Hubbry Logo
Maqam (shrine)Maqam (shrine)Main
Open search
Maqam (shrine)
Community hub
Maqam (shrine)
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Maqam (shrine)
Maqam (shrine)
Maqam (shrine)
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
This article is about religious shrines in the Levant. For other uses, see Maqam.
Maqam al-Khidr in al-Bassa
Part of a series on
Arabic culture
Architecture
Styles

Features

Types


Art
Styles

Types

Features


Cuisine
Dress
Headwear

Clothing

Music
Theory

Genres

Art music

Folk


Dance
Scripts
Literature
Prose

Islamic

Poetry

Genres

Forms

Arabic prosody

National literatures of Arab States

Science
Philosophy

Concepts

Texts


Mythology

Fictional Arab people

Spirituality
North Arabian deities

South Arabian deities

A maqām (Arabic: مقام) is a Muslim shrine constructed at a site linked to a religious figure or saint, commonly found in the Levant (or al-Shām), which comprises the present-day countries of Lebanon, Syria, Palestine, and Israel. It is usually a funeral construction, commonly cubic-shaped and topped with a dome.[1]

The cult for holy sites in Islamic Syria heightened during the 12th and 13th centuries, particularly under Zangid and Ayyubid rule. Historians attribute this surge to the political climate, notably the Crusades and the Muslim reconquest of the region. Funded by rulers and the elite, these shrines functioned as points of piety, attracting individuals from different levels of society, generating employment opportunities, and contributing to economic growth.[2] During this period, as demand increased, more sanctuaries emerged, some repurposed from Jewish and Christian holy sites, others built upon newly discovered tombs and relics, and some dedicated to honoring the graves of recent ulama and revered holy men.[2]

Maqams continued to be revered sites in modern times as well. In the 19th century, Claude Reignier Conder described maqams as an essential part of folk religion in Palestine, with locals attaching immense importance to them.[3][non-primary source needed][neutrality is disputed] Researchers have observed that alongside celebrated Muslim figures, some maqams can also be associated with ancient Semitic pagan, Judaic, Samaritan, and Christian traditions.[4][5]

The maqams of Palestine were considered highly significant to the field of biblical archaeology, as their names were used in the 18th and 19th centuries to identify much of biblical geography.[6]

Etymology

[edit]

From Arabic literally "a place" or "station."[7] It is used to denote a "sanctuary", such as a commemorative burial shrine or an actual tomb.[7] Its meaning can be restricted only to built structures that can be entered at such sites.[7] The literal meaning of maqam is "the place where one stands."[7] Such name for a holy tomb is mostly used in Lebanon, Syria and Palestine.

The form mukam appears in the essays of European travelers of the 19th century; as well as the words waly, wely (Arabic: ويلي wālī "saint"), mazar, and mashhad.

In Maghreb, similar tombs are known as Marabout, in Turkic-speaking Muslim countries as türbe, dürbe, or aziz, and in Persian-speaking countries dargah.

Purpose

[edit]

Maqams were dedicated to Biblical and Quranic, real or mythical, male and female figures from ancient times to the time of the Arab conquest or even late Ottoman rule.[8] Ali Qleibo, a Palestinian anthropologist, states that this built evidence constitutes "an architectural testimony to Christian/Moslem Palestinian religious sensibility and its roots in ancient Semitic religions."[5] In 1877, the British explorer Claude Reignier Conder wrote that:

It is in worship at these shrines that the religion of the peasantry consists. Moslem by profession, they often spend their lives without entering a mosque, and attach more importance to the favour and protection of the village Мukam than to Allah himself, or to Mohammed his prophet.[9]

Salah al-Houdalieh's study on Sheikh Shihab-Al-Din's maqam, which attracted rural Muslims from the village of Saffa, Ramallah, showed that visitations usually consisted of ritual prayers, burials, Quran recitation, commemorating the sheikh, or making vows.[10] Every village in the Palestine region has a wali or patron saint, whom people, predominantly rural peasants, would call upon for help at his or her associated sanctuary.[11] While wali can refer to both the saint and sanctuary, a sanctuary for a common saint is more precisely known as a maqam.[12]

Maqam of Sheikh Al-Nuwairi in the village of Al-Qara, Egypt.

Construction

[edit]

The most popular type of maqam is a single chamber square building topped with a dome, in the middle of which there is a stone cenotaph,[13] though the revered figures themselves were buried below ground level. In the south wall of the maqam, there is usually a small mihrab facing Mecca, decorated with inscriptions and floral ornament. The entrance to the chamber is mostly at the north wall. In the other arched walls there are usually small windows. Candelabras and lamps are hanging in an active maqam, a cenotaph is covered by a quilt (usually a green one), praying rugs are spread on the floor in front of the mihrab.

There are also bigger maqams, consisting of two, three or four chambers:[14] prayer chamber, entrance hall, zawiya or a room for pilgrims to have a rest. Big maqams have two or three similar domes. In times of old, the dome was decorated by a metal spire with a crescent, but nowadays such decoration is rare.

The maqams do not always stand over the tombs of the saints to whom they are dedicated.

Maqam of Nabi Samit (Samson) in Sar'a, destroyed in the 1950s

They are often situated near an ancient carob or oak tree or a spring or rock cut water cistern.[5][15] A Sacred tree was planted near maqams, mostly – a palm tree, oak or sycomore. There was also a well or spring. The location of maqams on or near these natural features is seen as indicative of ancient worship practices adapted by the local population and associated with religious figures.[16]

As a rule, maqams were built on hilltops or at crossroads. Besides functioning as a shrine and prayer place, they served as guard points and landmarks for travelers and caravans. Over the years, new burial places appeared near maqams; it was considered an honour to be buried next to a saint.

History

[edit]

Early origins

[edit]
See also: List of burial places of Abrahamic figures

According to Claude Reignier Conder, many maqams are originated in Jewish and Christian traditions from before the advent of Islam in the region.[17] He identified seven types of maqams:[17]

  1. Biblical characters: "These are, no doubt, generally the oldest, and can often be traced back to Jewish tradition"
  2. Christian sites venerated by the Muslim fellahin: "not always distinguishable from the first class, but often traceable to the teaching of the monasteries or to monkish sites"
  3. Other native heroes or deities: "perhaps sometimes the most ancient sites of all"
  4. Later and known historic characters
  5. Saints named from the place where they occur, or having appellations connected with traditions concerning them
  6. Sacred sites not connected with personal names: "Some of these are of the greatest value"
  7. Ordinary Muslim names which may be of any date

Middle ages

[edit]
See also: Ziyarat

In the seventh century, the Arab Rashiduns conquered the Levant; they were later succeeded by other Arabic-speaking Muslim dynasties, including the Umayyads, Abbasids and the Fatimids.[18] Early Islam disapproved worshipping of holy men and their burial places, considering it a sort of idolatry. However, the Shiites built sumptuous tombs for their deceased leaders – imams and sheikhs, and turned those tombs into religious objects. Very soon Sunnis followed their example. Arab travellers and geographers ‘Ali al-Harawi, Yaqut al-Hamawi and others described in their essays many Christian and Muslim shrines in Syria, Palestine and Egypt.

