the Bakarwals themselves, and there is no historical or traditional evidence supporting such an origin.[2][12][13]

The Bakarwals and Gujjars in Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir sometimes practice inter-tribal marriages as well.[15][16][full citation needed]

Etymology

[edit]

The term Bakarwal is an occupational one and is derived from the Gojri/Punjabi or Dogri word Bakari or Bakra meaning goat or sheep, and wal meaning "one who takes care of".[17][18][10]

Religion

[edit]

The Bakarwals are completely Muslim and adhere to the Sunni sect of Islam, similar to other Muslim Gujjar communities.[19][20]

Subgroups

[edit]

The Bakarwal Gujjars are primarily divided into two major subgroups: Kunhari Bakarwal and Illahiwal Bakarwal.[21] Moreover, Bakarwals, like other Gujjar communities, are also subdivided into numerous sub-clans.[22]

Kunhari

[edit]

The Kunhari is a subgroup of Bakarwals who claimed their origin from the Kunar province of Afghanistan.[23]

Illahiwal

[edit]

The Illahiwal are those who claimed their origin from the Illahiwal region in the Kohistan and Swat districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.[24]

Demographics

[edit]

The Bakarwal nomads are traditionally found throughout the Himalayan regions of India and Pakistan, including parts of Jammu & Kashmir and Azad Kashmir.[6][10][11][12]

Jammu and Kashmir

[edit]
Bakarwal and Gujjar people

The Bakarwal, often counted alongside the Gujjars, constitute a significant portion of the tribal population.[12] The Gujjar and Bakarwal are estimated to be around 20% of Jammu and Kashmir.[13]

Ladakh

[edit]

The Muslim Gujjars and Bakarwal communities in Ladakh are traditionally pastoralists, grazing livestock in areas like Rangdum. Recently, disputes over land encroachment and unauthorized construction have arisen. In 2024, the Lieutenant Governor of Ladakh intervened to address these issues, including the illegal occupation of grazing land and the ongoing legal dispute over land rights in the region.[25][26][27]

Himachal Pradesh

[edit]

The Bakarwal nomads are also found in the Himalayan state of Himachal Pradesh, which borders Jammu and Kashmir and Tibet.[28][29][30]

Pakistan

[edit]

In Pakistan, the Bakarwal are primarily found in some areas of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, where they continue their nomadic traditions across mountainous and highland regions.[6][31]

Azad Kashmir

[edit]

In Azad Jammu and Kashmir, the Bakarwal are a nomadic pastoralist community traditionally engaged in the seasonal herding of goats and sheep. They migrate annually across the Pir Panjal and Himalayan mountain ranges in search of grazing pastures, often traveling long distances by foot. Their routes typically span from lowland areas such as Kharian to high-altitude plateaus like Deosai in Gilgit-Baltistan, passing through regions including Muzaffarabad, Garhi Dupatta, and the Neelum Valley.[31]

Population

[edit]
Historical population
YearPop.±% p.a.
200160,724—    
2011113,198+6.43%
source: 2001 census[32] - 2011 census[1][33]

The Bakarwal population in Jammu and Kashmir was 60,724 according to the 2001 Indian census.[32]

The 2011 Indian census showed a 6.43% increase in the Bakarwal population, reaching 113,198 in the Jammu and Kashmir region.[1]

Economy

[edit]

As sheep and goat rearing transhumants, the Bakarwals alternate with the seasons between high and low altitudes in the hills of the Himalayas. From here, it is clear to see that the Bakarwals mainly follow a migration route through the foothills of the Himalayas as they can be found on the Upper Himalayan Range all the way down into the Lower Himalayan Range.[10][page needed]

Social status

[edit]

As of 1991, the Bakarwal were classified as a Scheduled Tribe under the Indian government's general reservation program of positive discrimination.[34][35]

[edit]
  • Bakarwal women from Chenab Valley of Jammu and Kashmir
    Bakarwal women from Chenab Valley of Jammu and Kashmir
  • Bakarwal shepherd woman from Jammu and Kashmir
    Bakarwal shepherd woman from Jammu and Kashmir
  • Sketch of Bakarwal man holding his son and smoking Hookah​​‌
    Sketch of Bakarwal man holding his son and smoking Hookah
  • Many Bakarwals live in such houses for periods of time​​‌
    Many Bakarwals live in such houses for periods of time

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Bakarwal

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Bakarwals are a nomadic subgroup of the Gujjar ethnic community, predominantly who specialize in herding and sheep across the mountainous terrains of Jammu and Kashmir in . The name "Bakarwal" derives from "bakar," the word for in their language, combined with "wal," denoting herder, underscoring their traditional reliance on caprine for sustenance and trade. As a Scheduled Tribe, they maintain a transhumant , seasonally migrating from high-altitude meadows in summer to lowland areas in winter to access pastures and evade harsh weather. Bakarwals speak Gojri, an Indo-Aryan language shared with Gujjars, and their culture emphasizes communal herding, oral traditions, and adaptation to rugged Himalayan ecology, with families often living in temporary thatched huts or tents during migrations. Historical accounts trace their presence in the region to migrations possibly originating from northwestern India or Central Asia, integrating into local societies while preserving pastoral autonomy. Their economy centers on wool, meat, and dairy production, though modernization pressures, including sedentarization policies and land restrictions, have challenged traditional practices, leading to gradual shifts toward partial settlement. Demographically, Bakarwals form a significant portion of Jammu and Kashmir's tribal population, often enumerated alongside Gujjars, who collectively account for about 11.9% of the state's Scheduled Tribes as per official records. Women play integral roles in herding, child-rearing, and household management during treks, contributing to a resilient social structure amid environmental and socioeconomic vulnerabilities. Despite low formal education rates and limited access to services due to mobility, community networks sustain cultural continuity and ecological knowledge, such as sustainable grazing that prevents overexploitation of alpine pastures.

