Hubbry Logo
The ChimesThe ChimesMain
Open search
The Chimes
Community hub
The Chimes
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
The Chimes
The Chimes
The Chimes
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Chimes: A Goblin Story of Some Bells that Rang an Old Year Out and a New Year In, commonly referred to as The Chimes, is a novella by Charles Dickens, first published in 1844, one year after A Christmas Carol. It is the second in his series of "Christmas books", five novellas with strong social and moral messages that he published during the 1840s. In addition to A Christmas Carol and The Chimes, the Christmas books include The Cricket on the Hearth (1845), The Battle of Life (1846), and The Haunted Man and the Ghost's Bargain (1848).

Key Information

Plot

[edit]

Toby ("Trotty") Veck, an elderly "ticket-porter", plies his trade from the steps of a church, whose Chimes have for many years cheered and encouraged him as he trots around delivering letters. Today, on New Year's Eve, Trotty is filled with gloom at reports in the newspapers of working class crime and immorality, and concludes that the poor must be incorrigibly bad by nature.

Trotty's daughter Meg and her long-time fiancé Richard arrive to announce their decision to marry the very next day. Although desperately poor and with few prospects, they see no point in waiting any longer, reasoning that they will otherwise regret in later years the missed opportunity to have cheered and helped each other as husband and wife. The couple's happiness is dispelled by an encounter with Alderman Cute who sanctimoniously lectures them on how they have brought their own misfortunes on themselves, and who promises to ‘Put down’ such people. The couple feel they barely have a right to exist, let alone to marry.

Trotty carries a note from Cute to Sir Joseph Bowley MP, who dispenses charity to the poor in the manner of a paternal dictator. Bowley is ostentatiously settling his debts, and berates Trotty because he is unable to pay a small debt to Mrs Chickenstalker, a local shopkeeper. Returning home, convinced that he and his fellows are naturally ungrateful and have no place in society, Trotty encounters Will Fern, a poor countryman, and his nine-year-old orphaned niece, Lilian. Fern has been accused of vagrancy and Trotty warns that Cute plans to have him arrested. Trotty takes Fern and Lilian home, and he and Meg share their meagre food and poor lodgings. Meg is distressed, and it seems the encounter with Cute has dissuaded her from marrying Richard.

Trotty sits up late with a newspaper and is reinforced in his belief that the working classes are naturally wicked by reading of a poor woman who in desperation has killed both herself and her baby. Suddenly, the Chimes burst violently in on his thoughts, and seem to call him to the church. Climbing to the bellchamber, he discovers a swarming, leaping cloud of dwarf phantoms that vanish as the Chimes cease. Then he sees the dark foreboding goblin figures of the bells. The goblin of the Great Bell berates him for the wrong he has done the Chimes in losing faith in man's destiny to improve.

Trotty sees himself lying dead at the base of the bell tower, and is told that he had fallen and died there nine years ago. Meg's life is to be an object lesson for him: he must "learn from the creature nearest to [his] heart" what pressures there are on the poor. There follows a series of visions in which, helpless to interfere, he is shown the troubled lives of Meg, Richard, Will and Lilian over the subsequent years. Richard descends into alcoholism; Meg eventually marries him in an effort to save him, but he dies ruined, leaving her with a baby; Will is driven in and out of prison; Lilian turns to prostitution[1] and dies of grief. At last, destitute and homeless, Meg is driven to contemplate drowning herself and her child. Trotty breaks down when he sees Meg poised to jump into the river, and cries that he has learned his lesson, that "there is no loving mother on the earth who might not come to this, if such a life had gone before". He finds himself able to catch her dress and prevent her from jumping.

Trotty awakens at home as the Chimes joyfully ring in the New Year on the day of Meg and Richard's wedding. Their friends arrive to provide a surprise feast and celebration. Will and Lilian are warmly greeted by Mrs Chickenstalker, who turns out to be an old friend. The author explicitly invites the reader to decide if this awakening is a dream-within-a-dream. The reader is asked to bear in mind "the stern realities from which these shadows come", and to endeavour to correct, improve, and soften them.

Trotty Veck by Kyd (Joseph Clayton Clarke)

Principal characters

[edit]
  • Toby "Trotty" Veck, the protagonist, a poor elderly messenger or "ticket-porter"
  • Margaret "Meg" Veck, Toby's daughter
  • Mrs Chickenstalker, a local shopkeeper
  • Alderman Cute, a Justice of the Peace
  • Sir Joseph Bowley, a rich paternalist MP
  • Will Fern, a countryman
  • Lilian Fern, Will's orphaned niece

Development history

[edit]

The book was written in late 1844, during Dickens's year-long visit to Italy.[2] John Forster, his first biographer, records that Dickens, hunting for a title and structure for his next contracted Christmas story, was struck one day by the clamour of the Genoese bells audible from the villa where they were staying.

