Hubbry Logo
Stokoe notationStokoe notationMain
Open search
Stokoe notation
Community hub
Stokoe notation
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Stokoe notation
Stokoe notation
from Wikipedia
Stokoe notation
Script type
alphabet
Period
1960 to present
DirectionLeft-to-right Edit this on Wikidata
LanguagesASL
Related scripts
Child systems
ASL-phabet
 This article contains phonetic transcriptions in the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA). For an introductory guide on IPA symbols, see Help:IPA. For the distinction between [ ], / / and ⟨ ⟩, see IPA § Brackets and transcription delimiters.

Stokoe notation (/ˈstki/ STOH-kee) is the first[1] phonemic script used for sign languages. It was created by William Stokoe for American Sign Language (ASL), with Latin letters and numerals used for the shapes they have in fingerspelling, and iconic glyphs to transcribe the position, movement, and orientation of the hands. It was first published as the organizing principle of Sign Language Structure: An Outline of the Visual Communication Systems of the American Deaf (1960),[2] and later also used in A Dictionary of American Sign Language on Linguistic Principles, by Stokoe, Casterline, and Croneberg (1965).[3] In the 1965 dictionary, signs are themselves arranged alphabetically, according to their Stokoe transcription, rather than being ordered by their English glosses as in other sign-language dictionaries. This made it the only ASL dictionary where the reader could look up a sign without first knowing how to translate it into English. The Stokoe notation was later adapted to British Sign Language (BSL) in Kyle et al. (1985)[4] and to Australian Aboriginal sign languages in Kendon (1988).[5] In each case the researchers modified the alphabet to accommodate phonemes not found in ASL.

The Stokoe notation is mostly restricted to linguists and academics. The notation is arranged linearly on the page and can be written with a typewriter that has the proper font installed. Unlike SignWriting or the Hamburg Notation System, it is based on the Latin alphabet and is phonemic, being restricted to the symbols needed to meet the requirements of ASL (or extended to BSL, etc.) rather than accommodating all possible signs. For example, there is a single symbol for circling movement, regardless of whether the plane of the movement is horizontal or vertical.

Writing direction

[edit]

Stokoe notation is written horizontally left to right like the Latin alphabet (plus limited vertical stacking of movement symbols, and some diacritical marks written above or below other symbols). This contrasts with SignWriting, which is written vertically from top to bottom (plus partially free two-dimensional placement of components within the writing of a single sign).

Symbol usage

[edit]

Stokoe coined the terms tab ("tabula" or sign location), dez ("designator" or handshape & orientation), and sig ("signation" or motion & action). These are used to categorize features of sign-language phonemes, somewhat like the distinction between consonant, vowel, and tone is used in the description of oral languages. A sign is written in the order tab-dez-sig: TDs. Compound signs are separated with a double dashed pipe, approximately TDs¦¦TDs.

A serious deficiency of the system is that it does not provide for facial expression, mouthing, eye gaze, and body posture, as Stokoe had not worked out their phonemics in ASL.[6] Verbal inflection and non-lexical movement is awkward to notate, and more recent analyses such as those of Ted Supalla have contradicted Stokoe's set of motion phonemes.[citation needed] There is also no provision for representing the relationship between signs in their natural context, which restricts the usefulness of the notation to the lexical or dictionary level. Nonetheless, Stokoe demonstrated for the first time that a sign language can be written phonemically just like any other language.

In the tables below, the first column is a web-based approximation of the Stokoe symbol using the inventory available in Unicode, and the second is an ASCII substitution for the purpose of citing examples in this article. Proper display of the third column requires the Stokoe font available at the external link below; without that font, you will see the corresponding ASCII character, as used in Mandel (1993).

Tab (Location)

[edit]

The tab symbols are a null sign for a neutral location and iconic symbols for parts of the head, arm, and torso. In addition, the dez (handshape) symbols below may be used to indicate that the location is the passive hand in a specific shape.

Unicode
approximation
ASCII
approximation
Stokoe[a] Description
Ø 0 0 neutral location
Q h face, or whole head (symbol is superimposed ᴖ and ᴗ)
P u forehead, brow, or upper face
T m eyes, nose, or mid face
U l lips, chin, or lower face
Ȝ } c cheek, temple, ear, or side face
Π N k neck
[ ] [ ] [] torso, shoulders, chest, trunk
Ƨ 7 i non-dominant upper arm
J j non-dominant elbow, forearm
ɑ 9 a inside of wrist
ɒ 6 b back of wrist

Given a handshape (dez) ⟨D⟩,[b] ⟨QD⟩ would be D signed at the face, ⟨JD⟩ the same handshape signed at the elbow, and ⟨9D⟩ on the inside of the wrist.

