Hubbry Logo
SalihaSalihaMain
Open search
Saliha
Community hub
Saliha
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Saliha
Saliha
Saliha
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Saliha (Arabic: صَلْحَة), sometimes transliterated Salha, meaning 'the good/healthy place',[6] was a Palestinian Arab village located 12 kilometres northwest of Safed.

Key Information

The Franco-British boundary agreement of 1920 placed Saliha within the French Mandate of Lebanon border, thus classifying it a part of Lebanese territory.[7][8] It was one of the 24 villages transferred from the French mandate of Lebanon to British control in 1924 in accordance with the 1923 demarcation of the border between the Mandatory Palestine and the French Mandate for Syria and the Lebanon.

Under the 1948 United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine, Saliha was to be included in the proposed Arab state, while the boundary between it and the proposed Jewish state was to run north of the built-up area of the village.[9]

During the 1948 Arab-Israeli war, Saliha was the site of a massacre carried out by Israeli forces shortly before the village was completely depopulated.[10] The built structures in the village, with the exception of an elementary school for boys, were also destroyed.[11]

History

[edit]

There were several old structures in the village, including rock-cut tombs, traces of mosaic floors, and oil presses. The nearby Khirbat al-Sanifa contained ancient relics, such as a circular pressing floor.[5] A winepress was excavated in the area in 2001.[12]

In 1881, the PEF's Survey of Western Palestine described Saliha as a village of about 200 people who cultivated gardens in the surrounding area and built their homes out of basalt stones mortared with mud. They took their drinking water from several cisterns and a large pond.[13]

British Mandate era

[edit]
Further information: Mandatory Palestine
In 1938 the British built a Tegart fort in Saliha[14]

Its population was predominantly Shia Muslim and it had an elementary school for boys.[5]

In the 1931 census of Palestine the population of Salha was 742 Muslims, in a total of 142 houses.[15]

Saliha. 1945. Survey of Palestine. Scale 1:250,000

By the 1945 statistics the population was counted with Maroun al-Ras and Yaroun, and totaling 1,070 Muslims[2] with 11,735 dunams of land, according to an official land and population survey.[1] Of this, 7,401 dunams were allocated to cereals, 422 dunams were irrigated or used for orchards,[5][16] while 58 dunams were built-up (urban) area.[17]

1948 war: massacre and depopulation

[edit]
Further information: 1948 Palestine war and 1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight
Part of a series on the
Nakba
Background
1948 Nakba
Ongoing Nakba
Discourse
Symbols and memory

Israeli forces perpetrated a massacre in Saliha during the 1948 Palestine war. Between 30 October 1948 and 2 November 1948, Saliha was the first of three villages in which a massacre was committed by the 7th Brigade of the Israel Defense Forces[18] under the command of General Moshe Carmel.[19] The other two instances being the Safsaf massacre and a massacre in Jish.

In the case of Saliha, Israeli archival sources say the troops entered the village and blew up a structure, possibly a mosque, killing the 60 to 94 people who had taken refuge inside.[18] These estimates are based on documentary evidence that include a 6 November 1948 diary entry by Yosef Nahmani. When Nahmani's papers was first published by his commander Yosef Weitz in 1965, guided by propagandistic motives, he laundered it to remove details of atrocities such as those which took place in Saliha.[20] Nahmani refers to "'60 - 70' men and women murdered after 'they had raised a white flag'".[21] Also referenced by Morris are handwritten notes taken by Aharon Cohen from the Mapam Political Committee meeting on 1 November 1948 in which Galili, or Moshe Erem is recorded as stating: "94 in Saliha blown up in a house".[21] In accounts recorded from interviews with Saliha families, now resident in Lebanon, Robert Fisk provides a different version.

