Hubbry Logo
Christian stateChristian stateMain
Open search
Christian state
Community hub
Christian state
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Christian state
Christian state
Christian state
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Part of a series on
Christianity
Principal symbol of Christianity
Theology
Related topics

A Christian state is a country that recognizes a form of Christianity as its official religion and often has a state church (also called an established church),[1] which is a Christian denomination that supports the government and is supported by the government.[2]

Historically, the nations of Armenia,[3][4] Aksum, Makuria, and the Holy Roman Empire have declared themselves as Christian states, as well as the Roman Empire and its continuation the Byzantine Empire, the Russian Empire, the Spanish Empire, the British Empire, the Portuguese Empire, and the Frankish Empire, the Belgian colonial empire, the French empire.[5][6]

Today, several nations officially identify themselves as Christian states or have state churches. These countries include Argentina, Armenia, Costa Rica, El Salvador,[7] Denmark (incl. Greenland and the Faroes),[8] England,[9] Dominican Republic,[10] Georgia,[11] Greece,[12] Hungary,[13] Iceland,[14] Liechtenstein,[15] Malta,[16] Monaco,[17] Norway,[18] Samoa,[19] Serbia,[20] Tonga,[21] Tuvalu,[22] Vatican City,[23] and Zambia.[24] The laws of various Christian countries, such as those of Denmark, Norway, and Sweden require their monarch to be a Christian (usually of a particular denomination, such as Evangelical Lutheranism).[25][26][27] A Christian state stands in contrast to a secular state,[28] an atheist state,[29] or another religious state, such as a Jewish state,[30] or an Islamic state.[31]

History

[edit]
The boundaries of the Eastern Roman Empire under Justinian the Great

The Armenian Apostolic Church traces its origins to the apostolic era, asserting apostolic succession from the apostles Bartholomew[32] and Thaddeus (Jude).[33][34][35] The formal establishment of Christianity as the state religion of Armenia is traditionally dated to 301 AD, during the reign of Tiridates III, following his conversion by Gregory the Illuminator. This makes Armenia the first nation to adopt Christianity as a state religion, although the exact date has been subject to scholarly debate.[36] In 380, three Roman emperors issued the Edict of Thessalonica (Cunctos populos), making the Roman Empire a Christian state,[5] and establishing Nicene Christianity, in the form of its State Church, as its official religion.[37]

After the fall of the Western Roman Empire in the late 5th century, the Eastern Roman Empire under the emperor Justinian (reigned 527–565), became the world's predominant Christian state, based on Roman law, Greek culture, and the Greek language."[6][38][39] In this Christian state, in which nearly all of its subjects upheld faith in Jesus, an "enormous amount of artistic talent was poured into the construction of churches, church ceremonies, and church decoration".[38] John Binns describes this era, writing that:[40]

A new stage in the history of the Church began when not just localised communities but nations became Christian. The stage is associated with the conversion of Constantine and the beginnings of a Christian Empire, but the Byzantine Emperor was not the first ruler to lead his people into Christianity, thus setting up the first Christian state. That honour traditionally goes to the church of Armenia.[40]

— John Binns, An Introduction to the Christian Orthodox Churches

As a Christian state, Armenia "embraced Christianity as the religion of the King, the nobles, and the people".[3] In 326, according to official tradition of the Georgian Orthodox Church, following the conversion of Mirian and Nana, the country of Georgia became a Christian state, the Emperor Constantine the Great sending clerics for baptising people. In the 4th century, in the Kingdom of Aksum, after Ezana's conversion to the faith, this empire also became a Christian state.[4][41]

In the Middle Ages, efforts were made in order to establish a Pan-Christianity state by uniting the countries within Christendom.[42][43] Christian nationalism played a role in this era in which Christians felt the impulse to also recover those territories in which Christianity historically flourished, such as the Holy Land and North Africa.[44]

The First Great Awakening, American Revolution, and Second Great Awakening caused two rounds of disestablishment among the states of the new United States, from 1776 to 1833.[45]

Modern era

[edit]
Countries with Christianity as their state religion are in blue.

