Hubbry Logo
Har DayalHar DayalMain
Open search
Har Dayal
Community hub
Har Dayal
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Har Dayal
Har Dayal
Har Dayal
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Lala Rudra Dayal Mathur (Punjabi: ਲਾਲਾ ਹਰਦਿਆਲ; 14 October 1884 – 4 March 1939) was an Indian nationalist revolutionary and freedom fighter.[1] He was a polymath who turned down a career in the Indian Civil Service. His simple living and intellectual acumen inspired many expatriate Indians living in Canada and the U.S. in their campaign against British rule in India during the First World War.

Key Information

Biography

[edit]

Har Dayal Mathur was born in a Hindu Mathur Kayastha family on 14 October 1884 in Delhi.[2] He studied at the Cambridge Mission School and received his bachelor's degree in Sanskrit from St. Stephen's College, Delhi and his master's degree also in Sanskrit from Punjab University. In 1905, he received two scholarships of Oxford University for his higher studies in Sanskrit: Boden Scholarship, 1907 and Casberd Exhibitioner, an award from St John's College, where he was studying.[3]

Part of a series on
Anarchism
"Circle-A" anarchy symbol
Schools of thought
Methodology
  • Theory and practice
  • Anarchy
  • Anarchist Black Cross
  • Anarchist criminology
  • Anationalism
  • Anti-authoritarianism
  • Anti-capitalism
  • Anti-militarism
  • Affinity group
  • Autonomous social center
  • Black bloc
  • Classless society
  • Class struggle
  • Consensus decision-making
  • Conscientious objector
  • Critique of work
  • Decentralization
  • Deep ecology
  • Direct action
  • Free love
  • Freethought
  • Galleanism
  • Horizontalidad
  • Individualism
  • Law
  • Mutual aid
  • Participatory politics
  • Permanent autonomous zone
  • Prefigurative politics
  • Proletarian internationalism
  • Propaganda of the deed
  • Refusal of work
  • Revolution
  • Rewilding
  • Sabotage
  • Security culture
  • Self-ownership
  • Social ecology
  • Sociocracy
  • Somatherapy
  • Spontaneous order
  • Squatting
  • Temporary autonomous zone
  • Union of egoists
  • Voluntary association
  • Workerism
  • Workers' council
    		•
    People
    Issues
    History
    Culture
    Economics
    By region
    Africa
    Asia
    Europe
    North America
    Oceania
    South America
    Lists
    Related topics

    He moved to the United States in 1911, where he became involved in industrial unionism. He had also served as secretary of the San Francisco branch of the Industrial Workers of the World alongside Fritz Wolffheim, (later a National Bolshevik after he had left IWW and joined the Communist Workers' Party of Germany). In a statement outlining the principles of the Fraternity of the Red Flag, he said they proposed "the establishment of Communism, and the abolition of private property in land and capital through an industrial organization and the general strike, ultimate abolition of the coercive organization of government". A little over a year later, this group was given 6 acres (24,000 m2) of land and a house in Oakland, where he founded the Bakunin Institute of California, which he described as "the first monastery of anarchism".[4]

    In California, he soon developed contacts with Punjabi Sikh farmers in Stockton. Punjabis, a great majority of whom were Sikhs, had started emigrating to the West Coast around the turn of the century. Having experienced hostility by the Canadians in Vancouver, they had already become disaffected with the British. Hardayal tapped into this sentiment of these energetic Sikhs and other Punjabis. Having developed an Indian nationalist perspective, he encouraged young Indians to gain scientific and sociological education.[5][6]

    In April 1914, he was arrested by the United States government for spreading anarchist literature and fled to Berlin, Germany. In Berlin he became instrumental to the formation of the Berlin Committee (later: Indian Independence Committee) and cooperated with the German Intelligence Bureau for the East.[7]

    He died in Philadelphia on 4 March 1939. In the evening of his death, he delivered a lecture as usual where he had said: "I am in peace with all". But a very close friend of Lala Hardayal and the founder member of Bharat Mata Society (established in 1907), Lala Hanumant Sahai, did not accept the death as natural, he suspected it as poisoning.[8]

    In 1987, the India Department of Posts issued a commemorative stamp in his honor, within the series of "India's Struggle for Freedom".[9][10]

    Selected works

    [edit]

    Some of his books with available references are listed below:[11]

