George Mallory
George Mallory
Main page
2217278

George Mallory

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
from Wikipedia

Olympic medal record
Men's Alpinism
Representing  United Kingdom
Olympic Games
Gold medal – first place 1924 Chamonix Everest expedition

Key Information

George Herbert Leigh-Mallory (18 June 1886 – 8 or 9 June 1924) was an English mountaineer who participated in the first three British Mount Everest expeditions from the early to mid-1920s. He and his climbing partner Andrew "Sandy" Irvine were last seen ascending near Everest's summit during the 1924 expedition, prompting speculation as to whether they reached it before they died.

Born in Cheshire, England, Mallory became a student at Winchester College, where a teacher recruited him for an excursion in the Alps, and he developed a strong natural climbing ability. After graduating from Magdalene College, Cambridge, where he became friends with prominent intellectuals, he taught at Charterhouse School while honing his climbing skills in the Alps and the English Lake District. He pioneered new routes and became a respected figure in the British climbing community.

His service in the First World War interrupted his climbing, but he returned with vigour after the war. Mallory's most notable contributions to mountaineering were his expeditions to Everest. Famously, when asked by a reporter why he wanted to climb Everest, Mallory purportedly replied, "Because it's there." In 1921, he participated in the first British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition, which established the North Col-North Ridge as a viable route to the summit. In 1922, he took part in a second expedition to attempt the first ascent of Everest, in which his team achieved a world altitude record of 27,300 ft (8,321 m)[1] using supplemental oxygen. They were awarded Olympic gold medals for alpinism.

During the 1924 expedition, Mallory and Irvine disappeared on Everest's Northeast Ridge. They were last seen at 800 vertical feet (240 metres) from the summit. Mallory's body, along with personal effects, was found in 1999 by the Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition at 26,760 feet (8,160 metres), some 688 vertical metres below the summit. The discovery, however, provided no evidence that he had reached the summit.

Early life and teaching career

[edit]

Childhood

[edit]
St Wilfrid's Church, Mobberley, Cheshire, which Mallory climbed aged 7

George Herbert Leigh Mallory was born at Newton Hall, Mobberley, Cheshire, on 18 June 1886.[2][3] He was the first son and second child of Annie Beridge Leigh-Mallory[4] and the Reverend Herbert Leigh Mallory,[4] rector of the parish.[5][6] Mallory had two sisters, Mary Henrietta[4] and Annie Victoria (Avie),[4] and a younger brother, Trafford,[4] who was a Second World War Royal Air Force commander.[7][8][n 1] (Herbert Mallory legally changed his surname to Leigh-Mallory in 1914; Trafford followed suit, but George remained known as Mallory.) At the end of 1891, the Mallorys moved from Newton Hall to Hobcroft House, Mobberley.[6] The family resided there until 1904, when they moved to Birkenhead, Cheshire.[11][6] Mallory exhibited an early proclivity for climbing[12], and at age 7 he climbed the roof of his father's church, St Wilfrid's, in Mobberley.[12] His sister Avie recalls, "He climbed everything that it was at all possible to climb."[12] Included in his climbing exploits were the drainpipes of Hobcroft House and the walls that divided the farmers' fields.[12]

1896–1905: Glengorse and Winchester College

[edit]
Winchester College Chapel (right) and scholars' College (left), where Mallory was a scholar 1900–1905

In 1896, Mallory was sent to Glengorse boarding school in Eastbourne on the south coast of England, after the abrupt closure of his first preparatory school in West Kirby, following the death of its headmaster.[13][14][15][16] Mallory won a mathematics scholarship to Winchester College, an English public school, where he started in September 1900.[15][17] At Winchester, he was proficient at sports, in addition to his academic ability.[18] He became the best gymnast in the school, the only one capable of performing the giant swing on the horizontal bar.[19][18] In July 1904, Mallory was a member of the Winchester team who won the Ashburton Shield for rifle shooting at Bisley.[18][20]

In 1904, Irving was seeking new climbing companions after the accidental death of his regular climbing partner.[21][22] R. L. G. Irving, the Master in College at Winchester, was a member of the Alpine Club and an accomplished mountaineer, [21][22] and he recruited Mallory and fellow pupil and friend, Harry Gibson,[23][n 2] for a trip to the Alps. It was there in early August 1904 that Mallory had his first experience with high-altitude mountaineering.[21][22][24][25] In his final year at Winchester, Mallory studied history instead of mathematics.[26] After sitting his exams, he was awarded a history scholarship, known as a sizarship, to Magdalene College, Cambridge.[26]

1905–09: Magdalene College, Cambridge

[edit]
Magdalene College, Cambridge

"Mon dieu!—George Mallory!... My hand trembles, my heart palpitates, my whole being swoons... he's six foot high, with the body of an athlete by Praxiteles, and a face—oh incredible—the mystery of Botticelli, the refinement and delicacy of a Chinese print, the youth and piquancy of an unimaginable English boy."

— Lytton Strachey, writing to Clive and Vanessa Bell of his first meeting with Mallory. 21 May 1909.[27][28][29][30]

In October 1905, Mallory entered Magdalene College to study history,[31][32] where his tutor, A. C. Benson, became enamoured of him.[33] On 6 February 1907 at Christ's College, Mallory dined with Charles Edward Sayle, under-librarian at Cambridge University Library.[34] At Sayle's he met undergraduates with whom he established enduring friendships[35] including painter Jacques Raverat, surgeon and author Geoffrey Keynes, poet Rupert Brooke, and psychoanalyst James Strachey.[36] On 12 February 1909, Mallory met Geoffrey Winthrop Young and they developed a strong friendship.[37][38] Through James Strachey and Geoffrey Keynes, Mallory got to know their brothers, Lytton Strachey and John Maynard Keynes, who were members of the Bloomsbury Group.[39][40] Through the Stracheys, he befriended their cousin, painter Duncan Grant,[n 3] a Bloomsbury member.[45][40] His letters attest to the flirtatious nature of these friendships. Following his engagement in 1914, he wrote to one-time partner[46] James Strachey: "It can hardly be a shock to you that I desert the ranks of the fashionable homosexualists (and yet I am still in part of that persuasion) unless you think I have turned monogamist. But you may be assured that this last catastrophe has not happened."[47]

Mallory developed into an accomplished rower at Magdalene,[34][48] and in October 1906, he was elected secretary of the Magdalene Boat Club and captain of boats from 1907 to 1908.[49][50][51] Mallory joined the University Fabian Society, and acted as college secretary on the University Women's Suffrage Association committee.[52][53] The Marlowe Society was established in 1907[54] and Mallory acted in its first production of Doctor Faustus.[54][55]

Academically, in May 1907, Mallory sat Part I of the history tripos, achieving a third class.[56][57] (In 1908, in Part II, he attained a second-class degree.)[58][57] Mallory had to consider a future career[59] and in 1907,[52] he consulted deputy headmaster of Winchester, Howard Rendall, about becoming a teacher there, but Rendall bluntly dismissed his prospects.[59] Mallory informed his tutor, A. C. Benson, that Randall "says that as I have nothing to teach and would probably teach it badly, there is not the least chance of ever getting to Winchester."[52][59] Rendall suggested he go into the church and Mallory unenthusiastically considered following in his father's footsteps, perhaps engaging in "parish work of some kind... [But] I'm at variance with so many parsons that I meet. They're excessively good, most of them much better than I can ever hope to be, but their sense of goodness seems sometimes to displace their reason."[52][59][60] Benson suggested Mallory return to Magdalene for a fourth year, where he could improve upon his degree.[61] Mallory took his tutor's advice and settled into rooms at Pythagoras House, a short distance from the college.[62][61][57]

In February 1909, Geoffrey Winthrop Young invited Mallory on a climbing trip to Wales.[63] After Mallory's return to Magdalene, Young sent him an application to join the Climbers' Club, and in May 1909, Mallory was elected a member.[63] The subject for the Members' Prize Essay in 1909 was James Boswell, biographer of Samuel Johnson. Mallory submitted an essay entitled Boswell the Biographer and it was awarded second place.[64][65][66][61][57] (Benson encouraged him to submit his essay for publication and in 1912 it was published by Smith, Elder & Co.)[67][68][69] Mallory completed his degree at Magdalene in July 1909.[70]

1909–10: Interim

[edit]

In October 1909, the painter Simon Bussy, whose wife Dorothy was the sister of Lytton and James Strachey, invited Mallory to spend the winter with them at their villa in Roquebrune in the Alpes-Maritimes.[71][72] Mallory, who had recently received a small family inheritance, accepted their offer and travelled to France in early November to stay with them.[73][70] He stayed in Paris for a month to improve his French by reading, conversing, and attending the theatre, music halls and Sorbonne lectures.[64][74][75]

In April 1910, Mallory returned to Cambridge, again considering his future career options.[76][77][75] In May he took a temporary teaching post at the Royal Naval College, Dartmouth, which lasted two weeks.[76][78][75] In July, Mallory received a letter from Gerald Henry Rendall[n 4], headmaster of Charterhouse, an English public school, offering him a job teaching Latin, mathematics, history, and French, which Mallory accepted.[81][79][80]

1910–14: Charterhouse School

[edit]

"He was wasted at Charterhouse... the boys generally despised him as neither a disciplinarian nor interested in cricket or football. He tried to treat his classes in a friendly way, which puzzled and offended them because of the school tradition of concealed warfare between boys and masters."

— Robert Graves, one of Mallory's students at Charterhouse.[82][83]

In September 1910, Mallory began teaching at Charterhouse as an assistant headmaster,[84][85][86] but due to his youthful appearance he was often mistaken by parents for a student.[87][88] He taught through enthusiasm and a friendly manner rather than by imposing authority.[89][88] He followed the teaching styles of Irving and Benson, who sought to educate through mutual respect, getting to know pupils as individuals, and rejecting the strict discipline common in British schools at the time.[85] Some of his colleagues, however, were hostile to his informal teaching methods, believing they eroded discipline.[88] He recommended students read literature extensively, write essays on subjects such as hypocrisy, candour, and popularity, and engaged them in discussions of politics and literature.[87][88] He also arranged visits to scenic landscapes and historic buildings.[87][88]

Robert Graves, a student from 1909 to 1914, said Mallory was the best teacher and first genuine friend he ever had.[90][n 5] In his autobiography, Good-Bye to All That, Graves wrote fondly of Mallory, who encouraged him in poetry[95] and took him climbing in Snowdon.[96] Irving and Young nominated Mallory for the Alpine Club, and in December 1910, he was elected a member.[97][98][99] During the summer of 1913, Mallory collaborated with Graves and other students to produce a magazine called Green Chartreuse, intended to rival other school magazines, with its first publication on Old Carthusian Day, 5 July 1913.[100][101][102] Mallory presented lectures on Italian painting in spring 1914, engaging students in a "rather philosophical" discussion about Botticelli, Michelangelo, and Raphael.[102]

Climbing in Europe

[edit]

The Alps

[edit]
Mallory, with Harold Porter, established a new route on the Aiguille des Grands Charmoz in Haute-Savoie, France in 1919

Mallory made eight expeditions to the Alps and accomplished four first ascents. His first climb was on 5 August 1904, when he, Irving, and Gibson ascended Mont Vélan on the Swiss-Italian border. The team, however, was forced to retreat 600 ft (183 m) below the summit because Mallory and Gibson were suffering from altitude sickness.[103][104] On 13 August, they reached the summit of Dufourspitze, the third-highest peak in Western Europe.[105] On 26 August, Irving and Mallory summited Mont Blanc, at 15,800 ft (4,807.81 m), the highest mountain in Western Europe, marking Mallory's entry into high-altitude mountaineering.[24]

In January 1905, Graham Irving established the Winchester Ice Club[26], and Mallory, Gibson, Harry Tyndale,[106] and Guy Bullock became members.[107] In August, the Ice Club travelled to the Alps.[26] Mallory would not return for another four years, when he would accomplish a first ascent of the Southeast Ridge of Nesthorn with Young and Charles Robertson on 4 August 1909.[108] Mallory wrote to his mother, "We were out 21 hours and were altogether pleased with ourselves,"[109] but he had also nearly fallen after missing a hold above an overhang. On 7 August, they crossed the mountain pass Grünhornlücke, followed by the Fiescher Glacier, and climbed to the summit via the Southeast Ridge of the highest mountain in the Bernese Alps, Finsteraarhorn, at 14,022 ft (4,274 m),[110][111] graded approximately 5.8, using the Yosemite Decimal System (YDS). One of Mallory's closest friends and climbing companions, whom he met in Switzerland on this trip, was a woman named Cottie Sanders, who became a novelist using the pseudonym of Ann Bridge.[112][113] Their relationship was unclear. Sanders was either a "climbing friend" or "casual sweetheart."[114] After Mallory died, Cottie wrote a memoir of him, which remains unpublished but provided much of the material used by later biographers.[115][116]

At the beginning of August 1911, Mallory returned to the Alps with Irving and Tyndale.[117] On 9 August, they reached the summit of Herbétet, by way of a first ascent of its Western Ridge.[118][119] On 18 August, Irving, Mallory, and Tyndale reached the summit of Mont Maudit, via the third ascent of its Southeast Ridge, and Mont Blanc.[120] In 1917, Mallory rewrote an impassioned account about the Maudit ascent.[121] It was published in the Alpine Journal of 1918 and contained the question, "Have we vanquished an enemy? None but ourselves."[92][122]

In August 1912, Mallory undertook his sixth expedition to the Alps, along with Harold Porter and Hugh Pope.[123][n 6] On 17 August, they established a new line on the West Face of Dent Blanche, graded 5.6–5.7.[127][128][129] On 2 August 1919, Mallory and Porter set out from Montenvers and ascended the Mer de Glace up to the Glacier de Trélaporte. From there they took a new route to the summit of Aiguille des Grands Charmoz, likely graded 5.7.[130][131] Three days later, they climbed a new route to the summit of Aiguille du Midi,[132] at 12,605 ft (3,842 m). This route, rectified by the climber Jean-Louis Urquizar in 1971, is now known as Rectified Mallory-Porter, totalling 5,020 ft (1,530 m) in elevation gain and graded approximately 5.8–5.9.[133][134]

Scotland

[edit]
North Face of Ben Nevis

On 6 April 1906, Mallory, Irving, and Leach reached the summit of Ben Nevis[n 7] in snowy conditions via Observatory Gully and Tower Gully on the northeast face.[137] The following day, the trio ascended Stob Bàn, following the corniced main arête to the summit.[138] On 9 April, they reached the summit of Càrn Mòr Dearg, before making a second successful ascent of Ben Nevis on the same day via North Trident Buttress.[139] On 10 April, they successfully scaled a feature on Ben Nevis that they named East Zmutt Ridge after Zmutt Ridge on the Matterhorn, likely graded YDS 5.5–5.6.[140] On 12 April, Mallory, Irving, and Leach made a successful snow-and-ice ascent of Ben Nevis via the North-East Buttress.[141] Their achievement was the second recorded winter ascent of this route, after the first in 1896.[140][142]

On 28 July 1918, Mallory, David Randall Pye, and Leslie Garnet Shadbolt,[143] climbing together, made a new route on the North Face of Sgùrr a' Mhadaidh on the Isle of Skye, Scotland, graded 5.5–5.6.[92][144] On 31 July, the trio with Mallory leading established another new route on the Western Buttress of the crag, Sron na Ciche, located in the Cuillin mountains; a route now known as Mallory's Slab and Groove, and graded about 5.5.[145][146][147]

Wales

[edit]
Mallory, climbing solo, established the first ascent of The Slab Climb on the East Buttress of Y Lliwedd

On 14 September 1907, Mallory accomplished his first two climbs in Wales: North Gully[148] and North Buttress on Tryfan.[149][150][151] On 18 September,[149] Mallory, Keynes, and Wilson climbed Terminal Arête, on Lliwedd's East Buttress,[152] and inadvertently dislodged a large rock when finishing their climb.[153][154] Much to their dismay, the rock almost hit James Thomson and partner E.S. Reynolds as they climbed below on a new route, which they aptly named Avalanche Route.[155][156]

On Craig yr Ysfa, the trio climbed two routes: Great Gully, at 732 ft (223 m),[157][158] and Amphitheatre Buttress, at 961 ft (293 m), both graded about 5.5.[149][159] Mallory returned to Snowdonia in August 1908, accompanied by his brother, Trafford.[160] Mallory, climbing solo, established the first ascent of The Slab Climb on the East Buttress of Lliwedd,[161] now known as Mallory's Slab, at 220 ft (67 m), and graded 5.5.[160][162] The ascent of The Slab Climb occurred due to Mallory scaling it to retrieve his pipe, which he had left behind on a ledge known as Bowling Green.[163] In April 1909, Mallory and Geoffrey Winthrop Young journeyed to Pen-y-Pass.[164] On the cliffs of Craig yr Ysfa, Mallory and Young established three new ascents and climbed The Slab Climb (Mallory's Slab) on the East Buttress of Lliwedd, which Young described as "The hardest rocks I have done."[164]

In September 1911, Mallory and his sister Mary were joined by Harold Porter, Mallory's climbing partner, and stayed at the Snowdon Ranger Inn on the shore of Llyn Cwellyn.[165][166] Mallory and Porter pioneered new routes that elevated Mallory to the pinnacle of British climbing.[167] On Y Garn, with Porter leading Mallory on the crux, they ascended a new route, now known as Mallory's Ridge, at 394 ft (120 m), graded 5.9–5.10a.[167][168] This route defeated James Thomson in 1910, who abandoned it on the most challenging pitch, a sixty-foot segment of vertical rock.[167]

