Hubbry Logo
Haredi JudaismHaredi JudaismMain
Open search
Haredi Judaism
Community hub
Haredi Judaism
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Haredi Judaism
Haredi Judaism
from Wikipedia

A Haredi Hasidic family walking in Brooklyn

Haredi Judaism (Hebrew: יהדות חֲרֵדִית, romanizedYahadut Ḥaredit, IPA: [χaʁeˈdi]) is a branch of Orthodox Judaism that is characterized by its strict interpretation of religious sources and its accepted halakha (Jewish law) and traditions, in opposition to more accommodating values and practices. Its members are often referred to as "ultra-Orthodox" in English, a term considered pejorative by many of its adherents, who prefer the terms strictly Orthodox or Haredi (plural: Haredim). Haredim regard themselves as the most authentic custodians of Jewish religious law and tradition which, in their opinion, is binding and unchangeable. They consider all other expressions of Judaism, including Modern Orthodoxy, as "deviations from God's laws", although other movements of Judaism would disagree.[1]

Some scholars have suggested that Haredi Judaism is a reaction to societal changes, including political emancipation, the Haskalah movement derived from the Enlightenment, acculturation, secularization, religious reform in all its forms from mild to extreme, and the rise of the Jewish national movement. In contrast to Modern Orthodox Jews, Haredim segregate themselves from other parts of society, although some Haredi communities encourage young people to get a professional degree or establish a business. Furthermore, some Haredi groups, like Chabad-Lubavitch, encourage outreach to less observant and unaffiliated Jews.

As of 2020, there were about 2.1 million Haredim globally, representing 14% of the world's Jewish population.[2] Haredim primarily live in Israel (17% of Israeli Jews and 14% of Israel's total population), North America (12% of American Jews), and Western Europe (most notably Antwerp and Stamford Hill and Golders Green in London). Absence of intermarriage, coupled with both a high birth and retention rate, spur rapid growth of the Haredi population, which is on pace to more than double every 20 years. Their numbers have been further boosted since the 1970s by secular Jews adopting a Haredi lifestyle as part of the baal teshuva movement; however, this has been somewhat offset by those leaving.

Terminology

[edit]
Young Haredi Jews in Jerusalem, 2005

The term Haredi is a Modern Hebrew adjective derived from the Biblical verb hared, which appears in the Book of Isaiah (66:2; its plural haredim appears in Isaiah 66:5)[3] and is translated as "[one who] trembles" at the word of God. The word connotes an awe-inspired fear to perform the will of God;[4] it is used to distinguish them from other Orthodox Jews (similar to the names used by Christian Quakers and Shakers to describe their relationship to God).[3][5][6][7]

The term most commonly used by outsiders, for example most American news organizations, is ultra-Orthodox Judaism.[8] Hillel Halkin suggests the origins of the term may date to the 1950s, a period in which Haredi survivors of the Holocaust first began arriving in America.[9] However, Isaac Leeser (1806–1868) was described in 1916 as "ultra-Orthodox".[10]

The word Haredi is often used in the Jewish diaspora in place of the term ultra-Orthodox, which many view as inaccurate or offensive,[11][12][13] it being seen as a derogatory term suggesting extremism;[14] English-language alternatives that have been proposed include fervently Orthodox,[15] strictly Orthodox,[12][16] or traditional Orthodox.[17] Others, however, dispute the characterization of the term as pejorative.[9] Ari L. Goldman, a professor at Columbia University, notes that the term simply serves a practical purpose to distinguish a specific part of the Orthodox community, and is not meant as pejorative.[17] Others, such as Samuel Heilman, criticized terms such as ultra-Orthodox and traditional Orthodox, arguing that they misidentify Haredi Jews as more authentically Orthodox than others, as opposed to adopting customs and practises that reflect their desire to separate from the outside world.[18][9]

The community has sometimes been characterized as traditional Orthodox, in contradistinction to the Modern Orthodox, the other major branch of Orthodox Judaism, and not to be confused with the movement represented by the Union for Traditional Judaism, which originated in Conservative Judaism.[19][20]

Haredi Jews also use other terms to refer to themselves. Common Yiddish words include Yidn (Jews), erlekhe Yidn (virtuous Jews),[11] ben Torah (son of the Torah),[3] frum (pious), and heimish (home-like; i.e., "our crowd").

In Israel, Haredi Jews are sometimes also called by the derogatory slang words dos (plural dosim), that mimics the traditional Ashkenazi Hebrew pronunciation of the Hebrew word datiyim (religious),[21] and more rarely, sh'chorim (blacks), a reference to the black clothes they typically wear;[22] a related informal term used in English is black hat.[23]

Population

[edit]

Due to its imprecise definition, lack of data collection, and rapid change over time, estimates of the global Haredi population are difficult to measure, and may significantly underestimate the true number of Haredim, due to their reluctance to participate in surveys and censuses.[24][25]

In 1992, out of a total of 1,500,000 Orthodox Jews worldwide, about 550,000 were Haredi (half of them in Israel).[26] One estimate given in 2011 stated that there were approximately 1.3 million Haredi Jews globally.[27] Studies have shown a very high growth rate, with a large young population.[28] Haredi population grew to 2.1 million in 2020 and is expected to double by 2040.[29]

The vast majority of Haredi Jews are Ashkenazi. However, some 20% of the Haredi population are thought to belong to the Sephardic Haredi stream. In recent decades, Haredi society has grown due to the addition of a religious population that identifies with the Shas movement. The percentage of people leaving the Haredi population has been estimated between 6% and 18%.[30]

Israel

[edit]
Haredi population in Israel in the recent years:
YearPop.±% p.a.
2009 750,000—    
2014 910,500+3.95%
2015 950,000+4.34%
2017 1,033,000+4.28%
2018 1,079,000+4.45%
2019 1,125,892+4.35%
2020 1,175,088+4.37%
2021 1,226,261+4.35%
2022 1,279,528+4.34%
2023 1,334,909+4.33%
2024 1,392,469+4.31%
Sources:[31][32][33]
Haredi Rabbis and students writing a Torah scroll (Haredi settlement of Beitar Illit, Gush Etzion)

Israel has the largest Haredi population.[34] In 1948, there were about 35,000 to 45,000 Haredi Jews in Israel. By 1980, Haredim made up 4% of the Israeli population.[35] Haredim made up 9.9% of the Israeli population in 2009, with 750,000 out of 7,552,100; by 2014, that figure had risen to 11.1%, with 910,500 Haredim out of a total Israeli population of 8,183,400. According to a December 2017 study conducted by the Israeli Democracy Institute, the number of Haredi Jews in Israel exceeded 1 million in 2017, making up 12% of the population in Israel. In 2019, Haredim reached a population of almost 1,126,000;[31] the next year, it reached 1,175,000 (12.6% of total population).[32] By the end of 2023, it reached almost 1,335,000, or 13.6% of total population; and by the end of 2024, it passed over 1,392,000, thus representing 13.9% of the total population.[33][36][37][38]

The number of Haredi Jews in Israel continues to rise rapidly, with their current population growth rate being 4% per year.[39] The number of children per woman is 7.2, and the share of Haredim among those under the age of 20 was 16.3% in 2009 (29% of Jews).[40]

By 2030, the Haredi Jewish community is projected to make up 16% of the total population, and by 2065, a third of the Israeli population, including non-Jews. By then, one in two Israeli children would be Haredi.[39][41][42][43] It is also projected that the number of Haredim in 2059 may be between 2.73 and 5.84 million, of an estimated total number of Israeli Jews between 6.09 and 9.95 million.[40][44]

The largest Israeli Haredi concentrations are in Jerusalem, Bnei Brak, Modi'in Illit, Beitar Illit, Beit Shemesh, Kiryat Ye'arim, Ashdod, Rekhasim, Safed, and El'ad. Two Haredi cities, Kasif and Harish, are planned.[citation needed]

United States

[edit]

The United States has the second largest Haredi population, which has a growth rate on pace to double every 20 years. In 2000, there were 360,000 Haredi Jews in the US (7.2 per cent of the approximately 5 million Jews in the U.S.); by 2006, demographers estimate the number had grown to 468,000 (30% increase), or 9.4 percent of all U.S. Jews.[45] In 2013, it was estimated that there were 530,000 total ultra-Orthodox Jews in the United States, or 10% of all American Jews.[46] By 2011, 61% of all Jewish children in Eight-County New York City metropolitan area were Orthodox, with Haredim making up 49%.[47]

In 2020, it was estimated that there were approximately 700,000 total ultra-Orthodox Jews in the United States, or 12% of all American Jews.[29] This number is expected to grow significantly in the coming years, due to high Haredi birth rates in America.

New York state

[edit]

Most American Haredi Jews live in the greater New York metropolitan area.[48][49]

New York City
[edit]
Brooklyn
[edit]
Hasidic family on the street in Borough Park, Brooklyn

The largest centers of Haredi and Hasidic life in New York are found in Brooklyn.[50][51]

Queens
[edit]

The New York City borough of Queens is home to a growing Haredi population, mainly affiliated with the Yeshiva Chofetz Chaim and Yeshivas Ohr HaChaim in Kew Gardens Hills and Yeshiva Shaar Hatorah in Kew Gardens. Many of the students attend Queens College.[59] There are major yeshivas and communities of Haredi Jews in Far Rockaway,[57] such as Yeshiva of Far Rockaway and a number of others. Hasidic shtibelach exist in these communities as well, mostly catering to Haredi Jews who follow Hasidic customs, while living a Litvish or Modern Orthodox cultural lifestyle, although small Hasidic enclaves do exist, such as in the Bayswater section of Far Rockaway.

Manhattan
[edit]

One of the oldest Haredi communities in New York is on the Lower East Side,[60] home to the Mesivtha Tifereth Jerusalem.

Washington Heights, in northern Manhattan, is the historical home to German Jews, with Khal Adath Jeshurun and Yeshiva Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch.[61] The presence of Yeshiva University attracts young people, many of whom remain in the area after graduation.[62]

Long Island
[edit]

The Yeshiva Sh'or Yoshuv, together with many synagogues in the Lawrence neighborhood and other Five Towns neighborhoods, such as Woodmere and Cedarhurst, have attracted many Haredi Jews.[63]

Hudson Valley
[edit]

The Hudson Valley, north of New York City, has the most rapidly growing Haredi communities, such as the Hasidic communities in Kiryas Joel[64][65][66] of Satmar Hasidim, and New Square of the Skver.[67] A vast community of Haredi Jews lives in the Monsey, New York, area.[68]

New Jersey

[edit]

There are significant Haredi communities in Lakewood (New Jersey), home to the largest non-Hasidic Lithuanian yeshiva in America, Beth Medrash Govoha.[69] There are also sizable communities in Teaneck,[70] Englewood, Mahwah,[71] Passaic[72] and Edison, where a branch of the Rabbi Jacob Joseph Yeshiva opened in 1982. There is also a community of Syrian Jews favorable to the Haredim in their midst in Deal, New Jersey.[73]

Connecticut

[edit]

The Haredi community of New Haven has close to 150 families and a number of thriving Haredi educational institutions.[74]

Waterbury, Connecticut has a growing Haredi community, in Waterbury proper, and in the neighboring areas of Blueridge and Naugatuck.

Maryland

[edit]

Baltimore, Maryland, has a large Haredi population. The major yeshiva is Yeshivas Ner Yisroel, founded in 1933, with thousands of alumni and their families. Ner Yisroel is also a Maryland state-accredited college, and has agreements with Johns Hopkins University, Towson University, Loyola College in Maryland, University of Baltimore, and University of Maryland, Baltimore County, allowing undergraduate students to take night courses at these colleges and universities in a variety of academic fields.[59] The agreement also allows the students to receive academic credits for their religious studies.

Silver Spring, Maryland, and its environs has a growing Haredi community, mostly of highly educated and skilled professionals working for the United States government in various capacities, most living in Kemp Mill, White Oak, and Woodside,[75] and many of its children attend the Yeshiva of Greater Washington and Yeshivas Ner Yisroel in Baltimore.

Florida

[edit]

Aventura,[76] Sunny Isles Beach, Golden Beach, Surfside[77] and Bal Harbour[78] are home to a large and growing Haredi population. The community is long-established in the area, with several synagogues including The Shul of Bal Harbour,[79] Young Israel of Bal Harbour, Aventura Chabad, Beit Rambam, Safra Synagogue of Aventura, and Chabad of Sunny Isles; mikvehs, Jewish schools and kosher restaurants. The community has recently grown much further, due to many Orthodox Jews from New York moving to Florida during the COVID-19 pandemic.[80][81]

North of Miami, the communities of Boca Raton, Lauderhill,[82] Boynton Beach, and Hollywood have significant Haredi populations.[83][84]

California

[edit]

Los Angeles has many Haredi Jews, most living in the Pico-Robertson and Fairfax (Fairfax Avenue-La Brea Avenue) areas.[85][86]

Illinois

[edit]

Chicago is home to the Haredi Telshe Yeshiva of Chicago, with many other Haredim living in the city.[87]

Pennsylvania

[edit]

Haredim in Philadelphia primarily live in Bala Cynwyd, and the community is centered around Aish HaTorah and the Philadelphia Community Kollel.[88][89]

In Pittsburgh a small yeshiva opened in 1945. Today there are approximately 200 Chabad families living in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood.[90]

Kingston has a young growing Chabad Haredi community which has been growing steadily over the past 20 years since the first families moved there when a yeshiva was opened.[91]

Colorado

[edit]

Denver has a large Haredi population of Ashkenazi origin, dating back to the early 1920s. The Haredi Denver West Side Jewish Community adheres to Litvak Jewish traditions (Lithuanian), and has several congregations located within their communities.[92]

Massachusetts

[edit]

Boston and Brookline, Massachusetts, have the largest Haredi populations in New England.

Students of Telshe yeshiva, 1936

Ohio

[edit]

One of the oldest Haredi Lithuanian yeshivas, Telshe Yeshiva, transplanted itself to Cleveland in 1941.[93][94] Beachwood, Ohio has a large and growing Haredi community, and is a heavily Jewish suburb of Cleveland. The haredi community is centered around the Beachwood Kehilla and Green Road Synagogue, has a mikvah and a Jewish day school.[95]

United Kingdom

[edit]

In 1998, the Haredi population in the Jewish community of the United Kingdom was estimated at 27,000 (13% of affiliated Jews).[26] The largest communities are located in London, particularly Stamford Hill, Golders Green, Hendon, Edgware; in Salford and Prestwich in Greater Manchester; and in Gateshead. A 2007 study asserted that three out of four British Jewish births were Haredi, who then accounted for 17% of British Jews (45,500 out of around 275,000).[45] Another study in 2010 established that there were 9,049 Haredi households in the UK, which would account for a population of nearly 53,400, or 20% of the community.[96][97] The Board of Deputies of British Jews has predicted that the Haredi community will become the largest group in Anglo-Jewry within the next three decades: In comparison with the national average of 2.4 children per family, Haredi families have an average of 5.9 children, and consequently, the population distribution is heavily biased to the under-20-year-olds. By 2006, membership of Haredi synagogues had doubled since 1990.[98][99] British Haredi fertility rate has also been estimated to be as high as 6.9 children per woman.[100]

An investigation by The Independent in 2014 reported that more than 1,000 children in Haredi communities were attending illegal schools where secular knowledge is banned, and they learn only religious texts, meaning they leave school with no qualifications and often unable to speak any English.[101]

The 2018 Survey by the Jewish Policy Research (JPR) and the Board of Deputies of British Jews showed that the high birth rate in the Haredi and Orthodox community reversed the decline in the Jewish population in Britain.[102]

In 2020, it was estimated that there were approximately 76,000 total ultra-Orthodox Jews in the United Kingdom, or 25% of all British Jews, a significant increase from 1998 and 2010.[29]

Elsewhere

[edit]

About 25,000 Haredim live in the Jewish community of France, mostly people of Sephardic, Maghrebi Jewish descent.[26] Important communities are located in Paris (19th arrondissement),[103] Strasbourg, and Lyon.

Other important communities, mostly of Ashkenazi Jews, are the Antwerp community in Belgium, as well as in the Swiss communities of Zürich and Basel, and in the Dutch community in Amsterdam. There is also a Haredi community in Vienna, in the Jewish community of Austria. Other countries with significant Haredi populations include: Canada, with a total number of 30,000 Haredim,[29] with large Haredi centres in Montreal and Toronto; South Africa, primarily in Johannesburg; and an estimated 7,500 Haredim in Australia,[29] centred in Melbourne. Haredi communities also exist in Argentina, especially in Buenos Aires, and in Brazil, primarily in São Paulo. A Haredi city is under construction (2021) in Mexico near Ixtapan de la Sal.[104] Decades after The Holocaust, Haredim are growing again in Budapest, opening several new synagogues and two mikvehs in the city over the past couple of years.[105][106]

Country Year Core Jewish Population Haredi Population[107] % Haredi Annual growth rate
Israel 2024 7,881,000 1,392,000[33] 18% 4%[33]
United States 2020 6,000,000 700,000[46][29] 12% 5.4%[45]
United Kingdom 2020 292,000 76,000[29] 26% 4%[108]
Canada 2020 393,500 30,000[107] 8%
Argentina 2020 175,000 13,500[107] 8%
France 2020 446,000 12,000 3%
Belgium 2020 28,900 10,000 35%
South Africa 2020 52,000 10,000 19%
Mexico 2020 40,000 7,500 19%
Australia 2020 118,000 7,500[107] 6%
Switzerland 2020 18,400 3,300 18%
Germany 2020 118,000 3,000 3%
Austria 2020 10,300 2,000 19%
Spain 2020 12,900 104 0.8%
Hungary 2020 46,800 885[107] 1.9%
Netherlands 2020 29,700 455 1.5%
Poland 2020 4,500 59 1.3%
Sweden 2020 14,900 34 0.2%

History

[edit]
Hasidic boys in Łódź, 1910

Throughout Jewish history, Judaism has always faced internal and external challenges to its beliefs and practices which have emerged over time and produced counter-responses. According to its adherents, Haredi Judaism is a continuation of Rabbinic Judaism, and the immediate forebears of contemporary Haredi Jews were the Jewish religious traditionalists of Central and Eastern Europe who fought against secular modernization's influence which reduced Jewish religious observance.[109] Indeed, adherents of Haredi Judaism, just like Rabbinic Jews, see their beliefs as part of an unbroken tradition which dates back to the revelation at Sinai.[110] However, most historians of Orthodoxy consider Haredi Judaism, in its most modern incarnation, to date back to the beginning of the 20th century.[110][111][112]

For centuries, before Jewish emancipation, European Jews were forced to live in ghettos where Jewish culture and religious observance were preserved. Change began in the wake of the Age of Enlightenment, when some European liberals sought to include the Jewish population in the emerging empires and nation states. The influence of the Haskalah movement[113] (Jewish Enlightenment) was also evident. Supporters of the Haskalah held that Judaism must change, in keeping with the social changes around them. Other Jews insisted on strict adherence to halakha (Jewish law and custom).[34][114]

In Germany, the opponents of Reform rallied to Samson Raphael Hirsch, who led a secession from German Jewish communal organizations to form a strictly Orthodox movement, with its own network of synagogues and religious schools. His approach was to accept the tools of modern scholarship and apply them in defence of Orthodox Judaism. In the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth (including areas traditionally considered Lithuanian), Jews true to traditional values gathered under the banner of Agudas Shlumei Emunei Yisroel.[115]

Moses Sofer was opposed to any philosophical, social, or practical change to customary Orthodox practice. Thus, he did not allow any secular studies to be added to the curriculum of his Pressburg Yeshiva. Sofer's student Moshe Schick, together with Sofer's sons Shimon and Samuel Benjamin, took an active role in arguing against the Reform movement. Others, such as Hillel Lichtenstein, advocated an even more stringent position for Orthodoxy.