Argentina

[edit]

Article 2 of the Constitution of Argentina explicitly states that "the Federal Government supports the Roman Catholic Apostolic Faith" and Article 14 guarantees freedom of religion.[46][47][48] Although it enforces neither an official nor a state faith,[49] it gives Catholic Christianity a preferential status.[50][51][52] Before its 1994 amendment, the Constitution stated that the President of the Republic must be a Roman Catholic.

Armenia

[edit]

In Armenia Christianity is the state religion and the Armenian Apostolic Church is the national church. Armenia is the first country which recognised Christianity as a state religion.

Costa Rica

[edit]

The constitution of Costa Rica states that "The Catholic and Apostolic Religion is the religion of the State".[7] As such, Catholic Christian holy days are recognized by the government and "public schools provide religious education", although parents are able to opt-out their children if they choose to do so.[53]

Denmark

[edit]
A Church of Denmark parish church in Holte, with the Dannebrog flying in its kirkyard

As early as the 11th century AD, "Denmark was considered to be a Christian state",[54][55] with the Church of Denmark, a member of the Lutheran World Federation, being the state church.[56] Prof. Wasif Shadid, of Leiden University, writes that:

The Lutheran established church is a department of the state. Church affairs are governed by a central government ministry, while clergy are government employees. The registration of births, deaths and marriages falls under this ministry of church affairs, and normally speaking the local Lutheran pastor is also the official registrar.[8]

— W. A. R. Shadid, Religious Freedom and the Position of Islam in Western Europe, page 11

Over 82% of the population of Denmark are members of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Denmark, which is "officially headed by the queen of Denmark".[57] The Act of Succession specifies that monarch "shall be a member of the Evangelical Church."[25] Furthermore, clergy "in the Church of Denmark are civil servants employed by the Ministry of Ecclesiastical Affairs" and the "economic base of the Church of Denmark is state-collected church taxes combined with a direct state subsidiary (12%), which symbolically covers the expenses of the Church of Denmark to run the civil registration and the burial system for all citizens."[57]

England

[edit]
Canterbury Cathedral houses the cathedra of the Archbishop of Canterbury, the primus inter pares of the worldwide Anglican Communion

Barbara Yorke writes that the "Carolingian Renaissance heightened appreciation within England of the role of king and church in a Christian state."[58] As such,

Since the 1701 Act of Establishment, England's official state church has been the Church of England, the monarch being its supreme governor and 'defender of the faith'. He, together with Parliament, has a say in appointing bishops, twenty-six of whom have ex officio seats in the House of Lords. In characteristically British fashion, where the state is representative of civil society, it was Parliament that determined, in the Act of Establishment, that the monarch had to be Anglican.[9]

— Christian Joppke, page 1

Christian religious education is taught to children in primary and secondary schools in the United Kingdom.[59] English schools have a legal requirement for a daily act of collective worship "of a broadly Christian character"[60] that is widely flouted.[61]

Dominican Republic

[edit]

The Dominican Republic is a Christian state, with Catholic Christianity being the official religion.[10] In view of the same, the government of the Dominican Republic extends special privileges to the Catholic Church.[10] National holidays include holy days of Christianity, such as the Epiphany (January 6), Good Friday, Corpus Christi, and Christmas Day. In the Dominican Republic, religious education classes must be of either a Catholic or evangelical Protestant basis and are required be taught in all elementary and secondary public schools.[10]

Faroe Islands

[edit]

The Church of the Faroe Islands is the state church of Faroe Islands.[62]

Georgia

[edit]

Georgia is one of the oldest Christian states. Article 8 of Georgian Constitution and the Concordat of 2002 grants the Georgian Orthodox Church special privileges, which include legal immunity to the Patriarch of Georgia. The Orthodox Church is the most trusted institution in the country[63][64] and its head, Patriarch Ilia II, the most trusted person.[65][66]

Greece

[edit]

Greece is a Christian state,[12][67] with the Church of Greece playing "a dominant role in the life of the country".[68]

Mount Athos and most of the Athos peninsula are governed as an autonomous region in Greece by the monastic community of Mount Athos, which is ecclesiastically under the direct jurisdiction of the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople.

Greenland

[edit]

Being an autonomous constituent country within the Kingdom of Denmark, the Church of Denmark is the established church of Greenland through the Constitution of Denmark:

The Evangelical Lutheran Church shall be the Established Church of Denmark, and, as such, it shall be supported by the State.