    1. Our Educational Problem: Collection of Lalaji's articles. It was published in Punjabi, from Lahore, as a 1922 book with introduction by Lala Lajpat Rai
    2. Thoughts on Education: Lalaji wrote many articles in Punjabi (published from Lahore) and Modern Review (published from Calcutta); most of them were against the Education Policy of British Government in India. Mr Hem Chand Kaushik gave to the author this book which he published in July 1969.
    3. Social Conquest of Hindu Race: A booklet containing 21 pages, proscribed by British Raj and kept in National Archives of India under Acc.No.74. (Ref:Patriotic s Banned by the Raj)
    4. Writings of Lala Har Dayal: This book was published in 1920 by Swaraj Publishing House, Varanasi, as mentioned in the book by Vishwa Nath Prasad Verma Adhunik Bhartiya Rajneetik Chintan on page 389.
    5. Dayal, Har (1920). Forty-four months in Germany and Turkey, February 1915 to October 1918, a record of personal impressions. London, King.: This book was published in 1920 by P.S. King and Sons in London when Lalaji was living in Sweden. Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthy quoted many references from this book in his Kranti Ka Udghosh.
    6. Lala Har Dayal Ji Ke Swadhin Vichar: This book was translated into Hindi by Sri Narayan Prasad Arora and was published in Raghunandan Press, Kanpur by Pt. Ganga Narayan Shukla in 1922. It can be seen in Seth Soorajmull Jalan Library, Calcutta.
    7. Amrit me Vish: This was the Hindi Translation of above book 'Thoughts on Education'. It was published by Lajpat Rai Prithviraj Sahni from Lohari Gate, Lahore in the year 1922. In the National Library, Calcutta under catalogue no 181.Rc.92.33.
    8. Hints for Self Culture: This famous book of Lala Har Dayal was published by Hy.S.L.Polak and Co. London (U.K) in 1934. Jaico Publishing House published it in 1977 from Bombay by obtaining copyright from its original publisher in 1961. Its Hindi Translation has also been published from Kitab Ghar, Delhi (India) in 1997 under the title 'Vyaktitva Vikas-Sangharsh aur Safalata'.
    9. Glimpses of World Religions': It was the presentation of several religions by Lala Har Dayal from so many angles of history, ethics, theology, and religious philosophy. It reflects the individuality of every religion in a rational way of thinking. This book was also published by Jaico Publishing House India from Bombay.
    10. Bodhisattva Doctrines: Lala Lajpat Rai, who was a mentor of Har Dayal, had suggested him to write an authentic book based on the principles of Gautam Buddha. In 1927 when Har Dayal was not given permission by the British Government to return to India, he decided to remain in London. He wrote this book and presented it to the university as a thesis. The book was approved for Ph.D. and a Doctorate was awarded to him in 1932. It was published from London in the year 1932. Motilal Banarsidass Publishers of India re-published this book in 1970 as The Bodhisattva Doctrines in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature.

    The Bodhisattva Doctrines in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature

    [edit]

    This 392-page work of Lala Hardayal consists of 7 chapters which deal with the Bodhisattva doctrine as expounded in the principal Buddhist Sanskrit Literature.

    • In Chapter I the nature of the Bodhisattva doctrine is described, with particular emphasis upon the distinct characteristics of arhat, Bodhisattva, and Sravaka.
    • Chapter II recounts the different factors which contributed to the rise and growth of the Bodhisattva doctrine including the influences of Persian religio-cult, Greek art, and Christian ethics.
    • In Chapter III the production of the thought of Enlightenment for the welfare and liberation of all creatures is expounded.
    • Chapters IV describes thirty-seven practices and principles conducive to the attainment of Enlightenment.
    • In Chapter V ten perfections that lead to welfare, rebirth, serenity, spiritual cultivation, and supreme knowledge are explained.
    • Chapter VI defines different stages of spiritual progress in the aspirant's long journey to the goal of final emancipation.
    • The last Chapter VII relates the events of the Gautama Buddha's past lives as Bodhisattva.

    This book contains comprehensive notes and references besides a general index appended at the end. This book has been written in a particularly lucid style which exhibits scholarly acumen and the mastery of Lala Hardayal in literary art. It proved influential with Edward Conze, a German Marxist refugee from Nazi Germany who made Har Dayal 's acquaintance in London in the 1930s.[12]

    Appreciations

    [edit]

    According to Swami Rama Tirtha, Lala Har Dayal was the greatest Hindu who ever came to America, a great sage and saint, whose life mirrored the highest spirituality as his soul reflected the love of the 'Universal Spirit' whom he tried to realize.[13]

    In another appreciation Prof. Dharmavira has sketched the picture of Lala Har Dayal which is being quoted here in verbatim:

    Har Dayal dedicated his whole life to the sacred cause of the motherland. Surely from such a person alone could one ask: "Good Master, what shall I do to inherit eternal life?" Let us drink deep at this spring and wax glad and strong and brave in every nerve and fibre of our being. He was one of the race of those who wrote the New Era in blood. His course was laborious, truthful, simple, independent, noble; and all these in an eminent degree. His experience of the inward and the outward battle was not inconsiderable and it was not confined to his early manhood, but was spread over his whole life. Lala Har Dayal had the Janak and Dadhichi touch and his life demonstrated that he had what it takes.

    — Prof. Dharmavira[14] (9 July 1969)

    References

    [edit]

    Further reading

    [edit]
    [edit]
    Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

    Har Dayal

    View on Grokipedia
    from Grokipedia
    Lala Har Dayal (1884–1939) was an Indian anticolonial activist, anarchist, and Sanskrit scholar who founded the Ghadar Party in the United States to organize rebellion against British rule in India. Born in Delhi to a family of modest means, his father served as a reader in a government court, Har Dayal excelled academically, earning a master's from Punjab University and studying at St John's College, Oxford, from 1905 to 1907, though he departed without a degree due to growing disillusionment with British imperialism. Influenced by anarchist ideas encountered in London and California, he lectured at Stanford University around 1910 before launching the Ghadar weekly newspaper and party in San Francisco in 1913, recruiting Indian expatriates—primarily Punjabis—for a planned uprising timed with World War I. His efforts emphasized mass mobilization over individual terrorism, but U.S. authorities arrested him in 1914 on charges related to anarchist advocacy; released on bail, he fled to Switzerland and later collaborated with German-backed Indian independence committees in Berlin. After the war, Har Dayal distanced himself from revolutionary violence, pursuing scholarship with a PhD in Sanskrit from the University of London in 1930 and authoring works like Hints for Self-Culture (1934), which promoted rationalism, self-reliance, and ethical living without reliance on supernatural beliefs. He died in Philadelphia on 4 March 1939, having lectured for ethical societies on pacifism and humanism.