England

[edit]
Napes Needle on Great Gable

Mallory's first rock climbing experience in England took place during a nine-day excursion to the Lake District in September 1908 with Geoffrey Keynes, Harry Gibson, and Harold Porter.[169][170][171] Their initial climb was Kern Knotts Crack on Great Gable, which is graded 5.5.[172] The following day they climbed Napes Needle, a rock pinnacle on Great Gable, at 56 ft (17 m), graded approximately 5.5.[170][173] Also on Great Gable, they climbed Eagle's Nest Ridge Direct, graded approximately 5.8.[170][173] They accomplished a successful ascent of North Climb on Pillar Rock,[174] graded YDS 5.6.[175][176]

On 21 September 1908, they pioneered two new routes on the Ennerdale face of Great Gable:[174] Mallory's Left-Hand Route, at 98 ft (30 m), graded YDS 5.5, and Mallory's Right-Hand Route, at 120 ft (37 m), graded about 5.8.[170][177][178] In August 1913,[179] Mallory and Geoffrey Winthrop Young achieved a new route, Pinnacle Traverse, at 200 ft (60 m), graded 5.4, on the crag, Carn Lés Boel, in Cornwall.[180][181] On 7 September 1913, Mallory and Alan Goodfellow, a Charterhouse student, created Mallory's Variation, a new route on Abbey Buttress, Great Gable, where Mallory finished the route by ascending a twenty-foot slab on tenuous grips, rather than exiting to the right.[182][183] On 8 September, with Mallory leading Goodfellow, the pair established another new route, this time on the West Face of Low Man, Pillar Rock, at 210 ft (65 m), and graded 5.9–5.10a, which they named North-West by West and now known as Mallory's Route.[182][184] (For comparison, climbers have rated Everest's Second Step at about 5.9.[185][186])

Marriage and the First World War

[edit]
Christiana Ruth Leigh-Mallory (née Turner)

Christiana Ruth Turner[187][188] was a daughter of architect Hugh Thackeray Turner[4] and embroiderer Mary Elizabeth Turner.[4][189][190][191][n 8] Mallory and the Turner family developed a close friendship and he regularly visited their dwelling at Westbrook.[191] In April 1914, Mallory joined Thackeray and his daughters on a holiday in Venice, where Mallory and Ruth fell in love.[193][194][191] On 1 May 1914, at Westbrook, Mallory and Ruth became engaged.[193][191][195] Thackeray purchased a six-bedroom house for them, named The Holt, in Godalming, Surrey.[196][195] On 29 July 1914, six days before Britain entered the First World War, Mallory and Ruth were married in Godalming,[n 9] with Mallory's father performing the ceremony and Geoffrey Winthrop Young acting as best man.[198][199][200] Mallory and Ruth had two daughters and a son: Frances Clare (1915–2001),[201][4][202] Beridge Ruth, known as "Berry" (1917–1953),[203][204] and John (1920–2011).[4][205][206][207]

Mallory enlisted in the war effort and started artillery training at Weymouth Camp in January 1916.[208] Frank Fletcher, headmaster of Charterhouse, had initially challenged Mallory's inquiries about enlisting and asked the government about policies regarding schoolmasters enlisting.[209][210][211] Mallory received additional training at the School of Siege Artillery at Lydd Camp.[212] He arrived in France in May 1916[213] and fought at the Battle of the Somme in the 40th Siege Battery.[214][215] Later that year, he was granted leave,[216][217] spending ten days at Westbrook House with Ruth and daughter Clare before returning to France on Boxing Day.[218]

He was reassigned as an orderly officer, serving as a colonel's assistant at the 30th Heavy Artillery Group headquarters, three miles behind the front line, for the first weeks of 1917.[219][220][217] At the beginning of February 1917, the command recommended Mallory for a staff lieutenancy, but he rejected it and was instead assigned a liaison officer position to a French unit.[219][221] At the end of March, he applied to rejoin the 40th Siege Battery, which had moved to a new location.[221] On 7 April, during the prelude to the Battle of Arras, he was back at the front with the 40th Siege Battery in an exposed observation post, directing artillery fire.[217]

"The trenches were in a filthy state, owing to a more or less futile attack made by our men the night before. I don't object to corpses so long as they are fresh. I soon found that I could reason thus with them... But this is an accepted fact that men are killed... your jaw hangs and your flesh changes colour and blood oozes from your wounds. With the wounded it is different. It always distresses me to see them."

— Mallory, in a letter to his wife, Ruth. 15 August 1916.[222][223]

In September Mallory was sent, under new orders, to Avington Park Camp near Winchester, and was transferred from the Siege Battery to a Heavy Battery. Mallory trained at the camp with the Royal Artillery's new generation of 60-pounder heavy guns.[224][225][226]

In October 1917, Mallory was promoted lieutenant and commenced a training course for newly promoted officers at Avington Park Camp.[227][225][228] On 23 September 1918, Mallory was reassigned to the 515th Siege Battery, stationed between Arras and the French coast.[229][230] On the evening of 11 November, at the officers' club in Cambrai, Mallory celebrated peace with his brother Trafford.[229][231][n 10] Due to the British requirement to demobilise more than a million men and a lack of ships, Mallory did not return to England until January 1919.[233][234][n 11]

The lure of Everest

[edit]

Following his return from France, Mallory and his family re-established themselves in their previous residence, The Holt in Godalming, Surrey.[236][234] At the end of January 1919, Mallory resumed his teaching position at Charterhouse, where he taught English and history.[237][238] Mallory felt dissatisfied as a schoolmaster, devoting more attention to mountaineering issues, the direction of international politics, and the fundamental objectives of education, and pondering how he could find more time for writing.[239][240]

Sir Francis Younghusband

In January 1921, representatives of the Royal Geographical Society and the Alpine Club jointly established the Mount Everest Committee to organise and finance an expedition to Mount Everest.[241][242] The committee consisted of four RGS members and four Alpine Club members. From the RGS were Sir Francis Younghusband, Arthur Robert Hinks, Edward Lygon Somers-Cocks, and Colonel Evan Maclean Jack; and from the Alpine Club were Professor John Norman Collie, John Percy Farrar, Charles Francis Meade, and John Edward Caldwell Eaton.[243][244] The committee's primary objective in 1921 was a thorough reconnaissance of the mountain and its approaches to determine the most viable route to the summit, and in 1922 to return for a second expedition, using this route for an attempt to reach the summit.[245] On 23 January 1921, Mallory received a letter from John Percy Farrar, secretary of the Alpine Club, its former president and member of the nascent Mount Everest Committee.[246] Farrar asked Mallory if he would be interested in participating in an expedition to Everest: "It appears an attempt on Everest will occur this summer. The party would depart in early April and return in October. Any ambitions?"[246]

North Face of Mount Everest

Although grateful for the invitation, Mallory questioned the viability of the expedition and was reluctant to accept, also knowing that his participation would mean a lengthy separation from his wife and young children.[247][248] Geoffrey Winthrop Young visited him at the Holt and upon learning of his hesitance, persuaded him and Ruth not to miss the opportunity, saying that not only would it be an incredible adventure, but it would also establish his reputation and enhance his prospects as an educator or writer.[249][247] Ruth was convinced that Mallory should join the expedition and, acknowledging it was "the opportunity of a lifetime," he decided to participate.[248] On 9 February 1921, in Mayfair, London, Mallory met with Sir Francis Younghusband, chairman of the Mount Everest Committee; John Percy Farrar, a committee member; and Harold Raeburn, the assigned mountaineering leader of the 1921 British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition.[250][248] At the meeting, Younghusband formally invited Mallory to join the expedition and was a bit puzzled by his less-than-enthusiastic response.[251][248] But nonetheless Mallory resigned from his mastership at Charterhouse[248] and on 8 April 1921 departed England on the SS Sardinia to join the expedition.[252][253]

Everest expeditions

[edit]

1921 British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition

[edit]
Eight members of the 1921 Everest expedition. Standing left to right are Guy Bullock, Henry Morshead, Oliver Wheeler, and George Mallory. Alexander Heron, Sandy Wollaston, Charles Howard-Bury, and Harold Raeburn are seated left to right.[n 12]

The objective of the first Everest expedition in 1921 was to reconnoiter the mountain and its approaches to determine the best route to the summit.[242] Expedition surveyors Henry Morshead and Oliver Wheeler, with the assistance of Indian surveyors, produced the first accurate maps of the region.[257][258][259] On 18 August, after a two-month survey of Everest's northern and eastern approaches, Mallory, Guy Bullock, Henry Morshead, and a porter left their camp at approximately 20,000 ft (6,096 m).[260][261] From the western head of the Kharta Glacier, they ascended to the col of Lhakpa La, at 22,470 ft (6,849 m).[261][262] The head of the East Rongbuk Glacier lay 1,200 ft (366 m) below Lhakpa La, and across the glacier rises a 1,000 ft (305 m) wall of snow and ice leading to Everest's North Col, at 23,030 ft (7,020 m). The team determined that the summit could be reached from there via the North Col-North Ridge-Northeast Ridge route.[261][263]

On 23 September, Mallory, Bullock, Wheeler, and ten porters left their camp on Lhakpa La, descended to the East Rongbuk Glacier, and pitched camp at an elevation of 22,000 ft (6,706 m),[264] 1 mile (1.6 km) from the beginning of the ascent to the North Col.[265][266][267] On 24 September, the three expedition members and three porters crossed the East Rongbuk Glacier to the foot of the 1,000 ft (305 m) wall of snow and ice, and after an arduous climb reached the North Col.[265][266][268] On the col and above, gale force winds were blowing from the northwest, making further progress impossible, and they were forced to return to their camp on the East Rongbuk Glacier.[269] The next day, with the severe winds unabated, Wheeler suffering from frostbite, and the porters exhausted, Mallory decided to abandon the attempt.[270][271][272][273]

On 29 October, Mallory departed from Bombay, India, on board SS Malwa.[274][275] On 9 November, Younghusband wrote to Mallory asking him to join the second expedition in 1922[276], explaining that he did not want to wait until 1923 for fear of losing the favour and support of the Tibetans.[276] Mallory wrote his sister Avie with his reservations about returning to Everest in 1922.[277] His wife Ruth awaited him in Marseille, where they spent a holiday touring Provence.[278][274] They discussed his participation in the 1922 expedition and again decided he should not miss the opportunity.[278][279][279][280] On 25 November, they arrived home,[278] and a few days afterwards Mallory met Hinks in London. Within a week he was on the list of mountaineers who had agreed to join the 1922 expedition.[278][279]

Lectures, writing, and preparation for the 1922 expedition

[edit]
Charles Howard-Bury

On 20 December 1921 in the Queen's Hall, London, Mallory and Charles Howard-Bury delivered a narrative of the 1921 expedition at a combined meeting of the Royal Geographical Society and Alpine Club.[276] In exchange for a quarter of the revenue earned, the Mount Everest Committee asked Mallory to lecture throughout Britain and contribute to the official expedition book, Mount Everest: The Reconnaissance, 1921.[278] On 10 January 1922, Mallory gave his first lecture in the Queen's Hall, afterward giving 30 more at various locations in Britain.[276][279] The financial results were lucrative, as his 25% share earned him £400, far exceeding his annual salary as a teacher.[281] Before departing for the 1922 British Mount Everest expedition, Mallory completed his written contribution to Mount Everest: The Reconnaissance, 1921.[276] The work, titled The Reconnaissance Of The Mountain, contained six chapters: The Northern Approach, The Northern Approach (continued), The Eastern Approach, The Assault, Weather And Conditions Of Snow and The Route To The Summit.[282] He then turned his attention to assisting the Committee and reviewing equipment for the 1922 expedition.[283]

1922 British Mount Everest expedition

[edit]
The Rongbuk Monastery, with Mount Everest in the background

Mallory returned to the Himalayas as a member of the 1922 British Everest expedition which was attempting to be the first to summit Everest.[284][285] On 2 March 1922, Mallory, Howard Somervell, John Noel, Edward Strutt, George Finch, and Arthur Wakefield,[286] crossed the English Channel, travelled by train to Marseille and, on 3 March, departed for Bombay on board the passenger liner Caledonia.[287][288][289] During the voyage, Mallory attended Finch's bottled oxygen class, which help him to overcome his uncertainty about its use.[290] After docking in Bombay, they arrived in Darjeeling on 20 March, where they met up with the rest of the expedition.[291][292] Members left in groups for the march to Phari.[293][294] Mallory's group departed under expedition leader General Charles Granville Bruce,[293] arriving in Phari on 6 April and joined the following day by the remainder of the expedition.[295] They arrived at the Rongbuk Monastery on 30 April.[296][297] On 1 May, the expedition pitched Base Camp at an altitude of 16,500 ft (5,029 m), 2.75 miles (4.43 km) below the junction of the Rongbuk Glacier and East Rongbuk Glacier.[298][299]

First summit attempt, Mallory, Somervell, Norton, and Morshead

[edit]

On 20 May, at 7:30 a.m., Mallory, Howard Somervell, Edward Norton, Henry Morshead, and four porters began their day at Camp IV, on the North Col at an elevation of 23,000 ft (7,010 m).[300][301] After roping up at 8:00 a.m., the team began their ascent without supplemental oxygen.[302][303] They planned to climb the North Ridge and establish Camp V at an altitude of 26,000 ft (7,925 m), and from there attempt to reach the summit.[304][305] At 11:30 a.m., they attained an elevation of 25,000 ft (7,620 m), a gain of 2,000 ft (610 m) from the North Col, in 3+12 hours, a vertical climbing rate of 571 ft (174 m) per hour, including stops.[306] Mallory estimated that from their present position, it would necessitate three hours to ascend 1,000 ft (305 m) and pitch Camp V. That would leave little time for the porters to return to Camp IV on the North Col before nightfall, and he was uncertain of finding a well-sheltered area from the strong winds on the lee-side of the North Ridge above them.[307][308] Mallory decided to abandon their initial plan and erected Camp V at their current altitude of 25,000 ft (7,620 m).[307][308] The four porters departed for the North Col camp at 3:00 p.m., and Mallory, Somervell, Norton, and Morshead spent the night at Camp V.[309][310]

Everest's North Face, with illustrations of the maximum elevations attained by the 1922 expeditions' first and second summit attempts[n 13][n 14]

The next day at 8:00 a.m., the four mountaineers roped up and began their attempt to reach the summit from Camp V.[315] But Morshead was suffering from frostbite and after a few steps declared he was unable to continue, and he stayed behind at Camp V.[307][316] Adverse weather conditions prevented the climbers from beginning their ascent at 6:00 a.m. as planned, leaving them behind schedule.[317] Other than possible mountaineering difficulties, their bid depended mainly on time and speed.[318] Mallory's calculations estimated their vertical ascent rate at an unsatisfactory 400 ft (122 m) per hour, not including stops, which meant they would be climbing after nightfall, a risk they did not want to take.[319] At 2:15 p.m., Mallory, Somervell, and Norton halted and lay against rocks on the North Ridge, where they remained for fifteen minutes and ate.[320] Their aneroid barometer read 26,800 ft (8,169 m), a height later rectified and confirmed by a theodolite as 26,980 ft (8,225 m), a new world altitude record.[321][1] They began their descent, and at 4:00 p.m. reached Camp V, where Morshead was waiting to join them for the return to Camp IV.[322][323] The four climbers roped up and began their descent to 23,000 ft (7,010 m).[323] As they descended, Morshead, who was third on the rope, slipped and dragged Somervell and Norton down a slope leading directly to the East Rongbuk Glacier, several thousand feet below.[322][324] Mallory, who was leading, forced the pick of his ice axe into the snow and hitched the rope around the axe's adze to stop the slide, saving the lives of the three mountaineers.[325][326] They reached Camp IV after nightfall, exhausted, hungry, frostbitten, and dehydrated.[327][328][329]

Second summit attempt, Finch and Bruce

[edit]
George Finch

On 27 May, George Finch, Geoffrey Bruce, and Tejbir Bura departed from Camp VI at 25,500 ft (7,772 m) on the North Ridge, for another attempt using supplemental oxygen.[330] They took Bura, who was carrying two spare oxygen cylinders, as far as the Northeast Shoulder at 27,400 ft (8,352 m), where he descended as planned.[331] Finch and Bruce loaded up the extra cylinders and dispensed with a climbing rope to advance faster.[332] When they reached 27,000 ft (8,230 m), they changed course and climbed towards a point on the Northeast Ridge, halfway between the Northeast Shoulder and the summit.[333] At midday their aneroid barometer registered an elevation of 27,300 ft (8,321 m), surpassing the previous attempt by 315 ft (96 m), a new world record.[1][334][335] But weakened by hunger and exhaustion, they were unable to continue, and returned to Camp VI.[336]

Third summit attempt, Mallory, Somervell, Crawford and the North Col avalanche

[edit]

