Automatic writing
Automatic writing
Main page
2238827

Automatic writing

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
Automatic writing
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

A piece of automatic writing produced by trance medium Leonora Piper, claimed to be a message from the spirit of Richard Hodgson

Automatic writing, also called psychography, is a claimed psychic ability allowing a person to produce written words without consciously writing. Practitioners engage in automatic writing by holding a writing instrument and allowing alleged spirits to manipulate the practitioner's hand. The instrument may be a standard writing instrument, or it may be one specially designed for automatic writing, such as a planchette or a ouija board.

Religious and spiritual traditions have incorporated automatic writing, including Fuji in Chinese folk religion and the Enochian language associated with Enochian magic. In the modern era, it is associated with Spiritualism and the occult, with notable practitioners including W. B. Yeats and Arthur Conan Doyle. Claims associated with automatic writing are unfalsifiable, while some documented examples result from the ideomotor phenomenon.[1][2][3][4]

History

[edit]

Spirit writing, later called fuji (扶乩/扶箕), has a long tradition in China, where messages from various deities and spirits were received by mediums since the Song dynasty. In the 19th century, messages received through spirit writing led to the foundation of several Chinese salvationist religions.[5] The spread of Chinese cultural techniques, such as printing and painting, introduced the influence of "spirit writing", practised by Japanese Zen Ōbaku monks, who were said to communicate with an ancient Taoist sage credited with creating the kung fu system.[6]

13th-century Spanish Kabbalists engaged in automatic writing, which may have been the method that produced the Zohar.[7] Joseph Karo (1488-1575)'s angelic mentor communicated via automatic writing on at least one occasion, dictating laws of Kiddush levana.[8]

Another early Western example of the practice is the 16th-century Enochian language, allegedly dictated to John Dee and Edward Kelley by Enochian angels and integral to the practice of Enochian magic.[9] The language is said to be extremely detailed and complex in its grammar and rules.[10] Dee also claimed that the Enochian instruction included information regarding the elixir of life in the ruins of Glastonbury Abbey.[10] Some scholars understand descriptions of Joseph Smith's process writing the Book of Mormon as a case of automatic writing.[11]

Approach

[edit]

Parapsychologist William Fletcher Barrett wrote that "automatic messages may take place either by the writer passively holding a pencil on a sheet of paper, or by the planchette, or by a 'ouija board'."[12] In Spiritualism, spirits are claimed to take control of the hand of a medium to write messages, letters, and even entire books.[13] Automatic writing can happen in a trance or waking state.[14] Some psychical researchers such as Thomson Jay Hudson have claimed that no spirits are involved in automatic writing and the subconscious mind is the explanation.[15]

Hoaxes

[edit]

Paranormal investigator Harry Price exposed the supposed automatic writing in the Borley Rectory as the wall-scrawling of a housewife attempting to hide an extramarital affair.[4]

A prominent alleged example of automatic writing is the Brattleboro hoax. When Charles Dickens died in 1870, he left The Mystery of Edwin Drood unfinished. According to the itinerant printer T. P. James, this angered Dickens' spirit so much that he channelled the rest of the novel through James's hand. This is supposed to have begun on Christmas Eve 1872 and continued in tri-weekly sessions until completion.[16]

Practitioners

[edit]

Automatic writing as a spiritual practice was reported by Hyppolyte Taine in the preface to the third edition of his De l'intelligence, published in 1878.[17] Besides "ethereal visions" or "magnetic auras", Fernando Pessoa claimed to have experienced automatic writing. He said he felt "owned by something else", sometimes feeling a sensation in the right arm he claimed was lifted into the air without his will.[18] Georgie Hyde-Lees, the wife of William Butler Yeats, also claimed she could write automatically.[19] Sri Aurobindo and his follower, The Mother (Mirra Alfassa), regularly practiced Automatic writing.[citation needed]

Catalan medium and artist Josefa Tolrà wrote poems and "transcribed" messages that she included in her drawings, which she ascribed to something or someone "guiding her hand".[20][21]

Shortly after his 1917 marriage to Georgie Hyde-Lees, the poet W. B. Yeats came to be heavily influenced by her delving into what they referred to as "the automatic script".[22]

In his 1918 book The New Revelation, Arthur Conan Doyle wrote that automatic writing occurs either by the writer's subconscious or by external spirits operating through the writer.[23] Doyle and his wife led an automatic writing séance with Harry Houdini wherein Lady Doyle wrote 15 pages of purported messages from Houdini's mother, although this information was immediately discounted as fraudulent by Houdini.[24]

The essay "The Automatic Message" (1933), first published in the magazine Minotaure, No. 3-4, (Paris), was one of André Breton's significant theoretical works about the method of surrealist automatism. In 1919, he and Philippe Soupault had used what later became the method to compose Les Champs Magnétiques (The Magnetic Fields).[25] In 1997, "The Magnetic Fields" was also the title of a compilation of surrealist writing of André Breton, Paul Éluard, Philippe Soupault, and others. It included the authorized translation of Breton's "The Automatic Message" in English by the poet David Gascoyne, whose Man's Life is This Meat (1936, a collection of his own surrealist writings and translations of the French surrealists) and Hölderlin's Madness (1938) established Gascoyne's reputation as one of a small group of English surrealists. Gascoyne's 1935 A Short Survey of Surrealism for the 1936 London International Surrealist Exhibition also expanded the movement to the English-speaking world. The Surrealist poet Robert Desnos claimed he was among the most gifted in automatic writing.[26] Surrealist automatists, most notably André Masson, adapted these methods to art-making in which the artist suppresses conscious control over the making process, allowing the unconscious mind to have great sway. Prior to the Surrealists, Dadaists, such as Hans Arp, made some use of this method through chance operations.[27]