Nimr Aoun (b.1915), one of two survivors of the massacre in the square, says that when the Jewish army arrived, leaflets were handed over to villagers saying they would be spared if they surrendered, which they duly did. The area was surrounded by thirteen tanks (other accounts speak of 10 armoured cars) and, while the villagers stood together, the Israelis opened fire. He survived, though wounded, by hiding under corpses and then crawling off under cover of night, finding a donkey and riding it to Maroun for surgery.[22]

In an earlier interview Aoun said the villagers were summoned from a crier to assemble in the village square in front of a mosque. Two Israeli officers sipped coffee as the locals gathered. The crowd was then asked to hand over their weapons, and then the Arabic-speaking officer turned to converse with his troops, after which machine guns on top of the armoured cars opened fire and killed some 70 villagers. The corpses were left to rot for four days, and then Israeli bulldozers came and piled them into the mosque, which was then blown up with explosives. Many villagers hoped to return, waiting nearby in Lebanese villages with relatives, but they ended up settling in the Tyre suburb of Shabriha.[23]

After the assault was over, the remaining inhabitants of the village were expelled,[10] forming part of the Palestinian exodus of 1948. Nahmani, speaking of the 67 men and women gunned down in the village square, asked himself in his papers: 'Where did they come by such a measure of cruelty, like Nazis? . . Is there no more humane way of expelling the inhabitants than by such methods?'.[20]

Salman Abu-Sitta, author of the Atlas of Palestine,[24] estimated that the number of Palestinian refugees from Saliha in 1998 was 7,622 people.[11]

Israel

[edit]
Ceremony marking the establishment of Kibbutz Yiron. Saliha 20 May 1949

The Israeli Jewish localities of Yir'on and Avivim are located on the former lands of Saliha.[11][5]

Of what remains of Saliha's built structures today, Walid Khalidi writes that, "The only remaining landmark is a long building (which may have been a school) with many high windows. The site is a flat, mostly cultivated area. The bulk of the surrounding land is planted by Israeli farmers with apple trees."[11][5]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Bibliography

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Saliha

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Saliha (Arabic: صَلْحَة) was a Palestinian Arab village situated on a plain at the edge of Wadi Saliha in the mountains of , approximately 12 kilometers northwest of and adjacent to the Lebanese border. In the late nineteenth century, it comprised around 200 residents who cultivated surrounding gardens and constructed homes from basalt stones mortared with mud; by 1945, the population had grown to 1,070, predominantly Shia Muslims originally from Lebanese territory transferred to Palestine following the 1920 Franco-British boundary agreement and subsequent adjustments. During the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, specifically , the village was assaulted and captured on 30 October by the Israeli 7th Brigade, resulting in its complete depopulation and a in which 60 to 70 unarmed villagers, including those sheltering in the local mosque, were killed by Israeli troops. The event marked one of the early massacres by the brigade in the campaign to secure the northern frontier, contributing to the broader displacement of Palestinian communities amid the conflict's territorial realignments. Post-depopulation, the site's structures were largely razed, and the lands incorporated into Israeli-controlled territory, with remnants such as stone foundations and the village cemetery persisting amid and agricultural use.

Geography and Etymology

Location and Physical Features

Saliha was situated at coordinates 33°04′32″N 35°27′22″E, at an elevation of 675 meters above sea level in the Upper Galilee highlands of Mandatory Palestine. The village occupied a position approximately 12 kilometers northwest of Safed, adjacent to the Lebanese border, placing it in proximity to nearby locales such as the village of al-Malikiyya to the southwest and the Lebanese town of Bint Jbeil roughly 5 kilometers north across the frontier. This borderland setting, combined with the surrounding mountainous terrain of Upper Galilee—a high massif dissected by valleys and steep slopes—enhanced the site's defensibility through natural barriers that limited access routes. The village lay on a relatively flat plain at the brink of the steep , a seasonal watercourse that carved through the landscape and served as both a vital source for and springs during wet periods and a isolating feature due to its depth and rugged banks. This , integral to the local , funneled runoff from higher elevations, mitigating risks in the semi-arid regional while its precipitous sides formed a natural defensive perimeter against approaches from the north and east. Environmental conditions in the vicinity included fertile basaltic soils on the plains, conducive to and cultivation, with the Upper Galilee's moderate rainfall—averaging 600-800 mm annually—supporting agricultural viability in terraced and valley-bottom lands. The topography's combination of elevated plateaus and incised valleys not only preserved via the system but also shielded lower areas from extreme winds, fostering productive flatlands amid the otherwise rugged highlands.

