Hubbry Logo
Alternative versions of SupermanAlternative versions of SupermanMain
Open search
Alternative versions of Superman
Community hub
Alternative versions of Superman
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Alternative versions of Superman
Alternative versions of Superman
from Wikipedia

Alternate versions of Superman
Variations of Superman throughout DC Comics' publications' parallel universes and alternate timelines. Interior artwork from Superman vol. 1, #708 (April 2011 DC Comics)
Art by Eddy Barrows
PublisherDC Comics
First appearanceAction Comics #1 (April 1938)
Created byJoe Shuster
Jerry Siegel
CharactersSuperman (Kal-L)
Superman (Earth-22)
Superboy-Prime
Ultraman
Hank Henshaw
Eradicator
Superman (Kal Kent)
Bizarro
Negative Superman
Superman – Calvin Ellis (Kalel)
Superman (Val Zod)
See alsoSuperman in other media

The character of Superman was created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, and has been continually published in a variety of DC Comics book titles since its premiere in 1938. There have been several versions of Superman over the years, both as the main hero in the stories as well as several alternative versions.

In mainstream comic continuity

[edit]

Originally, there was only one Superman. However, beginning in the late 1940s, demand for comics shifted from superheroes as war, horror, science fiction and romance comics became more popular. Most of the DC Comics superhero titles were cancelled or began featuring the more popular genres. Superman, along with Batman and Wonder Woman, continued to be published. To explain how Superman could have been active as a young man in the 1930s when later stories show Superman still youthful in the 1960s, DC Comics developed a multiverse, the existence of several realities. The original Golden Age Superman was retconned to Earth-Two, while the then-currently published hero was assigned to Earth-One.

In addition to these main two "official" variations of the standard Superman character, a number of characters have assumed the title of Superman in many variant stories set in both primary and alternative continuity. Following the storyline of The Death of Superman and during the subsequent Reign of the Supermen storyline, a number of characters claimed the mantle. In addition, Bizarro, for instance, is an imperfect duplicate of Superman. Other members of Superman's family of characters have borne the Super- prefix, including Supergirl, Krypto the Superdog and, in some instances, Superwoman.

Pre-Crisis 1938–1986

[edit]

Superman was first published in 1938. In 1986, DC Comics published Crisis on Infinite Earths, a 12-issue series designed to clean up and establish a new continuity for DC, affecting not only Superman, but all of the DC Comics characters. The versions of Superman from this time period are traditionally divided into three main periods.

Golden Age 1938–1950s

[edit]

The first version of Superman began being published by DC Comics in 1938 appearing in Action Comics #1. To explain discrepancies in the aging of Superman across several decades, his earliest stories were retroactively portrayed as having taken place on an alternate world called Earth-Two. These stories take place from 1938 until the late 1950s, although the exact dividing line is unclear and some stories happened identically to both the Golden Age and Silver Age Supermen. The Golden Age Superman started his career leaping tall buildings rather than flying, had heat from his x-ray vision and not heat vision as the Earth-One hero did. In addition, he had a very limited ability to change his facial features to resemble other men of similar height and build that the other Superman lacked. The Golden Age Superman (Kal-L) is the first primary superhero of Earth-Two, who began his career as an adult and emerges just before World War II. He is a member of the Justice Society and, during World War II, the All-Star Squadron. As Clark Kent, he works for the Daily Star as a reporter and eventually becomes editor-in-chief. Clark eventually marries Lois Lane[1] and settles down with her for several decades, and when Kal-L's long-lost cousin Power Girl arrives on Earth, they become her surrogate parents.[2] Kal-L is erased from Earth's history after the events of Crisis on Infinite Earths, but survives and enters a "paradise" dimension. During the Infinite Crisis event, both Kal-L and the Earth-Two Lois are killed.[3] His main two foes are the Ultra-Humanite and the red-haired Lex Luthor. In addition, his "S" symbol on his chest is generally drawn in a less distinctive manner.[4] Stories taking place in the 1970s and 1980s featuring this version of Superman are usually labelled as Earth-Two stories.

Silver Age 1950s–1971

[edit]

The more significant differences between the Golden Age version (later equated with Kal-L of Earth-Two) and Silver Age version (Kal-El of Earth-One) of Superman includes the Silver Age Kal-El beginning his public, costumed career as Superboy at the age of eight,[5] more than a decade before nearly all other Earth-One heroes. Superboy only finds super-powered peers in the 30th-century Legion of Super-Heroes, though he also meets as a teenager Earth-One's only other major superpowered hero, "Aquaboy" (the teenaged Aquaman).[6] Lex Luthor meets Superboy in Smallville when they are teens; the two are briefly friends before they become mortal enemies, years before they become adults.[7] As an adult, Clark Kent works at the Daily Planet and Superman is a founding member of the Justice League of America.

The Silver Age Superman was typically characterized as being more grounded in reality than previous depictions, in that he was portrayed with a realistic appearance and embedded within logical and rationalistic narratives.[8] While these were still based on the science fiction of his earlier iterations, Superman was portrayed in storylines that sought to uncover the mysteries of the world through observation and the use of evidence, including the concept of limits and the consequences of human action. This definition is attributed to Curt Swan, who was the principal artist of Superman comics from 1955 to 1985.[9] Swan's extensive work on the character, which was responsible for much of the public perception of the superhero, emphasized anatomical realism, embedding in the character a sense of Norman Rockwellesque Americana.[9] This depiction of the superhero resonated with the readers as indicated in the way some observers saw their own lived experiences in his stories.[10]

Bronze Age 1971–1986

[edit]

In 1971, Dennis O'Neil and Julius Schwartz set out to simplify Superman's elaborate framework. They streamlined the Superman mythos by downsizing his abilities and reducing his power levels. This version only lasted a few issues.[11] DC attempted more of a soft reboot in the 45th Anniversary issue of Action Comics. Lex Luthor and Brainiac were updated and modernized to make them more visibly dangerous for Superman.[12] The Silver/Bronze Age (Earth-One) Superman was given a send-off in the Alan Moore-penned "imaginary story" Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? (1986). Colloquially known as "The Last Superman Story", it was a conclusive ending to Superman's story as a character. The story was originally conceived by senior editor Julius Schwartz, who designed a goodbye for the hero in his final two Superman issues (prior to the John Byrne The Man of Steel relaunch) – Superman #423 and Action Comics #583 (1986). Both comics were illustrated by the long-tenured, mainstay Superman artist Curt Swan.

Other Pre-Crisis versions

[edit]

Before Crisis, the Multiverse was also used to explain an "evil" version of Superman from Earth-Three as well as other versions that officially existed. Earth-95 had Superman's father Jor-El rescue his entire family.[13] Earth-149 saw Lex Luthor succeed in killing Superman.[14] Earth-Prime was designated as the "real" world, even though Superboy-Prime is from that universe. This version of Clark Kent is from a world without other superpowered beings, where he grows to adolescence reading about the DC superheroes in comic books. During the Crisis on Infinite Earths, he gains powers like those of the Silver Age Superboy and helps to defeat the Anti-Monitor. However, his own world is lost and Superboy-Prime himself is confined to Limbo.

In addition to official versions, other stories listed as "What Ifs" or imaginary stories which were not originally an official part of DC continuity. One example, Superman Red/Superman Blue was the subject of several story lines. The Silver Age version of the tale was an "imaginary story" in which Superman splits into two beings, one which marries Lois Lane, and the other marries Lana Lang, and both are happy. Both retained their powers, with one having all red removed from his costume and the other having all blue removed. In Superman #300, a story imagines what would have happened if Superman had landed in the middle of the Cold War, with both the U.S. and the USSR trying to capture the capsule as it is landing. Kent is a reporter for a worldwide news service, and takes the name Skyboy.[15][unreliable source?]

Post-Crisis: 1986–present

[edit]

The Multiverse system was discarded in the aftermath of Crisis on Infinite Earths limited series (1986) by rebooting all of DC's various stories and continuities into one timeline taking place on a single Earth (later described as New Earth). A more modern adaptation of the mainstream "Earth-One" Superman debuted in John Byrne's The Man of Steel miniseries in 1986. The post-Crisis Superman was the Superman from 1986 to 2011. Superman's backstory was heavily revised and many Silver Age elements, such as his career as Superboy, were removed.[16] Significant changes included a reimagining of all Kryptonians being genetically bound to Krypton, making it fatal for them to leave the planet. Jor-El devises a serum to counter this, which he administers to baby Kal-El. DC used this plot device to make Superman Krypton's sole survivor until this was retconned in the mid 2000s to introduce the post-Crisis Kara Zor-El. Krypton was also reimagined as an emotionless and sterile society where all children are grown in a birthing matrix as Kryptonians find sexual reproduction to be barbaric. Clark never becomes Superboy, with his powers manifesting gradually as he matures in age. His power level is also toned down to where he is no longer able to travel through time with his super speed, is not strong enough to push planets out of orbit like his Silver Age incarnation, and will be at least disorientated if not outright hurt if forced to confront a nuclear explosion. Clark also spends some years traveling the globe trying to find himself after leaving Smallville and before settling in Metropolis, performing various low-key rescues before a crashing plane forces him to make a more public debut. Other differences include Lex Luthor as a business mogul with secret criminal dealings rather than a supergenius scientist who is a known crook to the public; both of his parents alive and well in the present; only green kryptonite existing (until the mid 2000s) and Superman thinking of himself as Clark Kent first, with "Superman" being a persona he adopts to preserve his privacy. Nuances in the characters mythos were later defined in various Superman origin stories, such as Superman: Birthright, where Mark Waid retooled Superman's origin in 2003. The trend continued after Infinite Crisis; when Superman's backstory was retooled once again by Geoff Johns, with Superman: Secret Origin in 2009.

The single-Earth continuity retained the dichotomy of a good and evil Superman by introducing an alternate version of Superman's Earth-Three double, Ultraman in the Antimatter Universe surviving the Crisis, as presented in JLA: Earth 2. Alternative Supermen were also depicted using literary devices such as time travel and "Hypertime". The subsequent sequel to Crisis, titled Infinite Crisis, would see a brief return of the Golden Age Superman, Kal-L as well as the teenage Superman of a world without heroes, who survived the original Crisis. The modern take on the Superman Blue/Red was a controversial storyline in which Superman develops energy-based powers while losing his original powers, and acquires a corresponding new costume. He eventually splits into two versions of the energy-Superman, known as Superman Red and Superman Blue, before the two Supermen manage to find a way to work together and merge back into one entity.

Due to the events of Infinite Crisis, as revealed in the subsequent weekly series 52, a new multiverse consisting of 52 alternative Earths was created, with most worlds featuring new alternative depictions of Superman. This backstory was kept intact for over a decade until it was revised in Superman: Birthright (2003) by Mark Waid, and then further modified following the events of Infinite Crisis (2006),[17] with the essence of the changes being elaborated on in the subsequent "Superman: Secret Origin" six-issue story arc written by Geoff Johns (debuted September 2009). Many of the Silver Age elements of Superman's biography (such as his meeting Lex Luthor at a younger age and his teenage membership as Superboy in the Legion of Super-Heroes) that were removed in The Man of Steel were restored in these continuity changes. Nonetheless, many of the elements added in the Man of Steel revamp remain in place. This version finally returns in the Convergence (2015) crossover where he and Lois have a son named Jon. Later the three of them travel back in time to the original Crisis on Infinite Earths (1985) to avert the collapse of the original Multiverse.

Another fresh incarnation of Superman was introduced in September 2011 in the wake of DC's Flashpoint event and as part of The New 52 publishing relaunch, and was retired in 2016 following the restoration of the post-Crisis Superman. The New 52 Superman's backstory is detailed in the first story arc of the second volume of Action Comics (2011–2012). This latest incarnation of Superman incorporates elements of nearly every previous version, and starts off as a reporter for the Daily Star (later changing to the Daily Planet). He and Lois are friends but not lovers, his parents are dead, and it is not until adulthood that he emerges as Superman. Later, after joining the Justice League, he starts a relationship with Wonder Woman. During the Truth storyline his secret identity is revealed to the world and he largely loses his powers after using a new power he calls a 'Solar Flare'. He struggles with vulnerability for the first time while fighting crime in an improvised way, while also dealing with not being taken as seriously, problems in his relationship with Wonder Woman that eventually cause him to end it, and regaining his powers. However, a combination of different trials, such as exposing himself to kryptonite to purge himself of the radiation inhibiting his powers and absorbing energy from the fire pits of Apokolips, compromise his health. After undergoing tests at the Fortress, Superman confirms that he is dying, eventually turning to dust after saving lives one last time. After this Superman's death, the Post-Crisis Superman- trapped in this reality after the events of the Convergence storyline- takes both his place as the current Superman and his place in the current Justice League, and, with the DC Rebirth initiative (the publisher's attempt to set right unpopular character changes) this Superman is told that there is more to the story of his replacing New 52 Superman than he realizes. At the conclusion of the "Superman Reborn" storyline, the histories of the pre-Flashpoint and New 52 Superman and Lois Lane are merged, effectively writing over the New 52 era as if it never happened and creating another soft reboot for characters in the Superman franchise.[18][19]

Alternative universe depictions

[edit]

Earth-1

[edit]

In the Silver Age of Comic Books, Earth-1 was home to the mainstream version of Superman known by most readers of DC Comics. Following DC's Flashpoint event, The New 52 Earth-1 is the setting of the Earth One graphic novel series, where Superman is one of a handful of heroes just starting out in modernized retellings of classic origin stories.

Val-Zod (Earth-2)

[edit]

Following 52 (2006), a nearly identical Earth-2 is created with only subtle differences like the Justice Society and Infinity, Inc. combining into the Justice Society Infinity, Green Lantern Alan Scott being dead and Superman being missing for years. Following Flashpoint (2011), the Earth-2 concept is revised again. After Kal-El is killed in an invasion of Earth by Darkseid, a new Kryptonian who resembles a blue eyed black man emerges as Superman, Val-Zod, a pacifist who reconsiders his beliefs to defeat an evil clone of Kal-El. Val-Zod is the son of the deceased Zod who, along with Power Girl, are both adopted by Jor-El and Lara.

Ultraman (Earth-3)

[edit]

There are several versions of the evil Superman analogue, which begins with Ultraman, who as originally introduced is Superman's evil analogue from Earth-Three. After the Multiverse concept was retired, Ultraman was introduced as an alien from Qward with powers similar to the original; this version made only one appearance. DC later attempted the "evil universe" trope again with the Antimatter Universe in JLA: Earth 2 (2000), introducing an Ultraman who is Lt. Clark Kent, a human astronaut who is experimented on during a deep space mission. He is a member of the Crime Syndicate of Amerika. Following DC's series 52, the maxiseries Countdown introduced a new "Golden Age" Ultraman from the new Earth-3, a member of the Crime Society of America. This Ultraman and his team are analogues for the elder Superman and the Justice Society Infinity of the new Earth-2. Following The New 52 reboot, DC revised Earth-3 again with Forever Evil (2013–14), making Ultraman of Earth-3 Superman from Earth-0's evil counterpart and a Kryptonian once again.

Captain Allen Adam (Earth-4)

[edit]

The Superman of Post-Crisis Earth-4 is Captain Allen Adam, the Quantum Superman, and one of the most powerful beings in all of the 52 Earths. An amalgamation of Captain Atom (a Charlton Comics superhero based on Superman and later acquired by DC) and Doctor Manhattan of the Watchmen maxiseries (who is a pastiche of Captain Atom), Air Force Captain Allen Adam gained his quantum abilities when he was disintegrated in a blast caused by an experimental U-235 engine. The U-235 particles fused with his body, and his disembodied consciousness built an enhanced copy of his former body, but he keeps his "quantum senses" at a managed level by using drugs. He is one of the Supermen from throughout the Multiverse who are recruited by the Monitor Zillo Valla in Final Crisis: Superman Beyond, and allows the drugs in his system to wear off in order to reach a grander state of being, fusing the consciousness of Ultraman and Superman together in order to operate the Superman Robot in the Monitor world and fight Mandrakk, the Dark Monitor.[20][21] This version of Captain Atom is revisited in The Multiversity: Pax Americana (2015), which details his origin in more depth.

Captain Marvel (Earth-5)

[edit]

On the Post-Crisis Earth-5, Superman's closest analogue is Captain Marvel (originally a Fawcett Comics superhero) as shown in Superman: Beyond and Final Crisis.

Herr Superman and Hyperious (Earth-8)

[edit]

Earth-8 is a Marvel Comics pastiche world, home to villains Lord Havok and the Extremists, who are opposed by Avengers pastiche characters the Meta Militia (a modernization of the Champions of Angor). When visited during Countdown, a German Superman called "Herr Superman", who serves in Monarch's army, is seen, but it is not certain what world he is from. In The New 52, Earth-8 is home to a Superman analogue named Hyperious who is a pastiche of Marvel's own Superman pastiche Hyperion. He is a member of an Avengers pastiche team named the Retaliators. Hyperious' current whereabouts are unknown.

Harvey Dent (Earth-9)

[edit]

The Superman from DC's Tangent Comics imprint is a radically different character from the traditional Superman. Due to an experiment conducted on an entire town by a government black ops group called Nightwing, Harvey Dent was the lone infant survivor of a failed super-human program that killed hundreds. After growing to adulthood, and falling from the world's tallest building in an attempt to save a suicidal man, his dormant powers activate and he develops advanced physical and psychic abilities. Evolving millions of years past normal humans, he eventually becomes a "modern-day superhero".[22] He is illustrated as a tall, bald, African American man wearing a blue robe, and carrying a staff. This version of Superman has become the most powerful person on Earth. After attempting to give his wife the same powers as his, through what he thought was a safe version of the experiment, which resulted in her apparent death, Superman instead married that reality's version of Power Girl and decided to protect the entire world by conquering it, as seen in Tangent: Superman's Reign. This Earth is numbered Earth-9 in the DC Multiverse.

Overman (Earth-10)

[edit]

Earth-10, which is under the control of the Nazi Party, depicts an alternative Superman, usually known as Overman, who supports the Nazis' policy of genetic purity. He is a member of the JL-Axis, a Nazi-themed Justice League. Two conflicting artistic renditions of this Superman have been shown. One is a stereotypical blond Aryan with a Nazi swastika replacing the S-shield, while the other is a black-haired twin of the standard Superman with an "S" resembling one from the Schutzstaffel emblem. The first blond-haired Superman, along with most of the JL-Axis was likely killed when they were fighting the Monitors on Earth-51 and that entire universe was destroyed by Superman-Prime and Monarch. The second, called Overman, is Karl Kant, a.k.a. Kal-L, whose rocket from Krypton crashed in a field in Czechoslovakia in 1938. Nazi scientists retro engineered technology found in the rocket to win the war, and later unleashed Overman to defeat the USA forces in the 1950s. Overman leads the New Reichsmen, his world's Justice League, consisting of Brunhilde, Leatherwing, Blitzen, Martian Manhunter, Underwaterman, while fighting Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters.[20] He is still mourning the death of his "cousin" Overgirl, from injuries sustained during her crossing of the Multiverse's interstitial Bleed medium.[23] He has growing doubts about his past use as enabler of the Nazi victory, especially after his discovery of an expanded Nazi Holocaust in North America during the fifties and sixties. He is apparently immortal. Although he attempts to halt the fall of the Eagles Ayrie due to the Freedom Fighters' sabotage, he is unable to prevent its impact in Metropolis and the death of millions.[23] Distraught over Metropolis' destruction, added with his guilt over the millions of deaths that his regime was responsible for, Overman flees Earth for years which causes the Nazis to create a cyborg replacement to take Overman's place.

Superwoman (Earth-11)

[edit]

On the gender-reversed Earth-11, Earth's greatest hero is Superwoman.

In Superman #349 ("The Turnabout Trap!"),[24] Superman returns from an interstellar mission to find that everyone on Earth is of the opposite sex. Among them are Penny White (a female Perry White), Jenny Olsen (a female Jimmy Olsen), Louis Lane (a male Lois Lane), Batwoman (a female Batman, rather than the actual character), Wonder Warrior (a male Wonder Woman), Black Condor (a male Black Canary), Superlad (a male Supergirl), and Superwoman (his female counterpart) herself. Believing he crossed into a parallel universe, Superman flies back to space to find a dimensional portal but is blocked by an invisible barrier. He notices the parallelism fails when he sees Superwoman and Clara Kent (Superwoman's presumed secret identity) are two separate people.

When he confronts Superwoman he discovers that he is regarded as a super-villain in this gender-reversed world, which leads to a battle with Superwoman, Superlad, and Wonder Warrior. They manage to trap Superman with Wonder Warrior on guard, but he manages to escape and takes Wonder Warrior's magic lasso with him. Superman figures out that his foe Mr. Mxyzptlk is behind this gender-reversed world. This was partly due to the discrepancy of Clara Kent and Superwoman being different people. However, Mxyzptlk's biggest mistake was being too vain to give himself a reverse-gender counterpart in Superwoman's rogues gallery in the Daily Planet morgue; all of Superwoman's foes were reverse-gender counterparts to Superman's foes (Leslie Luthor (Lex Luthor), Bizaress (Bizarro) and the Toywoman (Toyman)) – except for Mxyzptlk. Superman discovers as well that he was never in a parallel universe, but rather on Earth, which Mxyzptlk had altered with his magic. After using Wonder Warrior's magic lasso to make Mxyzptlk say his name backward and thus returning him to his native dimension, the effects of Mxyzptlk's magic (including the existence of Superwoman) vanish, returning the Earth to normal. Upon his return to his Clark Kent identity, he is startled to discover there is still a Louis Lane, but he turns out to be Lois Lane's cousin.

