Hubbry Logo
HanukkahHanukkahMain
Open search
Hanukkah
Community hub
Hanukkah
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Hanukkah
Hanukkah
from Wikipedia
Hanukkah
Official nameחֲנֻכָּה‎ or חֲנוּכָּה
English translation: 'Establishing' or 'Dedication' (of the Temple in Jerusalem)
Observed byRabbinic Jews
TypeJewish
SignificanceThe Maccabees successfully revolted against Antiochus IV Epiphanes. According to the Talmud, the Temple was purified and the wicks of the menorah miraculously burned for eight days, even though there was only enough sacred oil for one day's lighting.
CelebrationsLighting candles each night. Singing special songs, such as Ma'oz Tzur. Reciting the Hallel prayer. Eating food fried in oil, such as latkes and sufganiyot, and dairy foods. Playing the dreidel game, and giving Hanukkah gelt.
Begins25 Kislev
Ends2 Tevet or 3 Tevet
Date25 Kislev, 26 Kislev, 27 Kislev, 28 Kislev, 29 Kislev, 30 Kislev, 1 Tevet, 2 Tevet, 3 Tevet
2024 dateSunset, 25 December –
nightfall, 2 January[1]
2025 dateSunset, 14 December –
nightfall, 22 December[1]
2026 dateSunset, 4 December –
nightfall, 12 December[1]
2027 dateSunset, 24 December –
nightfall, 1 January[1]
Related toPurim, Day of Salvation and Liberation as a rabbinically decreed holiday.
Hanukkah table

Hanukkah[a] (/ˈhænəkə/, /ˈhɑːnəkə/; חֲנֻכָּהḤănukkā listen) is a Rabbinic Jewish festival commemorating the recovery of Jerusalem and subsequent rededication of the Second Temple at the beginning of the Maccabean Revolt against the Seleucid Empire in the 2nd century BCE.[3][4]

Hanukkah is observed for eight nights and days,[5] starting on the 25th day of Kislev according to the Hebrew calendar, which may occur at any time from November 28 to December 27 in the Gregorian calendar. The festival is observed by lighting the candles of a candelabrum with nine branches, commonly called a menorah or hanukkiah. One branch is placed above or below the others and its candle is used to light the other eight candles. This unique candle is called the shammash (שַׁמָּשׁ‎, "attendant"). Each night, one additional candle is lit by the shammash until all eight candles are lit together on the final night of the festival.[6]

Other Hanukkah festivities include singing Hanukkah songs, playing the game of dreidel and eating oil-based foods, such as latkes and sufganiyot (similar to jelly donuts), and dairy foods. Since the 1970s, the worldwide Chabad Hasidic movement has initiated public menorah lightings in open public places in many countries.[7]

Originally instituted as a feast "in the manner of Sukkot (Booths)", it does not come with the corresponding obligations, and is therefore a relatively minor holiday in strictly religious terms. Nevertheless, Hanukkah has attained major cultural significance in North America and elsewhere, especially among secular Jews, due to often occurring around the same time as Christmas during the festive season.[8]

Etymology

[edit]

The name "Hanukkah" derives from the Hebrew verb "חנך‎", meaning "to dedicate", because on Hanukkah, the Maccabean Jews regained control of Jerusalem and rededicated the Temple.[9][10]

Many homiletical explanations have been given for the name:[11]

  • The name can be broken down into חנו כ״ה‎, "[they] rested [on the] twenty-fifth", referring to the fact that the Jews ceased fighting on the 25th day of Kislev, the day on which the holiday begins.[12]
  • חינוךChinuch, from the same root, is the name for Jewish education, emphasizing ethical training and discipline.
  • חנוכה‎ (Hanukkah) is also the Hebrew acronym for ח נרות והלכה כבית הלל‎ – "Eight candles, and the halakha is according to the House of Hillel". This is a reference to the disagreement between two rabbinical schools of thought – the House of Hillel and the House of Shammai – on the proper order in which to light the Hanukkah flames. Shammai opined that eight candles should be lit on the first night, seven on the second night, and so on down to one on the last night (because the miracle was greatest on the first day). Hillel argued in favor of starting with one candle and lighting an additional one every night, up to eight on the eighth night (because the miracle grew in greatness each day). Jewish law adopted the position of Hillel.[13]
  • Psalm 30 is called שיר חנכת הביתShîr Ḥănukkāt HaBayit, "the Song of the 'Dedication' of the House", and is traditionally recited on Hanukkah. 25 (of Kislev) + 5 (Books of Torah) = 30, which is the number of the song.

Alternative spellings

[edit]
Spelling variations due to transliteration of Hebrew Ḥet Nun Vav Kaf Hey

In Hebrew, the word Hanukkah is written חֲנֻכָּה‎ or חֲנוּכָּה‎ (Ḥănukā). It is most commonly transliterated to English as Hanukkah or Chanukah. The spelling Hanukkah, which is based on using characters of the English alphabet as symbols to re-create the word's correct spelling in Hebrew,[14] is the most common[15] and the preferred choice of Merriam–Webster,[16] Collins English Dictionary, the Oxford Style Manual, and the style guides of The New York Times and The Guardian.[17] The sound represented by Ch ([χ], similar to the Scottish pronunciation of loch) is not native to the English language, so those not familiar with Hebrew pronunciation may pronounce it with an h ([h]).[b] Furthermore, the letter ḥeth (ח‎), which is the first letter in the Hebrew spelling, is pronounced differently in modern Hebrew (voiceless uvular fricative) from in classical Hebrew (voiceless pharyngeal fricative [ħ]), and neither of those sounds is unambiguously representable in English spelling. However, its original sound is closer to the English H than to the Scottish Ch, and Hanukkah more accurately represents the spelling in the Hebrew alphabet.[14] Moreover, the 'kaf' consonant is geminate in classical (but not modern) Hebrew. Adapting the classical Hebrew pronunciation with the geminate and pharyngeal Ḥeth can lead to the spelling Hanukkah, while adapting the modern Hebrew pronunciation with no gemination and uvular Ḥeth leads to the spelling Chanukah.[18][19][20]

Festival of Lights

[edit]

In Modern Hebrew, Hanukkah may also be called the Festival of Lights (חַג הַאוּרִים‎, Ḥag HaUrim), based on a comment by Josephus in Antiquities of the Jews, καὶ ἐξ ἐκείνου μέχρι τοῦ δεῦρο τὴν ἑορτὴν ἄγομεν καλοῦντες αὐτὴν φῶτα "And from then on we celebrate this festival, and we call it Lights". The first Hebrew translation of Antiquities (1864) used (חַג הַמְּאֹרוֹת‎) "Festival of Lamps", but the translation "Festival of Lights" (חַג הַאוּרִים‎) appeared by the end of the nineteenth century.[21]

Historical sources

[edit]

Books of Maccabees

[edit]

The story of Hanukkah is told in the books of the First and Second Maccabees, which describe in detail the rededication of the Temple in Jerusalem and the lighting of the menorah. These books, however, are not a part of the canonized Masoretic Text version of the Tanakh (Hebrew and Aramaic language Jewish Bible) used and accepted by normative Rabbinical Judaism and therefore modern Jews (as copied, edited and distributed by a group of Jews known as the Masoretes between the 7th and 10th centuries of the Common Era). However, the books of Maccabees were included among the deuterocanonical books added to the Septuagint, Greek-language translations of the Hebrew Bible originally compiled in the mid-3rd century BCE. The Roman Catholic and Orthodox Churches consider the books of Maccabees as a canonical part of the Old Testament.[22]

The eight-day rededication of the temple is described in 1 Maccabees,[23] though the miracle of the oil does not appear here. A story similar in character, and older in date, is the one alluded to in 2 Maccabees[24] according to which the relighting of the altar fire by Nehemiah was due to a miracle which occurred on the 25th of Kislev, and which appears to be given as the reason for the selection of the same date for the rededication of the altar by Judah Maccabee.[25] The above account in 1 Maccabees, as well as 2 Maccabees[26] portrays the feast as a delayed observation of the eight-day Feast of Booths (Sukkot); similarly 2 Maccabees explains the length of the feast as "in the manner of the Feast of Booths".[27]

Early rabbinic sources

[edit]

Megillat Taanit (1st century) contains a list of festive days on which fasting or eulogizing is forbidden. It specifies, "On the 25th of [Kislev] is Hanukkah of eight days, and one is not to eulogize". The scholion (9th-10th century) then references the story of the rededication of the Temple.[28]

The Mishna (late 2nd century) mentions Hanukkah in several places,[29] but never describes its laws in detail and never mentions any aspect of the history behind it. To explain the Mishna's lack of a systematic discussion of Hanukkah, Nissim ben Jacob postulated that information on the holiday was so commonplace that the Mishna felt no need to explain it.[30] Modern scholar Reuvein Margolies suggests that as the Mishnah was redacted after the Bar Kochba revolt, its editors were reluctant to include explicit discussion of a holiday celebrating another relatively recent revolt against a foreign ruler, for fear of antagonizing the Romans.[31]

Hanukkah lamp unearthed near Jerusalem about 1900

The miracle of the one-day supply of oil miraculously lasting eight days is described in the Talmud, committed to writing about 600 years after the events described in the books of Maccabees.[32] The Talmud says that after the forces of Antiochus IV had been driven from the Temple, the Maccabees discovered that almost all of the ritual olive oil had been profaned. They found only a single container that was still sealed by the High Priest, with enough oil to keep the menorah in the Temple lit for a single day. They used this, yet it burned for eight days (the time it took to have new oil pressed and made ready).[33]

The Talmud presents three options:[34]

  1. The law requires only one light each night per household,
  2. A better practice is to light one light each night for each member of the household
  3. The most preferred practice is to vary the number of lights each night.

Except in times of danger, the lights were to be placed outside one's door, on the opposite side of the mezuza, or in the window closest to the street. Rashi, in a note to Shabbat 21b, says their purpose is to publicize the miracle. The blessings for Hanukkah lights are discussed in tractate Succah, p. 46a.[35]

Section from the Aramaic Scroll of Antiochus in Babylonian supralinear punctuation, with an Arabic translation

Megillat Antiochus (probably composed in the 2nd century[36]) concludes with the following words:

...After this, the sons of Israel went up to the Temple and rebuilt its gates and purified the Temple from the dead bodies and from the defilement. And they sought after pure olive oil to light the lamps therewith, but could not find any, except one bowl that was sealed with the signet ring of the High Priest from the days of Samuel the prophet and they knew that it was pure. There was in it [enough oil] to light [the lamps therewith] for one day, but the God of heaven whose name dwells there put therein his blessing and they were able to light from it eight days. Therefore, the sons of Ḥashmonai made this covenant and took upon themselves a solemn vow, they and the sons of Israel, all of them, to publish amongst the sons of Israel, [to the end] that they might observe these eight days of joy and honour, as the days of the feasts written in [the book of] the Law; [even] to light in them so as to make known to those who come after them that their God wrought for them salvation from heaven. In them, it is not permitted to mourn, neither to decree a fast [on those days], and anyone who has a vow to perform, let him perform it.[37]

The Al HaNissim prayer is recited on Hanukkah as an addition to the Amidah prayer, which was formalized in the late 1st century.[38] Al HaNissim describes the history of the holiday as follows:

In the days of Mattiyahu ben Yohanan, high priest, the Hasmonean and his sons, when the evil Greek kingdom stood up against Your people Israel, to cause them to forget Your Torah and abandon the ways You desire – You, in Your great mercy, stood up for them in their time of trouble; You fought their fight, You judged their judgment, You took their revenge; You delivered the mighty into the hands of the weak, the many into the hands of the few, the impure into the hands of the pure, the evil into the hands of the righteous, the sinners into the hands of those who engaged in Your Torah; You made yourself a great and holy name in Your world, and for Your people Israel You made great redemption and salvation as this very day. And then Your sons came to the inner chamber of Your house, and cleared Your Temple, and purified Your sanctuary, and lit candles in Your holy courtyards, and established eight days of Hanukkah for thanksgiving and praise to Your holy name.

Narrative of Josephus

[edit]

The Jewish historian Titus Flavius Josephus narrates in his book, Jewish Antiquities XII, how the victorious Judas Maccabeus ordered lavish yearly eight-day festivities after rededicating the Temple in Jerusalem that had been profaned by Antiochus IV Epiphanes.[39] Josephus does not say the festival was called Hanukkah but rather the "Festival of Lights":

Now Judas celebrated the festival of the restoration of the sacrifices of the temple for eight days, and omitted no sort of pleasures thereon; but he feasted them upon very rich and splendid sacrifices; and he honored God, and delighted them by hymns and psalms. Nay, they were so very glad at the revival of their customs, when, after a long time of intermission, they unexpectedly had regained the freedom of their worship, that they made it a law for their posterity, that they should keep a festival, on account of the restoration of their temple worship, for eight days. And from that time to this we celebrate this festival, and call it Lights. I suppose the reason was because this liberty beyond our hopes appeared to us; and that thence was the name given to that festival. Judas also rebuilt the walls round about the city, and reared towers of great height against the incursions of enemies, and set guards therein. He also fortified the city Bethsura, that it might serve as a citadel against any distresses that might come from our enemies.[40]

Other ancient sources

[edit]

In the New Testament, John 10:22–23 says, "Then came the Festival of Dedication at Jerusalem. It was winter, and Jesus was in the temple courts walking in Solomon's Colonnade" (NIV). The Greek noun used appears in the neuter plural as "the renewals" or "the consecrations" (Ancient Greek: τὰ ἐγκαίνια; ta enkaínia).[41] The same root appears in 2 Esdras 6:16 in the Septuagint to refer specifically to Hanukkah. This Greek word was chosen because the Hebrew word for 'consecration' or 'dedication' is Hanukkah (חנכה). The Aramaic New Testament uses the Aramaic word hawdata (a close synonym), which literally means 'renewal' or 'to make new'.[42]

History

[edit]

Background

[edit]
A model of Jerusalem during the Second Temple Period

After the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BCE, Judea became part of the Ptolemaic Kingdom of Egypt until 200 BCE, when King Antiochus III the Great of Syria defeated King Ptolemy V Epiphanes of Egypt at the Battle of Panium. Judea then became part of the Seleucid Empire of Syria.[43] King Antiochus III the Great, wanting to conciliate his new Jewish subjects, guaranteed their right to "live according to their ancestral customs" and to continue to practice their religion in the Temple of Jerusalem.[44] The Seleucids, like the Ptolemies before them, held a suzerainty over Judea, where they respected Jewish culture and protected Jewish institutions. This policy was drastically reversed by Antiochus IV Epiphanes, the son of Antiochus III, seemingly after what was either a dispute over leadership of the Temple in Jerusalem and the office of High Priest, or possibly a revolt whose nature was lost to time after being crushed.[45] In 175 BCE, Antiochus IV invaded Judea at the request of the sons of Tobias.[46] The Tobiads, who led the Hellenizing Jewish faction in Jerusalem, were expelled to Syria around 170 BCE when the high priest Onias and his pro-Egyptian faction wrested control from them. The exiled Tobiads lobbied Antiochus IV Epiphanes to recapture Jerusalem. As Flavius Josephus relates:

The king being thereto disposed beforehand, complied with them, and came upon the Jews with a great army, and took their city by force, and slew a great multitude of those that favored Ptolemy, and sent out his soldiers to plunder them without mercy. He also spoiled the temple, and put a stop to the constant practice of offering a daily sacrifice of expiation for three years and six months.

