Hubbry Logo
Old Catholic ChurchOld Catholic ChurchMain
Open search
Old Catholic Church
Community hub
Old Catholic Church
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Old Catholic Church
Old Catholic Church
Old Catholic Church
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Old Catholic Church
PolityEpiscopal
Union of Utrecht
Union of Scranton
AssociationsWorld Council of Churches (Union of Utrecht only)
Full communionAnglican Communion (Union of Utrecht only)
Church of Sweden (Union of Utrecht only)[3]
Philippine Independent Church (Union of Utrecht only)
Separated fromCatholic Church
Also known as Old Catholics or Old-Catholic churches
Part of a series on
Christianity
Principal symbol of Christianity
Theology
Related topics

The terms Old Catholic Church, Old Catholics, Old-Catholic churches,[4] or Old Catholic movement,[5] designate "any of the groups of Western Christians who believe themselves to maintain in complete loyalty the doctrine and traditions of the undivided church but who separated from the See of Rome after the First Vatican Council of 1869–70".[6][7]

The expression Old Catholic has been used from the 1850s by communions separated from the Roman Catholic Church over certain doctrines, primarily concerned with papal authority and infallibility. Some of these groups, especially in the Netherlands, had already existed long before the term. The Old Catholic Church is separate and distinct from Traditionalist Catholicism.

Two groups of Old Catholic churches currently exist: the Union of Utrecht (UU, not to be confused with Unitarian Universalism) and the Union of Scranton (US). Neither group is in full communion with the Holy See. Member churches of the Union of Utrecht are in full communion with the Anglican Communion as well as the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Sweden and the Philippine Independent Church[8][9] and many UU churches are members of the World Council of Churches.[10][11] Other churches which claim to be Old Catholic yet are not members of the Union of Utrecht or Union of Scranton are Independent Old Catholics.[12]

Both groups trace their beginning to the 18th century when members of the See of Utrecht refused to obey papal authority and were excommunicated. Later Catholics who disagreed with the Roman Catholic dogma of papal infallibility, as defined by the First Vatican Council (1870), were thereafter without a bishop and joined with the See of Utrecht to form the Union of Utrecht of the Old Catholic Churches. Today, Utrechter Union churches are found chiefly in Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands, Austria, Poland, and the Czech Republic.

In 2008, the Polish National Catholic Church created the Union of Scranton and separated from the Union of Utrecht. This was done in protest of the older Union's decision to ordain women and bless same-sex marriages. The Nordic Catholic Church later joined the Union of Scranton as well.

History

[edit]

Pre-Reformation diocese and archdiocese of Utrecht

[edit]
Main article: Archdiocese of Utrecht (695–1580)

In the pre-Reformation era, there were already disputes that set the stage for an independent bishopric of Utrecht between the Catholic Church and the Holy Roman Empire, notably during between the 11th to 15th centuries.

Post-Reformation Netherlands

[edit]
Main articles: Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands and Old Catholic Archdiocese of Utrecht

The northern provinces that revolted against the Spanish Netherlands and signed the 1579 Union of Utrecht, persecuted the Roman Catholic Church, confiscated church property, expelled monks and nuns from convents and monasteries, and made it illegal to receive the Catholic sacraments.[13] As a result, priests and communities went underground. Groups would meet for the sacraments in the attics of private homes at the risk of arrest.[14] Priests identified themselves by wearing all black clothing with very simple collars.[15]

All the episcopal sees of the area, including that of Utrecht, had fallen vacant by 1580, because the Spanish crown, which since 1559 had patronal rights over all bishoprics in the Netherlands, refused to make appointments for what it saw as heretical territories, and the nomination of an apostolic vicar was seen as a way of avoiding direct violation of the privilege granted to the crown.[15] The appointment of an apostolic vicar, the first after many centuries, for what came to be called the Holland Mission was followed by similar appointments for other Protestant-ruled countries, such as England, which likewise became mission territories.[15] The disarray of the Roman Catholic Church in the Netherlands between 1572 and about 1610 was followed by a period of expansion of Roman Catholicism under the apostolic vicars,[16] leading to Protestant protests.[17]

The initial shortage of Roman Catholic priests in the Netherlands resulted in increased pastoral activity of religious clergy, among whom Jesuits formed a considerable minority, coming to represent between 10 and 15 percent of all the Dutch clergy in the 1600–1650 period. Conflicts arose between these, and the apostolic vicars and secular clergy.[18] In 1629, there were 321 Roman Catholic priests in the United Provinces, 250 secular and 71 religious, with Jesuits at 34 forming almost half of the religious. By the middle of the 17th century, the secular priests were 442, the religious 142, of whom 62 were Jesuits.[19]

The sixth apostolic vicar of the Dutch/Holland Mission, Petrus Codde, was appointed in 1688. In 1691, the Jesuits accused him of favouring the Jansenist heresy.[20] Pope Innocent XII appointed a commission of cardinals to investigate the accusations against Codde. The commission concluded that the accusations were groundless.[21] In 1702, Pope Clement XI deposed Codde, to which Codde obeyed.[22]

While the religious clergy remained loyal to the Holy See, three-quarters of the secular clergy at first followed Codde, but by 1706 over two-thirds of these returned to Roman Catholic allegiance.[23] Of the laity, the overwhelming majority sided with the Holy See.[19] Thus, most Dutch Catholics remained in full communion with the pope and with the apostolic vicars appointed by him.

After Codde's resignation, the Diocese of Utrecht elected Cornelius Steenoven as bishop.[24] The See of Utrecht declared the right to elect its own archbishop in 1724, after being accused of Jansenism. Following consultation with both canon lawyers and theologians in France and Germany, Dominique Marie Varlet, a Catholic bishop of the French Oratorian Society of Foreign Missions, consecrated Steenoven as a bishop without a papal mandate.[25] What had been de jure autonomous became de facto an independent Catholic church. Although the pope was notified of all proceedings, the Holy See still regarded the diocese as vacant due to papal permission not being sought. The pope, therefore, continued to appoint apostolic vicars for the Netherlands. Steenoven and the other bishops were excommunicated by the Roman Catholic Church, and thus began the Old Catholic Church in the Netherlands.[14] Subsequent bishops were then appointed and ordained to the sees of Deventer, Haarlem and Groningen under the See of Utrecht in later years.[26]

Due to prevailing anti-papal feeling among the powerful Dutch Calvinists, the Church of Utrecht was tolerated and even praised by the government of the Dutch Republic.[27]

In 1853 Pope Pius IX received guarantees of religious freedom from King William II of the Netherlands and re-established the Roman Catholic hierarchy in the Netherlands.[28] The Holy See considers the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Utrecht as the continuation of the episcopal see founded in the 7th century and raised to metropolitan status on 12 May 1559, thus not recognizing any legitimacy of Old Catholics.[29]

