Hubbry Logo
MarranoMarranoMain
Open search
Marrano
Community hub
Marrano
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Marrano
Marrano
Marrano
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Marranos: A secret Passover Seder in Spain during the times of Inquisition. An 1893 painting by Moshe Maimon.

Marranos were Spanish and Portuguese Jews, as well as Navarrese Jews, who converted to Christianity, either voluntarily or by Spanish or Portuguese royal coercion, during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, but who continued to practice Judaism in secret or were suspected of it. They are also called crypto-Jews, a term increasingly preferred in scholarly works over Marranos.

The related term converso was used for the wider population of Jewish converts to Catholicism, whether or not they secretly still practised Jewish rites. Converts from either Judaism or Islam were referred to by the more general term "New Christians".

The term marrano came into use in 1492 with the Castilian Alhambra Decree, which prohibited the practice of Judaism in Spain and required all remaining Jews to convert or leave. The vast majority of Jews in Spain had already converted to Catholicism, perhaps under pressure from the Massacre of 1391, and conversos numbered in the hundreds of thousands. Suspected by Old Christians of the secret practice of Judaism, the Spanish Inquisition, established prior to the decree, surveilled New Christians to try to detect whether their conversion to Christianity was sincere.

In modern Spanish, marrano means "pig", or, more often, "dirty person". For this reason, although its etymology is contested, present-day use of the term can be considered pejorative and offensive. Some scholars, however, continue to use marrano interchangeably with crypto-Jew, or even converso.[1]

Etymology

[edit]
First Cemetery of the Spanish and Portuguese Synagogue, Shearith Israel (1656–1833), in Manhattan, New York City

The origin of the term Marrano as applied to crypto-Jews is unclear, since there have been several proposed etymologies in addition to swine.

The Hebrew word for מְשֻׁמָּד‎ Meshumad, literally standing for "self-destroyed" or a heretic to Judaism, for a Jew who deliberately rebels against the observance of Jewish law.

The main difference between a Min, a Meshumad, and the Anusim is that the act of abandonment of Judaism is voluntary for a Min and a Meshumad, while for the Anusim it is not.

One source of the term derives from an Arabic word for "forbidden, illicit",[2] مُحَرّمٌ Muḥarram.[citation needed] The Arabic word in this context means "swine" or "pork", and either expresses the same repulsion towards the converts that the converts previously had for such ritually unclean meat.[2]

However, as applied to Crypto-Jews, the term Marrano derives from the Spanish & Portuguese verb "marrar" and "amarrar" meaning "to fail", "to plan to go wrong", "to break away", "to defraud", "to target", "to tie up", "to refrain", "to deviate", "to clinch", "to moor", illuminating that those targeted and forced by the Spanish Crown had no choice but to adopt Christianity, either leave the Kingdom of Spain all while the Crown seized their property and money and gave them no support to leave, be murdered either for not showing complete loyalty to Christianity or for leaving Spain and coming back showing that these Jews were traitors to the Spanish Crown.[3][4]

It also has Arabic origin meaning "to deviate" or "to err", in the sense that they deviated from their newly adopted faith by secretly continuing to practice Judaism. A third origin has been cited from Galician-Portuguese, where marrar means "to force" and marrano means "forced one", indicating the compulsory nature of the religious conversions.[1] José Meir Estrugo Hazán writes in his book Los Sefardíes[5] that "marrano" is the term the Spanish Jews prefer.

Demographics

[edit]

Under state pressure in the late 14th and early 15th century, over half of Jews in the Iberian Peninsula converted to Christianity, thus avoiding the Decree of Expulsion which affected Spain's remaining openly Jewish population in 1492. The numbers who converted and the effects of various migrations in and out of the area have been the subject of historical debate. A phylogeographic study in 2008 of 1,150 volunteer Y-chromosome DNA haplogroups appeared to support the idea that the number of conversions has been significantly underestimated, as 20% of the tested Iberian population had haplogroups consistent with Sephardi ancestry. This percentage was suggested as representing the proportion of Sephardi in the population at the time of mass conversions in the 14th and 15th centuries.[6] However, the authors concede that other historical population movements from the Near East such as Syrians and Phoenicians may also account for these results.[7][8][9][10][11][12]

Portugal

[edit]
Main article: History of the Jews in Portugal

Some Portuguese conversos or cristãos-novos continued to practice as crypto-Jews. In the early 20th century, historian Samuel Schwartz wrote about crypto-Jewish communities discovered in northeastern Portugal (namely, Belmonte, Bragança, Miranda, and Chaves). He claimed that members had managed to survive more than four centuries without being fully assimilated into the Old Christian population.[13] The last remaining crypto-Jewish community in Belmonte officially returned to Judaism in the 1970s and opened a synagogue in 1996. In 2003, the American Sephardi Federation founded the Belmonte Project to raise funds to acquire Judaic educational material and services for the Belmonte community, who then numbered 160–180.[citation needed]

Two documentary films have been made in north-eastern Portugal where present-day descendants of marranos were interviewed about their lives. In 1974 for The Marranos of Portugal, the Israel Broadcasting Authority (IBA) sent reporter Ron Ben-Yishai to conduct interviews with families about their religious practice. After being asked to prove he knew Hebrew before they would talk, he found people still reluctant to speak openly. Nevertheless, he did eventually gain a remarkable insight into their version of Jewish customs, prayers and songs. The film was commended at the 1976 Jerusalem Jewish Film and TV Festival. Another documentary, The Last Marranos, was made by the New York Jewish Media Fund in 1997.

After the expulsion of Jews and Muslims from Spain (1492) and the Forced Conversion by Portugal's King Manuel I in Portugal (1497), conversos continued to be suspect in socially strained times. In Lisbon in 1506, a months-long plague caused people to look for scapegoats. Some became suspicious that conversos might be practicing Judaism and therefore be at fault. On April 17, 1506, several conversos were discovered who had in their possession "some lambs and poultry prepared according to Jewish custom; also unleavened bread and bitter herbs according to the regulations for the Passover, which festival they celebrated far into the night." Officials seized several but released them after a few days.

On the same day on which the conversos were freed, the Dominicans displayed a crucifix and a reliquary in glass from which a peculiar light issued in a side-chapel of their church, where several New Christians were present. A New Christian who tried to explain the miracle as due to natural causes was dragged from the church and killed by an infuriated woman. A Dominican roused the populace still more. Friar João Mocho and the Aragonese friar Bernardo, crucifix in hand, were said to have gone through the streets of the city, crying "Heresy!" and calling upon the people to destroy the conversos.[citation needed] Attracted by the outcry, sailors from Holland, Zeeland and others from ships in the port of Lisbon, joined the Dominicans and formed a mob with local men to pursue the conversos.

The mob dragged converso victims from their houses and killed some. Old Christians who were in any way associated with New Christians were also attacked. The mob attacked the tax-farmer João Rodrigo Mascarenhas, a New Christian; although a wealthy and distinguished man, his work also made him resented by many. They demolished his house. Within 48 hours, many "conversos" were killed; by the third day all who could leave escaped, often with the help of other Portuguese. The killing spree lasted from 19 to 21 April, in what came to be known as the Lisbon massacre.

King Manuel severely punished those who took part in the killings. The ringleaders and the Dominicans who encouraged the riot were also executed. Local people convicted of murder or pillage suffered corporal punishment and their property was confiscated. The king granted religious freedom for 20 years to all conversos in an attempt at compensation. Lisbon lost Foral (municipal) privileges. The foreigners who had taken part generally escaped punishment, leaving with their ships.

New Christians were attacked in Gouveia, Alentejo, Olivença, Santarém, and other places. In the Azores and the island of Madeira, mobs massacred former Jews. Because of these excesses, the king began to believe that a Portuguese Inquisition might help control such outbreaks.

The Portuguese conversos worked to forestall such actions, and spent immense sums to win over the Curia and most influential cardinals. Spanish and Portuguese conversos made financial sacrifices. Alfonso Gutierrez, Garcia Alvarez "el Rico" (the rich), and the Zapatas, conversos from Toledo, offered 80,000 gold crowns to Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, if he would mitigate the harshness of the Inquisition.[14]

The Mendes of Lisbon and Flanders also tried to help. None was successful in preventing the Inquisition Papal Bull Meditatio Cordis of July 16, 1547, Inquisition in Portugal. This Bull Meditatio Cordis still did not have the "Power of Confiscation". Portuguese Marranos continued, with many bribes of the Popes in Rome, and with prolonged negotiation against this "Power of Confiscation" succeeded to delay it 32 years, but finally conceded this "deadly weapon" in 1579. The Portuguese Inquisition now had been endowed, 101 years after the Spanish Inquisition of November 1, 1478, with the same extremities of rigor as the Spanish prototype. The conversos suffered immensely both from mob violence and interrogation and testing by the Inquisition. Attacks and murders were recorded at Trancoso, Lamego, Miranda, Viseu, Guarda, and Braga.

At Covilhã, there were rumors that the people planned to massacre all the New Christians on one day. In 1562, prelates petitioned the Cortes to require conversos to wear special badges, and to order Jewish descendants to live in ghettos (judiarias) in cities and villages as their ancestors had before the conversions.

In 1641, João IV of Portugal ennobled the Curiel family, a Marrano family who initially served the Crown of Castile, defecting to Portugal after the expulsion of the Jews from Spain in 1498. They went on serving the King of Portugal in diplomatic positions across Europe until the late 18th century.[15]

In the 1970s, the Marranos of Belmonte officially rejoined Judaism and reestablished ties with the Jews of Israel.[16] The Museu Judaico de Belmonte was opened in 2005 in Belmonte, it is the first Jewish museum in Portugal.[17]

Spain

[edit]
Main article: History of the Jews in Spain

According to historian Cecil Roth, Spanish political intrigues had earlier promoted the anti-Jewish policies which culminated in 1391, when Regent Queen Leonora of Castile gave the Archdeacon of Écija, Ferrand Martinez, considerable power in her realm. Martinez gave speeches that led to violence against the Jews, and this influence culminated in the sack of the Jewish quarter of Seville on June 4, 1391. Throughout Spain during this year, the cities of Ecija, Carmona, Córdoba, Toledo, Barcelona and many others saw their Jewish quarters destroyed and inhabitants massacred.

It is estimated that 200,000 Jews saved their lives by converting to Christianity in the wake of these persecutions.[18] Other Jews left the country altogether and around 100,000 openly practicing Jews remained.

In 1449, feelings rose against conversos, breaking out in a riot at Toledo. Instigated by two canons, Juan Alfonso and Pedro Lopez Galvez, the mob plundered and burned the houses of Alonso Cota, a wealthy converso and tax-farmer. They also attacked the residences of wealthy New Christians in the quarter of la Magdelena. Under Juan de la Cibdad, the conversos opposed the mob, but were repulsed. They were executed with their leader. As a result, several prominent converso men were deposed from office, in obedience to a new statute.

Nearly 20 years later in July 1467, another riot occurred where a mob attacked conversos in Toledo. The chief magistrate (alcalde mayor) of the city was Alvar Gomez de Cibdad Real, who had been private secretary to King Henry IV of Castile. He was a protector of the conversos. Together with prominent conversos Fernando and Alvaro de la Torre, Alvar wished to take revenge for an insult by the counts de Fuensalida, leaders of the Old Christians. His intention was to seize control of the city, but fierce conflict erupted. Opponents set fire to houses of New Christians near the cathedral. The conflagration spread so rapidly that 1,600 houses were consumed. Both Old Christians and conversos perished. The brothers De la Torre were captured and hanged.