Traditional view

[edit]

When the Second Temple in Jerusalem was looted and services stopped, Judaism was outlawed. In 167 BCE, Antiochus ordered an altar to Zeus erected in the Temple. He banned brit milah (circumcision) and ordered pigs to be sacrificed at the altar of the temple.[48]

Antiochus's actions provoked a large-scale revolt. Mattathias (Mattityahu), a Jewish priest, and his five sons Jochanan, Simeon, Eleazar, Jonathan, and Judah led a rebellion against Antiochus. It started with Mattathias killing first a Jew who wanted to comply with Antiochus's order to sacrifice to Zeus, and then a Greek official who was to enforce the government's behest (1 Mac. 2, 24–25[49]). Judah became known as Yehuda HaMakabi ("Judah the Hammer"). By 166 BCE, Mattathias had died, and Judah took his place as leader. By 164 BCE, the Jewish revolt against the Seleucid monarchy was successful. The Temple was liberated and rededicated. The festival of Hanukkah was instituted to celebrate this event.[50] Judah ordered the Temple to be cleansed, a new altar to be built in place of the polluted one and new holy vessels to be made.[25] According to the Talmud,

"For when the Greeks entered the Sanctuary, they defiled all the oils therein, and when the Hasmonean dynasty prevailed against and defeated them, they made search and found only one cruse of oil which lay with the seal of the kohen gadol (high priest), but which contained sufficient [oil] for one day's lighting only; yet a miracle was wrought therein, and they lit [the lamp] therewith for eight days. The following year these [days] were appointed a Festival with [the recital of] Hallel and thanksgiving."

—Shabbat 21b

Tertiary sources in the Jewish tradition make reference to this account.[51]

Maimonides (12th century) described Hanukkah as follows:

When, on the twenty-fifth of Kislev, the Jews had emerged victorious over their foes and destroyed them, they re-entered the Temple where they found only one jar of pure oil, enough to be lit for only a single day; yet they used it for lighting the required set of lamps for eight days, until they managed to press olives and produce pure oil. Because of this, the sages of that generation ruled that the eight days beginning with the twenty-fifth of Kislev should be observed as days of rejoicing and praising the Lord. Lamps are lit in the evening over the doors of the homes, on each of the eight nights, so as to display the miracle. These days are called Hanukkah, when it is forbidden to lament or to fast, just as it is on the days of Purim. Lighting the lamps during the eight days of Hanukkah is a religious duty imposed by the sages.[52]

Academic sources

[edit]

Some modern scholars, following the account in 2 Maccabees, observe that the king was intervening in an internal civil war between the Maccabean Jews and the Hellenized Jews in Jerusalem.[53][54][55][56] These competed violently over who would be the High Priest, with traditionalists with Hebrew/Aramaic names like Onias contesting with Hellenizing High Priests with Greek names like Jason and Menelaus.[57] In particular, Jason's Hellenistic reforms would prove to be a decisive factor leading to eventual conflict within the ranks of Judaism.[58] Other authors point to possible socioeconomic reasons in addition to the religious reasons behind the civil war.[59]

Modern Israeli 10 agorot coin, reproducing the menorah image from a coin issued by Mattathias Antigonus

What began in many respects as a civil war escalated when the Hellenistic kingdom of Syria sided with the Hellenizing Jews in their conflict with the traditionalists.[60] As the conflict escalated, Antiochus took the side of the Hellenizers by prohibiting the religious practices the traditionalists had rallied around. This may explain why the king, in a total departure from Seleucid practice in all other places and times, banned a traditional religion.[61]

The miracle of the oil is widely regarded as a legend and its authenticity has been questioned since the Middle Ages.[62] However, given the famous question Joseph Karo (1488–1575) posed concerning why Hanukkah is celebrated for eight days when the miracle was only for seven days (since there was enough oil for one day),[63] it was clear that writing in the 16th century CE, he believed it to be a historical event. This belief has been adopted by most of Orthodox Judaism, in as much as Karo's Shulchan Aruch is a main code of Jewish Law.

Timeline

[edit]
Hasmonean Kingdom, 143 BCE
Tombs of the Maccabees, Modi'in, Israel
  • 198 BCE: Armies of the Seleucid King Antiochus III (Antiochus the Great) oust Ptolemy V from Judea and Samaria.[43]
  • 175 BCE: Antiochus IV (Epiphanes) ascends the Seleucid throne.[64]
  • 168 BCE: Under the reign of Antiochus IV, the second Temple is looted, Jews are massacred, and Judaism is outlawed.[65]
  • 167 BCE: Antiochus orders an altar to Zeus erected in the Temple. Mattathias and his five sons John, Simon, Eleazar, Jonathan, and Judah lead a rebellion against Antiochus. Judah becomes known as Judah Maccabee ("Judah the Hammer").
  • 166 BCE: Mattathias dies, and Judah takes his place as leader. The Hasmonean Jewish Kingdom begins; It lasts until 63 BCE.
  • 164 BCE: The Jewish revolt against the Seleucid monarchy is successful in recapturing the Temple, which is liberated and rededicated (Hanukkah).
  • 142 BCE: Re-establishment of the Second Jewish Commonwealth. The Seleucids recognize Jewish autonomy. The Seleucid kings have a formal overlordship, which the Hasmoneans acknowledge. This inaugurates a period of population growth and religious, cultural and social development. This includes the conquest of the areas now covered by Transjordan, Samaria, Galilee, and Idumea (also known as Edom), and the forced conversion of Idumeans to the Jewish religion, including circumcision.[66]
  • 139 BCE: The Roman Senate recognizes Jewish autonomy.[67]
  • 134 BCE: Antiochus VII Sidetes besieges Jerusalem. The Jews under John Hyrcanus become Seleucid vassals but retain religious autonomy.[68]
  • 129 BCE: Antiochus VII dies.[69] The Hasmonean Jewish Kingdom throws off Syrian rule completely.
  • 96 BCE: Beginning of an eight-year civil war between Sadducee king Alexander Yanai and the Pharisees.[70]
  • 85–82 BCE: Consolidation of the Kingdom in territory east of the Jordan River.[71]
  • 63 BCE: The Hasmonean Jewish Kingdom comes to an end because of a rivalry between the brothers Aristobulus II and Hyrcanus II, both of whom appeal to the Roman Republic to intervene and settle the power struggle on their behalf. The Roman general Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus (Pompey the Great) is dispatched to the area. Twelve thousand Jews are massacred in the Roman Siege of Jerusalem. The Priests of the Temple are struck down at the Altar. Rome annexes Judea.[72]

Battles of the Maccabean Revolt

[edit]
Maccabees on the Knesset Menorah

Selected battles between the Maccabees and the Seleucid Syrian-Greeks:

  • Battle with Apollonius and Battle with Seron: Judas Maccabeus defeats two smaller Seleucid detachments.
  • Battle of Emmaus: Judas Maccabeus performs a daring night march to make a surprise attack on the Seleucid camp while the Seleucid forces are split.
  • Battle of Beth Zur: Judas Maccabeus defeats the army of Lysias, and captures Jerusalem soon after. Lysias relents and repeals Antiochus IV's anti-Jewish decrees.
  • Battle of Beth Zechariah: The Seleucids defeat the Maccabees. Eleazar Avaran, another of Mattathias's sons, is killed in battle by a war elephant.
  • Battle of Adasa: Judas defeats the forces of Nicanor after killing him early in the battle.
  • Battle of Elasa: Judas dies in battle against the army of Bacchides. He is succeeded by his brother Jonathan Apphus, and eventually their other brother Simon Thassi, as leader of the rebellion. The Seleucids re-establish control of the cities for 8 years, but eventually make deals with the Maccabees and appoint their leaders as official Seleucid governors and generals in a vassal-like status before eventual independence.

Characters and heroes

[edit]
The Triumph of Judas Maccabeus, Rubens, 1634–1636

Rituals

[edit]
Children pull strings to tell story of Hanukah, c. 1940

Hanukkah is celebrated with a series of rituals that are performed every day throughout the eight-day holiday, some are family-based and others communal. There are special additions to the daily prayer service, and a section is added to the blessing after meals.[78]

Hanukkah is not a "Sabbath-like" holiday, and there is no obligation to refrain from activities that are forbidden on the Sabbath, as specified in the Shulkhan Arukh.[79][80] Adherents go to work as usual but may leave early in order to be home to kindle the lights at nightfall. There is no religious reason for schools to be closed, although in Israel schools close from the second day for the whole week of Hanukkah.[81][82] Many families exchange gifts each night, such as books or games, and "Hanukkah Gelt" is often given to children. Fried foods—such as latkes (potato pancakes), jelly doughnuts (sufganiyot) and Sephardic bimuelos—are eaten to commemorate the importance of oil during the celebration of Hanukkah. Some also have a custom of eating dairy products to remember Judith and how she overcame Holofernes by feeding him cheese, which made him thirsty, and giving him wine to drink. When Holofernes became very drunk, Judith cut off his head.[83]

Kindling the Hanukkah lights

[edit]
Chanukah Menorah opposite Nazi building in Kiel, Germany, December 1931.
Hanukkah festival at Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, December 2019
Public Hanukkiah lighting in Brussels next to the Berlaymont building, the headquarters of the European Commission, 2020
Boy in front of a menorah

Each night throughout the eight-day holiday, a candle or oil-based light is lit. As a universally practiced "beautification" (hiddur mitzvah) of the mitzvah, the number of lights lit is increased by one each night.[84] An extra light called a shammash, meaning "attendant" or "sexton",[85] is also lit each night, and is given a distinct location, usually higher, lower, or to the side of the others.[80]

Among Ashkenazim the tendency is for every male member of the household (and in many families, girls as well) to light a full set of lights each night,[86][87] while among Sephardim the prevalent custom is to have one set of lights for the entire household.[88]

The purpose of the shammash is to adhere to the prohibition, specified in the Talmud,[89] against using the Hanukkah lights for anything other than publicizing and meditating on the Hanukkah miracle. This differs from Sabbath candles which are meant to be used for illumination and lighting. Hence, if one were to need extra illumination on Hanukkah, the shammash candle would be available, and one would avoid using the prohibited lights. Some, especially Ashkenazim, light the shammash candle first and then use it to light the others.[90] So altogether, including the shammash, two lights are lit on the first night, three on the second and so on, ending with nine on the last night, for a total of 44 (36, excluding the shammash). It is Sephardic custom not to light the shammash first and use it to light the rest. Instead, the shammash candle is the last to be lit, and a different candle or a match is used to light all the candles. Some Hasidic Jews follow this Sephardic custom as well.[91]

The lights can be candles or oil lamps.[90] Electric lights are sometimes used and are acceptable in places where open flame is not permitted, such as a hospital room, or for the very elderly and infirm; however, those who permit reciting a blessing over electric lamps only allow it if it is incandescent and battery operated (an incandescent flashlight would be acceptable for this purpose), while a blessing may not be recited over a plug-in menorah or lamp. Most Jewish homes have a special candelabrum referred to as either a Hanukkah menorah (the traditional name, menorah being Hebrew for 'lamp') or a Chanukiah (the modern Israeli term). Some families use an oil lamp menorah (traditionally filled with olive oil) for Hanukkah; like the candle version, it has eight wicks to light plus the additional shammash light.[92]

In the United States, Hanukkah became a more visible festival in the public sphere from the 1970s when Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson called for public awareness and observance of the festival and encouraged the lighting of public menorahs.[93][94][95][96]

The reason for the Hanukkah lights is not for the "lighting of the house within", but rather for the "illumination of the house without", so that passersby should see it and be reminded of the holiday's miracle (i.e. that the sole cruse of pure oil found which held enough oil to burn for one night actually burned for eight nights). Accordingly, lamps are set up at a prominent window or near the door leading to the street. It is customary amongst some Ashkenazi Jews to have a separate menorah for each family member (customs vary), whereas most Sephardi Jews light one for the whole household. Only when there was danger of antisemitic persecution were lamps supposed to be hidden from public view, as was the case in Persia under the rule of the Zoroastrians,[25] or in parts of Europe before and during World War II. However, most Hasidic groups light lamps near an inside doorway, not necessarily in public view. According to this tradition, the lamps are placed on the opposite side from the mezuzah, so people passing through the door are surrounded by the holiness of mitzvot (the commandments).[97]

Generally, women are exempt in Jewish law from time-bound positive commandments, although the Talmud requires that women engage in the mitzvah of lighting Hanukkah candles "for they too were involved in the miracle."[98][99]

Some Jews in North America and Israel have taken up environmental concerns in relation to Hanukkah's "miracle of the oil", emphasizing reflection on energy conservation and energy independence. An example of this is the Coalition on the Environment and Jewish Life's renewable energy campaign.[100][101][102]

Candle-lighting time

[edit]
Biala Rebbe lights the menorah

Hanukkah lights should usually burn for at least half an hour after it gets dark.[103] Many light at sundown, while most Hasidim and many other communities light later, generally around nightfall.[104] Many Hasidic Rebbes light much later to fulfill the obligation of publicizing the miracle by the presence of their Hasidim when they kindle the lights.[105]

Inexpensive small wax candles sold for Hanukkah burn for approximately half an hour so should be lit no earlier than nightfall.[103] Friday night presents a problem, however. Since candles may not be lit on Shabbat itself, the candles must be lit before sunset.[103] However, they must remain lit through the lighting of the Shabbat candles. Therefore, the Hanukkah menorah is lit first with larger candles than usual,[103] followed by the Shabbat candles. At the end of the Shabbat, there are those who light the Hanukkah lights before Havdalah and those who make Havdalah before the lighting Hanukkah lights.[106]

If for whatever reason one didn't light at sunset or nightfall, the lights should be kindled later, as long as there are people in the streets.[103] Later than that, the lights should still be kindled, but the blessings should be recited only if there is at least somebody else awake in the house and present at the lighting of the Hannukah lights.[107]

Blessings over the candles

[edit]

Typically two blessings (brachot; singular: brachah) are recited during this eight-day festival when lighting the candles. On the first night only, the shehecheyanu blessing is added, making a total of three blessings.[108]

The blessings are recited before each candle is lit. On the first night of Hanukkah one light (candle or oil) is lit on the right side of the menorah, on the following night a second light is placed to the left of the first but it is lit first, and so on, proceeding from placing candles right to left but lighting them from left to right over the eight nights.[109]

Blessing for lighting the candles

[edit]
בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה ה', אֱ-לֹהֵינוּ מֶלֶךְ הָעוֹלָם, אֲשֶׁר קִדְּשָׁנוּ בְּמִצְוֹתָיו, וְצִוָּנוּ לְהַדְלִיק נֵר חֲנֻכָּה.[110]

Transliteration: Barukh ata Adonai Eloheinu, melekh ha'olam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu l'hadlik ner Hanukkah.

