Hubbry Logo
Apple MapsApple MapsMain
Open search
Apple Maps
Community hub
Apple Maps
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Apple Maps
Apple Maps
from Wikipedia

Apple Maps
DeveloperApple
Initial releaseSeptember 19, 2012; 13 years ago (2012-09-19)
Operating systemiOS 6 and later, iPadOS, watchOS, macOS, Safari and Chrome on Mac/iPad, Chrome and Edge on Windows PCs
Service nameApple Maps
Available in33 languages
List of languages
English, Arabic, Catalan, Croatian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Hebrew, Hindi, Hungarian, Indonesian, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Malay, Norwegian Bokmål, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Russian, Simplified Chinese, Slovak, Spanish, Swedish, Thai, Traditional Chinese, Turkish, Ukrainian, Vietnamese
TypeWeb mapping
Websitemaps.apple.com

Apple Maps is a web mapping service developed by Apple. As the default map system of iOS, iPadOS, macOS, tvOS, visionOS, and watchOS, it provides directions and estimated times of arrival for driving, walking, cycling, and public transportation navigation. A "Flyover" mode shows certain urban centers and other places of interest in a 3D landscape composed of models of buildings and structures.

First released in 2012, Apple Maps replaced Google Maps as the default map system on Apple devices.[1] At launch, it drew criticism from users and reviewers for incorrect directions, sparse data about public transportation, and various other bugs and errors. Apple has since further developed the software to address the issues raised by such criticism.[2]

While previously exclusive to Apple devices, Apple released a cross-platform MapKit JS API in 2018, allowing Apple Maps to be embedded on the web.[3][4]

History

[edit]

Initial release

[edit]
Apple Maps was announced along with iOS 6, OS X Mountain Lion, and iCloud during the 2012 Apple Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC).

Apple revealed that the application would replace Google Maps as the default web mapping service for iOS. Apple also announced that the application would include turn-by-turn navigation, 3D maps, and the virtual assistant Siri.[5][6] The mapping service was released on September 19, 2012.[7] Following the launch, Apple Maps was heavily criticized, which resulted in a public apology by Apple CEO Tim Cook in late September and the departure of two key employees of Apple (see also §Early inaccuracy).[7][8]

Google Maps was the default mapping app in iOS from the first generation iPhone in 2007.[9] In late 2009, tensions between Google and Apple started when the Android version of Google Maps featured turn-by-turn navigation, a feature which the iOS version lacked. At the time, Apple argued that Google collected too much user data.[10] When Apple made iOS 6 available, Google Maps could only be accessed by iOS 6 users via the web.[11] Although Google did not immediately launch an iOS version Maps, shortly after the announcement of Apple Maps, Google did add a Flyover feature to its virtual globe application Google Earth.[12] Three months later, in December 2012, Google Maps was released in the App Store. This version of Google Maps, unlike the previous version, featured turn-by-turn navigation. Shortly after it was launched, it was the most popular free application in the App Store.[13]

Speculation around Apple creating a mapping service of its own arose in 2009 after computer magazine Computerworld reported that Apple had acquired Jaron Waldman's company Placebase, an online mapping service, in July of that year.[14][15][16] The CEO of Placebase became a part of Apple's "Geo Team".[16][17] In the following two years, Apple acquired two more mapping related companies who specialized in 3D maps: Poly9 in 2010 and C3 Technologies in 2011.[18][19] C3 Technologies' imagery was later used for the Flyover feature in Apple Maps.[20] Earlier in 2011, Apple indicated its plan for a mapping service when it stated on its website that it was collecting location data to create "an improved traffic service in the next couple of years" for iPhone users.[21] In September 2012, when Apple Maps was released, a "source" connected to both Google and Apple Maps claimed to technology website TechCrunch that Apple was recruiting Google employees that worked on Google Maps.[22]

2012–2015

[edit]

In the first year after its release, Apple Maps received a number of improvements which solved various errors in the application.[23] Other changes included adding more satellite imagery and making the navigation available in more cities. In 2013, Apple also acquired a few companies to improve Apple Maps, namely HopStop, Embark, WifiSlam, and Locationary, as well as the team and the technology of the company BroadMap. HopStop and Embark both specialized in mapping public transportation, WifiSlam specialized in interior maps, Locationary provided accurate company data for mapping services, and BroadMap managed, sorted, and analyzed map data.[24][25][26]

During WWDC in June 2013, Apple announced the new version of Apple Maps in iOS 7. This new version (and the rest of the operating system) had a new look and icon.[27] Several new functions were also implemented, including full-screen mode, night mode, real-time traffic information, navigation for pedestrians, and the Frequent Locations feature. The latter feature, which can be switched on and off, was introduced to record the most frequently visited destinations by users in order to improve Apple Maps. In addition, new satellite imagery was added once again.[24][27] On September 18, 2013, Apple released iOS 7.[28] At that time, the new iPhone 5S included a new motion coprocessor, the M7, which can identify whether a user is walking or driving in order to adjust the navigation mode.[24]

During that same conference, Apple announced that a desktop version of the application would be made available for OS X Mavericks.[29] On October 22, 2013, Apple released OS X Mavericks and the desktop version of Apple Maps. The desktop version was similar to that in iOS 7, but it connected with the Contacts and Calendar applications. Additionally, the desktop version enabled users to send locations and directions to other devices with iOS.[30] In June of the following year, Apple acquired the company Spotsetter, a social search engine that gave personalized recommendations for places to visit. Since the acquisition, most of its employees work at Apple.[31]

On September 17, 2014, the successor of iOS 7, iOS 8, became available. Later that year, on October, 16, Apple released OS X Yosemite.[32] Neither update brought any major modifications to Apple Maps. However, the feature "City Tours" was introduced to both iOS and OS X. This function made it possible for the user to be guided through locations with Flyovers.[33] Also, Apple Maps results were shown in the search feature Spotlight in OS X Yosemite.[34] Later in 2014, Apple news website 9to5Mac reported that in the previous months a number of Apple Maps employees, including a key employee, had left the company to work for Uber.[35] In the next year, Apple Maps was added to the new Apple Watch, which was released on April 24.[36] The app indicates navigation instructions by taps on the user's wrist.[37]

2015–2018

[edit]

During WWDC on June 8, 2015, Craig Federighi, Apple's senior vice president of Software Engineering, announced that the new version of Apple Maps in iOS 9 would have information about public transportation in a number of global cities.[38] The function also became available for OS X El Capitan and watchOS 2.[39][40] In addition, Apple added the function "Nearby", which shows nearby points of interest in several categories. With the update, the application chooses a detour in case of a traffic delay. The three new versions of the operating systems became available in September 2015. In addition to these new releases, Apple acquired a few companies in 2015 in order to improve the mapping application even further. In the spring, Apple also acquired Coherent Navigation, that provides precise location data through High Integrity GPS, and the startup company Mapsense later that year.[41][42] The latter had developed software to organize large amounts of location data.[43]

In 2016, Apple Maps opened a new development center and it was updated for watchOS and iOS. The application was improved when watchOS 2.2 came out in March 2016. Apple Maps was renewed in the new version of the operating system and received several new features, including "Nearby" which had previously been exclusive to iOS.[44] Four months later, Apple CEO Tim Cook inaugurated a new office in partnership with IT company RMSI, Noida, at the WaveRock campus in Hyderabad, India. The development center focuses on the development of Apple Maps and employs 4,000 people.[45][46] According to ZDNet, the 250,000 square feet (23,000 square metres) office cost US$25 million.[47] In September, iOS 10 was released. The update of the Apple's mobile operating system was accompanied by a new design of Apple Maps. Moreover, the application was opened up to developers and gained a few features: it makes suggestions for places to go based on earlier usage of the app, it can remember the location where the user parked their vehicle, it allows a user to filter search suggestions, and the turn-by-turn navigation was improved.[48][49] The navigation automatically zooms in and out, shows traffic ahead, and allows users to search for points of interests along the route. These features are available for CarPlay as well.[48]

2018–present

[edit]
An Apple Maps Subaru Impreza data and image collection vehicle in Kent, England in April 2023

In early 2018, Apple announced that Maps now included bike-sharing stations in more than 175 cities in 36 countries, including San Francisco (Bay Wheels), New York (Citi Bike), Montreal (BIXI), London (Santander Cycles), Paris (Vélib' Métropole) and Brisbane (CityCycle).[50][51]

In summer 2018, Maps leader Eddy Cue announced major updates to Apple Maps, which he said had been rebuilt "from the ground up" using map data Apple had been quietly gathering for the past four years. Newly detailed maps were available first for the San Francisco Bay area, and later for other areas of the United States and other countries.[52][53] Areas with the new detail show outlines of buildings, more minor roads (for example, roads within parking lots), walking paths, and traffic lights and stop signs during navigation. Grassy areas also show more detail; for example, strips of grass and vegetation between roads, outlines of holes on golf courses, baseball/football fields within parks, etc.