  1. ^ Proper display requires installation of the Stokoe font available at the external link below.
  2. ^ "D" is not used for a specific handshape, but is a stand-in here for whichever dez is used.

Dez (Handshape)

[edit]

The symbols for handshapes are taken from the ASL manual alphabet: ⟨A⟩ represents a fist, the handshape used for fingerspelling "A" (and also "S" and "T", since the difference is not significant outside fingerspelling and initialisms); ⟨B⟩ represents a flat hand, the handshape used for fingerspelling "B" and "4", etc. When a dez involves two hands, two letters are used.

Dez symbols may also be used as tabs. For example, ⟨QB⟩ represents a flat hand, B, located at the face, Q, and <BB> represents a dominant flat hand B acting on a passive flat hand B. The latter is disambiguated from two B hands acting together by using another letter for the tab, such as ⟨ØBB⟩ for two B hands acting in neutral space, or ⟨QBB⟩ for both hands at the face.

Besides the shape of the hands, the dez includes their orientation. This is indicated, when necessary, with subscripts, which are introduced in the next section.

A fist (as ASL 'a', 's', or 't')
B flat hand (as ASL 'b' or '4')
5 spread hand (as ASL '5')
C cupped hand (as ASL 'c', or more open)
E claw hand (as ASL 'e', or more clawlike)
F okay hand (as ASL 'f'; thumb & index touch or cross)
G pointing hand (as ASL 'g' 'd' or '1')
H index + middle fingers together (as ASL 'h,' 'n' or 'u')
I pinkie (as ASL 'i')
K thumb touches middle finger of V (as ASL 'k' or 'p')
L angle hand, thumb + index (as ASL 'l')
3 vehicle classifier hand, thumb + index + middle fingers (as ASL '3')
O tapered hand, fingers curved to touch thumbtip (as ASL 'o')
R crossed fingers (as ASL 'r')
V spread index + middle fingers (as ASL 'v' or '2')
W thumb touches pinkie (as ASL 'w')
X hook (as ASL 'x')
Y horns (as ASL 'y', or as index + pinkie)
8 bent middle finger; may touch thumb (as ASL '8', this is a common allophone of Y)

There are three diacritics that modify the shape of the dez. A dot placed above it shows that a finger not normally seen is prominent, usually because it is involved in the production of the sign. For example, ⟨Ȧ⟩ (ascii 'A) is a fist with the thumb extended, as in ⟨UȦᶠ⟩ not. Three dots or ticks over a letter shows the fingers are flexed, so that ⟨B⃛⟩ (ascii ;B) is a flexed flat hand, and ⟨V⃛⟩ (;V) is two flexed fingers. The forearm tab sign prefixed to the dez (ascii j) shows that the forearms are prominent in the production of the sign, as in Bɑ jB^ω tree.

Sig (movement) and dez orientation

[edit]

The movement of the hand, or sig, is written with superscripted letters after the dez, as D# (any dez D which closes). Multiple movement sigs are arranged linearly when the movements are sequential, as in TD×∨× (any dez D which touches a tab T, moves down, and touches again),1 but stacked one above the other when signed simultaneously, as in TD×ͮ (a dez which moves down while in contact with the tab).2

A dot placed above the sig indicates that the motion is sharp, as in TD×̇ (sharp contact by the dez D),3 while a dot placed after the sig indicates that the motion is repeated, as in TD×· (repeated contact by the dez; TDx" in ASCII).

A tilde with a two-hand dez, TDDs~, indicates that first one hand performs the sig, then the other. Without the tilde, both hands are understood to act together.

A subset of the sig symbols used for motion are also used to indicate the orientation of the hand. In this use they are subscripted after the dez instead of superscripted, as in D# (any dez D which starts off closed).4 Stokoe analyzed the orientation of the hand as part of the tab, the handshape.