Maqam of Umayyad caliph Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan in Bab al-Saghir, Damascus

During the times of Mamluk dynasty, monumental tombs were built for Muslim holy men, scientists and theologists, some of these tombs have come down to present times. The major part of them is located in Egypt, and some parts are also in Syria and Palestine. These are namely the famous Rachel's Tomb in Bethlehem (though the burial place of matriarch Rachel was worshipped even before), the splendid mausoleum of Abu Hurairah in Yavne[19] and the maqam of sheikh Abu ‘Atabi in Al-Manshiyya, Acre.

Ottoman period

[edit]

In the Ottoman Empire times, maqams were constructed everywhere, and old sanctuaries were taken under restoration. New buildings were not as monumental and pompous as before, and looked quite unpretentious. In Turkish period, maqams had simple construction and almost no architectural décor.

Maqam in Northern Palestine (C. Wilson, 1881).

Mosques were uncommon in Palestinian villages until the late 19th century, but practically every village had at least one maqam which served as sites of worship in the Palestinian folk Islam popular in the countryside over the centuries.[11][15] Christians and Jews also held some of the maqams to be holy, such as that of Nabi Samwil.[12] In the period of Ottoman rule over Palestine, most of these sites were visited collectively by members of all three faiths who often travelled together with provisions for a multi-day journey; by the Mandate Palestine period, politicization led to segregation.[8] Some maqams, like Nabi Rubin and Nabi Musa among others, were also the focus of seasonal festivals (mawsims) that thousands would attend annually.

There is, however, in nearly every village, a small whitewashed building with a low dome – the "mukam," or "place," sacred to the eyes of the peasants. In almost every landscape such a landmark gleams from the top of some hill, just as, doubtless, something of the same kind did in the old Canaanite ages.[20]

Modern era

[edit]
Maqam in Judea, 1940s

The period of Mandatory Palestine has become the last time of maqams' prosperity. Dilapidated Muslim shrines were restored, and also new ones were built. The British built over and donated to Bedouins the maqam of Sheikh Nuran, which was damaged during the Sinai and Palestine campaign. This maqam was in the battle epicentre during the 1948 Arab–Israeli War. After having captured it, Israeli soldiers turned it into a watch and firing point. Since that time, the maqam of Sheikh Nuran has been a memorial for the Israel Defense Forces.

After the State of Israel was formed, numerous shrines were turned into Jewish shrines. For example, the Mausoleum of Abu Hurayra was transformed into the tomb of the Gamaliel II in Yavne;[21] the Maqam with seven domes of Ali in Yazur was converted into a synagogue; the mazar of Sakina bint Husayn in Tiberias was reconsecrated as the tomb of Rachel, the spouse of Rabbi Akiva; the maqam of sheikh al-Gharbawi into the tomb of Mattathias; the muqam of Nabi Sheman near the Junction Eyal, was identified with the tomb of Simeon (son of Jacob).

In ancient times, all maqams with the domes were coloured in white.[22] More recently, Palestinians and Arab citizens of Israel coloured the domes of shrines green, a color associated with Muhammad. The battle for one or another shrine resulted in the "war of colours", as it was called in the press.[23] Religious Jews paint domes in blue or white and install Jewish symbols, and Muslims, when returning, remove the symbols and repaint the dome green.

Notable maqams

[edit]
See also: Tomb of Benjamin; Sar'a; Sheikh Bureik § Sheikh Abreik shrine; Kaukab Abu al-Hija § Shrine of Abu al-Hija; Ed-Dahi § History; Maqam Sheikh al-Qatrawani; Ar'ara § Maqam Shaykh Khalaf; and Sharafat, East Jerusalem § Mamluk era

No more than 300 maqams have survived out of 800 existing in Palestine in 1948, the remainder having been demolished. Half of them are in Israel-proper, the remainder in the West Bank and Gaza Strip; most of the West Bank has been under Israeli control since 1967, and Gaza between 1967 and 2005. According to another source, the number of Palestinian maqams left is 184, with only 70 remaining in Israel-proper.[24]