All Genoa lay beneath him, and up from it, with some sudden set of the wind, came in one fell sound the clang and clash of all its steeples, pouring into his ears, again and again, in a tuneless, grating, discordant, jerking, hideous vibration that made his ideas "spin round and round till they lost themselves in a whirl of vexation and giddiness, and dropped down dead."[3]

Two days later Forster received a letter from Dickens which read simply: "We have heard THE CHIMES at midnight, Master Shallow!",[3] and the writing of the book began. Forster describes Dickens's intentions in writing The Chimes as striking "a blow for the poor".

"Charles Dickens reading 'The Chimes' to his friends in John Foster's chambers" by Daniel Maclise

They had always been his clients, they had never been forgotten in any of his books, but here nothing else was to be remembered ... he had come to have as little faith for the putting down of any serious evil, as in a then notorious city alderman's gabble for the putting down of suicide. The latter had stirred his indignation to its depths just before he came to Italy, and his increased opportunities of solitary reflection since had strengthened and extended it. When he came therefore to think of his new story for Christmas time, he resolved to make it a plea for the poor ... He was to try and convert Society, as he had converted Scrooge, by showing that its happiness rested on the same foundations as those of the individual, which are mercy and charity not less than justice.[3]

Dickens returned to London for a week in December 1844 and gave readings of the finished book to friends prior to publication, to judge its impact. The artist Daniel Maclise, who had contributed two illustrations to The Chimes and attended two of these events, portrayed the reading of 3 December 1844 in a well-known sketch.[4]

Title

[edit]

The chimes are old bells in the church on whose steps Trotty Veck plies his trade. The book is divided into four parts named "quarters", after the quarter chimes of a striking clock. (This parallels Dickens naming the parts of A Christmas Carol "staves" – that is "stanzas" – and dividing The Cricket on the Hearth into "chirps".)

Literary significance and reception

[edit]

A Christmas Carol had been extremely well received the previous year, and The Chimes aroused public interest and anticipation. Five different stage productions of the book were running within weeks of publication and nearly 20,000 copies were sold in the first three months. It had a high media profile, and was widely reviewed and discussed. Critical opinion was divided; those sympathetic to its social and political message liked the book, but others thought it dangerously radical. The Northern Star reviewer called Dickens "the champion of the poor"; John Bull rejected his unflattering caricatures of philanthropy.[5] It was certainly a financial success for Dickens, and remained popular for many years, although in the long term its fame was eclipsed by that of A Christmas Carol.

Allusions and references

[edit]

Adaptations

[edit]

In 1914, the book was made into a silent film, The Chimes, directed by Thomas Bentley.

A musical adaptation of The Chimes was created in 1992 by Lisa Kofod and Gay Donat Reed, with music by Paul Johnson. A staged reading of this work was produced at The Workhouse Theatre in New York City.

The Chimes was adapted into a 24-minute clay-animated film in 2000 by Xyzoo Animation. It won a Cine Special Jury award in 2002.[9]

The Colonial Radio Theatre in Boston produced a full cast radio production of The Chimes in 2000. This was released on CD by Blackstone Audio in 2007, and re-released by Brilliance Audio in 2011.

In 2004, a stage adaptation by Les Smith premiered at the Southwark Playhouse.

In 2015, Audible issued The Chimes as a free audible book with Christmas well wishes from the company to its subscribers.

In 2022, Average Romp released The Chimes as a full-cast audio dramatisation starring Toby Jones as Toby Veck.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Chimes

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a by , first published on 19 December 1844 by Chapman and Hall in . It marks the second installment in Dickens's series of Christmas books, following the success of the previous year. Illustrated by John Leech, the work features wood engravings that complemented its supernatural and social elements. The story centers on Toby "Trotty" Veck, a 68-year-old ticket-porter in , who supports himself and his daughter amid and waits for work outside a church on . Influenced by pamphlets echoing Malthusian theories that depicted the poor as burdensome and prone to vice due to , Trotty grows despondent and contemplates . Rescued by goblin spirits inhabiting the church bells, he ascends the tower and witnesses prophetic visions of catastrophic futures: his daughter reduced to and early death, his granddaughter to crime and , and broader into and during the "hungry forties." Awakening renewed, Trotty resolves against despair, embracing hope as a counter to fatalistic economic doctrines that rationalized neglect of the working classes. Dickens composed The Chimes during travels in and , drawing from the 1840s , Irish potato famine, and Chartist agitation to assail free-market policies like the and utilitarian views prioritizing statistical abstractions over individual suffering. The novella rejects empirical arguments for population controls and as excuses for systemic , instead positing moral warnings from the to spur . Commercially, it thrived with seven editions by May 1845, bolstering Dickens's influence on traditions despite dividing critics: admirers lauded its and urgency, while detractors deemed its anti-economist overwrought and less artistically refined than its predecessor. Dickens himself previewed it dramatically to friends, gauging its emotional resonance before release.