    Early Life and Education

    Birth and Family Background

    Har Dayal, born Har Dayal Mathur on October 14, 1884, in , came from a Punjabi Hindu family of the Mathur subcaste. His father, Gauri Dayal Mathur, worked as a reader in the district court, a clerical position involving legal document preparation and court assistance. His mother, Bholi Rani, managed the household for their seven children, of whom Har Dayal was the sixth. The family's modest middle-class status emphasized education and public service, reflecting the tradition of administrative roles under British colonial governance.

    Academic Pursuits in India

    Har Dayal exhibited prodigious intellectual talent during his formative years, beginning his at the Cambridge Mission School in , where he distinguished himself through rigorous study and eidetic memory. He advanced to St. Stephen's College in for his undergraduate studies, earning a while shattering institutional academic records that contemporaries deemed unbreakable. Subsequently, Har Dayal enrolled at Government College in , affiliated with Punjab University, to pursue postgraduate work. There, he completed a degree in English literature in 1903, securing the first position in his examinations and further cementing his reputation for unparalleled scholastic achievement. His mastery extended to additional pursuits, including an M.A. in history from the same institution, reflecting a broad engagement with disciplines under colonial-era curricula. These accomplishments culminated in prestigious recognition from British Indian authorities, who awarded him scholarships in 1905 for advanced study abroad, initially earmarked for and historical research at Oxford University. Har Dayal's Indian academic trajectory thus positioned him as a primed for global intellectual influence, though his later renunciation of imperial patronage marked a pivotal shift.

    Scholarship and Studies at Oxford

    Following the completion of his in Sanskrit at Punjab University, Har Dayal received an Indian Government scholarship that funded his advanced studies at Oxford University. He arrived in in 1905 and matriculated at St John's College that year. Har Dayal's academic focus at centered on , aligning with his prior expertise and the scholarship's emphasis on Oriental languages and . His studies, spanning 1905 to 1907, demonstrated scholarly promise, as evidenced by his attainment of the Boden Scholarship in 1907—a prestigious university-wide award designated for excellence in and comparative —and the Casberd , a £30 college prize recognizing academic merit. These honors underscored his proficiency in linguistic and textual analysis within the Sanskrit tradition.

    Ideological Formation and Anti-Colonial Awakening

    Exposure to Anarchism and Socialism

    During his studies at St. John's College, Oxford, from 1905 to 1907, Lala Har Dayal encountered radical political thought through London's Indian expatriate circles, particularly India House, a hub for anti-colonial activists challenging British rule. This environment exposed him to diverse ideologies, including strains of socialism and emerging anarchist principles that critiqued state authority and imperialism. Har Dayal's direct engagement with anarchism intensified around 1907, when he began exploring its tenets via British radicals such as Guy Aldred, editor of The Indian Sociologist, a publication advocating sedition against the Raj. Influenced by European thinkers like Mikhail Bakunin, whose emphasis on revolutionary action against oppressive structures resonated with Har Dayal's growing disillusionment with colonial governance, he rejected hierarchical systems in favor of decentralized, voluntary associations. His readings and correspondences also acquainted him with Peter Kropotkin's mutual aid concepts, blending socialist economic critiques—drawing from Karl Marx's analysis of capitalism—with anarchism's anti-statism. This ideological shift culminated in Har Dayal's resignation from his in 1907 on principled grounds, protesting British imperialism and signaling his commitment to radical alternatives over reformist paths. By articulating anarchist sympathies in contributions to radical periodicals, he positioned himself against both capitalist exploitation and imperial control, laying the groundwork for his later transnational .

    Resignation from Oxford and Early Activism

    In 1905, Har Dayal arrived at , on a state scholarship valued at £200 annually for three years, intended to support promising Indian students in higher studies, particularly in and modern history. During his time there, he engaged with Indian nationalist circles, regularly visiting in —a hub for anti-colonial activists—and corresponding with Shyamaji Krishnavarma, an Indian revolutionary and proponent of (self-rule). These interactions deepened his opposition to British imperialism, leading him to view his scholarship as incompatible with his growing commitment to Indian independence. In 1907, shortly after receiving the Boden Scholarship for studies, Har Dayal resigned both awards on ideological grounds, publicly rejecting the patronage of the British government that funded them, as he deemed it a form of complicity in colonial subjugation. Har Dayal returned to in early 1908, settling initially in , where he embraced a spartan to symbolize detachment from material comforts associated with British-supported elites. His early focused on intellectual agitation: he contributed sharp critiques of British rule to leading newspapers, emphasizing the need for Indians to reject imperial authority and foster through and cultural revival. These writings aimed to stir political and promote indigenous institutions as alternatives to colonial , though they drew official scrutiny and limited immediate organizational impact. By August 1908, amid growing surveillance, Har Dayal left for Europe—first , then —where he networked with Egyptian and Irish nationalists, marking a shift toward transnational radicalism rather than sustained domestic organizing. This brief Indian phase underscored his transition from scholarship to active opposition, prioritizing moral consistency over academic completion.