Origins and History

Etymology

The term Bakarwal (also spelled Bakkarwal or Bakerwal) is derived from the Gojri, , Punjabi, Kashmiri, or Dogri words bakra (or bakri), meaning "" or "sheep," combined with wal, signifying "one who tends" or "caretaker." This etymology reflects the group's primary occupation as nomadic herders of goats and sheep at high altitudes, distinguishing them as specialized pastoralists within broader ethnic communities. The name's occupational origin underscores the Bakarwals' seasonal practices, migrating between high pastures in summer and lower valleys in winter, a tied directly to rearing rather than settled . While some sources extend the reference to include sheep alongside , the core implication remains that of high-altitude shepherds, with no of alternative mythological or non-occupational derivations in ethnographic accounts.

Migration and Historical Origins

The Bakarwals, a nomadic of the Gujjar ethnic community, are believed to have originated from ancient migratory waves of Central Asian tribes entering the between the 3rd and 6th centuries CE, driven by regional disturbances and in search of new grazing lands. These migrants, associated with groups such as the Gurjaras and other pastoral nomads, traversed northwestern passes including Bolan and Koh-Suleiman, integrating into the indigenous populations while maintaining livestock-based economies centered on sheep and goats. By the 10th or 11th century, Gujjar-Bakarwal groups had dispersed into the Jammu and Kashmir region, drawn by the Himalayan foothills' abundant alpine pastures amid ongoing transhumant expansions from earlier footholds in and . This settlement reflected broader patterns of immigration into the area, influenced by political shifts, trade routes, and ecological suitability for , with Bakarwals specializing in (from bakar, meaning in local dialects) as a distinct adaptive niche within Gujjar society. Alternative scholarly views link their roots more directly to indigenous migrations rather than distant Central Asian incursions, highlighting debates over precise ethnic trajectories due to limited pre-medieval records. Their historical migrations established a semi-permanent presence in the and surrounding valleys, where seasonal movements—descending to lowland plains in winter (November to April) and ascending to high meadows in summer—persisted as a core survival strategy, adapting to altitudinal variations in forage availability. This , documented in ethnographic accounts, underscores causal ties between , , and , with herds numbering hundreds per family enabling economic resilience despite terrain challenges.

Adaptation and Settlement Patterns

The Bakarwals, a pastoralist of the Gujjar community, primarily engage in , an adaptive strategy involving seasonal migration of sheep and herds between high-altitude meadows during summer and lowland plains in winter to exploit varying availability and climatic conditions. This pattern, sustained for generations in the Jammu and Kashmir region of and adjacent areas in , enables efficient resource use in rugged Himalayan terrain where permanent is limited. Herds typically ascend to elevations above 3,000 meters from May to , descending by to avoid harsh winters with heavy snowfall. Adaptations to environmental challenges include reliance on indigenous knowledge for route selection, avoiding overgrazed areas, and integrating supplementary during shortages, though climate variability—such as reduced snowfall and erratic rainfall—has intensified vulnerabilities since the early 2000s, prompting shifts like shortened migrations or herd size reductions of up to 20-30% in affected groups. Nomads construct temporary encampments using portable woolen tents or wooden dhoks on migration routes, fostering mobility while providing against alpine extremes. Settlement patterns remain predominantly semi-nomadic, with families maintaining base camps in forested lowlands for winter residency and dispersing into smaller units during summer ; however, sedentarization has accelerated since the late 1980s, driven by factors including land reforms, security restrictions post-1990s , and access to , affecting an estimated 10-15% of households who have transitioned to fixed villages with rudimentary housing. This shift often involves partial abandonment of full in favor of localized or , though full nomadism persists among core pastoralists to preserve productivity.

Religion and Cultural Practices

Religious Affiliation and Observance

The Bakarwals are overwhelmingly Sunni Muslims, professing faith in as the supreme who revealed guidance through the Prophet Muhammad, the , and the . They recite the as the foundational declaration of faith and adhere to the Five Pillars of , including performance of the five daily prayers () oriented toward , fasting during the month of , payment of zakat (alms to the needy), and undertaking pilgrimage to when physically and financially able. Prohibitions against alcohol, , gambling, theft, slander, and idolatry form core ethical observances, with reliance on predestined fate (qadar) shaping their worldview. Daily and communal religious life emphasizes simplicity and devotion, with Friday congregational prayers (Jumu'ah) conducted at mosques during semi-settled phases of their seasonal migrations. Major annual observances include Eid al-Fitr, celebrating the conclusion of Ramadan with communal prayers and feasting, and Eid al-Adha, honoring the biblical Abraham's readiness to sacrifice his son through ritual animal sacrifice and distribution of meat to the poor. These festivals are marked with enthusiasm, incorporating traditional songs, attire, and communal gatherings that blend religious piety with cultural expressions. Historical via Sufi missionaries has infused Bakarwal observance with folk Sufi elements, particularly shared with the broader Gujjar community, including regular pilgrimages to shrines of saints such as Baba Ghulam Shah Badshah for blessings and participation in commemorations. Devotional practices feature zikr (ritual remembrance of God through repetitive chanting) and recitation of Sufi kalam (poetry) in Gojri or during weddings, funerals, and festivals, promoting themes of divine love, tolerance, and communal harmony. Such syncretic influences persist alongside orthodox Sunni rites, fostering shrine-based amid regional militancy challenges. Nomadic pastoralism adapts these observances to mobility, with salah often performed in open pastures or tent encampments using portable prayer mats, and reliance on itinerant maulvis (Islamic scholars) for guidance in life-cycle rituals like male circumcision (khitan), (nikah), and burial rites following prescriptions. This integration ensures religious continuity, though access to formal madrasas or fixed shrines varies with seasonal between highland meadows and lowland valleys.