A major historic event was the meltdown after the Universal Israelite Congress of 1868–1869 in Pest, Hungary. In an attempt to unify all streams of Judaism under one constitution, the Orthodox offered the Shulchan Aruch as the ruling Code of law and observance. This was dismissed by the reformists, leading many Orthodox rabbis to resign from the Congress and form their own social and political groups. Hungarian Jewry split into two major institutionally sectarian groups: Orthodox, and Neolog. However, some communities refused to join either of the groups, calling themselves "Status Quo".[citation needed]

Schick demonstrated support in 1877 for the separatist policies of Samson Raphael Hirsch in Germany. Schick's own son was enrolled in the Hildesheimer Rabbinical Seminary, headed by Azriel Hildesheimer, which taught secular studies. Hirsch, however, did not reciprocate, and expressed astonishment at Schick's halakhic contortions in condemning even those Status Quo communities that clearly adhered to halakha.[116] Lichtenstein opposed Hildesheimer, and his son Hirsh Hildesheimer, as they made use of the German language in sermons from the pulpit and seemed to lean in the direction of Zionism.[117]

Shimon Sofer was somewhat more lenient than Lichtenstein on the use of German in sermons, allowing the practice as needed for the sake of keeping cordial relations with the various governments. Likewise, he allowed extra-curricular studies of the gymnasium for students whose rabbinical positions would be recognized by the governments, stipulating the necessity to prove the strict adherence to the God-fearing standards per individual case.[118]

Haredi Jews from Galicia at the Karmelitermarkt [de] in Vienna's second district, Leopoldstadt, 1915

In 1912, the World Agudath Israel was founded, to differentiate itself from the Torah Nationalist Mizrachi and secular Zionist organizations. It was dominated by the Hasidic rebbes and Lithuanian rabbis and roshei yeshiva (deans). The organization nominated rabbis who subsequently were elected as representatives in the Polish legislature Sejm, such as Meir Shapiro and Yitzhak-Meir Levin. Not all Hasidic factions joined the Agudath Israel, remaining independent instead, such as Machzikei Hadat of Galicia.[119]

In 1919, Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and Yitzchok Yerucham Diskin founded the Edah HaChareidis as part of Agudath Israel in then-Mandate Palestine.

In 1924, Agudath Israel obtained 75 percent of the votes in the Kehilla elections.[120]

The Orthodox community polled some 16,000 of a total 90,000 at the Knesseth Israel in 1929.[121] But Sonnenfeld lobbied Sir John Chancellor, the High Commissioner, for separate representation in the Palestine Communities Ordinance from that of the Knesseth Israel. He explained that the Agudas Israel community would cooperate with the Vaad Leumi and the National Jewish Council in matters pertaining to the municipality, but sought to protect its religious convictions independently. The community petitioned the Permanent Mandates Commission of the League of Nations on this issue. The one community principle was victorious, despite their opposition, but this is seen as the creation of the Haredi community in Israel, separate from the other Orthodox and Zionist movements.[122]

In 1932, Sonnenfeld was succeeded by Yosef Tzvi Dushinsky, a disciple of the Shevet Sofer, one of the grandchildren of Moses Sofer. Dushinsky promised to build up a strong Jewish Orthodoxy at peace with the other Jewish communities and the non-Jews.[123]

Post-Holocaust

[edit]

In general, the present-day Haredi population originate from two distinct post-Holocaust waves.

The vast majority of Hasidic and Litvak communities were destroyed during the Holocaust.[124][125] Although Hasidic customs have largely been preserved, the customs of Lithuanian Jewry, including its unique Hebrew pronunciation, have been almost lost. Litvish customs are still preserved primarily by the few older Jews who were born in Lithuania prior to the Holocaust. In the decade or so after 1945, there was a strong drive to revive and maintain these lifestyles by some notable Haredi leaders.

The Chazon Ish was particularly prominent in the early days of the State of Israel. Aharon Kotler established many of the Haredi schools and yeshivas in the United States and Israel; and Joel Teitelbaum had a significant impact on revitalizing Hasidic Jewry, as well as many of the Jews who fled Hungary during the 1956 revolution who became followers of his Satmar dynasty, and became the largest Hasidic group in the world. These Jews typically have maintained a connection only with other religious family members. As such, those growing up in such families have little or no contact with non-Haredi Jews.[126][127]

The second wave began in the 1970s associated with the religious revival of the so-called baal teshuva movement,[128][129][130][131] although most of the newly religious become Orthodox, and not necessarily fully Haredi.[citation needed] The formation and spread of the Sephardic Haredi lifestyle movement also began in the 1980s by Ovadia Yosef, alongside the establishment of the Shas party in 1984. This led many Sephardi Jews to adopt the clothing and culture of the Lithuanian Haredi Judaism, though it had no historical basis in their own tradition.[citation needed] Many yeshivas were also established specifically for new adopters of the Haredi way of life.[citation needed]

The original Haredi population has been instrumental in the expansion of their lifestyle, though criticisms have been made of discrimination towards the later adopters of the Haredi lifestyle in shidduchim (matchmaking)[132] and the school system.[133]

Practices and beliefs

[edit]

The Haredim represent the conservative or pietistic form of Jewish fundamentalism, distinct from the radical fundamentalism of Gush Emunim,[134] and emphasising withdrawal from, and disdain for, the secular world, and the creation of an alternative world which insulates the Torah and the life it prescribes from outside influences.[135] Haredi Judaism is not an institutionally cohesive or homogeneous group, but comprises a diversity of spiritual and cultural orientations, generally divided into a broad range of Hasidic courts and Litvishe-Yeshivish streams from Eastern Europe, and Oriental Sephardic Haredi Jews. These groups often differ significantly from one another in their specific ideologies and lifestyles, as well as the degree of stringency in religious practice, rigidity of religious philosophy, and isolation from the general culture that they maintain.[citation needed] Some Haredis encourage outreach to less observant and unaffiliated Jews and hilonim (secular Israeli Jews).[136]

Some scholars, including some secular and Reform Jews, describe the Haredim as "radical fundamentalists".[137][138][139][140][141][142][143][144]

Efforts to keep clear of external influence is a core characteristic of Haredi Judaism. Historically, new mediums of communication such as books, newspapers and magazines, and later tapes, CDs and television, were dealt with by either transforming and controlling the content, or choosing to have rabbinic leadership censor it selectively or altogether. In the modern digital era, difficulty in censoring the Internet and conversely, the Internet's importance, resulted in a decades long and ongoing struggle of comprehension, adaption, and regulation on the part of rabbinical leadership and community activists.[145]

These beliefs and practices, which have been interpreted as "isolationist", can bring them into conflict with authorities. In 2018, a Haredi school in the United Kingdom was rated as "inadequate" by the Office for Standards in Education, after repeated complaints were raised about the censoring of textbooks and exam papers which contained mentions of homosexuality, examples of women socializing with men, pictures showing women's shoulders and legs, or information that contradicts a creationist worldview.[146][147]

Lifestyle and family

[edit]
Haredi Jewish women and girls in Mea Shearim, Jerusalem, 2013

Haredi life, like Orthodox Jewish life in general, is very family-centered and ordered. Boys and girls attend separate schools, and proceed to higher Torah study, in a yeshiva or seminary, respectively, starting anywhere between the ages of 13 and 18. A significant proportion of young men remain in yeshiva until their marriage (often arranged). After marriage, many Haredi men continue their Torah studies in a kollel.

Studying in secular institutions is often discouraged, although educational facilities for vocational training in a Haredi framework do exist. In the United States and Europe, the majority of Haredi males are active in the workforce. For various reasons, in Israel, a majority (56%) of their male members do not work, though some of those are part of the unofficial workforce.[148][149][150][151] Haredi families (and Orthodox Jewish families in general) are usually much larger than non-Orthodox families, with an average of seven children per family, but it is not unheard of for families to have twelve or more children.[127] About 80% of female Haredi Jews in Israel work.[152]

Haredi Jews are typically opposed to the viewing of television and films,[153] and the reading of secular newspapers and books. There has been a strong campaign against the Internet, and Internet-enabled mobile phones without filters have also been banned by leading rabbis.[154][155][156] In May 2012, 40,000 Haredim gathered at Citi Field, a baseball park in New York City, to discuss the dangers of unfiltered Internet.[155][157] The event was organized by the Ichud HaKehillos LeTohar HaMachane. The Internet has been allowed for business purposes, so long as filters are installed.

In some instances, forms of recreation which conform to Jewish law are treated as antithetical to Haredi Judaism. In 2013, the Rabbinical Court of the Ashkenazi Community in the Haredi settlement of Beitar Illit ruled against Zumba (a type of dance fitness) classes, although they were held with a female instructor and all-female participants.[158][159] The Court said in part: "Both in form and manner, the activity [Zumba] is entirely at odds with both the ways of the Torah and the holiness of Israel, as are the songs associated to it."[159]

Jewish Chicago has lauded the Haredim for their lifestyle, arguing that it has low crime and drugs, and a strong sense of family and community.[160]

Shidduch (matchmaking)

[edit]

With Haredi Judaism having a heavy emphasis on marriage, especially while young, some members rely on the shidduch (matchmaking) system. They employ a schadhan (a professional matchmaker) to support them in their search for a spouse. While there is no current statistical data showing how many people use the services of a schadhan, it is estimated that the vast majority of Haredi couples were paired by one.[161]

However, with the broader societal shift to online dating, matchmaking in Orthodox and Haredi Judaism has started making inroads online. Vastly different from the most popular online dating services, apps like Shidduch pair couples based upon shared values and life goals. To do this, users fill-out a digital resume. The app was made possible by a partnership between its developers and the Orthodox Union — the same group responsible for kosher food certification ("Circle-U").[162]

Dress

[edit]
Styles of Haredi dress
Typical Haredi dress for men and women
A Haredi couple in typical clothing

The standard mode of dress for males of the Lithuanian stream is a black or navy suit and a white shirt.[163] Headgear includes black Fedora or Homburg hats, with black skull caps. Pre-war Lithuanian yeshiva students also wore light coloured suits, along with beige or grey hats,[164] and prior to the 1990s, it was common for Americans of the Lithuanian stream to wear coloured shirts throughout the week, reserving white shirts for Shabbos.[165]

Beards are common among Haredi and many other Orthodox Jewish men, and Hasidic men will almost never be clean-shaven.

Women adhere to the laws of modest dress, and wear long skirts and sleeves, high necklines, and, if married, some form of hair covering.[166] Haredi women never wear trousers, although most do wear pajama-trousers within the home at night.[167]

Over the years, it has become popular among some Haredi women to wear sheitels (wigs), that are thought to be more attractive than their own natural hair (drawing criticism from some more conservative Haredi rabbis). Mainstream Sephardi Haredi rabbi Ovadia Yosef forbade the wearing of wigs altogether.[168] Haredi women often dress more freely and casually within the home, as long as the body remains covered in accordance with the halakha. More modernized Haredi women are somewhat more lenient in matters of their dress, and some follow the latest trends and fashions, while conforming to halakha.[167]

Non-Lithuanian Hasidic men and women differ from the Lithuanian stream by having a much more specific dress code, the most obvious difference for men being the full-length suit jacket (rekel) on weekdays, and the fur hat (shtreimel) and silk caftan (bekishe) on the Sabbath.

Neighborhoods

[edit]

Haredi neighborhoods have been said by some to be safer, with less violent crime, although this is a generalization, and even that may apply to only specific communities, rather than all.[169]

In Israel, the entrances to some of the most extreme Haredi neighborhoods are fitted with signs that ask for modest clothing to be worn.[170] Some areas are known to have "modesty patrols",[171] and people dressed in ways perceived as immodest may suffer harassment, and advertisements featuring scantily dressed models may be targeted for vandalism.[172][173] These concerns are also addressed through public lobbying and legal avenues.[174][175]

During the week-long Rio Carnival in Rio de Janeiro, many of the city's 7,000 Orthodox Jews feel compelled to leave the town, due to the immodest exposure of participants.[176] In 2001, Haredi campaigners in Jerusalem succeeded in persuading the Egged bus company to get all their advertisements approved by a special committee.[177] By 2011, Egged had gradually removed all bus adverts that featured women, in response to their continuous defacement. A court order that stated such action was discriminatory led to Egged's decision not to feature people at all (neither male nor female).[178] Depictions of certain other creatures, such as space aliens, were also banned, in order not to offend Haredi sensibilities.[179] Haredi Jews also campaign against other types of advertising that promote activities they deem offensive or inappropriate.[180]

Due to halakha, i.e., activities that Orthodox Jews believe are prohibited on Shabbat, most state-run buses in Israel do not run on Saturdays,[181] regardless of whether riders are Orthodox, or even whether they are Jewish. In a similar vein, Haredi Jews in Israel have demanded that the roads in their neighborhoods be closed on Saturdays, vehicular traffic being viewed as an "intolerable provocation" upon their religious lifestyle (see Driving on Shabbat in Jewish law). In most cases, the authorities granted permission after Haredi petitioning and demonstrations, some of them including fierce clashes between Haredi Jews and secular counter-demonstrators, and violence against police and motorists.[182]

Sex separation

[edit]
Gender-separate beach in Israel. To accommodate Haredi and other Orthodox Jews, many coastal resorts in Israel have a designated area for sex-separate bathing.[183][184]

While Jewish modesty law requires gender separation under various circumstances, observers have contended that there is a growing trend among some groups of Hasidic Haredi Jews to extend its observance to the public arena.[185]

In the Hasidic village of Kiryas Joel, New York, an entrance sign asks visitors to "maintain sex separation in all public areas", and the bus stops have separate waiting areas for men and women.[186] In New Square, another Hasidic enclave, men and women are expected to walk on opposite sides of the road.[185] In Israel, Jerusalem residents of Mea Shearim were banned from erecting a street barrier dividing men and women during the week-long Sukkot festival's nightly parties;[187][188] and street signs requesting that women avoid certain pavements in Beit Shemesh have been repeatedly removed by the municipality.[189]

Since 1973, buses catering to Haredi Jews running from Rockland County and Brooklyn into Manhattan have had separate areas for men and women, allowing passengers to conduct on-board prayer services.[190] Although the lines are privately operated, they serve the general public, and in 2011, the set-up was challenged on grounds of discrimination, and the arrangement was deemed illegal.[191][192] During 2010–2012, there was much public debate in Israel surrounding the existence of segregated Haredi Mehadrin bus lines (whose policy calls for both men and women to stay in their respective areas: men in the front of the bus,[193] and women in the rear of the bus) following an altercation that occurred after a woman refused to move to the rear of the bus to sit among the women. A subsequent court ruling stated that while voluntary segregation should be allowed, forced separation is unlawful.[194] Israeli national airline El Al has agreed to provide gender-separated flights in consideration of Haredi requirements.[195]

The Bais Yaakov graduating class of 1934 in Łódź, Poland

Education in the Haredi community is strictly segregated by sex. Yeshiva education for boys is primarily focused on the study of Jewish scriptures, such as the Torah and Talmud (non-Hasidic yeshivas in the United States teach secular studies in the afternoon); girls obtain studies both in Jewish religious education as well as broader secular subjects.[196]

Newspapers and publications

[edit]
Tziporah Heller, a weekly columnist for Hamodia

In 1930s Poland, the Agudath Israel movement published its own Yiddish-language paper, Dos Yiddishe Tagblatt. In 1950, the Agudah started printing Hamodia, a Hebrew-language Israeli daily.

Haredi publications tend to shield their readership from objectionable material,[197] and perceive themselves as a "counterculture", desisting from advertising secular entertainment and events.[198] The editorial policy of a Haredi newspaper is determined by a rabbinical board, and every edition is checked by a rabbinical censor.[199] A strict policy of modesty is characteristic of the Haredi press in recent years, and pictures of women are usually not printed.[200] In 2009, the Israeli daily Yated Ne'eman doctored an Israeli cabinet photograph replacing two female ministers with images of men,[201] and in 2013, the Bakehilah magazine pixelated the faces of women appearing in a photograph of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.[202] The mainstream Haredi political Shas party also refrains from publishing female images.[203] Among Haredi publishers which have not adopted this policy is ArtScroll, which does publish pictures of women in their books.[204]

No coverage is given to serious crime, violence, sex, or drugs, and little coverage is given to non-Orthodox streams of Judaism.[205] Inclusion of "immoral" content is avoided, and when publication of such stories is a necessity, they are often written ambiguously.[200] The Haredi press generally takes an ambivalent stance towards Zionism and gives more coverage to issues that concern the Haredi community, such as the drafting of girls and yeshiva students into the army, autopsies, and Shabbat observance.[198] In Israel, it portrays the secular world as "spitefully anti-Semitic", and describes secular youth as "mindless, immoral, drugged, and unspeakably lewd".[206][207] Such attacks have led to Haredi editors being warned about libelous provocations.[208]

While the Haredi press is extensive and varied in Israel,[198] only around half the Haredi population reads newspapers. Around 10% read secular newspapers, while 40% do not read any newspaper at all.[209] According to a 2007 survey, 27% read the weekend Friday edition of Hamodia, and 26% the Yated Ne'eman.[210] In 2006, the most-read Haredi magazine in Israel was the Mishpacha weekly, which sold 110,000 copies.[210] Other popular Haredi publications include Ami Magazine and The Flatbush Jewish Journal.