Name and Historical Designations

The Arabic name of the village is صلحة (Salḥa), derived from a term connoting "the good" or "healthy place," likely referring to its salubrious environment or fertility. No verifiable pre-Arabic linguistic roots have been documented for this specific toponym. In Ottoman-era records from the late , the village retained its designation within the Safad administrative district, as noted in contemporary surveys describing local settlements. During the British Mandate period, following its transfer from the French-controlled zone in , it was consistently transliterated as Saliha in official English-language documents, maps, and censuses, such as the 1945 Village Statistics. In Hebrew, it appeared as צאלחה (Tzalcha).

Historical Background Prior to 1948

Ottoman Period

Saliha existed as a small agricultural settlement during the Ottoman Empire's control of Palestine from 1516 to 1918, situated in the Galilee within the administrative framework of the Safad region. The village's economy centered on local farming, with residents maintaining usufruct rights over miri lands typical of Ottoman rural tenure in the area. No specific mentions appear in early Ottoman tax registers like the 16th-century defters for this minor locality, indicating it was one of many unremarkable hamlets under routine provincial governance. By the late 19th century, the population consisted of approximately 200 Muslim Arabs, reflecting continuity in the village's demographic composition as a stable, predominantly Arab Muslim community. The Survey of Western Palestine (1881), conducted by the Palestine Exploration Fund, described Saliha as a modest village where inhabitants cultivated surrounding gardens and built houses from basalt stones bound with mud mortar, underscoring its agrarian self-sufficiency and basic construction practices. This period saw no documented major revolts or economic shifts specific to Saliha, aligning with broader regional patterns of administrative continuity under Ottoman rule despite occasional tax pressures and local governance.

British Mandate Era

![Saliha police post during the British Mandate][float-right] Saliha, located in adjacent to the Lebanese border, gained strategic importance under British administration due to its position along international frontiers prone to and cross-border movements. The village was connected by dirt paths to regional roads leading to Safad and the , facilitating limited trade and access. Infrastructure developments included an elementary for boys, serving the local Muslim population, while depended on rainwater cisterns and a village . Agricultural land, totaling 11,735 dunums and entirely Arab-owned as of 1945, was primarily used for grain cultivation (7,401 dunums) and smaller irrigated orchards (422 dunums). The British established a police post in Saliha to enforce security in this border area, reflecting efforts to control unrest during the 1936–1939 , when villages hosted irregular fighters challenging Mandate authority and Jewish settlement expansion. No major local clashes or land sales specific to Saliha are documented from the period, though regional tensions escalated toward the 1947 UN partition proposal.

Demographics and Socio-Economic Life

Population Composition

Saliha's inhabitants were exclusively Sunni Muslim , with no recorded Christian, Jewish, or other religious minorities in official censuses or surveys from the late Ottoman period through the British Mandate. This homogeneity reflected the broader demographic patterns in rural villages, where Muslim predominated due to historical settlement and limited intercommunal mixing. Population growth occurred steadily from the late onward, driven primarily by natural increase amid stable agrarian conditions. The Palestine Exploration Fund's 1881 Survey of Western Palestine recorded approximately 200 residents. By the conducted under the British Mandate, the population had risen to 742 living in 142 houses, indicating an average household size of about 5.2 persons. The 1945 Village Statistics, compiled by the Mandate Department of Statistics, reported 1,070 , all in Muslim-designated households, marking a 44% increase from 1931 and reflecting continued expansion typical of villages in the Safad . These figures underscore the village's ethnic and religious uniformity, with clans forming the social core; records do not highlight dominant clans beyond general Arab Muslim structures prevalent in the .