Movement (sig) Orientation (dez)
Unicode ASCII Stokoe* Description Unicode ASCII Stokoe* Description
Dʌ D^ D^ moving upward Dʌ ^D D^ facing or pointing upward
Dv Dv Dv moving downward Dv vD Dv facing or pointing downward
Dɴ Dw moving up and down
D> D> D> to the dominant side D> >D D> facing the dominant side
D< D< D< to the center or non-dominant side D< <D D< facing the center or non-dominant side
D Dz Dᶻ side to side
D Dt Dᵗ toward signer D tD Dt facing signer
D Df Df away from signer D fD Df facing away from signer
Dᶦ Dm D= to and from
Dɑ Da Da supinate (turn palm up) Dɑ aD Da supine (palm facing up)
Dɒ Db Dᵇ pronate (turn palm down) Dɒ bD Db prone (palm facing down)
Dω Dg Dw twist wrist back & forth
Dᵑ Dr Dⁿ nod hand, bend wrist Dŋ rD Dn bent wrist
D[D′] D*[D′] D][D′] open up (resulting Dez D’ shown in brackets) D *D D] open
D#[D′] D#[D′] D#[D′] close (resulting Dez D’ shown in brackets) D# #D D# closed
D De De wriggle fingers
(symbol looks like a cursive e)
D@ D@ D@ circle
(symbol is a spiral)
D⁾⁽ D)( D) approach, move together D₎₍ )(D D) near
D× Dx Dx contact, touch D× xD Dx touching
D D$ Dg link, grasp D $D Dg linked
D D+ D+ cross D +D D+ crossed
Dʘ Do Do enter Dʘ oD Do inside
D÷ D% D: separate
Dʻʼ D§ or D& D( exchange positions

* Proper display requires installation of the Stokoe font available at the external link below.

1 TDx-v-x in ASCII
2 TDxv in ASCII
3 TDx! in ASCII
4 Closing hand and closed hand would be D# and #D in the ASCII system.

Several linguists, including Kyle & Woll, state that Stokoe's tab conflates two parameters, handshape and orientation, and split off ori (orientation of the hand) as a fourth parameter. Kendon, however, notes how this greatly complicates the phonological description of signs, and prefers to retain orientation as an aspect of the handshape, with changes of orientation analysed as other changes in the hands, rather than as changes in an independent parameter.

Relative location

[edit]

When the tab is a hand shape, or the dez consists of two hands, a symbol may be placed between the two letters to indicate their relative position. These include a few of the movement/orientation letters above. In addition, there are symbols to indicate position above, below, next to, and behind: the underscore on the B in B L shows that the L hand is placed under a B hand, with or without contact, etc.

Unicode ASCII[a] Description
B̲ A B A (underline) A under B
B̅ A B A (overline) A over B
BˡB B|B B next to B
AA A\A A behind A
BB B+B B hands or forearms cross
FF F$F F hands (fingers) clasped or linked
5ʘG 5oG G hand (finger) within 5 hand (between fingers)
  1. ^ The free font does not cover these symbols

Example

[edit]

This is the ASL word “Snake” in Stokoe notation:

The ASL word SNAKE in Stokoe notation
The ASL word SNAKE in Stokoe notation

The first letter, ᴗ (like a U), shows that the word is signed at the lower face (mouth or chin). The second, V⃛ɒ, shows that the hand has the shape of a fingerspelled "V". The V has two diacritics: the three dots ... above it show that the fingers are bent (curled), while the subscript ɒ shows that the hand is held with the back of the hand facing up. The last letters, @
, are a compound sig: the spiral shows a circular motion, and the tack ˔ underneath shows that the motion proceeds outward. This is a mimetic sign for 'snake', mimicking the motion of a fanged snake.[7] It is alphabetized under to the tab U, then by the dez V, then by the sig @; the searcher does not need to know what it means or that it is glossed with the English word snake in order to look it up.

Following is a passage from Goldilocks:

A passage from Goldilocks in ASL, transcribed in Stokoe notation
A passage from Goldilocks in ASL, transcribed in Stokoe notation
BɑBɑz~
story(?)
√V⃛√V⃛ ɑ̇•
quote
Ʒ
three
[]√C√Cv
×
bear(s)
ȜY@
v
Goldilocks
√Gʌ<v<
way.in
Bɑ√Bʌω
woods
G
up
BʌˡBʌ÷
v
house
ⱰȦ
sitting.there
BɒBɒ
enter
G>
that.there
ᴖ5×
father
[]√C√Cv
×
bear
XX÷
ɑ
open.paper
BVɒv•
read
BɑL#•
newspaper
XX÷
ɑ
open.paper
The story "Goldilocks and the Three Bears". Deep in the woods, there is a house sitting on a hill. (If you) go in, (you will see) there Papa Bear reading the paper.

