Hubbry Logo
Ray McGovernRay McGovernMain
Open search
Ray McGovern
Community hub
Ray McGovern
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ray McGovern
Ray McGovern
Ray McGovern
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Raymond McGovern (born August 25, 1939) is an American political activist and former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) officer.[1] McGovern was a CIA analyst from 1963 to 1990, and in the 1980s chaired National Intelligence Estimates and participated in preparing the President's Daily Brief. He received the Intelligence Commendation Medal at his retirement, returning it in 2006 to protest the CIA's involvement in torture.[2] McGovern's post-retirement work includes commenting for RT and Sputnik News, which are funded and controlled by the Russian government, and other outlets on intelligence and foreign policy issues. In 2003 he co-founded Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS).

Key Information

Personal life

[edit]

Ray McGovern was born and grew up in the Bronx, New York City. McGovern earned a BA from Fordham University, and received a scholarship to earn a MA with honours in Russian Language, Literature and History.[3] and in the early 1960s served as a U.S. Army infantry/intelligence officer and in the analysis division on Soviet foreign policy, especially with respect to China and Indochina.[4]

McGovern is married to Rita Kennedy; the couple have five children and eight grandchildren.[5]

Career

[edit]

McGovern was a CIA analyst for 27 years (April 1963 to August 1990), serving seven U.S. presidents.[6] His CIA career began under President John F. Kennedy, and lasted through the presidency of George H. W. Bush.[7] McGovern advised Henry Kissinger during the Richard Nixon administration, and during the Ronald Reagan administration he chaired National Intelligence Estimates and prepared the President's Daily Brief.[8][9]

At his retirement in 1990, McGovern received the CIA's Intelligence Commendation Medal.[2][8] He returned the medal "in protest in 2006 over CIA use of torture."[10]

Activism

[edit]

Intelligence activism

[edit]
McGovern, 2008

After retiring from the CIA, McGovern became a commentator on intelligence-related issues from the late 1990s onwards.[11] He was heavily critical of the government's handling of the Wen Ho Lee case in 2000.[12] In 2002, he was publicly critical of President George W. Bush's use of government intelligence in the lead-up to the war in Iraq.[13]

In 2003, together with other former CIA employees, McGovern founded the Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS), which is dedicated to analyzing and criticizing the use of intelligence, at first concerning the Iraq War.[14]

In 2006, McGovern confronted Donald Rumsfeld on a live CNN broadcast about his statements concerning weapons of mass destruction, an interaction later called the "vivisection of Donald Rumsfeld" by Keith Olbermann.[15]

In January 2006, McGovern began speaking out on behalf of the anti-war group Not in Our Name. According to the group's press release, McGovern served symbolic "war crimes indictments" on the Bush White House from a "people's tribunal."

In 2006, McGovern returned his Intelligence Commendation Medal in protest of the CIA's involvement with torture.[2] He wrote then that he "abhor[red] the corruption of the CIA in the past several years, believe it to be beyond repair, and do not want my name on any medallion associated with it.[16][unreliable source?]

On October 9, 2013, McGovern, along with three former winners, presented the Sam Adams Award for integrity in intelligence to Edward Snowden in a Moscow ceremony.[17]

In September 2015, McGovern and 27 other members of VIPS steering group wrote a letter to President Barack Obama lambasting Rebuttal: The CIA Responds to the Senate Intelligence Committee's Study of Its Detention and Interrogation, a then-recently published book that challenged the report of the United States Senate Intelligence Committee on the CIA's use of torture.[citation needed]

In December 2015, McGovern participated in Russian state media outlet RT's tenth anniversary celebration, alongside then-retired director of the Defense Intelligence Agency Michael Flynn and frequent Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein, hosted by Russian president Vladimir Putin.[18][19]

Arrests

[edit]

During a 2011 speech at George Washington University by then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, McGovern stood with his back turned during her remarks, blocking the view of some of the audience and media for about five minutes in "silent protest" of Clinton's foreign policy.[20][21] McGovern refused to cooperate when asked to leave by security, which led to his arrest for disorderly conduct.[20] McGovern said that the State Department placed him on a "be on the lookout" list, and that such a list authorized law enforcement to stop and question him on sight.[21] The charges were subsequently dropped. In 2014, McGovern's lawyer filed a lawsuit against the campus police department for allegedly using excessive force and also against the university and State Department for allegedly violating his right to peacefully protest.[21] McGovern said the police officers had "brutalized" him and "rammed" him into a door.[22] The suit against the arresting officer was dismissed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, which opined that police had probable cause to arrest McGovern, and that after viewing film made by news organizations of the event, that police did not use excessive force.[23]

In 2014, McGovern was arrested by the New York City police department at a private event where former CIA director and retired Army General David Petraeus was giving a speech. McGovern said he wanted to ask Petraeus about his involvement in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, but the event's host told him he was not welcome.[24] He said he had a ticket to the event, but when he refused to leave, was charged with criminal trespassing and resisting arrest.[25] On February 4, 2015, McGovern accepted adjournment in contemplation of dismissal, meaning the charges would be dropped if McGovern did not commit any new offenses.[26]

On May 9, 2018, McGovern was one of several protesters who disrupted the Senate confirmation hearing of Gina Haspel to become CIA director. After he began yelling about waterboarding, McGovern was forcibly removed by Capitol Police and charged with disruption and resisting arrest.[27][28]

Views

[edit]

Vietnam War

[edit]

In a 2003 interview with the UK's Independent newspaper, McGovern said that Lyndon B. Johnson seized on the Gulf of Tonkin incident as a "spur-of-the-moment thing" rather than as part of a calculated drive to war.[9]

Pope John Paul II

[edit]

A Catholic from birth,[29] McGovern was highly critical of Pope John Paul II's conservative stance on women's rights in church. He saw the former Pope as a repressive force. McGovern had been teaching Sunday school and earned a certificate in theology from Georgetown University. He has participated in Cursillo, and was district president of Bread for the City. By standing during mass for several weeks he protested against the teaching on sex roles and sexual ethics which to him seemed oppressive.[30]

Iraq War

[edit]

McGovern sharply criticised the 2003 invasion of Iraq and its justification by the Bush administration, which he described as a "very calculated, 18-month, orchestrated, incredibly cynical campaign of lies that we've seen to justify a war".[9]

McGovern testified at a Democratic National Headquarters forum in 2005 that had been convened by Rep. John Conyers (D-Mich.) of the House Judiciary Committee on the Downing Street memo. The Washington Post reported in 2005 that, in his testimony, McGovern "declared that the United States went to war in Iraq for oil, Israel and military bases craved by administration neocons so 'the United States and Israel could dominate that part of the world.'" He said that Israel should not be considered an ally and that Bush was doing the bidding of Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. 'Israel is not allowed to be brought up in polite conversation,' McGovern said. Genuine criticism of official Israeli policy is often portrayed as if it were anti-semitism: 'The last time I did this, the previous director of Central Intelligence called me anti-semitic.'"[31] He repeated the comments the following year in a television interview with Tucker Carlson on MSNBC. McGovern said: "I've been using the acronym O.I.L. for many—for two years now: O for oil; I for Israel; and L for logistics, logistics being the permanent—now we say "enduring"—military bases that the U.S. wants to keep in Iraq."[32]

