Hubbry Logo
History of the Jews in PakistanHistory of the Jews in PakistanMain
Open search
History of the Jews in Pakistan
Community hub
History of the Jews in Pakistan
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
History of the Jews in Pakistan
History of the Jews in Pakistan
History of the Jews in Pakistan
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Key Information

Part of a series on
Jews and Judaism
Religion
Texts
Tanakh
Talmud
Rabbinic
History
General
Ancient Israel
Second Temple period
Rabbinic period and Middle Ages
Modern era
Communities
Related groups
Population
Israel and Palestine
Africa
Asia
Europe
Northern America
Latin America and Caribbean
Oceania
Denominations
Culture
Customs
Music
Art
Cuisine
Literature
Surnames
Languages
Politics
Jewish political movements
Zionism
Part of a series on the
History of Pakistan
Arms of Pakistan
Arms of Pakistan
Timeline
Ancient
Classical
Medieval
Early modern
Modern
History of provinces

Pakistani Jews (Urdu: پاکستانی یہودی) are a small, historic community, mainly in Karachi. Most Pakistani Jews migrated to Israel after 1948. Jewish history in Pakistan goes back to 1839 when Pakistan was part of British India.[1][2] Various estimates suggest that there were about 50,000 to 60,000 Jews living in Karachi at the beginning of the 20th century, mostly comprising Iranian Jews and Bene Israel;[3][4][5] a substantial Jewish community lived in Rawalpindi,[1] and a smaller community also lived in Peshawar.

The Partition of India in August 1947 led to the establishment of two independent sovereign states: a Hindu-majority India and a Muslim-majority Pakistan. Following this event, Pakistani Jews began to leave the new country for India, Canada and the United States before the rise of their persecution in Pakistan after the establishment of Israel in 1948, which ultimately led to their exodus from the country; today, Pakistani Jews are predominantly found in the Israeli city of Ramla, while the Government of Pakistan claims to host a modest Jewish population. According to Pakistan's National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA), there are 745 registered Jewish families in the country.[6] However, the accuracy and transparency of the NADRA's database has been challenged;[7] Liel Leibovitz, an Israeli journalist, has doubted the correctness of the official numbers.[8]

It has been widely reported in Pakistani media that a man known as Fishel Benkhald, who preserves the last standing Jewish cemetery in Karachi, has claimed to be last Jew in Pakistan.[9][10] However, Benkhald's identity has been challenged by his brothers, who claim to be Muslims,[11][12] and he has been targeted and attacked in the country due to his activism for religious minorities in Pakistan. However, his Jewishness was formally recognized by the Pakistani government in 2017 after numerous appeals.[13]

History

[edit]

First migrations

[edit]

A community of Jews fleeing a revolt in Mashhad, Persia, settled in Rawalpindi, Punjab in 1839 when the city was ruled by the Sikh Empire. This Jewish community in Rawalpindi constructed a synagogue in the early 1900s, which is located in Rawalpindi's Babu Mohallah neighborhood.[1]

The interior of the Magain Shalome synagogue before its demolition

Colonial era (1842–1947)

[edit]

According to the 1881 census, there were 153 Jews in Sind Division, which is modern-day Sindh.[14] In the Sindh Gazetteer of 1907,[15] Edward Hamilton Aitken mentions that, according to the 1901 census, the total population of Jews in Sindh was 482, and almost all of them lived in Karachi.[16] By 1919, this figure had risen to about 650.[17] By 1947, there were about 1,500 Jews living in Sindh with the majority residing in Karachi. Most of these Jews were Bene Israel and they lived as traders, artisans, poets, philosophers and civil servants.[18]

In 1911, Jews constituted 0.3% of Karachi's population and at the time of independence from the British Empire, their number had reached 2,500.[19] Pakistani histiographer, Gul Hassan Kalmati, who focused extensively on the culture and history of Karachi, indicates that Jews arrived in Karachi from Maharashtra in the 19th century.[20][21]

A variety of associations existed to serve the Jewish community in Pakistan, including:

  • Magain Shalome Synagogue: Built in 1893 near Ranchore Line,[22] by Solomon David Umerdekar and his son Gershone Solomon. Other accounts suggest that it was built by Shalom Solomon, a surveyor for the Karachi Municipal Committee and his wife Shegula-bai. The synagogue soon became the center of a small but vibrant Jewish community. A member of this Synagogue, Abraham Reuben Kamarlekar, became a councilor in the Karachi City Corporation in 1936.
  • Young Man's Jewish Association: Founded in 1903 and whose aim was to encourage sports as well as religious and social activities of the Bene Israel in Karachi.
  • Karachi Bene Israel Relief Fund: Established to support poor Jews in Karachi.
  • Karachi Jewish Syndicate: Formed in 1918 and whose aim was to provide homes to poor Jews at reasonable rent fees.