The medium Pierre L. O. A. Keeler had an alleged spirit writing communication from Abraham Lincoln currently exhibited at the Lily Dale Museum.[28] Despite Lincoln being well-known for his skepticism and Keeler having been known to employ magician's tricks, this is used as one of the many examples of skeptics purportedly endorsing Spiritualism posthumously.[29] Skeptical investigator Joe Nickell who conducted a detailed examination of the "spirit" writing, concluded it had no resemblance to Lincoln's handwriting and described the message as "bogus".[30]

There was an apocalyptic cult led by a lapsed Scientologist named Dorothy Martin. She and her followers were waiting for an alien ship to take them to the nonexistent planet Clarion and save them from a worldwide flood that was to commence at midnight on 20 December 1954. When that did not occur, Martin allegedly got an automatic writing message from God calling the whole thing off.[31][32]

Since 1975

[edit]

In 1975, Wendy Hart of Maidenhead claimed she wrote automatically about Nicholas Moore, a sea captain who died in 1642.[33] Also in 1975, the CIA attempted to employ remote viewing through the Stargate Project. In the spring of 1989, Angela Dellafiora, a member of Stargate Project's remote viewing unit, claimed to be guided by spirits moving her hand in writing responses about the location of a fugitive DEA agent named Charlie Jordan. In reviewing the matter, Joe Nickell states, "[T]he Charlie Jordan case, touted as one of the most successful examples... in the U.S. government's psychic-spying project is not convincing evidence of anything — save perhaps folly. ...[I]t also illustrates the limitations of anecdotal evidence: conflicting versions, selective reporting, and lack of documentation, together with additional manifestations of faulty memory, bias, and other human foibles."[34]

Conspiracy theorist David Icke said he first became aware of being "Son of the Godhead" via automatic writing.[35] Vassula Ryden claims to receive and transcribe messages from her guardian angel Daniel, Jesus, Yahweh.[36] She has provoked both skepticism and credulity from Catholic laity and clergy, as well as the skeptical community at large.[37] Alleged cases of automatic writing have included Joseph Smith,[38] Patience Worth,[4] Aleister Crowley,[39] Jane Roberts,[40] Helen Schucman[41] and author Neale Donald Walsch.[42][43] Crowley, for instance, compiled the Collected Works over time, which included The Book of the Law as well as transcripts of his visions of the first two Enochian Aethyrs (planes).[44]

Scientific analysis and skepticism

[edit]

Scientists and skeptics consider automatic writing to be the result of the ideomotor effect.[1][2][3][4]

According to skeptical investigator Joe Nickell, "automatic writing is produced while one is in a dissociated state. It is a form of motor automatism, or unconscious muscular activity."[45] Neurologist Terence Hines has written "automatic writing is an example of a milder form of dissociative state".[46] In 1900, Swiss psychologist Theodore Flournoy studied the case of the French medium Helene Smith, particularly her handwriting during seances.[13] He concluded that the automatic writing phenomenon was an effect of autosuggestion produced by autohypnotization, leading to the emergence of a secondary self.[13]

Paranormal researcher Ben Radford writes in his 2017 book Investigating Ghosts that there is no real way to know if the writing is coming from "outside their bodies," you "must take their word for it. Because the source of the information is at issue and the medium cannot be validated, we must turn to the content of the material." Various psychic mediums have claimed to channel famous dead people. For example, Susan Lander claimed that Betsy Ross contacted her to say, "I am gay and I fly the flag of pride and liberty for all of us." According to Radford, historians say that there is "no credible historical evidence that Ross ... either made or had a hand in designing the American flag." Without some kind of validation, "anyone can claim to communicate with the spirit of anyone." Radford argues that "Automatic writing should logically hinder, not help spirit communication," given that spelling and grammar are more difficult than direct speech.[47]

Scientific studies

[edit]

In an 1890 paper on hypnotism, Morton Prince claims, "automatic writing is not a purely unconscious reflex act, but, the product of conscious individuality," and further claims that the hand that is writing is under the control of a separate hypnotic personality during trances.[48][49] Physician Charles Arthur Mercier, in the British Medical Journal (1894), criticized the spiritualist interpretation of automatic writing, concluding, "there is no need nor room for the agency of spirits, and the invocation of such agency is the sign of a mind not merely unscientific, but uninformed."[50]

Psychology professor Théodore Flournoy investigated the claim by nineteenth-century medium Hélène Smith (Catherine Müller) that she did automatic writing to convey messages from Mars in Martian language. Flournoy concluded that her "Martian" language had a strong resemblance to Ms. Smith's native language of French and that her automatic writing was "romances of the subliminal imagination, derived largely from forgotten sources (for example, books read as a child)." He invented the term cryptomnesia to describe this phenomenon.[51]

In 1927, psychiatrist Harold Dearden wrote that automatic writing is a psychological method of "tapping" the unconscious mind and that there is nothing mysterious about it.[52]

In 1986, A.B. Joseph investigated two female patients who were found to exhibit ictal hypergraphia.[53]

Automatic writing behavior was discovered by Dilek Evyapan and Emre Kumral in three patients with right hemispheric damage.[54]

A 2012 study of ten psychographers using single photon emission computed tomography showed differences in brain activity and writing complexity during alleged trance states vs. normal state writing.[55]

Pop culture and media

[edit]

Automatic writing is touted by medium Bonnie Page in a Sentinel and Enterprise article as a method of accessing claircognizance abilities.[56]

Automatic writing is featured prominently in a 1961 episode of Perry Mason, The Case of the Meddling Medium, and is also depicted in the 1980 film The Changeling and the 1999 film The Sixth Sense. In the 2008 film Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull automatic writing is referenced as a method of supernatural communication used by the character Harold "Ox" Oxley.