Later stories, including Countdown and The Multiversity, revisit the concept of a gender-reversed Superman known as Superwoman, and designated those stories as taking place on Earth-11 of the DC Multiverse.

Superdemon (Earth-13)

[edit]

On Earth-13, Superman's role is filled by Superdemon, a character who shares characteristics with Etrigan the Demon and Superman, and who leads the League of Shadows in a world of magic and cloak-and-dagger adventures.

Christopher Kent (Earth-16)

[edit]

Christopher Kent of Earth-16 is introduced in Countdown: Arena (2008) as a "more evolved" Superman who was able to reformat his power source to any energy source he could consciously choose, effortlessly overcoming the Earth-30 and Earth-31 Supermen with energy powers in a head-to-head battle. He was bald and wore a simple black T-shirt and jeans. He dies in an attempt to defeat Monarch using a massive amount of energy that burns out his body. The Earth-16 concept is refreshed following Flashpoint (2011). In The Multiversity (2015), Chris Kent, Superman's son, is the inheritor to his father's legacy in a world with no villains left to fight.[25]

Overman (Earth-17)

[edit]

The Superman of Pre-Crisis Earth-17 was the original Overman, created by the government as were the other heroes of this Earth. Likewise, all other heroes that were created were modified clones of Overman's cell scrapings, such as versions of Wonder Woman, Flash, and Green Lantern. Some time later, Overman went on a homicidal rampage (due to an STD which had affected his mind) and murdered everyone on the planet before he decided to commit suicide and destroy the planet at the same time with a doomsday bomb. This world was destroyed, and Overman was wiped out by the Crisis, until the Psycho-Pirate began bringing back characters the Crisis had killed in Animal Man #23, Overman and bomb included, despite trying not to remember him. Overman fought against Ultraman and Animal Man, before Overman was dragged out of the comic book panels and wiped out by a closing panel, ranting that it was not his fault he was like that before Animal Man disarmed the bomb.[26] In The New 52 DC Multiverse, Earth-17 is the world of the Atomic Knights and lacks a known Superman analogue.

Saganowana (Earth-18)

[edit]

Earth-18 is based on the Justice Riders comic; Superman's analogue is Saganowana, a bison-headed Native American hero.

The New Frontier (Earth-21)

[edit]

In Darwyn Cooke's DC: The New Frontier, Superman is one of the heroes of Earth-21, who has been active since the '40s, and still is during the events of the storyline, which occurs during the 1950s. As in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, he is a government agent, but unlike DKR, he is willing to go against the U.S. government when he feels that the tensions between the humans and superhumans has to end. He is also a friend of Batman, rather than his foe as he is in Dark Knight Returns.

Kingdom Come (Earth-22)

[edit]
The Kingdom Come Superman. Art by Alex Ross

The Kingdom Come miniseries shows an alternative future in which Kal-El went into self-imposed exile following the death of Lois Lane. He returns after ten years at the behest of Wonder Woman. This alternative Superman resides on Earth-22. He appeared in DC's mainstream continuity in the Justice Society of America story "Thy Kingdom Come", where he joined the Society in battling Gog. The Kingdom Come Superman is more powerful and less vulnerable to kryptonite than his younger mainstream counterpart, due to far greater exposure to yellow sun radiation (as explained by his Earth's Lex Luthor in the miniseries). He travels to the mainstream continuity in Justice Society: Thy Kingdom Come, and, after returning to his home universe, lives to see the formation of the Legion of Super-Heroes in the 31st century.[27]

Calvin Ellis (Earth-23)

[edit]

Final Crisis #7 introduces an African-American version of the Man of Steel who is the President of the United States in his secret identity, President Calvin Ellis (with the Kryptonian name of Kalel). Writer Grant Morrison confirmed that this Superman is a homage to President Barack Obama.[28] This Superman appears to be multiracial with both African and European features and wears the same costume as the New Earth Superman, except that his "S" insignia is yellow with a red backdrop. In Action Comics vol. 2 #9 (in The New 52) this Superman is redesigned to appear with full African features and a new costume. On Earth-23, African American heroes have risen to positions of prominence (such as Nubia being Wonder Woman)[29] inspired by Superman's legacy. He also leads Earth-23's Justice League and originates from Vathlo Island on Krypton. He plays a big role in The Multiversity (2014–2015) and forms the Justice Incarnate, a team of superheroes from throughout the Multiverse who combat multiversal threats. In Injustice 2, he makes a cameo appearance in Green Arrow's ending working with Red Son Batman, and Flashpoint Wonder Woman to combat the threat posed by various incarnations of Brainiac and ends up saving Green Arrow's Earth from his universe's Brainiac.

Captain Carrot (Earth-C/Earth-26) and Super-Squirrel (Earth-C-Minus)

[edit]

The 1980s series Captain Carrot and His Amazing Zoo Crew presented the parallel Earths of Earth-C and Earth-C-Minus, worlds populated by talking animal superheroes. Earth-C is home to the heroic Captain Carrot, who does not share Superman's patterning but does have similar abilities and standing in his universe. Earth-C-Minus parallels the mainstream DC Universe, with animal superheroes as members of the superhero team "Just'a Lotta Animals" (JLA). Superman's Earth C-Minus analogue is Super-Squirrel, a Chiptonian alien who is jealous of Captain Carrot's relationship with the Wonder Woman analogue of the world.[30] Since 52, the Zoo Crew has resided on Earth-26, and appeared as prominent heroes in Final Crisis (2008), The Multiversity (2014–2015) and Convergence (2015). It is not known if the inhabitants of Earth-C-Minus are on a new Earth.

Bizarro Superman (Earth-29)

[edit]

In the current DC Multiverse, Earth-29 is a cube-shaped and ringed Bizarro World in a "damaged continuum" that also hosts Sram (Mars-29), Nnar (Rann-29) and Raganaht (Thanagar-29). It is uncertain whether its Bizarro Superman, therefore, also originated on Notpyrk (Krypton-29).[31]

Red Son Superman (Earth-30)

[edit]
The Red Son Superman. Art by Dave Johnson.

Superman: Red Son explores what would have happened if Superman's ship had crashed in the Soviet Union instead of the United States and was raised under the control of Joseph Stalin. The Red Son Superman's birth name is stated to be Kal-L, the same as the aged pre-Crisis Earth-Two Superman, though he is essentially immortal as shown at the end of this mini-series. Moreover, he is from Earth's distant future and is a descendant of Lex Luthor and Lois Lane. A younger alternative Communist version of the Red Son Superman resides on Earth-30. The Earth-30 Superman was captured by Monarch and forced to join his war against the Monitors in the Countdown series. He is later seen in Final Crisis #7, flying along with 50 other Supermen.

Dark Knight Returns Superman (Earth-31)

[edit]

Prior to Flashpoint, Earth-31 is the setting of Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns, The Dark Knight Strikes Again and All Star Batman and Robin the Boy Wonder, first visited in Countdown: Arena #1 (2007).[32] In The Dark Knight Returns and its sequel, Superman is a pawn of the American government in a dystopian United States in the supposed 1980s, and mention of him by the media is implied to be strictly forbidden by the Federal Communications Division. Although Batman and Superman are no longer friends, Superman shows a grudging respect for the Caped Crusader in The Dark Knight Returns, and regrets when his fellow hero supposedly dies.

Flying Fox Superman (Earth-31)

[edit]

Following Flashpoint, in the New 52 DC Multiverse, the Earth-31 Superman is a member of the Flying Fox pirate crew on a post-apocalyptic waterworld. The Flying Fox crew is led by a version of Batman named Leatherwing.[31]

Super-Martian (Earth-32)

[edit]

On Earth-32, the closest equivalent to Superman is a fusion of that character and the Martian Manhunter, known as Super-Martian. Super-Martian is a member of the Justice Titans.[31]

Savior (Earth-34), Supremo (Earth-35), and Optiman (Earth-36)

[edit]

On Earth-34, Savior is the strongest terrestrial metahuman, although his origin and appearance differ from that of Superman, in that he is a survivor of ancient Mu, an Indian Ocean lost continent.[31] Meanwhile, Earth-35's Supremo is its alternate Superman, as is Earth-36's slain Optiman. Creator Grant Morrison has said that these three Supermen and worlds are based on Justice League pastiches created by other writers for rival DC publishing houses, now pastiched in turn by DC and made a part of its official Multiverse.[33]

Zod/Clark Kent (Earth-40)

[edit]

On the world of JSA: The Liberty Files, on the pre-Flashpoint Earth-40, the Superman was Zod, a sociopath banished to the Phantom Zone for creating a deadly synthetic plague when he was eleven. When American scientists breached the Zone in an experiment, they found Zod. He feigned almost no memory of his home or his name. Renamed Clark Kent, he was sent to live with the Kents under supervision from the Pentagon, and then began running tests on his powers when they started to develop. Zod fooled most of his superiors by acting dumb, while at the time he was murdering other agents looking for a device called "the Trigger", a device which could simultaneously detonate all power sources on the planet like bombs. Zod, knowing that, if activated, the Trigger would set off nuclear warheads, and that radiation was the only thing that could harm him, wanted the Trigger so he could destroy it. He was finally taken down by the other costumed agents, until the combined forces of the Bat and the Star were able to trap Zod in an orb of nuclear energy in space.

The post-Flashpoint Earth-40 has no such individual resident; it is a pulp fiction world dominated by villains, and an "opposite" world for Earth-20.[34]

Chibi Superman (Earth-42)

[edit]

A "Super deformed" version of Superman, Batman and the Justice League of America appeared in Superman/Batman #51 and #52. Grant Morrison's Action Comics (2011) run and The Multiversity later establish this world to be Earth-42 of the Multiverse.

Gold Superman (Earth-44)

[edit]

On Earth-44, the Superman of that world is a robot, a member of the Metal Men, robotic versions of Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman, Green Arrow, and Hawkman, created by Doc Tornado, an amalgamation of the Red Tornado and Will Magnus. Their base of operations separated with their Earth and collided with New Earth during Final Crisis #7, but New Earth's magnetic fields causes them to go berserk and attempt "technocide", destroying most of the mementos in the trophy room before they were shut down by Luthor and Dr. Sivana. He is given the name Gold Superman in The Multiversity Guidebook.

Superman and Superdoom (Earth-45)

[edit]

Earth-45 is visited in Grant Morrison's Action Comics run. On this world, Clark Kent is a genius who with Jimmy and Lois intends to invent a robot – Superman – to protect the world. However, the company Overcorp creates a twisted Superman in the form of Superdoom, who rampaged the Multiverse until he was defeated by the Earth-23 Superman.

Sunshine Superman (Earth-47)

[edit]

Sunshine Superman is a version of Superman who was initially lost in the destruction of the multiverse after the first Crisis. He first appeared as a memory projection of Psycho-Pirate along with his teammates in the Love Syndicate of Dreamworld: Speed Freak (an alternative female version of the Flash) and Magic Lantern (an alternative version of Green Lantern) in Animal Man #23 and 24 (May–June 1990). However, his world was subsequently recreated in the reborn DC Multiverse and he is seen in Final Crisis #7 flying with various other Superman analogues. He is portrayed as a tall, muscular, African-American man with an Afro and a yellow sun shaped S-shield. His name is a reference to the song "Sunshine Superman", by British singer Donovan. In The New 52, Sunshine Superman and other members of his Love Syndicate of Dreamworld exist on Earth-47 (which is based on the culture of the 1970s) and are financed by the immortal teen president "Prez" Rickard .[31]

Apollo and Mister Majestic (pre-Flashpoint Earth-50)

[edit]

DC's darker Wildstorm Comics imprint was designated as Earth-50 between 2005 and 2011, but Earth-50 was later merged with Earth-0 at the conclusion of Flashpoint; another Earth-50 then took its place. On the Wildstorm (pre-Flashpoint) Earth-50, Apollo is identified in Final Crisis #7 as a Superman of his world. Apollo was genetically enhanced to be a solar powered super-being. He is a member of the superhero team, the Authority, is openly gay, and is married to his superhero partner Midnighter, an analogue of Batman.

Mister Majestic of the Wildstorm (pre-Flashpoint) Earth-50 is also shown in Final Crisis #7 as a Superman analogue. Majestros is an alien warlord from the planet Khera who crashed his ship on Earth thousands of years ago while at war with the Kherans' longtime enemies, the Daemonites. He and his fellow Kherans protect the Earth until the present day inspiring many of Earth's myths and legends. He is also an off and on member of the superhero team the WildC.A.T.s and Earth-50's most powerful hero. For a time, Majestros was transported to the main DC Universe and filled in for Superman while he was trapped in Kandor. Majestros is nearly as strong as Superman with advanced longevity and is a born warrior with great intellectual prowess and centuries of experience.

Justice Lord Superman (post-Flashpoint Earth-50)

[edit]

Following Flashpoint and the merger of Earth-0 and the Wildstorm Universe, Earth-50 is home to the Justice Lords, an antagonistic counterpart of the Justice League who were originally created for the Justice League animated series. On this world, Superman murdered President Lex Luthor in retaliation for his killing of the Flash, Wally West, prompting the Justice League to rebrand as the Justice Lords.

Icon (Dakotaverse)

[edit]

The superhero Icon is mentioned in Final Crisis: Superman Beyond #2 as being an analogue to Superman. Icon is an alien named Arnus from the planet Terminus who crashes his lifepod in the southern United States in 1839, and is found by an African American slave woman. The lifepod alters his DNA to match the male equivalent of hers, but to a highly evolved rate. After more than a century and a half he does not physically age past the age of 40 and has near Superman-level strength and similar powers. He works as a high-class attorney in his secret identity of Augustus Freeman IV, and protects and resides in the city of Dakota. Originally, Icon resided in an alternative reality of unknown designation until his universe was merged with the mainstream DC Universe after the events of Final Crisis.

Kal-El (Unknown Universe)

[edit]

The first African-American version of Superman depicted was in Legends of the DC Universe: Crisis on Infinite Earths (February 1999), which saw a Kal-El and Kara who were husband and wife, and who had been selected as the last survivors of Krypton through polling selection. This Superman died early in the one-shot, leaving Supergirl to carry on, ultimately sacrificing herself.

Pocket Superboy (Pocket Universe)

[edit]

The Pocket Universe Superboy was created as an explanation for the existence of the Legion of Super-Heroes after Crisis on Infinite Earths. He originates from a pocket universe created by the Time Trapper and is essentially identical to the Silver Age Superboy, the young version of Superman who becomes a Legion member.[35] This version of Superboy dies saving Earth of the Pocket Universe in Legion of Super-Heroes #38 (1987), years before he would have become Superman.

Superboy-Prime (Earth-Prime)

[edit]

Superboy-Prime, or Superman-Prime, or simply Prime is from a parallel Earth called Earth-Prime, devoid of any superhumans. There, Superman and the other comic superheroes were fictional characters, as they are in real life. The Earth-Prime universe was erased during Crisis on Infinite Earths, and Superboy-Prime ended up in a "paradise" dimension where, during that time, he found himself unable to let go of his former life and destiny as Earth's greatest hero.

Over time, his convictions and morals become twisted, and he came to believe that Earth-Prime was the only proper Earth and that he himself was the only one worthy of the Superboy mantle. Prime firmly believes that being Superman is his calling despite the fact that he has become a psychotic, murderous, and even sadistic villain. His overwhelming strength, speed, unpredictability, and ruthlessness made him one of the most dangerous foes in the DC Universe.

Following a number of conflicts with the heroes of the mainstream DC Universe, the Dark Nights: Death Metal event saw Superboy-Prime returned to his home universe, which was altered from what he knew, but nonetheless his true home.

Prime Superman (All-Star Superman)

[edit]

The Superman featured in Grant Morrison's 12-issue All Star Superman, is a compassionate, gentle and altruistic Superman who, according to series writer Grant Morrison, is the Silver Age Superman, or at the very least has a virtually identical backstory.

In his secret identity, Clark Kent acts as a bumbling fool, but each seeming mistake subtly helps those around him. After being overdosed with solar radiation, his cells begin to die, the very source of his powers seemingly killing him. He attempts to make his final adventures as meaningful as possible, revealing his identity to his universe's Lois Lane, aiding the scientist Leo Quintum, and inspiring the Superman Squad of the future.

After a final confrontation with Lex Luthor, who had orchestrated Superman's solar overexposure, Kal-El flies into the sun to construct it an artificial heart. While the people of Earth believed Superman dead, he in truth lived within the sun until his final task was complete. Superman left behind his genetic code, so that Quintum could create the genetic son of Lois and Clark, the second Superman.

Absolute Superman

[edit]

Set on the reality of Alpha World, DC's Absolute Universe line of comics feature a world where superheroes are seen as outcasts and underdogs due to the world having been created and powered by Darkseid.

In this timeline, Superman arrives on Earth as an adolescent, rather than as an infant as depicted in many other versions of the character. Because this version of Kal-El never grew up amongst "Earthlings", he lacks humanity, as seen when he becomes reluctant to hunt down Christopher Smith due to the overwhelming desire to kill Smith for murdering innocent civilians.

Other characters known as Superman

[edit]
  • Kon-El, the modern Superboy, is a clone created from the combined genetic material of Superman and Lex Luthor. He arrived in Metropolis shortly after Superman's death.[36] When the original Superman returned, he declared that the clone had earned the name "Superboy", much to his dismay. Superboy eventually became a hero is his own right, and Superman came to think of him as family, giving him the Kryptonian name of Kon-El and the human alias Conner Kent.
  • Hank Henshaw was one of several to claim the name of Superman, following the original's death. To differentiate him from the others, the press dubbed him the Cyborg Superman.
  • The Eradicator also emerged as a Superman impostor, "the Last Son of Krypton", during the Reign of the Supermen. No longer able to absorb energy directly from the Sun, he used Kal-El's body as a power source. He eventually became delusional and believed himself to be Superman, but this taught him humanity. He eventually gave his life to stop the Cyborg Superman and restore Kal-El's powers.
  • John Henry Irons made a suit of armor and cape emblazoned with the Superman-insignia, as tribute to the fallen Man of Steel. Unfortunately, he was lumped in with the other Superman impostors, even though he made no claim to the name. Eventually dubbed "Steel" by the resurrected Superman, he became a close ally and friend to Kal-El.
  • The Superman Dynasty is the line of Superman's descendants and successors, featured in DC One Million. In this story, his first direct successor is called Superman Secundus. In the 853rd century, Kal Kent is the last scion of the dynasty, and leader of Justice Legion A.[37]

Bizarros

[edit]

Bizarro is the imperfect copy of Superman. There have been many incarnations of the character, varyingly portrayed as evil or as well-meaning but destructive. The Bizarros share many of the strengths and weaknesses of Superman, although there are some minor differences relating to kryptonite coloring and certain Kryptonian powers, for instance the Bizarros have at times been characterized by having heat breath and freeze vision.

  • Bizarro Superboy was the first version of Bizarro to appear in comics, making his first (and only) appearance in Superboy #68 (1958). Created by accident, Bizarro Superboy is a misunderstood monster who only wants to be accepted, but most residents of Smallville, including Superboy, regard him as a menace. The only friend he makes is a blind girl, and in the end he sacrifices himself to restore her sight.
  • The Silver and Bronze Age Bizarro #1 is accidentally created by Lex Luthor's duplicating ray when he uses it against Superman. Not only does he survive his initial encounter with Superman, he eventually gains a cast of supporting characters such as Bizarro versions of Lois, the Daily Planet staff, and the Justice League, and, eventually, Htrae, a cube-shaped world filled with Bizarros. His story comes to an end in Superman: Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow? He strives to be the "perfect imperfect duplicate" of Superman, after being manipulated by Mr. Mxyzptlk. Since Superman saves people, he goes on a murder spree, and since Superman is a survivor of Krypton, he kills himself.
  • The Man of Steel miniseries, which rebooted the Superman mythology in 1986, presents the first modern Bizarro, who is originally created by Lex Luthor. Because Luthor is unable to adequately replicate Kryptonian DNA, the clones' bodies would degenerate into a chalky-skinned caricature of the Man of Steel.[38] This Bizarro, too, sacrificed his life to restore the eyesight of a blind girl, Lucy Lane, that had befriended him.
  • Bizarro #1 is the only modern Bizarro that has survived, although he is not created like the others; having stolen the powers of Mr. Mxyzptlk, the Joker creates him (along with a Bizarro version of Batman, named Batzarro).[39]
  • In All-Star Superman, an entire race of Bizarros appear, spawned from a cube-shaped planet in another universe. Originally opaque, shapeless beings, they take on skewed characteristics of people they encounter.
  • In Superman: Red Son, Bizarro was one of many creatures created by Lex Luthor and the CIA in attempts to destroy the threat posed by the Communist Superman. This version was very similar in appearance to Solomon Grundy and wore a uniform similar to the original Golden Age Superman. He was said to have many of the same powers and abilities as Superman. After endangering much of London in his battle with Superman, Bizarro sacrificed himself to save the city from a nuclear detonation.
  • The Multiversity Guidebook (2015) reveals that Earth-29, also known as Htrae, is a parallel world populated by Bizarro characters.

Other alternative depictions

[edit]

Between 1989 and 2004, DC's Elseworlds imprint was used to showcase unofficial alternative universe stories; before 1989, "Imaginary Stories" served the same purpose. Since 2004, stories outside of the main DC continuity have carried no particular name or imprint. The examples listed below are just a few of the many alternative versions of Superman depicted in these stories.