Picture Name Former Location Present Location Coordinates Built in Current state Country
‘Abd an-Nabi Al-Mas'udiyya Tel Aviv 32°05′15″N 34°46′11″E / 32.08750°N 34.76972°E / 32.08750; 34.76972 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Hasan ar-Ra‘i Nabi Musa Nabi Musa 31°46′51″N 35°25′29″E / 31.78083°N 35.42472°E / 31.78083; 35.42472 Active shrine Palestine Palestine
Maqam al-Khidr Al-Bassa Shlomi, Israel 33°04′41″N 35°08′36″E / 33.07806°N 35.14333°E / 33.07806; 35.14333 Destroyed Israel Israel
Muadh ibn Jabal
(Sheikh Mu‘alla)		 Imwas Canada Park 31°50′08″N 34°59′30″E / 31.83556°N 34.99167°E / 31.83556; 34.99167 Reconstructed Israel Israel
Nabi ‘Anir Khirbat an-Nabi ‘Anir Gush Talmonim 31°57′20″N 35°06′27″E / 31.95556°N 35.10750°E / 31.95556; 35.10750 Object no longer in use Palestine Palestine
Nabi Bulus Khirbat an-Nabi Bulus Beit Shemesh 31°42′51″N 34°58′51″E / 31.71417°N 34.98083°E / 31.71417; 34.98083 Destroyed Israel Israel
Nabi Kifl Al-Tira, Ramle Tirat Yehuda 32°00′25″N 34°55′35″E / 32.00694°N 34.92639°E / 32.00694; 34.92639 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Nabi Shitt Bashshit Aseret 31°49′28″N 34°44′55″E / 31.82444°N 34.74861°E / 31.82444; 34.74861 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Caliph Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan Bab al-Saghir Cemetery Bab al-Saghir near Mu'awiya's mausoleum, Damascus 33°30′22″N 36°18′23″E / 33.50611°N 36.30639°E / 33.50611; 36.30639 Founded in the time of the Umayyads Syria Syria
Sheikh ‘Abdallah Dura al-Qar' Beit El, Located in area expropriated from Dura al-Qar' for Beit El 31°56′57″N 35°13′55″E / 31.94917°N 35.23194°E / 31.94917; 35.23194 Palestine Palestine
Sheikh ‘Abdallah as-Sahili Balad al-Sheikh Nesher 32°46′18″N 35°02′34″E / 32.77167°N 35.04278°E / 32.77167; 35.04278 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Sheikh Abu ‘Atabi Al-Manshiyya, Acre Acre, Israel 32°56′15″N 35°05′32″E / 32.93750°N 35.09222°E / 32.93750; 35.09222 Dwelling house Israel Israel
Sheikh Abu Ghazala Khirbat as-Sukriyya No'am 31°34′04″N 34°46′48″E / 31.56778°N 34.78000°E / 31.56778; 34.78000 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Sheikh Abu Shusha Ghuwayr Abu Shusha Migdal, Israel 32°51′13″N 35°30′27″E / 32.85361°N 35.50750°E / 32.85361; 35.50750 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Sheikh Abu az-Zeitun Beitunia Beit Horon 31°53′15″N 35°08′04″E / 31.88750°N 35.13444°E / 31.88750; 35.13444 Object no longer in use Palestine Palestine
Sheikh Ahmad al-Hubani Allar, Jerusalem Bar Giora 31°43′31″N 35°04′49″E / 31.72528°N 35.08028°E / 31.72528; 35.08028 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Sheikh ‘Ali ad-Dawayimi Al-Dawayima Amatzia, Israel 31°32′10″N 34°53′13″E / 31.53611°N 34.88694°E / 31.53611; 34.88694 Founded in the time of the Abbasids Israel Israel
Sheikh ‘Amir Jaba', Haifa Subdistrict Mizpe Ofer 32°39′16″N 34°57′54″E / 32.65444°N 34.96500°E / 32.65444; 34.96500 Reconstructed Israel Israel
Sheikh ‘Awad Hamama Ashkelon 31°41′15″N 34°33′47″E / 31.68750°N 34.56306°E / 31.68750; 34.56306 Founded in the time of the Ottoman Empire Israel Israel
Sheikh Baraz ad-Din
(Sheikh as-Sadiq)		 Majdal Yaba Migdal Afek 32°05′00″N 34°57′27″E / 32.08333°N 34.95750°E / 32.08333; 34.95750 Reconstructed Israel Israel
Sheikh Bilal Azmut Elon Moreh 32°14′33″N 35°19′40″E / 32.24250°N 35.32778°E / 32.24250; 35.32778 Object no longer in use Palestine Palestine
Sheikh Bureik (‘Abreik) Sheikh Bureik Kiryat Tiv'on 32°42′03″N 35°07′44″E / 32.70083°N 35.12889°E / 32.70083; 35.12889 Active shrine Israel Israel
Sheikh Ghanim Kafr Qallil Mount Gerizim 32°12′05″N 35°16′26″E / 32.20139°N 35.27389°E / 32.20139; 35.27389 Reconstructed Palestine Palestine
Sheikh al-Katanani Yazur Holon 32°01′17″N 34°48′18″E / 32.02139°N 34.80500°E / 32.02139; 34.80500 Reconstructed Israel Israel
Sheikh Marzuk ‘Ulleika, Jaulan Golan Heights 33°03′01″N 35°42′02″E / 33.05028°N 35.70056°E / 33.05028; 35.70056 Object no longer in use Golan Heights
Maqam Sheikh al-Qatrawani 'Atara 'Atara 31°59′36″N 35°11′52″E / 31.99333°N 35.19778°E / 31.99333; 35.19778 Founded in the time of the Mamluk dynasty Palestine Palestine
Sheikh as-Salihi Bayt Nattif Givat HaTurmusim, Sokho 31°40′58″N 34°57′59″E / 31.68278°N 34.96639°E / 31.68278; 34.96639 Object no longer in use Israel Israel
Sheikh ‘Usheish Dayr Nakhkhas Maresha Forest 31°36′39″N 34°56′01″E / 31.61083°N 34.93361°E / 31.61083; 34.93361 Active shrine Israel Israel

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Maqam (shrine)

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
A maqam (Arabic: مقام, plural maqāmāt) is a shrine in Islamic tradition dedicated to the tomb or reputed site associated with a prophet (nabi), saint (wali), or pious figure, typically comprising a modest architectural structure—often a domed room or chamber containing a cenotaph—that functions as a locus for veneration, prayer, and pilgrimage. The term maqam, meaning "station" or "standing place," underscores its role as a marker of spiritual significance where the holy person is believed to have resided, prayed, or been buried. Prevalent across the Levant, maqāms are especially abundant in Palestine, numbering in the hundreds and dotting rural and urban landscapes, often situated on elevated terrain to enhance visibility and accessibility for devotees. Many commemorate biblical prophets shared with Jewish and Christian traditions, such as Nabi Musa (Moses) or Nabi Yusuf (Joseph), fostering sites of interfaith overlap but also occasional contention amid territorial disputes. Historically documented from the Ottoman era onward, these shrines embody folk Islamic practices influenced by Sufism, involving rituals like vow-making (nidhr), candle lighting, and seasonal festivals (mawāsim), though such customs have waned due to urbanization, stricter Wahhabi-influenced interpretations decrying them as innovation (bid'ah), and geopolitical disruptions. In contemporary contexts, maqāms remain symbols of cultural continuity, with preservation efforts varying by region: some in Israeli-controlled areas have been restored or maintained, while others in Palestinian Authority territories face neglect or vandalism during unrest, as exemplified by the 2000 arson of maqam in . This duality highlights their embeddedness in both devotional life and the socio-political fabric of the region, where empirical records from Mandate-period surveys underscore their ubiquity—over 300 identified—prior to modern conflicts.

Definition and Terminology

Etymology and Meaning

The term maqām (مَقَام), plural maqāmāt (مَقَامَات), derives from the q-w-m (ق-و-م), connoting "to stand," "to rise," or "to take a stance," yielding meanings such as "station," "place," or "standing ground." In linguistic usage, it functions as a of place from the verb qāma ("to stand up"), reflecting a fixed position or site of permanence. In the context of Islamic shrines, maqām designates a sacred locale or edifice, typically a (qabr) or honoring a prophet, (walī), or pious figure, where the individual's spiritual influence (baraka) is believed to endure. This application underscores the site's role as a "station" of divine proximity or , common in folk Islamic practices across the , , and , though distinct from Sufi maqāmāt as progressive spiritual stages. Historically, the term may trace to an earlier sense of oratory or prayer site, as archaeologist Ernst Herzfeld observed in analyzing Damascene structures, predating its association with burial veneration.