Post-independence

[edit]
Pakistani Jews after making aliyah from Pakistan, 1963

1947–1970

[edit]
The rabbi of Megan Shalome Synagogue, photographed with his son, c. 1951

Leading up to the time of the Partition of India,[23] some 1300 Jews remained in Karachi, most of them Bene Israel Jews observing Sephardic Jewish rites.[24] The first real exodus of Jewish refugees from British India to Bombay and other cities in India came just prior to the creation of Israel in 1948 when antisemitism spread to Pakistan.[25][26] When Israel came into being in 1948, many Jews migrated to Israel, and after the Arab-Israel war a majority of them left Karachi.[27] By 1953, fewer than 500 Jews were reported to be in all of Pakistan.[28]

1971–present

[edit]
The Magain Shalome Synagogue in 1893. It was demolished on the orders of the military dictator General Zia ul-Haq in 1988, and a shopping plaza was built in place of it.

Magen Shalom, the Bene Israel's only synagogue in Karachi founded under the British Raj, was demolished in 1988 to make way for a shopping plaza by order of General Zia-ul-Haq shortly after the Bene Israel community in Israel petitioned for its maintenance and use as a historical or other community center.[29] As per another account, in July 1988 the synagogue was burnt and brought down by religious zealots (where today a building 'Madiha Square' stands).[30] The last custodian of the synagogue was Rachel Joseph, now deceased.[31][32][33] Many Jews who migrated from Pakistan have not updated their status since leaving Pakistan in NADRA's database so the database must be old and there may not actually be as many Jewish Pakistanis left in Pakistan despite NADRA showing existence of Jews in Pakistan.[citation needed]

Dan Kiesel, a Jew of German origin, was employed as a physiotherapist by the Pakistan Cricket Board from 1995 to 1999. His appointment brought some controversy, as Pakistani politicians questioned the hiring an Israeli Jew in the Senate of Pakistan.[34]

The term "Yehudi" and its variants remains a word of derision when directed at a Bene Israel or anyone else as noted by Reverend John Wilson, one of the founders of University of Bombay (now University of Mumbai). In Urdu (the national language of Pakistan), however, the word simply translates to 'Jewish'.[35] The Bene Israel's prayers include intercessions on behalf of His Majesty as in several Commonwealth countries.[36] The Jewish Chronicle of London reported on Karachi's Jews as recently as 2007.[37]

In general elections 2013, it was reported that 809 adult Jews were enrolled as voters. The number of Jewish women voters was 427 against 382 men in the community.[38] By 2017, according to the Election Commission of Pakistan around 900 Jews were registered as voters in the country.[39] Also in 2017 According to the National Database and Registration Authority, there are 745 registered Jewish families in Pakistan.[40]

Most of the Karachi Jews now live in Ramla, Israel; Mumbai, India; Toronto, Canada; and the United States.

Antisemitism

[edit]
Main article: Antisemitism in Pakistan

The creation of Israel and the Arab–Israeli conflict led to a rise in anti-Semitism in Pakistan. The Synagogue was demolished in 1988.[41] Incidents of violence against Jews started occurring following the establishment of Israel, creating a sense of insecurity within the community in Karachi. Karachi's Magain Shalome Synagogue was set ablaze, and attacks on Jews escalated after each Arab-Israeli war—in 1948, 1956, and 1967.[41] Since the 1970s, anti-Semitism has significantly mounted.[42]

Landmarks

[edit]

The Jewish Bene Israel Graveyard remains in the larger Mewa Shah Graveyard in Karachi.[43][44]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