Frank Miller's Superman

[edit]

Frank Miller's Superman, the Superman of All Star Batman & Robin, the Boy Wonder, is not the same as the Superman of All-Star Superman. The artist of All-Star Batman, Jim Lee, has stated that he is based on the Golden Age Superman,[40] which is why he is shown running on water instead of flying.[41] However, they make no mention of this in the actual comic. Conversely, Frank Miller's Superman is seen flying in his other comics about Batman. This is notionally the same Superman who will evolve to the jingoistic government agent seen in The Dark Knight Returns and The Dark Knight Strikes Again, at least from Miller's authorial point of view, as there is no official canonical link between the All-Star and Dark Knight continuities yet.

Superman: The Dark Side

[edit]

In Superman: The Dark Side (1998), Kal-El's rocket is diverted from Earth to Apokolips, and Superman is raised by Darkseid.

Superman: True Brit

[edit]

Superman: True Brit is a humorous re-imagining of Superman in which the ship crashed in England and his career as a superhero is severely limited both by glory-averse adoptive parents and the scandal-hungry tabloid press.

Superman, Inc.

[edit]

Superman, Inc. sees a world where Kal-El was placed in an orphanage rather than being found directly by the Kents, starting a chain of events that led to 'Dale Suderman' suppressing all memory of his powers after his foster mother died in an accident when she fell down a flight of stairs after witnessing him flying, Dale becoming withdrawn for years until he eventually found an outlet in sports. As a result, he becomes a major sports star and media figure, but when his actions undermine Lex Luthor's position, Luthor's research into his background exposes his otherworldly origins. At the story's conclusion, after a conversation with police detective 'John Jones' about his possible future, Dale goes into hiding as 'Clark Kent', taking journalism classes to find a normal life after publicly proclaiming that he is leaving Earth to investigate his true history and donating his fortune to a charitable foundation.

Superman: Kal-El's

[edit]

In Superman: Kal-El's, Kal-El's rocket lands on Earth in the Middle Ages, where he becomes a blacksmith's apprentice in a village ruled by Baron Luthor, who seeks to marry Lady Loisse, daughter of the village's murdered protector Lord Lane. After Kal uses his powers to forge the "silver egg" his parents found him in into a suit of armour for Baron Luthor, he asks for Loisse's hand in marriage as payment, but Luthor takes Loisse to his own bed on her wedding night due to an old feudal law- able to overpower Kal due to a kryptonite gemstone he wears- subsequently beating her to death while raping her. When Kal recovers the following morning, he leads a revolt against Luthor using a sword he forged for himself at the same time as he made Luthor's armour (the sword is implied to be Excalibur) In their final confrontation, Kal manages to slay Luthor, but he is severely wounded by Luthor's gemstone in the process, the story concluding with him being laid to rest in the lake where Loisse's body was thrown after her death.

Superman: Speeding Bullets

[edit]

Superman: Speeding Bullets has Superman found and adopted by the Waynes and christened Bruce. He sees his foster parents murdered in front of him and grows up to be a superpowered Batman, but decides to change tactics after a confrontation with the Joker (in this reality an insane Lex Luthor) and a conversation with Lois about the need for him to inspire rather than intimidate. Earlier imaginary stories, such as the stories of "Bruce (Superman) Wayne" told in Superman (vol. 1) #353, #358 and #363 (1980–1981), also explored the scenario of the infant Kal-El being adopted by the Waynes.

Superman: Last Son of Earth

[edit]

Superman: Last Son of Earth is a dramatic role reversal for many Superman traditions. In this story, he is Clark Kent, biological son of Jonathan and Martha Kent, who is sent into space to escape the impending destruction of Earth by collision with a space rock. He lands on Krypton and is adopted by Jor-El and Lara as their son, Kal-El, eventually discovering an Oan power ring.

Superman: Secret Identity

[edit]

In Superman: Secret Identity, a teenage boy named Clark Kent in the "real world" (where Superman is a just a comic book character) somehow develops superpowers like those of his namesake. After a brief career as a mysterious, non-costumed "Superboy", Clark dons the fictional character's colors and continues to work in secret as "Superman".

Superman & Batman: Generations

[edit]

Superman & Batman: Generations I-III, three limited series which present a unified cohesive history of many elements seen throughout the characters' history, with the characters interacting in real time from the early 20th century onward.

Batman: Holy Terror

[edit]

In Batman: Holy Terror (1991), the body of an alien known simply as "the Green Man" with a similar origin to Superman is shown, and his origin is described during this story. When he sees the body of the Green Man, Batman is struck by sorrow, feeling as though the world has lost its greatest hope. During the confrontation with Saul Erdel, the scientists responsible for analysing various superhumans for the Star Chamber, Erdel is killed when a bullet ricochets off the Green Man's chest to strike Erdel.

52 Pick-Up

[edit]

The Booster Gold story arc "52 Pick-Up" briefly depicts a Superman in Booster Gold #3, when showing a timeline where Superman was found by Lionel Luthor and raised as Lionel Jr. alongside Lex Luthor. Lex finds out his brother's secret and ends up killing him a year later.

Hypertension

[edit]

The Hypertension storyline in Superboy #60–64 (1999) shows an alternative version of Conner Kent named Black Zero. Black Zero is a genetically altered human clone of Superman that has successfully grown to adulthood after Superman is killed by Doomsday. For a time, he acts as the new Superman, even calling himself Superman 2. He exhibits both Superman's abilities as well as Superboy's tactile telekinesis. Without Superman alive to look up to, he instead views Paul Westfield as a father figure. Eventually he turns to evil after a battle between himself and several of Superman's enemies results in the deaths of Matrix, Brainiac and over 300 innocent people which causes widespread persecution of clones. He first conquers his Earth, then enlists the help of the New God Metron to travel to alternative realities and conquer them as well to protect the clone community. He is defeated by the combined efforts of Conner, multiple versions of Superboy and the Challengers of the Unknown. He is lost in Hypertime at the end of the story and has not been seen since.

Unlimited Access

[edit]

In Unlimited Access, a limited series which further explored themes introduced in DC vs. Marvel, the hero known as Access formed an amalgamation of what appeared to be the Silver Age versions of Thor and Superman (in his then-current blue energy form). Together, they were known as Thor-El.[42]

Just Imagine…

[edit]

In the Just Imagine… series, Superman is reimagined as a police officer from Krypton named Salden who is accidentally transported to Earth and only wishes to go home. He becomes a superhero because he believes Earth's primitive technology is a result of humans squandering their resources fighting crime, corruption, and other ills, and that alleviating these problems will allow humanity to advance to the point of creating a means to send him home. He has superhuman strength and speed, and wears a flying harness. This version was created by Stan Lee and John Buscema.

Marvel/DC Crossovers

[edit]

In the majority of the Marvel/DC crossovers, Superman is from the same universe as many Marvel characters, as in an Elseworlds story.

JLA: Shogun of Steel

[edit]

JLA: Shogun of Steel (2002), set in feudal Japan, features a Japanese Superman.

Supermen/Batmen

[edit]

Multiple versions of Superman appeared in Superman/Batman #25's "Supermen/Batmen", who come to aid the mainstream Superman. Among them are Bizarro #1; Superman Red; a blond-haired Superman; a Superman depicted as a stereotypical African-American; a Superman with a different style "S" shield resembling the Golden Age Superman's in Action Comics #1; and a black-suited, long-haired Superman from "The Return of Superman".

Injustice: Gods Among Us

[edit]

Injustice: Gods Among Us (2013) is a video game and tie-in comic book depicting a world in which Superman presides over an authoritarian regime. In this alternate universe, Superman is married to Lois Lane, who becomes pregnant with his child. However, the Joker tricks Superman into killing Lois and their unborn son, and a nuke placed on Lois' heart detonates upon her death, destroying Metropolis and killing millions. Driven over the edge by this, Superman kills the Joker in retaliation at the time when Batman was interrogating Joker. Afterwards, Superman takes drastic measures to "save" the world, forcing people to follow his will and killing those who resist.

JLA: The Nail

[edit]

JLA: The Nail and JLA: Another Nail show a Superman in which Kal-El was raised by Amish folk instead of the Kents. His Amish upbringing delays Superman from revealing himself to the world, which places Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) as the leader and most powerful member of the Justice League until Superman's discovery. This Superman is more humble, less in touch with the outside world, calmer and less experienced than other incarnations.

Flashpoint

[edit]

In the alternative timeline of the Flashpoint event, Kal-El's rocket crashed directly into Metropolis, resulting in the deaths of over thirty-five thousand people, and the infant was subsequently taken into government captivity to control his powers for uses to make supersoldiers.[43] Sam Lane takes a liking to him, as he becomes the son Lane never had. Kal-El later makes friends with Krypto, who was also being held in the facility, but they are separated after Kal fails to appease the government workers. Kal-El is helped by Neil Sinclair to free himself, and attacks Sam. Kal-El makes his way to Lane's office, where he finds Lois Lane, Sam's young daughter. Sinclair attempts to kill Lois, but Kal protects her. Sam uses a Phantom Zone gun to send himself and Sinclair into the Phantom Zone. Afterward, Kal-El is deemed Subject 1 and placed in a government underground bunker life sentence by General Nathaniel Adam.[44] Sometime later, attempting to rally support in his attempt to restore the timeline to normal, the Flash, aided by Batman and Cyborg break into the facility where Kal-El is being kept, only to find a very thin man incapable of speech who seems terrified just at the sight of others. Once they break out into the daylight, Kal-El rises into the air. He uses his heat vision on the attacking guards and flies away.[45] Kal-El arrives in Western Europe and rescues Lois from the Amazons who are attempting to kill her. Just as the two reunite, Sinclair attacks them. While Sinclair fights some Amazons, Lois tells Kal-El that he must leave. He refuses and says that he learned from Sam that they must protect people from villains like Sinclair. Kal-El overloads Sinclair's body with energy and punches him through the chest, killing him in a huge explosion; Lois is unfortunately caught in the blast. Kal-El holds the dying Lois in his arms, and Lois tells him to save the people.[46] Kal-El arrives at the scene of the Atlantean/Amazon war and intends to attack both leaders Aquaman and Wonder Woman at the last battle.[47]

In the sequel Flashpoint Beyond, the Flashpoint reality has been restarted after Prime-Earth's Batman stole the snowglobe associated with it from the Time Masters. In this reality's retelling, Batman found Kal-El's rocket and freed him from it. There has been many sightings of him as he is called Super-Man.[48]

Nightwing: The New Order

[edit]

In the alternate universe of Nightwing: The New Order, a major battle takes place in Metropolis between superpowered beings that causes the deaths of millions. During the conflict, Superman was infected with black kryptonite and murders Batman. This results in Nightwing activating a device that depowers ninety percent of the superpowered population. This builds to a future where superpowers are outlawed and any superpowered being must take inhibitor medications or be contained and studied. Despite being depowered, Superman still defends Metropolis as a vigilante with the help of Lex Luthor.[49]

Superman: American Alien

[edit]

In Superman: American Alien, by Max Landis, Clark's journey to becoming Superman is shown at different stages in his life. He first manifests his ability to fly while asleep as a child, which causes some trouble when he finds he cannot control it. He eventually gains better control of it and also gains a better understanding of empathy and consequences. As a teenager, he spends his time crushing on Lana Lang and spending time with his friends Pete Ross and Kenny, who are aware of his abilities. Things grow dark, however, when a murder takes place, and after an argument with Pete Clark tracks down the murderer and tries to stop them. He is hurt by the bullets, due to his powers having not fully developed, and in fear uses his heat vision on his attackers. When he is nineteen Clark wins a trip to the Caribbean, but the helicopter crashes near a yacht. Saving the pilot and coming on board, Clark is mistaken for Bruce Wayne due to it being his party. After some hesitation, he decides to enjoy himself and meets Oliver Queen, Sue Dearbon, Vic Zsasz and Barbara Ann Minerva, with whom he has a romantic fling. During the night, Clark is drugged by Deathstroke who tries to kill him, but Clark's powers surprise the assassin and result in Clark flicking him off the yacht. Afterwards Clark offers Barbara the choice to stay with him, but she refuses. Years later, Clark moves to Metropolis to be a reporter and on his first day he encounters Lois Lane and is reunited with Oliver, who forgives Clark after the latter comes clean about the mistaken identity. Oliver takes Clark to Lexcorp and introduces him to Lex Luthor. Clark interviews him, learning about Lex's arrogant and power-obsessed nature. Before leaving Lexcorp, Clark finds himself in a nursery and encounters Dick Grayson and after seeing everything that was in Dick's pockets as they agreed (using his x-ray vision), the two have a long discussion about Bruce Wayne and eventually Batman, with Dick accurately describing how the vigilante needs someone to balance out his darkness and fear with light and hope, foreshadowing the usual relationship between Superman and Batman. Afterwards, Clark is attacked by Batman, who is then overpowered by Clark and revealed as Bruce Wayne. Batman escapes, leaving behind his cape and Clark's recording of his conversation with Dick, and in return Clark does not reveal the truth about Bruce Wayne's double life. Approximately six months later, Clark has created a makeshift costume that includes Batman's cape and fights crime, and encounters Parasite. After defeating him, he learns that Parasite was created by Lex Luthor and confronts him. However, he is surprised and unable to respond when Lex swiftly explains how Clark made the mistake of confronting him with no actual plan. Clark leaves depressed, but after a conversation with Lois about his other identity (which she has no awareness of) becomes more determined and starts to use the name Superman, after what Lex had called him. After a unknown amount of time, Clark has started to wear the traditional Superman costume and is slowly entering a relationship with Lois, though it is not serious, and is visited by Pete and Kenny. Clark shows them around and introduces them to Jimmy Olsen, before the three head back to Clark's apartment. While talking about Batman, Kenny and Pete suggests he tries to contact the other people like him (such as the red blur in Central City, a woman with a lasso in DC, and a fish guy who sinks whaling boats). However Clark does not see them as like him, and this leads to an argument between him and Pete when he says that he has no intention of being Superman forever. Pete calls Clark out on how irresponsible he is being by not seeing the change he is creating as Superman, and how he worries everyone who know the truth about him, since they do not know what his intentions are by being Superman. This leads Clark to admit that he is hoping that any videos of him saving people with the symbol from his ship on his costume will be sent into space, and whoever left him on Earth would come back. When Clark attempts to turn the argument around by saying Pete is jealous, his friend points out that he is changing the world by accident and needs to stop waiting around and really do something, and that he is letting down his real parents who raised him. This upsets Clark and he attempts to fly to the Moon, but burns away his clothes when reaching the atmosphere and starts to choke due to a lack of oxygen. Before he can die he is saved by Abin Sur and Tomar-Re, who identify him as a Kryptonian before leaving him back on Earth. Clark reconciles with Pete, now apparently a little happier by knowing the name of his species. Skipping forward a few years later, Clark is living with Lois and is texting to Jimmy about having received a less than enthusiastic response from her when he told her that he loved her, when he hears explosions. He investigates as Superman and encounters Lobo, who reveals that Krypton exploded years ago and that the Kryptonians are dead. Finally accepting his human roots and letting go of his obsession with his alien origins, Clark battles Lobo and makes him leave the planet. Then as Clark, he checks himself into the hospital under the lie he was harmed in the battle, and Lois arrived and tells him that she loves him.

DC X Sonic the Hedgehog

[edit]

Superman appears in the intercompany crossover miniseries DC X Sonic the Hedgehog, which features him and the Justice League teaming up with Sonic and his friends in battling against Darkseid and his forces.[50]

Homage characters

[edit]

Outside comics published by DC Comics, the notoriety of the Superman or "Übermensch" archetype makes the character a popular figure to be represented with an analog in entirely unrelated continuities.

  • Rival publisher Marvel Comics parodies Superman through the character Hyperion.[51][52][53] Other Marvel Comics characters that serve as pastiches, homages, or parodies of Superman include Sentry, Gladiator, Ethan Edwards, Captain Ultra, Blue Marvel, and Sun God.[54]
  • Amalgam Comics' Super-Soldier is the amalgamated version of Superman and Captain America; Clark Kent volunteered during World War II to become a supersoldier using a combination of an enhancement serum and cells taken from an alien spacecraft, plus a super-charge of solar energy. He carries an adamantium shield which resembles Superman's chest insignia.
  • Robert Kirkman's Omni-Man of Image Comics is a clear homage to Superman. Both he and his son are children of a dying extraterrestrial race (though the aliens of Image's universe, the Viltrumites, are hostile).
  • "Superduperman!" was a parody comic seen in Mad Magazine #4, in which the title hero has "muscles on muscles", battles Captain Marbles (a parody of Captain Marvel), but in the end is still dismissed as "a creep".
  • Image Comics character Supreme, originally a violent, egotistical pastiche of Superman, later retooled by Alan Moore to more closely resemble the Silver Age Superman.
  • Malibu Comics features the characters Powerhouse, an unhinged pastiche of Superman with a similar origin story, and Prime (though this character is more closely based on DC's Captain Marvel).
  • The Plutonian of Boom! Studios' Irredeemable resembles Superman in many ways: he possesses a similar costume and powers, operates under a bespectacled secret identity, and is the head of his world's premiere team of superheroes, the Paradigm (which contains a few other members similar to the members of the Justice League). However, his lack of control over his powers, perceived ingratitude from the public, and emotional instability eventually cause him to snap under the pressure of protecting the world, becoming a dangerous supervillain. Near the end of the series, it is revealed that the Plutonian is living energy, a "golem" shaped into human form by force of will – but was tragically warped because of the human whose qualities he inherited. He is ultimately reduced back into energy and sent through the multiverse in the hopes that someone can "fix" him; his essence inspires Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster to create Superman.
  • Super-Turtle, an anthropomorphic superheroic turtle, was a series of long-running half-page gag strips that ran in various Silver Age DC comics starting in Adventure Comics #304 in 1963.
  • The Maximortal by Rick Veitch (1992–1993) – published under his own King Hell imprint
  • SuperDan, a webcomic character who gains Superman-like abilities after being bitten by a radioactive Superman.
  • Statesman, the first officially recognized superhero in the City of Heroes game world is a loose analogue to Superman, possessing superhuman speed, strength, senses, breath, and virtual invulnerability. He leads a pair of Justice Society/League-esque teams of heroes at different points in the game's timeline named the Freedom Phalanx, which include homages to characters from both Marvel and DC Comics characters. The character was slain shortly before the game itself was shut down. The character wore a blue and red costume as well, in apparent homage to the colors worn by Superman.
  • Samaritan of the Astro City series by Alex Ross and Kurt Busiek.
  • Astonishman of The End League.[55]
  • Últimos from Ben 10
  • Metro Man from Megamind
  • Silver Sentry from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
  • All Might from My Hero Academia
  • Son Goku from Dragon Ball
  • Suppaman from Dr. Slump
  • Meta Man from The Incredibles
  • Major Man from The Powerpuff Girls
  • Major Glory from Dexter's Laboratory
  • Mighty Mouse
  • Strongman from The Mighty Heroes
  • A-Ko from Project A-ko
  • Blast from One-Punch Man
  • Superlópez, a Spanish parody of Superman