Publication and Composition

Development History

Following the success of A Christmas Carol in 1843, Charles Dickens sought to challenge pessimistic philosophies that portrayed the poor as inherently degraded and incapable of improvement, aiming instead to affirm their potential for moral and social agency. This motivation arose amid contemporary debates influenced by political economists and social critics, prompting Dickens to craft a narrative emphasizing resilience against despair. Dickens conceived The Chimes during his family's extended stay in , , beginning in July 1844, where the incessant pealing of church bells provided the story's auditory inspiration. He initiated writing there but returned to in mid-October 1844 to complete the novella amid intensive revisions. To refine the , Dickens organized private readings for select friends, including biographer John Forster and actor , at Forster's chambers, soliciting feedback to sharpen its emotional impact. For visual accompaniment, Dickens collaborated with prominent illustrators, personally persuading John Leech to contribute after a meeting on December 2, 1844, alongside contributions from , Richard Doyle, and Clarkson Stanfield. The work was finalized in late 1844 and published by Chapman and Hall on December 16, 1844, as Dickens's second Christmas book.

Title and Inspirations

The full title of the , The Chimes: A Goblin Story of Some Bells that Rang an Old Year Out and a In, originates from the central role of church bells in marking the temporal shift from one year to the next, with the bells embodying voices that convey prophetic warnings. Dickens derived this concept directly from the auditory landscape of , , where he resided in the summer and autumn of while composing the work. The city's numerous church towers produced a constant cacophony of chimes, which Dickens found both overwhelming and evocative, inspiring him to envision bells as sentient entities capable of discourse. This personal inspiration stemmed from Dickens's immediate sensory experience upon settling in , where the bells' relentless pealing across the urban expanse below his vantage point ignited the story's premise. In correspondence with his biographer John Forster, Dickens recounted how the sounds prompted reflections on time's passage and human folly, leading to the framework as a mechanism for instruction, diverging from the spectral ghosts employed in (1843). The goblins, tied intrinsically to the bells' mechanics, thus represent a localized, mechanistic supernaturalism rooted in Dickens's Italian sojourn rather than ethereal apparitions. By anchoring the in this real-world acoustic , Dickens extended his emerging of seasonal allegories into a New Year's context, using the chimes to symbolize renewal amid societal critique, while maintaining the festive imperative of hope that characterized his publications. The title's specificity to the bells' annual underscores Dickens's intent to evoke the liminal moment of year-end reflection, distinct from broader motifs.

Historical Context

Victorian Social Conditions

During the , Britain experienced continued industrial expansion following the initial phases of the , with coal production reaching approximately 30 million tons annually by 1840 and railway mileage expanding from 98 miles in 1830 to over 2,000 miles by 1845, facilitating greater economic output and . The urban population share rose from about 30% in 1800 to roughly 50% by 1850, concentrating workers in manufacturing centers like and , where employment grew amid mechanized and iron industries. This growth contrasted sharply with stagnant or low for many laborers, as agricultural wages hovered around 8-10 shillings weekly while urban factory pay often failed to cover basic sustenance, exacerbated by the from potato blights and poor harvests reducing food availability. The Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834 centralized relief administration through unions of parishes and Poor Law Commissioners, mandating workhouses over to enforce the "less eligibility" principle, whereby institutional aid was made less desirable than the lowest-paid labor. This reform reduced per capita poor relief expenditures by 43% between 1831 and 1871, with workhouse populations peaking at over 130,000 inmates by the mid-1840s, as local rates funded austere conditions including family separations and regimented labor. Parliamentary reports from the era documented widespread , with annual relief recipients numbering around 1.5 million by 1840, representing about 7-8% of England's , though urban destitution strained systems amid migration from rural areas. Urban working-class housing in industrial cities consisted largely of back-to-back terraces and cellar dwellings lacking ventilation and , with Edwin Chadwick's 1842 Sanitary Report estimating that one-quarter of Manchester's population lived in single rooms and average for laborers at 17 years in due to and outbreaks from contaminated water. Overcrowding was acute, as factories drew migrants into districts where multiple families shared privies and pumps, contributing to rates exceeding 200 per 1,000 births in towns like by the 1840s. Child labor permeated industries, with the 1842 Children's Employment Commission revealing over 23,000 boys aged 10-14 employed in coal mines alone, often for 12-16 hour shifts in hazardous conditions, while textile mills relied on pauper apprentices and family labor under minimal regulation until the 1844 Act limited women's and children's hours. Workhouses provided basic schooling to inmate children but prioritized labor extraction, reflecting the era's reliance on juvenile workers to supplement household incomes amid high fertility and mortality.

