Hubbry Logo
ChamarChamarMain
Open search
Chamar
Community hub
Chamar
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Chamar
Chamar
Chamar
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Chamar (or Jatav)[2] is a community classified as a Scheduled Caste under modern India's system of affirmative action that originated from the group of trade persons who were involved in leather tanning and shoemaking.[3] They are found throughout the Indian subcontinent, mainly in the northern states of India and in Pakistan and Nepal.

Key Information

History

[edit]

The Chamars are traditionally associated with leather work.[4] Ramnarayan Rawat posits that the association of the Chamar community with a traditional occupation of tanning was constructed, and that the Chamars were instead historically agriculturists.[5]

The term chamar is used as a pejorative word for Dalits in general.[6][7] It has been described as a casteist slur by the Supreme Court of India and the use of the term to address a person as a violation of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.[8]

Movement for upward social mobility

[edit]

Between the 1830s and the 1950s, the Chamars in the United Provinces, especially in the Kanpur area, became prosperous as a result of their involvement in the British leather trade.[9]

By the late 19th century, the Chamars began rewriting their caste histories, claiming Kshatriya descent.[10] For example, around 1910, U.B.S. Raghuvanshi published Shri Chanvar Purana from Kanpur, claiming that the Chamars were originally a community of Kshatriya rulers. He claimed to have obtained this information from Chanvar Purana, an ancient Sanskrit-language text purportedly discovered by a sage in a Himalayan cave. According to Raghuvanshi's narrative, Vishnu, one of the principal deities in Hinduism, once appeared in form of a Shudra before the community's ancient king Chamunda Rai. The king chastised Vishnu for reciting the Vedas, an act forbidden for a Shudra. The god then revealed his true self, and cursed his lineage to become Chamars, who would be lower in status than the Shudras. When the king apologized, the god declared that the Chamars will get an opportunity to rise again in the Kaliyuga after the appearance of a new sage (whom Raghuvanshi identifies as Ravidas).[11]

A section of Chamars claimed Kshatriya status as Jatavs, tracing their lineage to Krishna, another major deity in Hinduism, and thus, associating them with the Yadavs. Jatav Veer Mahasabha, an association of Jatav men founded in 1917, published multiple pamphlets making such claims in the first half of the 20th century.[12] The association discriminated against lower-status Chamars, such as the "Guliyas", who did not claim Kshatriya status.[13]

In the first half of the early 20th century, the most influential Chamar leader was Swami Achutanand, who founded the anti-Brahmanical Adi Hindu movement, and portrayed the lower castes as the original inhabitants of India, who had been enslaved by Aryan invaders.[14][15]

Political rise

[edit]
See also: De-Sanskritisation

In the 1940s, the Indian National Congress promoted the Chamar politician Jagjivan Ram to counteract the influence of B.R. Ambedkar; however, he remained an aberration in a party dominated by the upper castes.[16] In the second half of the 20th century, the Ambedkarite Republican Party of India (RPI) in Uttar Pradesh remained dominated by Chamars/Jatavs, despite attempts by leaders such as B.P. Maurya to expand its base.[17]

After the decline of the RPI in the 1970s, the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) attracted Chamar voter base. It experienced electoral success under the leadership of the Chamar leaders Kanshi Ram and Mayawati; Mayawati who eventually became the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh.[18] Other Dalit communities, such as Bhangis, complained of Chamar monopolisation of state benefits such as reservation.[19] Several other Dalit castes, resenting the domination of Dalit politics by Chamars/Jatavs, came under the influence of the Sangh Parivar.[20]

Nevertheless, with the rise of BSP in Uttar Pradesh, a collective solidarity and uniform Dalit identity was framed, which led to coming together of various antagonistic Dalit communities. In the past, Chamar had shared bitter relationship with the Pasis, another Dalit caste. The root cause of this bitter relationship was their roles in feudal society. The Pasis worked as lathail or stick wielders for the "Upper Caste" landlords and the later had compelled them in past to beat Chamars many a times. Under the unification drive of BSP, these rival castes came together for the cause of unity of Dalits under same political umbrella.[21]

Social exploitation

[edit]

In reference to villages of Rohtas and Bhojpur district of Bihar, prevalence of a practice was revealed, in which it was obligatory for the women of Chamar, Musahar and Dusadh community to have sexual contacts with their Rajput landlords. In order to keep their men in submissive position, these upper-caste landlords raped these Dalit women, and often implicate the male members of latter's family in false cases, when they refused sexual contacts with them. The other form of oppression which was inflicted on them was disallowing them to walk on the pathways and draw water from the wells, which belonged to Rajputs. The "pinching of breast" by the upper caste landlords and the undignified teasings were also common form of oppression. In the 1970s, the activism of peasant organizations like "Kisan Samiti" is said to have brought an end to these practices and subsequently the dignity was restored to the women of lower castes. The oppression however was not fully stopped as the friction between upper-caste landlords and the tillers continued. There are reports which indicates that the upper-caste landlords often took the help of Police in order to beat the women of Chamar caste and draw them out of their villages on the question of parity in wages.[22][23][24]

Chamar Caste in different States of India

[edit]

Ad-Dharmi

[edit]

The Ad-Dharmi is a Chamar caste sect in the state of Punjab, in India and is an alternative term for the Ravidasia religion, meaning Primal Spiritual Path.[25][26][27] The term Ad-Dharm came into popular usage in the early part of the 20th century, when many followers of Guru Ravidas converted to Sikhism and were severely discriminated against due to their low caste status (even though the Sikh religion is strictly against the caste system). Many of these converts stopped attending Sikh Gurdwaras controlled by Jat Sikhs and built their own shrines upon arrival in the UK, Canada, and Fiji Island.[28][25] Ad-Dharmis comprise 11.48% of the total of Scheduled Caste communities in Punjab.[29][30][31]

Ahirwar

[edit]

The Ahirwar, or Aharwar are Dalit members of a north Indian caste categorised among the Scheduled Castes of Chamar. Predominantly are members of the Scheduled Castes with a higher population in Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh.[32][33][34]

They are present, for example, in the state of Madhya Pradesh.[35] The 2001 Census of India recorded them in the Bundelkhand area and as the largest caste group in Lalitpur district, Uttar Pradesh, with a total population of 138,167.

Dhusia

[edit]

Dhusia is a caste in India, associated with Chamars, Ghusiya, Jhusia or Jatav.[36][37] They are found in Uttar Pradesh,[38] and elsewhere.

Most of the Dhusia in Punjab and Haryana migrated from Pakistan after the partition of India. In Punjab, they are mainly found in Ludhiana, Patiala, Amritsar and Jalandhar cities. They are inspired by B. R. Ambedkar to adopt the surnames Rao[39] and Jatav.

Jatav

[edit]

Jatav (also known as Jatava, Jatan, Jatua, Jhusia, Jatia, Jatiya) is an Indian Dalit community that is a sub-caste of the Chamar caste,[40] who are classified as a Scheduled Caste under modern India's system of positive discrimination.

According to the 2011 Census of India, the Jatav community of Uttar Pradesh comprised 54% of that state's total 22,496,047 Scheduled Caste population.[41]

Ravidassia/Ramdasia

[edit]

Ravidassia is sect of Chamar Sikhs from Punjab who worship Guru Ravidass[42] and Ramdasia were historically a Sikh, Hindu sub-group that originated from the caste of leather tanners and shoemakers known as Chamar.[43][44]

Both the words Ramdasia and Ravidasia are also used inter changeably while these also have regional context. In Puadh and Malwa, largely Ramdasia is used while Ravidasia is predominantly used in Doaba.[45]

List of Scheduled Castes in Punjab

Chamar Diaspora

[edit]
Mahia Mehmi- One of the first Chamar settler in Canada in 1906.
Former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau at Guru Ravidass Temple, Vancouver

The Chamar diaspora consists of different subcastes who have emigrated from the different states of British India, as well as modern India, to other countries and regions of the world, as well as their descendants.[46] Apart from the Indian subcontinent, there is a large and well-established community of Chamars throughout different continents of the world, including Malaysia, Canada, Singapore, Caribbean, USA and UK, where they have established themselves as a trade diaspora.[47]

Gurdwara Guru Ravidass, Nasinu, Fiji Established in 1939
Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Bhavan, Birmingham
Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Sabha, Southall
Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Temple, Auckland
Shri Guru Ravidass Temple in the UK
Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Temple, Pittsburg, California
Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Sabha, Oostende

Italy

[edit]