History of the Jews in Pakistan

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The history of the in encompasses the settlement of primarily migrants from during British colonial rule, the development of urban communities centered in that peaked at approximately 2,500 members in the early twentieth century, and their subsequent near-total exodus amid antisemitic violence following the 1947 and the 1948 founding of , leaving a remnant population of fewer than 200 individuals today who largely conceal their identity to avoid . These , who spoke Marathi and followed Sephardic rites, arrived in the region as tradesmen, artisans, and civil servants under British administration, establishing institutions such as the Young Men’s Jewish Association in 1903 and the Karachi Jewish Syndicate in 1918 to support social, religious, and economic needs. In , the community constructed the Magain Shalome Synagogue in 1893, which served as a central hub until its destruction by in 1948 and eventual in the 1980s for commercial development. A notable milestone came in 1936 when Abraham Reuben became the first Jewish councilor in , reflecting the community's integration into municipal affairs prior to independence. The partition triggered immediate hostility, including attacks by Muslim refugees from who ransacked Jewish sites, exacerbated by the Arab-Israeli War of 1948, prompting around 3,000 Jews to flee initially to or directly to the nascent State of . Further waves of emigration occurred during subsequent conflicts in 1956 and 1967, as well as under military regimes like that of Ayub Khan, reducing the population to about 250 by 1968, with most survivors passing as for safety and relocating to cities like in . Today, the clandestine community, concentrated in and numbering under 200, faces ongoing challenges from intolerance and demographic attrition, with rare public figures such as Fishel BenKhald registering openly as Jewish in 2017—the first in decades—amid persistent risks tied to regional geopolitics. Smaller historical presences existed in and , but these have entirely dissipated.

Early Settlement and Colonial Era

Origins and Initial Migrations

The earliest documented Jewish presence in the territories that would become occurred in the early , coinciding with British colonial expansion in following the conquest of in 1839. Small groups of Jews, originating from the region and Bombay in , began migrating to port cities like as traders, artisans, and laborers in British service, drawn by economic opportunities in the burgeoning colonial trade networks. These initial migrants numbered only a few dozen by mid-century, with census records indicating 153 Jews residing in by 1881, primarily concentrated in urban centers rather than rural areas. Their arrival was facilitated by British infrastructure development, including railways and ports, which integrated the region into wider commerce, but lacked any indigenous pull factors or pre-existing Jewish networks in the area. Claims of pre-modern Jewish communities in the region, such as speculative connections to ancient Israelite exiles, medieval traders along the Silk Road, or even Pashtun tribes as descendants of the Lost Tribes of Israel, rely on oral traditions, anecdotal folklore, and superficial cultural parallels like tribal names or customs, but are unsupported by archaeological findings, genetic studies, or contemporary historical documents. For instance, while some Pashtun genealogies invoke Israelite origins, scientific analyses have found no definitive DNA or artifactual evidence linking them to ancient Judea, attributing resemblances to broader Semitic or Central Asian influences instead.

Community Development Under British Rule (1842–1947)

The Jewish population in the region that became grew modestly during British colonial rule, transitioning from sparse settlements to a more organized community centered in . By the 1881 census, province recorded 153 , primarily migrants from Bombay and other parts of attracted by opportunities in the expanding port city. This number increased to around 2,500 by the early , reflecting steady influxes facilitated by British infrastructure developments like railways and trade routes, though the community remained a small minority amid larger groups such as and . Institutional development marked this era's stability, with the construction of the Magain Shalome in 1893 by Solomon David Umerdekar, a merchant, serving as a central hub for religious and social activities in Karachi's Ranchore Lines neighborhood. The was extended in 1912, accommodating growing needs, and by 1916–1918, the community established a on its premises to preserve cultural and religious practices among the youth. These efforts underscored a period of relative communal cohesion, supported by British administrative policies that enforced legal protections for religious minorities, preventing the pogroms or expulsions seen elsewhere in the empire. Socially, Jews coexisted with other non-Muslim communities in , benefiting from the colonial emphasis on pluralistic urban governance and shared economic spaces, which fostered interdependence without major intercommunal strife. British legal frameworks, including equal rights under the and municipal councils, contributed to this tolerance, allowing the community to maintain distinct institutions while operating within the colonial order, though underlying Muslim-majority sentiments occasionally surfaced in isolated tensions rather than organized violence.

Economic Roles and Social Integration

The Jewish community in during the British colonial period primarily engaged in commerce and skilled trades, serving as merchants, artisans, tradesmen, and civil servants without exerting dominance over major economic sectors. By the early twentieth century, approximately 2,500 resided in , contributing to local trade networks and administrative functions under British oversight. Many were involved in import-export activities, leveraging family connections from and Baghdadi origins to facilitate goods movement through the port city, though they did not control key infrastructure like the Karachi Port Trust. Some individuals pursued technical roles, including as clerks in government offices and, notably, as pilots and professionals in the British Indian Air Force, reflecting their reliability in specialized positions. Socially, Jews maintained a low-profile integration within the multicultural colonial of , benefiting from British preferences for loyal minority groups who avoided entanglement in Hindu-Muslim political rivalries. Their apolitical stance, characterized by pro-British loyalty and neutrality toward Indian nationalist movements, fostered a degree of acceptance among other communities, as evidenced by rare but documented instances of professional collaborations with Muslim and Hindu traders. Inter-community marriages remained exceptional, with emphasizing distinct foreign roots to preserve identity, yet joint minority efforts occasionally emerged in advocacy for equitable treatment under colonial policies, underscoring their valued but peripheral status. This positioning stemmed from causal factors such as British recruitment of dependable non-majority workers for administrative stability and the Jews' strategic abstention from communal conflicts, which preserved social harmony until 1947.

