Hubbry Logo
History of the Italian RepublicHistory of the Italian RepublicMain
Open search
History of the Italian Republic
Community hub
History of the Italian Republic
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
History of the Italian Republic
History of the Italian Republic
from Wikipedia

The history of the Italian Republic concerns the events relating to the history of Italy that have occurred since 1946, when Italy became a republic after the 1946 Italian institutional referendum. The Italian republican history is generally divided into two phases, the First and Second Republic.

After the fall of the Fascist regime in Italy and the end of World War II, Italian politics and society were dominated by Christian Democracy (DC), a broad-based Christian political party, from 1946 to 1994. From the late 1940s until 1991, the opposition was led by the Italian Communist Party (PCI). Christian Democracy governed uninterrupted during this period, dominating every cabinet and providing nearly every prime minister. It governed primarily with the support of an array of minor parties from the centre-left to the centre-right, including the Italian Socialist Party (PSI), Italian Democratic Socialist Party (PSDI), Italian Republican Party (PRI), and Italian Liberal Party (PLI), and even far-right parties like the Italian Social Movement (MSI). The Communist Party was excluded entirely from government, with the partial exception of the short-lived Historic Compromise, in which the PCI provided external support to a DC minority government from 1976 to 1979.

The political situation was radically transformed in the early 1990s due to two major shocks: the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991 and the wide-reaching Tangentopoli corruption scandal from 1992 to 1994. The former caused the dissolution and split of the PCI and splintering of the opposition, while the latter led to the collapse of nearly every established political party in Italy, including Christian Democracy, the PSI, PSDI, PRI, PLI, and others. Anti-establishment sentiment resulted in a 1993 referendum enabling the reform of the electoral system from pure proportional representation to a majoritarian-leaning mixed system.

Media magnate Silvio Berlusconi entered politics with his conservative Forza Italia party and won the 1994 general election, forming the short-lived Berlusconi I Cabinet. He went on to become one of Italy's most important figures over the next two decades, serving as prime minister again from 2001 to 2006 and 2008 to 2011. The rise of the new conservative right saw the old centre and left consolidate into the Olive Tree coalition, comprising the post-Communist Democrats of the Left and Christian democratic The Daisy, which together founded the Democratic Party (PD) in 2007. They competed against Berlusconi's centre-right coalition, comprising Forza Italia, the right-wing National Alliance, and northern Italian regionalist Northern League.

The collapse of Berlusconi's fourth cabinet in 2011 resulted in the formation of the technocratic Monti Cabinet until 2013. Enduring dissatisfaction saw the rise of the populist Five Star Movement (M5S) and the Northern League (rebranded League, Lega). After the Italian general elections of 2013 and 2018, grand coalition governments were formed, this time with the participation of populist parties. The COVID-19 pandemic and its associated economic issues brought about a government of national unity led by Mario Draghi, the former president of the European Central Bank.

Background

[edit]

Republican ideas and the unification of Italy

[edit]
Giuseppe Mazzini. His thoughts influenced many politicians of a later period, among them Woodrow Wilson, David Lloyd George, Mahatma Gandhi, Golda Meir and Jawaharlal Nehru.[1]

In the history of Italy there are several so-called "republican" governments that have followed one another over time. Examples are the ancient Roman Republic and the medieval maritime republics. From Cicero to Niccolò Machiavelli, Italian philosophers have imagined the foundations of political science and republicanism.[a] But it was Giuseppe Mazzini who revived the republican idea in Italy in the 19th century.[2]

An Italian nationalist in the historical radical tradition and a proponent of a republicanism of social-democratic inspiration, Mazzini helped define the modern European movement for popular democracy in a republican state.[3] Mazzini's thoughts had a very considerable influence on the Italian and European republican movements, in the Constitution of Italy, about Europeanism and more nuanced on many politicians of a later period, among them American president Woodrow Wilson, British prime minister David Lloyd George, Mahatma Gandhi, Israeli prime minister Golda Meir and Indian prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru.[1] Mazzini formulated a concept known as "thought and action" in which thought and action must be joined together and every thought must be followed by action, therefore rejecting intellectualism and the notion of divorcing theory from practice.[4]

In July 1831, in exile in Marseille, Giuseppe Mazzini founded the Young Italy movement, which aimed to transform Italy into a unitary democratic republic, according to the principles of freedom, independence and unity, but also to oust the monarchic regimes pre-existing the unification, including the Kingdom of Sardinia. The foundation of the Young Italy constitutes a key moment of the Italian Risorgimento and this republican program precedes in time the proposals for the unification of Italy of Vincenzo Gioberti and Cesare Balbo, aimed at reunifying the Italian territory under the presidency of the Pope.[5] Subsequently, the philosopher Carlo Cattaneo promoted a secular and republican Italy in the extension of Mazzini's ideas, but organized as a federal republic.[6]

Pietro Barsanti, the first martyr of the modern Italian Republic[7][8]

The political projects of Mazzini and Cattaneo were thwarted by the action of the Piedmontese Prime Minister Camillo Benso, Count of Cavour, and Giuseppe Garibaldi. The latter set aside his republican ideas to favor Italian unity.[9] After having obtained the conquest of the whole of southern Italy during the Expedition of the Thousand, Garibaldi handed over the conquered territories to the king of Sardinia Victor Emmanuel II, which were annexed to the Kingdom of Sardinia after a plebiscite. This earned him heavy criticism from numerous republicans who accused him of treason.[10] While a laborious administrative unification began, a first Italian parliament was elected and, on 17 March 1861, Victor Emmanuel II was proclaimed king of Italy.[11]

From 1861 to 1946, Italy was a constitutional monarchy founded on the Albertine Statute, named after the king who promulgated it in 1848, Charles Albert of Sardinia. The parliament included a Senate, whose members were appointed by the king, and a Chamber of Deputies, elected by census vote. In 1861 only 2% of Italians had the right to vote.[11] In the political panorama of the time there was a republican political movement which had its martyrs, such as the soldier Pietro Barsanti.[7] Barsanti was a supporter of republican ideas, and was a soldier in the Royal Italian Army with the rank of corporal. He was sentenced to death and shot in 1870 for having favored an insurrectional attempt against the Savoy monarchy and is therefore considered the first martyr of the modern Italian Republic[7][8] and a symbol of republican ideals in Italy.[12]

Albertine Statute and liberal Italy

[edit]
Carlo Cattaneo
Felice Cavallotti

The balance of power between the Chamber and Senate initially shifted in favor of the Senate, composed mainly of nobles and industrial figures. Little by little, the Chamber of Deputies took on more and more importance with the evolution of the bourgeoisie and the large landowners, concerned with economic progress, but supporters of order and a certain social conservatism.[13]

The Republicans took part in the elections to the Italian Parliament, and in 1853 they formed the Action Party around Giuseppe Mazzini. Although in exile, Mazzini was elected in 1866, but refused to take his seat in parliament. Carlo Cattaneo was elected deputy in 1860 and 1867, but refused so as not to have to swear loyalty to the House of Savoy. The problem of the oath of loyalty to the monarchy, necessary to be elected, was the subject of controversy within the republican forces. In 1873 Felice Cavallotti, one of the most committed Italian politicians against the monarchy, preceded his oath with a declaration in which he reaffirmed his republican beliefs.[14] In 1882, a new electoral law lowered the census limit for voting rights, increasing the number of voters to over two million, equal to 7% of the population.[15] In the same year the Italian Workers' Party was created, which in 1895 became the Italian Socialist Party.[13] In 1895 the intransigent republicans agreed to participate in the political life of the Kingdom, establishing the Italian Republican Party. Two years later, the far left reached its historical maximum level in Parliament with 81 deputies, for the three radical-democratic, socialist components and Republican. With the death of Felice Cavallotti in 1898, the radical left gave up on posing the institutional problem.[16]

In Italian politics, the socialist party progressively divided into two tendencies: a maximalist one, led among others by Arturo Labriola and Enrico Ferri, and supporting the use of strikes; the other, reformist and pro-government, was led by Filippo Turati. A nationalist movement emerged, led in particular by Enrico Corradini, as well as a Catholic social and democratic movement, the National Democratic League, led by Romolo Murri. In 1904, Pope Pius X authorized Catholics to participate individually in political life,[17] but in 1909 he condemned the National Democratic League created by Romolo Murri, who was excommunicated.[18] Finally, a law of 3 June 1912 marked Italy's evolution towards a certain political liberalism by establishing universal male suffrage. In 1914, at the outbreak of World War I, Italy began to be counted among the world's liberal democracies.[17]

Fascism and World War II

[edit]
Benito Mussolini titled himself Duce and ruled the country from 1922 to 1943.

After World War I, Italian political life was animated by four great movements. Two of these movements were in favor of democratic development within the framework of existing monarchical institutions: the reformist socialists and the Italian People's Party. Two other movements challenged these institutions: the Republican Party on the one hand, and the maximalist socialists. In the 1919 elections, the parties most imbued with republican ideology (the maximalist socialists and the Republican Party) won, obtaining 165 out of 508 seats in the Chamber of Deputies.[19] In the 1921 elections, after the foundation of the Italian Communist Party, the three parties republican, maximalist socialist and communist obtained 145 deputies out of 535. Overall, at the beginning of the interwar period, less than 30% of those elected were in favor of the establishment of a republican regime.[20] In this context, the rise of Benito Mussolini's fascist movement was based on the bitterness generated by the "mutilated victory", the fear of social unrest and the rejection of revolutionary, republican and Marxist ideology. The liberal political system and part of the aristocracy chose to erect fascism as a bulwark against, in their way of seeing, these dangers.[21]

King Victor Emmanuel III of Italy

In October 1922, the nomination of Benito Mussolini as prime minister by King Victor Emmanuel III, following the march on Rome, paved the way for the establishment of the dictatorship. The Albertine Statute was progressively emptied of its content. Parliament was subject to the will of the new government.[b] The legal opposition disintegrated. On 27 June 1924, 127 deputies left Parliament and retreated to the Aventine Hill, a clumsy maneuver which, in effect, left the field open to the fascists. They then had the fate of Italy in their hands for two decades.[21]

Flag of Arditi del Popolo, an axe cutting a fasces. Arditi del Popolo was a militant anti-fascist group founded in 1921

With the implementation of fascist laws (Royal Decree of 6 November 1926), all political parties operating on Italian territory were dissolved, with the exception of the National Fascist Party. Some of these parties expatriated and reconstituted themselves abroad, especially in France. Thus an anti-fascist coalition was formed on 29 March 1927 in Paris, the "Concentrazione Antifascista Italiana", which brought together the Italian Republican Party, the Italian Socialist Party, the Socialist Unitary Party of Italian Workers, the Italian League for Human Rights and the foreign representation of the Italian General Confederation of Labour. Some movements remained outside, including the Italian Communist Party, the popular Catholic movement and other liberal movements.[22] This coalition dissolved on 5 May 1934 and, in August of the same year, the pact of unity of action was signed between the Italian Socialist Party and the Italian Communist Party.[23]

In the meantime, in Italy, clandestine anti-fascist nuclei were formed, in particular in Milan with Ferruccio Parri and in Florence with Riccardo Bauer.[23] Under the impetus of these groups, the Action Party, Mazzini's former republican party, was re-established.[23][c] Between the end of 1942 and the beginning of 1943, Alcide De Gasperi wrote The reconstructive ideas of Christian Democracy, which laid the foundations of the new Catholic-inspired party, the Christian Democracy. It brought together the veterans of Luigi Sturzo's Italian People's Party and the young people of Catholic associations, in particular of the University Federation.[24]

Not only did Victor Emmanuel III appeal to Mussolini to form the government in 1922 and allow him to proceed with the domestication of Parliament, but he did not even draw the consequences of the assassination of Giacomo Matteotti in 1924. He accepted the title of emperor in 1936 at the end of Second Italo-Ethiopian War, then the alliance with Nazi Germany and Italy's entry into World War II on 10 June 1940.[25]

Hostilities ended on 29 April 1945, when the German forces in Italy surrendered. Nearly half a million Italians (including civilians) died in World War II,[26] society was divided and the Italian economy had been all but destroyed; per capita income in 1944 was at its lowest point since the beginning of the 20th century.[27]

Birth of the Republic (1946–1948)

[edit]
Umberto II, the last King of Italy, was exiled to Portugal.

In the final phases of World War II, King Victor Emmanuel III, tainted by his former support for the Fascist regime, had tried to save the monarchy by nominating his son and heir Umberto "general lieutenant of the kingdom";[28] the king promised that after the end of the war the Italian people could choose its form of government through a referendum. In April 1945, the Allies of World War II advanced in the Po plain supported by the Italian resistance movement, and defeated the fascist Italian Social Republic, a puppet state instituted by Nazi Germany and headed by Benito Mussolini. Mussolini was killed by resistance fighters in April 1945. Much like Japan and Germany, the aftermath of World War II left Italy with a destroyed economy, a divided society, and anger against the monarchy for its endorsement of the Fascist regime for the previous twenty years. These frustrations contributed to a revival of the Italian republican movement.[29]

Electoral ballot of the 1946 Italian institutional referendum

Victor Emmanuel formally abdicated on 9 May 1946;[30] his son became king as Umberto II of Italy. The 1946 Italian institutional referendum was held on 2 June.[31] The republican side won 54% of the vote and Italy officially became a republic. The Kingdom of Italy was no more. It was the first time that the whole Italian Peninsula was under a form of republican governance since the end of the ancient Roman Republic. The House of Savoy, the Italian royal family, was exiled. Victor Emmanuel left for Egypt, where he died in 1947. Umberto, who had been king for only a month, moved to Portugal. The referendum at the origin of the Italian republic was, however, the subject of some controversy, not least because of some contested results and because of a geographical divide between the North, where the Republic won a clear majority, and the South, where the monarchists were in a majority.[32]

A Constituent Assembly, formed by the representatives of all the anti-fascist forces that contributed to the defeat of Nazi and Fascist forces during the liberation of Italy,[33] was in place between June 1946 and January 1948; it wrote the new Constitution of Italy, which took effect on 1 January 1948. The peace treaty between Italy and the Allies of World War II was signed in Paris in February 1947. In 1946, the main Italian political parties were:[34]

One of three original copies of the Constitution of Italy, now in the custody of Historical Archives of the president of the Republic.