Portions of Van Morrison's album Astral Weeks supposedly are inspired by dreams, reveries, and automatic writing.[57]

Czech director Jan Švankmajer claims he concocted the screenplay for his hybrid film Insect (Hmyz) in a fit of automatic writing.[58]

William S. Burroughs has described his book Naked Lunch as "automatic writing gone horribly wrong" and believed he found his subconscious taken over by a hostile entity.[59][60]

In an interview in GQ, David Byrne indicated an interest in automatic writing due to the influence of Brian Eno.[61]

[edit]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Automatic writing

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Automatic writing is a phenomenon and technique in which text is produced without the conscious intention or volitional control of the writer, often described as an automatism where the hand moves seemingly of its own accord.[1] It has been associated with various interpretations, including communication from spirits, access to the subconscious mind, or dissociated states of consciousness.[2] Historically, automatic writing gained prominence in the mid-19th century amid the rise of Spiritualism, beginning with events like the 1848 Rochester Rappings involving the Fox sisters, which popularized trance mediums and spirit communication through involuntary writing.[3] In this context, it was viewed as a form of psychography, enabling purported messages from the deceased and often linked to mechanical aids such as the planchette or Ouija board.[3] In psychology, automatic writing became a subject of experimental investigation starting in the late 19th century, with early researchers like Frederic Myers and Edmund Gurney exploring it as evidence of dissociated consciousness and secondary personalities.[4] Pioneering studies by figures such as Pierre Janet, William James, and Morton Prince examined its role in hysteria, split consciousness, and the unconscious, using techniques like the "stem device" to probe subconscious associations.[3] Notable experiments, including those by Leon Solomons and Gertrude Stein in 1896, demonstrated automatic writing under divided attention, contributing to understandings of implicit memory, awareness dissociations, and pathological versus normal mental states.[4] Beyond Spiritualism, the practice influenced literary movements, particularly Surrealism in the 1920s, where André Breton and collaborators like Robert Desnos employed "psychic automatism" to bypass rational thought and unleash creative expression, though it often led to intense psychological strain.[3] Contemporary perspectives continue to view automatic writing through psychological and neuroscientific lenses, as seen in studies using fMRI to analyze spontaneous instances, revealing brain activity patterns akin to channeled or unintentional production.[1] It also intersects with disability studies, highlighting how mediums with chronic conditions were idealized for their perceived extrasensory sensitivity, challenging traditional notions of authorship and agency.[2] Overall, automatic writing remains a multifaceted topic bridging parapsychology, clinical dissociation, and artistic innovation.

Definition and Principles

Definition

Automatic writing, also known as psychography, is a claimed psychic or altered consciousness phenomenon in which an individual produces written words or symbols without conscious intention or volitional control, with the resulting content purportedly originating from external spirits, the subconscious mind, or dissociated psychological states.[5] This process is described as an automatism, where the writing hand moves independently, often guided by an unseen influence, distinguishing it from deliberate composition.[6] Key characteristics of automatic writing include its occurrence in a trance-like or deeply relaxed state, during which the script may emerge rapidly—sometimes illegible or in unfamiliar handwriting—and the writer frequently reports no subsequent memory of the produced content.[5] The output can range from fragmented phrases to coherent narratives, though it is consistently experienced as involuntary, with reduced awareness of the motor actions involved.[7] These features underscore the phenomenon's emphasis on bypassing rational oversight to access purportedly hidden sources of information. Unlike related concepts such as free association—where individuals intentionally articulate uncensored thoughts to explore the psyche—or stream-of-consciousness writing, which deliberately captures the flow of waking mental processes in literature, automatic writing is defined by its complete lack of conscious direction or editing during production.[6] This involuntary quality sets it apart, positioning it as a passive conduit rather than an active expressive technique. The term "automatic writing" emerged in the 19th century amid the rise of Spiritualism, building on earlier mediumistic practices that involved spirit communication through writing, though the roots of psychography trace back nearly a millennium in various cultural contexts.[8]

Underlying Principles

In spiritualism, automatic writing is fundamentally understood as a channel for spirit communication, wherein disembodied entities purportedly guide the medium's hand to produce written messages, circumventing the conscious rational mind to ensure unfiltered transmission. This principle posits that the spirits exert influence on the physical body while the medium remains in a passive or semi-aware state, allowing the content to emerge as direct evidence of otherworldly presence. Early spiritualists, such as Andrew Jackson Davis and Stainton Moses, emphasized this mechanism as a verifiable form of psychography, distinct from deliberate authorship.[9] Psychologically, automatic writing is interpreted as a gateway to the unconscious mind, enabling the surfacing of repressed thoughts, forgotten memories, or latent inspirations without the interference of conscious censorship. This aligns with later Freudian concepts of the unconscious as a repository of instinctual drives and symbolic content, though the practice originated in occult and spiritualist contexts predating Freud's formal theories by decades, as seen in mediumistic spirit writing from the mid-19th century. Proponents viewed it as a tool for therapeutic self-exploration, akin to hypnotic suggestion, where subconscious processes manifest through motor automatism.[10][9] Philosophically, automatic writing rests on a dualistic framework separating mind from body, positing that non-physical consciousness—whether spiritual or subconscious—can independently direct corporeal actions, echoing Cartesian mind-body distinctions. This view draws from mesmerism and animal magnetism theories, which proposed invisible fluid forces influencing human vitality and inducing trance states conducive to automatism, thereby laying groundwork for interpreting automatic writing as an extension of magnetic or hypnotic control over the body.[11][12] Beliefs about automatic writing vary between direct spirit possession, where an external entity fully commandeers the hand during trance induction, and subconscious inspiration, wherein internal psychological forces alone generate the output without supernatural intervention. Trance states, whether spontaneous, hypnotically induced, or achieved through concentration, play a pivotal role in both paradigms, facilitating dissociation from voluntary control; however, some accounts describe it occurring in normal wakefulness, highlighting its adaptability across interpretive lenses.[9]