Partition, Independence, and Exodus

The 1947 Partition and Immediate Aftermath

The partition of British on August 14, 1947, which created the Dominion of , triggered massive primarily between , , and , resulting in the displacement or death of up to 2 million people and the migration of over 14 million across borders. In the territories that became , particularly and , and faced systematic attacks, expulsions, and property seizures, prompting nearly complete evacuation of those communities. The Jewish population, estimated at around 2,500 and concentrated in , experienced no such targeted pogroms or forced evacuations during the immediate partition riots, as they were viewed as a small, apolitical minority uninvolved in the inter-communal hostilities between the majority groups. This relative security stemmed from the Jews' historical neutrality and economic roles as traders and professionals, which distanced them from the militant associations of Sikh or Hindu nationalist groups. , Pakistan's founder, reinforced minority protections in his August 11, 1947, address to the , declaring that religion would have "nothing to do with the business of the State" and affirming equal citizenship for all, irrespective of faith—a secular vision that reassured Jewish leaders amid the chaos. Some Jews even participated in early administrative and economic efforts to stabilize the new state, including in commerce and civil services, without facing state-sanctioned discrimination or mass expulsion in the transitional months. By early 1948, the community remained largely intact, with synagogues operational and daily life continuing in 's Jewish quarters, though nascent geopolitical frictions from the emerging Arab-Israeli conflict began registering indirectly through public discourse. Empirical records show no significant demographic rupture for in through the partition's immediate aftermath, contrasting sharply with the fate of other non-Muslim minorities and highlighting the causal role of their marginal size and non-alignment in averting violence.

Mass Emigration Post-1948 and Ties to Israel

The establishment of the State of on May 14, 1948, marked a turning point for the Jewish community in , triggering a mass emigration primarily to as part of the broader Jewish exodus from Muslim-majority countries. The community, estimated at approximately 3,000 individuals—mostly Jews concentrated in —faced heightened antisemitic violence and social pressures conflating Jewish identity with , prompting voluntary departures amid regional Arab-Israeli hostilities. Incidents of violence in and other cities, including attacks on Jewish properties and individuals, intensified shortly after Israel's founding, fostering an atmosphere of insecurity that accelerated without documented state-enforced expulsions. Emigration logistics often involved indirect routes due to Pakistan's non-recognition of and subsequent passport restrictions prohibiting travel to the , treated as an adversarial entity. Pakistani joined efforts coordinated by Jewish agencies, with many settling in ; while exact figures for Pakistani-origin immigrants remain sparse in historical records, the community's rapid decline—from around 3,000 in 1948 to approximately 250 by 1968—reflects the scale of departures to and other destinations like the and . Economic boycotts targeting perceived Zionist sympathizers further eroded livelihoods, compounding the pull of 's , which facilitated absorption for fleeing Muslim lands. This migration mirrored patterns in Arab countries, where over 377,000 arrived in from Muslim regions between 1948 and 1952, though Pakistan's smaller community contributed modestly to the total. Pakistan's government policies, including the absence of diplomatic ties with and implicit alignment with Arab states against , indirectly hastened the outflow by limiting options for those wishing to remain neutral or prosperous. No evidence indicates systematic expulsion, distinguishing Pakistan's case from forced deportations elsewhere; instead, the stemmed from causal interplay of local antisemitic incidents, economic marginalization, and the ideological attraction of a Jewish homeland amid post-1948 geopolitical tensions. By the mid-1950s, the community had dwindled to under 500, with synagogues like Karachi's Magain Shalom seeing reduced congregations as families prioritized relocation over endurance in an increasingly hostile environment.

