Hubbry Logo
Dechristianization of France during the French RevolutionDechristianization of France during the French RevolutionMain
Open search
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution
Community hub
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution
Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Looting of a church during the Revolution, by Swebach-Desfontaines (c. 1793)

The aim of several policies conducted by various governments of France during the French Revolution ranged from the appropriation by the government of the great landed estates and the large amounts of money held by the Catholic Church to the termination of Christian religious practice and of the religion itself.[1][2] There has been much scholarly debate over whether the movement was popularly motivated or motivated by a small group of revolutionary radicals.[1] These policies, which ended with the Concordat of 1801, formed the basis of the later and less radical laïcité policies.

The French Revolution initially began with attacks on Church corruption and the wealth of the higher clergy, an action with which even many Christians could identify, since the Gallican Church held a dominant role in pre-revolutionary France. During a one-year period known as the Reign of Terror, the episodes of anti-clericalism became some of the most violent of any in modern European history. The revolutionary authorities suppressed the Church, abolished the Catholic monarchy, nationalized Church property, exiled 30,000 priests, and killed hundreds more.[3] In October 1793, the Christian calendar was replaced with one reckoned from the date of the Revolution, and Festivals of Liberty, Reason, and the Supreme Being were scheduled. New forms of moral religion emerged, including the deistic Cult of the Supreme Being and the atheistic Cult of Reason,[4] with the revolutionary government briefly mandating observance of the former in April 1794.[5][6][7][8][1]

Background

[edit]

Before 1789

[edit]

In 18th-century France, the vast majority of the population adhered to the Catholic Church, the only religion officially allowed in the kingdom since the revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685. Small minorities of French Protestants (mostly Huguenots and German Lutherans in Alsace) and Jews still lived in France. The Edict of Versailles,[9] commonly known as the Edict of Tolerance, had been signed by Louis XVI on 7 November 1787. It did not give non-Catholics in France the right to openly practice their religions but only the rights to legal and civil status, which included the right to contract marriages without having to convert to the Catholic faith. At the same time, libertine thinkers had popularized atheism and anti-clericalism.

The ancien régime institutionalised the authority of the clergy in its status as the First Estate of the realm. As the largest landowner in the country, the Catholic Church controlled vast properties and extracted massive revenues from its tenants;[10] the Church also had an enormous income from the collection of compulsory tithes.[10] Since the Church kept the registry of births, deaths, and marriages and was the only institution that provided hospitals and education in most parts of the country, it influenced all citizens.

Between 1789 and 1792

[edit]
General collection of writs and instructions relating to the French Revolution (Collection generale des brefs et instructions relatifs a la revolution francoise) of Pope Pius VI, 1798

A milestone event of the French Revolution was the abolition of the privileges of the First and Second Estate on the night of 4 August 1789. In particular, it abolished the tithes gathered by the Catholic clergy.[11]

The Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen of 1789 proclaimed freedom of religion across France in these terms:

Article IV – Liberty consists of doing anything which does not harm others: thus, the exercise of the natural rights of each man has only those borders which assure other members of the society the enjoyment of these same rights. These borders can be determined only by the law.

Article X – No one may be disturbed for his opinions, even religious ones, provided that their manifestation does not trouble the public order established by the law.

On 10 October 1789, the National Constituent Assembly seized the properties and land held by the Catholic Church and decided to sell them to fund the assignat revolutionary currency. On 12 July 1790, the assembly passed the Civil Constitution of the Clergy that subordinated the Catholic Church in France to the French government. It was never accepted by the Pope and other high-ranking clergy in Rome.

Policies of the revolutionary authorities

[edit]

The programme of dechristianization waged against Catholicism, and eventually against all forms of Christianity, included:[12][13][2][need quotation to verify]

  • destruction of statues, plates and other iconography from places of worship
  • destruction of crosses, bells and other external signs of worship
  • the institution of revolutionary and civic cults
  • the enactment of a law on 21 October 1793 making all nonjuring priests and all persons who harbored them liable to death on sight
Fête de la Raison ("Festival of Reason"), Notre Dame, Paris, 10 November 1793

An especially notable event that took place in the course of France’s dechristianization was the Festival of Reason, which was held in Notre Dame Cathedral on 10 November 1793. The dechristianization campaign can be seen as the logical extension[14] of the materialist philosophies of some leaders of the Enlightenment such as Voltaire, while for others with more prosaic concerns it provided an opportunity to unleash resentments against the Catholic Church (in the spirit of conventional anti-clericalism) and its clergy.[15]

Civic religions of the French Revolution

[edit]

The civic religions of the French Revolution were a series of state-sponsored deistic and atheistic belief systems introduced during the French Revolution and intended to replace Catholicism as the new moral and social framework of the French First Republic. Emerging from the radical policy of dechristianization, these religions sought to ground republican citizenship in rational, civic, and patriotic principles. The most prominent of these were the atheistic Cult of Reason (Culte de la Raison), which was succeeded by the deistic Cult of the Supreme Being (Culte de l'Être suprême) established by Maximilien Robespierre. During the Directory, these were followed by the semi-official Decadary Cult (Culte décadaire) and the private initiative of Theophilanthropy (Théophilanthropie). These movements aimed to inculcate civic virtue through secular morality, public festivals, and symbolic art. None succeeded in displacing established religious practice, and official support was terminated by Napoleon Bonaparte under the Concordat of 1801.[16][17]

Rationale

[edit]

The French Revolution's initial religious policy was not to abolish religion but to subordinate the Gallican Church to the state through measures like the 1790 Civil Constitution of the Clergy. Following the overthrow of the monarchy in 1792, a more radical dechristianization campaign emerged, championed by factions such as the Hébertists. This campaign involved closing churches, destroying religious iconography, and persecuting priests. Public life was systematically secularised through the introduction of the French Republican Calendar, which replaced the Gregorian calendar's system of Sundays and Christian feast days with a ten-day week (décade).[17][18] In this context, revolutionaries created civic religions designed to provide a new, shared moral framework for the Republic.[18]

Civic religions

[edit]

Cult of Reason

[edit]
Main article: Cult of Reason

The Cult of Reason (Culte de la Raison) was an atheistic and anthropocentric civic creed promoted by radical figures like Jacques Hébert, Pierre Gaspard Chaumette, and Antoine-François Momoro. It rejected the existence of a god, venerating instead the abstract concept of Reason as the pinnacle of human achievement. Churches were converted into "Temples of Reason," and its most famous ceremony was the Festival of Reason at Notre-Dame de Paris in November 1793, where an actress personified the Goddess of Reason.[19] The cult was opposed by the deist Maximilien Robespierre, who viewed its atheism as socially destructive and "aristocratic." It was officially suppressed following the execution of its leading proponents in March 1794 and rapidly disappeared from public life.[20][16]