At the beginning of June, the expedition arranged a third attempt.[337] The plan was to ascend to their old Camp V at 25,000 ft (7,620 m) without using supplemental oxygen and then, using a cylinder each, continue to an elevation of 26,000 ft (7,925 m) where they would establish the new Camp V. From there the team would use the supplemental oxygen to attempt to reach the summit.[338] On 7 June at 8:00 a.m., Mallory, Somervell, Colin Crawford, and 14 porters left Camp III at 21,000 ft (6,401 m) and crossed the head of the East Rongbuk Glacier. The team reached the base of the snow and ice wall on the North Col at 10:00 a.m.[339] and 15 minutes later Somervell, Mallory, Crawford, and one of the porters began the climb.[340] At 1:30 p.m. the group halted about 600 ft (183 m) below Camp IV to allow the other porters to join them.[341][342][343] At about 1:50 p.m., soon after the team continued the ascent, an avalanche began on an ice cliff above them and swept over the entire group.[344][341][345] Somervell, Mallory, Crawford and the porter managed to dig out from beneath the snow[346] and saw a group of four porters approximately 150 ft (46 m) below them[341][347] gesturing down the slope. The avalanche had swept the other 9 porters into a crevasse.[341][348] The remaining team members, later joined by expedition members John Noel and Arthur Wakefield, immediately began a search and rescue effort,[349][350] finding eight of the nine porters, but only two had survived.[349] A memorial cairn was erected at Camp III[351] in honour of the seven who perished: Lhakpa, Narbu, Pasang, Pema, Sange, Temba, and Antarge.[352][353] This ended the 1922 expedition and on 5 August, Mallory departed India and arrived in England in mid-August.[354][355]

Announcement of a third expedition, lectures and writing

[edit]

On 16 October 1922 at a combined meeting of the Royal Geographical Society and Alpine Club it was announced that the Tibetan government had formally authorised the third expedition to Everest.[356] The Everest Committee resolved that the third expedition would commence in spring 1924.[357] The committee was eager to generate money to cover some of the 1924 expedition's costs and discussed terms for a lecture programme.[358] A large-scale lecture tour was organised, with Mallory and George Finch selected as the two speakers.[359][360] On 20 October 1922, Mallory and Finch delivered their first public lectures on the 1922 expedition.[360][361] During the winter, Mallory presented a round of talks throughout Britain and Ireland, with engagements in Aberdeen, Brighton and Dublin,[362][363] receiving 30% of the proceeds.[363][364] In addition to authoring Everest and Himalaya-related articles for periodicals and encyclopaedias to supplement his income, the committee requested that Mallory contribute to the official book of the 1922 expedition, The Assault on Mount Everest: 1922.[365]

North America lecture tour and writing

[edit]
Broadhurst Theatre, New York

The Everest Committee arranged for Mallory to travel to North America on a three-month lecture tour.[366][367] Mallory and Ruth concurred he should strive for steady employment when he returned.[365] Mallory docked in New York on 17 January 1923.[366] After meeting lecture agent Keedick, Mallory was dismayed he had arranged only a meagre number of lectures, and had to wait 9 days to deliver his first speech.[368][367] He amended his lecture materials and wrote his finalised contribution to the 1922 expedition book, The Assault on Mount Everest: 1922.[368][369] His first contribution was titled The First Attempt, consisting of chapters: The Problem, The Highest Camp, and The Highest Point, and his second had chapters: The Third Attempt and Conclusions.[370] On 26 January, in Washington, D.C., Mallory delivered two lectures, which grossed $1000.[371][367] His next engagement was in Philadelphia, where he delivered two lectures for a combined audience of approximately 3000, grossing $1500.[372][373] After an evaluation by medical professionals at the NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital, they determined his lung capacity was twice that of the average person.[374][375] On 4 February, Mallory gave a lecture at the Broadhurst Theatre, New York, in front of an audience of 550, filling only half the seating capacity.[376][377] The next day, The New York Times ran a story under the headline, SAYS BRANDY AIDED MT EVEREST PARTY; A Swig 27,000 Feet Up 'Cheered Us All Up Wonderfully,' Mallory Tells Audience, which diverted its coverage of the tour into anti-prohibition propaganda.[378][379] A Toronto appointment resulted in a cancellation, and a Montreal appearance grossed a meagre $48.[377] In Boston, he delivered a lecture to the Appalachian Mountain Club, gave a speech in Cambridge, made a second visit to Philadelphia, where at the University Museum, he spoke to an audience of 1200, and delivered lectures in Toledo, Rochester, Iowa City, and Hanover, before a second engagement in Boston.[380][381] Under the headline, CLIMBING MOUNT EVEREST IS WORK FOR SUPERMEN, The New York Times of 18 March quoted Mallory as having replied to the question, "Why did you want to climb Mount Everest?" with the retort, "Because it's there."[382][383] The expression describes an existential desire to accomplish a physical and spiritual goal that mountaineers share.[381] Questions have arisen over the quote's authenticity and whether Mallory said it.[384][385] Some suggest it was an innovative paraphrase created by the reporter.[384][386] The tour was a financial failure; Mallory regretted that he, Ruth, and the children would have to live on less than he had anticipated, because he had no immediate prospects for permanent employment.[380] Mallory docked in Plymouth in early April.[387]

Cambridge lecturer and Olympic medal

[edit]
Mallory in the early 1920s

David Cranage, Secretary of the Board of Extra-Mural Studies at Cambridge University, and Arthur Robert Hinks of the Everest Committee travelled together on a train from London to Cambridge while Mallory was still in America, and discussed a vacancy that solved Mallory's situation.[388][389][390] Cranage advertised a vacancy for a history lecturer to educate in towns and villages outside of Cambridge and assist organising other courses.[391] They would conduct lectures in cooperation with the Workers' Educational Association, established to support working people who had missed the opportunity for education in favour of the privileged.[391] Cranage apprised Hinks about the job and questioned whether he knew possible candidates, Hinks suggested Mallory.[388] Hinks informed Mallory soon after he arrived back in England.[391] Mallory applied and following a successful interview was appointed on 18 May.[392] The occupation provided an annual income of £350, supplemented by lecture fees of £150 yearly.[391] He found a suitable residence for the family at Herschel House on Herschel Road, Cambridge.[393] Mallory immersed himself in his new employment with zeal, assisted organising the Golden Jubilee of Cambridge Local Lectures in July, and helped arrange summer schools during the Long Vacation.[394] In the fall of 1923, he commenced lectures in Hunstanton on the emergence of democracy in the 17th century; in Raunds, tutorial classes in modern history;[n 15] and conducted classes in Halstead.[395][394] On 18 October, Hinks wrote to Cranage, requesting Mallory obtain leave to participate in the 1924 expedition.[396] The Lecture Committee recommended six months' leave at half pay.[397][398][399]

SS California in 1925, entering New York Harbor

On 6 November, after a medical examination by a physician recommended by the Everest Committee, Mallory was declared "fit in every respect," eliminating the last potential obstacle between him and participation in the expedition.[399] On 5 February 1924, at the closing ceremony of the inaugural Winter Olympics in Chamonix, France, Pierre de Coubertin presented 13 gold medals, including for Mallory, for alpinism in recognition of the achievements of the 1922 Everest expedition members to Lt Col Edward Strutt, deputy expedition leader.[400][n 16]

1924 British Mount Everest expedition

[edit]
Andrew Irvine, Mallory's climbing partner

The expedition members included leader General Charles Bruce,[406] Edward Norton as second-in-command and mountaineering leader; mountaineers Andrew Irvine, Howard Somervell, Geoffrey Bruce, Bentley Beetham, and John de Vars Hazard; mountaineer and oxygen officer Noel Odell; photographer and cinematographer John Noel; naturalist and medical officer Richard Hingston; and transportation officer Edward Shebbeare.[407][408][406] On 29 February, Mallory and three other expedition members, Irvine, Beetham, and Hazard, departed from Liverpool on board SS California.[409][410] During the voyage to India, Mallory read Maurois's Ariel, studied Hindustani, and worked through the logistics of supplies and aspects of the organisation for the expedition.[410] Determined to remain physically healthy, he exercised regularly in the gymnasium, threw a medicine ball with Irvine and Beetham, and periodically ran ten laps around the deck.[411][412] In mid-March, California arrived at her destination, berthing in Bombay.[413] Mallory, Irvine, Beetham, and Hazard travelled to Darjeeling, where they rendezvoused with the other participants.[413][410] On 25 March, the entire expedition departed Darjeeling for the march to Everest Base Camp.[414] The trek of 350 miles (560 km) took them from Darjeeling to Kalimpong, Guatong, Jelep La, Yatung, Phari, Tang La, Donka La, Kampa Dzong, Tinki Dzong, Tinki La, Chiblung, Shekar Dzong, Chödzong, and Rongbuk, and they arrived at Base Camp on 29 April, at an altitude of 16,800 ft (5,120 m).[415][416] On 9 April, General Bruce had collapsed due to recurrent malaria and had ongoing cardiovascular issues during the trek to Base Camp.[417][418] Norton took charge, appointed Mallory as deputy and mountaineering leader, and Charles Bruce returned to India.[419][420]

Mallory and Bruce's attempt

[edit]

On 1 June, at 6:00 a.m., Mallory and Geoffrey Bruce, without supplemental oxygen, and eight porters commenced their ascent from Camp IV on the North Col at 23,000 ft (7,010 m).[421][422] They planned to climb the North Ridge and establish Camp V at approximately 25,500 ft (7,772 m), where they would sleep overnight; the following day, they would ascend to about 27,200 ft (8,291 m), where they would pitch Camp VI, sleep overnight, and on 3 June, attempt to reach the summit without oxygen.[423][424] The precise elevation for establishing Camps V and VI depended on the porters' abilities to carry heavy loads in the rarefied air and weather conditions.[424] As the two climbers and eight porters ascended the North Ridge with an average gradient of 45 degrees, they were exposed to a penetrating northwest wind.[425] At approximately 25,000 ft (7,620 m), four of the porters could not ascend any further after reaching the limits of their endurance.[425] Mallory, Bruce, and the four remaining porters progressed to an elevation of 25,200 ft (7,681 m), where they established Camp V.[421][426] Five porters descended to Camp IV, leaving three to shoulder loads the following day up to the location where the expedition intended to pitch Camp VI.[427] Mallory, Bruce, and the three porters slept at Camp V that night, and on the next day, only one porter was able to proceed, and two declared themselves sick and physically unable to carry loads.[427] Without enough porters to assist, the attempt was abandoned immediately, and the party returned to the North Col.[428][427]

On 2 June Somervell and Norton began a second attempt.[429] On 4 June Somervell and Norton left Camp VI and commenced their ascent to reach the summit. At midday, as they neared 28,000 ft (8,534 m), Somervell, who was suffering from an extremely sore throat and a severe cough, felt it impracticable to continue.[430][431] Somervell sat on a ledge while Norton proceeded solo.[432] At 1:00 p.m., suffering from temporary visual impairment due to oxygen deficiency,[n 17] exhausted from his efforts, and knowing that from his location and the current time, he stood no chance of reaching the summit and returning safely, Norton retreated from where he had attained a new world altitude record of 28,126.0 ft (8,572.8 m).[435][1] At 9:30 p.m., Somervell and Norton reached Camp IV.[436]

Mallory and Irvine's last climb

[edit]

Dear Odell,

"We're awfully sorry to have left things in such a mess—our Unna Cooker rolled down the slope at the last moment. Be sure of getting back to IV to-morrow in time to evacuate by dark, as I hope to. In the tent I must have left a compass—for the Lord's sake rescue it: we are here without. To here on 90 atmospheres for the 2 days—we'll probably go on 2 cylinders—but it's a bloody load for climbing. Perfect weather for the job!"

— Yours ever, G. Mallory.[437][438]

On 4 June at 2:10 p.m., Mallory and Irvine, using supplemental oxygen for the final half of their ascent, left Camp III at 21,000 ft (6,401 m) and reached Camp IV on the North Col at 23,000 ft (7,010 m) in 3 hours, at 5:10 p.m., including about 30 minutes at a dump choosing and testing oxygen cylinders.[439][440][441] That night, Mallory shared a tent with Norton, who had just returned from his summit attempt with Somervell, and told Norton that if his summit bid with Somervell had failed, he had planned to make one further attempt with supplemental oxygen.[442] Mallory returned to Camp III and with Bruce's assistance recruited enough porters for another attempt.[442] He chose Irvine as his climbing partner because of the initiative and mechanical expertise he exhibited with the oxygen apparatus.[443] On 6 June at 8:40 a.m., Mallory, Irvine, and eight porters set off from Camp IV in excellent weather for Camp V on the North Ridge at 25,200 ft (7,681 m).[444][445][446] Both mountaineers shouldered modified oxygen apparatus, each carrying two cylinders apiece, and their eight porters, not using oxygen, took provisions, bedding, and extra cylinders.[445][447] They progressed steadily and reached Camp V in good time. Shortly after 5:00 p.m., four of their porters arrived back at Camp IV with a note from the climbing party stating, "There is no wind here, and things look hopeful."[444][445] The two climbers and the four remaining porters spent the night at Camp V.[445] On 7 June, Mallory, Irvine, both using oxygen for part of their climb, and the four porters ascended to Camp VI at 26,700 ft (8,138 m) on the North Ridge.[444][445] That same day, expedition member Noel Odell and his porter Nema, in support of Mallory and Irvine, climbed to Camp V.[448][446] Soon after they reached Camp V, Mallory and Irvine's four remaining porters arrived from Camp VI, and gave Odell a note from Mallory.[437]

Odell's porter, Nema, was suffering from altitude sickness, so that evening Odell sent him back down, along with the other four porters, to Camp IV.[449][446] When they reached Camp IV, porter Lakpa Chedi Sherpa gave John Noel a second note from Mallory.[450] Noel's filming location was above Camp III, on the ledge of a buttress at 22,000 ft (6,706 m) on the Eastern Ridge of Changtse, which he called "Eagle's Nest Point."[451] From this vantage point, Noel had a clear view across the head of the East Rongbuk Glacier, the ice slope leading to the North Col, the Northeast Ridge, and the North Face.[451] Lakpa told him that Mallory and Irvine were in good health, had reached Camp VI, and the weather was fine.[450] Mallory's message reminded Noel of the locations and approximate time of where and when to look for them during their summit attempt as previously discussed and organised.[452] (Mallory erroneously wrote 8:0 p.m.; he meant a.m.[453])

Dear Noel,

"We'll probably start early tomorrow (8th) in order to have clear weather. It won't be too early to start looking for us either crossing the rock band under the pyramid or going up skyline at 8.0 p.m."

— Yours ever, G. Mallory.[454][438]

On 8 June at 8:00 a.m., after spending the night alone at Camp V, Odell, again supporting Mallory and Irvine, began his ascent to Camp VI and, on his way, intended to conduct a geological study.[455] (As Odell ascended to Camp VI he found the first fossils on Everest in a limestone band at approximately 25,500 ft (7,772 m).)[446] That same morning, Noel perched himself at "Eagle's Nest Point," where he directed the long lens of his motion picture camera towards the summit to film Mallory and Irvine.[456] He had two assistant porters peering through a telescope in turns but they saw nothing. 8:00 a.m. came and went without sighting the mountaineers and by 10:00 a.m. clouds and mist had enshrouded their view of the entire summit ridge.[453] When he reached an elevation of about 26,000 ft (7,925 m), Odell climbed a small crag and when he reached its top at 12:50 p.m., the air cleared to reveal the summit ridge and peak, where he saw Mallory and Irvine on a prominent rock step on the ridge.[457]

"At 12:50, just after I had emerged in a state of jubilation at finding the first definite fossils on Everest, there was a sudden clearing of the atmosphere, and the entire summit ridge and final peak of Everest were unveiled. My eyes became fixed on one tiny black spot, silhouetted on a small snow crest beneath a rock step in the ridge, and the black spot moved. Another black spot became apparent and moved up the snow to join the other on the crest. The first then approached the crest rock step and shortly emerged at the top. The second did likewise. Then the whole fascinating vision vanished, enveloped in cloud once more. There was but one explanation. It was Mallory and his companion, moving, as I could see even at that great distance, with considerable alacrity ... The place on the ridge mentioned is a prominent rock step at a very short distance from the base of the final pyramid."