According to the research paper of the European University Institute, Fiesole, Italy, the Ravidassia Chamar community is the second largest group of Indian diaspora in Italy. The Ravidassia community's migration starts in the early 80s, and currently the community is operating 18 Guru Ravidass temples throughout Italy. But due to the lack of recognized independent religious identity by the Italian government, the local Italian community leaders assume Ravidasias are Hindu or Sikh.[48]

North America

[edit]

Chamar diaspora emigrated from India and Pakistan is significant. There are Chamar Sikh settlers in Europe, as well as a sizable Chamar Sikh population in North America, primarily in the United States and Canada. Mahiya Ram Mehmi and Mahey were the very first people who landed in British Columbia in 1906 and in Lower Mainland area of Britsih Colombia, there are around 25,000 people of Chamar origin residing. This makes the largest and oldest Chamar diaspora population in North America region. Both Mahiya ram Mehmi and Mahey were also involved in the foundation of the first Canadian Gurdwara, the Khalsa Diwan Society, Vancouver.[49] In the United States, an estimated 20,000 Ravidassia Chamars live in California.[50]

Mauritius

[edit]

Ravived is a caste that is mainly found among Hindus in Mauritius.[51] The origin of this caste lay in an Indian caste named Chamar[52] This same caste is referred to as Ravidassia outside Mauritius, and this terminology is very seldom used in Mauritius.[53]

In the ship records on which Indian laborers migrated to Mauritius, around ten percent of the boarded people mentioned their caste as Chamar. After the establishment of caste hierarchies in Mauritius, the Chamar community families turned to the religious songs of Kabir and Ravidass for their own religious outlet. Slowly, they started adopting religious-sounding names from these devotional songs.[54]

Oceania

[edit]

There is a sizeable population of Chamar Sikhs in Oceania too. Ravidassia Chamars from Doaba established the second gurdwara in the Oceania region in Nasinu on Fiji Island in 1939.[55] A Classical Study by W.H. Briggs in his book Punjabis in New Zealand, Briggs penned down the precise number of Ravidassias in New Zealand during the very first wave of immigration.[56]

United Kingdom

[edit]

Chamar community from Punjab started immigrating from Punjab to Britain in 1950, and according to a book named 'Sikhs in Britain: An Annotated Bibliography' published in 1987, the population of the Ravidassia community in the West Midlands was around 30,000 during that period.[57] As of 2021, it is estimated that the Ravidasia population in Britain is around 70,000.[58]

Occupations

[edit]
Photograph of Chamars with caption "Chamars cutting leather and making shoes"

Chamars transitioning from tanning and leathercraft to the weaving profession adopt the identity of Julaha Chamar, aspiring to be acknowledged as Julahas by other communities. According to R. K. Pruthi, this change reflects a desire to distance themselves from the perceived degradation associated with leatherwork.[59]

Chamar Regiment

[edit]

The 1st Chamar Regiment was an infantry regiment formed by the British during World War II. Officially, it was created on 1 March 1943, as the 27th Battalion 2nd Punjab Regiment. It was converted to the 1st Battalion and later disbanded shortly after World War II ended.[60] The Regiment, with one year of service, received three Military Crosses and three Military Medals[61] It fought in the Battle of Kohima.[62] In 2011, several politicians demanded that it be revived.[63]

Demographics

[edit]

Chamar caste population in different states of India as per the 2011 census of India

State, U.T Population Population % Notes
Bihar[64] 4,900,048 4.7% Counted along Rabidas, Rohidas, Chamar, Charamakar
Chandigarh[65] 59,957 5.68% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Chamars, Ramdasi, Ravidasi, Raigar and Jatia
Chhattisgarh[66] 2,318,964 9.07% Counted as Chamar, Satnami, Ahirwar, Raidas, Rohidas, Jatav, Bhambi and Surjyabanshi
NCT of Delhi[67] 1,075,569 6.4 % Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Jatav, Chamars, Ramdasia, Ravidasi, Raigar and Jatia
Gujarat[68] 1,032,128 1.7% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Chamar, Bhambi, Asadaru, Chambhar, Haralaya, Rohidas, Rohit, Samgar
Haryana[69] 2,429,137 9.58% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Jatav, Chamars, Ramdasia, Ravidasi, Raigar and Jatia
Himachal Pradesh[70] 458,838 6.68% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Chamars, Ramdasia, Raigar and Jatia
Jammu and Kashmir[71] 212,032 1.72% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Chamars, Ramdasia, Rohidas
Jharkhand[72] 1,008,507 3.05% Counted as Chamar, Mochi
Karnataka[73] 605,486 1% Counted as Rohidas, Rohit, Samgar, Haralaya, Chambhar, Chamar, Bhambi
Madhya Pradesh[74] 5,368,217 7.39% Counted as Chamar, Jatav, Bairwa, Bhambi, Rohidas, Raidas, Ahirwar,Satnami, Ramnami, Surjyabanshi
Maharashtra[75] 1,411,072 1.25% Counted as Rohidas, Chamar, Chambhar, Bhambi, Satnami, Ramnami, Haralaya, Rohit, Samagar, Bhambi
Punjab[76] 3,095,324 11.15% During the 2011 census in Punjab, 1017192 people were counted as addharmi in a separate caste cluster, which is another term for Ravidassias.[77][78]

In the same census, the Ravidassias cluster population was 2078132, and both clusters together made a population of 3095324 in Punjab, which is an 11.15% population of Punjab.

Rajasthan[79] 2,491,551 3.63% Counted along with other caste synonyms such as Chamars, Bhambi, Ramdasia, Ravidasi, Raigar, Haralaya, Chambhar and Jatia
Uttarakhand[80] 548,813 5.44% Counted as Chamar, Jatava, Dhusia, Jhusia
Uttar Pradesh[81] 22,496,047 11.25% Counted as Chamar, Jatava, Dhusia, Jhusia
West Bengal[82] 1,039,591 1.13% Counted as Chamar, Rabidas, Charamakar, Rishi

Caste reservation

[edit]
Main article: Reservation in India

Chamar is classified as a scheduled caste in India. It is claimed that among the scheduled castes, Chamar benefitted more from the caste reservation system as compared to other Dalit castes due to larger political representation of the group.[83] However, due to significant regional variation and intra-community diversity,[84] different communities end up disproportionately benefiting from the reservation across the country.[85][86] In 2024, the Supreme Court of India allowed further sub-categorisation within the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe categories, allowing states such as Punjab, Bihar, Tamil Nadu, and Andhra Pradesh to do targeted refinements to their reservation policies.[87][84]

Chamars in Nepal

[edit]

The Central Bureau of Statistics of Nepal classifies the Chamar as a subgroup within the broader social group of Madheshi Dalits.[88] At the time of the 2011 Nepal census, 335,893 people (1.3% of the population of Nepal) were Chamar. The frequency of Chamars by province was as follows:

The frequency of Chamars was higher than national average (1.3%) in the following districts:[89]

Notable people

[edit]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Chamar

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Chamar is a caste primarily residing in the northern and central regions of , historically associated with occupations involving animal hides, such as tanning and , a role derived from the term carmakāra meaning "leather worker." Classified as a Scheduled under 's affirmative action framework, the community constitutes one of the most populous subgroups among s, with estimates placing their numbers in the tens of millions, concentrated in states like , , , and . Traditionally viewed as untouchables due to the perceived ritual impurity of their trade—linked to contact with dead animals and cow products, which contravene Hindu purity norms—the Chamars have endured systemic , yet they have pursued upward mobility through conversions, , and political mobilization. A defining feature is their devotion to Guru Ravidas (c. 1450–1520), a Chamar-born poet-saint whose egalitarian verses critiquing hierarchy are central to the faith, a distinct religion that emerged from the community in the early following tensions with Sikh orthodoxy. In contemporary , Chamars have gained prominence in politics, exemplified by the Samaj Party's reliance on their electoral support, while diaspora communities in the UK, , and elsewhere maintain cultural institutions like gurdwaras that blend devotional practices with assertions of separate identity.

