Hubbry Logo
Smithfield, LondonSmithfield, LondonMain
Open search
Smithfield, London
Community hub
Smithfield, London
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Smithfield, London
Smithfield, London
Smithfield, London
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

City of London coat of arms

Key Information

Smithfield, properly known as West Smithfield,[1] is a district located in Central London, part of Farringdon Without, the most westerly ward of the City of London, England.

Smithfield is home to a number of City institutions, such as St Bartholomew's Hospital and livery halls, including those of the Butchers' and Haberdashers' Companies. The area is best known for the Smithfield meat market, which dates from the 10th century, has been in continuous operation since medieval times,[2] and is now London's only remaining wholesale market. Smithfield's principal street is called West Smithfield.[3][4] Each summer, from the 12th century to the 19th century the area hosted Bartholomew Fair, and the area also contains the City's oldest surviving church building, St Bartholomew-the-Great, dating from 1123 (most City churches were destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666).

The area is located just beyond the New Gate and formerly its prison which held condemned prisoners. In former centuries, especially prior to the establishment of Tyburn, the area bore witness to many executions of heretics and political rebels,[5] as well as Scottish knight Sir William Wallace, and Wat Tyler, leader of the Peasants' Revolt, among many other religious reformers and dissenters (later on, public executions were generally moved out to Tyburn, until being moved back to the prison).

The present Smithfield Market, a Grade II listed-covered market building, was designed by Victorian architect Sir Horace Jones in the second half of the 19th century, and is the dominant architectural feature of the area.[6] Some of its original market premises fell into disuse in the late 20th century and faced the prospect of demolition. The Corporation of London's public enquiry in 2012[7] drew widespread support for an urban regeneration plan intent upon preserving Smithfield's historical identity.[8]

Smithfield area

[edit]
Smithfield from the "woodcut" map of c. 1561, illustrating its proximity with open fields to the west, and cattle pens by the City

In the Middle Ages, it was a broad grassy area known as Smooth Field, located beyond London Wall stretching to the eastern bank of the River Fleet. Given its ease of access to grazing and water, Smithfield established itself as London's livestock market, remaining so for almost 1,000 years. Many local toponyms are associated with the livestock trade: while some street names (such as "Cow Cross Street" and "Cock Lane") remain in use, many more (such as "Chick Lane", "Duck Lane", "Cow Lane", "Pheasant Court", "Goose Alley"[9]) have disappeared from the map after the major redevelopment of the area in the Victorian era.

Religious history

[edit]

In 1123, the area near Aldersgate was granted by King Henry I for the foundation of St Bartholomew's Priory at the request of Prior Rahere, in thanks for his being nursed back to good health. The Priory exercised its right to enclose land between the vicinity of the boundary with Aldersgate Without (to the east), Long Lane (to the north) and modern-day Newgate Street (to the south), erecting its main western gate which opened onto Smithfield, and a postern on Long Lane. By facing the open space of Smithfield and by having 'its back to' the buildings lining Aldersgate Street, the Priory site has left a continuing legacy of limited connectivity between the Smithfield area and Aldersgate Street.

The Priory thereafter held the manorial rights to hold weekly fairs, which initially took place in its outer court on the site of present-day Cloth Fair,[10] leading to "Fair Gate".[11]

An additional annual celebration, the Bartholomew Fair, was established in 1133 by the Augustinian canons. Over time, this became one of London's pre-eminent summer fairs, opening each year on 24 August. A trading event for cloth and other goods as well as being a pleasure forum, the four-day festival drew crowds from all strata of English society.

Smithfield in 1827, from John Greenwood's map of London

In 1855, however, the City authorities closed Bartholomew Fair as they considered it to have degenerated into a magnet for debauchery and public disorder.[12][13]

In 1348, Walter de Manny rented 13 acres (0.05 km2) of land at Spital Croft, north of Long Lane, from the Master and Brethren of St Bartholomew's Hospital, for a graveyard and plague pit for victims of the Black Death. A chapel and hermitage were constructed, renamed New Church Haw; but in 1371, this land was granted for the foundation of the Charterhouse, originally a Carthusian monastery.[14]

Nearby and to the north of this demesne, the Knights Hospitaller established a Commandery at Clerkenwell, dedicated to St John in the mid-12th century. In 1194 they received a Charter from King Richard I granting the Order formal privileges.[15] Later Augustinian canonesses established the Priory of St Mary, north of the Knights of St John property.[16]

By the end of the 14th century, these religious houses were regarded by City traders as interlopers – occupying what had previously been public open space near one of the City gates. On numerous occasions vandals damaged the Charterhouse, eventually demolishing its buildings. By 1405, a stout wall was built to protect the property and maintain the privacy of the Order, particularly its church where men and women alike came to worship.[14]

The religious houses were dissolved in the Reformation,[17] and their lands broken up. The Priory Church of St John remains,[18] as does St John's Gate.[19] John Houghton (later canonized by Pope Paul VI as St John Houghton),[20] The prior of Charterhouse went to Thomas Cromwell, accompanied by two other local priors, seeking an oath of supremacy that would be acceptable to their communities. Instead they were imprisoned in the Tower of London, and on 4 May 1535, they were taken to Tyburn and hanged – becoming the first Catholic martyrs of the Reformation. On 29 May, the remaining twenty monks and eighteen lay brothers were forced to swear the oath of allegiance to King Henry VIII; the ten who refused were taken to Newgate Prison and left to starve.[21]

With the monks expelled, Charterhouse was requisitioned and remained as a private dwelling until its reestablishment by Thomas Sutton in 1611 as a charitable foundation; it was the basis of the school named Charterhouse and almshouses known as Sutton's Hospital in Charterhouse on its former site. The school was relocated to Godalming in 1872. Until 1899 Charterhouse was extra-parochial;[22] that year it became a civil parish incorporated in the Metropolitan Borough of Finsbury.[23] Some of the property was damaged during The Blitz, but it remains largely intact. Part of the site is now occupied by Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry.

From its inception, the Priory of St Bartholomew treated the sick. After the Reformation it was left with neither income nor monastic occupants but, following a petition by the City Corporation, Henry VIII refounded it in December 1546, as the "House of the Poore in West Smithfield in the suburbs of the City of London of Henry VIII's Foundation". Letters Patent were presented to the City, granting property and income to the new foundation the following month. King Henry VIII's sergeant-surgeon, Thomas Vicary, was appointed as the hospital's first superintendent.[24] The King Henry VIII Gate, which opens onto West Smithfield, was completed in 1702 and remains the hospital's main entrance.[25]

The Priory's principal church, St Bartholomew-the-Great, was reconfigured after the dissolution of the monasteries, losing the western third of its nave. Reformed as an Anglican parish church, its parish boundaries were limited to the site of the ancient priory and a small tract of land between the church and Long Lane. The parish of St Bartholomew the Great was designated as a Liberty, responsible for the upkeep and security of its fabric and the land within its boundaries. With the advent of street lighting, mains water, and sewerage during the Victorian era, maintenance of such an ancient parish with so few parishioners became increasingly uneconomical after the Industrial Revolution. In 1910, it agreed to be incorporated by the Corporation of London which guaranteed financial support and security. Great St Barts' present parish boundary includes just 10 feet (3.048 m) of Smithfield – possibly delineating a former right of way.[11]

After the Reformation, a separate parish likewise dedicated to St Bartholomew was granted in favour of St Bartholomew's Hospital; named St Bartholomew-the-Less, it remained under the hospital's patronage, unique in the Church of England, until 1948, when the hospital was nationalized in the National Health Service.[26] The church benefice has since been joined again with its ancient partner, the Priory Church of St Bartholomew the Great.[27]

Following the diminished influence of the ancient Priory, predecessor of the two parishes of St Bartholomew, disputes began to arise over rights to tithes and taxes payable by lay residents who claimed allegiance with the nearby and anciently associated parish of St Botolph Aldersgate – an unintended consequence and legacy of King Henry VIII's religious reforms.[11]

Smithfield and its market, situated mostly in the parish of St Sepulchre, was founded in 1137, and was endowed by Prior Rahere, who also founded St Barts. The ancient parish of St Sepulchre extended north to Turnmill Street, to St Paul's Cathedral and Ludgate Hill in the south, and along the east bank of the Fleet (now the route of Farringdon Street). St Sepulchre's Tower contains the twelve "bells of Old Bailey", referred to in the nursery rhyme "Oranges and Lemons". Traditionally, the Great Bell was rung to announce the execution of a prisoner at Newgate.