Julian Assange, WikiLeaks and Edward Snowden

[edit]

When asked in 2010 on TVNZ whether Julian Assange was a hero or villain, he replied "hero".[33][non-primary source needed] When asked the same year whether Julian Assange was a journalist, he replied to the CNN reporter: "Yeah, actually, with all due respect, I think you should be following his example."[34][non-primary source needed] In 2010, he co-wrote an open letter of support for WikiLeaks and Assange, with Coleen Rowley, Lawrence Wilkerson, Craig Murray and others.[35][non-primary source needed]

Syria

[edit]

During the Syrian civil war, McGovern told Russian television channel RT and other outlets that the sarin used in the 2013 Ghouta chemical attack had not been manufactured by the Syrian government.[36][37]

Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election

[edit]

McGovern holds a position that the theft of the DNC emails was an inside job, and not the work of Russian agents.[38][39] In McGovern's view, the metadata in the files released by Guccifer 2.0 (whom the US intelligence community identifies as a Russian military intelligence operation) originated from a computer in the Eastern United States but was manipulated to give the appearance that the documents came from Russia. With William Binney, McGovern released a VIPS report in support of his theory, which was taken up by The Nation and other outlets[40] and promoted by Russian state media.[41] Many of the VIPS members, however, did not sign the report.[42] Binney later changed his mind and admitted that the underlying files were manipulated and a fabrication to support a pro-Kremlin disinformation campaign.[43] McGovern continues to take the position that the DNC wasn't hacked by Russian intelligence, but had actually hacked itself.[44]

Russia and Ukraine

[edit]

In 2016, McGovern said he was not convinced about Russian involvement in the shooting down of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 in 2014 over eastern Ukraine. He said the US had conducted a propaganda campaign "to paint Putin in the blackest of colours" and justify the imposition of sanctions.[45]

Publications

[edit]

Book chapters

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ray McGovern

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Ray McGovern (born August 25, 1939) is a former analyst who served for 27 years from 1963 to 1990, specializing in Soviet intelligence and preparing assessments for seven U.S. presidents.
In his CIA role, McGovern chaired National Intelligence Estimates on key issues and personally briefed on the .
Upon retirement, he was awarded the Intelligence , which he later returned in to protest the CIA's endorsement of coercive interrogation techniques.
McGovern co-founded in 2003 to scrutinize and publicize perceived manipulations of intelligence, particularly those underpinning the 2003 invasion, and has since issued group memos challenging official narratives on conflicts including and allegations of Russian interference.

Early Life and Education

Upbringing and Influences

Raymond McGovern was born on August 25, 1939, in the borough of . He spent his formative years in the , a densely populated urban environment that shaped his early worldview amid the social and economic dynamics of mid-20th-century New York. Raised in a Catholic family, McGovern's upbringing emphasized moral and ethical principles, including considerations of authority and justice, which later informed his perspectives on governance and conflict. This religious foundation, rooted in Catholic teachings, provided an initial framework for evaluating issues of power and responsibility, though specific childhood experiences tied to war ethics are not extensively documented in available accounts. Prior to entering professional service, his personal interest in military matters—possibly influenced by the post-World War II era and family or community narratives—led him to enlist in the U.S. Army, where he served two years as an infantry and intelligence officer, cultivating a foundational aptitude for analytical work in .

Academic and Early Professional Background

McGovern received a degree from in 1961, followed by a in Russian studies, graduating summa cum laude with honors in , literature, and history. His academic focus on Soviet affairs equipped him with proficiency in Russian and analytical skills centered on geopolitical and historical analysis of the region. Following graduation, McGovern served two years of active duty in the U.S. Army during the early as an infantry intelligence officer, specializing in the analysis division with emphasis on Soviet . This military role honed his expertise in and provided foundational experience in evaluating threats from communist states, bridging his scholarly background to professional intelligence work.

CIA Career

Entry and Analyst Roles


Ray McGovern entered the (CIA) in early 1963 as a junior analyst on the agency's analysis directorate, shortly after earning a in Russian studies from and completing two years of active duty as an infantry intelligence officer. His entry-level responsibilities centered on evaluating intelligence related to Soviet foreign policy, with a particular emphasis on Moscow's diplomatic and strategic interactions with amid the escalating . This period marked the height of rivalries, where analysts like McGovern processed , human reports, and open-source data to discern Soviet intentions toward key global adversaries. In his core analyst roles, McGovern conducted assessments of Soviet capabilities and threats, prioritizing the integration of disparate intelligence streams into coherent estimates that informed U.S. policy decisions. He advanced through the ranks to senior analyst positions, eventually leading the CIA's Soviet Foreign Policy Branch, where he oversaw teams producing detailed evaluations of Moscow's global maneuvers, including negotiations and proxy conflicts. These duties required methodical cross-verification of sources to mitigate biases inherent in covert reporting, contributing to products such as National Intelligence Estimates that shaped executive branch strategies from the Kennedy administration through the . McGovern's work spanned 27 years of service under seven presidents, from to , during which he maintained a focus on empirical to counterbalance institutional tendencies toward policy-driven interpretations. By the , his progression included chairing National Intelligence Estimates on Soviet affairs and contributing to the , underscoring his role in delivering unvarnished assessments of threats like Soviet expansionism and technological advancements. This trajectory highlighted his commitment to objective intelligence production amid the analytical demands of confrontation.

Key Responsibilities and Contributions

During his tenure as a senior CIA analyst from 1963 to 1990, Ray McGovern held key responsibilities in producing high-level intelligence assessments on Soviet capabilities, chairing National Intelligence Estimates (NIEs) in the that evaluated the USSR's , economic, and strategic posture. These NIEs, coordinated across the intelligence community, informed U.S. policymaking by synthesizing data on Soviet conventional forces, nuclear arsenals, and internal weaknesses, often highlighting stagnation amid Gorbachev's reforms rather than exaggerated threats. McGovern also prepared and delivered the (PDB) one-on-one to from 1981 to 1985, providing concise, evidence-based summaries of global intelligence priorities tailored to immediate executive needs. He extended similar briefings to , who ascended to the presidency in 1989, ensuring continuity in daily analytic support until McGovern's retirement in 1990. These sessions emphasized empirical analysis over policy advocacy, drawing on declassified indicators like and defector reports to assess Soviet decline accurately, in contrast to subsequent intelligence products criticized for politicization.

Founding and Role in VIPS

Establishment of VIPS

Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS) was co-founded in January 2003 by Ray McGovern, a retired CIA analyst with 27 years of service, along with four other former intelligence officers, amid concerns over the politicization of intelligence assessments leading to the . The group formed specifically to counter what its members viewed as the manipulation of evidence on Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) by administration officials, drawing on the founders' professional experience in objective analysis. McGovern, who had briefed presidents from Nixon to Bush, emerged as a principal organizer and spokesperson, leveraging his background to articulate VIPS's critiques. VIPS's stated objectives centered on restoring "sanity" to work by promoting rigorous, evidence-driven assessments free from policy-driven distortion, exposing instances of analytic , and encouraging internal dissent against unsubstantiated claims used to justify military action. Members aimed to provide policymakers with alternative views based on standards, such as distinguishing between and fabricated , in contrast to what they saw as the subordination of analysis to neoconservative agendas in the lead-up to . McGovern emphasized that the group's formation was a direct response to the absence of such pushback within active agencies. The organization's inaugural action was a memorandum sent to President in early 2003, cautioning that intelligence on Iraqi WMDs was unreliable and warning of the risks of predicated on flawed premises, including the potential for regional destabilization. This document set the tone for VIPS's approach, prioritizing factual scrutiny over consensus narratives and positioning the group as a non-partisan watchdog outside government structures.