Origins and Etymology

Linguistic and Historical Roots

The term "Chamar" derives from the word charmakāra (or carmakāra), literally meaning "worker in hides" or " artisan," referring to individuals engaged in tanning animal skins, processing , and crafting such as shoes. This etymology underscores the community's historical association with hereditary occupations involving the handling of animal carcasses and byproducts, a practical specialization in agrarian economies where such labor supported by utilizing hides from slaughtered . In ancient Indian texts, leather-working roles like those of the charmakāra are linked to the varna, the societal division encompassing service and artisanal trades essential for material sustenance, as outlined in the (circa 200 BCE–200 CE), which categorizes such manual professions without prescribing inherent moral inferiority but reflecting ritual purity norms tied to contact with death and decay. This textual framework emphasizes causal divisions of labor: tanning required skills in chemical preservation of perishable hides using vegetable or minerals, a process demanding specialized knowledge passed generationally to prevent spoilage in tropical climates. Archaeological evidence supports the antiquity of leather craftsmanship in the , with artifacts from the Indus Valley Civilization (circa 2600–1900 BCE) at sites like revealing tools for hide processing, such as awls and scrapers, alongside impressions of goods in pottery molds, indicating organized production for trade and utility. These findings, corroborated by Mesopotamian records of Indus exports, demonstrate empirical continuity in specialized hide-working from prehistoric urban centers through medieval periods, where vessels and straps appear in excavations at sites like (circa 500 BCE–500 CE), predating rigidification and highlighting economic pragmatism over later social overlays.

Historical Development

Pre-Colonial and Medieval Periods

In pre-colonial and , the Chamar community specialized in leather processing, and tanning hides from naturally deceased , sheep, and goats to produce essential items such as , bullock harnesses, saddles, and for blacksmiths. These goods were indispensable for agricultural operations, , and artisanal trades in agrarian villages, where served as primary draft animals. Within the —a hereditary patron-client network governing rural labor division—Chamars supplied these products to landowning families (jajmans) from higher castes, receiving payments in grain, clothing, or land access in return, which sustained economic interdependence amid ritual pollution taboos associated with handling dead animals. This occupational niche concentrated Chamars in northern India's cattle-rich regions, including , , and , where abundant livestock deaths from disease or age provided raw materials, and drier climates facilitated hide preservation. Mughal administrative practices and the broader Indo-Islamic economy reinforced village self-sufficiency, with leatherworkers contributing to local markets and regional trade in hides and finished goods, as hides from were often processed for export to urban centers in . The system's rigidity, enforced through jati guilds, limited mobility but ensured steady demand for Chamar skills, as evidenced by their allocation of the highest jajmani shares among servicing castes due to the indispensable nature of their work. Historical accounts from the period reveal no records of widespread Chamar-led revolts against structures, unlike later colonial-era mobilizations; instead, the community employed adaptive strategies such as specializing in sub-trades like cord-making or field labor to supplement income during lean seasons, while leveraging the jajmani's reciprocal obligations for survival. This integration reflected causal economic necessities—agriculture's reliance on —over ideological confrontation, with social positioning determined by utility in a pre-industrial order rather than egalitarian ideals. European travelers' observations of 16th- to 18th-century noted the system's occupational fixity without highlighting Chamar-specific unrest, underscoring stable, if hierarchical, coexistence.

Colonial Era Mobilization

British colonial censuses from the 1870s onward enumerated castes extensively, categorizing Chamars within the "Depressed Classes" due to their association with work deemed ritually impure. The identified Chamars as one of the largest groups among these classes, with a total population of approximately 4.65 million, showing concentrations in the United Provinces (over 50% of the community's numbers) and , where they comprised significant rural labor pools. This official labeling intensified missionary efforts, as Christian organizations viewed Depressed Classes like Chamars as prime candidates for conversion, providing schools and that led to thousands of baptisms, particularly in northern by the early . British policies also channeled Chamars into urban roles, such as municipal scavenging, which offered steady wages but perpetuated stigma while enabling some migration from villages. Community responses emphasized self-assertion over mere reaction to colonial impositions, with the establishment of organizations like the UP Chamar Mahasabha around the early 1900s to demand access to , jobs, and tenancy . Leaders within these groups promoted literacy drives and petitions against discriminatory practices, framing upliftment as a endeavor rooted in inherent capabilities rather than external , as evidenced by early conferences challenging untouchability's persistence under British rule. Such mobilization balanced administrative categorization's constraints with proactive strategies for socioeconomic advancement. Colonial economic policies disrupted hereditary leather trades through competition from European industrialized imports of boots and harnesses, which undercut village-level production by the late 19th century, while raw hide exports to Britain depleted local supplies. In response, colonial gazetteers and reports note Chamars' diversification efforts, including entry into modern tanneries in Kanpur—spurred by British military demand—and advocacy for agricultural leases to reduce dependence on stigmatized crafts. These shifts, documented in administrative records, highlighted adaptive agency amid broader industrialization's uneven impacts.

Post-Independence Evolution

Following India's independence in 1947, the adoption of the Constitution on January 26, 1950, classified Chamars as a Scheduled Caste, granting access to affirmative action measures including reservations in education, public sector employment, and legislative seats. These policies facilitated gradual socioeconomic mobility, with national Scheduled Caste literacy rates rising from approximately 10.3% in 1961 to 66.6% for males by 2001, driven by expanded access to primary education and quotas in higher institutions. In Uttar Pradesh, where Jatav (a prominent Chamar subcaste) predominates, Scheduled Caste literacy improved from low single digits in the 1951 census era to 36.75% overall by recent assessments, reflecting targeted interventions amid persistent regional disparities. Urban migration accelerated among Chamars from the 1970s onward, as in the sector—traditionally their hereditary occupation—reduced demand for artisanal labor, prompting shifts to industrial cities like and for factory work and informal economies. This transition was compounded by technological upgrades in tanning and production during the 1970s and 1980s, which prioritized machine-operated processes over manual skills, leading to job displacement but also diversification into non-leather trades supported by reservation-enabled entry into government services. Economic liberalization in the 1990s further reshaped opportunities, with deregulation fostering private sector growth and export-oriented leather manufacturing, though benefits were uneven; while some Chamars leveraged education quotas for white-collar roles, many remained in low-skill urban labor amid mechanized industry contraction. The Bihar caste survey released in October 2023 enumerated Chamars (including synonyms like Mochi, Ravidas, and Charmkar) at 5.25% of the state's 130.7 million population, or about 6.87 million individuals, underscoring subcaste consolidation and deviation from homogenized "Dalit" categorizations in policy discourse. This data highlights internal socioeconomic stratification, with urbanized subgroups showing higher literacy and asset ownership compared to rural counterparts, attributable to cumulative effects of quotas and migration rather than uniform upliftment.

Subcastes and Regional Identities

Major Subcastes in India

The Chamar in comprises numerous regional subcastes, each with self-identified distinctions shaped by local histories, occupations, and social assertions, though generally prevails within subgroups to maintain internal cohesion. Ethnographic accounts note that while traditional leatherworking persists in rural areas, urban and agrarian subgroups often diverge, with fewer adhering to tanning due to economic diversification and stigma avoidance. Some oral traditions among subgroups, particularly Jatavs, assert Kshatriya-like origins from ancient rulers, though these lack corroboration in historical records and contrast with hereditary . Jatavs, concentrated in , form a politically assertive subcaste that has mobilized through organizations like the Jatav Mahasabha since the early , emphasizing and anti-discrimination efforts over traditional trades. Urban Jatavs, numbering significantly in cities like and , have largely shifted from leatherwork to small businesses, government jobs, and politics, with 2011 census data showing over 20 million Jatavs in alone as a Scheduled Caste bloc. They practice strict , with gotra-based marriage rules reinforcing subgroup identity. Ahirwars, prevalent in and the region, represent another major subcaste with adaptations toward and labor migration, moving away from leather-related occupations amid post-independence land access and pressures. In like Sagar and , Ahirwars have engaged in crop cultivation and construction, benefiting from Scheduled quotas, though caste tensions persist in rural settings. is observed, with community panchayats regulating alliances to preserve lineage purity. In , the Dhusia subcaste maintains ties to Chamar identity but incorporates regional crafts, listed alongside Jatavas in state Scheduled Caste schedules from the 1950s onward. Occupational adherence varies, with some rural Dhusias involved in or allied trades rather than tanning, reflecting empirical shifts documented in northern Indian caste surveys. Ad-Dharmis in , emerging from early 20th-century reformist identities, have leveraged land reforms under the Punjab Land Reforms Act of 1972, enabling many to acquire holdings up to 17.5 acres per family unit and transition from jajmani labor to independent farming. This subcaste, constituting a significant portion in central , practices while asserting distinct cultural markers, with 2011 village-level data indicating their prominence among Scheduled Castes alongside Chamars.