Civil history

[edit]

As a large open space close to the City, Smithfield was a popular place for public gatherings. In 1374 Edward III held a seven-day tournament at Smithfield, for the amusement of his beloved Alice Perrers. Possibly the most famous medieval tournament at Smithfield was that commanded in 1390 by Richard II.[28] Jean Froissart, in his fourth book of Chronicles, reported that sixty knights would come to London to tilt for two days, "accompanied by sixty noble ladies, richly ornamented and dressed".[29] The tournament was proclaimed by heralds throughout England, Scotland, Hainault, Germany, Flanders and France, so as to rival the jousts given by Charles of France at Paris a few years earlier, upon the arrival of his consort Isabel of Bavaria.[30] Geoffrey Chaucer supervised preparations for the tournament as a clerk to the King.[31] It is told that, between 1389 and 1394, another large tournament was celebrated in the city[32] which spawned the Portuguese legend of the Twelve of England, where twelve Portuguese knights were called to defend the honour of several ladies-in-waiting of John of Gaunt's castillian wife Constance of Castile.[33] At the time, John of Gaunt's daughter Philipa of Lancaster was married to John of Aviz, King of Portugal, lending credence to the story, although how much and which parts of it are true is still debated.

Depiction of Wat Tyler's demise by the hand of Sir William Walworth in the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, with Richard II watching at right

Along with Tyburn, Smithfield was for centuries the main site for the public execution of heretics and dissidents in London. The Scottish nobleman Sir William Wallace was executed in 1305 at West Smithfield. The market was the meeting place prior to the Peasants' Revolt and where the Revolt's leader, Wat Tyler, was slain by Sir William Walworth, Lord Mayor of London on 15 June 1381.[34]

Religious dissenters (Catholics as well as other Protestant denominations such as Anabaptists) were sentenced to death in this area during the Crown's changing course of religious orientation started by King Henry VIII. About fifty Protestants and religious reformers, known as the Marian martyrs, were executed at Smithfield during the reign of Mary I.

G. K. Chesterton observed ironically:

It is foolish, generally speaking, for a philosopher to set fire to another philosopher in Smithfield Market because they do not agree in their theory of the universe. That was done very frequently in the last decadence of the Middle Ages, and it failed altogether in its object.

— Heretics 1905

On 17 November 1558, several Protestant heretics were saved by a royal herald's timely announcement that Queen Mary had died shortly before the wooden faggots were to be lit at the Smithfield Stake. Under English Law death warrants were commanded by Sign Manual (the personal signature of the Monarch), invariably upon ministerial recommendation, which if unexercised by the time of a Sovereign's death required renewed authority. In this case Queen Elizabeth did not approve the executions, thus freeing the Protestants. During the 16th century, the Smithfield site was also the place of execution of swindlers and coin forgers, who were boiled to death in oil.

By the 18th century, the "Tyburn Tree" (near the present-day Marble Arch) became the main place for public executions in London.[35] After 1785, executions were again moved, this time to the gates of Newgate Prison, just to the south of Smithfield.

The Smithfield area emerged largely unscathed by the Great Fire of London in 1666, which was abated near the Fortune of War Tavern, at the junction of Giltspur Street and Cock Lane, where the statue of the Golden Boy of Pye Corner is located. In the late 17th century several residents of Smithfield emigrated to North America, where they founded the town of Smithfield, Rhode Island.

West Smithfield Bars

[edit]

Until the 19th century, the area included boundary markers known as the West Smithfield Bars (or more simply, Smithfield Bars).[36] These marked the northern boundary of the City of London and were placed at a point approximating to where modern Charterhouse Street meets St John Street, which was historically the first stretch of the Great North Road. The Bars were on the route of the former Fagswell Brook, a tributary of the Fleet, which marked the City's northern boundary in the area.

Cloth Fair, West Smithfield, looking West, 1904 by Philip Norman

The Bars are first documented in 1170[36] and 1197,[37] and were a site of public executions.[38]

Today

[edit]

Since the late 1990s, Smithfield and neighbouring Farringdon have developed a reputation for being a cultural hub for up-and-coming professionals, who enjoy its bars, restaurants and nightclubs.

Nightclubs such as Fabric and Turnmills pioneered the area's reputation for trendy night life, attracting professionals from nearby Holborn, Clerkenwell and the City on weekdays. At weekends, the clubs and bars in the area, having late licences, draw people into the area from outside London too.

Smithfield has also become a venue for sporting events. Until 2002 Smithfield hosted the midnight start of the annual Miglia Quadrato car treasure hunt, but with the increased night club activity around Smithfield, the UHULMC (a motoring club) decided to move the event's start to Finsbury Circus. Since 2007, Smithfield has been the chosen site of an annual event dedicated to road bicycle racing known as the Smithfield Nocturne.[39]

Number 1, West Smithfield is head office of the Churches Conservation Trust.

Market

[edit]
Map outlining Smithfield Market's main buildings

Origins

[edit]

Meat has been traded at Smithfield Market for more than 800 years, making it one of the oldest markets in London.[40] A livestock market occupied the site as early as the 10th century.

In 1174 the site was described by William Fitzstephen as:

a smooth field where every Friday there is a celebrated rendezvous of fine horses to be traded, and in another quarter are placed vendibles of the peasant, swine with their deep flanks, and cows and oxen of immense bulk.[40]

Costs, customs and rules were meticulously laid down. For instance, for an ox, a cow or a dozen sheep one could get 1 penny.[41] The livestock market expanded over the centuries to meet demand from the growing population of the City. In 1710, the market was surrounded by a wooden fence containing the livestock within the market. Until the market's abolition, the Gate House at Cloth Fair ("Fair Gate") employed a chain (le cheyne) on market days.[11] Daniel Defoe referred to the livestock market in 1726 as being "without question, the greatest in the world",[42] and data available appear to corroborate his statement.

Between 1740 and 1750 the average yearly sales at Smithfield were reported to be around 74,000 cattle and 570,000 sheep.[43] By the middle of the 19th century, in the course of a single year 220,000 head of cattle and 1,500,000 sheep would be "violently forced into an area of five acres, in the very heart of London, through its narrowest and most crowded thoroughfares".[44] The volume of cattle driven daily to Smithfield started to raise major concerns.

The Great North Road traditionally began at Smithfield Market, with St John Street and Islington High Street forming the initial stages. Road mileages were taken from Hicks Hall, a short distance up St John Street, some 90 metres north of the West Smithfield Bars. The site of the hall continued to be used as the starting point for mileages even after it was demolished soon after 1778.[45] The road followed St John Street, and continued north, eventually leading to Edinburgh. Using the former site of the hall as the starting point ended in 1829, with the establishment of the General Post Office at St Martin's-le-Grand, which became the new starting point, with the route following Goswell Road before joining Islington High Street and then re-joining the historic route.

In modern days, the market was known for its Christmas Eve meat auction, where buyers thronged to buy surplus produce in cash-only bargain transactions.[46]

Local campaigning against the cattle market

[edit]

In the Victorian period, pamphlets started circulating in favour of the removal of the livestock market and its relocation outside of the City, due to its extremely poor hygienic conditions[43] as well as the brutal treatment of the cattle.[47] The conditions at the market in the first half of the 19th century were often described as a major threat to public health:

Of all the horrid abominations with which London has been cursed, there is not one that can come up to that disgusting place, West Smithfield Market, for cruelty, filth, effluvia, pestilence, impiety, horrid language, danger, disgusting and shuddering sights, and every obnoxious item that can be imagined; and this abomination is suffered to continue year after year, from generation to generation, in the very heart of the most Christian and most polished city in the world.[48]

Old Smithfield in 1855, an outdoor market

In 1843, the Farmer's Magazine published a petition signed by bankers, salesmen, butchers, aldermen and City residents against further expansion of the meat market, arguing that livestock markets had been systematically banned since the Middle Ages in other areas of London:

Our ancestors appear, in sanitary matters, to have been wiser than we are. There exists, amongst the Rolls of Parliament of the year 1380, a petition from the citizens of London, praying that, for the sake of the public health, meat should not be slaughtered nearer than "Knyghts-brigg", under penalty, not only of forfeiting such animals as might be killed in the "butcherie", but of a year's imprisonment. The prayer of this petition was granted, and its penalties were enforced during several reigns.[44]

Thomas Hood wrote in 1830 an Ode to the Advocates for the Removal of Smithfield Market, applauding those "philanthropic men" who aim at removing to a distance the "vile Zoology" of the market and "routing that great nest of Hornithology [sic]".[49] Charles Dickens criticised locating a livestock market in the heart of the capital in his 1851 essay A Monument of French Folly drawing comparisons with the French market at Poissy outside Paris:

Of a great Institution like Smithfield, [the French] are unable to form the least conception. A Beast Market in the heart of Paris would be regarded an impossible nuisance. Nor have they any notion of slaughter-houses in the midst of a city. One of these benighted frog-eaters would scarcely understand your meaning, if you told him of the existence of such a British bulwark.[50]