Types and Regional Variations

Maqams are primarily classified by the religious figure they commemorate, including prophets (anbiya), saints (awliya), local sheikhs, or other holy persons such as companions of the Prophet or early Islamic figures. Shrines dedicated to prophets, such as Maqam Nabi Musa near attributed to , often attract broader due to Quranic associations, whereas those for local saints or sheikhs, like Maqam Sheikh al-Katanani in , serve more localized veneration tied to folk traditions. A key distinction lies in whether the maqam houses an actual or functions as a commemorative "station" (maqam literally meaning "standing place"), with many containing only a or empty chamber marking a site of visitation rather than interment. Architecturally, maqams exhibit functional types: built structures typically feature a square base with a whitewashed dome (qubba) over the tomb chamber, often including a mihrab and sometimes a courtyard, while about 45% integrate natural elements like caves, trees, or hilltops without formal construction. Scale varies by category—village maqams are modest single-room edifices for local use, regional ones include arcades or prayer halls, and major international sites expand to complexes with minarets or surrounding facilities. Related terms like mazar (mausoleum) or kubba (domed tomb) denote slight variations, but maqam specifically emphasizes the site's sanctity over the physical remains. Regionally, maqams are most concentrated in the , spanning modern , , , , and , with over 300 documented in alone by the early , often on elevated terrain or near water sources for symbolic purity. In and , emphasis falls on and companion shrines, such as Maqam Shu'ayb for Jethro in Jordan's Hittite region (restored in the 19th century) or Maqam Nabi on the , reflecting Ottoman-era construction peaks between 1800 and 1920 using local . Syrian and Lebanese variants show minor elaborations, like integrated arcaded halls in urban-adjacent sites, but maintain the core cubic-domed form; for instance, maqams near incorporate influences from the 13th–15th centuries. Beyond the , the term and typology fade, supplanted by in or zawiya in , though analogous saint shrines exist with grander mausolea in under Ottoman styles. This Levantine uniformity stems from shared folk Islamic practices, with post-1948 documentation noting differential preservation rates across political boundaries.

Religious and Cultural Role

Purpose and Associated Practices

Maqam shrines primarily serve as sites for ziyarah, a devotional visitation practice in which seek to commemorate and draw spiritual benefit from the legacy of prophets, saints (awliya), or righteous figures believed to hold elevated proximity to . These locations facilitate (intercession), where pilgrims request divine aid through the saint's influence, often for purposes such as healing, protection, fertility, or fulfillment of personal needs, predicated on attributions of post-mortem karamaat (miraculous graces) to the interred. This purpose aligns with broader Sufi and folk Islamic traditions emphasizing the saint's enduring (blessing) as a conduit for , attracting visitors across social strata despite periodic scholarly reservations regarding excessive . Associated practices typically commence with ritual purification (wudu), followed by recitation of salutations (salam), Quranic verses, and targeted supplications (du'a) directed toward the and . Pilgrims may circumambulate the , light votive candles, affix cloths or personal items to surrounding trees or structures as offerings, or immerse in adjacent waters attributed healing properties; these acts symbolize ongoing connection and vows (nadhr) for answered prayers. Collective ziyarah often occurs on the 's death anniversary (), lunar dates like the 15th of the month, or during , incorporating communal (remembrance of ), storytelling of miracles, feasting, and poetry to reinforce communal bonds and faith in the site's efficacy. Regional variations influence specifics, such as the integration of processions or music in Sufi-affiliated maqams in the , where shrines often cluster near natural features like hilltops or springs to amplify perceived sanctity. These rituals underscore a popular focused on experiential devotion, contrasting with more ascetic emphases in orthodox interpretations, yet persisting as integral to local Islamic expression.

Veneration Rituals and Beliefs

Veneration at maqam shrines centers on the belief that the buried saint, known as a wali (friend of ), maintains spiritual proximity to after death, enabling () for supplicants' needs such as healing, fertility, or protection. Practitioners hold that these saints possess baraka (blessing) and (miraculous powers) that persist beyond the grave, allowing them to mediate divine favor or perform acts like averting calamity, rooted in folk Islamic interpretations of Quranic verses on divine friends (e.g., 10:62). This conviction draws from traditions attributing ongoing awareness and efficacy to righteous souls, though such beliefs vary regionally and are more pronounced in Sufi-influenced communities. Ziyarat (visitation) forms the core ritual, involving recitation of Surah Al-Fatiha, upon the , and personal supplications directed through the to God, often performed individually or in groups at the stone. Physical acts include circumambulation (tawaf) around the grave, (sijda) in reverence, kissing or touching the for , and rubbing hands over it to absorb baraka. Offerings such as flowers, money, , or votive candles are common, symbolizing devotion and vows (nadhr) for fulfilled requests, with some leaving cloths tied to nearby trees or notes inscribed for the 's attention. In certain traditions, sacrifices (dhabh) of animals occur, with meat distributed to the poor, echoing pre-Islamic but adapted folk customs. Collective ceremonies, particularly during the saint's death anniversary ( or ), feature (ritual remembrance of God through repetitive invocations), sama (spiritual listening with music and ), and communal feasts, attracting pilgrims for heightened spiritual efficacy believed to coincide with the saint's "" to earth. These gatherings, often under full moons or in , include storytelling of the saint's miracles, songs of praise, and merrymaking to foster communal baraka, though scale varies from local hilltop vigils to large regional events. Water immersion near springs or laying stones for wishes further embodies beliefs in the site's enduring sanctity for and fortune.

Theological Perspectives

Affirmative Views in Sufism and Folk Islam

In , maqams dedicated to awliya (saints or ) are regarded as focal points for spiritual elevation and divine proximity, where devotees engage in ziyara (visitation) to draw (blessings) from the saint's enduring spiritual presence. Sufi doctrine posits that awliya achieve a perfected state (insan kamil), enabling them to intercede ( or ) on behalf of supplicants even after physical death, as their souls remain actively connected to the divine realm. This belief stems from interpretations of Quranic verses and emphasizing the special status of God's elect, with visitation rituals involving (remembrance of ), supplication at the , and sometimes sama' (spiritual listening through poetry or music) to facilitate ecstatic union with the divine. Sufi orders, such as the and Qadiri, historically promote maqams as educational and communal hubs, where murids (disciples) learn adab (spiritual etiquette) and witness (miracles) attributed to the saint's influence, reinforcing the hierarchy of spiritual authority from the pir (guide) to the divine. Texts like those compiling saintly biographies (hagiographies) document instances of healing and guidance at these sites, attributing efficacy to the saint's proximity to rather than inherent shrine power, though practices often blur into folk customs. In folk Islam, particularly in regions like the , , and , maqams integrate pre-Islamic and local traditions, serving as venues for vows (nadhr), offerings, and rituals seeking protection from misfortune or cures for ailments, with communities viewing the saint as a patron () exerting ongoing guardianship. These shrines foster social cohesion, attracting diverse pilgrims who tie cloth strips or light candles as symbols of petition, practices rooted in the belief that the 's ruh (spirit) mediates human needs through divine favor. While orthodox Sufis caution against excess, folk veneration underscores maqams' role in accessible , contrasting elite theological abstraction with tangible, experiential faith.