Tensions arose in Córdoba between Old Christians and conversos, where they formed two hostile parties. On March 14, 1473, during a dedication procession, a girl accidentally threw dirty water from the window of the house of one of the wealthiest conversos (the customary way to dispose of it.) The water splashed on an image of the Virgin being carried in procession in honor of a new society (from which conversos had been excluded by Bishop D. Pedro.) A local blacksmith started arousing a rabble against the Jews, who he blamed for the insult, which immediately joined in a fierce shout for revenge.[dubious – discuss]

The mob went after conversos, denouncing them as heretics, killing them, and burning their houses. To stop the excesses, the highly respected D. Alonso Fernandez de Aguilar, whose wife was a member of the converso family of Pacheco, together with his brother D. Gonzalo Fernández de Córdoba ("El Gran Capitán"), and a troop of soldiers, hastened to protect the New Christians. D. Alonso called upon the mob to retire. Its leader insulted the count, who immediately felled him with his lance. Aroused, the people considered him a martyr. Incited by Alonso de Aguilar's enemy, they again attacked the conversos. The rioting lasted three days. Those who escaped sought refuge in the castle, where their protectors also took shelter. The government decreed that Jews and conversos should remain in their neighborhood or leave the city.

In 1473, attacks on conversos arose in numerous other cities: Montoro, Bujalance, Adamuz, La Rambla, Santaella, and elsewhere. Mobs attacked conversos in Andújar, Úbeda, Baeza, and Almodóvar del Campo also. In Valladolid, groups looted the belongings of the New Christians. At Segovia, there was a massacre (May 16, 1474). D. Juan Pacheco, a converso, led the attacks. Without the intervention of the alcalde, Andres de Cabrera, all New Christians might have died. At Carmona, it was reported that not one converso was left alive.

Inquisition

[edit]
Execution of Mariana de Carabajal in Mexico, 1601.

Tens of thousands of Jews were baptised in the three months before the deadline for expulsion, some 40,000 if one accepts the totals given by Kamen: most of these undoubtedly to avoid expulsion,[citation needed] rather than as a sincere change of faith. These conversos were the principal concern of the Inquisition; being suspected of continuing to practice Judaism put them at risk of denunciation and trial.[citation needed]

During 1492, about 12,000 conversos entered Navarre from Aragon's repression, where they were allowed to remain. Tudela in Navarre turned into a converso haven. The Tudelans had already proclaimed in 1486 that "if any inquisitor enters their city, he will be thrown into the Ebro river." Later the resistance to the inquisitors was so strong that its aldermen ordered commissioners and attorneys to ask the Catholic Monarchs to limit the power of the Inquisition in 1510.[19][20][21]

The most intense period of persecution of conversos lasted until 1530. From 1531 to 1560, however, the percentage of conversos among the Inquisition trials dropped to 3% of the total. There was a rebound of persecutions when a group of crypto-Jews was discovered in Quintanar de la Orden in 1588; and there was a rise in denunciations of conversos in the last decade of the sixteenth century. At the beginning of the seventeenth century, some conversos who had fled to Portugal began to return to Spain, fleeing the persecution of the Portuguese Inquisition, founded in 1536. This led to a rapid increase in the trials of crypto-Jews, among them a number of important financiers. In 1691, during a number of autos-da-fé in Mallorca, 37 chuetas, or conversos of Mallorca, were burned.[22]

During the eighteenth century the number of conversos accused by the Inquisition decreased significantly. Manuel Santiago Vivar, tried in Córdoba in 1818, was the last person tried for being a crypto-Jew.[23]

Converso-Jewish relations

[edit]

The conversos of Seville and other cities of Castile, and especially of Aragon, bitterly opposed the Spanish Inquisition established in 1478. They rendered considerable service to the king, and held high legal, financial, and military positions. The government issued an edict directing traditional Jews to live within a ghetto and be separated from conversos. Despite the law, however, the Jews remained in communication with their New Christian brethren.

"They sought ways and means to win them from Catholicism and bring them back to Judaism. They instructed the Marranos in the tenets and ceremonies of the Jewish religion; held meetings in which they taught them what they must believe and observe according to the Mosaic law; and enabled them to circumcise themselves and their children. They furnished them with prayer-books; explained the fast-days; read with them the history of their people and their Law; announced to them the coming of the Passover; procured unleavened bread for them for that festival, as well as kosher meat throughout the year; encouraged them to live in conformity with the law of Moses, and persuaded them that there was no law and no truth except the Jewish religion." These were the charges brought by the government of Ferdinand II of Aragon and Isabella I of Castile against the Jews. They constituted the grounds for their expulsion and banishment in 1492, so they could not subvert conversos. Jews who did not want to leave Spain had to accept baptism as a sign of conversion.

The historian Henry Kamen's Inquisition and Society in Spain in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries questions whether there were such strong links between conversos and Jewish communities. Whilst historians such as Yitzhak Baer state, "the conversos and Jews were one people",[24] Kamen claims, "Yet if the conversos were hated by the Christians, the Jews liked them no better."[24] He documented that "Jews testified falsely against them [the conversos] when the Inquisition was finally founded."[24] This issue is being debated by historians.

Conversos in Italy

[edit]

Although the vast majority of Spain's 250,000 conversos had abandoned Judaism and been assimilated into Spain's dominant Catholic culture, many of those continuing to secretly practice their former religion felt threatened and persecuted by the Inquisition which continued to actively persecute heresy. Some of these chose to leave Spain, in bands or as individual refugees. Many migrated to Italy, attracted by the climate, which resembled that of the Iberian Peninsula, and by the kindred language. When they settled at Ferrara, Duke Ercole I d'Este granted them privileges. His son Alfonso confirmed the privileges to twenty-one Spanish conversos: physicians, merchants, and others (ib. xv. 113 et seq.). A thoroughly researched history of these migrations is also contained in the book about one of their leaders Dona Gracia Nasi called, "The Woman Who Defied Kings", by the historian and journalist Andree Aelion Brooks.

Spanish and Portuguese conversos also settled at Florence and contributed to make Livorno a leading seaport. They received privileges at Venice, where they were protected from the persecutions of the Inquisition. In Milan they materially advanced the interests of the city with their industry and commerce. At Bologna, Pisa, Naples, and numerous other Italian cities, they freely exercised the Jewish religion again. They were soon so numerous that Fernando de Goes Loureiro, an abbot from Porto, filled an entire book with the names of conversos who had drawn large sums from Portugal and had openly avowed Judaism in Italy.

In Piedmont, Duke Emmanuel Philibert of Savoy welcomed conversos from Coímbra and granted them commercial and industrial privileges, as well as the free exercise of their religion. Rome was full of conversos. Pope Paul III received them at Ancona for commercial reasons. He granted complete liberty "to all persons from Portugal and Algarve, even if belonging to the class of New Christians." By 1553 three thousand Portuguese Jews and conversos were living at Ancona.

Two years later, Pope Paul IV issued orders to have all the conversos in Papal states be thrown into the prisons of the Inquisition which he had instituted. Sixty of them, who acknowledged the Catholic faith as penitents, were transported to the island of Malta; twenty-four, who adhered to Judaism, were publicly burned (May 1556). Those who escaped the Inquisition were received at Pesaro by Guidobaldo II della Rovere, Duke of Urbino. Guidobaldo had hoped to have the Jews and conversos of Turkey select Pesaro as a commercial center; when that did not happen, he expelled the New Christians from Pesaro and other districts in 1558 (ib. xvi. 61 et seq.).

Many conversos also went to Dubrovnik, formerly a considerable Croatian seaport on the Adriatic Sea. In May 1544, a ship landed there filled with Portuguese refugees.

Latin America

[edit]
Main articles: History of the Jews in Latin America, History of the Jews in Mexico, and History of the Jews in Brazil

During the 16th and 17th centuries, some conversos migrated to the Americas, often the Castilian territories of the Vice-royalties of New Spain, Peru, and the Río de la Plata in Argentina. Legal emigration to the New World was strictly controlled and required proof of three generations of Christian ascendance.[citation needed] Nevertheless, many conversos managed to evade these restrictions and managed to obtain "encomiendas" papers of legal identity in the New World.

France

[edit]
Main article: History of the Jews in France

According to Isidore Loeb, in a special study of the subject in the Revue des Études Juives (xiv. 162–183), about 3,000 Jews came to Provence after the Alhambra Decree expelled Jews from Spain in 1492.

From 1484, one town after another had called for expulsion, but the calls were rejected by Charles VIII. However, Louis XII, in one of his first acts as king in 1498, issued a general expulsion order of the Jews of Provence. Though not enforced at the time, the order was renewed in 1500 and again in 1501. On this occasion, it was definitively implemented. The Jews of Provence were given the option of conversion to Christianity and a number chose that option. However, after a short while – if only to compensate partially for the loss of revenues caused by the departure of the Jews – the king imposed a special tax, referred to as "the tax of the neophytes." These converts and their descendants soon became the objects of social discrimination and slanders.[25]

Estado da India (Portuguese India)

[edit]
Main articles: History of the Jews in India, Sephardic Jews in India, and The Goa Inquisition

In the "Marrano Factory: The Portuguese Inquisition and Its New Christians 1536-1765", Professor Antonio Jose Saraiva of the University of Lisbon, writes "King Manuel theoretically abolished discrimination between Old and New Christians by the law of March 1, 1507 which permitted the departure of New Christians to any part of the Christian world, declaring that they “be considered, favored and treated like the Old Christians and not distinct and separated from them in any matter.” Nevertheless, in apparent contradiction to that law, in a letter dated Almeirim, February 18, 1519, King Manuel promoted legislation henceforth prohibiting the naming of New Christians to the position of judge, town councilor or municipal registrar in Goa, stipulating, however, that those already appointed were not to be dismissed. This shows that even during the first nine years of Portuguese rule, Goa had a considerable influx of recently baptized Spanish and Portuguese Jews."[26]

Some New Christians sought to re-join Jewish populations in India (particularly through the Jewish community in Cochin), while others went on to be extremely influential in the spice trade, and the gems trade between Portugal, and India. This activity aroused the ire of the Catholic clergy. During this period, the first bishop of Goa, Gaspar Jorge de Leão Pereira wrote his anti-Semitic work "contra os Judeos" (tracts against Jews), and called for the establishment of the Inquisition in Goa (which was established in 1560).

Migrations

[edit]

There was no significant wave of emigration of conversos from Spain, the majority of Sephardic communities, such as that of Salonika having been formed as a result of the Alhambra Decree in 1492.[27] However, there was a steady trickle of crypto-Jewish marranos who wished to practice their faith freely to more liberal environments. One of their leaders who helped them get there was the Lisbon-born international banker, Gracia Mendes Nasi. They also migrated to Flanders, where they were attracted by its flourishing cities, such as Antwerp and Brussels. Conversos from Flanders, and others direct from the Iberian Peninsula, went under the guise of Catholics to Hamburg and Altona about 1580, where they established a community and held commercial relations with their former homes. Some migrated as far as Scotland. Christian IV of Denmark invited some New Christian families to settle at Glückstadt about 1626, granting certain privileges to them and to conversos who came to Emden about 1649.

The vast majority of Spain's conversos, however, remained in Spain and Portugal and were suspected of "Marranism" by the Spanish Inquisition. Although the wealthier among them could easily bypass discriminatory Limpieza de sangre laws, they constituted a significant portion of the over three thousand people executed for heresy by the Spanish Inquisition.[27] In his luminous book the "Marrano Factory: The Portuguese Inquisition and Its New Christians 1536-1765", Professor Antonio Jose Saraiva [1] of the University of Lisbon, writes that "After August 1531, when the establishment of the Inquisition in Portugal was in the offing and especially after June 14, 1532 when New Christian emigration from Portugal became a capital offense, anti-New Christian sentiment surged on all sides. The New Christians were panic-stricken and emigrants, legal or clandestine, headed for Flanders, Italy, the Ottoman Empire, the Portuguese possessions in India, North Africa. After the middle of the century, England, France, the Spanish Americas and Brazil were the favorite destinations, not necessarily in that order."[26] The New Christians breathed more freely when Philip III of Spain came to the throne. By the law of April 4, 1601, he granted them the privilege of unrestricted sale of their real estate as well as free departure from the country for themselves, their families, and their property. Many, availing themselves of this permission, followed their coreligionists to North Africa and Turkey. After a few years, however, the privilege was revoked, and the Inquisition resumed its activity.