Published use of Stokoe notation

[edit]

The first use of Stokoe notation appeared in the ASL Dictionary compiled by Stokoe, Casterline, and Croneberg, for which it was devised. Other indigenous sign language dictionary projects, for example the Dictionary of British Sign Language/English, ed. David Brien, pub. Faber and Faber 1992, and Signs of a Sexual Nature[citation needed] have included Stokoe notation. The notation has also been used to analyze Australian Aboriginal sign languages. These non-ASL projects have had to extend the notation to cover phonemes not found in ASL.

See also

[edit]
  • ASL-phabet, a simplified notation used in ASL-English dictionaries for Deaf children and Deaf education
  • HamNoSys, a phonetic notational system used primarily for linguistic research
  • SignWriting, a popular system that arranges symbols in a two-dimensional space rather than in a line
  • si5s

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Stokoe notation is a phonemic developed in 1960 by linguist William C. Stokoe at to transcribe and analyze the structure of (ASL), demonstrating that signed languages possess linguistic properties comparable to spoken languages. The system breaks down signs into core s—originally tab (location of the sign in space), dez (handshape), and sig (movement or action)—using a repertoire of 55 symbols derived from Latin letters, numerals, and punctuation marks, written sequentially in the order TAB-DEZ-SIG. A fourth , orientation (direction of the hand or palm), was later incorporated to enhance precision. This notation system emerged from Stokoe's pioneering research, detailed in the 1965 Dictionary of American Sign Language on Linguistic Principles, co-authored with Carl Croneberg and Dorothy Casterline, which formalized ASL as a distinct language with phonological components. For example, the ASL sign for "mother" is notated as ❍5⌒, where ❍ indicates the chin as the location, 5 represents the open spread handshape, and ⌒ denotes the thumb-to-chin contact movement. While primarily designed for ASL, adaptations have been applied to other signed languages, including British Sign Language and Australian Aboriginal sign languages, though it remains a tool for academic and research purposes rather than widespread daily use in Deaf communities. Stokoe notation's significance lies in its role as the first systematic phonemic script for any , laying the groundwork for the field of and inspiring subsequent transcription systems such as and HamNoSys. However, it has limitations, including the omission of nonmanual features like expressions, sign speed, , and manner of movement, which are crucial to ASL's full expressiveness. Despite these constraints, the system continues to be valued in linguistic analysis for its ability to represent the phonological building blocks of s in a compact, analyzable form.

History and Development

Origins with William Stokoe

, a linguist specializing in English literature, joined the faculty of in 1955 as a of English, marking his initial immersion in the Deaf community and (ASL). At the time, prevailing academic and educational views dismissed ASL as a mere collection of iconic gestures or , lacking the systematic structure of spoken languages. Stokoe's close observation of Deaf signers on campus led him to recognize ASL as a fully formed with its own phonological and grammatical organization, challenging these misconceptions and prompting him to apply linguistic analysis to . Motivated by a desire to rigorously examine ASL's underlying structure, Stokoe began developing a in the late , culminating in its formalization during the early . This system was specifically designed for transcribing ASL signs on a phonemic level, enabling precise documentation and analysis akin to in spoken languages. His work, supported by a 1960 National Science Foundation grant, focused on breaking down signs into analyzable components to demonstrate ASL's linguistic validity. Through this analysis, Stokoe identified three prime parameters essential to ASL's phonological system: tab (indicating location), dez (specifying handshape), and sig (denoting movement and orientation). This framework, first outlined in his 1960 publication Sign Language Structure, established the foundation for treating ASL as a legitimate linguistic object of study. Subsequent works, such as the 1965 Dictionary of American Sign Language on Linguistic Principles co-authored with colleagues, further disseminated these insights.