Technology

[edit]

Haredi leaders have at times suggested a ban on the internet and any internet-capable device,[211] their reasoning being that the immense amount of information can be corrupting, and the ability to use the internet with no observation from the community can lead to individuation.[212]

Some Haredi businessmen utilize the internet throughout the week, but they still observe Shabbat in every aspect by not accepting or processing orders from Friday evening to Saturday evening.[213] They utilize the internet under strict filters and guidelines. The Kosher cell phone was introduced to the Jewish public with the sole ability to call other phones. It was unable to utilize the internet, text other phones, and had no camera feature. In fact, a kosher phone plan was created, with decreased rates for kosher-to-kosher calls, to encourage community.[214][215]

News hotlines

[edit]

News hotlines are an important source of news in the Haredi world. Since many Haredi Jews do not listen to the radio or have access to the internet, even if they read newspapers, they are left with little or no access to breaking news. News hotlines were formed to fill this gap, and many have expanded to additional fields over time.[216][217] Currently, many news lines provide rabbinic lectures, entertainment, business advice, and similar services, in addition to their primary function of reporting the news. Many Hasidic sects maintain their own hotlines, where relevant internal news is reported and the group's perspective can be advocated for. In the Israeli Haredi community, there are dozens of prominent hotlines, in both Yiddish and Hebrew. Some Haredi hotlines have played significant public roles.[218]

In Israel

[edit]

Attitudes towards Zionism

[edit]

From the founding of Zionism in the 1890s, Haredi Jews leaders voiced objections to its secular orientation.[219][220] After the establishment of the State of Israel, some Haredi Jews observed the Israeli Independence Day as a day of mourning and referred to Israeli state-holidays as byimey edeyhem ("idolatrous holidays").[221]

Members of Neturei Karta protest against Israel (Washington, 2005)

The chief political division among Haredi Jews has been in their approach to the State of Israel. After Israeli independence, different Haredi movements took varying positions on it. Only a minority of Haredi Jews consider themselves to be Zionists. Haredim who do not consider themselves Zionists fall into two-camps: non-Zionist, and anti-Zionist. Non-Zionist Haredim, who comprise the majority, do not object to the State of Israel as an independent Jewish state, and many even consider it to be positive, but they do not believe that it has any religious significance. Anti-Zionist Haredim, who are a minority, but are more publicly visible than the non-Zionist majority, believe that any Jewish independence prior to the coming of the Messiah is a sin.[222][223]

The ideologically non-Zionist United Torah Judaism alliance comprising Agudat Yisrael and Degel HaTorah (and the umbrella organizations World Agudath Israel and Agudath Israel of America) represents a moderate and pragmatic stance of cooperation with the State of Israel, and participation in the political system. UTJ has been a participant in numerous coalition governments, seeking to influence state and society in a more religious direction and maintain welfare and religious funding policies. In general, their position is supportive of Israel.[224]

Haredim who are stridently anti-Zionist are under the umbrella of Edah HaChareidis, who reject participation in politics and state funding of its affiliated institutions, in contradistinction to Agudah-affiliated institutions. Neturei Karta is a very small activist organization of anti-Zionist Haredim, whose controversial activities have been strongly condemned, including by other anti-Zionist Haredim.[225] Haredi support is often required to form coalition governments in the Knesset.

In recent years, some rebbes affiliated with Agudath Israel, such as the Sadigura rebbe Avrohom Yaakov Friedman, have taken stances closer to the Israeli right wing on security, settlements and withdrawal from the Gaza Strip.[226]

Shas represents Sephardi and Mizrahi Haredim, and, while having many points in common with Ashkenazi Haredim, differs from them by its more enthusiastic support for the State of Israel and the IDF. The Sikirim group, an anti-Zionist group composed of Haredi Jews, is considered a radical organization by Israelis.[227]

Marriage

[edit]

The purpose of marriage in the Haredi (and Orthodox) viewpoint is for the purpose of companionship, as well as for the purpose of having children.[228]

There is a high rate of marriage in the Haredi community. 83% are married, compared to the non-Haredi community in Israel of 63%.[229] Marriage is viewed as holy, and as the natural home for a man and a woman to truly love each other.

Divorce

[edit]

In 2016, the divorce rate in Israel was 5% among the Haredi population, compared to the general population rate of 14%.[229]

In 2016, Haaretz claimed that divorces among Haredim are increasing in Israel.[230] In 2017, some predominantly Haredi cities reported the highest growth rates in divorce in the Israel, in the context of generally falling rates of divorce,[231] and in 2018, some predominantly Haredi cities reported drops in divorce, in the context of generally rising rates of divorce.[232]

When the divorce is linked to one spouse leaving the community, the one who chooses to leave is often shunned from his or her communities and forced to abandon their children, as most courts prefer keeping children in an established status quo.[230][233][234]

Education

[edit]

Haredim primarily educate their children in their own private schools, starting with chederim for pre-school to primary school ages, to yeshivos for boys from secondary school ages, and in seminaries, often called Bais Yaakovs, for girls of secondary school ages. Only Jewish religiously observant students are admitted, and parents must agree to abide by the rules of the school to keep their children enrolled. Yeshivas are headed by rosh yeshivas (deans) and principals. Many Hasidic schools in Israel, Europe, and North America teach few (or no) secular subjects, while some of the Litvish (Lithuanian style) schools in Israel follow educational policies to the Hasidic school. In the U.S., most teach secular subjects to boys and girls, as part of a dual curriculum of secular subjects (generally called "English") and Torah subjects. Yeshivas teach mostly Talmud and Rabbinic literature, while the girls' schools teach Jewish Law, Midrash, and Tanach (Hebrew Bible).

Between 2007 and 2017, the number of Haredim studying in higher education had risen from 1,000 to 10,800.[41]

In 2007, the Kemach Foundation was established to become an investor in the sector's social and economic development, and provide opportunities for employment. Through the philanthropy of Leo Noé of London, later joined by the Wolfson family of New York and Elie Horn from Brazil, Kemach has facilitated academic and vocational training. With a $22m budget, including government funding, Kemach provides individualized career assessment, academic or vocational scholarships, and job placement for the entire Haredi population in Israel. The Foundation is managed by specialists who, coming from the Haredi sector themselves, are familiar with the community's needs and sensitivities. By April 2014, more than 17,800 Haredim have received the services of Kemach, and more than 7,500 have received, or continue to receive, monthly scholarships to fund their academic or vocational studies. From 500 graduates, the net benefits to the government would be 80.8 million NIS if they work for one year, 572.3 million NIS if they work for 5 years, and 2.8 billion NIS (discounted) if they work for 30 years.[235]

The Council for Higher Education announced in 2012 that it was investing NIS 180 million over the following five years to establish appropriate frameworks for the education of Haredim, focusing on specific professions.[236] The largest Haredi campus in Israel is The Haredi Campus - The Academic College Ono.

In the midst of a controversy surrounding the limited secular education in some Haredi yeshivas, New York City mayor Eric Adams held up the Haredi yeshiva model as a model to emulate, arguing that "We need to ask, 'What are we doing wrong in our schools?' And learn what you are doing in the yeshivas to improve education."[237]

Tucker Carlson, in an interview with a former yeshiva student, observed that the yeshiva system, with its emphasis on asking questions, "seems like a great education".[238]

Military

[edit]
Haredi demonstration against the conscription of yeshiva pupils
Haredi demonstration against the conscription of yeshiva pupils

Upon the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948, universal conscription was instituted for all able-bodied Jewish males. However, military-aged Haredi men were exempted from service in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) under the Torato Umanuto arrangement, which officially granted deferred entry into the IDF for yeshiva students, but in practice allowed young Haredi men to serve for a significantly reduced period of time or bypass military service altogether. At that time, the Haredi population was very low and only 400 individuals were affected.[239] However, the Haredi population rapidly grew.[240][241] In 2018, the Israel Democracy Institute estimated that the Haredim comprised 12% of Israel's total population and 15% of its Jewish population.[242] Haredim are also younger than the general population. Their absence from the IDF attracts significant resentment from secular Israelis. The most common criticisms of the exemption policy are:

  • The Haredim can work in those 2–3 years of their lives in which they do not serve in the IDF, while most soldiers at the IDF are usually paid around $80–250 a month, in addition to clothing and lodging.[243] All the while, Haredi yeshiva students receive significant monthly funds and payments for their religious studies.[244]
  • The Haredim, if they so choose, can study at that time.[245][246]

Over the years, as many as 1,000 Haredi Jews have volunteered to serve in a Haredi Jewish unit of the IDF known as the Netzah Yehuda Battalion, or Nahal Haredi. The vast majority of Haredi men, however, continue to receive deferments from military service.[247] Haredim usually reject the practice of IDF service and contend that:

  • A yeshiva student has an important role in protecting the Jewish people because Haredim believe that Torah study brings spiritual protection similar to how a soldier in the IDF brings physical protection. Haredim maintain that each role is important in protecting the Jewish people, and one who is a yeshiva student should not abandon his personal duty in spiritually protecting the Jewish people.[248][249][250][251]
  • The Israeli army is not conducive to a Haredi lifestyle. It is regarded as a "state-sponsored quagmire of promiscuity" due to Israel conscripting both men and women, and often grouping them together in military activities.[252] Additionally, the keeping of military procedures makes it difficult to observe the Sabbath and many other Jewish practices.[253]

The Torato Umanuto arrangement was enshrined in the Tal Law that came into force in 2002. The High Court of Justice later ruled that it could not be extended in its current form beyond August 2012. A replacement was expected. The IDF was, however, experiencing a shortage of personnel, and there were pressures to reduce the scope of the Torato Umanuto exemption.[254] In March 2014, Israel's parliament approved legislation to end exemptions from military service for Haredi seminary students. The bill was passed by 65 votes to one, and an amendment allowing civilian national service by 67 to one.[255] In June 2024, the Supreme Court of Israel declared any continued exemption of IDF conscription unlawful. The army began drafting 3,000 Haredi men the following month.[256]

There has been much uproar in Haredi society following actions towards Haredi conscription. While some Haredim see this as a great social and economic opportunity,[257] others (including leading rabbis among them) strongly oppose this move.[258] Among the extreme Haredim, there have been some more severe reactions. Several Haredi leaders have threatened that Haredi populations would leave the country if forced to enlist.[259][260] Others have fueled public incitement against secular and National-Religious Jews, and specifically against politicians Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett, who support and promote Haredi enlistment.[261][262] Some Haredim have taken to threatening their fellows who agree to enlist,[263][264] to the point of physically attacking some of them.[265][266]

The Shahar program, also known as Shiluv Haredim (Ultra-Orthodox integration), allows Haredi men aged 22 to 26 to serve in the army for about a year and a half. At the beginning of their service, they study mathematics and English, which are often not well covered in Haredi boy schools. The program is partly aimed at encouraging Haredi participation in the workforce after military service. However, not all beneficiaries seem to be Haredim.[267]

Employment

[edit]

As of 2013, figures from the Central Bureau of Statistics on employment rates place Haredi women at 73%, close to the 80% for the non-Haredi Jewish women's national figure; while the number of working Haredi men has increased to 56%, it is still far below the 90% of non-Haredi Jewish men nationwide.[148] As of 2021, most Haredi boys instead go to yeshivas and then continue to study at yeshiva after getting married.[268]

The Trajtenberg Committee, charged in 2011 with drafting proposals for economic and social change, called, among other things, for increasing employment among the Haredi population. Its proposals included encouraging military or national service and offering college prep courses for volunteers, creating more employment centers targeting Haredim and experimental matriculation prep courses after yeshiva hours. The committee also called for increasing the number of Haredi students receiving technical training through the Industry, Trade, and Labor Ministry and forcing Haredi schools to carry out standardized testing, as is done at other public schools.[269] It is estimated that half as many of the Haredi community are in employment as the rest of population. This has led to increasing financial deprivation, and 50% of children within the community live below the poverty line. This puts strain on each family, the community, and often the Israeli economy.

The demographic trend indicates the community will constitute an increasing percentage of the population, and consequently, Israel faces an economic challenge in the years ahead due to fewer people in the labor force. A report commissioned by the Treasury found that the Israeli economy may lose more than six billion shekels annually as a result of low Haredi participation in the workforce.[270] The OECD in a 2010 report stated that, "Haredi families are frequently jobless, or are one-earner families in low-paid employment. Poverty rates are around 60% for Haredim."[271]

As of 2017, according to an Israeli finance ministry study, the Haredi participation rate in the labour force is 51%, compared to 89% for the rest of Israeli Jews.[272]

A 2018 study by Oren Heller, a National Insurance Institute of Israel senior economic researcher, has found that while upward mobility among Haredim is significantly greater than the national average, unlike it, this tends not to translate into significantly higher pay.[273]

Haredi families living in Israel benefited from government-subsidized child care when the father studied Torah and the mother worked at least 24 hours per week. However, after Israeli Finance Minister Avigdor Liberman introduced a new policy in 2021, families in which the father is a full-time yeshiva student are no longer eligible for a daycare subsidy. Under this policy, fathers must also work at least part-time in order for the family to qualify for the subsidy. The move was denounced by Haredi leaders.[274]

Work force and tax contribution

[edit]

A 2025 Israel Democracy Institute study found that although Haredim made up 14% of Israel’s working-age population in 2023, they generated only 4% of national tax revenue.[275] As a result, the average non-Haredi worker is projected to pay an extra 3,540 shekels in taxes in 2025.[275] Only 23% of Haredim pay income tax, compared to 62% of non-Haredi Jewish men and 46% of women.[275] Employment among Haredi men declined to 54% in 2024, while rates for Haredi women rose to 81% in 2023—just 2% below non-Haredi women.[275] Due to a lack of secular education, many Haredi men are poorly equipped for the labor market, leading to lower household incomes.[275] Despite contributing less in taxes, Haredi households consume more state services, receiving transportation and municipal tax discounts, housing aid, and other benefits; the Kohelet Policy Forum reported that 80% of Haredi households are net receivers of public funds.[275] The IDI called this imbalance unsustainable.[275]

Other issues

[edit]
Hasidim walk to the synagogue, Rehovot, Israel.

The Haredim in general are materially poorer than most other Israelis, but still represent an important market sector due to their bloc purchasing habits.[276] For this reason, some companies and organizations in Israel refrain from including women or other images deemed immodest in their advertisements to avoid Haredi consumer boycotts.[277][278] More than 50 percent of Haredim live below the poverty line, compared with 15 percent of the rest of the population.[279] Their families are also larger, with Haredi women having an average of 6.7 children, while the average Jewish Israeli woman has 3 children.[280] Families with many children often receive economic support through governmental child allowances, government assistance in housing, as well as specific funds by their own community institutions.[281]

In recent years, there has been a process of reconciliation and an attempt to merge Haredi Jews with Israeli society,[282] although employment discrimination is widespread.[283] Haredi Jews such as satirist Kobi Arieli, publicist Sehara Blau, and politician Israel Eichler write regularly for leading Israeli newspapers.

Another important factor in the reconciliation process has been the activities of ZAKA, a Haredi organization known for providing emergency medical attention at the scene of suicide bombings, and Yad Sarah, the largest national volunteer organization in Israel established in 1977 by former Haredi mayor of Jerusalem, Uri Lupolianski. It is estimated that Yad Sarah saves the country's economy an estimated $320 million in hospital fees and long-term care costs each year.[284][285]

Present leadership and organizations

[edit]

Rabbis and rabbinic authority

[edit]

Notwithstanding the authority of Chief Rabbis of Israel (Ashkenazi: David Lau, Sephardi: Yitzhak Yosef), or the wide acknowledgement of specific rabbis in Israel (for example, Rabbi Gershon Edelstein of the non-Hasidic Lithuanian Jews, and Yaakov Aryeh Alter, who heads the Ger Hasidic dynasty, the largest Hasidic group in Israel), Haredi and Hasidic factions generally align with the independent authority of their respective group leaders.