Techniques and Methods

Traditional Methods

Traditional methods of automatic writing in 19th-century spiritualism primarily involved inducing a trance state to facilitate spirit communication through unconscious hand movements. Practitioners entered trance via meditation or hypnosis, often aided by devices resembling early ouija boards, while holding a pen loosely to allow free motion.[13] Key tools included the planchette, a heart-shaped board on casters with a protruding pencil, commercialized in 1868 for use in séances; sealed slates for spirit-inscribed messages; and direct handwriting with pencil and paper. These implements, such as the planchette produced by firms like Kirby & Co. for prices ranging from 50 cents to $8, enabled mediums to produce script without conscious control.[13][14] The process began with relaxation in a quiet setting, typically during a séance, where participants invoked spirits by name or general call to "charge" the tool. The medium then permitted the hand or device to move autonomously, resisting any conscious interference, resulting in outputs like words, sentences, or symbols that could appear jumbled initially. Sessions often lasted from minutes to hours, yielding legible messages after practice.[13] Preparation emphasized safety through protective rituals, such as invoking guardian spirits or conducting sessions in controlled environments with dim light to deter malevolent influences. Common sensations included hand autonomy, tingling, cold breezes, or vibrations, signaling spirit presence and the onset of trance.[13]

Modern Variations

In contemporary therapeutic practices, automatic writing has evolved into a tool for accessing the subconscious and repressed memories, particularly within psychology and art therapy frameworks, with significant developments from the 1930s onward and formalization in the 1960s-1970s. Spontaneous techniques such as scribbling or drawing were integrated into dynamically oriented art therapy by Margaret Naumburg starting in the 1930s to bypass conscious censorship and reveal hidden emotional content.[15] In early 20th-century trauma therapy, as developed by Pierre Janet, techniques like automatic writing were employed alongside hypnosis to surface traumatic memories, emphasizing personal insight over external influence.[16] These applications prioritize shorter, self-guided sessions to support mental health without inducing deep trance states, distinguishing them from earlier ritualistic methods.[17] For example, digital tools such as voice-to-text applications (e.g., Otter.ai) allow hands-free dictation to capture spontaneous thoughts during relaxed states. Artistic adaptations of automatic writing have shifted toward stream-of-consciousness journaling, a non-trance method where individuals write freely without self-editing to explore inner thoughts and creativity. This parallel tradition to traditional automatic writing encourages effortless flow to reduce conscious interference, fostering personal expression in everyday practice.[18] Integration with mindfulness practices further modernizes the technique, often beginning with meditation or twilight imagery to induce a relaxed state before writing, promoting individuation and emotional release through unfiltered output.[19] Recent technological variations include digital forms of automatic writing, such as voice-to-text tools enabling hands-free dictation during relaxed or trance-like states, allowing practitioners to capture spontaneous thoughts without physical writing. Unlike traditional approaches focused on spirit communication, these modern iterations emphasize self-directed subconscious delving for therapeutic or artistic growth, often in brief, accessible sessions tailored to individual well-being.

Historical Development

Origins and Early Practices

The practice of automatic writing has ancient precursors in forms of spirit-guided inscription, notably in Chinese tradition. During the Liu Song Dynasty (420–479 CE), a method known as fuji or spirit writing emerged, where a planchette—a suspended sieve attached to a stick—was used to trace characters in sand or ashes, purportedly under the influence of deities or spirits to convey messages.[20] This technique, documented in early texts, represented an early instance of involuntary or guided writing attributed to supernatural forces, predating Western developments by centuries.[20] In medieval and Renaissance Europe, analogous phenomena appeared in accounts of demonic possession during witch trials, where possessed individuals exhibited involuntary utterances and actions interpreted as communications from spirits or demons. For example, in the 1593 Warboys witch trial in England, the afflicted Throckmorton children exhibited possession symptoms that included involuntary utterances and actions interpreted as demonic communications, with trial records documenting the role of written testimonies and signs in attributing the events to witchcraft.[21] Such cases linked possession to involuntary expression, laying groundwork for later interpretations of spirit-influenced writing, though often viewed through a lens of demonic malevolence rather than benign inspiration.[21] By the 18th century, Franz Mesmer's theory of animal magnetism introduced concepts of involuntary physical responses that served as a direct precursor to automatic writing. In the 1770s, Mesmer conducted experiments in Vienna and Paris, positing an invisible magnetic fluid that could induce trance-like states and convulsive movements in subjects, often without conscious control.[22] These sessions, involving manipulated "crises" of involuntary gestures, inspired early explorations of automatic behaviors, including writing, as extensions of mesmerized states where the subject's hand might produce text under subconscious or external influence.[22] A foundational example of claimed spirit dictation appeared in the works of Emanuel Swedenborg in the 1750s. The Swedish mystic and theologian described experiences where spirits directly guided his hand in writing, producing words and sentences without his conscious awareness, as detailed in his theological manuscripts.[23] Swedenborg's accounts, such as those in his Arcana Coelestia (1749–1756), portrayed these dictations as communications from the spiritual world, influencing later understandings of psychography as a medium for divine or otherworldly revelation.[23]