Criticisms from Orthodox Sunni and Salafi Perspectives

Orthodox Sunni scholars following the Athari creed, such as Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328 CE), viewed the veneration of saints at graves as a primary manifestation of shirk in their era, arguing that it elevates the dead to intermediaries between God and humans, thereby compromising tawhid. Ibn Taymiyyah specifically condemned seeking supplication or intercession from the inhabitants of graves, equating it to treating them as partners with Allah, a practice he traced to pre-Islamic pagan influences that persisted through exaggerated respect for the righteous. Salafi scholars extend this critique, prohibiting the construction of any structures over graves, citing hadiths where the Prophet Muhammad (d. 632 CE) forbade building mosques or other edifices atop them to prevent their transformation into sites of ritual worship akin to idols. They classify such buildings as (innovation), absent from the practices of the al-Salih (early generations), and warn that they facilitate shirk through acts like , vows, or supplications directed toward the occupant rather than alone. For instance, prominent Salafi jurists like Abdul Aziz ibn Baz (d. 1999 CE) ruled that even simple markers beyond basic identification stones are impermissible if they lead to undue veneration. In practice, this perspective has motivated demolitions of maqams deemed idolatrous; during the Wahhabi conquests in the early , forces under the Saudi state destroyed numerous shrines in and , including those over graves of companions, to eradicate potential sources of , a policy rooted in reviving the prophetic ban on grave exaltation. Modern Salafi fatwas reinforce that any ritual at maqams—such as lighting candles or seeking blessings—constitutes major shirk if it implies the saint's independent power, urging to limit grave visits solely to reflection on death without or festivity. These critiques prioritize emulation of the Prophet's simplicity in practices, where graves were leveled and unadorned to avoid deification.

Architecture and Construction

Design Features and Materials

Maqam shrines typically feature a simple, single-chamber design consisting of a square or rectangular room measuring approximately 5 to 10 meters per side, built directly over the of a or , with the chamber surmounted by a dome known as a . This compact form emphasizes isolation and reverence, often positioned on hilltops or in rural landscapes to serve as devotional landmarks. Entrances are usually arched, leading to an interior space that includes a (niche indicating the direction of ) and the cenotaph marking the grave, which may be elevated or enclosed. Some larger examples incorporate a surrounding enclosed by low stone walls for communal gatherings, though many remain austere without such extensions. Construction materials are predominantly local stone, such as roughly cut limestone or sandstone blocks prevalent in the Levant, bonded with mortar to form durable, low-maintenance walls that withstand arid climates. Domes are constructed from masonry or stone, frequently coated in white plaster or limewash to reflect sunlight and symbolize purity, with occasional use of pink or colored plaster in restorations. In Ottoman-era builds, which standardized many maqams in Palestine, additional elements like wooden doors or iron grilles protected interiors, while modern reconstructions may incorporate concrete coatings for reinforcement, though traditional sites prioritize vernacular stone to preserve authenticity. Roofs and domes avoid elaborate ornamentation, focusing on functional symbolism over decoration.

Symbolic and Functional Elements

Maqams feature architectural elements that convey spiritual symbolism through their design. The dome, known as , evokes the divine , signifying the saint's transcendent status and the shrine's connection to the heavens. Cenotaphs placed over represent the physical remains and persistent baraka (blessing) of the interred figure, serving as focal points for devotion. Mihrabs, oriented toward the , symbolize the direction of prayer and integrate the shrine into broader Islamic worship practices, even in modest structures. Stone construction, often on hilltops or near natural features like springs, underscores permanence and isolation as markers of sacred isolation from worldly concerns. Functionally, maqams act as hubs for personal and communal religious activities, where pilgrims seek from the as a mediator to . Visitors perform prayers, recite supplications, and offer vows (nadhr) at the , believing the site's baraka facilitates healing, protection, and fulfillment of requests. Annual festivals, such as celebrations, involve processions, recitations, and communal gatherings, reinforcing social bonds and cultural memory. In rural contexts, these shrines also guide seasonal practices, like agricultural rituals or migrations, embedding them in the landscape's functional sacred geography. Many incorporate adjacent natural elements, such as trees or caves, for votive offerings, blending built and unbuilt spaces in popular piety.

Historical Evolution

Pre-Modern Origins

The of holy figures through shrines, known as maqams, emerged in early alongside the concept of awliya (), pious individuals attributed with spiritual blessings or baraka, traceable to the 8th century when Sunni scholars began defining saints as intermediaries capable of . This practice drew from Quranic references to prophets and righteous forebears, evolving into physical commemorations at tombs or reputed visitation sites, though initial Islamic norms discouraged elaborate grave markers to prevent . In regions like the , maqams often repurposed pre-Islamic holy loci—such as hilltop natural features, springs, or caves associated with biblical prophets—adapting Jewish and Christian pilgrimage traditions into Muslim frameworks without direct scriptural mandate. Dedicated construction of maqam architecture in commenced under the (909–1171 CE), a Shiite Ismaili regime that conquered the region around 969–970 CE and promoted shrine-building to honor distinguished sheikhs, prophets, and saints as part of legitimizing their rule through sacred geography. These early structures typically featured simple domed chambers (qubbas) over cenotaphs or empty symbolic tombs, emphasizing modesty while facilitating communal rituals; Fatimid-era examples in Palestine marked a shift from informal grave veneration to formalized sites, influencing subsequent Sunni adaptations despite theological divergences. The parallel rise of Sufi orders in the Abbasid era (8th–9th centuries) accelerated this, as tariqas (Sufi brotherhoods) established zawiyas (lodges) incorporating maqams for ascetic teachers, blending mystical devotion with local saint cults. By the , following Saladin's expulsion of Crusaders in 1187 CE, maqam proliferation intensified in as Sufi networks expanded, transforming remote tombs into pilgrimage hubs amid renewed Muslim control. rulers (1250–1517 CE) provided key patronage, with Sultan Baybars I (r. 1260–1277 CE) funding prominent sites like Maqam al-Nabi Musa near in 1277 CE to bolster regional sacred identity and counter lingering Crusader influences. This era solidified maqams as architectural ensembles with white-domed qubbas, courtyards, and ablution areas, often numbering in the hundreds across the by the late medieval period, though subject to periodic orthodox critiques for resembling pre-Islamic shrine worship.