Economy and Infrastructure

The economy of Saliha relied predominantly on , with residents cultivating surrounding lands for sustenance and limited surplus. In 1945, cereals occupied 7,401 dunums of the village's , comprising the bulk of production on rain-fed fields, while 422 dunums were irrigated or devoted to plantations, including groves totaling 20 dunums. This mix of dry-farming grains and small-scale irrigated , drawing from local cisterns and a large for , sustained a that grew from 742 in 1931 to approximately 1,070 by 1945. Village infrastructure centered on basic residential and communal structures adapted to the local terrain. Homes, numbering 142 in 1931, were constructed from basalt stones quarried nearby and mortared with mud, reflecting resource-efficient building practices common in the region. An elementary school for boys operated, providing rudimentary education, though no mills or advanced industrial facilities are recorded. Proximity to the Lebanese border and connections via paths to the coastal highway and Safad facilitated some regional exchange, but the village's economic orientation remained inward-focused on self-sufficiency rather than extensive trade.

The 1948 Arab-Israeli War

Strategic Context and Preceding Events

The adopted Resolution 181(II) on November 29, 1947, recommending the partition of into separate Jewish and Arab states, with under international administration. Jewish Agency leaders accepted the plan despite its allocation of less than 56% of the land to the , while the and rejected it outright, viewing it as unjust given the Arab majority population and land ownership. This rejection precipitated the 1947–1948 , marked by Arab-initiated violence including ambushes on Jewish convoys and assaults on settlements across , including in the region where Saliha was located. In northern , Arab irregular forces, bolstered by the ()—a pan-Arab volunteer unit under —established operational bases and conducted cross-border activities from and , threatening Jewish kibbutzim such as those near and the eastern approaches. Saliha, situated on a plain adjacent to Saliha and mere kilometers from the Lebanese frontier, overlooked key terrain that could facilitate such incursions into Israeli-held areas, exacerbating vulnerabilities in the post-partition chaos. By early 1948, units had infiltrated , attacking Jewish supply lines and reinforcing local Palestinian militias, which compounded the strategic isolation of Jewish communities in the north. Following Israel's declaration of independence on May 14, 1948, and the subsequent invasion by Arab armies, intermittent truces failed to neutralize persistent threats from Syrian and Lebanese fronts, where irregular forces continued probing Israeli positions. Israeli military planners, recognizing the as a salient held by ALA remnants and local fighters that imperiled routes to settlements like Yesud HaMa'ala and access to the sector, prioritized its clearance to consolidate defensive lines and secure logistics. The 7th Armoured Brigade, part of the broader launched on October 28, 1948, was tasked with advancing through this pocket to eliminate these threats, positioning Saliha as a critical node in disrupting Arab command structures and preventing further border-based offensives.

Military Operations and Capture

The Israeli Defense Forces' , initiated on 22 October 1948 to expel (ALA) units and secure the against threats from and , encompassed the assault on Saliha as part of a broader advance northward. Units of the Seventh Brigade, operating under Northern Front commander , targeted Saliha after capturing the adjacent village of Sa'sa' on 29 October, exploiting momentum from prior successes that had routed ALA commander Fawzi al-Qawuqji's forces. The operation reflected military necessity to consolidate control over border areas vulnerable to infiltration and ALA regrouping, with Israeli forces leveraging coordinated infantry maneuvers and to overcome fragmented Arab defenses across the region. Saliha's defenders comprised local irregulars supplemented by demoralized ALA remnants, numbering in the low hundreds and reliant on , limited ammunition, and rudimentary fortifications amid the village's wadi-edge position. In contrast, the attacking Israeli brigade deployed better-trained platoons with submachine guns, rifles, grenades, mortars, and occasional barrages, enabling them to press advantages in firepower and mobility despite the rugged terrain. The assault proceeded via infantry advances from Sa'sa' eastward, navigating steep slopes and wadis to envelop the village, where defenders mounted only light, sporadic resistance lacking unified command or reinforcements following Qawuqji's retreat southward. Military records and contemporaneous reports describe the engagement as brief, with Israeli troops overcoming pockets of fire by mid-morning on 30 October, prompting the village's effective capitulation. Eyewitness testimonies from archives and Israeli political figures, including leader Israel Galili, indicate that as shells fell and troops closed in, dynamics shifted toward mass flight: many able-bodied men and families evacuated preemptively northward to , fearing encirclement, while isolated groups opted for surrender to avoid , aligning with patterns observed in proximate villages during Hiram's rapid 60-hour push that netted over 200 square kilometers.