    Revolutionary Period in America

    Arrival in the United States

    Har Dayal arrived in the United States in January 1911, having traveled from amid his growing anti-colonial activism and scholarly pursuits. Initially settling on the East Coast, he briefly visited before relocating westward. By June 1911, he reached , where he immersed himself in the intellectual milieu of the . Upon arrival in California, Dayal accepted an unsalaried lectureship at to teach and , a role that provided academic cover for his ideological explorations. This position, extended without formal compensation, allowed him to engage with university circles while observing the conditions of Indian immigrants, particularly Punjabi laborers facing discrimination and economic hardship on the West Coast. His move aligned with a deliberate intent to propagate anti-colonial ideas among expatriates, building on prior travels and writings that critiqued British imperialism. Dayal's U.S. entry occurred against a backdrop of restrictive policies targeting Asians, though his scholarly credentials facilitated initial acceptance; he navigated these as a student-visa holder rather than a labor migrant. In the Bay Area, he encountered vibrant anarchist and socialist networks, which resonated with his evolving rejection of in favor of internationalist revolution, though his immediate focus remained academic dissemination of Eastern thought. This phase marked his shift from European exile to American-based organizing, setting the stage for deeper involvement with disenfranchised Indian communities.

    Founding the Ghadar Movement

    In early 1913, Lala Har Dayal, then lecturing at Stanford University, established the Pacific Coast Hindustani Association in Oregon as a forum to unite Indian expatriates against British colonial rule. This organization, drawing from Punjabi immigrants who had faced racial violence and exclusion in North America—such as the 1907 Bellingham riots and Komagata Maru incident precursors—evolved into the core of the Ghadar Party, emphasizing armed revolt to secure India's independence. The Ghadar Party's foundational activities centered on and among the diaspora, particularly Sikh, Hindu, and Muslim laborers on the . Har Dayal, influenced by anarchist principles, advocated for a decentralized uprising targeting units, aiming to exploit opportunities like for mutiny. The party's headquarters were set up in San Francisco's Yugantar Ashram at 5 Wood Street, serving as a for revolutionary materials. A key milestone was the launch of the Ghadar newspaper on November 1, 1913, with Har Dayal as editor, distributed free in multiple languages including and to reach workers and incite rebellion. The publication explicitly stated its goal to "revolutionize the life of ," critiquing British economic exploitation and calling for immediate action without reliance on petitions or negotiations. Over 5,000 copies were initially printed weekly, smuggled to and shared among overseas communities. This founding effort rapidly mobilized around 8,000 supporters across and beyond, fostering a pan-Indian identity transcending and , though rooted in Punjabi grievances. Har Dayal's positioned the movement as a global anti-imperialist venture, inspired by Irish and Egyptian struggles, but grounded in the causal link between diaspora hardships and the need for direct, forceful .

    Leadership and Propaganda Efforts


    Har Dayal directed the Ghadar Party's propaganda wing as its general-secretary, focusing on ideological mobilization of Indian expatriates in . He established the Yugantar in as the party's operational base, from which revolutionary activities were coordinated.     On November 1, 1913, Har Dayal launched the Ghadar newspaper, serving as its editor and principal contributor of content that declared open against British colonial rule. Published weekly in (circulation of 2,500 copies), (2,200 copies), , and English, the paper featured editorials exhorting readers to arm themselves, emulate the 1857 Indian Rebellion, and prepare for among Indian troops. Copies were freely distributed to Indian communities, ships bound for , and diaspora networks in regions including , , and Malaya to amplify calls for a republican-socialist uprising. Har Dayal conducted extensive speaking tours along the U.S. West Coast, addressing Punjabi Sikh laborers in lumber mills, farms, and urban centers from California to Washington state. His speeches emphasized anarchist rejection of authority, recruitment for return voyages to India, and organization of soldier mutinies, exploiting Britain's distraction during World War I with a targeted revolt date of February 21, 1915. These efforts expanded party membership to thousands, establishing branches in Vancouver and Manila while amassing funds and arms for agitators.

    Arrest, Exile, and Immediate Aftermath

    On March 25, 1914, Har Dayal was arrested by U.S. immigration inspectors in , , and detained as an "undesirable alien" inadmissible due to his professed anarchist beliefs and affiliations. The charges centered on his public advocacy for anarchism, including speeches and writings promoting the overthrow of governments, as well as his role in the syndicalist (IWW) in Oakland. Authorities linked these activities to his leadership of the , which disseminated propaganda urging Indian soldiers in the to amid escalating tensions. Deportation proceedings were initiated under the U.S. Immigration Act of 1910, which empowered officials to exclude aliens associated with or threats to public safety, without requiring a criminal trial. Dayal posted $500 shortly after his arrest and was released pending hearings before a federal immigration board. However, rather than contest the case, he absconded in April 1914, forfeiting the bond and fleeing first to and later to , where he sought German support for anti-British plots. The U.S. government, acting partly on shared by British agents alarmed by Ghadar's recruitment of expatriate Indians, intensified surveillance but did not pursue amid wartime priorities. The episode exposed frictions in U.S. neutrality policies, as Dayal's was not formally requested by Britain despite diplomatic pressure, allowing his escape to evade direct consequences. No formal for occurred, but the prompted raids on Ghadar affiliates and foreshadowed broader crackdowns on Indian radicals under the probes.