Cult of the Supreme Being

[edit]
Main article: Cult of the Supreme Being

In response to the Cult of Reason, Maximilien Robespierre introduced the deistic Cult of the Supreme Being (Culte de l'Être suprême). Formally established by the National Convention in May 1794, it was based on the belief in a creator god and the immortality of the soul, which Robespierre considered essential for social order and republican virtue.[21] The cult's sole major celebration was the massive Festival of the Supreme Being, held in Paris on 8 June 1794 and orchestrated by the artist Jacques-Louis David. The event, which prominently featured Robespierre, was seen by his rivals as an attempt to create a personal dictatorship and contributed to his political isolation.[22] The movement was entirely dependent on its founder and was abandoned immediately following his execution in the Thermidorian Reaction in July 1794.[23]

Decadary Cult

[edit]
Main article: Decadary Cult

Established under the Directory, the Decadary Cult (Culte décadaire) was a secular civic religion designed to structure republican life around the ten-day week (décade) of the French Republican calendar. Citizens were legally required to observe the tenth day, the décadi, by attending civic festivals that replaced traditional Christian Sunday worship. These events aimed to instill republican virtues through patriotic ceremonies, readings of laws, and speeches on civic duty.[24] Mandated nationally in 1798, the cult was unpopular and widely resisted by the general populace, who remained attached to the traditional seven-day week and Catholic traditions. It was effectively abandoned after the Concordat of 1801 restored Catholicism's status, and the Republican calendar itself was abolished by Napoleon in 1805.[25]

Theophilanthropy

[edit]
Main article: Theophilanthropy

Theophilanthropy (Théophilanthropie, meaning "Friends of God and Man") was a deistic creed that emerged during the Directory as a private initiative. Founded by Jean-Baptiste Chemin-Dupontès and supported by the Director Louis Marie de La Révellière-Lépeaux, it sought to provide a rational moral framework based on the belief in God, the immortality of the soul, and civic duties. Its simple ceremonies, consisting of moral readings and hymns, often took place during the official décadi observances.[26] As a voluntary, semi-private society, it stood apart from the state-mandated cults. However, it was viewed with suspicion by both Catholics, who saw it as a heretical sect, and radical republicans, who found it bourgeois and sentimental. The movement lost influence after the Concordat of 1801 and was formally prohibited in 1803.[27]

Legacy of the civic religions

[edit]

Although the civic religions of the French Revolution were short-lived and failed to displace Catholicism, they represented a key experiment in the creation of secular civic ritual, symbolic politics, and republican pedagogy. Historians such as Mona Ozouf and Michel Vovelle have analyzed them as part of the Revolution's broader attempt to "transfer sacrality" from the traditional monarchy and church to the new republican state.[28][29]

The Revolution and the Church

[edit]

In August 1789, the state cancelled the taxing power of the Church. The issue of Church property became central to the policies of the revolutionary government. Declaring that all Church property in France belonged to the nation, confiscations were ordered, and Church properties were sold at public auction. In July 1790 the National Constituent Assembly published the Civil Constitution of the Clergy that stripped clerics of their special rights—the clergy were to be made employees of the state, elected by their parish or bishopric, and the number of bishoprics was to be reduced—and required all priests and bishops to swear an oath of fidelity to the new order or face dismissal, deportation or death. French priests had to receive papal approval to sign such an oath, and Pope Pius VI spent almost eight months deliberating on the issue. On 13 April 1791, Pius denounced the constitution, resulting in a split in the French Catholic Church. Over 50% became abjuring priests ("jurors"), also known as "constitutional clergy", and nonjuring priests as "refractory clergy".

Map of France showing the percentage of juring priests in 1791. The borders of the map are those of 2007, because the data come from archives of the modern departments.

In September 1792, the Legislative Assembly legalized divorce, contrary to Catholic doctrine. At the same time, the state took control of the birth, death, and marriage registers away from the Church. An ever-increasing view that the Church was a counter-revolutionary force exacerbated the social and economic grievances, and violence erupted in towns and cities across France.

In Paris, over a 48-hour period beginning on 2 September 1792, as the Legislative Assembly (successor to the National Constituent Assembly) dissolved into chaos, three Church bishops and more than 200 priests were massacred by angry mobs; this constituted part of what would become known as the September Massacres. Priests were among those drowned in mass executions (noyades) for treason under the direction of Jean-Baptiste Carrier; priests and nuns were among the mass executions at Lyons for separatism, on the orders of Joseph Fouché and Collot d'Herbois. Hundreds more priests were imprisoned and made to suffer in abominable conditions in the port of Rochefort.

Insurrection of 31 May – 2 June 1793

[edit]

After the insurrection of 31 May – 2 June 1793, there was a decisive turn away from the revolution's original principles of religious freedom, and in the late summer of 1793 dechristianization evolved into what Johnathan Israel describes as a "repressive, vandalistic, inquisitorial movement".[30] A major spasm of dechristianization broke out during the autumn with many of the acts of dechristianization in 1793 being motivated by the seizure of Church gold and silver to finance the war effort.[31] In November the département council of Indre-et-Loire abolished the word dimanche (English: Sunday).[32] The Gregorian calendar, an instrument decreed by Pope Gregory XIII in 1582, was replaced by the French Republican calendar which abolished the sabbath, saints' days and any references to the Church. The seven-day week became ten days instead.[33] It soon became clear, however, that nine consecutive days of work were too much, and that international relations could not be carried out without reverting to the Gregorian system, which was still in use everywhere outside of France. Consequently, the Gregorian calendar was reimplemented in 1795.[34]

Anti-clerical parades were held, and the Archbishop of Paris, Jean-Baptiste-Joseph Gobel, was forced to resign his duties and made to replace his mitre with the red "Cap of Liberty". Street and place names with any sort of religious connotation were changed, such as the town of Saint-Tropez, which became Héraclée. Religious holidays were banned and replaced with holidays to celebrate the harvest and other non-religious symbols. Many churches were converted into "temples of reason", in which deistic services were held.[35][13][2][1] Local people often resisted this dechristianisation and forced members of the clergy who had resigned to conduct mass again. Maximilien Robespierre and the Committee of Public Safety denounced the dechristianizers as foreign enemies of the revolution and established their own religion. This Cult of the Supreme Being, without the alleged "superstitions" of Catholicism,[36] supplanted both Catholicism and the rival Cult of Reason. Both new religions were short-lived.[37][36] Just six weeks before his arrest, on 8 June 1794, the still-powerful Robespierre personally led a vast procession through Paris to the Tuileries garden in a ceremony to inaugurate the new faith. His execution occurred shortly afterward, on 28 July 1794.[32]

Concordat of 1801

[edit]

By early 1795, a return to some form of religion-based faith was beginning to take shape, and a law passed on 21 February 1795 legalized public worship, albeit with strict limitations. The ringing of church bells, religious processions and displays of the Christian cross were still forbidden. As late as 1799, priests were still being imprisoned or deported to penal colonies. Persecution only worsened after the French army led by General Louis Alexandre Berthier captured Rome in early 1798, declared a new Roman Republic, and also imprisoned Pope Pius VI, who died in captivity. However, after Napoleon seized control of the government in late 1799, France entered into year-long negotiations with Pope Pius VII, resulting in the Concordat of 1801. This formally ended the dechristianization period and established the rules for a relationship between the Catholic Church and the French state.