First Vatican Council, Old Catholic Union of Utrecht

[edit]
Papal primacy, supremacy and infallibility
Overview
Patriarchs
compared to popes
Ecumenical councils
compared to popes
Catholic episcopal councils
compared to popes
Political rulers
compared to popes
Existing dogma
compared to popes
Objections and controversy

After the First Vatican Council (1869–1870), several groups of Roman Catholics in Austria-Hungary, Imperial Germany, and Switzerland rejected the Roman Catholic dogma of papal infallibility in matters of faith and morals and left to form their own churches.[30] The formation of the Old Catholic communion of Germans, Austrians and Swiss began under the leadership of Ignaz von Döllinger, following the First Vatican Council.[4] These were supported by the Old Catholic Archbishop of Utrecht, who ordained priests and bishops for them. Later the Dutch were united more formally with many of these groups under the name "Utrecht Union of Churches".[31]

In the spring of 1871, a convention in Munich attracted several hundred participants, including Church of England and Protestant observers.[32] Döllinger, an excommunicated Roman Catholic priest and church historian, was a notable leader of the movement but was never a member of an Old Catholic church.[33]

The convention decided to form the "Old Catholic Church" in order to distinguish its members from what they saw as the novel teaching in the Roman Catholic dogma of papal infallibility. Although it had continued to use the Roman Rite, from the middle of the 18th century the Dutch Old Catholic See of Utrecht had increasingly used the vernacular instead of Latin. The churches which broke from the Holy See in 1870 and subsequently entered into union with the Old Catholic See of Utrecht gradually introduced the vernacular into the liturgy until it completely replaced Latin in 1877.[34] In 1874, the Old Catholics removed the requirement of clerical celibacy.[21]

The Catholic Diocese of the Old Catholics in Germany received support from the government of Otto von Bismarck, whose 1870s Kulturkampf policies persecuted the Roman Catholic Church.[35] In Austria-Hungary, pan-Germanic nationalist groups, like those of Georg Ritter von Schönerer, promoted the conversion of all German speaking Catholics to Old Catholicism and Lutheranism, with poor results.[36]

Spread of Old Catholicism throughout the world

[edit]
Old Catholic parish church in Gablonz an der Neiße, Austria-Hungary (now Jablonec nad Nisou, Czech Republic). Some ethnic German Roman Catholics supported Döllinger in his rejection of the Roman Catholic dogma of papal infallibility.

In 1897 a group of Polish migrants in the United States broke away from the Holy See due to theological and liturgical issues; their leader, Franciszek Hodur, was consecrated a bishop by Old Catholic Archbishop of Utrecht Gerardus Gul, establishing the Polish National Catholic Church, which joined the Union of Utrecht.

Split of Old Roman Catholics and Liberal Catholics

[edit]

In 1910, Arnold Mathew—a former British Catholic and Anglican, who was consecrated by Old Catholic Archbishop Gul in 1908—split away from the Union of Utrecht, establishing the Old Roman Catholic Church in Great Britain. In 1914, he consecrated Rudolph de Landas Berghes, who emigrated to the United States in 1914 and planted the seed of Old Roman Catholicism in the Americas. Mathew also consecrated an excommunicated Capuchin Franciscan priest as bishop: Carmel Henry Carfora.[37] Various Christian denominations claiming apostolic succession from Mathew were founded in the world through Berghes, Carfora, and others including James Wedgwood—founder of the Liberal Catholic Church. Such groups' apostolic succession is deemed to be invalid by both the Holy See, the Union of Utrecht and the Anglican Communion. Mathew himself was excommunicated and declared a "pseudo-bishop" by Pope Pius X,[38] while the International Old Catholic Bishops' Conference declared his consecration to be null and void, obtained mala fide.[39]

Another significant figure, Joseph René Vilatte, who was ordained a deacon and priest by Bishop Eduard Herzog, of the Christian Catholic Church of Switzerland;[40] he worked with Catholics of Belgian ancestry living on the Door Peninsula of Wisconsin, with the knowledge and blessing of the Union of Utrecht and under the full jurisdiction of the local Episcopal Bishop of Fond du Lac, Wisconsin.[41] However, he subsequently left the Old Catholics and was later consecrated a bishop by Patriarch Mar Julius I of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, though the validity of such consecration is disputed.[39] He proceeded to establish a number of Christian denominations before eventually reconciling with the Holy See.[42]

Polish National Catholic schism from Utrecht

[edit]

In 2003, the Polish National Catholic Church voted itself out of the UU due to the Utrechter Union's acceptance of female ordination, and their attitude towards homosexuality, both of which the Polish National Catholic Church rejects.[43][44] Prior, in 1994, the German Old Catholic bishops of the Utrechter Union decided to ordain women as priests, and put this into practice on 27 May 1996. Similar decisions and practices followed in Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands.[45] By 2020, the Swiss church also voted in favour of same-sex marriage. Marriages between two men and two women were conducted in the same manner as heterosexual marriages.[46]

Old Catholic Church of Slovakia within Utrecht

[edit]

The Old Catholic Church of Slovakia was accepted in 2000 as a member of the Union of Utrecht.[47] As early as 2001 some issues arose concerning future consecration of Augustin Bacinsky as old-catholic bishop of Slovakia, and the matter was postponed.[48] The Old Catholic Church of Slovakia was expelled from the Union of Utrecht in 2004, because the episcopal administrator Augustin Bacinsky had been consecrated by an episcopus vagans.[49]

Independent Old Catholicism in the Americas

[edit]

At present, the only recognized Christian church in North America that is in communion with the Union of Utrecht is the Episcopal Church.[50] Since the Polish National Catholic Church schismed with the Utrechter Old Catholics, the two Old Catholic unions do not recognize each other. Christians claiming to be Old Catholic outside of both the Union of Utrecht and Union of Scranton are referred to as Independent Old Catholics; according to Robert Caruso in The Old Catholic Church:[12]

The history of the independent Old Catholic movement in the U.S. is highly disordered, partially because so many fragmented entities have erroneously adopted the term "Old Catholic," e.g., the Old Roman Catholic Church, the Liberal Catholic Church, the churches established by Bishop Vilatte and Bishop Mathew, and so on. This problem developed when more and more self-labeled independent Catholic bishops began falsely claiming to be part of the Old Catholic Church. These wandering bishops (as they are labeled by Utrecht and the Anglican churches) were, in a manner of speaking, altogether of another ecclesial origin apart from the Old Catholic churches of the Union of Utrecht.