Some migrated to London, whence their families spread to Brazil (where conversos had settled at an early date) and other colonies in the Americas. Migrations to Constantinople and Thessaloniki, where Jewish refugees had settled after the expulsion from Spain, as well as to Italy, Serbia, Romania, Bulgaria, Vienna, and Timișoara, continued into the middle of the 18th century.[citation needed]

Today

[edit]

Late 20th century political and social changes in Spain caused reappraisal of Jewish and Muslim contributions to its culture. There has been much new scholarship on Sephardic Jews, Moors and the consequences of conversion and expulsion. In addition, there have been official governmental efforts to welcome tourists of both ancestries to Spain. Towns and regions have worked to preserve elements of Jewish and Moorish pasts.

In Spanish Civil Code Art. 22.1, the government created concessions to nationals of several countries and Sephardi Jews historically linked with Spain allowing them to seek citizenship after five years rather than the customary ten required for residence in Spain. Later it was dropped to two years. In November 2012, the residency requirement was eliminated.[28] In October 2006, the Parliament of Andalusia asked the three parliamentary groups that form the majority to support an amendment that would similarly ease the way for nationals of Morisco descent to gain Spanish citizenship. The proposal was originally made by IULV-CA, the Andalusian branch of the United Left.[29]

In 2004, Shlomo Moshe Amar traveled to Portugal to celebrate the centennial anniversary of the Lisbon Synagogue "Shaare Tikvah". During his stay, Shlomo Moshe Amar met descendants of Jewish families persecuted by the Inquisition who still practice Judaism at the house of rabbi Boaz Pash. This was an historical meeting that had not happened between a Chief Rabbi and Portuguese Bnei Anusim in centuries. Rabbi Shlomo Moshe Amar promised to create a committee to evaluate the Halachic situation of the community. The delay of the Chief Rabbi to create the committee and help the descendants of Sephardi Jews in Portugal forced the creation of a second Jewish community in Lisbon, Comunidade Judaica Masorti Beit Israel, to ensure the recognition of the Bnei Anusim as Jews.

In literature

[edit]
  • Richard Zimler, The Last Kabbalist of Lisbon, The Overlook Press, ISBN 9781585670222
  • Richard Zimler, Hunting Midnight, Delacorte, ISBN 9780385336444
  • Richard Zimler, Guardian of the Dawn, Constable & Robinson, ISBN 9781845290917
  • Antonio Muñoz Molina, Sepharad, Harvest Books, ISBN 9780156034746
  • David Liss, The Coffee Trader, Abacus, ISBN 978-0349115009

See also

[edit]

Jews in Iberia

[edit]
[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Marrano

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
![Execution of Mariana de Carabajal.jpg][float-right] Marranos were in and who, following mass forced conversions during anti-Jewish pogroms in 1391 and subsequent royal decrees, outwardly adopted while secretly maintaining Jewish beliefs and practices. The term "Marrano," a derogatory Spanish word meaning "swine" or "pig" and likely alluding to Jewish prohibitions against , was applied by to these conversos suspected of "Judaizing." Approximately 250,000 Jews converted under duress in alone, with many fleeing to only to face similar expulsions in 1497, marking one of the largest coerced religious shifts in . The establishment of the in 1478 intensified persecution, as inquisitors targeted crypto-Jews for trials involving torture, public autos-da-fé, and executions to eradicate suspected heresy. Despite social stigma and isolation—even from established Jewish communities wary of their sincerity—Marranos preserved traditions such as lighting candles on Friday evenings and avoiding leavened bread during spring, often disguised as familial customs. Their clandestine resilience contributed to the Sephardic , with emigrants to the , Ottoman territories, and beyond sustaining hidden Jewish identities for centuries, influencing global amid ongoing risks of discovery.

Definition and Etymology

Origins of the Term

The term marrano, applied to Iberian Jews who converted to Christianity under duress but continued to practice Judaism secretly, has an etymology that remains disputed among historians and linguists. The most widely accepted derivation traces it to the Spanish word marrano, meaning "pig" or "swine," a pejorative label implying hypocrisy or impurity, possibly alluding to converts who publicly consumed pork to demonstrate adherence to Christian norms while privately adhering to kosher laws. This usage emerged in the context of suspicion toward conversos (converts) following the 1391 pogroms and intensified with the establishment of the Spanish Inquisition in 1478, where the term denoted those accused of crypto-Judaism. Alternative theories propose non-derogatory origins, such as from the Hebrew-Aramaic phrase mar 'ana ("our Lord") or maran atha ("the Lord has come"), reflecting a supposed blasphemous invocation by converts, though this lacks strong linguistic evidence and is considered less probable by modern etymologists. Another suggestion links it to Arabic muḥarram ("forbidden" or "sacred"), via the idea of deviating from faith, but this is speculative and not supported by primary Iberian texts. The slur's animal connotation aligns with medieval Christian anti-Jewish rhetoric, equating Jews with unclean beasts forbidden in their dietary laws, a motif seen in broader European polemic. The earliest documented English usage of "Marrano" appears in 1561, likely borrowed from Spanish inquisitorial records or travel accounts describing and Spanish converts. In Iberian sources, the term gained currency by the early , often in legal proceedings against suspected , underscoring its role as an accusatory rather than a neutral descriptor. Descendants of these groups have largely rejected marrano due to its inherent disdain, favoring terms like crypto-Jew in contemporary scholarship.

Historical Usage and Connotations

The term marrano first appeared in Iberian records around the early , primarily as a label applied by to who had converted to Catholicism, particularly those suspected of secretly adhering to Jewish practices (). It gained widespread use following the mass conversions during the anti-Jewish riots of 1391 in , when tens of thousands of outwardly accepted to avoid death or enslavement, though many continued private observance of . By the establishment of the in 1478, marrano had become a standard slur in inquisitorial documents and popular discourse to denote these conversos, emphasizing their perceived insincerity and dual allegiance. Etymologically, marrano derives from Spanish vernacular, with its core connotation linking to "swine" or "pig"—an animal ritually impure under Jewish law (kashrut)—symbolizing uncleanliness, hypocrisy, and rejection of Christian norms. Historians such as Yosef Kaplan note that the term evoked the image of converts who publicly consumed pork to demonstrate fidelity while privately abstaining, thus branding them as deceitful "pigs" masquerading as faithful. Alternative derivations, such as from Hebrew mar'it ayin ("appearance of the eye," implying feigned observance) or Arabic moharram ("forbidden"), have been proposed but lack primary evidence and are overshadowed by the porcine insult's prevalence in contemporary texts. The slur's anti-Jewish resonance intensified during Inquisition trials, where marranos faced accusations of Judaizing, often leading to torture, property confiscation, or execution, as documented in over 44,000 Inquisition cases by 1530. In , after the forced conversions of 1497, the term extended to cristãos-novos (New Christians), carrying similar derogatory weight and fueling , intermarriage bans, and economic resentments against perceived Jewish economic dominance. By the , marrano had transcended Iberia, appearing in Dutch, Italian, and English sources to describe Sephardic communities, often with connotations of inherent untrustworthiness that persisted into the . Despite occasional self-adoption by some groups in exile, its primary historical role was as a tool of Christian to delegitimize converts, reflecting broader medieval prejudices against Jewish "otherness" rather than neutral description.

Historical Origins in Iberia

Medieval Jewish Communities

Jewish communities in Iberia trace their presence to Roman times, but the medieval period began under Visigothic rule following the kingdom's establishment in the . From 589 onward, with King Reccared I's conversion to Catholicism at Council of Toledo, Jews faced escalating legal disabilities, including bans on intermarriage, office-holding, and property ownership of Christian slaves. Kings like in 613 mandated mass baptisms, while Recessuinth in 654 and in 693 enacted property confiscations and enslavement for resurgent , though enforcement varied and communities persisted through trade and agriculture. Despite prosperity in urban centers like Toledo, these policies reflected theological hostility codified in church councils such as the Fourth (633) and Twelfth (681) of Toledo. The Muslim conquest starting in 711 under brought relative alleviation, as , like Christians, became dhimmis—protected but subordinate non-Muslims paying taxes. No contemporary sources confirm later Christian claims of Jewish betrayal during the invasion, such as opening Toledo's gates; such narratives emerged in 13th-century chronicles like Lucas of Tuy's. Under Umayyad Cordoba (8th–11th centuries), accessed administrative roles, exemplified by (c. 915–c. 975), a physician-diplomat who served as to Caliph , fostering Hebrew scholarship and corresponding with the Khazar Khaganate on Jewish autonomy. Similarly, Samuel ibn Nagrela (993–1056) rose as , army commander, and nagid (communal leader) in Granada's kingdom, authoring poetry and Talmudic works while defending against Christian incursions. The 10th–12th centuries marked a cultural peak in , with Hebrew secular poetry, philosophy, and science thriving amid Arabic influences, though dhimmi restrictions barred from ruling and exposed them to sporadic , such as the of vizier Joseph ibn Nagrela's regime. Figures like Moses Maimonides (1138–1204), born in Cordoba, synthesized Jewish law () before fleeing Almohad intolerance, which enforced conversions from the 1140s. This era's "Golden Age" narrative, coined in the , overstates harmony—legal inferiority and pragmatic pluralism enabled Jewish economic roles in silk, trade, and medicine, but periodic upheavals underscored vulnerability compared to Christian Europe's more uniform expulsions. In northern Christian kingdoms during the Reconquista, post-1085 Toledo conquests positioned Jews as intermediaries, translators (e.g., toledan tables for Arabic sciences), and courtiers under kings like Alfonso VI and X of Castile (1252–1284), who granted charters amid economic utility as tax farmers and artisans. Portugal mirrored this, with Jews in Lisbon and Porto aiding maritime trade. Yet, by the 13th–14th centuries, canon law pressures, blood libels (e.g., 1255 Toledo boy-martyr myth), and guild exclusions eroded status, fostering convivencia—cultural exchange in shared urban spaces—but with rising clerical agitation and riots presaging 1391. By 1390, Iberian Jews numbered among Europe's largest communities, concentrated in Castile, Aragon, and Navarre, sustaining prosperity through finance and scholarship despite these tensions.

Pogroms and Initial Conversions of 1391

The anti-Jewish riots of 1391 originated in Seville, where archdeacon Ferrand Martínez had been delivering inflammatory sermons against Jews since 1378, accusing them of usury and ritual crimes while defying repeated royal orders from the regency of King Henry III of Castile to cease. Martínez's rhetoric, echoing longstanding Christian grievances over Jewish economic roles in moneylending and taxation collection, ignited mob violence that escalated despite initial suppressions; minor unrest in March gave way to a major assault on June 6, when crowds stormed the Jewish quarter (aljama), killing an estimated 4,000 Jews, destroying synagogues, and razing homes. Survivors faced the stark choice of death or baptism, leading to mass conversions among Seville's Jewish community of roughly 5,000 households, with most opting for nominal Christianity to preserve their lives. The violence rapidly spread across Castile to within days, then to Toledo, , and by late June, fueled by copycat mobs and rumors of Jewish "treachery," before extending into of , striking on July 5–9 (where at least 250 died and the aljama was obliterated) and on August 2. Royal responses proved ineffective amid the regency's weakness; Henry III issued edicts condemning the attacks and promising protection, but local authorities often acquiesced or participated, reflecting underlying clerical influence and popular resentment rather than a broad socioeconomic crisis, as debated by historians like Philippe Wolff. Overall, contemporary estimates suggest 10,000 to 20,000 killed across , with far larger numbers—potentially 100,000 or more—forced into baptism, drastically reducing open Jewish communities and birthing the population whose insincere conversions laid the foundation for later . These events marked a causal , shifting Iberian Jewry from relative tolerance to coerced assimilation under threat of annihilation.