Major representative groups and political parties

[edit]

Other representative associations may be linked to specific Haredi and Hasidic groups. For example:

Haredi political parties in Israel include:

Past leaders of Haredi Jewry

[edit]

Controversies

[edit]

Shunning

[edit]

People who decide to leave Haredi communities are sometimes shunned and pressured or forced to abandon their children.[230][233][234]

Pedophilia and sexual abuse cases

[edit]

Cases of pedophilia, sexual violence, assaults, and abuses against women and children occur in roughly the same rates in Haredi communities as in the general population; however, they are rarely discussed or reported to the authorities, and frequently downplayed by members of the communities.[286][287][288][289][290][291][292][293]

Divorce coercion

[edit]

To receive a religious divorce, a Jewish woman needs her husband's consent in the form of a get (Jewish divorce document). Without this consent, any future offspring of the wife would be considered mamzerim (bastards/impure). If the circumstances truly warrant a divorce, and the husband is unwilling, a dayan (rabbinic judge) has the prerogative of instituting community shunning measures to "coerce him until he agrees", with physical force reserved only for the rarest of cases.[294][17][295]

The New York divorce coercion gang was a Haredi Jewish group that kidnapped, and in some cases tortured, Jewish men in the New York metropolitan area to force them to grant their wives gittin (religious divorces). The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) broke up the group after conducting a sting operation against the gang in October 2013. The sting resulted in the prosecution of four men, three of whom were convicted in late 2015.[296]

Political controversies involving Haredi communities and parties in Israel

[edit]

In January 2023, the Times of Israel reported that Haredi citizens in Israel pay just 2% of the country's total income tax revenues, despite making up 13.9% of the nation's population. Furthermore, the article's author described their communities as an "epicenter of poverty", with over 60% of Haredi households classified as "poor" on the government's socio-economic index, with that figure remaining nearly constant in every Haredi community.[297]

While this disparity has been present in Israel for decades, it has garnered more attention since December 2022 for numerous reasons. First, Haredi families have the highest fertility rate in Israel, at 6.6 births per woman. In comparison, the average fertility rate in Israel is much lower, at 2.9 per woman. Current projections estimate that the Haredi population will double by 2036, and they will comprise 16% of the total population by 2030.[298]

The second aspect of the controversy surrounds their political connections to Israel's Religious Zionist alliance. Historically, they have remained politically uninvolved, but since the 1990s, they have continuously engaged more. Today, members of Israel's ultra-Orthodox community have long enjoyed benefits: exemption from army service for Torah students, government stipends for those choosing full-time religious study over work, and separate schools that receive state funds, even though their curriculums often do not fully teach government-mandated subjects. Today, many Israeli Haredi men do not work, preferring to study the Torah full-time, thus resulting in their high poverty rate.[299]

In media

[edit]

A Life Apart: Hasidism in America is a documentary film produced and directed by Menachem Daum and Oren Rudavsky, which aimed to portray the Hasidic Haredi world in more positive terms, stressing the close family ties as well as their rich traditions.[300][301]

Shtisel is an Israeli television drama series about a Haredi family in Jerusalem which has led to more favorable feelings about Haredi Jews.[302]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Bibliography

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia

Haredi Judaism, often termed ultra-, constitutes the most rigorous and separatist stream within , defined by meticulous observance of , deliberate segregation from secular society, and an overriding commitment to full-time for males alongside rigorous for females. The name "Haredi," meaning "those who tremble" in Hebrew, alludes to 66:5, symbolizing profound reverence and that compels avoidance of worldly temptations and innovations perceived as diluting faith.
Originating in 19th-century as a defensive response to the and movements, Haredi Judaism encompasses diverse subgroups including Hasidic dynasties with charismatic leadership, Lithuanian-style yeshiva-centric rationalism, and Sephardic variants, all unified by rejection of Zionism's secular nationalism prior to 's establishment. Post-Holocaust, survivors reconstituted communities in , the , and , achieving demographic resurgence through high rates of 6-7 children per woman, yielding a global population of approximately 2.1 million as of recent estimates, with over 1.3 million in comprising 13-14% of its populace and growing faster than any other sector. Defining features include uniform modest dress—black suits, hats, and sidelocks for men; long skirts, stockings, and headscarves or wigs for married women—gender-separated spheres, and institutional structures like sustaining perpetual study as a religious ideal over vocational training, resulting in male labor participation rates below 55% in Israel and heavy dependence on communal welfare and state support. This insularity has preserved Talmudic scholarship and ritual purity amid modernity's erosions, yet sparks persistent controversies, notably Israel's long-standing exemption of yeshiva students from compulsory , fueling protests and political leverage by Haredi parties amid debates, alongside critiques of limited hindering economic self-sufficiency and integration.

Terminology and Definition

Etymology and Core Meaning

The term "Haredi" derives from the Hebrew adjective ḥaredi (חרדי), plural ḥaredim (חרדים), rooted in the verb ḥ-r-d (חרד), signifying "to tremble" or "to shudder" in fear or awe. This etymological basis traces directly to Isaiah 66:2 in the , where God declares: "But to this one will I look: to him who is humble and contrite in spirit, and trembles [ḥared] at My word." The verse portrays the ḥared individual as one characterized by profound reverence and submission to divine authority, emphasizing spiritual humility over material or intellectual self-assurance. In the context of Judaism, "Haredi" thus connotes a deliberate posture of trepidation before God's commandments, rejecting complacency toward sacred texts and traditions. This biblical resonance underscores the self-conception of Haredi adherents as those who "tremble" in response to the weight of Torah observance, prioritizing unyielding fidelity to (Jewish law) amid external pressures for assimilation or reform. The term gained prominence in the mid-20th century, particularly among Orthodox Jewish communities rebuilding after , as a marker of distinction from more acculturated Jewish groups, though its linguistic and theological roots predate modern usages by millennia. At its core, Haredi Judaism embodies this etymological essence through a comprehensive that insulates traditional Jewish practice from secular , mandating full-time for males, strict gender segregation, modest dress codes, and large family sizes to perpetuate communal continuity. It represents not merely religious observance but a totalistic where every aspect of life—from to economics—aligns with rabbinic interpretations of divine will, viewing deviation as a to spiritual integrity. This framework fosters insularity, with Haredi communities often maintaining parallel institutions to avoid non-Jewish or modernist influences, reflecting the "trembling" deference to an unchanging covenantal order.

Distinctions from Other Variants

Haredi Judaism represents the most insular and stringent branch within , prioritizing complete separation from secular culture and maximal devotion to halakhic observance over integration with modernity, in contrast to Modern Orthodox approaches that synthesize religious fidelity with engagement in broader society. While Modern Orthodox communities encourage university education, professional vocations, and participation in democratic institutions alongside , Haredi practice emphasizes lifelong full-time learning for married men in yeshivot, often deferring or minimizing secular skills training to preserve spiritual purity. This divergence extends to family dynamics, where Haredi households average significantly larger sizes—27% of Haredi parents have four or more children at home compared to 4% in Modern Orthodox families—reflecting a theological imperative for pronatalism rooted in messianic anticipation rather than socioeconomic adaptation. Distinctive sartorial and communal norms further demarcate Haredi life from other Orthodox variants; men universally adopt black suits, hats, and sidelocks as symbols of unchanging tradition, eschewing the varied, less uniform attire common among Modern Orthodox, who may incorporate contemporary fashion while maintaining . Haredi enclaves, whether Hasidic courts or Lithuanian towns, function as self-contained societies with internal institutions for education, welfare, and governance, minimizing exposure to external media, technology, and interfaith interactions—practices less rigorously enforced in Centrist or Modern Orthodox settings that permit filtered use and civic involvement. Ideologically, Haredi rejection of as a secular intrusion on divine redemption contrasts sharply with the affirmative embrace of the State of Israel by most non-Haredi Orthodox groups, who view and national institutions as compatible with faith; Haredi factions historically opposed state formation, accepting benefits only pragmatically while advocating exemptions from for students. Even among right-leaning non-Haredi Orthodox, such as some American Orthodox, there is greater openness to vocational training and cultural exchange, whereas Haredi unity across Hasidic and Litvish hinges on shared antagonism toward Enlightenment-derived reforms like those influencing Modern Orthodoxy's tolerance for women's advanced secular roles or co-educational elements.

Historical Origins and Evolution

Emergence in 19th-Century Eastern Europe

In the early 19th century, Jewish communities across Eastern Europe, including the Russian Empire's Pale of Settlement, Poland, and Galicia, predominantly adhered to traditional practices of Torah study, halakhic observance, and communal autonomy, laying the groundwork for Haredi Judaism's distinct identity. These communities resisted encroaching secular influences from the Haskalah, which advocated for Jewish integration into European society via rationalist education and cultural adaptation. Rabbinic authorities viewed such reforms as existential threats to religious fidelity, prompting a reinforcement of insularity and scholarly immersion as countermeasures. A cornerstone of this response was the establishment of centralized yeshivas dedicated to advanced Talmudic study, epitomized by the founded in 1803 by Chaim of Volozhin, a leading disciple of the . This institution attracted hundreds of students annually, modeling a system where full-time scholarship served as both spiritual ideal and defense against assimilationist pressures, influencing the proliferation of similar yeshivas in and beyond. By prioritizing dialectical learning over vocational training, it institutionalized a elite class of scholars whose authority countered maskilic critiques. Parallel to the non-Hasidic (Litvish) emphasis on intellectual rigor, Hasidism expanded rapidly in the , with rebbes establishing dynastic courts that offered charismatic leadership and ecstatic worship, appealing to amid socioeconomic upheaval. Originating in the prior century, Hasidic groups grew to encompass at least half of by mid-century, providing communal solidarity through rituals and allegiance to tzaddikim while rejecting secular innovations. Initially opposed by Mitnagdim, these factions converged in their shared commitment to halakhic stringency and separation from gentile culture, solidifying proto-Haredi structures against emancipation's gradual advance in the region.

Responses to Haskalah and Emancipation

Traditional Jewish communities in Eastern Europe, precursors to modern Haredi Judaism, viewed the Haskalah—the Jewish Enlightenment movement that began in the 1770s—as a profound threat to rabbinic authority and Torah-centric life, rejecting its advocacy for secular education and cultural assimilation into European society. Emancipation decrees, starting with France's 1791 grant of citizenship to Jews and spreading across Europe by the mid-19th century, further exacerbated these concerns by enabling legal equality but encouraging integration that traditionalists feared would erode halakhic observance and lead to irreligiosity among the youth. In response, Orthodox leaders prioritized unadulterated Torah study over worldly knowledge, establishing fortified educational and communal structures to insulate against these influences. Both Hasidic and Misnagedic (Lithuanian non-Hasidic) factions, despite their mutual antagonism originating in the , increasingly aligned against the as a shared adversary, with Hasidim amplifying Talmudic scholarship in their courts to counter assimilationist appeals and Misnagdim reinforcing rigorous intellectual engagement with traditional texts. A pivotal institutional response was the founding of the in 1803 by Rabbi Chaim Volozhin, which revolutionized by centralizing advanced for hundreds of students, serving as a deliberate counter to Haskalah inroads and becoming the model for subsequent yeshivas that emphasized dialectical learning over secular curricula. In Hungary, Rabbi Moshe Sofer (known as the Chatam Sofer, 1762–1839), serving as rabbi of Pressburg from 1806, led uncompromising resistance, issuing rulings against Reform synagogues, secular innovations, and even the German language promoted by maskilim, famously punning on the Talmudic phrase to declare "Chadash asur min ha-Torah" (the new is forbidden by the Torah) to denounce any departure from established custom. These countermeasures extended to practical , including cherem (excommunications) against maskilim, promotion of as a barrier to Enlightenment literature, and the cultivation of autonomous kehillot (communities) that regulated internal affairs to minimize external cultural penetration. By the mid-19th century, such strategies had coalesced into a distinct ultra-Orthodox , prioritizing religious fidelity over individual civic participation, thereby preserving core practices amid emancipation's assimilatory tide. This foundational resistance not only thwarted widespread defection in Eastern European strongholds but also set precedents for Haredi in subsequent eras.

Impact of the Holocaust

Prior to World War II, Eastern Europe, particularly Poland and Lithuania, served as the primary centers of Haredi Judaism, encompassing vibrant Hasidic dynasties and Litvish yeshiva networks that produced generations of Torah scholars. Poland alone hosted the heart of Hasidism, with dense concentrations of ultra-Orthodox communities adhering strictly to traditional practices. The region's Jewish population exceeded 9 million across Europe, with a significant proportion in these areas maintaining Haredi-like observance amid broader Jewish diversity. The Holocaust inflicted near-total devastation on these communities, annihilating the institutional and human foundations of Haredi life. targeted populations systematically from 1941 onward, resulting in the murder of approximately 6 million , the majority from Eastern European strongholds where Haredi groups predominated. In , only about 15% of survived, decimating Hasidic centers and yeshivas; major institutions like those in , Lodz, and Vilna were eradicated, along with thousands of rabbis, rebbes, and students who embodied the chain of transmission. Efforts to rescue key figures—prioritizing rebbes and yeshiva students—yielded limited success, as systemic extermination overwhelmed escape attempts. Surviving Haredi leaders, such as those from Hungarian Hasidic lines who reached the or , initiated reconstruction amid profound loss. This catastrophe galvanized a post-1945 imperative to restore the pre-war world of and piety, fostering insularity to safeguard against secular influences and driving demographic recovery through elevated fertility rates in nascent communities in and America. The annihilation underscored the fragility of traditional Jewish continuity, prompting Haredi to frame the event as a divine necessitating unwavering adherence to for redemption.

Post-1945 Revival and Expansion

The Holocaust decimated Haredi communities, killing approximately 90% of , including most rabbinic leadership and students, leaving only scattered survivors worldwide. Post-1945 revival began with these remnants relocating primarily to (later ) and the , where they reestablished institutions amid Zionist and secular influences. In , the nascent Haredi population numbered around 400 students granted military exemptions under David Ben-Gurion's 1948 status quo agreement, enabling focus on rather than . This arrangement, combined with of survivors, laid the foundation for communal expansion in cities like Jerusalem's and the emerging . Key figures drove institutional rebuilding. Rabbi , the Chazon Ish, who settled in in 1933, became a guiding authority for post-war, counseling thousands and transforming the town into a Haredi center through emphasis on rigorous halakhic observance and study for married men. Yeshivot like (relocated to in 1944) and Ponovezh (revived in 1943) were reestablished or renamed after destroyed European counterparts, preserving pre-war Lithuanian-style learning. In the United States, Rabbi , escaping via , founded and expanded in Lakewood, , in 1943; by his death in 1962, it had grown to hundreds of students, pioneering full-time in America and inspiring similar institutions. Hasidic dynasties also revived prominently in the U.S. Rabbi , the Satmar , arrived in 1946 after rescue via the Kasztner and Wallenberg efforts, rejecting resettlement in due to ; he built into the largest Hasidic group from a New York base in Williamsburg, emphasizing isolation from secular society and culture, leading to rapid community growth through arranged marriages and large families. Similarly, other groups like Lubavitch () and reemerged, with adopting outreach while core Haredi sects maintained insularity. By the 1950s, Haredi networks formed in Brooklyn's Borough Park and Williamsburg, Lakewood, and upstate enclaves like Kiryas Joel, supported by fundraising from sympathetic donors. Demographic expansion accelerated due to high rates—averaging 6-7 children per woman—and minimal assimilation, contrasting with declining non-Orthodox Jewish populations. Hasidic numbers rose from about 20,000 survivors in 1945 to 350,000-400,000 by the late , comprising half in . Overall Haredi population grew to 2.1 million globally by 2022, representing 14% of world Jewry, with hosting 1.2 million (13% of its population) and the U.S. 700,000. This surge extended to (Antwerp, ’s ), (), and , fueled by chain migration and welfare systems in that subsidized study over employment, though U.S. communities emphasized self-reliance. New towns like and emerged in , while U.S. suburbs adapted to influxes, solidifying Haredi Judaism as Judaism's fastest-growing sector despite external pressures for integration.

Theological and Ideological Foundations

Absolute Adherence to Halakha and Torah Primacy

Haredi Judaism maintains that the Torah, encompassing both the Written Torah (the Five Books of Moses) and the Oral Torah (as codified in the Talmud and subsequent rabbinic literature), constitutes the eternal and divine blueprint for Jewish existence, superseding all human constructs including secular governance or rationalist philosophy. This primacy is not merely doctrinal but operational: every facet of personal, familial, and communal life must align with halakhic prescriptions, which Haredim regard as immutable derivations from Torah sources rather than adaptable interpretations subject to modern exigencies. For instance, Haredi authorities reject any reconciliation of halakha with democratic norms when conflicts arise, asserting halakha's precedence as the sole authentic guide to Jewish authenticity and survival. Central to this ideology is the elevation of Torah study (limmud Torah) as the paramount religious obligation, particularly for men, who are often exempted from secular pursuits to devote themselves full-time to its mastery in yeshivot (academies of Talmudic learning). Haredi thought posits that such study not only fulfills the mitzvah of Torah engagement but sustains the spiritual merit protecting the Jewish people, a belief rooted in interpretations of texts like the Talmudic tractate Shabbat 127a, which equates Torah scholars with the world's pillars. This practice, intensified post-Holocaust, underscores a causal view wherein collective Torah observance averts existential threats, prioritizing it over material or military contributions. Women, while obligated in practical mitzvot, support this framework through domestic roles aligned with halakhic modesty and family sustenance. The concept of Da'as Torah extends Torah primacy into practical authority, holding that preeminent rabbis (gedolim), through lifelong immersion in , attain intuitive wisdom applicable to all domains, including , , and personal choices beyond strict . Originating in Lithuanian Haredi circles, this doctrine mandates deference to these sages' guidance as an extension of divine will, critiqued by non-Haredi Orthodox as overextending rabbinic but defended within Haredi ideology as essential for preserving purity against secular dilution. In political contexts, such as Israeli negotiations or responses to state mandates, Haredi leaders invoke Da'as Torah to veto accommodations deemed halakhically compromising, reinforcing a hierarchical structure where rabbinic consensus overrides individual autonomy or electoral majorities.

Rejection of Secular Modernity

Haredi Judaism fundamentally opposes secular modernity, viewing it as a corrosive force that erodes adherence to and . This stance originated as a response to the , the 18th- and 19th-century Jewish Enlightenment movement that promoted integration into European society through , , and . Haredi leaders, emphasizing da'at Torah—the supremacy of rabbinic authority derived from —reject such influences to safeguard communal religious purity, arguing that exposure to modern ideas fosters doubt in divine revelation and leads to . In practice, this rejection manifests prominently in education systems, where Haredi yeshivas prioritize Talmudic study over secular subjects. In , many Haredi boys' schools allocate minimal time—often less than 10%—to core subjects like , , and English, resulting in low proficiency rates; for instance, in , only 15% of Haredi eighth-graders met basic math standards compared to 80% in secular schools. This approach stems from the that secular distracts from spiritual pursuits and introduces conflicting worldviews, though it contributes to high among Haredi men, exceeding 50% in some communities. Haredi girls receive somewhat more secular instruction to prepare for roles, but even this is curtailed to align with religious norms. Technological and cultural isolation further embodies this opposition. Haredi communities often impose bans or strict filters on , smartphones, and media to prevent exposure to secular content, with rabbinic edicts like the 2012 "kosher phone" initiative limiting devices to voice calls only. Television and cinema are broadly prohibited as vehicles of immorality and assimilation. Dress codes enforce traditional attire—black suits and hats for men, modest long skirts and wigs for married women—distinguishing adherents from modern society and symbolizing defiance of fashion-driven . While some Haredi subgroups, particularly Litvish (non-Hasidic), permit limited engagement with technology for economic necessity, the overarching maintains that modernity's materialistic ethos undermines , prioritizing eternal spiritual values over temporal .