Post-1971 Decline and Contemporary Remnants

Community Erosion in the 1970s–1990s

Following the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War, which resulted in the secession of as , the remaining Jewish population in , estimated at fewer than 250 individuals primarily in by 1968, faced intensified pressures leading to further emigration and concealment of identity. The war heightened anti-Indian sentiments, indirectly conflating local with due to the latter's covert arms supplies to during the 1965 and 1971 conflicts, prompting discreet departures to avoid association with perceived enemies. By the early 1970s, only 10 to 13 Jewish families remained, many opting for quiet relocation to the or rather than facing overt hostility. Under Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's policies from 1972 onward and subsequent Islamization efforts intensified by General Zia-ul-Haq after his 1977 coup, non-Muslim minorities encountered economic restrictions and a societal shift toward religious orthodoxy, accelerating the abandonment of communal institutions. Synagogues, including Karachi's Magain Shalome—the last functioning one—saw dwindling attendance as families adopted Parsi or Muslim identities for amid rising Islamist policies that promoted Sunni conformity and marginalized religious others. This internal decay manifested in the cessation of public services by the late 1970s, with properties left unattended due to insufficient congregants. By the 1990s, overt Jewish adherence had eroded to near zero, with survivors like Rachel Joseph, the final custodian of , maintaining private ties to heritage amid a community reduced to isolated individuals. Joseph's solitary efforts to preserve synagogue remnants underscored the transition from a to hidden remnants, driven by geopolitical tensions and state-driven Islamization rather than mass expulsions. This period marked the effective dissolution of organized Jewish life in , with assimilation and ensuring survival through obscurity.

Current Status, Hidden Families, and Fringe Claimants (2000–Present)

As of the early , Pakistan's overt Jewish remains negligible, with estimates suggesting fewer than 200 individuals of Jewish descent and only isolated cases of open identification. Fishel Benkhald, who publicly affirmed his in after discovering his mother's hidden Ashkenazi heritage, stands as a rare example, though he encountered familial denunciation and social isolation, with siblings labeling his claims "insane" and accusing him of . Benkhald, residing in and later , has advocated for kosher exports and visited in 2022 despite official prohibitions, highlighting the personal risks of visibility in a context of pervasive hostility. Small numbers of families tracing descent from pre-partition Jewish communities reportedly maintain concealed identities, often masquerading as or to evade scrutiny, with anecdotal accounts from estimating around 10 such households scattered in neighborhoods like Soldier Bazaar. These hidden lineages stem from post-1947 assimilations driven by security imperatives, where overt practice invites threats, though precise figures remain unverifiable due to deliberate obscurity and lack of institutional records. Fringe groups like the Bani Efraim, which surfaced publicly around 2012 among Pashtun communities, assert descent from the biblical tribe of Ephraim, numbering approximately 200 families and incorporating rituals such as Sabbath observance and Torah study. These claims, rooted in oral traditions linking Pashtuns to ancient Israelite exiles, lack substantiation from genetic studies or halakhic criteria—requiring matrilineal Jewish lineage or formal conversion—and are rejected by mainstream rabbinic authorities as ineligible for automatic recognition or aliyah, potentially incentivized by aspirations for Israeli immigration rather than verified ancestry. Recognition disputes persist, as illustrated by the Samuel family's 2023 case: Sajid and Farah , who fled with their children amid escalating antisemitic threats, sought refuge in but faced deportation proceedings after Israeli authorities denied their conversion validity and questioned their Jewish roots' authenticity, despite documented ties to . Compounding such challenges, a 2025 analysis of 86 official Pakistani textbooks revealed systemic indoctrination against , including , praise for Hitler, and portrayals of as deceitful enemies, fostering an environment where even latent invites peril.

Antisemitism and Societal Hostility

Shifts from Colonial Tolerance to Independence-Era Animosity

Under British colonial rule, the Jewish communities in regions such as and —numbering around 2,500 in alone by the early —experienced protection through imperial mechanisms that prioritized administrative stability over religious factionalism, enabling participation in trade, municipal service, and professional life without recorded instances of pogroms or organized violence. This era of relative tolerance, sustained by British oversight that suppressed communal riots unlike those in other parts of the subcontinent, shifted abruptly after the 1947 partition and the 1948 establishment of , as anti-Zionist fervor—largely imported via solidarity with Arab states—merged with rising Islamist rhetoric that framed Jewish presence through the lens of regional conflict rather than local integration. Muhammad Ali Jinnah's 1947 assurances of religious freedom for minorities, including Jews who had demonstrated loyalty by supporting the , were progressively undermined by post-independence constitutional developments, notably the 1956 Constitution's declaration of Pakistan as an , which embedded sharia-derived principles and elevated Muslim identity, facilitating the erosion of secular safeguards. Empirically, the pre-1948 absence of anti-Jewish disturbances contrasted with escalations, including public demonstrations and economic pressures from Pakistan's alignment with Arab-led , which targeted perceived Zionist affiliations and accelerated emigration despite the community's prior uncontroversial assimilation. These dynamics underscored animosity driven by exogenous geopolitical events, such as the Arab-Israeli wars, rather than endogenous Pakistani traditions, rendering reciprocal tolerance elusive.