Major VIPS Outputs and Impact

(VIPS) issued its first major memorandum on February 5, 2003, addressed to President , warning that U.S. intelligence on Iraq's weapons of mass destruction was unreliable, reliant on unvetted sources like defectors, and subject to politicization that sidelined dissenting analysts. The document highlighted suppressed intelligence community reservations, including cables from State Department analysts cautioning against exaggerated threats, and urged renewed focus on inspections over military action. This output played a role in early amplification of internal dissent, contributing to post-invasion scrutiny when no stockpiles were found, as subsequent inquiries confirmed intelligence failures and pressure on analysts to align with policy goals. In April 2009, VIPS released a memorandum to President decrying the CIA's post-9/11 " as , arguing they yielded unreliable information, violated U.S. law, and risked future prosecutions or retaliation against captured Americans. The group emphasized from declassified reports showing coerced confessions drove false narratives, such as inflated al-Qaeda-Iraq links. Later, in March 2018, VIPS opposed Gina Haspel's nomination as CIA director, citing her oversight of black sites where and other methods were applied, framing it as institutional complicity in war crimes. On Russiagate, VIPS published a February 2017 memorandum asserting that allegations of Russian hacking of servers lacked forensic substantiation, pointing to metadata indicating high-speed local transfers consistent with an internal leak rather than remote intrusion. A follow-up in 2019 critiqued Robert Mueller's report for omitting independent server analysis, reiterating that download speeds exceeding typical capabilities undermined the hacking narrative. These analyses, drawing on technical expertise from former NSA officials, spurred debates on evidence standards in attribution, influencing congressional inquiries and coverage, though dismissed by agencies and mainstream outlets as speculative and aligned with denied foreign influence operations. VIPS outputs elicited mixed reception: the Iraq memorandum was later hailed in retrospective analyses for anticipating the absence of WMD and analyst suppression, bolstering arguments against intelligence manipulation in public discourse. Torture critiques aligned with Senate Intelligence Committee findings on program ineffectiveness, aiding accountability pushes. However, Russiagate memos faced sharp rebukes from official assessments affirming Russian culpability via multiple indicators beyond metadata, with critics attributing VIPS positions to selective reasoning over empirical consensus from cybersecurity firms and U.S. agencies. Overall, the memoranda fostered ongoing toward unchecked narratives, highlighting tensions between institutional intelligence and independent veteran scrutiny.

Post-Retirement Analytic Work

Critiques of Intelligence Manipulation

McGovern has argued that post-9/11 U.S. assessments systematically distorted threats by cherry-picking supportive data while sidelining dissenting or inconclusive evidence, driven by a need to align with expansive policies rather than rigorous verification. In his analyses, he points to the rapid budget expansion from roughly $30 billion annually before , 2001, to $75 billion by 2010, which incentivized agencies and contractors to emphasize alarming interpretations of vague indicators, such as broad definitions of risks, to sustain funding and influence. This environment, McGovern contends, fostered a self-perpetuating cycle where threat exaggeration ensured ongoing relevance and resources, often at the expense of connecting verifiable dots from available . A key example McGovern cites is the 2009 Christmas Day underwear bomber incident involving , where U.S. intelligence possessed specific warnings—including his father's report to the embassy and intercepted messages—yet failed to act amid a flood of irrelevant data generated by the enlarged apparatus. He attributes this not to mere oversight but to systemic overload from politicized priorities that diluted focus on empirical signals, allowing the perpetrator to board a flight despite flagged travel risks. McGovern describes such dynamics as a "self-licking ice cream cone," where contractors and analysts, motivated by profit and job security, tailor outputs to reinforce perpetual vigilance against nebulous dangers. McGovern further critiques institutional mechanisms like "," the practice of routing raw, unvetted directly to senior officials to bypass standard scrutiny, which he says post-9/11 became normalized to expedite policy-supportive narratives over comprehensive analysis. He warns that these incentives, embedded in what he calls the Military-Industrial-Congressional-Intelligence-Media-Academia-Think-Tank (MICIMATT) complex, prioritize institutional preservation and advancement over truth-seeking, echoing but expanding Eisenhower's military-industrial complex caution to include entities complicit in for mutual benefit.

Analyses of Geopolitical Conflicts

McGovern advocates reviving , the methodical interpretation of signals through leaders' statements and actions, to counter the ideological distortions prevalent in contemporary Western analysis of Russian decision-making. He contends that this empirical technique, honed during the , reveals Putin's confidence in pursuing U.S. , as evidenced by Russia's measured responses to potential diplomatic overtures like a Trump-Putin summit in August 2025. In contrast, McGovern criticizes mainstream outlets for prioritizing narrative conformity over such scrutiny, citing examples like biased coverage in the that undermines objective evaluation of de-escalation prospects. Central to McGovern's framework is his critique of the MICIMATT complex—the interlocking Military-Industrial-Congressional-Intelligence-Media-Academia-Think-Tank apparatus—that he argues perpetuates adversarial policies to preserve institutional power and funding, sidelining evidence-based assessments of adversaries' incentives. This structure, McGovern asserts, fosters demonization of to justify sustained confrontation, as seen in the post-Cold War deterioration of U.S.- ties despite initial cooperative potentials in areas like . By prioritizing systemic self-perpetuation over causal drivers of foreign behavior, MICIMATT entrenches biases that obscure opportunities for pragmatic engagement. In evaluating multipolar dynamics, McGovern highlights Russia's demonstrated resilience to sanctions, projecting sustained economic adaptation through deepened ties with and non-Western partners, which erode U.S. leverage assumptions. He forecasts that this shift toward a Russia-China axis will compel Western recalibration, as isolation efforts falter against empirical realities of diversified global alliances, exemplified by Russia's military advances in despite prolonged pressure campaigns. McGovern's analyses thus stress grounding conflict evaluations in verifiable indicators of intent and capability, rather than preconceived .

Activism and Public Confrontations

Protest Actions and Arrests

In February 2011, McGovern was arrested following a silent during a speech by then-Secretary of State at , where he stood with his hands behind his back and duct tape over his mouth to symbolize suppressed dissent against U.S. . Security personnel forcibly removed him, resulting in bruises and bleeding from the head, after which he was charged with but the charges were later dropped. On October 30, 2014, McGovern was arrested outside an event at the in featuring retired General , despite holding a ticket, as he intended to question Petraeus on intelligence-related matters during the advertised Q&A session. Police detained him overnight, applying force that caused pain and injury, leading to misdemeanor charges of criminal and ; a subsequent challenged the actions as unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. During the May 9, 2018, Senate Intelligence Committee confirmation hearing for as CIA director, McGovern, then aged 78, disrupted proceedings by standing to protest her role in , shouting questions about before being physically dragged out by Capitol Police, sustaining injuries including to his arm. He was arrested on the spot but released without charges, framing the action as a stand against ethical lapses in intelligence practices.