Perspectives on Zionism and Statehood

Haredi attitudes toward and the State of Israel vary across sects and leaders, ranging from theological opposition to pragmatic political engagement, with a common thread of subordinating state authority to halakhic supremacy. Strongly anti-Zionist factions, such as —founded in 1938 in by Amram Blau—and the Satmar Hasidim, reject the state's legitimacy entirely, viewing its establishment as a violation of Talmudic oaths prohibiting Jewish mass return to the or rebellion against gentile nations before the Messiah's arrival. Joel Teitelbaum, Satmar's rebbe from 1946 until his death in 1979, articulated this in his 1959 treatise Vayoel Moshe, arguing that constitutes heresy by usurping divine redemption and provoking as punishment for defying rabbinic prohibitions. These groups, comprising a minority of Haredim, refuse Israeli citizenship benefits like voting or military exemptions tied to state recognition, and has controversially allied with anti-Israel causes, including meetings with Holocaust deniers and Palestinian leaders. In contrast, non-Zionist Haredi organizations like , established in 1912 as an umbrella for traditionalist rabbis opposing secular Zionism's , adopt a policy of da'at Torah-guided participation in the state to safeguard religious interests without endorsing its ideological foundations. entered Israeli politics in the 1949 elections as part of the United Religious Front, securing seats and influencing policies such as funding and observance, later forming part of , which has joined coalitions to negotiate exemptions and budgets. This pragmatic approach, rooted in pre-state alliances with Zionist leaders for communal protection, prioritizes over nationalism; for instance, Haredi parties resigned from Netanyahu's government in July 2025 over proposed expansions of military , underscoring their view of state demands as secondary to religious imperatives. A pivotal aspect of Haredi-state relations is the exemption from compulsory military service, initially granted in October 1948 by Prime Minister to 400 students as a gesture to secure ultra-Orthodox support amid the War of Independence, despite comprising less than 1% of the Jewish population at the time. This torato umanuto (Torah as profession) deferral expanded through political arrangements, exempting tens of thousands by the 2020s—around 13% of 's Jewish males in draft age—while Haredi enlistment rates remained below 1.5% annually, justified theologically as preserving the spiritual merit of full-time study that purportedly protects the nation. 's struck down the blanket exemption in June 2024, mandating gradual integration, yet enforcement faces resistance, including mass protests, reflecting deeper tensions over state sovereignty versus rabbinic autonomy. Over time, attitudes have softened pragmatically; a 2024 survey found 83% of Haredim report strong emotional ties to , though ideological rejection of persists, with post-1967 gains prompting some leaders to tacitly support territorial retention for security rather than redemption. This evolution from outright isolation to conditional involvement stems from demographic growth—Haredim now about 13.3% of 's population per 2023 data—and practical necessities, without altering core beliefs in messianic preconditions for true sovereignty.

Messianic Expectations and Geula

In Haredi Judaism, (redemption) refers to the eschatological process of divine liberation from exile, culminating in the ingathering of Jewish exiles to the , the rebuilding of the Third , the of the dead, and the establishment of universal peace under the rule of the (Mashiach), a Davidic descendant who will enforce observance worldwide. This vision draws from prophetic texts such as Isaiah 11:1-9, which describes the Messiah's era of knowledge of God covering the earth "as the waters cover the sea," and Ezekiel 37:21-28, foretelling national restoration and eternal covenant. Haredi thought emphasizes as a supernatural event initiated solely by God, achieved through collective Jewish piety, , and fulfillment of commandments (mitzvot), rather than political or military action, reflecting a deterministic where human agency cannot compel divine timelines. Central to Haredi messianic expectations is adherence to the Talmudic "" (Ketubot 111a), interpreted as prohibitions against collectively ascending to or rebelling against nations before the 's arrival, lest they provoke divine wrath and delay redemption. Groups such as Satmar Hasidim and invoke these oaths to reject as a blasphemous human imitation of , arguing that the secular State of , founded in 1948, constitutes a false that desecrates God's name by presuming to end exile through apostate means. Litvish () Haredim, while often pragmatically engaging with the state for welfare and , similarly subordinate national revival to passive awaiting of the , prioritizing spiritual preparation over territorial activism. Daily liturgy reinforces this, with prayers like and the concluding with pleas for "in our days," fostering a where current tribulations signal proximity to redemption but demand intensified insularity and observance. Exceptions exist within Haredi spectrum, notably Chabad-Lubavitch, which advocates "hastening" through global outreach to perform mitzvot and publicize the Messiah's imminence, based on the Baal Shem Tov's teaching that redemption aligns with merit accumulation. A minority faction persists in claiming their late , (d. 1994), as the , interpreting his life as fulfilling prophecies despite his death, though this view is widely rejected by other Haredim as deviation from normative expectation of a living redeemer. Overall, Haredi counters secular optimism with caution against messianic pretenders, as warned in Deuteronomy 13:1-5, insisting true transforms not just but human nature, eradicating evil inclination () through divine revelation.

Religious Practices and Rituals

Daily Observances and Prayer

Haredi men are obligated to recite three daily statutory prayers—Shacharit (morning), Mincha (afternoon), and Maariv (evening)—in accordance with halakhic requirements derived from biblical and rabbinic sources. These services center on the Shema (affirmation of God's unity) and the Amidah (standing prayer of eighteen blessings, plus a nineteenth added post-Temple destruction), recited silently by individuals and repeated aloud by the prayer leader when a quorum is present. Shacharit must commence after dawn (alot ha-shachar, approximately 72 minutes before sunrise) and conclude by midday, Mincha between midday and nightfall, and Maariv from nightfall onward, with precise timing varying by location and season to fulfill the mitzvah optimally. A defining feature of Haredi practice is the requirement for men to pray communally with a minyan—a quorum of ten adult Jewish males—whenever feasible, as this elevates the service through public recitation of certain prayers like Kaddish and Kedushah, which are unavailable in solitary prayer. In Haredi communities, men typically attend minyanim in synagogues (shuls), small prayer rooms (shtieblach), or yeshiva study halls, often multiple times daily; for instance, early risers may join a pre-dawn or dawn service before proceeding to Torah study. During Shacharit, men aged thirteen and above don tefillin (phylacteries containing Torah verses) on the arm and head, and married men wear a tallit (fringed prayer shawl), fulfilling time-bound mitzvot symbolizing constant awareness of divine commandments. Prayer is conducted with deliberate slowness and concentration (kavanah) to embody the "service of the heart," contrasting with rushed modern practices; Hasidic subgroups may extend services further with additional Psalms or meditative elements. Daily observances commence upon awakening with the blessing, thanking for restoring the soul, followed by ritual handwashing (netilat yadayim) to remove spiritual impurity from sleep, and a series of morning blessings (Birkhot HaShachar) acknowledging bodily functions, , and . These precede formal and integrate into a routine emphasizing constant performance, such as reciting blessings before and after eating (e.g., Hamotzi over bread) and donning (fringed undergarments) daily for men. punctuates the day, mandated from 1:8 ("day and night"), often comprising hours before and after prayers in yeshivas or kollels, where men review Talmudic texts, halakhah, and Kabbalistic works depending on subgroup (e.g., Litvish focus on analytical , Hasidic on mystical texts). Surveys indicate near-universal daily adherence among Haredim, with 76% reporting daily practice, underscoring its centrality amid critiques of secular influences. Haredi women, exempt from time-bound positive commandments, recite the same core prayers privately at home without or obligations, though many attend women's sections in synagogues for communal inspiration during or holidays. separation () ensures focus on devotion over distraction, aligning with halakhic principles prioritizing familial roles for women, who maintain home-based rituals like candle-lighting preparations or children. This structure reinforces communal insularity, as daily cycles orbit and study, fostering spiritual discipline verifiable through consistent observance rates exceeding 90% in core Haredi populations.

Sabbath, Holidays, and Lifecycle Events

Haredi observance of the , from sunset Friday to nightfall , prohibits 39 categories of melakha (creative labor), including kindling , cooking, writing, and using , with virtually all Haredim avoiding handling , driving vehicles, or traveling by during this period. To facilitate carrying items like prayer books or babies in public domains, many Haredi neighborhoods employ an —a symbolic enclosure of wires and poles that ritually transforms the area into a private domain under halakhic standards. Communal services feature extended prayers and readings, followed by elaborate family meals with , wine, and songs, emphasizing spiritual elevation and familial bonding as the Sabbath's core purpose. Jewish holidays, or Yom Tov, impose work restrictions akin to the , with Haredim adhering strictly to biblical and rabbinic mandates, such as refraining from commerce and travel on , , , , and . Specific rituals include fasting and atonement prayers on ; dwelling in temporary sukkot booths and waving the four species ( and ) during ; and, for , meticulous removal of leaven () and consumption of to commemorate . Hasidic subgroups often incorporate additional customs, such as the rebbe's tish (festive table gathering) for or , enhancing communal joy through feasting, Torah processions, and charity distribution. In , many Haredim observe a second day of these festivals () due to historical uncertainties in the calendar, extending prohibitions even where not locally required. Lifecycle events follow halakhic prescriptions with rigorous communal involvement. At birth, boys undergo (circumcision) on the eighth day, performed by a in a ceremony affirming covenantal entry into , often accompanied by a festive meal; first-born males later receive redemption from a . Bar mitzvah for boys at age 13 marks assumption of mitzvot obligations, typically with public Torah reading in synagogue, while girls' bat mitzvah equivalents emphasize private study milestones without public ritual. Marriages, arranged via matchmaking, feature gender-separated celebrations under a canopy, with the ketubah (marriage contract) read aloud, avoidance of weddings on Sabbaths or holidays, and post-ceremony seclusion (yichud) for the couple. Upon death, occurs within 24 hours in a plain wooden casket without , followed by (seven-day mourning) with restricted activities, mirror coverings, and communal visits to console the avel (mourner), underscoring rapid return to earth and soul's judgment.

Kashrut, Tahara, and Modesty Standards

![Hasidic family demonstrating traditional modesty attire in Borough Park, Brooklyn][float-right] Haredi Jews maintain stringent adherence to kashrut, the biblical and rabbinic dietary laws prohibiting certain animals, requiring proper slaughter (shechita), and mandating separation of meat and dairy products. Beyond minimal requirements, many Haredim insist on mehadrin certifications from rabbinical courts such as Badatz, which enforce additional stringencies like exclusively glatt kosher meat—lungs free of even minor adhesions—and avoidance of kitniyot (legumes) during Passover, practices rooted in heightened caution against potential violations. These standards exceed those of many Modern Orthodox communities, which may accept broader certifications like OU, reflecting Haredi prioritization of insularity from potentially lax external influences. Tahara, encompassing ritual purity laws particularly taharat hamishpacha (family purity), requires Haredi women to observe niddah—a period of separation from their husbands during and for seven days after —followed by immersion in a (ritual bath) to resume marital relations. Haredi practice incorporates chumrot (stringencies), such as meticulous bedikot (internal examinations with white cloths to confirm cessation of bleeding) and hefsek taharah (formal cessation declaration by a or expert), often under stricter supervision than in less observant Orthodox circles to uphold halakhic purity. This regimen, derived from Leviticus 15, aims to sanctify marital intimacy and is universally binding in Haredi communities, with dedicated mikvehs ensuring compliance. Modesty standards, or tzniut, dictate Haredi dress and behavior to foster humility and prevent provocation of lust, applying to both genders but with distinct emphases. Women must cover knees (even when seated), elbows, and collarbone; wear skirts or dresses excluding pants; and, post-marriage, cover hair via wig (sheitel) or scarf (tichel), with Hasidic subgroups mandating opaque stockings and long sleeves year-round. Men adhere to formal attire including white shirts, black suits or jackets, visible tzitzit fringes, and head coverings like black fedoras or fur shtreimels on Shabbat, alongside beards and sidelocks (payot) in many sects, distinguishing them from secular norms and reinforcing communal identity. These codes, extrapolated from Torah verses like Deuteronomy 22:5 on gender-specific clothing, prioritize internal restraint over mere externals, though Haredi enforcement often exceeds historical rabbinic minima to counter modern immodesty.

Communal and Family Structures

Marriage, Shidduch, and Family Dynamics

In Haredi communities, marriages are arranged through the shidduch system, a traditional matchmaking process facilitated by shadchanim (matchmakers) who introduce compatible singles based on criteria such as family background, religious observance, and socioeconomic status. Parents play a central role in vetting proposals, and prospective spouses typically engage in a limited number of supervised meetings—often one to five—before deciding on engagement, eschewing casual dating to maintain modesty and focus on marital compatibility. This process aligns with Talmudic stipulations requiring personal acquaintance prior to marriage while adhering to strict gender segregation norms. Haredi individuals marry at relatively young ages, with the average first marriage age for ultra-Orthodox women in Israel at approximately 22 years and for men at 23 years as of 2021. In the United States, ultra-Orthodox grooms average around 24 years and brides 22.5 years, reflecting a pattern of early union formation to facilitate family establishment and Torah study. Weddings emphasize religious rituals, including the chupah (canopy) ceremony, and post-marital life often involves the husband continuing full-time study in a kollel (institute for married scholars), supported financially by the wife. Family dynamics in Haredi Judaism prioritize large households and delineated roles, with women bearing primary responsibility for childrearing, , and often external to sustain the family's religious commitments. Fertility rates remain elevated, though declining; as of 2024, Haredi average 6.1 children per woman, down from 7.5 in prior decades, contributing to rapid amid economic pressures. Men focus on spiritual pursuits, reinforcing a division where familial stability enables uninterrupted observance, though this structure has faced scrutiny for potential strains like the perceived "shidduch crisis," where a marriage-age gap leaves more women single due to demographic imbalances. Divorce rates are low, sustained by communal emphasis on marital permanence, but challenges such as refusals persist in isolated cases.

Gender Separation and Roles

In Haredi Judaism, gender separation, known as mehitzah in ritual contexts and broader tsniut () practices in daily life, derives from interpretations of prohibiting physical contact or seclusion () between unrelated men and women to prevent impropriety. This extends to public spaces in Haredi communities, such as segregated seating on buses with men in front and women in the rear, and some grocery stores maintaining separate hours for each gender. Synagogues feature physical dividers ensuring no intermingling during , while events like beaches or lectures often enforce separate areas or times. Education reinforces this separation, with boys attending yeshivas focused on Talmudic study from age three, and girls enrolled in Bais Yaakov schools emphasizing practical Halakha, Jewish history, and domestic skills from similar ages, without advanced Talmudic analysis. Higher education tracks for Haredim, where permitted, may include gender-segregated programs to align with these norms, as seen in proposals for master's-level courses approved in preliminary Knesset votes in 2025. Men's roles center on full-time Torah scholarship, particularly post-marriage in kollels, reflecting the ideal that spiritual study sustains the community; in Israel, Haredi male workforce participation stood at 51% in 2021, rising to around 55% by 2023. Women, conversely, prioritize homemaking, child-rearing—often bearing six or more children—and financial provision, achieving employment rates of 78% in 2021 and over 80% by 2023, frequently in teaching or clerical roles compatible with modesty standards. Halakha bars women from rabbinic authority or public Torah expounding, channeling their religious engagement into supportive domestic piety. This division, while critiqued externally for limiting women's public roles, enables men's immersion in study, which Haredim view as causal to communal spiritual preservation.

Dress, Neighborhoods, and Insularity

Haredi men adhere to distinctive dress codes rooted in interpretations of Jewish law emphasizing and separation from secular influences, typically wearing black suits, white shirts without ties, black hats such as fedoras or shtreimels on Sabbaths and holidays for Hasidic subgroups, uncut (sidelocks), and beards. These garments symbolize continuity with historical Eastern European Jewish attire and serve as visible markers of , distinguishing adherents from non-Haredi and gentiles. Haredi women observe strict (modesty) standards derived from rabbinic interpretations of verses like :5, prohibiting mixed-gender clothing and mandating coverage of elbows, knees, and collarbones, with skirts or dresses below the knee, long sleeves, and high necklines; pants are forbidden, and married women cover their hair with wigs (sheitels) or scarves. These practices extend beyond apparel to subdued , aiming to foster inner and shield against external moral erosion, though variations exist between Litvish (non-Hasidic Haredi) and Hasidic groups, with the latter often enforcing more uniform styles. Haredi communities concentrate in self-contained neighborhoods to reinforce religious observance and minimize exposure to secular culture, such as and in , and in the United States, Borough Park, Williamsburg, and Crown Heights in , New York, where over 500,000 Haredi Jews reside amid dense populations exceeding 100,000 per area. These locales feature kosher-only businesses, signage, and infrastructure supporting yeshivas and mikvehs, enabling communal autonomy; for instance, 's Haredi enclaves maintain poverty rates around 30% while prioritizing over economic integration. Insularity in Haredi society stems from halakhic imperatives to avoid assimilation and preserve fidelity, manifested in limited secular media consumption, endogamous marriages, and segregated that prioritizes religious texts over , resulting in high retention rates above 90% but also challenges like low workforce participation—under 50% for Israeli Haredi men—and dependency on state welfare. This separation fosters rapid demographic growth, with Haredi populations doubling every 20-25 years due to fertility rates of 6-7 children per woman, yet it correlates with issues such as restricted and resistance to vaccinations during outbreaks, as seen in 2019 epidemics in New York Haredi areas affecting thousands. Critics attribute insularity to rabbinic authority structures that penalize dissent, while proponents view it as causal protection against modernity's perceived spiritual dilution.

Education and Intellectual Life

Yeshiva and Kollel Systems

The yeshiva system constitutes the primary framework for male Haredi , prioritizing full-time immersion in as the core purpose of life and a means of spiritual and communal preservation. Boys enter from age three or four, focusing on Hebrew reading, basic , and halacha, before advancing to ketana around age 12-13 for intensified analysis. Upon reaching gedola, typically post-bar mitzvah or after rudimentary high school equivalents, students dedicate 10-14 hours daily to dialectical of Talmudic texts, with minimal emphasis on , sciences, or in most institutions. Litvish yeshivot, rooted in Lithuanian traditions, emphasize analytical rigor through methods like Brisker derech, dissecting halachic concepts via conceptual abstraction, while Hasidic counterparts integrate Chassidic texts such as Tanya alongside for mystical insights. This structure discourages secular vocational training for males, viewing scholarship as superior to worldly pursuits, though some elite students may later enter rabbinate or communal roles. In , the system receives substantial state funding despite frequent non-compliance with core curriculum mandates for boys' schools. Kollels extend yeshiva study to married men, enabling avrechim to pursue lifelong learning as a family-supported endeavor, often subsidized by communal stipends or welfare. Originating in its modern form in 1943 under Rabbi to rebuild post-Holocaust scholarship without vocational redirection, kollels now host thousands globally, with participants expected to study intensively while raising families. This model idealizes full-time limud as a spiritual merit, though it correlates with delayed entry for many. In Israel, enrollment reached 169,366 and students in 2023, reflecting an 8% annual increase and comprising a significant portion of Haredi male youth. The doctrine, recognizing as a full-time , underpins exemptions from military , a policy formalized in Israel's early years and defended as essential for national spiritual continuity. In the United States, similar systems operate in communities like Lakewood and , though with less state support and greater emphasis on eventual self-sufficiency.