Variations in Nepal

In Nepal, Chamars are classified as a Dalit subgroup within the Madhesi or Tarai-origin castes, subject to constitutional protections against caste-based discrimination as outlined in the 2015 Constitution, which recognizes Dalits as historically marginalized communities facing social exclusion. This status aligns with earlier legal frameworks, such as the 1990 Constitution's prohibition on caste discrimination, though enforcement remains inconsistent due to entrenched customary practices in rural areas. Unlike their Indian counterparts, Nepalese Chamars exhibit adaptations to the subtropical Terai lowlands, where ecological factors like seasonal flooding influence their settlement patterns and resource access for traditional trades. The 2011 National Population and Housing Census recorded 335,893 Chamars, representing 1.3% of 's total population, with the vast majority concentrated in the districts of Provinces 1, 2, and 5, where they form part of the 19 Tarai castes comprising about 6.7% of the regional demographic. Traditional occupations center on processing animal byproducts, including leather tanning, , and handling carcasses from local livestock such as and goats, often supplemented by agricultural labor in flood-prone paddy fields. These roles persist amid economic vulnerabilities, with many households reliant on seasonal wage work due to limited land ownership—averaging under 0.5 hectares per family in areas—and exclusion from higher-value farming. Post-2006, following the end of the Maoist insurgency, Chamars have participated in labor mobilization efforts tied to reconstruction and development programs in the , where conflict-disrupted exacerbated poverty rates exceeding 40% among groups as of 2011 surveys. Economic data indicate heightened vulnerability to in informal sectors, with cross-border migration to for leather-related work common, driven by stagnant local markets and limiting access to formal credit—only 15% of households in reported bank loans in a 2014 study. Religious shifts show limited but notable conversions to , estimated at under 5% per ethnographic profiles, often linked to missionary outreach in underserved villages influenced by Indian border networks, though the majority retain Hindu practices centered on figures like Ravidass.

Religion and Culture

Traditional Practices and Beliefs

The Chamars adhered to a syncretic form of incorporating local folk elements, accepting core doctrines such as karma and samsara while worshipping village and household deities including Bahiroba, Janai, , and , often aligned with Shaiva and Vaishnava sects. Ancestor veneration featured prominently through rituals honoring familial spirits at household shrines, alongside participation in broader Hindu festivals like and , adapted to their socioeconomic context. Their principal communal festival, Sri Panchami, occurred on the fifth day of the lunar month of Magh (January-February), involving offerings and gatherings centered on devotional practices. Occupational beliefs intertwined with ritual purity norms, where handling hides from deceased animals—central to tanning and —incurred notions of due to contact with decomposing , a practical mechanism rooted in averting and transmission akin to imperatives observed across agrarian societies. This taboo reinforced endogamous occupational specialization, as Chamars avoided inter-caste intermingling in trades to preserve boundaries, evidenced by ethnographic accounts of segregated work sites and purity observances post-contact with carcasses. Family structures facilitated hereditary transmission of artisanal skills, with extended kin groups common in rural settings to enable in processing techniques, as noted in mid-20th-century village ethnographies where multi-generational households supported continuity amid economic interdependence. Oral narratives traced Chamar lineage to ancient charmakaras (skin workers), aligning with etymological roots and corroborated by genetic analyses revealing sustained in populations, including lower-caste clusters exhibiting distinct allele frequencies indicative of millennia-scale tied to vocational roles. The religion draws from the teachings of the 15th-century , who emphasized or devotion to a formless God through inner purity rather than external rituals or -based practices. , born into a Chamar family around 1450 in , composed verses rejecting social hierarchies and promoting spiritual equality, which resonated with marginalized communities seeking alternatives to ritualistic . His hymns, included in the , initially aligned followers with , but persistent caste dynamics within Sikh institutions fostered demands for a distinct identity preserving Chamar heritage. A pivotal schism from occurred following the May 24, 2009, attack at the Shri Guru Ravidass Gurdwara in , , where six Sikh assailants shot and killed Sant Ramanand Das, injuring Sant Niranjan Dass and over a dozen others during a religious gathering. This incident, attributed to objections over practices diverging from Sikh orthodoxy, triggered riots in northern and prompted Dera Sachkhand Ballan leaders to declare a separate faith. In response, many temples replaced the with the Amritbani Guru Ravidass , a compilation of Ravidas's 240 hymns, elevating him to supreme status over . This move rejected Sikh claims of assimilation, prioritizing caste-specific devotion amid historical exclusion. Primarily adhered to by Punjab's Ramdasia and Chamar communities, Ravidassia counts an estimated 2 to 5 million followers worldwide, concentrated in and diasporas in the UK, , and . Community estimates often inflate figures to 20-30 million by including broader Chamar populations, but census data from , where Ravidasias and Ramdasias comprise about 21% of residents, supports a more modest core adherent base. Tensions persist with over scriptural reverence, as Ravidassias view the Guru Granth Sahib's inclusion of Ravidas's bani as insufficient without exclusive primacy, reflecting causal persistence of endogamous identities against egalitarian ideals. Related movements, such as those under Dera Sachkhand, maintain separate gurdwaras emphasizing Ravidas's anti-ritual , fostering community-specific free from perceived Sikh dominance.

Occupations and Economy

Hereditary Trades and Challenges

The Chamars traditionally specialized in dead animals, tanning hides, and crafting goods such as shoes and bottles, occupations that utilized byproducts from naturally deceased in agrarian societies where live slaughter was culturally prohibited due to religious reverence for cows. This division of labor aligned with , as hides from animals dying of or —estimated at millions annually in India's population—provided raw material without conflicting with predominant Hindu practices, supporting local and export markets for products via historical routes like the . Tanning processes involved labor-intensive handling of hides, but introduced inherent difficulties, including exposure to toxic chemicals like used in modernizing colonial-era methods, leading to documented health risks such as , DNA damage, respiratory issues, and elevated cancer incidence among workers in Kanpur's tanneries. Groundwater contamination from these facilities has further amplified non-occupational risks, with levels exceeding safe limits by factors of 100 or more in affected areas, correlating with disorders and neurological effects in surrounding populations. Social stigma associated with handling "impure" animal remains compounded these challenges, empirically restricting access to credit and markets through caste-based networks that undervalued Chamar collateral and excluded them from broader trade partnerships, perpetuating low-capital artisanal production. In response, Chamars demonstrated agency through early 20th-century self-organization, including the formation of caste associations like the Chamar Mahasabha to advocate for industry interests and mitigate exclusion from colonial leather supply chains dominated by European firms.

Contemporary Economic Shifts

Following India's in 1991, members of the Chamar community, particularly the subcaste in , have increasingly engaged in small-scale and entrepreneurship within the sector. In , a major hub, Jatavs constitute the predominant workforce in the leather footwear cluster, employing over 100,000 workers and supporting around 60 exporters who generated approximately Rs. 1,100 crores in annual export revenue by the early 2000s, with the cluster accounting for 22% of India's total footwear exports. This shift reflects broader post-liberalization opportunities in unorganized , where among Scheduled Castes expanded due to private capital growth, though often limited to low-value chains dominated by informal artisanal production. Urban Chamar populations continue to face elevated poverty rates, with National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) data from 2011-12 indicating that around 25-30% of Scheduled Caste households in urban areas remained below the poverty line, compared to lower rates among upper castes, highlighting persistent economic vulnerabilities despite sectoral diversification into retail and services. In contrast, remittances from Chamar diaspora communities in the UK, Canada, and elsewhere have bolstered rural asset accumulation, funding land purchases and housing improvements in origin villages, thereby offsetting local income deficits through migrant earnings in overseas services and manual labor. Critics attribute ongoing reliance on informal —encompassing over 90% of India's , with Scheduled Castes disproportionately represented—to educational and deficiencies that restrict access to formal, high-skill sectors. Periodic Labour Force Survey data reveal caste-based gaps in skilled job participation, with labor force involvement skewed toward casual and self-employed roles lacking social security, underscoring the need for targeted skill development amid post-1990s structural shifts.