Forced Conversions and the Inquisition Era

Edicts of Expulsion and Baptism in Spain and Portugal

On March 31, 1492, King Ferdinand II of Aragon and Queen Isabella I of Castile issued the Alhambra Decree from Granada, mandating that all Jews in their realms either convert to Christianity or depart by July 31, 1492, under penalty of death and confiscation of property. The edict cited the influence of unconverted Jews on recent converts (conversos) as a primary rationale, accusing them of inducing relapses into Judaism and obstructing Christian unity following the Reconquista's completion with Granada's fall. This policy built on prior pressures, including the 1391 pogroms and voluntary conversions, affecting an estimated Jewish population of 150,000 to 300,000 across Castile and Aragon. Implementation involved severe restrictions: Jews could sell property only to Christians at fixed prices, prohibiting export of gold, silver, or coined money, which forced many sales at undervalued rates and exacerbated economic hardship. Historical estimates indicate that between 40,000 and 150,000 departed for destinations including , , , and the , while a —potentially over 100,000—opted for to remain, swelling the class and fostering suspicions of insincere adherence that later fueled the . The decree's enforcement was inconsistent in remote areas, with some lingering beyond the deadline, but it effectively dismantled open Jewish communities in . In , King Manuel I initially decreed the expulsion of and on December 5, 1496, requiring departure by October 20, 1497, amid pressures to align with for his marriage to Isabella of , which stipulated a "pure" free of non-Christians. had become a refuge for Spanish exiles, hosting perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 by 1496, many of whom had arrived post-1492. However, Manuel reversed course to retain their economic value, ordering mass baptisms instead: on May 2, 1497 (the eve of ), Dominican friars in forcibly baptized thousands of assembled confined in the Estaus Palace and city, with children aged 2 to 10 separated from parents for Christian upbringing. Few escaped Portugal; ships were blocked, and those attempting flight faced enslavement or death, resulting in nearly universal nominal conversion and the creation of "New Christians" (cristãos-novos), a group numbering around 15,000 to 25,000 families, many of whom practiced in secret as Marranos. This policy, distinct from Spain's choice-based expulsion, prioritized retention through coercion, driven by fiscal incentives—New Christians paid a special tax—and labor needs, though it sowed distrust that prompted 's in 1536. The forced baptisms' brutality, including public humiliations and family separations, underscored the edicts' role in eradicating overt while incubating crypto-Jewish resilience amid .

Establishment and Operations of the Inquisitions

The Spanish Inquisition was formally authorized by Pope Sixtus IV through the bull Exigit sincerae devotionis affectus on November 1, 1478, in response to petitions from King Ferdinand II of Aragon and Queen Isabella I of Castile, who sought to address the perceived threat of Judaizing among conversos following the mass conversions of 1391 and subsequent influxes. Initial operations commenced in Seville in late 1480 under Dominican inquisitors, focusing on New Christians suspected of secretly adhering to Jewish practices, with early tribunals arresting hundreds in the region. By 1483, Tomás de Torquemada was appointed as the first Inquisitor General, centralizing authority and expanding tribunals across Castile and Aragon, where procedures emphasized anonymous denunciations, prolonged imprisonments, and interrogations to uncover crypto-Judaism. Inquisitorial operations relied on a structured legal process adapted from , beginning with secret accusations often from neighbors or rivals, followed by summary arrests without formal charges and sequestration of property to fund proceedings. Suspects faced isolation in Inquisition prisons, where interrogators employed psychological pressure and, if unyielding, —such as the potro (rack) or toca (waterboarding-like method)—to elicit confessions of Judaizing, though papal and royal edicts limited to avoid permanent harm or death, requiring medical oversight. Trials culminated in verdicts classifying offenders as reconciled (fined, penanced, or galley-sent), penitents (publicly humiliated in ceremonies), or unrepentant heretics consigned to secular arms for execution by burning, with Seville's 1481 alone resulting in over 700 convictions, many against families. The , established in 1536 under King John III with Cum ad Inquisitio from , mirrored Spanish models but intensified scrutiny of cristãos-novos (New Christians) amid forced conversions post-1497 edict, setting up tribunals in , , and that operated until 1821. Procedures paralleled those in , with a Familiars network of informants enforcing surveillance, confiscations funding lavish autos-de-fé—public spectacles reconciling thousands while executing hundreds, peaking in the 1540s—and a focus on detecting residual Jewish customs like observance or kosher dietary remnants, leading to over 40,000 trials by the 18th century, disproportionately targeting mercantile elites. Both Inquisitions justified operations as safeguarding Catholic purity against internal subversion, yet archival records reveal motivations intertwined with economic gain from property seizures and social leveling against prominence in and administration.

Trials, Auto-da-Fé, and Punishments

Inquisition trials targeting Marranos, or crypto-Jews suspected of secretly adhering to , began with denunciations from informants, often neighbors or family members motivated by grudges or incentives. Authorities issued secret warrants for without prior notification, leading to immediate in Inquisition dungeons under harsh conditions of isolation and deprivation. Interrogations proceeded in phases, starting with psychological coercion and escalating to —such as the potro (a form of ) or —when approved by tribunals to extract detailed confessions of "judaizing" rituals like observing or dietary laws. The accused faced secret proceedings where identities of witnesses were concealed, and defense relied heavily on counter-denunciations or implausible denials, with trials potentially lasting years. Sentences culminated in the , a public spectacle of reconciliation and judgment held in major plazas or cathedrals, featuring processions of penitents and condemned clad in sanbenitos—yellow tunics emblazoned with symbols of . These ceremonies, presided over by inquisitors, bishops, and civil officials, included a , sermon decrying , and reading of verdicts for hundreds at once, serving both as religious affirmation and deterrent. The first such event occurred in on February 6, 1481, where six conversos were burned alive following convictions for judaizing. By November 1481, Seville's tribunals had conducted multiple autos-da-fé, resulting in approximately 300 executions and 79 life imprisonments. Punishments varied by degree of perceived and : minor offenders received spiritual penances, fines, via sanbenito wearing, or temporary , often with property confiscation to fund operations. Relapsed or unrepentant faced severe penalties, including perpetual service, lifelong incarceration in squalid conditions, or "relaxation to the secular arm"— for handover to civil authorities for burning at the stake (quemadero), typically alive if defiant or in effigy for the deceased or fugitives. Under Grand Inquisitor Tomás de Torquemada (1483–1498), over 8,000 individuals, predominantly conversos, suffered execution by fire across Spain. In Portugal, after the 's 1536 establishment, similar autos-da-fé imposed burnings, such as six in on December 15, 1647, alongside 60 imprisonments. Notable cases include Mariana de Carabajal, burned in in 1590 for persistent despite prior reconciliations. Estimates of total executions for , largely against Marranos, range from thousands to over 30,000 across Iberian tribunals and colonies from 1481 to the , though precise figures remain debated due to incomplete records.

Crypto-Judaism Practices

Secret Observances and Syncretism

Crypto-Jews, or Marranos, maintained Jewish observances in private domestic settings to evade scrutiny, often adapting rituals for secrecy after the forced conversions of 1492 in and 1497 in . These practices centered on core elements of such as observance, dietary laws, and prayers, performed covertly within households where women frequently played central roles in transmission and execution. For instance, families lit candles hidden in cupboards or under beds on Friday evenings to mark the onset, recited the prayer facing eastward while kneeling, and recited omitting the Christian doxology. Dietary restrictions were upheld discreetly by avoiding pork and animal fats, sometimes rationalized through appeals to saintly examples or prepared meals separately from Christian households; involved and roasted meats in secret gatherings, while clean clothing distinguished days without public cessation of work. High holidays like saw communal and rituals in homes, with participants confessing sins orally to family elders rather than priests. occurred sporadically in infancy or later, viewed syncretically as a path to salvation akin to Catholic sacraments, though often postponed to minimize detection risks. Syncretism emerged as a survival mechanism, fusing Jewish rites with Catholic forms to mask intent; conversos attended publicly while interpreting saints as proxies for Jewish angels or patriarchs, and blended obedience with narratives, such as equating dietary laws with avoidance. This improvisation created hybrid customs, like timing Jewish fasts to coincide with Catholic vigils or using domestic Catholic icons for private Jewish meditations, preserving identity amid fragmentation over generations. trials, such as those of the Carvajal family in 1595 —descended from Iberian crypto-Jews—revealed these adaptations through confessions of oral transmission from parents to children around age 13, underscoring how sustained practices despite erosion of full rabbinic knowledge.

Familial Transmission and Detection Risks

Crypto-Jewish practices among Marranos were primarily transmitted orally within families, with parents instructing children in secret rituals despite public adherence to . Mothers often played a central role, teaching prayers, holiday observances, and customs like avoiding to safeguard male family members from . Specific methods included employing discreet agents for kosher slaughter and , as well as home-based gatherings for seders using and roasted meats. Transmission emphasized syncretic adaptations, such as fasting on while feigning Catholic vigils or fleeing to rural areas to evade urban surveillance during festivals. and genealogical awareness were preserved covertly across generations, even as families adopted Christian identities. In cases like the Carvajal family, traditions spanned four generations post-1492, with oral teachings of Mosaic law delayed until adolescence for security. Detection risks were acute due to the Inquisition's familial focus, prosecuting entire lineages upon suspicion. Common triggers included denunciations by servants noticing kosher preparations, absence of chimney smoke on Sabbaths, or donning clean clothes on Fridays. Inquisitorial methods involved secret interrogations, to extract confessions implicating relatives, and scrutiny of physical evidence like during trials or autopsies. Children's testimonies under duress often exposed family practices, as in the 1595 trials of the Carvajals, where a community of about 35 faced exposure via a single confession. Broader perils included mob violence, as in the 1506 of over 2,000 Marranos discovered with items, and property confiscation following convictions. These mechanisms perpetuated a climate of betrayal fears, with even internal family disputes leading to mutual accusations under .

Theological and Causal Factors Behind Persistence

Jewish classifies individuals subjected to forced , known as , as retaining their inherent Jewish status, rendering coerced baptisms theologically invalid and obligating secret adherence to commandments (mitzvot) where overt practice is impossible. Rabbinic authorities, including Isaac ben Sheshet Perfet (Ribash), who himself converted under duress during the 1391 pogroms before returning to , issued responsa affirming that remain fully Jewish, with their marital bonds and ritual capacities intact; Ribash advised outward conformity to for survival while inwardly preserving faith and performing clandestine observances, drawing on precedents like Queen Esther's concealment of her identity. This doctrinal framework provided a theological justification for persistence, framing not as but as resilient fidelity amid persecution, with hopes of eventual redemption or messianic restoration reinforcing commitment. Causally, persistence relied on intergenerational transmission within families, where women played a pivotal role in embedding practices into household routines—such as veiled candle-lighting, blood-draining of meat to approximate kosher laws, or whispered prayers—allowing rituals to evade detection while embedding in children from infancy. trials from the late 15th century onward, including those in and , document over 1,000 cases of such familial secrecy, where practices like or avoidance of Christian sacraments were passed matrilineally, sustaining despite risks of denunciation and execution. This mechanism was amplified by within converso networks, fostering in-group solidarity and that deterred full assimilation, as abandonment would fracture kinship ties forged in shared duress. Scholars analyzing Inquisition archives, such as , contend that among persistent —estimated at a minority but devout core of conversos—the drive was sincere theological conviction rather than superficial habit, evidenced by deliberate risks like maintaining Hebrew texts or observing fasts, which persisted into the even after generational dilution. External pressures, including perpetual suspicion from the established in 1478, paradoxically bolstered causal resilience by reinforcing group cohesion and viewing public as a temporary , with empirical patterns in trial data showing higher persistence in isolated or kin-dense communities. This interplay of immutable identity and adaptive secrecy explains the endurance of crypto-Judaism beyond initial conversions, influencing diaspora communities into the 17th century.

