Hubbry Logo
Q starQ starMain
Open search
Q star
Community hub
Q star
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Q star
Q star
from Wikipedia
A simple diagram illustrating how some but not all light can escape from a grey hole

A Q-star, also known as a grey hole, is a hypothetical type of compact, heavy neutron star with an exotic state of matter. Such a star can be smaller than the progenitor star's Schwarzschild radius and have a gravitational pull so strong that some light, but not all light, can escape.[1] Light going in the opposite direction of the star’s center would be the most likely to escape from it, while light going in a direction almost parallel to its surface is the most likely not to escape. The Q stands for a conserved particle number. A Q-star may be mistaken for a stellar black hole.[2] Some stellar black holes might be grey holes, two of which are V404 Cygni and Cygnus X-1. [1]

Types of Q-stars

[edit]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
A Q star, also known as a or grey hole, is a hypothetical type of compact star composed of matter, an exotic state where up, down, and s are deconfined under extreme densities. Predicted by the matter hypothesis, Q stars could form through the conversion of a core when densities exceed about 5–10 times nuclear density, leading to a from hadronic to matter. Unlike neutron stars, which are supported against by neutron degeneracy pressure, Q stars are self-bound by the strong nuclear force, resulting in greater (radii potentially below 10 km for solar masses around 1.4 M⊙) and stability up to higher masses (possibly exceeding 2 M⊙) without forming black holes. Their surfaces would consist of bare matter, potentially explaining observed anomalies in some pulsars, such as rapid cooling or high densities, though no conclusive exists as of November 2025.

Theoretical Foundations

Quark Matter Basics

Quark matter represents a distinct phase of matter within quantum chromodynamics (QCD), characterized by the deconfinement of quarks and gluons from their usual hadronic bound states. In this phase, quarks and gluons behave as asymptotically free quasiparticles, forming a plasma-like state under extreme conditions of density exceeding approximately 101510^{15} g/cm³, which is several times the nuclear saturation density of ordinary matter. This deconfinement transition occurs when the energy scales overcome the strong force's confining potential, allowing collective excitations of quarks and gluons to dominate the thermodynamics. A key feature enabling this deconfined state is , a fundamental property of QCD where the strong coupling constant αs\alpha_s diminishes at high momentum transfers or short distances. At the ultra-high densities relevant to matter, this weakening of interactions permits quarks to propagate with perturbative accuracy, approximating an ideal of massless or lightly massive quarks. This contrasts with the non-perturbative regime at lower densities, where confinement binds quarks into color-neutral hadrons like protons and neutrons. The MIT bag model provides a phenomenological framework to model quark matter by treating the deconfined region as a "bag" with an additional energy term accounting for the vacuum's confinement pressure. The energy density ε\varepsilon in this model, for thermal quark matter, is expressed as ε=π230gT4+B,\varepsilon = \frac{\pi^2}{30} g T^4 + B, where gg denotes the effective number of relativistic (e.g., approximately 37 for two light flavors including gluons), TT is the temperature, and BB is the bag constant, typically valued between 50 and 100 MeV/fm³, representing the energy difference between the perturbative and true QCD vacua. This simple addition captures the essence of confinement without solving full QCD dynamics. Compared to hadronic matter, the equation of state (EOS) of quark matter—relating pressure PP to energy density ε\varepsilon via P=P(ε)P = P(\varepsilon)—is notably softer, implying a lower pressure for a given ε\varepsilon. This softness stems from the increased number of degrees of freedom in the deconfined phase and its near-conformal behavior at high densities, governed by asymptotic freedom, in contrast to the stiffer hadronic EOS dominated by fewer interacting baryons. Consequently, quark matter supports more compact configurations in stellar objects, enhancing mass-to-radius ratios.