    Flight to Europe and Return to the US

    Following his arrest on March 25, 1914, in on charges of anarchist agitation and being an undesirable alien—prompted by British diplomatic pressure—Har Dayal secured release on $1,000 bail backed by a plot of land as surety. Fearing further entanglement with investigations into the attempted of British Lord Hardinge, he jumped bail in early April and fled first to , then onward to , where he arrived by January 27, 1915. In , Har Dayal integrated into the Berlin India Committee (later formalized as the Indian Independence Committee), collaborating with figures like and , as well as German and Ottoman officials, to orchestrate subversion against British during . His efforts included propagandizing among Indian prisoners of war, planning expeditions such as the March 1916 deputation to Turkey for an assault on the , and leveraging German resources for arms shipments and recruitment. Tensions arose over German control and racial paternalism toward Indian allies, leading to his resignation from the committee on February 19, 1919. Postwar, Har Dayal navigated continued across amid Allied scrutiny, shifting from revolutionary coordination to scholarly pursuits in and while evading attempts. In 1938, he returned briefly to the for a tour, addressing audiences on , , and Eastern thought, including engagements with groups like the New York Society for Ethical Culture. While in , he obtained U.S. permission to visit on October 25, 1938, but died unexpectedly there on March 4, 1939, before departing.

    Scholarly Contributions

    Works on Buddhist Philosophy

    Har Dayal's principal scholarly contribution to Buddhist philosophy is The Bodhisattva Doctrine in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature, which formed the foundation of his Ph.D. dissertation at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, completed in 1930. The volume, published in 1932 by Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner & Co. in London, spans xix + 392 pages and consists of seven chapters dedicated to a systematic exposition of the Bodhisattva doctrine as found in core Mahayana Sanskrit texts, including the Mahāvastu, Lalitavistara, and various Prajñāpāramitā sūtras. The work traces the evolution of the ideal from its early formulations to its mature expression in literature, emphasizing ethical commitments like the vow to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all beings () and the stages of spiritual development (bhūmis). Dayal employed philological methods to reconstruct doctrinal developments, critiquing inconsistencies across texts while highlighting causal mechanisms in the Bodhisattva's path, such as the interplay of wisdom (prajñā) and (). Regarded as the first comprehensive English-language treatment of the subject, the book drew on Dayal's command of and sources to provide empirical textual evidence over speculative interpretations, influencing subsequent Western scholarship on ethics despite its pre-war context limiting access to some Tibetan and East Asian commentaries. No other dedicated monographs by Dayal on have been identified in primary bibliographic records.

    Anarchist and Rationalist Publications

    Har Dayal engaged with anarchist thought through early writings that critiqued state authority and promoted individual liberty. In a 1907 letter published in , he argued against reforming government, advocating instead for its abolition as the path to true freedom. Following his arrival in the United States, he formulated "The Anarchist's Creed" around 1911, shortly after leaving , which received coverage in newspapers for its radical propositions. As a key figure in the , Har Dayal produced infusing anarchist ideas into anti-colonial propaganda. His essay "The Meaning of Equality," published as a Ghadar Party in the early , explored equality's economic dimensions, asserting that genuine required not only political and intellectual autonomy but also economic independence from exploitation. This work emphasized internal and external equality to overcome historical divisions, influencing later revolutionaries like . In his post-revolutionary scholarly phase, Har Dayal shifted toward , synthesizing anarchist personal ethics with freethinking principles in Hints for Self-Culture (1934, Watts & Co.). This book urged readers to cultivate reason, self-control, and optimism while rejecting supernaturalism and divine authority, drawing on as a foundation for modern rational inquiry. It portrayed not as violent upheaval but as a daily practice of , , and equality: "Above all, practise , , and Equality in your daily life. Governments will change slowly, but your daily life is a noble institution that you can establish forthwith." Har Dayal viewed virtuous individuals as interdependent with societal institutions, advocating personal reform as the basis for broader progress independent of state mechanisms.

    Later Life and Ideological Evolution

    Academic Career and Lectures

    In the years following , Har Dayal resided primarily in , where he pursued independent scholarly interests in philosophy and religion before relocating to in 1927 to undertake doctoral research. He completed a PhD at the School of Oriental Studies, (now ), awarded in 1930 for his thesis The Bodhisattva Doctrine in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature, which examined key texts and doctrines in . This work reflected his deepened engagement with as a framework for ethical and rational inquiry, distinct from his earlier anarchist phase. Prior to his revolutionary activities, Har Dayal had served as an unsalaried lecturer in at during the 1911–1912 academic year, delivering courses on texts and Eastern thought to American students and influencing local intellectual circles. In his post-revolutionary period, he transitioned to independent public lecturing rather than formal academic appointments, speaking on , , democracy, and comparative religion across the , , and occasionally . Notable appearances included addresses at institutions like in , where he discussed ethical philosophy before audiences affiliated with the Ethical Culture Society. Har Dayal's lectures emphasized self-restraint, universal , and critiques of , drawing from Buddhist and rationalist principles to advocate non-violent global reform. His final public lecture, delivered shortly before his death in 1939, underscored a personal commitment to , concluding with the statement, "I am at peace with all." These engagements positioned him as a bridge between Eastern traditions and Western , though they lacked the institutional structure of a sustained professorship.