19th and 20th Century Spiritualism

The emergence of automatic writing within organized Spiritualism in the 19th century was closely tied to the movement's origins in the United States, sparked by the Fox sisters' reported communications with spirits in 1848. In Hydesville, New York, sisters Margaret and Kate Fox claimed to receive raps from a spirit, which evolved into a system of spirit communication that rapidly gained public attention and laid the groundwork for mediumistic practices, including writing as a means of spirit dictation.[24] This event marked the beginning of modern Spiritualism, with mediums soon adopting automatic writing—known as psychography—to transcribe messages from the deceased, viewing it as a direct channel for spirit voices. By the 1880s, American medium Leonora Piper elevated the practice during her seances in Boston, where she produced detailed scripts in trance states, purportedly from spirits, which attracted investigations from psychical researchers.[25] During the Victorian era, automatic writing gained popularity in both Europe and the United States, integrating with broader esoteric movements such as Theosophy. Allan Kardec's 1857 publication, The Spirits' Book, endorsed psychography as a legitimate form of mediumship, drawing from seances where spirits communicated through writing to outline Spiritist principles, influencing the codification of spirit communication across continents.[26] Theosophy, founded by Helena Blavatsky in 1875, incorporated Spiritualist elements like automatic writing into its synthesis of Eastern and Western occultism, appealing to Victorian intellectuals seeking alternatives to materialism and promoting mediums who channeled "Mahatmas" via scripted messages.[27] This period saw psychography flourish in seance rooms and publications, with Victorian society embracing it as a tool for moral and philosophical guidance from the spirit world. The early 20th century represented a peak for automatic writing in Spiritualism, particularly during and after World War I, when grief over massive casualties fueled demand for spirit communications. Bereaved families turned to mediums for messages from soldiers, with psychography providing scripted consolations that surged in popularity across the Atlantic; in Britain and the U.S., seances featuring automatic writing became widespread, as seen in the 1916 publication of Oliver Lodge's Raymond, which detailed spirit scripts from his son killed in the war.[28] This cross-Atlantic exchange was facilitated by traveling mediums and organizations like the Society for Psychical Research, which documented thousands of psychographic cases, reinforcing Spiritualism's role in collective mourning. By the 1920s, exposures of fraud among mediums contributed to Spiritualism's decline, with automatic writing often revealed as deliberate trickery using concealed props or accomplices. High-profile debunkings by figures like Harry Houdini highlighted staged psychography, eroding public trust and leading to legal actions against fraudulent practitioners.[29] Post-1930s, the movement further waned as radio broadcasting and emerging psychological theories offered alternative explanations for trance states and subconscious scripting, shifting cultural focus from spirit mediums to scientific and mass media interpretations of the mind.[30]

Surrealism and Beyond

In the early 20th century, automatic writing evolved from its spiritualist roots into a core technique of the Surrealist movement, emphasizing artistic liberation of the subconscious. André Breton's Manifesto of Surrealism (1924) defined Surrealism as "psychic automatism in its pure state, by which one proposes to express—verbally, by means of the written word, or in any other manner—the actual functioning of thought," positioning automatic writing as a means to bypass rational control and access unconscious desires. This approach drew partial influence from the Dada movement of the 1910s, which had already experimented with chance operations and irrational expression to challenge conventional logic, though Surrealists refined automatism into a deliberate tool for psychological exploration.[31] By the mid-20th century, automatic writing reemerged in the occult revival associated with New Age movements of the 1960s and 1970s, often blended with psychedelic experiences to facilitate altered states of consciousness. These movements, which saw rapid growth during this period, incorporated automatic writing as a form of channeling to receive spiritual insights, reflecting a broader cultural interest in expanded awareness beyond traditional religion.[32] A prominent example is A Course in Miracles (1976), scribed by Helen Schucman through inner dictation described as an involuntary process akin to automatic writing, where she reported receiving the text from a non-physical source over seven years starting in 1965.[33] In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, automatic writing integrated into Wicca and modern paganism as a personal divination practice, shifting from communal mediumship to individual empowerment within nature-based spiritualities. Practitioners use it to connect with deities or inner guidance, aligning with the eclectic revival of pagan traditions since the 1970s.[34] This practice has experienced minor renewed interest in the 2020s through online spiritual communities, where it serves as an accessible tool for self-exploration amid digital discussions of mysticism.[35] Key shifts in automatic writing's application transitioned it from spirit mediumship—focused on external entities—to personal creativity and psychological integration, influenced by evolving understandings of the mind. In art, it became a vehicle for subconscious expression, as seen in Surrealism's departure from Spiritualist passivity.[3] Similarly, Carl Jung's concept of active imagination in the early 20th century framed automatic writing as a therapeutic method to dialogue with the unconscious, promoting self-awareness over external channeling.[36]

Notable Practitioners

Historical Figures

Leonora Piper (1857–1950), a prominent American medium based in Boston, gained fame for her automatic writing sessions that produced detailed scripts purportedly from spirits, often including personal information unknown to her.[37] Her work attracted scrutiny from psychologist William James, who attended sittings in the 1880s and 1890s, describing her as a "white crow" amid fraudulent mediums due to the evidential quality of her communications.[38] Piper's trance-induced writings, which evolved from speaking to pen-based scripts, influenced early psychical research by providing verifiable details about deceased individuals.[39] Hélène Smith (1861–1929), a Swiss medium born Élise Müller, became renowned for her automatic writing that allegedly conveyed messages from extraterrestrial sources, particularly inhabitants of Mars.[40] Studied by psychologist Théodore Flournoy in the 1890s, she produced scripts in a invented "Martian" language, complete with illustrations of alien landscapes and customs, which she translated into French.[41] Smith's sessions, often conducted in trance states, popularized automatic writing as a tool for interplanetary communication within spiritualist circles, though Flournoy later interpreted them as products of her subconscious imagination.[40] Pearl Lenore Curran (1883–1937), a St. Louis housewife, channeled the spirit entity "Patience Worth" through automatic writing starting in 1913, after initial contact via Ouija board.[42] This collaboration yielded over 2 million words of literature, including novels like The Sorry Tale (1917), set in biblical times and praised for its archaic English style mimicking 17th-century prose.[43] Curran's rapid production—up to 8,000 words per session—challenged skeptics and inspired debates on subconscious creativity, with Patience Worth claiming to be a 17th-century Englishwoman executed during the Puritan era.[42] William Butler Yeats (1865–1939), the Irish poet and Nobel laureate, incorporated automatic writing into his esoteric practices as a member of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn from the 1890s onward.[44] Beginning in 1917, shortly after his marriage to Georgie Hyde-Lees, the couple conducted over 400 sessions of automatic script, during which she channeled philosophical and symbolic content that shaped Yeats's mystical treatise A Vision (1925).[45] These writings, blending Celtic mythology with occult cosmology, influenced his poetry and plays, emphasizing themes of fate, reincarnation, and the soul's journey.[44]