Cultural Traditions and Lifestyle

The Bakarwals lead a nomadic lifestyle characterized by , seasonally migrating with herds of goats and sheep between high-altitude summer pastures from March to August and lowland winter grazing areas from September to February across the Himalayan regions of Jammu and Kashmir. This mobility supports their primary occupation of , supplemented by wool shearing and limited small-scale , while women manage domestic tasks, child-rearing, and assist in herding during migrations. Socially, Bakarwal society is patrilineal and patriarchal, organized into clans (kabila), lineages (dada-potre), and nuclear family households (dera), with functional groups like herding units and migrating caravans (kafila) facilitating collective movement. Traditional governance occurs through Jirga councils of elders, which resolve disputes internally, though state interventions like panchayats have increasingly influenced this system. Family life emphasizes endogamous, patrilocal marriages arranged by elders, often consanguineous, with rituals such as Matti Khunni (proposal) and Nikha (wedding contract); while the average marriage age is around 25, instances of child marriage persist as a noted social challenge. As Sunni Muslims, Bakarwals observe Islamic festivals like Eid and life-cycle rituals including (Khutna) and burials, alongside visits to shrines of Pirs for blessings involving animal sacrifices. They also participate in regional celebrations such as Nawroz and Baisakhi, reflecting cultural adaptations in their multi-ethnic environment. Cultural preservation occurs through oral traditions like folktales and Gojri-language songs, maintaining ethnic identity amid nomadic hardships. Traditional attire suits their high-altitude existence, with men donning , turbans (pagheri), and carrying sticks, while women wear jubo or pheerni garments, often adorned with silver jewelry such as gani and . Woolen fabrics predominate for warmth, distinguishing their practical dress from more settled groups. Despite modernization pressures, these practices underscore the Bakarwals' resilience in sustaining a herd-dependent way of life with limited access to education and healthcare.

Ethnic Composition and Subgroups

Relation to Gujjar Community

The Bakarwals are widely regarded as a subgroup of the larger Gujjar ethnic community, differentiated primarily by their specialized occupation as nomadic herders of sheep and —a term derived from "bakar," meaning goat in their . This distinction emerged in British colonial census records, with Bakarwals first categorically identified in the 1911 and 1921 reports based on their vocation, while Gujjars encompassed both nomadic and semi-settled or settled populations often involved in or buffalo rearing. Together, Gujjars and Bakarwals form the third-largest ethnic group in Jammu and Kashmir, comprising over 1.1 million individuals as per recent estimates, and are recognized as a single Scheduled Tribe category in Indian administrative classifications, reflecting their shared ethnic origins tracing back to migratory Gujjar tribes from and beyond. Linguistically and culturally, Bakarwals and Gujjars exhibit strong similarities, including the use of the Gojri language (an Indo-Aryan dialect) and adherence to Sunni Islam with comparable customs such as clan-based social organization and seasonal migration patterns. However, lifestyle differences persist: Bakarwals maintain a fully transhumant existence, migrating annually with herds across high-altitude meadows in summer and lower valleys in winter, whereas many Gujjars have transitioned to semi-permanent settlements, cultivating land or engaging in dairy farming with less mobility. These occupational divergences have led some anthropological accounts to describe them as distinct sub-ethnic groups within the broader Gujjar umbrella, though intermarriage and shared ancestry underscore their interconnected identity. In contemporary socio-political contexts, the Gujjar-Bakarwal collective advocates for unified reservation benefits under Scheduled Tribe status, as seen in protests against dilutions of quotas for Pahari communities in Jammu and Kashmir since 2024, highlighting their strategic alignment despite internal lifestyle variations. Genetic and historical studies support common Rajasthani-Gujarati roots for both, with migrations into the occurring in waves from the 5th to 17th centuries CE, adapting to amid geographic isolation. This relation underscores a continuum rather than rigid separation, where economic specialization fosters subgroup identity within an overarching ethnic framework.

Distinct Subgroups

The Bakarwals, as a nomadic of the broader Gujjar ethnic community, exhibit internal divisions primarily based on historical migration origins and cultural influences. They are mainly categorized into two major subgroups: the Kunhari Bakarwals and the Illahiwal Bakarwals. These distinctions arise from differing ancestral claims and linguistic-cultural affinities, though both maintain the core transhumant lifestyle of herding sheep and goats between high-altitude summer pastures in the and winter lowlands in Jammu and Kashmir. Kunarhi Bakarwals trace their origins to the Kunhar Valley in present-day , reflecting a historical migration pattern tied to routes in the . In contrast, Illahiwal Bakarwals assert descent from the Illahiwal region in Kohistan and Swat areas of , where Pushto linguistic and cultural elements have influenced their dialects and traditions, distinguishing them somewhat from other Bakarwal groups more aligned with standard Gojri speech. These subgroups often organize seasonal migrations independently, with variations in route preferences shaped by terrain access and historical settlements, yet they share endogamous practices within broader structures to preserve lineage purity. Beyond these primary divisions, Bakarwal society is further segmented into numerous clans (known as kabila or gotra), analogous to those in the settled Gujjar communities, which regulate social organization, inheritance, and exogamous marriages at the clan level while enforcing endogamy at the community level. Specific clan names are not uniformly documented across sources, but they function as descent groups descending from common ancestors, influencing internal alliances and conflict resolution during joint pastoral movements. This clan-based structure reinforces cohesion amid the challenges of nomadism, with no evidence of rigid hierarchical castes within the subgroups.

Demographics and Distribution

Population Estimates

The Bakarwal population in Jammu and Kashmir, , stood at 113,198 according to the , representing 7.58% of the region's total Scheduled Tribe population of approximately 1.49 million. This figure reflects their enumeration as a distinct nomadic within the broader Gujjar community, though undercounting is likely due to seasonal migrations that complicate census capture. District-wise distribution shows concentrations in (36,163), (16,393), (14,225), and (7,946), with smaller numbers in urban-adjacent areas like (710). No official data post-2011 exists for Jammu and Kashmir owing to administrative changes and delays in national enumeration, leaving current estimates speculative; anecdotal reports suggest modest growth aligned with regional demographics, but nomadic lifestyles continue to hinder precise tracking. In , Bakarwal population figures lack dedicated census categorization, with estimates varying widely; one assessment from 2020 identifies 7,400 families in the Hazara and Malakand divisions alone, implying a total potentially exceeding 50,000 individuals assuming average household sizes of 6-8, though comprehensive national data remains unavailable. These approximations underscore the challenges of quantifying transborder nomadic groups without targeted surveys.