Political and Intellectual Debates

In the 1840s, Thomas Malthus's theories from An Essay on the Principle of Population (first published 1798, with revisions through 1826) continued to shape intellectual discourse on poverty and population, positing that population growth outpaced food supply, rendering the poor a perpetual burden exacerbated by relief systems that removed natural checks like famine and disease. These ideas underpinned the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, which restricted outdoor relief and mandated workhouses under the "less eligibility" principle, ensuring conditions deterred idleness and aligned with Malthusian warnings against subsidizing reproduction among the lower classes. Debates intensified over economics versus state intervention, with proponents like Nassau Senior defending minimal aid to preserve incentives for , while critics highlighted the 1834 Act's role in fostering resentment amid industrial urbanization. Anti-Poor Law agitation peaked in the early , particularly in , where unions protested conditions as dehumanizing and economically disruptive, fueling broader Chartist demands for parliamentary reform and linking to class antagonism. Countering Malthusian fatalism, Edwin Chadwick's Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population of (1842) employed statistical evidence from medical officers and data to attribute high mortality—such as death rates exceeding 50% in some urban districts—to preventable filth and rather than innate or alone. This utilitarian analysis, drawing on Benthamite principles, advocated centralized to reduce disease incidence by up to 13,000 annual deaths in alone, shifting debates toward environmental causation and empirical intervention over abstract demographic inevitability.

Narrative Elements

Plot Summary

On , Trotty Veck, a sixty-year-old ticket-porter, waits idly near the Church of St. Dunstan-in-the-West for messenger work, whiling away the time by listening to the ringing of its bells, known as the Chimes. His daughter arrives carrying a hot meal of and onions, which they share while she discusses her plans to marry her fiancé, , the next day at a modest registry office. The gathering is interrupted by Sir Joseph Bowley and his assistant Cute, who lecture Trotty on the idleness of the poor and decry Meg's impending marriage as irresponsible amid concerns over and ; they depart after distributing election handbills. Shortly thereafter, the laborer Will Fern enters with his orphaned young niece Lilian, seeking charity from the alderman, but receives only rebuke and expulsion for his poverty and perceived ; Trotty, initially swayed by the elite's views, relents and invites the pair to share his for the night. Deeply despondent over reports of societal ills, , and human degradation—exacerbated by the bells' ceaseless chiming that seems to mock him—Trotty climbs the dark spiral staircase of the at , resolved to end his life by jumping as the begins. Suddenly, goblin figures emerge from the bells, seize him, and compel him to witness prophetic visions of calamity befalling his family and others if such and self-destruction persist: Meg's dissolves into years of grinding toil and destitution, culminating in her driving their daughter to by in the Thames; Richard descends into drunkenness, , and ; Lilian starves amid neglect; and waves of vice, , and moral collapse engulf the lower classes. Trotty plummets from the tower in horror but awakens unharmed on at its base, interpreting the events as a admonition. He returns home to find and reconciled after a quarrel, their proceeding joyfully with support; Will Fern and Lilian receive aid rather than scorn; and even glimpses of the alderman's hypocritical feast underscore contrasts in fortune. Trotty, transformed, pledges ongoing vigilance against despair.

Principal Characters

Toby "Trotty" Veck serves as the central figure, portrayed as a sixty-year-old ticket-porter in who delivers summonses and messages for meager fees while lingering near St. Dunstan's Church. His character embodies humility and a light-hearted disposition amid chronic , often engaging whimsically with the church bells as if in conversation, though he proves susceptible to despondency when confronted with societal views on the . Margaret "Meg" Veck, Trotty's daughter, appears as a devoted young in her early twenties, characterized by her practical and resilience in supporting her father through domestic labors and simple meals. She maintains an optimistic outlook, fostering familial bonds despite economic hardships. Richard, Meg's fiancé, is depicted as an earnest apprentice striving for self-improvement through diligent work in his trade, rejecting unearned aid in favor of honest endeavor. His traits highlight determination and moral integrity among the aspiring laboring class. The goblins, ethereal messengers embodied by the spirits of the church bells, function as otherworldly guides who interact directly with Trotty, compelling reflection through vivid, admonitory encounters. They exhibit a stern yet instructive demeanor, drawing from the bells' resonant authority to influence human perception.

Themes and Analysis

Warning Against Despair and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies

In The Chimes, the goblins compel Trotty Veck to witness visions of his daughter 's future, revealing how his pervasive despair over the poor's fate directly precipitates the dire outcomes he fears. These spectral sequences depict 's illegitimate child suffering neglect and death, not as inevitable destiny, but as consequences of decisions stemming from Trotty's internalized conviction that breeds and helplessness. The goblins emphasize that Trotty's pessimistic —echoing views of the poor as inherently degraded—instills in , prompting her to forgo and , thereby enacting the very degradation Trotty anticipates. This narrative device underscores a causal wherein beliefs filter perceptions of opportunity, guiding choices that actualize negative expectations. Trotty's visions conclude with his own form haunting the living, symbolizing how unchecked propagates across generations, eroding agency and perpetuating hardship through diminished effort and resolve. Upon awakening, Trotty rejects this trajectory, affirming that , rather than fixed social conditions, determines life's course—a rejection validated by the novella's resolution where yields improved prospects for and her family. Empirical observations parallel this mechanism in poverty dynamics, where pessimistic beliefs form self-fulfilling cycles by suppressing in , , and . Economic analyses indicate that hopelessness fosters behaviors like reduced labor participation and , sustaining low-income equilibria despite potential escapes. corroborates that expectations of diminish and opportunity-seeking, mirroring Trotty's influence on Meg and contrasting deterministic interpretations by highlighting volitional agency over immutable constraints.