Statistics

[edit]

As of 2016, there were 115,000 members of Old Catholic churches.[51]

Church Membership
Catholic Diocese of the Old-Catholics in Germany 15,500[52]
Old Catholic Church of Austria 14,621[53]
Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands 10,000[54]
Christian Catholic Church of Switzerland 13,500[55]
Old Catholic Mariavite Church in Poland 29,000[56]
Polish Catholic Church in Poland[b] 20,000[57]

Doctrine

[edit]

Old Catholic theology views the Eucharist as the core of the Christian Church; from this point of view, the church is a community of believers. All are in communion with one another around the sacrifice of Jesus Christ, as the highest expression of the love of God. Therefore, the celebration of the Eucharist is understood as the experience of Christ's triumph over sin. The defeat of sin consists in bringing together that which is divided.[58]

An active contributor to the Declaration of the Catholic Congress of Munich, 1871—and all later assemblies—was Johann Friedrich von Schulte, professor of dogmatics at Prague. Von Schulte summed up the results of the congress as follows:[59]

  • adherence to the ancient Catholic faith;
  • maintenance of the rights of Catholics;
  • rejection of new Roman Catholic dogmas;
  • adherence to the constitutions of the ancient Church with repudiation of every dogma of faith not in harmony with the by-then established conscience of the Church;
  • reform of the Church with constitutional participation of the laity;
  • preparation of the way for reunion of the Christian confessions;
  • reform of the training and position of the clergy;
  • adherence to the State against the attacks of Ultramontanism;
  • rejection of the Society of Jesus;
  • claim to the real property of the Church

The 1889 Declaration of Utrecht states the Union of Utrecht believes in Vincent of Lérins's following quote from his Commonitory: "all possible care must be taken, that we hold that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, by all; for this is truly what is catholic".[60][61] The UU allows those who are divorced to have a new religious marriage in the church,[62] and Old Catholics had gradually replaced the Latin mass with the vernacular by 1877.[34] In 1989, the Union of Utrecht opposed abortion, but "[u]nusual exceptions should be made in consultation with a priest".[63]

Apostolic succession

[edit]

Old Catholicism values apostolic succession by which they mean both the uninterrupted laying on of hands by bishops through time (the historic episcopate), and the continuation of the whole life of the church community by word and sacrament over the years and ages. Old Catholics consider apostolic succession to be the handing on of belief in which the whole Church is involved. In this process the ministry has a special responsibility and task, caring for the continuation in time of the mission of Jesus Christ and his apostles.[58]

According to the principle of ex opere operato, certain ordinations by bishops not in communion with Rome are still recognised as being valid by the Holy See, and the ordinations of and by Old Catholic bishops in the Union of Utrecht churches has never been formally questioned by the Holy See until the more recent ordinations of women as priests.[64]

Ecumenism

[edit]

The Union of Utrecht considers that the reunion of the churches has to be based on a re-actualization of the decisions of faith made by the undivided Church. In that way, they claim, the original unity of the Church could be made visible again. Following these principles, later bishops and theologians of the Union of Utrechts churches stayed in contact with Russian Orthodox, Lutheran and Anglican representatives.[3][65]

Old Catholic involvement in the multilateral ecumenical movement formally began with the participation of two bishops, from the Netherlands and Switzerland, at the Lausanne Faith and Order (F&O) conference (1927). This side of ecumenism has always remained a major interest for Old Catholics who have never missed an F&O conference. Old Catholics also participate in other activities of the WCC and of national councils of churches. By active participation in the ecumenical movement since its very beginning, the OCC demonstrates its belief in this work.[65]

See also

[edit]

Movements

[edit]

People

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Old Catholic Church

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Old Catholic Churches comprise a federation of autonomous Western Christian denominations that originated from schisms with the Roman Catholic Church following the First Vatican Council (1869–1870), chiefly in opposition to the dogma of papal infallibility. United primarily under the Union of Utrecht, established in 1889, these national churches—centered in countries including the Netherlands, Germany, Austria, and Switzerland—preserve apostolic succession, the Nicene Creed, and the seven sacraments in a liturgical form akin to pre-Tridentine Catholicism, while rejecting Vatican I's ultramontane definitions of papal primacy and infallibility as innovations diverging from the collegial governance of the early Church. Governed through an episcopal-synodal structure emphasizing consensus among bishops via the International Old Catholic Bishops' Conference, the churches permit and, in several member bodies, the to the priesthood, practices aligned with their interpretation of scriptural and patristic norms over centralized Roman discipline. Notable for fostering ecumenical ties, they entered with the through the 1931 Bonn Agreement, reflecting a shared commitment to apostolic faith amid rejection of post-Reformation papal claims, though their small scale has limited broader influence.

History

Origins in the Archdiocese of Utrecht

The Diocese of Utrecht originated in the missionary work of Saint Willibrord, an Anglo-Saxon monk born around 658, who was consecrated bishop for the by on 21 June 695 and established his episcopal see at by 696, following grants of territory from . This foundation laid the groundwork for Christianity in the , with Willibrord's efforts focusing on converting pagan and organizing ecclesiastical structures independent of immediate Roman oversight, though under the broader Carolingian framework. From its inception, the exhibited jurisdictional through the election of bishops by the local of canons, a privilege recognized by papal authority and sustained for over a millennium under Frankish and Holy Roman imperial systems, allowing to administer its affairs with minimal direct interference from . Despite nominal suffragan status to the Archdiocese of Cologne from the 8th century onward, Utrecht preserved this electoral right via papal confirmations, resisting encroachments that characterized Roman centralization elsewhere; conflicts arose in the 11th and 12th centuries over territorial boundaries and metropolitan claims by , prompting papal interventions such as those under around 1090, which upheld Utrecht's privileges while mediating disputes without subordinating its customs. The , composed of canons who increasingly aligned with the Rule of St. Augustine amid 11th- and 12th-century reforms emphasizing regular observance, fostered unique local traditions, including liturgical rites that diverged from strict Roman uniformity by incorporating regional elements and preserving pre-Carolingian usages distinct from the curial rite's standardization. These practices, such as variations in the and use of indigenous languages in devotions, underscored Utrecht's early , enabling continuity of apostolic governance amid broader ecclesiastical tensions.

Post-Reformation Autonomy in the Netherlands

Following the (1568–1648), which secured the independence of the northern provinces from Spanish Habsburg rule, the established the Reformed Church as the dominant public faith, confiscating Catholic properties and restricting open worship. Despite this suppression, the metropolitan chapter of the preserved a clandestine hierarchical structure, drawing on ancient canonical rights to elect bishops independently of , fueled by local resentment toward centralized Habsburg—and by extension, papal—authority. This autonomy stemmed from the chapter's historical privileges, recognized since the , which allowed metropolitan election without prior papal confirmation, enabling survival amid Protestant ascendancy through hidden churches (schuilkerken) and informal toleration after the 1572 . Tensions escalated in the late when , suspecting Jansenist sympathies in , dispatched Jesuit investigators to enforce and probe Vicar Apostolic Petrus Codde (serving as de facto from 1686). Codde, accused of favoring Jansenist texts like Pasquier Quesnel's Réflexions morales, faced deposition by papal in 1702, though the chapter upheld his legitimacy until his death in 1710. The resulting vacancy prompted the chapter to elect Cornelius van Steenoven as in April 1722, bypassing papal approval amid Rome's refusal to confirm candidates tainted by perceived . Steenoven's consecration on 15 October 1724 by Dominique-Marie Varlet, a missionary bishop temporarily in , marked the initiation of an episcopal lineage outside Roman oversight, as Varlet's own faculties had lapsed due to similar disputes. This act preserved through non-papal channels, reflecting Dutch Catholic resistance to ultramontane intrusions, which had intensified to counter Jansenist rigor—characterized by emphasis on , , and ascetic morality over indulgences and frequent sacraments. The chapter's defiance, rooted in national independence from , fostered a distinct identity prioritizing synodal governance and moral austerity, sustaining the tradition without full submission to vicarial structures imposed by on other Dutch Catholics.