Each party had run separate candidates in the 1946 general election, and the Christian Democrats won a plurality of votes. The PSI and the PCI received some ministerial posts in a Christian Democrat–led coalition cabinet. PCI's leader Palmiro Togliatti was minister of Justice. As in France, where Maurice Thorez and four other Communist ministers were forced to leave Paul Ramadier's government during the May 1947 crisis, both the Italian Communists (PCI) and Socialists (PSI) were excluded from government the same month under pressure from US President Harry Truman.[35]

Since the PSI and the PCI together received more votes than the Christian Democrats, they decided to unite in 1948 to form the Popular Democratic Front (FDP). The 1948 general elections were heavily influenced by the then flaring cold-war confrontation between the Soviet Union and the US.[36] After the Soviet-inspired February 1948 communist coup in Czechoslovakia the US became alarmed about Soviet intentions and feared that the Soviet-funded[37][38] PCI would draw Italy into the Soviet Union's sphere of influence if the leftist coalition were to win the elections. In response, in March 1948 the United States National Security Council issued its first document proffering recommendations to avoid such an outcome which were widely and energetically implemented. Tons of letters were sent by mostly Italian Americans urging Italians not to vote Communist.[39] US agencies made numerous short-wave propaganda radio broadcasts and funded the publishing of books and articles, warning the Italians of the perceived consequences of a Communist victory. The CIA also funded the centre-right political parties and was accused of publishing forged letters to discredit the leaders of the PCI. The PCI itself was accused of being funded by Moscow and the Cominform, and in particular via export deals to the communist countries.[40]

Fears in the Italian electorate of a possible Communist takeover proved crucial for the electoral outcome on 18 April; the Christian Democrats (Democrazia Cristiana, DC), under the undisputed leadership of Alcide De Gasperi won a resounding victory with 48% of the vote, which was their best result ever and not repeated since,[41] while the FDP only received 31% of the votes. The Communist Party widely outdid the Socialists in the distribution of seats in Parliament, and gained a solid position as the main opposition party in Italy, even if it would never return in government. For almost four decades, Italian elections were successively won by the DC, a centrist party.

The symbolic photo of the birth of the Republic

[edit]
The symbolic photo of the birth of the Republic, which portrays the face of a young woman emerging from a copy of Il Corriere della Sera of 6 June 1946 with the title «È nata la Repubblica Italiana» ("The Italian Republic is born").

The photo, which later became a "symbol" of the celebrations for the outcome of the referendum, portrays the face of a young woman emerging from a copy of Il Corriere della Sera of 6 June 1946 with the title «È nata la Repubblica Italiana» ("The Italian Republic is born").

The symbolic photo of the birth of the Republic was taken by Federico Patellani for the weekly Tempo (n. 22, 15-22 June 1946) as part of a photo shoot celebrating the Republic and the new role of women; it was also featured on the front page of the Il Corriere della Sera itself and was later reused in many campaigns and posters.[42]

Only in 2016 was the woman identified as Anna Iberti (1922–1997).[43]

First Republic (1948–1994)

[edit]

1950s and 1960s: post-war economic boom

[edit]

Under the Treaty of Peace with Italy, 1947, Istria, Kvarner, most of the Julian March as well as the Dalmatian city of Zara was annexed by Yugoslavia causing the Istrian-Dalmatian exodus, which led to the emigration of between 230,000 and 350,000 of local ethnic Italians (Istrian Italians and Dalmatian Italians), the others being ethnic Slovenians, ethnic Croatians, and ethnic Istro-Romanians, choosing to maintain Italian citizenship.[44] Later, the Free Territory of Trieste was divided between the two states. Italy also lost all of its colonial possessions, formally ending the Italian Empire. In 1950, Italian Somaliland was made a United Nations Trust Territory under Italian administration until 1 July 1960. The Italian border that applies today has existed since 1975, when Trieste was formally re-annexed to Italy.

Alcide De Gasperi, the first republican Prime Minister of Italy and one of the Founding Fathers of the European Union. He was Prime Minister from 1945 to 1953

In the 1950s Italy became a founding member of the NATO alliance (1949), a member of the United Nations (1955) and an ally of the United States, which helped to revive the Italian economy through the Marshall Plan. In the same years, Italy also became a founding member of the ECSC (1952) and of the European Economic Community (1957), later developed into the European Union. At the end of the 1950s, an impressive economic growth was termed "Italian economic miracle", a term that is still recognized in Italian politics. The impact of the economic miracle on Italian society was huge. Fast economic expansion induced massive inflows of migrants from rural Southern Italy to the industrial cities of the North. Emigration was especially directed to the factories of the "industrial triangle", the name for the region placed between the major manufacturing centres of Milan and Turin and the seaport of Genoa. Between 1955 and 1971, around 9 million people are estimated to have been involved in inter-regional migrations in Italy, uprooting entire communities and creating large metropolitan areas.[45] At the same time, the doubling of Italian GDP, which occurred between 1950 and 1962[46] Italians families used their newfound wealth to purchase consumer durables for the first time. In 1955, only 3% of households owned refrigerators and 1% washing machines; by 1975, the respective figures were 94% and 76%. In addition, 66% of all homes had come to possess cars.[47] As noted by the historian Paul Ginsborg:[48]

The signing ceremony of the Treaty of Rome on 25 March 1957, creating the European Economic Community, forerunner of the present-day European Union
The Fiat 500, launched in 1957, is considered a symbol of Italy's economic miracle.[49]

In the twenty years from 1950 to 1970 per capita income in Italy grew more rapidly than in any other European country: from a base of 100 in 1950 to 234.1 in 1970, compared to France's increase from 100 to 136 in the same period, and Britain's 100 to 132. By 1970 Italian per capita income, which in 1945 had lagged far behind that of the northern European countries, had reached 60 per cent of that in France and 82 per cent of that in Britain.

A gaping north–south divide was a major factor of socio-economic weakness,[50] a problem that still exists today, and even now there is a huge difference in official income between northern and southern regions and municipalities.[51] Christian Democracy's main support areas (sometimes known as "vote tanks") were the rural areas in South, Center and North-East Italy, whereas the industrial North-West had more left-leaning support because of the larger working class. An interesting exception were the "red regions" (Emilia Romagna, Tuscany, Umbria) where the Italian Communist Party has historically had a wide support.[52] This is considered a consequence of the particular sharecropping ("mezzadria") farming contracts used in these regions.

The Holy See actively supported the Christian Democracy, judging it would be a mortal sin for a Catholic to vote for the Communist Party and excommunicating all its supporters.[53] Giovannino Guareschi wrote his novels about Don Camillo describing a village, Brescello, whose inhabitants are at the same time loyal to priest Camillo and Communist mayor Peppone, who are fierce rivals.

In 1953, a Parliamentary Commission on poverty estimated that 24% of Italian families were either "destitute" or "in hardship", 21% of dwellings were overcrowded, 52% of homes in the south had no running drinking water, and only 57% had a lavatory.[54] In the 1950s, several important reforms were launched: e.g., agrarian reform (legge Scelba), fiscal reform (legge Vanoni), and the country enjoyed a period of extraordinary economic development (Italian: miracolo economico, lit.'economic miracle'). In this period of time, a massive population transfer, from the impoverished South to the booming industrial North, took place. This however exacerbated social contrasts, including between the old-established "worker aristocracy" and the new less qualified immigrants ("operaio-massa") of Southern origin. In addition, a wide gap between rich and poor continued to exist. By the end of the Sixties, it was estimated that 4 million Italians (out of a population of 54.5 million) were unemployed, underemployed, and casual labourers. As noted by the historian Paul Ginsborg, the affluent society to this section of the Italian population "might have meant a television set but precious little else".[48]

During the First Republic, the Christian Democracy slowly but steadily lost support, as society modernised and the traditional values at its ideological core became less appealing to the population. Various options of extending the parliamentary majority were considered, mainly an opening to the left (apertura a sinistra), i.e., to the Socialist Party (PSI), which after the 1956 events in Hungary had moved from a position of total subordination to the Communists to an independent position.[55] Proponents of such a coalition proposed a series much-needed "structural reforms" that would modernize the country and create a modern social-democracy. In 1960, an attempt by the right wing of the Christian Democrats to incorporate the neo-fascist Italian Social Movement (MSI) in the Tambroni government led to violent and bloody riots (Genoa, Reggio Emilia), and was defeated.[56]

Up until the Nineties, two types of governmental coalitions characterised the politics of post-war Italy. The first were "centrist" coalitions led by the Christian Democracy party together with smaller parties: the PSDI, the PRT, and the PLI. The first democratic government (1947) excluded both the PCI and the PSI, which brought about the political period known as "centrist government", which ruled over Italian politics from 1948 to 1963. The centre-left coalition (DC-PRI-PSDI-PSI) was the second type of coalition that characterised Italian politics, coming about in 1963 when the PSI (formerly the opposition party) went into government with the DC. This coalition lasted in parliament throughout the Sixties and Seventies and then experienced a revival in the Eighties that lasted until the start of the Nineties.[57]

Aldo Moro, Prime Minister from 1963 to 1968 and from 1974 to 1976

The PSI entered government in 1963. During the first year of the new Centre-Left Government, a wide range of measures were carried out which went some way towards the Socialist Party's requirements for governing in coalition with the Christian Democrats. These included taxation of real estate profits and of share dividends (designed to curb speculation), increases in pensions for various categories of workers, a law on school organisation (to provide for a unified secondary school with compulsory attendance up to the age of 14), the nationalisation of the electric-power industry, and significant wage rises for workers (including those in the newly nationalised electric-power industry), which led to a rise in consumer demand. Urged on by the PSI, the government also made brave attempts to tackle issues relating to welfare services, hospitals, the agrarian structure, urban development, education, and overall planning.[58] For instance, during the Centre-Left Government's time in office, social security was extended to previously uncovered categories of the population.[59] In addition, entrance to university by examination was abolished in 1965.[48] Despite these important reforms, however, the reformist drive was soon lost, and the most important problems (including the mafia, social inequalities, inefficient state/social services, north–south imbalance) remained largely untackled.

The Italian Parliament voted, in December 1962, a law which created an Antimafia Commission. Any question about the need for such a law was obviated by the Ciaculli massacre in June of the following year, in which seven policemen and soldiers were killed attempting to defuse a car bomb in the suburbs of Palermo. The existence of the bomb had been disclosed by an anonymous telephone call. The massacre took place in the frame of the First Mafia War in the 1960s, with the bomb intended for Salvatore Greco, head of the Sicilian Mafia Commission formed in the late 1950s. The Mafia was fighting for the control of the profitable opportunities brought about by rapid urban growth and the heroin trade to North America.[60] The ferocity of the struggle was unprecedented, reaping 68 victims from 1961 to 1963. The Antimafia Commission submitted its final report in 1976. The Mafia had created ties with the political world. The period 1958–1964, when Salvo Lima (DC) was mayor of Palermo and Vito Ciancimino (DC) was assessor for public works, was later referred to as the "Sack of Palermo".

In 1965, the SIFAR intelligence agency was transformed into the SID following an aborted coup d'état, Piano Solo, which was to give the power to the Carabinieri, then headed by General De Lorenzo.

The difficult equilibrium of Italian society was challenged by a rising left-wing movement, in the wake of 1968 student unrest (Sessantotto). This movement was characterized by such heterogeneous events as revolts by jobless farm workers (Avola, Battipaglia 1969), occupations of universities by students, social unrest in the large Northern factories (1969 hot autumn, autunno caldo). While conservative forces tried to roll back some of the social advances of the 1960s, and part of the military indulged in "sabre rattling" to intimidate progressive political forces, numerous left-wing activists became increasingly frustrated at social inequalities, while the myth of guerrilla (Che Guevara, the Uruguayan Tupamaros) and of the Chinese Maoist "cultural revolution" increasingly inspired extreme left-wing violent movements.[61]

Social protests, in which the student movement was particularly active, shook Italy during the 1969 Hot Autumn (autunno caldo), leading to the occupation of the Fiat factory in Turin. In March 1968, clashes occurred at La Sapienza university in Rome, during the "Battle of Valle Giulia". Mario Capanna, associated with the New Left, was one of the figures of the student movement, along with the members of Potere Operaio and Autonomia Operaia such as Antonio Negri, Oreste Scalzone, Franco Piperno and of Lotta Continua such as Adriano Sofri.

1970s: strategy of tension and Years of Lead

[edit]
Giulio Andreotti, Prime Minister from 1972 to 1973, from 1976 to 1979 and from 1989 to 1992

The period of the late 1960–1970s came to be known as the Opposti Estremismi, (from left-wing and right-wing extremists riots), later renamed Years of Lead (anni di piombo) because of a wave of bombings and shootings – the first victim of this period was Antonio Annarumma, a policeman, killed on 12 November 1969 in Milan during a left-wing demonstration.[62]

In December, four bombings struck in Rome the Monument of Vittorio Emanuele II (Altare della Patria), the Banca Nazionale del Lavoro, and in Milan the Banca Commerciale and the Banca Nazionale dell'Agricoltura. The later bombing, known as the Piazza Fontana bombing of 12 December 1969, killed 16 and injured 90. The bombing was the work of the right-wing group Ordine Nuovo ("New Order"), whose aim was to prevent the country from falling into the hands of the left wing by duping the public into believing the bombings were part of a communist insurgency.[63]

On 17 May 1972, police officer Luigi Calabresi, who was subsequently awarded a gold medal of the Italian Republic for civil valour, was assassinated in Milan. Sixteen years later, Adriano Sofri, Giorgio Pietrostefani and Ovidio Bompressi and Leonardo Marino were arrested in Milan, accused by the confession of Leonardo Marino, one of the participants in the assassination. Highly controversial, the trial concluded, after an alternance of convictions and acquittals, to their guilt.

During a ceremony in honour of Luigi Calabresi on 17 May 1973, where the Interior Minister Mariano Rumor was present, an anarchist, Gianfranco Bertoli, threw a bomb killing four and injuring 45.[64]

Count Edgardo Sogno revealed in his memoirs that in July 1974, he visited the CIA station chief in Rome to inform him of the preparation of a neo-fascist coup. Asking him what the US government would do in case of such an operation, Sogno wrote that the CIA officer responsible for Italy answered him that "the United States would have supported any initiative tending to keep the communists out of government." General Maletti declared, in 2001, that he had not known about Sogno's relations to the CIA and had not been informed of the right-wing coup, known as Golpe Bianco (White Coup), and prepared with Randolfo Pacciardi.[65]

General Vito Miceli, chief of the SIOS military intelligence agency from 1969 on, and head of the SID from 1970 to 1974, was arrested in 1974 on charges of "conspiracy against the state".[66] Following his arrest, the Italian secret services were reorganized with a 24 October 1977 law in a democratic attempt to regain civilian and parliamentary control of them. The SID was divided into the current SISMI, the SISDE and the CESIS, which had a coordination role and was directly led by the president of the Council. Furthermore, a Parliamentary Committee on Secret services control (Copaco) was created at the same occasion. 1978 was the year with the most terrorist actions.[67]

Aldo Moro, photographed during his kidnapping by the Red Brigades

Christian Democrat Aldo Moro was assassinated in May 1978 by the Red Brigades, a terrorist leftist group then led by Mario Moretti. Before his murder, Aldo Moro, a central figure in the Christian Democrat Party, several times prime minister, was trying to include the Communist Party, headed by Enrico Berlinguer, in the parliamentary majority, an operation called the Historic Compromise. At this point, the PCI was the largest communist party in western Europe; this was largely due to its reformist orientation, to its growing independence from Moscow and to the new Eurocommunism doctrine.[68]

In the period of terror attacks of the late 1970s and early 1980s, the parliamentary majority was composed by the parties of the arco costituzionale, i.e., all parties supporting the Constitution, including the Communists, who took a very strong stance against the Red Brigades and other terrorist groups; however, the Communists never took part in the government itself, which was composed by the "Pentapartito" (Christian Democrats, Socialists, Social Democrats, Liberals, and Republicans).[69][70]

Although the 1970s in Italy was marked by violence, it was also a time of great social and economic progress. Following the civil disturbances of the 1960s, Christian Democracy and its allies in government (including the PSI) introduced a wide range of political, social, and economic reforms. Regional governments were introduced in the spring of 1970, with elected councils provided with the authority to legislate in areas like public works, town planning, social welfare, and health. Spending on the relatively poor South was significantly increased, while new laws relating to index-linked pay, public housing, and pension provision were also passed. In 1975, a law was passed entitling redundant workers to receive at least 80% of their previous salary for up to a year from a state insurance fund.[71] Living standards also continued to rise, with wages going up by an average of about 25% a year from the early 1970s onwards, and between 1969 and 1978, average real wages rose by 72%. Various fringe benefits were raised to the extent that they amounted to an additional 50% to 60% on wages, the highest in any country in the Western world. In addition, working hours were reduced so that by the end of the decade they were lower than any other country apart from Belgium. Some categories of workers who were laid off received generous unemployment compensation which represented only a little less than full wages, often years beyond eligibility. Initially, these benefits were primarily enjoyed by industrial workers in northern Italy where the "Hot Autumn" had its greatest impact, but these benefits soon spread to other categories of workers in other areas. In 1975, the escalator clause was strengthened in wage contracts, providing a high proportion of workers with nearly 100% indexation, with quarterly revisions, thereby increasing wages nearly as fast as prices.