In November 2018, Apple said that it would send its backpack-wearing team to various locations, including Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Santa Clara County, in an attempt to improve Apple Maps' walking directions along footpaths and walkways. The company also said it would deploy its mapping cars throughout the US and the UK to gather its own data and add details to the maps.[54][55]

By the end of January 2020, Apple completed the rollout of their new maps detail in the United States and the District of Columbia; several U.S. territories were also added in April 2020.[56] Apple also said that Europe would receive updated maps later that year.[57] During WWDC on June 22, 2020, Apple announced that the UK, Ireland, and Canada would be the first countries outside of the U.S. to receive the updated maps.[58]

In September 2020, cycling directions were added to Maps alongside the public rollout of iOS 14, iPadOS 14, and watchOS 7. As of launch, cycling directions were only available in the cities of New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Shanghai, and Beijing, but Apple intends to add more over time.[59] In October, Apple updated the United Kingdom and Ireland to include their new maps detail, Look Around, and cycling directions.[60] On October 19, 2020, Apple began testing their new maps for Canada and rolled out the final version on December 10, 2020.[61][62]

On April 22, 2021, Apple began testing its new maps for Spain and Portugal, with the final version going live during Apple's annual WWDC conference on June 7, 2021. In addition, Apple announced that Italy and Australia would get the new maps later in the year.[63] During WWDC 2021, Apple had announced a brand new "city experience" for select areas that would include real-world road widths and marking, vegetation, turn lanes and realistic building models and colors, among other things. Apple released this new experience in seven cities in 2021, including Los Angeles and New York. In addition, Apple announced new changes to the "Transit" feature and non-vehicle directions, such as new AR walking directions and the ability to follow transit on an Apple Watch. Apple published its new map data in Italy, San Marino, Vatican City and Andorra on September 10, 2021, while also adding real-time transit for Rome, Milan, and Turin on the 26th. Apple released its new map data for Australia on December 9, 2021.[64] In August 2021, native ratings and a photo system became available to US users, previously using Foursquare, Yelp and Tripadvisor.[65]

On March 4, 2022, Apple began testing its new map data in Germany and Singapore, with the final version launching on April 21, 2022.[66] On March 24, 2022, Apple released its new detailed city experience for Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver.[67] On May 29, 2022, Apple began testing its new map data in France, Monaco, and New Zealand, with the final version launching on July 7, 2022.[68] During Apple's annual WWDC conference on June 6, 2022, Apple announced that in addition to France, Monaco, and New Zealand, the new maps would be expanded to Belgium, Israel, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Palestinian Territories, Saudi Arabia, and Switzerland. As for the Detailed City Experience, Apple had announced that Atlanta, Chicago, Las Vegas, Miami, Seattle, Sydney and Melbourne would be getting it later in the year. Apple had introduced multi-stop routing, Pay in Transit, and Mapkit for better integration of products in apps for developers.[69]

On August 5, 2022, Apple began testing its new map data in Israel, the Palestinian Territories and Saudi Arabia.[70] Apple also published the new Detailed City Experience for Atlanta, Miami and Seattle. On September 12, 2022, Apple published the new Detailed City Experience for Chicago and Las Vegas alongside the launch of iOS 16. On November 2, 2022, Apple began testing its new map data in Belgium, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Netherlands, and Switzerland, with the final version launching on December 15, 2022, alongside Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Palestinian Territories.[71]

On January 19, 2023, Apple launched the new Detailed City Experience for Sydney and Melbourne.[72] On January 23, 2023, Apple began testing its new map data in Austria, Finland, Norway, and Sweden, with the latter three being released on March 2, 2023.[73] On March 10, 2023, Apple started testing its new map in Austria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, and Slovenia.[74] The map data was officially published on April 6, 2023.[75] On May 2, 2023, Apple started testing its new map in Hong Kong, Slovakia, and Taiwan.[76] The new maps began rolling out to all users on June 15, 2023.[citation needed]

During Apple's annual WWDC conference on June 5, 2023, it was announced that offline maps would be coming to the Maps app, along with enhanced EV routing.[77][78] Later that day, Apple released the Detailed City Experience for Paris.[79]

On July 27, 2023, Apple released the Detailed City Experience for Dallas and Houston and added Look Around imagery for Dallas, Minneapolis, and Tampa Bay.[80] On July 31, 2023, Apple began testing its new map data in Denmark and Greece.[81] The new maps launched for everyone on October 12, 2023.[82]

On July 24, 2024, Apple began public beta testing Apple Maps on the web. The web version is available on Safari, Chrome, and Edge on Windows PCs and iPads.[83]

On October 25, 2024, Apple released the Detailed City Experience for Amsterdam.[84] In order to improve the service in India, the Apple Maps team has been surveying roads in several states since November 2024 using sophisticated camera and Lidar-equipped backpacks to obtain precise road markings.[85][86]

On January 25, 2025, Apple began testing its new map data in Thailand. On January 30, 2025, Apple released the Detailed City Experience for New Orleans.[87]

On August 7, 2025, Apple released the Detailed City Experience for Singapore.[88] Later in August, Apple released its new map data in Mexico.[89]

Features

[edit]
Apple Maps giving directions from San Francisco to Los Angeles, as shown on an iPad running iOS 9

Apple Maps started using vector graphics before competitor Google Maps, which allowed the application to use less data than Google Maps.[90] The map has four available layers: regular map, satellite view, hybrid view (a combination of regular and satellite view), and public transit view.[27] The main provider of map data is TomTom, but data is also supplied by Automotive Navigation Data, Getchee, Hexagon AB, IGN, Increment P, Intermap Technologies, LeadDog, MDA Information Systems, OpenStreetMap, and Waze.[91] Apple renewed their agreement with TomTom in 2015, though later decided to gradually switch to OpenStreetMap and remove all of TomTom-contributed map data except for live traffic information.[92][93] TomTom is the parent company of Tele Atlas, which is also used by Apple Maps' competitor, Google Maps.[24] The satellite imagery comes from Maxar Technologies.[91] iPhones located in China use data from AutoNavi and MapKing for Hong Kong instead.

Apple Maps can be used to plan routes. Apple expands their basic Maps interface by adding badges. A weather and air quality index badge will be seen alongside the current traffic information constantly. Before, a user could only observe the traffic information while using the turn-by-turn directions.[94] According to Apple, the navigation function is available in 56 countries worldwide.[95] Apple Maps can also be used to see real-time traffic information. In addition, Apple's virtual assistant, Siri, is integrated into Apple Maps. The map displays points of interest provided by approximately twenty companies, including Booking.com, Foursquare, TripAdvisor, and Yelp. The data from Foursquare was added in late 2015.[91][96] Users can drop pins on the map to save places for later retrieval. The satellite view features Flyovers, three-dimensional satellite views, in designated locations.[97]

Flyover and 3D maps

[edit]

With Flyover, certain locations — mainly big cities and landmarks — can be seen from a birds-eye perspective.[27] The three-dimensional views are photo-realistic, and users can change the perspective.[98] Flyover has been available since the first release of Apple Maps. Many cities with Flyovers also have "City Tours." With this feature, the user is guided in the Flyover view along landmarks in that location. "City Tours" was added to Apple Maps in iOS 8 (released on September 17, 2014) and in OS X Yosemite (released on October 16, 2014).[32][33][34] In addition to Flyovers, more than 300 cities also feature 3D maps. This feature enables the user to see three-dimensional models of structures in the map view. These models, which are not photo-realistic, can also be seen when using the turn-by-turn navigation.[27][98]

Nearby

[edit]

The "Nearby" feature in Apple Maps is available on iOS 15 and watchOS 8[99] It allows users to search for nearby places of interest, such as restaurants, gas stations, and parking lots, among others.[99][100] Users can also access indoor maps of select airports and shopping malls.[99]

When a user selects a category, such as "food" or "transportation," nearby points of interest in that category are displayed with their names, distances, and reviews on Yelp.[99] Pins also appear at the locations of these places on the map[99] Turn-by-turn navigation can be activated with Nearby as well.[99]

Transit

[edit]

The function "Transit" shows the public transport networks on the map in a number of cities and their surroundings. The functionality was added to iOS 9 (released on September 16, 2015), OS X El Capitan (released on September 30), and watchOS 2 (released on September 21).[39][40][101] Apple Maps displays the networks of buses, subways, trains, and ferries in these cities.[38] Additionally, the mapping service includes public transit schedules and shows the locations of the entries and exits of the subway and train stations.[102]

Support for all the routes of Amtrak in the United States has been added as of October 2, 2016. The routes of NSW TrainLink in New South Wales were added in April 2016. The routes of V/Line (Regional Rail) in Victoria (Australia) were added on October 9, 2016. Transit directions were expanded across the United Kingdom, excluding Northern Ireland, on December 19, 2016. Ireland (Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland) was added on October 16, 2017.[103][104][105]

Apple's transit directions are not available in third-party apps.

In iOS 16, Apple added the ability to add Transit Cards to the Maps app, as well as see Transit Fares.[106][107]

Congestion zones

[edit]

With the release of iOS 14, various countries in Europe received congestion zone alerts in the Maps app to reduce harmful emissions in the area. Users have the option of inputting navigation that avoids these areas. As of iOS 16, this feature has expanded outside of Europe.

Indoor airport and shopping mall maps

[edit]

Apple Indoor Maps is a feature of Apple Maps that provides indoor maps for select airports and shopping malls. It was first introduced in iOS 11 and has since been expanded to include more locations. The feature provides detailed information about the interior of these buildings, allowing users to navigate them more easily.

Apple developed the Indoor Mapping Data Format (IMDF) to provide indoor maps for venues. The format is designed to be mobile-friendly, compact, human-readable, and highly extensible. It provides a basis for orientation, navigation, and discovery within indoor spaces.