Emphasis on Personal Agency and Hope

Trotty Veck's arc in The Chimes exemplifies the narrative's for individual resilience against despair-induced passivity. Having absorbed tracts portraying the as inherently prone to vice and ruin, Trotty descends into fatalistic gloom on 1843, viewing his own honest labors as futile and contemplating . The bells' spirits compel him to witness a projected future born of this mindset: his daughter driven to and after her fiancé Will Fern's execution for , their orphaned grandson Richard's and amid societal scorn for the destitute. This vision culminates in Trotty's entreaty to the spirits, who affirm that such outcomes arise not from inexorable class destiny but from the "idle, proud, and discontented" yielding to "black despair," which poisons actions and propagates misery across generations. Upon awakening, Trotty's deliberate embrace of —exclaiming, "Lord! If a poor man's thoughts can help to tide it over... let us have for the !"—triggers a transformative rejection of victimhood. His renewed volition manifests in active support for 's prospects, rejecting the predicted tragedies through personal resolve rather than awaiting systemic . The story's resolution validates this agency: by January 1, 1844, secures a viable union with Will, who channels into legitimate enterprise, yielding familial stability and their grandson's upbringing in opportunity, not destitution. Dickens thereby illustrates causal realism, wherein mindset-driven choices interrupt downward spirals, countering narratives that attribute trajectories solely to external conditions without regard for human initiative. This emphasis underscores proactive as antidote to self-fulfilling , with Trotty's post-vision conduct—urging others to "hope, and trust in "—fostering resilience amid Victorian . Unlike deterministic philosophies absolving individuals of responsibility, the tale posits agency as pivotal: despair begets through inaction, while equips one to navigate hardships via ethical perseverance, as evidenced by the Veck family's averted . Scholarly readings affirm this as Dickens' rebuke to passive , prioritizing volition over fatalistic excuses that exacerbate social ills.

Critiques of Class Attitudes and Malthusianism

In The Chimes, published in , Dickens critiques the condescending class attitudes of Victorian elites toward the , particularly their utilitarian rationalizations for viewing laborers as a societal burden. Alderman Cute, a self-appointed reformer, exemplifies this by urging restrictions on poor marriages and reproduction, declaring to the displaced laborer Will Fern that "any man who... presumes to lead the life of a human creature... must be a vicious man," thereby dehumanizing the impoverished as irresponsible breeders exacerbating . This stance mirrors Thomas Malthus's 1798 Essay on the Principle of Population, which argued that unchecked among the lower classes outstrips resources, necessitating moral restraints like delayed marriage to avert famine and vice. Complementing Cute's approach, Sir Joseph Bowley, the wealthy styling himself the "Poor Man's Friend," displays paternalistic condescension by dispensing annual New Year's gifts to select dependents, ostensibly for self-improvement but in practice fostering dependency and moral lectures on . Bowley insists the poor should emulate his benevolence rather than agitate for , reflecting a broader elite tendency to prioritize statistical abstractions—such as Mr. Filer's ledgers tallying human lives as consumable "figures"—over individual agency or hardship. Dickens targets not the economic theories themselves but their deployment to justify elite self-interest, as administrators applied selectively to suppress working-class vitality while ignoring aristocratic excess. Dickens implicitly rebuts these dehumanizing views by depicting the poor's resilience and ethical fortitude amid adversity, as seen in Trotty Veck's daughter defending honest labor against elite calumnies and Will Fern prioritizing his niece's welfare despite . Such portrayals challenge the "surplus " notion—echoed in contemporary —by affirming the poor's capacity for virtue and contribution, not mere subsistence. Yet the narrative balances this by attributing societal ills more to the poor's internalized acceptance of inferiority complexes imposed by elites, rather than immutable structures; Trotty's initial echo of Malthusian despair underscores how self-doubt perpetuates cycles of want, resolvable through renewed personal resolve over collective reform. This emphasis aligns with Dickens's broader advocacy for individual as a counter to both condescending and deterministic economics.