Regional Presence in India

The Bakarwals maintain a primary presence in the of Jammu and Kashmir, where they form a significant nomadic community inhabiting the Himalayan and Pir Panjal regions. Their distribution is shaped by seasonal migrations, with summer pastures in high-altitude meadows of the and winter settlements in lower elevations of the . Key districts include and Poonch in , where concentrations are highest due to favorable grazing lands, alongside , , and ; smaller numbers are recorded in (718 individuals) and (13 individuals) as per ethnographic surveys. In the Jammu division, Bakarwals are also found in Reasi, Ramban, Doda, Kishtwar, Kathua, and Samba, often utilizing forested and meadow areas for livestock herding. This regional footprint excludes Ladakh, where their nomadic routes do not extend significantly, reflecting ecological preferences for specific altitudinal zones between 1,500 and 4,000 meters. Their mobility leads to temporary encampments rather than permanent villages, with groups traversing predefined routes across these districts annually. Beyond Jammu and Kashmir, smaller Bakarwal communities exist in adjacent northern states, including —particularly in the Pir Panjal extensions—and , where they engage in similar transhumant practices amid Himalayan foothills. These peripheral populations are less documented but tied to historical migrations from core Gujjar-Bakarwal heartlands, comprising marginal shares of local tribal demographics. ![Bakarwals in Rajouri][float-right]

Regional Presence in Pakistan

The Bakarwal community, a nomadic subgroup of the Gujjars specializing in goat and sheep herding, maintains a presence in Pakistan across Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK), Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP), and Punjab. In AJK, they are integrated within the larger Gujjar population, estimated at 829,000 individuals, where they continue traditional transhumance, migrating seasonally between alpine pastures and valley floors. Their herds graze in districts such as Muzaffarabad and Neelum, adapting to the region's rugged terrain while facing restrictions from border tensions and deforestation. In , particularly the and Malakand region, approximately 7,400 Bakarwal families oversee herds totaling over one million goats and sheep as of 2020 estimates. These groups undertake annual migrations starting in spring from lowland settlements to high-altitude meadows in the Hindu Kush and ranges, returning in autumn to avoid harsh winters. Such patterns sustain their economy but expose them to vulnerabilities like erratic weather and loss from projects. Smaller Bakarwal populations exist in , often semi-nomadic and concentrated near the and Potohar Plateau, where they supplement herding with limited agriculture. Across these regions, Bakarwals number in the tens of thousands, though precise data distinguishing them from sedentary Gujjars remains limited due to their mobility. Their distribution reflects historical migrations from Central Asian steppes, with subgroups like the Kunhari tracing origins to Pakistan's Kunhar Valley.

Economy and Livelihood

Pastoral Nomadism

The Bakarwals practice transhumant , characterized by seasonal vertical migrations with herds of sheep and goats between high-altitude alpine meadows in summer and lowland plains in winter. This pattern follows the availability of pastures, with families relocating en masse to sustain viability amid Jammu and Kashmir's varied . Migration typically commences in April or May from winter bases in districts such as Poonch and , ascending the to pastures, covering distances exceeding 300 kilometers over 20-30 days. Herds, numbering hundreds of goats and sheep per family unit, rely on established routes through mountain passes, with equines like donkeys serving as pack animals for household goods and weaker animals. Return journeys occur in September or October, timed to evade early snowfalls that render high pastures inaccessible. Livestock rearing centers on indigenous breeds adapted to rugged terrains, yielding wool, meat, and limited dairy products as primary economic outputs, supplemented by sale of live animals at seasonal markets. Herd management involves communal under male herders, with women handling milking and processing, though veterinary access remains limited along migration paths. In Pakistan-administered areas, similar cross-border persists among Bakarwal groups, navigating seasonal shifts in Azad Kashmir's meadows.

Economic Challenges and Adaptations

Bakarwals, as transhumant pastoralists herding 50 to 150 goats and sheep per family, face significant economic challenges from climate variability disrupting traditional migration patterns. Erratic weather, including early heatwaves and unseasonal snowfall, has forced migrations a month ahead of schedule, leading to livestock exposure to suboptimal pastures and increased mortality; for instance, unseasonal snow in 2009 killed over 25,000 across Gujjar-Bakarwal herds. Reduced rainfall over two decades has turned pastures barren, with 79% of herders reporting fodder scarcity and poor quality, exacerbating and forcing supplemental feed purchases that strain finances. Land access issues compound these pressures, as encroachment, , and restrictions from past insurgencies (e.g., conflicts) and border fencing limit grazing routes, reducing available meadows and prompting conflicts over resources. Market vulnerabilities further erode incomes, with exploitation by private dairies, absence of cooperatives, and weak value chains for , , and leaving herders without fair prices or support. Lack of veterinary services in remote terrains contributes to diseases like during 1.5-month migrations, while the broader transhumant of 612,000 in Jammu and Kashmir contends with these amid minimal contributions to . In response, Bakarwals have adopted diversification strategies, including selling locally, renting to sedentary farmers, and engaging in wage labor, handicrafts, or gathering wild herbs and timber for supplemental income. Some families, citing pasture losses (noted by 50% in surveys), have pursued partial sedentarization, integrating or seeking jobs and to mitigate risks, though this erodes traditional expertise. Despite these shifts, core persists with adjusted timings and eco-centric herd management to sustain yields amid depleted resources.

Social Structure and Status

Family, Kinship, and Marriage Practices

The Bakarwal family structure is traditionally organized around the dera, a mobile unit comprising extended kin groups led by senior male members who manage and migration routes. This patriarchal system emphasizes collective decision-making, with authority vested in elders who oversee resource allocation and within the group. Joint families predominate among nomadic households to pool labor for and tent maintenance, though sedentarization has prompted shifts toward nuclear units in settled areas. Kinship among Bakarwals follows patrilineal descent, tracing lineage through male ancestors within () frameworks that regulate of herds and grazing rights. confines marriages to the broader Gujjar-Bakarwal community, reinforcing social cohesion, while operates at the level to avoid taboos, such as prohibiting unions between children of the same mother, foster siblings, or parallel cousins. These norms sustain reciprocal obligations, including mutual aid during migrations and support, though economic pressures have weakened extended kin ties in recent decades. Marriage practices are arranged by family elders through negotiations emphasizing alliance-building and (bata-sata), with ceremonies spanning multiple days including betrothal (mangni), (barat), and post-wedding rituals. Unions are patrilocal, requiring brides to join the husband's dera, and often consanguineous, favoring cross-cousin matches to consolidate herds and land claims. Girls typically marry between ages 14 and 15, boys between 17 and 18, reflecting pastoral priorities for early integration into labor roles, while occurs sporadically among affluent herders but remains rare overall. Contemporary influences, including state interventions and , have introduced delays in marriage age and adoption of simplified rituals from sedentary neighbors, eroding distinct Bakarwal customs like unique pre-wedding feasts.