Curriculum Focus and Outcomes

In Haredi boys' yeshivas, the curriculum emphasizes intensive study of Talmudic texts (), (Jewish law), and related from early childhood, with the goal of preparing students for lifelong scholarship rather than vocational or secular careers. Elementary education may include rudimentary Hebrew reading and basic arithmetic, but by seventh grade, secular subjects such as , , and English are often minimized or absent, particularly in where many ultra-Orthodox schools fail to meet state-mandated core requirements without facing sanctions. In the United States, Hasidic yeshivas similarly prioritize over a "substantially equivalent" secular , leading to documented deficiencies in English and basic skills among graduates. For girls in seminaries, the curriculum integrates religious instruction—focusing on , women's halakhic obligations, ethics, and practical Jewish duties—with secular subjects like language arts, mathematics, history, and vocational skills such as budgeting and , though Talmudic study is excluded as it is reserved for males. In , secular components receive less emphasis compared to North American or European branches, reflecting a of domestic roles and piety over professional preparation. This approach aims to foster religiously observant women capable of supporting family , with framed as subordinate to . Outcomes for boys include exceptional proficiency in oral and textual analysis of religious sources, enabling advanced rabbinic discourse, but often result in in secular Hebrew or English, limited mathematical competence, and challenges in scientific reasoning at the individual level. In , this contributes to low higher education attainment—only 2.3% of Haredi men hold academic degrees—and high rates, exacerbating despite community-level adaptations like informal knowledge networks. In the , Haredi men fare better economically due to greater exposure to practical skills, with 19% holding degrees in 2023, though this rate is declining amid intensifying religious insularity. Haredi girls generally achieve stronger secular outcomes, with higher matriculation rates and degree attainment (5.8% in ), supporting family finances through in , clerical work, or community services. However, even here, religious primacy limits STEM participation and broader professional integration, with Israeli Haredi colleges reporting dropout rates exceeding 75% for men and over 50% for women in secular-adapted programs. These patterns sustain communal cohesion and religious continuity but hinder adaptation to modern economies, prompting internal debates over incremental secular inclusion without diluting centrality.

Torah Scholarship Achievements

Haredi Torah scholarship emphasizes rigorous, full-time study of the Talmud and halachic codes, fostering generations of poskim who issue rulings on contemporary issues while adhering strictly to traditional sources. This approach, rooted in the Litvish yeshiva model pioneered by Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin's Volozhin Yeshiva founded in 1803, prioritizes analytical depth over breadth, producing novellae (chiddushim) and responsa that resolve complex legal questions. A landmark achievement is the Igros Moshe by Rabbi (1895–1986), comprising nine volumes of responsa published between 1959 and 1986, which addressed novel challenges such as the use of electricity on the , , and organ transplants, establishing precedents accepted by Orthodox communities worldwide. Feinstein's rulings, issued from his position as in New York, demonstrated causal reasoning grounded in Talmudic precedents, influencing halachic practice in diaspora Haredi life. Similarly, Rabbi , known as the Chofetz Chaim (1838–1933), authored the (1904–1907 onward), a multi-volume commentary on the Orach Chaim section of the , which clarifies practical daily laws on prayer, , and holidays through meticulous analysis of sources, becoming the standard halachic guide for Ashkenazi observance. Its systematic presentation and preference for stringency in unresolved disputes have shaped Haredi ritual practice, with ongoing study cycles like Daf HaYomi B'Halacha promoting its dissemination. Post-Holocaust reconstruction amplified these efforts, as Haredi yeshivas like Lakewood (founded 1943 by Rabbi Aharon Kotler) and Mir Yerushalayim (rebuilt 1944) expanded to host thousands of students annually, yielding works such as the Chazon Ish by Rabbi Avrohom Yeshaya Karelitz (1878–1953), a comprehensive halachic treatise on tractates like Yevamos and Shabbos that reconciles rishonim discrepancies and guides modern poskim. This institutional framework sustains high-level scholarship, with kollelim producing unpublished chiddushim and printed seforim that preserve and extend pre-war Lithuanian traditions.

Demographics and Distribution

Global Population Estimates and Growth Rates

As of 2020, the global Haredi population was estimated at approximately 2.1 million, comprising about 14% of the worldwide Jewish population of roughly 15 million.
Region/CountryEstimated Haredi Population (circa 2020)Share of Local Jewish Population
Israel1,200,00017%
United States700,00012%
United Kingdom76,00026%
Canada30,0008%
Europe (total)109,000N/A (5% of global Haredi)
Rest of World68,500N/A (3% of global Haredi)
Haredi growth rates average 3.5% to 4% annually—substantially higher than the 0.2% rate for non-Haredi Jews—resulting in a doubling of population every 18 to 20 years. This expansion stems primarily from elevated total fertility rates of 6 to 7 children per woman, extended life expectancy (males around 83 years, females 86 years), and high intracommunal retention, with net disaffiliation estimated at about 20%. Approximately 70% to 80% of global Haredi growth occurs in Israel, where the population reached 1.39 million by 2024, or 13.9% of Israel's total residents. Projections based on these trends forecast Haredim comprising 21% to 23% of global Jewry by 2040, assuming sustained and minimal external disruptions like assimilation or policy changes. communities, while growing, face slightly moderated rates due to and secular influences, though overall momentum remains driven by large families and .

Israel: Current Numbers and Projections to 2065

As of 2024, 's Haredi population numbers approximately 1.39 million individuals, representing 13.9% of the country's total population of about 10 million. This figure reflects an increase from 1.335 million (13.6%) at the end of 2023, with the community exhibiting the highest growth rate among major demographic groups at around 4% annually. The rapid expansion stems from a (TFR) of 6-7 children per Haredi woman, compared to the national Jewish average of about 3.0, alongside low rates of emigration or defection from the community and minimal net . Projections by Israel's Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), incorporating these fertility differentials and assuming stable trends in mortality, migration, and internal mobility, forecast the Haredi share rising to 16% by 2030. By 2065, amid an expected national population of 20 million, Haredim are projected to comprise 32% of the total populace and 40% of Jews, potentially exceeding 6 million individuals if growth sustains at current levels without significant assimilation or policy-induced fertility declines. These estimates account for variances, with low-end scenarios (e.g., gradual TFR convergence) yielding 23% and high-end (persistent high fertility) up to 40% by mid-century.
YearProjected Haredi Share of Total PopulationKey Assumption
203016%Continued 4% annual growth
204020-24%Stable TFR differentials
206532% (range: 23-40%)High fertility persistence; total pop. 20M
Such trajectories imply Haredim forming nearly half of Israeli children under 15 by 2065, amplifying long-term influences on societal structures, though projections carry uncertainty from potential economic pressures or cultural shifts reducing family sizes.

United States and Major Diaspora Communities

The hosts the second-largest Haredi population globally, estimated at approximately 600,000 to 700,000 individuals as of the early 2020s, comprising about 10-12% of the total American Jewish population of around 6 million. This community exhibits rapid growth, with fertility rates averaging 6-7 children per woman, leading to a population doubling approximately every 20 years due to high birth rates and low rates of assimilation or defection. Haredi communities in the are heavily concentrated in the , particularly in neighborhoods such as Borough Park, which features diverse Hasidic groups including Bobov and , and Williamsburg, dominated by the sect with a population exceeding 50,000 in the Hasidic core. Outside , , stands as a major hub with over 60,000 residents, many affiliated with the , the largest such institution outside , driving local economic and demographic expansion. Other significant enclaves include Monsey and New Square in , and Kiryas Joel, a -dominated village in Orange County with around 25,000 inhabitants, characterized by high insularity and poverty rates often exceeding 40%. In the , Haredi Jews number around 76,000, representing over 25% of the affiliated Jewish , primarily in areas like and , where Litvish and Hasidic groups maintain separate institutions and Yiddish-speaking networks. , , sustains a notable Haredi of about 15,000, centered on Hasidic dynasties like Ger and , benefiting from the city's diamond trade for economic self-sufficiency despite cultural isolation. In , Montreal's Outremont hosts a sizable Hasidic exceeding 20,000, mainly Satmar and adherents, with similar patterns of demographic growth and limited secular integration. Smaller but growing communities exist in , particularly and , totaling under 10,000, focused on education and ritual observance. These groups collectively account for a significant portion of global Haredi growth outside , sustained by internal marriage and communal welfare systems amid broader Jewish stagnation.

Other Regions: Europe, UK, and Beyond

In , Haredi communities constitute about 5% of the global Haredi population, totaling roughly 105,000 individuals as of 2022 estimates. These groups maintain high rates, often exceeding six children per woman, driving demographic expansion amid broader European Jewish population declines. Major concentrations exist in , the , , and smaller pockets in the , , and , where Haredim form a significant proportion—sometimes over 20%—of local Jewish populations due to insularity and low intermarriage. Belgium's hosts one of Europe's largest Haredi enclaves, with approximately 20,000 residents, predominantly Hasidic, comprising nearly 90% of the city's Jewish population. This community, centered near the , emphasizes Yiddish-speaking Hasidic dynasties like and , with robust networks and economic ties to gem trade. In , Haredi numbers stand at around 12,000, or 3% of the national Jewish populace, largely Sephardic-origin families in suburbs like and , focused on and ritual observance amid rising secular pressures. maintains a smaller contingent of about 3,300, while the ' Haredi presence remains marginal within its 30,000 core , concentrated in Amsterdam's Orthodox quarters. The sustains the continent's most substantial Haredi sector outside , estimated at 80,000 in 2023, representing a quarter of Britain's 320,000 . Growth stems from fertility rates averaging 5.3 children per family, fueling expansion in enclaves like London's (home to diverse Hasidic groups including and ), Manchester's Broughton Park, and Gateshead's Litvish hub. These communities prioritize separate systems, often resisting secular curricula mandates, as evidenced by ongoing tensions over state oversight of schools. Beyond Europe, Haredi populations persist in Canada (around 30,000, mainly in Montreal and Toronto's Hasidic neighborhoods), Australia (approximately 5,000 in Melbourne and Sydney), South Africa (under 10,000 in Johannesburg), and Latin American outposts like Argentina (13,500). These diaspora groups mirror core traits of religious seclusion, welfare mutual aid, and rabbinic authority, though they adapt to local antisemitism risks and economic niches, such as kosher commerce, sustaining modest growth via high birthrates despite assimilation challenges.

Organizational and Leadership Framework

Rabbinic Authority and Daas Torah

In Haredi Judaism, rabbinic authority is vested in gedolim (eminent Torah scholars), who serve as spiritual, communal, and decisional leaders, guiding adherents on matters ranging from ritual observance to and societal choices. This authority derives from the belief that prolonged immersion in equips rabbis with unparalleled moral and intellectual discernment, extending beyond strict halakhic rulings to broader ethical and practical counsel. Haredi communities emphasize unquestioning adherence to these leaders to preserve religious integrity amid external influences. The concept of Daas Torah (knowledge of Torah) encapsulates this framework, asserting that Torah scholars attain an intuitive, divinely informed perspective on worldly affairs due to their scholarly purity and detachment from secular distortions. Proponents argue it enables rabbis to discern underlying spiritual truths invisible to the untrained, applying Torah principles analogically to non-halakhic domains like politics or health. This view gained prominence in the late 19th and early 20th centuries as a bulwark against Enlightenment-era challenges to rabbinic leadership, with early articulations appearing in works like the Chafetz Chaim's commentary on the Torah, framing it as an extension of prophetic-like insight rooted in Talmudic precedents. In practice, Daas Torah manifests through consultations with gedolim for personal decisions—such as career paths, marriages, or medical treatments—and collective issues like electoral endorsements or responses to crises, often disseminated via Haredi media or rabbinic councils. For instance, during political upheavals in , Haredi parties like align with rabbinic directives on coalition formations, viewing them as Torah-derived imperatives. This system fosters communal cohesion but relies on the rabbis' perceived , with deviations risking social ostracism. Critics within , including some Litvish and Modern Orthodox thinkers, contend that Daas Torah overextends rabbinic purview into empirical domains where expertise lies elsewhere, potentially leading to flawed guidance on verifiable matters like or . Rabbi Natan Slifkin, an Orthodox zoologist, has argued it can oppose Torah values when invoked to justify insularity or errors, as seen in historical rabbinic hesitancy toward vaccinations despite halakhic compatibility. Such debates highlight tensions: while Haredi sources from figures like Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky uphold it as essential for spiritual fidelity, detractors cite instances of rabbinic misjudgments—e.g., on secular education's harms—as evidence against claims, favoring first-principles evaluation over deference. These critiques, often from rationalist Orthodox outlets, underscore that Daas Torah's authority stems from tradition rather than empirical validation, prompting internal Haredi reevaluations amid modern pressures.

Hasidic Dynasties vs. Litvish Traditions

Hasidic Judaism and Litvish (Yeshivish) traditions represent the two primary streams within Haredi society, originating from the 18th-century schism between the Hasidic movement founded by Rabbi Israel Baal Shem Tov (c. 1698–1760) and the Mitnagdic opposition led by Rabbi Elijah of Vilna (1720–1797). Hasidism promoted emotional, mystical devotion to God through practices like devekut (cleaving to the Divine) and joyful prayer, contrasting with the Mitnagdim's focus on rigorous intellectual analysis of Torah texts. In Hasidic dynasties, leadership is centralized around a , viewed as a (righteous intermediary) with near-infallible spiritual authority passed dynastically, often hereditarily, influencing everything from marriage arrangements to political stances. Major dynasties include (anti-Zionist, founded 1905 by Rabbi ), (reestablished post-Holocaust), and Chabad-Lubavitch (outreach-oriented, led by Rabbi until 1994). This structure fosters tight-knit courts (chassidic kehillot) where loyalty to the rebbe shapes communal life, with customs like distinctive fur hats (shtreimels) on and use of as vernacular. Litvish tradition, conversely, emphasizes Talmudic scholarship in large yeshivas modeled after institutions like Volozhin (1803–1892) and , with authority distributed among roshei yeshiva (deans) and gedolim (eminent Torah sages) chosen for intellectual prowess rather than charisma or descent. Leadership is meritocratic and consultative, as seen in bodies like the , without a singular figurehead. Prayer follows , study prioritizes (dialectical reasoning), and attire is standardized (black suits, hats), reflecting a rationalist over . These differences extend to social organization: Hasidic groups maintain autonomous dynasties with internal courts handling disputes and welfare, often more insular and Yiddish-centric, while Litvish communities revolve around networks promoting broader dissemination, with Hebrew and English more common in education. On Zionism, Hasidim like remain staunchly opposed, viewing the state as heretical, whereas Litvish vary from neutral to supportive, as in the approach of Avraham Yeshaya Karelitz (1878–1953). Despite divergences, both uphold strict halakhic observance and resistance to , collaborating politically through entities like Agudat since the 1912 founding.

Key Institutions and Political Entities

Haredi communities maintain independent rabbinical courts that adjudicate personal status and civil matters according to , operating parallel to state systems in . These courts, such as the Badatz of the , enforce strict religious standards and handle issues like , , and kosher certification. In Israel, Ashkenazi Haredim are politically represented by (UTJ), an alliance formed in 1992 between , which draws support from Hasidic groups, and , aligned with the Litvish yeshiva tradition. Sephardi and Mizrahi Haredim are represented by , founded in 1984 by Rabbi Ovadia Yosef to advocate for their interests within the Haredi framework. These parties prioritize exemptions from , funding for , and enforcement of observance, often leveraging coalition influence. Globally, the , established in 1912 as a non-Zionist alternative to political movements, coordinates Haredi educational, social, and advocacy efforts across communities. In the , affiliates like lobby for religious freedoms and institutional support. Hasidic dynasties, such as , Ger, and , function as semi-autonomous entities with their own rebbes, synagogues, and welfare systems, exerting significant internal authority. Litvish institutions center on major yeshivas that emphasize analytical study, though specific enrollment figures vary and are often self-reported by communities.

Societal and Economic Engagement

Employment Patterns and Self-Sufficiency

In , where Haredim comprise about 13.6% of the population as of 2023, male rates remain significantly lower than the national average, with 54% of Haredi men aged 25-64 employed in the first three quarters of 2024, compared to 87% for non-Haredi Jewish men. This figure represents a modest increase from 48% in 2014 but has stalled since 2023, with many employed men working part-time—42% of those aged 30-64 in 2017—due to commitments to full-time study. Haredi women, by contrast, exhibit higher participation at approximately 80%, often in lower-wage sectors like and services, supporting family incomes amid larger household sizes averaging six to eight children. This pattern stems from a religious imperative prioritizing for men as a communal and spiritual vocation over secular employment, a value reinforced by rabbinic guidance and state subsidies for yeshivas that enable deferral of work and . Consequently, Haredi households face elevated rates—over 50% in recent years—and substantial reliance on government welfare, child allowances, and subsidies, with only 23% of Haredi men paying versus 62% of non-Haredi Jewish men. Such dependency is exacerbated by limited , with Haredi men averaging fewer years of schooling focused on religious texts rather than vocational skills, contributing to an estimated annual burden on non-Haredi of NIS 3,540 per taxpayer in 2025 due to lower Haredi contributions. Efforts to enhance self-sufficiency include government and private initiatives promoting vocational training and flexible work arrangements tailored to religious observance, with surveys indicating 90% of Haredim support male employment in principle. Internal tzedakah networks provide mutual aid, with 89% of Haredim engaging in philanthropy, mitigating some welfare gaps through community voluntarism rather than state reliance alone. However, critics argue that ongoing subsidies perpetuate low productivity and fiscal strain, as Haredi population growth—projected to reach 25% of Israel's total by 2065—amplifies these dynamics without proportional economic output. In the United States and other communities, Haredi employment patterns diverge toward greater self-sufficiency, with 84% of Hasidic men employed in 2023—aligning with national averages—often in skilled professions, , or trades, while female participation stands at 59%. This integration reflects less state support for full-time study, stronger emphasis on family provision amid urban enclaves like Brooklyn's Borough Park, and adaptation to market demands without the Israeli model's exemptions, resulting in lower despite similar cultural priorities. Comparable trends appear in European Haredi groups, where economic necessities foster higher male entry than in .