Strange Quark Matter Hypothesis

The strange quark matter hypothesis posits that a phase of matter consisting of roughly equal numbers of up, down, and could represent the absolute of baryonic , potentially more stable than ordinary composed of protons and neutrons. This idea builds on the earlier suggestion by A. R. Bodmer in 1971, who proposed that deconfined in collapsed nuclear configurations might be stable if it possesses a lower per than atomic nuclei. However, it was who, in 1984, specifically advocated for the inclusion of strange quarks to achieve this stability, arguing that three-flavor (u, d, s) minimizes the through balanced flavor populations, thereby reducing the overall compared to two-flavor (u, d) or nuclei, which have an energy per of approximately 930 MeV. The Bodmer-Witten hypothesis implies absolute stability of strange quark matter if its energy per baryon falls below that of the most stable atomic nuclei, a condition met when the strange quark mass allows for sufficient binding. Calculations indicate that this energy per baryon can be as low as 100-200 MeV below the nuclear threshold under favorable parameters. A key quantity in these assessments is Ω, defined as the difference in energy per baryon relative to the neutron mass, approximated for the rest mass contribution as Ω = (m_u n_u + m_d n_d + m_s n_s)/n_B - m_N, where m_u, m_d, and m_s are the quark masses, n_u, n_d, and n_s are the respective quark number densities (with n_u ≈ n_d ≈ n_s ≈ n_B/3 for equal flavor content), n_B is the baryon number density, and m_N ≈ 939 MeV is the nucleon mass. With m_s ≈ 150 MeV and assuming massless up and down quarks, this yields Ω < 930 MeV, confirming the potential for strange quark matter to be more stable than iron-56. Theoretical modeling of strange quark matter often employs the Fermi gas approximation for non-interacting quarks to estimate the kinetic energy contributions from the degenerate quark Fermi seas, which dominate at high densities. This approximation treats the quarks as a free Fermi liquid, with the total energy per baryon including both kinetic terms (proportional to the Fermi momentum cubed) and the strange quark mass effects that suppress the Fermi level compared to lighter flavors. To account for strong interactions, perturbative quantum chromodynamics (QCD) corrections are incorporated, primarily through one-gluon exchange potentials that introduce attractive and repulsive components, further lowering the energy per baryon and supporting the stability hypothesis for a range of bag model parameters. These corrections ensure consistency with asymptotic QCD freedom at ultra-high densities while respecting confinement at lower scales.

Physical Properties

Density and Structure

Q-stars, hypothetical compact objects composed primarily of deconfined quark matter, exhibit central densities ranging from approximately 101510^{15} to 101610^{16} g/cm³, significantly exceeding the core densities of typical neutron stars, which are around 101410^{14} to 101510^{15} g/cm³. This ultra-high density regime arises from the equation of state (EOS) of quark matter, often modeled using frameworks like the MIT bag model or Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model, where quarks are treated as nearly free particles confined by a phenomenological bag constant. At these densities, a quark-hadron phase transition surface may form within the star, marking the boundary where hadronic matter transitions to the quark phase, influencing the overall density profile and potentially leading to mixed phases in hybrid configurations. The internal structure of Q-stars is determined by solving the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation, which governs hydrostatic equilibrium in general relativity for spherically symmetric, static configurations. The TOV equation is expressed as: dPdr=Gm(r)ε(r)r2(1+Pε)(1+4πr3Pm(r))(12Gm(r)rc2)1,\frac{dP}{dr} = -\frac{G m(r) \varepsilon(r)}{r^2} \left(1 + \frac{P}{\varepsilon}\right) \left(1 + \frac{4\pi r^3 P}{m(r)}\right) \left(1 - \frac{2 G m(r)}{r c^2}\right)^{-1}, where PP is the pressure, ε\varepsilon the energy density, m(r)m(r) the enclosed mass, GG the gravitational constant, and cc the speed of light. This differential equation is numerically integrated using a quark matter EOS, yielding mass-radius (M-R) relations that characterize the star's structure. For instance, Q-stars support stable configurations up to masses of about 2 M_\odot with corresponding radii around 10-12 km, depending on the specific EOS parameters. The compactness parameter for Q-stars, defined as R/MR/M (with RR in km and MM in solar masses), typically ranges from approximately 5-7 km/M_\odot for a 1.4 M_\odot object, indicating greater compactness compared to neutron stars due to the stiffer EOS of quark matter at ultra-high densities, which resists compression more effectively beyond nuclear saturation. This stiffness allows Q-stars to achieve higher maximum masses while maintaining smaller radii relative to softer EOS models. At the surface, Q-stars feature a sharp transition either to a thin hadronic crust (if present) or a bare quark surface, where the density drops abruptly from quark matter levels to near-zero, potentially leading to emissions such as pions from the exposed quark layer due to strong interactions at the interface.