— Section IV of Constitution of Denmark[69]

This applies toof the Kingdom of Denmark, except for the Faroe Islands, as the Church of the Faroe Islands became independent in 2007.

Hungary

[edit]

The preamble to the Hungarian Constitution of 2011 describes Hungary as "part of Christian Europe" and acknowledges "the role of Christianity in preserving nationhood", while Article VII provides that "the State shall cooperate with the Churches for community goals". However, the constitution also guarantees freedom of religion and separation of church and state.[13]

Iceland

[edit]
Reykjavík Cathedral, mother Church of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Iceland

Around AD 1000, Iceland became a Christian state.[70] The Encyclopedia of Protestantism states that:

The majority of Icelanders are members of the state church. Almost all children are baptized as Lutheran and more than 90 percent are subsequently confirmed. The church conducts 75 percent of all marriages and 99 percent of all funerals. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in Iceland is a member of the Lutheran World Federation and the World Council of Churches.[14]

— J. Gordon Melton, Encyclopedia of Protestantism, page 283

All public schools have mandatory education in Christianity, although an exemption may be considered by the Minister of Education.[71]

Liechtenstein

[edit]

Liechtenstein's constitution designates the Catholic Church as being the state Church of that country.[15] In public schools, per article 16 of the Constitution of Liechtenstein, religious education is given by Church authorities.[15]

Malta

[edit]
The Civil Ensign of Malta

Section Two of the Constitution of Malta specifies the state's religion as being the Roman Catholic Apostolic Religion.[72][16] It holds that the "authorities of the Roman Catholic Apostolic Church have the duty to teach which principles are right and which are wrong" and that "religious teaching of the Roman Catholic Apostolic Faith shall be provided in all State schools as part of compulsory education".[72]

Monaco

[edit]

Article 9 of the Constitution of Monaco describes "La religion catholique, apostolique et romaine [the catholic, apostolic and Roman religion]" as the religion of the state.[17]

Norway

[edit]
The Bible in the Norwegian language

Cole Durham and Tore Sam Lindholm, writing in 2013, stated that "For a period of one thousand years Norway has been a kingdom with a Christian state church" and that a decree went out in 1739 ordering that "Elementary schooling for all Norwegian children became mandatory, so that all Norwegians should be able to read the Bible and the Lutheran Catechism firsthand."[73] The modern Constitution of Norway stipulates that "The Church of Norway, an Evangelical-Lutheran church, will remain the Established Church of Norway and will as such be supported by the State."[74] As such, the "Norwegian constitution decrees that Lutheranism is the official religion of the State and that the King is the supreme temporal head of the Church."[75][76] The administration of the Church "is shared between the Ministry for Church, Education and Research centrally and municipal authorities locally",[75] and the Church of Norway "depends on state and local taxes".[77] The Church of Norway is responsible for the "maintenance of church buildings and cemeteries".[78] In the mid-20th century, the vast majority of Norwegians participated in the Lutheran Church. According to a 1957 description, "[o]ver 90 percent of the population are married by state church clergymen, have their children baptized and confirmed, and finally are buried with a church service."[79] However, current membership in the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Norway is lower, standing at 65% of the population in 2021.[80]

In 2017, the Church of Norway was made self-governing, with the identity of the denomination shifting from a state church to a national church.[81] The Church of Noway continues to be supported by public funding.[81] Succession rules governing the Monarchy of Norway require that the monarch be an Evangelical Lutheran holding membership in the Church of Norway.[26] Those who marry into the royal family of Norway are expected to be or become Evangelical Lutherans.[26]

Samoa

[edit]

Samoa became a Christian state in 2017. Article 1 of the Samoan Constitution states that “Samoa is a Christian nation founded of God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit”.[19]

Serbia

[edit]
Main articles: Religion in Serbia, Eastern Orthodoxy in Serbia, and Serbian Orthodox Church

Serbia as a territory became a Christian state during the time of Constantine the Great in Christianization of Eastern Roman Empire, according to the research and discoveries of artifacts left by the Illyrians, Triballi and other kindred tribes. More research has since been made that perhaps prove the existence of Serbs living in the Balkans during Roman times in Ilyria. In the centuries that followed from the 4th to the 12th century, when Catholic Church was in a battleground between Serbia due the Eastern Orthodox Church, Serbia prevailed as Orthodox Christian state under his jurisdiction through Saint Sava.[82]