Education, Health, and Socioeconomic Indicators

Literacy rates among Bakarwals remain notably low, reflecting the challenges posed by their transhumant lifestyle, which disrupts consistent school attendance and leads to high dropout rates, particularly at the upper primary level where rates reach 11.38%. A 2018 study reported Bakarwal at 22.51%, compared to 31.65% for settled Gujjars and 55.52% for the general population in Jammu and Kashmir, with female literacy lagging significantly at around 25.25% overall for Gujjars and Bakarwals. These figures position Bakarwals among the least educated scheduled tribes in the region, lower than the 50.6% tribal average, exacerbated by geographic isolation and limited infrastructure in migration routes.
GroupLiteracy Rate (%)
Bakarwals22.51
Gujjars31.65
General Population (J&K)55.52
Scheduled Tribes (J&K)50.6
Health outcomes for Bakarwals are compromised by inadequate access to facilities, with nomadic migration limiting utilization of static healthcare and contributing to delayed treatments for common ailments. Poverty drives poor nutritional status and higher vulnerability to respiratory issues, such as elevated prevalence in high-altitude areas, alongside endemic conditions like thyroid disorders linked to and environmental factors. Basic amenities are scarce, with widespread reports of , smoking-related illnesses, and insufficient , further widening disparities compared to settled populations. Socioeconomic indicators reveal persistent deprivation, characterized by reliance on low-yield rearing, which yields unstable incomes vulnerable to fodder shortages and market fluctuations, perpetuating below-poverty-line conditions for most households. In Jammu and Kashmir, Bakarwals exhibit lower human development metrics than regional averages, with economic profiles marked by limited diversification into non-pastoral activities and exclusion from urban opportunities due to mobility. Comparable patterns in Pakistan-administered areas show literacy around or below 20-30% in some subgroups, underscoring cross-border similarities in marginalization despite varying policy contexts.

Scheduled Tribe Classification and Reservations

The Bakarwals, a nomadic subgroup of the Gujjar ethnic community primarily residing in Jammu and Kashmir, were officially notified as a Scheduled Tribe under the Jammu and Kashmir Scheduled Tribes Order in 1991. This classification followed the initial recognition of Gujjars as Scheduled Tribes in 1989, with Bakarwals added via state amendments to address their socioeconomic vulnerabilities, including nomadism and limited access to settled resources. The status was integrated into the national framework after the 2019 reorganization of Jammu and Kashmir into union territories, maintaining their inclusion in the central Scheduled Tribes list under Article 342 of the Indian Constitution. As Scheduled Tribes, Bakarwals are entitled to constitutional reservations aimed at promoting educational and economic upliftment, including a 10% quota in government jobs and admissions to higher education institutions within Jammu and Kashmir. These benefits encompass priority in scholarships, land allocation schemes for communities, and representation in legislative bodies, such as reserved seats in the . Additional affirmative actions include targeted development programs under the , focusing on health, housing, and skill training to mitigate the challenges of their migratory lifestyle. In 2024, amendments to the Scheduled Tribes list extended status to newly recognized groups like Paharis, prompting concerns from Bakarwal representatives over potential dilution of quotas; however, government assurances emphasized protection of existing 10% reservations for Gujjars and Bakarwals through sub-categorization or adjusted allocations. Despite these entitlements, empirical assessments indicate uneven utilization due to low literacy rates and seasonal migration, with only partial enrollment in reservation schemes as of the early 2020s.

Political Engagement and Advocacy

The Bakarwal subgroup within the Gujjar-Bakarwal community achieved Scheduled Tribe (ST) status in Jammu and Kashmir on April 29, 1991, following sustained advocacy for recognition of their distinct nomadic identity and socioeconomic marginalization, which included demands for in , , and . This status granted them a 10% reservation quota, addressing historical exclusion but prompting ongoing mobilization to safeguard these benefits against perceived dilutions. Political engagement intensified in the 2020s amid disputes over ST expansions. Bakarwals protested the 2022-2024 legislative moves to include Pahari-speaking people in the ST list, fearing it would halve their effective quotas through increased competition for limited seats and resources; demonstrations in districts like , Poonch, and featured rallies with slogans such as "ST status se chher-chhar, nahi chalegi" (no tampering with ST status), drawing thousands and halting traffic on key routes. These actions pressured authorities, resulting in a 2024 delimitation that reserved nine assembly seats for STs—primarily benefiting Gujjar-Bakarwals in Pir Panjal and Chenab regions—while maintaining their 10% quota intact, though sub-quotas were not implemented. Advocacy extends to intra-ST equity, with Bakarwals demanding sub-categorization by December 2024 to prioritize nomadic herders over settled Gujjars, arguing that urbanized subgroups disproportionately capture current benefits; leaders announced plans to petition courts for this reform, citing data on uneven access to reservations. Community organizations, such as the Gujjar-Bakarwal Action Committee, coordinate these efforts, often aligning with broader tribal forums to lobby for forest grazing rights and against evictions under environmental laws, as seen in 2020 Pahalgam shelter demolitions that displaced hundreds. Despite limited formal affiliations, Bakarwals leverage ST-reserved constituencies to influence outcomes in Jammu's Muslim-majority areas, contributing to electoral shifts post-2019 Article 370 abrogation by supporting integrationist policies that promise quota protections.