Victims of the Reign of Terror totaled somewhere between 20,000 and 40,000. According to one estimate, among those condemned by the revolutionary tribunals about 8 percent were aristocrats, 6 percent clergy, 14 percent middle class, and 70 percent were workers or peasants accused of hoarding, evading the draft, desertion, rebellion, and other purported crimes.[38] Of these social groupings, the clergy of the Catholic Church suffered proportionately the greatest loss.[38]

Anti-Church laws were passed by the Legislative Assembly and its successor, the National Convention, as well as by département councils throughout the country. The Concordat of 1801 endured for more than a century until it was abrogated by the government of the Third Republic, which established a policy of laïcité on 11 December 1905.

Toll on the Church

[edit]

Under threat of death, imprisonment, military conscription, and loss of income, about 20,000 constitutional priests were forced to abdicate and hand over their letters of ordination, and 6,000 to 9,000 of them agreed or were coerced to marry. Many abandoned their pastoral duties altogether.[1] Nonetheless, some of those who had abdicated continued covertly to minister to the people.[1]

By the end of the decade, approximately 30,000 priests had been forced to leave France, and several hundred who did not leave were executed.[39] Most French parishes were left without the services of a priest and deprived of the sacraments. Any non-juring priest faced the guillotine or deportation to French Guiana.[1] By Easter 1794, few of France's 40,000 churches remained open; many had been closed, sold, destroyed, or converted to other uses.[1]

Victims of revolutionary violence, whether religious or not, were popularly treated as Christian martyrs, and the places where they were killed became pilgrimage destinations.[1] Catechising in the home, folk religion, syncretic and heterodox practices all became more common.[1] The long-term effects on religious practice in France were significant. Many who were dissuaded from their traditional religious practices never resumed them.[1]

Destruction of monasteries

[edit]

The revolution saw the widespread dissolution and destruction of many French monasteries, as revolutionary authorities sought to suppress religious institutions and confiscate their wealth.[40] Many monastic buildings were seized, looted, repurposed for secular use, or demolished entirely. Orders such as the Benedictines, Cistercians, Franciscans, and Carmelites were particularly affected.[41]

Letter Monastery Order Fate
A Arrouaise Abbey Augustinian Canons Abandoned and destroyed[42]
A Aulne Abbey Cistercian Burned and largely ruined[43]
B Beaupré Abbey (Picardy) Cistercian Suppressed, later demolished[44]
B Bœuil Abbey Benedictine Destroyed[45]
B Bonneval Abbey (Aveyron) Cistercian Seized and sold as national property[46]
C La Cambre Abbey Cistercian Converted into a military facility[47]
C Chelles Abbey Benedictine Suppressed and repurposed as a school[48]
C Convent of Poor Clares, Gravelines Poor Clares Dissolved, nuns expelled[49]
C Couvent des Minimes de Grenoble Minims Confiscated and demolished[50]
G Glanfeuil Abbey Benedictine Converted into a farm[51]
H Hasnon Abbey Benedictine Destroyed[52]
H Holy Cross Abbey (Poitiers) Benedictine Used as a prison[53]
L Ligugé Abbey Benedictine Suppressed, later restored[54]
L Lyre Abbey Benedictine Destroyed[55]
M Maison Coignard Unknown Confiscated and sold[56]
M Marmoutier Abbey, Tours Benedictine Converted into barracks[57]
M Martyrs of Compiègne Carmelite Nuns executed, monastery closed[58]
M Maubeuge Abbey Benedictine Demolished[59]
M Monastery of Our Lady of Prouille Dominican Suppressed, later restored[60]
M Montmajour Abbey Benedictine Confiscated and abandoned[61]
O Oignies Abbey Augustinian Converted into a residence[62]
R Romainmôtier Priory Cluniac Suppressed[63]
S Abbey of Saint-Evre, Toul Benedictine Partially destroyed[64]
S Abbey of Saint Genevieve Augustinian Converted into a library[65]
W Wurmsbach Abbey Cistercian Dissolved[66]
Z San Zaccaria, Venice Benedictine Suppressed[67]


[edit]

See also

[edit]

Notes and references

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Dechristianization of France during the French Revolution

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The dechristianization of France during the refers to a radical anti-clerical campaign waged primarily from September to July 1794 amid the , aimed at suppressing Catholicism through church closures, iconoclasm, clergy persecution, and the promotion of atheistic civic cults. This policy, driven by revolutionary extremists such as the , sought to replace Christian worship with secular alternatives like the , reflecting Enlightenment hostility toward organized religion and suspicions of the Church's loyalty during wartime crises. The campaign escalated following the in 1790, which subordinated the Church to the state and provoked a between oath-taking "constitutional" priests and refractory ones loyal to the , rendering the latter targets for arrest and execution. Intensified by the on 17 September 1793, which broadly defined "enemies of the Revolution" to include non-juring clergy, dechristianization involved vandalizing sacred sites, melting down church bells and vessels for war funding, and compelling priests to publicly renounce their faith under threat of death. Notable events included the November 1793 Festival of Reason held in a desecrated and the conversion of churches, such as Strasbourg's into a , symbolizing the state's assault on religious institutions. While radicals pursued outright atheism, resisted full eradication, enacting the in June 1794 as a deistic compromise to maintain social order, though this did little to halt the violence that claimed thousands of through guillotine, prison deaths, or mass drownings. The effort provoked fierce resistance, including the Vendée uprising where Catholic peasants rebelled against godless policies, contributing to the that ended the Terror and gradually restored religious practice. Ultimately, dechristianization failed to extirpate , fostering long-term state-church tensions but underscoring the Revolution's causal reliance on coercive force rather than voluntary .

Antecedents to Radical Dechristianization

Pre-Revolutionary Grievances Against the Church

The in pre-revolutionary , as the First Estate, comprised approximately 0.5% of the population yet controlled significant economic resources, owning roughly 10% of the nation's land. This vast holdings generated substantial revenue, estimated at around 150 million livres annually, derived primarily from rents, fees, and the —a compulsory levy equivalent to about 10% of agricultural produce paid by parishioners, predominantly peasants. Compounding these burdens, the enjoyed broad tax exemptions, including from the taille, the principal direct land tax that fell heavily on the Third Estate. This exemption shielded church properties and income from state levies, allowing the institution to amass wealth while contributing minimally to royal finances amid France's mounting in the 1780s. Parishioners, particularly rural communities, viewed the as an onerous and regressive imposition, often collected during harvest seasons and subject to local abuses by tithe collectors, exacerbating food shortages and agrarian discontent. These economic grievances surfaced prominently in the , the lists of complaints compiled by electoral assemblies in early ahead of the Estates-General. Third Estate delegates frequently demanded the abolition or reform of the , the taxation of church lands, and curbs on ecclesiastical property accumulation, reflecting widespread resentment over perceived fiscal inequity. Internal divisions within the amplified these external critiques; lower parish priests, who received modest stipends and relied on tithe shares, often protested the disproportionate wealth held by higher prelates—many of whom were aristocratic appointees living luxuriously—highlighting systemic inequalities that undermined the Church's . Beyond economics, grievances extended to the Church's social and political influence, including its monopoly on education, censorship of publications, and role in enforcing feudal dues through parish records. Critics, including Enlightenment thinkers and reformist clergy, argued that these privileges perpetuated stagnation and obstructed merit-based advancement, fueling calls for secular oversight of church affairs as articulated in Third Estate cahiers. Such sentiments, rooted in observable fiscal disparities rather than abstract ideology, laid the groundwork for revolutionary assaults on ecclesiastical immunity.