Social and Political Dynamics

Early Reform Associations

The , established in on October 28, 1917, under leaders such as Pt. Sundarlal Sagar, marked an early self-help initiative among the Chamar () community in , prioritizing education and social purification to elevate status through rather than external interventions. This association, later linked to the Akhil Bharatiya Jatav Mahasabha founded by figures including Manik Chand , conducted membership drives in districts like and , fostering via pamphlets and gatherings that stressed merit-based advancement. Subsequent groups reinforced these efforts with pragmatic reforms, including the Jatav Pracharak Mandal formed in 1924 to propagate educational upliftment and the Chamar Mahasabha inaugurated in in May 1924, which organized conferences across 24 districts such as and . These associations advocated temperance through bans on consumption, promotion of , and incentives to abandon hereditary work, imposing fines for non-adherence to purity codes aimed at claiming Kshatriya-like respectability within Hindu society. Unlike broader Adi-Hindu movements emphasizing pre-Aryan origins and , Jatav-led initiatives rejected such mythological repositioning in favor of tangible self-reform, as evidenced in conferences highlighting and economic over identity-based . These early associations yielded measurable gains in and enrollment among Jatavs before 1947, driven by prosperity from and targeted drives like those of the later Jatav Jan Shiksha Sansthan (1939), which built on prior momentum to counter narratives of inherent dependency by demonstrating community-led progress in districts with active chapters.

Rise of Political Influence

The (BSP), established by on April 14, 1984, channeled Chamar aspirations into organized electoral politics by advocating for Bahujan (majority) interests, primarily drawing from communities including the subcaste predominant in . Under Mayawati, Kanshi Ram's successor, the BSP achieved its pinnacle in the 2007 Uttar Pradesh assembly elections, securing 206 of 403 seats—a rare outright majority—and enabling Mayawati's full-term tenure as from May 13, 2007, to March 15, 2012. This victory stemmed from strategic broadening beyond core voters to include upper-caste support, yielding a 30.43% vote share amid high turnout. In , consolidation proved pivotal, with the subcaste exhibiting bloc voting patterns that amplified BSP leverage in regional alliances during the 2010s, such as tacit understandings with other communities in local polls. This cohesion influenced outcomes in Jatav-heavy districts, where voter mobilization rates exceeded state averages, enabling shifts like partial alignments with the or in select contests. However, such identity-driven strategies often prioritized arithmetic over programmatic appeals, contributing to BSP's post-2007 reversals, including a vote share plunge to 22.23% in the assembly polls and further erosion to 12.88% by 2022. Critics, including political analysts, argue that BSP's reliance on vote-bank consolidation exacerbated fragmentation in Dalit politics, diluting potential for wider anti-establishment coalitions and allowing rivals like the BJP to siphon disillusioned voters through alternative narratives. Electoral data underscores this, with BSP's parliamentary seats dropping from 10 in 2009 to zero in 2014 and 2019, reflecting splintered Dalit support amid perceived leadership missteps and failure to adapt beyond caste silos. This pattern highlights causal trade-offs in identity mobilization: short-term gains via ethnic solidarity but long-term vulnerabilities to counter-mobilization and internal divisions.

Military History

Formation and Role of Chamar Regiment

The Chamar Regiment was raised by the British Indian Army on 1 March 1943 as an infantry unit composed primarily of recruits from the Chamar community, a group traditionally associated with leatherworking and classified as a lower Hindu caste. Initially designated as the 27th Battalion before formalizing as the 1st Chamar Regiment, it was assigned to the 268th Indian Infantry Brigade within the 15th Corps under General William Slim, specifically to bolster forces for operations in the Burma theater against Japanese advances. The regiment participated in key engagements of the , including defensive actions in the Imphal-Kohima sector in 1944, where units under the broader corps structure earned recognition for holding critical positions amid intense and supply challenges. British military records note instances of gallantry citations awarded to Chamar Regiment personnel for combat effectiveness in these battles, contributing to the eventual turning of the tide against Japanese forces through resilient assaults and perimeter defense. Disbanded in amid postwar demobilization and army restructuring to reduce caste-specific units in favor of a more integrated peacetime force, the decision reflected broader British efforts to streamline the following the war's end, though operational records affirmed the regiment's reliability in sustained combat roles. No direct evidence ties the disbandment to the 1946 , which primarily involved naval ratings and separate loyalty concerns unrelated to infantry caste regiments' battlefield performance. Post-independence, demands for reviving the have periodically arisen from Scheduled Caste advocacy groups, such as the in 2017, arguing that its historical combat record demonstrates the value of community-specific recruitment for enhancing and effectiveness, rather than reliance on general quotas. These calls emphasize of the regiment's contributions in WWII over symbolic affirmative measures, positing that targeted enlistment from proven martial communities could improve overall military readiness without diluting merit-based standards.

Demographics and Distribution

Population Statistics in India

In , the Chamar community—enumerated in the alongside related groups such as , Dhusia, and Jhusia—numbered 22,496,047 individuals, constituting approximately 11.25% of the state's total of 199.8 million and over 54% of its population. The subcaste alone accounted for about 54% of Uttar Pradesh's total in , down slightly from 56.3% in the previous decadal , highlighting its dominance within the broader Chamar grouping in the state. These figures underscore Uttar Pradesh as the epicenter of Chamar demographics, with concentrations particularly high in western and central districts. In , the 2023 state caste survey reported that Chamar, , , and Charmkar together comprised 5.25% of the , equating to roughly 6.87 million individuals out of a total of 130.7 million. Adjusting for Bihar's of 104 million, this proportion suggests a comparable share of around 5 million Chamars at that time, reflecting steady demographic weight amid the state's overall growth rate of 25.4% from 2001 to . Nationally, aggregating state-level data yields an estimated 50-60 million Chamars in , forming a substantial portion—potentially 10-12%—of India's total Scheduled of 201.4 million, though exact national sub-caste breakdowns remain unavailable due to methodologies. Literacy among Scheduled Castes, encompassing the population, reached 66.1% in , marking a marked rise from 10.3% in 1961 and even lower rates around 8-9% in 1951, attributable in part to expanded access to under reservation policies yet tempered by persistent rural-urban and gender disparities (e.g., SC literacy at 56.5% versus at 75.2%). trends showed about 17-18% of Scheduled Castes residing in urban areas by , up from under 10% in 1971, indicating gradual shifts driven by migration but with internal variations, as rural Chamars in states like lagged behind urban counterparts in access to amenities. These patterns reveal demographic growth aligned with national averages (17.7% decadal increase for SCs) but highlight uneven progress across subcaste and regional lines.

Global Diaspora Presence

![Gurdwara Guru Ravidass Bhavan, Birmingham][float-right] The Chamar diaspora, often aligned with the community, established significant communities in the and through labor migration waves peaking in the , driven by industrial demands in post-war economies. Punjabi migrants, including Ad-Dharmi subgroups from the Chamar , arrived primarily from rural to fill factory roles in cities like and Birmingham, with chain migration sustaining growth via networks. By 2021, the population in the UK reached approximately 70,000, reflecting sustained community formation amid ongoing dynamics. In , similar patterns emerged among Chamar Sikh settlers, contributing to North American Punjabi networks. In , Chamar-linked migrants arrived post-1990s, forming the largest Punjabi in the , attracted by agricultural opportunities in regions like the . This migration involved chain networks from , integrating into low-wage farm labor despite exploitation challenges, with community identity reinforced through distinct religious practices separate from mainstream . Smaller pockets trace to 19th-century indentured labor systems, with Chamar groups among early Indian arrivals in from 1834 and , where they participated in plantation economies. In , including and , settlers established gurdwaras, such as in Nasinu, Fiji, preserving cultural ties from colonial-era displacements. These communities demonstrate patterns of entrepreneurship and adaptation, with networks funding homeland kin through remittances, though specific Chamar flows remain embedded in broader Indian totals exceeding $135 billion annually as of FY25. Cultural retention manifests via Guru Ravidass temples worldwide, serving as hubs for identity assertion and community organization in cities like Birmingham, , and Sacramento, countering assimilation pressures and fostering intergenerational ties. These institutions underscore causal links between migration drivers—economic opportunity and escape from —and sustained ethnic cohesion abroad.