State and Institutional Promotion of Antisemitism

Following the Islamization policies initiated by General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq in 1977, Pakistani public school textbooks across , , and federal boards have systematically incorporated tropes, portraying as inherently treacherous and linking them to global conspiracies, often conflated with demonization of as an imperialist entity. A 2025 analysis of 86 government-approved textbooks revealed recurrent depictions of Jewish tribes in as pact-breakers who "as usual" betrayed Prophet Muhammad, alongside claims of Jewish control over and economies to perpetuate enmity against . These narratives, absent any mention of or Jewish historical suffering, extend to madrassa curricula, where anti-Jewish rhetoric is embedded in religious instruction, fostering generational hostility beyond mere geopolitical critique. State-controlled media outlets, including Pakistan Television (PTV) and official broadcasts, reinforce this through routine anti-Zionist programming that equates with aggression, portraying as a Jewish cabal orchestrating Muslim subjugation. Such content, amplified since the Zia era's alignment of media with Islamist ideology, promotes tropes of Jewish financial dominance and ritual malice, as seen in state-endorsed publications detailing historical expulsions of as justified retribution. In November 2024, the Standing Committee on Interior approved legislation criminalizing the promotion of or display of Zionist symbols, imposing up to three years' imprisonment and fines, framing any pro-Israel advocacy as a to national sovereignty and implicitly targeting residual Jewish sympathies. While Pakistani officials maintain that institutional stances reflect opposition to Israeli policies rather than —dismissing global critiques as conflations of with Jew-hatred—empirical reviews indicate deeper bias, including erasure of Jewish contributions and normalization of violence-justifying narratives in a nuclear-armed state with over 60% youth population exposed to such curricula. This persistence challenges claims of limited "anti-occupation" sentiment, as textbooks and policies exhibit classic stereotypes untethered from contemporary conflicts, heightening risks for any perceived Jewish affiliation amid provisions that indirectly penalize deviations from state orthodoxy.

Notable Incidents and Policy Impacts

In the wake of the 1965 Indo-Pakistani War and the 1967 , which Pakistan vocally supported on the Arab side, suspicions arose that local harbored loyalties to , accelerating emigration from an already dwindling community of fewer than 500 individuals by the late 1960s. This period marked a causal escalation in hostility, as state-aligned media and public discourse equated Jewish identity with , prompting families to leverage international networks for relocation to or the West, reducing the resident population to isolated remnants. A prominent 2017 incident involved Fishel Benkhald, who successfully petitioned to register officially as Jewish—the first such approval since the —only to face immediate social ostracism and threats from family and society. Benkhald, born to a Jewish mother and Muslim father, reported denunciations by siblings labeling his maternal heritage "insane" and fears of as an apostate, highlighting the risks of public Jewish identification amid pervasive antisemitic tropes. This outing underscored empirical patterns of familial and communal rejection, deterring hidden families from surfacing and contributing to the community's effective invisibility. Pakistan's longstanding non-recognition of enforces policies with direct impacts on any Jewish presence, including passports explicitly stating they are "not valid for travel to ," which prohibits visits and complicates returns for those acquiring Israeli stamps elsewhere. This restriction, rooted in , has barred potential returnees and reinforced isolation, as evidenced by cases where travel to leads to passport invalidation or of re-entry. Constitutionally mandated protections for religious minorities under Article 20 have proven ineffective in practice for , whose near-total exodus—from approximately 2,000 at to fewer than 100 today, per official estimates—contrasts with the persistence of larger Hindu (1.6%) and Christian (1.6%) populations, attributable in part to ' access to global networks facilitating relocation. Persistent state positions, including 2025 UN statements condemning Israeli actions in Gaza and the without reciprocal moderation toward Jewish rights, sustain a policy environment of hostility that precludes community revival. These stances, while framed as anti-occupation, empirically amplify domestic by institutionalizing zero-tolerance for perceived Zionist affiliations, further eroding any residual Jewish ties to .