An act of Parliament, the Metropolitan Market Act 1851 (14 & 15 Vict. c. 61), was passed, under the provisions of which a new cattle market should be constructed at Copenhagen Fields, Islington.[51] The Metropolitan Cattle Market opened in 1855, leaving West Smithfield as waste ground for about ten years during the construction of the new market.[52]

Victorian Smithfield: meat and poultry market

[edit]
Further information: Smithfield General Market and Smithfield Poultry Market
Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market Act 1860
Act of Parliament
Parliament of the United Kingdom
Long titleAn Act to establish at Smithfield in the City of London a Metropolitan Market for Meat, Poultry, and other Provisions; and for other Purposes connected therewith.
Citation23 & 24 Vict. c. cxciii
Dates
Royal assent13 August 1860
Other legislation
Amended by
  • Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market (Borrowing) Act 1864
Text of statute as originally enacted
Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market (Borrowing) Act 1864
Act of Parliament
Parliament of the United Kingdom
Long titleAn Act to amend the Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market Act, 1860, and other Acts, with respect to the borrowing of Money; and for other Purposes.
Citation27 & 28 Vict. c. xv
Dates
Royal assent28 April 1864
Other legislation
Amends
  • Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market Act 1860
London Central Markets Act 1886
Act of Parliament
Parliament of the United Kingdom
Long titleAn Act for empowering the Mayor and Commonalty and Citizens of the City of London to make further and better provisions with reference to the London Central Markets; and for other purposes.
Citation49 & 50 Vict. c. viii
Dates
Royal assent16 April 1886
Status: Amended
Text of statute as originally enacted
London Central Markets Act 1875
Act of Parliament
Parliament of the United Kingdom
Long titleAn Act for the establishment of a Fruit, Vegetable, and Flower Market in the City of London, and the extension of the Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market there, and the abolition of Farringdon Market; and for other purposes.
Citation38 & 39 Vict. c. lix
Dates
Royal assent14 June 1875
Status: Amended
Text of statute as originally enacted
Dilapidated decorations at Smithfield.

The present Smithfield meat market on Charterhouse Street was established by act of Parliament, the Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Market Act 1860 (23 & 24 Vict. c. cxciii).[53] It is a large market with permanent buildings, designed by architect Sir Horace Jones, who also designed Billingsgate and Leadenhall markets. Work on the Central Market, inspired by Italian architecture, began in 1866 and was completed in November 1868 at a cost of £993,816 (£113 million as of 2023).[40][54]

The Grade II listed main wings (known as East and West Market) are separated by the Grand Avenue, a wide roadway roofed by an elliptical arch with decorations in cast iron. At the two ends of the arcade, four prominent statues represent London, Edinburgh, Liverpool and Dublin; they depict bronze dragons charged with the City's armorial bearings. At the corners of the market, four octagonal pavilion towers were built, each with a dome displaying carved stone griffins.

As the market was being built, a cut and cover railway tunnel was constructed below street level to create a triangular junction with the railway between Blackfriars and Kings Cross through Snow Hill Tunnel. The tunnel was closed in 1916, but it has been reopened[55] and is now used by Thameslink rail services.[56] The construction of extensive railway sidings, beneath Smithfield Park, facilitated the transfer of animal carcasses to its cold store, and directly up to the meat market via lifts. These sidings closed in the 1960s. They are now used as a car park, accessed via a cobbled descent at the centre of Smithfield Park. Today, much of the meat is delivered to market by road.

The first extension of Smithfield's meat market was built between 1873 and 1876 with the construction of the Poultry Market immediately west of the Central Market. A rotunda was built at the centre of the old Market Field (now West Smithfield), comprising gardens, a fountain and a ramped carriageway to the station beneath the market building. Further buildings were subsequently added to the market. The General Market, built between 1879 and 1883, was intended to replace the old Farringdon Market located nearby and established for the sale of fruit and vegetables when the earlier Fleet Market was cleared to enable the laying out of Farringdon Street between 1826–1830.[57]

A further block (also known as Annexe Market or Triangular Block,) consisting of two separate structures (the Fish Market and the Red House), was built between 1886 and 1899. The Fish Market, built by John Mowlem & Co.,[58] was completed in 1888, one year after Sir Horace Jones' death. The Red House, with its imposing red brick and Portland stone façade, was built between 1898 and 1899 for the London Central Markets Cold Storage Co. Ltd.. It was one of the first cold stores to be built outside the London docks, and continued to serve Smithfield Market until the mid-1970s.[57]

20th century

[edit]

During the Second World War, a large underground cold store at Smithfield was the theatre of secret experiments led by Dr Max Perutz on pykrete, a mixture of ice and woodpulp, believed to be possibly tougher than steel. Perutz's work,[59] inspired by Geoffrey Pyke and part of Project Habakkuk, was meant to test the viability of pykrete as a material to construct floating airstrips in the Atlantic to allow refuelling of cargo planes in support of Admiral the Earl Mountbatten's operations.[60][61] The experiments were carried out by Perutz and his colleagues in a refrigerated meat locker in a Smithfield Market butcher's basement, behind a protective screen of frozen animal carcasses.[62] These experiments became obsolete with the development of longer-range aircraft, resulting in abandonment of the project.

Towards the very end of the Second World War, a V-2 rocket struck the north side of Charterhouse Street, near the junction with Farringdon Road (1945). The explosion caused massive damage to the market buildings, affected the railway tunnel structure below, and caused more than 110 deaths.[63][64]

On 23 January 1958, a fire broke out in the basement of Union Cold Storage Co at the Smithfield Poultry Market. The fire spread throughout the maze of basements under the market and burned for three days. Over 1,700 fire fighters with 389 fire engines were required to bring the blaze under control. Two firefighters were killed and 50 were injured or treated for smoke inhalation. The market was largely destroyed, and large portions not directly affected by fire collapsed as basements caved in. The introduction of breathing apparatus by the London Fire Brigade was a direct result of the fire.

A red plaque commemorating the two firefighters who died was unveiled at the market on the 60th anniversary of the fire.[65][66] A replacement building was designed by Sir Thomas Bennett in 1962–63,[67] with a reinforced concrete frame, and external cladding of dark blue brick. It is Grade II listed. The main hall is covered by an enormous concrete dome, shaped as an elliptical paraboloid, spanning 225 feet (69 m) by 125 feet (38 m) and only 3 inches (7.6 cm) thick at the centre. The dome is believed to have been the largest concrete shell structure built at that time in Europe.[68]

Today

[edit]
Smithfield Central Market at work

Smithfield is the City of London's only major wholesale market (Leadenhall Market nowadays attracts more tourist trade)[69] which has escaped relocation out of central London to cheaper land, better transport links, and more modern facilities. (Covent Garden, Spitalfields and Billingsgate have all relocated). The market operates to supply inner City butchers, shops and restaurants with quality fresh meat, and so its main trading hours are 4:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon each weekday.[40] Instead of moving away, Smithfield Market continues to modernise its existing site: its imposing Victorian buildings have had access points added for the loading and unloading of lorries.

The buildings stand above a warren of tunnels: previously, live animals were brought to market by hoof (from the mid-19th century onwards they arrived by rail) and were slaughtered on site. The former railway tunnels are now used for storage, parking and as basements. An impressive cobbled ramp spirals down around West Smithfield's public garden,[3] on the south side of the market, providing access to part of this area. Some of the buildings on Charterhouse Street on Smithfield's north side maintain access to the tunnels via their basements.

Some of the former meat market buildings have now changed use. For example, the former Central Cold Store, on Charterhouse Street is now, most unusually, a city centre cogeneration power station operated by Citigen.[70] The Metropolitan Cold Stores was converted in 1999 into the nightclub Fabric[71] and the 'Smiths' of Smithfield bars and restaurants.[72]

Smithfield comprises the market as its central feature, surrounded by many old buildings on three sides and a public open space (or Rotunda Garden) at West Smithfield, beneath which there is a public car park.[73] The south side is occupied by St Bartholomew's Hospital (known as Barts in common parlance), and on the east side by the Priory Church of St Bartholomew the Great. The Church of St Bartholomew the Less is located next to the King Henry VIII Gate, the hospital's main entrance.