Film and television

[edit]
  • In the Superman cartoons produced by Max Fleischer, Superman is much as he appears in the first years of Action Comics ' publication, despite changes in his costume, notably the all-red belt or absence of one in later cartoons, and the S-shield with a darkened blue plane and a red S instead of the yellow plane with the red S. He is said to have been found by "a passing motorist" who brought him to an orphanage. This version of Superman lives in and protects Manhattan rather than Metropolis, although in some cartoons such as "The Bulleteers", Metropolis is clearly named by the antagonists.
  • Kirk Alyn starred as Superman in two 15-chapter serials produced by Columbia Pictures, Superman (1948) and Atom Man vs. Superman (1950). In it, Superman has many of the powers demonstrated in the comics. The origin story is similar to what is described in a 1942 novel about Superman, with his foster parents being named Sarah and Eben.
  • Adventures of Superman (1952–1958) was a television series that featured George Reeves in the title role, which he first played in the 1951 movie Superman and the Mole Men. While he had many of the powers demonstrated in the comics, they are not shown at the tremendous levels depicted in the contemporary Silver Age comics. The show often featured Superman battling generic gangsters.
  • In 1966, Filmation produced The New Adventures of Superman and from 1973 to 1986, Hanna-Barbera produced different versions of the Justice League-influenced Super Friends, both of which were animated series aimed at children. In both cartoons, Superman was similar to his contemporaneous comic book counterpart. In one episode of The World's Greatest Super Friends, the Super Friends battled evil Super Friends from an alternative universe, led by an evil Superman.
  • In the 1978 feature film Superman and its sequels, Superman II, Superman III, and Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, Superman is portrayed by Christopher Reeve and is depicted as possessing an array of abilities never before seen in the comics. He was able to erase Lois' memory of his secret identity with a kiss, restore the Great Wall of China with the use of blue eye beams, and possibly teleport among other abilities. Kryptonian foes such as General Zod even demonstrated telekinetic ability.
  • In 1988, the producers of Superman (1978) produced a syndicated TV series entitled Superboy which featured John Haymes Newton in the role for one season before he was fired and replaced by Gerard Christopher. The show concentrated on a college-aged Kal-El as a journalism student at Siegel University.
  • The 1988 Superman series, produced by Ruby-Spears Productions, offered the first animated incarnation of the post-Crisis Superman. Acting as story editor, Crisis on Infinite Earths writer Marv Wolfman provided several changes to this Superman that included elements from The Man of Steel. In this series, Lex Luthor is not a publicly known criminal, but a rich entrepreneur instead. Clark Kent is Superman's alter ego, instead of the other way around. Furthermore, Martha and Jonathan Kent are still alive in Superman's adulthood in this series. This version of Superman was never Superboy as a teenager, although his powers had appeared very early in childhood. Clark Kent is clumsy in this series.
  • In Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman, Dean Cain played the first live-action Superman affected by the changes to the character after Crisis on Infinite Earths, and various elements on the series reference The Man of Steel miniseries, which heavily influenced the show. This is the first live action Superman series that showed Clark Kent as his "real" persona and Superman as the constructed alter ego. As he explained to Lois in the second-season episode "Tempus Fugitive", "Superman is what I can do, Clark is who I am." As the title implies, Clark is the primary identity with Superman making more sporadic appearances. The Lois and Clark version reverses the traditional hairstyle distinction between Clark Kent and Superman; here it is Superman who has slicked-back hair and Clark whose fringe falls more naturally. In neither mode does the character feature his trademark spitcurl, making it one of the few depictions of Superman to lack this distinctive feature. His full name was changed from the comic strip adaptations to Clark Jerome Kent.
  • The Superman of the DC animated universe is a synthesis of Superman's 60-plus year history. At first glance, it appears to be an adaptation of The Man of Steel, but also took many aspects of the Silver Age and modernized them. In this continuity, Superman was believed to be the only Kryptonian survivor until Professor Hamilton found a device with access to the Phantom Zone, where two other Kryptonians were found. Kara In-Ze (Supergirl) from Krypton's "sister" planet, Argo, and the artificial intelligence of Brainiac were also shown to be survivors of Krypton's destruction. His archenemy is the "wealthy business tycoon" version of Lex Luthor.
  • The Clark Kent of the Smallville TV series leads his life differently, never becoming Superboy, although he secretly performed heroic feats as a teenager and young man before moving to Metropolis and becoming its resident superhero. He meets Lois at a younger age, maintains a complicated friendship with Lex Luthor into young adulthood and for the most part of the series was romantically interested in Lana Lang. Clark's best friends in this version was Chloe Sullivan, who for a while worked as a reporter for the Daily Planet, and for the first few seasons, an African-American Pete Ross.
  • In Superman Returns, Brandon Routh takes over the role of Superman. Director Bryan Singer had stated[citation needed] that this film's continuity is based only loosely on the first two Superman films directed by Richard Donner and Richard Lester, and thus Reeve and Routh's Supermen, though similar in places (even having identical fathers—Jor-El played by Marlon Brando and Jonathan Kent played by Glenn Ford), may not be exactly the same individual. For example, the events of the third and fourth films, and Supergirl, are ignored.
  • The animated series Legion of Super Heroes features a teenage Superman, who, like the original Superboy, travels to the future to join the Legion. The second season features Kell-El, a clone of Superman from the 41st century.
  • The animated series The Batman featured Superman in the two-part season 5 episode "The Batman/Superman Story". This Superman is not related to previous animated versions of the character.
  • Clark Kent / Superman is portrayed by Henry Cavill in the DC Extended Universe, first appearing in the 2013 movie Man of Steel, a reboot of the Superman film series. His parents, Jor-El and Lara, imbue Kal-El with the genetic codex of the entire Kryptonian race before sending him to Earth. He arrives on Earth in 1980, and is 33 years old during the present timeline of the film. Jonathan and Martha Kent are depicted as being around 30 when they find him. Jonathan is 46 when he dies in 1997, killed by a tornado outbreak, refusing help from his son to keep his powers secret in what he believed was an unprepared world. Martha helped Clark control his powers while he is young. Deciding it is time for him to find out the reason for why he was sent to Earth, he travels the world and takes a series of odd jobs under assumed identities in his 20s, but leaves each job when he is forced to use his powers for good, leaving a trail of urban legends which Lois Lane eventually finds and investigates. Clark's lifelong secrecy comes to an end when General Zod arrives on Earth to transform Earth into a new Krypton after the destruction of the planet, as he is forced to take the mantle of Superman to stop him. He would later be confronted by Batman in the wake of the destruction his final battle with Zod caused, but teams up with him and Wonder Woman to take down Doomsday (created by Lex Luthor), in which he apparently sacrifices his life in the process. In the 2017 film Justice League and its 2021 director's cut Zack Snyder's Justice League, Clark Kent's body is exhumed and placed in the incubation waters of the Kryptonian ship alongside a Mother Box, which in turn activates and resurrects Superman. This version of Superman appears for the last time to confront Black Adam and is erased from existence when Barry Allen, as The Flash, alters the timeline.

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Alternative versions of Superman refer to the diverse depictions of the character Kal-El, or analogous figures, in DC Comics narratives outside the primary continuity, including parallel-universe counterparts in the multiverse and standalone tales under the Elseworlds imprint that reimagine his origins, upbringing, and worldview. These variants explore hypothetical divergences, such as a medieval knight empowered by Kryptonian heritage or a post-apocalyptic survivor navigating a irradiated Earth, allowing creators to probe the archetype's resilience against altered historical, cultural, or moral contexts without disrupting canonical events. Prominent examples include the aged, disillusioned Superman of Kingdom Come, who confronts a new generation of reckless metahumans amid escalating global threats, and the Soviet-raised Kal-L in Superman: Red Son, whose communist ideology leads to authoritarian governance in an alternate timeline. Such stories highlight defining characteristics like Superman's struggle with absolute power, often resulting in either heroic restraint or tyrannical overreach, as seen in multiversal assemblies like the or darker inversions such as from Earth-3. These reinterpretations have influenced broader DC lore by occasionally integrating elements into mainline continuity and underscore the character's adaptability as a cultural icon since his 1938 debut.

Variants in DC's Core Continuity

Pre-Crisis Depictions (1938–1986)

Superman first appeared in Action Comics #1, published by National Periodical Publications (later DC Comics) on April 18, 1938, created by writer and artist . In this debut, the character was portrayed as an extraterrestrial refugee from the doomed planet , rocketed to Earth as an infant by his scientist father , and raised as Clark Kent by adoptive parents in rural ; his powers stemmed from Earth's yellow sun granting him abilities far beyond human limits, including strength to hurl automobiles, speed surpassing locomotives, and resilience against gunfire, though initially limited to leaping great distances rather than sustained flight. Early stories emphasized against urban corruption, corrupt officials, and domestic threats, aligning with pulp adventure tropes of the era, without advanced abilities like heat vision or that emitted heat. By the 1940s, amid , depictions shifted to include flight—first demonstrated in Superman #14 (1941)—and wartime heroism against Axis saboteurs and spies, with , a radioactive remnant of weakening him, originating in the 1943 radio serial before comic integration in Superman #61 (1949). The version, retroactively designated as Earth-Two Superman in later multiverse lore, aged in real time, marrying by the 1960s in Justice League of America crossovers, contrasting the youthful, static iteration emerging post-1950s. The Silver Age, from roughly 1956 onward under editor , vastly amplified Superman's capabilities to godlike levels, incorporating super-intelligence, freeze breath, microscopic vision, and feats like towing planets or time travel via speed, often in self-contained "imaginary" tales exploring hypotheticals like alternate careers or romances. Stories proliferated scientific adversaries like Brainiac (debuting 1958) and expanded lore with the (1958), Kandor (shrunk Kryptonian city), and relatives including (1959) and Krypto the Superdog, while gimmicks like super-ventriloquism underscored the era's emphasis on boundless, physics-defying inventiveness. Bronze Age portrayals (1970s–1986) under successors like introduced subtle humanization, such as temporary power reductions in Superman #302–309 (1976–1977) by Denny O'Neil to heighten vulnerability against foes like , alongside social commentary on issues like and , though core invincibility persisted until the continuity reset. These evolutions reflected editorial mandates for relevance, culminating in pre- complexities where reconciled multiversal histories, maintaining his role as an optimistic, moral paragon amid escalating cosmic threats.

Golden Age Foundations (1938–1950s)

Superman debuted in Action Comics #1, released on April 18, 1938, created by writer Jerry Siegel and artist Joe Shuster for National Allied Publications (later DC Comics). In this inaugural story, the character possessed superhuman strength enabling him to hurl a car over his head and overpower armed gangsters, speed exceeding that of automobiles and locomotives, and the ability to leap one-eighth of a mile or clear tall buildings in a single bound. He demonstrated partial invulnerability by withstanding pistol fire, which ricocheted off his skin, and enhanced senses allowing him to eavesdrop on distant conversations. These abilities stemmed from unexplained enhanced physiology rather than solar energy absorption, distinguishing the foundational version from subsequent power escalations. The character's origin was briefly alluded to in early appearances as an infant survivor from a distant dying planet, adopted and raised in an orphanage before discovering his abilities as Clark Kent, a reporter for the Daily Star. This backstory expanded in Superman #1 (summer 1939), detailing Kal-L's parents, scientist Jor-L and Lora, launching their baby from the exploding planet Krypton in a prototype rocketship, which crash-landed in America. Kent's dual life as a mild-mannered journalist masked his vigilante pursuits, where he targeted corruption by intimidating officials, deposing mayors, and assaulting wrongdoers, reflecting a proactive, reformist ethos amid the Great Depression and rising fascism. Unlike modern portrayals emphasizing restraint and moral absolutism, Golden Age Superman employed psychological terror and physical coercion against exploiters of the vulnerable, as seen in stories exposing labor abuses and political graft. Through the 1940s, depictions evolved with power additions like true flight, first depicted consistently around 1941 in newspaper strips and Superman , transitioning from mere super-leaping influenced by animated adaptations. By mid-decade, he exhibited greater durability against and early heat-based vision variants, though still vulnerable to high explosives and lacking full flight mastery initially. These incremental changes, alongside radio serials portraying him aiding war efforts against from 1940 onward, solidified Superman as a symbol of American resilience, yet retained a gritty, interventionist core that later contrasted with Silver Age , informing retroactive distinctions in continuity.

Silver Age Innovations (1950s–1970s)

The Silver Age of Superman comics, spanning roughly from the late 1950s to the early 1970s, marked a significant evolution in the character's portrayal within DC's core continuity, introducing a more scientifically oriented, super-powered iteration distinct from the version. Under editor , —now explicitly Kal-El of —gained enhanced abilities powered by Earth's yellow sun, including effortless flight, vast super-strength, heat vision, and , contrasting the 's leaping and reliance on dense musculature. This , retroactively differentiated from the Earth-Two counterpart in The Flash #123 (1961), embodied atomic-age optimism with feats like towing planets or surviving nuclear blasts, reflecting post-World War II technological fascination. A hallmark innovation was the proliferation of "Imaginary Stories," non-canonical tales prefixed with "Not a hoax! An Imaginary Story!" to explore hypothetical divergences from 's life without disrupting continuity. Debuting prominently in Superman #132 (October 1959) with "The Superman Super-Spectacular," these narratives delved into alternate paths, such as Superman revealing his identity early, marrying and fathering a super-powered son, or dying prematurely, allowing writers like and to test character limits in "what if" scenarios. Over 100 such stories appeared in titles by the 1970s, often structured as novels resolving personal dilemmas like identity concealment or romantic tensions, though critics later noted their contrived resolutions prioritized status quo preservation. Other variants emerged through temporary transformations, exemplified by the 1963 bifurcation into Superman-Red and Superman-Blue in Superman #162 (July 1963). Exposed to a Kandorian-enlarging serum granting super-intelligence, Superman split into two entities: Superman-Red, impulsive and action-oriented, and Superman-Blue, analytical and inventive; together, they shrank Kandor to normal size, invented cures for diseases, and resolved cosmic threats before recombining. This duality highlighted thematic splits in heroism—passion versus intellect—while introducing elements like red kryptonite's unpredictable mutations, which spawned further short-lived alter egos such as (debuting 1958) via duplicator ray mishaps, inverting Superman's traits into clumsy imperfection. Supporting innovations reinforced these alternatives, including the bottled city of Kandor (introduced 1958), housing microscopic who occasionally influenced Superman's dual identity, and the Phantom Zone projector (1961), exiling criminals to intangible limbo and enabling ghostly "" interactions. Such devices expanded narrative flexibility, enabling stories of Superman collaborating with phantom selves or facing kryptonite variants (e.g., red causing behavioral shifts, gold depowering permanently), though these often reverted to baseline continuity, underscoring the era's emphasis on reversible spectacle over lasting change.

Bronze Age Evolutions (1970s–1986)

During the early 1970s, under editor , Superman's portrayal in DC's core continuity shifted toward more realistic and introspective narratives, departing from the Silver Age's emphasis on extravagant superhuman feats. This evolution culminated in the "Kryptonite Nevermore" storyline ( #389–391, December 1970–February 1971), written by Denny O'Neil, where Superman overloads a kryptonite-fueled to avert a catastrophe, triggering an explosion that transmutes all known on into harmless iron. The blast, however, permanently diminishes his power levels, rendering him unable to perform previous god-like acts such as towing planets or surviving nuclear blasts unscathed, compelling reliance on strategy and ingenuity over raw might. This depowering aimed to ground the character amid cultural demands for relevance, though it sparked debate among creators and fans about diluting his archetypal invincibility. Building on this vulnerability, the "Sand Superman Saga" (Superman #233–235, 237–238, 240–242, January–November 1971), also by O'Neil with art by , introduced a entity from the Quarrm dimension—a sentient construct mimicking Superman's form and powers, dubbed the Sand Superman. Formed from irradiated during the kryptonite explosion's dimensional rift, this alternate self impersonates Clark Kent and the hero, draining the original's abilities while embodying a distorted, power-hungry reflection of 's ideals. The arc forces the Man of Steel into an , exiled to the alien dimension and stripped of his identity, ultimately resolved through willpower and aid from allies like Batman, reinforcing themes of self-doubt and resilience. This narrative presented an "alternative" Superman as a cautionary mirror, influencing subsequent stories by emphasizing psychological depth over physical supremacy. Throughout the decade, these evolutions extended to Superman's civilian life and societal role, with Clark Kent transitioning from print journalism to television anchoring at WGBS-TV in by 1973, reflecting media shifts and allowing stories to tackle contemporary issues like and . Narratives incorporated , such as environmental threats in encounters with ( #237, 1971) or racial tensions via alliances with heroes like , portraying as a exemplar engaging real-world causal dynamics rather than fantastical . By the mid-1980s, arcs like the "Immortal Superman" ( #385–387, 1970, extended influences) explored temporary godhood via a magical artifact, contrasting his grounded baseline and foreshadowing continuity resets, yet maintaining core continuity until in 1985–1986. These changes, while innovative, were critiqued by some for undercutting the character's aspirational symbolism, prioritizing editorial relevance over unyielding heroism.

Post-Crisis and Continuity Reboots (1986–Present)

Following the Crisis on Infinite Earths event concluding in 1986, DC Comics relaunched Superman's core continuity with John Byrne's six-issue The Man of Steel miniseries, establishing a streamlined origin that eliminated multiversal duplicates and pre-adolescent exploits like Superboy. Kal-El, rocketed from Krypton as an infant during its destruction on an unspecified date in the 30th century, crash-landed in Smallville, Kansas, where he was adopted by Jonathan and Martha Kent; his Kryptonian physiology granted superhuman abilities solely under Earth's yellow sun, with no inherent powers on Krypton itself, and energy absorption functioned akin to a biological battery requiring periodic recharge. This iteration positioned Superman as the definitive "Last Son of Krypton," with Clark Kent prioritizing his Metropolis reporter role over Smallville roots, and Lex Luthor recast as a bald, self-made corporate executive harboring personal grudges rather than scientific rivalry. Subsequent titles like Superman (vol. 2) #1 in February 1987 and Adventures of Superman #424 in January 1987 continued this portrayal, emphasizing psychological depth and reduced godlike invulnerability compared to prior eras. Temporary physiological variants emerged within this continuity, such as the 1998 "Superman Blue" transformation in Superman (vol. 2) #123, where prolonged exposure to cosmic and solar energies during the Superman: The Man of Steel finale altered his cellular structure into a pure energy form, granting enhanced intelligence, phasing abilities, and electric blasts but diminishing raw strength; he adopted a blue energy-based suit and operated from the Fortress of Solitude as a mentor figure until reverting in Superman (vol. 2) #175 in 2002. Another split occurred in Superman: Red and Blue (2003-2004), where Superman bifurcated into rational "Superman Red" (enhanced intellect, red solar-powered) and emotional "Superman Blue" (impulsive, blue energy-manipulating), resolving after clashing over Metropolis threats; these forms highlighted internal conflicts without permanent continuity shifts. The era also featured pseudo-replacements during the 1992-1993 "Death of Superman" arc in Superman (vol. 2) #75, where Superman perished combating Doomsday on January 26, 1993 (in-universe), prompting four claimants—the cloned Superboy (Kon-El), the Eradicator (a Kryptonian artifact manifesting as armored Superman), the Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw, a malevolent impostor), and Steel (John Henry Irons in powered armor)—each embodying alternative heroic archetypes until the original's resurrection via Kryptonian regeneration matrix in The Adventures of Superman #500 on June 15, 1994. The 2011 New 52 relaunch, triggered by the Flashpoint event's timeline alterations in May 2011, introduced a rebooted approximately five years younger, with a condensed history omitting decades of prior adventures; debuting in Justice League #1 on September 21, 2011, he initially wore casual jeans under his cape, exhibited a more confrontational demeanor toward authorities, and displayed powers including a devastating "superflare" energy release but with feats suggesting reduced baseline durability, such as vulnerability to magic and at lower thresholds than predecessors. This version's origin retained infancy exile but accelerated his public debut to age 29, with Clark Kent as a novice reporter encountering fewer supporting figures like a diminished history; inconsistencies arose, including variable solar absorption rates and a 2014 marriage to in Superman (vol. 2) #30, producing daughter Cir-El (later retconned), diverging from Post-Crisis family dynamics. By 2016, sales data indicated declining interest, with Superman (vol. 3) circulation dropping below 50,000 units monthly by mid-decade, prompting narrative convergence. DC's Rebirth initiative in June 2016, launched via DC Universe: Rebirth #1 on May 25, 2016, hybridized New 52 and pre-Flashpoint elements through the "Superman Reborn" arc in Action Comics #975-976 and Superman (vol. 4) #18-19, merging the younger New 52 Superman—revealed as a pre-Flashpoint refugee—and the elder Post-Crisis version into a singular entity via Mr. Mxyzptlk's reality-warping intervention on May 24, 2017 (in-universe), restoring marriage to Lois Lane, son Jonathan Kent (born circa 2015, aging accelerated), and extended history including Smallville youth and global threats like the 1990s Doomsday event. This Rebirth Superman, resuming in Superman (vol. 4) #1 on June 28, 2018 under writer Brian Michael Bendis, balanced enhanced powers—such as refined heat vision precision and sunlight-clone generation in The Superman Family tie-ins—with grounded vulnerabilities, while Infinite Frontier's 2021 expansions in Infinite Frontier #1 on June 9, 2021, further integrated multiversal echoes without full reboots, maintaining core Kryptonian heritage amid ongoing threats like Brainiac's coluan variants. Power scaling stabilized closer to Post-Crisis benchmarks, with feats like towing planetary masses in Action Comics #1000 (June 2018), though editorial shifts emphasized ensemble dynamics over solo invincibility.

Post-Crisis Reconstruction (1986–2011)

The Post-Crisis era began with John Byrne's six-issue miniseries The Man of Steel, published from June to October 1986, which comprehensively rebooted Superman's origin and characterization following . In this depiction, Kal-El is the sole survivor of , launched as an infant in a single that arrives on Earth shortly after; he is adopted by the childless , who raise him as Clark Kent in , concealing his alien heritage until his teenage years when powers manifest due to prolonged exposure to Earth's yellow sun. Clark relocates to as an adult, balancing a career as a reporter with as , whose costume derives from a blanket rather than traditional alien garb; is reimagined as a bald, wealthy corporate driven by megalomania rather than scientific rivalry. This reconstruction emphasized Superman's isolation as the last , his gradual power development, vulnerabilities to , magic, and red sun radiation, and a more humanized Clark Kent persona, stripping away pre-Crisis elements like Kryptonian relatives, super-pets, and a vast prison. Subsequent depictions in core continuity maintained this foundation but introduced evolutionary changes, such as the addition of a in 1988 stocked with Kryptonian artifacts recovered from space, and power fluctuations tied to depletion. A pivotal storyline from August to October 1993, Reign of the Supermen!, presented four alternative claimants to the Superman mantle after his apparent death battling Doomsday in The Death of Superman (1992); these substitutes tested public faith in the hero while the real recovered in a regenerative Kryptonian matrix. The alternatives included:
  • Superboy (Kon-El): A teenage clone engineered from Superman's DNA, Lex Luthor's, and human elements, possessing tactile mimicking powers rather than true invulnerability; he patrolled as "The Metropolis Kid," later adopting the identity and joining .
  • Steel (John Henry Irons): A weapons engineer donning powered armor forged from Superman's shield remnants, emphasizing intellect and over superhuman physiology; Irons operated as "The Man of Steel," founding Steelworks to aid .
  • The Eradicator: An ancient bio-engineered device programmed to preserve Kryptonian purity, manifesting as a Superman-like figure with energy manipulation and resurrection abilities; it sought to terraform into a new , clashing with the returned before self-sacrifice.
  • Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw): A uploading his into alien , impersonating with shape-shifting and energy projection; revealed as the villain orchestrating destruction, including Engine City and the manipulation of , he was unmasked during the storyline's climax.
The real Superman's return integrated select elements, such as adopting the black recovery suit and mentoring and , while 's defeat affirmed the original's primacy. Later developments included temporary power shifts, such as energy-based abilities from 1998 to 2000 after solar overload, depicted as blue-skinned "Superman Blue" with expanded cosmic awareness but reduced physical strength, reverting after further solar exposure. Superman: Birthright (2003–2004) attempted a partial retcon, portraying as a vibrant society with Jor-El's warnings ignored and the Kents having a stillborn daughter, but inconsistencies led to its de-canonization by 2006 in favor of the Byrne baseline. These iterations reinforced Superman's core as a solar-empowered alien symbol of hope, with alternatives serving narrative explorations of legacy without supplanting the primary continuity.