The First Vatican Council and Initial Schism

The First Vatican Council, summoned by Pope Pius IX via the bull Aeterni Patris on June 29, 1868, and opening its first session on December 8, 1869, culminated in the dogmatic constitution Pastor aeternus promulgated on July 18, 1870. This document defined the Pope's universal episcopal jurisdiction as immediate and independent over the entire Church, granting him full power to rule, govern, and tend the universal flock without mediation by councils or bishops. It further asserted papal infallibility, stating that when the Roman Pontiff speaks ex cathedra—defining a doctrine on faith or morals for the whole Church—he possesses, by divine assistance promised to Peter and his successors, that infallibility which Christ willed the Church to enjoy in such definitions, rendering them irreformable by their own nature. These decrees represented a consolidation of ultramontane principles, prioritizing over conciliar authority, which provoked immediate rejection among clergy in the autonomous Archdiocese of . Long independent from Roman oversight due to prior conflicts over , Utrecht's leaders viewed the dogmas as innovations contradicting the ecclesiological balance established by earlier ecumenical councils, particularly Constance (1414–1418), where decrees like Haec sancta affirmed a general council's superiority to the in resolving s, heresies, and reforms. The Utrecht declaration against the Vatican definitions emphasized fidelity to patristic and conciliar traditions over centralized papal claims, framing the as a preservation of collegial governance rather than rebellion. In , intellectual opposition led by theologian Johann Joseph Ignaz von Döllinger, who argued the infallibility lacked historical and scriptural warrant, spurred defections among and , resulting in such as that of Döllinger in 1871 and subsequent priests who refused submission. This dissent prompted the formation of independent Old Catholic parishes, with Joseph Hubert Reinkens elected and consecrated as the first German Old Catholic bishop in 1873 after his own excommunication. Parallel movements in saw similar parish establishments under figures like Eduard , driven by shared concerns over papal overreach undermining episcopal autonomy. Archbishop Johannes Heykamp of Utrecht bolstered these nascent communities by authorizing confirmations for children of the excommunicated as early as 1872 and participating in Reinkens' consecration, providing apostolic continuity amid the . This support underscored the causal rift: not mere doctrinal disagreement, but a principled stand against decrees perceived to erode the Church's synodal character in favor of monarchical absolutism, setting the stage for distinct Old Catholic identities in Europe.

Formation and Consolidation of the Union of Utrecht

The was formally established on September 24, 1889, when bishops from the Old Catholic Churches of the , , , and convened in to adopt the Declaration of Utrecht, a foundational document affirming adherence to the faith and order of the undivided early Church, including the , while explicitly rejecting the dogmas of and universal jurisdiction promulgated by the . This declaration served as the doctrinal basis for the union, emphasizing shared rejection of post-Reformation Roman innovations to preserve , yet permitting national churches autonomy in non-essential disciplinary and liturgical matters to accommodate regional contexts. Consolidation of the union progressed through episcopal collaborations that standardized sacramental validity and , particularly under Archbishop Gerardus Gul of (1892–1920), who conducted key consecrations to ensure continuity amid the small size and isolation of these communities from Roman structures. This pragmatic institutionalization countered marginalization by , fostering mutual recognition among member churches while gradually moderating the rigorous Jansenist influences inherited from the Dutch tradition, shifting toward a broader patristic orientation without rigid moralism. A milestone in external consolidation came with the Bonn Agreement of July 2, 1931, negotiated between representatives of the Union of Utrecht's Old Catholic Churches and the in , , which established limited intercommunion by mutually recognizing each other's , admitting members to sacraments, and pledging no , thereby bolstering the union's viability through alliances without compromising its core anti-infallibilist principles. This accord underscored the union's strategy of selective ecumenical ties for survival, prioritizing doctrinal fidelity to pre-Vatican I Catholicism over isolation.

Global Expansion and Major Schisms

Following the consolidation of the in 1889, the Old Catholic Churches pursued expansion through international congresses initiated in 1890, which facilitated missionary outreach and the establishment of new national jurisdictions across Europe and . The most significant early growth occurred via the (PNCC), founded in 1897 among Polish immigrants in the United States seeking liturgical and administrative autonomy from Roman Catholic oversight; it entered with Utrecht in 1897 for its American branch and 1907 for its Canadian extension, enabling and shared doctrinal frameworks. This affiliation supported PNCC development into multiple dioceses, contributing to Old Catholic presence in , while parallel efforts established parishes in (joining formally in 1890), post-World War I successor states like (splitting from Austrian Old Catholics), and smaller communities in , , , and under delegated oversight. In the early 20th century, internal tensions over doctrinal adaptation versus preservation of tradition manifested in key fractures. The emerged in 1916 through a reorganization of the Old Catholic movement in , led by Bishop James , who incorporated theosophical influences emphasizing esoteric spirituality and universalist sacraments, diverging from Utrecht's ecclesial norms and prompting separation from mainstream Old Catholic bodies. Concurrently, traditionalist factions coalesced into various Old Roman Catholic jurisdictions, which rejected perceived liberal encroachments in Utrecht-affiliated churches—such as ecumenical overtures and liturgical flexibilities—opting instead for stricter adherence to 19th-century Catholic practices while maintaining claims to Utrecht-derived succession but outside its communion. Later 20th-century schisms intensified amid Utrecht's progressive shifts, particularly clerical liberalization. The Croatian Old Catholic Church, admitted in 1924, experienced sharp decline after , losing diocesan structure due to geopolitical disruptions and assimilation pressures, with remnants absorbed or dormant by mid-century. The PNCC, facing Utrecht's endorsement of women's starting in the 1990s, terminated communion in 2003, citing irreconcilable divergences on and ; this severed ties with the largest non-European member, reducing Utrecht's transatlantic footprint. Similarly, the Old Catholic Church of gained recognition in 2000 but was excluded in 2004 after its bishop received consecration from an independent (vagans) source, undermining apostolic validity under Utrecht statutes and highlighting vulnerabilities to external influences amid adaptation debates. These fractures contributed to post-World War II stagnation, with empirical records indicating limited numerical growth despite sporadic missions. Global membership in Utrecht churches hovered around 115,000 by the mid-2010s, concentrated in (e.g., , , ) with minimal gains elsewhere, reflecting challenges from , , and schismatic losses rather than robust evangelization.