Initial Reforms: Nationalization and the Civil Constitution of the Clergy (1789-1791)

The National Constituent Assembly, facing severe financial distress from pre-revolutionary debt, initiated reforms targeting the Catholic Church's economic role. On November 2, 1789, it decreed that all church property—including lands, buildings, and revenues—be placed at the disposition of the nation, effectively nationalizing assets estimated to comprise about 10% of France's cultivable territory. This measure aimed to liquidate ecclesiastical holdings via public auctions to fund the issuance of assignats, a paper currency backed by the seized properties, while compensating the clergy through state salaries derived from former tithes and feudal dues. The nationalization abolished tithes immediately and suppressed contemplative religious orders in February 1790, retaining only those engaged in education or care for the poor, as monastic vows were deemed incompatible with civic oaths of liberty. Building on , the Assembly enacted the on July 12, 1790, to restructure the French church under state authority. The law aligned dioceses with the 83 new administrative departments, reducing bishoprics from over 130 to 83 and eliminating metropolitan sees, with bishops and curés elected by active citizens—potentially including non-Catholics—in assemblies open to lay participation. Clergy became salaried public functionaries, with bishops receiving 10,000–25,000 livres annually and curés 4,000–6,000 livres, funded by the state from redirected church revenues; bishops were required to seek papal canonical institution but forbidden from corresponding with without government approval, severing practical ultramontane influence. King reluctantly sanctioned the constitution on August 24, 1790, after papal delay in response, viewing it as a safeguard against radicalism despite internal reservations. Implementation provoked division when, on November 27, 1790, the Assembly mandated an oath of fidelity to the nation, the king, the law, and the constitution, to be sworn by January 1, 1791, with non-compliance leading to dismissal and replacement by electors. Roughly 60% of parish priests—around 24,000 of 40,000—took the oath, often under pressure from local revolutionary fervor and promises of stable income, while fewer than 4 of 135 bishops complied, reflecting stronger episcopal loyalty to papal authority. This created a schism between jurants (oath-takers) and réfractaires (refractories), exacerbating tensions as non-juring clergy faced exclusion from parishes and public worship. formally condemned the constitution in his brief Quod aliquantum on March 10, 1791, declaring its provisions sacrilegious and null, forbidding the oath under pain of excommunication, which galvanized refractory resistance and deepened the church-state rift. These reforms, justified by revolutionaries as democratizing a privileged institution, initiated the subordination of religious authority to civil power, eroding the church's independence and autonomy in doctrine and appointments.

Escalation Under Radical Leadership

Jacobin Policies and the Law of Suspects (1793)

The , having consolidated power through the National Convention's Montagnard faction following the expulsion of the in June 1793, pursued aggressive policies to eradicate perceived counter-revolutionary influences, including the , which they viewed as a pillar of monarchical loyalty and aristocratic privilege. These measures intensified during the , with the Convention declaring on September 5, 1793, that "terror is the order of the day" to suppress internal enemies amid external wars. leaders, including figures like and the , framed religious institutions as threats to republican virtue, leading to decrees that encouraged the closure of churches and the suppression of public worship, though implementation varied locally under representatives on mission. The , enacted on September 17, 1793, formalized this crackdown by empowering revolutionary tribunals to arrest and try individuals vaguely defined as "suspects," including those showing "attachment to the old regime" through conduct, associations, or writings, as well as former nobles, émigrés, and public officials dismissed for insufficient republican zeal. While the law's text did not explicitly target , it was rapidly applied to non-juring priests—those who refused the 1790 and thus deemed —who were presumed counter-revolutionary for maintaining allegiance to over the Republic. This enabled mass detentions, with suspects required to prove their patriotism or face imprisonment without , effectively broadening prior orders (such as the March 18, 1793, mandating for priests) into a system of preemptive repression. Under the law's auspices, persecution of the clergy escalated dramatically; by late 1793, additional decrees, such as the November 7 order declaring non-juring liable to immediate if caught performing religious functions, intertwined with arrests to facilitate executions. Revolutionary tribunals, lacking juries and legal defenses for , processed cases swiftly, contributing to an estimated 300,000 arrests nationwide during the Terror, with approximately 17,000 official executions by and many more in or summary killings. formed a disproportionate share of victims, with historians estimating 2,000 to 3,000 executed between 1792 and 1794, many under charges for sheltering émigrés or opposing dechristianization efforts like the destruction of religious symbols and forced renunciations of vows. This policy not only dismantled ecclesiastical networks but also served Jacobin aims of ideological purification, as churches were repurposed for civic festivals and crosses removed to symbolize the rupture with feudal superstition. The law's vagueness fostered denunciations and local vigilantism, particularly against rural priests who resisted urban Jacobin mandates, exacerbating regional tensions that fueled uprisings like the Vendée revolt. While Robespierre critiqued extreme Hébertist atheism, the overall Jacobin framework tolerated dechristianization as a wartime necessity, prioritizing state control over religious autonomy until his own pivot toward the in 1794. These policies marked a causal escalation from earlier reforms, driven by the Revolution's existential threats, but their indiscriminate application eroded public support and highlighted the Terror's reliance on fear rather than consent.