Apple Indoor Maps is a useful feature for users who need to navigate large and unfamiliar buildings. It is also beneficial for businesses that want to provide their customers with an easy way to find their way around their premises.[108]

Traffic information

[edit]

Apple Maps shows real-time traffic information on the map. In addition, the turn-by-turn navigation takes delays into account when calculating the estimated time of arrival and will occasionally choose a detour in case of traffic.[98] Apple introduced this function in iOS 7 (released on September 18, 2013) and it is available in 75 countries as of June 2019.[27][28][109] In the beginning of 2015, Consumentenbond, a Dutch organization promoting consumer rights, researched the traffic information of various navigation applications and concluded that Apple Maps gave the most false responses of all seven applications that were tested.[110]

Speed cameras and incident reporting

[edit]

iOS 14 introduced the addition of speed cameras when doing turn-by-turn navigation. More countries will be added as time goes on. In iOS 14.5, Apple implemented new ways to report incidents in real-time, with users able to report accidents, hazards, and speed checks during their route using Siri.

Cycling directions

[edit]

When Apple announced iOS 14 at WWDC 2020, they introduced cycling directions for Apple Maps in select cities to start with and now covers multiple countries, including United States, Canada, Australia, Japan, United Kingdom, Ireland, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Switzerland, Germany, Belgium, Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Czech Republic, Austria, Greece, Poland, New Zealand, China Mainland, Thailand, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Luxembourg, Mexico, Andorra, Lichtenstein.

Look Around

[edit]

Look Around allows the user to view 360°street-level imagery, with smooth transitions as the scene is navigated to provide precision in city environment. Look Around was introduced with iOS 13 at Apple Worldwide Developers Conference in June 2019. It was publicly released as part of iOS 13, with additional areas to be covered as time goes on.[111]

Apple Maps Connect

[edit]

In October 2014, Apple introduced Apple Maps Connect,[112] which allows small business owners to claim their business listing and edit business information, such as location and open hours. After the user logs in with their Apple ID, they are given a prompt to claim and link an Apple Maps listing to their account. The user can search through Apple's database to locate their listing or add a missing listing to Apple's database.[113]

Detailed City Experience

[edit]

At WWDC 2021, Apple officials announced they would add new information to Apple Maps' portrayal of various cities, including real-world widths of roads, accurate elevations, and more detailed depictions of some buildings and landmarks.

Native ratings and reviews

[edit]
Map showing Apple Maps' Native Ratings and Photos feature's availability worldwide as of the update in February 2024[114]

iOS 14 introduced the addition of native ratings and reviews to make it easier to search ratings. Yelp, as a result, is slowly being phased out in exchange for this new system. The feature allows users to rate the app with a thumbs up or thumbs down on a select range of categories depending on the type of business, alongside an overall rating. The average rating for each category is displayed for each business, and the "Overall" category can be seen in search results.

Users are also now able to upload their own photos they took of the locations.

This feature is available only in certain countries, as shown on the map.

Guides

[edit]

At WWDC 2020, Apple announced that iOS 14 would bring "Guides"—packages of tourist information—for certain cities, many produced by third-party publications.[115]

Market share

[edit]
A graph showing the percentage of American smartphone users who used Apple Maps (blue) and Google Maps (orange) between July 2013 and February 2016 (estimated by comScore)

Prior to the launch of Apple Maps in September 2012, there were 103.6 million Americans with iOS or Android, 81 million of whom used Google Maps. One year after the release of Apple Maps, there were 136.7 million Americans with iOS or Android. During this time, Google Maps users decreased to 58.7 million, while Apple Maps gained 35 million new users.[116] Out of the 60.1 million iPhone users, 8.3 million used Google Maps. However, some of those iPhone users were not able to use Apple Maps, since their devices were not updated to iOS 6.[10]

Between July 2013 and February 2016, 20% to 30% of all American smartphone users utilized Apple Maps, including those with operating systems that were not compatible. During the same timeframe, 40% to 51% of American smartphone owners used Google Maps.[117]

In September 2013, one year after its launch, more than 6.2 million of the total 10.35 million British iPhone owners used Apple Maps. Google Maps had the second largest market share on British iPhones with over 1.8 million British iPhone users.[118]

In 2024, Google Maps has approximately 1.8 billion users while Apple maps has 500 million users.[119]

Reception

[edit]

Early inaccuracy (2012)

[edit]

Apple Maps received considerable criticism after its launch on September 19, 2012, due to wrong and inaccurate information about places and points of interests. Many of these errors are now fixed.[7][24][120]

Some places were misspelled, were displayed with the wrong name, or were missing entirely.[7][11] Examples of those mistakes included the Ukrainian capital Kyiv, which was incorrectly spelled as "Kylv", the Welsh town Pontypridd, whose label was shown 6 miles (10 kilometres) northeast of its actual location, and the English town Stratford-upon-Avon, which was missing altogether in Apple Maps. Also, when users looked up "London," they were directed to the Canadian city London, Ontario, instead of its namesake, the capital of the United Kingdom.[11] Many complained about outdated or inaccurate data about companies and places of interest. For example, in the United Kingdom, chains that no longer exist were still on the maps, and large stores were accidentally mapped in backyards.[24] Furthermore, in the United States, the label of the Willis Tower was displayed in the wrong location.[11] Apple Maps was sometimes inadequate to find companies or other points of interest at all.[24] For instance, the London train and underground station Paddington and Tokyo Station were missing, and the Helsinki Central railway station was shown as a park.[10][11] Also, parks were occasionally displayed as airports.[7] Some instances of maps had cloud cover that obstructed the view of the road.[121]

On several occasions, government authorities and politicians warned citizens of errors with Apple Maps. In early December 2012, the police department of the Australian city Mildura alerted people who planned to reach the city using Apple Maps, because Mildura was shown in the middle of Murray-Sunset National Park, 40 miles (64 kilometres) from its actual location. The police department stated that the error was potentially life-threatening, as national park temperatures could rise to 114 °F (46 °C) and those traveling would be without water supplies. The police rescued at least four people, one of whom was stranded for 24 hours. After that, the police department tried to contact Apple to solve the problem. Apple fixed the error in December 2012.[122][123][124] Alan Shatter, the Minister for Justice and Equality and Minister of Defence of Ireland, issued a warning because of a mistake in Apple Maps: a non-existent airport was shown near the Irish capital Dublin. This location was in reality a public farm called "Airfield." Shatter wrote in his statement that the mistake was dangerous because a pilot could try to make an emergency landing there.[125][126]

Apple's response

[edit]

As a result of the criticism, Tim Cook, CEO of Apple, published a letter of apology on Apple's website on September 28, 2012, in which he apologized for the "frustrations" experienced by users. He said that Apple fell short and that the company was making every effort to improve the mapping service. Cook also suggested that dissatisfied users could use rival mapping applications like Bing Maps, MapQuest, Waze, Google Maps, and Nokia Maps.[127] Steve Jobs, former CEO of Apple, had used this way of apologizing in the past.[7] A week before the release of the letter of apology, just after the launch of Apple Maps, spokesperson Trudy Miller had stated to technology news website All Things Digital that Apple Maps was a major initiative and that they "were just getting started with it." Miller also said the application would improve as more people used it.[128][126]

In the aftermath of the criticism, two key employees left the company due to the problems associated with Apple Maps. The departure of Scott Forstall, senior vice president of iOS, was announced in October 2012.[8] Sources told technology news website The Verge that he had been fired for refusing to sign Tim Cook's letter of apology.[129] According to business magazine Bloomberg Businessweek, Richard Williamson, the person responsible for the mapping team at Apple, left the following month. He was succeeded by Eddy Cue.[8]

In June 2016, Eddy Cue said in an interview with Fast Company that Apple "had completely underestimated the product, the complexity of it." He also said the problems with Apple Maps led to "significant changes to all of our development processes." After the launch of Maps, Apple started offering public betas of new versions of iOS and OS X. Furthermore, Cue commented that before Maps was launched Apple's executive team long discussed if Apple should have its own mapping service.[130] One month later, Tim Cook looked back to the launch of Apple Maps in an interview with The Washington Post and said "Maps was a mistake." He added that the company admitted its mistake and that Maps is something the company is now proud of because of the improvements.[131]

TomTom's response

[edit]

As the primary provider of map data, TomTom has also received criticism. Cees van Dok, TomTom's head of user experience design, in April 2013 told technology news website TechRadar that Apple was the problem. According to him, Apple was trying to combine too many sources of data to create Apple Maps.[132]

2016–present

[edit]

Despite fixing preliminary issues, Apple Maps has received mixed reviews, with some critics complimenting its "Flyover" feature and appearance of the street map,[133] while others are criticizing its lack of features similar to those in Google Maps. ZDNet said "[Apple Maps] had its share of problems, but Apple Maps is back with a vengeance. Powered by some jaw-dropping 3D graphics and enjoying an aggressive multi-platform strategy, Apple is finally set to redefine our geospatial expectations – and take Google down a few notches."[133] An editor of The Street wrote "But, today, and presumably after the iOS 7 update, Apple Maps has come into its own.