20th Century and Later

In the mid-20th century, Jane Roberts (1929–1984) emerged as a prominent figure in automatic writing through her channeling of the non-physical entity known as Seth, beginning in 1963. Roberts, an American author and poet, first made contact with Seth via Ouija board sessions with her husband, Robert Butts, after which she transitioned to trance-induced automatic dictation, producing thousands of pages of philosophical and metaphysical material over two decades until her death in 1984.[46] This work, transcribed by Butts, resulted in seminal books such as Seth Speaks: The Eternal Validity of the Soul (1972) and The Nature of Personal Reality (1974), which explored themes of consciousness, reality creation, and multidimensional existence, influencing the New Age movement.[46] Geraldine Cummins (1890–1969), an Irish playwright and medium, practiced automatic writing from the 1920s through the 1950s, producing scripts purportedly from deceased historical figures. Influenced by spiritualist mentors like Hester Dowden, Cummins conducted sessions that yielded communications from F. W. H. Myers, a founder of the Society for Psychical Research, as detailed in her book The Road to Immortality (1932), which chronicled Myers' supposed post-mortem progression.[47] She also recorded scripts from Oscar Wilde in 1923, assisted by sitters S. G. Soal and Dowden, capturing the playwright's witty observations on the afterlife, alongside other works like Swan on a Black Sea (1965) featuring scripts from Winifred Coombe Tennant.[47] Cummins' output, often verified through cross-references with living acquaintances of the communicators, emphasized evidential mediumship and contributed to parapsychological investigations.[47] From the 1980s onward, Esther Hicks (born 1948) has channeled teachings from a collective non-physical consciousness called Abraham, initially through Ouija board and early writing sessions that evolved into verbal transmissions during workshops.[48] Beginning in the late 1970s with her husband Jerry Hicks, Esther's channeling produced foundational texts like Ask and It Is Given (2004), focusing on the Law of Attraction and emotional guidance, which have been disseminated through books, recordings, and live events continuing into the present.[48] This work has reached a global audience via Abraham-Hicks Publications, blending automatic-inspired techniques with contemporary self-help.[48] In the 21st century, automatic writing has seen a shift toward self-published channeled works, facilitated by digital platforms that enable rapid dissemination without traditional gatekeepers.[49] Post-2000 trends reflect greater inclusion of diverse genders and cultural perspectives, with practitioners from non-Western backgrounds incorporating indigenous spiritual elements into their scripts, often shared via online communities and e-books.[50] By the 2020s, online mediums have popularized virtual workshops and guided sessions, allowing global participants to explore automatic writing for personal guidance, as seen in structured programs emphasizing intuitive journaling.[51]

Scientific and Psychological Perspectives

Empirical Studies

Early investigations into automatic writing emerged in the late 19th century, with psychologist William James conducting observations of the trance medium Leonora Piper starting in 1885. James attended multiple sittings where Piper produced automatic writing purportedly from deceased individuals, documenting instances of accurate personal details that he deemed difficult to explain by normal means, though he remained cautious about broader implications for survival after death.[52][53] The Society for Psychical Research (SPR), founded in 1882, systematically examined automatic writing through case studies and controlled inquiries from the 1880s to the 1920s, including the cross-correspondences—a series of over 3,000 scripts from multiple automatic writers that allegedly formed interconnected messages only comprehensible when combined. While some SPR researchers interpreted these as evidence of discarnate intelligence, others highlighted inconsistencies, potential cryptomnesia, or subconscious cueing, leading to mixed conclusions without definitive proof of paranormal agency.[54] Contemporary neuroscience has begun exploring the brain mechanisms underlying automatic writing through neuroimaging. A 2023 functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) study examined a single spontaneous automatic writer and four highly hypnotizable individuals during trance-induced writing tasks, revealing decreased activation in areas such as the premotor cortex, insula, and supplemental motor area, alongside increased activity in the temporoparietal junctions and occipital lobes during production compared to a copying task. Effective connectivity analyses further indicated disrupted frontoparietal control, suggesting a shift toward automated motor output with reduced conscious oversight.[55][1] Despite these findings, empirical studies on automatic writing face persistent methodological challenges, including small sample sizes that limit generalizability—as seen in the 2023 fMRI research with only five participants—and difficulties in standardizing or replicating trance states across subjects, which complicates controlled comparisons. Broader parapsychological research has struggled with replication, with meta-analyses showing inconsistent effect sizes and no conclusive evidence for psi phenomena in automatic writing despite occasional positive outcomes.[1][56][57]