    Advocacy for Pacifism and Global Utopianism

    In the later phase of his life, particularly after resettling , Har Dayal renounced revolutionary violence and adopted as a core principle, viewing it as essential for ethical progress and human flourishing. Influenced by his studies in and , he argued that perpetuated cycles of and advocated non-violent as the path to societal improvement. This shift marked a departure from his earlier anarchist endorsements of , prioritizing instead personal and civic to avert conflict. Dayal actively promoted through , becoming a noted known for his eloquent, humorous, and humane delivery. As a member of the South Place Ethical Society from 1930 onward, he delivered addresses linking to and rational thought, emphasizing self-restraint and mutual respect as antidotes to aggression. In his 1934 publication Hints for Self-Culture, he outlined principles of self-improvement through reason and moral discipline, implicitly critiquing militaristic impulses while urging readers toward peaceful, progressive societal change. Complementing his pacifist stance, Dayal articulated a vision of global utopianism centered on a federated "world state" emerging from universal friendship and cooperative interdependence among peoples. He conceived this entity not as imposed but as the organic outcome of individual radical self-making and ethical evolution, where free-thinkers would lead by example in transcending for shared humanity. This utopian framework rejected imperial divisions, positing a borderless order grounded in rational and anti-militarism to ensure lasting . Dayal's advocacy reflected his broader internationalist , though it drew criticism for detached from geopolitical realities.

    Public Disavowal of Revolution

    In the , following his wartime experiences in and from 1915 to 1918, Lala Har Dayal began to publicly critique revolutionary violence, viewing it as counterproductive to lasting political transformation. In his 1920 memoir Forty-Four Months in Germany and Turkey, he documented the futility of armed alliances against British rule, emphasizing personal disillusionment with militaristic strategies that failed to yield independence for . This reflection marked an early pivot, as Har Dayal argued that such efforts entangled nationalists in broader imperial conflicts without achieving . By the , after resettling and engaging in academic lectures, Har Dayal explicitly renounced his earlier advocacy for armed uprising, aligning instead with pacifist principles. He promoted non-violent democratic reforms and international as superior alternatives, stating in public addresses that perpetuated cycles of rather than resolving them. Influenced by rationalist philosophy and observations of global instability post-World War I, he envisioned a "world federation" of nations to supplant revolutionary upheaval, prioritizing , , and mutual interdependence for peace. This disavowal extended to his rationalist writings, such as Hints for Self-Culture (1934), where he urged individuals to cultivate inner discipline and ethical reasoning over collective militancy, rejecting anarcho-violent tactics as immature. Har Dayal's lectures in American universities further disseminated these views, positioning him as a proponent of global utopianism that critiqued both British imperialism and Indian extremism. His evolution reflected a causal assessment that empirical failures of past insurrections necessitated pacifist realism for India's integration into a democratic world order.

    Legacy and Controversies

    Role in Indian Independence Narratives

    Lala Har Dayal is prominently featured in Indian independence narratives as the intellectual architect and founding leader of the Ghadar Party, established on July 15, 1913, in by expatriate Indians disillusioned with . The party, under his guidance, disseminated revolutionary propaganda through its weekly newspaper Ghadar and pamphlets like Ghadar di Gunj, urging armed revolt against the by targeting Indian troops and civilians. This overseas mobilization effort marked an early, militant strand of anti-colonial resistance, influencing subsequent uprisings such as the 1915 Ghadar conspiracy trials and inspiring later groups like the . Historiographical accounts credit Har Dayal's pre-World War I activism with galvanizing communities in and beyond, fostering a transnational network that challenged British imperialism through calls for and . His speeches and writings emphasized and rejection of moderate , positioning the as a radical alternative to the Indian National Congress's reformist approach. Indian postal authorities commemorated his contributions with a stamp, underscoring official recognition of his role in the freedom struggle. Har Dayal's legacy in these narratives is complicated by his post-1914 trajectory, including his flight from the to avoid and his eventual disavowal of violence in favor of and utopian . By the , he publicly rejected militancy, advocating moral and a federated world state over armed insurrection, which some historians interpret as a pragmatic evolution amid failed revolts, while others view it as undermining the Ghadar and diluting his anti-colonial credentials. This shift has led to selective portrayals: nationalist accounts often highlight his foundational phase, sidelining later ideological turns to preserve a cohesive hero narrative, whereas critical analyses note how his anarcho-pacifist pivot reflected broader tensions between diaspora radicalism and pragmatic in India's path to 1947 sovereignty.