In 2019, Apple began rolling out a comprehensive overhaul of Apple Maps to certain areas. The redesigned Maps introduced significant improvements, including more comprehensive views of roads and buildings, enhanced pedestrian data, more precise addresses, and detailed land cover. Apple completed the rollout of this new experience in the United States by early 2020, adding features like faster navigation, Look Around (a high-resolution, interactive street-level imagery feature), and Favorites for quick access to frequently visited places. Eddy Cue described the update as a complete rebuild of the app, with privacy as a central focus. The redesign received praise for its visual improvements and functionality, with critics noting that it addressed many of the app's initial shortcomings and brought the experience closer to competing services like Google Maps. These "new maps" have continued to expand to other countries over time.[57]

Macworld wrote in 2021, "Apple Maps has vastly improved since it was first launched and now we conclude the turn-by-turn navigation is a lot better than Google's offering. While there are areas that both Google and Apple can improve on, we're certain that using Apple Maps won't direct you to drive into the Thames and that most of the initial issues have been fixed."[134] Thrillist wrote an article about "Things Apple Maps Does Better Than Google Maps," praising its ability to let the user "send directions instantly from your computer to your phone," "see turn-by-turn directions from the lock screen," "get more specific recommendations for nearby attractions," "know which subway car to get on and which exit to use," "see true-to-life details," and "get seamless directions from Siri." Apple Maps was also praised for its Look Around feature offering higher quality images than Google Street View.[135]

Apple Maps allows integration with a car's multi-media system through CarPlay.[134]

Taiwan (Republic of China) was classified as a province of the People's Republic of China in the application in 2013; searches for "Taiwan" were changed automatically to "China Taiwan province" in Simplified Chinese, prompting the Taiwan Ministry of Foreign Affairs to demand a correction from Apple.[136]

Controversies

[edit]

China

[edit]

Apple has received criticism regarding its map concerning the greater China region. Apple uses Chinese map suppliers for map display within China and uses TomTom and local map suppliers for Taiwan and Hong Kong. If the phone is located within mainland China, it can result in all geotagged photos taken in Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan, Arunachal Pradesh, or the disputed South China Sea islands being applied with an incorrect location, or displaying the area as part of China. There are some English language issues with the Chinese pinyin transliterations of the Chinese names in Taiwan and Hong Kong. Photos taken in Taipei or Itanagar will display the location respectively as "Taiwan Province, China"[137] or "Tibet Autonomous Region, China".[138] Additionally, Apple in China has agreed to manipulate Apple Maps to support China in the Senkaku Islands dispute by making Chinese-claimed islands appear larger than they actually are, as part of a business deal that was personally negotiated by Apple CEO Tim Cook.[139]

South Korea

[edit]

Apple Maps has limited functionality in South Korea due to restrictions on geographic data in South Korea.[140]

Ukraine

[edit]

Apple's compliance with local laws has been criticized. For example, Apple labels Crimea as part of Russia in Apple Maps, specifically for users who were accessing the app with a Crimean IP address.[141] Users in the rest of the world are shown Crimea as belonging to Ukraine.[142]

In response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Apple suspended its business operations in Russia. As a safety precaution to those in Ukraine, Apple had also disabled live traffic and other features in Maps.[143]

United States

[edit]

Apple's response to the Gulf of Mexico–America naming dispute was to relabel the Gulf of Mexico to "Gulf of America" due to the signing of Executive Order 14172 by President Trump.[144]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia

Apple Maps is a proprietary digital mapping and navigation application developed by Apple Inc., first released on September 19, 2012, alongside as the default replacement for on , , and devices. The service provides turn-by-turn directions, location search, traffic information, and exploratory tools such as 3D Flyover views and Look Around street-level imagery, all integrated across Apple's ecosystem including macOS, , and .
Its debut was overshadowed by widespread inaccuracies, including misplaced landmarks, erroneous routing, and missing locations, which prompted CEO to issue a public apology and recommend alternatives like while promising fixes. This launch fiasco, stemming from reliance on third-party data aggregators rather than Google's established service, led to executive departures and a multi-year effort to rebuild Maps from the ground up using Apple's own mapping vehicles and data partnerships. Subsequent redesigns, beginning in 2020 for select regions and expanding globally, have introduced enhanced accuracy, safeguards—such as on-device processing and no location history sharing without consent—and features like curated Guides and incident reporting, differentiating it from ad-driven competitors. As of 2025, Apple Maps supports web access in beta and continues to add intelligent personalization, though it maintains a minority , with estimates around 18-23% among U.S. users compared to ' dominance.

Development History

Origins and Pre-2012 Integration

Prior to developing its proprietary mapping service, Apple integrated into its operating system starting with the original launch on June 29, 2007, relying on 's backend for location services, routing, and imagery. This partnership provided users with core mapping functionality, including search, directions, and Street View integration, but Apple sought greater control over data and user experience amid growing tensions with , particularly as the latter expanded into mobile hardware with Android. Apple initiated internal mapping development around 2009 to reduce dependence on third-party providers, beginning with the acquisition of Placebase, a UK-based mapping software firm specializing in geospatial data visualization and APIs, in September 2009. This move enabled Apple to build custom map rendering capabilities. In July 2010, Apple acquired Poly9, a company from Québec City, Canada focused on 3D globe rendering and vector-based mapping technology, enhancing its ability to handle interactive 3D visualizations without raster imagery limitations. Further bolstering its efforts, Apple purchased C3 Technologies, a Swedish firm developing photorealistic 3D city models from aerial imagery, in August 2011; this technology laid groundwork for features like Flyover in future iterations. These acquisitions, totaling undisclosed sums but part of Apple's broader strategy to aggregate expertise in , , and rendering, positioned the company to launch an independent service by 2012 while continuing to license data from providers like for base maps. Through 2011, iOS devices retained Google Maps integration, with Apple's work remaining internal and undisclosed until the iOS 6 announcement.

2012 Launch and Immediate Fallout

Apple announced its proprietary mapping service, Apple Maps, at the (WWDC) on June 11, 2012, as part of , stating it would replace with features including turn-by-turn navigation, 3D flyover views, and integration with . The update rolled out on September 19, 2012, coinciding with the launch, making Apple Maps the default for over 100 million devices and prompting users to download it automatically. Upon release, Apple Maps faced widespread for severe inaccuracies, including misplaced landmarks, distorted 3D renderings, and erroneous directions that directed users to incorrect or hazardous locations, such as bodies of water in where police issued warnings. Other issues encompassed missing street labels, incomplete public transit information in major cities, and unreliable search results, which contrasted sharply with the reliable it supplanted and eroded user trust in Apple's ecosystem. On September 28, 2012, CEO issued a public apology via Apple's website, acknowledging the frustration caused by the "Maps" app's shortcomings and stating, "We are extremely sorry for the frustration," while recommending alternatives like the web app, , and as interim solutions until improvements were made. The backlash contributed to a rapid decline in usage, with reports indicating only 4% of users continued relying on it within days, and Apple's stock value dropped approximately 4.5%, erasing about $30 billion in in the immediate aftermath.

Recovery Phase (2013–2015)

Following the problematic launch of Apple Maps in , Apple underwent significant internal restructuring to address the service's deficiencies. On October 29, 2012, iOS software chief departed the company after refusing to sign an apology letter regarding the Maps issues, with responsibilities for Maps shifting to , Apple's senior vice president of Internet software and services. Subsequently, on November 27, 2012, Richard Williamson, the vice president overseeing the Maps team, was dismissed amid the ongoing fallout. These changes positioned Cue to lead recovery efforts, emphasizing data accuracy and enhancements. In 2013, Apple pursued acquisitions to strengthen its mapping data foundations, including the talent and technology from BroadMap, a firm specializing in location-infused data services, to support improvements in place recognition and indoor mapping capabilities. The release of on September 18, 2013, introduced a redesigned with full-screen , night mode for turn-by-turn directions, real-time traffic data integration, and pedestrian walking —features absent in the initial version. These updates addressed core usability gaps, such as limited options, while expanding coverage and refining 3D Flyover views in select urban areas. By mid-2014, Apple implemented daily data updates, pushing corrections every day at 3:00 a.m. Eastern Time based on user-submitted feedback, which accelerated fixes for inaccuracies in road layouts, points of interest, and routing. In October 2014, the company launched Apple Maps Connect, a web-based tool enabling business owners to directly edit and verify their listings, thereby improving the timeliness and reliability of commercial data. Flyover functionality expanded with additions like the Grand Canyon, enhancing visual fidelity for aerial exploration. Into 2015, Apple renewed its data licensing agreement with , ensuring continued access to high-quality vector map data while integrating crowdsourced corrections to mitigate prior errors in geographic rendering and search results. These iterative enhancements, driven by Cue's oversight and a focus on , marked a transition from crisis response to foundational stability, though challenges in global transit coverage and rural accuracy persisted. By the end of 2015, user satisfaction metrics indicated measurable progress, with Maps regaining traction as the default navigation tool amid reduced reports of egregious errors.