Role in Conflicts and Security

Contributions to Counter-Militancy Efforts

The Bakarwal community, known for their seasonal migrations across remote mountainous terrains in Jammu and Kashmir, has played a significant role in counter-militancy operations by leveraging their intimate knowledge of the landscape to provide actionable to Indian security forces. Their nomadic practices enable them to traverse areas often inaccessible to static patrols, allowing them to observe and report on militant movements, infiltration routes from , and hideouts in forested or high-altitude regions. This has been instrumental in preempting attacks and facilitating targeted operations, particularly in the where militancy has persisted post-2000. During the Kargil conflict in 1999, Bakarwals alerted security forces to Pakistani infiltrators crossing the , contributing to the detection of positions that aided India's defensive response. In Operation Sarp Vinash, launched in 2003 in the Poonch-Rajouri sector, local Bakarwal herders supplied critical leads on terrorist concentrations, enabling the to eliminate over 60 militants and dismantle their bases in the . Their reports on supply caches and movement patterns were pivotal, as the operation's success relied heavily on from such mobile communities rather than technology alone. Individual acts of resistance have further highlighted their contributions, such as in 2009 when Bakarwal woman from killed a who attacked her family, using an axe to defend herself and providing subsequent intelligence that led to the neutralization of his accomplices. Community-level efforts include the formation of the Militancy Mukhalif Morcha (Anti-Militancy Front) by Gujjar-Bakarwal leaders in the 1990s and 2000s, which organized patrols and information-sharing networks to counter and report suspicious activities. These initiatives stemmed from the community's rejection of ideologies, which clashed with their pastoral traditions and loyalty to the Indian state. Ongoing engagements underscore their continued value; in April 2023, units in met with Bakarwal and Gujjar village leaders to gather real-time inputs on presence in remote areas, a practice that has helped sustain low militancy levels in compared to the . Experts note that this network has been a key factor in the rollback of in the region since the early , with Bakarwals acting as de facto village defense committees in upland pastures. However, maintaining these ties requires addressing occasional trust deficits arising from isolated incidents, though their historical reliability remains a of success.

Tensions and Controversies with Security Forces

The Bakarwal community, known for their seasonal migrations through remote and forested terrains in Jammu and Kashmir, has historically cooperated with Indian security forces by providing intelligence on movements, owing to their intimate knowledge of the . However, this has been strained by specific incidents of alleged mistreatment during counter-terrorism operations, where nomads are sometimes detained on suspicions of aiding insurgents due to their mobility. Such episodes have fueled controversies over custodial and eroded trust, despite the community's general loyalty to Indian forces. A prominent controversy arose in December 2023 in Poonch district following a on December 21 that killed four soldiers near Bufliaz. On December 22, security forces detained several Gujjar-Bakarwal civilians from Topa Peer village for questioning regarding the attack and missing weapons, including Safeer Ahmed (aged 44), Shabir Ahmed (28), and Mohammad Showkat (26), who were related and part of the nomadic herding community. The three men died in custody later that day, with post-mortem examinations revealing multiple marks, including bruises and injuries consistent with beatings. A surfaced showing detainees, identified by village Mehmood Ahmed as including the deceased, being stripped, tied to a , beaten, and having applied to wounds by uniformed personnel. The acknowledged the deaths, initiated an internal investigation, relieved a brigadier-level officer of duties, and provided compensation of Rs 30 per family along with offers of government jobs. registered a under Section 302 (murder) against unidentified persons, though it did not explicitly name the . The Gujjar-Bakarwal expressed profound , protesting the incident as a violation of their longstanding support for security operations, including forming village defense groups and sharing real-time intelligence that aided in rolling back militancy in the early . Local leaders demanded criminal prosecution of those responsible, highlighting how such actions risk alienating a key demographic comprising about 11.9% of and Kashmir's population per the 2011 . Tensions persisted into 2025, with reports of an officer allegedly assaulting a group of Gujjar-Bakarwal nomadic men in the Daghwan mountains near on July 26, amid accusations that they were aiding militants following a terror attack in . The incident, occurring at a newly established base camp in higher reaches, involved claims of beatings but lacked independent verification beyond tribal accounts, prompting calls from security experts for the to rebuild ties to avoid gaps in border areas. These events underscore a pattern where operational pressures in militancy-prone zones lead to friction, though the maintains that investigations ensure accountability while emphasizing the community's strategic value as "eyes and ears" in rugged terrains.

Contemporary Developments

Integration Pressures and Protests

In recent decades, Bakarwals have encountered mounting pressures to transition from their transhumant to sedentary lifestyles, influenced by socioeconomic incentives and policy shifts. Access to formal , particularly for children, has prompted many families to establish semi-permanent residences in lowland areas during winter migrations, reducing the feasibility of full nomadism. A 2017 survey of 40 Bakarwal households in Jammu and Kashmir found that the "acquired need of " was the chief driver of sedentarization, with families citing improved opportunities for schooling and healthcare as key factors. Government initiatives, including tribal welfare schemes under the Scheduled Tribes status, have further encouraged settlement by linking benefits like housing subsidies to fixed locations, though implementation often overlooks nomadic mobility needs. The abrogation of Article 370 in August 2019 intensified these pressures through the application of national conservation laws, leading to drives targeting alleged encroachments on lands traditionally used for . In October 2020, the Jammu and Kashmir department issued notices to over seven Bakarwal families in , , questioning their land requirements and enforcing stricter delineations under the Indian Forest Act. Similar actions in , including a violent clash in Shopian's Zampathri village on May 24 where families resisted demolition of temporary structures, highlighted conflicts over access to meadows essential for . These , justified by officials as protecting and preventing illegal occupation, have forced herders to seek alternative, often urban-adjacent, settlements, accelerating cultural erosion of nomadic practices. Bakarwal protests have centered on demands for recognition of customary rights under the Forest Rights Act (FRA) of , whose delayed implementation in Jammu and Kashmir until 2021 left communities vulnerable. In November 2020, amid widespread evictions, tribal leaders urged full FRA enforcement to grant community forest rights for , protesting what they described as arbitrary demolitions disregarding historical usage. By 2025, Gujjar-Bakarwal groups in condemned ongoing eviction orders, calling for FRA benefits to sustain rather than compel sedentarization. Parallel agitations have arisen over perceived dilutions of tribal entitlements, exacerbating integration tensions. From October 2022, ahead of Union Home Minister Amit Shah's visit, Bakarwals protested proposed inclusions of Pahari communities in the Scheduled Tribes list, fearing a reduction in their 10% reservation quota for jobs and , which supports socioeconomic mobility amid nomadic constraints. This escalated in August 2023 with road blockades and demonstrations against the Jammu and Kashmir Reservation (Amendment) Bill, viewed as an assault on hard-won ST protections secured in 1991. Protests peaked again in December 2024, with leaders warning of disrupted in assembly seats reserved for STs. These actions underscore resistance to policies that, while aiming for equitable integration, risk marginalizing nomadic subgroups by prioritizing settled demographics.