Allusions and Symbolism

The church bells, known as the Chimes, symbolize the collective voice of , their peals incorporating direct allusions to contemporary political rhetoric and statistical arguments on . In the , the bells articulate phrases drawn from Malthusian doctrines, such as warnings against the multiplication of the poor and justifications for limiting relief, reflecting debates in publications like Thomas Malthus's An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798, revised editions through 1826). These vocalizations parody the era's utilitarian and political speeches, including references to rates and the moral hazards of charity, as heard by the on the bells' tower steps. Trotty Veck's visions, induced by the goblin spirits of the bells, contain specific allusions to the social fallout from the 1834 Poor Law Amendment Act, which centralized relief in workhouses and curtailed outdoor aid, exacerbating urban hardship. Scenes depict destitute individuals contemplating by drowning in the Thames, mirroring documented increases in London river suicides during the and 1840s amid economic distress and welfare restrictions; one vision shows a young , burdened by , attempting self-destruction, echoing real cases reported in parliamentary inquiries and newspapers. Further visions portray among the impoverished, linking such acts causally to the law's stigmatization of the poor as morally deficient, without broader thematic judgment. The goblins, anthropomorphic embodiments of the bells baptized by bishops centuries prior, evoke traditions of mischievous spirits tied to ancient church artifacts, manifesting as ignored societal warnings through their forms and prophetic guidance. Their depiction blends ecclesiastical with pre-Christian folk motifs of bell-associated entities, underscoring textual references to lost baptismal records dating back to .

Reception and Criticism

Contemporary Reviews and Sales

Upon its release on December 16, 1844, The Chimes enjoyed immediate commercial success, selling over 20,000 copies almost at once. This rapid sales volume, following the precedent set by A Christmas Carol, generated substantial profits for Dickens and his publishers, Chapman and Hall, though exact royalty figures for the novella remain undocumented in primary accounts. Critical reception distinguished between the work's commercial appeal and its didactic intensity. Liberal-leaning periodicals, such as the Illustrated London News, praised its moral vigor, describing the novella as "replete with refined sentiments… which must humanise and elevate the heart" and a timely effort "for the reform of social abuse, and the uprooting of deeply-rooted popular error." Reviewers in radical outlets like the Chartist Northern Star hailed Dickens as a champion of the poor for his assault on pessimistic views of the working classes. Conservative publications offered more qualified or negative assessments, critiquing the propagandistic tone and perceived overreach in social advocacy. The John Bull condemned it for promulgating "low Radical doctrines," reflecting unease with its challenge to prevailing economic orthodoxies. Even sympathetic reviewers noted drawbacks, with the Illustrated London News observing that the goblin elements were "less jocund than the ‘Ghost’ of last year" and the plot construction less robust than its predecessor. Such divisions underscored a broader political split, where liberal and reformist voices embraced the message against despair and class prejudice, while others viewed it as excessively partisan.

Political Interpretations and Controversies

Interpretations of The Chimes frequently portray it as a liberal assault on and Malthusian doctrines, with Dickens lambasting the dehumanizing tendency to reduce the poor to statistical "surplus " or inherent burdens on society. Characters such as Mr. Filer, who fixates on utilitarian metrics like the caloric waste of consumed by the impoverished, embody this , underscoring free-market indifference to human dignity amid the economic hardships of the 1840s. Alderman Cute and Sir Joseph Bowley further exemplify patronizing attitudes that dismiss the as skivers deserving minimal aid, reflecting prevalent views that stems from personal failings rather than structural inequities. Countering such readings, perspectives emphasizing individual responsibility interpret the as a rebuke to defeatist mindsets that foster dependency and self-sabotage, prioritizing hope and over systemic excuses for failure. Trotty Veck's vision illustrates how internalizing elite dismissals of the poor's worth precipitates familial , whereas renewed resolve averts , thereby debunking entitlement-driven narratives and affirming that despair functions as a inhibiting . Contemporary controversies erupted along ideological lines, with liberal and radical outlets lauding the work for humanizing the downtrodden and challenging Malthusian that erodes sympathy for their emotional lives. In contrast, reviewers decried it as peddling "low Radical doctrines," viewing its goblin-orchestrated indictments of parliamentary hypocrisy and economic abstraction as inflammatory likely to incite unrest among the lower classes. Even as some conservative voices acknowledged its narrative potency, the partisan rift highlighted fears that Dickens' blend of fantasy and social satire risked sentimentalizing grievances without prescribing practical reforms, potentially entrenching victimhood over disciplined aspiration.