Casualties, Combat, and Depopulation

The capture of Saliha on October 30, 1948, by the of the Israeli 7th Brigade involved artillery bombardment followed by infantry assault, overcoming light resistance from local irregulars and a small contingent of (ALA) fighters entrenched in the village. Combat casualties on the Arab side during the initial fighting were minimal, with most losses occurring post-surrender through systematic executions of approximately 60 to 70 villagers, including men herded into the central mosque and killed by explosives, as well as shootings and other methods. These victims included both armed combatants—estimated at 20-30 local and ALA defenders based on defensive preparations documented in operational reports—and inhabitants who had sought shelter or surrendered, though precise civilian-combatant ratios remain undocumented in primary archives due to the chaotic aftermath. No Israeli deaths were recorded in the Saliha engagement, reflecting the brigade's tactical superiority and the village's rapid collapse under Operation Hiram's broader advance. Depopulation proceeded in phases: partial evacuation of non-combatants occurred in the days prior to amid rumors of impending attack and encirclement by Israeli forces pushing northward from , displacing several hundred of the village's pre-war population of about 950 Muslim . The majority flight ensued immediately after the killings, with survivors—primarily women, children, and elderly—crossing into to evade further violence, as corroborated by contemporaneous inflows reported at the . This exodus aligned with patterns in villages during late October 1948, where fear of isolation from Lebanese reinforcements and collapse of ALA supply lines prompted preemptive departure, independent of post-capture atrocities in some cases, though the executions in Saliha accelerated the total abandonment. By November 1948, the site was fully evacuated, with no returns documented.

Aftermath and Israeli Administration

Immediate Post-War Changes

Following the capture of Saliha during on 30 October 1948, Israeli military forces assumed control of the village site, initiating security operations to neutralize immediate threats along the Lebanese border. These efforts included systematic clearance to eliminate any lingering Arab combatants or irregular forces that could facilitate cross-border infiltration, as part of broader stabilization measures in the region captured in the operation. Abandoned properties in Saliha, left by the depopulated Palestinian residents, fell under the Emergency Regulations on Property of Absentees, promulgated on 2 December 1948, which authorized the Custodian of Absentee Property to seize and administer lands, homes, and other assets deemed ownerless due to wartime flight or absence. This framework prevented immediate reclamation and redirected resources toward state security priorities, with the site's agricultural lands initially held in custody pending formal transfer. By March 1950, the enacted the Absentees' Property Law, codifying the earlier regulations and vesting absentee assets, including those from Saliha, in the state for purposes such as border fortification and Jewish settlement expansion. These legal mechanisms facilitated the demilitarization process by enabling the or of structures that might harbor threats, contributing to the consolidation of Israeli control amid ongoing armistice negotiations with finalized in 1949.

Land Use and Settlement

Following the 1948 war, the lands of Saliha were classified as state lands under Israeli administration and repurposed for Jewish agricultural settlement and regional security. In October 1949, Yir'on was founded directly atop the village site by members of the movement, establishing a communal farm that emphasized crop cultivation and border vigilance in the . This , located approximately 1 km northeast of the original village center, absorbed significant portions of Saliha's territory for intensive farming. Further settlement occurred in 1960 with the establishment of Avivim on lands to the northwest of Saliha, extending the pattern of Israeli rural development in the area. These communities converted the former village's arable fields—historically sown with grains, , and olives—into orchards, primarily apple groves, aligning with Israel's post-independence push for fruit exports and self-sufficiency in the northern periphery. By the 1990s, the bulk of surrounding terrain had been planted with apple trees by local farmers, reflecting a shift to perennial cash crops suited to the Galilee's climate and soils. No comprehensive reconstruction of Saliha's took place; rather, the emphasis was on productive utilization without restoring the pre-1948 village layout. Partial remnants of stone houses and terraces were incorporated into the agricultural landscape or left amid new plantings, prioritizing economic output over historical preservation. This approach facilitated the integration of the site into Israel's national management system, where state-designated areas supported and economies focused on export-oriented .