Serbia as modern state, defines in its constitution as a secular state with guaranteed religious freedom.[83] However, Orthodox Christians with 6,079,396 adherents comprise 84.5% of the country's population. The Serbian Orthodox Church is the largest traditional church of the country, adherents of which are overwhelmingly Serbs. The SOC directly or indirectly has cultural influence on both the decisions and positions of the state.[84][85][86]

Sweden

[edit]
Lutheran priest elevating the host during the offering of the Mass at Alsike Church, Sweden

Under the reign of Gustav Vasa, Sweden became an Evangelical-Lutheran Christian country.[87] The Protestant Reformation in Sweden was led by the Evangelical-Lutheran divines Olaus Petri and Laurentius Petri.[87] Laurentius Petri was consecrated in the apostolic succession that, according to the Swedish Church Ordinance 1571 "must remain in the future, so long as the world lasts."[87] In 1544, the Parliament in Västerås declared Sweden to be an Evangelical-Lutheran kingdom.[87] The Kyrkogångsplikt was the legal obligation for Swedish citizens to attend Mass every Lord's Day in the Evangelical Lutheran church. The Evangelical-Lutheran Church of Sweden historically served as the state church, though in 2000, this relationship was loosened; "the Church of Sweden is still legally regulated by the state, and the monarch must be a member and assent to its theology."[88] The Swedish Act of Succession requires monarchs to "profess the pure evangelical faith".[27]

Tonga

[edit]

Tonga became a Christian state under George Tupou I in the 19th century,[21][89] with the Free Wesleyan Church, a member of the World Methodist Council, being established as the country's state Church.[90] Under the rule of George Tupou I, there was established a "rigorous constitutional clause regulating observation of the Sabbath".[21]

Tuvalu

[edit]

The Church of Tuvalu, a Calvinist church in the Congregationalist tradition, is the state church of Tuvalu and was established as such in 1991.[91] The Constitution of Tuvalu identifies Tuvalu as "an independent State based on Christian principles".[22]

Vatican City

[edit]
St. Peter's Square, Vatican City

Vatican City is a Christian state, in which the "Pope is ex officio simultaneously leader of the Catholic Church as well as Head of State and Head of the Government of the State of the Vatican City; he also possesses (de jure) absolute authority over the legislative, executive and judicial branches."[23]

Zambia

[edit]

Jeroen Temperman, a professor of international law at Erasmus University Rotterdam writes that:

Zambia is officially a Christian state as well, though the legal ramifications clearly do not compare to the latter state. The Preamble of the Constitution of Zambia establishes Zambia as a Christian state without specifying "Christian" denominationally. It simply proclaims: "We, the people of Zambia...declare the Republic a Christian nation..." As far as state practice is concerned, it may be pointed out that the Government maintains relations with the Zambian Council of Churches and requires Christianity to be taught in the public school curriculum.[92]

— Jeroen Temperman, State-Religion Relationships and Human Rights Law, page 18

After "Zambia declared itself a Christian nation in 1991", "the nation's vice president urged citizens to 'have a Christian orientation in all fields, at all levels'."[24]

Established churches and former state churches

[edit]

Current

[edit]
Location Church Denomination Notes
Denmark Church of Denmark Lutheran
England Church of England Anglican
Faroe Islands Church of the Faroe Islands Lutheran Elevated from a diocese of the Church of Denmark in 2007 (the two remain in close cooperation)
Greece Greek Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox[93] The Church of Greece is recognized by the Greek Constitution as the "prevailing religion" in Greece.[93] However, this provision does not give official status to the Church of Greece, while all other religions are recognized as equal and may be practiced freely.[94]
Greenland Church of Denmark Lutheran Under discussion to be elevated from The Diocese of Greenland in the Church of Denmark to a state church for Greenland, along-the-lines the Faroese Church took in 2007
Iceland Lutheran Evangelical Church Lutheran
Liechtenstein Catholic Church[95] Catholic
Malta Catholic Church Catholic
Monaco Catholic Church Catholic
Nicaragua Catholic Church Catholic
Tuvalu Church of Tuvalu Reformed