Scholarly Perspectives and Legacy

Scholars in the twentieth century, including and Edward Wagenknecht, viewed The Chimes as a critique of pessimistic attitudes toward social reform, positing that despair among the undermines effective action and perpetuates stagnation. Wagenknecht highlighted Dickens's concurrence with Chesterton that reformers influenced by lack the motivational force needed for change, framing Trotty Veck's visions as a causal demonstration of how internalized hopelessness manifests in destructive outcomes. Later analyses emphasize the novella's psychological realism in portraying anti-pessimism, where supernatural elements serve as metaphors for cognitive mechanisms like self-fulfilling prophecies driven by class-based . A study in Dickens Studies Annual defends the integration of fantasy and realism, arguing that the goblins' prophecies empirically mirror how mental states influence real-world behaviors and futures, rather than mere . This approach anticipates modern understandings of mindset's role in resilience, as the text causally links Trotty's initial to projected societal decay, averted only through renewed agency. The work's enduring legacy resides in contesting normalized despair within discourses, rejecting deterministic views that attribute destitution to inherent flaws or . Dickens targets Malthusian principles, which posited exponential outstripping resources as an inexorable cause of , by illustrating how such ideologies foster self-sabotage among the impoverished; instead, and effort emerge as pivotal causal agents for improvement. identifies The Chimes as Dickens's most explicitly radical narrative, directly impugning elite rationalizations that absolve systemic neglect by deeming the poor fated to misery. In 2010s–2020s scholarship, these elements inform debates on versus structural , with The Chimes cited for its prescient emphasis on individual volition countering narratives of inevitable decline. Matthias Bauer's examination portrays the bells' chimes as symbolizing a rhythmic, life-affirming pattern that combats modern , linking Victorian to contemporary calls for proactive mindset shifts amid economic . This interpretation underscores the novella's relevance in critiquing overly fatalistic analyses, prioritizing of agency-driven recoveries over ideologically biased in academic and policy discussions.

Adaptations and Influence

Early Stage and Media Adaptations

Shortly after its publication on 27 December 1844, The Chimes received prompt theatrical adaptations in . Mark Lemon and Gilbert Abbott à Beckett, with Dickens's authorization, premiered their version at the on 19 December 1844, just days before the novella's release, capitalizing on advance publicity from Dickens's readings. This adaptation retained core elements like Trotty Veck's visions induced by the church bells' spirits, though stage constraints necessitated simplifications of the supernatural sequences compared to the printed text. Subsequent media adaptations remained sparse through the , far fewer than those of , attributable to the story's elaborate goblin lore and dream-vision structure, which posed challenges for visual realism in early and . A British directed by Thomas Bentley appeared in , starring Stewart as Trotty Veck and emphasizing the moral redemption arc amid working-class poverty, but it deviated by streamlining the bell-spirits' prophecies into more linear narrative beats for cinematic pacing. In radio, the Colonial Radio Theatre produced an audio in the late , faithful to the dialogue and Toby's suicidal despair resolved by hopeful intervention, while preserving the auditory chimes as a central motif. Television adaptations were minimal; a 1999 short narrated by aired, focusing on Toby's bell-inspired epiphany but condensing the future visions to fit 24 minutes, thus altering the temporal scope of the original's warnings. These early efforts generally adhered to the novella's in portraying personal despair yielding to agency, though practical limitations often muted the allegorical intensity of the spirits' interventions.

Broader Cultural Impact

The Chimes formed a pivotal element in ' Christmas book series, which from 1843 to 1848 reshaped holiday literature by embedding narratives of moral awakening and communal benevolence against the backdrop of industrial-era destitution. As the second installment after , published on December 16, 1844, it amplified Dickens' vision of Yuletide as a catalyst for ethical , influencing subsequent festive traditions that prioritize familial and acts of over mere revelry. This contributed to the broader Victorian resurgence of observances, where stories like The Chimes fostered a cultural norm of seasonal , evidenced by increased charitable donations and public readings that drew crowds exceeding 1,000 in by the late 1840s. Through its portrayal of protagonist Trotty Veck's descent into despondency and subsequent revelation via goblin-induced visions, the advanced a cultural pivot in conceptualizing not as an inexorable fate dictated by theories but as a condition amenable to individual volition and renewed purpose. Dickens explicitly targeted Malthusian pessimism, urging readers to reject self-defeating prophecies that perpetuate hardship, a stance that resonated in an era of Poor Law debates and urban squalor reports documenting over 100,000 inmates in by 1844. This messaging permeated public sentiment, aligning with reformist calls for personal upliftment that echoed in parliamentary discussions on welfare by the . In literary traditions, The Chimes endures as an for tales valorizing solitary ethical resolve over institutional dependency for transcending adversity, a motif traceable in later works emphasizing self-empowerment amid . Its integration into annual anthologies and family readings sustained a favoring intrinsic , influencing 20th-century interpretations of Dickensian themes in popular media that highlight resilience as key to social harmony.