Engagements with Government and Media

McGovern confronted Defense Secretary during a question-and-answer session following a speech on May 4, 2006, at the Richard B. Russell Federal Building in , directly challenging him on assertions about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction and purported operational ties to , which McGovern described as false pretexts for war. Rumsfeld rejected the accusation of lying, attributing discrepancies to evolving intelligence and post-invasion findings, while security personnel stood by without immediate intervention. This exchange highlighted McGovern's effort to publicly press officials on intelligence claims amid ongoing debates. On February 15, 2011, McGovern engaged indirectly through a silent at her speech on internet freedom at , standing with a sign echoing her remark on defying leaders like Muammar Qaddafi with "So would I." University police arrested him, and video footage showed agents striking him multiple times, resulting in charges later dropped but drawing criticism of excessive force against non-violent dissent. During the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence confirmation hearing for as CIA Director on May 9, 2018, McGovern disrupted proceedings by rising with a sign protesting her involvement in post-9/11 interrogation programs, leading to his physical removal by Capitol Police. The incident underscored restrictions on direct challenges within congressional settings, with McGovern later characterizing it as an attempt to highlight unaddressed intelligence accountability issues. McGovern has sought to influence media narratives by appearing on outlets like Democracy Now! and C-SPAN to question mainstream intelligence reporting, such as coverage of pre-Iraq War assessments. However, he has faced exclusion from major networks, describing himself as blacklisted after public critiques of administration claims, with VIPS analyses forwarded to national media in the early 2000s receiving no airtime despite relevance to policy debates. This marginalization extended to outlets like The New York Times, which avoided citing dissenting former analysts like McGovern on topics including Russian election interference.

Positions on Specific Issues

Vietnam War Dissent

As a junior CIA analyst in 1963, Ray McGovern contributed to intelligence assessments on Soviet and Chinese policies toward , positioning him to observe the agency's internal handling of Vietnam-related data during the war's escalation. CIA estimates often highlighted discrepancies between field reports and the Johnson administration's portrayal of threats, including doubts about the immediacy of communist domino effects beyond itself, where internal analyses indicated that regional allies like and showed resilience against subversion absent direct U.S. collapse in Saigon. McGovern's exposure to these analyses fostered early skepticism toward escalatory policies predicated on exaggerated perils, though overt remained constrained within the agency. The incidents of August 2 and 4, 1964, exemplified this tension, as McGovern later described how analysts, including a colleague who reviewed , determined that no North Vietnamese attack occurred on the second date—evidence deemed "highly dubious" yet deliberately suppressed by senior officials to preserve access to the and support President Lyndon B. Johnson's pre-existing plans for retaliatory strikes. This manipulation enabled the on August 7, 1964, granting broad war powers and paving the way for massive U.S. troop deployments that peaked at 535,000 by 1968. McGovern has characterized the episode as a foundational case of politicized intelligence, where empirical data yielded to policy imperatives, eroding analyst integrity. In post-retirement reflections, McGovern has framed these Vietnam-era deceptions as harbingers of systemic flaws, drawing parallels to later conflicts while acknowledging that U.S. involvement did achieve partial of —evident in Indonesia's 1965 pivot away from pro-Beijing elements and sustained non-communist governments in and the —against the backdrop of flawed premises that inflated costs, including 58,220 American fatalities and Vietnam's eventual unification under in 1975. He critiques the overreliance on rhetoric, which internal CIA views tempered by noting localized rather than inevitable regional cascades, as contributing to a self-inflicted quagmire driven more by signaling than verifiable threats.

Iraq War Intelligence Failures

Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS), co-founded by McGovern in January 2003, issued a memorandum to President George W. Bush on February 5, 2003, cautioning that intelligence on Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction (WMD) was being manipulated to support the decision to invade, with senior administration officials "fixing" facts around policy rather than allowing empirical analysis to guide assessments. McGovern, drawing on his experience as a CIA analyst, emphasized in contemporaneous interviews that dissenting expert views within the intelligence community—such as those from the Department of Energy and the State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research—were systematically sidelined, prioritizing politicized interpretations over technical evidence. This critique centered on key WMD claims, including Iraq's supposed pursuit of nuclear capabilities. A primary focus of VIPS' analysis was the administration's assertion that high-strength aluminum tubes procured by were intended for uranium enrichment centrifuges, a claim central to Colin Powell's February 5, , presentation. McGovern highlighted that metallurgical and engineering experts had determined the tubes' dimensions and specifications aligned with conventional high-pressure launchers, not nuclear centrifuges, a view corroborated by the (IAEA) inspections which found no evidence of reconstitution. Similarly, VIPS exposed flaws in the claim that sought from , based on forged documents whose inconsistencies—such as anachronistic references to a post-dissolution Nigerian government—were known to intelligence analysts prior to President Bush's January 28, , address, yet the assertion persisted as "Britain has said." These pre-invasion warnings from VIPS and internal dissenters were disregarded, contributing to the invasion on March 20, . Post-invasion investigations validated core elements of VIPS' critiques. The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence's July 9, 2004, report concluded that prewar assessments overstated Iraq's WMD stockpiles and active programs, with intelligence influenced by and pressure to align with goals, while no operational chemical, biological, or nuclear weapons were found. Declassified documents, including a 2002 CIA , later revealed limited specific evidence for many claims, with analysts acknowledging uncertainties that were downplayed. The 2004 Duelfer Report further confirmed the absence of WMD stockpiles, attributing the intelligence failures to overreliance on unreliable sources and a predisposition to view ambiguous dual-use activities as reconstitution efforts. McGovern attributed this to a causal dynamic where predetermined drove intelligence interpretation, supplanting rigorous empiricism. While VIPS emphasized systemic politicization, some intelligence elements held partial validity regarding Saddam Hussein's ambitions; historical records showed Iraq's prior WMD use against Iran and Kurds in the 1980s, and post-1991 efforts to retain expertise and materials under sanctions suggested intent to rebuild capabilities if opportunities arose, though lacking active production in 2003. The Senate report noted accurate assessments of Iraq's chemical weapons infrastructure preservation but criticized exaggeration of immediate threats. McGovern countered that such ambitions did not justify the hyped claims of imminent danger used to rationalize the war.