Translation: "Blessed are You, LORD our God, King of the universe, Who has sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us to kindle the Hanukkah light[s]."

Blessing for the miracles of Hanukkah

[edit]
בָּרוּךְ אַתָּה ה' אֱ-לֹהֵינוּ מֶלֶךְ הָעוֹלָם, שֶׁעָשָׂה נִסִּים לַאֲבוֹתֵֽינוּ בַּיָּמִים הָהֵם בַּזְּמַן הַזֶּה.[110]

Transliteration: Barukh ata Adonai Eloheinu, melekh ha'olam, she'asa nisim la'avoteinu ba'yamim ha'heim ba'z'man ha'ze.

Translation: "Blessed are You, LORD our God, King of the universe, Who performed miracles for our ancestors in those days at this time..."

Hanerot Halalu

[edit]

After the lights are kindled the hymn Hanerot Halalu is recited. There are several different versions; the version presented here is recited in many Ashkenazic communities:[111]

Ashkenazi version:
Hebrew Transliteration English
הַנֵּרוֹת הַלָּלוּ שֶׁאָנוּ מַדְלִיקִין, עַל הַנִּסִּים וְעַל הַנִּפְלָאוֹת וְעַל הַתְּשׁוּעוֹת וְעַל הַמִּלְחָמוֹת, שֶׁעָשִׂיתָ לַאֲבוֹתֵינוּ בַּיָּמִים הָהֵם בַּזְּמַן הַזֶּה, עַל יְדֵי כֹּהֲנֶיךָ הַקְּדוֹשִׁים. וְכָל שְׁמוֹנַת יְמֵי הַחֲנֻכָּה הַנֵּרוֹת הַלָּלוּ קֹדֶשׁ הֵם וְאֵין לָנוּ רְשׁוּת לְהִשְׁתַּמֵּשׁ בָּהֶם, אֶלָּא לִרְאוֹתָם בִּלְבָד, כְּדֵי לְהוֹדוֹת וּלְהַלֵּל לְשִׁמְךָ הַגָּדוֹל עַל נִסֶּיךָ וְעַל נִפְלְאוֹתֶיךָ וְעַל יְשׁוּעָתֶךָ. Hanneirot hallalu anu madlikin 'al hannissim ve'al hanniflaot 'al hatteshu'ot ve'al hammilchamot she'asita laavoteinu bayyamim haheim, (u)bazzeman hazeh 'al yedei kohanekha hakkedoshim. Vekhol-shemonat yemei Hanukkah hanneirot hallalu kodesh heim, ve-ein lanu reshut lehishtammesh baheim ella lir'otam bilvad kedei lehodot ul'halleil leshimcha haggadol 'al nissekha ve'al nifleotekha ve'al yeshu'otekha. We kindle these lights for the miracles and the wonders, for the redemption and the battles that you made for our forefathers, in those days at this season, through your holy priests. During all eight days of Hanukkah these lights are sacred, and we are not permitted to make ordinary use of them except for to look at them in order to express thanks and praise to Your great Name for Your miracles, Your wonders and Your salvations.

Maoz Tzur

[edit]

In the Ashkenazi tradition, each night after the lighting of the candles, the hymn Ma'oz Tzur is sung. The song contains six stanzas. The first and last deal with general themes of divine salvation, and the middle four deal with events of persecution in Jewish history, praising God for survival despite these tragedies (the exodus from Egypt, the Babylonian captivity, the miracle of the holiday of Purim, the Hasmonean victory) and expressing a longing for the days when Judea will finally triumph over Rome.[112]

The song was composed in the thirteenth century by a poet only known through the acrostic found in the first letters of the original five stanzas of the song: Mordechai. The familiar tune is most probably a derivation of a German Protestant church hymn or a popular folk song.[113]

Other customs

[edit]

After lighting the candles and Ma'oz Tzur, singing other Hanukkah songs is customary in many Jewish homes. Some Hasidic and Sephardi Jews recite Psalms, such as Psalm 30, Psalm 67, and Psalm 91. In North America and in Israel it is common to exchange presents or give children presents at this time. In addition, many families encourage their children to give tzedakah (charity) in lieu of presents for themselves.[114][115]

Special additions to daily prayers

[edit]

"We thank You also for the miraculous deeds and for the redemption and for the mighty deeds and the saving acts wrought by You, as well as for the wars which You waged for our ancestors in ancient days at this season. In the days of the Hasmonean Mattathias, son of Johanan the high priest, and his sons, when the iniquitous Greco-Syrian kingdom rose up against Your people Israel, to make them forget Your Torah and to turn them away from the ordinances of Your will, then You in your abundant mercy rose up for them in the time of their trouble, pled their cause, executed judgment, avenged their wrong, and delivered the strong into the hands of the weak, the many into the hands of few, the impure into the hands of the pure, the wicked into the hands of the righteous, and insolent ones into the hands of those occupied with Your Torah. Both unto Yourself did you make a great and holy name in Thy world, and unto Your people did You achieve a great deliverance and redemption. Whereupon your children entered the sanctuary of Your house, cleansed Your temple, purified Your sanctuary, kindled lights in Your holy courts, and appointed these eight days of Hanukkah in order to give thanks and praises unto Your holy name."

Translation of Al ha-Nissim[116]

An addition is made to the "hoda'ah" (thanksgiving) benediction in the Amidah (thrice-daily prayers), called Al HaNissim ("On/about the Miracles").[117] This addition refers to the victory achieved over the Syrians by the Hasmonean Mattathias and his sons.[118][119][25]

The same prayer is added to the grace after meals. In addition, the Hallel (praise) Psalms[120] are sung during each morning service and the Tachanun penitential prayers are omitted.[118][121]

The Torah is read every day in the shacharit morning services in synagogue, on the first day beginning from Numbers 6:22 (according to some customs, Numbers 7:1), and the last day ending with Numbers 8:4. Since Hanukkah lasts eight days it includes at least one, and sometimes two, Jewish Sabbaths (Saturdays). The weekly Torah portion for the first Sabbath is almost always Miketz, telling of Joseph's dream and his enslavement in Egypt. The Haftarah reading for the first Sabbath Hanukkah is Zechariah 2:14 – Zechariah 4:7. When there is a second Sabbath on Hanukkah, the Haftarah reading is from 1 Kings 7:40–50.

The Hanukkah menorah is also kindled daily in the synagogue, at night with the blessings and in the morning without the blessings.[122]

The menorah is not lit during Shabbat, but rather prior to the beginning of Shabbat as described above and not at all during the day. During the Middle Ages "Megillat Antiochus" was read in the Italian synagogues on Hanukkah just as the Book of Esther is read on Purim. It still forms part of the liturgy of the Yemenite Jews.[123]

Zot Hanukkah: Hanukkah as the end of the High Holy Days

[edit]

The last day of Hanukkah is known by some as Zot Hanukkah and by others as Chanukat HaMizbeach, from the verse read on this day in the synagogue Numbers 7:84, Zot Hanukkat Hamizbe'ach: "This was the dedication of the altar". According to the teachings of Kabbalah and Hasidism, this day is the final "seal" of the High Holiday season of Yom Kippur and is considered a time to repent out of love for God. In this spirit, many Hasidic Jews wish each other Gmar chatimah tovah ("may you be sealed totally for good"), a traditional greeting for the Yom Kippur season. It is taught in Hasidic and Kabbalistic literature that this day is particularly auspicious for the fulfillment of prayers.[124]

Some Hasidic scholars teach that the Hanukkah is in fact the final conclusion of God's judgment extending High Holy Days of Rosh Hashana when humanity is judged and Yom Kippur when the judgment is sealed:

Hassidic masters quote from Kabbalistic sources that the God's mercy extends even further, giving the Children of Israel till the final day of Chanukah (known as "Zot Chanukah" based on words which appear in the Torah reading of that day), to return to Him and receive a favorable judgment. They see several hints to this in different verses. One is Isaiah 27:9: "Through this (zot) will Jacob's sin be forgiven" – i.e., on account of the holiness of Zot Chanukah.[125]
[edit]

It is customary for women not to work for at least the first half-hour of the candles' burning, and some have the custom not to work for the entire time of burning. It is also forbidden to fast or to eulogize during Hanukkah.[80]

Customs

[edit]

Music

[edit]
Radomsk Hasidic Ma'oz Tzur.

Hanukkah songs (in Hebrew except where indicated) include "Ma'oz Tzur" (Rock of Ages), "Latke'le Latke'le" (Yiddish: "Little Latke, Little Latke"), "Hanukkiah Li Yesh" ("I Have a Hanukkah Menorah"), "Ocho Kandelikas" (Judeo-Spanish: "Eight Little Candles"), "Kad Katan" ("A Small Jug"), "S'vivon Sov Sov Sov" ("Dreidel, Spin and Spin"), "Haneirot Halolu" ("These Candles Which We Light"), "Mi Yimalel" ("Who Can Retell") and "Ner Li, Ner Li" ("I have a Candle").

Among the best known songs in English-speaking countries are "Dreidel, Dreidel, Dreidel"[126] and "Oh Chanukah".[127]

In the Nadvorna Hasidic dynasty, it is customary for the rebbes to play violin after the menorah is lit.[128]

Penina Moise's Hannukah Hymn published in the 1842 Hymns Written for the Use of Hebrew Congregations was instrumental in the beginning of Americanization of Hanukkah.[129][130][131]

Foods

[edit]
Sufganiyot/doughnuts filled with strawberry jelly

There is a custom of eating foods fried or baked in oil (preferably olive oil) to commemorate the miracle of a small flask of oil keeping the Second Temple's Menorah alight for eight days.[132] Traditional foods include potato pancakes, known as latkes in Yiddish, especially among Ashkenazi families. Sephardi, Polish, and Israeli families eat jam-filled doughnuts (Yiddish: פּאָנטשקעס pontshkes), bimuelos (fritters) and sufganiyot which are deep-fried in oil. Italkim and Hungarian Jews traditionally eat cheese pancakes known as "cassola" or "cheese latkes".[133]

Latkes are not popular in Israel, having been largely replaced by sufganiyot due to local economic factors, convenience and the influence of trade unions.[134] Bakeries in Israel have popularized many new types of fillings for sufganiyot besides the traditional strawberry jelly filling, including chocolate cream, vanilla cream, caramel, cappuccino and others.[135] In recent years, downsized, "mini" sufganiyot containing half the calories of the regular, 400-to-600-calorie version, have become popular.[136]

Potato latke frying in hot olive oil.

Rabbinic literature also records a tradition of eating cheese and other dairy products during Hanukkah.[137] This custom, as mentioned above, commemorates the heroism of Judith during the Babylonian captivity of the Jews and reminds us that women also played an important role in the events of Hanukkah.[138] The deuterocanonical book of Judith (Yehudit or Yehudis in Hebrew), which is not part of the Tanakh, records that Holofernes, an Assyrian general, had surrounded the village of Bethulia as part of his campaign to conquer Judea. After intense fighting, the water supply of the Jews was cut off and the situation became desperate. Judith, a pious widow, told the city leaders that she had a plan to save the city. Judith went to the Assyrian camps and pretended to surrender. She met Holofernes, who was smitten by her beauty. She went back to his tent with him, where she plied him with cheese and wine. When he fell into a drunken sleep, Judith beheaded him and escaped from the camp, taking the severed head with her (the beheading of Holofernes by Judith has historically been a popular theme in art). When Holofernes' soldiers found his corpse, they were overcome with fear; the Jews, on the other hand, were emboldened and launched a successful counterattack. The town was saved, and the Assyrians defeated.[139]

Roast goose has historically been a traditional Hanukkah food among Eastern European and American Jews, although the custom has declined in recent decades.[140]

Indian Jews traditionally consume gulab jamun, fried dough balls soaked in a sweet syrup, similar to teiglach or bimuelos, as part of their Hanukkah celebrations.

Italian Jews eat fried chicken, cassola (a ricotta cheese latke almost similar to a cheesecake), and fritelle de riso par Hanukkah (a fried sweet rice pancake).

Romanian Jews eat pasta latkes as a traditional Hanukkah dish.

