Recent from talks
Nothing was collected or created yet.
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
|
A vow (Lat. votum, vow, promise; see vote) is a promise or oath. A vow is used as a promise that is solemn rather than casual.
Marriage vows
[edit]Marriage vows are binding promises each partner in a couple makes to the other during a wedding ceremony. Marriage customs have developed over history and keep changing as human society develops. In earlier times and in most cultures the consent of the partners has not had the importance now attached to it, at least in Western societies and in those they have influenced.[1] Protestants, for instance, consider marriage vow as an unchangeable divine law since it needs not only "conciliar assertion" but also the support of the Scripture, making marriage a form of divine ordinance.[2]
Divine vows
[edit]Within the world of monks and nuns, a vow is sometimes a transaction between a person and a deity, where the former promises to render some service or gift, or devotes something valuable to the deity's use. The vow is a kind of oath, with the deity being both the witness and recipient of the promise. For examples, see the Book of Judges or the Bodhisattva vows. In the Roman Catholic Code of Canon Law, the vow and the oath are not considered acts of worship (cultus) like the liturgical celebration. However, they are considered acts of religion due to their sacred character, including the religious obligations they entail.[3] Here, an important characteristic of the vow involves the manner by which non-Catholics are recognized to be capable of making a vow, which must also be fulfilled by reason of the virtue of religion.[3]
The god is usually expected to grant, on entering into contracts or covenants with man, the claims his vow establishes on their benevolence, and valuing of his gratitude. Conversely, in taking a vow, the petitioner's piety and spiritual attitude have begun to outweigh those merely ritual details of the ceremony that are all-important in magical rites.[4]
Sometimes the old magical usage survives side by side with the more developed idea of a personal power to be approached in prayer. For example, in the Maghreb (in North Africa), in time of drought the maidens of Mazouna carry every evening in procession through the streets a doll called ghonja, really a dressed-up wooden spoon, symbolizing a pre-Islamic rain-spirit. Often one of the girls carries on her shoulders a sheep, and her companions sing the following words:[4]
Here we have a sympathetic rain charm, combined with a prayer to the rain viewed as a personal goddess and with a promise or vow to give her the animal. The point of the promise lies of course in the fact that water is in that country stored and carried in sheep-skins.[5][4]
Secondly, the vow is quite apart from established cults, and is not provided for in the religious calendar. The Roman vow (votum), as W. W. Fowler observes in his work The Roman Festivals (London, 1899), p. 346, "was the exception, not the rule; it was a promise made by an individual at some critical moment, not the ordered and recurring ritual of the family or the State.' The vow, however, contained so large an element of ordinary prayer that in the Greek language one and the same word (Ancient Greek: εύχή) expressed both. The characteristic mark of the vow, as the Suda and the Greek Church Fathers remark, was that it was a promise either of things to be offered to God in the future and at once consecrated to Him in view of their being so offered, or of austerities to be undergone. For offering and austerity, sacrifice and suffering, are equally calculated to appease an offended deity's wrath or win his goodwill.[4]
The Bible affords many examples of vows. Thus in Judges xi. Jephthah "vowed a vow unto the Lord, and said, If thou wilt indeed deliver the children of Ammon into my hand, then it shall be that whosoever cometh forth out of the doors of my house to meet me, when I return in peace from the children of Ammon, it shall be the Lord's, and I will offer it up for a burnt-offering." In the sequel it is his own daughter who so meets him, and he sacrifices her after a respite of two months, granted so she could "bewail her virginity upon the mountains." A thing or person thus vowed to the deity became holy[4] and sanctified to God. (Jephthah could not have lawfully burned his daughter in sacrifice as it would constitute human sacrifice - something that God explicitly forbade.[citation needed] Some [who?] have suggested that his daughter remained unmarried and was given to serve the Lord in the temple.) It belonged to once to the sanctuary or to the priests who represented the god. In the Jewish religion, the latter, under certain conditions, defined in Leviticus 27, could permit it to be redeemed. But to substitute an unclean for a clean beast that had been vowed, or an imperfect victim for a flawless one, was to court with certainty the divine displeasure.[4]