Funerals of the victims of the Bologna bombing of 2 August 1980, the deadliest attack ever perpetrated in Italy during the Years of Lead

A statute of worker's rights that was drafted and pushed into enactment in 1970 by the Socialist labour minister Giacomo Brodolini, greatly strengthened the authority of the trade unions in the factories, outlawed dismissal without just cause, guaranteed freedom of assembly and speech on the shop floor, forbade employers to keep records of the union or political affiliations of their workers, and prohibited hiring except through the state employment office.[72]

From 1957, Italian workers had partly been sheltered from the falling value of money by what was termed a "moving staircase", which automatically raised wages as prices increased. In 1975, this provision was extended so that all workers received a flat fee that automatically compensated them for as much as 75% of the previous three months' price increases. This meant in practice that money wages rose faster than the cost of living, because better-paid groups fought for extra sums to maintain their differentials, and also because various industries negotiated local and national wage deals in addition to the increments that all workers received. By 1985, the average Italian was twice as rich in real terms as he was in 1960.[54]

By the mid-1970s, Italy had the most generous welfare provisions in Europe, while average Italian workers were among the best paid, most protected, and best treated on the continent.[71]

Because of reforms carried out in the Seventies, Italian families in the Eighties had access to a far wider range of state services than before, such as recreational and sports facilities, subsidies for medicines, proper medical care, and kindergarten schools. In addition, the growth in the income of most Italian families during the Seventies and Eighties was so significant that Giuseppe De Rita wrote of this period as a "watershed in the history of the Italian family".[48]

Despite these achievements, socio-economic inequalities continued to pervade Italy by the early Eighties. In 1983, it was estimated that over 18% of the population of the South lived below the official poverty line, compared with 6.9% of the population of the North and Centre.[48]

1980s: economic recession and reforms under Bettino Craxi

[edit]
Bettino Craxi, first Socialist Prime Minister from 1983 to 1987

The economic recession went on into the mid-1980s until a set of reforms led to the independence of the Bank of Italy[73] and a big reduction of the indexation of wages[74] that strongly reduced inflation rates, from 20.6% in 1980 to 4.7% in 1987.[75] The new macroeconomic and political stability resulted in a second, export-led "economic miracle", based on small and medium-sized enterprises, producing clothing, leather products, shoes, furniture, textiles, jewelry, and machine tools. As a result of this rapid expansion, in 1987 Italy overtook the UK's economy (an event known as il sorpasso), becoming the fourth richest nation in the world, after the US, Japan and West Germany.[76] The Milan stock exchange increased its market capitalization more than fivefold in the space of a few years.[77]

Meanwhile, the PSI, which was at an all-time low, squeezed in the pincer of the historic compromise attempt between the two major parties, called on the new secretary Bettino Craxi to revive his fortunes, whose political rise represented a factor of innovation in the system of First Republic, now unable to give adequate responses to the changes taking place in Italian society.[78]

In the 1980s, for the first time since 1945, two governments were led by non-Christian Democrat Premiers: Republican Giovanni Spadolini and Socialist Bettino Craxi.[79] The DC remained, however, the main force supporting the government.

With the end of the Years of Lead, the PCI gradually increased their votes under the leadership of Enrico Berlinguer. The Socialist Party (PSI), led by Bettino Craxi, became more and more critical of the Communists and of the Soviet Union; Craxi himself pushed in favour of US President Ronald Reagan's positioning of Pershing II missiles in Italy, a move the Communists hotly contested.[80]

As the Socialist Party moved to more moderate positions, the ranks of the PCI increased in numbers, and the Communist Party surpassed the Christian Democracy (DC) in the European election of 1984, barely two days after Berlinguer's death, that likely drew sympathy in the population.[81] Huge crowds attended Berlinguer's funeral. That was to be the only time the Christian Democracy was not the largest party in a nationwide election they participated in.[81] In 1984, the Craxi government revised the 1929 Lateran Pacts with the Vatican, which concluded the role of Catholicism as Italy's state religion.

With the Mani Pulite investigation, starting just one year after the collapse of the Soviet Union, the discovery of the extent of corruption, which involved most of Italy's important political parties, apart from the PCI, led the whole power structure to falter. The scandal became known as Tangentopoli, and seemingly indestructible parties like the DC and the PSI disbanded. The Communist Party, although it had not been much worried by legal investigations, changed its name to Democratic Party of the Left. Observing the fall of the Soviet Union, it took the role of being essentially just one more democratic party in Italy.[82] What was to follow was then called the transition to the Second Republic.

Economic prosperity rose during the 1980s, with rises in the ownership of goods such as color televisions, cars, washing machines, telephones and refrigerators. Home ownership reached over 66% of Italian families, while over 5 million also had holiday homes as well. Homelessness was also rare.[83] In addition, per capita income rose to $15,120 by 1989; higher than that of Britain's (which stood at $14,610) but lower than that of the United States ($20,630).[84]

1990s: Tangentopoli corruption scandal and mani pulite inquiry

[edit]
Sheets with the iconic picture of Giovanni Falcone and Paolo Borsellino, exposed as a sign of protest against Italian Mafia. They read: "You did not kill them: their ideas walk on our legs".

Italy faced several terror attacks between 1992 and 1993 perpetrated by the Sicilian Mafia as a consequence of several life sentences pronounced during the "Maxi Trial", and of the new anti-mafia measures launched by the government. In 1992, two major dynamite attacks killed the judges Giovanni Falcone (23 May in the Capaci bombing) and Paolo Borsellino (19 July in the Via D'Amelio bombing).[85] One year later (May–July 1993), tourist spots were attacked, such as the Via dei Georgofili in Florence, Via Palestro in Milan, and the Piazza San Giovanni in Laterano and Via San Teodoro in Rome, leaving 10 dead and 93 injured and causing severe damage to cultural heritage such as the Uffizi Gallery. The Catholic Church openly condemned the Mafia, and two churches were bombed and an anti-Mafia priest shot dead in Rome.[86][87]

From 1992 to 1997, Italy faced significant challenges as voters (disenchanted with past political paralysis, massive government debt, extensive corruption, and organized crime's considerable influence collectively called Tangentopoli after being uncovered by Mani pulite – "Clean hands") demanded political, economic, and ethical reforms. The scandals involved all major parties, but especially those in the government coalition: between 1992 and 1994 the DC underwent a severe crisis and was dissolved, splitting up into several pieces, among which were the Italian People's Party and the Christian Democratic Center. The PSI (and the other governing minor parties) completely dissolved. This "revolution" of the Italian political landscape, happened at a time when some institutional reforms (notably changes in the electoral laws intended to diminish the power of political parties) were taking place.

Umberto Bossi at the first Lega Nord rally in Pontida, 1990

In the Italian referendums of 1993, voters approved substantial changes, including moving from a proportional to partially compensatory mixed member majoritarian (not mixed-member proportional representation) system (with the requirement to obtain a minimum of 4% of the national vote to obtain representation) which is largely dominated by a majoritarian electoral system and the abolishment of some ministries (some of which have however been reintroduced with only partly modified names, as the Ministry of Agriculture being renamed the Ministry of Agricultural Resources).[88]

Major political parties, beset by scandal and loss of voter confidence, underwent far-reaching changes. The main changes in the political landscape were:

  • The left-wing vote appeared to be close to winning a majority. As of late 1993, it appeared that a coalition of left-wing parties may have won 40% of the vote, which would have sufficed to obtain a majority with the new electoral system given the disarray of other factions;[89]
  • The neo-fascist Italian Social Movement changed name and symbol into National Alliance, a party that its president Gianfranco Fini called "post-fascist". Some new members entered into the newly formed party, such as Publio Fiori from the Christian Democracy, but not to a large extent.
  • The Northern League movement vastly increased its support, with some polls indicating up to 16% on a national basis, remarkable when considering that it was only presenting itself in one-third of the country. Secretary Umberto Bossi was gathering protest votes and the support of northern people.[90]
  • In the meantime, Silvio Berlusconi, previously very close to Bettino Craxi and even having appeared in commercials for the Italian Socialist Party, was studying the possibility of making a political party of his own to avoid what seemed to be the unavoidable victory of the political left at the next elections. Only three months before the election, he presented, with a televised announcement, his new party, Forza Italia. Supporters believe he wanted to avert a Communist victory; opponents that he was defending the ancien régime by rebranding it. Whatever his motives, he employed his power in communication (he owned all of the three main private TV stations in Italy) and advanced communication techniques he and his allies knew very well, as his fortune was largely based on advertising.[91]

Berlusconi managed to ally himself to both the National Alliance and the Northern League, without these being allied with each other. Forza Italia teamed up with the League in the North, where they competed against National Alliance, and with National Alliance in the rest of Italy, where the League was not present. This unusual coalition configuration was caused by the deep hate between the League, which had many supporters who wanted to separate from the rest of Italy and held Rome in deep contempt, and the nationalist post-fascists; on one occasion, Bossi encouraged his supporters to go find National Alliance supporters "house by house," seemingly suggesting a lynching (which however did not actually take place).[92]

The left-wing parties formed a coalition, the Progressisti, which however did not have as clear a leader as Berlusconi. Achille Occhetto, secretary of the Democratic Party of the Left, was however considered to be its main figure.

The remains of the Christian Democracy formed a third, centrist coalition, proposing reformist Mario Segni as their prime minister candidate. The Christian Democracy reverted to the old name "Popular Party," first used at the beginning of the 20th century, and was led by Mino Martinazzoli.

The election saw a major turnover in the new parliament, with 452 out of 630 deputies and 213 out of 315 senators elected for the first time.[93]

Second Republic (1994–present)

[edit]

The 1994 elections marks the beginning of the Second Republic.[94] They were the first elections to use the new Mattarellum majoritarian voting system, adopted in 1993 to replace the proportional representation system that had been in use since 1946. The transition from the first to the second Republic represented a change within the political system, rather than an overhaul of the constitution, as happened in France, as the republican constitution and most of the institutions but the voting system remained the same in force since 1948. The term is commonly used, at a journalistic[95] but also a scientific level,[96] to emphasize the comparison of the Italian institutional political structure before and after the period 1992–1994, but also its reflection on important economic aspects.[97]

Silvio Berlusconi's first government (1994–1995)

[edit]

The 1994 elections also swept media magnate Silvio Berlusconi (leader of the Pole of Freedoms coalition, which included Forza Italia, the regionalist far-right Lega Nord party and the far-right National Alliance), into office as prime minister; however, Berlusconi was forced to step down in December 1994 when Lega Nord withdrew support because they disagreed on the pension reform.[98] The Berlusconi government was succeeded by a technical government headed by Lamberto Dini, who left office in early 1996.

Centre-left governments (1996–2001)

[edit]
Romano Prodi, Prime Minister from 1996 to 1998 and from 2006 to 2008

A series of centre-left coalitions dominated Italy's political landscape between 1996 and 2001, which introduced a number of progressive reforms in areas such as social security.[99][100][101] In April 1996, national elections led to the victory of a centre-left coalition under the leadership of Romano Prodi. The Olive Tree included PDS, PPI (the largest surviving piece of the former DC), and other small parties, with "external support" from the Communist Refoundation Party (voting confidence but not entering government). Prodi's government became the third-longest to stay in power before he narrowly lost a vote of confidence, by three votes, in October 1998. Prodi's programme consisted in restoring the country's economic health, to pursue the then seemingly unreachable goal of leading the country within the strict Euro convergence criteria set at Maastricht and make the country join the Euro. He succeeded in this in little more than six months.

U.S. Air Force F-15E Strike Eagle takes off from Aviano Air Base (1999)

His government fell in 1998 when the Communist Refoundation Party withdrew its support. This led to the formation of a new government led by Massimo D'Alema as prime minister. As the result of a vote of no confidence in Prodi's government, D'Alema's nomination was passed by a single vote, with the support of a loyal Communist faction (PdCI) and of some centrist MPs (UDR) led by former president of the Republic Francesco Cossiga. While D'Alema was prime minister, Italy took part in the NATO bombing of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia in 1999. The attack was supported by Silvio Berlusconi and the centre-right opposition, but the far left strongly contested it.[102] It was a very important test about the government loyalty to NATO and the country's foreign policy, as it concerned the first post-Communist leader of Italy and the first military action formally outside a UN mandate.[103]

In May 1999, the Parliament selected Carlo Azeglio Ciampi as the president of the Italian Republic. Ciampi, a former prime minister and Minister of the Treasury, and before the governor of the Bank of Italy, was elected on the first ballot with an easy margin over the required two-thirds votes.[104] In April 2000, following poor performance by his coalition in regional elections, D'Alema resigned. The succeeding caretaker centre-left government, including most of the same parties, was headed by Giuliano Amato (who previously served as prime minister in 1992–93) until the 2001 election. A constitutional referendum in 2001 confirmed a constitutional amendment to introduce early federalization, with residual legislative competence upon the Regions instead than upon the State.

Berlusconi's first comeback (2001–2006)

[edit]

The May 2001 election, where both coalitions used decoy lists to undermine the proportional-compensation part of the electoral system, ushered a refashioned centre-right coalition, House of Freedoms dominated by Berlusconi's party, Forza Italia (29.2%) and including Alleanza Nazionale (12.5%), the Lega Nord, the Christian Democratic Center and the United Christian Democrats. The Olive Tree coalition (The Daisy (14.5%) and the Democrats of the Left (16.7%)) sat in the opposition.

Protesters try to stop members of the G8 from attending the summit during the 27th G8 summit in Genoa, Italy by burning vehicles on the main route to the summit

Berlusconi's II foreign policy was characterised by a strong atlanticist trend, coupled with a positive attitude towards Putin's Russia and Erdogan's Turkey. Berlusconi advocated the accession of Turkey to the EU (notwithstanding the opposition of coalition partner Lega Nord) and at the 2002 Rome summit a NATO-Russia Council was set up. In UN reform issues, Italy took the lead of the Uniting for Consensus group, aiming at blocking a new German seat at the UN Security Council, while advocating for a unitary EU seat

The 27th G8 summit, held in Genoa in July 2001 represented the first international task of the government. The huge protest, mounting to 200,000 demonstrators from all over Europe, was countered by strong police repression.[105] Dozens were hospitalized following clashes with police and night raids by security forces on two schools housing activists and independent journalists. People taken into custody after the raids have alleged severe abuse at the hands of police. One demonstrator was shot dead.