Syrian Jews consume Kibbet Yatkeen, a dish made with pumpkin and bulgur wheat similar to latkes, as well as their own version of keftes de prasa spiced with allspice and cinnamon.[141]

Dreidel

[edit]
Dreidels in a Jerusalem market

After lighting the candles, it is customary to play (or spin) the dreidel The dreidel, or סביבון (romanized: sevivon) iin Hebrew, is a four-sided spinning top that children play with during Hanukkah. Each side is imprinted with a Hebrew letter which is an abbreviation for the Hebrew words נס גדול היה שם (Nes Gadol Haya Sham, "A great miracle happened there"), referring to the miracle of the oil that took place in the Beit Hamikdash. The fourth side of some dreidels sold in Israel are inscribed with the letter פ (Pe), rendering the acronym נס גדול היה פה (Nes Gadol Haya Po, "A great miracle happened here"), referring to the fact that the miracle occurred in the land of Israel, although this is a relatively recent[when?] innovation. Stores in Haredi neighborhoods sell the traditional Shin dreidels as well, because they understand "there" to refer to the Temple and not the entire Land of Israel, and because the Hasidic Masters ascribe significance to the traditional letters.[142][143]

Hanukkah gelt

[edit]
Chocolate gelt

Chanukkah gelt (Yiddish for "Chanukkah money"), known in Israel by the Hebrew translation Hebrew: דְּמֵי חֲנֻכָּה, romanizeddmei Hanukkah, is often distributed to children during the festival of Hanukkah. The giving of Hanukkah gelt also adds to the holiday excitement. The amount is usually in small coins, although grandparents or relatives may give larger sums. The tradition of giving Chanukah gelt dates back to a long-standing East European custom of children presenting their teachers with a small sum of money at this time of year as a token of gratitude. One minhag favors the fifth night of Hanukkah for giving Hanukkah gelt.[144] Unlike the other nights of Hanukkah, the fifth does not ever fall on the Shabbat, hence never conflicting with the Halachic injunction against handling money on the Shabbat.[145]

Hanukkah in the White House

[edit]
Israeli Prime Minister Ben-Gurion (center) gives President Truman (left) a Hanukkah menorah as ambassador Abba Eban watches in the Oval Office

The earliest Hanukkah link with the White House occurred in 1951 when Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion presented United States President Harry Truman with a Hanukkah menorah. In 1979 President Jimmy Carter took part in the first public Hanukkah candle-lighting ceremony of the National Menorah held across the White House lawn. In 1989, President George H. W. Bush displayed a menorah in the White House. In 1993, President Bill Clinton invited a group of schoolchildren to the Oval Office for a small ceremony.[94]

The United States Postal Service has released several Hanukkah-themed postage stamps. In 1996, the United States Postal Service (USPS) issued a 32 cent Hanukkah stamp as a joint issue with Israel.[146] In 2004, after eight years of reissuing the menorah design, the USPS issued a dreidel design for the Hanukkah stamp. The dreidel design was used through 2008. In 2009 a Hanukkah stamp was issued with a design featured a photograph of a menorah with nine lit candles.[147] In 2008, President George W. Bush held an official Hanukkah reception in the White House where he linked the occasion to the 1951 gift by using that menorah for the ceremony, with a grandson of Ben-Gurion and a grandson of Truman lighting the candles.[148]

In December 2014, two Hanukkah celebrations were held at the White House. The White House commissioned a menorah made by students at the Max Rayne school in Israel and invited two of its students to join U.S. President Barack Obama and First Lady Michelle Obama as they welcomed over 500 guests to the celebration. The students' school in Israel had been subjected to arson by extremists. President Obama said these "students teach us an important lesson for this time in our history. The light of hope must outlast the fires of hate. That's what the Hanukkah story teaches us. It's what our young people can teach us – that one act of faith can make a miracle, that love is stronger than hate, that peace can triumph over conflict."[149] Rabbi Angela Warnick Buchdahl, in leading prayers at the ceremony commented on the how special the scene was, asking the President if he believed America's founding fathers could possibly have pictured that a female Asian-American rabbi would one day be at the White House leading Jewish prayers in front of the African-American president.[150]

Dates

[edit]

The dates of Hanukkah are determined by the Hebrew calendar. Hanukkah begins at the 25th day of Kislev and concludes on the second or third day of Tevet (Kislev can have 29 or 30 days). The Jewish day begins at sunset. Hanukkah dates for recent and upcoming:

  • Sunset, 18 December 2022 – nightfall, 26 December 2022[1]
  • Sunset, 7 December 2023 – nightfall, 15 December 2023
  • Sunset, 25 December 2024 – nightfall, 2 January 2025
  • Sunset, 14 December 2025 – nightfall, 22 December 2025
  • Sunset, 4 December 2026 – nightfall, 12 December 2026
  • Sunset, 24 December 2027 – nightfall, 1 January 2028
  • Sunset, 12 December 2028 – nightfall, 20 December 2028
  • Sunset, 1 December 2029 – nightfall, 9 December 2029

In 2013, on 28 November, the American holiday of Thanksgiving fell during Hanukkah for only the third time since Thanksgiving was declared a national holiday by President Abraham Lincoln. The last time was 1899, and due to the nature of the Gregorian and Jewish calendars being slightly out of sync with each other, it will not happen again in the foreseeable future.[151] This rare convergence prompted the creation of the neologism Thanksgivukkah.[152][153][154]

Symbolic importance

[edit]
Second night of Hannukah at Jerusalem's Western Wall

Major Jewish holidays are those when all forms of work are forbidden, and that feature traditional holiday meals, kiddush, holiday candle-lighting, etc. Only biblical holidays fit these criteria, and Chanukah was instituted some two centuries after the Hebrew Bible was completed. Nevertheless, though Chanukah is of rabbinic origin, it is traditionally celebrated in a major and very public fashion. The requirement to position the menorah, or Chanukiah, at the door or window, symbolizes the desire to give the Chanukah miracle a high-profile.[155] Moreover, Hallel (a set of Psalms expressing praise that is recited on significant Jewish holidays) is recited on all eight days of Hanukkah, which signifies Hanukkah's importance on the Jewish calendar. While not considered the most significant holiday, the recitation of Hallel on Hanukkah highlights its importance in Jewish tradition.[156]

Some Jewish historians suggest a different explanation for the rabbinic reluctance to laud the militarism.[clarification needed] First, the rabbis wrote after Hasmonean leaders had led Judea into Rome's grip and so may not have wanted to offer the family much praise. Second, they clearly wanted to promote a sense of dependence on God, urging Jews to look toward the divine for protection. They likely feared inciting Jews to another revolt that might end in disaster, as the Bar Kochba revolt did.[157]

Modern history

[edit]

Zionism

[edit]

"Hanukkah is an ancient holiday, but a modest one. The holiday of the Hasmoneans is new, yet it is full of spiritual exaltation and national joy. What was Hanukkah forty years ago? 'Al ha-nissim' and Hallel; a short reading in the synagogue; lighting the tiny, slender wax candles or oil lights; at home, levivot [latkes-potato pancakes], cards for the older children, and sevivonim [dreidels-spinning tops] for the little ones. But what is Hanukkah today? The holiday of the Hasmoneans. A holiday of salvation. A great national holiday, celebrated in all the countries of the Diaspora with dances and speeches, melody and song, outings and parades, as if a new soul has been breathed into the ancient holiday, another spirit renewed within it. One thing is clear: if those tiny, modest candles had been extinguished in Diaspora times, if our grandparents had not preserved the traditions of Hanukkah in the synagogue and at home . .., the holiday of the Hasmoneans could never have been created. There would have been nothing to change, nothing to renew. The new soul of our times would not have found a body in which to envelop itself."

Joseph Klausner, 1938, in Haim Harari's Sefer Hanukkah[158][159]

The emergence of Jewish nationalism and the Zionist movement in the late 19th and early 20th centuries had a profound impact on the celebration and reinterpretation of Jewish holidays. These developments resulted in increased emphasis on certain Jewish celebrations, of which Hanukkah and Tu BiShvat are prominent examples.[160]

Hanukkah took on renewed meaning following the rise of Jewish nationalism as a nationalist holiday, symbolizing the struggle of the Jewish people against foreign oppression and their desire for national re-creation[161] (although the struggle of Jews against foreign oppression has always been a core component of Hanukkah, as shown by the Al HaNissim, which has been part of Jewish liturgy since at least 700 CE).[162] Hanukkah served as a common ground where both religious and secular Zionists could unite around their nationalist agenda. Rabbi Shmuel Mohilever, an early religious Zionist, proposed making Hanukkah the official holiday of the proto-Zionist organization Hovevei Zion in Russia in 1881. Public celebrations of Hanukkah gained prominence in the early 20th century, with parades and public events becoming common. Schools in Mandate Palestine played an early role in promoting these celebrations.[163]

With the advent of Zionism and the state of Israel, the themes of militarism were reconsidered. In modern Israel, the national and military aspects of Hanukkah became, once again, more dominant.[164][165]

North America

[edit]
US President Jimmy Carter attends Menorah Lighting, Lafayette Park, Washington, D.C., 1979

In North America, Hanukkah in the 21st century has taken a place equal to Passover as a symbol of Jewish identity. Both the Israeli and North American versions of Hanukkah emphasize resistance, focusing on some combination of national liberation and religious freedom as the defining meaning of the holiday.[166][8]

Diane Ashton attributed the increased visibility and reinvention of Hanukkah by some of the American Jewish community as a way to adapt to American life, re-inventing the festival in "the language of individualism and personal conscience derived from both Protestantism and the Enlightenment".[129]

Relationship to Christmas

[edit]

In North America, Hanukkah became increasingly important to many Jewish individuals and families during the latter part of the 20th century, including a large number of secular Jews, who wanted to celebrate a Jewish alternative to the Christmas celebrations which frequently overlap with Hanukkah.[167][168] Diane Ashton argues that Jewish immigrants to America raised the profile of Hanukkah as a kid-centered alternative to Christmas as early as the 1800s.[169] This in parts mirrors the ascendancy of Christmas, which like Hanukkah increased in importance in the 1800s.[170] During this time period, Jewish leaders (especially Reform) such as Max Lilienthal and Isaac Mayer Wise made an effort to rebrand Hanukkah and started creating Hanukkah celebration for kids at their synagogues, which included candy and singing songs.[169][171] By the 1900s, it started to become a commercial holiday like Christmas, with Hanukkah gifts and decorations appearing in stores and Jewish Women's magazines printing articles on holiday decorations, children's celebrations, and gift giving.[169] Ashton says that Jewish families did this in order to maintain a Jewish identity which is distinct from mainline Christian culture, on the other hand, the mirroring of Hanukkah and Christmas made Jewish families and kids feel that they were American.[169] Though it was traditional for Ashkenazi Jews to give "gelt" or money to children during Hanukkah, in many families, this tradition has been supplemented with the giving of other gifts so that Jewish children can enjoy receiving gifts just like their Christmas-celebrating peers do.[172] Children play a big role in Hanukkah, and Jewish families with children are more likely to celebrate it than childless Jewish families, and sociologists hypothesize that this is because Jewish parents do not want their kids to be alienated from their non-Jewish peers who celebrate Christmas.[167] Recent celebrations have also seen the presence of the Hanukkah bush, which is considered a Jewish counterpart to the Christmas tree. Today, the presence of Hanukkah bushes is generally discouraged by most rabbis.[173]

See also

[edit]

Footnotes

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia

Hanukkah, known as the Festival of Dedication, is an eight-day Jewish holiday observed beginning on the 25th of Kislev in the Hebrew calendar, commemorating the rededication of the Second Temple in Jerusalem in 164 BCE after its desecration during the Maccabean Revolt against Seleucid imperial control under Antiochus IV Epiphanes. The revolt, led by the priestly Hasmonean family including Judah Maccabee, arose from Seleucid suppression of Jewish religious practices, including bans on circumcision, Sabbath observance, and Temple sacrifices, culminating in the recapture and purification of the Temple following military victories over larger Hellenistic forces. While historical accounts in 1 and 2 Maccabees emphasize the rededication and establishment of the festival without reference to supernatural events, rabbinic tradition in the Babylonian Talmud (Shabbat 21b) attributes the holiday's eight-day duration to a miracle wherein a single cruse of ritually pure oil, sufficient for one day, burned in the Temple's menorah for eight days until new oil could be prepared.
Observance centers on the daily lighting of the hanukkiah, a nine-branched candelabrum distinct from the seven-branched Temple menorah, with one additional light kindled each night alongside a shamash helper candle, symbolizing both the historical miracle and the triumph of light over darkness in a causal framework of resistance against assimilation and tyranny. Traditional practices include recitation of blessings, the Hallel psalms, and consumption of foods prepared in oil such as potato latkes and jelly doughnuts to evoke the oil's role, alongside games like spinning the dreidel inscribed with Hebrew letters representing "a great miracle happened there," though some customs like widespread gift-giving emerged later in diaspora contexts. The holiday underscores themes of religious liberty and national independence, as the Hasmoneans established the Judean monarchy, marking a pivotal restoration of Jewish sovereignty absent since the Babylonian exile.

Etymology and Terminology

Origins and Meaning of "Hanukkah"

The Hebrew term Hanukkah (חֲנֻכָּה), transliterated variously as Hanukkah, Chanukah, or Ḥanukah, derives from the root verb ḥānak (חנך), signifying "to dedicate," "to consecrate," or "to inaugurate." This root appears in biblical contexts to denote the or for a specific purpose, such as dedicating a new or house, reflecting a ceremonial act of setting apart for sacred use. In modern Hebrew, the related phrase hanukkat bayit refers to a housewarming marking the dedication of a new home, underscoring the term's enduring association with formal consecration. The holiday's name specifically commemorates the rededication of the Second on 25 in 164 BCE, following its desecration by Seleucid forces under three years prior. This event, detailed in ancient Jewish texts like , involved the Maccabean rebels purifying the Temple altar, reinstating sacrificial rites, and restoring Jewish worship after a period of Hellenistic suppression that included pagan altars and prohibitions on observance. The term Hanukkah thus encapsulates not merely the linguistic root but the historical act of reclaiming and sanctifying the central site of Jewish religious practice, distinguishing it from later interpretive traditions emphasizing the miracle of oil. While primary sources such as the Books of Maccabees (written in Greek circa 100 BCE) and Josephus's Antiquities of the Jews (circa 94 CE) link the name directly to this Temple event, the festival's observance evolved to include an eight-day duration, possibly influenced by pre-existing Jewish customs or the time required for Temple purification rituals. Scholarly analysis attributes no earlier attestation of the term Hanukkah as a holiday name prior to the Hasmonean period, confirming its origin in the specific causal sequence of revolt, victory, and reconsecration rather than broader mythological or universal dedication motifs.