Theology and Doctrine

Core Affirmations and Rejections of Roman Dogmas

The Old Catholic Churches affirm the doctrines established by the of the undivided Church, spanning from Nicaea I in 325 to Nicaea II in 787, as the normative expression of apostolic faith, including the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed and definitions on and the veneration of icons. These councils are regarded as binding due to their reception across the early Church, in contrast to later Roman developments viewed as departures from consensual tradition. The Churches also uphold the seven sacraments—, , , , , , and Matrimony—as efficacious signs of grace instituted by Christ, accepting the Council of Trent's dogmatic formulations on these only insofar as they align with patristic sources and Scripture. Central to Old Catholic Eucharistic theology is the affirmation of Christ's real presence in the under the of and wine, received as a commemorative and communal meal that unites believers into one body, without positing a propitiatory repetition of Calvary's . This draws from scriptural warrants such as 9:11–12, 24 and 1 Corinthians 10:17, emphasizing the Eucharist's role in perpetuating the once-for-all offering of Christ rather than re-enacting it. Unlike Roman scholasticism, Old Catholics eschew transubstantiation's Aristotelian categories of substance and accidents as an unnecessary philosophical overlay, prioritizing instead the mystery's experiential and biblical reality over speculative metaphysics. Rejections of post-Reformation Roman dogmas stem from adherence to the Vincentian canon—doctrines held "everywhere, always, by all"—as the criterion for orthodoxy, deeming later innovations as accretions driven by centralized papal authority rather than organic consensus. The dogma of , promulgated at Vatican I on July 18, 1870, is repudiated as contradicting the collegial episcopate and historical primacy of Rome as , introducing a monarchical absolutism that supplants synodal discernment with individual decree. Similarly, the of Mary, defined by Pius IX in , lacks attestation in Scripture or the Fathers of the first millennium and is rejected as an unsubstantiated elevation beyond devotional piety. This commitment to pre-Vatican I consensus privileges Scripture, , and reasoned interpretation over ultramontane impositions, critiquing Roman centralization as fostering doctrinal stasis by subordinating episcopal colleges to unilateral pontifical fiat, thereby hindering the Church's adaptive fidelity to primitive norms. In practice, Utrecht-aligned churches permit eucharistic hospitality to baptized Christians affirming presence, extending beyond Roman confines of full ecclesial communion to foster visible unity amid doctrinal divergence.

Sacramental Practices and Apostolic Succession

The Old Catholic Church traces its apostolic succession to the ancient Diocese of Utrecht, established in 695 AD, with continuity preserved through episcopal consecrations amid tensions with Rome over Jansenist sympathies in the early 18th century. A pivotal event occurred on October 15, 1724, when Dominique-Marie Varlet, the Roman Catholic Bishop of Babylon, consecrated Cornelius van Steenoven as the seventh Archbishop of Utrecht, restoring the episcopate after papal refusals to confirm local elections. This act, performed by a bishop in full apostolic lineage, ensured the transmission of holy orders via the traditional rite of laying on hands and prayer, independent of subsequent schism. Empirical records of these ordinations demonstrate unbroken formal validity, as Varlet's own consecration in 1716 derived from standard Roman lines. This Utrecht succession gained external validation through the 1931 Bonn Agreement, whereby Old Catholic bishops and the Anglican Churches mutually recognized each other's orders and permitted sacramental sharing among laity, affirming the efficacy of their respective episcopal lines. Roman Catholic assessments have similarly upheld the validity of Old Catholic ordinations post-1724, distinguishing them from Anglican lines critiqued in (1896), due to the direct Roman provenance of the intervening bishops. However, traditional Roman perspectives debate a "tincture of jurisdiction," positing that prolonged separation from papal may diminish jurisdictional potency without invalidating the ontological character of orders imparted through valid form and intention. Sacramental practices emphasize the seven traditional sacraments as channels of grace, with by water and as the normative entry to the church, removing and incorporating the child into the covenant community. , administered by bishops in , strengthens baptismal grace via anointing and invocation of the , typically following at a later age. The holds centrality, confected through and by ordained priests, affirming real presence without Aristotelian , and reserved for the baptized who examine their conscience. In the sacrament of penance, demands explicit and purpose of amendment from the penitent, rejecting any notion of mechanical efficacy detached from personal , in contrast to perceived Roman overemphasis on automatism that might undervalue disposition. Priests in valid succession pronounce forgiveness only after of grave sins, underscoring causal dependence on the recipient's interior resolve alongside the minister's role. This approach aligns with patristic emphases on metanoia, ensuring sacraments effect what they signify only through integrated faith and obedience.

Variations in Moral and Liturgical Teachings

The Old Catholic churches within the Union of Utrecht exhibit variations in moral teachings that diverge from the Roman Catholic emphasis on the absolute indissolubility of sacramental marriage. In contrast to the Roman position that prohibits remarriage after divorce while both spouses live, certain Old Catholic jurisdictions permit remarriage under pastoral considerations, such as doubts about the original validity of the union due to deficient intent or disposition. Similarly, contraception is treated as a matter of personal conscience rather than an intrinsic moral wrong, allowing artificial methods without doctrinal prohibition, which marks a departure from the Roman encyclical Humanae Vitae (1968) upholding natural family planning as the sole licit means. Ordination practices further highlight these divergences, with women's to the priesthood introduced in member churches of and beginning in the mid-1990s. The first such ordinations in occurred on May 27, 1996, when Bishop Joachim Vobbe consecrated two female deacons as priests, reflecting a synodal decision to extend to women amid broader ecumenical influences. This practice, absent in historical Catholicism prior to the , underscores adaptations aligned with contemporary egalitarian norms rather than apostolic precedent. Liturgically, Old Catholic churches adopted vernacular languages in the Mass well before the Roman Church's post-Vatican II reforms, incorporating them into Tridentine-style rites as early as the late to enhance accessibility. While embracing modern elements like orientation in many settings, they retain options for traditional celebration, preserving a balance between historical form and contemporary expression without mandating uniformity across jurisdictions. These evolutions in moral and liturgical teachings, shaped by responses to secular and Protestant influences post-1870 , have coincided with organizational stagnation. churches report approximately 115,000 members as of 2016, a fraction of the Roman Catholic global exceeding 1.3 billion, suggesting that concessions to prevailing cultural pressures—rather than adherence to unchanging doctrinal norms—have not fostered vitality but contributed to marginalization in secularizing . Empirical patterns in religious demographics indicate that traditions maintaining stricter fidelity to pre-modern teachings exhibit greater resilience against attrition driven by and .