Russian Interference in 2016 Election

McGovern, as a co-founder of (VIPS), co-authored memos challenging the official narrative that Russian actors remotely hacked (DNC) servers in 2016. A July 24, 2017, VIPS memorandum to President Trump analyzed metadata from files posted by the persona "," which U.S. intelligence attributed to Russian military intelligence. The analysis revealed transfer speeds of approximately 23 megabytes per second—far exceeding typical internet capabilities of the era (e.g., under 10 MB/s even on high-speed lines)—indicating a copy by an insider rather than a remote hack. VIPS argued this forensic evidence pointed to a , urging independent verification over reliance on CrowdStrike's private assessment, which lacked full forensic transparency. Subsequent VIPS analyses, including those post-Mueller, reinforced that Robert Mueller's team ignored such forensics, failing to examine DNC servers directly and instead accepting CrowdStrike's conclusions without challenge. McGovern emphasized in 2020 that House Intelligence Committee documents further undermined the hack claim, showing no for alleged Russian intrusions and inconsistencies in timing that suggested internal manipulation of files before transfer to a thumb drive. This aligned with empirical tests by former NSA technical director William Binney, demonstrating that the observed speeds and artifacts (e.g., FAT formatting typical of USB transfers) were incompatible with transatlantic hacking. McGovern critiqued the —privately funded compiled by ex-MI6 officer —as a cornerstone of unverified Russiagate allegations, noting its reliance on from biased sources. The FBI incorporated dossier claims into FISA applications against Trump associate despite internal awareness of its raw, uncorroborated nature, as detailed in the 2019 DOJ report, which found the material "only minimally corroborated" and highlighted 17 significant errors or omissions in surveillance warrants. The 2023 similarly concluded that the FBI lacked sufficient predication to treat Steele's sub-sources as reliable, treating speculative reports as fact without basic validation. The , released in March 2019, ultimately found insufficient evidence to establish that the Trump campaign conspired or coordinated with on interference, after examining over 500 witnesses and millions of documents. McGovern viewed this as vindication of VIPS skepticism, arguing that outlets amplified dossier-driven and intelligence assessments (e.g., the January 2017 ICA) without awaiting forensic proof, fostering a politicized detached from causal evidence of direct . He attributed such amplification to institutional biases in intelligence and media, prioritizing over data-driven .

Syria and Middle East Policies

McGovern has consistently questioned U.S. intelligence assessments attributing chemical weapon attacks in Syria to the regime of Bashar al-Assad, emphasizing the need for verifiable forensic evidence over circumstantial claims. Regarding the August 21, 2013, Ghouta attack near Damascus, which reportedly killed over 1,400 civilians via sarin gas, McGovern co-authored a memorandum signed by 12 former U.S. intelligence officials asserting that the evidence pointed away from Assad's forces, citing intercepted communications suggesting rebel involvement and inconsistencies in rocket trajectories. He argued in a contemporaneous analysis that no public proof linked Assad directly to the incident, warning that rushing to judgment risked repeating intelligence politicization seen in prior conflicts. In later incidents, such as the April 7, 2018, Douma attack involving cylinders, McGovern endorsed critiques of the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) investigation, signing a 2021 statement from (VIPS) that highlighted leaked internal documents revealing suppressed dissenting analyses and potential evidence tampering by OPCW inspectors, including alternative explanations for cylinder impacts consistent with staged scenarios rather than aerial drops. These doubts drew on forensic discrepancies, such as signatures in 2013 samples matching Turkish precursors rather than declared Syrian stockpiles, which McGovern cited in interviews as indicative of opposition fabrication to provoke intervention. McGovern framed U.S. Syria policy as a driven by regime-change imperatives, with American support for anti-Assad rebels—totaling over $1 billion in aid by 2017—escalating and enabling groups like to exploit power vacuums, while ignoring Assad's 2013 agreement to dismantle chemical stockpiles under Russian mediation. He critiqued this approach as causally linked to prolonged instability, arguing that arming proxies prolonged the conflict beyond its 2011 origins in Arab Spring protests, fostering Iranian and Russian countermeasures that entrenched divisions. Opposing assessments, including OPCW reports on Douma and Khan Shaykhun (April 2017), concluded with "high confidence" that Syrian air forces deployed and , corroborated by U.S., French, and British intelligence sampling and witness accounts from regime-held areas. McGovern dismissed such findings as institutionally biased toward interventionist narratives, pointing to whistleblower testimonies from OPCW staff alleging pressure to align with Western attributions despite engineering analyses favoring non-aerial origins. Broader analyses by McGovern positioned within a pattern of U.S. efforts to counter Iranian influence, with airstrikes and sanctions since 2014 aiming to weaken Assad's alliances but inadvertently strengthening non-state actors and regional adversaries, as evidenced by the 2015-2016 Russian intervention that reclaimed territory from at minimal cost. He advocated de-escalation via over escalation, cautioning that proxy dynamics risked direct confrontation with nuclear-armed , whose bases in secured Mediterranean access.

Ukraine-Russia Dynamics

McGovern has attributed the escalation of tensions leading to Russia's 2022 invasion to NATO's eastward expansion, which he describes as violating post-Cold War assurances given to Soviet leaders like that the alliance would not enlarge beyond a unified . He points to the 2014 Maidan events as a U.S.-backed operation, citing leaked conversations involving Assistant Secretary of State discussing the composition of a post-Yanukovych , which installed a leadership hostile to Russian interests and accelerated Ukraine's alignment. Regarding the of 2014 and 2015, intended to grant autonomy to regions and cease hostilities, McGovern argues that Ukraine under Petro Poroshenko and later Volodymyr Zelensky failed to implement key provisions, such as political decentralization and elections, while using the pacts to buy time for military buildup with Western support; this non-compliance, monitored by OSCE reports showing over 14,000 deaths in from 2014-2022, provided Russia a for intervention to protect Russian-speaking populations. Prior to the February 24, 2022, invasion, McGovern predicted Russian military superiority would lead to swift operational successes, drawing on Russia's demonstrated capabilities in and 's internal weaknesses, including entrenched corruption that siphoned Western — ranked 122nd out of 180 on Transparency International's 2021 —and the integration of far-right elements like the Azov Battalion into national forces, which Russia cited as a "denazification" rationale amid documented neo-Nazi symbolism and ideology within units comprising up to 10% of frontline troops by 2019. He has highlighted Russian security concerns over U.S.-funded biological research laboratories in , numbering over 30 facilities under the Pentagon's Biological Threat Reduction Program, which alleged posed bioweapon risks, a claim echoed in UN briefings though dismissed by Washington as . While critiquing the conflict as a U.S. to weaken —evidenced by $113 billion in by mid-2023 propping up Kyiv's defenses—McGovern acknowledges Ukrainian agency in Zelensky's rejection of early peace talks in (March-April 2022), where neutrality and territorial concessions were on offer, opting instead for prolonged attrition despite high casualties exceeding 500,000 combined by 2025 estimates from Western intelligence. In 2025 commentary, McGovern assessed that delays in Western aid packages, including stalled U.S. congressional approvals amid domestic political divisions, have critically undermined 's position, enabling Russian advances that captured over 4,000 square kilometers in alone and rendering Kyiv's counteroffensive aspirations unviable; he described as "lost" with Russian forces achieving "aggressive attrition" dominance, projecting further territorial gains absent escalation. This outcome, he contends, stems from causal overreach in ignoring Russia's red lines on proximity and ethnic kin protection, rather than inherent Ukrainian resilience alone, though he notes Kyiv's of 1 million troops reflects genuine national will against perceived existential threats. McGovern urges over indefinite proxy escalation, arguing empirical data—Russian shell production at 3 million annually versus 's 1.5 million—confirms Moscow's strategic edge.