Alternative Names and Spellings

Hanukkah is transliterated from the Hebrew חֲנֻכָּה (ḥănukkāh), leading to multiple English spellings that reflect variations in pronunciation and orthographic conventions. The most prevalent forms include Hanukkah, which aligns with modern Israeli Hebrew's softer fricative /χ/ approximated as "h", and Chanukah, which captures the traditional Ashkenazi Jewish guttural /χ/ sound akin to Scottish "loch". Other common variants are Hanukah, Hannukah, Chanuka, Chanukkah, Channukah, and Chanukka, arising from inconsistencies in rendering the doubled kaf (כּ) and final heh (ה). These spelling differences stem from the absence of standardized English rules for Hebrew until the , compounded by regional influences; for instance, Khanike or Khanuka appear in Yiddish-influenced contexts. No single spelling is definitively "correct," as usage varies by community and publication, with Hanukkah dominating contemporary sources due to its phonetic simplicity. Beyond its primary name, Hanukkah is known as the Festival of Lights (Hebrew: חַג הָאוּרִים, Chag HaUrim or Ḥag Ha'urim), emphasizing the commemoration of the Temple menorah's oil enduring , a designation popularized in and modern observance. It is also termed the Feast of Dedication, directly translating the Hebrew root ḥanakh ("to dedicate") and referenced in the (John 10:22) as a marking the Second Temple's rededication. Less frequently, it appears as the Feast of the Maccabees in some historical Christian contexts, highlighting the Hasmonean leaders' role. In Hebrew, informal alternatives include Chag HaNerot ("Festival of Candles"), though Chag HaUrim prevails for its biblical resonance with light imagery.

Historical Context

Seleucid Rule and Jewish Hellenization

Following the Battle of Panium in 200 BCE, Antiochus III the Great wrested control of Coele-Syria, including Judea, from Ptolemaic Egypt, establishing Seleucid dominance over the region by 198 BCE after defeating Ptolemaic forces decisively. This transition ended roughly a century of Ptolemaic administration, which had been relatively tolerant of Jewish customs, and integrated Judea into the Seleucid provincial system under a governor in Syria. Antiochus III issued a charter granting Jews the right to govern by their ancestral laws, exempting the Jerusalem Temple priesthood from taxes, and permitting the import of sacrificial animals duty-free, measures that secured loyalty and ensured a stable revenue flow without immediate cultural impositions. The early decades of Seleucid rule, spanning from Antiochus III's death in 187 BCE through the reign of his son Seleucus IV (187–175 BCE), remained largely peaceful, with minimal interference in Jewish religious life and evidence of economic recovery in Judea. However, under Antiochus IV Epiphanes (r. 175–164 BCE), fiscal pressures from military campaigns—particularly against Ptolemaic Egypt—led to the commodification of the high priesthood, auctioned to the highest bidder among Jerusalem's elite. In 175 BCE, Jason (a Hellenized form of the name Joshua), from a priestly but pro-Greek family, displaced the traditionalist Onias III by pledging 440 talents of silver annually to the Seleucid treasury, an increase over prior payments, and securing royal approval to erect a gymnasium in Jerusalem. This institution, modeled on Greek paideia, trained youth in athletics, philosophy, and civic virtues; participants, including noble Jewish boys, exercised nude and competed in events like the ephebeia, adopting Greek dress and customs that clashed with Jewish norms of modesty and ritual purity. Jason's tenure (175–172 BCE) marked an acceleration of voluntary Jewish Hellenization, driven by internal elite ambitions rather than direct Seleucid coercion, as urban sought integration into broader Hellenistic networks for social, economic, and political advancement. He dispatched envoys to the Tyrian Games in 174 BCE, funded by Temple resources, and enrolled Jerusalemites as citizens of Antioch, fostering a civic identity blending Jewish and Greek elements. In 172 BCE, , a non-priestly Benjaminite and brother of the Temple administrator Simon, outbid with a promise of 300 talents more, further eroding Zadokite high priestly legitimacy and aligning the office with Seleucid fiscal demands; to meet his obligations, sold Temple vessels, intensifying Hellenizing reforms amid reports of ritual neglect. These developments exacerbated preexisting fault lines within Judean society, where Hellenistic adaptations—evidenced by Greek names among elites, epigraphic Greek inscriptions, and cultural in urban centers—contrasted with rural adherence to Torah-based practices. While some embraced Hellenism for its intellectual and administrative utilities, viewing it as compatible with , traditionalists perceived the gymnasium and priestly innovations as threats to covenantal fidelity, setting the stage for escalating conflicts without yet provoking outright revolt. Seleucid support for these internal Hellenizers prioritized imperial unity and revenue over religious uniformity, reflecting a pragmatic policy that tolerated diversity until perceived disloyalty emerged.

Internal Divisions and Triggers for Revolt

Jewish society in during the early 2nd century BCE was sharply divided between Hellenizing elites, who embraced Greek culture including language, athletics, and civic institutions, and traditionalist factions committed to observance and ancestral customs. Urban priests and aristocracy, seeking alignment with Seleucid rulers, promoted ; for instance, Jason (appointed 175 BCE) constructed a gymnasium in where youths trained nude and some underwent epispasm to reverse for Greek acceptance. These reforms, including sending envoys to participate in Hellenic games at Tyre, alienated rural and pious communities who viewed such adaptations as erosion of Jewish distinctiveness. The high priesthood became a flashpoint of and factionalism, exacerbating divisions. , brother of the Zadokite high priest , bribed Seleucid king for the office in 175 BCE, promising increased tribute and Hellenic loyalty. In 172 BCE, —a non-priestly Benjaminite—outbid with a larger payment, securing appointment despite lacking hereditary claim; to fund this, he despoiled Temple vessels, further profaning sacred institutions and provoking outrage among traditionalists. These bids reflected not mere personal ambition but competing visions: Jason's moderate Hellenism versus Menelaus's more radical alignment with Seleucid interests, both alienating those prioritizing ritual purity. Tensions escalated in 168 BCE when , fearing deposition, launched an armed incursion into , which Antiochus mistook for a general revolt; the king responded by sacking the city, massacring thousands, and plundering the Temple. To enforce loyalty and suppress perceived , Antiochus issued decrees in 167 BCE prohibiting , observance, , and Jewish sacrifices, while mandating consumption and installing an to Olympios in the Temple, where swine were sacrificed—acts of deliberate desecration. The immediate trigger occurred in Modein, where a Seleucid official enforced sacrifices to Greek gods; when a compliant Jew stepped forward, priest ben Johanan slew him along with the official, demolished the altar, and fled to the hills with his five sons, rallying adherents with the cry to uphold amid persecution. This act, around late 167 BCE, ignited widespread guerrilla resistance, transforming internal discontent into open revolt against Seleucid overreach.

The Maccabean Revolt

Outbreak and Initial Resistance

In 167 BCE, Seleucid king intensified by prohibiting core religious practices such as , observance, and , while desecrating the Temple with pagan altars and sacrifices to . Royal officials were dispatched to enforce compliance through coerced sacrifices in local villages, including Modein, a rural priestly settlement northwest of . There, , a local of the Hasmonean family, publicly refused the order to sacrifice to Greek gods, declaring adherence to Jewish law over imperial decree. When a Hellenistic Jew volunteered to comply, killed him, followed by the Seleucid official and his attendants, then razed the makeshift pagan altar. This act of defiance, recorded in as the revolt's ignition, prompted and his five sons—including Judah, later called Maccabeus—to flee to the Judean hills, rallying pious fugitives who rejected . Initial resistance took the form of guerrilla operations: small bands destroyed pagan altars, executed apostate collaborating with Seleucids, and evaded larger forces by hiding in caves and mountains. Early challenges included debates over fighting on the , resolved by ' ruling permitting defensive combat to preserve life, after initial losses to surprise attacks. These tactics exploited terrain advantages against superior Seleucid numbers and equipment, marking a shift from passive endurance to active . died shortly thereafter from illness, ceding leadership to Judah, who formalized the mobile warfare strategy.

Key Battles and Military Tactics

The Maccabean Revolt's military campaigns under relied heavily on guerrilla warfare, exploiting the rugged Judean hills for ambushes, rapid maneuvers, and surprise attacks against numerically superior Seleucid forces equipped with heavy and . Initial rebel bands, numbering in the hundreds, avoided pitched battles in open terrain, instead using to harass supply lines and isolate commanders, which disrupted Seleucid cohesion and morale. This approach capitalized on local knowledge of narrow passes and elevated positions, where the Seleucids' formations proved cumbersome and vulnerable to flanking. One of the earliest significant engagements occurred in late 167 BCE near Michmash, where Judas ambushed the Seleucid commander Apollonius, who led a force of approximately 1,000 and ; the rebels seized the enemy's swords and initiated organized raids thereafter. In early 166 BCE, at the Battle of Beth Horon, Judas's force of about 6,000-8,000 irregulars defeated Seron's army of roughly 20,000 by drawing them into the steep ascent of the Beth Horon pass, where the terrain negated Seleucid advantages in armor and numbers, resulting in a rout with heavy enemy losses. The Battle of Emmaus in 165 BCE exemplified Judas's tactical ingenuity against a combined Seleucid force under Nicanor and , estimated at 40,000-50,000 troops including ; with around 10,000 fighters, Judas feigned a retreat to lure Gorgias's pursuing into the hills for , while a night march allowed the main body to assault and torch the unguarded enemy camp, prompting a disorganized withdrawal. Later that year, at Beth Zechariah, Judas's brother reportedly killed an to disrupt a advance, though the battle ended in retreat due to overwhelming Seleucid reinforcements. In the decisive Battle of Beth Zur in late 164 BCE, Judas commanded perhaps 20,000 troops against Lysias's 60,000-strong army with war elephants; positioning in fortified hills, the withstood assaults through coordinated archery and slinging to target beasts and infantry, forcing Lysias to divide forces amid internal pressures, enabling the rebels to claim victory and march on . As victories mounted, Judas transitioned toward semi-conventional formations, incorporating captured arms and rudimentary phalanxes, but core tactics remained asymmetric, emphasizing mobility, intelligence from scouts, and morale bolstered by religious zeal to sustain a revolt against imperial overextension.

Temple Rededication and Immediate Aftermath

Following their victory over the Seleucid general at Beth Zur, and his brothers assembled forces to cleanse and rededicate the Second Temple in Jerusalem. Upon arriving at , they discovered the sanctuary desolate, the profaned, the gates burned, and the courts overgrown with weeds. The priests removed the defiled stones of the old , which could not be sanctified, and stored them aside until a prophet should arise to determine their fate; they then constructed a new altar using unhewn stones, in accordance with the Torah's prohibition against hewing altar stones with iron tools. They rebuilt the sanctuary furnishings, including the lampstand, incense , and table of showbread, and fortified the Temple courts. On the 25th of Chislev in the 148th year of the Seleucid era—corresponding to December 164 BCE, exactly three years after the Temple's by Antiochus IV—sacrifices were offered on the new for the first time. The rededication featured hymns, musical instruments, and joyous celebrations mimicking the Festival of Booths, complete with boughs, palm fronds, and citrons; the people decreed this eight-day observance perpetual, beginning annually on 25 Chislev. The rededication did not end hostilities, as Seleucid forces retained control of the Akra citadel overlooking the Temple, from which they continued desecrating the and holy days. soon returned with reinforcements numbering 100,000 infantry, 20,000 cavalry, and 32 elephants, besieging Beth Zur and then itself with siege towers and engines of war. The Jews, weakened by famine during the sabbatical year, resisted but faced starvation; , learning of the usurper Philip's advance on Antioch and the instability under young King Antiochus V, proposed terms permitting Jewish religious autonomy and observance, which Judas accepted to avert total defeat. The Seleucids withdrew, though Antiochus V subsequently demolished 's walls before departing for Antioch. Conflict reignited under I, who dispatched Bacchides with a large against the . In 160 BCE, Judas encamped at Elasa near Beth Horon with 3,000 men, but desertions reduced his force to 800 amid reports of Bacchides' 20,000 infantry and 2,000 cavalry. Urging his followers to fight valiantly for their kindred and faith, Judas initially routed the Seleucid right wing but perished in the ensuing as Bacchides' forces overwhelmed the from dawn until dusk. Jonathan and Simon recovered and buried Judas in the ancestral at Modein; national mourning ensued, with the people lamenting the fall of their savior, while Jonathan assumed command, sustaining the revolt through guerrilla tactics.

Primary Sources and Scholarly Analysis

Books of Maccabees and Josephus

The First Book of Maccabees provides a detailed historical chronicle of the , spanning from approximately 175 BCE to 134 BCE, focusing on the priestly family of and his son as leaders in resisting Seleucid oppression under . It recounts the desecration of the Temple in 167 BCE, including the erection of a altar and prohibition of Jewish practices, followed by , key victories such as at Beth Horon and , and the recapture of in 164 BCE. The narrative culminates in the purification and rededication of the Temple on 25 164 BCE, three years after its profanation, establishing an eight-day to commemorate the event without reference to any miraculous prolongation of ; instead, it emphasizes ritual reinstitution and military success as divine favor earned through zealous adherence to . Written likely in Hebrew around 100 BCE by an anonymous Judean author sympathetic to the , the text adopts a pragmatic tone, attributing victories to human strategy, piety, and collective resolve rather than overt supernatural interventions. In contrast, the Second Book of Maccabees, composed as an epitome of a five-volume history by of Cyrene around 124 BCE, covers the period from 180 BCE to 161 BCE with a more theological emphasis, highlighting , martyrdoms, and prayers for the dead as pivotal to the revolt's success. It details pre-revolt Hellenizing pressures, the martyrdom of figures like the and the seven brothers under Antiochus V, and Judas's campaigns, framing the Temple rededication on 25 Kislev—explicitly noted as the desecration's anniversary—as a joyous restoration involving new vessels, , and an eight-day akin to the festival missed due to prior exile. Unlike 1 Maccabees, it incorporates miraculous elements, such as heavenly horsemen aiding battles, and stresses atoning deaths of the righteous over punitive actions against apostates as securing God's intervention, reflecting a Pharisaic-leaning perspective that influenced later Jewish thought. Both books, preserved in Greek and deuterocanonical in Catholic and Orthodox traditions but apocryphal in Protestant and Jewish canons, serve as foundational yet divergent accounts, with 1 Maccabees prioritized for its chronological detail and 2 Maccabees for its ethical and providential interpretations. Flavius Josephus, in his Antiquities of the Jews (circa 93–94 CE), draws heavily from 1 Maccabees for his narration of the revolt in Books 12–13, describing the Temple's desecration, Judas's triumphs, and the 164 BCE rededication while omitting 2 Maccabees' martyrdom vignettes and miracles to align with his theme of cautious rebellion yielding divine support only through moral and strategic merit. He terms the festival Phota ("Lights"), attributing the name to the joy's "illumination" of homes with lamps rather than any oil miracle, and notes its observance among diaspora Jews, including in Rome, as a testament to uncompromised worship. Josephus adapts the sources to critique presumptuous uprisings, paralleling the Maccabees' success with his era's failed revolt against Rome, thereby presenting the events as a model of justified resistance against cultural erasure while underscoring Hasmonean achievements in restoring autonomy until internal corruptions. These texts collectively affirm the revolt's historicity through convergent details on timeline and rededication, though their biases—Hasmonean partisanship in Maccabees and Roman-flavored pragmatism in Josephus—necessitate cross-verification with archaeological evidence like Hasmonean coins and inscriptions for causal realism.