Feature Maturation (2016–2018)

In 2016, with the release of on September 13, Apple Maps underwent a significant redesign featuring brighter and bolder text for improved readability, particularly during . The app introduced a persistent search bar with categorized suggestions for nearby points of interest, such as food, gas, and services, drawing from user data like calendars and favorites to provide proactive routing options and detours with estimated times. Additional enhancements included automatic logging of parked car locations (excluding home addresses), integration for restaurant reservations via , and ride-sharing estimates from and directly within the app. These changes aimed to simplify discovery and , building on backend improvements in search and Siri-powered suggestions for stops along routes. The following year, , released on September 19, 2017, expanded Apple Maps' capabilities with indoor floor plans for select airports and malls, enabling users to navigate complex interiors like Chicago O'Hare or . Navigation features matured further through the addition of lane guidance in multiple countries, displays, and a lighter guidance mode for reduced visual clutter during turns. Throughout 2017, Apple aggressively broadened public transit coverage, incorporating directions for cities including (January 30), (April 24), (May 9), and (October 12), alongside bike-sharing stations in major European and U.S. hubs. Indoor mapping extended to European airports like those in and by November, reflecting Apple's growing investment in detailed venue data. By 2018, maturation accelerated with on September 17, marking the debut of first-party map derived from Apple's mapping vehicles, initially in and expanding to regions like , southern , , , and by year's end. This shift from third-party reliance improved road accuracy, pedestrian details, and real-time updates for , leveraging collected since 2015 via an international fleet equipped with and cameras. Transit expansions continued, covering additional U.S. states (e.g., , on September 10) and international areas like and (June 25), while indoor maps proliferated to over 20 malls and airports including Narita in . Apple also launched MapKit JS on June 6, enabling web embedding of Maps for broader integration. These developments signaled a transition toward , privacy-focused control, enhancing overall precision without compromising user .

Contemporary Advancements (2019–Present)

In 2019, Apple unveiled a comprehensive redesign of Apple Maps as part of , introducing Look Around, a street-level imagery feature captured by Apple vehicles that provides 360-degree panoramas for navigation and exploration, initially launched in major U.S. cities including , , and New York by the end of the year. The update also initiated the rollout of enhanced map detail with higher-resolution , improved building outlines, and better indoor maps for select venues like airports and malls, aiming to address prior accuracy shortcomings through proprietary . These changes prioritized visual fidelity and user privacy by blurring faces and license plates in imagery from the outset. Subsequent expansions in 2020 and 2021 focused on navigation enhancements; iOS 14 added (EV) routing, which factors in battery range to suggest routes with compatible charging stops, supporting models from manufacturers like Ford and via integration. In iOS 14.5 (April 2021), Apple implemented crowdsourced incident reporting, allowing users to flag crashes, road hazards, speed traps, and construction in real-time during navigation, with reports verified and displayed to others for dynamic rerouting. By 2022, iOS 16 introduced multi-stop routing for up to 15 destinations, optimizing paths for efficiency and integrating transit schedules more seamlessly in supported regions. From 2023 onward, Apple accelerated global coverage of its Detailed City Experience (DCE), a high-fidelity mapping layer with granular details like sidewalks, crosswalks, medians, and changes, extending beyond initial U.S. rollout to cities in , , and ; by mid-2023, over a dozen additional U.S. metropolitan areas gained DCE, with further expansions to in August 2025 as the first Southeast Asian city. Look Around coverage similarly grew, reaching in 2025 after vehicle surveys began in 2022, while 18 (September 2024) added exploration tools such as guided hikes in U.S. national parks, customizable walking routes, and a Places Library for saving and organizing locations with personal notes. In July 2024, Apple launched a beta web version of Maps at maps.apple.com, enabling browser-based access to core features like and search, with Look Around integration added in December 2024. These developments relied on ongoing data acquisition via branded Apple mapping vehicles, which became more visible starting in 2023 to enhance transparency in imagery collection.

Technical Architecture

Data Acquisition Methods

Apple acquires core mapping data through proprietary ground surveys utilizing specialized equipped with cameras, sensors, GPS receivers, and onboard computing systems like Mac Pros to capture 360-degree imagery, 3D point clouds, and positional traces. These surveys, conducted globally since the mid-2010s, enable the of an in-house base by systematically traversing roadways and capturing changes in infrastructure, with periodic revisits to maintain currency. In regions or terrains inaccessible to vehicles, such as dense urban pedestrian areas or narrow pathways, Apple deploys pedestrian surveys using backpack-mounted camera arrays or handheld devices including iPads and iPhones to collect analogous data sets of images, , and GPS information. This method complements vehicle efforts by filling coverage gaps, particularly in city centers like streets. To augment these professional surveys, Apple launched the Surveyor app on March 14, 2025, permitting opted-in users to submit geotagged photographs of street signs, landmarks, and roadside details, thereby incremental updates to map features in underserved locales. Although Apple shifted to a predominantly in-house base by 2020, reducing reliance on external providers, it integrates licensed third-party where proprietary collection lags, including vector elements attributed to contributors as of 2025. Historical dependencies on suppliers like have diminished as in-house capabilities matured. Anonymized, opt-in user location from devices contributes to refining dynamic elements like flows and incidental discoveries such as new sidewalks, but serves secondary to survey-derived foundational for static geometry and .

Mapping Engines and Rendering

Apple Maps utilizes a rendering engine developed by Apple, which enables efficient, on-device visualization of map data across , , macOS, and other platforms. This engine supports the display of detailed geographic features in the native Apple Maps application and extends to third-party apps via the MapKit framework, emphasizing real-time graphics processing for interactive elements like zooming, panning, and 3D views. The system relies on rather than raster images, allowing maps to scale infinitely without fidelity loss and reducing data transfer requirements by representing features as mathematical descriptions of lines, polygons, and points. This approach contrasts with pre-rendered bitmap tiles, contributing to up to 80% lower data usage compared to alternatives like during initial loads and updates. Vector rendering occurs client-side, leveraging hardware-accelerated graphics APIs such as Metal on devices to handle complex scenes, including building facades and terrain shading, with minimal latency. On the backend, Apple's mapping engine processes aggregated data sources into these , incorporating proprietary algorithms for feature extraction and stylization to ensure consistency and performance. Introduced with in 2012, the engine has evolved to support advanced visualizations, such as detailed road rendering and immersive 3D flyovers, refined through iterative updates like the 2020 redesign that enhanced urban detail granularity. This in-house control allows for optimizations tailored to Apple's ecosystem, including seamless integration with device sensors for overlays in features like Look Around.

Ecosystem Integration and APIs

Apple Maps integrates natively across Apple's operating systems, including , , macOS, , , and , enabling seamless access to mapping and navigation features within the ecosystem. On and devices, it serves as the default mapping application, supporting widgets for quick glances at routes or locations, and from other apps. Integration with allows voice-activated commands for obtaining directions, traffic updates, and estimated travel times, with support extending to for in-vehicle displays that provide clean, seamless mirroring of turn-by-turn navigation, reliable estimated times of arrival, and speed limit warnings without requiring phone interaction; Apple Watch offers haptic feedback for turn-by-turn guidance; and Continuity enables cross-device handoff, providing deeper integration advantages within the Apple ecosystem compared to third-party alternatives like Google Maps. The Shortcuts app further enhances automation, permitting users to create personal workflows that trigger Maps actions based on events like connection or time-of-day travel triggers. For developers, Apple provides the MapKit framework, which enables embedding interactive Apple Maps views directly into iOS, macOS, and applications, including capabilities for adding annotations, overlays, and custom points of interest. MapKit supports route calculation, real-time traffic integration, and 3D visualizations, with updates introduced in and later enhancing detailed city experiences and place identifiers for persistent referencing of locations. Complementing client-side tools, MapKit JS allows web developers to incorporate Apple Maps into websites with similar features like annotations and searches, while Apple Maps Server APIs handle backend operations such as geocoding, routing, and place lookups to reduce client-side processing and improve efficiency across platforms. These APIs emphasize Apple's proprietary data stack, prioritizing privacy by processing requests without requiring user location sharing beyond the app context.

Privacy and Data Practices

User Data Handling and Controls

Apple Maps processes data primarily on-device to minimize server-side collection, ensuring that queries and calculations do not transmit personally identifiable information unless anonymized aggregation is required for features like . The service does not maintain a persistent user tied to individual accounts for or profiling purposes, unlike competitors that track movements across sessions. This approach aligns with Apple's broader architecture, where Maps usage data remains dissociated from user identities. Users retain granular control over location access via , , or macOS settings, where they can restrict Maps to "Never" access, prompt on each use, or allow while using the app, with options to exclude precise location if preferred. Within the Maps app, recent searches and viewed places can be individually deleted or cleared entirely from the "Recents" section by swiping left on entries or selecting "Clear Recents," preventing storage of search patterns on-device beyond the session. For system-level , users can disable "Significant Locations" in Settings > Privacy & Security > Location Services > System Services, which clears stored visit history and prevents future logging of frequented areas. Optional data-sharing features, such as "Improve Maps" and "Routing & Traffic" under System Services, allow users to contribute anonymized route and speed to enhance global mapping accuracy; these can be toggled off to halt any transmission, with Apple employing techniques to obscure individual contributions when enabled. Navigation history from guided trips is not retained server-side but can be reviewed and deleted locally if cached for offline use. As of 2025, Apple confirms no monetization of Maps-derived user , reinforcing user agency through these controls without reliance on third-party trackers.