Recent Socioeconomic Shifts

The Bakarwal community has undergone gradual sedentarization since the late , transitioning from full to semi-nomadic or settled lifestyles, with approximately 3% adopting sedentary patterns by the early , driven by government programs, modernization, and social awakening. This shift has resulted in the construction of semi-permanent dwellings in areas like and Poonch, reducing reliance on seasonal migrations while preserving some activities. However, it has also led to the erosion of traditional transhumant knowledge and increased vulnerability to land disputes over pastures. Urban migration and technological integration have introduced new economic avenues, such as wage labor and small-scale trade, supplementing livestock-based incomes amid declining availability due to and encroachments. Studies from indicate that these changes have diversified livelihoods but disrupted kinship networks and cultural practices, with younger Bakarwals increasingly engaging in non-pastoral jobs. schemes under Scheduled status have provided reservations and subsidies, yet implementation gaps persist, limiting broad upliftment. The exacerbated vulnerabilities, with lockdowns post-Article 370 abrogation in August 2019 halting migrations and markets, causing livestock losses and income drops for many households. Recovery efforts have been uneven, with some communities benefiting from enhanced infrastructure investments in Jammu and Kashmir, though nomadic patterns complicate access to aid. Recent data from 2023-2024 highlight ongoing challenges in and health, hindering full socioeconomic integration despite policy frameworks aimed at tribal upliftment.