The north and south of the square are now closed to through traffic, as part of the City's security and surveillance cordon known as the Ring of steel. Security for the market is provided by its market constabulary.[74]

Closure

[edit]

Abandoned plans for relocation to Dagenham

[edit]

In early 2019, the City of London Corporation's main decision-making body, the Court of Common Council, proposed that Billingsgate Fish Market, New Spitalfields Market and Smithfield Market should move to a new consolidated site in Dagenham Dock.[75] A formal planning application was made in June 2020,[76] and received outline permission in March 2021. However, in November 2024, the council announced it did not intend to proceed with these plans as they were no longer economically viable; the £800M cost was deemed too expensive[77]

2028 closure

[edit]

The City of London Corporation announced in November 2024 that Smithfield market, along with Billingsgate Fish Market, would close in or after 2028 with no replacement.[78] A deal was struck between the Corporation and a group of traders, who would receive £150 million in compensation, and would not protest against the closure.[77]

Demolition and development plans

[edit]
Red House, built 1898, formerly a cold store.

Since 2005, the General Market (1883) and the adjacent Fish Market and Red House buildings (1898), part of the Victorian complex of the Smithfield Market, have been facing a threat of demolition. The City of London Corporation, the ultimate owner of the property, has been engaged in public consultation to assess how best to redevelop the disused property and regenerate the area. Former property developers Thornfield Properties had planned to demolish the historic site and build a seven-storey office block, offering 350,000 square feet (33,000 m2) of office space, with a retail outlet on the ground floor.[79]

Several campaigns, promoted by English Heritage[80] and Save Britain's Heritage[57] among others,[81][82] were run to raise public awareness of this part of London's Victorian heritage. Grade II listed building protection was approved for the Red House Cold Store building in 2005 by Culture Secretary Tessa Jowell, on the basis of new historical evidence qualifying the complex as "the earliest existing example of a purpose-built powered cold store".[83]

Whilst the market continues to trade, its future remains unclear following a major public inquiry in 2007, instigated by Planning Minister Ruth Kelly.[84] The public inquiry concerning the proposed demolition and redevelopment of the General Market Building was held between 6 November 2007 and 25 January 2008. In August 2008, Communities Secretary Hazel Blears announced that planning permission for the General Market's redevelopment had been refused, stating that the threatened buildings made "a significant contribution" to the character and appearance of Farringdon and the surrounding area.[85][86]

On 12 October 2012, Henderson Group unveiled its £160 million plan for redeveloping the western side of the Central Market. Henderson proposed that the fish market, General Market and Red House buildings, all over a century old, be demolished to make way for restaurants, retailers and office buildings, while they would restore and retain much of the market building's original perimeter walls, with a new piazza being created in the General Market.[87] Marcus Binney of the campaign group Save Britain's Heritage said: "This proposal constitutes the worst mutilation of a Victorian landmark in the last 30 years."[88]

Construction work in 2023

Some of the buildings on Lindsey Street opposite the East Market were demolished in 2010 to allow the construction of the new Elizabeth line station at Farringdon. The demolished buildings included Smithfield House (an early 20th-century unlisted Hennebique concrete building), the Edmund Martin Ltd. shop (an earlier building with alterations dating to the 1930s), and two Victorian warehouses behind them.[89]

In March 2015, the Museum of London revealed plans to vacate its Barbican site at 150 London Wall and move into the General Market Building.[90][91] The Barbican site closed on 4 December 2022, to prepare for the subsequent move.[92][90] The foundation stone for its new West Smithfield site was unveiled on 16 October 2023, with the reopening of the museum at the new site still planned for 2026.[93]

Cultural references

[edit]
[edit]
  • The Central Market and Grand Avenue from the south
    The Central Market and Grand Avenue from the south
  • The entrance of the Grand Avenue from the south
    The entrance of the Grand Avenue from the south
  • Inside the Poultry Market
    Inside the Poultry Market
  • Market interior
    Market interior
  • The General Market (now abandoned)
    The General Market (now abandoned)
  • Inside the General Market (now abandoned)
    Inside the General Market (now abandoned)
  • East Poultry Avenue
    East Poultry Avenue
  • Butchers' Hall
    Butchers' Hall
  • St Bartholomew the Great Priory Church's cloisters and Barts Hospital
    St Bartholomew the Great Priory Church's cloisters and Barts Hospital
  • St Bartholomew the Less & Barts Hospital
    St Bartholomew the Less & Barts Hospital
  • St John's Gate
    St John's Gate
  • Charterhouse Square
    Charterhouse Square
  • The Port of London Authority building
    The Port of London Authority building
  • The former Central Cold Store, currently a power station
    The former Central Cold Store, currently a power station

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Smithfield, London

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Smithfield is a historic district located in the northwestern part of the , , originally known as an open space called "Smoothfield" in Saxon times, where trading began as early as 1174 and was formalized by in 1327, granting market rights to the . The area evolved from a medieval venue for sales, tournaments, public executions—including those of during the Peasants' Revolt in 1381—and annual fairs like St Bartholomew's, into the site of London's principal wholesale , which transitioned to dead meat sales in the mid-19th century and remains operational today as the largest of its kind in the , serving and with fresh provisions. The market's Victorian-era buildings, designed by Sir Horace Jones and constructed starting in 1868, feature that has earned Grade II listed status, symbolizing the site's enduring role in London's food despite challenges like wartime damage and recent relocation debates resolved in favor of remaining as of early 2025. Beyond commerce, Smithfield's significance includes its adjacency to institutions like , founded in 1123, and its role in urban development, with the area now encompassing conservation zones that preserve medieval and post-fire layouts amid modern pressures. Notable controversies have centered on the market's nocturnal operations causing noise disturbances and concerns in its earlier phase, though empirical assessments by the City Corporation have prioritized its economic contributions over relocation.

Historical Background

Medieval Origins and Early Development

Smithfield originated as an open, level expanse of grassland immediately west of London's Roman and medieval city walls, known in as smēþefeld or "smooth field," reflecting its flat terrain suitable for communal activities. Its location near the River Fleet provided access to water and adjacent pastures, enabling early medieval use for grazing , particularly horses and cattle driven from rural . This natural suitability positioned the area as an extramural commons, distinct from the densely regulated markets within the walled city. The site's commercial development began in the early with the establishment of a weekly horse fair, documented by chronicler William Fitzstephen around 1180 as occurring every Friday, drawing traders with destriers, palfreys, and other mounts for sale. This market evolved from informal on the open ground into a structured gathering, capitalizing on Smithfield's centrality for overland routes while avoiding city restrictions on . By the mid-, sales supplemented , held initially on Fridays and expanding to Mondays by the late 1100s, as livestock volumes grew with London's population exceeding 20,000. A pivotal institutional catalyst arrived in 1123, when Rahere, a and to King Henry I, founded the Augustinian of St. Bartholomew—the elder—on the field's edge after vowing to do so during a recovery from in . The , which included an adjoining , introduced monastic oversight and attracted pilgrims, fostering ancillary economic activity amid the markets; Henry I's 1133 formalized an annual August fair for the 's benefit, initially limited to cloth and domestic wares but expanding trade ties. These developments transformed the erstwhile grazing plain into a multifaceted extramural hub by the close of the , blending secular commerce with religious patronage.

Religious Significance and Institutions

The , founded in 1123 by —a courtier of King Henry I who reportedly vowed its establishment after recovering from illness through a vision of Saint Bartholomew—served as the centerpiece of an Augustinian in Smithfield. Dedicated to the apostle Bartholomew, the church functioned as both a monastic house and parish, with its largely intact despite later alterations. The priory encompassed surrounding lands used for fairs and markets but prioritized religious observance, including daily canons' services and charitable works. Adjacent to the church, originated in 1123 as a religious institution under the same , where Augustinian canons provided care for the poor and sick as an act of piety, blending monastic discipline with early medical aid. The hospital's foundation charter emphasized spiritual welfare alongside physical healing, reflecting medieval Christian priorities of almsgiving and redemption. St Bartholomew-the-Less, a smaller within the hospital precincts built around 1190, reinforced this ecclesiastical presence, surviving the in 1539 when the priory was suppressed but the core institutions persisted under royal refounding. Smithfield gained notoriety as an execution site for religious dissenters, particularly during Queen Mary I's reign (1553–1558), where at least 29 Protestant martyrs were burned at the stake for heresy, contributing to the approximately 290 executions nationwide aimed at restoring Catholicism. Earlier, from the early 15th century, Lollards and other perceived heretics faced burning under statutes like De heretico comburendo (1401), with Smithfield's open space facilitating public spectacles intended to deter non-conformity. These events underscored the area's role in enforcing doctrinal orthodoxy, though estimates of total religious executions there vary, with around 50 heretics overall from the law's enactment until Henry VIII's time.