Affirmative Action

Reservation Policies and Implementation

The Indian Constitution provides for affirmative action for Scheduled Castes (SCs), including the Chamar caste, through Article 341, which authorizes the President to notify specific castes, races, or tribes as SCs for each state and union territory, and Article 335, which requires consideration of SC claims to appointments in public services and posts, balanced against administrative efficiency. The Chamar caste was included in the initial SC list via the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950, promulgated on August 10, 1950, which enumerated Chamars (along with synonyms like Jatava or Jatav) as eligible across multiple states such as Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, and Bihar, subject to regional variations and exclusions for converts to non-Hindu, non-Sikh, or non-Buddhist faiths. Implementation of SC reservations allocates 15% of seats in jobs (Groups A, B, C, and D) and higher education institutions, with direct quotas enforced through competitive exams like the ; states adjust to 16-22.5% based on local SC population shares (e.g., 21% in , where Chamars form a significant portion). Post-1995 constitutional amendments via the 77th, 81st, 82nd, and 85th Amendments enabled reservations in promotions, upheld by the in M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (2006) with conditions for backwardness data and efficiency maintenance. Carry-forward rules allow unfilled SC vacancies to roll over up to 50% of total seats in a cycle, though implementation faces backlogs, with over 50,000 SC-reserved central government posts vacant as of 2023 due to litigation and candidate shortages. Empirical outcomes show SC representation in civil services rising from negligible levels—less than 1% in the during the 1950s, with the first SC IAS officer, Achyutananda Das, selected in 1951—to around 15% by the 2020s in direct recruits, reflecting quota utilization amid expanded coaching and awareness programs, though senior echelons lag due to promotion bottlenecks. The 1993 Indra Sawhney v. Union of India ruling (Mandal case) introduced exclusions for Other Backward Classes to target aid at the truly disadvantaged but exempted SCs/STs from such economic cutoffs, preserving caste-based eligibility without income thresholds, as SC disadvantages were deemed more entrenched and less reversible. This has enabled broader SC access but sparked debates on intra-caste inequities, with sub-quotas proposed in states like (2016) to prioritize most backward SC subgroups, including certain Chamar sections, without altering overall mechanics.

Outcomes and Empirical Impacts

Reservation policies have facilitated improved access to education for Scheduled Castes (SCs), including the Chamar community, with data indicating higher literacy and school enrollment rates compared to earlier rounds, though inter-caste gaps in persist due to differences in quality and completion rates. For instance, SC children continue to lag in height-for-age metrics as a proxy for nutritional and educational deficits, remaining 0.4 standard deviations shorter than upper-caste peers, reflecting ongoing socioeconomic barriers despite quota-enabled entry. Income and wealth disparities endure, with SC households facing significantly lower average annual incomes and weaker economic returns on relative to the general category, as evidenced by analyses of household surveys showing diminished productivity gains from schooling for SCs. Upper castes, comprising about 25% of the population, hold 55% of national wealth, underscoring limited upward mobility from public-sector quotas alone, where private-sector credit access for SCs remains constrained by caste-based . Critiques highlight potential merit dilution in promotions and institutional efficiency, with claims of increased judicial backlogs linked to lowered selection standards, though direct causal evidence remains contested in peer-reviewed . Econometric assessments suggest reservations institutionalize categories, perpetuating identity-based consciousness rather than eroding it, as beneficiaries navigate opportunities framed by ascriptive group affiliations. While quotas enable initial mobility, empirical patterns reveal their limits without complementary factors; SC entrepreneurship in the private sector has grown modestly, with enterprises often smaller, family-based, and concentrated in traditional occupations like leatherwork, indicating reliance on state mechanisms hinders broader diversification and sustained wealth accumulation. This underscores quotas as partial correctives to historical exclusion, where deficits constrain private gains despite policy interventions.

Notable Contributions

Political and Social Leaders

Swami Achutanand (1879–1933), a key early social reformer from the Chamar community in , founded the Adi-Hindu movement in the 1920s, promoting a distinct identity for s as original inhabitants predating invasion and rejecting assimilation into reformist Hindu groups like . His writings, including poetry and tracts in vernacular and , advocated for untouchables' rights, separate electorates, and cultural assertion, influencing Dalit consciousness in northern through organizations like the Adi-Hindu Mahasabha established around 1922. Jagjivan Ram (1908–1986), born into a family in , emerged as a prominent leader and advocate for Scheduled Castes during India's independence struggle and post-1947 governance. He served in multiple ministerial roles, including as Minister of Labour and Communications, and became from 1977 to 1979, focusing on labor reforms and upliftment programs for depressed classes while navigating intra-party dynamics to advance representation. Kanshi Ram (1934–2006), from a Ramdasia Chamar Sikh family in , initiated the in 1981 and founded the (BSP) on April 14, 1984, to consolidate Scheduled Castes, Tribes, Other Backward Classes, and minorities against upper-caste dominance. His strategy emphasized grassroots mobilization, "" arithmetic, and Ambedkarite ideology adapted for broader coalitions, laying the groundwork for BSP's breakthrough in politics despite initial limited electoral wins. Mayawati (born January 15, 1956), from the subcaste of Chamars in , rose within BSP after Kanshi Ram's mentorship and succeeded him as party president in 2003, becoming the first woman to serve multiple terms as Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh: June 3, 1995–October 18, 1995; March 21, 1997–September 21, 1997; May 3, 2002–August 29, 2003; and May 13, 2007–March 15, 2012. Under her leadership, BSP achieved its landmark 2007 assembly victory, securing 206 of 403 seats through a rainbow coalition transcending bases, enabling policies like infrastructure development in areas and welfare schemes, though criticized for centralizing power and deviating from Kanshi Ram's mass-based vision toward personality-driven control. leaders allied with B.R. Ambedkar's legacy, blending reverence with constitutional advocacy, propelled BSP's focus on reservations and anti-discrimination enforcement.

Military and Cultural Figures

The , raised by the British in 1943 as an infantry unit primarily from the Chamar community, served in against Japanese forces during , demonstrating combat effectiveness despite initial skepticism toward non-"" castes. One notable officer, Captain Mohan Lal Kureel, exemplified determination by defecting as a to join Subhas Chandra Bose's in pursuit of independence, leading to his and imprisonment by British authorities after the war. Earlier, during the 1857 Indian Rebellion, (1820–1857) from Kuarpur village in Jaunpur led guerrilla actions against British forces, coordinating local resistance until his capture and execution, highlighting early contributions from the community. In cultural spheres, Ginni Mahi, a Punjabi singer from a Chamar background in , rose to prominence through self-produced music addressing identity and social issues, with her 2016 track "Danger Chamar" going viral and amassing millions of views for reclaiming a slur as an of . Starting performances at local events and school competitions around age 10, she released devotional albums like Guruan Di Diwani (2015) and Gurpurab Hai Kanshi Wale Da, blending folk and pop to honor figures such as Guru Ravidas and , while performing internationally, including at Germany's Global Media Forum. Her independent ascent via and small labels underscores entrepreneurial grit in the arts, countering narratives of systemic dependency through market-driven success. Contemporary visual artist Akash Jatav, from the subgroup, captures everyday Chamar life in expressive paintings using earthy tones to depict labor and resilience, gaining recognition for works that challenge stereotypes without institutional patronage. These figures illustrate tangible, self-reliant achievements in military valor and creative expression, rooted in community-driven efforts rather than external aid.

Controversies and Critiques

Religious Schisms and Identity Conflicts

On May 24, 2009, six armed Sikh men attacked a temple in , , killing Sant Ramanand Dass, the deputy head of Ballan, and injuring Sant Niranjan Dass; the assailants objected to perceived alterations in the recitation of hymns from the during a . This incident, rooted in longstanding frictions over devotional practices diverging from Sikh orthodoxy, directly precipitated the formal , as it heightened fears among Ravidassia followers of marginalization within Sikh institutions. In response, on January 30, 2010, Ravidassia leaders at a gathering in , , declared a distinct , adopting the Amritbani Guru Ravidass Ji as their scripture, which compiles writings attributed to Ravidas while excluding broader Sikh texts, and removing copies of the from their temples. This separation intensified scriptural tensions with , who maintain that the Guru Granth Sahib's authority is indivisible and view elevating Ravidas from bhagat (devotee) to guru status as a challenge to Sikh epistemic norms. Ravidassia adherents, conversely, frame this as reclaiming their founder's centrality, free from hierarchical impositions. The schism manifested in physical proliferations of independent Ravidassia temples post-2010, particularly in the UK diaspora, where communities established dedicated gurdwaras emphasizing Ravidas's teachings, such as the Guru Ravidass Sabhas in Southall and Birmingham, signaling institutional autonomy. Identity conflicts persist, with Ravidassia separation positioned by proponents as empowering Chamar-specific assertion against caste-based erasure in Sikhism, yet critiqued by some Dalit unity advocates as fragmenting broader anti-caste coalitions that historically leveraged Sikh egalitarianism. Hindu perspectives occasionally claim Ravidassia as an assimilable Bhakti offshoot within Hinduism to counter separatism, though such views overlook the community's explicit rejection of Vedic authority in favor of Ravidas's egalitarian critique.