Medieval and Early Modern Expansion

During the medieval period, particularly from the 12th to 15th centuries, the construction and veneration of maqams proliferated in the amid the rise of Sufi orders and the political strategies of Sunni dynasties seeking to consolidate legitimacy through pious patronage. The (1171–1260 CE), founded by , invested heavily in shrines associated with prophets and early Muslim figures, integrating them into efforts to revive Sunni orthodoxy following Fatimid Shi'ism; this included likely the erection of structures like the maqam at in during this era, reflecting a broader pattern of architectural sponsorship to link rulers with sacred heritage. This expansion was part of an unprecedented building surge under , Zangid, and subsequent rule, where shrines served as focal points for ziyara (visitation) practices, drawing pilgrims and reinforcing social cohesion across diverse communities. The Mamluk Sultanate (1260–1517 CE) further accelerated this development, commissioning monumental tombs for saints, theologians, and scholars across Syria and Palestine as extensions of madrasa and mosque complexes, often funded by sultans and amirs to project power and piety. Examples include the Maqam al-Nabi Musa near Jericho, where the initial shrine, mosque, and minaret were constructed in 1269 CE under Sultan Baybars, establishing it as a key pilgrimage site en route to Jerusalem. Additional expansions, such as courtyard extensions and decorative enhancements, occurred by 1475 CE, underscoring the era's emphasis on durable stone architecture with domes and iwans to accommodate growing ritual gatherings. These projects not only preserved oral traditions of saintly baraka (blessing) but also mapped sacred landscapes, with estimates of hundreds of maqams documented in later surveys tracing origins to this period. Into the (circa 1500–1800 CE), maqam expansion continued through local endowments and Sufi networks, though at a steadier pace amid Ottoman administrative integration, with renovations focusing on rural sites in and to sustain folk veneration amid theological debates. Structures like those in Judean hills, often simple white-domed enclosures over reputed saintly graves, saw incremental builds using local , reflecting rather than imperial spectacle. This phase embedded maqams deeper into agrarian lifeways, where they functioned as communal anchors for annual mawsim festivals, though records indicate fewer large-scale commissions compared to medieval peaks.

Ottoman Period Developments

During the Ottoman Empire's rule over the , commencing with the conquest of the in 1516–1517, maqam shrines experienced continued expansion and institutionalization as centers of popular piety, particularly within Sufi traditions. Ottoman administrators and sultans supported the construction and renovation of numerous shrines, often integrating them into the system to ensure perpetual maintenance through dedicated endowments of land and revenues. This patronage reflected the empire's pragmatic tolerance for folk Islamic practices, which bolstered social cohesion in provincial territories, with local governors and elites funding projects that numbered in the hundreds across and by the 18th century. For instance, shrines like that of Sheikh al-Qatrawani in Atara exemplify the transitional Mamluk-Ottoman architectural phase, built atop earlier Byzantine ruins and featuring typical domed tomb chambers with adjacent prayer spaces. Sufi orders, including the Naqshbandiyya and , drove much of this development by establishing zawiyas (lodges) adjacent to maqams, transforming isolated tombs into hubs for spiritual retreats, ceremonies, and communal gatherings. These networks linked rural shrines to urban centers, facilitating the dissemination of veneration amid the empire's emphasis on orthodox Hanafi jurisprudence tempered by Sufi influence at the popular level. Archival records indicate that Ottoman officials documented and regulated shrine activities, as seen in directives for repairs and pilgrimage oversight in Iraq's sites, a pattern extending to Levantine maqams where sultanic firmans authorized restorations to prevent decay. Joseph's Maqam in , representative of Ottoman-Islamic architecture, underwent modifications including arched entrances and stone facades, preserving its role as a site of intercommunal reverence despite theological debates over cults. By the , maqams adapted to growing pilgrimage traffic, with events like the annual Nebi Musa festival evolving into mass processions drawing thousands from and beyond, underscoring their socio-political significance under late Ottoman governance. This period saw architectural simplifications—whitewashed domes, minimal ornamentation, and functional layouts—contrasting earlier elaborations, prioritizing accessibility over grandeur in rural settings. However, emerging Salafi critiques within reformist circles began challenging shrine veneration as , though Ottoman authorities generally upheld their cultural role until the empire's dissolution. ![Nebi Musa maqam shrine][float-right]

Modern Era Challenges and Adaptations

In the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, maqam shrines encountered ideological opposition from Salafi and Wahhabi movements, which condemned tomb veneration as (innovation) and shirk (), prompting targeted demolitions in controlled territories. Saudi authorities, influenced by Wahhabi doctrine, systematically razed numerous early Islamic mausolea and sites between the 1920s and ongoing projects into the , including expansions around that obliterated adjacent historical tombs to prevent pilgrimage practices deemed superstitious. This approach, rooted in a literalist interpretation of hadiths prohibiting structures, extended beyond Saudi borders through funded propagation, contributing to attacks on shrines in (e.g., 2006 bombing of Al-Askari Mosque precursors) and by affiliated groups in the . Political conflicts exacerbated physical threats, particularly in the , where maqams became collateral in territorial disputes and ethnic displacements. Following the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, over 500 Palestinian villages were depopulated, leading to the abandonment or partial erasure of associated shrines, with many structures deteriorating due to lack of maintenance amid crises. In and the occupied territories, sites like Maqam Yusuf (Joseph's Tomb) faced repeated vandalism and military clashes, including in 2015 and restricted access protocols that limited Muslim pilgrims while enabling Jewish visits, reflecting competing national narratives over sacred space. Urbanization in the post-Ottoman era further strained rural maqams through land redevelopment and population shifts, reducing visitation as younger generations migrated to cities, though pilgrimage persisted in adapted forms like seasonal mawsim festivals. Adaptations have involved institutional preservation and technological interventions to counter erosion. In , initiatives since the have mapped over 300 surviving maqams using GIS and , creating virtual tours to safeguard intangible heritage against physical loss and foster intergenerational . Israeli authorities have restored select sites, such as those in , as archaeological landmarks under the Antiquities Authority, balancing security with cultural recognition, while Palestinian efforts emphasize communal custodianship (mutawalli) to maintain rituals amid restrictions. Pilgrimage patterns evolved post-1967, incorporating bus tours and state-regulated access, sustaining devotional economies despite secular pressures and ideological critiques from global Salafi networks.