Italian military forces in Iraq (Tallil)

Berlusconi made Italy take part in the Afghanistan war (2001) and in the US-led military coalition in Iraq in 2003, although always stressing that Italy was taking part in a "peace operation" and not in a war operation outside the UN framework (prohibited by art.11 of the Italian Constitution). The move was widely unpopular (especially in the case of Iraq), and was met by protests and manifestations.[106]

Italy's participation in the Iraq war, with the control over the Nassiriya sector was marked by the 2003 Nasiriyah bombing, in which 17 soldiers were killed, and by an incident with the US, concerning the death, by friendly fire, of a SISMI agent, Nicola Calipari, during the March 2005 rescue of Giuliana Sgrena, a reporter from Il Manifesto.

In labour law, the government introduced extensive flexibility through the 30/2003 Act. In the field of justice, a reform of the Right of self-defense Act was introduced to please the Lega Nord. The 2002 Bossi-Fini Act represented a restrictive approach to immigration, while the 2006 Fini-Giovanardi Act strengthened the prohibitionary approach to drug policy. A point-system driver's licence was introduced in 2003, and compulsory conscription was replaced by a professional army since 2005.[107] A constitutional reform including federalization and strengthened executive powers, passed in the Parliament, was rejected by a confirmation referendum in 2006.

Berlusconi's term was widely criticised for the approval of ad personam (personal) laws (usually named from the rapporteur minister or MP), especially in the field of justice,[108] such as:

  • the Frattini Act on conflict of interest;
  • the 2002 Cirami Act on the recusation of judges by the accused;
  • the 2003 Schifani Act, shielding the five highest state posts from criminal proceedings (declared unconstitutional in 2004);
  • the 2005 ex-Cirielli Act, about statute of limitations, especially applicable in the case of Cesare Previti, Berlusconi's lawyer;
  • the 2006 Pecorella Act, making it impossible for the public prosecutors to appeal a sentence of acquittal (partially declared unconstitutional in 2006);
  • the de-criminalisation of false accounting;
  • the Gasparri Act on the radio & TV market, making it easier for Mediaset to escape roof limits of advertisement collection, and considered not in compliance with EU Law by the EU Commission;
"Pace da tutti i balconi": peace flags hanging from windows in Milan, Italy (March 2003) as over 1,000,000 were hung against the Iraq War

Internally, Berlusconi set up the Mitrokhin Commission, directed by senator Paolo Guzzanti (Forza Italia), to investigate on alleged KGB ties by left-wing (then-opposition) politicians. The commission, closed in March 2006 without producing a final report, was very controversial, in particular after claiming that Romano Prodi, at that time Prime Minister of Italy, and former president of the European Commission, had been "KGB's man in Italy."[109] One of the Senator Guzzanti's informants, Mario Scaramella, was arrested at the end of December 2006 for defamation and arms-trade.

A new electoral law was established in 2005 by the Calderoli Law, and it is a form of semi-proportional representation. A party presents its own closed list and it can join other parties in alliances. The coalition which receives a plurality automatically wins at least 26 seats. Respecting this condition, seats are divided between coalitions, and subsequently to party lists, using the largest remainder method with a Hare quota. To receive seats, a party must overcome the barrage of 8% of the vote if it contests a single race, or of 3% of the vote if it runs in alliance. The change in the electoral law was strongly requested by the UDC, and finally agreed by Berlusconi, although criticised (including by political scientist Giovanni Sartori[110]) for its comeback to proportionalism and its timing, less than one year before general elections. Provision was also included, on the input of Mirko Tremaglia, to ease the vote of Italians resident abroad; paradoxically, Italians abroad proved crucial in securing centre-left victory in 2006 elections.[111]

The Union government of Romano Prodi (2006–2008)

[edit]

Romano Prodi, with a centre-left coalition (The Union), won the April 2006 general election by a very narrow margin due to Calderoli new electoral law, although Silvio Berlusconi first refused to acknowledge defeat.[112] Prodi's coalition proved to be extremely frail, as the two-vote margin in the Senate allowed almost any party in the coalition to veto legislation and political views inside the coalition spanned from the left-wing communist parties to the centrist Christian Democrats.[113]

Italian UNIFIL soldier on guard duty in Lebanon

In foreign policy, the Prodi II Cabinet continued the engagement in Afghanistan, under UN command, while withdrawing troops from post-invasion Iraq. The major effort of foreign minister Massimo D'Alema concerned the aftermath of the 2006 Lebanon War, being the first to offer troops to the UN for the constitution of the UNIFIL force, and assuming its command in February 2007.[114] Less than a year after he had won the elections, on 21 February 2007, Prodi tendered his resignation to Head of State Giorgio Napolitano after the government was defeated in the Senate by 2 ballots in a vote on foreign policy. On 24 February, President Napolitano invited him to return to office and face a vote of confidence.

Major causes of friction inside the coalition were, the 2006 pardon Act (criticised by the right and by the IDV party), a draft bill to establish civil unions (vetoed by Christian Democrats), Italy's continued involvement in Afghanistan (strongly opposed by left-wing parties), and finally the much publicized house-arrest of Clemente Mastella's wife (then a prominent politician at the regional level) over a corruption scandal. Mastella's party, UDEUR, held just enough seats in the Senate that his eventual decision to withdraw its support for the government meant the end of the legislature on 6 February 2008. Mastella, who also resigned from his office as Minister of Justice, cited the lack of personal support from his coalition partners' as one of the reasons behind his decision,[115] together with a proposed reform of the electoral system which would have made it difficult for small parties like his own to gain seats in the Italian Parliament.

Berlusconi's third term (2008–2011)

[edit]
Silvio Berlusconi, Prime Minister from 1994 to 1995, from 2001 to 2006 and from 2008 to 2011

Berlusconi won the last snap elections in 2008, with the People of Freedom party (fusion of his previous Forza Italia party and of Fini's Alleanza Nazionale) against Walter Veltroni of the Democratic Party.

The electoral campaign was waged by Berlusconi on the tones of criminal insecurity brought in the country by the 2006 pardon act, on the Naples waste management issue (although this will remain haunting the government in the following years), on the need to avoid bankruptcy of Alitalia or its takeover by Air France, on the need to limit the use of wiretapping by prosecutors and magistrates to avoid judicial prosecution of citizens, and on the abolition of the local council property tax.[116]

The 2008 Lodo Alfano Act (declared unconstitutional in 2009) granted immunity from prosecution to the four highest political offices in Italy, including Berlusconi. The 2009 Maroni decree (dubbed security package) includes a set of measures against criminality and illegal immigration, allowing for the use of private patrols (however with modest actual impact), criminalisation of stalking and compulsory incarceration for sex offenses. The 2009 fiscal shield provided for the regularisation of capitals illegally detained abroad;[117] local council property tax was abolished the same year.

A Treaty of Friendship was signed between Italy and Libya in 2008 in Benghazi. The treaty provides for the closure of colonial contentious, upon investments from Italy for 5 bln € in 20 years in infrastructure in Libya; for the mutual commitment not to act in a hostile way (criticised as not legally compliant with Italy's NATO obligations). Libyan Dictator Muammar al-Gaddafi subsequently visited Rome in June, July and August 2009, sparkling controversies for his initiatives and speeches. The Berlusconi government was criticised for the lack of firmness toward the Libyan autocracy and the lack of requests of respect of human rights.[118]

The case of Eluana Englaro (who had been comatose for 17 years) re-ignited the debate on the right to die in Italy. After the family of Eluana Englaro succeeded in having her right to die recognised by the judges and getting doctors to stop her forced feeding in the way established by the court, the government issued a legally controversial decree to stop the doctor from letting her die,[119] thrusting Italy into a constitutional crisis when the president Giorgio Napolitano refused to sign the decree.[120] The crisis was defused by Eluana's final death.

The L'Aquila prefecture (a government office) damaged by the earthquake

The 2009 L'Aquila earthquake caused the death of 308 persons and made about 65,000 homeless. Berlusconi made a point of honour of the reconstruction, although this was accompanied by criticisms, especially by the inhabitants of L'Aquila. The 35th G8 summit of 2009 was hastily moved from La Maddalena to L'Aquila in an effort to promote reconstruction.[121]

On 13 December 2009, Berlusconi was hit in the face with an alabaster[122] statuette of Milan Cathedral after a rally in Milan's Piazza Duomo, suffering facial and teeth injuries. The attacker was found to have a history of mental illness but no previous criminal record.[123][124] Between 2009 and 2010, Berlusconi was involved in a prostitution scandal leading to his divorce: he was revealed to having had close acquaintance with pre-18-year-old girls, and several call girls presented proofs of having had sex with him and having been paid for that. In one case, Berlusconi was accused of using his influence to obtain the release of a 17-year-old Moroccan girl, of his acquaintance, who was arrested for theft; Berlusconi pretended she was a close relative of Hosni Mubarak.[121]

In 2010, Berlusconi's party saw the splintering of Gianfranco Fini's new faction, which formed a parliamentary group and voted against him in a no-confidence vote on 14 December 2010. Berlusconi's government was able to avoid no-confidence thanks to support from sparse MPs, but lost a consistent majority in the lower Chamber.[125] A controversial university reform was passed in late 2010 and carries the name of Education minister Mariastella Gelmini. Berlusconi's already low international credibility fell further in 2011 during the European sovereign-debt crisis. Financial markets showed their disapproval through an unsustainable increase of spreads between Italian and German government bond yields. Berlusconi resigned in November 2011; he later blamed German chancellor Angela Merkel.[126]

Monti government (2011–2013)

[edit]

On 12 November 2011, Mario Monti was invited by President Giorgio Napolitano to form a new technocratic government following Berlusconi's resignation. Monti's government was made up of non-political figures but received very wide support in Parliament, both on the centre-right and on the centre-left; the Northern League was in opposition.[127] Monti proceeded to implement structural reforms and to cut government expenses.[128]

Coalition governments (2013–2021)

[edit]
The most important offices of the Italian State have pinned on the jacket, during the military parade of the Festa della Repubblica celebrated every 2 June, a cockade of Italy.

After the general election held on 24 and 25 February 2013, the centre-left alliance Italy Common Good led by the Democratic Party obtained a clear majority of seats in the Chamber of Deputies, thanks to a majority bonus that has effectively trebled the number of seats assigned to the winning force, while in the popular vote it narrowly defeated the centre-right alliance of former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi. Close behind, the new anti-establishment Five Star Movement of comedian Beppe Grillo became the third force, clearly ahead of the centrist coalition of outgoing Prime Minister Mario Monti. In the Senate, no political group or party won an outright majority, resulting in a hung parliament.[129]

On 22 April 2013, the President of the Republic, Giorgio Napolitano, after his re-election and consultations with the political forces, gave to the vice-secretary of the Democratic Party, Enrico Letta, the task of forming a government, because Pier Luigi Bersani, leader of the winning centre-left coalition Italy Common Good, could not form a government because it did not have a majority in the Senate.[130]

Asylum seekers arrive in Sicily, 2015. The Arab Spring and the Syrian War caused a migrant crisis that saw hundred of thousands of people seeking refuge by sea in Italy and other Mediterranean countries.

In the European migrant crisis of the 2010s, Italy was the entry point and leading destination for most asylum seekers entering the EU. From 2013 to 2018, the country took in over 700,000 migrants and refugees,[131] mainly from sub-Saharan Africa,[132] which caused strain on the public purse and a surge in the support for far-right or Eurosceptic political parties.[133][134]

Letta's cabinet lasted until 22 February 2014, as the government fell apart after the Democratic Party retired its support of Letta in favour of Matteo Renzi, the mayor of Florence and nicknamed il Rottamatore ("The Scrapper", or "The Wrecker"). Renzi succeeded Letta as prime minister at the head of a new grand coalition government with Democratic Party, New Centre-Right, Civic Choice, and a number of minor parties. The Renzi Cabinet is the youngest government of Italy up to date, with an average age of 47.[135] In addition, it is also the first in which the number of female ministers is equal to the number of male ministers.[136]

On 31 January 2015 Sergio Mattarella, judge of the Constitutional Court, former DC minister and former member of the PD, was elected President of the Italian Republic at the fourth ballot with 665 votes out of 1,009, with support from the government parties, Left Ecology Freedom, and non-party independents.[137][138] Mattarella was officially endorsed by the Democratic Party, after his name was put forward by the Prime Minister Matteo Renzi.[139] Mattarella replaced Giorgio Napolitano, who had served for nine years, the longest presidency in the history of the Italian Republic.

The Renzi cabinet had several new laws passed: labour was reformed (Jobs act), same-sex unions were recognized, and a new electoral system was approved (labelled Italicum). The latter, however, was eventually abolished by the Constitutional Court.[140] The government also tried to amend the Constitution to reform the composition and powers of the Parliament: however, when the voters were called to confirm or reject the reform through referendum, the majority (59%) voted against it.

Exhausted nurse takes a break in an Italian hospital during the COVID-19 emergency.

Renzi and his government resigned and President Mattarella appointed new prime minister, Renzi's minister of Foreign Affairs Paolo Gentiloni, who led Italy until the 2018 Italian general election, where the first party of Parliament become the anti-establishment Five Star Movement.

Through an alliance with Matteo Salvini's eurosceptical Lega Nord, Five Star Movement proposed to President Mattarella the appointment of Giuseppe Conte as new prime minister of a coalition government. After a failed attempt, caused by the veto of President Mattarella to the appointment of Paolo Savona as Minister of Finance,[141] Conte formed the new government (Conte I Cabinet). In August 2019, after the 2019 European Parliament election where Lega Nord exceeded the Five Star Movement, and the increase of the tension between the political parties, Lega Nord proposed a no-confidence vote versus Conte,[142] so the Prime Minister resigned. After new consultations, President Mattarella reappointed Conte as prime minister in a coalition government between the Five Star Movement and the Democratic Party, led by the new Secretary Nicola Zingaretti (Conte II Cabinet).

Mario Draghi, former president of the European Central Bank and Italian Prime Minister of a coalition government 2021-2022

In 2020, Italy was hit by the COVID-19 pandemic, along with several other countries. The Italian government implemented restrictive measures of social distancing and lockdown with the aim to slow down contagion. In January 2021, after some week of tension, the Conte II government lost the support of Italia Viva, the political party of former prime minister Renzi. Conte, after some attempts to remain at the head of government, was therefore forced to resign.

Draghi government (2021–2022)

[edit]

President Mattarella, because of the severe nature of the economic and pandemic crises, appointed a new prime minister of a grand coalition government, former president of the European Central Bank, Mario Draghi, who led a cabinet with the support of all political parties in Parliament, except the right-wing party Brothers of Italy.