Socioeconomic Dependency Debates

Critiques of socioeconomic dependency among the Chamar community, particularly its Jatav subcaste in Uttar Pradesh, center on arguments that affirmative action policies like reservations have inadvertently promoted reliance on state quotas rather than entrepreneurial initiative, potentially breeding complacency in accessing education and government jobs. Empirical observations note that while reservations have facilitated entry into public sector roles, they correlate with underrepresentation in private enterprise, where self-reliance demands competitive skills unbuffered by quotas; for instance, Scheduled Caste enterprise ownership remains low despite policy support, suggesting barriers beyond discrimination to cultural or motivational factors. Contrasting this, successful Jatav entrepreneurs like Deepak Jatav, a footwear manufacturer from Saharanpur who built a thriving business through design innovation and market expansion without reliance on reserved categories, exemplify paths to prosperity via traditional leather trade modernization and political networking for protection, not subsidies. Internal community analyses highlight subcaste divisions and rivalries as impediments to cohesive advancement, with dominant Jatav groups within the broader Chamar fold often monopolizing reserved benefits—capturing over two-thirds of Uttar Pradesh's Scheduled Caste quotas—while marginalizing smaller subgroups like Valmikis, fostering resentment and fragmented political unity. Such dynamics, per political scholarship, undermine collective bargaining power and perpetuate intra-Dalit competition over limited resources, as seen in disputes over sub-categorization that pit numerically superior Jatavs against less advantaged peers. Assertions of identity and rights in the , amid rising political mobilization in , frequently escalated into violent clashes, illustrating the costs of confrontational strategies over negotiated ; reports document retaliatory attacks on Chamar settlements following disputes over land and processions, as in broader conflicts where defiance provoked upper-caste reprisals, resulting in arson and fatalities without proportional socioeconomic gains. Left-leaning media and academic narratives, often sourced from groups with institutional biases toward emphasizing perpetual exploitation, overstate victimhood while downplaying pre-independence Chamar mobilizations like the Mahasabha's 1920s campaigns for education and status claims, which predated quotas and stressed community self-upliftment through associations and leather industry cooperatives. Similarly, the Ravidassia —largely Chamar-origin migrants to and —demonstrates via emigration-driven , achieving professional diversification and gurdwara-funded welfare by the through remittances and labor migration, independent of Indian state aid. These examples underscore causal factors like individual agency and global networks over systemic barriers alone in explaining variance in outcomes.