Key Publications and Evolution

William C. Stokoe's seminal monograph, Sign Language Structure: An Outline of the Visual Communication Systems of the American Deaf, published in 1960 as part of the Studies in Linguistics Occasional Papers series by the University of Buffalo, introduced the foundational principles of analyzing (ASL) as a linguistic system. This work outlined the phonemic structure of ASL through parameters such as location, handshape, and movement, challenging prevailing views that sign languages were mere gestures rather than full languages. In 1965, Stokoe collaborated with Dorothy C. Casterline and Carl G. Croneberg to produce A Dictionary of American Sign Language on Linguistic Principles, published by Gallaudet College Press, marking the first major application of his notation system. This dictionary employed Stokoe notation to transcribe over 1,000 ASL signs, organizing them according to linguistic criteria and demonstrating the systematic nature of ASL's . The publication provided for ASL's phonological and morphological complexity, serving as a key resource for linguists studying signed languages. During the 1970s, Stokoe notation underwent refinements amid growing interest in sign language linguistics, culminating in the 1978 revised edition of Sign Language Structure: The First Linguistic Analysis of American Sign Language, published by Linstok Press. This update expanded on syntactic structures and lexical organization, incorporating new analyses of ASL's grammatical rules and integrating feedback from emerging research. These developments addressed limitations in the original framework, such as notation for complex movements, and facilitated broader applications in linguistic transcription. The publications collectively transformed perceptions of sign languages within , establishing ASL as a legitimate with phonological, syntactic, and semantic properties comparable to spoken languages. This shift influenced the founding of Deaf studies as a discipline and revolutionized by promoting bilingual approaches that recognize ASL's role in cognitive and cultural development. Stokoe's work inspired international research on other sign languages and underscored the visual-gestural modality's linguistic validity.

Core Components

Tab: Location

In Stokoe notation, the "tab" parameter, derived from the Latin word tabula meaning "table" or "place," specifies the spatial location where a sign is articulated, relative to the signer's body or the neutral signing space. This component captures the fixed point of reference for the sign's production, distinguishing it as one of the three primary cheremes—minimal contrastive units analogous to phonemes in spoken languages—that structure signs in (ASL). The tab parameter identifies key locations such as the face (including specific areas like the forehead, cheek, or chin), the torso, the non-dominant hand or arm, and the absolute neutral space in front of the body where signs may occur without contact. These locations serve as anchors for the active hand(s), ensuring that variations in placement can create phonemic contrasts between distinct signs. For instance, signs articulated near the face versus the trunk often convey different meanings due to this locative distinction. Stokoe notation employs approximately 12 primary tab symbols, each representing standardized points on or near the body, as detailed in the foundational . These symbols are iconic where possible, facilitating intuitive recognition of anatomical references. The following table outlines the core tab symbols, their descriptions, and representative ASL examples (glosses):
SymbolDescriptionASL Example (Gloss)
Neutral space (no body contact)DRIVE
Face or whole headSLEEP
or browBECAUSE
Mid-face (eye/ area)BLIND
or lower faceREAL
], temple, or HOME
THIRSTY
[ ]Trunk (shoulders to hips)ADDRESS
\Upper armHOSPITAL
or AUTUMN
a (supinated, palm up)DOCTOR
ɔ (pronated, palm down)TIME
These symbols combine with dez (handshape) and sig (movement) cheremes to form complete sign representations, allowing for systematic of ASL's phonological .

Dez: Handshape

In Stokoe notation, the dez parameter, short for "designator," specifies the configuration of the hand or hands forming the core manual articulator of a sign. This active aspect captures the static shape of the fingers and thumb, using uppercase Latin letters, numerals, and a few specialized symbols to denote distinct forms, such as A for a closed with the thumb over the fingers or B for an extended flat hand with fingers together and thumb alongside. Originally developed for (ASL), the dez emphasizes the hand's role as the primary mover in sign production, distinguishing it from passive elements. The core handshapes in Stokoe notation consist of approximately 19 basic forms, derived from the phonemic inventory of ASL and selected for their frequency and distinctiveness in sign formation. These include configurations based on finger positions, such as extended (e.g., G for pointed), bent (e.g., C for curved fingers), or clustered (e.g., V for separated index and middle fingers), along with others like 5 (all fingers spread and extended) and O (fingers and thumb forming a circle). This limited set prioritizes phonologically contrastive shapes, allowing efficient representation while grouping similar variants under single symbols to reflect ASL's structural economy. In two-handed signs, the dez typically denotes the handshape of the dominant or active hand, which performs the primary action, while the non-dominant or passive hand may be indicated separately if it contributes a distinct configuration. This distinction underscores the asymmetric roles in articulation, with the active hand's dez often written first to highlight its prominence. Orientation, which involves palm or finger direction, is indicated by subscript symbols under the dez. As a chereme—the sign language equivalent of a —the handshape denoted by dez holds phonemic significance, serving as a minimal unit that can alter a sign's meaning. For instance, the ASL signs "" (using an A handshape at the ) and "" (using an I handshape at the ) differ solely in dez, demonstrating how subtle handshape variations create lexical contrasts. This phonemic role was central to Stokoe's analysis, establishing handshape as one of the three foundational parameters in sign structure.