Anonymization and Collection Policies

Apple Maps collects usage including request timestamps, device models, software versions, input languages, approximate locations (if authorized), searched areas, search terms, feature interactions, route origins and destinations, travel modes, and charging details if opted in, primarily to enhance service accuracy and functionality. This is not linked to individual Apple Accounts and incorporates rotating identifiers to prevent personal identification. Crowd-sourced contributions, such as anonymized GPS coordinates, speed, direction, barometric pressure, and nearby or cell tower signals, are periodically transmitted in encrypted form to refine predictions, pedestrian routing, and atmospheric modeling without identifying users. Anonymization techniques include coarsening precise data to less granular levels within 24 hours of collection, fragmenting routes into randomized, scrambled segments processed on servers to obscure full paths, and applying mechanisms to aggregate probe data from subsections rather than complete journeys, ensuring no entity—including Apple—can reconstruct individual routes. Significant Locations and preferred routes are computed and stored on-device with before optional syncing, rendering them unreadable by Apple even during transmission. Data shared with mapping partners is aggregated to meet minimum volume thresholds and stripped of identifiable elements, while app launch locations and timestamps for Maps improvements are retained solely in anonymous, encrypted formats. Retention policies prohibit storing personal data; only anonymized coordinates and metrics are kept indefinitely to support ongoing map enhancements, with user-adjustable controls for features like Visited Places. Users can disable collection via device settings, such as toggling off Location Services for Maps, opting out of "Improve Maps" or "Routing & Traffic" under System Services, or restricting analytics sharing, thereby preventing transmission of location-derived altogether. Apple's self-reported policies emphasize minimal necessary collection, though independent verification of anonymization efficacy remains limited to technical descriptions rather than third-party audits.

Comparisons with Google Maps

Apple Maps emphasizes on-device processing for navigation queries and search requests, utilizing random, non-persistent identifiers that prevent association with individual user accounts or . This approach ensures that routine Maps usage, such as generating directions, occurs locally without transmitting identifiable location information to Apple's servers. In contrast, collects precise location data via GPS and IP addresses, linking it to user accounts when features like Timeline are enabled, to enable personalization, route optimization, and ad targeting across services. Apple Maps does not maintain a server-side location history by default; features like Visited Places in iOS 18 store data encrypted on-device, accessible only to the user without cloud syncing unless explicitly chosen. Google Maps' Timeline, historically stored on servers for indefinite retention, underwent a policy shift in late , transitioning to on-device storage with automatic deletion of server-held data older than unless users opt to export or back up. This change reduces long-term server retention but retains collection for active sessions tied to Web & App Activity, which can include Maps searches and movements for service improvement and advertising. Both services employ anonymization for aggregate data used in map enhancements—Apple through techniques and Google via pseudonymized datasets—but Apple's model avoids cross-service profiling, limiting data use to Maps-specific improvements without ad ecosystems. Google integrates Maps data into broader activity logs, enabling derived inferences for recommendations and ads unless users disable settings like Web & App Activity. Independent reviews highlight Apple Maps as preferable for -conscious users, as it minimizes and third-party sharing compared to Google's more expansive data practices.

Core Features

Apple Maps provides for driving, walking, cycling, and transit routes, delivering spoken directions and visual overlays on a detailed interface. The system calculates estimated times of arrival (ETAs) incorporating real-time and allows for route previews showing upcoming turns. Users can plan multi-stop trips with up to 15 destinations, enabling efficient sequencing of errands or travel itineraries. Real-time traffic monitoring integrates crowd-sourced data from enabled devices to display congestion levels, predict delays, and trigger automatic rerouting when faster alternatives emerge. The app overlays current , nearby speed cameras, and incident reports such as accidents or hazards, with users able to contribute updates via an in-app reporting tool where legally permitted. Speed camera alerts were introduced in in 2020, initially in select regions like and the , expanding globally thereafter. indicators followed in subsequent updates around 2022, appearing dynamically during navigation. Lane guidance highlights specific turn lanes, medians, crosswalks, and dedicated paths for bikes, buses, or taxis to assist precise maneuvering in complex intersections. On-device machine learning, enhanced in iOS updates through 2025, learns user-preferred routes from frequent trips and provides proactive notifications for delays or alternative paths based on historical patterns. This predictive routing operates without transmitting personal data to servers, relying on anonymized aggregates for traffic modeling. Integration with Apple Watch and CarPlay provides clean turn-by-turn navigation with hands-free voice prompts, reliable ETAs incorporating real-time traffic adjustments, and speed limit warnings, emphasizing privacy through on-device processing; while incident reporting and rerouting are supported, these may be less aggressive in traffic avoidance than some competitors. Lock Screen widgets offer quick access to ongoing navigation status.

Immersive Visualizations

Apple Maps incorporates immersive visualization tools to provide users with enhanced spatial awareness and exploration capabilities, including street-level panoramas, aerial 3D flyovers, and detailed urban . These features leverage proprietary imaging data collected via Apple vehicles equipped with sensors, enabling interactive views that simulate physical presence in supported areas. Look Around delivers a 360-degree, interactive street-level perspective akin to ground-based , available in select cities worldwide. Users access it by tapping the Look Around button in the Maps app, which overlays panoramic imagery on the map for panning, zooming, and seamless navigation between frames. Initially rolled out with the redesigned Maps in the on January 30, 2020, coverage has expanded progressively to regions including , , , the , and by December 15, 2022, with further additions in the and by October 2020. As of December 2024, Look Around extended to the web version of Apple Maps, allowing desktop access to updated imagery from surveys conducted in 2024 in areas like the and . Flyover enables animated 3D aerial tours of major landmarks and metropolitan areas, rendering photorealistic models that users can control by tilting, rotating, or following guided paths. This feature, identifiable via a Flyover button on place cards, supports exploration of structures like and in three dimensions, with enhancements for smoother added in subsequent updates. Flyover data derives from high-resolution aerial and processed into immersive models, distinct from static satellite views. The Detailed City Experience integrates advanced in major urban centers, featuring realistic textures, shadows, and building facades for a more lifelike map tilt and rotation. Announced on September 27, 2021, it includes an interactive globe view for global navigation and photo-realistic Flyover expansions, with ongoing rollouts improving road-level details for driving previews. Users activate 3D mode by rotating the map with two fingers or selecting the 3D toggle, revealing layered visualizations of and landscapes where data availability permits. Coverage remains concentrated in densely imaged metros, with expansions tied to Apple's mapping vehicle surveys. Augmented reality elements complement these visualizations through AR walking directions, where raising the aligns camera-captured surroundings with overlaid arrows and landmarks for precise guidance. This integrates real-time environmental scanning with pre-rendered data, enhancing immersion during pedestrian navigation in supported locales.

Transit and Multi-Modal Options

Apple Maps provides public transit directions in numerous cities worldwide, offering step-by-step guidance for routes involving buses, subways, trains, ferries, and , with details on departure times, transfer connections, walking segments between stops, and estimated fares where data is available. These directions are accessible across , , macOS, and devices by selecting the transit mode when requesting routes, though availability varies by location and requires compatible transit agency data feeds. Real-time transit information enhances usability in supported areas, displaying live arrival and departure times, current vehicle positions, service alerts, and disruptions such as delays or outages. As of 2024, this includes major metropolitan regions like those in , the , , , (including ), and parts of , with ongoing expansions; for instance, real-time data covers subways, buses, and trains in over 32 metropolitan areas across multiple countries. Users can add transit cards to for seamless fare payments and balance checks integrated into directions. Multi-modal routing in Apple Maps primarily combines public transit legs with incidental walking to stations or platforms, optimizing for transfers and total travel time within the transit network. However, it does not natively generate fully integrated routes blending transit with , , or ride-hailing services in a single optimized itinerary; users must often plan such hybrid trips by switching modes or using separate searches. Multi-stop planning, added in in 2022, supports up to 15 waypoints but is optimized mainly for , with limited application to transit-inclusive paths. This contrasts with more flexible multi-modal apps, though Apple Maps prioritizes privacy by avoiding cross-mode data aggregation that could track user movements across transport types.

Specialized Directions (Cycling, Walking, Hiking)

Apple Maps offers specialized routing modes for non-vehicular travel, prioritizing paths suited to , , and while incorporating data, considerations, and safety factors unavailable in standard driving directions. These modes leverage topographic data, user location accuracy via device sensors, and integration with for hands-free guidance where applicable. Cycling and walking options have been available since the app's early iterations, with expansions in and iOS 18; hiking-specific navigation emerged as a distinct feature in September 2024 with iOS 18. Cycling Directions
routes emphasize bike paths, dedicated lanes, and low-traffic roads to minimize risks from motorized vehicles, with real-time previews of route busyness and profiles displayed before starting . Users receive proactive alerts for steep inclines exceeding specified thresholds, aiding planning for physical demands. These features, supported on , , and compatible Apple Watches, draw from crowdsourced and mapping data but remain unavailable in regions lacking sufficient bike infrastructure coverage, such as parts of and as of 2024. Turn-by-turn voice guidance includes distance to next maneuvers and estimated arrival times adjusted for typical cycling speeds.
Walking Directions
Walking mode provides step-by-step guidance optimized for sidewalks, crosswalks, and pedestrian zones, integrating overlays from the Look Around feature to align users with landmarks in supported cities. Indoor mapping extends this to airports, malls, and transit hubs, reducing disorientation in complex interiors. iOS 18 introduced custom walking route creation in September 2024, allowing users to plot personalized paths via drag-and-drop on the map, with automatic snapping to viable trails and elevation summaries for each segment. Raise-to-view functionality on displays ongoing directions without manual interaction, and integration with enables wrist-based progression tracking. Availability depends on detailed pedestrian data, which lags in rural or underdeveloped areas.
Hiking Directions
Hiking navigation, rolled out in 18 on September 16, 2024, focuses on U.S. national parks with topographic basemaps showing contours, vegetation, and water features for off-road precision. Users filter trails by difficulty, length (e.g., under 5 miles), and elevation gain, then receive turn-by-turn spoken directions synced to GPS and barometric data for accurate incline tracking. By November 2024, coverage extended to all 63 national parks, supporting custom route planning options like out-and-back loops or point-to-point treks, with offline downloads for areas lacking cellular service. compatibility includes haptic alerts for junctions and battery-efficient topographic rendering. These capabilities rely on partnerships with park services for verification but are limited outside U.S. parks, where general walking modes substitute for informal hikes.