Ecclesiology and Governance

Synodal Decision-Making and Clerical Discipline

The Old Catholic Churches of the employ a synodal model emphasizing episcopal over centralized authority, rejecting the Roman Catholic assertion of and as articulated in the First Vatican Council's 1870 decrees on . National synods, involving bishops, clergy, and laity, manage doctrinal, liturgical, and administrative matters within each autonomous church, while the International Old Catholic Bishops' Conference (IBC), convened annually since its founding in 1889 by the bishops of the , , and , coordinates inter-church relations, upholds communion, and resolves disputes through consensus rather than hierarchical fiat. This decentralized structure fosters accountability via mutual oversight among equals, enabling adaptive responses to local contexts but often prolonging decision processes due to the need for unanimous agreement among disparate national bodies. Clerical discipline reflects this collegial ethos, with national synods enforcing standards on conduct, , and accountability without a supreme pontifical enforcer, leading to uniform core principles like but variations in implementation. Since the late , following the initial schisms, Old Catholic policy has permitted priests to marry prior to , aligning with pre-Gregorian Western practices and Eastern traditions while diverging from Roman mandatory imposed since the 12th century. Proponents cite reduced incentives for clandestine relationships and scandals, as evidenced by lower reported abuse rates in some decentralized traditions compared to centralized ones, though comprehensive cross-church data remains sparse; critics from Roman perspectives contend this erodes the eschatological symbolism of clerical continence as a total dedication to the kingdom. Empirically, synodal decentralization has enabled doctrinal flexibility—such as vernacular liturgies and ecumenical dialogues—but causal analysis reveals drawbacks in unity preservation, as slower consensus mechanisms have permitted progressive reforms in some churches (e.g., ethical stances on personal matters) to outpace others, contributing to fractures like the 2003-2008 departures from the Union over irreconcilable positions. This contrasts with Roman hierarchy's efficiency in doctrinal enforcement, which Old Catholics view as prone to overreach, prioritizing causal realism in governance: mitigates authoritarian risks but amplifies fragmentation where shared convictions wane.

Ordination Practices and Church Hierarchy

The Old Catholic churches within the operate under an episcopal-synodal structure, with each national or regional church functioning autonomously under the oversight of its , who collaborates with a composed of and lay delegates to address , , and matters. Synods convene periodically—typically every one to five years depending on the church—and hold advisory or deliberative authority, emphasizing shared responsibility between and while affirming the bishop's role in maintaining unity and sacramental oversight. At the international level, the International Old Catholic Bishops' Conference facilitates coordination on doctrinal and ecclesial issues among member bishops, without imposing centralized authority. The Archbishop of Utrecht holds an honorary primacy as primus inter pares among the bishops, serving as president of the Bishops' Conference but exercising no jurisdictional power over other churches, a arrangement that preserves the confederated autonomy originating from post-Vatican I schisms and historical Dutch independence. This titular role, exemplified by the election and consecration of Bernd Wallet on September 18, 2021, following his selection by the Utrecht Electoral College on February 15, 2020, symbolizes continuity with the Utrecht succession while avoiding Roman-style . Bishops are selected through synodal elections involving and , often requiring confirmation by peer bishops to ensure , a process rooted in early church practices but adapted to reject ultramontane centralization. Priests and deacons are ordained by bishops in rites claiming unbroken , with the diaconate sometimes including permanent, non-transitional roles for pastoral service. Clerical celibacy is not required; married men may be ordained as priests or even bishops, aligning with Eastern Orthodox precedents and the early church's tolerance of married prior to later Latin impositions, though this permits continuation of marital relations post- unlike some traditions. Since 1996, to the diaconate, presbyterate, and episcopate has been opened to women in most Union churches, based on egalitarian interpretations of baptismal equality and ministry, enabling female bishops such as those in and . Traditionalist critiques, drawing from patristic and scriptural precedents of male-only apostolic commissions, argue this innovation disrupts the causal realism of sacraments—wherein the priest acts in persona as male incarnate—potentially invalidating orders and correlating with numerical stagnation in churches compared to expanding conservative bodies adhering to male exclusivity.

Ecumenical and Inter-Church Relations

Dialogue with Roman Catholicism

Following the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965), bilateral dialogues between the Old Catholic Churches of the and the Roman Catholic Church commenced at national levels from 1966 and internationally via a joint committee in 1972–1973. These early talks sought mutual recognition for pastoral cooperation, such as eucharistic sharing, but stalled due to Old Catholic insistence on rejecting the First Vatican Council's (1869–1870) dogmas of and , which Rome deems essential to ecclesial unity. The Roman Catholic perspective frames the Old Catholic separation—originating in 1870—as a precipitated by opposition to these doctrines, preserving shared adherence to early creeds like Nicaea-Constantinople (381) but lacking absent acceptance of Petrine primacy as divinely instituted. A renewed International Roman Catholic–Old Catholic Dialogue Commission convened from 2004 to 2009, producing the report Kirche und Gemeinschaft ("Church and Communion"), which affirmed common ground in , the seven sacraments, and the while employing "differentiated consensus" on doctrine. Nonetheless, irreconcilable divergences over papal authority persisted: Old Catholics view the as primus inter pares without jurisdictional supremacy, a position rooted in pre-1870 , whereas upholds Vatican I's definitions as non-negotiable for reconciliation. The Roman Church acknowledges the validity of Old Catholic baptisms and —conferred via undisputed apostolic lineage—but deems them illicit outside full hierarchical unity, precluding sacramental intercommunion. Empirical outcomes underscore the causal impasse: no significant reunions or structural mergers have occurred since 1870, with dialogues yielding theological clarifications but no resolution on primacy, as Rome's post-Tridentine (–1563) and Vatican I framework renders synodal equality incompatible with its monarchical constitution. Periodic papal overtures, such as Francis's 2014 letter to Old Catholic bishops emphasizing shared baptismal faith, have fostered cordiality without bridging the chasm. This divide reflects a fundamental causal realism: Old Catholic ecclesiology prioritizes collegial governance to avert perceived , while Roman doctrine derives supreme from scriptural Petrine commissions (e.g., :18–19), rendering compromise structurally untenable.