Socio-Economic Roles and Societal Tensions

Involvement in Finance, Trade, and Professions

New Christians, following the mass conversions of 1391 in and 1497 in , gained access to economic sectors and professions previously restricted to , such as moneylending, administration, and guild-based trades, due to their nominal Christian status. This shift allowed many to leverage pre-conversion mercantile skills and international networks, particularly in where forced baptisms preserved a larger pool of conversos integrated into society. By the early , New Christians constituted a significant portion of farmers and royal contractors, handling collections for duties and monopolies like , which fueled revenues amid expanding colonial enterprises. Their role in these fiscal mechanisms, however, often bred resentment among Old Christians, who viewed such positions as exploitative despite the contracts being competitively bid. In finance and banking, prominent New Christian families established operations that bridged Iberian ports with . The Mendes brothers, Francisco (d. 1536) and Diogo (d. c. 1542), originating from stock, built a vast enterprise in spices, silks, and bullion exchange, with branches in , (founded 1512), and beyond, serving as financiers to emperors like Charles V. Similarly, families like the Ximenes engaged in bill-of-exchange practices and colonial financing from and , facilitating Spain's transatlantic ventures despite inquisitorial scrutiny. These activities, reliant on familial ties across borders, positioned New Christians as key intermediaries in credit networks, though accusations of persisted, rooted in prohibitions that Old Christians evaded through proxies. Trade saw New Christians dominate import-export sectors, including goods routed through and Atlantic commodities via . In the 16th century, they controlled much of Portugal's logistics and provisioning for fleets, often as agents for royal asientos (contracts). In , conversos like those in the Mendes network handled wool, sugar, and dyestuffs, contributing to economic vitality but facing purity-of-blood statutes that limited guild entry after 1500. Their commercial acumen stemmed from connections, enabling ventures Old Christians shunned due to risk or prejudice. In liberal professions, New Christians entered , , and administration, barred to Jews but open post-conversion. Physicians of converso origin, such as those documented in 15th-16th century Castile, treated nobility and held university chairs, drawing on Hebrew medical texts adapted to Christian practice. Scribes, notaries, and jurists proliferated among them, aiding bureaucratic expansion; for instance, conversos staffed royal chancelleries and inquisitorial tribunals ironically. Artisans in silk weaving and dyeing also featured prominently, with New Christian workshops in Toledo and supplying luxury markets, though economic success amplified suspicions of Judaizing networks. Overall, their socioeconomic ascent, peaking mid-16th century before inquisitorial purges, underscored tensions between utility to the state and perceived disloyalty.

Economic Contributions Versus Suspicions of Usury and Disloyalty

New Christians, including many crypto-Jews known as Marranos, filled critical roles in Iberian finance and commerce after the forced conversions of the late 15th century, drawing on pre-existing Jewish expertise in international trade networks and moneylending. In Portugal, following the 1497 edict mandating baptism, they rapidly assumed dominance in sectors like tax farming and speculative ventures in commodities such as cereals, which fueled economic expansion but also contributed to inflation as noted by the chronicler Damião de Góis in the early 16th century. Their involvement extended to overseas enterprises, including the lucrative spice and luxury goods trade with Asia, where they utilized familial and diasporic connections to facilitate capital flows and merchant partnerships otherwise limited by religious restrictions on Old Christians. Despite these contributions, New Christians faced persistent accusations of usury from Old Christian competitors, who viewed their lending practices—permitted under Jewish law but canonically forbidden to Christians—as exploitative and evidence of insincere conversion. Medieval , such as the Fourth Council's 1215 prohibitions, had confined usury to , fostering resentment when conversos inherited and expanded these roles post-expulsion, often charging interest rates deemed exorbitant amid economic pressures like the 16th-century . Inquisition tribunals frequently scrutinized financial dealings as indicators of Judaizing, with trials revealing stereotypes of Marrano frugality and profit-seeking as "proof" of secret allegiance to rather than economic acumen. Suspicions of disloyalty compounded these economic tensions, as crypto-Judaism was portrayed not only as religious apostasy but as a threat to state loyalty, with New Christians accused of prioritizing imagined Jewish kin abroad over Iberian crowns. In Spain and Portugal during the 16th century, their prominence in transatlantic and Indian Ocean trade raised fears of covert alliances with Ottoman or Dutch rivals, especially as Inquisition records documented alleged conspiracies blending economic espionage with ritual crimes. Such charges, often amplified by envy over their upward mobility—evident in the overrepresentation of conversos in urban professions by 1500—served to justify discriminatory statutes like the 1449 Toledo purity-of-blood laws, which barred them from public office despite their fiscal utility to monarchs reliant on their loans and expertise. While some accusations stemmed from verifiable secret networks, many reflected causal Old Christian insecurities in a mercantilizing economy where New Christians' adaptability outpaced traditional guilds.

Impact on Iberian Society and Economy

The forced conversions and subsequent among New Christians initially filled critical economic voids in Iberia left by the 1492 expulsion of unconverted from and the 1497 mass baptisms in , as these groups dominated , , and artisanal production—sectors shunned by Old Christians due to religious prohibitions on and preferences for noble or agrarian pursuits. In , New Christians controlled much of the 16th-century Atlantic and Asian trade networks, including the lucrative Brazil and monopolies, leveraging familial ties across the empire to facilitate capital flows and merchant ventures that sustained revenues and colonial expansion. Their and commercial acumen, evidenced by lower age-heaping in records compared to Old Christians, underscored their role in advancing Iberian economic sophistication during the . However, escalating suspicions of Judaizing fueled by the Inquisitions—established in in 1478 and in 1536—imposed severe disruptions, including property confiscations, trials of over 40,000 Portuguese New Christians, and the execution or sentencing of approximately 1,200, which eroded merchant networks and provoked to rival powers like the . These persecutions exacerbated long-term economic stagnation, as the loss of skilled expertise mirrored the post-1492 decline in , where the departure of Jewish financiers and traders contributed to reduced innovation and fiscal inefficiencies persisting into the . Emigration of affluent New Christians transferred commercial know-how abroad, bolstering competitors' economies while depriving Iberia of taxable wealth and entrepreneurial dynamism. Socially, the Marrano phenomenon entrenched divisions through statutes, originating in Toledo in 1449 and proliferating across institutions by the mid-16th century, which barred New Christians from universities, military orders, and public offices unless proving untainted ancestry, thereby institutionalizing and fostering resentment among Old Christians envious of converso success. This purity-of-blood regime, rationalized as safeguarding Catholic orthodoxy, stifled and merit-based advancement, perpetuating a bifurcated society where New Christians faced perpetual stigma despite nominal integration, leading to insular communities prone to detection and further inquisitorial scrutiny. The resultant atmosphere of suspicion undermined trust in institutions, inhibited cultural exchange, and reinforced a confessional absolutism that prioritized doctrinal uniformity over societal cohesion, with ripple effects evident in reduced intermarriage and persistent ethnic-religious hierarchies into the 18th century.

Diaspora Migrations

Movements to Italy and Southern Europe

Following the 1492 Alhambra Decree expelling Jews from and the 1497 edict in , numerous conversos, including practicing Marranos, migrated to offering relative tolerance and economic opportunities, often reverting openly to where permitted. Rulers in fragmented Italian principalities, seeking to bolster commerce, extended privileges to these skilled merchants and professionals, who brought networks spanning Iberia, , and the . While some maintained crypto-Judaic practices amid risks, many integrated into existing Jewish communities, contributing to trade in silks, spices, and dyes. In , under the d'Este dukes, Ercole I granted settlement and religious to 21 Spanish and Marrano families as early as 1492–1493, enabling open profession of and refuge for those fleeing expulsions from , , and elsewhere. The Jewish population swelled to approximately 3,000 by the mid-16th century, fueled by Marrano influxes that stimulated exports to Iberian colonies and via connections in , , and . Abraham Usque, a former Marrano, established a prominent Hebrew press there from 1552 to 1555, producing the influential Ferrara Bible in Ladino for use. These privileges endured until the papal annexation in 1597, after which persecutions intensified, including arrests leading to burnings in by 1583. Ancona emerged as a papal trading hub attracting Portuguese Marranos; explicitly invited them in 1547 to enhance commerce, with Julius III renewing protections against charges, resulting in about 3,000 Portuguese Jews and Marranos residing there by 1553. This settlement advanced port activities but provoked backlash under Paul IV, who in 1555–1556 ordered mass arrests, culminating in 24 public burnings and 60 individuals sentenced to galleys or . Interventions, such as bribes and advocacy by figures like , spared some, though the community fragmented, with failed relocation attempts to . Venice hosted early Marrano settlements in the 15th and early 16th centuries, but issued expulsions in 1497 and 1550 amid pressures; subsequent policy shifts resisted extradition, viewing forced converts as beyond papal jurisdiction, allowing open reversions among "Ponentine" (western) Marranos from and . Further south, Tuscany's became a late-16th-century haven when I issued a 1593 safeguarding Marranos as a free port, drawing conversos who reverted to and expanding the community to thousands by the through trade exemptions. These Italian enclaves, while not immune to reversals under zealous popes or dukes, preserved Marrano lineages and facilitated further dispersals.

Settlement in France and Northern Europe

In the mid-16th century, Portuguese New Christians, many of whom were crypto-Jews fleeing the , began settling in southwestern , particularly in and the surrounding regions of , under favorable royal edicts issued by King Henry II in 1550. These patents permitted them to reside and trade as Catholic merchants without immediate scrutiny of their religious practices, though they continued crypto-Judaic observances in secrecy, such as clandestine rituals and dietary restrictions, to evade detection by local authorities and the Church. emerged as a primary hub, attracting merchants skilled in Atlantic trade, including the importation of sugar, dyes, and later , which they introduced to French markets through connections with colonies. By the late , several hundred such families had established themselves, forming semi-autonomous communities while outwardly conforming to Catholicism; suspicions of Judaizing persisted, leading to occasional inquisitorial probes from extending into French territory. Further south, near , the suburb of Saint-Esprit developed as another key settlement site starting in the 1550s, where Portuguese immigrants concentrated in and artisanry, maintaining hidden synagogues and transmission of Jewish traditions within families. These communities in and nearby areas like Bidache operated under nominal Catholic identity until the , when formal recognition as came piecemeal; for instance, limited occurred in the , though full legal status awaited the . Smaller pockets existed in and , where crypto-Jews engaged in shipping and finance but faced heightened risks of exposure due to proximity to inquisitorial networks, prompting some to relocate northward or abroad. In , the offered greater refuge following its revolt against Spanish rule, with Portuguese New Christians arriving in from the late 1590s onward, initially via after its fall in 1585. By 1599, approximately 100 Portuguese Jews resided there, swelling to several hundred by 1602, as documented in municipal records granting them trading privileges without religious coercion. Unlike in , the tolerant policies of the United Provinces allowed many to openly revert to , establishing early prayer halls like around 1598–1600 and formal synagogues by the early , fostering a vibrant community that peaked at over 2,500 members by mid-century. These settlers, often affluent merchants, contributed to 's ascent as a global trade center, specializing in spices, diamonds, and colonial goods, while integrating crypto-Judaic families from who had first passed through or . Smaller groups reached in the 1590s, practicing semi-clandestine under Lutheran oversight, and later after Oliver Cromwell's informal readmission in 1656, though the remained the epicenter with its relative religious liberty.