Rabbinic and Other Ancient Accounts

The Babylonian Talmud, compiled around the 5th-6th centuries CE, offers the principal rabbinic account of Hanukkah's institution, emphasizing a miraculous event over the military triumphs detailed in earlier sources. In tractate Shabbat 21b, it records that Seleucid forces defiled all Temple oils upon their incursion, but the Hasmoneans discovered one sealed cruse of ritually pure oil—bearing the High Priest's seal—sufficient for a single day's menorah lighting; yet it miraculously burned for eight days, prompting the Sages to ordain an eight-day celebration beginning on the 25th of Kislev, during which mourning and fasting are prohibited. This brief narrative, absent from the Mishnah (c. 200 CE), shifts focus to divine sustenance of Temple worship amid desecration, interpreting the extended burning as grounds for annual commemoration through lights and praise. Subsequent rabbinic expansions in midrashic works, such as le-Hanukkah (a compilation blending homiletic interpretations), elaborate on the Hasmonean purification while reinforcing the oil miracle as emblematic of spiritual resilience against Hellenization's impurities. These texts, redacted later (possibly 6th-10th centuries CE), integrate Hanukkah into a framework of Torah-centric , downplaying militaristic elements evident in 1-2 ; for instance, they attribute success to rather than strategy, reflecting rabbinic post-Temple priorities amid Roman rule. overall treats Hanukkah sparingly compared to , with no dedicated tractate and minimal elaboration, possibly due to ambivalence toward the Hasmonean dynasty's later priestly-kingly overreach or a deliberate pivot from nationalist revolt to ritual observance. Beyond core rabbinic corpora, other ancient or tradition-preserving accounts include the Megillat Antiochus (Scroll of Antiochus), an text narrating the , Temple rededication on Kislev 25 (164 BCE), and the oil miracle, framing the events in biblical-prophetic style akin to . Likely composed in the early medieval period (c. 7th-9th centuries CE) but incorporating older oral or lost traditions from the Second Temple era, it was recited in some Yemenite and Sephardic communities during Hanukkah services to publicize the miracle (pirsumei nisa). The scroll details Seleucid decrees, Mattathias's uprising, Judas's victories, and post-rededication celebrations, blending historical recall with haggadic flourishes like angelic interventions absent in . An earlier calendrical reference appears in Megillat Ta'anit (c. 1st century CE), a Aramaic list of joyous days prohibiting fasts, which marks the eight days of Hanukkah as commemorating the Temple's cleansing without specifying the oil miracle, aligning more closely with Maccabean victory emphases. These accounts, while varying in detail and dating, collectively attest to Hanukkah's entrenchment in Jewish practice by the late Second Temple period, evolving from a Hasmonean-era dedication festival into a rabbinically codified rite centered on light amid persecution.

Debates on Causes and Divine Intervention

Scholars debate whether the Maccabean Revolt stemmed primarily from Seleucid religious persecution or from internal Jewish political and economic pressures. Traditional accounts, drawing from 1 and 2 Maccabees, emphasize Antiochus IV Epiphanes' decrees in 167 BCE, which banned Jewish practices such as circumcision, Sabbath observance, and Torah study, while desecrating the Temple with pagan altars, framing the uprising as a defense of religious liberty. However, analyses grounded in Seleucid fiscal policies highlight economic motivations: High Priest Menelaus, appointed in 172 BCE after outbidding the Hellenizing Jason, incurred massive debts to Antiochus through bribes exceeding 300 talents annually, prompting the looting of Temple treasures to repay them, which alienated pious Jews and escalated tensions beyond mere ideology. This perspective posits the revolt not as a unified anti-Hellenistic front but as a civil conflict exacerbated by elite rivalries, where rural traditionalists like clashed with urban Hellenizers who welcomed gymnasia and for social advancement, with Seleucid intervention tipping internal divisions into open . Critics of the persecution-centric view, including those examining Ptolemaic and Seleucid administrative records, argue that Antiochus' edicts were reactive to Jerusalem's unrest following ' sacrilege rather than proactive cultural erasure, suggesting causal primacy in Jewish factionalism over imperial fiat; empirical evidence from coinage and inscriptions supports heavy taxation as a trigger, as faced demands amid Antiochus' eastern campaigns costing millions of talents. Regarding divine intervention, 1 Maccabees portrays victories as outcomes of human piety, strategy, and zeal—such as ' enforcement of amid guerrilla tactics—invoking God's favor through covenantal obedience without events, aligning with a causal chain of disciplined resistance against a distracted empire. In contrast, 2 Maccabees incorporates overt divine agency, including angelic apparitions, heavenly horsemen aiding battles like Beth Zur in 164 BCE, and miraculous deliverances, interpreting Maccabean success as God's direct retribution against apostates and reward for martyrs' fidelity. These divergences fuel scholarly contention: Proponents of theological realism, often from traditions, affirm divine causation as verifiable through the improbable and triumph of a numerically inferior force—Judas' 6,000 partisans routing Seleucid armies of 40,000–60,000—against historical odds, citing patterns of providential timing like Lysias' withdrawal due to Egyptian threats. Secular analyses, prioritizing empirical military factors such as terrain exploitation, hit-and-run ambushes, and Seleucid logistical overextension post-168 BCE Egyptian setbacks, dismiss intervention claims as post-hoc rationalizations to legitimize Hasmonean rule, noting ' Diasporic emphasis on miracles may reflect audience needs for transcendent hope rather than eyewitness testimony; no contemporaneous non-Jewish sources corroborate elements, underscoring their interpretive nature.

Historicity of the Oil Miracle

The miracle of the cruse of oil, describing a sealed flask containing sufficient pure oil for one day that miraculously burned for eight days in the following its rededication in 164 BCE, is absent from all near-contemporary historical accounts of the . The Books of 1 and , composed within a century of the events and serving as primary sources for the rededication, attribute the eight-day festival to the time required to consecrate a new or to imitate the Feast of Tabernacles (), with no reference to any supernatural prolongation of oil. Similarly, Flavius , writing in the late CE in Antiquities of the Jews, recounts the Temple purification and the institution of an eight-day holiday but mentions neither the discovery of a single cruse nor its miraculous endurance. The earliest attestation of the oil miracle appears in the Babylonian Talmud, tractate Shabbat 21b, compiled around 500 CE, approximately 660 years after the rededication. There, the story is presented as an etiology explaining the custom of lighting lamps during Hanukkah, emphasizing divine intervention in the form of a single day's oil sufficing for the full period until new supplies could be prepared. Rabbinic tradition posits this as a foundational miracle, yet its late emergence raises questions about historical transmission, as earlier sources like the Megillat Antiochus or Qumran texts also omit it. Scholars generally regard the as a post-event rather than a verifiable occurrence, likely developed to underscore theological themes of purity and divine favor amid Hasmonean political decline and rabbinic efforts to spiritualize . From a causal perspective, in an ancient menorah lamp would consume its volume within 10–12 hours under normal conditions, requiring replenishment for sustained burning; no empirical mechanism or archaeological evidence supports or non-consumptive combustion in this context. The absence in secular and Jewish historical , combined with the Talmud's aggadic (non-legal) style prone to symbolic elaboration, indicates the story functions more as moral than eyewitness report, with some analyses suggesting influences from earlier fire-miracle motifs like those in 1:19–22 involving . While traditional observance accepts it as historical, critical prioritizes the silence of proximate sources as evidence against literal occurrence.

Theological and Symbolic Dimensions

Traditional Religious Narrative

According to the traditional Jewish religious narrative, the holiday of Hanukkah commemorates events in the 2nd century BCE during the Seleucid Empire's rule over , when King imposed Hellenistic practices and desecrated the Second by erecting an altar to and sacrificing swine upon it. This oppression included banning core Jewish observances such as , , and , leading to martyrdoms among pious Jews who refused compliance. The revolt began in 167 BCE when Mattathias, a priest from Modiin, killed a Seleucid official and a collaborating Jew at the village altar, sparking armed resistance; his five sons, led by Judah (known as Maccabee, meaning "hammer"), continued the guerrilla warfare against superior Seleucid forces. After initial victories, including the Battle of Beth Horon and the defeat of larger armies, Judah's forces captured Jerusalem in 164 BCE, purifying the Temple by removing pagan idols and restoring Jewish worship. The centerpiece of the narrative is the miracle of the oil, as recorded in the Babylonian Talmud: Upon searching the Temple, the Maccabees found only one sealed cruse of ritually pure olive oil, sufficient for one day's lighting of the menorah, bearing the High Priest's seal amid widespread defilement by the Greeks; yet, when kindled, it burned for eight days until new oil could be prepared. The Talmud decrees these eight days as festivals of joy and illumination to publicize this divine intervention, establishing the custom of kindling lights nightly, with the miracle symbolizing God's enduring protection of Jewish observance against assimilation. This emphasis on the oil's supernatural endurance, rather than solely the military triumph, underscores the holiday's religious focus in rabbinic tradition.

Rabbinic Interpretations and Evolution

The primary rabbinic interpretation of Hanukkah originates in the Babylonian Talmud, tractate 21b, which attributes the holiday's observance to the of a single cruse of pure , sealed by the , found amid the Temple's by Seleucid forces. This , sufficient for one day's lamp kindling, miraculously burned for , prompting the Sages to institute an festival of lights with recitations and thanksgiving. The Talmudic narrative frames the event as divine intervention preserving ritual purity, contrasting with the Books of Maccabees, which emphasize military triumphs without mentioning the . This selective focus reflects rabbinic prioritization of spiritual sanctity over martial prowess, as the Hasmonean victory enabled Temple rededication but the sustained its service. Rabbinic literature minimally references Hanukkah's historical battles, instead embedding the holiday in themes of resistance to assimilation and divine favor for Torah adherence. The Al Hanissim prayer, inserted into Amidah and Grace after Meals during Hanukkah, acknowledges the military aspect—"You delivered the many into the hands of the few, the weak into the hands of the mighty"—yet ties commemoration to lights symbolizing enlightenment against Hellenistic idolatry. This dual acknowledgment appears in post-Talmudic liturgy, but the Talmud omits extended military praise, possibly due to later rabbinic opposition to Hasmonean priest-kingship, viewed as usurping prophetic authority forbidden in Deuteronomy 17:15. Early sources like Megillat Antiochus, an Aramaic midrash from the Talmudic era, blend historical revolt with miraculous elements but align with the Talmud's oil-centric rationale. In medieval codification, (Rambam) in (Hilchot Chanukah 3:1-3) integrates both miracles explicitly: the Hasmoneans' divinely aided defeat of the restored sovereignty for over 200 years, but the oil's endurance necessitated the festival's enactment to publicize God's wonders. Rambam stresses the mitzvah's preciousness, urging kindling even at personal expense to proclaim the nes (miracle), underscoring causal realism in attributing outcomes to providence amid empirical odds. This balances the Talmud's narrative without elevating political independence, influencing subsequent halachic works like the Tur and , which standardize lighting rituals while marginalizing dynastic glorification. Rabbinic evolution shifted Hanukkah from a Second Temple-era rededication akin to —focused on purification and joy—to a post-Temple emphasis on domestic lights evoking Temple service, adapting to conditions without sovereignty. By the geonic period (7th-11th centuries), responsa affirm the oil miracle's status, rejecting natural explanations despite debates in sources like Talmudology analyses questioning its against Maccabean silence. Later commentators, such as Maharal of , interpret the lights as illuminating inner spiritual victory over external force, symbolizing intellect's triumph over —a first-principles reading of Hellenism's causal threat to Jewish causality rooted in monotheistic law. This interpretive trajectory persists, prioritizing empirical ritual over unverifiable military , though modern Zionist rereadings revive martial motifs absent in core rabbinic texts.

Core Symbols: Light, Victory, and Resistance

The core symbol of in Hanukkah originates from the rabbinic account of the oil miracle, as recorded in the Babylonian (Shabbat 21b), stating that after the Temple's recapture, priests discovered one cruse of ritually pure oil sealed by the , sufficient for one day, yet it burned for eight days in the menorah. This tradition, absent from the earlier Books of , interprets the event as divine intervention affirming spiritual purity against defilement, with the increasing nightly lights of the hanukkiah—adding one candle each evening from right to left, kindled from left to right—symbolizing progressive revelation of truth, resilience amid scarcity, and the dispelling of ideological darkness by unyielding faith. Scholarly analysis notes this symbolism evolved to emphasize enlightenment and human spirit over mere historical commemoration, contrasting with the Maccabean texts' focus on martial achievement. Victory represents the Maccabees' decisive military triumphs, culminating in the Temple's rededication on 25 Kislev 164 BCE, following guerrilla campaigns that overcame Seleucid forces despite numerical inferiority. As narrated in 1 Maccabees 4:36-59, Judah Maccabee's forces purified the altar and reinstituted sacrifices, marking the reassertion of Jewish sovereignty and the Hasmonean dynasty's founding, which endured until 63 BCE. This symbol underscores causal efficacy of unified resolve and tactical innovation—such as ambushes in Judean hills—against imperial overreach, serving as empirical evidence of underdog perseverance rather than unattributed fortune, with later traditions layering providential validation atop historical fact. Resistance embodies defiance against Antiochus IV's edicts from 167 BCE, which mandated Hellenistic , prohibited practices like observance and circumcision, and installed a in the Temple, sparking civil strife with pro-assimilation . The revolt, sparked by ' refusal to sacrifice to idols in Modiin as detailed in 2, prioritized monotheistic fidelity and national autonomy over cultural , rejecting both external and internal Hellenizers who favored accommodation for social advancement. This symbol highlights causal realism in identity preservation: armed rebellion halted erosion of distinct practices, averting potential dissolution akin to other ancient peoples under empire, while rabbinic emphasis shifted focus to spiritual endurance, critiquing assimilation as self-undermining despite short-term gains. Collectively, light, victory, and resistance interlink human initiative with transcendent support, framing Hanukkah as validation of particularism's viability against universalist pressures.