Sig: Movement and Orientation

In Stokoe notation, the "sig" parameter, short for signation, represents the dynamic aspects of a sign, encompassing both movement and orientation of the hand or hands relative to the body. This component captures how the hand travels through space or remains static, distinguishing signs through their kinetic features rather than solely static form. Originally developed by William C. Stokoe in his analysis of American Sign Language (ASL), sig symbols are typically written as superscripts or stacked vertically to indicate sequential or simultaneous motions, allowing for a phonological breakdown of signs into actionable elements. Movement types in sig notation include linear paths, which denote straight-line trajectories such as upward (^) or outward (>); arcuate motions, involving curved or circular paths like a full circle (@); inflections, which indicate repetitive or alternating actions such as wiggling (e) or side-to-side oscillation (Z); and holds, represented by the absence of a sig symbol or a static indicator for signs with no motion. These categories emphasize path direction and manner, though distinctions between sharp and soft movements are limited, often marked by diacritics like a dot for tension. Sig may include rotational movements that affect orientation, such as supination (ɑ) or pronation (ɒ), in addition to path movements like toward the signer (T). Stokoe's system employs approximately 20-30 sig symbols to encode these elements, focusing on paths, rotations, and interactions between hands. The following table lists representative sig symbols, grouped by category for clarity:
CategorySymbolDescription
Linear Up/Down^Upward motion
Downward motion
NUp and down (repetitive)
Linear Sideways>Rightward/outward motion
<Leftward motion
ZSide to side
DepthTToward signer
Away from signer
IBack and forth
Arcuate/Circular@Circular motion
ωTwisting or spiral
ɑSupinating rotation (palm up)
ɒPronating rotation (palm down)
Inflection/Repetitive~Alternating or wavy
eWiggling fingers
ηNodding or bending
Hand Interaction) (Convergent (hands approaching)
×Touching or contacting
÷Divergent (hands separating)
#Closing handshape
Opening handshape
OthertCrossing hands
¤Entering space
These symbols can be modified with subscripts or diacritics to refine orientation or manner, such as combining a movement arrow with a palm-facing indicator to specify direction relative to the sign's location (tab).

Notation Mechanics

Writing Direction

Stokoe notation employs a horizontal writing direction from left to right, analogous to scripts used for spoken languages, which facilitates linear transcription of signs on a page. This convention aligns the notation with standard textual flow, allowing it to be read sequentially while representing the spatial and temporal aspects of signs from the signer's perspective. Although sign parameters such as location, handshape, and movement occur simultaneously in production, they are notated sequentially in the order of tab (location), dez (handshape, including orientation), and sig (movement). For a basic one-handed sign, this results in a tab-dez-sig format, such as the representation of the ASL sign for "mother" as ͜5x, where ͜ denotes the tab, 5 the dez, and x the sig. Two-handed signs extend this by repeating dez or sig symbols, as in TDDs or LHHm, to capture bilateral simultaneity without altering the core sequence. To address simultaneity in more complex structures, such as compound signs or varying elements within a single sign, Stokoe notation incorporates ties, like the caret (^), to link sequential components, and square brackets [] to enclose changes in handshape or secondary features. Vertical stacking of sig symbols may also indicate multiple simultaneous movements, with ties or control markers ensuring proper grouping; non-manual features, when included, are similarly bracketed to denote their overlap with manual elements. For instance, a compound like "zoom-off" might be rendered as ɑL[O]⊥#[O], using brackets for handshape transitions. Early adaptations for print relied on typewriters equipped with custom fonts to render the 55 symbols derived from Latin letters, numerals, and punctuation, enabling straightforward mechanical production. In modern contexts, digital fonts and Unicode proposals have enhanced accuracy, supporting superscripted orientations, bracketed groupings, and scalable rendering for computational and publishing applications.