Promotion of Alternative Cults: Reason and the Supreme Being

The Cult of Reason emerged in late 1793 as an atheistic civic religion promoted by radical revolutionaries, particularly the Hébertists, to supplant Catholic worship amid the dechristianization campaign. This initiative aligned with the Law of 17 September 1793, which authorized the closure of churches and encouraged the establishment of alternative cults emphasizing rationalism and republican virtues over traditional faith. Proponents, including journalist Jacques Hébert and printer Antoine Momoro, repurposed churches as Temples of Reason, installing symbols like busts of philosophers and allegorical figures representing liberty and truth. A pivotal event was the Festival of Reason held on 10 November (20 Brumaire Year II) in Paris's Notre-Dame Cathedral, where participants paraded a actress portraying the Goddess of Reason on a chariot adorned with revolutionary insignia, followed by speeches denouncing superstition and clerical influence. Similar ceremonies proliferated in provincial centers, such as Strasbourg's conversion of its cathedral into a by late , involving theatrical processions and the destruction of Christian icons to symbolize the triumph of enlightenment over dogma. These rituals aimed to foster civic unity through secular festivals, but participation was often coerced, reflecting the revolutionary government's use of public spectacles to enforce ideological conformity during the . Opposition to the Cult of Reason's overt atheism grew among moderates, culminating in Maximilien Robespierre's advocacy for the as a deistic alternative. On 7 May 1794 (18 Floréal Year II), Robespierre delivered a speech to the arguing for recognition of a supreme being and the soul's to counter and Hébertist , leading to a decree establishing the cult as a state-endorsed religion blending with vague . Robespierre viewed as destabilizing, having previously orchestrated the execution of Hébert and his followers on 24 March 1794 to eliminate rivals, positioning the new cult as a tool for social order and virtue. The Festival of the Supreme Being on 8 June 1794 (20 Prairial Year II) marked the cult's public debut, with Robespierre leading a massive in from the Tuileries Gardens to the , featuring floral arches, statues of and , and hymns to nature and reason. Nationwide celebrations followed, incorporating bonfires, oaths of republican fidelity, and invocations of a creator , intended to instill civic without priestly mediation. Despite initial pomp, the cult waned after Robespierre's fall on 27 July 1794 (9 Year II), as Thermidorian leaders rejected its authoritarian overtones, and both cults were formally abolished in under Napoleon's on Cults. These efforts highlight the state's experimental imposition of synthetic religions to legitimize power and erode Christianity's cultural dominance, though they failed to achieve enduring popular adherence.

Mechanisms of Suppression

Persecution of Clergy and Religious Orders

The refusal of approximately 25,000 to 30,000 priests—roughly half of the French clergy—to swear the oath required by the in 1790 marked the onset of systematic against non-juring or refractory clergy, who were deemed counter-revolutionary by revolutionary authorities. These priests faced initial restrictions such as the withholding of pensions and exclusion from public worship spaces by November 1791. Persecution escalated with the Legislative Assembly's decree of August 26, 1792, mandating that non-juring priests emigrate within fourteen days or face by departmental authorities upon by twenty citizens. Non-compliance led to widespread arrests, culminating in the of September 2–6, 1792, when and mobs stormed prisons, summarily executing around 200 refractory priests alongside other prisoners amid fears of internal betrayal during the Prussian invasion. Further s in March 1793 authorized immediate of refractory priests, with death penalties for resistance or sheltering them, while the in September 1793 expanded arrests to include constitutional suspected of disloyalty. During the (1793–1794), refractory priests faced execution by , mass drownings (noyades), or summary shootings, particularly in western regions like the Vendée where clergy supported counter-revolutionary insurgencies; estimates indicate hundreds were judicially executed nationwide, with additional thousands dying in prisons or during forced labor. By late 1793, a of rendered non-juring priests liable to immediate upon sighting, without . Overall, some 30,000 priests were driven into , while domestic persecution claimed the lives of roughly 2,000 clergy through execution or related violence. Religious orders faced earlier dissolution under the February 1790 decree suppressing contemplative monasteries and convents, which expelled monks and nuns, confiscated their properties, and required them to adopt secular dress and or risk for continuing vows. Thousands of religious—estimated at over 40,000 members pre-revolution—were dispersed, with many facing or execution for refusing to renounce their orders; prominent cases include the guillotining of 16 Carmelite nuns in on July 17, 1794, for maintaining conventual life and liturgical practices deemed fanatical. This targeted suppression aimed to eradicate monastic influence, often conflating religious vows with resistance to the Revolution's secularizing agenda.

Destruction of Religious Infrastructure and Symbols

The destruction of religious infrastructure and symbols formed a core component of the dechristianization efforts, escalating during the from September 1793 onward. Local revolutionary committees, empowered by the Law of 17 September 1793, systematically closed churches and removed ecclesiastical furnishings deemed emblematic of superstition and monarchy. Altars were dismantled, crucifixes shattered, and sacred vessels confiscated for state use, often melted down to finance the revolutionary wars. In , the Cathedral of Notre-Dame underwent severe in , with mobs stripping religious imagery including statues, paintings, and relics. The 28 exterior statues of biblical kings on the facade were decapitated and destroyed, erroneously believed to represent French monarchs. The site was repurposed as a on 10 November , hosting ceremonies mocking Christian rites. Similarly, the , necropolis of French royalty, saw its tombs violated under an 1 August decree targeting "monuments of "; between 19 and 21 October , remains of 46 kings and 32 queens were exhumed, desecrated, and discarded in a nearby ditch, while effigies and metalwork were melted for armaments. Church bells, numbering in the tens of thousands nationwide, were requisitioned en masse; by 1792-1794, most were lowered, broken, and recast into , sparing only select large examples like Notre-Dame's Emmanuel bell. Statues of saints and reliquaries faced iconoclastic fury, with wooden figures burned in public bonfires and stone ones pulverized to erase visible from public spaces. Cemeteries lost crosses and religious inscriptions, replaced by revolutionary emblems such as liberty trees. This campaign, peaking between September 1793 and July 1794, transformed thousands of sacred sites into warehouses, markets, or civic temples, though outright demolition remained selective to preserve utilitarian structures. Regional variations intensified the toll; in , following its 1793 counter-revolutionary resistance, numerous churches were razed or repurposed with interiors gutted. Such acts were rationalized as purging aristocratic and clerical influence, yet they inflicted irreversible losses on France's medieval heritage, with surviving accounts documenting the deliberate effacement of Catholic to impose secular symbolism.

Patterns of Resistance

Clerical Refusal and the Non-Juring Priests

The , enacted on July 12, 1790, required French clerics to swear an oath of fidelity to the nation and the constitution by November 27, 1790, effectively subordinating the Church to state control and reorganizing dioceses along civil boundaries. Refusal to take the oath, known as non-jurement, created a within the French clergy, with approximately half of the roughly 50,000 parish priests—around 24,000 to 30,000—opting not to swear, alongside nearly all of the 135 bishops, who viewed the measure as an infringement on ecclesiastical autonomy and papal authority. These non-juring or refractory priests maintained loyalty to the , continuing to administer sacraments in defiance of revolutionary decrees that suspended them from public ministry by early 1791. Pope Pius VI formally condemned the Civil Constitution in the brief Quod aliquantum on March 10, 1791, declaring it null and void, and reiterated this in the Charitas on April 13, 1791, exhorting the faithful to reject juring clergy and threatening for oath-takers who persisted after admonition. This papal intervention galvanized non-juring resistance, as refractory organized clandestine worship, hid in sympathetic rural communities, or emigrated to neighboring states, with estimates indicating over 30,000 eventually fleeing to evade . In regions like the and , where refusal rates exceeded 80 percent according to contemporary maps of oath compliance, non-juring clerics sustained underground networks that preserved traditional Catholic practice amid growing state hostility. Persecution intensified following the Legislative Assembly's decrees: on April 6, 1792, refractory priests were barred from public worship and stripped of pensions; the May 27, 1792, decree authorized upon by 20 citizens; and by October 21, , under the Terror, non-juring clerics and their harborers faced without trial. Despite such measures, non-juring priests demonstrated resilience through secret ordinations, pastoral visitations under cover of night, and moral exhortations against revolutionary cults, embodying a principled stand that contributed to broader sentiment without direct involvement in armed revolt. Their refusal underscored the Revolution's challenge to institutional , fracturing clerical unity and fueling dechristianization by alienating a significant portion of the faithful from state-sanctioned worship.