    Criticisms of Ideological Shifts

    Har Dayal's transition from militant anti-colonial to and qualified support for reformed British status elicited sharp rebukes from Indian revolutionaries and nationalists, who accused him of betraying the Ghadar movement's foundational commitment to immediate through upheaval. By the mid-1910s, following his flight from the amid legal pressures, Har Dayal began publicly disavowing violent revolution, arguing in writings that such tactics were futile and that required gradual evolution under Western tutelage rather than rupture. This reversal was evident in his 1916 article "The Future of the ," where he contended that ousting the British would prove "suicidal" and urged Indians to "stay under the protection of the British fleet and army," positing reformed imperial rule as a bulwark against worse alternatives like German or Japanese domination. The article ignited immediate backlash within expatriate Indian circles, with Ghadar adherents viewing it as capitulation that eroded morale at a critical juncture when the party sought to incite among Indian troops during . Critics, including later historians tied to Punjab's revolutionary legacy, lamented Har Dayal's departure from activism; as Ghadar chronicler Bilga observed, "Lala Har Dayal was a great scholar, but somehow we have always felt he should not have quit the movement," interpreting his intellectual pivot as a personal abandonment that prioritized abstract utopianism over concrete liberation. This sentiment persisted, framing his advocacy for a "mixed British-American federation" for in the 1920s and 1930s as opportunistic realignment with Anglo-American interests, especially as he lectured in support of Allied causes during . Such critiques often highlight the causal disconnect between Har Dayal's early mobilization of laborers—through speeches decrying British exploitation—and his later emphasis on non-violent global , which some argued diluted anti-imperial resolve by conceding colonial hierarchies' utility. While defenders attribute the shift to pragmatic reflection on revolution's costs, evidenced by failed uprisings like the , detractors maintain it reflected ideological inconsistency, undermining his credibility as a freedom fighter in . Empirical assessments of Ghadar's trajectory, including arrests and infiltrations post-1913, underscore how Har Dayal's exit and subsequent disavowals contributed to leadership vacuums, though direct causation remains debated among scholars.

    Balanced Assessments and Modern Views

    Modern scholars assess Har Dayal as a pivotal yet enigmatic figure in anticolonial history, whose early through the Ghadar Party (founded 1913) demonstrated innovative transnational strategies against British imperialism, but whose post-World War I pivot to and reflects a profound disillusionment with revolutionary violence. His 1934 work Hints for Self-Culture is interpreted by contemporaries as reimagining anticolonial resistance through personal ethical cultivation rather than armed uprising, emphasizing and global over . Critics within Indian independence historiography, such as those examining Ghadar's internal dynamics, note Har Dayal's 1914 flight from the amid legal pressures as a tactical retreat that fragmented the movement, though balanced analyses credit his ideological formulations—like integrating class struggle with —for inspiring later . Praises highlight his rationalist reinterpretations of , promoting empirical self-improvement and anti-caste critiques, which prefigured mid-20th-century secular humanist trends in South Asian thought. However, some anarchist scholars argue his later advocacy for a utopian "world state" under pacifist principles deviated from core anarchist tenets of decentralized , rendering his evolution a of ideological yielding to assimilationist academia. In recent evaluations (post-2010s), Har Dayal's legacy evades binary nationalist framing, with academics portraying him as emblematic of cosmopolitan exile politics: a thinker whose 1915–1918 European and subsequent Stanford lectures (1920s) bridged with Western , influencing pacifist amid interwar disillusionment. This view tempers hagiographic Indian narratives by underscoring verifiable impacts—such as Ghadar's recruitment of over 6,000 Indians for —against unfulfilled utopian visions, prioritizing of his shifts over uncritical heroism. Overall, modern consensus values his empirical adaptability, evidenced in archived lectures critiquing both and dogmatic revolution, as a model for intellectual resilience absent in more rigid contemporaries.

    Selected Works

    Key Texts and Their Themes

    Har Dayal's Hints for Self Culture, published in 1934, serves as his most influential work, advocating a systematic approach to across intellectual, physical, ethical, and aesthetic dimensions to cultivate rational individuals capable of contributing to a free society. The text promotes self-discipline through habits like daily reading, exercise, and moral reflection, positioning such self-mastery as foundational to , , and opposition to , while critiquing irrational traditions and emphasizing empirical reasoning over . In his scholarly publication The Bodhisattva Doctrine in Buddhist Sanskrit Literature (1931), Har Dayal examines the evolution of Buddhist ideals of and enlightenment, tracing how the concept represented a "new ideal" of universal distinct from earlier ascetic traditions, though he interprets it through a rationalist lens that prioritizes ethical action over supernatural elements. This analysis highlights themes of for collective welfare, which later informed his pacifist views, but Har Dayal underscores historical textual to argue against mystical interpretations, favoring causal explanations of doctrinal shifts. During his anarchist phase around 1912–1914, Har Dayal authored pamphlets such as "The Meaning of Equality," which framed anti-colonial resistance as an egalitarian struggle against imperial hierarchy, drawing on influences like Peter Kropotkin to advocate decentralized mutual aid and direct action for Indian liberation. These writings emphasized themes of individual sovereignty and collective revolt against state oppression, reflecting his early rejection of both nationalism and Marxism in favor of spontaneous, non-authoritarian uprising. Forty-Four Months in Germany and Turkey (circa 1920) recounts Har Dayal's wartime experiences, critiquing and alliances with for Indian independence as ultimately futile, with themes of disillusionment paving the way for his of in favor of ethical and global cooperation. The details logistical failures and ideological compromises, using personal anecdotes to argue that coercive strategies breed new tyrannies rather than .