It is often difficult to distinguish a vow from an oath. A vow is an oath, but an oath is only a vow if the divine being is the recipient of the promise and is not merely a witness. Therefore, in Acts 23:21, over forty men, enemies of Paul, bound themselves, under a curse, neither to eat nor to drink till they had slain him. In the Christian Fathers we hear of vows to abstain from flesh diet and wine. But of the abstentions observed by votaries, those with no relation to the barber's art were the commonest. Wherever individuals were concerned to create or confirm a tie connecting them with a god, a shrine or a particular religious circle, a hair-offering was in some form or other imperative. They began by polling their locks at the shrine and left them as a soul-token in charge of the god, and never polled them afresh until the vow was fulfilled. So Achilles consecrated his hair to the river Spercheus and vowed not to cut it until he should return safe from Troy; and the Hebrew Nazarite, whose strength resided in his flowing locks, only cut them off and burned them on the altar when the days of his vow were ended, and he could return to ordinary life, having achieved his mission. So in Acts 18:18 Paul had shorn his head in Cenchreae, for he had a vow. In Acts 21:23 we hear of four men who, having a vow on them, had their heads shaved at Paul's expense. Among the ancient Chatti, as Tacitus relates (Germania, 31), young men allowed their hair and beards to grow, and vowed to court danger in that guise until they each had slain an enemy."[4]
In Christianity, the vow has more weight than an oath when approached from the view that it binds one to God whereas the oath binds one to man.[6] This was explained further by St. Thomas Aquinas, who said:
The obligation both of a vow and of an oath arises from something Divine; but in different ways. For the obligation of a vow arises from the fidelity we owe God, which binds us to fulfil our promises to Him. On the other hand, the obligation of an oath arises from the reverence we owe Him which binds us to fulfil our promises to Him.[6]
See also
[edit]- Albanian sworn virgins
- Marriage vows
- Religious vows (or monastic vows)
- Heitstrenging
References
[edit]- ^ Claire Elise Campton (17 August 2016). "Writing your own wedding vows". Claire Elise Photography. Archived from the original on August 28, 2016. Retrieved 17 August 2016.
- ^ Hovey, Craig; Olsen, Cyrus (2014). The Hermeneutics of Tradition: Explorations and Examinations. Eugene, OR: Cascade Books. p. 134. ISBN 9781625644985.
- ^ a b Beal, John (2000). New Commentary on the Code of Canon Law. New York: Paulist Press. p. 1416. ISBN 0809140667.
- ^ a b c d e f g This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Conybeare, Frederick Cornwallis (1911). "Vow". In Chisholm, Hugh (ed.). Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 28 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 219.
- ^ Professor A. Bel in paper Quelque rites pour obtenir la pluie, in xivme Congres des Orientalistes (Alger, 1905).
- ^ a b Aquinas, Thomas (2007). Summa Theologica, Volume 3 (Part II, Second Section). New York: Cosimo Classics. p. 1578. ISBN 9781602065574.
External links
[edit]
Quotations related to Vow at Wikiquote- Seven Vows of Marriage
Definition and Origins
Definition
A vow is defined as a solemn, voluntary promise or commitment, typically invoking a higher power, deity, or personal honor, that imposes a binding obligation on the individual making it.[8] This form of commitment distinguishes itself through its performative nature, where the spoken or declared words create a moral or existential tie, often aiming to regulate future behavior or achieve a specific purpose. Key characteristics of vows include voluntariness, as they arise from deliberate personal choice without external coercion; solemnity, reflected in their serious tone and frequent association with ritualistic elements that underscore their gravity; and specificity, whereby vows usually outline clear terms, such as conditions, duration, or scope, to ensure enforceability within the individual's conscience or community.[9][8] These traits emphasize the internal motivation and self-imposed nature of vows, setting them apart from casual assurances. Vows differ from oaths in that they represent personal, often unilateral commitments directed toward oneself or a transcendent entity, whereas oaths function as formal declarations in public, legal, or official settings that invoke an external witness to affirm truth or fidelity.[8] This distinction highlights vows' focus on individual moral agency rather than procedural verification.[9] The concept of vows has evolved historically from ancient rituals, such as those in pre-Roman and Gallo-Roman traditions where voluntary pledges integrated into religious and social practices to foster cultural continuity, through medieval adaptations emphasizing moral irrevocability, to modern applications as personal or ethical bindings in secular contexts.[10] In contemporary usage, marriage vows serve as a common example, illustrating vows' role in formalizing lifelong personal commitments.[9]Etymology