Support for Assange, Snowden, and WikiLeaks

McGovern has advocated for WikiLeaks' publication of the Iraq War Logs in 2010, leaked by Bradley Manning, which documented over 100,000 civilian deaths and instances of torture by Iraqi forces known to U.S. coalition partners, arguing these disclosures fulfilled an ethical duty to expose war crimes rather than conceal them under state secrecy. He joined rallies in support of Manning that year, asserting the soldier's actions upheld the constitutional oath to defend against domestic threats, including government overreach in wartime conduct. McGovern backed campaigns to free Manning, framing the leaks as a necessary counter to intelligence community complicity in unaccountable operations. In defending Julian Assange, McGovern argued in April 2022 that U.S. extradition efforts represent retaliation for ' role in revealing evidence of war crimes, corruption, and abuses, such as the August 2010 Afghanistan War Diary, rather than genuine concerns over handling. He highlighted the suspicious timing of Swedish rape allegations immediately following the leaks and U.S. hypocrisy in shielding its own operations in secrecy while prosecuting publishers for transparency that implicates official misconduct. McGovern portrayed Assange's persecution as emblematic of eroding press freedoms, endangering First Amendment protections for journalistic exposure of government excesses. McGovern's support extended to WikiLeaks founder Assange personally; in December 2010, he co-signed international petitions backing Assange amid legal pressures over releases, praising the organization's strategic dissemination as a check on diplomatic opacity. He visited Assange at the Ecuadorian embassy in in 2013 alongside other advocates, underscoring his view of the publisher as a defender of accountability against institutional self-preservation. On , McGovern hailed the June 2013 NSA revelations as confirmation of prior community warnings about unchecked , exposing programs that created a "turnkey tyranny" infringing on without adequate oversight. He declared Snowden's decision "the right thing," rooted in a conscience-driven adherence to constitutional oaths and imperatives to prioritize public welfare over agency loyalty. In October 2013, McGovern and fellow whistleblowers from awarded Snowden the Sam Adams Prize in , recognizing the leaks' role in fostering democratic debate and restoring First Amendment-enabled information flows. McGovern contrasted Snowden's principled risk-taking with institutional incentives for silence, positioning the disclosures as a validation of within .

Criticisms and Controversies

Allegations of Bias and Disinformation

Vox Ukraine, a Ukrainian fact-checking organization, has accused Ray McGovern of disseminating that echoes narratives on the Russia-Ukraine war, particularly by justifying Russian military actions and portraying the Russian army as overwhelmingly superior to Ukraine's forces while downplaying Ukrainian capabilities. In a November 25, 2023 analysis, Vox Ukraine highlighted McGovern's June 2023 claim attributing the destruction of the Hydroelectric Power Plant—and the resulting flooding of approximately 600 square kilometers and evacuation of 2,412 people—to Ukrainian sabotage, a narrative aligned with Russian assertions. Critics have further alleged that McGovern's analyses exhibit pro-Russian bias through repeated calls for Western concessions to , including opposition to for . For example, memos from the (VIPS), which McGovern co-founded, urged German Chancellor in 2014 to dismiss evidence of Russian troop involvement in as lacking credibility; advised against U.S. or arms assistance in April 2021; and opposed weapons shipments to in September 2022, favoring diplomatic compromises with instead. In July 2022, McGovern publicly condemned U.S. arms manufacturers for escalating the conflict through profiteering, a stance Vox Ukraine framed as undermining Ukrainian defense efforts. Such positions have drawn accusations of underestimating Ukrainian resolve and military resilience, especially in early war predictions that anticipated a rapid Russian victory after the , 2022 invasion, forecasts that proved overly favorable to as Ukrainian forces repelled advances on and other fronts. Ukrainian watchdogs, including Vox Ukraine and the National Security and Defense Council's , have included McGovern in networks promoting Russia-beneficial narratives, citing his commentary on platforms like RT's "" as contributing to Western skepticism toward NATO's role in the conflict.

Associations with Russian State Media

Ray McGovern has contributed regular commentary to RT (formerly Russia Today) and Sputnik, outlets funded and directed by the Russian government through entities like TV-Novosti and Rossiya Segodnya, beginning in the early 2010s. His appearances include a 2013 RT segment on the Sam Adams Award presentation to Edward Snowden in Moscow, where he participated alongside other former U.S. intelligence figures, and more recent Sputnik contributions, such as a October 5, 2025, analysis dismissing U.S. Tomahawk missile discussions for Ukraine as political theater rather than substantive strategy. These platforms have featured McGovern's critiques of U.S. Russia policy, often framing them as counterpoints to Western consensus narratives. Critics, particularly from pro-Ukrainian outlets, have portrayed McGovern's engagements as amplifying Kremlin-aligned , citing instances like his 2023 claims on the incident as evidence of or narrative alignment with Russian interests. Such assessments often emanate from sources embedded in Western advocacy, which exhibit selective scrutiny toward dissenting analysts while overlooking parallel state influences in U.S. and European media ecosystems. In defense, McGovern's appearances are contextualized by proponents as filling a void in U.S. discourse, where mainstream outlets—frequently aligned with official narratives via and funding ties—marginalize empirical challenges to interventionist policies, akin to RT's role in hosting views critical of that Russian state media suppresses internally. This dynamic underscores RT and Sputnik's function as conduits for non-consensus analysis on topics like assessments and geopolitical escalations, though their state oversight raises questions of absent in independent Western alternatives.

Rebuttals and Empirical Validations of Views

McGovern's involvement with (VIPS), which he co-founded in 2003, produced a memorandum on July 10, 2003, warning President that on Iraq's weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) was being manipulated to support , asserting that claims of for nuclear enrichment and uranium purchases from were unreliable. This analysis aligned with subsequent findings in the U.S. Select Committee on 's Report on Prewar Assessments about Postwar (S. Rept. 108-301, July 2004), which concluded that key judgments on Iraq's WMD programs were overstated and not supported by underlying , with analysts pressured to align with policy preferences. Further validation came in the committee's Phase II report (2006), documenting how administration officials, including Vice President , presented selectively, such as exaggerating mobile biological labs and ties to al-Qaeda, despite contrary evidence from CIA sources. These reports empirically corroborated VIPS' causal critique that was "fixed around the policy" rather than derived from objective analysis, countering narratives of mere "intelligence failure." On allegations of Russian interference in the 2016 U.S. presidential election, McGovern argued from 2017 onward that the narrative of direct collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia lacked forensic evidence, particularly questioning the Steele dossier's credibility and the FBI's use of it to obtain FISA warrants on Carter Page. The 2023 Durham report, issued by Special Counsel John Durham after investigating the FBI's Crossfire Hurricane probe, validated these concerns by finding the FBI rushed into the investigation without sufficient predication, failed to corroborate key Steele dossier claims (later deemed opposition research funded by the Clinton campaign), and exhibited confirmation bias in handling exculpatory evidence like the dossier's primary sub-source's disavowals. Durham concluded no evidence supported a Trump-Russia conspiracy, attributing the probe's origins to politically motivated tips rather than empirical predicates, thus empirically supporting McGovern's first-mover skepticism against institutional rushes to judgment. Regarding Ukraine-Russia dynamics, McGovern predicted in analyses from that Russia's superior resource depth, industrial base, and avoidance of overextension would enable sustained attrition against Ukraine's NATO-backed forces, dismissing U.S. claims of imminent Russian collapse as akin to past misjudgments in and . By mid-2025, Russian forces had captured over 4,000 square kilometers in and oblasts since January, with monthly advances averaging 200-300 square kilometers, per Institute for the Study of War mappings, reflecting Russia's 3:1 manpower and artillery production advantages (e.g., 3 million shells annually vs. Ukraine's 1 million). McGovern's October 2025 assessment that "Russia has already won" as Ukrainian lines fracture under manpower shortages ( yielding under 500,000 effectives amid desertions exceeding 100,000) and delayed Western aid aligned with these outcomes, validating his emphasis on causal asymmetries in sustainment over initial tactical setbacks. This countered optimistic Western projections of Ukrainian counteroffensives, which stalled by late 2023 due to minefields and fortified defenses, per admissions.