Controversies and Destructions

Theological and Ideological Conflicts

Certain interpretations within , particularly those associated with Salafism and , regard the construction and veneration of maqams as violations of (the oneness of God), classifying associated practices such as seeking intercession from buried saints () or circumambulating graves as shirk (polytheism) and (religious innovation). These critics, drawing on scholars like Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328) and (d. 1792), argue that elevating the dead through domes, offerings, or rituals diverts worship from Allah alone, citing hadiths prohibiting the erection of structures over graves to prevent idolatrous emulation of pre-Islamic practices. While Salafi sources assert this stance aligns with the consensus of the four Sunni madhhabs against excessive grave veneration, mainstream Ash'ari and Maturidi theologians permit visitation for reflection on mortality—provided it avoids to the deceased—viewing outright bans on modest commemoration as overly rigid. This ideological rift has fueled practical conflicts, with Wahhabi-led campaigns systematically demolishing maqams deemed conducive to shirk. In 1803–1804, Saudi forces under the first Wahhabi state captured Mecca and Medina, razing shrines including those associated with early companions and prophets, on grounds that such sites fostered superstition alien to pristine Islam. Similar actions recurred in 1925 after the Saudi reconquest of the Hijaz, when forces leveled the Jannat al-Baqi cemetery's domed maqams over graves of figures like Ibrahim al-Mu'min (son of the Prophet Muhammad) and numerous sahaba, prioritizing monotheistic purity over historical preservation. These efforts, justified theologically as eradicating bid'ah, extended to Sunni saint shrines beyond the Hijaz, as seen in the 1802 Wahhabi sack of Karbala—though targeting a Shi'a site, it exemplified broader iconoclasm against tomb veneration. In contemporary contexts, Salafi-Wahhabi ideology continues to inspire opposition, with groups like destroying Levantine maqams (e.g., those of Sufi saints in and between 2014–2017) under the same rationale of combating shirk, though such acts deviate from state-sanctioned by targeting even prophetic sites. Defenders of maqams, often from Sufi-influenced Sunni traditions, counter that permissible honors righteous forebears without deifying them, citing prophetic precedents for grave visitation, yet Salafi critiques persist in framing these as gateways to , exacerbating sectarian divides within Sunni communities.

Political and Conflict-Driven Incidents

In the context of the 1948 Arab-i War, numerous maqam shrines located in Palestinian villages depopulated during the conflict were systematically destroyed by i forces as part of post-conquest operations to prevent return or symbolic continuity. This included over 400 such sites in what became , often reduced to rubble alongside village structures, though some were repurposed or left intact if deemed architecturally valuable. During the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Israeli authorities have demolished individual maqams in the to facilitate settlement expansion or infrastructure. For instance, in September 2020, a maqam near the settlement of Ariel was razed to construct a barrier, leaving no remnants of the structure. In Gaza, the 2023-2024 Israel-Hamas resulted in the destruction of multiple maqams amid broader airstrikes on heritage sites, including the maqam of al-Khidr in and others in areas like Tall al-Mintar and Al-Shaykh Ijlin, with confirming over 100 affected cultural-religious structures by early 2024. In 's civil war, militants targeted maqams as part of their campaign against perceived idolatrous practices associated with Sufi veneration. In September 2014, demolished several Sufi shrines in eastern , including those dedicated to local saints, using explosives to erase sites they labeled as sites of shirk (). Similar ideologically driven attacks occurred elsewhere in ISIS-held territories, though maqams were secondary to pre-Islamic monuments in their . These incidents reflect broader Salafi-jihadist opposition to shrine-based piety, contrasting with state or territorial conflicts where destruction served security or expansion aims.

Notable Examples

Prominent Maqams in the

The maqam, situated approximately 6 kilometers east of in the , , is among the most significant shrines in the , traditionally marking the burial site of the prophet (Musa in ). Constructed in 1269 CE by I, the structure exemplifies unadorned Mamluk architecture with a white-domed and prayer halls, serving as a focal point for Muslim pilgrims. Annual festivals at the site, documented from the medieval period through the Ottoman era, attracted tens of thousands, reinforcing communal identity until disruptions in the due to regional conflicts. In southern Israel, the Nabi Rubin maqam, dedicated to , the eldest son of the biblical patriarch , stands as a notable example of 15th-century construction in the coastal plains near Palmachim. Built over a purported saint's , it featured a large complex with courtyards and a , hosting seasonal pilgrimages that blended religious observance with local until its partial destruction in the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. The site's , including striped stone facades and arched entrances, reflects adaptations of regional building techniques for devotional purposes. Further north in the region, numerous maqams dot the landscape, such as the Maqam al-Khidr in (now near Shlomi), a monumental structure originally from a Palestinian village, honoring the saint al-Khidr (associated with in some traditions). Erected in the Ottoman period with domed interiors and intricate tilework, these shrines facilitated Sufi practices and interfaith veneration, though many faced demolition or repurposing post-1948. In the Judean hills, the Maqam Neby Kifl near Tirat Yehuda commemorates the prophet (Dhul-Kifl), featuring a simple tomb enclosure that underscores the proliferation of prophetic attribution in Levantine sacred geography. Across the in modern Jordan, maqams like that of Prophet Shuayb (Jethro) near the ancient city of represent extensions of Levantine traditions, with structures dating to the Ayyubid-Mamluk transition emphasizing prophetic lineages shared in Islamic . In Lebanon, the Maqam Shamoun al-Safa in Shamaa honors the apostle Simon (Shamoun), blending early Christian and Islamic saint veneration in a modest setting that highlights syncretic elements in southern Levantine piety. Syrian examples, such as those in the countryside dedicated to local walis, parallel these but often integrate urban complexes, though rural maqams like the Tomb of Hud in al-Balad maintain pilgrimage roles amid diverse sectarian contexts.

Maqams in Other Regions

In , particularly modern-day , the term "makam" is applied to certain saint shrines, often alongside local designations like "türbe" or "yatır," reflecting Ottoman-era influences from Levantine traditions. These structures venerate Sufi sheikhs, prophets, or companions of the Prophet , serving as sites for and supplication. For example, tombs in regions such as and are explicitly named "maqam," associated with beliefs in the intercession of buried saints and practices like votive offerings. In , while maqams in the strict Levantine architectural sense—small, white-domed enclosures for local walis—are uncommon, analogous saint shrines embody similar devotional functions under terms like "zaouia" or "." Morocco's , including the tomb of Jazuli (d. 1465), draw pilgrims for baraka (spiritual blessing), with rituals mirroring those at Levantine maqams, such as and prayer for healing or prosperity; these sites trace to medieval Sufi networks that paralleled Levantine saint veneration. Further afield in , the maqam concept manifests in dargahs, expansive complexes housing tombs that attract mass visitation, though the term "maqam" appears sporadically for imported or hybrid sites. Rare instances include the Maqam Hazrat in Kallar, , dedicated to a 17th-century Malaysian , illustrating transregional Sufi migration and the of shrine-building amid local Hindu-Buddhist influences. Overall, these regional variants underscore a shared folk Islamic emphasis on , distinct from orthodox Salafi critiques but rooted in empirical patterns of devotion observed across Sunni-majority areas since the medieval period.