Thanks to a massive influx of vaccine doses, it was possible to accelerate the vaccination campaign against COVID-19 pandemic (with 85% of the population over-12 vaccinated at the end of December 2021).[143] The National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) was also drawn up and started to apply, a document that established the intended use of the Next Generation EU funds and loans due to Italy.[144]

In January 2022, Italian President Sergio Mattarella was re-elected to serve a second consecutive seven-year term.[145] On 21 July 2022, following a government crisis which ended with FI, League and the M5S deciding to withdraw their support to the government, Prime Minister Draghi resigned. President Sergio Mattarella consequently dissolved the Parliament[146] and called a snap election, which resulted in the centre-right coalition gaining an absolute majority of seats.[147]

Meloni government (2022–present)

[edit]
Giorgia Meloni, Prime Minister since 2022

On 22 October 2022, Giorgia Meloni was sworn in as Italy's first female prime minister. Her Brothers of Italy party formed a right-wing government with the far-right League and centre-right Forza Italia of ex-prime minister Silvio Berlusconi.[148] The Meloni government is the 68th government of the Italian Republic. The government was announced on 21 October 2022 and was officially sworn in on the next day.[149][150] It was one of the fastest government formations in the history of the Italian Republic.[151] It was variously described as a shift to the political right,[152] as well as the first far-right-led coalition in Italy since World War II.[153][154]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
The Italian Republic is a established on 2 June 1946, when a national abolished the monarchy with 54.3 percent of valid votes favoring the republican form of government, ending the Kingdom of that had existed since unification in 1861. The new state, born amid the devastation of and Allied occupation, promulgated its on 1 January 1948, which enshrined principles of democracy, regional autonomy, and social welfare while prohibiting the reorganization of the Fascist party. Under Christian Democratic leadership, particularly , the Republic achieved rapid postwar reconstruction, joining in and becoming a founding member of the in 1951, which facilitated integration into Western institutions. The 1950s and 1960s witnessed the "," with annual industrial growth exceeding 8 percent from 1958 to 1963, transforming Italy from an agrarian economy into a major industrial power through state-directed investments in , automobiles, and consumer goods, though this boom exacerbated north-south divides and relied on undervalued and emigrants' remittances. Political fragmentation defined the era, with over 60 governments since 1948 amid , coalition dependencies, and tensions that marginalized communists despite their resistance role. The 1970s and 1980s brought the "Years of Lead," a period of involving leftist groups like the —responsible for over 14,000 attacks and the 1978 kidnapping and murder of Prime Minister —and right-wing neofascist bombings, such as the 1980 Bologna station massacre killing 85, fueled by ideological polarization, state infiltration allegations, and socioeconomic strains from oil shocks. The 1990s "" (Mani Pulite) investigations exposed systemic corruption in the "Tangentopoli" scandal, implicating thousands in bribery networks that collapsed the dominant parties, triggered over 5,000 arrests, and spurred electoral reforms toward , though corruption persisted amid judicial overreach critiques. Subsequent decades saw adoption in 1999, persistent high public debt exceeding 130 percent of GDP, influences, and migration pressures, underscoring the Republic's resilience amid chronic instability and uneven development.

Historical Background

Republican Traditions and the Risorgimento

Republican sentiments in Italy drew from a legacy of independent city-states during the and , including enduring examples like the , which maintained self-governance from 697 until its conquest by in 1797. These traditions emphasized civic participation and resistance to monarchical centralization, influencing later nationalist thinkers who sought to revive republican governance amid fragmentation under foreign and papal rule. The Risorgimento amplified these ideas through revolutionary organizations promoting a unified . founded in as a secret society to foster democratic republicanism and expel foreign dominators, attracting thousands of members who viewed monarchy as incompatible with true national sovereignty. Mazzini's vision contrasted with monarchist strategies, prioritizing moral regeneration and popular uprising over diplomatic alliances, though his insurrections, such as the 1833 Savoy revolt, largely failed due to lack of broad support and Austrian suppression. The 1848–1849 revolutions tested republican aspirations concretely. In Rome, following Pope Pius IX's flight amid unrest, the was proclaimed on February 9, 1849, with a constitution establishing universal male suffrage and ; a led by Mazzini, Carlo Armellini, and Aurelio Saffi governed until French intervention. commanded its defense during the Siege of Rome from April 30 to July 3, 1849, but after heavy losses—including 1,500 defenders killed—the assembly voted to surrender, marking a decisive republican defeat. This episode highlighted tactical weaknesses, as republican forces lacked international backing compared to monarchist Piedmont-Sardinia's alignments with Britain and . Despite such setbacks, republican ideals persisted, with figures like Garibaldi pragmatically allying with King for unification in 1861, subordinating anti-monarchical views to expel Austrian influence and complete territorial integration by 1870. The resulting adopted the Albertine Statute as a , yet underlying republican currents—evident in ongoing agitation by Mazzini's successors—foreshadowed 20th-century institutional shifts, underscoring a tension between federalist republicanism and Savoyard centralism that shaped debates over governance legitimacy.

Liberal Monarchy under the Albertine Statute

The Albertine Statute, granted on 4 March 1848 by King Charles Albert of Sardinia, became the foundational document for the Kingdom of Italy upon its proclamation on 17 March 1861, establishing a constitutional monarchy that endured until 1946. This rigid charter outlined a system where the king retained substantial executive authority, including supreme command of the armed forces, the power to declare war and peace, and the appointment and dismissal of ministers, who answered to the monarch rather than parliament. Legislative power was shared between the crown and a bicameral parliament consisting of the Chamber of Deputies, elected by qualified voters, and the Senate, whose members were appointed for life by the king from prominent figures in politics, military, and society. The statute guaranteed basic civil liberties such as equality before the law and limited freedoms of the press and assembly, but lacked mechanisms for formal amendment, leading to changes via ordinary legislation. Electoral laws under the statute initially restricted suffrage to literate males over 25 who paid a minimum annual tax of 40 lire, enfranchising only about 2.5% of the population—roughly 420,000 voters in 1861. Reforms expanded this base: in 1882, eligibility extended to all literate males over 21 paying at least 5 lire in taxes, increasing voters to over 3 million; by 1912, universal male suffrage for those over 30 was introduced, with proportional representation, raising participation to around 8 million. Political life was dominated by liberal elites practicing trasformismo, a strategy of co-opting opposition factions into governing coalitions to maintain stability, pioneered by during his premierships from 1876 to 1887. This system, while enabling longevity for figures like (premier 1887–1891 and 1893–1896) and (five terms between 1892 and 1921), fostered clientelism and corruption, sidelining mass-based parties until the early 20th century emergence of socialists and popular Catholics. Under the statute, governments navigated unification's aftermath, including the 1870 capture of Rome as capital, which resolved territorial completion but strained relations with the papacy through the unresolved "Roman Question." Crispi pursued aggressive colonial expansion, securing Eritrea and Somalia but suffering defeat at Adwa in 1896 against Ethiopia, exposing military weaknesses and triggering a banking crisis. Giolitti's eras emphasized industrial modernization in the north, state intervention in infrastructure like railways, and social reforms including accident insurance in 1898 and old-age pensions in 1919, yet failed to bridge the north-south economic divide, where southern latifundia persisted amid agrarian unrest. Emigration surged, with over 14 million Italians leaving between 1876 and 1915, primarily to the Americas, reflecting rural poverty and unemployment rates exceeding 20% in some regions. Social conditions remained challenging, with illiteracy rates above 70% in the south as late as 1900, fueling socialist growth—the , founded in 1892, gained traction through strikes and gained parliamentary seats by 1900. The 1912 under Giolitti aimed to integrate these forces, but intervention in 1915, despite initial neutrality, led to 600,000 Italian deaths and postwar disillusionment, exacerbating inflation and strikes during the 1919–1920 "Red Biennium." The liberal system's reliance on elite consensus proved inadequate against rising mass politics, around 0.45 in 1911—and irredentist tensions, culminating in governmental paralysis by 1922.

Fascist Dictatorship and World War II

Benito Mussolini, leader of the National Fascist Party, rose to power amid post-World War I social unrest and political instability in Italy. On October 28, 1922, fascist squads initiated the March on Rome, a demonstration threatening to seize the capital, prompting King Victor Emmanuel III to appoint Mussolini as prime minister on October 30 without significant violence. The Fascists capitalized on widespread dissatisfaction with liberal governments' handling of economic woes and strikes, positioning themselves as restorers of order. In the 1920s, Mussolini consolidated dictatorial control. The 1923 Acerbo Law awarded a two-thirds parliamentary majority to the leading party in elections, enabling Fascists to dominate the 1924 vote amid intimidation. The assassination of socialist deputy Giacomo Matteotti in December 1924 by fascists triggered a crisis, after which Mussolini's January 3, 1925, speech assumed responsibility for squadristi violence, effectively ending parliamentary opposition. By 1926, laws suppressed press freedom, banned opposition parties, and established a secret police; Mussolini adopted the title Il Duce and ruled as dictator. The 1929 Lateran Pacts with the Vatican resolved church-state tensions, granting the Holy See sovereignty over Vatican City in exchange for recognizing the Italian state. Fascist foreign policy grew aggressive, seeking imperial revival. Italy invaded Ethiopia on October 3, 1935, despite condemnation; economic sanctions were imposed but excluded key commodities like oil, proving ineffective in halting conquest by May 1936. Alignment with intensified via the 1936 Axis agreement and the May 22, 1939, , pledging mutual military assistance. Mussolini declared war on and Britain on June 10, 1940, with Italy unprepared: its lacked modern equipment, relying on outdated tactics and insufficient industry. Italian military efforts faltered early. The October 28, 1940, invasion of stalled in harsh terrain, requiring German intervention by spring 1941. In , forces under advanced into but were routed by British counteroffensives in 1941, straining Axis logistics. Allied landings in on July 10, 1943, exposed regime weaknesses; Mussolini was dismissed by the king on July 25 and arrested. The Badoglio government signed an armistice with Allies on September 8, 1943, but German forces occupied , rescuing Mussolini to establish the (Republic of Salò) as a from September 23, 1943, to April 1945. The armistice ignited a civil war from 1943 to 1945 between partisans—comprising communists, socialists, and monarchists—and fascist loyalists backed by Germans. Partisan bands, numbering over 200,000 by 1945, conducted sabotage and liberated areas, contributing to Allied advances. German reprisals, like the Marzabotto massacre killing 770 civilians in September 1944, underscored occupation brutality. Mussolini's execution by partisans on April 28, 1945, near Lake Como marked fascism's collapse; Allied forces liberated northern Italy by May, ending the conflict with Italy's unconditional surrender. The war caused approximately 450,000 Italian military deaths and devastated infrastructure, paving the way for postwar institutional overhaul.

Establishment of the Republic

The 1946 Institutional Referendum

The 1946 institutional referendum was held on June 2, 1946, in the Kingdom of Italy to determine whether the country would transition to a republic or retain the constitutional monarchy, marking the first national vote under universal suffrage that included women for the first time. The referendum occurred concurrently with elections for a Constituent Assembly tasked with drafting a new constitution, amid the post-World War II transition from fascist rule and Allied occupation. The monarchy's legitimacy had been severely undermined by King Victor Emmanuel III's decision to appoint Benito Mussolini as prime minister in 1922 and to remain in power during the fascist dictatorship, which included Italy's entry into the war on the Axis side, leading anti-monarchist forces—particularly from the left and center-left parties—to demand an end to the House of Savoy's rule. In a bid to rehabilitate the institution, abdicated on May 9, 1946, elevating his son Umberto II to the throne as the last King of Italy. reached approximately 89% of the eligible 25 million, with ballots clearly distinguishing the republican option (a schematic of a symbol crossed out) from the monarchist one (the ). The prevailed with 12,718,641 votes (54.27%) against 10,718,502 for the (45.73%), out of 23,437,143 valid ballots, though over 1.5 million were invalid or blank. Support for the was strongest in the industrial north and center (e.g., over 70% in and ), reflecting resentment over the 's fascist associations and wartime failures, while the agrarian south and islands favored retention of the (e.g., over 70% monarchist in and ), where dynastic loyalty and fears of radical change persisted. Results were initially provisional, with delays in southern counting fueling monarchist claims of irregularities and fraud, prompting Umberto II to protest to the government and appeal to the . On June 11, 1946, the Court proclaimed the official outcome in favor of the republic, rejecting challenges due to lack of substantiated evidence of systemic manipulation despite isolated incidents of violence and intimidation reported in monarchist strongholds. Umberto II departed for exile in on June 13 without formally abdicating, declaring the vote unconstitutional but avoiding civil conflict; the republican government under Prime Minister then enacted Decree No. 164, abolishing the monarchy and establishing the Italian Republic effective June 18, 1946, with as provisional head of state. This narrow victory reflected deep societal divisions but decisively ended 85 years of rule, paving the way for constitutional amid ongoing Allied oversight and the looming 1947 peace treaty.

Constitutional Assembly and the 1948 Constitution

The was elected on June 2, 1946, concurrently with the institutional referendum that established the Republic, comprising 556 deputies chosen by across 32 constituencies, excluding areas under Allied like and the . The Christian Democratic Party (DC) emerged as the largest force with approximately 35% of the vote, securing 207 seats, while the Popular Democratic Front—uniting the (PCI) and (PSI)—obtained around 31%, translating to 104 seats for the PCI and 115 for the PSI, reflecting a balance between centrist, Catholic-inspired forces and the Marxist left amid post-fascist reconstruction. Smaller liberal and republican groups filled the remainder, ensuring no single ideology dominated outright, which shaped the drafting as a negotiated compromise rather than imposition. Tasked with framing a new fundamental charter to replace the Albertine Statute's monarchical framework, the Assembly convened under provisional President —who also served as and interim —beginning substantive work in July 1946 with the formation of specialized subcommittees on rights, organization, and economic provisions. Over 18 months, debates addressed core tensions: the DC advocated limited with checks against radicalism, drawing from interwar failures, while PCI and delegates pushed for expansive social guarantees, including labor's foundational role and public economic intervention, concessions extracted due to their combined parliamentary weight despite lacking majority. A 75-member drafting committee synthesized inputs, refining texts through multiple readings, with key compromises evident in provisions balancing individual liberties against collective duties, informed by Allied occupation oversight that deterred overtly socialist structures. The final text, approved by secret ballot on December 22, 1947, with 453 votes in favor and 62 against—primarily from monarchist and far-right holdouts—declared a " founded on labour," enshrining inviolable , parliamentary supremacy with a bicameral , a ceremonial , judicial independence via a Constitutional Court, and regional autonomies to accommodate 's north-south divides. Promulgated by De Gasperi on December 27, 1947, and entering force on January 1, 1948, the Constitution's rigid amendment process and emphasis on antifascist principles reflected causal lessons from , prioritizing institutional stability over ideological purity, though leftist influences persisted in socioeconomic articles that later fueled debates on implementation fidelity. This framework, while compromising on Marxist goals like nationalizations, embedded worker protections that pragmatic governance often subordinated to market realities in subsequent decades.