Symbol Usage and Relative Location

In Stokoe notation, symbols for the dez parameter, representing handshape and orientation, are primarily selected from Latin letters of the alphabet, such as A, B, C, 5, V, and O, which correspond to common configurations in American Sign Language (ASL) based on the manual alphabet or numerical representations. These letters are chosen for their familiarity and simplicity, allowing quick identification of hand forms like the flat hand (B) or bent finger (G), though some use digits or modified characters for less common shapes. For the sig parameter, denoting movement and action, diacritics and superscript symbols are employed, including arrows like ^ for upward motion, ∨ for downward, > for rightward, and @ for circular paths, which are positioned above or below the dez symbol to indicate direction and type of motion. The tab parameter, indicating location, utilizes numbers, circles, and bracket-like glyphs, such as ❍ for the face, ∩ for the , or ∅ for neutral space, selected to evoke the spatial or bodily reference points efficiently. Relative location rules in Stokoe notation describe signs in relation to the signer's own body, ensuring consistency from the signer's perspective rather than the viewer's. For instance, movements to the right (>) or left (<) are interpreted as directions from the signer's facing position, with the signing space divided into zones like the neutral area in front of the torso or specific body parts such as the chin or shoulder. Symmetry is handled through orientation symbols and modifiers; for symmetric signs performed identically on both sides, a single notation suffices, but asymmetric variations require explicit specification of left or right via additional diacritics or duplicated elements. This body-centric approach maintains notational economy while capturing the egocentric nature of signing. For two-handed signs, conventions designate the non-dominant hand as the tab if it functions passively, such as providing a static base for the dominant hand's action, notated by placing the tab symbol before the dez of the active hand. Hand arrangement is further clarified with symbols like a vertical line (|) for side-by-side positioning or a cross (t) for overlapping hands, ensuring the relative roles—active versus supportive—are unambiguous. These rules build on the standard tab-dez-sig sequence, adapting it for bilateral symmetry or interaction. Challenges in Stokoe notation arise from the dynamic, three-dimensional signing space, where ambiguities occur without accompanying video, as static symbols may not fully convey subtle shifts in position or perspective. Interpretive guidelines, such as prioritizing the signer's viewpoint and using stacked diacritics for simultaneous elements, help mitigate this, but users often rely on contextual knowledge or supplementary diagrams to resolve potential misinterpretations in complex or rapid signs.

Practical Applications

Illustrative Examples

To illustrate the application of Stokoe notation, consider the ASL sign for "MOTHER," which is transcribed as ͜5x. Here, the tab (location) is represented by ͜, indicating the chin as the place of articulation; the dez (handshape) is 5, denoting an open spread hand with fingers extended; and the sig (movement and orientation) is x, signifying a brief contact where the thumb touches the chin. This notation captures the essential cheremes of the sign, performed with the dominant hand near the lower face. Another simple sign is "THANK-YOU," transcribed as [chin] Ḃ ⊥ ⊥. The tab is the chin, marked with a curved shape symbol for its location; the dez is Ḃ, an open flat hand with the thumb extended alongside the fingers; and the sig combines ⊥ for palm orientation facing the signer and another ⊥ for outward movement away from the body. The sign involves touching the fingertips to the chin and then moving the hand forward in a salute-like gesture. For compound signs, which involve sequential cheremes blending into a single meaningful unit, the ASL sign "CHAIN" demonstrates how notation handles multiple components over time. It is transcribed as ∅FFI> ^~., where the tab is ∅ for neutral space in front of the signer; the dez consists of two F handshapes (curled fingers with [thumb](/page/The_Thumb) over index and middle); the sig includes I for alternating orientations (one palm facing the signer, the other away), > for rightward movement, for grasping action, ^ for linking or hooking, and ~. for repetition and alternation between hands. This represents two hands interlinking and pulling apart repeatedly to evoke connected links. Compound notations like this use separators or stacked symbols to indicate the temporal sequence while preserving the core parameters. Interpreting Stokoe notation alongside English glosses or descriptive text aids understanding by aligning the linear symbols with the visual-spatial execution of signs. For instance, the gloss "" pairs with ͜5x to clarify that the contact (x) occurs simultaneously with the handshape (5) at the specified location (͜), allowing linguists or learners to reconstruct the sign's form without video. Similarly, for "CHAIN," the gloss highlights the repetitive linking (^~.), emphasizing how sequential cheremes fuse into a cohesive . A common pitfall in reading Stokoe notation is overlooking the simultaneity of parameters in simple signs, where tab, dez, and sig co-occur rather than unfold sequentially, potentially leading to misinterpretation as linear actions; in compounds like "," careful attention to movement modifiers (e.g., ~ for alternation) ensures the temporal flow is captured accurately.