Military Service Debates and Exemptions

The exemption of Haredi men from mandatory military service in Israel originated in October 1948, when Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion approved deferrals for 400 yeshiva students under the principle of torato umanuto ("his Torah is his profession"), allowing full-time Torah study to be considered a national contribution equivalent to military duty. This arrangement aimed to preserve Jewish religious scholarship after the Holocaust, with the number initially limited but expanding over time; by 1968-1977, annual quotas reached 800 exemptions. Legal challenges intensified in 1998 when Israel's ruled that torato umanuto lacked statutory basis and ordered legislative action or enforcement of drafts. Subsequent temporary laws, including the 2002-2012 arrangement and the 2014-2024 Equal Share in the Burden Law, sought gradual Haredi integration but repeatedly deferred full amid political pressures. The 2014 law expired on June 1, 2024, prompting the to unanimously rule on June 25, 2024, that the state must draft Haredi men and cease funding non-compliant yeshivot, declaring blanket exemptions discriminatory and unconstitutional under Israel's : Human Dignity and Liberty. Haredi leaders argue that continuous Torah study provides spiritual protection for the nation, citing Talmudic precedents where scholars' merits shielded from harm, positioning it as a causal equivalent to physical defense rather than evasion. They contend exemptions safeguard the " world" essential to Jewish continuity, with resistance rooted in fears that military exposure would erode religious observance and enrollment. Critics, including secular and national-religious , assert the undermines equality and burden-sharing, as Haredim—comprising about 13% of 's —contribute minimally to defense despite manpower shortages exacerbated by the , 2023, attack and ensuing war. Enlistment remains low despite the 2024 ruling; from July 2024 to May 2025, only 1,212 of 24,000 summoned Haredi men (5%) initiated enlistment processes, far below the IDF's target of 4,800 recruits by June 2025. Specialized units like Netzah Yehuda accommodate religious needs, but overall participation hovers below 1% of eligible Haredim, prompting protests—such as thousands chanting "better death than army" in October 2025—and political maneuvers to reinstate exemptions via new legislation. As of October 2025, the Netanyahu coalition faces collapse risks over the issue, with approximately 80,000 draft-eligible Haredi men aged 18-24 unenlisted.

Welfare Networks and Tzedakah

Haredi communities operate robust internal welfare systems centered on , the religious imperative to provide for the needy as an act of justice, distinct from optional . This obligation, derived from commandments such as the triennial for the poor (Deuteronomy 26:12), compels traditional , including Haredim, to allocate at least ten percent of their income to charity, fostering a culture of mutual support amid economic challenges. A cornerstone of these networks is the gemach system, comprising volunteer-run repositories for interest-free loans, shared goods, and services that embody gemilut chasadim (acts of loving-kindness). Emerging in the late within Jewish enclaves, gemachs lend or distribute essentials like , baby supplies, furniture, dresses, and even wigs or devices, often gratis or for a token fee to cover operations, thereby resources and alleviating without fostering dependency. In Haredi neighborhoods from to , these facilities number in the hundreds per community, enabling large families to meet despite low workforce participation rates among men. Dedicated charities amplify this framework; for example, Kupat Ha'ir, founded in 2000 in , , disburses over 100 million shekels yearly to approximately 20,000 needy Haredi families, funding food, utilities, housing, and holiday provisions through donor campaigns and rabbinic endorsements. Similar entities in the U.S., such as local Haredi aid societies in New York, provide emergency relief and stipends, supporting households where 53% qualify as poor or near-poor by federal metrics. These initiatives draw on communal , including pushkes (charity boxes) in homes and synagogues, sustaining operations independently of state systems. Empirical data underscore Haredi generosity despite systemic poverty: in Israel, Haredi households donate an average 4.6% of income to charity—triple the 1.2% from non-Haredi Jews—with 89% engaging in giving or volunteering, outpacing other sectors. This voluntarism offsets high poverty incidence (over 50% in Israel, per National Insurance Institute indices) and supplements government transfers, which average 3,577 NIS monthly per Haredi family versus 2,157 NIS for others. Critics, often from secular perspectives, highlight welfare reliance as a fiscal strain, yet internal metrics reveal self-reinforcing solidarity that prioritizes Torah study and family over secular employment, with gemachs and tzedakah funds enabling subsistence for the ultra-Orthodox underclass.

Political Influence and Interactions

In Israel: Parties, Coalitions, and Tensions

Haredi political influence in is channeled primarily through two major parties: (UTJ), representing Ashkenazi Haredim via the alliance of and , and , which serves Sephardi and Mizrahi Haredim. UTJ focuses on preserving Litvish and Hasidic traditions, while Shas emphasizes social welfare alongside religious observance, drawing support from lower socioeconomic Haredi communities. In the November 2022 elections, UTJ secured 7 seats and Shas 11 seats, forming a combined bloc of 18 mandates that proved essential for coalition arithmetic. These parties routinely participate in governing coalitions, particularly those led by under , to advance policies favoring religious institutions, such as increased funding for and enforcement of laws. The 2022 coalition agreement with Netanyahu's government included commitments to legislate Haredi exemptions from mandatory , a longstanding arrangement originating from a 1948 deferral for 400 yeshiva students that expanded as the Haredi grew to over 13% of Israel's by 2024. Their pivotal role grants disproportionate influence relative to voter base, enabling veto power over budgets and legislation impacting religious autonomy, though this has drawn criticism for perpetuating economic dependency, with Haredi men exhibiting workforce participation rates below 50% amid high birth rates straining public resources. Tensions escalated following the , 2023, attacks, which intensified demands for equitable burden-sharing in amid IDF manpower shortages. The Israeli Supreme Court ruled in June 2024 that Haredi draft exemptions lacked legal basis, prompting the IDF to issue summons to approximately 3,000 students initially, with plans to expand to 50,000 eligible Haredim. Haredi leaders mobilized mass protests against , viewing as a spiritual defense equivalent to military duty, while secular and national-religious sectors decried the exemptions as unfair, fueling public resentment and protests in cities like . Coalition fractures emerged in 2025 over stalled legislation to codify exemptions. UTJ withdrew from Netanyahu's government on July 15, 2025, citing insufficient progress on a conscription bill, reducing the coalition majority to one seat. Shas followed by resigning from all Knesset committee positions on October 23, 2025, amid rabbinic pressure on leader Aryeh Deri to prioritize draft avoidance, though both parties maintained external coalition support to avoid early elections. These events underscore broader frictions, including Haredi resistance to secular education mandates and gender-integrated public spaces, which have sparked clashes with municipal authorities and heightened perceptions of separatism among non-Haredi Israelis.

Diaspora Advocacy and Agudath Israel

Agudath Israel was established in 1912 in , , as a centralized organization uniting Haredi rabbis and communities to counter secular Jewish movements, including and , while promoting strict adherence to in public life. Initially focused on , it achieved success in building independent al networks and representing Orthodox interests to governments, such as securing recognition for Haredi schools in interwar Poland. During , affiliated groups like Vaad Hatzala coordinated rescue and relief efforts for rabbinic leaders and students, saving thousands through negotiations with neutral parties and Allied forces. Post-World War II, expanded aid operations across displaced persons camps in Europe, facilitating the relocation of survivors to new Haredi centers in the United States, , and elsewhere, thereby preserving communal structures amid rebuilding. In the United States, , formalized in 1922, serves as the primary advocacy body for Haredi communities, maintaining national offices in New York and , alongside regional branches to address local needs. It lobbies federal and state governments on issues like religious exemptions in , such as observance and kosher dietary accommodations, including support for the 2023 ruling in Groff v. DeJoy that strengthened protections under Title VII. Through its legal arm, Agudah Legal submits briefs in cases involving religious liberty, such as advocating for the Religious and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) of 2000, which has aided Haredi plaintiffs in zoning disputes for synagogues and mikvaot. The organization also pushes for funding of private , partnering with philanthropies to expand voucher programs and counter public school mandates that conflict with Haredi curricula emphasizing over secular subjects. European branches, including in the , extend this advocacy through welfare and immigration support tailored to Haredi populations, as seen in Agudas Israel Community Services' assistance with benefits claims and relocation for Orthodox families facing assimilation pressures. In the UK, it has intervened in high-profile cases, such as securing U.S. emergency visas for Haredi children denied local medical accommodations in , highlighting tensions between religious practices and secular healthcare rulings. Across the , Agudath Israel maintains a non-Zionist stance, prioritizing daas Torah-guided policies that reject political solutions to Jewish continuity in favor of spiritual insularity, though it pragmatically engages governments to safeguard communal , such as against anti-ritual slaughter laws in . This framework has enabled Haredi growth in diaspora hubs like and , where membership exceeds hundreds of thousands, supported by internal networks funding advocacy efforts.

Relations with Secular and Non-Haredi Jews

Haredi Judaism maintains a stance of ideological opposition toward secular and non-Haredi Jewish identities, viewing them as conducive to assimilation and erosion of strict observance. Haredi leaders and texts often denounce and even Modern Orthodox approaches as threats to Jewish continuity, emphasizing insularity to preserve religious purity amid perceived modern encroachments. This perspective fosters limited social interactions, with Haredi communities prioritizing internal cohesion over engagement with those deemed insufficiently observant. In Israel, relations with secular Jews (hilonim) are marked by minimal personal contact and recurring public tensions. A 2015 survey indicated that Haredi and secular rarely interact, reflecting parallel societies with divergent values on issues like observance, public modesty, and state institutions. Pew Research in 2016 found few cross-group friendships, with secular identifying primarily as Israeli and Haredim prioritizing , exacerbating mutual distrust. Conflicts frequently erupt over military conscription exemptions for yeshiva students, seen by secular majorities as an unfair burden shift during national crises, as evidenced by 2024 protests and clashes following rulings against blanket deferrals. Interactions with non-Haredi Orthodox Jews, such as Modern Orthodox (dati leumi), involve additional frictions over religious stringency and . Haredim often critique these groups for integrating and , perceiving such adaptations as compromises with that undermine halakhic fidelity. Political coalitions in , like those between Haredi parties and right-wing governments, enable policy influence but do not mitigate underlying cultural divides, including disputes over curriculum in state-funded Haredi schools lacking core secular subjects. In the diaspora, Haredi communities in places like the and sustain high levels of separation from secular and non-Orthodox , residing in enclaves with parallel institutions to avoid assimilation influences. While most groups minimize outreach, exceptions like Chabad-Lubavitch engage non-observant through kiruv efforts to encourage observance, though this is not representative of broader Haredi insularity. Tensions mirror Israeli patterns but are less politicized, focusing on community boundaries rather than state policies.

Cultural Preservation and Media

Yiddish, Publications, and Internal Media

serves as a primary language among many Hasidic subgroups within Haredi Judaism, particularly in communities originating from , where it functions as a marker of cultural and religious insularity. In the United States, Hasidic families, comprising an estimated 200,000 individuals as of the early 2000s, frequently use as the home language, with children acquiring it alongside English or Hebrew for religious study. Globally, the majority of daily speakers in the are Hasidim and other Haredim, whose populations have grown rapidly due to high birth rates, sustaining the language's transmission through family, yeshivas, and community interactions despite its decline elsewhere among Jews. In , native speakers constitute about 2% of adults over age 20, concentrated among Haredi Hasidim who employ it in daily life and education to limit exposure to modern Hebrew's secular connotations. Haredi publications in Yiddish emphasize religious content, community news, and moral guidance, often under rabbinic oversight to align with halakhic standards. Der Yid, established in the mid-20th century, remains the oldest and most widely circulated Yiddish newspaper in Orthodox circles, distributing tens of thousands of copies weekly to Hasidic readers in New York and beyond, focusing on interpretations, synagogue announcements, and avoidance of politically sensitive or secular topics. Similarly, Der Blatt, a Satmar Hasidic outlet, publishes in Hasidic Yiddish dialect, prioritizing intra-community events and religious discourse while eschewing images of women or external cultural influences to uphold modesty norms. These periodicals, printed on low-quality paper for affordability and disposability, reinforce communal boundaries by filtering information, a practice rooted in leaders' concerns over assimilation. Internal Haredi media, including and Hebrew outlets, operate within a framework of self-imposed to safeguard doctrinal purity and social cohesion. Rabbinic boards review content for compliance, prohibiting depictions of women, internet-derived news, or critiques of communal leaders, as seen in guidelines from the for the Purity of the Camp that banned certain ad imagery in Israeli Haredi papers. This control extends to digital platforms, where "kosher" cellphones and filtered websites limit access, reflecting a causal prioritization of spiritual isolation over unrestricted information flow, though emerging independent voices like challenge traditional gatekeeping by reporting uncensored community issues. Such mechanisms, while effective in preserving insularity amid external pressures, have drawn internal for suppressing and factual reporting on scandals, as evidenced by delayed coverage of cases until rabbinic approval.

Technology Use and Restrictions

Haredi communities impose significant restrictions on technology to safeguard religious observance and insulate members from secular influences that could undermine and traditional values. Rabbinic authorities, such as those in the , frequently issue proclamations against unfiltered devices, viewing them as conduits for immorality and distraction. For instance, television was banned upon its introduction to in 1965, with fewer than half of Haredi households possessing one today despite broader societal access. Smartphones and face the strictest scrutiny, with many sects prohibiting non-"kosher" models that enable web browsing, apps, cameras, or multimedia. Kosher phones, which limit functionality to calls and texts while blocking data, , and bilateral messaging with non-kosher devices, predominate; in , 84% of Haredim used them as of 2022. A oversees approvals for these devices, a control reinforced by Israeli in July 2024 affecting approximately 500,000 users. Violations, such as using standard smartphones, incur severe communal sanctions including social and , enforced to maintain normative compliance. Computers and are permitted selectively, often for vocational purposes with mandatory filtering software, though adoption lags behind the general : 61% of Haredi households own a computer compared to 88% of other Jewish , and usage remains limited even where available. Hasidic subgroups, such as or , tend to enforce stricter prohibitions than Lithuanian (Litvish) Haredim, who may tolerate filtered devices in professional settings like accounting or publishing. Recent extensions include a June 2023 ban by 25 prominent rabbis on chatbots, citing risks to ethical and religious integrity. Despite these measures, economic necessities drive incremental adaptations, with filtered online platforms emerging for and under rabbinic supervision.

External Media Portrayals and Biases

External media coverage of Haredi Judaism frequently emphasizes controversies such as exemptions, welfare dependency, gender segregation, and resistance to , portraying the community as insular and burdensome to broader society. During the in 2020, Israeli and international outlets highlighted Haredi gatherings and quarantine violations in communities like , often generalizing non-compliance across the entire population despite evidence that most Haredi neighborhoods adhered to protocols after initial rabbinic guidance adjusted. This selective focus amplified perceptions of , with reports framing Haredi leaders' initial hesitancy—rooted in historical of state mandates—as reckless defiance rather than contextual caution informed by past experiences like secular assimilation pressures. Such portrayals reflect a systemic secular in , which prioritizes narratives of Haredi "otherness" over balanced accounts of internal or demographic resilience. A 2009 survey found that 69% of secular and 83% of Haredim viewed media coverage as exacerbating tensions between the groups, with secular respondents perceiving inherent negativity in reporting. Outlets like have faced accusations of in pieces on Hasidic , such as a 2022 investigation into yeshiva curricula that critics argued exaggerated underfunding of secular subjects while ignoring community-funded initiatives and high literacy rates, revealing more about reporters' assumptions of religious inferiority than verifiable systemic failure. Similarly, Israeli radio depicts Haredim as out-of-touch isolates, reinforcing stereotypes without exploring causal factors like deliberate cultural preservation against assimilation, which empirical data shows sustains Jewish continuity amid declining observance elsewhere. Hollywood representations compound these biases, with a 2024 Center study revealing that up to one-third of Orthodox characters are played by ex-Orthodox actors, often portraying Haredi life through lenses of repression or escape, as in documentaries like One of Us (2017), which critics argue fosters by privileging defector narratives over representative voices. This pattern aligns with broader media tendencies to underreport Haredi contributions, such as low crime rates in insular neighborhoods or robust welfare networks reducing state reliance in crises, while overemphasizing fiscal drains—estimated at 10-15% of Israel's welfare budget for Haredim, though offset by their 7-8% stabilizing demographics. Mainstream sources, often aligned with progressive secularism, thus exhibit a causal blind spot: viewing Haredi insularity not as adaptive realism against historical pogroms and Holocaust-era losses but as pathological avoidance, leading to unbalanced coverage that erodes public sympathy without proportionate scrutiny of secular societal issues like rising intermarriage rates exceeding 50% among non-Orthodox .

Controversies and Internal Challenges

Enforcement of Norms and Shunning

In Haredi communities, adherence to religious norms is maintained primarily through informal social controls rather than frequent recourse to formal rabbinic sanctions. These include psychological pressures such as , ridicule, and from communal institutions like synagogues, mikvehs, and yeshivas, which target behaviors deemed deviant, including , , , or unauthorized contact with the opposite sex. Expulsion from schools or temporary relocation of adolescents by parents serves as a physical sanction for severe infractions, while economic measures like withholding community loans or boycotting businesses reinforce . Traditional Jewish mechanisms of niddui—a temporary ban lasting seven to thirty days, during which others avoid association—and herem, a fuller excluding one from communal life, derive from Talmudic law but are invoked sparingly in modern Haredi contexts, favoring subtler peer and familial enforcement to avoid overt division. Rabbinic figures and parents monitor behavior closely, issuing warnings against excesses like overindulgence during or secular media exposure, with yeshivas extending study hours from early morning to late evening to minimize free time for deviance. Shunning intensifies against those perceived as informers or "mosers" who involve secular authorities in internal matters, drawing on ' prohibitions against such actions; public posters (pashkevilim) denounce them, as seen in 2020 when Brooklyn journalist Jacob Kornbluh was labeled a moser for reporting violations of restrictions, and Yakov Horowitz faced similar backlash for criticizing secret prayer gatherings. In a 2013 Brooklyn case, a Hasidic woman testifying against convicted abuser Nechemya Weberman endured public shaming as a moser during services, compelling her departure. Individuals deviating through secular pursuits, such as enlisting in the Israeli Defense Forces, face stigma as spiritual failures, with barriers to and community reintegration; Haredi soldiers report a "social chasm" upon return, though 2023-2024 surveys noted a 14% drop in negative views amid wartime needs. Secondary affects relatives, as in a 2017 family court case where a Haredi man's nine-year-old daughter was ostracized for her mother's driving, non-kosher feeding, and immodest dress, prompting legal intervention to mitigate isolation. Marriage prospects suffer from markers of nonconformity, such as part-time secular work or lapses (e.g., non-standard shirts), branding one "second class" and limiting matches within the insular network. These controls, bolstered by strict separation and cultural isolation tactics like rural camps, prioritize preserving over individual , with peer influence and reverence for rebbes amplifying enforcement.