Expansion to the Americas and the Caribbean

Portuguese New Christians, including those secretly adhering to Judaism, participated in the colonization of Brazil starting from the early 16th century, forming part of the Gente da Nação diaspora and engaging in trade, sugar production, and exploration. By the 1540s, significant numbers had settled in regions like Bahia and Pernambuco, where they contributed to economic development despite facing suspicions of Judaizing. The Portuguese Inquisition conducted visitations in Brazil from 1591, resulting in numerous trials for crypto-Judaism, with records indicating around 400 cases by the 18th century, primarily targeting New Christians accused of maintaining Jewish rituals such as Sabbath observance and kosher practices. In Spanish American colonies, royal decrees from 1501 prohibited Jewish converts from emigrating to the , yet many New Christians arrived covertly, often via trade networks, settling in , , and Cartagena de Indias by the mid-16th century. The established tribunals in in 1571 and Cartagena in 1610, prosecuting crypto-Jews for offenses like and avoidance of , with intensified activity between 1610 and 1650 leading to executions and expulsions. Notable cases, such as the in in 1590 involving Mariana de Carabajal, highlighted the persistence of secret Jewish networks amid colonial commerce. Expansion into the occurred primarily through Portuguese and Dutch colonial spheres, where New Christians initially practiced before some communities transitioned to open observance after Dutch seizures in the . In Brazil's Dutch period (1630–1654), from and bolstered settlements, fleeing to , , and upon Portuguese reconquest in 1654, establishing synagogues and cemeteries that evidenced their Iberian Marrano origins. British capture of in 1655 facilitated Jewish settlement in , integrating former crypto-Jews into plantation economies while maintaining familial transmission of Judaic customs. These migrations underscored the role of economic opportunities in sustaining Marrano lineages despite inquisitorial pressures.

Presence in Portuguese India and Asia

Following the establishment of control over in 1510, New Christians of Jewish origin migrated to as part of the colonial enterprise, drawn by commercial prospects in the and relative distance from metropolitan inquisitorial oversight. These settlers, outwardly professing Catholicism, included professionals and merchants who integrated into the colonial administration and economy; for example, , a physician of descent, arrived in around 1532 and authored influential works on Indian and , reflecting their contributions to knowledge dissemination amid empire-building. Their presence in Cochin, another early Portuguese foothold from 1500 onward, similarly supported in diamonds and textiles, though open Jewish communities there predated Portuguese arrival and operated separately under royal protection until tensions arose. Suspicions of persistent Judaizing practices among these New Christians prompted ecclesiastical alarm, with figures like decrying their influence in letters to King John III as early as the 1540s, urging expulsion to safeguard Catholic purity in the colonies. The , formally instituted in 1560 under royal decree, extended Portuguese inquisitorial mechanisms to , targeting crypto-Jewish activities such as secret observance and dietary restrictions; by 1565, it was operational, leading to over 16,000 trials across its history, with New Christians comprising a significant portion of defendants in the initial decades. Documented cases underscore the scale of scrutiny: in 1543, Jerónimo Dias was executed in for Judaizing, one of the earliest convictions; between 1558 and 1561, Diogo Soares and Simão Nunes faced arrests in and Cochin respectively for similar charges; and in 1568–1569, Catarina da Horta and Gonçalo Rodrigues were prosecuted in for clandestine Jewish rites. Later instances, such as the 1598–1602 trial of João Nunes Baião in , involved accusations of maintaining Jewish customs, often substantiated by denunciations from slaves or rivals, highlighting how economic rivalries fueled inquisitorial actions. Beyond , New Christians extended into Portuguese Asia's trade networks, reaching and Macao by the mid-16th century, where they facilitated intra-Asian commerce in slaves, spices, and textiles, though their numbers remained modest compared to and subject to vigilant oversight by viceregal authorities and missionaries. The of , Dom Gaspar Jorge de Leão Pereira, actively campaigned against crypto-Jewish enclaves in the 1560s, viewing them as threats to conversion efforts among indigenous populations, which inadvertently amplified their visibility through forced public penances and confiscations. Despite such pressures, their economic roles persisted until the Inquisition's relocation to in 1774 diminished colonial enforcement, allowing some descendants to assimilate or disperse further.

Modern Descendants and Genetic Legacy

Demographic Distribution Today

Descendants of Marranos, referred to as Bnei Anusim in Hebrew, are primarily concentrated in regions historically linked to Iberian colonial expansion, including the and , with genetic traces extending to an estimated 200 million individuals worldwide possessing Sephardic ancestry. The estimates the core Bnei Anusim population—those with traceable forced-convert lineage and potential for cultural reconnection—at several million globally. Most remain assimilated within Catholic or secular populations, unaware of or uninterested in their heritage, though DNA testing and citizenship programs have spurred identification among subsets. In and , where forced conversions originated, descendants comprise a substantial demographic layer; genetic analyses reveal Sephardic Jewish markers in roughly 20% of the combined population of approximately 57 million, equating to over 11 million individuals with such ancestry as of studies through the early , a pattern corroborated in subsequent research. Recent reconnection efforts highlight this: 's 2015 Sephardic citizenship law has drawn over 250,000 applications by 2023, predominantly from , , and the , while processed 132,226 applications by the 2019 deadline for its analogous program. These figures, though representing self-selecting claimants rather than the full descendant pool, underscore latent demographic presence amid ongoing legal reforms tightening eligibility as of 2024. Latin America hosts the largest concentrations outside Iberia, with genetic surveys indicating Jewish ancestry—often Marrano-derived—in up to 25% of the region's 650 million inhabitants, particularly in , , , , and . Crypto-Jewish practices persist in isolated rural pockets, such as northern 's criptojudíos, though formal communities number in the thousands rather than millions; alone has documented several hundred families maintaining hidden rituals into the . Broader populations in these countries carry the heaviest , reflecting colonial-era migrations of New Christians, with and leading in absolute terms due to their sizes (over 200 million and 130 million, respectively). Smaller but growing pockets exist , where immigrants and DNA-tested individuals (often from n stock) form informal networks, contributing to tens of thousands of self-identified descendants amid the 60 million-plus Latino population. In , Bnei Anusim immigrants from and Iberia number in the low thousands annually, bolstering organized reconnection programs. European remnants, including in the and , trace to 16th-17th century exiles but remain demographically marginal today, with fewer than actively claiming Marrano ties. Overall, while precise self-identifying counts elude enumeration due to assimilation, genetic and migratory data affirm a skewed toward Ibero-American spheres.

Genetic Studies Confirming Ancestry

Genetic studies have identified elevated frequencies of Sephardic Jewish (mtDNA) and Y-chromosome haplogroups in populations historically associated with Portuguese crypto-Jews, such as communities in the Trás-os-Montes region near Bragança. For instance, analysis of mtDNA in self-identified crypto-Jewish descendants revealed lineages like HV1b, K1a1b1a, and J1c, which trace back to Near Eastern origins and are characteristic of pre-expulsion Sephardic Jewish maternal pools, with frequencies higher than in surrounding non-Jewish populations. Similarly, Y-chromosome data from these groups show overrepresentation of haplogroups J1-M267 and E-M34, markers linked to ancient Jewish patrilineal descent, supporting a genetic continuity with medieval Iberian Jewry despite centuries of and admixture. In broader Iberian populations, a study of over 1,100 males found that 11% to 19% carry Y-chromosome lineages attributable to Sephardic Jewish ancestry, particularly in western and , reflecting the impact of forced conversions during the 15th-century expulsions and Inquisition.00592-2) This patrilineal signal aligns with historical records of integration into Christian society, where male converts often married local women, preserving Jewish paternal markers while diluting maternal ones through assimilation. North African Berber ancestry was also detected at 8-10% in some regions, consistent with Moorish influences, but the Jewish component remains distinct due to its Levantine genetic affinities. Among Latin American descendants of Iberian migrants, genome-wide analyses of thousands of individuals from , , , and other countries indicate that 10-15% exhibit at least 25% recent Sephardic Jewish ancestry, often undetected in self-reported identities due to cultural erasure post-Inquisition. These findings, derived from admixture mapping against reference panels of medieval Jewish genomes, confirm migration patterns to the , where crypto-practices persisted in isolated communities; for example, Puerto Rican samples showed up to 20% Jewish autosomal components, corroborating documentary evidence of Marrano settlement in the . However, such population-level signals do not universally validate individual claims of unbroken crypto-Jewish transmission, as gene flow from non-converso complicates attribution.
Study FocusKey FindingPopulation SampledSource
mtDNA in Portuguese crypto-JewsElevated Sephardic lineages (e.g., J1c at 20-30%)100+ Bragança descendantsEJHG 2014
Y-chromosome in Iberia11-19% Sephardic Jewish haplogroups1,100+ Spanish/Portuguese malesAJHG 2008
Autosomal in 10-15% with ≥25% Jewish ancestry6,500+ from 7 countriesNature Comm. 2018 via Atlantic

Contemporary Reconnection and Identity Claims

In recent decades, descendants of Marranos—forced converts from during the Iberian Inquisitions—have increasingly sought to reclaim their ancestral through genealogical research, DNA testing, and formal affiliation with Jewish communities. This reconnection often involves verifying family traditions of , such as avoiding , lighting candles on Friday evenings, or observing unique rituals, which persisted in isolated pockets despite centuries of assimilation. Organizations like the Sephardic Brotherhood and initiatives by groups such as Netivyah facilitate education and support for these individuals, enabling some to undergo formal conversion or recognition as under Orthodox standards. A prominent example is the community in , where crypto-Jews maintained secret practices for over 450 years after the 1497 forced conversions. Rediscovered in the 1910s by engineer Samuel Schwarz and publicly emerging in the 1980s following the Portuguese Revolution, the group built the Mekor Haim Synagogue in 1996 and now numbers around 300 openly identifying members, blending preserved customs with mainstream . Similar revivals have occurred in nearby regions like Trancoso, where locals have transitioned from hidden observances to public Jewish life, aided by and cultural preservation efforts. Legislative measures have accelerated these claims. In 2015, enacted a granting to Sephardic descendants as restitution for the 1492 expulsion, requiring proof of ancestry via rabbinical certificates or ; over 130,000 applied by 2019, though approvals demanded rigorous verification to prevent unsubstantiated claims. Portugal's analogous 2015 policy, extended indefinitely in 2022, has processed tens of thousands of applications, particularly from Latin American applicants demonstrating ties to Portuguese Sephardim through surnames, language (e.g., Ladino elements), or community endorsements. Critics note that while many applications reflect genuine heritage, economic incentives like access have prompted scrutiny of weaker cases lacking continuous Jewish self-identification. Among Hispanic populations in the Americas, identity claims often stem from family lore and DNA results indicating Sephardic markers, with studies estimating 15-20% of Latinos carry such ancestry from converso migrants during the colonial era. Communities in New Mexico and Mexico, for instance, have formed groups like the Society for Crypto-Judaic Studies to explore these roots, leading some to affiliate with synagogues or immigrate to Israel under the Law of Return. However, scholars emphasize that genetic presence does not equate to unbroken cultural Judaism, as many descendants assimilated fully into Catholicism, rendering some claims more aspirational than evidentiary.