Counter-Revolutionary Uprisings, Including the Vendée

The counter-revolutionary uprisings in western , particularly in the , were precipitated by the convergence of under dechristianization policies and the imposition of mass conscription via the levée en masse decree of February 24, 1793, which mandated the enlistment of 300,000 men to defend the Republic against external foes. Rural populations, predominantly devout Catholics who viewed the expulsion, execution, or forced oaths of non-juring priests as assaults on their faith, mobilized against republican authorities enforcing these measures; local resistance escalated into open rebellion after failed attempts to quash dissent in early March 1793, with initial riots breaking out in on March 4. The insurgents framed their cause in explicitly religious terms, adopting the white cockade of the monarchy alongside the emblem and forming the Armée Catholique et Royale (Catholic and Royal Army) by April 1793 under leaders such as the tradesman , who positioned the revolt as a "crusade" to restore worship and royal authority. The Vendée forces, comprising up to 80,000 poorly equipped peasants at their peak, achieved early successes through guerrilla tactics and numerical superiority, capturing the key towns of on June 9, 1793, and on June 18, thereby threatening as a potential bridgehead for British intervention. However, the failure to seize on June 29—marked by Cathelineau's mortal wounding—halted their momentum, allowing republican generals like François Joseph Westermann and Louis Marie Turreau to regroup and launch counteroffensives; by October 1793, the Vendéans undertook the disastrous Virée de Galerne (Galerne Retreat), a northward exodus attempting to link with guerrillas in , which culminated in catastrophic defeats at Granville (November 14), (December 12, with over 15,000 insurgents slain), and Savenay (December 23). Leadership fragmented after executions of figures like Maurice Gigost d'Elbée in 1794, though pockets of resistance persisted under until his capture and execution in March 1796. Republican suppression intensified from January 1794 under Turreau's "," 30 mobile detachments authorized to conduct scorched-earth operations, including village burnings, mass (over 1,800 victims in a single November 1793 incident), and summary executions targeting combatants and civilians alike, with orders emphasizing extermination to eradicate sentiment rooted in Catholicism. Estimates of total deaths in the Vendée war (1793–1796) range from 170,000 to 250,000, representing approximately 20% of the region's 800,000 inhabitants, with civilian losses predominant due to , , and deliberate atrocities rather than battlefield engagements alone. Parallel uprisings, such as the Chouannerie in Brittany and Maine, emerged from similar grievances—clerical persecution and conscription—beginning sporadically in 1792 but coalescing into organized guerrilla warfare by 1794 under leaders like Jean Cottereau (Jean Chouan), employing hit-and-run tactics against republican supply lines and tax collectors until pacification efforts in 1795–1796. These western revolts, unified by fidelity to refractory priests and traditional piety, contrasted with more urban, federalist resistances elsewhere (e.g., Lyon in June 1793), underscoring how dechristianization galvanized rural Catholic strongholds into sustained armed opposition, ultimately requiring the Republic to divert tens of thousands of troops from frontline armies.

Immediate Reversal and Long-Term Consequences

Thermidorian Reaction and the Directory Period (1794-1799)

Following the execution of on 28 July 1794, the initiated a moderation of revolutionary policies, including a relaxation of the aggressive dechristianization measures enforced during the . Imprisoned priests were released en masse, and many clergy began returning to France, though anti-Catholic legislation remained formally in place without rigorous enforcement. Religious practice, previously confined to clandestine settings such as private homes where lay-led "white masses" occurred due to clerical shortages, gradually resurfaced as public tolerance increased. Key legislative steps formalized this shift. The Law of 3 Ventôse Year III, enacted on 21 February 1795, established the , granting freedom of worship to citizens provided it did not disturb public order, while terminating state funding for salaries. This measure enabled both constitutional (juring) and () priests to officiate if they pledged adherence to republican laws, and it facilitated the release of remaining priests from detention. Subsequently, the Law of 11 Prairial Year III on 30 May 1795 explicitly permitted the reopening of churches for religious services under municipal oversight, marking a practical end to the mandatory closure of sacred spaces imposed earlier. By mid-1795, thousands of churches across had resumed operations, reflecting widespread popular demand for Catholic rites despite official . Under the Directory, established by the Constitution of Year III on 2 November 1795, religious policy maintained a cautious tolerance amid ongoing anti-clerical sentiment and fears of alliances between and royalists. The prohibited public displays of religious symbols and enforced the décadi (ten-day week) to supplant observances, while promoting Theophilanthropy—a deistic civic —as an alternative to , though it attracted minimal adherence. A notable reversal occurred with the Year V on 4 September 1797, which targeted perceived royalist threats and prompted the arrest and deportation of approximately 2,000 refractory priests to , reinstating deportations and executions on a limited scale. Despite these interruptions, religious revival persisted, driven by lay initiatives and returning , with an estimated 20,000 to 30,000 priests active by 1799, signaling the exhaustion of militant dechristianization without achieving its goal of eradicating Catholic practice.

Napoleon's Concordat and Partial Restoration (1801)

Following the Directory's instability and ongoing religious tensions from the Revolution's dechristianization campaigns, Napoleon Bonaparte, as First Consul, initiated negotiations with in 1800 to stabilize France by reconciling the state with the . The was signed on July 15, 1801, in , though formally dated July 16 and ratified by the Italian legislature on August 1, 1801, and by the French Senate on February 9, 1802. It acknowledged Catholicism as the religion of the "great majority" of French citizens without designating it the state religion, thereby ending the formal schism between revolutionary constitutional clergy and non-juring priests loyal to . The agreement's core provisions restructured ecclesiastical governance under state oversight: the French government gained the right to nominate bishops, who would then receive canonical institution from the ; dioceses were reduced from 83 to 51 to align with post-revolutionary administrative departments, with elevated to an archbishopric; and all were required to swear an of to the government and . The state assumed payment of clerical salaries—initially set at 1.5 million francs annually for bishops and lower ranks—while confiscated church properties sold during the Revolution remained with purchasers, though the state pledged equivalent revenue for worship needs. worship resumed in reopened churches, seminaries were reestablished under episcopal direction, and regained sacramental status, marking a partial reversal of dechristianization by permitting organized Catholic practice after years of suppression. Complementing the , unilaterally promulgated the Organic Articles on April 8, 1802, as 77 regulations for Catholics and 44 for Protestants, embedding Gallican principles to assert state supremacy over religious affairs. These mandated government approval for papal communications, restricted clerical immunities, placed seminaries under state inspection, and barred appeals to foreign authority, effectively subordinating the Church to consular control despite VII's protests that they contradicted the Concordat's spirit. While fostering domestic pacification—particularly in scarred by Vendéean revolts—these measures prevented full autonomy, preserving revolutionary secular gains like property and state oversight of appointments, thus rendering the restoration partial and instrumental to Napoleon's regime consolidation rather than a complete revival of pre-1789 Church power.