— Noel Odell, support climber and last man to see Mallory and Irvine alive, 8 June 1924. This version of Odell's sighting appeared in the Aberdeen Press and Journal on 5 July 1924.[458]

The location of Odell's final sighting of Mallory and Irvine before they disappeared into the clouds was at the top of the Second Step, determined by expedition member John de Vars Hazard to be at an elevation of 28,230 ft (8,603.5 m).[459][460][n 18] At approximately 2:00 p.m., as Odell reached Camp VI at 26,700 ft (8,138 m), snow began to fall and the wind strengthened.[463] Inside Mallory and Irvine's tent, he found spare clothes, food scraps, sleeping bags, oxygen cylinders, and parts of the oxygen apparatus. Outside he found parts of the oxygen apparatus and the duralumin carriers.[463] They left no note stating when they had commenced their attempt or what might have transpired to create a delay.[464] Odell departed from Camp VI, ascended about 200 ft (60 m) in the direction of the summit in visibility of no more than a few yards, and whistled and yodelled in an attempt to direct Mallory and Irvine towards Camp VI in case they happened to be within hearing distance.[464] After no response, at approximately 4:00 p.m. he returned to Camp VI. The weather cleared and the entire North Face became bathed in sunlight. The upper crags became visible but there was no sign of Mallory or Irvine.[464] Odell left Mallory's compass, which he had retrieved from Camp V, inside the tent at Camp VI and at about 4:30 p.m. descended to Camp IV.[465]

On the morning of 9 June, Odell and Hazard searched Camps V and VI using binoculars but found no sign of either mountaineer.[466][467] Odell and two porters left Camp IV and reached Camp V at 3:30 p.m., where they spent the night.[468][469] The following morning, Odell sent his porters back to Camp IV, as they were unable to ascend to Camp VI.[470] In a strong wind Odell climbed alone to Camp VI, reaching it at about 11:00 a.m. It was apparent that Mallory and Irvine had not returned, as everything was as he had left it two days previously.[471][472] Odell discarded his oxygen apparatus and set off along the route the climbers would have taken, to search within the limited time available.[472] After two hours with no sign of Mallory or Irvine, he resigned himself to the fact that the likelihood of finding them among the extensive crags and slabs was remote, and an extensive search towards the final pyramid would require a larger party.[472] Odell returned to Camp VI and positioned two sleeping bags on a snow-patch in the shape of a "T" to indicate there was no trace of Mallory or Irvine.[473] At 2:10 p.m., Hazard, 3,700 ft (1,128 m) below at Camp IV, saw the T-shaped signal and knew what it meant as he and Odell had drawn up a code of signals.[474][475][476] At approximately 2:15 p.m., Hazard sent the signal for death--six blankets on the snow surface in the shape of a cross--to notify the watchers at Camp III.[474][475][477] After being informed about the situation, expedition leader Norton ordered the signal to "Abandon hope and come down".[478][478] After retrieving Mallory's compass and an oxygen apparatus, Odell descended to Camp IV.[479]

On 8 June, the same day that Mallory and Irvine were last seen alive, Mallory's wife Ruth and their children were on holiday in Bacton, Norfolk.[474] On 13 and 14 June, Howard Somervell and Bentley Beetham oversaw the carving and building of a memorial cairn at Base Camp in memory of those who perished in the 1921, 1922, and 1924 expeditions, with the inscription: In Memory Of Three Everest Expeditions; 1921, Kellas; 1922, Lhakpa, Narbu, Pasang, Pema, Sange, Temba, Antarge; 1924, Mallory, Irvine, Shamsher, Manbahadur.[480][352][481] In London on 19 June, Arthur Robert Hinks received a coded telegram that read, "Mallory Irvine Nove Remainder Alcedo," sent from expedition leader Edward Norton. "Nove" meant death and "Alcedo" meant unharmed, so the message was that Mallory and Irvine had died but the rest of the expedition had survived.[474] Later that day, Hinks sent a telegram to Ruth Mallory informing her of the tragedy and conveying the condolences of the Mount Everest Committee.[482]

Message from the King and memorial service at St Paul's Cathedral

[edit]
St Paul's Cathedral, London

On 24 June, a message sent from King George V to Younghusband of the Everest Committee appeared in The Times, in which the King conveyed "an expression of his sincere sympathy" to the families and committee concerning the deaths of the "two gallant explorers".[483] On 17 October, a solemn memorial service at St Paul's Cathedral, was held in honour of the two climbers, at which the Right Reverend Henry Paget, Bishop of Chester, from whose diocese both men had come, delivered the sermon.[484][485] The parents of both mountaineers, Ruth, relatives and close friends, members of the expeditions and Mount Everest Committee, the Alpine Club, Royal Geographical Society, and other explorers and scientists attended.[485] Additionally present were representatives of the royal family; Sir Sidney Greville represented the King; Lieutenant colonel Sir Piers Legh, the Prince of Wales; Lieutenant Colin Buist, the Duke of York.[486][485] Mallory's will was proven on 17 December; he bequeathed his estate of £1706 17s. 6d. (equivalent to £90,000 in 2025[487]) to his wife.[488]

Lost on Everest for 75 years

[edit]

Discovery of the ice axe (1933)

[edit]

On 30 May 1933, during the 1933 British Mount Everest expedition, Percy Wyn-Harris and Lawrence Wager began their summit attempt from Camp VI, at 27,490 ft (8,380.4 m), on the Yellow Band, below the Northeast Ridge.[489][490] At an elevation of 27,720 ft (8,450 m) after approximately one hour of climbing, Wyn-Harris, who was leading, found an ice axe located about 60 ft (18 m) below the crest of the Northeast Ridge and 751 ft (229 m) east of and below the First Step.[491][492] The axe was left where it had been found and, after returning from a failed summit attempt, Wyn-Harris retrieved the axe, apparently leaving his own in its place.[493][494][n 19]

Because of its location the axe was thought to be either Mallory or Irvine's.[496] During his descent with Edward Norton on 4 June 1924, Howard Somervell had dropped his ice axe in the Yellow Band near the Norton Couloir,[n 20] farther west from where Wyn-Harris had found the ice axe, and no mountaineers from the expeditions before 1933, other than Mallory and Irvine, had moved through the location where Wyn-Harris had discovered the axe.[497][498] When Wyn-Harris showed the axe to Noel Odell in 1934, Odell noticed three parallel horizontal nick marks on its shaft.[499][498] Odell thought it was a mark Irvine might have used on his equipment, and some members of Irvine's family seemed to remember seeing a similar marking.[499] Mallory's widow Ruth told Odell that "as far as she was aware" Mallory did not mark his equipment with triple marks or any other type of mark, and therefore believed the axe belonged to Irvine.[499] To Odell, Wyn-Harris suggested a porter may have cut the triple mark to identify individuals' property during the 1924 expedition, though this was not the practice of all of the 1924 porters.[499] Wyn-Harris told Odell that his porter Pugla cut the X mark, seen lower down on the shaft of the axe, during the return journey from the 1933 expedition.[499] Several 1933 expedition members thought the axe belonged to Mallory because it had a Swiss manufacturer, Willisch of Täsch, stamped on it, and Mallory had journeyed to the Alps shortly before the 1924 expedition, where he may have acquired it.[499] They were unaware, however, that this manufacturer had supplied all members of the 1924 expedition with light axes, and Mallory or Irvine might have used them during their summit attempts.[499] In 1962 Irvine's brother found a military swagger stick presumed to have belonged to Irvine, and on it were three horizontal identification nick marks resembling those on the axe discovered by Wyn-Harris in 1933, which seemed to suggest that the axe was Irvine's.[498][500]

In 1977 Walt Unsworth, author of Everest: The Ultimate Book of the Ultimate Mountain, examined the axe and observed four sets of marks on its shaft.[501] In addition to the three nicks seen by Odell and the cross mark cut by Pugla, he noted a single horizontal nick mark above the three observed by Odell and another three nick marks, though fainter in appearance, on the other side of the shaft opposite the cross mark.[501]

Frank Smythe's sighting (1936)

[edit]

"Since my search for the two Oxford fellows, I feel convinced that it marks the scene of an accident to Mallory and Irvine. There is something else... it's not to be written about, as the press would make an unpleasant sensation. I was scanning the face from the Base camp through a high-power telescope last year [1936] when I saw something queer in a gully below the scree shelf... it was a long way away and very small... but I've a six/six eyesight, and I do not believe it was a rock... when searching for the Oxford men on Mont Blanc, we looked down onto a boulder-strewn glacier and saw something which wasn't a rock either—it proved to be two bodies. The object was at precisely the point where Mallory and Irvine would have fallen had they rolled on over the scree slopes below the yellow band. I think it is highly probable that we shall find further evidence next year."

— Frank Smythe, in a letter to Edward Norton, 4 September 1937.[502][503]

In 1937 Frank Smythe wrote to Edward Norton in reply to Norton's praise for Smythe's book Camp Six, an account of the 1933 expedition.[503] In his letter he mentioned the discovery of the ice axe in 1933, which he felt certain marked the scene of an accident to Mallory and Irvine.[504][505] Smythe said that when scanning Everest's North Face with a high-powered telescope during the 1936 British Mount Everest expedition he had spotted an object which he believed was either Mallory or Irvine. At the time he decided not to publicize what he had seen to avoid press sensationalism.[506][505] Smythe's sighting remained unknown to the public until his son Tony Smythe revealed it in his 2013 book, My Father, Frank: Unresting Spirit of Everest.[507]

Tom Holzel's theory (1971)

[edit]

Everest historian Tom Holzel, co-author with Audrey Salkeld of The Mystery of Mallory and Irvine, first became interested in the two mountaineers after reading about them in a 1970 edition of The New Yorker.[508] Holzel's theory, published in a 1971 edition of Mountain magazine,[509] was that Mallory and Irvine split up soon after Odell had sighted them ascending the Second Step at 12:50 p.m. Each had only 1+12 hours of supplemental oxygen remaining, insufficient for both to reach the summit in two or three hours.[510] Mallory took Irvine's oxygen equipment, belayed him down the Second Step—from which point Irvine would descend towards Camp VI at 26,700 ft (8,138 m)—and with the additional oxygen attempted to reach the summit alone.[511] As Irvine descended, the "rather severe blizzard" described by Odell[512] as lasting from approximately 2 to 4 p.m.[513] covered the mountain with snow, causing him to slip and fall to his death.[511][514] Continuing on, Mallory could have reached the summit in the late afternoon.[514] Holzel theorised that from where the ice axe was found in 1933–presumably the scene of an accident—a body tumbling down the North Face would come to a halt on a snow terrace below at approximately 26,900 ft (8,200 m).[511]

In 1980 Holzel received a letter from Hiroyuki Suzuki, foreign secretary of the Japanese Alpine Club.[515] Suzuki's letter was in reply to Holzel, who had previously written to the Club about their upcoming 1979 Sino-Japanese Everest expedition, asking that they look for Irvine's body and camera on the snow terrace identified in his 1971 article.[516] Suzuki's letter contained tragic news.[517] On 12 October 1979, as their party attempted to reach the North Col, an avalanche swept three climbers to their deaths in a crevasse.[517][518][519] The day before the fatal incident, one of the three climbers, Wang Hongbao, had told expedition leader Ryoten Hasegawa that he had seen "two deads" (dead bodies) during the 1975 Chinese Mount Everest expedition.[517][520] One was close to a side moraine in the East Rongbuk Glacier below the 1975 expedition Camp III, and the other was on the Northeast Ridge route at an altitude of 26,570 ft (8,100 m).[517][520][521] Suzuki said that although Hongbao did not speak English he repeated the words "English, English" when describing the bodies to Hasegawa.[517][520] Suzuki thought that the first body was possibly Maurice Wilson, but could offer no identification for the second body. Hongbao said he had seen torn clothes on the second body and buried it under the snow.[517][520][n 21]

Mount Everest North Face Research Expedition (1986)

[edit]

On 25 August 1986 the Everest North Face Research Expedition, organized by Tom Holzel, arrived at the North Base Camp to try to determine what had happened to Mallory and Irvine.[525] Their primary objective was to ascend to the 27,000 ft (8,230 m) snow terrace where they hoped to locate the remains of the "dead" English that Hongbao claimed to have seen during the 1975 Chinese expedition.[526] In addition, they hoped that if the body or bodies were indeed Mallory or Irvine, the cameras they carried might have images that could help solve the mystery of whether or not they had reached the summit.[526] Their secondary objective was to search the area immediately above the Second Step where they hoped to find Mallory and Irvine's used oxygen cylinders, proving they had reached that elevation and thus possibly the summit.[526] They successfully established Camp V on the North Ridge at an elevation of 25,500 ft (7,772 m) but snowstorms and avalanches prevented them from reaching 27,500 ft (8,382 m) where they had planned to establish Camp VI and search for Mallory and Irvine.[527][528][529] Although that effort was unsuccessful they did find two oxygen cylinders from the 1922 expedition.[528]

Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition (1999)

[edit]
Vest Pocket Kodak

The 1999 Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition was undertaken to determine whether Mallory and/or Irvine had been the first to summit Everest. Objectives included locating Irvine’s body and retrieving his camera that might hold proof of any summit success.[530][531][532][533] It was organised by expedition leader Eric Simonson, advised by researcher Jochen Hemmleb, and included mountaineers Conrad Anker, cameraman Dave Hahn and others.[534]

After re-examining the historical record of Everest North Face expeditions, Jochen Hemmleb realized that, other than artefacts such as the ice axe found in 1933, the only seemingly solid information about Mallory and Irvine was Wang Hongbao's assertion that he had discovered an "English" body during a twenty-minute walk from Camp VI.[535] The initial challenge was to identify the location of Chinese Camp VI and use it as the centre point of a circular search zone with a twenty-minute walk radius.[536][537] From a photo of Camp VI, Hemmleb determined it was on an ill-defined rib of rock that bisected the snow terrace on the North Face.[536]

On the morning of 1 May 1999, Anker, Hahn, Norton, Politz, and Richards reached 26,900 ft (8,199 m) where they established Camp VI.[538] From there, they set out for the "ill-defined rib", traversing west over the North Face's precipitously angled terrain.[539][537] Anker searched on intuition and descended to the lower margin of the snow terrace, where it drops away approximately 7,000 ft (2,000 m) to the head of the central Rongbuk Glacier. While zig-zagging back up in the direction of Camp VI at 26,800 ft (8,156 m) he noticed a "patch of white" to his west. Upon investigation he found it was a body partially frozen into the scree with the remnants of a braided cotton climbing rope tied to its waist and tangled around the body.[540][541][542][543][544][545][546][547]

Since it was believed that Irvine had fallen from the place where the ice axe was found in 1933 the team expected the body to be his, but Politz said, "This is not him."[548][n 22] After finding garment labels reading "G. Mallory"[550] the expedition members realised that they had found, not Irvine as expected, but Mallory.[551][544] The team used ice axes and pocketknives to search the site for any artefacts, especially the Vest Pocket Kodak camera that Somervell had lent Mallory for his attempt.[552][553] If found, the camera might contain images that could help solve the mystery of whether or not the summit was reached for the first time in 1924, nearly 30 years before the first confirmed summit in 1953.[554] (Experts from Kodak said it might be possible to develop images from the film and have drawn up guidelines for any expedition that might discover the camera.[554][555][556]) Personal possessions including letters were found on Mallory's body[n 23] but the most sought-after object, the camera, was not found.[560] The mountaineers buried Mallory, covering his remains with rocks, and Politz read a Church of England committal ceremony provided by the Bishop of Bristol.[561][562]

North Face of Everest, altitudes of discoveries, the Three Steps, and its summit

Sir Edmund Hillary welcomed the discovery of Mallory's body and described it as "very appropriate" that Mallory might have summited decades earlier. "He was really the initial pioneer of the whole idea of climbing Mount Everest," Hillary said. Mallory's son John said, "To me the only way you achieve a summit is to come back alive; the job's half done if you don't get down again."[563]

Further expeditions

[edit]

The 2001 Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition retraced Mallory and Irvine’s route and attempted to find artefacts from the early attempts.[564][565][566] Jake Norton and Brent Okita discovered the remnants of the 1924 Camp VI at an altitude of 26,700 ft (8,138 m), from which Mallory and Irvine had departed on 8 June.[567][568] Norton found a wool mitten of unknown origin on the Northeast Ridge at an altitude of 27,690 ft (8,440 m) that may have belonged to Mallory or Irvine.[569] There were research initiatives in 2004, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2018, 2019 and the 2007 Altitude Everest expedition that retraced Mallory and Irvine's footsteps.[570][571][572]

Timeline

[edit]
  • 1893: Aged 7, climbed the roof of a church.
  • 1904: Aged 18, made his first significant climb by summiting Mont Blanc, the highest peak in Western Europe.
  • 1909: First ascent of the Southeast Ridge of Nesthorn (3,822 m).
  • 1911: First ascent of the Western Ridge of Herbétet (3,778 m) and third ascent of the Southeast Ridge (Frontier Ridge) of Mont Maudit (4,465 m).
  • 1912: Established a new route on the West Face of Dent Blanche, marking a first ascent of this face.
  • 1915–18: Officer in the First World War.
  • 1919: First ascent of a new route on the Aiguille des Grands Charmoz (3,445 m) and Aiguille du Midi (3,842 m), later named the "Rectified Mallory-Porter Route."
  • 1920: Summiting the Matterhorn (4,478 m) and Zinalrothorn (4,221 m).
  • 1921: First British reconnaissance expedition to Everest, helping to map out potential routes to the summit.
  • 1922: Second British expedition to Everest, where his team set a world altitude record of 27,300 feet (8,231 m)[1] using supplemental oxygen.
  • 1924: Disappeared near the summit along with Andrew "Sandy" Irvine, leading to one of the greatest mysteries in mountaineering.
  • 1924–1950s: Speculation about whether Mallory and Irvine reached the summit, adding to the mystery surrounding their disappearance.
  • 1953: Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay became the first climbers confirmed to have reached the summit of Everest, renewing interest in Mallory and Irvine.
  • 1975: A Chinese climber reported finding the body of an "old English dead" climber on the north face of Everest, likely either Mallory or Irvine.
  • 1986: Climbers Conrad Anker and David Roberts examined the route Mallory might have taken and considered the possibility of successful ascent.
  • 1999: Publication of Ghosts of Everest: The Search for Mallory & Irvine brought renewed attention to the mystery of Mallory and Irvine.
  • 1999: Mallory's mortal remains and personal effects were discovered, but whether he had reached the summit remains unknown.
  • 2007: Conrad Anker, who had helped discover Mallory's body, completed a replica climb of Everest using period gear similar to what Mallory would have used.
  • 2010: The film The Wildest Dream highlighted both his life and modern efforts to uncover the truth.
  • 2024: A National Geographic team found Irvine's partial remains on the Central Rongbuk Glacier at an altitude at least 7,000 feet lower than where Mallory's body was discovered.[573][574][575][576]

Theories

[edit]
Some members of the 1924 expedition: Mallory is highlighted beside Edward F. Norton to the right and Geoffrey Bruce far right, in the town of Shelkar. The local Dzongpen (governor) is second from right.