Publications and Media Presence

Authored Works

McGovern contributed a chapter to the 2004 edited volume Patriotism, Democracy, and Common Sense: Restoring America's Promise at Home and Abroad, analyzing U.S. risks through the lens of assessments and historical precedents. In 2017, he provided a to Remember the Liberty!: Almost Sunk by Treason on the High Seas, a book examining the 1967 and its implications for accountability. As a co-founder of (VIPS) in January 2003, McGovern co-authored foundational memoranda critiquing intelligence manipulation, including the April 26, 2003, VIPS memo "The Stakes in the Search for Weapons of Mass Destruction," which urged rigorous verification of Iraq-related claims amid post-invasion scrutiny. Subsequent VIPS publications under his involvement, such as the May 8, 2025, memo " — Toward Lasting Peace," draw on declassified data and forensic analysis to advocate over escalation. McGovern has authored dozens of op-eds for Consortium News, emphasizing empirical review of intelligence products on conflicts like and ; for instance, his December 2, 2024, piece "Neocons Try Again in " dissects regime-change narratives using timeline discrepancies in official reports. Similarly, in ScheerPost contributions, such as analyses tied to VIPS findings, he prioritizes verifiable metrics like weapons inspection records over interpretive consensus. These writings consistently reference primary sources, including National Intelligence Estimates and leaked assessments, to highlight deviations from analytical standards.

Interviews, Lectures, and Recent Commentary

In 2025, McGovern participated in several interviews and lectures emphasizing the revival of as a tool for understanding n decision-making amid Western policy failures. On August 14, he discussed applying this "lost art" to analyze recent U.S.- exchanges, arguing that flexibility exists on Ukraine's margins despite Putin's June 2024 terms, based on observed diplomatic signals. In an August 15 discussion, he critiqued the replacement of objective with ideological media narratives, attributing this shift to diminished analytical rigor in U.S. intelligence circles. McGovern addressed the potential consequences of escalated conflict with in mid-2025 commentary. On June 24, in a Brave New Europe interview, he warned of enduring regional instability from U.S.-involved strikes, predicting strengthened Iran-Russia ties and accelerated multipolar shifts that undermine U.S. dominance. He echoed these concerns in a July 3 alongside Middle East scholar Assal Rad, highlighting how media consent-manufacturing sustains endless wars while ignoring 's defensive posture. Regarding and , McGovern's 2025 appearances critiqued perceived Western irrationality. In a July 26 lecture, he described 's abandonment of as self-marginalizing in a multipolar order, with emerging as Russia's primary adversary over the U.S. On , he asserted 's position as untenable, claiming Russian advances signal a de facto victory and urging U.S. recognition to avert broader escalation. Earlier, at Moscow's Znanie Youth Forum on April 29, he spoke on rebuilding U.S.-Russia trust, tying it to Victory in Europe commemorations and rejecting maximalist pressures. Through (VIPS), McGovern contributed to 2025 updates advocating de-escalation. A May 8 VIPS memorandum, co-signed by him, called for renewed to foster lasting peace, warning against unchecked escalation in and beyond. These efforts aligned with his predictions of a multipolar world, as reiterated in June and October interviews forecasting U.S. policy pivots under Trump to negotiate with .