Assessments of Impact and Toll

Human Casualties and Demographic Losses

The dechristianization campaign directly targeted refractory , resulting in thousands of executions and summary killings between 1792 and 1794. During the of 1792, mobs killed approximately 200 to 223 priests held in prisons, many of whom were non-juring arrested for refusing the . In the subsequent , constituted a disproportionate share of victims; for instance, 28% of the 1,515 guillotinings in during June and July 1794 involved ecclesiastics. Overall estimates place the number of priests, monks, and nuns killed at around 2,000, though some accounts suggest up to 6,000 when including drownings (noyades) and mass shootings in provincial centers like and , where Carrier's noyades claimed thousands, many religious. These direct casualties exacerbated demographic losses through forced and . Approximately 30,000 priests fled by the late 1790s to avoid persecution, leaving vast pastoral vacuums that persisted into the and contributed to a sharp decline in sacramental practices. The (September 1793) facilitated the arrest of over 200,000 individuals, including refractory clergy, with many dying in overcrowded prisons or during forced marches to penal colonies like , where mortality rates exceeded 50%. Indirect casualties arose from counter-revolutionary uprisings provoked by dechristianization policies, most notably the rebellion (1793–1796), where resistance to church suppression fused with opposition to and economic controls. The conflict depopulated the region, with 170,000 to 200,000 inhabitants—about 20% of the 's population—killed through combat, scorched-earth tactics, and mass executions under generals like Turreau. Similar though smaller-scale losses occurred in the and revolts, where religious defiance amplified republican reprisals, contributing to broader demographic shifts including orphaned children and disrupted family structures in western France. These tolls, while intertwined with civil war dynamics, stemmed causally from the state's aggressive eradication of Catholic institutions, as evidenced by orders to destroy religious symbols and execute resisters.

Societal and Cultural Ramifications

The suppression of Catholic religious practices during the dechristianization campaign profoundly disrupted traditional family and community structures in . With churches closed en masse by November 1793 and public worship banned in of that year, sacraments such as baptisms, marriages, and burials—long central to lifecycle events—shifted underground or ceased altogether, as lay-led "white masses" substituted for priest-led rites amid shortages. The Church's role in administering charity, hospitals, and , which had enforced social norms and provided welfare to the poor, was dismantled through property starting December 2, 1789, and monastic suppressions in February 1790, creating gaps in that the revolutionary state struggled to fill immediately. Culturally, dechristianization imposed a radical reconfiguration of public life through state-sponsored alternatives to . The revolutionary calendar introduced in abolished Sundays with a ten-day week (décade) and replaced Christian holidays with festivals honoring Reason, Liberty, and the Supreme Being, as exemplified by the Festival of Reason on November 10, , at Notre-Dame Cathedral, where Christian was profaned in favor of allegorical processions. The , an atheistic civic religion peaking in late , and its successor, Robespierre's deist decreed on May 7, 1794, sought to instill revolutionary virtues but fostered transient, coercive rituals that alienated many, contributing to moral disorientation as philosophe-influenced hostility toward religion eroded inherited ethical frameworks. Destruction of crosses, church bells, and religious art under the Law of 17 September further erased visible Christian symbols from the landscape, symbolizing a deliberate on cultural continuity. Long-term, these policies accelerated a secular trajectory, with many French citizens never resuming pre-revolutionary religious observance, privatizing faith and weakening the Church's societal influence—a structural rupture that underpinned modern laïcité. Demographically, while fertility decline predated the Revolution, dechristianization intensified it by further undermining clerical authority; regions with denser historically exhibited higher birth rates, and national trends showed secular wills surging from 10% in 1710 to 80% by 1780, correlating with reduced family sizes as religious moral constraints on reproduction loosened. This shift, compounded by violent upheavals like the massacres from August 1793, fragmented social cohesion, replacing ecclesiastical unity with ideological conformity enforced by terror.

Controversies and Historiographical Perspectives

Revolutionary Rationales: Enlightenment Liberation or Counter-Revolutionary Necessity?

The dechristianization campaign during the was justified by its proponents primarily as a means to eradicate the Catholic Church's perceived role in perpetuating superstition and feudal oppression, aligning with Enlightenment ideals of rational governance and human progress. Radical revolutionaries, including like and Pierre-Gaspard Chaumette, argued that the Church embodied intellectual tyranny, fostering ignorance and blind obedience that hindered societal advancement; they advocated replacing Christian worship with the Culte de la Raison (Cult of Reason), inaugurated in Notre-Dame Cathedral on November 10, 1793, to symbolize the triumph of reason over dogma. This perspective drew from materialist philosophies of Enlightenment figures such as and , who critiqued religion as a tool of elite control, though revolutionaries extended these ideas into coercive state policy rather than mere critique. Simultaneously, dechristianization was framed as a pragmatic necessity to neutralize threats, given the Catholic clergy's widespread alignment with monarchist forces and resistance to the Republic. Non-juring priests, who refused the enacted on July 12, 1790, numbered around 50,000 by 1791 and were seen as inciting uprisings, such as the revolt that began in March 1793, where religious grievances mobilized peasant insurgents against republican and secular reforms. Revolutionaries like , in his mission to starting October 1793, justified and church closures as measures to dismantle networks of refractory clergy who sheltered émigrés and coordinated with foreign invaders, including Austrian and British forces. The seizure of church assets, which constituted up to 10% of France's wealth, was explicitly rationalized to fund the war effort against coalitions formed by Catholic monarchies, with the (September 17, 1793) enabling mass deportations of suspected clerical sympathizers. These dual rationales often intertwined, as ideological provided cover for suppressing perceived fifth columns, yet internal divisions emerged: criticized extreme dechristianization as atheistic excess that alienated the masses, leading to his promotion of the via decree on May 7, 1794, to restore without fully restoring . While emphasized liberation from "priestcraft" to forge a new order, pragmatic actors like the viewed it as essential for survival amid , where the Church's authority sustained royalist propaganda and desertions estimated at over 100,000 troops by late 1793. This tension highlights how Enlightenment aspirations for secular converged with the brutal exigencies of counter-insurgency, though the campaign's — including the execution of over 200 priests in alone during the of 1792—reveals a departure from purely philosophical motives toward state-enforced .