Core Rituals and Practices

Menorah Lighting Procedure

The Hanukkiah, the nine-branched candelabrum used for Hanukkah, features eight holders of equal height for the nightly and a distinct ninth holder, often elevated or offset, for the (helper ) that is used to kindle the others without violating the prohibition against deriving benefit from the ritual lights. or oil lamps are traditionally used, with paraffin or being common in modern practice; the flames must burn for at least 30 minutes to fulfill the . The lighting occurs nightly after nightfall, ideally once three are visible (approximately 18-30 minutes after sunset, varying by location and season), to publicize the , though some kindle precisely at sunset if wind protection allows. On Fridays, Hanukkah lights precede ; on Saturday nights, they follow . The menorah is placed in a doorway or window, elevated on the right side as one enters (left from outside view for visibility), within 40 cubits (about 60 feet) of the home's entrance to balance public display with safety. The procedure unfolds as follows:
  1. Arrange the candles: Insert one into the rightmost holder (viewer's right) on the , adding one more to the left each subsequent night, culminating in eight on the final night; position the separately.
  2. Light the using a or existing flame, then hold it aloft while reciting the blessings.
  3. Recite the blessings: On the (or if delayed), three are said—"Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the universe, who has sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us to kindle the Hanukkah lights" (le-hadlik ner shel Chanukah); "who performed miracles for our ancestors in those days at this time"; and ("who has kept us alive and sustained us and brought us to this season"). On subsequent nights, only the first two.
  4. Kindle the Hanukkah candles starting with the leftmost (newest added) and proceeding rightward to the first night's candle, using the held in the dominant hand; women, obligated due to their in the miracle's , may light in some customs.
  5. Place the menorah stably and allow the lights to burn undisturbed until they extinguish naturally, ideally without deriving practical benefit like reading by them.
This , rooted in Talmudic sources mandating illumination to commemorate the Temple's rededication, emphasizes increasing light nightly to symbolize growing sanctity.

Associated Blessings and Prayers

The primary blessings associated with Hanukkah are recited immediately before lighting the chanukiah (menorah), while holding the candle. These include the blessing over the commandment to kindle the Hanukkah lights, recited every night: Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu Melech ha'olam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav, v'tzivanu l'hadlik ner shel Chanukah ("Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the universe, who has sanctified us with His commandments and commanded us to kindle the Chanukah lights"). The blessing acknowledging the miracles is also recited nightly: Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu Melech ha'olam, she'asah nissim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem bazman hazeh ("Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the universe, who performed miracles for our ancestors in those days at this time"). On the first night only, the blessing is added: Baruch atah Adonai Eloheinu Melech ha'olam, shehecheyanu v'kiy'manu v'higianu lazman hazeh ("Blessed are You, Lord our God, King of the universe, who has kept us alive, sustained us, and enabled us to reach this season"). Following the lighting, the declaration Haneirot halalu is recited, emphasizing the sanctity of the lights as a to divine and prohibiting their use for mundane purposes: Haneirot halalu kodesh hem, lo na'aseh me'hem melacha, kol mishteh, rak bir'otam kiyeman nigzru, lesaper nissimcha, u'nifla'otcha, v'nis'otayich beyn aravim ("These lights are holy; we may not use them except to behold them, in order to give thanks for Your , Your wonders and Your salvations"). This , drawn from Talmudic sources, underscores the ritual's commemorative intent rather than utilitarian function. Throughout the eight days, the insertion is added to the prayer and Grace After Meals (Birkat Hamazon), recounting the Maccabean victory and rededication of the Temple: Al hanissim ve'al haniflaot... ("For the miracles and for the wonders... in the days of Mattityahu ben Yochanan the , the Hasmonean, and his sons"). This paragraph, absent from the Hanukkah story in the but rooted in historical events described in the Books of , integrates thanksgiving into daily and mealtime . Traditional songs often follow the lighting, with (Rock of Ages) being the most prominent, composed in medieval and sung to invoke divine protection amid : Maoz tzur yeshuatenu... ("Mighty Rock of our salvation..."). Its verses reference historical deliverances, culminating in a plea for redemption, reflecting Hanukkah's themes of resistance and survival. Other hymns, such as Mi Yimalel or folk tunes, vary by community but emphasize victory over oppression.

Dietary Customs and Foods

The central dietary custom of Hanukkah involves consuming foods prepared by frying in , commemorating the Talmudic account of the small cruse of that miraculously lasted to rededicate the after the . This practice, referenced in medieval rabbinic texts, emphasizes as a symbol of divine provision amid scarcity. Among , —shredded potato pancakes mixed with onion, egg, and flour, then fried crisp—dominate holiday meals, typically topped with , , or sugar. Earlier precursors included cheese-based fritters documented by 14th-century Italian Jewish scholars like , evolving to potato versions post-16th-century introduction of New World tubers to . In the United States, latke consumption peaks during Hanukkah, with families grating an estimated 20-30 pounds of potatoes per household in traditional preparations. Sufganiyot, yeast-dough balls filled with jelly and dusted with powdered sugar, represent another oil-fried staple, especially in where the Israel Bakers' Union promoted their starting in the 1920s to bolster local against European imports, resulting in over 20 million units sold annually by the mid-20th century. Sephardic and Mizrahi traditions feature diverse fried treats like Iraqi sambousak (meat- or cheese-filled pastries), Moroccan bumuelos (honey-drizzled dough balls), or Turkish hojuelas (flaky fried ribbons), all immersed in oil to evoke the same miracle while incorporating regional flavors such as or . These variations underscore how the oil custom adapts to local culinary histories without altering its core ritual significance.

Additional Customs and Games

Dreidel and Play

The , a four-sided spinning top, serves as the central element in a traditional Hanukkah involving chance and small stakes. Players typically use tokens such as chocolate coins known as gelt, nuts, or pennies, placing an ante into a central pot before each turn. Each side of the bears a Hebrew letter— (נ), (ג), hei (ה), and shin (ש)—acronymically representing "nes gadol haya sham" ("a great miracle happened there"), referencing the Hanukkah oil . In produced in , the shin is replaced by pei (פ) to signify "haya po" ("happened here"). To play, participants sit in a circle and take turns spinning the on a flat surface. The outcome determines the action: means the player does nothing and passes the turn; allows the player to take the entire ; hei entitles the player to half the ; and shin requires the player to add another ante to the . If the pot empties, players may restart with fresh antes. The game continues until one player collects all tokens or participants agree to end, often lasting around two hours with four players starting with ten tokens each based on simulations. This setup mirrors mechanics, reflecting the dreidel's roots as a Jewish of the European , a dice-like used for betting documented as early as the with Latin inscriptions like "aufer" (take), "dorbere" (put in), "nihil" (nothing), and "totum" (all). Historically, the emerged in Ashkenazi Jewish communities in medieval , likely borrowed from non-Jewish spinning top games prevalent among in German-speaking regions by the . A folk legend claims in the Maccabean era (2nd century BCE) used dreidels to disguise under Seleucid persecution, spinning tops as a cover when Greek inspectors approached, but no contemporary historical evidence supports this; the association with Hanukkah developed later, possibly in the , as a way to infuse play with holiday symbolism. The game's integration into Hanukkah customs promotes lighthearted family entertainment, contrasting the holiday's themes of resistance and rededication, while the uneven probabilities— being most advantageous—add an element of chance that encourages repeated play among children. In modern observance, the dreidel game remains a staple for teaching children about Hanukkah through interactive fun, often paired with songs like ", , " composed in the early . Variations include non-gambling adaptations for younger children, such as using the spins to draw pictures or perform actions, and commercial twists like "Super Dreidel" with added boards or rules for fairness, though traditional play persists in homes and communal events. Dreidels are commonly made of wood, plastic, or clay, with mass-produced versions featuring vibrant designs, and the game underscores Hanukkah's emphasis on joy amid historical adversity without direct theological mandate in rabbinic texts.

Gelt and Gift-Giving Traditions

The tradition of , where gelt derives from the and German word for money or , involves distributing coins or coin-like items during the holiday, primarily to children. This custom commemorates the Hasmoneans' minting of independent Jewish coins following their victory, symbolizing sovereignty and the rededication of the Temple. It also traces to 17th-century Polish Jewish practices of giving small sums to children for teachers or charity, extending to aid the poor in purchasing candles without stigma. By the early , real coins were often replaced with versions wrapped in gold or silver foil, mimicking . American candy company Loft's introduced mass-produced gelt in the 1920s, though earlier European Jewish chocolatiers in the 18th and 19th centuries produced similar confections. These foil-wrapped s are commonly used in games like , where winnings consist of gelt pieces, fostering play while teaching gambling's risks in moderation. Beyond gelt, broader gift-giving emerged as a 20th-century custom, particularly , lacking roots in biblical or Talmudic sources and instead reflecting assimilation to counter parallels. American Jewish families often exchange modest presents over the eight nights, a practice traceable to the mid-20th century but amplified post-World War II amid cultural integration, with surveys indicating over 70% of U.S. incorporating gifts by the 1990s. This adaptation emphasizes family bonding but has drawn critique for diluting Hanukkah's religious focus on miracles and resilience.

Public Displays and Communal Events

Public menorah lightings constitute a prominent form of Hanukkah observance, initiated by the movement to promote the holiday's message of religious freedom in public spaces. The first such event occurred on December 22, 1974, when Abraham Shemtov erected and lit a modest wooden menorah near the in Philadelphia's Independence Mall. This practice expanded rapidly; by 1975, oversized wooden menorahs appeared in locations like San Francisco's Union Square, organized by Chaim Drizin. Today, erects approximately 15,000 public menorahs annually across cities worldwide, often accompanied by communal gatherings featuring music, doughnuts, and educational programs. These displays typically use electric lights for safety in outdoor settings, contrasting with traditional flame-lit home observances. Notable examples include the annual lighting of towering steel menorahs claimed as the world's largest, such as the 32-foot structure at New York City's Grand Army Plaza, weighing 4,000 pounds and lit nightly from December 25 to January 1, requiring a lift for the shamash candle. Guinness World Records has recognized similar installations in Manhattan for their scale. In Washington, D.C., the National Menorah lighting draws public officials and features traditional blessings. Overseas, events like London's inaugural public lighting in 1984 by Chabad Golders Green have become annual traditions, fostering community participation. Chabad supports these with distributions of over 30 million candles and multilingual guides in 13 languages. In , communal Hanukkah events emphasize national heritage, with large-scale lightings at sites like the and city centers in , often incorporating laser shows, markets, and concerts. 's municipality hosts themed festivals featuring children's performers and actors, aligning with the Maccabean victory narrative. Northern regions like offer family-oriented activities, including music, storytelling, and tours of ancient synagogues tied to Kabbalistic traditions. Public parades and reenactments, such as torch runs commemorating the ' journey, occur in various locales, blending historical symbolism with modern festivity. Elsewhere, communal events extend to parades and festivals; for instance, New Orleans features a Mobile Menorah Parade with decorated vehicles traversing Uptown streets on the holiday's final night. Cultural centers like ' Skirball host multi-day festivals with games, storytelling, and candle-lighting ceremonies open to broader audiences. These gatherings underscore Hanukkah's role in reinforcing through shared rituals amid diverse settings.

Observance Variations

Practices in Israel

In , Hanukkah practices combine traditional home rituals with prominent public observances, facilitated by the Jewish-majority context. Families light the hanukkiah each evening after nightfall, adding one additional candle per night alongside the , while reciting the three blessings on the first night and two thereafter, followed by songs such as . The menorah is typically placed in windows or doorways to publicize the miracle of the . Public lighting ceremonies feature large-scale hanukkiot in urban centers, town squares, and landmarks, lit nightly to draw communities together. hosts major events, including at the Plaza, where gatherings include prayers, music, and addresses, commencing on the holiday's start—such as , 2024, for the first night—with subsequent nights following the . Similar events occur nationwide, emphasizing national heritage tied to the Maccabean victory in the Judean . Fried foods symbolize the oil miracle, with sufganiyot—deep-fried doughnuts often filled with jelly or custard—serving as the holiday's iconic treat. Around 20 million sufganiyot are sold and consumed annually, with over 80% of partaking in at least one, produced by bakeries experimenting with flavors from classic to innovative varieties like salted caramel. Latkes appear but are secondary to sufganiyot's mass appeal and commercial scale. Children play with the sevivon, the Hebrew-named dreidel inscribed with נ (nun), ג (gimel), ה (hei), and פ (pei), acronym for "nes gadol haya po" ("a great miracle happened here"), reflecting the local miracle site unlike the diaspora "sham" ("there"). The game proceeds by spinning for letters dictating token intake or contribution, using items like chocolate coins. Schools observe a vacation period of about one week, featuring Maccabee-themed plays, dreidel tournaments, and educational outings rather than full closures for all; adults generally work, distinguishing Israeli observance from diaspora patterns where routines persist uninterrupted. These activities instill historical awareness of the Hasmonean revolt and Temple rededication.

Diaspora Differences, Especially North America

In North American Jewish communities, Hanukkah lacks the official public holiday status it enjoys in Israel, where the first day features school closures, reduced work hours, and nationwide festivities including theatrical productions and sufganiyot sales in markets. Instead, observances occur primarily in evenings and on weekends around regular work schedules, emphasizing home-based rituals like menorah lighting and family meals. A 2018 survey by the Jewish People Policy Institute found that while 80% of American Jews consider Hanukkah important, only 60% light the menorah for all eight nights, compared to 73% of Israeli Jews, reflecting greater variability in commitment amid assimilation pressures. Public displays of Hanukkah have gained prominence since the 1970s, driven by Chabad-Lubavitch campaigns to increase visibility in secular spaces. The first major outdoor lighting occurred in San Francisco's Union Square in 1975, followed by annual events in over 100 U.S. cities featuring oversized menorahs. The National Menorah lighting near the began in 1979 under President , with subsequent presidents attending or sending representatives, symbolizing Jewish integration into American civic life while asserting religious identity. These events often include concerts, games, and doughnut distributions, contrasting with Israel's more uniformly national tone. Gift-giving practices diverged notably in 20th-century America, expanding from traditional —small sums of money or chocolate coins given to children, rooted in 17th-century Eastern European customs commemorating Temple rededication tithes—to nightly presents across . This evolution, accelerating post-World War II, responded to children's exposure to consumerism in mixed neighborhoods, though it lacks direct religious mandate and predates modern scales in earlier gelt traditions. Such adaptations elevated Hanukkah from a minor festival to a culturally significant one for , with surveys indicating higher perceived importance than among , yet without transforming it into a theological parallel to .