References

  1. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/chamar
  2. https://joshuaproject.net/people_groups/16561/IN
  3. https://pragyata.com/the-real-cost-of-leather-chamars-cow-and-colonialism/
  4. https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/16/7/922
  5. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590291125005078
  6. https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/chamars
  7. https://www.wisdomlib.org/definition/charmakara
  8. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-history-of-chamars
  9. https://www.instagram.com/p/DNfl47HyZjW/
  10. https://www.instagram.com/reel/DEtdIXUTbTq/
  11. https://artkarel.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/karel-indus-valley-1.pdf
  12. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44124164
  13. https://www.jstor.org/stable/312475
  14. https://foundationchamar.org/the-leather-archive-of-india
  15. https://www.quora.com/Why-werent-there-any-Dalit-revolts-in-Indian-history-in-the-ancient-and-medieval-periods
  16. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00194646231183350
  17. https://oaji.net/pdf.html?n=2021/1201-1615364642.pdf
  18. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/380324362_Social_Condition_of_Chamar_in_United_Provinces_under_Colonial_Rule
  19. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383532688_EVOLUTION_OF_CHAMAR_AND_JATAV_MAHASABHA_FOR_DALIT_SOCIETY_IN_UNITED_PROVINCES
  20. https://www.scitcentral.com/documents/dd6865e717990586a80a4bfa519de448.pdf
  21. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5327158
  22. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Prashant-Kain-2/publication/329520265_Caste_Labour_and_History_The_Leather_Workers_of_Agra_During_the_Colonial_Period/links/5c0d047ca6fdcc494fe58dcd/Caste-Labour-and-History-The-Leather-Workers-of-Agra-During-the-Colonial-Period.pdf
  23. https://www.cuhimachal.ac.in/admin/assets/uploads/researchPublications/20230328180832dc7d28b409.pdf
  24. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-asian-studies/article/out-of-tradition-master-artisans-and-economic-change-in-colonial-india/C8D8575BB73372C4B5B0FD722321F712
  25. https://www.mospi.gov.in/sites/default/files/reports_and_publication/statistical_publication/social_statistics/WM17Chapter3.pdf
  26. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/271293538_A_Regional_Analysis_of_Literacy_and_Educational_Levels_of_Scheduled_Caste_in_Uttar_Pradesh
  27. https://books.google.co.in/books?id=JcstAAAAMAAJ
  28. https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2004/wp0443.pdf
  29. https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/bihar-caste-census-data-8965210/
  30. https://m.thewire.in/article/caste/bihar-caste-survey-the-whos-who-in-the-data-chamar
  31. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/103490/
  32. https://www.academia.edu/42097942/_Chamars_as_Peasants_Investigating_the_Stereotype_in_Reconsidering_Untouchability
  33. https://www.everyculture.com/South-Asia/Jatav-History-and-Cultural-Relations.html
  34. https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/jatav
  35. https://www.matrimonialsindia.com/blog/jatav-caste-and-gotra.htm
  36. https://www.deccanherald.com/elections/caste-matters-most-in-bundelkhand-vindhya-732177.html
  37. https://www.indiatoday.in/india-today-insight/story/why-dalits-riding-horses-gets-the-goat-of-upper-castes-in-mp-s-bundelkhand-1916408-2022-02-22
  38. https://socialjustice.gov.in/writereaddata/UploadFile/Compendium-2016.pdf
  39. https://sanhati.com/articles/20079/
  40. https://fas.org.in/research/pari/punjab-round/
  41. https://www.adrnresearch.org/publications/list.php?at=view&idx=255
  42. https://www.hurights.or.jp/archives/focus/section2/2002/12/dalits-in-nepal-story-of-discrimination.html
  43. https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic-social/census/documents/Nepal/Nepal-Census-2011-Vol1.pdf
  44. https://www.nepjol.info/index.php/pragya/article/view/64205
  45. https://elibrary.tucl.edu.np/bitstreams/e3020c84-1766-4696-a358-b66e80188679/download
  46. https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/NP/OHCHR_Nepal_Conflict_Report2012.pdf
  47. https://samatafoundation.org/data-of-dalits/
  48. https://joshuaproject.net/people_groups/16561/NP
  49. http://www.indpaedia.com/ind/index.php/Chamar
  50. https://www.csds.in/uploads/custom_files_new/1756190347_The%2520Smell%2520of%2520Caste%2520Leatherwork%2520and%2520Scientific%2520Knowledge%2520in%2520Colonial%2520India.pdf
  51. https://www.scribd.com/document/160257671/Chamar-Family-in-a-North-Indian-Villagea-Structural-Contingent
  52. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/6404581_Genetic_affinities_between_endogamous_and_inbreeding_populations_of_Uttar_Pradesh
  53. https://www.jkyog.org/blog/lessons-on-purity-of-mind-and-power-of-devotion-from-the-life-of-sant-ravidas/
  54. https://www.sikhdharma.org/bhagat-ravidas-ji-life-and-teachings/
  55. https://kbssidhu.substack.com/p/guru-ravidas-a-beacon-of-equality
  56. https://encyclopedia.pub/entry/37947
  57. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna30933094
  58. https://foref-europe.org/blog/2019/09/12/the-untouchables-in-europe-10-years-ago-their-guru-was-murdered-in-vienna/
  59. https://www.sikhphilosophy.net/threads/final-rift-ravidassia-shrines-shift-out-guru-granth-sahib-saroops.25908/
  60. https://wlv.openrepository.com/entities/publication/5ddefab7-7c61-4d81-93b1-56a3457d52ce
  61. https://www.sikhchic.com/article-detail.php?id=1264&cat=12
  62. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-67559084
  63. https://ijssrr.com/journal/article/download/2751/1941/
  64. https://www.indiatoday.in/elections/punjab-assembly-polls-2022/story/punjab-election-2022-why-ravidasia-ramdasia-dalits-votes-matter-in-electoral-scene-1901686-2022-01-19
  65. https://ecsas2025.com/paper/from-bhagat-to-guru-epistemic-violence-and-the-ravidassia-challenge-to-sikh-orthodoxy/
  66. https://www.understandingreligion.org.uk/p/ravidassia-religion/
  67. https://browbands-uk.com/blogs/blogs/the-history-of-leather-throughout-the-ages-india-s-role-and-why-we-use-buffalo-leather
  68. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0047877
  69. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12017675/
  70. https://www.geojournal.net/uploads/archives/7-8-7-871.pdf
  71. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X18301943
  72. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26364323
  73. https://www.academia.edu/41009733/A_Case_Study_of_Footwear_Industry_in_India
  74. https://www.scribd.com/document/162548266/Foot-Wear-Cluster-Agra-DS
  75. https://idsn.org/wp-content/uploads/user_folder/pdf/New_files/India/IIDS_-_Dalits_in_Business.pdf
  76. https://www.vifindia.org/print/13837
  77. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590291125005820
  78. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/09737030241238930
  79. https://old.rrjournals.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/180-186_RRIJM18030538.pdf
  80. https://frontline.thehindu.com/cover-story/article30191661.ece
  81. https://www.epw.in/engage/discussion/mayawatis-2007-uttar-pradesh-victory-looking
  82. https://www.thequint.com/opinion/2024-lok-sabha-elections-uttar-pradesh-understanding-the-bsp-and-mayawatis-inexorable-decline
  83. https://www.informahealthcare.com/doi/epub/10.1080/14662043.2020.1700018
  84. https://theses.hal.science/tel-03455169v1/file/2016IEPP0043_Verniers_Gilles_these.pdf
  85. https://www.deccanherald.com/opinion/fall-bsp-2007-win-1994015
  86. https://www.jstor.org/stable/27388858
  87. https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/drastic-decline-on-the-bsp/article68300601.ece
  88. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2019/09/the-dawn-of-indias-fourth-party-system?lang=en
  89. https://frontline.thehindu.com/politics/dalit-politics-uttar-pradesh-mayawati-bsp-decline-chandrashekhar-azad-future-bjp-sp-congress/article69333811.ece
  90. https://collection.nam.ac.uk/detail.php?acc=2013-10-20-55-33
  91. https://ravidassia.wordpress.com/chamars-in-the-military/
  92. https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/battle-imphal
  93. https://www.drishtiias.com/blog/the-story-of-the-1946-indian-naval-mutiny
  94. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/courts/scheduled-castes-panel-for-revival-of-chamar-regiment-391418/
  95. https://theprint.in/opinion/from-ambedkar-to-jagjivan-ram-to-ncsc-dalits-long-struggle-for-inclusion-in-indian-army/1503199/
  96. https://censusindia.gov.in/nada/index.php/catalog/2114/study-description
  97. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/lucknow/jatavs-on-top-of-sc-population-in-up/articleshow/47931787.cms
  98. https://mospi.gov.in/sites/default/files/reports_and_publication/statistical_publication/social_statistics/WM16Chapter3.pdf
  99. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4412439
  100. https://mondediplo.com/2016/05/12ukindian
  101. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/840862km
  102. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/394021675_The_Ravidassia_in_Italy_History_Geography_and_Identity_Politics_of_the_Largest_Punjabi_Dalit_Diaspora_in_the_EU
  103. https://library.hsu.edu/site/assets/files/4537/2000-1afindians_in_mauritius_and_fiji.pdf
  104. https://m.economictimes.com/nri/invest/diaspora-remittances-hit-new-record-at-135-46-bn-in-fy25/articleshow/122144367.cms
  105. https://ijirt.org/publishedpaper/IJIRT180359_PAPER.pdf
  106. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262122685_Punjabis_in_England_The_Ad-Dharmi_Experience
  107. https://www.insightsonindia.com/2024/07/17/article-341-of-the-constitution/
  108. https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1113850/
  109. https://socialjustice.gov.in/writereaddata/UploadFile/CONSTITUTION%2520%28SC%29%2520ORDER%25201950%2520dated%252010081950.pdf
  110. https://anagrasarkalyan.gov.in/documnts/07-07-2017-11-33-12.pdf
  111. http://dopt.gov.in/sites/default/files/FAQ_SCST.pdf
  112. https://vajiramandravi.com/current-affairs/reservation-in-india/
  113. https://doptcirculars.nic.in/OM/ViewOM.aspx?id=471
  114. https://www.forwardpress.in/2016/06/the-making-of-the-first-sc-and-st-ias-officers%25E2%2580%25A8/
  115. https://blog.ipleaders.in/indra-sawhney-v-union-of-india-and-ors-1992-case-analysis/
  116. https://www.shankariasparliament.com/current-affairs/creamy-layer-for-scs-and-sts
  117. https://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/FR375/FR375.pdf
  118. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11009545/
  119. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X24000688
  120. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11449120/
  121. https://www.irjweb.com/A%2520Study%2520on%2520Socioeconomic%2520Status%2520Of%2520Scheduled%2520Castes%2520%28SC%29%2520And%2520Scheduled%2520Tribes%2520%28ST%29%2520In%2520India.pdf
  122. https://academic.oup.com/oxrep/article/40/3/443/7907278
  123. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43621-025-01805-6
  124. https://thewire.in/rights/affirmative-action-in-faculty-recruitment-necessary
  125. http://s3-ap-southeast-1.amazonaws.com/ijmer/pdf/volume14/volume14-issue1%284%29/4.pdf
  126. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/09708464241254162
  127. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304393223000144
  128. https://m.thewire.in/article/caste/remembering-swami-achutanand-the-pioneer-of-dalit-identity-and-consciousness-in-north-india
  129. https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/comment/saga-of-dalits-assertion-648789/
  130. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jagjivan-Ram
  131. https://bahujansamajparty.net/the-founder
  132. https://frontline.thehindu.com/politics/india-at-75-epochal-moments-1984-kanshi-ram-launches-the-bahujan-samaj-party-bsp/article65735949.ece
  133. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Kumari-Mayawati
  134. https://indianexpress.com/elections/mayawati-kanshi-ram-political-heir-and-up-first-dalit-cm-7807303/
  135. https://nehadixit.in/the-mission-inside-mayawatis-battle-for-uttar-pradesh/
  136. https://discover.hubpages.com/education/A-Look-at-the-only-Scheduled-Caste-Regiment-the-Chamar-regiment-of-the-Indian-army
  137. https://www.infipark.com/articles/banke-chamar-the-forgotten-revolutionary-of-1857/
  138. https://www.dw.com/en/indian-chamar-pop-singer-challenges-caste-with-music/a-35947703
  139. https://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/a-17-year-old-dalit-voice-from-punjab-is-making-waves-an-artist-has-no-caste-3003291/
  140. https://www.livemint.com/Leisure/vInFgOP6POSxxOOznQ7qzO/The-rise-of-a-brave-singer.html
  141. https://www.stuff.co.nz/entertainment/music/85002090/lower-caste-indian-singer-embraces-centuriesold-slur-caste-pride-is-driving-her-success
  142. https://www.abirpothi.com/distorted-realities-and-expressive-canvases-everyday-life-through-akash-jatavs-art/
  143. https://frontline.thehindu.com/other/article30187272.ece
  144. https://www.sikhawareness.com/topic/12380-ravidass-followers-declare-separate-religion-released-separate-religious-granth/
  145. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263760185_The_Place_of_Scripture_in_the_Trajectories_of_a_Distinct_Religious_Identity_among_Ravidassias_in_Britain_Guru_Granth_Sahib_or_Amritbani_Guru_Ravidass
  146. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/241743871_Religious_transnationalism_ravidasi_identity_and_the_dera_sant_sarwan_dass_ballan
  147. https://research.manchester.ac.uk/en/studentTheses/from-chamar-to-ravidassi-recasting-caste-as-religion-in-north-wes
  148. https://swarajyamag.com/politics/how-can-dalits-come-out-of-the-elite-controlled-victimhood-narrative
  149. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1409054
  150. https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/wcfia/files/caste_and_entrepreneurship_in_india.pdf
  151. https://countercurrents.org/2024/08/arguments-of-convenience-reflect-the-hypocrisy-of-political-responses-on-the-sc-categorization-issue/
  152. https://www.theindiaforum.in/caste/redesigning-reservations-how-heterogeneous-are-scheduled-castes
  153. https://www.hrw.org/report/1999/03/01/broken-people/caste-violence-against-indias-untouchables
  154. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2455328X221136385
  155. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40279109
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.