"Second Step"

[edit]

As Mallory and Irvine used the Northeast Ridge route, they would have had to free-climb the formidable Second Step.[577] Of the Three Steps on the upper Northeast Ridge, the Second and most prominent, rising approximately 100 ft (30 m) and consisting of precipitous, brittle rock at an extreme altitude of 28,250 ft (8,610 m), is the most demanding.[577] The final upper section of this step is its crux, a 16 ft (4.87 m) nearly vertical headwall slab to which the 1975 Chinese expedition affixed a 15 ft (4.6 m) aluminium ladder.[577][578][579] Although disputed, the first successful ascent of the Second Step occurred during the 1960 Chinese Mount Everest expedition, as all four mountaineers were breathing supplemental oxygen.[580] They used a technique called "short ladder" in which Chu Yin-hau stood on Liu Lianman's shoulders to climb to the top of the crux.[580] Chu Yin-hau then belayed himself to a rock at the top of the Step and brought others up on the rope.[581][580] It took 3 hours for 4 mountaineers to ascend the crux, and they used pitons, which neither Mallory nor Irvine had.[577][580]

In 1985, during full-monsoon conditions and without supplementary oxygen, Òscar Cadiach, climbing on lead, achieved the first successful free-climb of the Second Step, ascending the crux on belay with a sling tied to one of the rungs of the Chinese ladder. He graded the vertical crack, that forms the crux, at about 5.8.[186][582][583] In 2001, Theo Fritsche free-soloed the crux without supplementary oxygen, and assessed it as about 5.7.[584][585] In 2003, Nickolay Totmjanin free-climbed it without supplementary oxygen.[186][586] On the 2007 Altitude expedition, Anker and Leo Houlding successfully free-climbed the crux headwall, having first removed the ladder, both rating it about 5.9.[186][572][587] Although the crux has been free-climbed, questions remain, e.g. concerning oxygen.[186]

Western disturbance

[edit]

Research published in 2010 indicates an extreme storm may have contributed to the deaths of Mallory and Irvine.[588][589][590] Physicist George Moore discovered meteorological data from the 1924 expedition at the Royal Geographical Society's library in London.[588][589][590] The data consisted of daily barometric pressure and temperature measurements recorded at Base Camp at 16,500 ft (5,029 m).[591] Temperature measurements were also recorded at higher camps.[592] The data collected, together with an analysed sea-level pressure map hand-drawn by the India Meteorological Department, were used to show that Mallory and Irvine's summit attempt occurred when there was a drop in barometric pressure and temperature, which was likely the result of the passage of an upper-level trough.[591][593] This is known locally as a western disturbance.[591] The authors hypothesised that the passage of the disturbance possibly triggered an outbreak of convective activity that resulted in the blizzard, witnessed by observation, engulfing Everest during the attempt.[591] Odell described the morning of 8 June as "clear and not unduly cold",[594] with snowfall and increasing winds beginning at approximately 2:00 p.m.,[463] which he described as a "rather severe blizzard,"[512] lasting about two hours and possibly severe enough to force Mallory and Irvine to abandon their bid.[464][593] Records show a drop in barometric pressure at Base Camp of 18 millibars during the attempt.[593] A drop of a similar magnitude possibly occurred at higher altitudes on the Himalayan peak.[593] This decrease in barometric pressure likely induced aggravation of their hypoxic state.[595] Also, if they had run out of supplemental oxygen during the early afternoon, this would have exacerbated their hypoxic condition.[595] The cumulative effects of hypoxia, fatigue and bitter cold during a severe blizzard would have left Mallory and Irvine at their limits of endurance.[595] The authors believe there is persuasive evidence the severe weather they experienced may have been more extreme than previously thought.[595] This harsh weather and decreased barometric pressure may have contributed to their demise.[595]

Legacy

[edit]
Mallory Court at Magdalene College, Cambridge, his college
Memorial to George Mallory and Andrew Irvine in Chester Cathedral

At Winchester College there is a memorial to him in the cloister adjacent to the college chapel.[596] Mallory was honoured by having a court named after him at Magdalene College,[597] with an inscribed stone commemorating his death set above the doorway to one of the buildings.[598][599] To commemorate Mallory's position as Magdalene Boat Club Captain, the Friends of Magdalene Boat Club changed their name to the Mallory Club.[600] A plaque commemorates him in the South African Cloisters at Charterhouse.[601][602] A stained-glass triptych window at St Wilfrid's Church, Mobberley, Cheshire, portraying three figures from English mythology, Saint George, King Arthur and Sir Galahad, also has two panels with inscriptions commemorating Mallory.[8][603] In addition to his father, Herbert Leigh Mallory, the rector of Mobberley, Mallory's grandfather, George Leigh Mallory, was the parish's rector.[604] In the cloisters of Chester Cathedral, there is a memorial window commemorating Mallory and Irvine.[605] Two high peaks in California's Sierra Nevada, Mount Mallory and Mount Irvine, are named after them.[606][607]

Sir Trafford Leigh-Mallory

Two other members of Mallory's family died in the mountains. His brother, Air Chief Marshal Sir Trafford Leigh-Mallory, died when the Avro York carrying him crashed in the French Alps in 1944, killing all on board.[608][609][610] Mallory's daughter, Frances Clare, married physiologist Glenn Allan Millikan, who was killed in a climbing accident in 1947 at Buzzard's Roost in Fall Creek Falls State Park, Tennessee.[611][612][557]

Frances Mallory's sons, Richard and George Millikan, became respected climbers in the 1960s and 70s.[613] In July 1963, Richard Millikan and other members of the Harvard Mountaineering Club, made the first ascent of the central rib of the Wickersham Wall on the north face of Denali, reaching North Peak at 19,470 ft (5,934 m).[614] In 1995, together with six other climbers, George Millikan reached the summit of Everest via the North Col-North Ridge-Northeast Ridge route as part of an American Everest expedition and evoked a sense of "unfinished business" by leaving a photo of his grandparents on the summit.[615][557][616]

Mallory was filmed by expedition cameraman John Noel, who released his film of the 1924 expedition, The Epic of Everest.[617][618] Film director George Lowe used footage from The Epic of Everest in the 1953 documentary, The Conquest of Everest.[619] A documentary on the 2001 Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition, Found On Everest: Detectives on the Roof of the World, was produced by Riley Morton.[620][621] Brian Blessed played Mallory in Galahad of Everest, a 1991 re-creation of his last climb.[622] In Anthony Geffen's 2010 documentary about Mallory's life and final expedition, The Wildest Dream, Conrad Anker and Leo Houlding attempt to reconstruct the climb, dressed and equipped like Mallory and Irvine.[572][623]

Mallory and Irvine inspired Baku Yumemakura to author the 1998 novel The Summit of the Gods, which in turn inspired a manga series published from 2000–03, which was adapted into an anime-influenced animation film, Le Sommet des Dieux, in 2021. Everest, a proposed Hollywood version of the 1924 attempt, adapted from Jeffrey Archer's novel Paths of Glory, to be directed by Doug Liman, had Ewan McGregor slated to play Mallory.[624][625] As of 2022 it was not in production.[626]

In September 2009, a temporary exhibition detailing Mallory and Irvine's lives opened at the Salt Museum (now Weaver Hall Museum and Workhouse), Northwich.[627] The exhibition, "Above the Clouds – Mallory and Irvine and the Quest for Everest," featured items discovered on Mallory's body, as well as artefacts and photos from the 1924 expedition.[627][628]

Mallory was referenced by President John F. Kennedy in 1962, in his "We choose to go to the Moon" speech, regarded as one of the greatest speeches of the 20th century: "... the great British explorer George Mallory, who was to die on Mount Everest, was asked why did he want to climb it. He said, "Because it is there". Well, space is there, and we're going to climb it ..."[629]

See also

[edit]

Footnotes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
George Herbert Leigh Mallory (18 June 1886 – 8 or 9 June 1924) was a pioneering British mountaineer best known for his participation in the first three expeditions to Mount Everest organized by the Royal Geographical Society and the Alpine Club in the early 1920s, during which he reached altitudes previously unattained by Western climbers and famously declared his motivation for attempting the peak as "Because it's there."[1][2] Born in Mobberley, Cheshire, to the Reverend Herbert Leigh Mallory, a clergyman, Mallory grew up as the eldest of four siblings and developed an early passion for adventure and literature.[1] He studied history at Magdalene College, Cambridge, from 1905, where he formed connections with notable figures such as the poet Rupert Brooke and became involved in the intellectual circles of the Bloomsbury Group.[3] After graduating in 1908, he pursued a career as a schoolmaster, teaching history at Charterhouse School, where he was known for his charismatic teaching style and encouragement of outdoor pursuits among students.[2] Mallory's climbing career began in earnest in the Lake District and the Alps, where he earned a reputation as an exceptionally graceful and bold rock climber with a strong sense of balance, though he was sometimes criticized for impetuosity.[2] In 1914, he married Ruth Turner, and the couple had three children—Clare, Berry, and John—while maintaining a close bond sustained through extensive correspondence during his absences.[1] His mountaineering ambitions were interrupted by the First World War, in which he served as an officer in the Royal Garrison Artillery, participating in the Battle of the Somme and rising to the rank of captain despite sustaining injuries.[1] The 1921 British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition marked Mallory's entry into high-altitude exploration; as a member of the team led by Charles Howard-Bury, he helped map routes to the North Col and photograph the mountain's approaches, reaching about 23,000 feet (7,000 meters).[2] He returned in 1922 as part of the expedition led by Brigadier General Charles Bruce, pioneering the use of supplemental oxygen and climbing to approximately 27,000 feet (8,230 meters) on the North East Ridge, though the effort was marred by a tragic avalanche that killed seven Sherpa porters and left Mallory with lasting guilt.[2][1] Mallory's third and final Everest attempt came in 1924, co-led by Brigadier General Charles Bruce, with the goal of summiting the world's highest peak without modern equipment.[1] Paired with the young Andrew Irvine, Mallory made a bold push from the North Col on June 6, and the last confirmed sighting of them came from expedition mate Noel Odell on June 8, who reported seeing two figures near what is now known as Mallory's Step at around 28,200 feet (8,600 meters).[2] The pair vanished in a sudden storm, their fate unknown for 75 years until American climber Conrad Anker discovered Mallory's well-preserved body on May 1, 1999, at 26,760 feet (8,155 meters) on the North Face, suggesting a fatal fall during descent; no camera or conclusive evidence of a summit success was found, fueling ongoing debates about whether Mallory and Irvine achieved the first ascent decades before Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay in 1953. In October 2024, partial remains believed to be Irvine's were discovered lower on the mountain, intensifying searches for the missing camera and evidence of a summit success.[1][2][4] Beyond his Himalayan feats, Mallory's legacy endures as a symbol of exploratory spirit and human endurance, inspiring generations of climbers through his writings, such as letters revealing his inner conflicts between family devotion and the "wildest dream" of conquest.[3] His body remains interred on Everest, a testament to the perils of early 20th-century mountaineering.[1]

Early Life and Education

Childhood and Family Background

George Herbert Leigh Mallory was born on 18 June 1886 at the rectory in Mobberley, Cheshire, as the eldest son of Herbert Leigh Mallory (1856–1943), a clergyman who served as rector of the local parish, and his wife, Annie Beridge Jebb (1863–1945), the daughter of another clergyman from Walton, Derbyshire. The family resided in the rectory, where Herbert's clerical duties shaped a structured, religious household environment typical of late Victorian England. Mallory had an elder sister named Mary and a younger sister named Avie, along with a younger brother, Trafford Leigh-Mallory (1892–1944), who later rose to prominence as an RAF commander during World War II.[5] From an early age, Mallory exhibited an adventurous spirit, intellectual curiosity, and athleticism, traits that contemporaries later attributed to his graceful yet impetuous nature, earning him the nickname "Sir Galahad" among peers. His upbringing in the rural Cheshire countryside, combined with his father's ecclesiastical role, provided a formative backdrop that encouraged exploration and physical activity within the bounds of a disciplined family life. Mallory received his early education at Glengorse, a preparatory boarding school in Eastbourne, Sussex, from 1897 to 1900, where he transitioned from a local school in West Kirby. In 1900, he proceeded to Winchester College on a mathematics scholarship.

Winchester College and Early Interests

In 1900, at the age of fourteen, George Mallory entered Winchester College on a competitive mathematics scholarship, supported by his family's emphasis on education. He remained there until 1905, during which time he demonstrated strong academic aptitude, particularly excelling in classics and history. These subjects aligned with his emerging intellectual curiosity, fostering a foundation that would later influence his reflective writings on exploration and human endeavor.[5][6] Mallory's introduction to mountaineering occurred at Winchester through extracurricular activities and mentorship, igniting a passion that would define his life. His tutor, R. L. G. Irving, a member of the Alpine Club, recognized Mallory's innate athleticism—evident in his gymnastics and unorthodox scaling of school buildings—and recruited him for a three-week school trip to the Alps in 1904. There, Mallory attempted peaks such as Mont Vélan, though altitude sickness forced a retreat short of the summit; this experience, combined with Irving's guidance, marked his formal entry into climbing. Complementing these trips, Mallory developed early interests through reading mountaineering literature and initial scrambles in the Lake District during family outings, where he honed basic rock-climbing skills on crags like those around Scafell. He also co-founded the Winchester Ice Club with Irving and fellow students, promoting alpine techniques among peers.[6][5] Among Mallory's influential connections at Winchester was his school-friend Guy Henry Bullock, a fellow classicist who shared his adventurous spirit and later joined him on the 1921 Everest reconnaissance. Irving's mentorship proved pivotal, shaping Mallory's climbing philosophy and encouraging bold, intuitive ascents. These relationships, alongside his academic pursuits, culminated in Mallory's decision to continue his studies in history at Magdalene College, Cambridge, where he arrived in 1905 with a second-class degree in mind but a growing commitment to mountaineering.[5]

Cambridge University Years

In 1905, George Mallory enrolled at Magdalene College, Cambridge, to study history, joining a small and intimate institution with around 50 undergraduates.[7] He pursued the History Tripos, achieving a third-class honors in Part I during his second year before improving to a second-class honors in Part II upon graduation in 1909; during his final year, he also composed a Member’s Prize Essay on the biographer James Boswell, which he later expanded into the published work Boswell the Biographer (1912).[7][8] Mallory's undergraduate years were marked by vibrant social and intellectual engagements that shaped his worldview and personal connections. He joined the Cambridge University Fabian Society, a socialist discussion group that fostered his progressive ideals, and served as college secretary for the University Women's Suffrage Association, reflecting his support for social reform; these involvements often included lively debates on politics and society.[7] Additionally, he participated in theater through the Marlowe Dramatic Society, where he performed in plays that honed his dramatic flair and charisma.[8] Mallory captained the Magdalene Boat Club in 1907–1908, leading the college eight in rowing competitions, and developed a keen interest in literature, poetry, and art, which he pursued alongside his studies.[7] He formed enduring friendships with prominent contemporaries, including the poet Rupert Brooke, economist John Maynard Keynes, and physicist Charles Galton Darwin, grandson of the naturalist Charles Darwin, as well as his history tutor Arthur Benson, whose intellectual guidance profoundly influenced him.[7][5] Mallory's initial forays into mountaineering began during university vacations, with climbs in the Lake District and north Wales that revealed his natural aptitude for the activity.[8] In 1909, shortly after meeting the experienced mountaineer Geoffrey Winthrop Young at a Cambridge dinner, he joined him for a transformative Easter climbing trip to Pen-y-Pass in Snowdonia, where they pioneered new routes on Craig yr Ysfa.[7] That summer, Mallory accompanied Young to the Alps for his first major expedition there, tackling challenging peaks such as the Finsteraarhorn and Nesthorn in Switzerland, experiences that highlighted his graceful technique but also his tendency for bold risks.[7][9] Following graduation, Mallory remained in Cambridge for a year to refine his Boswell essay, while contemplating his future career.[8] In 1909–1910, he spent five months in Roquebrune, in the French Alpes-Maritimes, ostensibly to improve his French language skills, during which time he continued climbing in the region and further immersed himself in European culture.[8] These travels, combined with his Alpine successes, cemented Mallory's passion for mountaineering, transitioning it from a youthful pursuit to a defining element of his identity.[7] In April 2024, Magdalene College digitized over 200 of Mallory's letters from his undergraduate years, offering detailed glimpses into his social and intellectual activities.[10]