References

  1. https://www.bethlehem.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Syntheses-Maqamat_FINAL-VERSION.pdf
  2. https://staff.najah.edu/media/published_research/2021/08/12/Muslim_shrines_in_Palestine.pdf
  3. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267632318_Mapping_Muslim_Sacred_Tombs_in_Palestine_During_the_Mandate_Period
  4. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/703467
  5. https://revistas.rcaap.pt/cct/article/download/39778/28344
  6. https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1235758
  7. https://themarkaz.org/not-forgotten-not-all-erased-palestines-sacred-shrines/
  8. https://journals.openedition.org/cidades/9804
  9. https://www.platformspace.net/home/islamic-pasts-and-futures-in-palestine
  10. https://corescholar.libraries.wright.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1307&context=history
  11. https://madainproject.com/list_of_notable_muslim_shrines_in_palestine
  12. https://www.academia.edu/8402487/Muslim_Shrines_in_Palestine
  13. https://www.academia.edu/128763711/The_spiritual_architecture_of_Maqamat_From_the_digitisation_of_Architectural_Heritage_sites_to_the_enhancement_of_cultural_memory_through_virtual_narratives
  14. https://oxfordre.com/religion/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199340378.001.0001/acrefore-9780199340378-e-952
  15. https://journals.eikipub.com/index.php/jcpas/article/download/156/116/447
  16. https://nocousinsleft.com/2021/03/21/veneration-of-pirs-at-dargahs/
  17. https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1461&context=jams
  18. https://www.techofheart.com/2008/03/sufi-shrines-in-america.html
  19. https://al-islam.org/media/spiritual-authority-awliya-shii-and-sufi-traditions
  20. https://mshmsdin.com/en/5802
  21. https://rsaa.org.uk/blog/sufism-and-the-state-saints-shrines-in-central-asia/
  22. https://ia601506.us.archive.org/2/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.21915/2015.21915.Sufism-Its-Saints-And-Shrines_text.pdf
  23. https://blog.sufinama.org/sufi-practices-as-the-cause-of-spiritual-mental-and-physical-healing/
  24. https://islamicdiscourse.substack.com/p/ibn-taymiyyah-on-the-root-cause-of
  25. http://www.tawhidfirst.com/monotheism/articles/rbduh-shaykh-al-islam-ibn-taymiyyah-on-those-seeking-supplication-and-intercession-from-inhabitants-of-graves.cfm
  26. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/26312
  27. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/130919
  28. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/8991
  29. https://www.opindia.com/2024/07/the-destruction-of-mecca-medina-how-wahabi-islam-razed-down-ancient-structures-fearing-idolatry/
  30. https://www.wrightstreetmosque.com/30-statements-and-observations-on-the-grave-worshippers-and-those-that-call-upon-the-dead-by-shaikh-sulaimaan-aal-ash-shaikh/
  31. https://www.abuaminaelias.com/dailyhadithonline/2021/10/14/haram-build-sit-salat-graves/
  32. https://www.palestine-studies.org/sites/default/files/attachments/jps-articles/Bones_of_Contention_Muslim_Shrines_in_Palestine.pdf
  33. https://borisfenus.blogspot.com/2013/01/10-rebuilt-maqams-and-modern-replicas.html
  34. https://journals.openedition.org/cidades/9804?lang=en
  35. https://sannyassa.co.uk/sidi-ishaq-and-meditations-on-baraka/
  36. https://ethnobiomed.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1746-4269-3-28
  37. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233704716_The_Sacred_Place_of_Sheikh_Shihab_Ed-Din
  38. http://ijtihadnet.com/wp-content/uploads/The-Shrines-of-the-Alids-in-Medieval-Syria.pdf
  39. https://www.academia.edu/5542553/Holy_Place_in_the_Making_Maqam_al_Nabi_Musa_Jericho_in_the_Early_Mamluk_Period
  40. https://www.travelpalestine.ps/en/Site/22/Maqam-of-Sheikh-al-Qatrawani%2C-Atara-town-%28Shrine%29
  41. https://brill.com/view/journals/jesh/64/7/article-p897_2.xml?language=en
  42. https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/10.3366/hlps.2020.0228
  43. https://www.jerusalemstory.com/en/article/pilgrimage-festival-uprising-evolution-nabi-musa-tradition
  44. https://imcra-az.org/uploads/public_files/2025-05/23.pdf
  45. https://www.citiesfromsalt.com/blog/the-destruction-of-mecca-and-medinas-historic-landscapes
  46. https://doi.org/10.3366/edinburgh/9781474417570.003.0003
  47. https://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004444270/BP000008.xml?language=en
  48. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/390715649_The_spiritual_architecture_of_Maqamat_From_the_digitisation_of_Architectural_Heritage_sites_to_the_enhancement_of_cultural_memory_through_virtual_narratives
  49. https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/14/8/1043
  50. https://ebnhussein.com/2021/07/25/grave-veneration-according-to-the-four-sunni-schools-the-origin-of-shirk/
  51. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/10843
  52. https://www.pharosjot.com/uploads/7/1/6/3/7163688/article_26_106_4__regular_issue_august.pdf
  53. https://www.icit-digital.org/articles/meccahattan
  54. https://arabamericannews.com/2021/05/15/never-ending-destruction-of-historical-sites-in-mecca-and-medina-cradle-of-islam/
  55. https://www.chieftain.com/story/opinion/columns/2004/06/19/tearing-down-house-wahhabis-have/8901031007/
  56. https://www.972mag.com/palestinian-holy-sites-west-bank/
  57. https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/node/1655123
  58. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/1/14/a-cultural-genocide-which-of-gazas-heritage-sites-have-been-destroyed
  59. https://www.npr.org/2023/12/03/1216200754/gaza-heritage-sites-destroyed-israel
  60. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/islamic-state-destroys-sufi-shrines-in-eastern-syria-watchdog-idUSKBN0H80K2/
  61. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/150901-isis-destruction-looting-ancient-sites-iraq-syria-archaeology
  62. https://madainproject.com/nabi_musa
  63. https://www.biblewalks.com/nebimusa/
  64. https://www.travelpalestine.ps/en/Site/236/The-Shrine-of-Nabi-Musa
  65. https://www.timesofisrael.com/explore-the-medieval-shrines-left-behind-by-a-ruling-class-of-warriors/
  66. https://borisfenus.blogspot.com/2018/10/7-maqams-galilee-and-golan-heights.html
  67. https://jecs.pl/index.php/jecs/article/view/1494/1266
  68. https://sacredfootsteps.com/2015/05/16/untold-marrakesh-the-seven-saints/
  69. https://somaliwave.com/index.php?threads/why-do-muslims-build-maqam-shrines.20713/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.