Place Discovery and User Contributions

Apple Maps facilitates place discovery via a search interface that incorporates , enhanced by Apple Intelligence in iOS 18 and later, allowing queries like "coffee shops nearby with outdoor seating." Filters refine results by attributes such as cuisine, price, ratings, and accessibility, drawing from a combination of proprietary data and licensed sources. Location-specific enhancements, introduced in iOS 18, tailor searches to the visible map area, improving relevance for exploratory queries. Specialized tools include integration with for concert discovery, announced on May 16, 2023, and hike route suggestions in U.S. national parks, added in September 2024. The Places Library feature, debuted in iOS 18, enables users to curate and share collections of locations, while Visited Places logs travel history for personalized recaps. User contributions to Apple Maps primarily involve submitting photos, ratings, and reports to refine place data. Native photo uploads and thumbs-up/thumbs-down ratings became available in select regions starting 2020, with U.S. rollout on August 24, 2021, via iOS 15. expanded this to allow direct photo additions to place cards, fostering richer visual details for other users. Contribution prompts appear for recently visited sites, adjustable in Maps settings on iOS and macOS. These inputs supplement expert-curated insights and third-party integrations, such as Yelp reviews prior to native expansion, though remains less voluminous than in competing services. Users can also submit reports for inaccuracies or incidents, but Apple does not publicly detail verification processes or notify submitters of outcomes. As of May 2025, Apple Maps incorporates user ratings alongside expert reviews for categories like restaurants and hotels to aid discovery.

Traffic and Incident Reporting

Apple Maps provides real-time traffic information by displaying color-coded overlays on routes, indicating flow levels from (uncongested) to (heavy delays), with estimated times of arrival adjusted dynamically based on aggregated, anonymized data from participating devices. This traffic visualization has been available since the app's integration in , drawing initially from third-party providers like before shifting to Apple's proprietary data collection via mapped vehicles and user devices. Incident reporting enables users to crowdsource alerts for road events, introduced in iOS 14.5 in April 2021, allowing reports of crashes, hazards, and speed checks during navigation. To submit a report, users tap the route card in the app, select "Report an Incident," and choose the category; reports are anonymized and shared with other users in real-time without identifying the reporter. Users can also report via by saying phrases like "There's an accident ahead" or through interfaces, with the feature available in select countries including the , , and expanding regions like and as of April 2023. By iOS updates in 2025, incident categories expanded to six, incorporating , road closures, and general conditions alongside existing options, enhancing rerouting suggestions for delays or obstructions. Apple Maps verifies reports through volume and consistency from multiple users before prominently displaying them, reducing false positives compared to purely user-driven apps, though coverage remains denser in high-usage areas like urban U.S. routes. Users may report incidents as cleared to update maps promptly, supporting safer navigation without relying on personal data retention. This system prioritizes by processing reports on-device where possible and aggregating them server-side without tracking individuals.

Market Adoption

Usage Statistics and Market Share

In the global navigation app market, maintains dominance with approximately 67% as of early 2025, driven by its cross-platform availability and extensive user base exceeding 1.8 billion monthly . Apple Maps, integrated as the default on , , and macOS devices, accounts for an estimated 10-12% of the mobile mapping , reflecting its confinement to Apple's ecosystem amid competition from third-party alternatives. Adoption among iOS users is higher but incomplete, with data from 2021 indicating that 54-58% of U.S. adult iOS users rely on Apple Maps for navigation, equating to roughly 62-66 million adult users in the U.S. at that time. Globally, Apple Maps user estimates range from 500-600 million, largely overlapping with Apple's installed base of over 2 billion active devices, though precise monthly active figures remain undisclosed by Apple. These figures underscore persistent preference for Google Maps even among iPhone owners, attributed to factors like broader feature familiarity and Android integration. Usage growth for Apple Maps has accelerated since major redesigns in 2012 and subsequent enhancements, with reports noting increased reliance in privacy-focused scenarios and urban iOS-heavy regions; however, the overall navigation sector generated $16.2 billion in revenue in 2022, predominantly from Google Maps. Market analysts project continued expansion for bundled apps like Apple Maps as iOS penetration stabilizes around 28% of global smartphones, but displacement by Google Maps downloads on iOS—exceeding 100 million annually—limits deeper penetration.

Regional Variations and iOS User Preferences

Apple Maps' feature set and data quality vary by region due to staggered rollouts of updated mapping data and local regulatory requirements. The Detailed City Experience, offering enhanced 3D views and detailed landmarks, launched in the United States in January 2020 and expanded to parts of , including , , Czechia, , , and by April 2023, with further countries like the and receiving it in December 2022. In contrast, adoption of these high-fidelity features remains limited in and , where Apple's vehicle-based data collection is ongoing but incomplete as of mid-2024, leading to reliance on older vector data in countries like and . Transit directions, a key navigation tool, are available in 56 countries as of recent updates, but coverage density differs; for instance, comprehensive public transport integration is more robust in and than in emerging markets. In the , the , effective from 2024, allows users to designate alternative default mapping apps, potentially influencing regional usage patterns by reducing Apple's pre-installed advantage. Among iOS users, preferences lean toward despite Apple Maps being the default app, with a 2016 survey finding 70% of users favoring for its perceived superior accuracy and features, compared to 13% for Apple Maps. More recent informal polls suggest roughly two-thirds of iOS users still prefer , though Apple Maps' share has grown to approximately 23% in iOS-heavy markets like the , , and by mid-2025, driven by privacy-focused design and ecosystem integration. This preference gap persists partly because offers broader global coverage and user-contributed updates, appealing to iOS users in regions with incomplete Apple data.

Growth Drivers and Barriers

Apple Maps' growth has been propelled by its tight integration with the iOS ecosystem, where it serves as the default mapping application on over 1.5 billion active Apple devices as of 2024, facilitating seamless navigation via and enhancements that improve in-vehicle experiences. Continuous feature additions, including high-definition maps, Look Around imagery, and real-time incident reporting, have addressed early deficiencies and attracted users seeking alternatives to data-intensive competitors. By 2025, these developments contributed to Apple Maps capturing approximately 23% market share in iOS-heavy regions such as the , , and , reflecting a shift among users prioritizing native performance and privacy-focused data handling over cross-platform alternatives. A core driver stems from Apple's privacy-centric , which processes location data on-device and eschews ad-targeted tracking, contrasting with rivals' reliance on user profiling; this appeals to segments wary of , as evidenced by user reports of switching post-updates emphasizing on-device computation. Enhanced routing algorithms providing clearer, plain-language instructions and superior battery efficiency on Apple hardware further bolster retention, particularly for and walking directions where empirical user feedback highlights advantages in route realism and interface intuitiveness. Developer tools and expanded coverage, such as multi-stop and detailed urban visualizations rolled out progressively since , have incrementally built trust through verifiable accuracy gains in covered areas. Barriers to broader adoption persist, primarily Google Maps' entrenched dominance with an estimated 88% overall preference due to its vast, crowdsourced dataset amassed from Android's larger global footprint and years of refinement, enabling superior global place discovery and offline capabilities that Apple Maps still trails in breadth. Historical inaccuracies from the launch continue to shape perceptions, compounded by slower data accumulation in underrepresented regions and weaker like reviews, limiting appeal for comprehensive local searches. Apple's ecosystem lock-in restricts cross-platform accessibility, alienating non-iOS users and service-area businesses challenged by requirements for fixed addresses over dynamic service zones. Convincing habitual users remains difficult, as entrenched behaviors and feature parity gaps, such as less robust public transit integration outside major metros, sustain loyalty despite Apple's advances.

Reception and Criticisms

Early Reception (2012)

Apple Maps debuted as the default mapping application in , released on September 19, 2012, coinciding with the launch, marking Apple's shift away from to gain independence in data sourcing and integration. Within hours, users reported widespread inaccuracies, including missing or mislabeled landmarks such as the omitted from New York views, the in incorrectly identified as a nearby office building, and distorted 3D renderings like a pancaked in . often appeared warped, with buildings rotated or streets absent, while points of interest lacked detail and public transit information was largely unavailable in major cities like and . Navigation errors drew particular scrutiny for posing safety risks, as routes frequently directed users to incorrect locations or nonexistent paths; for instance, bridges like the appeared to plunge into rivers, and in , the town of was displaced about 50 miles northwest, leading police to warn of life-threatening strandings in remote desert areas during 104°F (40°C) heat. These flaws stemmed from Apple's aggregation of data from multiple third-party providers like and , which proved inconsistent and unpolished at launch, contrasting sharply with the polished users expected. Media outlets and analysts labeled it a significant misstep, with comparing the backlash to the 1993 Newton PDA failure, highlighting execution shortfalls despite strategic intent. On September 28, 2012, CEO published an apologizing for the "frustration," stating Apple was "extremely sorry" and actively improving the service, while unusually recommending competitors' apps like , Bing, or as interim solutions. The incident precipitated internal repercussions, including the October 29, 2012, departure of software chief , who reportedly refused to co-sign the apology amid board pressure to accept responsibility for the rushed rollout.