Former

[edit]
Location Church Denomination Disestablished
Anhalt Evangelical State Church of Anhalt United Protestant 1918, during the German Revolution
Armenia Armenian Apostolic Church Oriental Orthodox 1921
Austria Catholic Church Catholic 1918, under the Federal Constitutional Law
Baden Catholic Church Catholic 1918, during the German Revolution
United Evangelical Protestant State Church of Baden United Protestant 1918, during the German Revolution
Bavaria Catholic Church Catholic 1918, during the German Revolution
Protestant State Church in the Kingdom of Bavaria right of the Rhine Lutheran and Reformed 1918, during the German Revolution
United Protestant Evangelical Christian Church of the Palatinate United Protestant 1918, during the German Revolution
Bolivia Catholic Church Catholic 2009, under the Constitution of Bolivia
Brazil[note 1] Roman Catholic Church Catholic 1890
Brunswick Evangelical Lutheran State Church in Brunswick Lutheran 1918, during the German Revolution
Bulgaria Bulgarian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1946
Chile Catholic Church Catholic 1925
Colombia Catholic Church Catholic 1991[96][97]
Connecticut Congregational Church Reformed 1818, under the Constitution of Connecticut
Cuba Catholic Church Catholic 1902
Cyprus Cypriot Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1977, with the death of the Ethnarch Makarios III
Czechoslovakia Catholic Church Catholic 1920, under the Czechoslovak Constitution
East Florida Church of England Anglican 1783
Ethiopia Ethiopian Orthodox Church Oriental Orthodox 1974, after the formation of the Derg
Finland Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland Lutheran 1869, however the organisation of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland is regulated by the Constitution of Finland[98] and Church Act of 1993.[99] The state also carries out taxing for the funding of the church on its members.[99]
Finnish Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1917
France[note 2] Catholic Church Catholic 1905, under the law on the Separation of the Churches and the State
Georgia (country) Georgian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1921
Guatemala Catholic Church Catholic 1871
Haiti Catholic Church Catholic 1987
Hawaii Church of Hawaii Anglican 1893, after the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom
Hesse Evangelical Church in Hesse United Protestant 1918, during the German Revolution
Hungary[note 3] Roman Catholic Church Catholic 1946
Ireland[note 4] Church of Ireland Anglican 1871
Republic of Ireland[note 5] Catholic Church Catholic 1973
Italy Catholic Church Catholic 1985, see Lateran Treaty § After 1946
Lippe Church of Lippe Reformed 1918
Lithuania Catholic Church Catholic 1940
Lübeck Evangelical Lutheran Church in the State of Lübeck Lutheran 1918
Luxembourg Catholic Church Catholic Not an official state church
North Macedonia Macedonian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1921
Mecklenburg-Schwerin Evangelical Lutheran State Church of Mecklenburg-Schwerin Lutheran 1918
Mecklenburg-Strelitz Mecklenburg-Strelitz State Church Lutheran 1918
Mexico Catholic Church Catholic 1857, under the Federal Constitution (reestablished between 1864 and 1867)
Netherlands Dutch Reformed Church Reformed 1795
New Netherland Reformed Church in America Reformed 1674 (colony surrendered to English rule)
New Brunswick Church of England Anglican 1850
Norway Church of Norway Lutheran 2017, by legislation[106][107]
Nova Scotia Church of England Anglican 1850
Oldenburg Evangelical Lutheran Church of Oldenburg Lutheran 1918
Panama Catholic Church Catholic 1904
Paraguay Catholic Church Catholic 1992[108]
Peru Catholic Church Catholic 1993, under the Constitution of Peru
Philippines[note 6] Catholic Church Catholic 1898
Poland[note 7] Catholic Church Catholic 1947
Portugal Catholic Church Catholic 1911
Prince Edward Island Church of England Anglican 1850
Georgia (US state) Church of England Anglican 1789
Province of Maryland Church of England Anglican 1776
Massachusetts Congregational Church Reformed 1834[109]
New Hampshire Church of England Anglican 1877
North Carolina Church of England Anglican 1776
South Carolina Church of England Anglican 1790
Prussia
pre-1866 provinces		 Evangelical State Church of Prussia's older Provinces with nine ecclesiastical provinces United Protestant 1918
Prussia
Province of Hanover		 Evangelical Reformed State Church of the Province of Hanover Reformed 1918
Prussia
Province of Hanover		 Evangelical Lutheran State Church of Hanover Lutheran 1918
Prussia
Province of Hesse-Nassau (partially)		 Evangelical State Church of Frankfurt upon Main United Protestant 1918
Prussia
Province of Hesse-Nassau (partially)		 Evangelical Church of Kurhessen-Waldeck United Protestant 1918
Prussia
Province of Hesse-Nassau (partially)		 Evangelical State Church in Nassau United Protestant 1918
Prussia
Province of Schleswig-Holstein		 Evangelical Lutheran Church of Schleswig-Holstein Lutheran 1918
Quebec Catholic Church Catholic 1960, after the Quiet Revolution
Romania Romanian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1947
Russia Russian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1917, after the Russian Revolution
Taiping Heavenly Kingdom God Worshipping Society God Worshipping Society 1864
Thuringia church bodies in principalities which merged in Thuringia in 1920 Lutheran 1918
Saxony Evangelical Lutheran State Church of Saxony Lutheran 1918
Schaumburg-Lippe Evangelical State Church of Schaumburg-Lippe Lutheran 1918
Scotland[110] Church of Scotland Presbyterian State control disclaimed since 1638. Formally recognised as not an established church in 1921
Serbia Serbian Orthodox Church Eastern Orthodox 1946
Spain Catholic Church Catholic 1978
Sweden Church of Sweden Lutheran 2000
Switzerland separate Cantonal Churches («Landeskirchen») Zwinglianism & Calvinism or Catholic during the 20th century
United Province of Canada Church of England Anglican 1854
Uruguay Catholic Church Catholic 1918, (into effect in 1919)
Virginia Church of England Anglican 1786
Waldeck Evangelical State Church of Waldeck and Pyrmont United Protestant 1918
Wales[note 8] Church of England Anglican 1920
West Florida Church of England Anglican 1783
Württemberg Evangelical State Church in Württemberg Lutheran 1918