References

  1. https://tribalaffairs.jk.gov.in/ethonographic.pdf
  2. https://www.aarf.asia/current/2018/Apr/MgYXyW9exvKvxEI.pdf
  3. https://repository.tribal.gov.in/upload/bitstream/123456789/62130/1/Documentation%2520of%2520Intangible%2520Heritage%2520of%2520Gujjar%2520And%2520Bakarwal%2520Tribes%2520of%2520Jammu%2520And%2520Kashmir.pdf
  4. https://www.arfjournals.com/image/catalog/Journals%2520Papers/IJAR/2023/No%25201%2520%282023%29/5_Upaid.pdf
  5. https://www.ijmra.us/project%2520doc/2017/IJRSS_NOVEMBER2017/IJMRA-12745.pdf
  6. https://repository.tribal.gov.in/upload/bitstream/123456789/62132/1/Socio-Economic%2520Status%2520of%2520Scheduled%2520Tribe%2520%2528Gujjars%2529%2520%2526%2520Impact%2520of%2520Various%2520Government%2520Schemes%2520on%2520their%2520Livelihoods%25202%2520A.pdf
  7. https://pastoralismjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s13570-022-00264-2
  8. https://www.academia.edu/113958067/Gujjar_Bakarwals_the_eco_friendly_tribals_of_Jammu_and_Kashmir_since_centuries
  9. https://www.nilerd.ac.in/writereaddata/UploadFile/Sajad%2520Ahmad%2520Dar.pdf
  10. https://joshuaproject.net/people_groups/16305/IN
  11. https://www.ijrrjournal.com/IJRR_Vol.10_Issue.1_Jan2023/IJRR55.pdf
  12. https://journals.pen2print.org/index.php/ijr/article/download/9798/9450
  13. https://ibtidahforeducation.com/the-bakrwal-community-in-pakistan/
  14. https://www.gktoday.in/gujjar-bakarwal-tribes/
  15. https://www.earthtribalcare.org/article/bakarwal
  16. https://philarchive.org/archive/SHECAO-3
  17. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/08039410.2025.2546312
  18. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/00380229241287352
  19. https://pastoralismjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s13570-019-0137-9
  20. https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol11-issue6/G01166367.pdf
  21. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2211464523001306
  22. https://www.envirobiotechjournals.com/EEC/vol30issue1/EEC-43.pdf
  23. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00380229241287352
  24. https://antrocom.net/wp/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/dar-himalayan-pastoralism-livelihood-mobility-bakarwal.pdf
  25. http://researchjournal.co.in/upload/assignments/9_232-238.pdf
  26. https://www.questjournals.org/jrhss/papers/vol10-issue5/Ser-1/F10052732.pdf
  27. https://www.arfjournals.com/image/catalog/Journals%20Papers/IJAR/2023/No%201%20(2023)/5_Upaid.pdf
  28. https://theacademic.in/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/13.pdf
  29. https://pulitzercenter.org/projects/overlooked-toll-climate-change-kashmirs-gujjar-bakarwal-community
  30. https://migrationletters.com/index.php/ml/article/view/8537
  31. https://ilearncana.com/details/Gurjar--Bakarwal--Tribes/1609
  32. https://kashmirtimes.com/jammu-and-kashmir-news/gujjars-and-bakerwals-protest-inclusion-of-paharis-in-jk-scheduled-tribes-list
  33. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/1683478X.2025.2540252
  34. https://censusindia.gov.in/nada/index.php/catalog/530/download/1768/DH_2011_0121_PART_A_DCHB_JAMMU.pdf
  35. https://dialogue.earth/en/nature/bakarwal-community-faces-dual-threat-pakistan/
  36. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327122022_Nomadic_Education_in_Northern_Pakistan_The_Bakarwal_Case
  37. https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol.29-Issue1/Ser-9/H2901094448.pdf
  38. https://www.earlytimes.in/newsdet.aspx?q=250865
  39. https://www.indianetzone.com/gujjar_bakarwals_india
  40. https://joshuaproject.net/people_groups/16879/pk
  41. https://www.dawn.com/news/1578926
  42. https://serialsjournals.com/abstract/38188_5-muzamil.pdf
  43. https://www.newkerala.com/news/o/autumnal-migration-nomadic-bakarwals-begins-winter-cant-far-away-605
  44. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342638864_Routes_Adopted_by_Bakarwals_during_Migration_of_Livestock_and_its_Constraints
  45. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341103752_A_study_on_socio-economic_profile_of_Bakarwals_using_equines_as_pack_animals_for_highland_pasture_migration
  46. https://www.frontierspartnerships.org/journals/pastoralism-research-policy-and-practice/articles/10.3389/past.2025.14926/full
  47. https://www.jkpi.org/climate-change-a-threat-to-livelihood-of-gujjars-bakarwals/
  48. https://www.jkpi.org/sustaining-pastoral-livelihoods-in-jk-challenges-and-recommendations/
  49. https://www.eco-business.com/news/no-route-home-climate-change-threatens-kashmirs-nomadic-traditions/
  50. https://jneonatalsurg.com/index.php/jns/article/download/2516/2272/13132
  51. https://www.ijhssi.org/papers/v2%289%29/Version-2/I0292063067.pdf
  52. https://www.cabidigitallibrary.org/doi/pdf/10.5555/20183195507
  53. https://iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol19-issue1/Version-3/D019132436.pdf
  54. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3139413
  55. https://www.jkpi.org/educational-status-of-gujjars-and-bakarwals-in-jk/
  56. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12216878/
  57. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12231670/
  58. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7652166/
  59. https://www.ijfmr.com/papers/2023/6/10752.pdf
  60. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/325883655_Socio-Economic_and_Educational_Status_of_Tribal_Gujjar_and_Bakarwal_of_Jammu_and_Kashmir_An_Overview
  61. https://jklpp.org/state-bakarwal-tribe-times-covid-crisis/
  62. https://www.ijrti.org/papers/IJRTI2501089.pdf
  63. https://www.ijfmr.com/papers/2023/4/5313.pdf
  64. https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/gujjars-bakerwals-pahadis-in-jammu-kashmir-to-get-quota-benefits-122100400750_1.html
  65. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/j-k/gujjars-bakarwals-threaten-to-protest-over-grant-of-st-status-to-paharis-586803/
  66. https://ras.org.in/index.php?Article=gujjars_of_jammu_and_kashmir
  67. https://m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/reservation-quota-for-gujjars-bakerwals-paharis-in-j-k-says-home-minister-amit-shah/articleshow/94640020.cms
  68. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/08039410.2025.2546312?src=
  69. https://indianexpress.com/article/political-pulse/jk-gujjars-bakerwals-protest-st-status-pahadis-8268413/
  70. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/gujjar-bakerwal-protests-gaining-steam-in-jk-over-move-to-include-paharis-in-st-list/article67116587.ece
  71. https://frontline.thehindu.com/politics/gujjar-bakarwals-agitated-over-bill-granting-st-status-for-paharis/article67152879.ece
  72. https://m.thewire.in/article/rights/the-reservation-tug-of-war-in-jk-puts-political-parties-in-a-tight-spot
  73. https://www.earlytimes.in/newsdet.aspx?q=378075
  74. https://thekashmirwalla.com/in-jammu-and-kashmir-concerns-of-gujjar-bakarwal-community-for-their-land/
  75. https://kashmirlife.net/are-reservations-in-jammu-and-kashmir-a-political-instrument-rather-than-a-social-engineering-tool-396066/
  76. https://thewire.in/security/gujjar-bakharwal-jammu-kashmir-army-general-hooda
  77. https://asiatimes.com/2018/07/eyes-and-ears-of-the-indian-army-gujjars-want-their-own-regiment/
  78. https://www.outlookindia.com/national/caught-between-separatism-and-nationalism-gujjar-bakarwal-tribes-in-search-of-a-new-life-news-203538
  79. https://www.news18.com/news/opinion/opinion-by-lt-gen-retd-ds-hooda-how-bakarwals-helped-indian-army-in-operation-sarp-vinash-1725291.html
  80. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/jammu-and-kashmir/army-must-rebuild-ties-with-gujjar-bakerwal-tribes-to-prevent-intelligence-gap-on-ground-say-experts/article70076658.ece
  81. https://www.asianage.com/india/all-india/270418/kathua-put-the-spotlight-on-bakarwals-the-armys-eyes-and-ears-along-loc.html
  82. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/j-k/army-meets-gujjars-village-leaders-in-akhnoor-for-intelligence-inputs-500316/
  83. https://scroll.in/article/1061326/in-poonch-deaths-in-army-custody-leave-tribal-community-with-a-bitter-sense-of-betrayal
  84. https://frontline.thehindu.com/the-nation/custodial-deaths-of-gujjars-in-poonch-jammu-kashmir-puts-army-in-a-spot-bjp-2024-lok-sabha-assembly-elections/article67705323.ece
  85. https://thewire.in/rights/poonch-civilians-killed-are-among-the-men-seen-in-video-being-tortured-by-soldiers-sarpanch-confirms
  86. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/j-k/gujjar-bakarwal-tribal-men-allege-assault-by-army-officer-in-srinagars-daghwan-region/
  87. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/j-k/army-officer-accused-of-thrashing-nomadic-men-near-srinagar/
  88. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/314515501_The_sedentarization_process_of_the_transhumant_Bakarwal_tribals_of_the_Jammu_Kashmir_India
  89. https://www.landconflictwatch.org/conflicts/forest-department-evicts-bakarwal-families-in-jammu-allegedly-questions-need-for-land
  90. https://www.landconflictwatch.org/conflicts/gujjar-families-clash-with-forest-officials-during-eviction-drive-in-kashmir-s-shopian
  91. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-62886711
  92. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/11/20/tribal-community-face-eviction-from-forests-in-kashmir
  93. https://cjp.org.in/exclusive-implement-forest-rights-act-to-protect-bakarwals-of-kathua-talib-hussain/
  94. https://kmsnews.org/kms/2025/01/12/gujjar-bakarwal-communities-deplore-eviction-orders-in-kathua.html
  95. https://www.newsclick.in/gujjar-bakerwals-protest-amit-shah-jammu-kashmir-fearing-dilution-ST-status
  96. https://www.hindutvawatch.org/gujjar-bakarwal-agitation-why-kashmiri-tribals-are-up-in-arms-frontline-thehindu/
  97. https://www.academia.edu/127534643/Sedentarization_of_Gujjar_Bakarwals_in_Jammu_Region_A_Case_Study_of_Rajouri_Poonch
  98. https://sibe.rpress.co.in/index.php/jimr/article/download/496/23/49
  99. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/386567172_Urbanization_and_Transformation_in_Tribal_Communities_A_Study_of_the_Gujjar_and_Bakarwal_Tribes_of_Doda_District/download
  100. https://ijrti.org/viewpaperforall.php?paper=IJRTI2501089
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.