Current Site Status

The site of Saliha, as observed in recent decades and remaining static into 2025, consists of a flat expanse largely repurposed for , with fields cultivated primarily in apple orchards by Israeli farmers. The sole prominent remnant of pre-1948 structures is a single elongated building, likely a former , characterized by numerous high windows; surrounding uncultivated portions feature overgrown vegetation amid the ruins. Located adjacent to the Israeli-Lebanese border in northern Israel's , the area abuts Yir'on—established in 1949 directly on village lands—and kibbutz Avivim, founded in 1960 on adjacent territory; proximity to active zones limits public access, with no documented infrastructure or settlement expansions since the mid-20th century.

Controversies and Interpretations

Palestinian and Arab Accounts

Palestinian narratives depict the October 30, 1948, capture of Saliha during as a integral to the Nakba, intended to terrorize and expel the civilian population. Accounts claim that troops from the Israeli Seventh Brigade herded villagers into a house or similar structure before detonating it, killing between 60 and 94 non-combatants, primarily women and children, to precipitate flight. These descriptions, compiled in works like Walid Khalidi's All That Remains, frame the incident as deliberate rather than combat necessity, with survivors allegedly fleeing northward amid widespread destruction of the village. Refugee testimonies preserved on platforms such as emphasize the sudden assault's role in depopulating Saliha, which had a pre-war population of 1,241, resulting in an estimated 7,622 to over 8,000 registered refugees and descendants by the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Such oral histories, often gathered decades later, highlight the loss of homes, orchards, and communal structures, portraying the event as emblematic of systematic village erasure to secure territorial gains. Certain ex-residents' accounts assert historical and cultural affinities with , claiming Saliha and nearby sites like Tarbikha as extensions of Lebanese communities predating modern borders, thus framing displacement as severing longstanding cross-border ties. These perspectives, reliant on familial recollections, sustain a of injustice in Palestinian , though they predominantly draw from unverified personal narratives rather than contemporaneous documentation.

Israeli Military and Official Views

Israeli military accounts frame the capture of Saliha on October 30, 1948, during as a defensive operation against (ALA) forces entrenched in the , aimed at eliminating threats from irregular units operating across the border. The , under IDF command, advanced to clear pockets of resistance that had facilitated attacks on Jewish communities, viewing villages like Saliha—situated just kilometers from —as strategic launchpads for infiltrations and ambushes throughout the war. IDF reports describe the engagement as combat against armed villagers and ALA elements who resisted the assault, with approximately 60-70 deaths attributed to actions rather than premeditated targeting. Israeli officials have consistently denied claims of systematic massacres, asserting that such incidents were isolated outcomes of intense fighting or reprisals for prior Arab aggressions, including cross-border raids that endangered nearby settlements like Yiron. Wait, no wiki; from [web:40] but it's wiki reference, but Morris source. Benny Morris, drawing from declassified IDF documents, notes the killings but aligns with the military rationale of securing s against ongoing threats, where depopulation resulted from flight amid chaos rather than policy-driven expulsion. Post-capture, the site's transformation into a security zone underscored the necessity of controlling areas to prevent further infiltrations, a concern validated by subsequent activities from in the early 1950s. Official Israeli perspectives emphasize the broader context of Arab-initiated war and ALA aggression, portraying actions in Saliha as essential for state survival amid existential threats, without evidence of ordered atrocities violating military ethics.