Published and Modern Uses

Stokoe notation was first applied in the 1965 publication of A Dictionary of American Sign Language on Linguistic Principles, where it facilitated the lexical transcription of approximately 500 signs by breaking them into phonemic components for systematic documentation. In the , the system gained prominence in phonological studies, as evidenced by Stokoe's 1972 Semiotics and Human Sign Languages that expanded on his earlier work to analyze 's structural elements, including cheremes and their combinations. In academic research, Stokoe notation has been instrumental in dissecting sign phonology, enabling researchers to identify minimal pairs and parametric contrasts in ASL, such as variations in handshape or movement that distinguish meanings. It has also supported investigations into dialectal variation, allowing transcription of regional differences in signs like "," which may involve subtle shifts in or orientation across ASL communities. Modern extensions include adaptations for other sign languages, such as trials for (BSL) documented in Kyle et al. (1985), which modified symbols to accommodate BSL-specific handshapes and movements while preserving the core tab-dez-sig framework. Post-2000 developments feature digital tools for notation input, including prototypes that process ASCII-based Stokoe representations to generate sign animations or corpora for analysis. As of 2025, Stokoe notation sees limited everyday use due to its complexity for non-specialists, but it remains foundational in , informing AI models for sign recognition by providing structured phonological features like handshape and location parameters. For example, recent frameworks incorporate Stokoe parameters to improve isolated sign recognition accuracy in datasets like WLASL.

Limitations and Comparisons

Criticisms and Shortcomings

One significant limitation of Stokoe notation lies in its inability to distinguish fine-grained nuances of movement, such as variations in sharp versus soft articulation, versus laxness, or irregular paths during signing. For example, the system employs a single symbol to represent all circular or non-linear movements, which inadequately captures more complex trajectories like loops or arcs. This restriction hinders precise , as linguists require tools capable of documenting these dynamic aspects for accurate analysis. Another major shortcoming is the omission of non-manual signals, which are essential phonological components in (ASL), including facial expressions, head tilts, eye gaze, and body posture. Although Stokoe's original framework acknowledged the importance of these elements, the notation itself provides no dedicated symbols for them, despite research identifying at least six distinct non-manual channels that convey grammatical and lexical meaning. This gap limits the system's utility for representing the full structure of signs, where non-manuals often determine distinctions like questions or negations. Stokoe notation's abstract symbols, which bear little resemblance to the visual form of signs (such as using arbitrary diacritics for handshapes), impose a steep on users, particularly those unfamiliar with linguistic transcription. This complexity makes it less accessible for practical teaching or everyday application, as the symbols are not intuitive and require specialized training to interpret or produce. Furthermore, the system's incompatibility with standard keyboards exacerbates its impracticality for digital use or widespread adoption. From a phonological perspective, the notation's heavy reliance on cheremes—the minimal units of handshape, , and movement—has been critiqued for overemphasizing these manual parameters at the expense of prosodic features, such as rhythm and intonation, and the role of mouthing ( approximations integrated into signs). Additionally, by limiting handshapes to just 19 categories, it fails to account for the broader phonological diversity in ASL; subsequent analyses have identified over 150 distinct hand configurations, including subtle variations in finger positioning and orientation. These issues underscore how the system, while pioneering, imposes phonological assumptions that do not fully reflect the language's complexity.

Relation to Other Sign Language Notations

Stokoe notation, with its linear phonemic structure focusing on three primary parameters—handshape (dez), location (tab), and movement (sig)—differs markedly from SignWriting, developed by Valerie Sutton in 1974. While Stokoe notation arranges symbols sequentially to represent signs as linguistic units akin to phonemes in spoken languages, SignWriting employs a pictorial and spatial approach that visually maps the simultaneous positions and movements of the signer's body, hands, and facial expressions on a two-dimensional plane. This contrast highlights Stokoe's emphasis on taxonomic analysis for linguistic research versus SignWriting's schematic representation designed for intuitive readability and broad application across sign languages. The Hamburg Sign Language Notation System (HamNoSys), developed in the 1980s by researchers at the , builds directly on Stokoe's foundational parameters of handshape, , and movement, but expands them to include orientation and nonmanual signals for greater universality. Unlike Stokoe's use of arbitrary Latin letters tailored primarily to (ASL), HamNoSys employs more iconic symbols and a phonetic-level detail to accommodate diverse sign languages internationally, facilitating cross-linguistic research and computational processing. This evolution reflects Stokoe's influence in establishing a parametric framework while addressing limitations in scope and adaptability. Other systems, such as developed in the late , extend Stokoe's for specialized computational purposes like synthesis and animation. represents signs through synchronized geometric constraints in 3D space, incorporating temporal and contextual dependencies to generate realistic virtual signing, which surpasses Stokoe's hand-focused, rigid notation for machine processing needs. As a pioneer in , Stokoe notation laid the groundwork for analyzing signs as structured linguistic units beyond ASL, influencing global phonological studies, though its abstract symbols have limited its adoption for everyday writing due to challenges, with video and further diminishing practical reliance.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.