Early Republican Governments and Cold War Integration

The early governments of the Italian Republic were dominated by the Christian Democratic Party (DC), led by Prime Minister Alcide De Gasperi, who held office from 1945 until 1953 across multiple coalition cabinets. Following the April 18, 1948, general elections, the DC achieved a decisive victory with approximately 48% of the popular vote, securing an absolute majority of seats in the Chamber of Deputies and enabling the formation of centrist governments that excluded the Italian Communist Party (PCI) and its allies. These coalitions typically included moderate parties such as the Italian Socialist Workers' Party (later the Italian Democratic Socialist Party) and liberals, reflecting De Gasperi's strategy of broad consensus to stabilize the fragile post-war democracy amid threats from both communist insurgencies and neo-fascist elements. De Gasperi's leadership emphasized administrative continuity, anti-communist policies, and economic liberalization, which laid the groundwork for Italy's integration into Western institutions. Economic recovery was bolstered significantly by the , through which Italy received approximately $1.2 billion in aid between 1948 and 1952, equivalent to about 2.3% of its annual GDP on average. This assistance, channeled primarily into , , and industrial sectors, facilitated the rebuilding of war-damaged facilities and spurred initial growth, with investments in like roads and energy production yielding measurable productivity gains. Empirical analyses indicate that funds accelerated Italy's post-war reconstruction by enhancing and technical expertise transfers, countering the domestic economic disruptions caused by wartime devastation and . De Gasperi's government prioritized efficient allocation of these resources, often in coordination with U.S. advisors, to prioritize export-oriented industries and avert communist influence in labor unions and regional administrations. In the context of the , Italy's alignment with the Western bloc was cemented by its founding membership in the on April 4, 1949, alongside eleven other nations. This decision, driven by De Gasperi's pro-Western orientation, positioned Italy as a key southern flank defender against Soviet expansionism, hosting NATO commands and contributing to collective defense despite its Mediterranean geography lacking direct Atlantic access. The move was motivated by geopolitical necessities, including countering the PCI's substantial electoral strength (around 31% in 1948) and potential Soviet sympathies, with U.S. diplomatic pressure reinforcing Italy's rejection of neutralism or Eastern alignment. Subsequent integrations, such as joining the in 1951, further embedded Italy in transatlantic structures, fostering security guarantees and economic interdependence that marginalized domestic communist challenges during the early republican phase.

The First Republic (1948–1994)

Post-War Reconstruction and Economic Boom (1948–1969)

Under the leadership of Christian Democrat , who held office from 1945 to 1953 across eight coalition governments, prioritized political stability and economic recovery in the immediate post-war years. De Gasperi's centrist coalitions, supported by U.S. aid and anti-communist policies, facilitated the integration of into Western institutions, including in 1949 and the in 1951. The 1948 general elections, resulting in a decisive victory for the Christian Democrats, marginalized communist influence and enabled focused reconstruction efforts. Italy received approximately $1.2 billion in aid between 1948 and 1952, ranking as one of the largest recipients, which funded infrastructure rebuilding, public works, and industrial modernization. This aid, equivalent to about 2-3% of annual GDP, complemented domestic initiatives like the maintenance of state-controlled enterprises under the Institute for Industrial Reconstruction (IRI) while promoting market-oriented reforms. Agrarian reform, enacted via the 1950 Stralcio laws, targeted latifundia in , , and , expropriating around 800,000 hectares by the mid-1950s and redistributing them to smallholders to boost productivity and counter rural unrest. These measures addressed war devastation, where industrial production had fallen to 40% of pre-war levels by 1945, laying groundwork for sustained recovery. The period from 1950 to 1963 marked the "economic miracle" (miracolo economico), with real GDP growing at an average annual rate of 5.9%, driven by industrialization, expansion, and . Industrial output surged, particularly in northern regions like the "industrial triangle" of Milan-Turin-Genoa, with key sectors including automobiles (e.g., Fiat's of models like the 500 in 1957), , chemicals, and machinery. Exports, fueled by undervalued and European demand, rose sharply; by the early , manufactured goods accounted for over 80% of exports, transforming from an agrarian —where employed 40% of the workforce in 1950—to one dominated by industry and services. Urbanization accelerated as over 3 million southerners migrated northward between 1955 and 1965, supplying labor to factories and reducing agricultural employment from 42% to 22% of the workforce. Peak growth occurred from 1958 to 1963, with industrial expansion exceeding 8% annually, supported by infrastructure investments like the Autostrada del Sole highway (1956 onward) and entry into the in 1957, which opened markets and encouraged competitiveness. Wage moderation, state intervention, and family-owned firms' agility contributed to productivity gains, though southern disparities persisted, with per capita income in the Mezzogiorno lagging at half the northern level by 1960. By the late , the boom showed strains, including and labor unrest precursors, but the era solidified 's transition to a modern industrial economy, with GDP per capita rising from $350 in 1950 to over $1,000 by 1969 (in constant dollars). This growth, while aided by external factors like U.S. assistance, stemmed primarily from domestic policies emphasizing export-led industrialization and , averting the communist threats that plagued other war-torn nations.

Years of Lead and Domestic Terrorism (1969–1980s)

The Years of Lead, spanning from 1969 to the early 1980s, marked a period of widespread domestic terrorism in Italy characterized by bombings, assassinations, and kidnappings carried out by both far-left and far-right extremist groups amid intense political polarization following the 1968 student and worker protests. This violence, often framed as part of a "strategy of tension" by right-wing actors to destabilize democratic institutions and provoke public demand for authoritarian measures, resulted in hundreds of fatalities and thousands of injuries, exacerbating social divisions in a country already strained by economic stagnation and Cold War influences. Left-wing groups, inspired by Marxist-Leninist ideologies, focused on targeted killings of state officials and capitalists, while right-wing neofascist factions conducted indiscriminate bombings to attribute blame to communists and justify crackdowns. The era began with the on December 12, 1969, when a device exploded inside the Banca Nazionale dell'Agricoltura in , killing 17 people and injuring 84; the attack, initially misattributed to anarchists, was later linked to neofascist elements aiming to sow chaos and discredit the left. Far-left terrorism escalated with the formation of the (Brigate Rosse) in 1970, which conducted over 14,000 attacks by the decade's end, including assassinations of judges, policemen, and industrialists to dismantle the capitalist state. A pivotal event was the kidnapping of former on March 16, 1978, by Red Brigades militants in , where his five bodyguards were killed during the ambush; Moro was held captive for 55 days before his execution on May 9, 1978, in an apartment, with his body dumped in a car trunk to protest his role in negotiating a potential Communist inclusion in government. Right-wing violence persisted, exemplified by the August 2, 1980, bombing at Bologna's central railway station, where a in a killed 85 civilians and injured over 200, the deadliest single attack of the period, perpetrated by members of the (NAR), a neofascist group responsible for over 100 acts between 1978 and 1982. The NAR and similar outfits targeted left-wing symbols, such as the 1979 storming of Radio Città Futura, but their broader aim aligned with efforts to exploit public fear for political gain. Government countermeasures, including enhanced police coordination and the 1979-1980 "pentiti" laws offering leniency to repentant terrorists for testimony, led to mass arrests—such as leader in 1976 and NAR figures by 1982—contributing to the decline of organized terrorism by the mid-1980s. Despite revelations of covert networks like involving units, judicial inquiries confirmed primary responsibility lay with extremist militants rather than proven state orchestration, though tolerance or infiltration by security services remains debated among historians.

Craxi Era: Socialist Reforms and Mounting Corruption (1980s)

, leader of the () since 1976, formed Italy's 44th post-war government on August 4, 1983, becoming the first Socialist and heading a coalition that included Christian Democrats, Socialists, Republicans, Liberals, and Social Democrats. This administration lasted until March 1987, marking the longest-serving postwar government at the time, during which Craxi sought to modernize public administration and assert executive authority amid ongoing political fragmentation. Key domestic reforms under Craxi included the revision of the 1929 Lateran Treaty via a new concordat signed on February 18, 1984, between Italy and the , which abolished Catholicism's status as the , removed from compulsory schooling, and ended automatic civil validity of Catholic marriages while maintaining financial support for the Church through an 8 tax allocation option. To combat double-digit inflation averaging over 12 percent prior to his tenure, Craxi's government issued decrees in February 1984 scaling back the scala mobile—the automatic wage indexation system—prompting a failed Communist-backed in June 1985 that upheld the cuts, contributing to inflation's decline to 8.5 percent by mid-decade. Economically, the Craxi era coincided with robust growth, with GDP expanding by 2.6 percent in 1984 and sustaining around 2.3 percent annually through 1986, supported by austerity measures such as tax hikes and public spending restraints that improved fiscal discipline despite resistance from trade unions and opposition parties. These policies facilitated Italy's alignment with requirements and bolstered competitiveness, though state-owned enterprises remained dominant and inefficient. Parallel to these reforms, corruption within the political class intensified, with the PSI under Craxi increasingly entangled in a system of kickbacks (tangenti) from public contracts, where bribes reportedly funneled tens of millions annually to parties, including an estimated 50 percent share to Socialists in Milan alone. Early allegations surfaced in the mid-1980s, eroding coalition support and culminating in Craxi's resignation on March 28, 1987, amid probes into illicit party financing, though systemic graft—rooted in partitocrazia and clientelism—predated and outlasted his premiership, foreshadowing the 1992 Mani Pulite investigations.

Tangentopoli Scandal and the End of the First Republic (1992–1994)

The Tangentopoli scandal, known as Mani Pulite ("Clean Hands"), originated on 17 February 1992 when Milan prosecutors, led by Antonio Di Pietro, arrested Mario Chiesa, a local Socialist Party (Partito Socialista Italiano, PSI) official, for accepting a bribe in connection with public works contracts. Chiesa's subsequent cooperation triggered a cascade of confessions, exposing a pervasive system of tangenti (kickbacks) where politicians across parties demanded 5-10% of contract values from businesses in exchange for awarding public tenders, a practice entrenched since the post-war era. The investigation rapidly expanded beyond Milan, implicating over 5,000 suspects, including more than half of Italy's parliament members at its peak and leading to the dissolution of over 400 municipal councils due to corruption. Key figures faced severe consequences, with six former prime ministers and several thousand local administrators under scrutiny by 1993. High-profile cases included the suicide of president Gabriele Cagliari on 20 July 1993 while in custody, amid broader reports of dozens of suicides linked to the probes. PSI leader , accused following the December 1992 local elections, resigned his party role and fled to in April 1994 to evade arrest; he received multiple definitive sentences totaling over 27 years but died in exile on 19 January 2000 without serving time. Di Pietro's team secured numerous convictions, though the operation's intensity waned after his resignation on 6 December 1994 amid counter-allegations. The scandal dismantled the governing coalition, particularly devastating the Christian Democrats (Democrazia Cristiana, DC) and , which had dominated Italian politics since 1948 through clientelistic networks and state subsidies. In the 5-6 April 1992 general elections, the DC retained plurality with 29.7% of the vote but formed fragile governments amid ongoing revelations. By 1993, public outrage fueled an referendum on 18 April, replacing with a mixed system favoring , paving the way for the 27-28 March 1994 elections where traditional parties collapsed—DC and garnered under 7% combined—marking the effective end of the First Republic and the rise of new forces like Forza Italia. The four smaller coalition partners (PSDI, PRI, PLI) also vanished from the political landscape.

Transition to the Second Republic

Electoral Reforms and Political Realignment (1993–1994)

The April 18, 1993, referendum marked a pivotal shift in Italy's electoral framework, with voters approving the partial abrogation of the 1948 Senate electoral law (Law No. 29), which had enshrined pure proportional representation. This outcome, supported by approximately 83% of valid votes amid high turnout exceeding 80%, compelled Parliament to abandon proportional systems in favor of majoritarian elements, driven by public demand for accountability amid the ongoing Mani Pulite corruption probes that had ensnared leaders from dominant parties like the Christian Democrats (DC) and Socialists (PSI). In response, on August 4, 1993, lawmakers enacted the Mattarellum electoral law, named after its proponent Sergio Mattarella, establishing a hybrid system: for the Chamber of Deputies, 75% of seats (475) allocated via first-past-the-post in single-member districts and 25% (155) proportionally from national party lists; for the Senate, 232 single-member districts and 83 proportional seats from regional lists. This reform aimed to foster bipolar competition and stronger government majorities, replacing fragmented proportional outcomes that had perpetuated coalition instability since 1948. The reforms unfolded against the disintegration of Italy's postwar party establishment, accelerated by investigations starting in 1992, which led to over 5,000 arrests and indictments by 1994, including DC secretary and PSI leader , eroding public trust and vote shares for traditional centrists. Surviving DC factions reorganized into the centrist Italian People's Party (PPI) in early 1994, while the post-fascist rebranded as the more moderate National Alliance (AN) under , capturing southern conservative voters. Northern regionalism gained traction through the , founded earlier but pivotal in 1993–94 for advocating federalism amid economic disparities, securing around 8% nationally in subsequent polls. Media magnate launched Forza Italia on January 30, 1994, positioning it as a catch-all conservative force emphasizing liberalization and anti-corruption, rapidly building a network via television appeals. These developments crystallized in the March 27–28, 1994, general elections, the first under Mattarellum, which rewarded coalition discipline in districts. The right-wing Pole of Freedoms alliance (Forza Italia, in the north, AN in the south) captured 49.3% of the proportional vote, translating to 366 of 630 Chamber seats and a Senate majority, with Forza Italia alone gaining 21% of votes and 30% of proportional seats. The center-left , led by the (PDS), secured 34.3% but lagged in districts, while the centrist Pact for Italy splintered. This realignment dismantled the dominance, ushering in bipolar dynamics though initial governments proved volatile.

Initial Instability and Berlusconi's Rise (1994–1996)

The 1994 Italian general elections, conducted on 27–28 March under the newly introduced Mattarellum system—which allocated 75% of seats via first-past-the-post and 25% proportionally—reflected the fragmentation of the traditional in the wake of the Tangentopoli corruption investigations. , a Milan-based media magnate who established the Forza Italia movement on 18 January 1994 as a liberal-conservative force emphasizing anti-corruption, tax cuts, and private enterprise, rapidly built electoral coalitions. In the north and center, Forza Italia allied with Umberto Bossi's Northern League to form the Pole of Freedoms; in the south, it partnered with Gianfranco Fini's National Alliance (a rebranded successor to the ). This center-right bloc secured 366 of 630 seats in the and a majority, with proportional vote shares yielding Forza Italia 21% nationally despite its novelty. Berlusconi was appointed on 10 May , forming Italy's 53rd postwar cabinet with 26 ministers drawn largely from his partners. His government prioritized , of state assets, and pension system adjustments amid high public debt (over 110% of GDP) and efforts to qualify for European Monetary Union convergence criteria. However, internal frictions emerged quickly, exacerbated by Berlusconi's concurrent legal scrutiny over alleged in his business dealings—charges that critics, including judicial figures, portrayed as conflicts of interest between his media empire and policy influence, though supporters dismissed them as politically motivated. Coalition discord peaked over and a proposed reform scaling back benefits, which the Northern League viewed as insufficiently devolutionary to northern regions. On 6 December 1994, Bossi announced the League's withdrawal, citing unmet demands for greater autonomy and opposition to perceived centralizing tendencies. Lacking a parliamentary majority, Berlusconi tendered his resignation to President on 22 December 1994, averting a formal no-confidence vote but ending his term after just 209 days—the shortest postwar government to that point. This collapse underscored the volatility of Italy's nascent bipolar party alignments, where ideological overlaps masked regional and programmatic divides. Scalfaro subsequently tasked , a career technocrat who had served as director general (1979–1994) and Berlusconi's treasury minister, with forming an interim non-partisan government on 17 January 1995. Backed initially by the Northern League, post-communist , and independents, Din's cabinet—comprising economists and officials rather than politicians—enacted austerity measures, including a 1995 budget with 35 trillion lire in spending cuts, tax hikes on high earners, and structural reforms to pensions and public administration to align with fiscal targets (deficit below 3% of GDP). These steps stabilized markets and advanced EU integration but faced resistance over their regressive impacts on welfare. Dinì's administration endured until May 1996, surviving a 1995 League pullout and passing limited electoral tweaks, but it failed to forge a lasting partisan consensus or avert further deadlock. Resignation followed parliamentary refusal to endorse broader reforms, triggering snap elections in April 1996 that shifted power to a center-left alliance under Romano Prodi. The 1994–1996 interlude thus exemplified transitional chaos: Berlusconi's meteoric ascent disrupted entrenched elites but exposed coalition brittleness, while technocratic rule provided breathing room for economic stabilization without resolving underlying partisan distrust rooted in the prior republic's discredit.