Skeptical Views and Explanations

Skeptics attribute automatic writing primarily to natural psychological and neurological processes rather than supernatural influences. One key explanation is the ideomotor effect, where subtle, unconscious muscle movements guide the hand to produce text without deliberate control, akin to the operation of Ouija boards or facilitated communication. This phenomenon occurs when expectations or subconscious suggestions prompt involuntary actions, creating the illusion of external guidance.[58] Another psychological factor is cryptomnesia, the unconscious recollection of previously encountered information mistaken for novel or channeled content. In cases of purported spirit communications or past-life revelations through automatic writing, skeptics argue that the material derives from forgotten books, conversations, or media exposures rather than discarnate entities. For instance, analyses of the SPR cross-correspondences have suggested cryptomnesia as a possible explanation for interconnected scripts.[59] Historical hoaxes further illustrate deliberate fraud in spiritualist practices involving automatic writing. In 1888, Margaret Fox confessed that she and her sister Kate had fabricated the spirit rappings that launched the modern spiritualism movement in 1848, using joint-cracking and other physical tricks to simulate ghostly communications during séances. This admission implicated broader deceptions, including automatic writing sessions where mediums feigned trance states to produce scripted messages. In contemporary settings, fraudsters employ cold reading techniques—vague statements, body language cues, and probabilistic guesses—to mimic spirit-guided writing, often in paid séances or online consultations.[60] From a neurological perspective, automatic writing aligns with dissociative states and motor automatisms, where the brain's motor cortex activates independently of conscious intent, similar to tics in Tourette's syndrome or movements during hypnosis. Neurologist Terence Hines describes it as a "milder form of dissociative state," involving temporary detachment from voluntary control without invoking paranormal agents.[61] No empirical neuroimaging or physiological data supports external spirit involvement; instead, patterns resemble internal cognitive dissociation. Critics highlight the absence of rigorous, controlled evidence validating automatic writing as a paranormal phenomenon, with parapsychological experiments often failing replication under double-blind conditions.[29] Parapsychology faces broader accusations of cultural bias, prioritizing Western spiritualist traditions while ignoring psychological alternatives prevalent in diverse populations.[62] Ethically, promoting automatic writing for therapy—such as accessing "repressed" memories—poses risks of inducing false beliefs or psychological harm without proven benefits.

Cultural and Artistic Influence

In Literature and Art

Automatic writing profoundly shaped surrealist literature, serving as a core technique for accessing the unconscious mind. André Breton's 1928 novel Nadja exemplifies this approach, blending diary-like narratives of chance encounters with symbolic drawings and references to psychic automatism to evoke a dreamlike "surreality." Breton defined surrealism itself as "pure psychic automatism by which one proposes to express... the actual functioning of thought" free from rational control, a method directly applied in Nadja through spontaneous textual fragments and illustrations that bypass aesthetic constraints.[63] This technique, first demonstrated in the 1924 journal Littérature, influenced broader surrealist texts by prioritizing the dictation of thought over deliberate composition.[64] Beyond surrealism, automatic writing extended to channeled literature, where mediums produced novels attributed to spiritual entities. In the early 20th century, Pearl Lenore Curran, a St. Louis housewife, generated multiple novels, poems, and plays under the name Patience Worth, initially via Ouija board but later through rapid automatic writing sessions that produced thousands of words in hours. Works like The Sorry Tale (1917), a historical novel set in biblical times, emerged from these trance-like states, gaining commercial success and sparking debates on authorship.[65] Similarly, The Urantia Book (1955), a expansive philosophical and religious text spanning over 2,000 pages, originated from transmissions through a sleeping subject in Chicago between 1924 and 1955, though not via traditional automatic writing or trance mediumship; it was materialized in written form by celestial beings, as per accounts from the Urantia Foundation.[66] In visual art, automatic writing inspired extensions into drawing and collage, emphasizing chance and subconscious form. Jean Arp's 1920s collages, such as Untitled (Collage with Squares Arranged According to the Law of Chance) (1916–1917), prefigured surrealist automatism by arranging torn paper elements without conscious intervention, creating biomorphic abstractions that influenced later Dada and surrealist practices.[67] These techniques paralleled automatic drawing, where lines flowed freely to reveal unconscious shapes, as seen in Arp's ink works from the period. The impact rippled into the Beat Generation's free writing in the 1950s, with Jack Kerouac's "spontaneous prose"—a Benzedrine-fueled, stream-of-consciousness method—directly echoing surrealist automatic writing to capture raw experience in works like On the Road (1957).[68] Central themes in automatic writing's literary and artistic outputs include the exploration of the uncanny, where the familiar turns strangely alien, and its role in fostering postmodern experimental prose. Surrealist applications often invoked Freud's concept of the uncanny through irrational juxtapositions and dream logic, unsettling perceptions of reality in automatic texts.[69] This legacy persists in postmodern works, where automatism-inspired techniques like fragmented narratives and metafiction challenge linear storytelling, prioritizing subconscious flux over coherent plots to probe identity and meaning.[70]

In Media and Popular Culture

Automatic writing has been portrayed in horror films as a symptom of demonic possession or psychological unraveling, often serving as a visual cue for the intrusion of the supernatural into the conscious mind. The 1973 film The Exorcist, directed by William Friedkin, draws inspiration from the 1949 exorcism case of a boy pseudonymously known as Roland Doe, during which automatic writing was documented as part of the disturbing phenomena, including words appearing on the boy's body without his conscious effort. Although the film emphasizes Regan's verbal outbursts and physical contortions, the underlying real-life elements, including uncontrolled script production, contribute to the trope of writing as a conduit for malevolent forces. This depiction cemented automatic writing's place in popular horror, influencing subsequent portrayals of possession. The 2018 film Hereditary, written and directed by Ari Aster, incorporates horror tropes of loss of volition through mysterious inscriptions and compelled actions by the character Annie Graham, who uncovers cult-related symbols amid her family's descent into madness. In television, the series Medium (2005–2011), created by Glenn Gordon Caron, features psychic Allison DuBois receiving spirit communications through dreams and visions, blending procedural drama with supernatural mediumship to depict the practice as a tool for solving crimes. References to automatic writing appear in Stephen King's occult novels, where it symbolizes the blurring of self and otherworldly inspiration. In The Dark Half (1989), protagonist Thad Beaumont experiences automatic writing from his murderous alter ego, George Stark, who communicates through Thad's unconscious scribbles on paper, heightening the psychological terror of dissociated identity. This narrative device underscores King's recurring theme of creativity as a potentially dangerous trance state. In modern media, automatic writing has shifted toward self-empowerment narratives, particularly in podcasts exploring channeled texts. Shows like Michael Sandler's Inspire Nation in the 2020s discuss automatic writing as a meditative practice for accessing subconscious guidance, often tying it to spiritual awakening without supernatural dread. Emerging sci-fi, such as the 2014 film Ex Machina directed by Alex Garland, invites analogies between automatic writing's unconscious output and AI's generative text creation, probing ethical questions about authorship in machine-driven expression. Culturally, post-2010 pop psychology books have mainstreamed the practice for subconscious journaling; Michael Sandler's The Automatic Writing Experience (2021) presents it as a channeling technique to overcome blocks and find life direction, influencing wellness trends.[71]