Stability Conditions

The maximum mass of Q-stars, determined by solving the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation for the equation of state (EOS) of quark matter, typically ranges from 1.5 to 2.0 MM_\odot, depending on the bag constant BB in the MIT bag model, comparable to observed neutron star masses. Lower values of BB (e.g., B1/4145170B^{1/4} \approx 145-170 MeV) yield higher maximum masses approaching 2 MM_\odot or more, while higher BB reduces the limit to around 1.5 MM_\odot or below. Stability against radial oscillations requires the adiabatic index Γ\Gamma of quark matter to exceed 4/34/3 everywhere in the star, preventing dynamical collapse; the relativistic degenerate EOS of strange quark matter satisfies this criterion, ensuring configurations up to the maximum mass remain stable. A Chandrasekhar-like mass limit for Q-stars arises from the TOV structure equations, with Mmax(c/G)3/2μ2,M_\mathrm{max} \propto \frac{(\hbar c / G)^{3/2}}{\mu^2}, where μ\mu is the quark chemical potential, which depends on the baryon density and BB. This scaling reflects the balance between gravitational binding and the Fermi energy of quarks, analogous to white dwarf limits but adapted for self-bound quark matter. Color superconductivity further stabilizes Q-stars by inducing quark pairing that stiffens the EOS at high densities, potentially increasing MmaxM_\mathrm{max} by 10-20% relative to unpaired quark matter through enhanced pressure support.

Formation and Evolution

Gravitational Collapse Pathways

Q stars primarily form through the core-collapse process in massive stars with zero-age main sequence masses greater than 8 M_⊙, where the collapse surpasses the neutron degeneracy pressure limit, reaching densities exceeding 5 × 10^{14} g/cm³ and triggering quark deconfinement to form stable quark matter. In this scenario, the failure of neutron support leads directly to a transition from hadronic to deconfined quark matter, supported by the stiff quark matter equation of state at supranuclear densities. The dynamics of this phase transition are characterized by a first-order process featuring a mixed phase of coexisting hadronic and quark matter, during which latent heat is released, potentially causing a temporary halt in the collapse and enabling a rebound that contributes to the supernova explosion mechanism. This rebound occurs at densities around 3–7 × 10^{14} g/cm³, depending on the bag constant parameter in the quark equation of state, with the transition altering the adiabatic index and facilitating shock propagation. An alternative formation pathway involves the gradual conversion of preexisting neutron stars into Q stars via strangeness production in their dense cores, driven by spin-down over timescales of approximately 10^5 years for typical magnetic fields and initial rotation periods. This process requires the core density to exceed the deconfinement threshold through gradual compression, leading to a metastable transition without explosive dynamics. Recent theoretical studies as of 2025 suggest additional pathways, such as the formation of strange quark stars from supernova explosions in compact star binaries involving evolved companions like carbon-oxygen or Wolf-Rayet stars.