The word "vow" entered the English language around 1200 CE through Middle English, initially denoting a solemn engagement to a religious order or a promise to God or a saint.[11] It derives from Old French voe or vou (circa 13th century, modern French vœu), meaning a solemn pledge.[11] This Old French term stems directly from Latin votum, a neuter noun signifying "a promise to a god, solemn pledge, or dedication," which is the past participle of the verb vovere, "to promise or vow."[11] In ancient Roman religion, votum referred to vows made to deities, often involving offerings or dedications as precursors to the concept's broader evolution. Tracing further back, the Latin vovere connects to the Proto-Indo-European root *h₁wegʷʰ- (often simplified as wegwh-), which conveys "to speak solemnly, vow, or preach," emphasizing invocatory or promissory speech acts.[11] This root underscores the word's historical tie to religious and ritualistic contexts, where vows functioned as binding declarations.[11] Cross-linguistically, parallels emerge in other Indo-European branches, reflecting similar notions of solemn commitment. In Germanic languages, the Old High German gilubida (modern German Gelübde, "vow" or "pledge") arose from giloubo, meaning "belief" or "faith," highlighting a conceptual link between trust and promissory obligation.[12] In Sanskrit, vrata denotes a religious vow or resolve, derived from the root vṛ ("to choose or will") with the suffix -ta, evoking disciplined self-imposition in Vedic traditions. These terms illustrate convergent developments in expressing vows across cultures, though not always from identical roots.[11]Types of Vows
Marriage Vows
Marriage vows typically consist of solemn promises exchanged between partners during a wedding ceremony, emphasizing fidelity, mutual support, and a commitment to lifelong partnership. These declarations often include pledges to love, honor, and cherish one another through various life circumstances, such as prosperity and adversity, health and illness. For instance, in many traditions, vows articulate a bond of exclusivity and assistance, symbolizing the couple's intention to build a shared future.[13] The historical roots of marriage vows trace back to ancient Roman rituals, where brides and grooms exchanged simple affirmations like "Ubi tu Gaius, ego Gaia" (Where you are Gaius, I am Gaia), signifying a shared domestic life and unity under Roman law. These evolved through medieval Christian practices, influenced by betrothal promises that formalized commitments before the full ceremony, often involving rings as symbols of oaths and emphasizing chastity and mutual consent. By the early modern period, such vows were codified in texts like the Anglican Book of Common Prayer, standardizing phrases that underscored enduring partnership.[14][15] Cultural variations in marriage vows reflect diverse matrimonial structures and values. In Western monogamous traditions, common declarations include "to have and to hold from this day forward, for better, for worse, for richer, for poorer," highlighting possession, endurance, and equality in partnership. Hindu ceremonies feature the saptapadi, or seven steps around a sacred fire, where each step represents a vow—such as promises to provide nourishment, strength, and progeny—binding the couple irrevocably through these ritualized commitments. In Islamic nikah proceedings, vows take the form of verbal affirmations by the bride and groom, confirming acceptance of the marriage contract and mutual responsibilities under Sharia, often recited before witnesses to establish consent and fidelity.[13][16][17] In the 20th and 21st centuries, civil ceremonies have increasingly incorporated personalized elements into marriage vows, moving toward egalitarian language that avoids hierarchical terms like "obey" in favor of mutual respect and shared growth. This trend reflects broader societal shifts toward gender equality, with couples crafting declarations that emphasize partnership, emotional support, and individual fulfillment, often blending traditional phrasing with contemporary sentiments like commitments to adventure or environmental stewardship together. Such customizations allow for inclusivity in diverse unions, including same-sex marriages, while maintaining the core promise of lifelong companionship.[18][19]Religious Vows
Religious vows constitute solemn commitments undertaken by individuals in spiritual or monastic settings to pursue devotion, renunciation, and discipline as expressions of faith. These vows serve as binding promises that structure the votary's life around ethical and spiritual ideals, often requiring a profound detachment from worldly concerns to deepen communion with the divine or ultimate reality. In various traditions, they emphasize self-sacrifice and communal harmony, distinguishing them from casual oaths by their public nature and lifelong implications. Central to many Christian monastic traditions are the vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, known as the evangelical counsels, which trace their formalized expression to the Benedictine Rule composed by St. Benedict of Nursia in the 6th century. The vow of poverty requires the renunciation of personal property and material possessions, promoting simplicity and reliance on communal resources; chastity demands celibacy and purity in relationships, redirecting energies toward spiritual pursuits; and obedience entails submission to the superior and the rule of the order, fostering humility and unity within the monastery. These vows, implied in the Benedictine framework though not always explicitly named, draw from Gospel exhortations such as Jesus' counsel to the rich young man to sell his possessions and follow him (Matthew 19:21).