Legacy, Landmarks, and Notable Figures

Synagogues, Cemeteries, and Physical Remnants

The Magen Shalom Synagogue in Karachi, established in 1893 as the principal house of worship for the local Jewish community, ceased operations in the 1960s amid declining membership and was subsequently demolished on July 17, 1988, to facilitate construction of a shopping plaza. This structure, renovated in 1936, represented the last operational synagogue in Pakistan, with no surviving synagogue buildings documented today. The Bani Israel Graveyard, integrated within the expansive Mewa Shah interfaith cemetery along the Lyari River in , constitutes the sole remaining Jewish burial site in , encompassing graves from the British colonial period onward. Spanning part of the 1,000-acre Mewa Shah complex, which includes Muslim, Christian, and Hindu sections, the Jewish portion has endured encroachment from adjacent Muslim burials and general deterioration due to prolonged neglect. Reports from 2023 underscore this erosion, attributing the site's decay to insufficient maintenance rather than targeted vandalism, with overgrown vegetation and structural damage evident amid broader indifference to minority heritage. Preservation initiatives for these remnants remain negligible, lacking formal legal safeguards despite sporadic advocacy for recognition as , a stark departure from the upkeep observed during the colonial era when Jewish sites received community and administrative support. The absence of active Jewish stewardship has amplified vulnerability to urban pressures, rendering the graveyard a poignant, unattended testament to the community's historical presence without institutional intervention to halt progressive dilapidation.

Cultural Contributions and Prominent Individuals

Jewish members of the community in contributed to the region's economy and administration during the British colonial period, primarily as tradesmen, artisans, and civil servants, with an estimated 2,500 individuals engaged in these roles by the early . Solomon David Umerdekar (also spelled Omerdekar), a prominent community leader and surveyor for the Municipality, exemplified these efforts; he oversaw municipal land surveys and played a key role in constructing the Magain Shalome Synagogue in 1893 alongside his son Gershone Solomon, reflecting Jewish integration into local and development. These activities supported port-related commerce in , though specific aviation involvement remains undocumented in primary accounts. Following mass emigration after Pakistan's independence, diaspora preserved through documentation and personal narratives. Yoel Moses Reuben, a Pakistani-born Jew who relocated to , authored The Jews of Pakistan: A Forgotten Heritage (2010), compiling family histories, records, and photographs to chronicle the community's pre-partition life and rapid decline, drawing on oral testimonies and archival materials without scholarly pretensions. Such works highlight underappreciated Jewish roles in early urban development, contrasting with post-independence nationalist histories that emphasize Muslim contributions while marginalizing non-Muslim legacies, leading to the erasure of these narratives in official discourse. Rachel Joseph, regarded as the last openly identifying in , symbolized the community's tenacity; born into a family in , she advocated for preserving Jewish gravesites and remnants until her death in 2006 at age 88, amid legal battles against encroachments that underscored the rejection of prior communal ties. In , Pakistani-origin Jews like Emanuel Matat, who emigrated from in 1988, sustain cultural links through shared stories of pre-emigration tolerance and traditions, fostering intergenerational awareness despite 's non-recognition of . These efforts counterbalance the eventual societal shift that prompted exodus, preserving intangible heritage amid physical dispersal.