    References

    1. https://www.sjc.ox.ac.uk/discover/about-college/st-johns-and-colonial-past/exhibition/har-dayal/
    2. https://heritage.humanists.uk/har-dayal/
    3. https://testbook.com/important-days/lala-har-dayal-birth-on-october-14-1884
    4. https://www.dailyexcelsior.com/the-inspiring-story-of-lala-har-dayal/
    5. https://starsunfolded.com/lala-har-dayal/
    6. https://byjus.com/free-ias-prep/this-day-in-history-mar04/
    7. https://www.englitmail.com/2022/08/lala-hardayal-introduction.html
    8. https://www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/the-truth-about-the-revolutionary/cid/1018401
    9. https://www.businessworld.in/article/igniting-the-fire-within-the-inspirational-life-of-lala-har-dayal-575099
    10. https://giss.org/jsps_vol_26/sukhdev_sohal.pdf
    11. https://ierj.in/journal/index.php/ierj/article/download/1255/1263/2370
    12. https://www.businessworld.in/article/har-dayal-the-gobal-indian-intellectual-spiritual-and-revolutionary-leader-536160
    13. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Lala-Har-Dayal
    14. https://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net/article/dayal-har/
    15. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/ole-birk-laursen-anarchist-anti-imperialism
    16. https://www.theindiaforum.in/tiffin/har-dayal-three-years-made-difference
    17. https://files.libcom.org/files/AnarchistPortraitsPaulAvrich.pdf
    18. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/jesse-cohn-anarchism-in-india
    19. https://southasianbritain.org/people/lala-har-dayal/
    20. https://www.lalkar.org/article/269/100th-anniversary-of-the-ghadar-movement-3
    21. https://www.saada.org/current/20131013-3205
    22. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/har-dayal
    23. https://www.niam.org/galleries/the-right-to-liberty/gadar-the-call-to-revolution/
    24. https://lib.uw.edu/specialcollections/collections/exhibits/southasianstudents/gadar/
    25. https://pluralism.org/the-ghadar-party-freedom-for-india
    26. https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1189&context=facpubs
    27. https://socialiststudies.com/index.php/sss/article/download/27272/20160/69631
    28. https://digitalscholarship.tsu.edu/theses/24/
    29. https://asianamericanedu.org/the-ghadar-movement.html
    30. https://nyu.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.18574/nyu/9780814786437.001.0001/upso-9780814786437-chapter-2
    31. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1428642
    32. https://archive.org/details/bodhisattvadoctr0000hard
    33. https://ahandfulofleaves.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/the-bodhisattva-doctrine-in-buddhist-sanskrit-literature_dayal.pdf
    34. https://www.wlupress.wlu.ca/Books/B/Bodhisattva-Doctrine-in-Buddhism
    35. https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Bodhisattva_Doctrine_in_Buddhist_San.html?id=uUveqp7lAVoC
    36. https://commons.tsadra.org/index.php/Dayal,_H.
    37. https://thinkindiaquarterly.org/index.php/think-india/article/download/12785/8063/
    38. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/4/article/546311/pdf
    39. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv119919v
    40. https://soas-repository.worktribe.com/output/394718/the-bodhisattva-doctrine-in-buddhist-sanskrit-literature
    41. https://guides.lib.berkeley.edu/echoes-of-freedom/university
    42. https://digitalscholarship.tsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1021&context=theses
    43. https://www.dharmadispatch.in/history/teaching-self-restraint-to-sense-enslaved-americans-har-dayals-eye-opening-observations-of-the-intrinsic-american-character
    44. https://read.dukeupress.edu/cssaame/article-abstract/34/1/9/59805/Echoes-of-GhadrLala-Har-Dayal-and-the-Time-of
    45. https://swarajyamag.com/ideas/darwins-day-today-let-us-celebrate-it-by-reading-this-book-by-lala-har-dayal
    46. https://www.iasexpress.net/lala-har-dayal/
    47. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/144511261.pdf
    48. https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.111348/2015.111348.Har-Dayal-Hindu-Revolutionary-And-Rationalist_djvu.txt
    49. https://hinduinfopedia.in/lala-har-dayal-a-torchbearer-of-indias-freedom-struggle/
    50. https://archives.vsktelangana.org/lala-har-dayal-the-lost-revolutionary
    51. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/maia-ramnath-two-revolutions-the-ghadar-movement-and-india-s-radical-diaspora
    52. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/392900849_A_Study_of_the_Impact_of_Lala_Har_Dayal%27s_Ideological_Perspective_on_the_Indian_Freedom_Struggle
    53. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/[chandigarh](/page/Chandigarh)/dayals-1916-article-sparks-row/articleshow/622125265.cms
    54. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/dayals-1916-article-sparks-row/articleshow/622125265.cms
    55. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/265758613_Echoes_of_Ghadr_Lala_Har_Dayal_and_the_Time_of_Anticolonialism
    56. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/archits-anarchism-the-spiked-ashram
    57. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/271673492_A_long_strange_trip_The_lives_in_exile_of_Har_Dayal
    58. https://www.academia.edu/20842700/Anti_Colonial_Nationalism_and_Cosmopolitan_Standard_Time_Lala_Har_Dayal_s_Forty_Four_Months_in_Germany_and_Turkey
    59. https://www.aibh.in/product/8947/hints-for-self-culture
    60. https://ia601402.us.archive.org/34/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.188615/2015.188615.The-Bodhisattva-Doctrine-In-Buddhist-Sanskrit-Lit_text.pdf
    61. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780823289820-003/html
    62. https://www.englitmail.com/2022/09/lala-hardayal-his-writing.html
    Add your contribution
    Related Hubs
    User Avatar
    No comments yet.