Key Events and Executions

Smithfield served as a prominent site for medieval tournaments and jousts, hosting spectacles that drew international participants to demonstrate chivalric prowess and foster alliances. Notable events included a tournament in October 1390 under Richard II, which attracted nobles from various regions to affirm royal authority through displays of martial skill. Earlier, in 1305, Scottish leader was executed there on August 23 by drawing, hanging, and quartering following his capture for rebellion against Edward I, marking a departure from standard practice to publicly parade his punishment before Londoners. The "Elms of Smithfield" functioned as London's primary execution ground from the until the early 1400s, where condemned individuals, including heretics and criminals, faced hanging or other penalties amid public gatherings. During the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, rebel leader met King Richard II at Smithfield on June 15 for negotiations, but tensions escalated when London Mayor struck Tyler, followed by a fatal stab from royal squire Ralph Standish, leading to the revolt's collapse and subsequent executions of captured rebels at the site. In the Tudor era, Smithfield became infamous for religious persecutions, particularly burnings of Protestants. Under , was executed by burning on July 16, 1546, for denying , enduring torture beforehand. Queen Mary I's reign (1553–1558) saw intensified Marian Persecutions, with over 200 Protestants burned nationwide, many at Smithfield, including groups of up to ten at a time to enforce Catholic orthodoxy amid fears of . At least 48 such executions occurred there, contributing to Mary's epithet "Bloody Mary" for restoring papal authority through public spectacles of suffering.

Civil and Political History

Rebellions and Public Assemblies

Smithfield's open expanse made it a favored location for medieval public assemblies, including tournaments and annual fairs that drew large crowds from across and beyond. From the onward, the field hosted competitive displays of martial prowess, such as the seven-day organized by Edward III in 1375 to entertain his court. Similarly, in 1467, a grand at Smithfield celebrated Anglo-Burgundian alliances, featuring elaborate pageantry and combats witnessed by thousands. These events underscored the site's role as a communal gathering space for spectacle and social interaction, often blending entertainment with displays of royal authority. The annual , established by royal charter in 1133 and held each August near , exemplified recurring public assemblies at Smithfield, attracting merchants, performers, and visitors for trade in cloth, , and amusements until its suppression in 1855 due to rowdy excesses. Such fairs fostered economic exchange but occasionally descended into disorder, reflecting the site's dual capacity for orderly congregation and unrest. Rebellions and riots have also marked Smithfield's history, often culminating in violent confrontations. In 1196, William Fitz Osbert, dubbed "Longbeard," led a populist revolt against oppressive taxation and elite corruption in London, rallying the poor before seeking sanctuary in a church; he was forcibly removed and hanged at Smithfield, an event chronicled as one of the city's earliest recorded uprisings. The most prominent rebellion occurred during the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, when thousands of insurgents from and converged on demanding an end to , poll taxes, and feudal dues. On June 15, , the revolt's de facto leader, negotiated with 14-year-old King Richard II at Smithfield, but tensions escalated when Tyler demanded further concessions; Mayor struck him down, prompting royal forces to disperse the rebels, though the king temporarily issued charters of liberty later revoked. Centuries later, on February 15, 1647, amid the English Civil War's fiscal strains, an erupted at Smithfield Market when a buyer refused payment of the controversial on , sparking clashes between protesters, tax collectors, and soldiers that highlighted popular resistance to Commonwealth-era levies, though it remained localized without broader revolutionary impact. These incidents illustrate Smithfield's recurrent role as a flashpoint for grievances against authority, where assemblies turned rebellious under economic and political pressures. Smithfield functioned as a key venue for public executions in medieval and early modern , particularly at the area known as The Elms, where were erected amid trees from at least the until the early 15th, with continued use for specific punishments thereafter. This site hosted hangings, drawings, quarterings, beheadings, and burnings for offenses such as , , and , serving an administrative purpose in conducting judicial spectacles outside the city walls to minimize ritual pollution while maximizing deterrent visibility to crowds. Notable cases include the 1305 execution of , convicted of after capture in 1304, who was hanged, emasculated, eviscerated, beheaded, and quartered on 23 August. The site's legal prominence peaked during Queen Mary I's reign (1553–1558), when it became a primary location for burning Protestant heretics convicted under ecclesiastical courts for denial of and other doctrines, with records indicating at least 30 such executions between February 1555 and October 1558 as part of the Marian persecutions to enforce Catholic orthodoxy. Administratively, these events were coordinated by city officials and clergy, reflecting the integration of secular and religious authority in punishment, though the open-air format allowed for public participation in affirming royal justice. Executions here declined after became the standard site in the late , but Smithfield's role persisted in collective memory as a locus of . Complementing its punitive function, Smithfield hosted the Court of Piepowder during the annual (established 1133) and , exercising summary over commercial disputes, debts, thefts, and minor crimes arising from fair trade. This itinerant tribunal, named for the "dusty feet" (pieds poudreux) of itinerant merchants, convened under tents or local structures like the Hand and Shears inn, delivering verdicts within hours via a steward appointed by the fair's lord—initially the Prior of St Bartholomew, and post-1539 Dissolution under royal patents to the . Fines, amercements, and corporal penalties enforced fair rules, ensuring expeditious resolution to sustain economic activity without burdening permanent courts, a pragmatic administrative for transient markets granted charter privileges by monarchs like Henry III in 1229. These mechanisms positioned Smithfield as an extension of London's , where legal processes supported civil order amid assemblies of thousands, though the piepowder court's waned with the fairs' decline by the under regulatory reforms like the 1855 Metropolitan Market Act.

19th and 20th Century Transformations

During the 19th century, Smithfield transitioned from a venue for large-scale public assemblies and fairs to a more regulated commercial district, reflecting broader Victorian emphases on public order, sanitation, and administrative control. The , an annual event since 1133 that drew crowds for trade, entertainment, and occasional political agitation, was discontinued in 1855 after centuries of declining oversight led to widespread violence, drunkenness, and petty crime, prompting authorities to prioritize civic discipline over traditional liberties. This closure aligned with parliamentary interventions like the 1852 Smithfield Market Removal Act, which abolished the chaotic open-air livestock trade at the site—handling up to 15,000 cattle weekly by the 1840s—to mitigate urban health hazards, relocating live animal sales to Copenhagen Fields (later Caledonian Market) and enabling covered market construction under centralized governance. Earlier, in the post-Peterloo era, Smithfield hosted radical reform meetings, such as the July 21, 1819, gathering organized by and addressed by Henry Hunt, which advocated parliamentary reform amid fears of revolutionary unrest, underscoring the area's lingering role in popular politics before stricter policing curtailed such uses. In the , Smithfield's civil landscape evolved through labor organization and shifting political affiliations, particularly among market workers who embodied a traditionalist, anti-immigration atypical of urban labor. Meat porters, formalized into guilds like the United Smithfield Porters from the late , maintained pre-entry closed shops granting monopoly wages—estimated at 20% premiums—until outlawed by the 1990 Employment Act, preserving an insular workforce culture resistant to external reforms. By the early 1900s, the area gained a as a Conservative stronghold, with politicians courting porters' support; this crystallized in when Smithfield workers vocally backed Enoch Powell's "Rivers of Blood" speech against mass immigration, highlighting a "white working-class" backlash that challenged narratives of uniform proletarian and influenced debates on metropolitan labor's . Administratively, Smithfield remained under the City of London's ancient corporation, resisting 20th-century municipal expansions while adapting to post-war reconstructions after Blitz damage, including hospital expansions at St Bartholomew's, which reinforced its institutional continuity amid London's .

The Smithfield Market

Establishment and Medieval Operations

Smithfield emerged as London's principal livestock market during the medieval period, with the site functioning as an open-air trading ground for live animals outside the city's walls. The earliest surviving description dates to 1174, when Fitzstephen recorded it as a venue for the sale of horses, pigs, cows, and oxen, operating primarily on Fridays. Livestock was driven from distant regions, including the , to the smooth, open field—originally termed "Smeeth field" in —where animals were rested, fattened, and inspected before purchase. In 1327, King Edward III granted a to the , formalizing Smithfield's status as an official market and conferring rights over its operations, which had previously operated informally. This charter empowered the city corporation to regulate tolls and oversight, establishing Smithfield as a centralized hub for live animal trade to supply the growing urban population's meat needs. Buyers, including butchers from districts like and , acquired animals on-site for subsequent slaughter and retail, with the market's location facilitating access while minimizing intra-city disruptions from herding. Medieval operations emphasized live sales to ensure freshness, though the absence of permanent structures meant reliance on temporary pens and verbal agreements, subject to seasonal fairs like the nearby Bartholomew Fair established in 1133 for broader trade. No comprehensive codified regulations for animal health or pricing survive from this era, but city oversight likely enforced basic standards through toll collection and dispute resolution to sustain trade volume amid London's expansion. By the late Middle Ages, Smithfield handled thousands of beasts annually, underpinning the capital's provisioning amid feudal agricultural surpluses.