Evolutionary Differences from Neutron Stars

Q stars, composed of deconfined quark matter, exhibit distinct evolutionary trajectories compared to neutron stars due to their unique internal composition and interaction mechanisms. One key difference lies in their cooling processes. In Q stars, neutrino emission is dominated by the quark direct Urca process, which proceeds via quark flavor conversions (e.g., d+uu+e+νˉed + u \to u + e + \bar{\nu}_e) and results in an emissivity ϵνT6\epsilon_\nu \propto T^6, where TT is the temperature. This contrasts with neutron stars, where the slower modified Urca process governs cooling in the absence of direct Urca, yielding ϵνT8\epsilon_\nu \propto T^8. Consequently, Q stars cool more rapidly in their early phases, achieving surface temperatures significantly lower than those of neutron stars after approximately 10310^3 years, often by factors of 10 or more, due to the enhanced neutrino luminosity. This faster thermal evolution can lead to Q stars appearing as relatively cold objects in X-ray observations even at young ages. Another evolutionary distinction arises in spin evolution and magnetic field dynamics. Q stars may generate stronger magnetic fields, potentially reaching surface strengths of 1015\sim 10^{15} G, through dynamo processes driven by turbulent convection in the quark matter core during the post-formation deleptonization phase. These fields, amplified by the high electrical conductivity of quark matter, exceed typical neutron star dipolar fields (1012\sim 10^{12} G) and resemble those in magnetars. The resultant magnetic torque accelerates spin-down, but the smaller moment of inertia of Q stars—arising from their higher compactness—allows them to support faster initial rotations. This enables Q stars to evolve into pulsars with periods below 1 ms, faster than the 1\sim 1 ms limit for most neutron stars, particularly in low-mass configurations. Such rapid rotators provide a potential observational signature, as millisecond pulsars with periods under 1 ms could indicate quark matter interiors. The outcomes of binary mergers further highlight evolutionary divergences. When two Q stars merge, the combined system may directly collapse into a black hole composed of quark matter, bypassing intermediate hadronic phases, or trigger ignition of burning fronts that propagate through any admixed nuclear material, converting it to stable strange quark matter. This differs from neutron star mergers, where the post-merger remnant often undergoes a phase transition to hyperonic matter before collapsing, potentially delaying black hole formation or producing distinct gravitational wave signatures. These processes in Q star binaries can release energy through quark recombination or deflagration waves, influencing ejecta dynamics and electromagnetic counterparts. Finally, Q stars may have shorter overall lifetimes compared to neutron stars, primarily due to dynamical instabilities at high masses. For masses exceeding 2M\sim 2 M_\odot, certain equations of state predict mechanical instability, leading to collapse on timescales of seconds to minutes under perturbations. In principle, if strangeness fraction decreases via diffusion or weak interactions in marginally stable configurations, a Q star could revert to a neutron star state, though this process remains theoretically debated and unobserved. These instabilities contrast with the longer-term stability of neutron stars up to similar masses, underscoring the precarious equilibrium of quark matter.

Types and Variants

Strange Stars

Strange stars represent the canonical form of quark stars, consisting entirely of bulk strange quark matter (SQM) in which up, down, and strange quarks coexist in roughly equal proportions without any overlying hadronic crust. These self-bound objects arise under the hypothesis that SQM is the absolute ground state of baryonic matter, more stable than nuclear matter at zero pressure. For a typical mass of 1 MM_\odot, strange stars have compact radii of approximately 10 km, comparable to those of neutron stars but distinguished by their uniform quark composition throughout. The equation of state (EOS) for strange stars is commonly described using the MIT bag model, treating quarks as non-interacting fermions confined within a phenomenological "bag" to account for confinement. In the limit of equal or massless up, down, and strange quarks, the EOS takes the simple form: P=13(ϵ4B),P = \frac{1}{3} (\epsilon - 4B), where PP is the pressure, ϵ\epsilon is the energy density, and BB is the bag constant (typically 50–100 MeV/fm³). This ultrarelativistic EOS implies a speed of sound vs=c/3v_s = c / \sqrt{3}
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.