[20][21] The adoption of religious vows follows a deliberate process, commencing with temporary vows during a novitiate period—typically lasting one to three years—to test and cultivate the candidate's resolve—before progressing to perpetual vows, which are irrevocable and bind the individual for life. This progression is enshrined in canon law for Catholic institutes, where public profession of vows, whether temporary or perpetual, is pronounced before the community and accepted by a superior in the Church's name, marking a formal entry into religious life.[22][23] Beyond Christian monasticism, religious vows appear in Eastern traditions as structured precepts or great vows integral to ethical discipline. In Buddhism, lay practitioners and monastics undertake the five precepts—refraining from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, false speech, and intoxicants—as voluntary vows that align with the ethical dimensions of the Noble Eightfold Path, such as right speech, right action, and right livelihood, to cultivate mindfulness and end suffering. Monks and nuns extend these to the full set of 227 precepts in the Theravada tradition, reinforcing commitments to non-harm and communal harmony. In Jainism, ascetics observe the five mahavratas, or great vows, which demand absolute adherence: ahimsa (non-violence toward all life forms), satya (truthfulness in thought and word), asteya (non-stealing), brahmacharya (chastity), and aparigraha (non-possession), forming the bedrock of purification and liberation from karma. These vows, taken upon initiation into the ascetic order, prohibit even subtle forms of harm, underscoring non-violence as the supreme religious principle.[24][25][26][27] Theologically, religious vows function as covenants between the individual and the divine, imposing sacred obligations that demand fulfillment to maintain spiritual integrity. This understanding is rooted in scriptural precedents, such as Numbers 30 in the Hebrew Bible, which delineates the binding nature of vows and oaths made to the Lord, prohibiting their violation and emphasizing their weight as pledges before God, with provisions for oversight by family heads in certain cases to ensure communal order. Such covenants underscore vows not merely as personal resolutions but as acts of worship that invite divine favor and accountability.[28][29]Secular and Personal Vows
Secular and personal vows refer to voluntary, self-imposed commitments made by individuals to foster personal growth, discipline, and behavioral change outside of religious or legal frameworks. These vows often take the form of promises to oneself, emphasizing motivation and accountability without external enforcement. Common examples include New Year's resolutions, where people pledge to adopt healthier habits like regular exercise or improved financial management, serving as a ritual for self-reflection at the year's start.[30] Similarly, sobriety pledges in programs such as Alcoholics Anonymous involve personal commitments through the 12-step process, where participants resolve to admit powerlessness over addiction and make amends as steps toward recovery.[31] Historically, secular vows draw from traditions like ancient Greek athletic oaths, which competitors swore to uphold fair play and rules, a practice secularized in the modern Olympic oath introduced in 1920 and revised to focus solely on sportsmanship and ethical conduct without invoking deities.[32] During the Enlightenment era, figures like Benjamin Franklin exemplified personal covenants through self-designed systems of moral improvement; in 1726, he outlined 13 virtues—such as temperance, resolution, and frugality—and tracked daily adherence in a journal to cultivate disciplined habits.[33] These examples illustrate how secular vows evolved from ritualistic promises into tools for individual ethical and practical advancement. In contemporary settings, secular vows appear in self-help practices facilitated by habit-forming apps, which allow users to set and monitor personal pledges for goals like daily reading or mindfulness meditation; apps such as Streaks and Habitica gamify these commitments to enhance adherence through reminders and progress visualization.[34] Environmental pledges have also surged since the 2010s, with initiatives like Plastic Free July—launched in 2011—encouraging millions annually to vow against single-use plastics for the month, promoting sustainable behaviors through collective yet personal accountability.[35] Psychologically, these vows function as commitment devices that bolster self-discipline by creating anticipated regret for non-compliance, thereby aiding long-term behavior change. Research shows that such devices increase short-term weight loss by an average of 1.5 kg when integrated into interventions, as they leverage cognitive strategies to overcome procrastination and reinforce motivation. A 2015 theoretical analysis further highlights how commitment devices balance flexibility and restriction to support sustained goal pursuit, particularly in health and productivity contexts.[36][37] Unlike binding religious vows enforced by spiritual consequences, secular ones rely on intrinsic motivation, making their efficacy dependent on personal resolve.[38]Vows in Religious Traditions