New 52 Redefinition (2011–2016)

The initiative rebooted DC Comics' continuity in September 2011, presenting a younger who operated with less public experience and altered personal history compared to prior depictions. Clark Kent, raised by adoptive parents who perished in a car accident during his adolescence, concealed his powers longer while working menial jobs before fully embracing his heroic role in . This version emphasized Superman's alien heritage more prominently, with artifacts playing a central role in his development, diverging from the post-Crisis emphasis on human upbringing and integration. In Grant Morrison's run (issues #1–18, starting November 2011), the narrative depicted Superman's earliest vigilante phase, where he intervened in social injustices using rudimentary tactics, such as disrupting a corrupt landlord's in a hover-sled battle. dispatched baby Kal-El from a facing internal collapse due to advanced experiments, rather than planetary destruction, with the infant's pod crash-landing in . initially lacked flight, relying on super-leaps, and wielded a "energy armor" suit that enhanced durability but required solar charging; his powers fluctuated, reflecting incomplete solar absorption under Earth's yellow sun. The redesigned costume omitted the traditional red trunks, adopting a streamlined with a textured, scale-like texture derived from battle armor that bonded semi-organically to the wearer's skin via DNA recognition, providing hazard protection and resistance. In casual early appearances, Superman donned a simple T-shirt emblazoned with the of El , , and a cape fashioned from his pod's lining, symbolizing a gritty, working-class aesthetic before upgrading to the armored form. Powers evolved to include full flight, super-speed exceeding Mach 1, invulnerability, heat vision, freeze breath, and enhanced senses, though vulnerabilities like magic and persisted, with occasional solar flare overloads causing cellular instability. Romantic developments shifted Superman away from Lois Lane, establishing a relationship with Wonder Woman that began with mutual respect in Justice League #1 (September 2011) and culminated in a kiss confirmed under the Lasso of Truth in Justice League #12 (May 2012). This pairing, co-led by the duo in the League, highlighted shared outsider status and power dynamics, though it drew criticism for sidelining Lane and altering iconic dynamics. Lois, aware of Clark's identity as a colleague at the Daily Planet, maintained a professional rivalry without initial romance. Key storylines included Superman: Earth One (2010 graphic novel influencing New 52 tones, with Clark as a blogger exposing corruption) and ongoing threats like Lex Luthor's machinations in Action Comics, where Luthor deployed metahuman proxies and genetic experiments. The H'el on Earth crossover (2012–2013) pitted Superman against the Kryptonian sorcerer H'el, who sought to restore Krypton by sacrificing Earth, forcing alliances with Superboy and Supergirl. Superman: Doomed (2014), a six-issue event, revisited Doomsday, transforming Superman into a berserk "Superdoom" via viral infection, straining his Wonder Woman partnership and culminating in a Fortress of Solitude showdown. These arcs explored themes of isolation and hybrid identity, with Superman founding the Justice League as a co-leader alongside Batman and Wonder Woman against Darkseid's invasion in Justice League #1–6 (2011–2012). The era concluded amid declining sales and fan pushback, paving the way for DC Rebirth in June 2016.

Rebirth and Infinite Frontier Era (2016–Present)

In June 2016, DC Comics' Rebirth relaunch restored legacy elements to Superman's core continuity depiction, introducing a version of the character from a pre- timeline who was married to and father to a son, Jonathan. This Superman materialized in after being pulled through a dimensional rift, coexisting alongside the existing iteration, who lacked those personal ties and exhibited a more isolated demeanor. The two collaborated against threats including the enigmatic Mr. Oz, revealed as a manipulated projection of Dr. , highlighting tensions between their divergent histories and power levels. The duality concluded in the "Superman Reborn" crossover (April–May 2017), spanning Action Comics #975–976 and Superman #18–19, where fifth-dimensional entities Mxyzptlk and Mr. Mxyzptlk disclosed that Superman's essence had been divided by timeline alterations during the era. The story merged the pair into a unified individual with amalgamated memories, experiences, and abilities, reinstating a family-oriented, optimistically heroic closer to Post-Crisis norms while retaining select developments like enhanced solar-powered physiology. This synthesis emphasized resilience against reality-warping manipulations, solidifying a single core by mid-2017. Parallel to these changes, Rebirth introduced as the New Super-Man in New Super-Man #1 (July 2016), a teenager empowered through a Chinese government experiment transferring Kryptonian energy from the fading via a and kryptonite matrix. Initially reliant on technological augmentation for flight, super-strength, and energy projection mimicking 's abilities, Kenan operated as 's state-sanctioned hero, forming the of with analogues like the New Bat-Man and New . Subsequent revelations in the series (2016–2018) disclosed his powers evolving toward innate traits due to experimental DNA from 's foe Dr. Ching, positioning him as an extension of the legacy in global contexts. Kenan persisted in core continuity appearances, including team-ups with Jonathan Kent and conflicts against the People's Heroes. The era, initiated in June 2021 following previews and , shifted focus to multiversal connectivity while maintaining core continuity through expansive threats like the Phaelosian empire in . A notable variant emerged when Jonathan Kent, accelerated to young adulthood by , assumed the Superman mantle in Superman: Son of Kal-El #1 (July 2021), as Clark pursued off-world investigations into Warworld. Jon's tenure emphasized activism against authoritarianism and environmental collapse, diverging from Clark's traditional restraint by publicly challenging oppressive regimes, though criticized for inconsistent power scaling compared to his father's benchmarks. Clark resumed primacy by 2022, with Jon reverting to amid ongoing family dynamics. These iterations reflected DC's iterative refinements, balancing restoration of inspirational roots with contemporary expansions, though the merged Superman's portrayal under writers like Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason prioritized paternal themes until Brian Michael Bendis's run (2018–2021) introduced metaphysical vulnerabilities tied to solar energy fluctuations.

Multiverse Counterparts

Heroic Earth Variants

Heroic Earth variants of in the DC Multiverse comprise altruistic iterations from parallel worlds where the character functions as a protector embodying truth, justice, and moral integrity, in contrast to villainous counterparts. These versions generally originate as Kryptonian survivors rocketed to , acquiring solar-empowered abilities such as super strength, flight, heat vision, and invulnerability, and adopt secret identities to integrate into human society while thwarting existential threats. Distinct from core continuity, they reflect alternate historical or cultural divergences, such as succession crises or intertwined political roles, yet preserve the archetype's emphasis on and inspiration. Prominent examples include the Earth-Two Superman Val-Zod, introduced in the Earth 2 series, who assumes the mantle after the original Kal-El's demise amid an Apokoliptian invasion, confronting a corrupted predecessor to safeguard his world. On Earth-23, Kalel operates as Calvin Ellis, the President, covertly deploying his powers to foster global stability and counter supervillainy, exemplifying a fusion of and . Earth-One's parallels pre-Crisis depictions, featuring a youthful maturing into Metropolis's defender through classic narratives of origin and heroism, as re-explored in the Superman: Earth One graphic novels launched in 2010. These variants underscore Superman's adaptability across realities while anchoring in empirical heroism derived from Kryptonian physiology and adoptive Earth values.

Earth-One and Pre-Flashpoint Parallels

The Superman, established as the central heroic iteration in DC Comics' primary continuity from the late 1950s through the 1985 event, exhibits core structural and thematic parallels with the Pre-Flashpoint Superman, who anchored the rebooted mainline continuity from John Byrne's The Man of Steel miniseries in 1986 until the 2011 Flashpoint storyline. Both versions depict Kal-El as a infant rocketed to Earth from the exploding planet , crash-landing in rural and adopted by the childless farmers , who instill in him traditional American values of hard work, humility, and moral integrity. These iterations maintain a dual identity framework, with Clark Kent posing as a mild-mannered reporter for the in while operating as , the archetypal protector clad in a blue suit with red cape and "S" emblem derived from the House of El. Powers in both cases stem from physiological adaptation to Earth's yellow sun, granting (capable of lifting massive structures or vehicles), invulnerability to conventional harm, flight, accelerated healing, and sensory enhancements like and super-hearing, though feats often escalated to cosmic scales such as towing planets or surviving nuclear blasts without strain. The serves as a recurring sanctuary housing artifacts and providing isolation for reflection, first conceptualized in stories around and retained in Pre-Flashpoint narratives as a crystalline technological hub. Supporting elements further align the portrayals: functions as a tenacious investigative journalist and eventual romantic partner, as a plucky photographer sidekick, and as the gruff editor; persists as the quintessential arch-nemesis, evolving from in Earth-One tales to corporate titan in Pre-Flashpoint arcs, embodying human ambition unchecked by ethics. Superman's ethos—defending "truth, justice, and the American way"—remains invariant, positioning him as an optimistic symbol of hope against threats ranging from street-level crime to interstellar invasions, with Pre-Flashpoint emphasizing emotional vulnerabilities like weakness and familial bonds to humanize the inherited from 's near-omnipotent blueprint. These continuities underscore a causal lineage where Pre-Flashpoint refines Earth-One's foundational realism, pruning Silver Age excesses like fifth-dimensional imps while preserving the immigrant's assimilation narrative as a bulwark against .

Earth-Two: Val-Zod and Golden Age Successors

In the DC Comics , Earth-Two originated as the continuity for Superman stories, retroactively designated following the 1956 debut of the Silver Age Superman on . This Kal-L version, introduced in Action Comics #1 (June 1938), exhibited superhuman strength, speed, stamina, invulnerability, and enhanced senses, initially relying on leaping rather than flight. He actively combated during , joining the and maintaining a public identity as Clark Kent, reporter for the Daily Star. Unlike later iterations, Kal-L's powers derived from denser molecular structure rather than solar energy, and he operated without a secret identity fortress or extensive supporting cast until later retcons. The pre-Crisis Earth-Two Superman represented a direct lineage from 1938 publications, with no immediate mantle successors in Golden Age narratives; Kal-L continued adventuring postwar, occasionally crossing to Earth-One for joint tales. Post-Crisis on Infinite Earths (1985–1986), Kal-L sacrificed himself to preserve the universe, dissolving Earth-Two's distinct continuity. However, the New 52 reboot (2011) reintroduced an Earth-2 with Golden Age-inspired elements, such as a World War II-era Justice Society, but altered the Superman lineage: the initial Kal-El debuted publicly in 2011 equivalents, only to perish combating Parademon invaders from Apokolips. Val-Zod, a Kryptonian survivor dispatched in infancy alongside Kal-El and Kara Zor-El during Krypton's destruction, became this rebooted Earth-2's Superman successor. Encased in a projector for safeguarding, Val-Zod endured isolation, emerging with and solar deprivation that initially hindered his powers. First depicted in Earth 2 #19 (May 2014) by writer and artist , he was liberated by Kent Nelson () and acclimated to yellow-sun empowerment, donning a suit designed by (Kara). By Earth 2 #25 (October 2014), Val-Zod fully embraced the role, battling a tyrannical, corrupted iteration of the original Kal-El while allying with Earth-2's heroic remnants against Apokoliptian threats. Val-Zod's narrative arc underscores legacy inheritance amid multiversal upheaval, integrating him into crossovers like Convergence (2015), where he defended his reality, and Justice League of America (2013–2014), emphasizing psychological resilience over raw might. As one of few Kryptonians left on Earth-2, his succession honors Golden Age heroism—public duty and societal protection—while adapting to modern crises, including multiversal incursions by figures like Ultraman. This version prioritizes tactical restraint, reflecting his trauma-induced aversion to violence, yet affirms Superman's emblem as hope's symbol across Earth-2's iterations.

Earth-23: Calvin Ellis and Diverse Interpretations

Earth-23 designates an alternate reality in the DC Multiverse where Superman is Kalel, who operates under the civilian identity of Calvin Ellis, the President of the United States. Ellis first appeared in Final Crisis #7, published in May 2009 by DC Comics, with the character conceived by writer Grant Morrison and illustrated by Doug Mahnke. In this continuity, Ellis was rocketed from the doomed planet Krypton by his parents Jorel and Lara, landing on Earth where he was raised to embody values of justice and equality. Endowed with Kryptonian physiology amplified by Earth's yellow sun, Ellis exhibits conventional Superman powers including superhuman strength capable of moving planets, invulnerability to most physical harm, flight at supersonic speeds, heat vision, freeze breath, and enhanced senses such as x-ray and telescopic vision. As Superman, he maintains global peace while covertly fulfilling presidential responsibilities, leading a Justice League that includes members like a black-skinned Green Lantern, Nubia as Wonder Woman, Vixen, Steel, and Batman. This dual role underscores Ellis's commitment to defending the oppressed through both superhuman intervention and political leadership. The portrayal of Calvin Ellis represents a deliberate diversification of the Superman archetype, introducing an African-American hero who ascends to the highest office while wielding godlike abilities. Morrison explicitly modeled Ellis after , elected U.S. President in November 2008, and , blending political acumen with physical prowess to symbolize aspirational black leadership. This interpretation has sparked discussions on representation in narratives, positioning Earth-23's as a figure of integrated heroism rather than isolation from societal structures, though some observers critique it as overly symbolic or contrived in its alignment with contemporary political milestones. Subsequent appearances in events like (2014–2015) expand on these themes, depicting Ellis collaborating with other multiversal Supermen against cosmic threats.

Antagonistic and Twisted Variants

Antagonistic variants of Superman in the DC Multiverse invert the character's heroic , often through reversed moral frameworks, traumatic isolations, or authoritarian upbringings that prioritize domination over protection. These depictions, emerging primarily in crossover events and alternate Earth narratives, explore how physiology combined with adverse environments yields destructive potential rather than benevolence. Ultraman serves as the primary antagonist from Earth-3, a reality where heroic archetypes are supplanted by the , a cabal of supervillains ruling through terror. Unlike Superman's empowerment by yellow sunlight, Ultraman derives abilities from exposure, rendering sunlight his vulnerability and enabling a physiology geared toward conquest. As the Syndicate's leader, he embodies unbridled aggression, frequently invading prime Earths to subjugate heroes, as depicted in multiversal conflicts where his raw power rivals or exceeds standard limits due to unchecked toxin dependency. Superboy-Prime, hailing from Earth-Prime—a realm mirroring real-world fiction where superhumans were mythical until his emergence—transitions from isolated heroism to vehement villainy following the Crisis on Infinite Earths in 1985-1986 storylines. As the sole survivor of his destroyed universe, he develops profound resentment toward the DC Universe's altered continuity, punching reality-warping barriers to "fix" timelines and killing heroes like Conner Kent in fits of entitlement. His pre-Crisis-level strength, unhindered by modern power dampeners, fuels rampages marked by psychological instability, portraying a twisted adolescence warped by loss and rejection. Earth-40 features Zod-dominated hybrids, exemplified by Super-Man, a Kryptonian entity assuming the Clark Kent mantle yet rooted in General Zod's militaristic lineage, blending alien conquest imperatives with terrestrial assimilation. This variant, active in the 52 Multiverse framework post-Flashpoint, represents hybrid vigor from Kryptonian-human intermingling under Zod's influence, yielding enforcers loyal to expansionist agendas over . Such figures prioritize Kryptonian supremacy, engaging in hybrid breeding programs or invasions that twist Superman's adoptive heritage into tools of subjugation.

Earth-Three: Ultraman and Crime Syndicate

Earth-Three designates a DC Multiverse world where societal norms and historical outcomes are reversed from Earth-Prime, fostering a dominance of super-criminals over heroic protectors. The , the world's ruling cabal, serves as the malevolent counterparts to the , first depicted in Justice League of America #29–30 (August–September 1964), written by and illustrated by . Composed of (Superman analogue and leader), (Batman), (Wonder Woman), Johnny Quick (Flash), and Power Ring (Green Lantern), the Syndicate enforces totalitarian control from their Eyrie of Evil headquarters, having eradicated opposition through conquest. Their incursions into other realities, such as , typically involve schemes thwarted by dimensional barriers or direct confrontations, highlighting the Syndicate's strategic yet ruthless modus operandi. Ultraman, born Kal-El (later adopting Clark Kent as a disguise), crash-landed on Earth-Three as an infant from , but unlike Superman's nurturing upbringing, he was raised in a criminal environment that amplified his innate ruthlessness. His physiology inverts Kryptonian vulnerabilities: exposure to green radiation empowers him with , flight, invulnerability, and other abilities, granting a novel power per distinct exposure while fostering and physiological dependency for sustained potency. Prolonged deprivation leads to power loss and withdrawal, compelling Ultraman to hoard , which he rations intravenously in later depictions; sunlight exposure, conversely, weakens him akin to Superman's susceptibility. Subsequent continuities retooled Earth-Three's framework. Post-Crisis on Infinite Earths (1985–1986), the Syndicate relocated to an Antimatter Universe accessed via Qward, as explored in Grant Morrison's JLA: Earth 2 (1999–2000), where Ultraman's empowerment persists but ties into broader cosmic threats. The reboot (2011) reinstated Earth-3 with Ultraman as Kal-Il, a bio-engineered subjected to experimentation by his world's regime, leading to his Syndicate leadership and invasion of Prime Earth in Forever Evil #1–7 (September 2013–May 2014), where he briefly decapitated Pandora's corpse to avert multiversal collapse before imprisonment. Rebirth and eras (2016–present) further integrated the Syndicate into crossovers like (2015–2016), emphasizing Ultraman's tyrannical expansionism and the group's internal fractures, such as Superwoman's affair with yielding a son, . These iterations underscore the Syndicate's role as a foil to heroic ideals, with Ultraman embodying unchecked power's corrupting influence absent moral restraints.

Earth-Prime: Superboy-Prime

, originally known as Clark Kent or Kal-El of Earth-Prime, is a from a parallel universe designated Earth-Prime, where superheroes exist solely as fictional characters in comic books rather than as real entities. His rocket from arrived on Earth-Prime during the same era as the 1938 debut of in , leading to adoption by Jerry and Naomi Kent in a world without inherent superhuman phenomena under its yellow sun. Unlike standard , he exhibited no powers during adolescence, only discovering his latent abilities during a cosmic disturbance involving a comet and exposure to Superman's narrative influence. His first canonical appearance occurred in DC Comics Presents #87, published November 1985, where writers Elliot S. Maggin and artist Curt Swan introduced him as a teenage Superboy aiding Superman against threats amid multiversal convergence. Pulled into the DC Multiverse during the Crisis on Infinite Earths event (1985–1986), he assisted in combating the Anti-Monitor's antimatter wave, which destroyed his home universe, leaving him one of the last survivors alongside heroes from Earth-Two and Earth-Three. Post-Crisis, reality was rebooted into a single unified Earth, and Superboy-Prime was confined to a paradise dimension by Superman and Alexander Luthor Jr. to prevent timeline disruptions, a isolation that fostered resentment toward the altered heroic landscape. Superboy-Prime possesses amplified Kryptonian physiology comparable to pre-Crisis variants, granting capable of shattering dimensional barriers—demonstrated by physically punching retcon waves to revert events like Jason Todd's resurrection in 2005—along with invulnerability, flight, heat vision, freeze breath, and enhanced speed exceeding light velocity. His powers derive from yellow solar radiation but operate at peak efficiency without the typical vulnerabilities to magic or in later depictions, partly due to his origin in a "real-world" analogue ; however, prolonged exposure to red sun energy or psychic assaults has temporarily depowered him. In #1–7 (2005–2006), his villainous turn manifested as he escaped confinement, formed the Suicide Squad briefly, and orchestrated multiversal incursions, killing heroes like Conner Kent () and while decrying the "soft" post-Crisis heroes as unworthy successors. Subsequent arcs amplified his antagonistic role: in the Sinestro Corps War (2007–2008), he joined the Sinestro Corps as a yellow-lantern wielder, fueled by fear manipulation, before defecting amid escalating rage. Final Crisis: Legion of 3 Worlds #1–5 (2008–2009) saw him clash with the Legion of Super-Heroes across timelines, attempting to impose his vision of heroism by allying with the Time Trapper. By Blackest Night (2009–2010), undead Black Lantern reanimation briefly harnessed his corpse-like state for necrotic attacks, underscoring his narrative as a cautionary figure of unchecked power and isolation-induced psychosis. Recent mentions in Dark Nights: Death Metal (2020) portray shadowy multiversal echoes of him as apocalyptic threats, reinforcing his status as a recurring destabilizer rather than a redeemable anti-hero. His arc critiques idealized heroism, evolving from naive youth to a reality-warping tyrant who rationalizes mass casualties—over 50 heroes slain or maimed in Infinite Crisis alone—as necessary for "fixing" a flawed universe.