References

  1. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/pakistan-virtual-jewish-history-tour
  2. https://imageusa.com/jews-and-judaism-in-pakistan-4/
  3. https://aemagazine.pk/article/history-of-jews-in-pakistan
  4. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/asia-pacific/pakistan-s-jews-struggle-to-maintain-their-community/1377518
  5. https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/the-bene-israel/
  6. https://dailytimes.com.pk/239196/pakistani-jews-and-pti/
  7. https://goodoldkarachi.com/2018/08/16/the-lost-tribe-of-karachi/
  8. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/jan/17/israel-lost-tribes-pashtun
  9. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/jewish-communities-in-modern-asia/south-asia-identity-and-culture-in-british-and-independent-india/A46A61E36C33B175BEB21D1770BAAAAE
  10. https://almamaterjics.com/makale_indir/5002
  11. https://asiasociety.org/jael-silliman-bringing-indias-jews-light
  12. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/06/29/the-great-divide-books-dalrymple
  13. https://www.gatewayhouse.in/partition-stayed-behind-karachi/
  14. http://beta.dawn.com/news/827017/no-more-in-karachi
  15. https://www.dw.com/en/pakistan-whats-left-of-jewish-architecture-in-karachi/a-66440931
  16. https://brownhistory.substack.com/p/unveiling-the-legacy-of-karachis
  17. https://www.meforum.org/middle-east-quarterly/the-strangely-parallel-careers-of-israel
  18. https://jewishtimesasia.org/community-spotlight-topmenu-43/pakistan/544-pakistan-communities/2806-a-jewish-presence-in-pakistan-karachi-in-another-time?tmpl=component&print=1&layout=default&page=
  19. https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/pakistanis-anti-semitics-or-anti-zionists/
  20. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/immigrants-to-israel-1948-1952
  21. https://www.haaretz.com/2004-09-06/ty-article/the-jewish-general-who-beat-pakistan/0000017f-e952-dc91-a17f-fddf993c0000
  22. https://defencepk.com/forums/threads/magen-shalom-the-last-synagogue-in-pakistan.18530/
  23. https://www.dw.com/en/pakistans-islamization-before-and-after-dictator-zia-ul-haq/a-19480315
  24. https://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/karachis-lost-jews/
  25. https://www.thejc.com/news/world/pakistans-last-jew-in-battle-to-win-empathy-ke90nw4v
  26. https://appgfreedomofreligionorbelief.org/media/Jews-of-Pakistan-Lyn.pdf
  27. https://www.timesofisrael.com/denounced-by-his-brothers-pakistani-jew-says-hes-being-thrown-to-an-apostate-lynch-mob/
  28. https://www.aapeaceinstitute.org/latest/in-a-first-pakistani-jew-openly-visits-israel
  29. https://theprint.in/opinion/letter-from-pakistan/a-few-pakistani-american-jews-reached-israel-pakistans-having-a-heartburn/984762/
  30. https://www.facebook.com/groups/histimages/posts/3628539907398459/
  31. https://kulanu.org/pakistan/
  32. https://afgazad.com/2023-EU-Langueges/030423-Are-Pashtuns-the-Lost-Tribe-of-Israel.pdf
  33. https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/sjplldk5i
  34. https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/israel/society/1672588221-pakistani-jewish-family-faces-deportation-from-israel
  35. https://www.timesofisrael.com/schools-in-pakistan-promote-hostility-toward-jews-and-israel-report-finds/
  36. https://www.israelhayom.com/2025/08/24/pakistans-schools-indoctrinate-students-with-holocaust-denial-hitler-praise/
  37. https://minorityrights.org/wp-content/uploads/old-site-downloads/download-139-Religious-Minorities-in-Pakistan.pdf
  38. https://www.eurasiareview.com/11072011-history-and-disappearance-of-jewish-presence-in-pakistan-analysis/
  39. https://www.impact-se.org/wp-content/uploads/Pakistan-Report.pdf
  40. https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/antisemitism/article-864563
  41. https://themedialine.org/mideast-daily-news/pakistani-filmmaker-challenges-national-narrative-on-israel/
  42. https://www.memri.org/reports/column-pakistans-urdu-daily-promotes-antisemitism-details-expulsions-jews-european-nations
  43. https://themedialine.org/headlines/pakistan-senate-panel-passes-bill-criminalizing-promotion-of-zionism/
  44. https://themedialine.org/mideast-daily-news/new-law-bans-zionist-symbols-and-advocacy-in-pakistan/
  45. https://edition.cnn.com/2021/05/21/world/pakistan-diplomat-gaza-interview-intl
  46. https://www.state.gov/reports/2024-country-reports-on-human-rights-practices/pakistan
  47. https://www.haaretz.com/jewish/2014-10-19/ty-article/when-jews-found-refuge-in-pakistan/0000017f-e1a3-d568-ad7f-f3eb19700000
  48. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09584935.2022.2142518
  49. https://www.dw.com/en/pakistans-last-jew-fishel-benkhald-complains-of-anti-semitism/a-41480953
  50. https://mofa.gov.pk/press-releases/spokespersons-response-to-questions-about-visit-by-pakistani-journalists-to-israel?mission=statements
  51. https://tribune.com.pk/story/2536628/pakistan-passport-does-not-allow-israel-visit
  52. https://minorityrights.org/country/pakistan/
  53. https://mofa.gov.pk/press-releases/joint-statement-condemning-israeli-illegal-legislative-measures-aiming-to-impose-sovereignty-over-the-occupied-west-bank
  54. https://www.dawn.com/news/1950803
  55. https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/the-special-journey-of-bene-israels-shalom-torah-606226
  56. https://www.findagrave.com/cemetery/2733495/bani-israel-graveyard
  57. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/dec/26/pakistan-last-jewish-cemetery-campaign
  58. https://tribune.com.pk/story/626468/secret-histories-the-jews-built-karachi-but-we-built-shopping-plazas-on-their-synagogue
  59. http://www.mei.org.in/uploads/jijscontent/215-1555610850-jijsarticlepdf.pdf
  60. http://beta.dawn.com/news/245618/karachi-bene-israel-graveyard-buried-in-time-or-conscience
  61. https://peermudassir.com/a-pakistani-jew-in-israel-podcast-114/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.