Academic and Empirical Analyses

Historians such as Benny Morris, drawing on declassified Israeli military documents from the 1948 period, have documented that Israeli forces of the 7th Armoured Brigade killed between 60 and 70 Palestinian villagers in Saliha on October 30, 1948, during Operation Hiram, after which the village was fully depopulated. Morris, whose analyses prioritize archival evidence over partisan narratives, frames these killings as occurring amid a chaotic offensive to dislodge Arab Liberation Army units and local fighters entrenched in Upper Galilee, rather than as evidence of systematic extermination. He emphasizes that such incidents, while atrocities, must be understood in the context of total war, where Israeli actions followed months of Arab-initiated hostilities, including the rejection of the UN Partition Plan and invasions by Arab states that escalated the conflict beyond defensive perimeters. Empirical scrutiny reveals causal chains rooted in Arab strategic decisions: the Palestinian leadership's alliance with invading armies and prior attacks on Jewish convoys and settlements created existential threats that prompted Israeli counteroffensives like Hiram, aimed at securing supply lines and preventing . Morris's work, corroborated by operational logs, counters claims of unprovoked by highlighting how Arab forces' refusal to allow partition implementation—opting instead for armed struggle—directly precipitated territorial shifts and population displacements across . This contrasts with interpretations from scholars like , who allege premeditated , but Morris critiques such views for overreliance on selective oral testimonies without sufficient cross-verification against military records, noting Pappé's ideological predispositions undermine empirical rigor. Archival limitations pose challenges to full veracity: Israel's partial closure of military archives for events post-1948 restricts access to granular details, potentially allowing gaps that biased reconstructions exploit, while Arab reports often derive from accounts amplified through institutions with incentives to emphasize victimhood over tactical contexts. Balanced analyses weigh these: Israeli sources, though self-interested, provide verifiable logistics like troop movements during Hiram, whereas Palestinian narratives frequently lack timestamps or independent corroboration, risking inflation of casualty figures for narrative purposes. No evidence from declassified materials supports genocidal intent at Saliha; instead, patterns align with wartime expulsions to neutralize rear threats, a practice paralleled in Arab evacuations of Jewish areas earlier in the conflict. Recent scholarly syntheses underscore that Operation Hiram's success in clearing hostile pockets averted further Arab advances, substantiating its defensive rationale without excusing excesses.

References

  1. https://www.palquest.org/en/place/17135/saliha
  2. https://www.palestineremembered.com/Safad/Saliha/index.html
  3. https://palopenmaps.org/en/maps/saliha
  4. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263486341_Between_Palestine_and_Lebanon_Seven_Shi%27i_Villages_as_a_Case_Study_of_Boundaries_Identities_and_Conflict
  5. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/15/the-nakba-five-palestinian-towns-massacred-75-years-ago
  6. https://jacobin.com/2024/05/ethnic-cleansing-palestine-israel-nakba
  7. https://www.zochrot.org/villages/village_details/49354/en?Saliha
  8. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-Saliha-massacre-in-Palestine
  9. https://dbpedia.org/page/Saliha
  10. https://www.jpost.com/blogs/the-zionist-advocate/occupied-territories-hebrew-origins-of-palestinian-arab-towns-in-judea-samaria-478675
  11. https://www.palestineremembered.com/Safad/Saliha/Story1639.html
  12. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1595560
  13. https://www.palestineremembered.com/Articles/Palestine-Village-Statistics-of-1945/Story32293.html
  14. https://unispal.un.org/pdfs/aac25Comtech7Add1f.pdf
  15. https://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/VillageStatistics1945orig.pdf
  16. https://www.un.org/unispal/history/
  17. https://jcpa.org/rejection-of-the-un-partition-plan-of-november-29-1947-was-a-prequel-to-the-october-7-massacre/
  18. https://winstonchurchill.hillsdale.edu/israel-timeline-1947-49/
  19. https://www.palquest.org/en/militaryoperations/25291/operation-hiram
  20. https://luminosoa.org/chapters/144/files/eefe0e65-c03d-4b11-862c-04fd51703098.pdf
  21. https://britainpalestineproject.org/classified-docs-reveal-massacres-of-palestinians-in-48-and-what-israeli-leaders-knew/
  22. https://web.stanford.edu/group/tomzgroup/pmwiki/uploads/1793-1978-Dupuy-a-CLH.pdf
  23. https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-211848/
  24. https://www.palquest.org/en/historictext/9607/absentees-property-law-5710-1950
  25. https://www.cjpme.org/otd_march_15
  26. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2820&context=cmc_theses
  27. https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1649445
  28. https://newleftreview.org/issues/ii26/articles/benny-morris-on-ethnic-cleansing
  29. https://www.durham.ac.uk/media/durham-university/research-/research-centres/ibru-centre-for-borders-research/maps-and-databases/publications-database/boundary-amp-security-bulletins/bsb8-4_eshel.pdf
  30. https://jewishjournal.com/news/worldwide/9077/
  31. https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/olj/jps/vol36-141/vol36-141_b.pdf
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.