References

  1. https://www.theguardian.com/profile/ray-mcgovern
  2. https://eisenhowermedianetwork.org/staff/ray-mcgovern/
  3. https://www.ttbook.org/people/ray-mcgovern
  4. https://americanswhotellthetruth.org/portraits/ray-mcgovern/
  5. https://therealnews.com/author/raymond-mcgovern
  6. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1632020/bio/
  7. https://keywiki.org/Ray_McGovern
  8. https://www.iraqtribunal.org/ray_mcgovern
  9. https://news.fordham.edu/inside-fordham/alumnus-says-activism-requires-courage/
  10. https://forthright.media/2022/04/07/ray-mcgovern-veteran-intelligence-professionals-for-sanity-russia-ukraine/
  11. https://now.fordham.edu/education-and-social-services/alumnus-cia-officer-to-address-peace-and-justice-graduates/
  12. https://braveneweurope.com/ray-mcgovern-russia-china-two-against-one
  13. https://www.alternativeradio.org/speaker/ray-mcgovern/
  14. https://www.gp.org/speaks_out_for_jill
  15. https://www.fosters.com/story/news/2007/12/21/former-cia-analyst-says-evidence/52702951007/
  16. https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Veteran_Intelligence_Professionals_for_Sanity
  17. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2004/03/skeptical-spy/
  18. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/vips-memorandum-re-tortur_b_193973
  19. https://consortiumnews.com/2016/02/26/vips-offers-advice-to-candidates/
  20. https://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/02/27/unique-resource-available-all-2016-candidates-vips
  21. https://www.theamericanconservative.com/exposing-shabby-intelligence/
  22. https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB163/index.htm
  23. https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB254/index.htm
  24. https://consortiumnews.com/category/vips/
  25. https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU00/20170228/105636/HMKP-115-JU00-20170228-SD006.pdf
  26. https://consortiumnews.com/2019/03/13/vips-muellers-forensics-free-findings/
  27. https://theintercept.com/2017/11/07/dnc-hack-trump-cia-director-william-binney-nsa/
  28. https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2017/01/attributing_the_1.html
  29. https://original.antiwar.com/mcgovern/2010/07/23/terrors-self-licking-ice-cream-cone/
  30. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381306491_Ray_McGovern%27s_MICIMATT_The_Military-Industrial-Congressional-Intelligence-_Media-Academia-Think-Tank
  31. https://consortiumnews.com/2018/03/14/intel-committee-rejects-basic-underpinning-of-russiagate/
  32. https://scheerpost.com/2025/08/14/ray-mcgovern-applying-the-lost-art-of-kremlinology/
  33. https://consortiumnews.com/2020/05/08/ray-mcgovern-once-we-were-allies-then-came-micimatt/
  34. https://raymcgovern.com/2020/12/30/why-russia-must-be-demonized/
  35. https://consortiumnews.com/2024/05/17/ray-mcgovern-russia-china-two-against-one/
  36. https://www.democracynow.org/2011/2/18/ex_cia_analyst_ray_mcgovern_beaten
  37. https://www.commondreams.org/views/2014/11/09/mystery-ray-mcgoverns-arrest
  38. https://www.democracynow.org/2014/11/4/headlines/former_cia_analyst_ray_mcgovern_details_painful_arrest_at_petraeus_event
  39. https://www.justiceonline.org/news/important-victory-in-case-of-ray-mcgoverns-brutal-arrest/
  40. https://therealnews.com/police-brutalize-78-year-old-cia-whistleblower-protesting-at-torturer-gina-haspels-senate-hearing
  41. https://www.dailysabah.com/americas/2018/05/11/us-police-forcibly-remove-79-year-old-cia-veteran-from-haspel-hearing
  42. https://www.c-span.org/clip/senate-committee/user-clip-former-cia-analyst-gets-arrested-while-protesting-cia-directors-nomination/4728749
  43. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna12632127
  44. https://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/05/04/cnna.mcgovern/
  45. https://www.c-span.org/program/senate-committee/cia-director-confirmation-hearing/502643
  46. https://www.democracynow.org/appearances/ray_mcgovern
  47. https://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/03/24/torture-doesnt-work-2016-election-campaign-edition
  48. https://lancasteronline.com/features/faith_values/former-cia-analyst-ray-mcgovern-says-the-agency-is-not-serving-americas-best-interests-coming/article_6d230824-0b40-11e7-b612-4fb9ef074dbb.html
  49. https://monthlyreview.org/articles/fake-news-on-russia-and-other-official-enemies/
  50. https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/46633/426158498-MIT.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y
  51. https://original.antiwar.com/mcgovern/2008/01/14/gulf-of-tonkin-will-be-tough-to-repeat/
  52. https://sputnikglobe.com/20231221/cia-veteran-bidens-proxy-war-in-ukraine-evokes-strong-memories-of-vietnam-disaster-1115725605.html
  53. https://x.com/i/grok/share/FvKZ5pphtNnPvJmYuO2UuUyKw
  54. https://www.counterpunch.org/2003/02/08/a-memo-to-bush-on-iraq/
  55. https://www.democracynow.org/2003/9/17/the_crazies_are_back_bush_sr
  56. https://www.democracynow.org/2003/7/15/intelligence_agents_from_the_u_s
  57. https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL0407/S00118/ray-mcgovern-the-cia-and-iraq.htm
  58. https://www.congress.gov/committee-report/108th-congress/senate-report/301/1
  59. https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/2008/06/05/press-senate-intelligence-committee-unveils-final-phase-ii-reports-prewar-iraq-intelligence/
  60. https://consortiumnews.com/2020/05/09/ray-mcgovern-new-house-documents-sow-further-doubt-that-russia-hacked-the-dnc/
  61. https://consortiumnews.com/2020/06/05/vips-memo-to-the-ag-muellers-forensics-free-findings-part-2/
  62. https://consortiumnews.com/2016/12/12/us-intel-vets-dispute-russia-hacking-claims/
  63. https://www.congress.gov/116/meeting/house/110281/documents/HHRG-116-JU00-20191204-SD1284.pdf
  64. https://www.justice.gov/storage/durhamreport.pdf
  65. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/mueller-report-conclusions-trump-congress-attorney-general-william-barr-n986611
  66. https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2019/03/mueller-concludes-investigation/
  67. https://consortiumnews.com/2020/05/15/consortium-news-blazed-the-trail-of-russiagate-reporting-help-us-to-continue-telling-the-story/
  68. https://wbai.org/articles.php?article=1424
  69. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Foreign-Policy/2013/0908/Chemical-attacks-in-Syria.-Where-s-the-proof-Assad-was-responsible
  70. https://mronline.org/2021/03/15/statement-of-concern-the-opcw-investigation-of-alleged-chemical-weapons-use-in-douma-syria/
  71. https://www.counterpunch.org/2019/11/15/the-opcw-and-douma-chemical-weapons-watchdog-accused-of-evidence-tampering-by-its-own-inspectors/
  72. https://original.antiwar.com/mcgovern/2016/08/31/putin-bailed-obama/
  73. https://fpif.org/syria-helps-know-whodunit-sentencing/
  74. https://original.antiwar.com/mcgovern/2022/02/21/what-accounts-for-putins-assertiveness-on-ukraine/
  75. https://scheerpost.com/2025/05/07/behind-the-frontlines-ray-mcgovern-in-russia-discussing-russia-ukraine-and-the-quest-for-peace/
  76. https://scheerpost.com/2022/04/25/katrina-vanden-heuvel-on-russia-ukraine-the-war-and-the-us/
  77. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OOLAdsh88vY
  78. https://voennoedelo.com/en/posts/id2184-ex-cia-analyst-russia-has-already-won-as-ukraine-loses-ground
  79. https://truthout.org/articles/the-humiliation-of-bradley-manning/
  80. https://www.commondreams.org/newswire/2010/08/07/veterans-peace-activists-rally-quantico-base-support-wikileaks-whistleblower
  81. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/sep/15/bradley-manning-campaign-michael-moore
  82. https://original.antiwar.com/mcgovern/2022/04/25/bogus-charge-of-rape-did-in-julian-assange/
  83. https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/pm/former-cia-analyst-supports-wikileaks/2375516
  84. https://peaceandplanetnews.org/ray-mcgovern-the-man-who-got-russiagate-right/
  85. https://therealnews.com/rmcgovernnsawhistleblower0610
  86. https://progressive.org/latest/whistleblowers-present-award-edward-snowden/
  87. https://voxukraine.org/en/messing-with-the-truth-disinformation-in-the-west-spread-by-ray-mcgovern
  88. https://voxukraine.org/en/the-network-of-russian-propaganda-what-connects-western-experts-promoting-narratives-beneficial-to-russia
  89. https://news.online.ua/en/ukraines-watchdog-analysts-name-the-list-of-western-speakers-who-spread-russian-propaganda-details-873044/
  90. https://www.rt.com/news/snowden-award-wikileaks-video-093/
  91. https://sputnikglobe.com/person_Ray_McGovern/
  92. https://en.sputniknews.africa/20251005/1079099136.html
  93. https://kyivindependent.com/investigation-where-does-russian-disinformation-incubate-in-us/
  94. https://truthout.org/articles/kerrys-propaganda-war-on-russias-rt/
  95. https://scheerpost.com/2024/07/02/president-gets-a-reality-check-on-ukraine/
  96. https://www.scheerpost.com/2025/08/14/ray-mcgovern-applying-the-lost-art-of-kremlinology/
  97. https://archive.org/details/patriotismdemocr0000curt
  98. https://www.isbns.net/author/Ray_Mcgovern
  99. https://consortiumnews.com/2025/05/08/vips-memo-arms-control-toward-lasting-peace/
  100. https://consortiumnews.com/2024/12/02/ray-mcgovern-neocons-try-again-in-syria/
  101. https://consortiumnews.com/tag/ray-mcgovern/
  102. https://consortiumnews.com/2025/08/14/ray-mcgovern-applying-the-lost-art-of-kremlinology/
  103. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3hr5iqzrmME
  104. https://braveneweurope.com/ray-mcgovern-glenn-diesen-the-lasting-consequences-of-the-iran-war
  105. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MTfUBi4EMk
  106. https://podcasts.apple.com/co/podcast/ex-cia-analyst-ray-mcgovern-dr-assal-rad-on-iran-israel/id1020563127?i=1000715653260
  107. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irSg8pl47Os
  108. https://scheerpost.com/2025/05/27/ray-mcgovern-on-trust-between-russia-the-us/
  109. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgF_DF3l3o4
  110. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TOku7aFyRUA
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.