Controversies and Scholarly Debates

Debates on Conversion Sincerity and Crypto-Judaism's Extent

![Execution of Mariana de Carabajal.jpg][float-right] Scholars have long debated the sincerity of converso conversions to following the mass baptisms of 1391 and the 1492 expulsion edict, with positions diverging on whether most Marranos genuinely assimilated or maintained secret Jewish practices. Historians such as Yitzhak Baer portrayed Marranos as steadfast Jews who preserved their identity covertly, viewing as a form of resistance integral to Jewish continuity despite persecution. In contrast, revisionist scholars like argued that the majority of conversos became sincere Christians over time, with limited to a small minority; he contended that records exaggerated relapses, as most conversos rejected and integrated into Christian society, facing ethnic prejudice rather than widespread . The extent of crypto-Judaism remains contentious, with evidence drawn primarily from tribunals documenting practices like avoiding pork, observing secret Sabbaths, and reciting prayers in hiding. Haim Beinart's analysis of trials (1483–1527) highlighted persistent judaizing among families, interpreting these as indicators of broad subterranean adherence rather than isolated anomalies. However, Henry Kamen and Netanyahu emphasized the low prosecution rates relative to the population—estimated at 150,000 to 300,000 in Castile alone by the early —against only about 2,000 executions for between 1480 and 1530, suggesting crypto-Judaism was not pervasive but amplified by social rivalries and false denunciations from Old Christians envious of economic success. This historiographical divide reflects differing interpretations of Inquisition archives: earlier Zionist scholars like Baer prioritized narratives of Jewish resilience, potentially overstating 's scope to affirm collective endurance, while later analyses, informed by critical source evaluation, highlight assimilation dynamics and the 's role in enforcing social purity statutes over combating a genuine religious underground. Empirical patterns, such as declining relapse rates post-1520s and conversos holding high ecclesiastical positions, support the view that sincere conversion predominated, though pockets of persisted in familial networks, particularly among Portuguese conversos after 1497.

Interpretations of Persecution Versus Self-Interest

Historians interpreting the Marrano phenomenon have contrasted explanations rooted in relentless persecution with those emphasizing self-interested motivations for conversion and assimilation. Traditional accounts, exemplified by Yitzhak Baer's A History of the Jews in Christian Spain, portray conversions as largely coerced responses to pogroms like those of 1391 and the 1492 expulsion decree, with crypto-Judaism emerging as a clandestine preservation of faith amid existential threats from the Inquisition and "purity of blood" statutes. Baer viewed Marranos as embodying Jewish resilience, their secret practices a testament to spiritual endurance against state-enforced Christianity. Benzion Netanyahu challenged this in The Marranos of Spain, analyzing Inquisition tribunals, rabbinic responsa, and contemporary chronicles to argue that many conversions from the late 14th to early 16th centuries were voluntary pursuits of integration, driven by Jews' exclusion from Christian guilds, land tenure, and public offices under discriminatory laws. Post-conversion, conversos leveraged their literacy and mercantile skills for rapid advancement: by the 1440s, figures like Solomon Halevi (later Archbishop of Toledo) exemplified rises in ecclesiastical and administrative roles previously barred to Jews. Netanyahu contended that widespread crypto-Judaism was a minority phenomenon, exaggerated by Inquisition records prone to unsubstantiated denunciations from Old Christian rivals envious of New Christian prosperity in trade and finance. Evidence from over 13,000 cases in the 1480s–1520s shows variability: while some trials uncovered Judaizing (e.g., observance or kosher avoidance lapses), many convictions rested on or social grudges rather than concrete relapse, supporting Netanyahu's view that often targeted successful assimilators irrespective of prior adherence. Critics, including those echoing Baer, counter that systemic terror—evidenced by 2,000 executions in the 's first decade—rendered "voluntary" conversion illusory, prioritizing physical survival over doctrinal sincerity. Netanyahu's thesis, though influential for its primary-source rigor, remains contested for downplaying communal pressures and violence's psychological toll, with some scholars noting its divergence from narratives valorizing Marrano martyrdom. This interpretive divide reflects broader historiographic tensions: persecution-centric views align with Jewish communal traditions emphasizing collective victimhood, while analyses highlight causal factors like economic incentives, where conversion enabled tens of thousands—comprising up to 200,000 by 1492—to evade Jewish-specific taxes and restrictions, fostering a elite despite enduring antisemitic backlash. Primary records indicate neither extreme dominated; instead, decisions blended duress with opportunism, as seen in conversos who thrived secularly without versus those reverting under kin influence. Netanyahu's approach, prioritizing empirical scrutiny of biased inquisitorial data over idealized resistance stories, underscores how envy of converso gains fueled statutes like Toledo's 1449 blood purity law, perpetuating conflict beyond religious fidelity.

Mythologization and Political Uses of Marrano History

The Marrano experience has been mythologized in both popular and scholarly narratives as a tale of unyielding , depicting conversos as uniformly preserving Jewish rituals in secrecy across generations despite pressures. Historical analyses, however, reveal that by the early 16th century, the majority of Spanish Marranos had assimilated into , detaching from Judaizing practices amid social and economic incentives for conformity rather than perpetual hidden fidelity. This romanticization often attributes ambiguous folk customs—such as lighting candles on Fridays or avoiding —in contemporary communities to Marrano ancestry, though evidence frequently points to later cultural revivals or coincidences rather than unbroken transmission. In , the "" elevates this duality into a foundational for , arguing that conversos' split existence—outward Christian observance masking inner Jewish adherence—engendered subjective , , and the modern will to reform . Philosopher Yirmiyahu Yovel contends that Marranos "discovered the subjective mind" through their hybrid condition, positioning them as precursors to secular and tolerance, a view echoed in interpretations linking hidden to emerging Western rationality. Such framings, while insightful for tracing cultural influences, risk overgeneralizing a minority phenomenon of genuine into a paradigm-shifting , sidelining cases of sincere conversion or full assimilation driven by pragmatic . Politically, Marrano narratives have served diverse agendas, from bolstering claims of enduring —as in Benzion Netanyahu's use of to underscore immutable hostility—to symbolizing fluid, non-monolithic identities in postmodern . Thinkers like invoked the Marrano as an emblem of managing "inner tensions" between and , appealing to multicultural ideologies that valorize over fixed communal boundaries. In policy realms, and Portugal's 2015 citizenship laws for Sephardic descendants explicitly referenced Inquisition-era expulsions, facilitating around 100,000 applications by 2023 as a form of historical reparations, while Israel's has prompted debates over Bnei eligibility, with rabbinical scrutiny often highlighting evidentiary gaps in claimed continuity. These uses, though rooted in verifiable , amplify mythic elements of unbroken lineage to advance reparative or identitarian goals, sometimes at the expense of nuanced showing widespread Catholic integration by the 17th century.

Cultural Representations

In Literature and Art

Depictions of Marrano persecution appear in historical art illustrating inquisitorial punishments, such as Francisco Goya's Caprichos series (1799), where etchings like "What courage!" satirize the Inquisition's brutality against suspected Judaizers, reflecting ongoing suspicions of crypto-Judaism into the 18th century. Paintings of autos-da-fé, public executions targeting conversos accused of relapse into Judaism, became emblematic of the era's religious enforcement, with Pedro Berruguete's St. Dominic Presiding over an Auto-da-fé (c. 1495) exemplifying early visual records of such spectacles, though primarily depicting earlier heretics, it set precedents for later Marrano trials. The 2023 Prado Museum The Lost Mirror: Jews and in Medieval curated over 200 artworks from 1285 to , revealing Christian portrayals of conversos as both integrated societal members and objects of stigmatization, including proselytizing images aimed at conversion and post-1391 visuals marking them as "Marranos" through derogatory symbolism like swine motifs to deter backsliding. patronage in Golden Age art often emphasized Catholic devotion to counter Judaizing accusations, as analyzed in studies of artists navigating dual heritage amid institutional bias toward viewing them as insincere converts. In literature, Marranos symbolize fractured identity and emergent modernity, as explored in Yirmiyahu Yovel's The Other Within (2009), which frames their crypto-practices as fostering skepticism toward religious absolutes, influencing philosophical narratives of hidden otherness. Ex-converso writers like Miguel de Barrios (1635–1701) incorporated Marrano martyrdom into , portraying inquisitorial flames as illuminating divine faith in sonnets reworking crypto-Jewish resilience for Sephardic audiences post-expulsion. Modern fiction, such as Perry Jeffe's Between Testaments, Marrano trilogy (2016), draws on 15th-century records to fictionalize family dynamics under coercion, highlighting tensions between outward and covert rituals. These representations, often sourced from archives, underscore debates over conversion sincerity, with scholarly works cautioning against romanticizing as uniform resistance rather than varied survival strategies.

Influence on Broader Jewish and Iberian Narratives

The Marrano phenomenon, characterized by forced conversions and clandestine adherence to , has shaped Sephardic Jewish narratives by exemplifying themes of duality, secrecy, and resilient identity preservation amid . This "borderline " influenced 20th-century Jewish memory, positioning Marranos as symbols of cultural hybridity that challenged traditional boundaries of Jewishness, with scholars noting its role in modern Western cultural explorations of hidden traditions. In the Sephardic following the 1492 and subsequent Portuguese edicts, former crypto-Jews established communities in the , , and , where reversion to open fostered intellectual centers; for instance, Amsterdam's Portuguese Synagogue, dedicated in 1675, became a hub for ex-Marranos like , whose drew from the Marrano experience of navigating religious facades and rational doubt. In Iberian narratives, Marranos embody the tensions of religious intolerance and cultural amalgamation, with their history underscoring the Inquisition's (established 1478 in Spain, 1536 in Portugal) role in enforcing purity-of-blood statutes that permeated social structures for centuries. Crypto-Jewish practices persisted in domestic spheres, particularly among women who maintained rituals like Passover observances and traditional recipes, embedding subtle Jewish elements into Iberian folklore, oral literature, and even poetic myths such as la llave (the key), symbolizing locked-away heritage. This legacy contributed to post-colonial Hispanic cultural motifs in Latin America, where converso descendants influenced early colonial economies and inadvertently seeded hidden Jewish customs, reframing Iberian expansion as intertwined with coerced diaspora rather than unalloyed conquest. The Marrano story has informed broader historiographical debates, highlighting causal links between expulsion policies and the decline of Iberia's medieval Jewish —once a center of and —while prompting modern reevaluations of national identities; for example, Portugal's 16th-century crypto-Jewish influx elevated mercantile networks before inquisitorial crackdowns dispersed them globally, altering perceptions of Iberian economic prowess as reliant on, yet undermined by, religious exclusion. Overall, these narratives emphasize empirical patterns of over romanticized victimhood, with Marrano agency in and intellect underscoring how inadvertently propelled Jewish contributions to Enlightenment-era thought and transatlantic exchanges.