Ties to Anglican, Orthodox, and Protestant Bodies

The Old Catholic Churches of the entered with the via the Bonn Agreement of July 2, 1931, which mutually recognizes the validity of episcopal orders, sacraments, and Eucharistic celebrations, permitting clergy interchange and lay participation in each other's liturgies. This accord, ratified by the and extended to other Anglican provinces including the by 1934, exemplifies pragmatic by prioritizing shared apostolic heritage over doctrinal uniformity in areas like liturgical diversity. Ongoing joint theological conferences, such as the 2023 gathering in , continue to affirm this sacramental fellowship amid evolving Anglican practices. Dialogues with Eastern Orthodox Churches date to the 1870s Bonn conferences, evolving through five phases of intermittent commissions focused on creed, sacraments, and ecclesiology, yet yielding no full communion due to Old Catholics' adherence to the Filioque clause—"and the Son"—in the , which Orthodox deem an illicit unilateral addition disrupting Trinitarian monarchy of the Father. Early agreements acknowledged the clause's erroneous insertion but permitted Orthodox-compatible explanations, but retention by Old Catholics has precluded deeper unity, underscoring causal theological barriers rooted in Western patristic traditions versus Eastern conciliar fidelity. Ties to Protestant bodies lack equivalent formal pacts, manifesting instead through Old Catholic membership in the since 1948, enabling collaborative ecumenical efforts and shared critiques of ultramontane authority, partly traceable to 19th-century Protestant liberal influences that encouraged synodalism and doctrinal flexibility in Old Catholic circles. These affinities have fostered anti-hierarchical postures akin to Reformed traditions, yet stark sacramental divergences—Old Catholics' insistence on seven sacraments, , and —preclude intercommunion, as Protestant views often reject such realist ontologies. While yielding practical interfaith achievements like joint social initiatives, such engagements draw criticism for diluting Old Catholic continuity with undivided Church practices, prioritizing accommodation over dogmatic rigor.

Current Status and Demographics

Membership Statistics and Geographic Distribution

The Union of Utrecht of Old Catholic Churches reported approximately 115,000 members worldwide as of 2016. More recent estimates place the figure closer to 60,000, reflecting ongoing declines amid broader European Christian trends of and low retention. Membership is heavily concentrated in , with hosting the largest national body at 15,688 baptized members as of the end of 2023, up slightly from 15,396 the prior year but still indicative of long-term stagnation. The Old Catholic Church of the , the Union's foundational church, numbers around 5,000 to 10,000 adherents, though recent reports highlight parish closures and a priest shortage signaling vitality challenges. Smaller presences exist in (approximately 5,000), (around 2,000), and the , with negligible organized communities elsewhere, including the , where no Union-affiliated dioceses operate. Demographically, congregations skew elderly, mirroring patterns in mainline European denominations where median member ages exceed 50, compounded by rates below 1.5 children per woman in host countries and minimal or conversion inflows. This contrasts sharply with Roman Catholicism's global 1.4 billion adherents, sustained by growth in the Global South despite European parallels. Empirical patterns link such stagnation to post-schism isolation from Catholicism's demographic reservoirs and internal reforms emphasizing doctrinal flexibility, which have not reversed attrition in low-evangelism contexts.

Recent Organizational Developments

In the early 2000s, the continued its established practice of ordaining women to the diaconate, priesthood, and episcopate, a policy initiated in member churches like the Old Catholic Church of the in and expanded thereafter. This approach, coupled with liturgical adaptations in some dioceses permitting blessings for same-sex partnerships—such as in the Old Catholic Diocese of and —reinforced internal commitments to progressive ecclesial reforms but exacerbated tensions with traditionalist elements. These developments prompted further fragmentation, most notably the 2008 establishment of the by the and aligned Old Catholic bodies dissenting from the 's trajectory on ordination and moral teachings. The International Bishops' Conference of the Union of Utrecht, meeting regularly, upheld these positions into the 2010s without reversal, reflecting doctrinal continuity despite outflows to more conservative formations. The 2020s have seen no substantive organizational expansion or mergers for the , with membership stabilizing at low levels—estimated under 100,000 globally, concentrated in —and no documented influx from ecumenical dialogues with Anglican or Orthodox groups. This stasis contrasts with the relative resilience of schismatic traditionalist bodies, suggesting that the embrace of reforms has not reversed secularization pressures evident in broader European Christianity, where conservative-leaning communions exhibit greater retention amid cultural shifts. Ongoing synodal governance and minor inter-church talks persist, but without yielding structural integration or vitality gains.

Controversies and Criticisms

Debates on Doctrinal Continuity and Liberal Reforms

The Old Catholic Churches, originating from schisms following the First Vatican Council's 1870 declaration of , positioned themselves as preservers of pre-conciliar Catholic doctrine through emphasis on synodal governance and authority over centralized . This ecclesiological framework, rooted in the 1889 Declaration of , rejected while affirming fidelity to the first millennium's traditions, including rejection of later Roman developments like the . Proponents argue this maintains empirical continuity with undivided , avoiding perceived Vatican I innovations that centralized authority at the expense of episcopal collegiality. However, the flexible conciliar model facilitated doctrinal adaptations post-1960s, amid broader Western cultural shifts toward and secular ethics, diverging from historical sacramental norms. Synods in member churches, such as the German Old Catholic Synod in 1990, reclassified women's as a disciplinary rather than doctrinal matter, enabling its introduction. The Swiss Old Catholic Church ordained its first female in 1987 and in 2000, with similar practices spreading to other bodies, prompting schisms like the 2003 departure of some Polish-aligned groups opposed to the policy. These reforms, justified internally as aligning with egalitarian principles absent in early church prohibitions, have been critiqued by traditionalist observers as importing Protestant concessions, undermining the causal link between and male-only priesthood evidenced in patristic texts and consistent practice. Parallel ethical shifts include normalization of blessings for remarried divorcees, reflecting a relativized view of indissolubility that contrasts with the absolute marital bond upheld in pre-modern Catholic teaching. While Old Catholics resisted certain post-Vatican II Roman liturgical novelties, such as vernacular minimalism in the Novus Ordo, their own synod-driven liberalizations—prioritizing contemporary consensus over immutable deposit—have correlated with organizational fragmentation and stagnant membership, suggesting a causal erosion of distinct Catholic . Traditionalist analysts, drawing from historical precedents, contend these changes represent not organic development but reactive accommodation, forfeiting the realism of sacraments as objective realities unbound by majority vote.