Victorian Expansion and Modernization

In the mid-19th century, longstanding issues with Smithfield's open-air livestock market— including street congestion from herding animals and concerns from slaughtering on-site—prompted legislative action to modernize the facility. The Smithfield Market Removal Act of 1852 relocated the live cattle trade to Copenhagen Fields in , freeing the central site for a dedicated dead-meat wholesale market that could receive carcasses via rail, thereby reducing urban filth and traffic disruptions. The Corporation of London commissioned new covered structures in 1860 to centralize meat distribution under controlled conditions, with construction commencing in 1866 under City Architect Sir Horace Jones, who employed iron-framed designs with glass roofing for ventilation and . The London Central opened on 24 November 1868, featuring underground railway sidings for direct carcass delivery from distant suppliers, a enabled by expanding rail networks that bypassed live animal drives. Subsequent expansions included the Poultry Market, authorized by the Metropolitan Meat and Poultry Act and opened in 1875 to handle birds and provisions separately, further streamlining operations with similar iron-and-glass . The General Market followed in 1883, accommodating broader wholesale needs and solidifying Smithfield's role as Europe's largest meat hub, where hygienic handling and rapid turnover minimized spoilage in an era before widespread . These developments reflected causal priorities of and , driven by urban growth and technological advances rather than mere tradition.

20th Century Challenges and Adaptations

During the First World War, Smithfield Market experienced disruptions from meat rationing and supply shortages, with approximately 75% of its meat imports from abroad by 1914, making it vulnerable to naval blockades and export restrictions from supplier nations. The saw reliance on cheap imports sustain volumes, but global economic shifts reduced availability after 1945. The Second World War forced temporary closure of the market, with operations curtailed by bombing risks and that limited throughput to essential military and civilian needs. A strike on 8 March 1945 destroyed J.J. Mack & Sons premises on Farringdon Road, killing an estimated 110 people, including many women and children sheltering nearby, and severely damaging adjacent market structures. An underground cold store at Smithfield was repurposed for wartime preservation of perishables, adapting to heightened demand for efficient storage amid air raids. Post-war reconstruction emphasized resilience, with repairs focusing on Victorian iron frameworks to restore capacity by the late 1940s. A catastrophic fire on 12 January 1958 engulfed the market's dead meat section, fueled by hanging carcasses and grease, resulting in the deaths of nine firefighters—the highest single-incident loss for the London Fire Brigade since —and destruction of significant inventory. This incident prompted safety adaptations, including improved and compartmentalized storage in subsequent repairs. From the onward, the market adapted to technological shifts by integrating rail and for pre-slaughtered carcasses, reducing on-site live handling and leveraging refrigeration to extend supply chains from regional abattoirs. However, gradual decline set in due to suburban expansion, which eroded wholesale demand by offering direct retail alternatives, and intensified from out-of-town distribution centers with lower overheads. By the late 20th century, throughput had stabilized but faced pressures from deregulated imports and urban congestion, prompting debates on viability without major infrastructural overhauls.

Economic Contributions and Innovations

Smithfield Market has historically served as a critical node in London's meat supply chain, facilitating the distribution of livestock and later carcasses to feed the city's expanding population during the Industrial Revolution. Established as a livestock market by at least 1174, it became the primary venue for trading animals from the English Midlands, underpinning urban growth by enabling efficient provisioning for a metropolis that reached over one million residents by 1800. The market's operations supported ancillary industries, including transport via drovers and early rail links, contributing to the economic integration of rural agriculture with urban consumption. In the , Smithfield underwent transformative innovations that enhanced its economic efficiency and global reach. The shift from live animal trading to a "dead meat" wholesale model in the , prompted by hygiene concerns and advancements, allowed for centralized carcass processing and reduced urban congestion from livestock drives. Architect Sir Horace Jones redesigned the market starting in 1866, incorporating cast-iron Phoenix columns, laminated timber roofs, and extensive glass roofing for natural light, which improved workflow and preservation. Pioneering features included basement sidings connected to the national network via hydraulic lifts and a spiral ramp, enabling direct freight delivery of meat from distant suppliers, including frozen imports from , , and by the 1880s. These adaptations positioned Smithfield as a hub for imperial trade, handling vast volumes that reflected Britain's dominance in global meat importation. Quantitatively, the market's peak economic output underscores its contributions: in the mid-20th century, it processed approximately 400,000 to 500,000 tonnes of fresh annually, supporting thousands of jobs among traders, porters, and related services while generating turnover estimated at £300 million by the early . Even in recent decades, despite a decline to around 100,000 tonnes per year amid shifting supply chains and dominance, it remains a key wholesaler for London's sector, sustaining local high streets and . These operations have yielded broader economic multipliers, with proposed relocations projected to generate billions in through sustained trade and infrastructure upgrades.

Controversies and Criticisms

Animal Welfare and Urban Conflicts

In the mid-19th century, Smithfield Market's handling of live drew widespread criticism for animal mistreatment, including , whipping, and exhaustion during through London's streets, which exacerbated urban chaos and prompted parliamentary inquiries into welfare standards. These concerns, amplified by reformers like in , highlighted graphic abuses such as animals being beaten or left to suffer in pens, contributing to the 1852 Metropolitan Market Act that relocated live cattle trading to the new Caledonian Market in by 1855 to reduce both cruelty and street congestion. By the late 19th century, Smithfield had shifted to primarily dead wholesale, minimizing direct on-site animal handling, though supply chain issues like long-haul transport persisted as points of contention among welfare advocates. In recent decades, the market has served as a symbolic target for broader anti- industry protests rather than site-specific welfare violations; on October 7, 2019, approximately 100 activists from Animal Rebellion, an offshoot of , blockaded entrances for several hours, gluing themselves to gates and demanding government subsidies shift from animal agriculture to plant-based alternatives, resulting in one arrest for aggravated . Similar actions, including a starting at Smithfield decrying factory farming imports, reflect activist focus on systemic production over verifiable local practices at the market, which complies with Food Standards Agency regulations for hygiene and transport. Urban conflicts have centered on the market's nocturnal operations—deliveries from 2 a.m. to 8 a.m.—generating resident complaints about heavy goods vehicle noise, exhaust fumes, and vibration in the surrounding Farringdon and areas, where residential conversions have increased since the . The Corporation's 2016-2026 Noise Strategy identifies market-related traffic as a key source of disruption, with measures like retrofitted silencers on lorries and designated loading zones implemented to mitigate over 500 annual complaints logged via the corporation's team, though tensions persist amid debates over the market's viability in a densifying . These frictions underscore causal trade-offs between preserving a historic economic hub and accommodating modern urban sensibilities, with no evidence that welfare protests have significantly amplified resident-market hostilities beyond episodic disruptions.

Preservation Efforts vs. Commercial Pressures

The Grade I-listed Victorian structures of Smithfield Market, designed by Sir Horace Jones between 1866 and 1868, have been central to preservation debates due to their architectural significance as exemplars of high Victorian and ornamentation. Heritage organizations like SAVE Britain's Heritage successfully opposed early 21st-century proposals to demolish the General Market building for office and retail development, winning two public inquiries that preserved the fabric through plans, such as conversion into a museum. These efforts underscore a commitment to retaining the site's historical integrity amid London's escalating property values, where central locations command premiums incompatible with low-margin wholesale operations. Commercial pressures intensified with the Corporation's November 2024 decision to close the market by 2028, abandoning a prior relocation to due to £350 million in escalated costs and opting instead for on-site into cultural, office, and spaces projected to generate £9.1 billion in over decades. This shift prioritizes higher-yield land uses in a district where demands drive out traditional functions, as evidenced by the market's declining throughput—from 100,000 tonnes of meat annually in the mid-20th century to under 20,000 tonnes by 2020—exacerbated by nighttime and competition from suburban facilities. Preservation advocates countered with petitions amassing over 15,000 signatures by December 2024, arguing that closure erodes London's working heritage and , though these faced limited traction against fiscal imperatives. Balancing these forces, the Smithfield Conservation Area designation since 1972 mandates retention of key facades and interiors during repurposing, preventing outright demolition while allowing commercial adaptation—such as the Museum of London Docklands' integration—but critics from heritage groups contend this commodifies irreplaceable assets, subordinating cultural value to revenue maximization in a market where office developments yield returns 5-10 times higher than wholesale trading. Ongoing 30-year masterplans announced in 2025 emphasize "regeneration" blending heritage with economic viability, yet they highlight persistent tensions, as trader displacement and heritage dilution risks persist despite legal safeguards.