In Abrahamic Religions
In Judaism, vows, known as nedarim, form a significant aspect of religious practice, often involving commitments to God through offerings or abstinences. Korbanot, or votive offerings, are detailed in the Torah, particularly in Leviticus 27, where individuals pledge animals, property, or personal service to the sanctuary as a fulfillment of a vow made in response to a divine favor or petition.[39] These offerings underscore the irrevocability of vows, emphasizing their role in drawing closer to God (korban deriving from the root meaning "to approach"). Another prominent example is the Nazirite vow, outlined in Numbers 6, where a person voluntarily abstains from wine, grape products, and haircuts for a designated period to consecrate themselves to God, culminating in specific sacrificial rites upon completion.[40] Rabbinic tradition allows for annulment (hatarat nedarim) by a qualified authority if the vow causes undue hardship, as per the positive commandment in Numbers 30:3-14, ensuring vows do not become burdensome traps.[41] In Christianity, vows are integrated into key sacraments and callings, reflecting a commitment to Christ and the community. Baptismal vows, recited by candidates or on their behalf, involve renouncing evil, sin, and the devil while affirming faith in the Trinity, as practiced in rites across denominations to symbolize spiritual rebirth.[42] Ordination vows for clergy similarly bind individuals to pastoral duties, such as preaching the gospel, administering sacraments, and upholding church doctrine, often sworn before a congregation or bishop.[43] The New Testament, particularly Matthew 5:33-37, teaches simplicity in oaths and vows, urging believers to let their "yes" be yes and "no" be no, avoiding elaborate swearing that could lead to perjury or hypocrisy, thereby prioritizing integrity over ritualistic pledges.[44] Monastic vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience emerged prominently after the 4th century, formalized in communities inspired by early ascetics like St. Anthony, to emulate Christ's self-denial and foster communal holiness.[45] In Islam, nadhr refers to personal vows made to Allah, typically promising an act of worship or charity in anticipation of or gratitude for divine aid, distinct from obligatory ibadat (ritual worship like prayer or fasting). The Quran in Surah Al-Insan 76:7 reinforces their binding nature: "They fulfill their vows and fear a Day whose evil is widespread." Hadith collections emphasize fulfillment, with the Prophet Muhammad stating, "Whoever vowed to obey Allah, let him obey Him, and whoever vowed to disobey Allah, let him not disobey Him," highlighting that vows should only pertain to permissible acts.[46] Breaking a nadhr requires kaffarah (expiation), such as feeding the poor or fasting, but annulment is not typically dispensed unless unforeseen circumstances arise under scholarly ruling.[47] Across Abrahamic traditions, vows embody solemn promises to God, generally irrevocable to maintain their sanctity, yet provisions for dispensation—such as rabbinic annulments in Judaism—prevent them from causing harm, reflecting a shared emphasis on sincere devotion over rigid legalism.[41]In Eastern Religions
In Hinduism, vows known as vratas represent voluntary acts of austerity and discipline undertaken to accumulate spiritual merit and purify the mind, often aligned with lunar cycles and festivals. These practices emphasize self-control and devotion, serving as personal commitments to deities for blessings or atonement. A prominent example is the Ekadashi vrata, observed on the eleventh day (ekādaśī) of the waxing and waning moon phases, involving fasting from grains and certain foods to honor Vishnu and foster mental clarity.[48] Another key rite is the Upanayana ceremony, an initiation for boys marking entry into formal education and spiritual life, where the initiate receives a sacred thread (yajñopavīta) and vows fidelity to the guru, celibacy, and study of the Vedas during the brahmacarya stage.[49] In Jainism, vows form the core of ascetic and lay practice, with monks and nuns taking the five great vows (mahavratas): non-violence (ahimsa), truthfulness (satya), non-stealing (asteya), chastity (brahmacharya), and non-possession (aparigraha). Ahimsa, the foremost vow, prohibits harm to all living beings through thought, word, or deed, underpinning Jaina ethics and soteriology as the means to liberate the soul from karma. Lay Jains observe partial versions (anuvratas) to cultivate virtue in daily life.[50][51] In Buddhism, vows manifest differently across traditions, underscoring ethical conduct as foundational to the path toward liberation. In Vajrayana, or tantric Buddhism, samaya vows constitute sacred commitments taken during empowerments (abhiṣeka), binding practitioners to their guru, deities, and the non-dual view of reality; these include root pledges against disparaging the Three Jewels and branch commitments to maintain purity in body, speech, and mind, with violations seen as severing the path to enlightenment.[52] In Theravada, sīla (moral precepts) function as daily or periodic vows, such as the Five Precepts (pañca-sīla)—abstaining from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and intoxicants—recited as training rules to cultivate virtue and mindfulness, often renewed during Uposatha observances.