The Second Republic (1996–Present)

Center-Left Governments and Economic Challenges (1996–2001)

The center-left Olive Tree coalition, led by Romano Prodi, assumed power following the general elections on April 21, 1996, marking the first national victory for the post-communist left in Italy's republican history. The government's primary economic objective was to fulfill the Maastricht criteria for Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) entry, requiring a budget deficit below 3% of GDP, inflation convergence, and a declining debt-to-GDP trajectory. Prodi implemented stringent austerity measures, including spending cuts and tax adjustments, which reduced the fiscal deficit from approximately 7% of GDP in 1996 to 2.7% in 1997, enabling Italy's participation in the initial eurozone launch on January 1, 1999. These fiscal consolidations were complemented by privatization efforts, which generated revenues to curb borrowing; notable sales included stakes in state-controlled firms like Telecom Italia and ENEL, aligning with broader structural liberalization to enhance competitiveness. However, Italy's public debt-to-GDP ratio remained elevated, hovering around 120% in the late 1990s, necessitating reliance on one-off measures and favorable global conditions rather than deep productivity gains. Economic growth averaged modest levels, with annual GDP expansion at 1.7% in 1996 and 2.0% in 1997, while structural unemployment persisted at over 11%, exacerbated by rigid labor markets and southern regional disparities. Pension system adjustments, building on prior 1995 reforms, shifted toward contributory principles but faced resistance, limiting long-term sustainability improvements. Prodi's administration collapsed on October 9, 1998, after losing a confidence vote by three ballots due to withdrawal of support from the over budget austerity. , leader of the , formed a new on October 21, 1998, continuing EMU commitments and pursuing incremental reforms, including NATO involvement in the 1999 Kosovo intervention, which strained domestic consensus. D'Alema's tenure ended in April 2000 following poor regional election results, succeeded by Giuliano Amato's interim from April 25, 2000, to June 11, 2001, which maintained fiscal prudence amid ongoing challenges like subdued and stagnation. Despite achieving adoption—a milestone credited to cross-party fiscal discipline—the period underscored persistent vulnerabilities: debt reduction slowed to 108.2% of GDP by , growth decelerated post-2000, and declined only marginally to around 9%, reflecting insufficient structural overhauls in labor, justice, and sectors. Critics, including economists, noted that while short-term convergence succeeded, underlying causal factors like regulatory burdens and low failed to be addressed, sowing seeds for future stagnation. The center-left's instability, with three prime ministers in five years, highlighted fragilities that undermined bold reforms, culminating in electoral defeat to Silvio Berlusconi's center-right alliance in May .

Berlusconi's Center-Right Dominance (2001–2006)

Silvio Berlusconi's center-right , known as the House of Freedoms (Casa delle Libertà), secured a decisive victory in the Italian general election held on 13 May 2001, capturing approximately 45% of the vote in the and obtaining majorities in both houses of . The , comprising Forza Italia, National Alliance, , and the Christian Democratic Centre-United Christian Democrats, defeated the center-left Olive Tree alliance led by Francesco Rutelli, who conceded defeat shortly after the polls closed. This outcome enabled Berlusconi to form Italy's 57th postwar government on 11 June 2001, marking the first time since that a completed a full five-year term without collapsing. The government's legislative agenda emphasized economic liberalization, tax reductions, and structural reforms amid persistent high public debt exceeding 100% of GDP and sluggish growth. Key measures included the Biagi Law (Legislative Decree 276/2003), which promoted labor market flexibility by introducing temporary contracts and reducing rigidities in hiring and firing, aiming to boost employment. Complementary reforms addressed pensions via the 2004 enabling law (No. 243), transitioning toward a notional defined contribution system, incentivizing deferred retirement, and linking benefits more closely to contributions to curb long-term fiscal burdens. Immigration policy tightened under the Bossi-Fini Law (No. 189/2002), criminalizing and mandating repatriation, while imposing penalties on employers hiring undocumented workers, reflecting Lega Nord's influence and responding to rising inflows. Economic performance under the administration showed modest gains but lagged European peers, with annual GDP growth averaging around 1% from to 2005—1.8% in , 0.3% in , 0.0% in 2003, 1.5% in 2004, and 0.8% in 2005—hampered by global slowdowns, adoption rigidities, and incomplete structural changes. fell slightly from 9.5% in to 7.7% by 2006, partly due to labor reforms and , though youth unemployment remained elevated. Tax cuts, including reductions in income and corporate rates, were implemented but fell short of promised flat-tax ambitions, contributing to fiscal deficits that widened to 3.4% of GDP by 2005. reforms faced repeated setbacks amid clashes with the , which Berlusconi accused of ; a constitutional devolved powers to regions but failed to overhaul the overloaded court system. In foreign affairs, Berlusconi aligned Italy closely with the , supporting operations in post-9/11 and committing 3,000 troops to the coalition from July 2003 until gradual withdrawal began in 2005, despite widespread domestic protests and parliamentary divisions. This pro-Atlantic stance strained relations with partners opposing the invasion, yet Berlusconi maintained Italy's commitments and advocated for Mediterranean dialogues. The government's durability stemmed from coalition discipline and Berlusconi's media influence via , though it weathered scandals, including corruption probes against allies and personal legal entanglements often portrayed in left-leaning outlets as evidence of systemic favoritism rather than isolated misconduct. By 2006, accumulated and voter fatigue led to a narrow electoral defeat to Romano Prodi's center-left union.

Fragile Union and Prodi's Second Term (2006–2008)

The 2006 Italian general election, held on 9–10 April, resulted in a narrow victory for the centre-left L'Unione coalition led by Romano Prodi, which secured majorities in both chambers of Parliament against Silvio Berlusconi's centre-right House of Freedoms coalition. In the Senate, L'Unione held a slim two-seat advantage with 158 seats to the opposition's 156 among elected senators. This razor-thin margin, combined with the coalition's composition of nine parties spanning social democrats to communists, foreshadowed the government's inherent instability from the outset. Prodi formed his second cabinet on 17 May 2006, including representatives from the , , and smaller allies such as the , the , and the UDEUR Populars. The government's policy agenda emphasized fiscal consolidation to meet EU stability criteria, welfare reforms including adjustments, and a shift in foreign policy, notably the withdrawal of Italian troops from completed by November 2006 while maintaining commitment to UN-mandated operations in . It also contributed to a multinational force in amid the 2006 Israel-Lebanon conflict. However, ideological divisions hampered legislative progress, with frequent protests from coalition flanks over labor market flexibility and budget austerity measures. Internal fractures intensified in early 2007, when the government narrowly survived a parliamentary defeat on a motion in February, retaining power only after passing subsequent confidence votes. Economic stagnation, with GDP growth averaging under 2% annually, and rising public debt exacerbated tensions, as coalition partners clashed over tax policies and public spending cuts proposed in the 2008 budget. The decisive crisis erupted in January 2008 when Justice Minister Clemente Mastella, leader of the UDEUR party, resigned following his wife's arrest on charges and his own placement under investigation; he subsequently withdrew UDEUR's support, depriving the government of its one-vote majority. On 24 January 2008, Prodi's administration lost a confidence vote in the by 161 to 156, prompting his after 20 months in office and triggering early elections. This collapse underscored the vulnerabilities of oversized coalitions in Italy's fragmented political landscape, where often yields governments reliant on disparate ideological groups, leading to policy paralysis and short tenures.

Global Financial Crisis and Berlusconi's Final Term (2008–2011)

The global financial crisis, originating from the U.S. subprime mortgage collapse and exacerbated by the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy on September 15, 2008, reached Italy amid pre-existing high public debt levels exceeding 100% of GDP. Italy's banking sector demonstrated relative stability, with no major institutions failing due to limited exposure to toxic assets and conservative regulatory practices, as credit default swap spreads for Italian banks remained moderate compared to peers. Unemployment stood at a record low of 6.25% entering the crisis, but GDP contracted sharply, with the debt-to-GDP ratio surging from 106.1% in 2008 to 115.8% in 2009 amid fiscal deficits peaking at 5.4% of GDP. Silvio Berlusconi's center-right government, re-elected in April 2008, initially responded with expansionary measures including support for banks and large enterprises through liquidity provisions and guarantees, alongside public spending cuts to contain deficits. The administration adopted an "anti-crisis decree" in late 2008, extending tax credits and short-time work schemes (cassa integrazione) to preserve , which mitigated immediate unemployment spikes but failed to address underlying stagnation. turned more restrictive by 2009, prioritizing compliance over aggressive stimulus, a choice that preserved short-term financial stability but contributed to prolonged as private investment faltered. Critics, including officials, noted insufficient structural reforms to liberalize labor markets or reduce guild protections, which hindered growth amid rising bond yields. By 2010–2011, the crisis evolved into a sovereign contagion within the , with Italian 10-year bond spreads over German bunds exceeding 300 basis points, signaling investor flight and fears of default despite Italy's primary surpluses. Public ballooned toward 120% of GDP, climbed above 8%, and GDP stagnated, exposing vulnerabilities from chronic low growth averaging under 1% annually pre-crisis. Berlusconi's government faced accusations of obfuscating fiscal data through accounting maneuvers, delaying pension and tax reforms demanded by the and IMF. Market pressures intensified in summer 2011, with declines and downgrades, prompting EU leaders to urge deeper . Political instability compounded economic woes, as coalition fractures emerged over reform implementation. On November 8, 2011, Berlusconi's parliamentary majority eroded after a key vote on austerity measures, leading him to announce resignation contingent on passage of EU-mandated budget reforms including pension adjustments and spending cuts. The lower house approved the package on November 12, after which Berlusconi formally resigned on November 16, paving the way for technocratic . This marked the end of Berlusconi's fourth and final term, amid consensus that delayed structural changes had amplified Italy's crisis exposure despite initial banking resilience.

Technocratic and Grand Coalition Governments (2011–2018)

In November 2011, amid the European sovereign debt crisis that threatened Italy's financial stability, resigned as prime minister after losing parliamentary support, paving the way for economist to form a technocratic government on November 16. Composed entirely of non-partisan experts without elected politicians, the cabinet received external backing from major parties including Berlusconi's (PdL), the Democratic Party (PD), and the Union of the Centre (UDC) to implement emergency measures demanded by international markets and the . Key policies included a €30 billion austerity package raising property taxes, increasing the to 67 by 2018, and liberalizing labor markets through the controversial Fornero reform, which facilitated easier hiring and firing but sparked widespread protests over reduced worker protections. The government lasted until the February 2013 general elections, during which it lost formal support but continued in a caretaker role until Enrico Letta's administration took office. Following inconclusive 2013 elections that left no clear majority, of the PD formed a government on April 28, sworn in with support from the PD, PdL, and Monti-backed , marking a rare left-right to address ongoing economic woes and EU fiscal requirements. , a PdL splinter faction leader, served as , symbolizing the coalition's cross-aisle nature aimed at stability rather than ideological purity. The Letta cabinet focused on incremental reforms, including partial labor market adjustments and public spending cuts totaling €10 billion annually, but internal tensions over austerity's social costs and PdL demands for leniency in Berlusconi's tax fraud trial eroded unity. Letta's tenure ended prematurely on February 14, 2014, when PD leader Matteo Renzi forced his resignation via a party vote, citing insufficient reform pace amid youth unemployment exceeding 40% and GDP contraction of 1.9% in 2013. Renzi assumed the premiership on February 22, 2014, leading a reconfigured with the PD dominant and allies from the New Centre-Right (NCD, PdL successor) and others, emphasizing structural changes to boost competitiveness. The flagship Jobs Act, enacted in 2015, dismantled Article 18 protections against arbitrary dismissals for new hires, subsidized youth employment contracts, and aimed to reduce dual labor market rigidities, though critics argued it weakened without proportionally cutting , which hovered around 12% by 2015. Additional measures included the "Buona Scuola" education overhaul investing €3.5 billion in infrastructure and teacher evaluations, and a constitutional reform package to abolish perfect by reducing powers and introducing direct prime ministerial investiture, intended to curb instability but rejected in a 2016 referendum (59.1% no vote) that prompted Renzi's resignation on December 7. Paolo Gentiloni succeeded Renzi on December 12, 2016, maintaining the PD-led grand coalition with minor adjustments, securing confidence votes in parliament by margins of 368-105 in the Chamber and 168-112 in the Senate. His government prioritized continuity, passing a 2017 budget with €18 billion in deficit spending for social measures like poverty alleviation (introducing the Inclusion Income for 1.8 million households) while complying with EU rules capping deficits at 2.9% of GDP, and handling banking sector cleanups amid non-performing loans reaching €360 billion. Economic recovery materialized modestly, with GDP growth at 1.7% in 2017—the highest since 2010—but persistent structural issues like public debt at 132% of GDP fueled discontent, contributing to the coalition's defeat in the March 2018 elections where PD support plummeted to 18.8%. These administrations, blending technocratic expertise with broad partisan pacts, stabilized finances post-crisis but faced criticism for prioritizing creditor demands over growth, exacerbating inequality and eroding public trust in traditional parties.