Debates Over Market Viability

In recent years, debates over the viability of Smithfield Market have centered on its financial amid declining trade volumes, escalating operational costs, and incompatibility with modern urban constraints. The , which operates the market, has argued that ongoing subsidies are required to cover losses, with parts of the site remaining partially disused for decades, rendering long-term maintenance uneconomical given the Grade I listed status of its Victorian structures. In November 2024, the Corporation's voted to cease operations by 2028, citing a significant decline in meat consumption, rising inflation, and prohibitive construction costs that derailed a proposed relocation to . Proponents of closure emphasize practical challenges, including severe from nightly lorry deliveries—handling thousands of tons of meat—which conflicts with expanding restrictions on heavy goods vehicles and low-emission zones. These factors, combined with the high of prime near , have led consultants to deem heritage-preserving refurbishments "unviable," favoring redevelopment for higher-yield uses like offices or cultural venues. The decision to abandon relocation plans, originally approved in but ballooning in expense, underscores causal pressures from urban densification and shifting supply chains toward suburban or regional hubs. Critics, including market traders and heritage advocates, counter that Smithfield remains viable for niche wholesale of premium, traceable meats essential to London's restaurants and butchers, warning that closure would inflate costs and complexity for small-to-medium enterprises reliant on its early-morning efficiency. A garnering over 15,000 signatures by late 2024, followed by a formal objection filed in February 2025, highlighted alternative refurbishment models akin to Market's revival, arguing that subsidies reflect public investment in cultural infrastructure rather than inherent unprofitability. These stakeholders view the Corporation's financial rationale as overstated, pointing to the market's historical adaptability and potential for hybrid uses to offset losses without full closure. Despite such opposition, the 2024 vote allocated approximately £300 million in compensation to traders, signaling a prioritization of fiscal realism over preservation amid broader trends sanitizing central London's industrial functions.

Closure and Redevelopment

Decision to Close and Timeline

The Corporation's voted on November 26, 2024, to abandon longstanding plans to relocate Smithfield Market and to a new £1 billion facility at Dock, opting instead for permanent closure of the existing sites to enable redevelopment. This decision reversed prior commitments outlined in feasibility studies and public consultations dating back to the , which had projected the move commencing in 2028 amid concerns over the aging infrastructure's inability to meet modern operational demands, including refrigeration, access, and hygiene standards. The closure timeline stipulates that trading at Smithfield will continue uninterrupted until at least the end of 2028, providing traders with a transitional period supported by financial assistance from the to identify and shift to alternative locations within the M25 orbital motorway. In December 2024, Smithfield's meat traders reached an agreement with the for a potential "New Smithfield" site elsewhere, though specifics remain under negotiation and do not alter the 2028 deadline for vacating the historic location. Post-2028, the Smithfield site—spanning approximately 11 hectares—is slated for mixed-use redevelopment, including residential, commercial, and cultural elements, as part of a broader 30-year masterplan for the Smithfield-Barbican area approved in mid-2025.

Abandoned Relocation Attempts

In the early 2020s, the proposed relocating Smithfield Market, along with , to a new £1 billion purpose-built site at Dagenham Dock in , aiming to consolidate wholesale operations into a modern "mega-market" facility while freeing the central Smithfield site for redevelopment. The plan, developed with input from market traders and architects such as Chetwoods, envisioned improved logistics, sustainability features, and capacity for up to 70% of Smithfield's traders to relocate, with operations ceasing at the historic site by 2028. The Dagenham proposal faced escalating challenges from post-pandemic supply chain disruptions and inflation, driving projected costs beyond initial estimates and rendering the project financially unviable for the , which cited a "sharp rise in construction costs" as the primary factor. On November 26, 2024, the voted to abandon the relocation, withdrawing support and paving the way for Smithfield's permanent closure rather than pursuing the option. This decision disappointed traders who had anticipated continuity, though the offered approximately £300 million in compensation to facilitate potential independent relocations elsewhere. Prior to the Dagenham initiative, discussions of relocation surfaced intermittently in the late 20th and early 21st centuries amid urban pressures, but none advanced beyond preliminary stages; for instance, 2018 proposals to shift traders elicited strong opposition from historians and locals emphasizing heritage preservation, ultimately stalling without formal abandonment. The Corporation's official stance post-Dagenham has shifted toward supporting trader-led searches for alternative sites within the M25 orbital motorway, though no new relocation has been finalized as of late 2025, underscoring ongoing viability debates for the aging infrastructure.

Post-Closure Development Plans

Following the Corporation's November 2024 decision to terminate wholesale operations at Smithfield Market by 2028, redevelopment efforts shifted toward repurposing the historic site for cultural, commercial, and public uses while preserving its Grade I and II listed structures. In June 2025, the Corporation unveiled a comprehensive regeneration programme, including a 30-year masterplan for the Smithfield and area, aimed at establishing an international cultural and commercial hub on the site. This initiative, contingent on the passage of enabling legislation, seeks to integrate of the Victorian-era buildings with new developments to enhance the area's appeal as a destination for visitors and businesses. A new planning brief issued in May 2025 outlined options for the market buildings post-trading, emphasizing retention of architectural heritage alongside mixed-use transformations such as exhibition spaces, retail, and event venues. Proposals include creating a "Cultural Quarter" within the broader Smithfield precinct, potentially incorporating institutions like a dedicated London Museum to house collections on the city's , with an estimated investment of £250 million. Economic analyses project that the full redevelopment, encompassing Smithfield and the related site, will generate £9.1 billion in to the economy over the coming decades through job creation, , and property value increases. These plans prioritize sustainable , with commitments to minimize disruption during the transition and collaborate with heritage bodies to safeguard features like the market's ironwork halls and . However, implementation timelines remain fluid, pending trader relocation to an as-yet-unconfirmed site within the M25 orbital motorway and approval of the Markets Bill.

Cultural and Architectural Legacy

Architectural Features and Heritage

The core architectural features of Smithfield Market stem from designs by Sir Horace Jones, the City Architect, who oversaw the construction of the East and West Market Halls, completed in 1868 to replace earlier structures and accommodate rail connections beneath for efficient meat transport from across Britain. These halls showcase Victorian prowess through cast-iron frameworks supporting vast, column-free interiors, with expansive roofs enabling natural illumination essential for wholesale trading operations. The design emphasized monumental scale and functionality, incorporating ornate ironwork, arched entrances, and decorative elements that evoked grandeur akin to a "cathedral of meat," reflecting the era's industrial optimism and urban infrastructure ambitions. Adjacent structures enhance the site's architectural diversity, including the Poultry Market, originally built in 1875 under Jones's plans but rebuilt after a 1958 fire and featuring one of Europe's largest "handkerchief" shell concrete domes for acoustic and structural efficiency. The General Market, dating to the 1870s and intended for fruit and vegetables, incorporates distinctive riveted iron Phoenix Columns—salvaged elements reused in later adaptations—alongside twin turrets and an octagonal corner turret that add vertical emphasis to the composition. The clock tower, constructed in 1899 by architect J. B. Bunning and engineer Stanley Peach, stands as a later addition, its Gothic Revival detailing and four-faced clock serving as a visible across the . Heritage designation underscores the ensemble's enduring value: the East and West Market Halls hold Grade II* listing for their architectural innovation and role in London's Victorian market system, while the Poultry Market received Grade II status in 2000, acknowledging its post-war reconstruction within the historic context. Preservation efforts, including adaptive reuse proposals for cultural institutions like the Museum of London, balance the site's protected status against modern pressures, ensuring that original ironwork, spatial volumes, and fabric—such as the Red House cold store annexe from the early 20th century—remain integral to future developments. This heritage reflects Smithfield's evolution from medieval open-air trading ground to a symbol of industrialized commerce, with Jones's contributions exemplifying causal linkages between architectural form, material innovation, and economic function.

Representations in Literature, Language, and Media

Ben Jonson's Jacobean comedy (1614) is set amid the annual Bartholomew Fair at Smithfield, portraying the site's chaotic revelry, pickpockets, and satirical vignettes of Puritan hypocrisy and consumer excess through characters like the hog-woman Ursula and the naive Bartholomew Cokes. frequently evoked Smithfield Market in his novels to symbolize London's sensory overload and underclass grit; in (1861), protagonist Pip's first glimpse of the blood-soaked market upon arriving from the marshes underscores the city's brutal vitality and class contrasts. Dickens drew from personal observations of the site's pre-dawn cattle drives and slaughter, integrating it into works like (1838) to critique urban poverty and the meat trade's visceral commerce. The idiom "Smithfield bargain," originating in the 17th century, denoted an exploitative deal mirroring the market's haggling, evolving by the 19th to imply a pragmatic but unromantic marriage alliance. In film and television, Smithfield's Victorian architecture has represented dystopian or historical London; its market halls featured as Gotham City police headquarters in Batman Begins (2005) and The Dark Knight Rises (2012), leveraging the site's grand yet eerie interiors. The location appeared in 28 Weeks Later (2007) for apocalyptic sequences and V for Vendetta (2005) along Cloth Fair for revolutionary intrigue. Documentaries, such as British Pathé's 1954 footage, captured the market's nocturnal operations, emphasizing its enduring role as London's "cathedral of meat."