[53] Other Eastern traditions incorporate vows in initiation and cultivation practices. In Sikhism, the Amrit Sanchar ceremony, established by Guru Gobind Singh in 1699, initiates individuals into the Khalsa through ingestion of amrit (sweetened water stirred with a sword), accompanied by vows to uphold the Five Ks (uncut hair, comb, bracelet, undergarment, and dagger), reject caste distinctions, and live in service to the divine while combating injustice.[54] In Taoism, pledges form part of ordination and immortality (xiān) pursuits, particularly in internal alchemy (nèidān), where adepts vow adherence to ethical codes and meditative disciplines to refine qi (vital energy) and achieve transcendence, substituting symbolic commitments for earlier ritual severances like hair-cutting.[55] Philosophically, vows in these traditions serve as disciplined pathways to enlightenment, generating positive karma and aligning the practitioner with cosmic harmony. Central to many is ahimsa (non-harm), integrated into vows as a commitment to avoid injury to sentient beings through thought, word, or deed, thereby purifying karma and fostering compassion as essential for spiritual awakening.[50]Legal and Social Implications
Enforceability and Contracts
In modern legal systems, vows are generally treated as unilateral promises rather than bilateral contracts, and their enforceability depends on whether they meet the criteria for a binding obligation, such as the presence of consideration or detrimental reliance by the promisee. Under U.S. common law, for instance, a vow may be enforced through the doctrine of promissory estoppel if the promise induces reasonable action or forbearance by another party, resulting in foreseeable detriment, even absent traditional consideration. This principle, rooted in equity to prevent injustice, allows courts to award reliance damages or, in some cases, expectation damages to protect the relying party.[56][57] The historical roots of vows as enforceable commitments trace back to Roman law, where the stipulatio served as a formal verbal contract consisting of a solemn question-and-answer exchange, such as the stipulator asking "Do you promise?" and the promisor responding "I promise," creating a binding obligation enforceable through civil actions. This institution evolved into medieval canon law, which integrated Roman principles to regulate religious vows, treating them as sacred yet juridically binding acts that imposed moral and legal duties, often influencing the development of European civil codes by emphasizing the enforceability of promises made under oath. Canon law's framework, as codified in collections like Gratian's Decretum in the 12th century, extended these concepts to vows of chastity, poverty, and obedience, which were dispensed only by ecclesiastical authority and shaped secular contract doctrines on good faith and obligation.[58][59] In contemporary contexts, marriage vows, while symbolic, can indirectly influence enforceability through associated legal instruments like prenuptial agreements or divorce settlements, where courts may reference the intent behind vows to interpret property division or spousal support obligations, though the vows themselves are not independently actionable as contracts. For example, in U.S. family courts, a vow to "love and cherish" might inform equitable distribution in no-fault divorces, but enforcement relies on statutory marriage laws rather than the vows' wording. Similarly, corporate "vows" articulated in mission statements—such as commitments to ethical practices or stakeholder interests—can impose fiduciary duties on directors under corporate law, requiring them to align decisions with the stated purpose to avoid breaches of the duty of loyalty, as seen in cases where deviations lead to shareholder derivative suits.[60][61][62] Jurisdictional variations highlight stark differences in how vows are treated: in theocratic systems governed by Sharia, such as courts in Saudi Arabia or Iran, oaths and vows (yamin or nadhr) are strictly binding as religious and legal obligations, enforceable through judicial penalties or expiation (kaffara) if breached, reflecting Islam's emphasis on fulfilling promises to God or others. In contrast, secular jurisdictions like those in the United States or Europe view vows as advisory or non-binding unless they satisfy contract elements like offer, acceptance, and consideration, with courts refusing enforcement of purely religious vows to avoid entanglement with establishment clause concerns. Personal vows, such as self-imposed promises for personal growth, typically remain non-enforceable analogs in all systems, serving moral rather than legal purposes.[63][64][65]Consequences of Breaking Vows