Teaching Career

Charterhouse School Appointment

In 1910, following his graduation from Magdalene College, Cambridge, where he had studied history, George Mallory was appointed as an assistant master at Charterhouse School in Godalming, Surrey, taking up the role in the autumn of that year.[8][11] He served primarily as a history master, teaching boys aged 13 to 18, including those preparing for Oxford scholarships.[11][8] His responsibilities also extended to instruction in English and French.[8] Mallory's daily routines at Charterhouse encompassed classroom instruction in history, dormitory supervision as part of the house master system, and extracurricular involvement in coaching sports such as cricket and football.[5][11] These duties reflected the demanding structure of a British public school, where masters oversaw both academic and residential life for boarding students.[5] Early in his tenure, Mallory faced challenges adapting to the rigid traditions of the public school environment, where his attempts at a more friendly and approachable style with students often met resistance.[5] He also struggled to balance these professional obligations with his personal passion for mountaineering, frequently arranging climbing trips during school holidays that tested his commitment to the role.[11] These tensions contributed to emotional difficulties, as noted in his correspondence from the period.[11] Despite these hurdles, Mallory quickly earned a reputation as an inspiring and unconventional educator at Charterhouse, particularly among pupils like the poet Robert Graves, whom he encouraged in literature and introduced to mountaineering; Graves later described him as the best teacher he ever had.[8][12][5] His charismatic presence and progressive outlook made him a memorable figure, fostering personal growth in select students even as his methods occasionally alienated others.[12][5]

Educational Philosophy and Influence

Mallory's educational philosophy centered on experiential learning, where he integrated the study of history with outdoor activities and lively discussions to foster deeper understanding and personal growth among students. At Charterhouse School, where he began teaching in 1910, he rejected rigid, authoritarian approaches in favor of mutual respect, trust, and self-exploration, encouraging pupils to pursue individual interests rather than conform to standardized curricula.[6] This method often involved taking students on climbing excursions that blended physical challenge with historical reflection, drawing from his own early experiences in the Alps to illustrate themes of exploration and human endeavor.[6] His approach frequently clashed with the traditional public school emphasis on brutal discipline, compulsory sports, and exam-focused rote learning, positioning Mallory as an advocate for progressive education that prioritized initiative, broad cultural exposure, and collaboration between teachers and parents. By 1919, after his wartime service, he had drafted a prospectus for a new school embodying these ideals, proposing a curriculum free of mandatory games and centered on pupil-driven inquiry.[12] Mallory's innovative style profoundly influenced notable students, including poet Robert Graves, who credited him as his best teacher and first true friend for inspiring imagination beyond formal subjects.[8][12] From 1910 until the outbreak of World War I in 1914, Mallory progressed in his role at Charterhouse, teaching English, history, and French while refining his methods through essays on topics like candor and hypocrisy to provoke critical thinking. During this period, he published Boswell the Biographer (1912), an analytical work on historical biography that reflected his scholarly engagement with history, though not explicitly focused on pedagogical techniques.[8][13] His emphasis on individuality and experiential approaches left a lasting legacy in educational circles, influencing debates on student-centered learning in early 20th-century Britain.[6]

Early Mountaineering

Alpine Expeditions

Mallory's introduction to the European Alps began in earnest during the summer of 1909, when he joined the experienced mountaineer Geoffrey Winthrop Young and Donald Robertson for climbs in the Bernese Oberland. Together, they ascended the south ridge of the Unterbächhorn and the southeast ridge of the Nesthorn, routes that demanded precise rock work and glacier navigation, marking Mallory's rapid adaptation to high-altitude environments.[14] His technical prowess earned him election to the British Alpine Club in December 1910, proposed by R. L. G. Irving and Geoffrey Winthrop Young, recognizing his emerging status among Britain's top climbers.[15] The following summer of 1911 saw Mallory undertake a demanding tour in the Graian Alps and Mont Blanc massif with H. E. G. Tyndale. Their achievements included a difficult new route on the Herbetet, the north ridge of the Grivola via the Col des Clochettes—requiring crampon use on steep ice and loose rock—and the eastern buttress of Mont Maudit leading to the summit of Mont Blanc. These expeditions, spanning glacier crossings, ice axes for steep ascents, and coordinated rope techniques on exposed ridges, solidified Mallory's expertise in ice climbing, rope management, and sustained high-altitude endurance.[16][14] By 1913, Mallory had established himself as an elite mountaineer within the British Alpine Club, contributing to its legacy through bold ascents in the Chamonix region, including challenging faces that further refined his graceful, intuitive style on mixed terrain.[14] Complementary practice on British rock faces, such as those in Snowdonia, helped maintain his edge between Alpine seasons. These pre-war experiences not only built Mallory's physical capabilities but also his philosophical appreciation for the mountains as a profound personal challenge.

Climbs in Britain

Mallory's early mountaineering experiences in Britain served as crucial training grounds, where he honed his technical skills on challenging rock and ridge terrain while balancing his responsibilities as a teacher at Charterhouse School. Beginning in the Welsh mountains of Snowdonia, he completed his first two significant British rock climbs on Tryfan in 1909, navigating its exposed east face and north ridge, which demanded precise footwork and rope management on weathered granite.[17] He returned to the region frequently, undertaking routes in the Glyderau range, such as ascents of Glyder Fawr and Y Garn, often leading groups of Charterhouse students to foster their appreciation for the outdoors and build teamwork under variable weather conditions.[18] These outings integrated climbing with his educational duties, as he revived the school's mountaineering club after World War I, using Snowdonia's compact but demanding crags to teach navigation, belaying, and resilience.[1] In the Scottish Highlands, Mallory tackled the jagged gabbro ridges of the Cuillin on the Isle of Skye, where he participated in traverses and first ascents during trips in the late 1910s. In 1918, alongside climbers Leslie Shadbolt and David Pye, he pioneered new lines on the Black Cuillin's steep faces, including routes on Bidean an Eoin Deirg and the Inaccessible Pinnacle, emphasizing bold exposure and sustained scrambling that tested endurance over multi-pitch terrain.[19] These Scottish expeditions, with their unpredictable midges and sudden storms, sharpened his ability to manage group dynamics and route-finding in remote, technical landscapes, skills he later applied to larger teams. Shorter trips to England's Lake District provided opportunities for focused rock practice, particularly on Scafell's crags and Borrowdale's slate walls. A highlight came in 1913, when Mallory achieved the first ascent of Pillar Rock via what became known as Mallory's Route, a committing 5.9 (Hard Very Severe) line involving overhanging cracks and delicate traverses on the fell's imposing west face.[20] These ascents, often solo or with minimal partners, allowed quick escapes from teaching commitments and contributed to his reputation for elegant, fluid movement on British rock. Through these British climbs, Mallory developed essential leadership qualities, such as inspiring confidence in novices and adapting to Britain's fickle climate, which contrasted with the more predictable high-altitude challenges of the Alps but prepared him for expedition command.[1] He briefly referenced applying Alpine techniques, like ice-axe arrest and crevasse rescue, to mitigate risks on snow-swept ridges in Wales and Scotland.

Personal Life and World War I

Marriage and Family

George Mallory met Ruth Turner, the daughter of architect Hugh Thackeray Turner, in early 1914, and their courtship quickly blossomed into an engagement by May of that year. They married on 29 July 1914 in Godalming, Surrey, just weeks before the outbreak of World War I. The couple spent their honeymoon in Porlock, Somerset, enjoying a brief period of seclusion before the war disrupted their plans.[21] The Mallorys had three children: their first, daughter Frances Clare (known as Clare), born on 19 September 1915; second daughter Beridge Ruth (known as Berry), born on 16 September 1917; and son John Leigh, born on 21 August 1920. The family resided at The Holt, a house near Godalming in Surrey, provided by Ruth's father along with an annual income of £750 to support their lifestyle. This financial assistance from Turner was crucial, as Mallory's salary as a teacher at Charterhouse School was modest, and the costs associated with his mountaineering pursuits, including equipment and travel for Alpine expeditions, often strained their household budget.[21][22] Their marriage was marked by a deep affectionate and intellectual partnership, evident in the extensive correspondence they maintained throughout their lives, preserved in the Mallory archive at Magdalene College, Cambridge. These letters reveal Mallory's tender expressions of love and shared philosophical discussions, portraying Ruth as a supportive confidante who engaged with his ideas on education, literature, and adventure. The outbreak of war briefly separated them, with Mallory's service imposing emotional and practical challenges on family life, though their bond endured through ongoing written exchanges.[10]

Military Service and Injuries

In December 1915, George Mallory was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Royal Garrison Artillery after training at the Royal Military Academy, Woolwich.[23] He deployed to the Western Front on 4 May 1916 with the 40th Siege Battery in the northern sector, where he participated in the Somme offensive that summer and served near Ypres amid intense artillery exchanges.[5][23] Mallory was promoted to lieutenant later in 1916 and took on the role of forward observation officer, involving perilous trips into no-man's-land for artillery spotting and gun registration to direct fire on enemy positions.[5] His experiences in trench warfare exposed him to the grim realities of the front, including desolate landscapes marked by small white crosses and unburied corpses, as he described in letters home expressing guilt over the potential for friendly fire casualties.[5] By 1917, he had advanced to acting captain and battery commander, overseeing operations in the ongoing attritional battles.[23] In May 1917, Mallory suffered an ankle injury that severely impaired his mobility, necessitating his return to England for surgery; the wound caused a lifelong limp and chronic pain.[5][23] He rejoined the front briefly in September 1918 with the 515th Siege Battery near Arras before demobilization in January 1919.[5] Throughout his service, Mallory, a committed pacifist shocked by the war's outbreak, conveyed its profound futility in correspondence with his wife Ruth, writing on 14 July 1916, "Shall we find suddenly one day that the war is over?"—a sentiment underscoring his hope for an abrupt end amid the endless stalemate.[5] His family provided vital emotional support during his absences, as evidenced by their exchanged letters sustaining him through the ordeal.[5]

Path to Everest

Growing Interest in High-Altitude Climbing

Following his service in World War I, during which he sustained an ankle injury requiring surgery in 1917,[23] George Mallory sought renewal through mountaineering as a counterpoint to the war's devastation, viewing it as an essential adventure that offered both escape and profound challenge. His wartime experiences intensified this draw, as he later reflected on expeditions involving "tremendous efforts and exhaustion and dismal looking out of a tent door on to a dismal world of snow and vanishing hopes—and yet, and yet, and yet there have been a good many things to see the other side," highlighting the mountains' irresistible balance of hardship and revelation.[6] Drawing inspiration from his pre-war Alpine successes, such as ascents of Mont Blanc and other peaks that had ignited his passion for high-altitude endeavors, Mallory returned to the mountains in 1919 after a seven-year hiatus imposed by the war.[24] That summer, he joined companions for a climbing trip in the Mont Blanc region, starting from Chamonix, where he tackled routes like the Requin, Col du Geant, and Charmoz, reaching the summit of the latter after overcoming loose rock and prolonged exposure.[24] These efforts served to rebuild his physical fitness and rekindle his technical skills, as he noted the "fresh vision" of snow-covered peaks evoking a child's wonder, while emphasizing his affinity for snow's "radiant forms" as quoted from Shelley.[24] Mallory's growing fascination extended to the Himalayas through reading accounts of earlier explorations and correspondence with Arthur Hinks, secretary of the Royal Geographical Society, who was organizing reconnaissance for Mount Everest.[25] In letters around 1920–1921, Mallory discussed the logistical and physiological demands of Himalayan climbing, expressing enthusiasm for the ultimate challenge while voicing concerns about team endurance for such extreme altitudes.[25] This exchange aligned with his philosophical musings on the "lure" of mountains, articulated in personal writings as a compulsion to confront the unknown for its intrinsic joy and test of human limits, famously encapsulated in his response to why climb Everest: "Because it's there." In these reflections, Mallory portrayed high-altitude pursuits not merely as physical feats but as existential escapes that restored harmony amid life's chaos, prioritizing the rhythmic variety of ascent—effort, exhilaration, and mystery—over mere conquest.[24] His 1919 Alpine traverse of Mont Blanc further embodied this, where he found the peak's grandeur to symbolize an enduring call to adventure, bridging his post-war recovery with ambitions for uncharted heights.[24]

Recruitment for British Expeditions

In 1920, the joint committee of the Royal Geographical Society and the Alpine Club selected George Mallory, then 34 years old, as one of the key climbers for the 1921 reconnaissance expedition to Mount Everest, recognizing his pre-war Alpine expertise and physical prowess.[25] Mallory accepted the invitation despite initial reservations, particularly as a married father of three young children; in a March 1921 letter to expedition organizer Arthur Hinks, secretary of the Royal Geographical Society, he noted, “I’m a married man and I can’t go into it bald-headed,” reflecting concerns about the risks to his family life.[25] His wife, Ruth, also expressed opposition to his participation when the proposal first arose, viewing the journey through Tibet as excessively perilous for a family man.[26] To prepare for the high-altitude challenges, Mallory drew on his extensive pre-1914 Alpine experience, including climbs with fellow expedition member Guy Bullock, which served as informal training for the Himalayan environment.[25] Although no formal high-altitude simulations occurred immediately before departure, his selection emphasized proven endurance from European peaks, with the committee allocating £50 (potentially up to £100) per climber for personal gear procurement, including woolen clothing, ice axes, and crampons—equipment climbers largely sourced themselves in a relatively ad hoc manner.[25] Following the 1921 reconnaissance, Mallory contributed to fundraising for subsequent expeditions through public lectures and writings, leveraging his growing reputation to secure support from the Royal Geographical Society and Alpine Club.[25] During a 1923 U.S. lecture tour to raise funds for the 1924 effort, he famously articulated his motivation for attempting Everest when asked by a New York Times reporter, replying, “Because it’s there.”[27] This quip, published in the Times on March 18, 1923, encapsulated the philosophical drive behind the British endeavors.[27] Team dynamics during recruitment highlighted tensions; Mallory clashed with Hinks over the expedition's composition, criticizing leader Charles Howard-Bury as overly aristocratic (“the landlord”) and questioning the capabilities of other members like Harold Raeburn, whom he deemed incompetent for high-altitude work.[25] Despite these frictions, his role solidified as the lead climber, emphasizing the need for “men who can last” in the final pushes.[25]

Everest Reconnaissance and 1922 Expedition

1921 British Mount Everest Expedition

The 1921 British Mount Everest Reconnaissance Expedition marked the first organized Western effort to approach and assess routes to the summit of Mount Everest, with the primary goals of mapping potential ascent paths, conducting scientific surveys, and evaluating human physiological limits at extreme altitudes. Led by Lieutenant-Colonel Charles Howard-Bury, the team included key climbers George Mallory, Guy Bullock, and surveyor-photographer Major Edward Oliver Wheeler, among others such as surveyor Major Henry Morshead, geologist Dr. Arthur Heron, and naturalist Dr. Alexander Wollaston. The expedition departed from Darjeeling, India, in late May 1921, crossing into Tibet via Sikkim and arriving in the Tingri region by mid-June, after navigating challenging monsoon conditions and logistical hurdles with mule transport.[28][29] Mallory, a seasoned British mountaineer with no prior Himalayan experience, played a central role in the climbing efforts alongside Bullock, focusing on exploratory ascents to scout viable routes while Wheeler concentrated on photographic mapping. The team conducted the first Western exploration of Everest's approaches, systematically mapping the North Face and surrounding terrain, including over 600 square miles at scales of 1:253,440 and more detailed 1:100,000 surveys, which filled significant blanks in Tibetan cartography. They identified the North Col (Chang La) via the Rongbuk Glacier as a promising access point to the North-East Ridge, reaching altitudes of approximately 23,000 feet during climbs in late September 1921, though no summit attempt was made due to the reconnaissance nature of the mission. A major discovery was the East Rongbuk Glacier, spotted by Wheeler in August 1921, which offered a potential eastern approach to the North Col and influenced future expeditions.[28][29] The expedition faced severe challenges, including widespread altitude sickness that caused headaches, fatigue, and sleeplessness above 19,000 feet, affecting both team members and local porters, with some climbers like Harold Raeburn forced to withdraw early. Political tensions arose from Tibetan authorities' initial reluctance to grant passage, resolved only through diplomatic intervention by British representative Charles Bell, though local wariness persisted due to historical grievances and restrictions on foreign activities like shooting for scientific collections. Monsoon weather, with heavy rains and gales, further complicated movements through the Rongbuk and Kharta Valleys, delaying progress and exacerbating health issues, ultimately leading to the team's return to Darjeeling by mid-October 1921. Despite these obstacles, the expedition provided essential data on routes and logistics, paving the way for subsequent assaults on Everest.[28][29][29]