References

  1. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/supporting-businesses/wholesale-markets/smithfield-market/history-of-the-market
  2. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/things-to-do/city-gardens/find-a-garden/smithfield-rotunda-garden
  3. https://www.londonmuseum.org.uk/collections/london-stories/history-smithfield-market/
  4. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/supporting-businesses/wholesale-markets/smithfield-market
  5. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/supporting-businesses/wholesale-markets/the-future-of-smithfield-and-billingsgate-markets
  6. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Services-Environment/smithfield-conservation-area-character-summary-management-strategy.pdf
  7. https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/SMIT1.htm
  8. https://www.londonmuseum.org.uk/blog/5-things-about-smithfield-market-you-might-not-know/
  9. https://www.medievalists.net/2024/11/buy-medieval-warhorse/
  10. https://guildhallhistoricalassociation.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/22-smithfield-before-the-london-central-markets.pdf
  11. http://www.medart.pitt.edu/image/england/london/st-bartholomew/london-stbarth-the-great.html
  12. https://medievallondon.ace.fordham.edu/collections/show/45
  13. https://www.greatstbarts.com/history-of-st-barts
  14. https://www.britainexpress.com/London/st-bartholomew-the-great.htm
  15. https://www.british-history.ac.uk/old-new-london/vol2/pp351-359
  16. https://www.londonremembers.com/subjects/marian-martyrs-executed-at-smithfield
  17. https://www.layersoflondon.org/map/records/martyrdoms-at-smithfield
  18. https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/why-queen-mary-was-bloody
  19. https://chaucer.fas.harvard.edu/pages/jousts-smithfield-ad-1388
  20. https://www.academia.edu/123388554/The_execution_of_William_Wallace_Saint_Bartholomew_s_Eve_Monday_23_August_1305
  21. https://www.historic-uk.com/HistoryMagazine/DestinationsUK/The-Elms-Smithfield/
  22. https://historyguide.org/ancient/wat_tyler.html
  23. https://au.thegospelcoalition.org/article/tragedy-and-triumph-the-story-of-anne-askew/
  24. https://symbolsandsecrets.london/2020/09/03/smooth-field-a-wander-around-smithfield/
  25. https://londonist.substack.com/p/smithfield-how-it-all-began
  26. https://martcult.hypotheses.org/1391
  27. https://www.history.org.uk/publications/resource/4605/smithfields-bartholomew-fair
  28. https://www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofEngland/Wat-Tyler-the-Peasants-Revolt/
  29. https://www.historyextra.com/period/medieval/your-guide-peasants-revolt-facts-timeline/
  30. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2639564
  31. https://www.historyhit.com/guides/london-former-execution-sites/
  32. https://www.nytimes.com/1889/07/21/archives/the-court-of-pie-powder.html
  33. https://alondoninheritance.com/tag/bartholomew-fair/
  34. https://www.historic-uk.com/CultureUK/Bartholomew-Fair/
  35. https://crimereads.com/bartholomew-fair-laura-shepherd-robinson/
  36. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/247357617_The_death_of_Smithfield_Market_Urbanization_and_the_meat_markets_of_19th-century_London
  37. https://journals.openedition.org/caliban/10085
  38. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0950017091005002002
  39. https://academic.oup.com/hwj/article/doi/10.1093/hwj/dbaf003/8096621
  40. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Services-Environment/planning-draft-local-plan-kaoc-land-use-smithfield-and-barbican.pdf
  41. https://www.bdonline.co.uk/news/building-archives-replacing-old-smithfield-market-1864-68/5123490.article
  42. https://wellcomecollection.org/stories/fairs--fires-and-the-future-of-smithfield
  43. https://londonsociety.org.uk/report-smithfield-market-past-present-and-future/
  44. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03058034.2024.2429323?af=R
  45. https://lookup.london/v2-bomb-jjmack-smithfield-market/
  46. https://www.londonmuseum.org.uk/blog/smithfield-market-the-iron-legacy-of-sir-horace-jones/
  47. https://beyondtheflamesandmore.home.blog/2021/01/19/smithfield-the-meat-market-fire-january-1958/
  48. https://www.historyworkshop.org.uk/food/meat-and-museums/
  49. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Business/markets-food-study.pdf
  50. https://www.veganfoodandliving.com/news/londons-smithfield-meat-market-to-close-after-850-years-as-demand-for-meat-falls/
  51. https://www.london.gov.uk/sites/default/files/gla_migrate_files_destination/il-wholesale-markets-review.pdf
  52. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00094633.2021.1926158
  53. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/805664/summary
  54. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-49976197
  55. https://uk.news.yahoo.com/hundreds-protesters-campaign-against-animal-131021088.html
  56. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Services-Environment/city-of-london-noise-strategy-2016-2026.pdf
  57. https://www.cityoflondon.gov.uk/assets/Business/city-of-london-noise-attitude-survey.pdf
  58. https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2014/feb/23/smithfield-market-public-inquiry-redevelopment-rowan-moore
  59. https://www.savebritainsheritage.org/campaigns/smithfield-campaign-hub
  60. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/26/realestate/commercial/battle-over-london-market-raises-larger-development-issues.html
  61. https://fortune.com/europe/2024/11/27/900-year-old-london-smithfield-meat-market-closed-2028/
  62. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2025/jun/28/smithfield-billingsgate-market-redevelopment-plans-traders-city-of-london-corporation
  63. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c4g3ldpwdwgo
  64. https://connections.commons.london/new-plans-for-smithfield-market/
  65. https://www.reddit.com/r/london/comments/1h76le1/smithfield_market_petition_signed_by_more_than/
  66. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cje050wz22qo
  67. https://www.building.co.uk/news/heritage-scheme-for-smithfield-unviable/5065900.article
  68. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/nov/26/smithfield-meat-market-to-close-for-good-after-relocation-plans-voted-down
  69. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy8n304g6n7o
  70. https://www.thegrocer.co.uk/news/meat-trade-warns-closure-of-historic-smithfield-market-will-add-cost-and-complexity/698351.article
  71. https://www.mylondon.news/news/zone-1-news/objection-smithfield-billingsgate-closures-filed-31024029
  72. https://plmr.co.uk/2017/02/a-tale-of-two-cities-the-battle-over-smithfield-market-continues/
  73. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/nov/27/an-emotional-wrench-smithfield-traders-absorb-news-that-market-is-to-close
  74. https://spitalfieldslife.com/2023/07/23/the-last-days-of-smithfield-market/
  75. https://meatmanagement.com/news/city-of-london-report-finds-smithfield-market-no-longer-meets-demand/84475.article
  76. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/28/world/europe/london-smithfield-meat-market.html
  77. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cnv32443e60o
  78. https://www.architectsjournal.co.uk/news/chetwoods-1bn-smithfield-market-relocation-project-halted
  79. https://www.gardiner.com/us/stories/2022/1bn-plan-to-move-billingsgate-and-smithfield-east
  80. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14129487/Historic-London-market-targeted-pro-vegan-campaigners-closed-800-years.html
  81. https://www.islingtontribune.co.uk/article/outrage-over-plan-to-move-historic-meat-market
  82. https://www.ec1echo.co.uk/smithfield-markets-new-location-to-be-confirmed-soon/
  83. https://news.cityoflondon.gov.uk/investing-for-londons-future--city-corporation-lays-foundations-to-make-destination-city-a-reality/
  84. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14133225/Smithfield-Market-Architect-future-historic-meat-market-London-Museum.html
  85. https://victorianweb.org/art/architecture/jones/2.html
  86. https://historicengland.org.uk/images-books/photos/item/CC97/00551
  87. https://stantonwilliams.com/en/journal/city-makers-west-smithfield
  88. https://www.savebritainsheritage.org/docs/articles/The_Curious_Case_of_the_Phoenix_Columns_at_Smithfield_General_Market_-_FINAL.pdf
  89. https://alondoninheritance.com/london-buildings/buildings-smithfield-market/
  90. https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1381209
  91. https://julianharraparchitects.co.uk/projects/museum-of-london
  92. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/49461/49461-h/49461-h.htm
  93. https://victorianweb.org/authors/dickens/ge/hogue2.html
  94. https://www.countryfile.com/farming/adam-henson-smithfield-market
  95. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44371441
  96. https://londonist.com/2010/03/inside_the_hidden_film_set_of_smith
  97. https://moviemaps.org/locations/bgr
  98. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3N-KqSH7mg
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.