Breaking a vow carries profound spiritual penalties across religious traditions, often framed as divine retribution or karmic repercussions. In the Abrahamic faiths, particularly Judaism and Christianity, the Bible warns that failing to fulfill a vow to God invites His displeasure and potential judgment; Ecclesiastes 5:4-5 states, "When you make a vow to God, do not delay to fulfill it... It is better that you should not vow than that you should vow and not pay," emphasizing that God has no pleasure in fools who break such promises.[66][67] This breach is seen as a form of unfaithfulness, akin to lying, which can disrupt one's fellowship with the divine and lead to spiritual setbacks.[68] In Eastern religions such as Hinduism and Buddhism, breaking vows contributes to negative karma, perpetuating cycles of suffering through rebirth and hindering spiritual progress. The doctrine of karma posits that intentional actions, including the violation of solemn promises, generate consequences that bind the individual to samsara, the wheel of existence, until atonement or merit accumulation alters the trajectory.[69][70][71] For instance, unfulfilled vows to deities or personal commitments accrue demerit, weakening moral resolve and inviting future adversities as retributive balance. Socially, the rupture of vows erodes trust and communal bonds, with infidelity in marriage serving as a stark example. Betrayal through extramarital affairs often precipitates divorce, as it shatters the foundational promise of fidelity; studies indicate that infidelity contributes to approximately 20-40% of marital dissolutions, leading to emotional devastation and family fragmentation.[72][73] In broader communities, particularly religious ones, such breaches inflict reputational damage, ostracizing individuals from social networks and diminishing their standing; historical analyses of oath-breaking in medieval societies reveal that violations of communal vows resulted in loss of honor, exclusion, and familial disgrace.[74] Psychologically, vow-breaking induces guilt and cognitive dissonance, manifesting as internal conflict when actions contradict personal values or commitments. Research from the early 2020s links perceived promise violations to heightened stress, anxiety, and depression, as individuals grapple with self-discrepancy and eroded self-trust; for example, a 2020 study on workplace broken promises found correlations with emotional distress and reduced mental well-being, effects amplified in intimate contexts like marriage.[75][76] In romantic relationships, this dissonance fosters ongoing insecurity and difficulty in future attachments, with betrayed parties experiencing persistent doubt.[77] Mitigation of these consequences often involves formal processes for release or absolution. In Catholicism, papal indults or dispensations from the Holy See can relieve individuals from private or religious vows for just cause, such as impossibility or undue burden, restoring spiritual equilibrium without full culpability; Canon 1196 outlines that the Roman Pontiff or designated authorities may grant such exemptions to prevent greater harm.[78] Similarly, ecclesiastical annulments declare certain marital vows invalid ab initio, addressing irreconcilable unions while upholding doctrinal integrity, though this pertains to sacramental rather than civil remedies.Cultural and Historical Significance
In Literature and Media
In literature, vows frequently function as symbols of profound commitment that ignite conflict and tragedy, underscoring the tension between personal pledges and external forces. In William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, the titular lovers' clandestine exchange of marriage vows during the balcony scene represents a bold defiance of their feuding families, yet these vows become harbingers of doom as patriarchal societal norms clash with their union. Literary scholar Lynda E. Boose notes that the secret wedding circumvents established rites, intensifying the tragedy when Lord Capulet seeks to nullify it by betrothing Juliet to Paris, ultimately driving the lovers to suicide.[79] Similarly, Coppélia Kahn interprets the vows as a challenge to gender-based violence, but their entrapment within Verona's feud renders the commitment fatal, highlighting vows' role in amplifying relational fragility.[79] Medieval epics further illustrate vows as embodiments of chivalric duty, propelling heroic narratives through pledges that test loyalty amid peril. In The Song of Roland, knightly oaths to Charlemagne exemplify fealty and honor, with Roland's vow to safeguard the rear-guard at Roncevaux Pass serving as a central plot device that escalates the battle's stakes. LitCharts analysis reveals how Roland's adherence to this pledge, coupled with his prideful refusal to blow the Olifant for aid, results in the annihilation of his comrades, transforming the vow into a catalyst for epic sacrifice and Charlemagne's vengeful pursuit.[80] This portrayal evolves vows from mere promises into markers of martial identity, where breach or overzealous fulfillment invites devastating consequences. In contemporary media, vows adapt into tropes that both celebrate and complicate commitment, often driving comedic or dramatic resolutions. Romantic comedies since the 1990s frequently employ wedding scenes as feel-good climaxes, symbolizing relational affirmation amid modern stresses like infidelity or routine. A University of Nevada, Las Vegas thesis on wedding films analyzes how portrayals in such films idealize weddings as affirmations of enduring love, yet subtly critique unrealistic expectations by juxtaposing them with chaotic pre-wedding antics.