References

  1. https://www.jewishhistory.org/the-marranos/
  2. https://www.sephardichorizons.org/Volume3/Issue1/Akman.html
  3. https://ohr.edu/explore_judaism/ask_the_rabbi/ask_the_rabbi/8409
  4. https://www.jewishgen.org/infofiles/sefard5.htm
  5. https://www.etymonline.com/word/Marrano
  6. https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/10388-marano
  7. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Marrano
  8. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/religion-and-philosophy/marranos
  9. https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v31/n14/david-nirenberg/unrenounceable-core
  10. https://escholarship.org/content/qt17h688pf/qt17h688pf.pdf
  11. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Hisdai-ibn-Shaprut
  12. https://sephardicu.com/notables/samuel-ibn-naghrela/
  13. https://assets.press.princeton.edu/chapters/p10098.pdf
  14. https://trace.tennessee.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1692&context=utk_chanhonoproj
  15. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-judaism/iberia-and-beyond/EF0473E76A327C41A0B9D4F1C41D1D6A
  16. https://publicmedievalist.com/tale-two-europes-jews-medieval-world/
  17. https://jewishcurrents.org/march-15-riots-in-seville
  18. https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/2435009/jewish/The-Beginning-of-the-End.htm
  19. https://openiberiaamerica.hcommons.org/2024/03/18/accounts-of-the-anti-jewish-riot-in-valencia-july-1391/
  20. https://jhvonline.com/the-pogroms-that-lasted-months-p22482-152.htm
  21. https://www.jstor.org/stable/650241
  22. https://globalmiddleages.org/sites/default/files/Martinez-Roger-Catholics-Converts.pdf
  23. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/antijewish-riots-in-the-crown-of-aragon-and-the-royal-response-13911392/introduction/E4BEE74BDDD27F2271BB5167501C00A9
  24. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/march-31/spain-announces-it-will-expel-all-jews
  25. https://www.fau.edu/artsandletters/pjhr/chhre/pdf/hh-alhambra-1492-english.pdf
  26. https://mjhnyc.org/blog/1492-letter-regarding-jewish-property-in-spain/
  27. https://www.pbs.org/wnet/exploring-hate/2022/07/26/expelled-from-spain-july-31-1492/
  28. https://cryptojews.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Volume_V_Winter_1997_Issue_4.pdf
  29. https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/jewish-expulsion-from-portugal/
  30. https://inquisition.library.nd.edu/history-timeline
  31. https://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004393875/BP000010.xml
  32. https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/2430792/jewish/The-Spanish-Inquisition.htm
  33. https://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004393875/BP000012.xml
  34. https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/sjvbhf2h2
  35. https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/8122-inquisition
  36. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/auto-de-fe
  37. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=8665&context=etd
  38. https://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/conversas
  39. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780295800837-011/html
  40. https://www.mybelmonte.com/wordoc/en-a1-odot.htm
  41. https://historia.fflch.usp.br/sites/historia.fflch.usp.br/files/THE%2520MYTH%2520OF%2520THE%2520MARRANO%2520NAMES.pdf
  42. https://cryptojewisheducation.com/2013/07/30/the-responsa-of-the-ribash-and-the-jewish-status-of-anusim/
  43. https://www.gorgiaspress.com/conversos-in-the-responsa-of-sephardic-halakhic-authorities-in-the-15th-century
  44. https://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004416826/BP000001.xml
  45. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1387078
  46. https://cryptojews.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Volume_VIII_Spring_2000_Issue_2.pdf
  47. https://yalehistoricalreview.ghost.io/whispered-tradition/
  48. https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1996/02/01/the-secret-of-the-inquisition/
  49. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/442620/summary
  50. https://www.jstor.org/stable/jj.7249503
  51. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004500969/B9789004500969_s010.pdf
  52. https://read.dukeupress.edu/hahr/article/54/2/233/151251/Old-Christian-Merchants-and-the-Foundation-of-the
  53. https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/mendes-diogo
  54. https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.74967/2015.74967.A--History-Of-The-Marranos_djvu.txt
  55. https://albert.ias.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.12111/7870/Trivellato_Jews_and_the_early_modern_economy_2017.pdf
  56. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004500969/B9789004500969_s006.pdf
  57. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/nasi-gracia
  58. https://oar.princeton.edu/bitstream/88435/pr1154dn89/1/Yerushalmi.pdf
  59. https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2010/03/11/modernizing-the-marranos/
  60. https://www.brown.edu/Departments/Portuguese_Brazilian_Studies/ejph//html/issue8/pdf/apereira.pdf
  61. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/marrano-diaspora
  62. https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/beyond-the-myth-of-the-inquisition-ours-is-the-golden-age-4139
  63. https://www.smu.edu/perkins/publicprograms/latinocenter/~/media/site/perkins/pdf/latino/silverblatt%2520newchrn%2520peru.ashx
  64. https://scholarblogs.emory.edu/surveyjh/files/2016/08/Oct.-20-110-1-114-5-120-1-132-3.pdf
  65. https://www.bhsportugal.org/uploads/fotos_artigos/files/InquisitionandPortugueseEconomy.pdf
  66. https://brill.com/downloadpdf/display/book/9789004686441/BP000010.pdf
  67. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/revista-de-historia-economica-journal-of-iberian-and-latin-american-economic-history/article/numeracy-of-religious-minorities-in-spain-and-portugal-during-the-inquisition-era/F0B49AE7BA5AFA17406F3A6C734EA949
  68. https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/abstract/document/obo-9780195399301/obo-9780195399301-0101.xml
  69. https://www.academia.edu/24987263/Iberian_Blood_Purities
  70. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00194646241241671
  71. https://books.openedition.org/ceup/2134?lang=en
  72. https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/6090-ferrara
  73. https://cojs.org/northward_expansion/
  74. https://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004392489/BP000015.xml?language=en
  75. https://referenceworks.brill.com/display/entries/EJHC/COM-0111.xml?language=en
  76. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1454184
  77. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9781782389767-017/html?lang=en
  78. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/marranos-conversos-and-new-christians
  79. https://cryptojews.com/the-portuguese-crypto-jews-of-nantes-in-the-16th-century/
  80. https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/1442-amsterdam
  81. https://www.morasha.com.br/en/diaspora-communities/the-Portuguese-Jews-of-Amsterdam.html
  82. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004685796/BP000013.xml?language=en
  83. https://www.unmpress.com/9780826367174/portuguese-jews-and-new-christians-in-colonial-brazil-1500-1822/
  84. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/bahia
  85. https://www.morasha.com.br/en/modern-Jewish-history/action-of-the-portuguese-inquisition-in-brazil.html
  86. https://www.jstor.org/stable/42943275
  87. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9781782389767-013/html?lang=en
  88. https://stars.library.ucf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3292&context=etd
  89. http://media.newmexicoculture.org/release/425/fractured-faiths-spanish-judaism-the-inquisition-and-new-world-identities
  90. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-judaism/jews-in-the-early-modern-caribbean-and-the-atlantic-world/BB4CE30407F837A7F6A4C2C21FD4D28E
  91. https://jewishstudies.asu.edu/sites/g/files/litvpz531/files/2021-06/Jewish-Treasures-Program-Book-cropped.pdf
  92. https://www.facebook.com/groups/269202760462518/posts/1327656094617174/
  93. https://academic.oup.com/book/57591/chapter/469192371
  94. https://sephardicgenealogy.com/researching-sephardic-ancestry/sephardic-jews-in-india/
  95. https://www.worldheritageofportugueseorigin.com/2015/07/17/portuguese-marrano-jewish/
  96. https://jewish-paris-tours.com/the-roads-of-the-jewish-portuguese-diaspora/
  97. https://purl.stanford.edu/jn741tb7794
  98. https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/international/culture/1663579057-nearly-200-million-people-worldwide-have-sephardic-roots
  99. https://sephardicu.com/communities/bnei-anusim/bnei-anusim/
  100. https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn16200-spanish-inquisition-left-genetic-legacy-in-iberia/
  101. https://www.globalcitizensolutions.com/portuguese-citizenship-sephardic-jews/
  102. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/02/132000-sephardic-jews-apply-for-spanish-citizenship
  103. https://abreuadvogados.com/en/conhecimento/publications/portuguese-citizenship-for-sephardic-jews-what-to-expect/
  104. https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/antisemitism/article-804339
  105. https://sephardicgenealogy.com/crypto-jews-in-america/
  106. https://www.nature.com/articles/ejhg2014140
  107. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4402619/
  108. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4313780/
  109. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/12/dna-reveals-the-hidden-jewish-ancestry-of-latin-americans/578509/
  110. https://blog.23andme.com/articles/an-unexpected-result-genetics-sheds-light-on-the-spanish-inquisition
  111. https://k-larevue.com/en/crypto-jews/
  112. https://www.timesofisrael.com/initiatives-help-descendants-of-crypto-jews-reconnect-with-stolen-sephardic-heritage/
  113. https://netivyah.org/the-marranos-a-forgotten-treasure-being-discovered-today/
  114. https://www.morasha.com.br/en/diaspora-communities/a-visit-to-the-land-of-crypto-Jews-in-Portugal.html
  115. https://www.giltravel.com/blog/the-crypto-jews-the-hidden-secrets-from-portugals-jewish-history/
  116. https://mishpacha.com/out-of-the-shadows/
  117. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/11/spain-law-citizenship-jews
  118. https://www.cilisboa.org/home/nationality/?lang=en
  119. https://www.relocate.world/en/articles/Portugal-nationality-Sephardic-Jews
  120. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21789512/
  121. https://thejewishindependent.com.au/research-reveals-almost-25-latinos-hispanics-jewish-dna
  122. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Society/2008/1229/p03s05-ussc.html
  123. https://www.jewishbookcouncil.org/book/the-other-within-the-marranos-split-identity-and-emerging-modernity
  124. https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Marranos_of_Spain.html?id=9y_FvYcR0cYC
  125. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.2307/2671318
  126. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/16/article/369523
  127. https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/abstract/document/obo-9780195399301/obo-9780195399301-0190.xml
  128. https://read.dukeupress.edu/hahr/article/47/3/392/158244/A-History-of-the-Jews-in-Christian-Spain
  129. https://www.amazon.com/Marranos-Spain-Century-According-Contemporary/dp/0801485681
  130. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/benzion-netanyahu
  131. https://www.spainthenandnow.com/spanish-history/jews-and-conversos-in-15th-century-spain
  132. https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-netanyahus-mufti-holocaust-allegation-echoes-of-his-fathers-maverick-approach-to-history/
  133. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/392126300_Reconsidering_Converso_History_On_the_Use_of_Jewish_Sources
  134. https://read.dukeupress.edu/hahr/article/47/2/256/158198/The-Marranos-of-Spain-from-the-Late-XIVth-to-the
  135. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9781618114754-015/html?lang=en
  136. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691135717/the-other-within
  137. https://www.[academia.edu](/page/Academia.edu)/96657694/Introduction_The_Marrano_Hypothesis_The_Rise_of_the_Modern_Subject_out_of_the_Sources_of_Hidden_Judaism
  138. https://brill.com/edcollchap/book/9789004671171/B9789004671171_s008.pdf
  139. https://www.netivyah.org/the-marranos-a-forgotten-treasure-being-discovered-today/
  140. https://www.museodelprado.es/en/whats-on/exhibition/the-lost-mirror-jews-and-conversos-in-medieval/ac516c08-08d9-42fb-a7fd-1cba121e9946
  141. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004395701/BP000006.xml
  142. https://www.academia.edu/115711208/_From_Conversos_to_Marranos_Proselytising_and_Visual_Stigmatisation_1391_1492_in_Joan_Molina_Figueras_ed_The_Lost_Mirror_Jews_and_Conversos_in_Medieval_Spain_Madrid_Barcelona_2023_pp_71_91
  143. https://reinventionjournal.org/index.php/reinvention/article/view/892/873
  144. https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/between-testaments-marrano-perry-jeffe/1123159185
  145. https://www.mdpi.com/journal/religions/special_issues/marrano
  146. https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/the-sephardic-diaspora-after-1492/
  147. https://sephardifolklit.illinois.edu/FLSJ/OLSJ
  148. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/17/article/962960/pdf
  149. https://www.jhiblog.org/2019/11/27/the-myth-of-la-llave-in-crypto-jewish-poetry-and-spanish-memory/
  150. https://revista.drclas.harvard.edu/buscando-america-a-sephardic-pre-history-of-jewish-latin-america/
  151. https://boulderjewishnews.org/2018/recognition-of-sephardim-crypto-jews-changes-world-judaism/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.