References

  1. A neurophenomenological fMRI study of a spontaneous automatic ...
  2. Extra Consciousness, Extra Fingers: Automatic Writing and Disabled ...
  3. [PDF] The Automatic Hand: Spiritualism, Psychoanalysis, Surrealism - MIT
  4. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/1520-6696(199201
  5. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0049360
  6. https://doi.org/10.1590/s1516-44462011000500004
  7. Moral Mediums: Spirit-Writing and the Cultural Construction ... - Érudit
  8. Patent Drawings from Beyond the Grave - The Unwritten Record
  9. Automatic Writing - 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica - StudyLight.org
  10. Surrealist Techniques: Automatism (article) | Khan Academy
  11. [PDF] Rene Descartes and the Legacy of Mind/Body Dualism
  12. Animal Magnetism | Scholarly Resources - Esalen Institute
  13. [PDF] SPIRITUALISM'S SUPERNATURAL ECONOMY, 1848 – 1900
  14. None
  15. Drawing as Instrument, Drawings as Evidence: Capturing Mental ...
  16. [PDF] TRAUMA THERAPY IN TREATMENT OF PSYCHOSIS - RUcore
  17. [PDF] UC Riverside - eScholarship
  18. Two Parallel Traditions: Automatic Writing and Free Writing
  19. [PDF] Meditation. Twilight Imagery. and Individuation in Creative Writing
  20. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3182924
  21. Writing Demon Possession: The Case of the Witches of Warboys
  22. Automatic writing: a history from Mesmer to Breton - Dissertation.com
  23. [PDF] Emanuel Swedenborg: Scientist and Mystic
  24. Very Mysterious: The Fox Sisters and the Spiritualist Movement
  25. Mediumship | Scholarly Resources - Esalen Institute
  26. How did the Spirits communicate with Kardec?
  27. What Theosophy did for us – I: Introduction - Enfolding.org
  28. Spirits and Friends Beyond (The Seas): Spiritualism and the ... - MDPI
  29. A Case of Automatic Writing From Robert G. Ingersoll's Spirit?
  30. Spiritualism and the Birth of Radio - Efram Sera-Shriar
  31. Surrealism - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
  32. [PDF] A THEOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF THE USE OF NEW AGE ...
  33. A Course in Miracles
  34. Automatic Writing as a Divination Tool - Learn Religions
  35. Spiritualism and the Occult: Automatic Writing and When Ghosts ...
  36. Jung on Active Imagination: Features, Methods and Warnings
  37. Mrs. Piper & the Society for Psychical Research - Project Gutenberg
  38. William James and the Psychics | Skeptical Inquirer
  39. The Medium Had The Message - AMERICAN HERITAGE
  40. Hélène Smith | Psi Encyclopedia
  41. Speaking Martian | Daniel Rosenberg - Cabinet Magazine
  42. Patience Worth: Author From the Great Beyond
  43. The Strange Case of Pearl Curran & Patience Worth
  44. William Butler Yeats | The Poetry Foundation
  45. The Vision of W.B. Yeats - Theosophical Society
  46. How Elmira's Seth, a supernatural New Age teacher, defined reality
  47. Geraldine Cummins | Psi Encyclopedia
  48. Abraham-Hicks Publications - Law of Attraction Official Site
  49. Self-Publishing's Output and Influence Continue to Grow
  50. (PDF) Self-Publishing: Opportunities and Threats in a New Age of ...
  51. Automatic Writing Courses - The College of Psychic Studies
  52. William James | Psi Encyclopedia - Society for Psychical Research
  53. Psychical research and the origins of American psychology - NIH
  54. Society for Psychical Research | Psi Encyclopedia
  55. JB Rhine - Psi Encyclopedia - Society for Psychical Research
  56. About the Exhibit · Early Studies in Parapsychology at Duke
  57. A neurophenomenological fMRI study of a spontaneous automatic ...
  58. [PDF] Replication and Meta-Analysis in Parapsychology
  59. [PDF] REPLICATION AND META-ANALYSIS IN PARAPSYCHOLOGY - CIA
  60. Ask the pendulum: personality predictors of ideomotor performance
  61. [PDF] Cryptomnesia-and-Parapsychology.pdf
  62. cryptomnesia - The Skeptic's Dictionary - Skepdic.com
  63. Mediums
  64. How Does the Ouija Board Work? | Skeptical Inquirer
  65. [PDF] COMMENTARY - Journal of Scientific Exploration
  66. Analysis of André Breton's Nadja - Literary Theory and Criticism
  67. André Breton | The Poetry Foundation
  68. The Patience of Pearl - Project MUSE
  69. Who wrote The Urantia Book? - TruthBook
  70. Jean (Hans) Arp. Untitled (Collage with Squares Arranged ... - MoMA
  71. Beat generation | Research Starters - EBSCO
  72. Surrealism Movement Overview | TheArtStory
  73. Postmodern Literature Guide: 10 Notable Postmodern Authors - 2025
  74. The Automatic Writing Experience (AWE): How to Turn Your ...
  75. Margaret Naumburg papers
User Avatar
No comments yet.