Populist Surge and Conte Governments (2018–2021)

The , held on 4 March, marked a significant populist surge, with the anti-establishment (M5S) securing 32.7% of the vote and 227 seats in the , while Matteo Salvini's League obtained 17.4% and 125 seats, outperforming expectations through nationalist and anti-immigration rhetoric. The centre-right coalition, including the League and Forza Italia, won a plurality of seats but fell short of a majority in both chambers, resulting in a and highlighting voter disillusionment with traditional parties amid and high rates exceeding 30%. This outcome reflected a broader rejection of post-2008 austerity measures imposed by the , with both M5S and the League campaigning on Eurosceptic platforms promising reduced influence and . Following 88 days of negotiations, M5S leader Luigi Di Maio and League leader Salvini agreed on 31 May 2018 to form a "government of change" coalition, nominating law professor Giuseppe Conte—a political novice without prior elected experience—as prime minister. Conte was sworn in on 1 June 2018, heading the first Conte cabinet supported by the "yellow-green" alliance of M5S and the League, which controlled a slim majority of 350 seats in the 630-seat Chamber and 171 in the 315-seat Senate. The coalition's programmatic contract emphasized flattening taxes to 15-20%, introducing a universal basic income ("reddito di cittadinanza") for low-income households, pension reforms via "Quota 100" allowing earlier retirement, and stricter immigration controls, including port closures to NGO vessels and expedited deportations. These measures addressed empirical grievances like irregular migration spikes—over 23,000 arrivals in early 2018—and welfare gaps, though implementation faced EU fiscal scrutiny, leading to a 2019 budget standoff where Conte defended higher deficits before conceding adjustments to avoid infringement procedures. Tensions escalated by mid-2019, as the League surged in elections to 34% amid Salvini's hardline stance on security, while M5S stagnated at 17%, exposing policy divergences on infrastructure like the bridge rebuild and . On 8 August 2019, Salvini withdrew coalition support and tabled a no-confidence motion against Conte, aiming to trigger snap elections where polls projected League dominance; Conte resigned on 20 August, delivering a speech criticizing Salvini's opportunism as prioritizing personal gain over national stability. President Sergio Mattarella's consultations revealed M5S willingness to ally with the centre-left Democratic Party (PD) to block early polls, averting a League-Fratelli d'Italia government. Conte received a fresh mandate on 28 August 2019 and formed the second cabinet on 5 September, comprising M5S, PD, and Matteo Renzi's splinter group , shifting toward pro-EU integration while retaining populist elements like Di Maio as foreign minister. This Conte II government navigated the from early 2020, imposing nationwide lockdowns in March that contained initial outbreaks but contracted GDP by 8.9% that year, prompting €200 billion-plus in stimulus and securing Italy's €209 billion share of the Recovery and Resilience Facility. Policies included schemes covering 90% of private-sector workers and accelerated rollouts, though bureaucratic delays drew criticism for inefficiencies rooted in Italy's fragmented regional governance. The government's stability unraveled in January 2021 over disputes on allocating recovery funds, with withdrawing support on 13 January after failing to secure key ministries, depriving Conte of a majority. Conte resigned on 26 January, framing it as a tactical bid for a reinforced mandate amid , but Mattarella's talks yielded no viable coalition, paving the way for a technocratic transition. The period underscored populism's volatility: the League's nationalist pivot bolstered Salvini's base but isolated it temporarily, while M5S's pivot to establishment alliances eroded its outsider appeal, contributing to internal fractures and electoral declines thereafter.

Draghi's National Unity Government (2021–2022)

The government of emerged from a political crisis in the Conte II cabinet, triggered by the withdrawal of Italia Viva's parliamentary support on 13 January 2021 over disagreements on pandemic management and EU recovery funds allocation. President conducted consultations with party leaders and, on 3 February 2021, tasked former President with forming a new executive to address the ongoing emergency and economic fallout. presented his cabinet on 12 February, securing broad cross-party backing—including from the Democratic Party, League, Forza Italia, and (M5S)—excluding only , which opted for opposition to maintain electoral distinctiveness. The 23-member government, sworn in on 13 February 2021, operated as a technocratic-national unity administration with a mandate focused on vaccination rollout, fiscal stabilization, and implementation of the European Union's program, receiving votes of confidence in both parliamentary chambers shortly thereafter. Draghi's executive prioritized accelerating Italy's vaccination campaign, which had lagged under the prior government; by mid-2021, mandatory green passes for work and travel were introduced on 22 July to boost uptake, contributing to over 80% of the population aged 12+ receiving at least one dose by . Economically, the government approved the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) on 28 April 2021 by parliament and submitted it to the on 30 April, securing €191.5 billion in grants and loans by Council approval on 13 July; this framework targeted infrastructure, digitalization, and green transitions amid a 2021 GDP rebound of 6.6%, the strongest since 1999, driven by domestic demand and transfers. However, fiscal pressures mounted from extensions to the Superbonus—a 110% for energy-efficient building renovations introduced under Conte—which ballooned to projected costs exceeding €200 billion by 2023, fueling fraud allegations and grid strain while M5S defended it as essential for construction jobs. Coalition fragility intensified in amid the Russia-Ukraine war's price spikes and PNRR execution delays, with M5S clashing over proposed cuts to citizen's and Superbonus phase-outs, viewing them as betrayals of anti-poverty pledges. On 13 2022, M5S leader announced abstention from a vote scheduled for 14 , citing unmet demands for targeted aid; Draghi tendered that day, rejected by Mattarella to allow renegotiation. A subsequent 20 vote passed 95-38 amid mass abstentions by M5S and others, prompting Draghi's irrevocable on 21 , which Mattarella accepted, dissolving for snap elections on 25 September. The government's tenure stabilized public finances—reducing the deficit to 7.2% of GDP in —and enhanced Italy's standing, but critics, including populist factions, argued its technocratic nature deferred democratic accountability and entrenched centrist compromises over structural reforms.

Meloni Government: Right-Wing Stability and Policy Shifts (2022–Present)

The , held on September 25, resulted in a decisive victory for the center-right coalition led by Giorgia Meloni's party, which secured approximately 26% of the vote share for its leading component and a combined coalition majority of around 44% in the , enabling control of both parliamentary houses. This outcome followed the collapse of Mario Draghi's in July 2022 amid coalition disputes over economic reforms and EU recovery funds. Meloni was sworn in as Italy's first female on October 22, 2022, forming a cabinet dominated by her party and allies including Forza Italia and , marking a shift toward conservative after years of technocratic and fragmented administrations. By October 2025, the Meloni government had achieved notable political longevity, becoming the first administration in over a decade to maintain stability without major internal collapses or early elections, contrasting with Italy's historical average prime ministerial tenure of under two years. This durability stemmed from disciplined coalition management and Meloni's high personal approval ratings, bolstered by fiscal restraint that earned Italy a credit rating upgrade to A (low) with stable outlook from DBRS in October 2025. Economic policies emphasized deficit reduction, halving the fiscal gap from prior levels to project below 3% of GDP by 2026, alongside measures like tax incentives for families with multiple children and housing aid for young households to address demographic decline. Unemployment reached multi-decade lows, and GDP per capita surpassed the United Kingdom's for the first time since 2001, though overall growth remained modest at 0.5% forecasted for 2025 per IMF estimates, lagging the eurozone average due to limited structural reforms in labor markets and productivity. Critics, including business leaders, highlighted stalled overhauls in bureaucracy and justice as risks to long-term competitiveness. Immigration policy marked a significant shift toward enforcement, with bilateral agreements such as those with in 2023-2024 and for migrant processing centers aimed at curbing irregular Mediterranean crossings, which reportedly declined amid naval patrols and cooperation with origin countries. The administration balanced restriction with selective legal inflows, planning up to 165,000 work visas annually while prioritizing skilled migration and rejecting unchecked entries, framing this as a pragmatic response to demographic pressures rather than open borders. In , Meloni pursued Atlanticist alignment, providing to exceeding prior Italian commitments and advocating expansion, while pragmatically engaging the by implementing required legislative changes to access recovery funds, thus avoiding fiscal sanctions. Relations with the strengthened under potential alignment with conservative leadership, and Mediterranean strategy focused on and countering instability in . Domestic social initiatives, including defenses of traditional family structures and curbs on extreme rhetoric within her party, underscored a conservative reorientation, though challenges like persistent public debt near 137% of GDP and aging tested .

Major Controversies and Institutional Critiques

Strategy of Tension and State Involvement in Terrorism

The strategy of tension refers to a series of terrorist attacks in Italy during the late 1960s and 1970s, primarily bombings attributed to neo-fascist groups, intended to generate public fear, discredit leftist movements, and bolster anti-communist policies amid the Cold War. These acts, part of the broader "Years of Lead" (Anni di piombo), from approximately 1969 to 1980, resulted in over 14,000 incidents of political violence, including around 500 deaths, with neo-fascist bombings targeting civilians to mimic leftist extremism. Investigations revealed patterns of false-flag operations, where attacks were initially framed as anarchist or communist deeds to shift blame and justify state repression against the Italian Communist Party (PCI), which polled over 30% in elections. The Piazza Fontana bombing on December 12, 1969, in Milan—where a device exploded in the Banca Nazionale dell'Agricoltura, killing 17 and injuring 88—exemplifies the strategy. Initial probes by Milan police implicated anarchists, leading to the suspicious death of Giuseppe Pinelli, an anarchist questioned in the case, who fell from a fourth-floor window at police headquarters on December 15, 1969, officially ruled a suicide but widely contested as murder or staging. Subsequent inquiries, including parliamentary commissions in the 1970s and 1980s, uncovered neo-fascist involvement from groups like Ordine Nuovo, with bomb components traced to members such as Franco Freda and Giovanni Ventura, though early convictions were overturned on procedural grounds. In 2001, an appeals court sentenced three neo-fascists—Carlo Digilio, Giancarlo Rognoni, and Marco Pozzan—to life for related roles, confirming right-wing orchestration, but the masterminds evaded final accountability due to expired statutes by 2005 Supreme Court rulings. Evidence of state complicity emerged through ties between perpetrators and intelligence agencies. Italy's military secret service (SID, predecessor to ) employed neo-fascists like , linked to multiple attacks, and deviated investigations by planting evidence against leftists, as testified in trials. , a stay-behind network exposed by on November 24, 1990, involved clandestine arms depots and paramilitary units prepared for Soviet invasion; while Gladio officially denied terrorism, declassified documents and confessions indicated overlaps, with SID officers coordinating with neo-fascists and CIA assets to counter PCI influence. Historian Daniele Ganser's analysis of Gladio archives posits it facilitated "deviations" into domestic bombings, though critics argue such links rely on rather than direct orders, emphasizing instead institutional tolerance amid anti-communist imperatives. Further bombings, such as the 1974 Brescia Piazza della Loggia attack (8 killed) and the 1980 station massacre (85 killed, claimed by ), followed similar patterns: neo-fascist execution with delayed or obstructed probes. In 's case, 2017 convictions of four neo-fascists for procurement upheld state failure to preempt via ignored warnings, but acquitted higher officials. Judicial outcomes, spanning dozens of trials, convicted over 50 neo-fascists for terrorism by the 1990s, yet persistent acquittals and statute limitations fueled perceptions of impunity, attributed to Cold War-era pacts shielding allies. Academic assessments, drawing from trial records, highlight causal realism in state negligence—prioritizing geopolitical stability over transparency—rather than monolithic conspiracy, though left-leaning in Italian academia often amplifies deviation theories without proportionate scrutiny of leftist , which claimed fewer but targeted lives.

Judicial Overreach in Political Scandals

The Mani Pulite investigations, launched in on February 17, 1992, with the arrest of Socialist politician Mario Chiesa for accepting a bribe, exposed widespread known as Tangentopoli, leading to over 5,000 convictions and the collapse of major political parties by 1994. While initially hailed for uncovering systemic bribery involving politicians, business leaders, and bureaucrats, critics argue the probe exemplified judicial overreach by relying heavily on coerced confessions through plea bargains, creating a cascade of accusations that destabilized governance without addressing underlying institutional flaws. The judiciary's expanded role, with prosecutors like gaining celebrity status, heightened tensions between branches of government, as politicians accused magistrates of substituting themselves for elected legislators in policy enforcement. Former Prime Minister Bettino Craxi, convicted in 1994 on corruption charges stemming from Mani Pulite, fled to Tunisia in 1994 to avoid further trials, exemplifying how judicial actions prompted political exile and party dissolution, with the Socialist Party effectively ending. Subsequent analyses indicate that despite the scandal's scale—implicating over 50% of parliamentarians—the prosecutions failed to eradicate corruption, as Italy's Corruption Perceptions Index remained low, scoring 56/100 in 2023, suggesting judicial activism prioritized spectacle over structural reform. Silvio Berlusconi faced numerous trials from the 1990s onward, including convictions for tax fraud upheld in 2013 (later annulled due to ) and charges in cases like the 2011 Rubygate scandal involving underage allegations, which he and supporters decried as orchestrated by left-leaning "Toghe Rosse" (red robes) magistrates aiming to undermine his center-right governments. Berlusconi's 2001-2006 and 2008-2011 terms saw legislative attempts to curb perceived judicial politicization, such as immunity laws, amid claims that over 2,500 proceedings targeted him personally, far exceeding peers, indicating against conservative figures. In 2019, , then , was prosecuted for "kidnapping" and dereliction of duty after blocking the Open Arms migrant vessel from docking with 147 migrants on August 20, 2019, under his "closed ports" policy, a trial critics labeled as judicial intrusion into executive immigration prerogatives. Acquitted on December 20, 2024, by a court that ruled his actions protected national interests, the case nonetheless consumed years of resources, with prosecutors appealing to the Cassation Court, highlighting ongoing friction where policy decisions are reframed as criminal acts. These episodes reflect a pattern where Italy's , recruited via competitive exams but influenced by associations like Magistratura Democratica (left-leaning), has been accused of activism, with data showing 80% of magistrates self-identifying as progressive in surveys, potentially biasing high-profile political prosecutions against right-wing leaders while sparing systemic issues in . Reforms under Giorgia Meloni's 2022 , echoing Berlusconi's efforts, aim to separate prosecutorial and judicial careers to mitigate such overreach, amid scrutiny.

Persistent Political Instability and Electoral System Flaws

The Italian Republic has endured chronic governmental turnover since its establishment in 1946, with 68 governments formed by October 2022, averaging approximately 13.5 months per administration. This pattern persisted through the First Republic (1948–1994), where 52 cabinets lasted an average of just 10.8 months, driven by coalition fragility amid ideological divisions and policy impasses. Even after the 1990s transition to the Second Republic, instability continued, with 17 governments from 1994 to 2022, though durations varied by coalition type—right-wing ones averaging longer terms than left-leaning alternatives. A primary structural cause lies in the electoral system's heavy reliance on (PR), which has consistently produced fragmented parliaments lacking clear majorities. The 1948 Constitution's pure PR framework, with minimal thresholds (initially none, later 5% for coalitions), enabled dozens of parties to secure seats, diluting voter mandates into multiparty coalitions prone to defection. This fragmentation incentivized short-term bargaining over long-term governance, as smaller parties wielded veto power in centrist alliances dominated by the Christian Democrats until the 1990s, exacerbating instability through frequent no-confidence votes facilitated by parliament's secret balloting. Successive reforms have sought to mitigate these flaws by introducing majoritarian elements, yet none have fully resolved the underlying issues of disproportionality and party proliferation. The 1993 referendum shifted to the Mattarellum system—75% first-past-the-post single-member districts and 25% PR—aiming for a bipolar party structure, but it still yielded hung parliaments in and 1996. The 2005 Porcellum law amplified via a national majority bonus for winning coalitions, but its closed-list PR components and threshold manipulations produced seat distortions, such as the center-left's 2006 victory despite near-parity votes, prompting invalidation of key provisions in for violating equality. Subsequent iterations, including the 2015 Italicum (struck down in 2017 for similar reasons) and the 2017 Rosatellum mixed system (37% majoritarian, 63% PR), have alternated between over-representing winners and under-representing minorities, perpetuating coalition dependencies without curbing the , which hovered around 7–10 in recent legislatures. These electoral mechanics have compounded broader institutional weaknesses, including requiring identical majorities in both chambers under varying rules until recent alignments, and a party-centric that prioritizes internal factions over voter . Critics argue that PR's low barriers foster clientelistic micro-parties focused on regional pork-barreling rather than national coherence, while majoritarian tweaks invite strategic manipulations that undermine representativeness without ensuring durability—evident in the election's "yellow-green" populist coalition collapse after 14 months. Judicial interventions, while safeguarding constitutional principles, have created cycles of fixes, delaying stable reform and reinforcing perceptions of a "worst-in-class" framework ill-suited to Italy's polarized, multi-level . Despite the 2022 Rosatellum enabling a rare center-right majority under , ongoing debates over referendums and prime ministerial primacy highlight unresolved tensions between proportionality's inclusivity and the governability deficits it engenders.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.