Sephardic and Other Regional Traditions

Sephardic communities, originating from the Iberian Peninsula and their subsequent diasporas in North Africa, the Ottoman Empire, and the Balkans, observe Hanukkah with an emphasis on familial menorah lighting using a single hanukkiyah per household, in contrast to the Ashkenazi practice of individual sets for women and girls. Fried foods symbolic of the oil miracle feature prominently, including bimuelos (honey-drizzled dough fritters), sfenj (orange-scented doughnuts in Moroccan tradition), and fritas de prasa (leek patties), prepared with olive oil to evoke the Temple's cruse. These customs prioritize modest home celebrations over elaborate games or gelt distribution, focusing on communal meals and Ladino songs such as Ocho Kandelikas, which recounts lighting eight candles and historical deliverance. In North African Sephardic variants, such as Moroccan and Algerian practices, the eighth night often includes Chag Habanot (Festival of the Daughters), where women receive gifts and sweets like , honoring female figures in Hanukkah lore and providing a to male-centric Maccabean narratives. Some families culminate the holiday with a merenda, a gathering featuring fried pastries and shared , reinforcing ties without the commercial elements common elsewhere. Yemenite Jews, sometimes grouped under broader Sephardic-Mizrahi observances, incorporate auditory elements by having women don bell-adorned attire and ring bells during post-lighting songs, amplifying joy through rhythmic sounds. Mizrahi traditions from , , and Persia exhibit further regional diversity, with Iraqi communities favoring zalabia (rosewater-infused fritters) and occasional card games over dreidels, while Iranian Jews maintain subdued rituals centered on oil-fried dishes without unique innovations. These variations stem from local ingredients and historical isolation from Ashkenazi influences, preserving halakhic fidelity to menorah kindling and recitation amid everyday integration. Overall, Sephardic and Mizrahi Hanukkah emphasizes culinary symbolism and intimate piety over spectacle, adapting core rituals to subtropical climates and multicultural environs while upholding the holiday's commemorative essence.

Modern Developments and Cultural Role

Zionist Reinterpretation and National Significance

Zionist ideology reinterpreted Hanukkah by emphasizing the Maccabean Revolt's aspects of national liberation and military heroism over the traditional focus on the Temple's rededication and the miracle of oil, portraying the as ancient exemplars of Jewish sovereignty and resistance to foreign domination. This shift aligned the holiday with the Zionist vision of a self-reliant "new Jew," transforming the into proto-nationalist warriors whose fight for in the BCE paralleled the modern struggle for a . In early 20th-century Zionist thought, Hanukkah served as a foundational myth supporting efforts, with the Hasmonean dynasty's establishment of Jewish rule invoked to legitimize claims to political autonomy in the . Figures like critiqued diaspora traditions for suppressing Maccabean militarism, advocating instead for its revival to foster a fighting spirit among . Post-1948, the State of Israel integrated this narrative into , designating Hanukkah as an official holiday with school closures from 1949 onward and public ceremonies emphasizing unity and heroism. The holiday's national significance manifests in state symbols, such as the seven-branched menorah outside the , erected in 1956 to represent Jewish perseverance and the return to , drawing directly from Hanukkah's themes of Temple restoration and endurance. Annual events, including military parades and reenactments of Maccabean battles, reinforce Hanukkah as a celebration of Jewish defensive capabilities, with kibbutzim and youth movements staging performances that link ancient victories to contemporary state defense. This politicization, while elevating Hanukkah's public profile—evident in widespread menorah lightings and sufganiyot distributions—has sparked debates over whether it dilutes the religious core, though Zionist maintains the revolt's causal primacy in preserving Jewish continuity.

Interactions with Christmas and Secular Society

In pluralistic secular societies, particularly the , Hanukkah's proximity to —often overlapping in —has led to comparative amplifications of its customs, with gift-giving over eight nights emerging as a response to rather than from ancient practice. This adaptation, noted since the mid-20th century amid rising , positions Hanukkah as a "Jewish " in popular perception, though rabbinic sources emphasize its minor status and warn against equating the two to avoid diluting distinct religious meanings. The "December dilemma" describes tensions in interfaith households, where families navigate celebrating Hanukkah, , or both, often facing pressure from societal dominance and concerns over identity erosion; surveys indicate many Jewish partners in such couples light menorahs privately while participating in publicly to maintain harmony. Coined in Jewish discourse, this term highlights causal pressures from cultural , with some opting for ""—a blended observance—as in 2024 when Hanukkah began at sundown on , a rare alignment occurring roughly every 165 years. Public Hanukkah displays, spearheaded by Chabad-Lubavitch since 1974 with a 32-foot menorah at New York's , now number thousands annually across cities worldwide, asserting Jewish visibility in spaces featuring trees and lights. These events, often including unconventional forms like ice or menorahs, foster communal pride amid secular but have sparked legal challenges; the U.S. Supreme Court in County of Allegheny v. (1989) upheld a menorah display alongside a and as secular context preventing government endorsement of religion. Halachically, placing a menorah near a tree poses no , though some view such juxtapositions as reinforcing parallel narratives of light over darkness. In broader secular interactions, Hanukkah menorahs symbolize resistance to assimilation—echoing the —while coexisting with holiday ; organizations like promote public lightings to "reclaim the public square," countering perceptions of as secondary in non-Jewish dominated calendars. Despite this, empirical data from Jewish community reports show varied observance, with unaffiliated Jews more likely to engage in festive but non-ritual elements like dreidels and latkes in office or civic settings, reflecting pragmatic adaptation over strict .

Recent Events Amid Antisemitism and Public Debates

In the wake of the , 2023, Hamas attack on Israel, which killed over 1,200 people and initiated the ongoing Gaza war, Hanukkah celebrations from December 7 to 15, 2023, unfolded against a backdrop of sharply rising incidents worldwide. The (ADL) reported a 315% increase in U.S. antisemitic acts in the two months following the attack compared to the prior year, including harassment, vandalism, and assaults targeting Jewish institutions and individuals. In , public menorah lightings proceeded under enhanced security amid fears of attacks, with Jewish leaders noting a pervasive sense of mourning and caution that tempered traditional joy. Similarly, in the , communities marked the holiday with subdued gatherings, linking the Maccabean victory over ancient oppressors to contemporary threats from Islamist and anti-Israel protests. Many American Jewish families grappled with visible displays, opting to forgo window menorahs or large parties to avoid drawing attention, particularly in areas with recent vandalism or protests. In , some households cited safety concerns tied to post-October 7 harassment, viewing public symbols as potential targets. Jewish organizations ramped up security at events, with reports of canceled or scaled-back celebrations reflecting broader anxiety; one survey by the Jewish Federations indicated heightened vigilance among participants. Yet defiance persisted in pockets, as in , where communal lightings emphasized resilience, with organizers arguing that hiding traditions would concede to hate. The White House's response to reports of toned-down events, which equated with Islamophobia, drew criticism from Jewish advocates for diluting focus on specific threats to . Hanukkah 2024, spanning December 25, 2024, to January 2, 2025, and unusually overlapping with , saw continued tensions, with the Combat Antisemitism Movement documenting 13 incidents of vandalism or disruption targeting public menorahs and events across the U.S. and . Examples included antisemitic graffiti discovered at an , gathering site just before a planned , forcing organizers to adapt amid disappointment. In , a municipal decision to limit a Hanukkah display for "safety" reasons amid rising hate sparked local controversy, with critics arguing it stigmatized Jewish visibility while ignoring broader security needs. Public debates intensified over balancing caution with assertion, as some rabbis framed menorah lightings as direct counters to erasure efforts, invoking Hanukkah's narrative of rededication against assimilationist pressures—echoed in calls for unapologetic observance despite threats. Others, however, concealed displays privately, citing empirical risks from tracked incidents, highlighting a divide between resilience advocates and those prioritizing immediate safety. These events underscored Hanukkah's evolving role as a flashpoint for Jewish self-assertion amid empirically verified surges in hostility, often linked by sources to anti-Zionist spilling into general .

Political and Ideological Controversies

Maccabees as Heroes vs. Zealots

The , initiated in 167 BCE by and his sons against Seleucid persecution under , is traditionally celebrated in Jewish sources as a heroic defense of religious liberty. Antiochus had outlawed core Jewish practices, including and observance, desecrated the Second Temple by erecting an altar to , and enforced sacrifices to Greek gods, prompting widespread Jewish resistance. The Books of portray the Hasmoneans () as liberators who, after , recaptured and rededicated the Temple in 164 BCE, restoring Jewish worship. This narrative frames their zeal—exemplified by Mattathias slaying a fellow Jew compromising with Hellenism and a Seleucid enforcer—as a necessary Pinhas-like act to preserve covenantal fidelity amid existential threat. Critics, however, depict the Maccabees as due to their intra-Jewish violence and rejection of Hellenistic cultural integration favored by some elites. First Maccabees recounts the killing of apostate Jews who adopted Greek customs, actions that escalated a civil conflict between traditionalists and Hellenizers before the full Seleucid crackdown. Later Hasmonean rule under (134–104 BCE) and (103–76 BCE) involved forced conversions of Idumeans and civil wars, suggesting zealotry devolved into authoritarianism; the dynasty even Hellenized by adopting royal titles and Greek names, undermining their anti-assimilation purity. , wary of militarism, marginalizes the Maccabees in the , elevating the Temple oil miracle over conquest and portraying more moderately than in ' zealous depiction. In modern scholarship and discourse, the "zealot" label often reflects interpretive biases, with some academics and progressive commentators analogizing Maccabean fundamentalism to contemporary , emphasizing opposition to over response to . Yet historical evidence indicates the revolt enjoyed broad support among Judeans, not fringe radicalism; Seleucid policies constituted verifiable tyranny, including mass executions for adherence, rendering Maccabean resistance causally proportionate rather than gratuitous fanaticism. Analogies to later in the Roman era (66–73 CE) overlook distinctions: achieved sovereignty, while precipitated catastrophe, though both invoked divine zeal. Zionist traditions reclaim them as national heroes symbolizing , countering assimilationist critiques that downplay the revolt's empirical success in averting cultural erasure.

Anti-Assimilation Message in Contemporary Contexts

The anti-assimilation core of Hanukkah, commemorating the ' revolt against Hellenistic cultural imposition in the BCE, manifests in contemporary Jewish thought as a imperative for maintaining distinct religious and amid globalizing pressures. In , the holiday reinforces narratives of collective survival and resistance to external influences, with public celebrations emphasizing the Maccabean model of armed self-defense against erasure, as articulated in analyses linking it to modern statehood imperatives. This interpretation gained prominence post-1948, framing Hanukkah as a Zionist emblem of sovereignty over assimilationist alternatives. In the diaspora, particularly the United States, the Maccabean legacy critiques internal Hellenist-like tendencies among Jews favoring cultural blending, such as high intermarriage rates exceeding 50% among non-Orthodox Jews since the 1990s. Commentators like those in Tablet Magazine argue for reviving the "hard-as-nails" defiance against survival threats, including secular dilution and identity erosion, especially after events like the October 7, 2023, attacks heightened perceptions of vulnerability. Rabbi Mijal Bitton has described modern Hanukkah observance as ironically co-opted for assimilation, urging reclamation of its defiant origins to counter trends where the holiday parallels Christmas consumerism rather than ritual particularism. This message intersects with broader debates on Jewish continuity, where orthodox and nationalist voices decry assimilated elites—echoing ancient Hellenizers—for prioritizing universalism over particularist fidelity, as seen in critiques of Reform adaptations minimizing militancy. Empirical data from Pew Research in 2021 shows 82% of U.S. Jews view Hanukkah as culturally significant, yet only 15% of non-Orthodox families emphasize its historical resistance narrative, underscoring a divide between observance and anti-assimilation ethos. Proponents of the unadulterated Maccabean reading, often from conservative outlets, contend that diluting this—via "progressive" reinterpretations—mirrors the very cultural capitulation the revolt opposed, substantiated by historical precedents of Jewish communities vanishing through syncretism.

Criticisms of Commercialization and Politicization

Critics of Hanukkah's commercialization, especially within American Jewish communities, contend that the holiday's transformation into a gift-giving extravaganza mirrors consumer culture, overshadowing its core religious elements of commemorating the Temple's rededication and the of the oil's endurance. This trend emerged in the among and Conservative Jews seeking cultural parity with Christian neighbors, with small gifts exchanged to engage children, but escalated post-World War II as department stores promoted Hanukkah merchandise alongside items, leading to widespread sales of themed toys, decorations, and foods like mass-produced sufganiyot and chocolate gelt. Traditional Orthodox voices, such as those in rabbinic commentaries, argue this commercialization erodes the holiday's emphasis on spiritual resilience and anti-assimilation defiance, reducing it to superficial rituals driven by market forces rather than Talmudic observance. Further critiques highlight the proliferation of low-quality, culturally insensitive merchandise, including items like Hanukkah-themed gnomes that inadvertently evoke antisemitic tropes of hidden Jewish wealth, despite their intent to foster festive visibility. Jewish journalists have noted the lack of oversight in production, resulting in errors such as menorahs with incorrect branch counts or dreidels bearing mistranslated Hebrew, which undermine authenticity and exploit seasonal demand without regard for halakhic integrity. This commercial boom, fueled by retailers like Target and Amazon offering expansive Hanukkah sections since the 2010s, is seen by some as a response to dominance but criticized for prioritizing profit over preserving Hanukkah's minor festival status in Jewish , where it ranks below major holidays like . On politicization, detractors argue that reinterpretations of Hanukkah as a symbol of unyielding Jewish sovereignty—often invoked in Israeli state ceremonies or advocacy against assimilation—distort its historical nuances, including the ' internal conflicts with Hellenistic Jews and their authoritarian rule post-victory, as detailed in ancient sources like the Books of Maccabees. In modern contexts, public Hanukkah displays, such as large-scale menorah lightings in cities like New York since the 1970s under Chabad's campaign, have faced accusations of injecting religious symbolism into civic spaces, sparking debates over and alienating secular . Progressive Jewish groups, including those producing anti-nationalist materials, criticize Zionist framings that equate Maccabean militancy with contemporary Israeli policies, viewing them as promoting ethnocentric narratives that exacerbate tensions amid ongoing conflicts, rather than fostering universal themes of religious . These interpretations, amplified during events like the 2023 Israel-Hamas war, underscore how Hanukkah's anti-imperialist origins are selectively invoked to serve ideological agendas, prompting calls for depoliticized observances centered on personal piety.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.