Post-Launch Improvements and Praise

Following the problematic 2012 debut, Apple initiated incremental fixes in 2012–2013, addressing mapping errors through data corrections and feature additions like traffic incident reporting. By 2018, the company announced a ground-up rebuild of Apple Maps, leveraging proprietary , for road detection, and partnerships for fresh imagery to supplant outdated third-party data. This overhaul culminated in the 2020 redesign, which delivered faster computations, enhanced road detail rendering, and real-time public transit schedules, enabling smoother urban . The update in September 2021 represented the most extensive redesign to date, introducing photogrammetric 3D city experiences in select locales such as and , alongside refined pedestrian guidance with AR walking directions and lane-specific turn alerts. Subsequent expansions in 2022 extended these capabilities— including Look Around panoramic street views—to additional countries, while bolstering 3D flyover coverage and navigation accuracy via crowdsourced incident reports. iOS 18 in 2024 further advanced exploration tools with offline map downloads, customizable guides, and broader transit integration, while a 2025 addition of expert-sourced ratings from outlets like elevated place recommendations. In March 2025, Apple launched the Surveyor app to crowdsource high-fidelity environmental data, directly targeting persistent accuracy gaps in complex terrains. These evolutions have garnered acclaim for prioritizing user —eschewing ad-driven tracking inherent in competitors—and for superior ecosystem synergy, such as hands-free integration and optimizations. Reviewers in 2025 praised Apple Maps' nuanced audio prompts for turns and hazards, quick transit duration previews, and crisp interface over ' clutter. rated it 4.0 out of 5, crediting parity in urban routes and curated Guides while noting its edge in minimization. WIRED highlighted four advantages: precise voice guidance, effortless multi-modal trip planning, seamless Apple device continuity, and inherent safeguards. User adoption metrics reflect this shift, with users increasingly favoring Maps for domestic travel due to refined algorithms yielding fewer erroneous detours compared to early iterations.

Persistent Shortcomings

Despite substantial updates since its troubled launch, Apple Maps has retained deficiencies in GPS accuracy and reliability, particularly during . User reports and technical analyses indicate that the app often experiences location jumping or erroneous positioning, leading to missed exits or incorrect turns, a problem exacerbated in environments where raw GPS data is followed more closely without sufficient signal correction. This issue persists as of 2025, with 16 Pro users noting glitches where the map stalls or shifts to parallel roads, contrasting with competitors' more robust algorithms. Data incompleteness remains a core limitation, with frequent complaints of missing points of interest, fabricated locations, or incorrect addresses, undermining place discovery and search utility. Reviews highlight a subpar ratings and review system that lags behind ' crowdsourced depth, resulting in less reliable business information and user contributions. These gaps are evident in non-urban areas, where mapping deteriorates, as seen in specific incidents like erroneous directions on roads such as Colonial Boulevard in as of March 2025. Real-time incident and traffic reporting trails industry leaders, lacking the integrated hazard alerts from sources like that incorporates, prompting some users to abandon Apple Maps for drives requiring dynamic rerouting. Comparative assessments in 2025 affirm Google's superiority in live traffic visualization and adaptability, attributing Apple Maps' shortfalls to its privacy-focused architecture, which restricts pervasive . Location refinement errors, such as inability to precisely set home addresses for reminders, have endured since at least 2019, affecting contextual features like geofencing. These functional persistences stem from Apple's siloed data ecosystem, which, while enhancing on-device , limits the scale of empirical mapping improvements compared to Google’s broader .

Major Controversies

Geopolitical Mapping Disputes

Apple Maps has encountered controversies over its depictions of disputed territories, primarily due to location-based customizations implemented to comply with local laws and regulations in various countries. These adjustments often prioritize regulatory adherence and over uniform global representations, leading to accusations of geopolitical bias or capitulation to authoritarian demands. Critics, including affected governments and advocates, argue that such practices undermine factual accuracy and international norms, as maps effectively endorse contested claims when viewed from specific regions. A prominent case involved , annexed by from in 2014. On November 25, 2019, Apple updated Apple Maps and Weather to display the peninsula as Russian territory—including Russian administrative boundaries and labels—for users located in Russia or Crimea. This complied with Russian legislation requiring digital services to reflect the annexation, but it provoked immediate backlash from Ukraine, whose foreign ministry labeled it an "unacceptable legitimization" of the seizure, and from international observers who viewed it as tacit endorsement of aggression. Apple justified the change as necessary to operate in Russia, where non-compliance risked app store bans, but announced a review of its border-handling policies amid the outcry. Following Russia's February 2022 full-scale invasion of , Apple quietly altered its global depiction on March 3, 2022, reverting to Ukrainian sovereignty for users outside —showing it with a dashed-line boundary and Ukrainian labels—while retaining the Russian version for Russian IP addresses. This partial reversal aligned with heightened Western support for but highlighted ongoing localization inconsistencies, as the app still varies by viewer location rather than adhering to a single empirical or legal standard like UN recognition. Similar dynamics apply elsewhere; for instance, in , Apple Maps integrates data from state-approved provider (Gaode Map), which conforms to Beijing's territorial assertions, such as in the , though global versions depict independently without provincial qualifiers. Fact-checks have debunked viral claims of explicit "" labeling outside China-compliant contexts. In , Apple Maps has adjusted Jammu and Kashmir portrayals for Indian users to reflect India's full territorial claims post-2019 revocation of Article 370, labeling disputed areas as integral without "disputed" qualifiers, in line with New Delhi's regulations on digital maps. This mirrors broader industry practices but underscores how economic incentives— and represent massive markets—can lead to fragmented truths, with maps serving as tools of state influence rather than neutral geographic records. Apple has not publicly detailed a overarching philosophy beyond compliance, though post-2019 reviews reportedly aimed at balancing legal necessities with transparency, such as using ambiguous dashed lines for disputes where feasible.

Accuracy and Safety Incidents

Upon its release with on September 19, 2012, Apple Maps faced immediate and widespread criticism for accuracy deficiencies, including misplaced landmarks, incorrect road labels, and erroneous that suggested impossible paths such as driving off bridges or into bodies of . These errors stemmed from Apple's aggregation of data from third-party providers like and , which lacked sufficient integration and verification, leading to routes that disregarded physical barriers and real-world geography. While many inaccuracies were comical or merely inconvenient, such as labeling a Berlin suburb as the capital in , others posed tangible safety risks by directing users into hazardous situations. One prominent safety incident occurred in during late 2012, where Apple Maps incorrectly geolocated the town of approximately 70 kilometers northwest into the remote Murray-Sunset , a arid region lacking roads, services, and cell coverage. At least six motorists were reported stranded as a result, with some enduring up to 24 hours without food or water in temperatures exceeding 46°C (115°F), forcing them to trek through treacherous terrain for help. Victorian police described the flaw as "potentially life-threatening," urging users to disable the app for navigation in the area, and Apple corrected the error on December 10, 2012. In September 2013, a mapping error at in directed vehicles onto an active aircraft , prompting the airport to close the route to prevent collisions between cars and planes. Airport officials confirmed multiple instances of drivers following the app's guidance onto the restricted path, highlighting risks to , and the issue was resolved after public reporting. Such incidents underscored early reliance on unvetted data sources, though Apple subsequently enhanced its mapping infrastructure through proprietary and partnerships, reducing similar high-profile errors in subsequent years.

Regulatory and Vendor Conflicts

In 2012, Apple ended its reliance on as the primary mapping provider for devices following a dispute over access to voice-guided technology. , which had supplied mapping data and services since the iPhone's inception in 2007, refused to grant Apple the necessary APIs, data layers, and server-side support to implement these features natively within , preferring to reserve them for its own application. This refusal stemmed from competitive concerns, as viewed the capability as a key differentiator for its mobile search and navigation dominance. Apple's CEO later acknowledged the limitations of the initial Apple Maps rollout, but the split was driven by strategic independence from a rival controlling critical user data flows. The disagreement did not result in litigation but accelerated Apple's pivot to alternative vendors, including for base map data and routing algorithms, alongside crowdsourced contributions from and proprietary collection via Apple-owned vehicles. , a leading digital mapping supplier, provided core vector data for Apple Maps' debut on September 19, 2012, defending its quality amid early glitches attributed more to Apple's and integration than raw data inaccuracies. Subsequent contract renewals, such as in 2015, strengthened this partnership without reported frictions, though analysts noted Apple's leverage in negotiations due to its massive user base potentially supplying probe data in return. This vendor diversification mitigated risks of single-supplier dependency but exposed Apple to integration challenges with less comprehensive datasets compared to Google's vast index. Regulatory scrutiny specific to Apple Maps has been minimal, with no dedicated antitrust actions or fines targeting its operations as of 2025. Broader probes into Apple's platform dominance, such as U.S. Department of Justice cases and EU enforcement, have referenced mapping defaults as elements of lock-in—e.g., pre-installation and prominence favoring Apple Maps over rivals—but these focus on app distribution rather than mapping accuracy or data practices. For instance, during Google's 2023 U.S. antitrust trial, testimony highlighted how the iOS 6 switch reduced Google's mobile map traffic by 60%, illustrating indirect competitive impacts without implicating Apple in violations. Apple's emphasis on on-device processing for location queries has aligned with privacy regulations like GDPR, avoiding the data-sharing controversies faced by vendor-dependent models, though calls for sector-wide oversight on digital mapping monopolies persist in policy discussions.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
Contribute something
User Avatar
No comments yet.