Conservative Critiques: Atheistic Fanaticism and Moral Decay

Conservative critics of the , including , characterized the dechristianization campaign as a zealous promotion of that mirrored the intensity of religious fervor but substituted abstract Reason for divine authority, thereby undermining the ethical restraints essential to social stability. In his work Reflections on the Revolution in France, Burke warned that the revolutionaries' preference for over inherited religious forms would engender societal ruin, observing that "they preferred to a form of not agreeable to their ideas" and that this shift ultimately destroyed both the targeted faith and its assailants. Burke attributed the emerging moral disorder to the erosion of prescriptive religious traditions, which he viewed as bulwarks against human passions, arguing that without such anchors, political abstractions devolved into tyranny and violence, as evidenced by the escalating persecutions following the in September 1793. Joseph de Maistre extended this critique by framing dechristianization as an antireligious crusade imbued with a "satanic quality," positing that the Revolution's assault on represented not rational reform but a providential chastisement for prior , culminating in that inverted sacred zeal into profane destruction. In Considerations on France (1797), Maistre contended that the systematic of churches and execution of —over 2,000 priests killed or deported by 1794—reflected a metaphysical rebellion, fostering moral decay through the void left by abolished sacraments and doctrines, which permitted unchecked revolutionary excesses like the of 1792, where approximately 1,400 prisoners, many ecclesiastical, perished. He argued this atheistic fervor, exemplified by the Cult of Reason's establishment in Notre-Dame Cathedral on November 10, 1793, supplanted transcendent morality with ephemeral civic virtues, precipitating the Reign of Terror's 16,594 official executions nationwide from 1793 to 1794. These perspectives persisted among later conservative historians, who linked dechristianization to a broader ethical collapse, wherein the rejection of —viewing humans as fallen yet redeemable—yielded to materialist ideologies that justified atrocities as progress. and Maistre's analyses highlighted causal connections between religious demolition and moral disintegration, with the former decrying Enlightenment atheists like and Rousseau as precursors whose doctrines eroded piety, paving the way for revolutionary barbarism without remorse or restraint. Empirical manifestations included the proliferation of secular festivals glorifying Reason, which conservatives saw as idolatrous parodies that failed to instill lasting , contributing to the Directory's (1795–) corruption and instability, marked by financial scandals and military adventurism untethered from ethical limits.

References

  1. https://www.iwp.edu/articles/2018/01/12/the-dechristianization-of-france-during-the-french-revolution/
  2. https://museeprotestant.org/en/notice/dechristianisation-during-the-reign-of-terror-1793-1794/
  3. https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7496&context=doctoral
  4. https://greyhistory.com/french-revolution-articles/explained-the-first-estate/
  5. https://www.historytoday.com/archive/french-revolution-and-catholic-church
  6. https://www.swansea.ac.uk/history/history-study-guides/the-long-and-short-reasons-for-why-revolution-broke-out-in-france-in-1789/
  7. https://alphahistory.com/frenchrevolution/cahiers-de-doleance/
  8. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1960/the-three-estates-of-pre-revolutionary-france/
  9. http://www.fsmitha.com/h3/h33-fr3b.htm
  10. https://alphahistory.com/frenchrevolution/civil-constitution-of-the-clergy/
  11. https://www.worldhistory.org/Civil_Constitution_of_the_Clergy/
  12. https://history.hanover.edu/courses/excerpts/111civil.html
  13. https://thejosias.com/2024/08/14/pius-vi-quod-aliquantum/
  14. https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/on-the-civil-oath-in-france-3570
  15. https://www.britannica.com/event/Reign-of-Terror
  16. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13009a.htm
  17. https://revolution.chnm.org/d/417/
  18. https://worldhistoryedu.com/what-was-frances-cult-of-reason/
  19. https://www.thecollector.com/fate-of-religion-french-revolution/
  20. https://alphahistory.com/frenchrevolution/cult-of-the-supreme-being/
  21. https://www.worldhistory.org/Cult_of_the_Supreme_Being/
  22. https://www.oldwestbury.edu/news-events/prof-focuses-clergy-chaos-during-french-revolution
  23. https://alphahistory.com/frenchrevolution/assembly-deports-non-juring-clergy-1792/
  24. https://www.historyspage.com/post/the-french-revolution-the-church-and-the-reign-of-terror
  25. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780773559875-007/html
  26. https://aleteia.org/2022/07/14/did-the-french-revolution-persecute-catholics/
  27. https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/they-sang-all-the-way-to-the-guillotine
  28. https://parisianfields.com/2013/06/09/the-nuns-tale/
  29. https://www.history.com/articles/notre-dame-fire-french-revolution
  30. https://mavcor.yale.edu/conversations/essays/revolutionary-exhumations-st-denis-1793
  31. https://uk.tourisme93.com/basilica/desecration-of-the-royal-tombs.html
  32. https://www.notredamedeparis.fr/en/understand/architecture/the-bells/
  33. https://azertag.az/en/xeber/notre_dame_moves_to_scrap_out_of_tune_bells-229708
  34. https://open.clemson.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2790&context=all_theses
  35. https://minds.wisconsin.edu/bitstream/handle/1793/94675/auto_convert.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y
  36. https://scholar.colorado.edu/downloads/3x816n28k
  37. https://www.papalencyclicals.net/pius06/p6charit.htm
  38. https://alphahistory.com/frenchrevolution/vendee-uprising/
  39. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-world-history-of-genocide/vicious-civil-war-in-the-french-revolution/576E50A9A665BB2501A8BFE71302302C
  40. https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/westernumirror/article/download/16071/12465
  41. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/war-vendee
  42. https://www.worldhistory.org/War_in_the_Vendee/
  43. https://study.com/academy/lesson/war-vendee-overview-causes-aftermath.html
  44. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/9781118316399.ch15
  45. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1057/9780230228818_9
  46. https://www.catholic.com/encyclopedia/french-concordat-of-1801-the
  47. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04204a.htm
  48. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-hccc-worldhistory2/chapter/the-concordat-of-1801/
  49. https://www.napoleon-series.org/research/government/diplomatic/c_concordat.html
  50. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01756a.htm
  51. https://www.concordatwatch.eu/napoleons-concordat-and-organic-articles-1801-texts-and-commentary--t826
  52. https://greyhistory.com/french-revolution-articles/the-september-massacres/
  53. https://www.thoughtco.com/french-revolution-the-terror-1793-94-1221883
  54. https://www.wisdomlib.org/science/journal/archives-of-social-sciences-of-religions/d/doc1448557.html
  55. https://bigthink.com/the-past/secularization-population-decline-france/
  56. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3163003
  57. https://llbahwar.wordpress.com/french-revolution-1789-1799/constitutional-monarchy/national-constituent-assembly-1789-1791/revolution-and-the-church/dechristianisation-of-france-during-the-french-revolution/
  58. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/2105/power-struggles-in-the-reign-of-terror/
  59. https://www.constitution.org/2-Authors/eb/rev_fran.htm
  60. https://socserv2.mcmaster.ca/~econ/ugcm/3ll3/burke/revfrance.pdf
  61. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/maistre-considerations-on-france/french-revolution-considered-in-its-antireligious-character/72F159E8B34AD4A3953996BFF78A41A0
  62. http://www.ricorso.net/rx/library/authors/classic/Burke_E/Reflections/Reflect_04.htm
  63. https://www.earlymoderntexts.com/assets/pdfs/burke1790part2.pdf
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.