Sexual Abuse Cases and Community Responses

Numerous cases of child sexual abuse have been documented within Haredi communities, often involving rabbis or authority figures in yeshivas and schools. In Israel, approximately one in five men and boys reports experiencing sexual abuse during childhood, with 63% of children receiving treatment for such abuse belonging to the Haredi sector, according to data from treatment centers analyzed in 2025. Under-reporting remains prevalent due to communal norms prioritizing internal resolution over secular authorities, a practice rooted in the prohibition of mesirah (informing non-Jewish courts about fellow Jews). Studies of former Haredi individuals indicate higher lifetime rates of sexual trauma compared to the general Jewish population, attributed partly to insularity limiting external oversight. Notable convictions include Rabbi Todros Grynhaus, a prominent Haredi figure in the UK, sentenced in 2015 for seven counts of sexually assaulting two teenage girls over several years. In , Malka Leifer, former principal of an ultra-Orthodox girls' school affiliated with the Adass Israel community, was convicted in 2023 on 18 charges of , including , and received a 15-year sentence after years of evasion allegedly facilitated by community leaders. In the US, a Hasidic man in was convicted in December 2012 of sexually abusing a boy, marking a rare successful prosecution amid community resistance to testimony. Rabbi Eliezer Berland, leader of the Shuvu Bonim Hasidic sect, was convicted in in 2021 of against followers. Haredi responses traditionally involve rabbinical courts (batei din) handling allegations privately to avoid public scandal and preserve communal cohesion, often resulting in relocation of accused individuals rather than expulsion or police referral. Critics, including victim advocates, argue this approach enables , as seen in cases where abusers continued roles in other communities post-allegation. Victims reporting to authorities have faced , including (cherem) and , reinforcing silence. Recent developments show incremental shifts, influenced by external pressures like #MeToo and rising reports to crisis lines; in , Haredi-specific organizations such as Zaakah have emerged to support victims and encourage professional intervention since the , with call volumes surging post-2020. Activist groups like Jewish Community Watch document over 65 suspected or convicted abusers in Orthodox circles, pushing for transparency. In some instances, rabbinic bans against figures like author in 2021 followed public allegations, signaling rare communal accountability. However, systemic barriers persist, with data indicating a sharp rise in treated cases in Haredi areas from 2013 onward, yet prosecutions lag due to witness intimidation.

Divorce Coercion and Family Pressures

In Jewish law (halakha), a religious divorce requires the husband to voluntarily deliver a get (bill of divorce) to his wife; without it, she remains an agunah ("chained woman"), unable to remarry under Orthodox standards while civilly divorced. This asymmetry has led to get refusal in Haredi communities, where approximately 20% of women seeking divorce in Israel face such delays or denials, exacerbating family breakdowns amid cultural emphasis on marital permanence. A 2025 survey of Orthodox Jewish divorcees found at least 30% encountered get refusal, with one-third reporting pressure to forgo financial claims for the document. Haredi divorce rates remain low—around 5% compared to 13-45% in secular Israeli groups—reflecting communal stigma against dissolution, but refusals prolong suffering in cases of abuse or incompatibility. Batei din (rabbinical courts) in Haredi circles employ enforcement tactics against recalcitrant husbands, including social ostracism, economic sanctions like license revocations, and in extreme historical cases, physical deemed permissible under halakha if not rendering the get invalid. In Israel, courts have jailed men for get refusal, with over 99% of cases resolved in 2024, though persistent holdouts fuel controversy. A notorious example is the New York "divorce coercion gang" of Haredi men in the 1990s-2010s, convicted for kidnapping and assaulting get-refusers on rabbinic orders, highlighting how community desperation can veer into criminality. These methods, while aimed at freeing agunot, raise ethical concerns over and potential invalidation of coerced getim. Family pressures compound these dynamics, with arranged teenage marriages, limited female workforce participation, and dependence on communal welfare discouraging separation. In high-conflict Haredi divorces, extended kin and rabbis often intervene to preserve unity, prioritizing child-rearing norms over individual , which can trap women in coercive control or . Initiatives like halachic prenups, recently endorsed by some Haredi rabbis, seek to preempt refusals via pre-agreed , though adoption lags due to fears of undermining marital sanctity. Despite criticisms, low baseline rates suggest these pressures foster demographic resilience, with Haredi families averaging higher amid external assimilation threats.

Political Maneuvering Criticisms

Haredi political parties in , such as (UTJ) and , have faced criticism for leveraging their status in coalitions to secure exemptions from mandatory for their constituents. These parties, which held nearly one-third of seats in Benjamin Netanyahu's 2022 coalition, have repeatedly threatened to withdraw support or collapse governments unless legislation formalizes draft deferrals for full-time students, a practice rooted in a 1948 agreement but expanded amid Haredi population growth. In July 2025, quit coalition positions in protest over increased draft enforcement and failure to pass exemption laws, highlighting tactics perceived as prioritizing communal interests over amid ongoing wars. Critics, including secular and national-religious , argue this maneuvering undermines IDF readiness and equality under the law, as Haredi men—numbering tens of thousands eligible—avoid service while others bear the burden, especially post-October 7, 2023. Another focal point of criticism is the extraction of disproportionate state funding for and kollels, often tied to political threats. In March 2025, UTJ demanded immediate approval of $360 million in yeshiva funds to support the 2025 budget passage, a move seen as coercive given Haredi low participation rates around 50% for men. receive substantial allocations—e.g., one institution obtained NIS 18 million in 2022 and NIS 25 million in 2023—totaling billions annually, which critics claim incentivizes prolonged enrollment to evade both drafts and , straining public finances. Opponents contend this fiscal leverage, enabled by Haredi parties' veto power in fragmented Knessets, fosters dependency and economic drag, with Haredi households comprising a growing share of welfare recipients despite taxpayer funding for religious institutions. Accusations of self-serving rigidity extend to broader coalition dynamics, where Haredi factions are faulted for blocking reforms in , observance, and conversion standards to preserve insularity, even at the cost of national unity. Instances of alleged corruption, such as leader Aryeh Deri's past and subsequent political rehabilitation, fuel claims that maneuvering prioritizes rabbinic loyalty over ethical governance. While Haredi advocates frame these actions as defending values against secular erosion, detractors from outlets like and Times of Israel portray them as ideological obstructionism, exacerbating societal fractures in a state where Haredim project to reach 25% of the population by 2040.

Defenses, Resilience, and Contributions

Preservation of Jewish Continuity Amid Assimilation

![Hasidic family in Borough Park, Brooklyn][float-right] Haredi communities maintain Jewish continuity by fostering environments that minimize exposure to secular influences, emphasizing Torah study, ritual observance, and endogamous marriages. This approach counters assimilation pressures evident in other Jewish denominations, where intermarriage rates exceed 50% among non-Orthodox groups. Strict gender segregation, community-enforced norms, and Yiddish or Hebrew-centric education systems from early childhood reinforce insularity, preserving traditional practices across generations. Empirical data underscore this resilience: Haredi total fertility rates stand at 6-7 children per woman globally, compared to 1.4-1.9 for non-Haredi , driving annual of 3.5-4%. In , recent has dipped to 6.1 but remains far above the national Jewish average of 3.0, contributing to Haredim comprising 13.5% of the in 2023 and projected to reach 16% by 2030. In the United States, the second-largest Haredi doubles every 20 years through similar dynamics. Retention rates further exemplify preservation, with Haredi offspring adhering to the lifestyle at rates exceeding those in other Orthodox subgroups, enabling net growth despite limited defections. While disaffiliation occurs—estimated at under 10% in some studies—the community's high birth rates and low intermarriage sustain demographic vitality, contrasting with broader Jewish trends where nearly 25% of those raised Jewish in America disaffiliate entirely. This success stems from causal factors like full-time education for males and parallel religious schooling for females, which prioritize scriptural immersion over vocational training until adulthood. Projections indicate Haredim could constitute over 30% of Israel's Jewish population by 2050, positioning the sector as a primary vector for Jewish demographic continuity amid global assimilation. Such outcomes validate the efficacy of Haredi strategies in resisting cultural dilution, though they occur alongside internal adaptations to economic necessities.

Empirical Success in Demographic Vitality

Haredi Judaism exhibits notable demographic vitality through elevated fertility rates and rapid population expansion, distinguishing it from broader Jewish and secular trends. The total fertility rate (TFR) among Haredi women averages 6-7 children per woman globally, far exceeding the replacement level of 2.1 and contributing to sustained growth amid declining birth rates in developed societies. In , the Haredi TFR stood at 6.1 children per woman in recent data, a decline from prior peaks of 7.5 but remaining substantially higher than the national Jewish average of approximately 3.0. This high drives exceptional rates of 3.5-4.0% annually for Haredim worldwide, compared to 1.4% for general Jewish populations in the West. In , the Haredi population reached about 1.28 million in 2022, comprising 13.3% of the total populace, with projections indicating it will constitute 16% by the decade's end due to these dynamics. Globally, Haredim number around 2.1 million, representing 14% of world Jewry, a share expected to increase to 23% by 2040. In the United States, Haredi fertility mirrors this pattern at approximately 6.6 children per woman, supported by norms of early and large families, fostering community expansion in enclaves like those in New York. These rates contrast sharply with secular Jewish TFRs of about 2.5 in and lower elsewhere, enabling Haredim to counteract assimilation pressures and maintain intergenerational continuity. Such vitality underscores the empirical efficacy of Haredi adherence to traditional family structures in preserving population size against global fertility declines.

Scholarly and Ethical Counterarguments to Critiques

Scholars defending Haredi educational practices argue that curricula, emphasizing intensive Talmudic study, cultivate advanced analytical and reasoning skills from an early age, with 80-90% of students in certain institutions engaging in semi-independent textual analysis by , fostering evidence-based argumentation akin to secular goals. Empirical data from Haredi enclaves like , indicate employment rates of approximately 70%—near the state average of 75%—and median household incomes of $50,613, close to New York's $54,262, despite minimal secular coursework, suggesting functional socioeconomic adaptation without broad academic deficits. These outcomes counter claims of systemic underpreparation by highlighting comparable proficiency metrics to underperforming public schools in adjacent districts, where students showed 0-2.1% proficiency in core subjects from 2015-2017. Haredi isolation from secular influences is presented by scholars as a deliberate strategy to safeguard authentic Jewish tradition against assimilationist pressures, rooted in historical responses to Enlightenment-era dilutions of observance, resulting in unprecedented institutional revival post-Holocaust with enrollments at historic highs and global Haredi populations in the hundreds of thousands sustained by elevated rates. This insularity yields high social cohesion and near-absent in impoverished Haredi areas, outcomes attributed to communal moral frameworks rather than state intervention, challenging narratives of dysfunction by demonstrating resilience and self-sufficiency that reduce taxpayer burdens, such as $2.75 billion annually in avoided public schooling costs in New York. Ethically, Haredi prioritization of aligns with classical Jewish sources viewing it as the paramount for preserving national continuity, ethically justifying exemptions from secular obligations like as a collective spiritual contribution over individualistic duties. Concepts like da'at Torah—deferential guidance from rabbinic authorities—are defended not as authoritarian innovations but as extensions of Mishnaic principles encompassing all life domains, providing ethical coherence amid modernity's . In response to critiques of internal norm enforcement, proponents argue that community autonomy enables tailored ethical resolutions emphasizing (teshuvah) and rehabilitation, potentially yielding lower through social pressures absent in secular punitive systems, though empirical verification remains limited. These counterarguments underscore Haredi society's moral vitality derived from unwavering adherence to divine commandments, positing that secular critiques often overlook causal links between religious and empirical successes in demographic persistence and ethical communal stability, privileging instead biased preferences for modernization.

Recent Developments

Post-2023 Shifts: , Draft, and Divisions

The October 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel, which killed approximately 1,200 people and led to over 900 Israeli soldier deaths in the ensuing Gaza war by October 2025, intensified scrutiny on Haredi military exemptions. While the broader Israeli society mobilized rapidly— with the (IDF) calling up 360,000 reservists in the first days— Haredi communities largely maintained their historical deferrals for study, contributing to heightened resentment among non-Haredi who viewed the exemptions as unfair burden-sharing during national crisis. Despite this, polls indicated growing Haredi support for military service post-attack, with some volunteering, though overall enlistment remained minimal at around 2,700 Haredim joining the IDF in the year following October 7. Israel's ruled unanimously on June 25, 2024, that there was no legal basis for exempting Haredi men from compulsory , voiding prior arrangements and mandating the IDF to draft them alongside other citizens. This decision, building on earlier rulings like the 2017 extension's expiration in July 2023, prompted the IDF to issue draft orders to over 54,000 Haredi students by September 2025, though actual enlistment rates stayed low due to resistance. Haredi leaders argued that full-time provides spiritual protection equivalent to , a position contested by secular and national-religious citing empirical security needs amid ongoing conflict. Legislative efforts to reinstate exemptions failed, leading to political turmoil, including the party's withdrawal from coalition positions on October 23, 2025, over disputes. These developments exacerbated divisions within Haredi society and Israeli polity. Internally, while rabbinic authorities overwhelmingly opposed mass enlistment— viewing it as a threat to religious observance— a minority of Haredim, including some from less insular subgroups, expressed willingness to serve, highlighting emerging fissures over balancing spiritual ideals with national defense. Externally, protests against grew, with Haredi demonstrations clashing against IDF enforcement, and surveys showing widening gaps between Haredim and other religious Jews on war support and obligations. By mid-2025, the issue threatened coalition stability under Netanyahu, as Haredi parties prioritized exemptions, underscoring causal tensions between demographic growth— Haredim comprising 13% of Israel's — and equitable civic contributions in a security-dependent state. In , where the majority of Haredim reside, approximately 13.3% of individuals aged 20-64 raised in ultra-Orthodox communities have left the sector, with leaving rates varying by subgroup: 5.4% among Hasidim, 8.6% among Lithuanian Haredim, and 26.4% among . Younger cohorts show higher disaffiliation, with 12.5% of those born between 1997 and 2001 no longer identifying as Haredi—the highest rate in recent decades—compared to 11.3% for the 1992-1996 cohort and lower figures for older groups, indicating a gradual upward trend since the 1970s. Projections estimate around 420,000 leavers from the Haredi sector between 2017 and 2067, driven by a tenfold disparity between leaving and joining rates among youth. Among those who leave, full —defined as complete abandonment of religious observance—is limited, with only about 18% becoming fully secular; roughly two-thirds (66%) retain some , identifying as religious (46%) or traditional-religious (20%), while another 16% describe themselves as traditional but less observant. Similarly, 64% of leavers continue to self-identify as religious or very religious post-disaffiliation. Women exhibit slightly lower leaving rates than men, though older women may disaffiliate later in life. These patterns suggest that while community exit is rising, ideological commitment to often persists, potentially mitigating broader erosion of faith. In the United States, where Haredim constitute about 12% of the Jewish , specific attrition data is scarcer, but overall Orthodox retention has improved to around 67% in recent decades, with Haredi subgroups likely experiencing even higher rates due to greater insularity and cultural separation from secular influences. Low disaffiliation, combined with rates exceeding seven children per woman, sustains rapid demographic expansion, outpacing losses even if modest OTD numbers exist. Overall, Haredi retention remains robust relative to other Jewish denominations, supported by high birth rates and communal pressures, though increasing exposure to external , media, and economic necessities correlates with rising exits in ; absolute numbers of leavers grow alongside the sector's expansion from 1.2 million Haredim globally in 2022, projected to double by mid-century. Despite this, the proportion of full apostates stays low, preserving core adherence amid selective adaptations.

Ideological Evolutions and Adaptations

Haredi Judaism originated in the as a deliberate ideological bulwark against the (Jewish Enlightenment), political , and emerging movements, which threatened traditional halakhic observance by promoting and . Leaders like the Chatam Sofer articulated a stance of fierce opposition to innovations, encapsulated in the maxim "חדש אסור מן התורה" (new is forbidden by ), prioritizing isolation from influences and unwavering fidelity to rabbinic authority over worldly progress. This fundamentalist posture, rooted in medieval precedents but intensified by modern disruptions, positioned Haredim as "tremblers" before divine law, fostering communal structures like yeshivas that emphasized Talmudic study as the pinnacle of Jewish existence. Following , which decimated European Haredi centers, ideological reconstruction occurred primarily in and the through rebuilt networks of rabbinic seminaries and Hasidic dynasties, transforming a near-extinct group into a demographically robust movement by the late 20th century. Core tenets of da'at Torah—extending rabbinic guidance to secular affairs—and rejection of autonomous individual reasoning persisted, but practical necessities prompted adaptations, such as the establishment of kollels for married scholars, which institutionalized lifelong as a societal norm rather than elite pursuit. In , initial non-recognition of the gave way to pragmatic political engagement via , founded in 1912 to counter Zionist secularism without endorsing it, allowing Haredim to negotiate exemptions from and state funding for religious institutions while upholding ideological . Over decades, Haredi thought has exhibited selective adaptations to socioeconomic pressures without diluting fundamentalist commitments; for instance, amid rising living costs in during the 2000s, some communities introduced limited vocational training for men alongside study, reflecting rabbinic approvals for partial workforce integration to sustain family welfare. Responses to technology evolved from outright bans—such as internet restrictions decreed by councils like Badatz in the —to filtered usage endorsed by figures like in the 2010s, justified as tools for religious dissemination rather than leisure. These shifts underscore a pattern of ideological resilience: core aversion to endures, with adaptations framed as defenses against assimilation, as evidenced by intensified gender segregation and cultural insulation in response to global media influences.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.