Challenges to Sacramental Validity and Schismatic Legitimacy

The Roman Catholic Church officially recognizes the validity of Old Catholic holy orders and sacraments ex opere operato, tracing their apostolic succession to the historic episcopate of the Church of Utrecht, which preserved continuity despite excommunications in the 18th century related to Jansenist influences and irregular consecrations by Bishop Dominique Varlet in 1724. This acknowledgment stems from the principle that sacramental efficacy depends on proper form, matter, and intent rather than ecclesial communion alone, as affirmed in post-Vatican II dialogues and canonical assessments. However, challenges arise from Old Catholic innovations, including the ordination of women priests starting in 1994 and bishops in subsequent decades, which Rome deems invalid on doctrinal grounds, arguing that such actions defectively transmit orders, akin to the nullity declared for Anglican ordinations in Apostolicae Curae (1896). This has led to critiques that ongoing Old Catholic ordinations risk accumulating defects, undermining long-term sacramental integrity absent adherence to traditional Catholic norms on ministerial eligibility. Eastern Orthodox churches, by contrast, do not recognize Old Catholic sacraments as conveying , viewing them as performed outside the Orthodox tradition and lacking the ecclesial fullness required for sacramental reality, a position paralleling their non-acceptance of Roman Catholic mysteries due to post-schism alterations. Orthodox emphasizes that true sacraments presuppose communion within the undivided Church, rendering Old Catholic rites, despite superficial similarities in form, spiritually inefficacious; joint commissions since the 1931 Bonn Agreement have explored dialogue but yielded no mutual recognition of orders or . Anglicans, however, partially accept Old Catholic orders through historical interconsecrations, as formalized in the 1931 Bonn Agreement, where Old Catholic bishops participated in Anglican episcopal lines to bolster claims against Roman nullification, though this mutual validation remains contested by Catholic authorities as insufficient to remedy prior defects. The schismatic status of the Old Catholic churches—originating from rejection of at Vatican I in 1870 and earlier separations—raises fundamental questions of legitimacy, as their empirical isolation from both Roman and Orthodox communions has fostered a hybrid blending Catholic liturgical forms with liberal doctrinal adaptations, such as remarriage of divorced and rejection of certain dogmas. This divergence, critics argue, evidences a causal disconnect from the historic Church's magisterial unity, where schisms historically atrophy without reunion if diverging from core truths, as seen in the diminishment of prior Jansenist or Febronianist movements. From a realist perspective, the absence of widespread adherence or miraculous perseverance—contrasted with the endurance of apostolic communions—suggests limited divine endorsement, with Old Catholic bodies numbering under 115,000 members globally as of 2020, concentrated in and fragmented into national jurisdictions. Internal critiques within broader Catholic circles further highlight that schismatic legitimacy falters without hierarchical communion, rendering their claims to "Old Catholic" fidelity more nominal than substantive amid evolving practices.

References

  1. https://canonlawmadeeasy.com/2016/10/13/what-is-the-old-catholic-church/
  2. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/welcome/
  3. https://www.oikoumene.org/member-churches/old-catholic-church-in-the-netherlands
  4. https://www.episcopalchurch.org/ministries/ecumenical-interreligious/old-catholic-churches-union-utrecht/
  5. https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/saints/willibrord-807
  6. https://www.occus.org/history
  7. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15245a.htm
  8. http://augnet.org/en/history/general/4315-before-the-augustinians/4109-augustinian-canons-01/
  9. https://www.britannica.com/event/Eighty-Years-War
  10. https://saintceciliacatholiccommunity.org/apostolic-succession/
  11. https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/90589/9789048558469.pdf?sequence=8&isAllowed=y
  12. http://www.wrmosb.org/oldcath.html
  13. https://www.academia.edu/66451055/Jansenism_Across_the_Border_The_interaction_in_the_17th_and_18th_century_between_Catholic_theologians_in_Franc_and_in_the_Dutch_Republic
  14. https://www.papalencyclicals.net/councils/ecum20.htm
  15. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/about-us/what-is-the-union-of-utrecht/the-declaration-of-utrecht/
  16. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/about-us/what-is-the-ibc/history/
  17. https://www.oxfordreference.com/abstract/10.1093/acref/9780199642465.001.0001/acref-9780199642465-e-7449
  18. https://referenceworks.brill.com/display/entries/RPPO/SIM-026253.xml?language=en
  19. https://religion.fandom.com/wiki/Gerardus_Gul
  20. https://eccpnw.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Declaration-of-Utrecht-and-ECC.pdf
  21. https://www.prounione.it/dia/a-oc/dia-A-OC-01-bonn-1931-eng.pdf
  22. https://www.episcopalchurch.org/glossary/bonn-agreement/
  23. https://liberalcatholic.tripod.com/history.htm
  24. https://www.naorcc.org/faq
  25. https://www.oikoumene.org/organization/international-old-catholic-bishops-conference
  26. https://www.oikoumene.org/church-families/old-catholic-churches
  27. https://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/varlet_dominique_marie_3F.html
  28. https://www.catholic.com/qa/the-validity-of-old-catholic-church-sacraments
  29. https://theoldcatholic.church/about-us
  30. https://independentoldcatholicchurch.org/history/
  31. https://www.womendeacons.org/catholic-womens-ordination-ecumenical-implications-women-deacons-armenian-apostolic-church-orthodox-church-greece-union-utrecht-old-catholic-churches-zagano/
  32. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2025/02/26/decline-of-christianity-in-the-us-has-slowed-may-have-leveled-off/
  33. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/about-us/what-is-the-ibc/
  34. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/ecumenism/relations-with-the-roman-catholic-church/
  35. https://www.catholic.com/encyclopedia/celibacy-of-the-clergy
  36. https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/married-priests-do-it-divinelyrent-a-priest-uses-clerics-who-wear-wedding-rings-and-collars-6425279/
  37. https://www.touchstonemag.com/archives/article.php?id=12-01-021-f
  38. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/ecclesiastical-law-journal/article/abs/canon-law-of-the-old-catholic-churches-utrecht-union/16113791C73AF3678FBEF16A0C0BFA5B
  39. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/about-us/old-catholic-churches/ministry-and-leadership/
  40. https://liturgy.co.nz/bernd-wallet-archbishop-of-utrecht
  41. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/2020/05/bernd-wallet-elected-as-new-archbishop-of-utrecht/
  42. https://www.catholic.com/tract/women-and-the-priesthood
  43. https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/30844/pope-francis-reaches-out-to-schismatic-old-catholic-church
  44. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/partners/the-anglican-communion/
  45. https://www.anglicancommunion.org/ecumenism/churches-in-communion.aspx
  46. https://www.churchofengland.org/about/building-relationships/ecumenical-relations/working-together-internationally/anglicans-and
  47. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/ecumenism/relations-with-the-orthodox-churches/
  48. https://www.orthodox-theology.com/media/PDF/3.2020/Panteleimon_Champidis.pdf
  49. https://livingchurch.org/news/news-anglican-communion/old-catholic-mar-thoma-christians-celebrate-unity/
  50. https://www.alt-katholisch.de/stabile-mitgliederentwicklung/
  51. https://www.nd.nl/geloof/katholiek/1253189/oud-katholieke-kerk-van-nederland-in-zwaar-weer-het-is-vitali
  52. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/
  53. https://theunionofscranton.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Old-Catholicism-the-Nature-and-Promise-of-the-Union-of-Scranton-Prime-Bishop-Mikovsky.pdf
  54. https://www.utrechter-union.org/en/2016/10/conference-of-secretaries-of-christian-world-communions-in-rome-from-11-to-13-october-2016/
  55. https://nordiccatholic.com/history-of-the-union-of-scranton/
  56. https://sarumuse.org/2013/04/20/conciliarism/
  57. https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/old-catholic-and-polish-national-churches-4615
  58. https://orthodoxwiki.org/Orthodox_-_Old_Catholic_Dialogue
  59. https://anglicanhistory.org/oc/bonn1931.html
  60. https://anglicanhistory.org/cbmoss/orders.html
  61. https://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/anglican-orders-on-demand/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.