[81] Television series such as Game of Thrones invert this optimism, depicting oath-breaking as a harbinger of ruin in a world governed by feudal codes. The Washington Post review of the episode "Oathkeeper" details how Jaime Lannister's violation of his Kingsguard vows fractures his bond with Cersei, while Night's Watch mutineers' betrayal unleashes brutality against innocents, underscoring vows' power to unleash cycles of violence and death.[82] Symbolically, vows transition from heroic ideals in early literature to instruments of modern critique, functioning as plot devices that expose commitment's double-edged nature. Scholarly examinations, such as those in Vows and Violence in the Medieval and Early Modern Chivalric Romance, trace this evolution: medieval texts dramatize vows' susceptibility to failure through knights' perilous pledges, while later narratives question their rigidity, using broken or renegotiated vows to probe ethical dilemmas and power dynamics.[83] In 21st-century media, this shift manifests in portrayals favoring fluid over absolute commitments, reflecting broader cultural moves toward viewing marriage as adaptable partnerships rather than irrevocable bonds.Historical Examples
One prominent ancient example of a vow shaping historical events was Hannibal Barca's oath of enmity against Rome, sworn as a young boy around 237 BCE by his father, Hamilcar Barca, on the altar of a Carthaginian deity. According to Roman historians like Livy and Polybius, this blood oath committed Hannibal to lifelong hostility toward Rome, motivating his leadership in the Second Punic War (218–201 BCE) and his audacious crossing of the Alps with war elephants, which nearly toppled the Roman Republic despite ultimate defeat at Zama.[84] In ancient Sparta, the agoge training system for boys aged seven to twenty instilled unbreakable loyalty through rigorous physical and moral discipline, culminating in oaths that Spartan hoplites swore to fight valiantly without retreating, even to death, to defend the polis. This pledge, rooted in the 7th-century BCE traditions, reinforced the Spartan warrior ethos during conflicts such as the Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BCE, where King Leonidas and his 300 fulfilled it by holding the pass against overwhelming Persian forces, preserving Greek city-state independence.[85] During the medieval period, the vows taken at the Council of Clermont in 1095 by Pope Urban II marked a pivotal moment, as thousands of European nobles and knights pledged to reclaim Jerusalem from Muslim control, sewing crosses onto their garments as symbols of their sacred commitment. These crusading vows, promising plenary indulgence for sins, mobilized diverse armies across Europe, leading to the capture of Antioch in 1098 and Jerusalem in 1099, but also sparking centuries of geopolitical conflict, including the establishment of Latin kingdoms in the Levant and heightened Christian-Muslim antagonism.[86] In the modern era, the Founding Fathers of the United States formalized their revolutionary vow on July 4, 1776, by signing the Declaration of Independence, mutually pledging "our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor" to support independence from Britain.[87] This oath-like commitment exposed signers like Thomas Jefferson and John Hancock to treason charges, financial ruin, and execution, yet galvanized colonial resistance, contributing to victory in the American Revolutionary War and the founding of a new republic based on Enlightenment principles. During World War II, resistance movements often began with personal or group vows of defiance against Nazi occupation, such as those sworn by French Maquis fighters to sabotage German operations and aid Allied liberation, embodying a commitment to national sovereignty amid persecution.[88] These pledges sustained underground networks, facilitating key actions like intelligence for D-Day, though many resisters faced capture and death. A striking success of a modern vow was Mahatma Gandhi's lifelong commitment to ahimsa (non-violence), formalized in campaigns like the 1942 Quit India Movement, where he urged followers to pledge peaceful resistance against British rule, declaring "Do or Die" while insisting on non-violent means. This vow-inspired mass civil disobedience pressured Britain, accelerating India's independence in 1947 and influencing global non-violent movements, though it faced challenges from sporadic violence by participants.[89] Conversely, numerous historical treaties served as solemn vows between nations that were subsequently broken, leading to profound consequences; for instance, the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie promised the Lakota Sioux perpetual rights to the Black Hills, but U.S. government violations through gold rush encroachments and military seizures in the 1870s sparked the Great Sioux War and ongoing land disputes.[90] Similarly, the 1835 Treaty of New Echota, coercing Cherokee removal, was ignored in practice, resulting in the Trail of Tears and the displacement of thousands, exemplifying how failed interstate vows eroded trust and fueled indigenous resistance.[91]References
- https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/An_Etymological_Dictionary_of_the_German_Language/Annotated/Glaube