Earth-Forty: Zod-Dominated Hybrids

In the DC Multiverse's Earth-40, the primary counterpart to is General Dru-Zod, a figure who assumes the heroic mantle of "Super-Man" while harboring inherently psychopathic traits. Originating from a utopian , Zod demonstrated violent tendencies early in life by unleashing a that killed dozens, leading to his unprecedented sentencing as a child to the Phantom Zone. In the , a U.S. government experiment teleported him to Earth, where he was raised under strict Army supervision in as "Clark Kent," feigning amnesia to conceal his origins and true nature. This version integrates Zod into a noir-inspired narrative, diverging sharply from Kal-El's altruistic by portraying him as a government-controlled asset rather than a voluntary defender. As Super-Man, Zod possesses standard Kryptonian abilities under Earth's yellow sun, including , flight, invulnerability, heat vision, and enhanced senses, though his training limits his tactical finesse compared to traditional heroes. He operates as part of the "Unholy Three," a covert team alongside "the Bat" (a Batman analogue) and "the Clock" (an analogue), tasked with infiltrating and neutralizing superhuman threats like Parasite and Steelwolf in . Their missions focus on sabotaging Nazi superweapons, including a Russian nuclear device that exploits Zod's vulnerabilities, such as potential exposure and psychic attacks. This collaborative dynamic underscores a twisted heroism, where Zod's raw power dominates operations but his underlying instability—evident in his history—foreshadows , culminating in his before fully averting global catastrophe. Earth-40's framework reconciles inconsistencies with Earth-Two while amplifying antagonistic elements through Zod's infiltration of the identity, effectively "dominating" the hybrid pulp-noir archetype of DC's iconic hero. Unlike benevolent variants, this Zod embodies causal aggression rooted in his military background and unchecked impulses, serving U.S. interests only insofar as they align with personal survival and power exertion, without the moral compass of Kal-El. His narrative appears primarily in JSA: The Liberty Files (2000) and its sequel JSA: The Unholy Three (2003), positioning Earth-40 as a realm where might fuels shadowy rather than open justice.

Thematic and Historical Divergences

Thematic and historical divergences in Superman variants explore counterfactual scenarios where key events in his origin, upbringing, or societal role lead to profound ideological shifts, often critiquing power structures, , and heroism's moral costs. These Earths deviate from the canonical American-raised Clark Kent by altering historical contexts like outcomes or alignments, resulting in Supermen who embody or challenge authoritarian regimes rather than liberal democratic ideals. Such narratives, originating in Elseworlds-style tales later retrofitted into the , prioritize speculative "what if" premises to probe Superman's adaptability to non-Western or dystopian frameworks, with creators like and using them to examine real-world ideologies without endorsing them. On Earth-10, Kal-L crash-lands in pre-World War II instead of , where he is discovered and indoctrinated by , who renames him Overman and molds him into a symbol of Aryan supremacy. Raised amid the Third Reich's expansion, Overman aids the Nazis in conquering and eventually the world, deploying his powers to enforce totalitarian control and commit atrocities, including the subjugation of Allied forces through advanced weaponry and superhuman might. This variant, first detailed in and ' works integrating pre-Crisis Earth-X into post-Crisis continuity, culminates in Overman's post-victory remorse upon discovering the Holocaust's scale, leading him to isolate himself in guilt-ridden exile while his regime persists under figures like Leatherwing (a Batman analogue). Thematically, Earth-10 inverts Superman's immigrant assimilation narrative into one of fascist co-option, highlighting how unchecked power in ethnonationalist hands amplifies historical evils, with Overman's S-shield reinterpreted as a hybrid to underscore corrupted heroism. Earth-30 reimagines Superman's rocket landing in the 1930s Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin's regime, where the infant Kal-L is adopted by Kryptonian-like physiology but raised as a communist icon, eventually rising to lead the USSR as an infallible enforcer of collectivism. Published in 2003 as a three-issue miniseries by writer and artists Dave Johnson and Kilian Plunkett, Superman: Red Son depicts this Soviet quelling dissent, expanding influence globally during the , and clashing with American counterparts like a capitalist Batman and , who engineers a Superman clone to undermine him. By the story's 21st-century arc, Superman's utopian vision falters under bureaucratic stagnation, prompting his retirement and a descendant's desperate time-travel intervention to avert planetary destruction from Luthor's machinations. This divergence thematically contrasts Superman's traditional individualism with state absolutism, portraying ideological zeal as eroding personal agency and fostering surveillance states, while critiquing both Soviet inefficiency and Western opportunism without favoring either. Earth-31, rooted in Frank Miller's 1986 four-issue Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, presents an aged Superman, approximately 60 years old, who has retreated from public life after personal losses, emerging only as a U.S. government operative to maintain order in a decaying society. In this timeline, Clark Kent operates covertly under Ronald Reagan's administration, deploying against threats like Batman’s vigilante resurgence and Soviet incursions, culminating in a brutal, kryptonite-weakened duel with the Dark Knight amid . Designated Earth-31 in later mappings, this version diverges historically by emphasizing Superman's institutional co-optation, where his powers serve military-industrial interests rather than autonomous justice, leading to public disillusionment and his symbolic "death" in battle. Thematically, it explores heroism's and compromise, portraying as a weary symbol of fading , constrained by bureaucracy and physical decline, in contrast to Batman's defiant , with Miller's narrative underscoring the perils of superhuman intervention in .

Earth-Ten: Overman in Nazi Conquest Scenarios

In the DC Multiverse, Earth-10 depicts an alternate timeline where Kal-L, the survivor later known as Overman, arrives on in 1938, landing in the Nazi-occupied region of . Discovered by Nazi forces, his rocket's advanced technology is reverse-engineered, providing the with propulsion and weaponry advantages that enable their conquest of and eventual global dominance by 1945. Raised under the ideology of the and personally mentored by , Kal-L adopts the identity of Overman (German: Übermensch), embodying a enforcer of Nazi supremacy while possessing standard abilities such as super strength, flight, invulnerability, heat vision, and enhanced senses powered by yellow solar radiation. Overman leads the New Reichsmen, a cadre of superhuman operatives analogous to the Justice League but aligned with totalitarian control, including figures like Leatherwing (a Batman-like vigilante), Blitzen (a speedster), and Brunhilde (a Valkyrie-inspired warrior). This team enforces the Reich's rule across conquered territories, suppressing resistance such as the Freedom Fighters, a covert Allied remnant. Unlike purely villainous counterparts, Overman exhibits internal conflict, haunted by the moral weight of his role in genocidal campaigns and the discovery of his cousin Power Girl's corpse amid a concentration camp's horrors, which shatters his faith in the regime and prompts suicidal ideation during multiversal incursions. His psyche reflects a tragic arc, torn between indoctrinated loyalty and emerging doubts about the Reich's atrocities, culminating in acts of quiet rebellion against escalating extremism. The character debuts in Final Crisis: Superman Beyond #1-2 (2008), where Overman crosses into the main DC Universe during a Monitor-orchestrated crisis, confronting Superman and revealing Earth-10's dystopian history. Further explored in Multiversity: Mastermen #1 (2013) and The Multiversity #1 (2014-2015), these stories portray Earth-10 as a cautionary divergence from canonical Superman lore, emphasizing themes of power's corruption under authoritarianism without redeeming the Nazi framework. Overman's feats include single-handedly dismantling Allied superteams during WWII and withstanding multiversal threats, though his vulnerabilities mirror Superman's—Kryptonite, magic, and red sun radiation—while psychological torment serves as a self-imposed weakness. No canonical redemption arc exists, positioning him as a perpetual symbol of what Clark Kent's nurture might yield in a fascist cradle.

Earth-Thirty: Red Son and Soviet Superman

Earth-30, also known as the Red Son universe, represents an alternate reality in the DC Multiverse where Kal-El's rocket lands in the Soviet Union's Ukrainian steppes circa 1920 rather than Kansas. Discovered by a local shepherd, the infant is adopted into Soviet society and raised under communist principles, emerging as an adult superhuman in 1953 to serve as a champion for Joseph Stalin's regime. This divergence transforms Superman into a symbol of proletarian might, leveraging his powers to enforce ideological conformity and elevate the USSR to unchallenged global supremacy during the Cold War era. The core narrative, detailed in the 2003 Elseworlds miniseries Superman: Red Son written by with pencils by Dave Johnson for the first issue and Kilian Plunkett for the subsequent two, unfolds across three decades. Superman's allegiance prompts Western countermeasures, including a Batman-inspired guerrilla operative funded by the U.S. government and Lex Luthor's Manhattan Project-style initiative to engineer a counterpart. Conflicts escalate as Superman's interventions suppress dissent—employing gulag-like facilities for ideological reeducation—while grappling with the inherent tensions between his morality and enforced collectivism, culminating in a crisis of faith that reshapes world orders. Thematically, the story probes the perils of unchecked power wedded to , depicting Superman's Soviet tenure as yielding material prosperity at the cost of individual and ethical , before his disillusionment fosters a pivot toward liberal governance. Integrated into the broader post-Infinite Crisis, Earth-30 features in tie-ins like Countdown Presents: The Search for Ray Palmer – Red Son #1 (October 2007), where its heroes intersect with multiversal seekers. An animated adaptation released on March 17, 2020, by further popularized the premise, emphasizing moral ambiguities in nationalism and .

Earth-Thirty-One: The Dark Knight Returns Aging Hero

In Frank Miller's 1986 four-issue miniseries Batman: , Superman appears as a weathered, government-affiliated figure in his mid-50s, having endured decades of superheroic exertion, the death of , and a debilitating nuclear exposure during a between the and the . Unlike his mainstream depictions as an unwavering symbol of hope, this version of Kal-El/Clark Kent has retreated from public view after the government deemed superheroes a destabilizing force, instead conducting black-ops missions at the behest of the Reagan-era administration to maintain global order. Miller frames him as a reluctant enforcer of the status quo, prioritizing institutional stability over individual liberty, which culminates in his deployment to neutralize an emboldened Batman whose vigilante resurgence inspires widespread civil unrest. The storyline positions Superman as Batman's ideological foil: while Batman embodies chaotic individualism and defiance against bureaucratic overreach, Superman represents pragmatic compromise with authority, having survived a direct hit from a Soviet nuclear device that temporarily stripped his powers and left him physically diminished with scarred, radiation-weakened cells. His confrontation with Batman occurs atop a rain-swept Gotham rooftop, where he wields suppressed heat vision and flight but is ultimately felled by a kryptonite-tipped arrow crafted by Batman, resulting in a staged "death" for the Dark Knight that Superman helps orchestrate to quell public panic. This aging Superman exhibits reduced invulnerability and speed compared to his prime, relying on tactical restraint rather than overwhelming force, reflecting Miller's intent to humanize him through frailty and moral ambiguity rather than omnipotence. Post-confrontation, Superman feigns Batman's demise to preserve societal calm, then withdraws further into seclusion on a remote , mentoring a successor to the Batman mantle while grappling with the ethical costs of his enforced neutrality. Miller's narrative, influenced by tensions and critiques of exceptionalism, portrays this Superman not as villainous but as a casualty of , where absolute power yields to survivalist alliances—a departure from optimism that some analysts attribute to the author's objectivist leanings, emphasizing personal agency over collective mandates. This Earth-31 iteration influenced subsequent dystopian takes on the character, highlighting how prolonged heroism erodes idealism amid geopolitical entropy.

Elseworlds and Non-Canonical Narratives

Dystopian and Authoritarian Futures

In dystopian and authoritarian futures of DC Comics' narratives, Superman often embodies the perils of absolute power, either enforcing rigid order in chaotic worlds or serving as an instrument of tyranny. These stories explore causal consequences of Superman's interventionist ethos pushed to extremes, where his pursuit of leads to suppression of freedoms or alignment with despots, diverging from his role as a defender of democratic ideals. Such portrayals highlight tensions between security and liberty, with Superman's god-like abilities enabling regimes that prioritize stability over individual rights. Kingdom Come (Earth-22), written by and illustrated by in 1996, depicts a future where a new generation of superheroes operates without restraint, mirroring the violence of their foes and causing widespread destruction. , having retired after the murder of by the Joker, returns to lead veteran heroes in reimposing moral discipline on the reckless successors, culminating in a catastrophic battle at the prison that forces global intervention via nuclear threats. This effort, while framed as restorative, involves 's coalition demanding compliance from younger heroes, evoking authoritarian oversight critiqued by Batman as overreach. The narrative resolves with advocating regulated heroism under auspices, underscoring the risks of superhuman governance in averting apocalypse. Injustice: Gods Among Us, originating from the 2013 video game by and expanded in comics by from 2013 to 2016, portrays descending into tyranny following the Joker's manipulation: tricked into killing his pregnant wife , which detonates a nuclear bomb obliterating on November 11, 2012, killing millions including his unborn child. Enraged, executes the Joker on December 5, 2012, and establishes the One Earth Regime, a global dictatorship allying with select heroes like and Yellow Lantern to eliminate threats preemptively, including mind-controlling billions via fear toxin antidotes and constructing fear-based governance structures. Opposed by Batman-led insurgents, the Regime's five-year rule enforces peace through surveillance and lethal force, illustrating how personal trauma can corrupt 's principles into , with public support initially high due to reduced crime but eroding under oppression. Superman: The Dark Side, a 1998 miniseries by John Francis Moore and Kieron Dwyer, reimagines Kal-El crash-landing on instead of Earth, where he is indoctrinated by as a weaponized enforcer devoid of earthly morals. Raised in the fire pits, this Superman quells rebellions with brutal efficiency, embodying Darkseid's ideology and crushing dissent across planets, including a failed New Genesis incursion. Lacking conscience, he serves as the tyrant’s unyielding arm, suppressing and perpetuating Apokoliptian , which contrasts sharply with the hero's typical nurture-derived benevolence, emphasizing environment's causal role in moral formation.

Kingdom Come (Earth-22)

In the Kingdom Come miniseries, published by DC Comics from May to August 1996 under its Elseworlds imprint, Superman exists on Earth-22 as an elderly, retired hero who has withdrawn to his Fortress of Solitude after the death of Lois Lane in a nuclear detonation. The blast resulted from Captain Atom's containment failure during a confrontation with the Joker, who had rigged a nuclear device at the Daily Planet headquarters, killing 2 million people including Lane and prompting Superman's disillusionment with heroism. Written by Mark Waid and painted by Alex Ross, the story portrays Superman as a bearded, farmhand figure symbolizing traditional moral values amid a dystopian future dominated by violent, media-driven metahumans. Superman's return is catalyzed by pastor Norman McCay's apocalyptic visions, foretold by the Spectre, and the public acquittal of Magog for executing the Joker, which fractures the heroic community and unleashes chaos from unregulated "" vigilantes. Reforming the with allies like and Batman, Superman leads an intervention, capturing thousands of these new-generation heroes and confining them in a gulag-like facility on his farm to enforce accountability and prevent further escalation. This approach initially manifests as rigid control, diverging from his classic optimistic persona, as he prioritizes order over individual freedoms in response to the lethal excesses of successors inspired by figures like the . The narrative culminates in a global conflict when the , backed by American forces, deploys a hyper-advanced Captain Marvel to assault the , inadvertently activating the ancient engine of destruction Mageddon and causing widespread devastation, including the deaths of over 1 million metahumans. , humbled by the losses—including and Captain Marvel—rejects authoritarianism, brokers peace with humanity, and establishes the United Planets of America, mentoring a hybrid generation of heroes under stricter oversight. His powers remain Kryptonian-standard under a yellow sun, augmented by age-earned wisdom but strained by physical decline, emphasizing themes of legacy, restraint, and the perils of unchecked power in society.

Injustice: Gods Among Us

In the Injustice: Gods Among Us alternate universe, Superman's descent into authoritarianism begins with a meticulously planned scheme by the Joker. Laced with and Scarecrow's fear toxin, Superman experiences vivid hallucinations, perceiving his pregnant wife as Doomsday; in his delirium, he kills her, which activates a nuclear bomb hidden in her body, obliterating and claiming millions of lives, including Lane and their unborn son. This tragedy shatters Superman's restraint, prompting him to publicly execute the Joker by breaking his neck on , an act that violates his longstanding no-kill principle and signals his rejection of Batman's ethical framework. Superman subsequently forms the One Earth Regime, a global superhuman enforcer imposing draconian order to eradicate crime and prevent repeats of the Metropolis catastrophe. Backed by allies such as , (as a Yellow Lantern), and select members, he deploys lethal force against supervillains and perceived threats, establishes , and overthrows resistant governments, framing his rule as benevolent guardianship. Opposed by Batman leading the —a guerrilla force of dissenting heroes—Superman's Regime escalates into civil war, with Superman justifying imprisonment, execution, and mind control (via protocols like Brother Eye) as essential for human safety. This iteration diverges from canonical Superman by embracing over , prioritizing outcome security through coercion rather than inspirational justice or legal processes. The storyline, originating in the 2013 video game and expanded via a 72-issue DC Comics prequel series (2013–2016) written by , culminates in multiversal conflicts, including clashes with prime-Earth heroes who view the as a dystopian perversion. Superman's powers remain comparable to his mainstream counterpart—super strength, flight, heat vision, and invulnerability under a yellow sun—but his psychological amplifies , enabling feats like single-handedly subduing global armies. Unlike the hopeful, democratic of primary continuity, this embodies the perils of unchecked power post-trauma, substantiating critiques that absolute authority corrupts even noble intentions, as evidenced by his willingness to bomb cities or assassinate leaders for "peace."

Superman: The Dark Side

Superman: The Dark Side is a three-issue miniseries published by DC Comics from August to October 1998, written by John Francis Moore and illustrated by Kieron Dwyer on pencils with Hilary Barta on inks. The story reimagines Superman's origin by having Kal-El's rocket intercepted en route to Earth and redirected to the hellish planet , where claims the infant as his adopted son and heir. raises and trains the as a ruthless warrior, exploiting his growing powers under Apokolips' red sun to forge him into the ultimate enforcer against threats like the of New Genesis. In the narrative, the adult Superman, clad in black-and-red armor symbolizing his allegiance to , eagerly leads Darkseid's forces in a devastating invasion of New Genesis, overpowering and contributing to the realm's near-total annihilation. His loyalty appears absolute, as he serves as Darkseid's disciple in suppressing rebellion and enforcing tyranny across ' domains. However, exposure to records of his heritage and Earth's potential—contrasting Apokolips' brutality—triggers an internal conflict, revealing an innate moral code that resists full corruption. This confrontation culminates in Superman overthrowing in direct combat, assuming rule over himself. Rather than perpetuating endless oppression, he begins reforming the planet by liberating slaves and attempting benevolent governance, though this leads to unrest among the indoctrinated populace who view as weakness. The miniseries underscores a nature-over-nurture , positing that Superman's inherent heroism—rooted in his biological and cultural origins—endures even amid the most dehumanizing , ultimately prioritizing over . Critics have noted its exploration of environmental determinism's limits, with Superman's arc affirming that core ethical imperatives can override tyrannical upbringing.

Alternate Origins and Identities

In the Elseworlds storyline Superman: Red Son, published in 2003 by DC Comics and written by with art by Dave Johnson and Kilian Plunkett, Superman's origin diverges from the canonical narrative when his rocket ship lands in the Ukrainian steppes of the during the 1920s rather than rural . Raised by a adoptive family in Stalin's regime, the infant, named Kal-L, grows into a powerful symbol of communist ideology, using his abilities to advance Soviet interests and reshape global politics during an extended . This version explores themes of power's corrupting influence, as Superman initially serves the state but later questions authoritarian control, leading to conflicts with figures like , who heads a capitalist U.S. Another non-canonical identity appears in Superman: Secret Identity, a 2004 four-issue written by and illustrated by , set in a reality where superheroes exist only as fictional . The protagonist, , a teenager from born in 1972, unexpectedly manifests Superman-like powers—super strength, flight, invulnerability, and enhanced senses—during a high school outing, with no extraterrestrial or experimental origin explained. Living a double life as a journalist while vigilantly protecting incognito, this Clark navigates government surveillance, personal relationships, and aging, emphasizing the psychological toll of secrecy over cosmic destiny; he fathers daughters who inherit powers and eventually reveals his identity in old age before dying in 2037. The Just Imagine series, launched by DC Comics in 2001 as a collaboration with , reimagines in Just Imagine Stan Lee Creating Superman, where the hero is Salden, an adult law enforcement officer from the planet (analogous to ) rather than an infant refugee. Fleeing a planetary cataclysm via experimental , Salden crash-lands on in the , gaining solar-empowered abilities similar to traditional 's; his girlfriend dies in the disaster, motivating his heroic turn as "Superman" to combat crime and investigate his homeworld's fate, blending Lee's narrative style with DC elements like a more personal vendetta-driven origin. This Earth-6 designation in later contexts highlights Lee's reinterpretation, prioritizing detective procedural aspects over adoptive family upbringing.