Preparation and 1922 Summit Attempts

Following the 1921 reconnaissance expedition, George Mallory returned to the United Kingdom in October 1921, where he contributed six chapters to the official account, Mount Everest: The Reconnaissance, co-authored with Charles Howard-Bury and published in 1922, detailing the exploration of potential routes to the mountain's summit.[30] This work synthesized the team's findings, including the identification of the North Col as a viable approach, which informed subsequent planning efforts.[31] Mallory also delivered lectures to audiences, such as at the Royal Geographical Society, sharing insights from the journey and heightening public interest in Everest. The 1922 British Mount Everest Expedition was organized by the Mount Everest Committee during the winter of 1921–1922, assembling a larger team of 17 members compared to the prior reconnaissance, including experienced climbers like Mallory, Edward Felix Norton, Thomas Howard Somervell, and George Ingle Finch, under the leadership of Brigadier-General Charles Granville Bruce.[32] Supplies, including food rations, climbing gear, and scientific instruments, were packed in England and shipped to India, with the full party convening in Darjeeling by late March 1922 to recruit approximately 150 porters for the trek across Tibet.[32] A key innovation was the inclusion of supplemental oxygen apparatus, developed by Oxford University researchers and weighing about 30 pounds per set, intended to aid high-altitude performance despite logistical challenges in transport and maintenance.[33] Mallory expressed skepticism toward the oxygen equipment, advocating instead for extended acclimatization to reach extreme heights without it, arguing that the physiological benefits at altitudes above 27,000 feet were marginal given the apparatus's bulk and unreliability.[33] He believed climbers could ascend to around 28,000 feet unaided through gradual adaptation, reserving oxygen for the final summit push if needed, a view shaped by his 1921 experiences on the North Col route.[32] Despite his reservations, the team tested the devices during training at lower elevations, such as Phari Dzong, to assess their impact on fatigue and breathing.[34] The expedition departed Darjeeling on March 29, 1922, establishing Base Camp in the East Rongbuk Glacier by early May, with Mallory playing a central role in logistics, overseeing the stocking of intermediate camps and porter assignments to ferry loads up to 23,000 feet on the North Col.[32] Multiple summit attempts followed, beginning with a party led by Norton and Somervell on May 20, who, without oxygen and supported by porters, reached approximately 27,000 feet before turning back due to exhaustion and deteriorating weather.[34] Mallory participated in this push, helping establish Camp IV at 25,000 feet and managing high-camp supplies, though he retreated earlier due to illness.[32] A subsequent attempt by Finch and Geoffrey Bruce utilized oxygen, achieving a height of 27,300 feet on May 27— the highest point reached to date—demonstrating the apparatus's potential to accelerate progress and mitigate cold, though they halted short of the summit owing to hunger, wind, and equipment issues.[34] Mallory supported these efforts from lower camps, coordinating oxygen cylinder distribution and porter relays, while emphasizing the need for robust high-altitude infrastructure based on the 1921 route reconnaissance.[32] These climbs established new altitude records and validated aspects of the North Col approach, setting the stage for further assaults despite the expedition's ultimate failure to summit.[32]

North Col Avalanche and Aftermath

During the third and final summit attempt of the 1922 British Mount Everest Expedition, George Mallory, Howard Somervell, and Henry T. Morshead set out from Camp III at approximately 21,000 feet on June 7, accompanied by 14 Sherpa porters carrying oxygen equipment and supplies for a push toward the North Col, a 7,000-foot ascent from the East Rongbuk Glacier that marked a critical gateway to higher altitudes.[32] The party roped together in groups of four and five navigated a steep, snow-covered slope below the Col, which prior reconnaissance had deemed feasible despite recent heavy snowfall from the early monsoon.[32] At around 1:30 p.m., roughly 600 feet below the intended Camp IV site on the North Col at 23,000 feet, the group triggered an avalanche when the powdery snow, softened by south winds and laden with the party's weight, suddenly cracked with an explosive sound and swept them downward over a 40-to-60-foot ice cliff.[32][35] The avalanche claimed the lives of seven Sherpa porters—Lhakpa, Norbu, Pasang, Pema, Sange, Temba, and Dorge—marking the first recorded fatalities on Mount Everest and highlighting the perilous scale of Himalayan climbing compared to Alpine efforts.[35][32] Mallory, Somervell, and Morshead survived with minor injuries by instinctively adopting a swimming motion during the slide and arresting their fall using the rope, while two porters emerged unharmed and another sustained serious but recoverable injuries.[35][32] Mallory took immediate leadership in the rescue, directing the survivors to dig out the buried men and recover bodies where possible, though most fatalities resulted from the initial fall rather than suffocation; the group then built a memorial cairn at Camp III before descending.[32] The emotional toll on Mallory was profound, as he later confided in a letter to his wife Ruth, expressing deep sadness and personal responsibility: "My mind does go back very often to the terrible consequences of our attempt with great sadness" and "through my fault seven of them have been killed."[35] This guilt stemmed from his misjudgment of the snow's stability on what appeared a gentle slope, prompting a reevaluation of the unmeasurable risks in high-altitude pursuits: "Perhaps with the habit of dealing with certain kinds of danger one becomes accustomed to measuring some that are best left unmeasured."[35] The expedition leader, General Charles Bruce, echoed this in the official account, noting the porters' quiet mourning and fatalistic acceptance, while analyzing the avalanche as a confluence of monsoon-induced powder snow and the party's collective movement destabilizing the surface.[32] In the immediate aftermath, the survivors abandoned the 1922 summit efforts, evacuating higher camps amid worsening weather and salvaging equipment before retreating to Base Camp via the Kharta Valley by June 8.[32] This tragedy not only ended the season but underscored the human cost of the expedition's ambitions, with the loss of experienced Sherpas complicating future logistics and forcing a somber return to Britain for reflection and planning.[32]

1924 Everest Expedition

Team Assembly and Journey

The 1924 British Mount Everest Expedition was led by Lieutenant Colonel Edward Felix Norton, who assumed command after the original leader, Brigadier General Charles Bruce, fell ill shortly after arrival in India. George Mallory, a veteran of the 1921 reconnaissance and 1922 expeditions, served as the chief climber, leveraging his prior high-altitude experience to guide summit strategies. Andrew "Sandy" Irvine, a 22-year-old Oxford engineering student with strong endurance from rowing and a brief Spitzbergen expedition but limited alpine climbing background, was selected by Mallory as his summit partner, primarily for his mechanical aptitude in handling oxygen apparatus. Noel Odell, a geologist and oxygen specialist with Alpine and polar experience, joined to support acclimatization efforts and equipment testing, while other key members included Howard Somervell, Geoffrey Bruce, Bentley Beetham, and transport officer Edward Shebbeare. The team, comprising about a dozen British climbers and support staff, emphasized physical fitness and teamwork, with 70 porters recruited in Darjeeling, many returning from the 1922 effort to apply lessons in logistics and morale management.[36] The expedition departed Darjeeling, India, on March 25, 1924, embarking on an overland route designed for gradual acclimatization through Sikkim and into Tibet. The journey covered roughly 400 miles, progressing via Kalimpong, the Jelap La pass (14,390 feet) into Tibet, Phari, Kampa Dzong, Tinki Dzong, Shekar Dzong, and finally the Rongbuk Valley, utilizing yaks, ponies, and coolies for transport amid variable weather and terrain. This path, refined from 1922 experiences to avoid avalanche risks and optimize porter loads, allowed the team to reach the Rongbuk Monastery by late April before advancing to Base Camp at 16,500 feet on the Rongbuk Glacier on April 29. En route, initial oxygen tests were conducted near Shekar Dzong at 15,000 feet, where Irvine modified the apparatus to reduce weight by 4-5 pounds, though debates persisted on its necessity versus the burden of 20-30-pound sets.[36] Intermediate camps were established progressively: Camp I and II in the lower Rongbuk, and the critical Camp III (later designated Camp IV) on the North Col at 23,000 feet by May 21, involving steep ice walls and snow platforms reinforced with ice blocks for tent stability. Oxygen debates intensified during setup, with proponents like Odell noting marginal benefits above 27,000 feet despite issues such as leaking valves and throat irritation, while skeptics like Somervell favored pure acclimatization over the "man-killing" gear. Equipment trials revealed inconsistent performance, leading to partial abandonment by some during higher pushes, though Mallory and Irvine committed to using it for their attempt. Team dynamics remained cohesive, bolstered by shared hardships, but strained by health challenges: Mallory suffered from recurrent colitis, throat infections, and exhaustion that delayed his recovery at Kampa Dzong, while Irvine's youth and relative inexperience required mentorship from veterans like Odell.[36]

Mallory-Irvine Final Ascent

On June 6, 1924, George Mallory and Andrew Irvine departed from Camp IV on the North Col, accompanied by porters and oxygen equipment, as part of the final summit push for the 1924 British Mount Everest Expedition.[37] They reached Camp VI, sited at approximately 26,800 feet (8,170 meters) on the Northeast Ridge, by the evening of June 7, after sending the porters back down to meet Noel Odell.[38] Early the next morning, June 8, Mallory and Irvine left Camp VI for their summit attempt, carrying lightweight oxygen apparatus with two cylinders each, aiming to traverse the Northeast Ridge toward the summit pyramid.[39] The chosen route followed the Northeast Ridge, a steep and exposed snow-and-rock arête, rather than an alternative via the Great Couloir or other faces, due to prior reconnaissance and the need to manage oxygen supplies over the approximately 2,000 feet of elevation gain to the summit.[40] A key obstacle on this path was the Second Step, a near-vertical rock tower around 28,000 feet, which would have required technical climbing skills and potentially aid from the oxygen gear; estimates suggest they made steady but slow progress, covering perhaps 800-1,000 vertical feet by midday, based on Odell's later observations of their position relative to identifiable features like the Step. Weather conditions that day began clear in the morning but deteriorated with building clouds and high winds by afternoon, contributing to reduced visibility and challenging climbing conditions without modern gear.[41] Noel Odell, ascending from Camp V to support the pair and conduct geological surveys, caught the last confirmed sighting of Mallory and Irvine at 12:50 p.m. on June 8, when a brief break in the clouds revealed them moving upward near what Odell described as the Second Step, with Mallory leading and Irvine following, appearing to surmount a rock feature together.[42] After this glimpse, the ridge was again enveloped in mist and worsening weather, and neither man returned to Camp VI that evening or the following day, leading to the presumption of a fatal fall, possibly from the steep slabs or during a descent in deteriorating conditions.[43] Odell conducted an immediate search on June 9, climbing above Camp VI into the gathering storm but finding no trace of the pair or their equipment amid the obscuring clouds and high winds, which forced him to descend without success.[38] The rest of the expedition, led by Edward Norton from lower camps, waited anxiously for over 48 hours, monitoring the ridge for any signals or return, but with no sign amid the persistent bad weather, the attempt was abandoned, marking the tragic end of the 1924 summit effort.[44]

Immediate Aftermath and Memorials

Following the disappearance of George Mallory and Andrew Irvine on June 8, 1924, during their final summit attempt, expedition leader Lieutenant-Colonel E. F. Norton directed a limited search effort led by Noel Odell, who ascended from Camp V to Camp VI on June 9 but found no trace of the pair amid the vast terrain and deteriorating weather.[45] Norton, who had assumed command earlier that April after General Charles Bruce's illness, convened a post-disaster conference at Base Camp, where the team concluded the deaths likely resulted from a mountaineering accident such as a slip, though Odell dissented, believing a summit might have been achieved before a fatal delay.[45] Facing physiological strain—evidenced by dilated hearts in all high-altitude members, as noted by expedition doctor T. H. Somervell—exhausted porters, and the onset of monsoon conditions, Norton ordered the abandonment of further summit efforts on June 12.[45] The team evacuated Camp IV on June 10, reaching Base Camp by June 13, where they erected a stone monument commemorating Mallory, Irvine, and two deceased Sherpas, Shamsher and Manbahadur.[45] Base Camp was cleared on June 15, with the party descending to the Rongshar Valley for recuperation before proceeding to Darjeeling, arriving there on August 1.[45] The expedition's return to England in late August prompted immediate public announcements via telegrams and press communiqués drafted by Norton, detailing the loss and the team's record altitude of 8,570 meters achieved earlier by Norton himself.[45] News of the tragedy spread rapidly through British media, evoking national mourning for the fallen climbers, whose sacrifice was seen as emblematic of British resolve.[45] King George V extended a personal message of condolence to the families, conveyed through Sir Francis Younghusband, expressing deep sympathy for the "gallant explorers" and their loved ones.[46] A formal memorial service for Mallory and Irvine was held on October 17, 1924, at St. Paul's Cathedral in London, attended by their relations and friends, representatives of the King, Prince of Wales, Duke of York, Duke of Connaught, and Prince Arthur of Connaught, as well as members of prior Everest expeditions, the Alpine Club, and the Royal Geographical Society.[47] The service featured an address by the Right Reverend Henry Luke Paget, Lord Bishop of Chester, drawing on Psalm 84:5 to honor their courage and the spiritual dimension of their "ascent," with media coverage in outlets like The Times amplifying the event as a tribute to mountaineering heroism.[47] The loss profoundly affected Mallory's family, with his wife, Ruth, receiving dozens of condolence letters from figures including Geoffrey Keynes, Geoffrey Young, Robert Graves, E. F. Norton, and Noel Odell, alongside messages from climbing clubs that underscored the communal grief.[46] Ruth, who had supported her husband's expeditions despite personal strains, expressed deep sorrow in her responses, including a letter to Andrew Irvine's father conveying shared mourning.[46] Their three children—Clare, Beridge, and John—were left fatherless at ages approximately 9, 7, and 4, respectively, in June 1924;[48] Ruth raised them in Cambridge, drawing on an inheritance from her father to maintain stability, while encouraging their later pursuits in education and adventure, as evidenced by John's compilation of a family booklet preserving the condolence correspondence for future generations.[46] A smaller memorial service was also held at Magdalene College Chapel in Cambridge, addressed by A. C. Benson, the Master, who lauded Mallory's modesty and contributions to mountaineering and education.[47]

Disappearance and Historical Searches

Early Discoveries (1933–1999)

In 1933, during the British Mount Everest expedition led by Hugh Ruttledge, climber Percy Wyn-Harris discovered an ice axe on the Northeast Ridge at approximately 27,600 feet (8,410 meters) while attempting a summit push with Lawrence Wager.[49] The axe, marked with initials consistent with those of Andrew Irvine, was found embedded in snow near the base of the Yellow Band and is widely believed to have been dropped during the fatal 1924 climb by either Mallory or Irvine, indicating a possible slip in that vicinity.[50] This artifact provided the first tangible clue to their whereabouts but offered no further evidence of their fate. Three years later, in 1936, during Eric Shipton's reconnaissance expedition to Everest, team member Frank Smythe reported sighting what appeared to be a human body through a telescope from the North Col at around 23,000 feet (7,010 meters).[51] Smythe described the figure as lying in a gully, partially covered by snow, but chose not to disclose the observation publicly during his lifetime, citing respect for the deceased and logistical challenges in recovery; the detail emerged posthumously from his diaries in 2013.[51] Although unconfirmed, this sighting fueled speculation that it could have been one of the lost climbers, preserved by the extreme altitude. The next significant lead came in 1975 during a Chinese expedition when climber Wang Hongbao, while on a brief walk from Camp VI at about 26,900 feet (8,200 meters) on the North Face, encountered a body clad in archaic Western mountaineering gear, which he described as an "old English dead" with fabric flapping in the wind.[40] Wang shared this account four years later with Japanese climber Ryoten Hasegawa during a joint Sino-Japanese expedition, but he perished in an avalanche shortly after, leaving no photographs or precise coordinates.[52] This report prompted subsequent investigations, including a 1986 American-led search expedition organized by Tom Holzel, which sought to verify Wang's claim through liaison with Chinese officials but was hampered by weather and yielded no findings.[53] The expedition's efforts, however, corroborated elements of Wang's story via independent Chinese accounts, heightening interest in the site's potential connection to the 1924 disappearance.[42] A breakthrough occurred on May 1, 1999, when American climber Conrad Anker, as part of the Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition sponsored by the BBC and Nova/PBS, located George Mallory's well-preserved body at 26,750 feet (8,155 meters) on the North Face below the Yellow Band.[54] The remains, face-down in a scree field with a broken rope tangled around the waist, showed severe injuries including a compound fracture of the right tibia and perimortem trauma to the head, consistent with a high-altitude fall and subsequent slide down the mountain.[55] Notably, no camera was found among the artifacts recovered—such as a rucksack, altimeter, and personal letters—despite hopes it might contain summit proof; the body's position aligned closely with Wang Hongbao's 1975 description, suggesting it was the same remains.[54] The expedition respectfully buried Mallory in place, marking a poignant closure to decades of speculation while leaving Irvine's fate unresolved.[55]

Modern Expeditions (2000–2023)

In the years following the 1999 discovery of George Mallory's body, subsequent expeditions focused on locating Andrew Irvine's remains and the Kodak camera believed to have been carried during their 1924 summit attempt, with the goal of resolving whether they reached the summit. The 2001 Mallory and Irvine Research Expedition, organized by Jochen Hemmleb and Eric Simonson, returned to the site of Mallory's body to document its precise GPS coordinates at approximately 8,156 meters on the north face. The team conducted extensive searches in potential fall zones and along the Northeast Ridge for Irvine and the camera but found no trace of either, though they recovered additional artifacts from earlier British expeditions, such as oxygen equipment remnants. Analyses of Mallory's preserved body revealed signs of severe trauma, including a fractured right ankle, a deep laceration on his back, and injuries to his right elbow, consistent with a fatal fall; frostbite was evident on exposed skin, but no tattoos were noted, and the absence of a photograph of his wife Ruth—promised to be left at the summit—provided no conclusive proof of a successful ascent.[56] Between 2004 and 2010, search efforts intensified with technological aids and access to restricted areas. In 2004, climbers including Jake Norton and Dave Hahn conducted surveys from Rongbuk Base Camp, exploring crevasses and ledges below the Yellow Band where Irvine might have fallen, but yielded no significant discoveries. Later expeditions in this period incorporated early drone surveys to map inaccessible terrain on the north face and Northeast Ridge, while a 2007 team ventured to the Chinese side of the mountain—the first permitted access since the 1960s—to investigate reports of a 1933 sighting of a body near the Second Step. These efforts, however, produced limited results, with no confirmation of Irvine's location or the camera, though they refined search models based on aerial imagery and historical eyewitness accounts. The focus remained on camera hunts, as any summit photographs could settle the debate, but environmental challenges like avalanches and high winds hampered progress.[56][57] From 2019 onward, National Geographic spearheaded renewed investigations, emphasizing advanced tools amid growing commercial traffic on Everest. The 2019 expedition, led by Mark Synnott with climbers Jamie McGuinness and Renan Ozturk, targeted a specific crevice at around 8,300 meters on the Northeast Ridge, informed by a 1960 Chinese climber's report and photo analysis by Tom Holzel. The team summited on May 30 and deployed drones to capture over 400 high-resolution images of the area, but found no body, camera, or other evidence despite rappelling into the site. Subsequent efforts through 2023 continued this camera-centric approach, building on prior data but facing obstacles from overcrowding and weather; no breakthrough occurred, leaving the mystery of Mallory and Irvine's fate unresolved as of 2023, with analyses reaffirming the lack of definitive summit indicators from Mallory's artifacts.[58][56] For developments after 2023, including the 2024 discovery of believed Irvine remains, see the "Recent Developments and Discoveries" section.[4]