References

  1. https://www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?an=Charles%2BDickens&fe=on&pics=on&sortby=1&tn=The%2BChimes
  2. https://www.historyhit.com/culture/charles-dickens-books-in-order/
  3. https://victorianweb.org/art/illustration/chimes/gallery.html
  4. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/xmas/chimes2.html
  5. https://writersinspire.org/content/chimes-dickens%E2%80%99s-new-year-carol
  6. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/xmas/ilnreview.html
  7. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2932389
  8. https://commonreader.wustl.edu/let-charles-dickenss-the-chimes-invigorate-your-sense-of-hope/
  9. https://inews.co.uk/culture/television/dickens-in-italy-david-harewood-review-2815491
  10. https://www.dickensfellowship.org/index.php/central-fellowship-news/301-exhibition-celebrates-dickens-s-links-with-genoa
  11. https://writersinspire.org/content/chimes-dickens%25E2%2580%2599s-new-year-carol
  12. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/xmas/chimes4.html
  13. https://www.italymagazine.com/featured-story/tale-one-city-charles-dickens-genoa
  14. https://wreninkpaper.com/2022/12/26/this-week-in-the-dickens-club-the-chimes/
  15. https://kids.kiddle.co/The_Chimes
  16. https://www.vam.ac.uk/blog/museum-life/chiming-in-the-new-year-with-dickens-2
  17. https://files.ehs.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/29061004/Craft4a.pdf
  18. https://englishancestors.blog/2024/09/20/housing-the-urban-poor-in-19th-century-england/
  19. https://www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2013/jun/05/britains-working-classes-changes-since-1840s
  20. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/education/resources/1834-poor-law/
  21. https://eh.net/encyclopedia/english-poor-laws/
  22. https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/livinglearning/coll-9-health1/health-02/
  23. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7186836/
  24. https://learncheme.com/wp-content/uploads/Prausnitz/QualityofLife/TechnologyChildLaborCoalMines.pdf
  25. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/historical-journal/article/malthus-and-the-poor-law/F3860F08D70A3DB888D0EF3FC6EDC411
  26. https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/80535/1/745868568.pdf
  27. https://www.libertarianism.org/publications/essays/laissez-faire-nineteenth-century-britain-fact-or-myth
  28. https://jepson.richmond.edu/signature-programs/summer-institute/papers2015/pdf/MMontaigneSIpaper2.pdf
  29. http://protesthistory.org.uk/the-story-1789-1848
  30. https://victorianweb.org/history/chadwick2.html
  31. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2140185/
  32. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953617307281
  33. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/653
  34. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/97/97-h/97-h.htm
  35. https://www.nber.org/system/files/chapters/c13832/c13832.pdf
  36. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/313664188_Self_Fulfilling_Prophecy_Perpetuation_of_Poverty_and_a_Means_to_Solve_It
  37. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/46/46-h/46-h.htm
  38. https://dickenssociety.org/archives/4701
  39. https://fee.org/articles/a-tale-of-two-stories/
  40. https://crisismagazine.com/opinion/the-chimes-by-charles-dickens
  41. https://thomaslmcdonald.wordpress.com/2014/12/15/dickens-on-hope-and-despair-the-chimes/
  42. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/653/653-h/653-h.htm
  43. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/diniejko.html
  44. https://financialpost.com/opinion/how-charles-dickens-rebukes-overpopulation-fearmongers-like-scrooge-malthus-and-even-todays-environmentalists
  45. https://academic.oup.com/book/36591/chapter/321563429
  46. https://shs.cairn.info/revue-etudes-anglaises-2012-1-page-80
  47. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/an-underground-history-of-early-victorian-fiction/social-citizenship-in-the-poor-law-debates/384012178B62A3B9E08EBBE66AF96BC3
  48. http://victorian-studies.net/dickens/misc/andrews-dickens.pdf
  49. https://theseaofbooks.com/2024/02/02/the-bestselling-english-novels-of-the-19th-century-ranked-part-one/
  50. https://www.victorianweb.org/art/illustration/chimes/review.html
  51. https://www.enotes.com/topics/charles-dickens/criticism/criticism/edward-wagenknecht-essay-date-1931
  52. https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1651646
  53. https://www.jstor.org/stable/i40182823
  54. https://www.jstor.org/stable/29770051
  55. http://www.englit.uni-tuebingen.de/wp-content/uploads/Bauer-Matthias-The-Chimes-and-the-Rhythm-of-Life.pdf
  56. https://www.victorianweb.org/victorian/mt/theaters/pva234.html
  57. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/dickensian-dramas-volume-1-9780198787952
  58. https://fisherdigitus.library.utoronto.ca/exhibits/show/christmas/stories
  59. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1720257/
  60. https://www.averageromp.com/the-chimes/
  61. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/xmas/pold1.html
  62. https://dornsife.usc.edu/news/stories/how-charles-dickens-created-christmas-as-we-know-it/
  63. https://egarp.lt/index.php/aghel/article/download/227/224
  64. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/276842040_Sentiment_and_Vision_in_Charles_Dickens%27s_A_Christmas_Carol_and_The_Cricket_on_the_Hearth
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
Contribute something
User Avatar
No comments yet.