Superman: Red Son (Earth-30, Extended Analysis)

Superman: Red Son is a three-issue Elseworlds miniseries published by DC Comics in 2003, written by Mark Millar with artwork by Dave Johnson, Gary Frank, and Cameron Stewart. The narrative reimagines Superman's origin by having his rocket land in the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1918 rather than rural Kansas, leading to his upbringing as a loyal defender of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). This alternate universe, designated Earth-30 in the DC Multiverse following the 2011 New 52 reboot, explores the premise of a "Soviet Superman" whose powers tip the Cold War balance toward communist dominance. The story unfolds across three eras: the 1950s "Red Son Rising," where Superman's emergence prompts the to accelerate its and recruit to counter him; the 1970s-1980s "Red Son Ascendant," depicting Superman's rise to leadership after Joseph Stalin's death in 1953, his utilitarian policies eradicating poverty and hunger worldwide but at the cost of individual freedoms; and the "Red Son Setting," where internal dissent, including a Batman-led and Luthor's creation of as a flawed Superman duplicate, culminates in Superman's . Influenced by journalist , whom he marries, Superman confronts the ethical failures of enforced collectivism, leading to a time-loop resolution where he adopts an American identity to preserve human agency. In extended analysis, Red Son serves as a on , demonstrating that while environment profoundly shapes —Superman internalizes Marxist-Leninist principles, viewing as exploitative—core moral imperatives persist, driving his eventual rejection of . Millar, in interviews, framed the work as questioning whether Superman's heroism stems from Kryptonian biology or American values, with the narrative illustrating causal failures of : material successes (e.g., global resource redistribution eliminating scarcity by the 1980s) breed stagnation and resistance, as Batman embodies libertarian defiance against Superman's paternalistic rule. This contrasts with canonical , whose Kent upbringing fosters ; here, Soviet yields a utilitarian ethic prioritizing utility, yet empirical outcomes—widespread , suppressed , and Pyotr Roslov's (Stalin's son) failed power grab—underscore ideology's practical limits absent voluntary cooperation. Character reinterpretations amplify thematic depth: evolves from nemesis to democratic president by 2000, leveraging intellect for anti-Superman tech like the "red sunlight" device, symbolizing capitalism's adaptive ingenuity. defects to the U.S. as a symbol of free enterprise, while ( analogue) becomes a Soviet psy-ops enforcer, highlighting how superhumans enable state overreach. Superman's arc critiques absolute power's corrupting influence, as his "Brainiac" AI advisor embodies technocratic hubris, mirroring real-world communist experiments' reliance on centralized planning over market signals. The story's acclaim, including an Eisner nomination for Best Limited Series, stems from its rigorous extrapolation: Superman's godlike abilities make ideological purity feasible yet reveal inherent human needs for autonomy, evidenced by defections and underground movements. Earth-30's integration into DC canon post-Flashpoint allows crossovers, such as in Convergence (2015), where Red Son Superman allies with mainstream variants against multiversal threats, affirming the tale's non-canonical status while preserving its analytical value on power dynamics. Critics note the narrative's prescience, anticipating debates on technocratic ; Millar attributed its appeal to avoiding simplistic good-evil binaries, instead probing how benevolent intent under flawed systems yields . Ultimately, Red Son posits causal realism in heroism: Superman's innate decency triumphs over nurture, but only through recognizing ideology's empirical costs, a lesson drawn from historical communist regimes' collapses despite resource advantages.

Superman: Secret Identity

Superman: Secret Identity is a four-issue prestige miniseries published by DC Comics between June and September 2004, written by Kurt Busiek with art by Stuart Immonen, colors by Danny Miki, and lettering by Todd Klein. The narrative unfolds in a contemporary real-world setting where superheroes exist solely as fictional comic book characters, centering on Clark Kent, a teenager from Smallville, Kansas, whose parents named him after the comic hero, leading to lifelong teasing. At age 15 in 1987, Clark awakens to discover he possesses Superman's canonical powers, including superhuman strength, speed, flight, invulnerability, heat vision, freeze breath, and enhanced senses, with no explained origin. The story spans Clark's life across four eras—adolescence (1980s), young adulthood (1990s), midlife (2000s), and old age (2020s)—focusing on his decision to operate as the costumed vigilante "Superman" in secret while navigating civilian existence. He relocates to , works as a for the (ironically mirroring the fictional Lane's colleague), and forms a romance with a colleague named , whom he marries and with whom he has twin daughters, eventually revealing his secret to her. Clark's heroism remains low-key and anonymous, avoiding public spectacle to preserve his dual life, though it draws covert government surveillance via programs like , reflecting post-9/11 privacy concerns. Thematically, the series privileges Clark's humanity over mythic alien origins, portraying his powers as a catalyst for exploring identity duality, ethical restraint, and the burdens of in an ordinary life. Busiek draws parallels to the original Superman's debut as a socially conscious against , but reorients the toward personal rather than global threats, emphasizing how sustained enables without fame's distortions. Immonen's artwork employs realistic proportions and subtle lighting to ground the fantastical elements, enhancing the perspective. Collected in trade paperback in 2004 and later editions, it received acclaim for humanizing the , with critics noting its avoidance of spectacle in favor of quiet heroism.

Just Imagine Stan Lee’s Superman

Just Imagine Stan Lee with John Buscema Creating is a one-shot published by DC Comics on September 19, 2001, as part of the series in which co-creator reimagined DC's iconic characters. Written by Lee and illustrated by , the story diverges sharply from the canonical origin by portraying the hero not as a infant rocketed to but as an adult alien law enforcer named Salden from a distant high-gravity planet. Salden's homeworld features advanced science that grants its inhabitants superhuman abilities by standards, but he refuses performance-enhancing drugs mandated for his role as a "Lawbringer," relying instead on skill and determination. The narrative begins with Salden pursuing the criminal Gundor Gorrok, who murders Salden's wife Lyella in revenge for a prior arrest. Gorrok escapes via a space-time bender device, prompting Salden to follow, which strands him on after a crash landing in the American Southwest. Our planet's lower gravity amplifies Salden's inherent strength to godlike levels, enhanced further by exposure to a green meteor element from his damaged craft, allowing feats like durability, flight via manipulation, and energy projection. Adopting the alias —derived from a headline—and fashioning a from his tattered , including a cape symbolizing his lost home, Salden initially seeks Gorrok but shifts to combating Earth-based threats like mobsters and corrupt officials, driven by a personal code of vengeance and justice rather than altruistic selflessness. This version emphasizes gritty, self-interested heroism akin to Lee's Marvel archetypes, with Salden exhibiting a tough, no-nonsense demeanor and reluctance to trust humans, contrasting the traditional Superman's optimistic immigrant narrative and boy scout morality. The story integrates familiar elements like and (reimagined as a tough reporter) but alters their roles to fit Lee's pulp-influenced style, including brutal action sequences and a focus on Salden's isolation as an outsider. Collected in the 2013 omnibus Just Imagine Stan Lee Creating the , the issue received mixed reception for its bold reinvention, praised by some for Buscema's dynamic art but critiqued for plot inconsistencies and Lee's signature soap-opera tropes applied to Superman's .

Crossovers and Genre Blends

In inter-company crossovers, Superman has been reimagined through fusions that blend his Kryptonian heritage with elements from other franchises, creating hybrid protagonists adapted to shared narratives. The 1996 initiative, a collaborative effort between DC and , produced Super-Soldier as the merger of and . This version, Clark Kent, originates as a World War II government experiment infused with a Kryptonian-derived super-soldier serum, granting enhanced strength, flight, and invulnerability alongside patriotic resolve; he is frozen in ice after a battle and revived in the modern era to confront hybrid villains like Ultra-Metallo (Lex Luthor and combined). Super-Soldier's portrayal emphasizes tactical heroism over raw power, reflecting Captain America's influence in a serum-limited power set that requires strategic use against threats such as Hydra. The 2025 DC x Sonic the Hedgehog miniseries extends crossover blending into video game-inspired action, pitting Superman against Darkseid's dimensional invasion of Sonic's world via the Ranga Rock artifact. Superman retains his core abilities but operates in a high-speed, chaos emerald-infused environment, teaming with Sonic's allies like Knuckles—who shares thematic overlaps in brute strength and guardianship—against Apokoliptian forces. This genre fusion incorporates platforming agility and ring-based power-ups into superhero combat, with Superman's role highlighting interdimensional cooperation amid multiversal threats. Promotional tie-ins, such as action figures depicting Knuckles armored in Superman's iconography, underscore the parallel archetypes of enduring protectors. Genre blends within DC's and event variants alter Superman's upbringing and psyche through historical divergences, yielding isolated, psychologically scarred iterations. In the 1998 JLA: The Nail, a literal nail deflects Kal-El's rocket, preventing his Kent adoption and leading to government captivity; the resulting emerges as a gaunt, albino-like figure with immense but feral power, rescued by and struggling with rage-fueled aggression in a world without his formative moral compass, ultimately aiding a fractured against threats like the Joker. This version critiques unchecked power, portraying as a raw force requiring external restraint rather than inherent optimism. The 2011 Flashpoint timeline, triggered by Barry Allen's time alterations, confines infant Kal-El to Project Superman, a U.S. military experiment subjecting him to lifelong isolation and experimentation. This "Lab Rat" Superman develops as a emaciated, power-suppressed prisoner—designated Subject 1—lacking sunlight exposure and social bonds, manifesting sporadic bursts of strength only upon eventual liberation by and others; his arc culminates in a desperate, vengeful clash with the regime, embodying a of power divorced from nurture. Collected in The World of Flashpoint Featuring Superman, this variant underscores causal links between early deprivation and diminished heroism.

Marvel/DC Amalgamations

Super-Soldier, the primary amalgamation of Superman and Marvel's Captain America, debuted in the intercompany crossover miniseries DC vs. Marvel #3, published in May 1996 by in association with DC Comics. This character embodies a fusion of Superman's heritage and enhanced abilities with Captain America's super-soldier serum origins, reimagined within the shared Amalgam Universe imprint launched that year. Clark Kent, orphaned from the planet and raised in the United States, undergoes a experiment during , receiving a prototype super-soldier serum that amplifies his latent alien physiology, granting him , flight, invulnerability, heat vision, and other powers akin to Superman's while incorporating Captain America's tactical prowess and moral steadfastness. In the character's self-titled four-issue , released starting September 1996, Super-Soldier wields a —echoing America's iconic weapon—and confronts threats like the villainous Luthorlehnsherr, a merger of and Magneto, who seeks to manipulate global conflicts using magnetic mastery and intellectual schemes. Frozen in Arctic ice after a wartime battle for decades, is revived in the present day to lead the All-Star Winners Squadron, a blended team of amalgamated heroes, emphasizing themes of enduring patriotism and superhuman duty amid post-war disillusionment. The series portrays him as a symbol of unyielding heroism, with powers scaled to balance Superman's god-like might with serum-enhanced human limits, avoiding full solar dependency to align with the serum's artificial augmentation. The Amalgam imprint, spanning 1996 to 1997 with 24 one-shots and miniseries, produced limited official Superman fusions beyond Super-Soldier, though secondary characters like Mutant Man—amalgamating with Marvel's —included temporal displacement and energy absorption traits in ensemble stories such as X-Patrol. These amalgamations arose from a brief period of corporate collaboration between Marvel and DC, driven by 1990s market competition, resulting in non-canonical tales that explored hypothetical merged realities without altering primary continuities. Super-Soldier's narrative underscores causal links between WWII-era experimentation and modern heroism, privileging empirical heroism over fantastical invincibility, as evidenced by his reliance on strategic combat and alliances rather than solitary dominance.

DC X Sonic the Hedgehog

The DC X miniseries, published by DC Comics from March to June 2025, features as a key member of the responding to an interdimensional incursion by into Sonic's world, where the villain seeks Chaos Emeralds as a source of ultimate power. Written by with art by Adam Bryce Thomas, the four-issue event depicts collaborating with Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and other Mobians to counter 's forces, emphasizing themes of heroism across universes through high-speed chases and superpowered confrontations. 's portrayal adheres to his core attributes of strength, flight, and moral leadership, as he coordinates defenses and engages Parademons alongside Knuckles, highlighting synergies between might and echidna gliding capabilities. In issue #2, Superman teams directly with Sonic's speedsters, including himself and the Flash, to disrupt Darkseid's dimensional portals, showcasing Superman's tactical invulnerability in a landscape blending ruins with aesthetics. By issue #4, Superman leads the assembled heroes in a climactic assault on Darkseid's stronghold, utilizing heat vision and super-breath adapted to Sonic's ring-collecting mechanics for energy amplification. This integration portrays Superman not as an altered but as a stabilizing force in a chaotic, velocity-driven narrative, where his restraint contrasts with the impulsive energies of his temporary allies. Promotional tie-ins, such as action figures depicting Knuckles in a Superman costume, further blend the characters, with Knuckles adopting Superman-like poses and gliding emulating flight, though these represent merchandise interpretations rather than canonical depictions. The crossover's non-canonical status limits its impact on Superman's primary continuity, serving instead as a fan-service event that tests his against video game pacing and collectible power-ups, without altering his origin or powers. Flynn's scripting, informed by his extensive Sonic work, prioritizes accessible action over deep character reimagining, resulting in Superman functioning as a mentor figure to Knuckles during joint battles, as seen in sequences where the Man of Steel imparts lessons on measured power usage amid emerald-fueled chaos.

JLA: The Nail and Flashpoint Variants

In JLA: The Nail, a 1998 Elseworlds miniseries written and penciled by Alan Davis with inks by Mark Farmer, Kal-El's rocket evades discovery by Jonathan and Martha Kent after their truck suffers a flat tire from a stray nail en route to the crash site in Smallville. The infant is instead located by the Eradicator, a Kryptonian terraforming device programmed for planetary conquest and genetic purity, which activates upon detecting the ship's signal and raises Kal-El in isolation within a crystalline fortress. This upbringing instills in him a rigid, militaristic Kryptonian ideology emphasizing superiority over humans, resulting in an adult Superman who possesses standard Kryptonian abilities—super strength, flight, heat vision, freeze breath, and invulnerability under a yellow sun—but deploys them with greater lethality and emotional detachment compared to the canonical version. Emerging decades later amid escalating human-metahuman tensions exacerbated by Lex Luthor's anti-powered bigotry, this Superman initially views humanity with suspicion but allies with a fractured Justice League against Luthor's genocidal schemes, ultimately sacrificing himself to thwart an imperfect, energy-based duplicate created by The Ray as a weapon. The narrative underscores Superman's role as a moderating influence on metahuman excesses, portraying a world devolving into prejudice and violence without his early benevolent example. In the 2011 Flashpoint event, triggered by Barry Allen's timeline alterations, Kal-El's pod is intercepted mid-flight over by U.S. military forces rather than landing in rural , leading to his indefinite confinement in Project Superman, a black-site initiative led by General Sam Lane to engineer a controllable superweapon. Deprived of sunlight and subjected to experimental suppressants and psychological conditioning for over three decades, the resulting emerges physically emaciated, psychologically feral, and unaccustomed to his latent powers, which include flight, enhanced strength, and energy projection but manifest erratically due to nutritional and solar deprivation. Freed during the Atlantean-Amazonian war ravaging the altered Earth, he immediately demonstrates unchecked rage by incinerating Lane with heat vision and dismembering 's father in a lab explosion, before tentatively joining Thomas Wayne's resistance coalition including Batman (Wayne) and . This variant highlights the causal importance of nurture in 's heroism, depicting governmental secrecy and abuse as fostering monstrosity rather than guardianship, with his arc culminating in a suicidal assault on the Atlantean forces to aid timeline restoration. The storyline, detailed in Flashpoint: The World of Flashpoint Featuring by Rex Ogle and Amarfio Ramos, serves as a prelude to reboot, emphasizing institutional overreach's role in perverting potential saviors into threats.

The Absolute Universe Initiative (2024–Present)

Absolute Superman: Lone Wanderer Reimagining

Absolute Superman reimagines the iconic hero as a solitary adult arrival on , devoid of adoptive family, , or technological sanctuary, emphasizing his role as an itinerant defender of the marginalized. In this version, Kal-El escapes the destruction of and crash-lands on fully grown, immediately confronting a world rife with exploitation and corporate overreach without the nurturing influence of the Kent family or the guidance of a . This iteration strips away elements traditionally providing with stability and support, positioning him as a perpetual outsider who relies solely on his innate powers and to aid the downtrodden. The series, launched as part of DC Comics' imprint on November 6, 2024, is written by and illustrated by Rafa Sandoval, with the narrative framing as the "Absolute Man of Steel" unburdened by earthly ties or home. Without a Clark Kent , he operates openly as a wandering champion, targeting systemic injustices such as oppressive labor conditions and authoritarian control, often clashing with entities like weaponized government agents. This reimagining draws on 's foundational ethos of protecting the vulnerable but amplifies his isolation, portraying him as a self-reliant force shaped by Krypton's loss rather than human upbringing. Key departures from canonical Superman include the absence of Jor-El's holographic mentorship or advanced Kryptonian artifacts, forcing Kal-El to navigate his abilities through trial and direct confrontation with Earth's harsh realities. Early issues depict him intervening in worker uprisings and evading pursuit by militarized forces, underscoring a theme of raw, unmediated heroism. By August 2025, the collected edition Absolute Superman Vol. 1: Last Dust of Krypton compiled the initial arc, highlighting this lone wanderer's unyielding commitment amid a backdrop of global inequities.

Homages, Parodies, and External Inspirations

DC Internal Homages

DC Comics features internal homages to through characters that replicate or distort his core archetype, often emphasizing themes of imperfection, opposition, or fusion with other mythological elements to explore the limits of heroism and identity. These variants, embedded within the main or its , serve as narrative foils, highlighting Superman's virtues by contrasting them with flawed or hybridized counterparts. Unlike external parodies, these homages maintain ties to DC's continuity, frequently interacting with the prime Superman in ways that underscore causal links between creation, duplication, and moral inversion.

Bizarro and Imperfect Duplicates

Bizarro represents a primary internal homage as an imperfect physical and philosophical duplicate of , embodying reversed logic and to critique the hero's perfection. Created by writer and artist , Bizarro first appeared in Superboy #68 in October 1958, originating from a duplicator ray invented by a Kryptonian scientist named to clone for companionship on a desolate planet; the ray's malfunction produced a backward-aging, chalky-skinned entity with inverted powers, such as freeze vision instead of heat vision and a vulnerability to fire rather than sunlight. In subsequent iterations, Bizarro's origin shifted to deliberate villainy, such as Lex Luthor's cloning experiments in post-Crisis continuity or the Joker's manipulation of fifth-dimensional imp Mr. Mxyzptlk's powers in the 2005 Empire of the Atom storyline, yielding a pale, super-strong being who speaks in negated phrases ("Me am not Bizarro") and seeks "good" through destructive acts, like building monuments from ruins. This duplication motif extends to other imperfect copies, including Bizarro's own flawed replicas like Zibarro, a more intelligent but tormented variant from Bizarro World (Htrae), a cubed planet of opposites introduced in Adventure Comics #293 (1962), where reversed societal norms parody Superman's moral absolutism. These duplicates empirically demonstrate causal flaws in replication technology or magic, often resulting in tragic anti-heroes whose existence challenges Superman's isolation as the sole Kryptonian archetype.

Superdemon and Hybrid Entities

Superdemon, the Earth-13 incarnation of , functions as a hybrid homage fusing Superman's extraterrestrial savior origin with demonic possession, adapting the archetype to a mystical, perpetual-twilight realm governed by 13-hour days and 13-month years. Originating from the doomed planet —a direct parallel to —Etrigan was rocketed to Earth-13 by to combat evil, landing as a rhyming, hellfire-wielding protector who leads the League of Shadows against vampiric incursions and arcane threats. This entity first gained prominence in The Multiversity: Guidebook (2015) and expanded in Justice League Incarnate #2 (2022), where Superdemon intervenes in multiversal conflicts, showcasing Superman-like flight and strength augmented by infernal blasts and immortality curses, thus hybridizing solar-powered invincibility with Faustian bargains. Unlike pure duplicates, such hybrids causally integrate Superman's immigrant-hero narrative with DC's occult lore, as seen in Etrigan's battles against interdimensional vampires who exploit magical vulnerabilities absent in the prime Superman's physiology. Other hybrid entities, like the Superman-Etrigan mashup in crossover events, further homage the archetype by probing the empirical tensions between scientific heroism and supernatural agency, often portraying these fusions as unstable power sources prone to moral corruption.

Bizarro and Imperfect Duplicates

Bizarro, Superman's most prominent imperfect duplicate, debuted in Superboy #68 (August 1958), crafted by writer Otto Binder and artist George Papp as a chalky, backward-speaking counterpart formed when a duplicating ray invented by Professor Dalton malfunctioned during a demonstration on Superboy in the bottle city of Kandor. This pre-Crisis iteration embodied reversed morality and logic, with powers inverted—such as flame breath producing ice and freeze vision emitting heat—rendering him a tragic, childlike antagonist who adhered to a "Bizarro Code" prizing imperfection and ugliness. Post-Crisis on Infinite Earths (1985–1986), 's origin shifted to a Lex Luthor-engineered clone via genetic manipulation at LexCorp, debuting as an unstable, radiation-damaged facsimile lacking 's intellect and moral compass, as detailed in Superman vol. 2 #87 (1993) by . This version emphasized causal flaws in cloning technology, where incomplete produced a devolving entity prone to rapid cellular breakdown, often cured temporarily by blue kryptonite. Subsequent iterations, like Bizarro II from Adventures of Superman #444 (1988), arose from Luthor's further experiments, exhibiting enhanced durability but persistent cognitive reversal, leading to alliances with against greater threats before self-destructive ends. Additional imperfect duplicates include , an early flawed copy from Superboy #83 (1961), and the collective Bizarros populating Htrae (), a cubed planet introduced in Adventure Comics #293 (1962), where duplication rays mass-produced reverse-Superman entities, fostering a inverting norms for satirical effect. In modern continuity, such as DC Universe: Rebirth #1 (2016), Luthor's manifests as a hulking, devolved clone deployed as a asset, underscoring themes of scientific hubris in replicating physiology without accounting for solar energy's stabilizing role. These variants collectively homage by exaggerating his archetype's vulnerabilities—physical invulnerability paired with mental frailty—while grounding their existence in verifiable comic precedents of experimental failure rather than innate malevolence.