Recent Developments and Discoveries

2024 Irvine Remains Finding

In September 2024, a National Geographic expedition team led by filmmaker Jimmy Chin and mountaineer Conrad Anker discovered partial remains believed to belong to Andrew "Sandy" Irvine on the Central Rongbuk Glacier, at an altitude at least 7,000 feet (2,134 meters) lower than the location of Mallory's body on the North Face.[4] The find, made during a documentary project exploring the 1924 expedition, included a boot containing a mummified human foot and a sock embroidered with the label "A.C. Irvine," providing strong initial identification based on personal clothing markers consistent with Irvine's known gear from the era.[4] DNA samples were collected from the remains for forensic verification, though glacial conditions preserved the tissue sufficiently for analysis.[4] The location of the remains aligns closely with the trajectory of George Mallory's body, discovered in 1999 on the same ridge, suggesting Irvine and Mallory likely shared a fatal fall while roped together during their descent.[59] A broken climbing rope found around Mallory's waist in 1999 supports this scenario, indicating the pair may have been unroped or the rope snapped under strain, with Irvine's body carried further by avalanches and ice movement over the century.[59] No accompanying artifacts such as a sleeping bag were reported in the discovery, and searches for Irvine's Kodak Vest Pocket camera—potentially carrying summit evidence—yielded no results at the site.[4] Initial examinations by the team and experts point to death by traumatic fall, followed by prolonged exposure and compression within the glacier, mirroring Mallory's injuries which included multiple broken bones and a head wound consistent with a slip on steep terrain.[59] Irvine's foot showed signs of frostbite and mummification but no specific trauma details beyond the presumed impact, with further pathological analysis pending DNA confirmation and ethical considerations for disturbing high-altitude remains.[4] This breakthrough culminates efforts from modern expeditions since the 1999 Mallory find, offering the first physical evidence of Irvine's fate after 100 years.[4]

Ongoing Expeditions and Evidence (2024–2025)

Following the 2024 discovery of partial remains believed to be those of Andrew "Sandy" Irvine on the Central Rongbuk Glacier, forensic examinations were initiated to analyze the boot, sock marked "A.C. Irvine," and preserved foot.[4] Irvine's family volunteered DNA samples for comparison to confirm the identity, with testing coordinated through the British Consulate and the China Tibet Mountaineering Association.[4][60] As of November 2025, these analyses continue to provide crucial context for reconstructing the 1924 expedition's final moments, though full DNA results remain pending.[61] In April 2024, Magdalene College at the University of Cambridge digitized and released online an extensive archive of George Mallory's personal correspondence, including 361 letters primarily to his wife Ruth, three sets of diary entries from his Everest expeditions, and two sonnets.[10] This collection, spanning from 1914 to 1924, offers detailed insights into Mallory's motivations, family life, wartime experiences, and strategic preparations for the mountain, marking the centenary of his final climb.[62] The freely accessible materials have enabled scholars to reassess Mallory's mindset without relying on previously unpublished or fragmented sources.[63] August 2025 saw renewed scholarly attention to the 1924 ascent through evidence reviews, including analyses of video footage and simulations evaluating the Second Step's climbability with period equipment.[64] One key publication examined potential routes, injury patterns from Mallory's 1999 recovery, and Irvine's likely trajectory, concluding that a fall below the First Step aligns with glacial evidence while questioning summit feasibility based on oxygen constraints and rockfall risks.[65] These reviews, drawing on recent Irvine findings, emphasize how the Second Step—a 30-meter near-vertical rock face—posed extreme challenges without aids like the modern ladder installed in 1975.[66] In October 2025, identical twins Hugo and Ross Turner launched a Himalayan expedition to test 1920s-era gear against modern equipment, directly inspired by Mallory and Irvine's kit.[67] Hugo ascended Mera Peak (6,476 meters) in replica wool, leather, and canvas attire sourced from historical patterns, including hand-stitched boots by Crockett & Jones, while Ross used contemporary Montane gear for comparison.[68] Supported scientifically by the University of Portsmouth, the climb assessed thermal performance, mobility, and endurance in sub-zero conditions, yielding data on how early 20th-century materials might have influenced high-altitude survival during the 1924 attempt.[69] By November 2025, the twins had summited, providing empirical evidence that such gear performed well up to the summit, though it was slightly colder (a couple of degrees) than modern equipment.[70]

Theories on the 1924 Summit

Route and Feasibility Debates

The potential route taken by George Mallory and Andrew Irvine during their 1924 summit attempt followed the Northeast Ridge of Mount Everest, ascending from the Yellow Band at approximately 8,440 meters through a series of gullies and rock steps toward the Second Step at around 8,600 meters. This path, characterized by steep rock faces and exposed traverses below the ridge crest, avoided the more direct but highly technical crestline in places, allowing for a feasible line that Mallory, an experienced rock climber, could navigate with Irvine's assistance. Modern assessments, including free ascents by climbers like Conrad Anker in 1999, rate the Second Step's difficulty at 5.8 to 5.10 without supplemental oxygen, suggesting it was within Mallory's capabilities, particularly in the potentially snow-covered conditions of early June that could have eased friction-based moves.[71][72][49] Time estimates for a round-trip summit push from Camp VI at about 8,170 meters indicate a demanding 12 to 18 hours, factoring in the era's primitive equipment and the need to conserve energy on unroped terrain. Departing near sunrise around 5:00 a.m., the pair could have reached the base of the Second Step by late morning, with Odell's 12:50 p.m. sighting placing them at or near that crux; a summit by late afternoon, around 4:30 to 5:00 p.m., was possible if progress remained steady, but the descent in fading light would extend the total effort significantly. These timelines align with later expeditions' data, such as an 8-hour ascent to 8,534 meters in 1984, adjusted for the additional 500 meters to the top and return.[73][74][71] Oxygen use was limited to a few cylinders—likely three for Irvine and two for Mallory—carried from Camp VI, with each set to provide about 3.5 to 4 hours of flow at 2 to 2.5 liters per minute, significantly impacting their speed and endurance. The apparatus, experimental and prone to freezing, was used intermittently to extend supplies, but depletion above the Second Step would have forced reliance on natural acclimatization, slowing progress by up to 50% compared to modern fixed-flow systems; the discovery of cylinder No. 9, partially used, at 8,440 to 8,500 meters supports partial consumption during the initial push. No oxygen gear was found on Mallory's body, indicating it was likely discarded higher up when exhausted or malfunctioning.[72][73][74] Mallory's body, discovered in 1999 at 8,155 meters on a scree slope below the Yellow Band, was positioned face down and fully extended uphill, with arms outstretched and fingertips embedded in gravel, legs trailing downhill, and a broken right tibia/fibula suggesting a slip or short fall rather than a long free plunge. This orientation, combined with a snapped rope still attached to his waist, points to a descent mishap near the Yellow Band, where he may have slipped in a gully while roped to Irvine, leading to a partial arrest before the rope broke and both tumbled. The injuries— including head lacerations and a dislocated elbow—align with impact from a controlled slide down the steep marble and phyllite slabs of the Yellow Band, occurring possibly after midnight in low visibility.[72][49][75]

Evidence Analysis and Controversies

Noel Odell's sighting of Mallory and Irvine at approximately 12:50 p.m. on June 8, 1924, remains a central piece of evidence in debates over their potential summit success, but its interpretation is fraught with ambiguity due to weather conditions and Odell's own later revisions. Odell reported observing the pair from about 26,500 feet, describing them as moving dynamically near a prominent rock step on the northeast ridge, possibly the Second Step, with Mallory slightly ahead and Irvine trailing with equipment; however, swirling clouds quickly obscured the view, preventing confirmation of their exact position or progress toward the final pyramid roughly 800 feet higher.[76] Subsequent analysis has questioned whether the sighting occurred at the Second or Third Step, as Odell's initial dispatch assumed the former, while his 1925 book suggested a higher vantage, potentially nearer the summit ridge; this discrepancy, combined with the brief window of visibility amid deteriorating weather, has led historians to debate whether the climbers were ascending toward success or already in distress.[77] The absence of the Kodak Vest Pocket camera carried by the pair, likely by Irvine, fuels ongoing controversies about photographic proof of a summit attainment. Mallory had vowed to place a photograph of his wife, Ruth, at the top if successful, yet no such image was found on his body when discovered in 1999, prompting speculation that they reached the summit and the camera—potentially containing summit photos—remains lost higher on the mountain.[60] Claims of Chinese mountaineers recovering the camera during a 1975 expedition surfaced in the 1990s, with unverified reports of film showing summit views, but official denials and lack of produced evidence have dismissed these as unsubstantiated, leaving the device's whereabouts and contents as tantalizing unknowns that could resolve or refute summit claims.[4] The 2024 discovery of remains believed to be Sandy Irvine's, including a boot labeled "A.C. Irvine" and a detached foot on the Central Rongbuk Glacier, adds new layers to the evidence but provides no conclusive proof of summit success. Found by a National Geographic expedition led by Jimmy Chin at an elevation far below Mallory's 1999 recovery site (around 26,000 feet), the remains suggest a catastrophic fall that separated the climbers or displaced Irvine's body over time, possibly via avalanche or glacial movement, implying they were roped together during descent rather than ascending post-summit.[59] While this supports theories of a shared fatal accident without summit artifacts like the camera or Ruth's photo, it neither confirms nor disproves reaching the top, as the low recovery site aligns with post-fall dynamics rather than climb progress.[78] Historians remain divided, with Tom Holzel advocating for summit success based on photo analysis and climbing timelines, while skeptics like Peter Gillman argue the evidence points to failure. Holzel, in his 1986 book The Mystery of Mallory and Irvine co-authored with Audrey Salkeld, used high-resolution images to propose the pair bypassed major obstacles and summited by late afternoon, interpreting Odell's sighting as near the final pyramid and the missing photo as intentional summit placement.[71] In contrast, Gillman and Leni Gillman, in their 2000 biography The Wildest Dream, express skepticism, citing oxygen limitations, weather data showing a pressure drop indicating blizzard conditions by 2 p.m., and the absence of high-altitude artifacts to conclude the climbers likely fell short of the summit during an ambitious but doomed push.[76] These opposing views underscore the enduring interpretive conflicts, where physical evidence like the 2024 find bolsters descent-failure narratives but cannot fully silence ascent-possibility arguments.

Legacy

Influence on Mountaineering

George Mallory's expeditions to Mount Everest exemplified a pioneering approach to mountaineering that relied heavily on human skill and minimal equipment, eschewing the technological aids that would later become standard. In an era before synthetic fabrics, crampons, or reliable oxygen systems, Mallory and his companions ascended to altitudes exceeding 8,000 meters using woolen clothing, basic ice axes, and hemp ropes, emphasizing personal technique and adaptability over mechanical support. His skepticism toward supplemental oxygen, which he described as an "abomination" that hindered freedom of movement, underscored a philosophy of minimalism that prioritized the climber's innate abilities and the raw challenge of the mountain.[79] Mallory's training regimen further highlighted this focus on endurance rather than technological reliance, drawing from his athletic background at Cambridge University and his experiences in the British Army during World War I. He advocated for rigorous physical conditioning through prolonged Alpine seasons and high-altitude acclimatization, building stamina via repeated exposure to harsh conditions rather than specialized gear or short-term preparations. This method influenced early 20th-century British mountaineering by promoting sustained effort and mental resilience as the core of success, a contrast to later expeditions that incorporated more engineered solutions.[80] Mallory's daring attempts on Everest profoundly inspired subsequent generations, including Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay, whose successful 1953 summit was seen as fulfilling the unfinished quest of the 1924 expedition, viewing their predecessors' efforts as a foundational motivation for British mountaineering's persistence. The enduring mystery of whether Mallory reached the summit has continued to drive modern expeditions and debates, motivating climbers to probe Everest's history.[81] Posthumously, Mallory was honored for his contributions through the 1922 British Mount Everest expedition's receipt of the Olympic gold medal in alpinism at the 1924 Winter Olympics, recognizing the team's collective achievement despite the tragedies. This award, shared among expedition members including Mallory, cemented his legacy as a symbol of mountaineering's heroic ethos.[82]

Cultural and Literary Impact

George Mallory's enigmatic response to a journalist's query—"Why do you want to climb Mount Everest?"—with the phrase "Because it's there," delivered during a 1923 lecture tour in the United States, has become one of the most iconic quotes in exploration literature, symbolizing the intrinsic human drive for challenge and discovery.[83] This retort, first reported in The New York Times, has permeated popular culture, appearing in films, books, and motivational speeches to encapsulate the allure of unattainable goals, from mountaineering to space exploration.[83] Mallory's own writings, including essays on his Alpine climbs and expeditions, contributed significantly to the early 20th-century genre of adventure literature, emphasizing emotional and philosophical dimensions over mere technical accounts.[84] His reflective prose, such as in pieces detailing the psychological pull of high-altitude pursuits, influenced subsequent authors by blending personal introspection with the romance of the mountains, shaping narratives that prioritize human endeavor and vulnerability.[6] Key biographies and adaptations have further amplified Mallory's cultural resonance. The 1999 book Ghosts of Everest: The Search for Mallory & Irvine by Jochen Hemmleb, Eric Simonson, and Larry A. Johnson chronicles the expedition that discovered Mallory's preserved body on Everest's North Face, reigniting public fascination with his 1924 disappearance and blending historical analysis with expeditionary drama.[85] This was followed by the 2010 documentary film The Wildest Dream, directed by Anthony Geffen, which recounts Mallory's obsession with Everest through dramatic reenactments and modern climber Conrad Anker's retracing of his route, earning acclaim for humanizing the legend while exploring themes of ambition and loss.[86] The 2024 centennial of the 1924 British Mount Everest Expedition spurred renewed commemorations, including events in the UK such as talks and exhibitions honoring Mallory and Andrew Irvine's legacy.[87] National Geographic produced a documentary highlighting a 2024 expedition's discovery of a boot believed to be Irvine's, further embedding Mallory's story in contemporary media as a timeless tale of mystery and heroism.[59] In 2025, British shoemaker Crockett & Jones recreated Mallory's 1920s mountaineering boot, which was tested on Mera Peak by twin climbers Michael and James Turner as part of centennial-inspired projects.[88]

Timeline

  • 18 June 1886: Born in Mobberley, Cheshire, England, to Reverend Herbert Leigh Mallory.[89]
  • 1899: Enters Winchester College, where he develops an interest in mountaineering.[5]
  • 1905–1908: Studies history at Magdalene College, Cambridge, forming connections with figures like Rupert Brooke.[89]
  • September 1910: Begins teaching at Charterhouse School, Godalming, Surrey.[5]
  • 29 July 1914: Marries Ruth Turner in London.[5]
  • 19 September 1915: Birth of first child, daughter Frances Clare.[1]
  • 1917: Birth of second child, daughter Beridge Ruth ("Berry").
  • 4 May 1916–1919: Serves as an officer in the Royal Garrison Artillery during World War I, including at the Battle of the Somme; rises to captain despite injuries.[5]
  • 1920: Birth of third child, son John.
  • 1921: Joins the British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition, reaching about 23,000 feet (7,000 m) on the North Col.[89]
  • 1922: Participates in the second British Mount Everest expedition, climbing to approximately 27,000 feet (8,230 m); avalanche on March 7 kills seven Sherpa porters.[89]
  • 8 June 1924: Last confirmed sighting by Noel Odell near the summit ridge during the third British Mount Everest expedition; Mallory and Andrew Irvine disappear in a storm.[90]
  • 8 or 9 June 1924: Presumed date of death on Mount Everest's North Face, aged 37.[89]
  • 1 May 1999: Body discovered at 26,760 feet (8,155 m) by climber Conrad Anker; no summit evidence found.[89]
  • October 2024: National Geographic expedition discovers what is believed to be a boot and foot from Andrew Irvine on the Central Rongbuk Glacier.[4]
  • 2025: Ongoing analysis of 1924 evidence and planning for replica expeditions in period gear to investigate the Mallory-Irvine mystery.[67]

References

User Avatar
No comments yet.