Superdemon and Hybrid Entities

Superdemon represents a demonic reinterpretation of the Superman within DC's Earth-13, a multiversal reality steeped in magic where traditional science-based heroes are supplanted by supernatural counterparts. In this iteration, the demon Etrigan is rocketed from the perishing planet to Earth-13, assuming the mantle of protector under Merlin's directive and combating threats alongside the League of Shadows. Unlike the solar-powered original, Superdemon draws strength from hellfire and infernal magic, embodying a chaotic, rhyming anti-hero who inverts Superman's optimistic idealism with brute, otherworldly force. This version debuted as part of Grant Morrison's The project, highlighting how DC adapts core heroic tropes to fantastical domains. Hybrid entities in Superman lore often emerge from experimental genetic manipulations or viral interventions, blending the Man of Steel's physiology with alien or adversarial elements to create unstable, powerful adversaries. In continuity, engineers a "Hybrid" Superman via a DNA-rewriting that infects and alters the original, producing a monstrous duplicate designed to overpower its progenitor; Superman's eventually neutralizes the infection, but the resultant entity persists as a targeted weapon. Such constructs underscore causal vulnerabilities in Superman's biology, where external agents exploit his cellular adaptability to forge rivals that mimic yet exceed his capabilities, as seen in Luthor's repeated attempts to "improve" upon superiority through hybridization. These variants serve as internal homages, exploring themes of identity fragmentation and the perils of unchecked bio-engineering within DC's narrative framework.

Non-DC Parodies and Archetypes

, the flagship character of Media's series debuting in June 1993, serves as a prominent echoing Superman's alien refugee motif while incorporating distinct socio-political elements. Created by writer and artist Turner, Icon—real name Augustus Freeman IV—is an extraterrestrial explorer whose scout ship crashed in in 1839, leading to his adoption into human society and assumption of a conservative persona. His physiology grants , flight, speed, invulnerability, and energy absorption/projection abilities, paralleling Superman's power set but derived from a cellular structure that mimics solar empowerment with added versatility for energy manipulation. Unlike Superman's optimistic immigrant narrative, Icon embodies generational wealth and , often clashing with progressive vigilantes like his , reflecting creator McDuffie's intent to diversify tropes amid 1990s urban storytelling. Milestone Media, founded in 1993 by African American creators including McDuffie, , Jim Hudson, and Michael Davis, positioned as a counterpoint to mainstream archetypes, emphasizing black cultural experiences without direct . The character's longevity includes crossovers and relaunches, such as the 2021 Milestone relaunch under DC's imprint, yet his core design predates full integration, maintaining an independent ethos in exploring themes of identity and power dynamics. 's narrative critiques systemic issues through a lens of personal responsibility, diverging from Superman's universal heroism by grounding abilities in and ethical .

Broader Cultural Parodies

Beyond Milestone, independent and rival publishers have produced Superman substitutes as parodies or archetypes, often to circumvent licensing while satirizing or reinterpreting the Man of Steel's invincibility and moral absolutism. Supreme, introduced by Image Comics in Youngblood #3 (1992) and later refined by Alan Moore in Supreme (1996–2000), exemplifies a direct homage turned parody: an ageless hero with solar-powered flight, strength, and heat vision, whose metafictional adventures lampoon Superman's mythos through deconstruction of comic history and celebrity culture. Moore's run explicitly nods to Superman's Siegel-Shuster origins, portraying Supreme as a dimension-hopping everyman whose "real world" alter ego critiques media commodification of icons. The Plutonian from ' Irredeemable (2009–2012), created by , offers a darker , depicting a Superman-like guardian who snaps under public scrutiny, slaughtering millions in a causal chain of burnout and resentment toward ungrateful humanity. This inverts Superman's restraint, attributing downfall to psychological strain rather than inherent evil, with powers including planet-shattering strength and breath used for mass destruction. Similarly, Homelander in Dynamite Entertainment's The Boys comics (2006–2012) by parodies the through corporate corruption: a supe with flight, eyes, and super strength marketed as a savior but driven by and abuse, exposing how unchecked power fosters tyranny absent Superman's ethical core. In anime and manga, Saitama of One Punch Man (serialized from 2009) functions as a satirical archetype, a bald hero who achieves effortless invincibility through mundane training, parodying Superman's overwhelming might by reducing heroism to boredom and existential ennui amid escalating threats. This gag-driven take, originating as a webcomic by ONE, highlights the trope's fatigue in overpowered narratives, with Saitama's casual defeats underscoring parody over homage. These non-DC iterations collectively demonstrate the archetype's adaptability, often amplifying flaws like isolation or hubris to probe real-world power structures, though they risk diluting the original's aspirational foundation without equivalent narrative discipline.

Icon and Milestone Media Echoes

Icon, the flagship character of Milestone Media's debut lineup, serves as a deliberate homage to Superman, reimagining the archetypal alien savior through the lens of African-American history and social critique. Created by writer Dwayne McDuffie and artist M.D. Bright, Icon first appeared in Icon #1 in June 1993, depicting Augustus Freeman IV—an extraterrestrial from the planet Terminus who crash-landed in Alabama in 1839—as a long-lived figure who assumed a human guise amid slavery and later rose to prominence as a conservative businessman and civil rights-era icon. His powers, derived from exposure to Earth's yellow sun, include superhuman strength capable of leveling buildings, invulnerability to conventional weaponry, flight at supersonic speeds, heat vision, and enhanced senses, positioning him as a near-peer to Superman in raw capability while emphasizing grounded, street-level applications over cosmic battles. This echoing of Superman's origin— an otherworldly refugee adopting human identity and wielding godlike abilities for protection—aligns with and Joe Shuster's 1938 intent for the Man of Steel to combat societal ills like and inequality, rather than solely extraterrestrial foes, a focus McDuffie revived in Icon's narrative of addressing and gang violence in Dakota. Unlike Superman's optimistic assimilation into American heartland values, Icon's story critiques assimilation through Freeman's initial conservatism, shaped by his 19th-century Southern upbringing, which clashes with his protégé Rocket's (Raquel Ervin) radical activism, highlighting tensions between individual uplift and systemic reform. McDuffie, a Milestone co-founder alongside , Michael Davis, and Jim Hudson, established the imprint in 1993 to center black protagonists, with Icon embodying a "black Superman" archetype that prioritizes cultural representation without direct imitation. Milestone's broader roster occasionally nods to Superman analogs, such as , a 1938-debuting hero in the Dakotaverse whose stature as a benchmark for other powered individuals mirrors 's foundational role in lore, though Tower remains a minor figure without 's prominence. Crossovers like the 1994 Worlds Collide event pitted against , affirming their parallel power sets while underscoring Icon's distinct thematic emphasis on personal agency amid racial strife. These echoes, distributed through DC's partnership with , underscore the archetype's adaptability, influencing later revivals such as the 2021 digital-first Icon and : Season One series, which reaffirmed Icon's role in exploring heroism's conservative versus progressive dimensions.

Broader Cultural Parodies

Underdog, an animated television series produced by Total Television Productions and premiered on on October 3, 1964, features a canine who transforms from a humble shoeshine boy into a caped crusader via energy pills consumed in a phone booth, directly spoofing Superman's and quick-change mechanics. The character, voiced by , delivers rhyming heroic declarations and exhibits flight, super strength, and invulnerability, exaggerating the archetype's bombast while concluding episodes with the ironic sign-off "There's no need to fear, Underdog is here!" after initial failures. The series ran through , influencing later satires with its blend of earnest heroism and comedic ineptitude against villains like Simon Bar Sinister. In children's educational media, 's Super Grover, debuting in the 1970s and voiced by , parodies 's iconic introduction—"faster than a speeding bullet, more powerful than a locomotive, able to leap tall buildings in a single bound"—while consistently bungling feats like crashing into walls or failing to fly properly. Clad in a red cape and blue outfit as alter ego Grover Kent, the Muppet emphasizes problem-solving and perseverance through trial-and-error segments, subverting the flawless invincibility of the original for teachable moments on resilience. Robert Mayer's 1977 novel Superfolks, published by Dial Press, satirizes the superhero genre through protagonist , a retired, depowered analogue to who grapples with suburban ennui, impotence, and absurd threats like a giant , critiquing the archetype's detachment from human frailty and aging. The book analogizes other heroes—e.g., a Batman-like figure—and employs adult humor to dismantle the escapist purity of narratives, influencing later deconstructions like those in Alan Moore's works. Contemporary inversions appear in The Boys (Amazon Prime Video, premiered 2019), where Homelander, originated in Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson's 2006 comic but culturally amplified via Antony Starr's portrayal, embodies a lab-created Superman surrogate driven by narcissism, mommy issues, and authoritarian impulses rather than altruism. His laser vision, flight, and invulnerability enable atrocities masked as heroism, lampooning corporate commodification of icons and the perils of god-like power without ethical restraint. In animation, (DreamWorks, released November 5, 2010) introduces Metro Man, voiced by , as an alien exile who adopts the mold—super speed, strength, and a Metropolis-like city defense—but abruptly retires for a life of music and leisure, mocking the trope of unending duty. This self-aware twist highlights the archetype's potential for burnout, contrasting with villain Megamind's obsession.

Representations in Film, Television, and Animation

Animated Series and Direct-to-Video Variants

Animated series within the DC Animated Universe (DCAU) have portrayed alternative Supermen primarily through multiverse explorations, emphasizing divergences in moral philosophy and governance. In the two-part episode "A Better World" from Justice League (2003), which sets up arcs continuing into Justice League Unlimited (2004–2006), an alternate Superman known as Justice Lord Superman emerges from a parallel Earth. This version, alongside his Justice Lords teammates, imposes draconian order after killing President Lex Luthor to avert a nuclear war initiated by Luthor's schemes; he routinely lobotomizes criminals instead of incarcerating them, viewing such measures as necessary for absolute peace. Voiced by Tim Daly like the prime Superman, this iteration critiques unchecked heroism by demonstrating how trauma—here, the loss of innocents in Luthor's conflict—can erode restraint, leading to tyranny masked as protection.) The narrative contrasts this authoritarian with the main universe's collaborative Justice League, highlighting causal links between pivotal choices and societal outcomes. Direct-to-video animated films extend these themes with cloned and psychologically fractured Supermen, often triggered by personal catastrophe. The 2007 film Superman: Doomsday, adapting "The Death of Superman" storyline, features a clone engineered by Lex Luthor using Superman's post-Doomsday battle DNA. This duplicate, initially clad in a black Kryptonian recovery suit, displays amplified aggression, summarily executing low-level threats like escaped convict Metallo, diverging from the original's no-kill code. Regenerated original Superman, empowered by a solar matrix, confronts and dismantles the clone in Metropolis, underscoring Luthor's manipulative exploitation of genetic material for control. The clone embodies a distorted mirror, prioritizing dominance over justice, as evidenced by its lethal tactics against human foes. The 2021 film , drawn from the Injustice: Gods Among Us continuity, depicts a regime-building Superman radicalized by the Joker's orchestration of Lane's death—via toxin-induced triggering a nuclear detonation in . This alternate Kal-El, voiced by , executes the Joker publicly, then coerces global submission through the One Earth Regime, allying with select heroes while battling resistors like Batman. Empirical fallout includes subjugated nations and hero schisms, with Superman's solar-enhanced might enforcing a paternalistic order he deems essential post-tragedy, though critics note the adaptation's rushed pacing compresses the source's multi-year escalation. Such portrayals prioritize causal realism, tracing to grief-fueled overreach rather than inherent villainy. Additional direct-to-video entries include Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths (2010), introducing as the Crime Syndicate's Superman counterpart from Earth-3—an inverted morality universe where he gains strength from Kryptonite exposure under a . This villainous variant leads interdimensional conquests, inverting heroic tropes by allying with President Lex Luthor's good counterpart against the Syndicate's tyranny. These depictions collectively substantiate Superman's archetype's robustness, tested via empirical stressors like loss, , or ethical inversion, without reliance on mainstream media narratives favoring redemption arcs over stark consequences.

Justice League Unlimited and Multiverse Episodes

In the DC Animated Universe, an alternate version of Superman known as Lord Superman appears in the Justice League two-part episode "A Better World," which aired on November 1, 2003. This multiverse storyline depicts a parallel Earth where the murder of Lois Lane by the Joker using a lethal toxin drives Superman to violate his no-kill principle by snapping the Joker's neck in rage. Subsequently, after Lex Luthor's election as president and his orchestration of the Joker's release from prison, Lord Superman confronts and executes Luthor in the Oval Office, prompting the Justice League to overthrow the U.S. government and establish a global dictatorship to eradicate crime, war, and poverty—albeit at the expense of civil liberties, free will, and democratic processes. Lord Superman retains the standard Kryptonian physiology and powers of his mainstream counterpart, including super strength, flight, invulnerability, heat vision, and freeze breath, but exhibits a more authoritarian demeanor, justifying lethal force as a necessary tool for imposing order. The , led by this version of , detect the main Justice League's universe through a dimensional anomaly and cross over to supplant their counterparts, capturing the League and attempting to brainwash them into adopting the Lords' methods. A pivotal confrontation ensues between the two Supermen, highlighting the ideological clash: the mainstream Superman upholds restraint and without tyranny, ultimately resisting the Lords' influence while his teammates disrupt the invasion. The episode explores the causal risks of unchecked superhuman power, positing that personal tragedy can erode moral boundaries, leading to dystopian outcomes rather than heroic . This multiverse event carries over into , influencing the Cadmus Project arc across multiple episodes in season 1, particularly "Question Authority," which aired on February 5, 2005. The vigilante Question uncovers classified records of the Justice League's encounter with the Lords, revealing how alternate Superman's killing of Luthor exemplified the potential for the League to devolve into rulers, fueling government paranoia and the creation of human-made countermeasures like clones and weaponry. These references underscore a recurring theme in Unlimited of institutional distrust toward Superman's god-like abilities, portraying the Lords' path as a cautionary divergence where emotional loss overrides ethical constraints, without depicting the variant's physical return.

Injustice Animated Adaptations

The Injustice animated film, released digitally on October 19, 2021, and on physical media on October 26, 2021, adapts the premise of the 2013 video game Injustice: Gods Among Us and its prequel comics, portraying an alternate who establishes a totalitarian following personal tragedy. In this continuity, (voiced by ), manipulated by the Joker into killing his pregnant wife and inadvertently destroying via a nuclear detonation, abandons his moral restraint and enforces global peace through fear and lethal force, forming the "Regime" with loyal members while clashing with Batman (Anson Mount) and dissenters. This version diverges from the canonical heroic by emphasizing his godlike power as a tool for authoritarian control, rationalized as necessary to eradicate threats like supervillains, though it compresses the source material's multiyear arc into a 78-minute runtime, omitting key comic elements such as the full Insurgency buildup and character backstories. Superman's characterization in the film highlights a causal chain from grief-induced rage to ideological tyranny, where he imprisons or executes opponents, including heroes like and who join him, while portraying Batman as the defender of flawed human freedom; the narrative culminates in a multiversal confrontation with a prime-Earth who rejects the Regime's methods. Directed by Matt Peters and produced by , the adaptation received mixed reception for its animation quality and voice acting but criticism for rushed pacing and deviations, such as early deaths of characters like and Yellow Lantern, which undermine the story's exploration of power corruption. No direct animated sequel adapting (2017) has been produced as of 2025, though fan discussions and reviews speculate on potential expansions.

Live-Action and Hybrid Media Takes

Live-action television has prominently featured alternative versions of Superman, often as flawed duplicates or multiverse counterparts diverging from the canonical hero. In the series (2001–2011), emerges as a key imperfect duplicate, originating as the last wraith that possesses a Kryptonian corpse animated by black , granting it reversed abilities: enhanced strength in darkness but vulnerability to sunlight, contrasting Clark Kent's solar-powered physiology. Introduced in the season 7 premiere "Bizarro," aired September 27, 2007, this entity impersonates Clark, exhibiting erratic behavior and pursuing , before being destroyed in a confrontation that highlights its unstable, antagonistic nature. The CW series Superman & Lois (2021–2024) expands on multiverse divergences, with portraying multiple Superman variants alongside the primary Clark Kent. These include Superman from an alternate Earth, depicted as a more savage, irradiated version with distorted features and aggressive tendencies, who arrives via a portal and clashes with the main hero in season 1. Hoechlin also embodies other iterations, such as the mind-controlled "evil" in the 2018 Elseworlds crossover, where a reality-altering stone transforms him into a tyrannical ruler imposing on National City, distinguishable by a black suit and authoritarian demeanor. Additionally, the show features Superman from John Henry Irons' alternate universe, a battle-hardened figure arriving with advanced technology to combat perceived threats, underscoring causal divergences in upbringing and environmental factors shaping heroic identity. James Gunn's (2025), released July 11, 2025, presents a contextual twist on the archetype within the rebooted , blending classic optimism with ensemble integration and fantastical elements atypical of prior gritty cinematic portrayals. David Corenswet's Clark Kent operates in a world already populated by heroes like Mr. Terrific and , emphasizing collaborative heroism over solitary icon status, while incorporating whimsical threats such as interdimensional monsters and pocket universes, diverging from the restrained realism of Zack Snyder's iteration. The film restores traditional costume elements like red trunks and prioritizes internal emotional conflicts—Clark's struggle with identity and kindness amid cynicism—over physical invincibility, fostering a narrative realism grounded in hopeful causality rather than deconstructed angst. This approach, informed by Gunn's vision of Superman as an aspirational , yields a less violent, heart-centered depiction that critiques prior versions' tonal imbalances without endorsing institutional narratives of heroism.

Smallville and Superman & Lois Divergences

Smallville (2001–2011), developed by and , chronicles Clark Kent's teenage years in , emphasizing his gradual acquisition of powers and reluctance to embrace a public heroic identity, diverging from comic portrayals where operates as a fully powered adult icon from early in his mythos. Clark exhibits super strength and speed from the pilot episode aired October 16, 2001, but other abilities manifest episodically: in "X-Ray" (November 6, 2001), in "Heat" (February 5, 2002), and flight only in season 10's "Finale" (May 13, 2011), contrasting comics' depiction of near-instantaneous power suite post-arrival on Earth. The series forgoes Clark's traditional glasses disguise, relying instead on behavioral contrasts between his mild-mannered persona and Kryptonian strength, and introduces in season 4 without the classic involving a prior interest like dominating early arcs as in pre-Crisis comics. Villains frequently stem from Kryptonite-mutated "meteor freaks" rather than extraterrestrial or criminal foes, while Doomsday appears as the human Davis Bloome, a shape-shifting vessel, unlike the comics' mindless, evolved Kryptonian monster. evolves from childhood ally to antagonist through personal betrayals, amplifying moral ambiguity absent in standard canon where their enmity arises from ideological clashes post-'s debut. Superman & Lois (2021–2024), created by Todd Helbing and Greg , reimagines an established () relocating to with () and their twin sons Jonathan and Jordan after 20 years in , introducing familial pressures like and inherited powers that sidestep ' typical or dynamics until later eras like the 2011 . Jordan inherits abilities including flight and invulnerability, while Jonathan initially lacks them due to prenatal exposure, inverting traditional lore where 's offspring, such as in Kingdom Come or Superman & Supergirl: Maelstrom, exhibit powers without such medical caveats. The series features as an alternate-world variant ruling a dystopian with inverted moral alignments, diverging from ' imperfect duplicate originating from a flawed process in #254 (1959). () is portrayed as Clark's childhood acquaintance turned foe, echoing 's relational depth but conflicting with canon where Luthor's grudge forms after repeated public confrontations. Season 4, concluding December 3, 2024, culminates in Lois's death from recurring cancer and Clark aging into humanity without powers, a closure emphasizing mortality over the enduring invincibility central to 's .

Upcoming James Gunn Superman (2025) Contextual Twists

's (2025), released on July 11, 2025, introduces contextual twists to the character's lore by reimagining Kal-El's heritage as morally compromised, diverging from the traditional depiction of and Lara as virtuous scientists who sacrificially launch their infant son to to escape planetary doom. In this version, the parents' involvement in Krypton's authoritarian or corrupt elements frames 's heroism as a deliberate rejection of his alien lineage rather than an inherited destiny, a change Gunn drew from select comic precedents and the series while amplifying for thematic emphasis on personal agency and found family. This alteration has sparked debate among fans and critics, with some arguing it dilutes the immigrant central to Superman's creation as a symbol of assimilation and for outsiders, as Kal-El's upbringing by the Kents becomes a sharper contrast to a tainted biological origin rather than a seamless extension of parental benevolence. Gunn has defended the twist as enhancing the narrative's exploration of Superman's internal conflict between his alien "otherness" and human empathy, positioning Kent's choices—such as intervening in Lex Luthor's engineered —as affirmations of nurture over nature. The film omits a full origin retelling, assuming an established Superman in a shared , which shifts focus to consequences of his actions, like public backlash and alliances with other heroes, rather than discovery of powers. Thematically, Gunn emphasizes Superman's optimism and individual rescues amid ensemble chaos, contrasting darker prior adaptations by highlighting vulnerability and restraint—Superman sustains severe defeats and prioritizes civilian protection over spectacle—while integrating elements like Krypto the Superdog to underscore loyalty and whimsy drawn from . Lex Luthor's plot, involving fabricated threats and anti-alien sentiment, tests Superman's restraint against authoritarian manipulation, twisting the classic rivalry into a commentary on unchecked power without endorsing interventionist overreach. Critics note this lighter tone restores "heart" to the but risks diluting stakes through off-screen resolutions, such as the inciting war halt. Overall, these twists prioritize psychological depth and moral ambiguity in Kryptonian legacy, making heroism a conscious ethic amid flawed inheritance.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.