National church

[edit]
Main article: National church

A number of countries have a national church which is not established (as the official religion of the nation), but is nonetheless recognised under civil law as being the country's acknowledged religious denomination. Whilst these are not Christian states, the official Christian national church is likely to have certain residual state functions in relation to state occasions and ceremonial. Examples include Scotland (Church of Scotland) and Sweden (Church of Sweden). A national church typically has a monopoly on official state recognition, although unusually Finland has two national churches (the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland and the Finnish Orthodox Church), both recognised under civil law as joint official churches of the nation.

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Christian state

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

A Christian state is a sovereign entity that officially endorses Christianity as its religion, typically establishing a state church with legal privileges, funding, and influence over public institutions such as education and law. This arrangement embeds Christian teachings into governance, aiming to align civil authority with ecclesiastical principles for moral and social order. Historically, the model originated in the late Roman Empire when Emperor Theodosius I decreed Nicene Christianity the sole legitimate faith in 380 AD, suppressing paganism and heresies to consolidate imperial unity. Subsequent examples include the , which maintained Orthodox Christianity as central to its identity until 1453, and medieval entities like the , where the pope exercised temporal power. In Europe, confessional monarchies such as those in and retained established Lutheran and Anglican churches, respectively, shaping national identity amid Reformation-era divisions. Modern instances persist in nations like , where Roman Catholicism holds official status, and , which amended its constitution in 1996 to affirm Christianity's role without mandating adherence. These states often cite Christianity's contributions to ethical foundations, including concepts of dignity and derived from biblical sources, though they have faced critiques for potential restrictions on . Defining characteristics include oaths invoking divine right, laws in some cases, and state ceremonies rooted in , reflecting a fusion of sacred and secular authority that contrasts with secular models emphasizing strict separation.

Definition and Characteristics

In Christian states, constitutional provisions typically designate a particular or broadly as the official or established , granting it legal primacy while often preserving freedoms for other . Such elements may include state funding for institutions, mandatory religious instruction aligned with the established , representation of in legislative bodies, and oaths of office invoking principles. These arrangements stem from historical precedents where church and state mutually reinforce social order through shared moral foundations, though modern implementations vary in intensity and frequently coexist with pluralism. Denmark exemplifies this through Section 4 of its 1953 Constitutional Act, which declares: "The Evangelical Lutheran Church shall be the Established Church of Denmark, and, as such, it shall be supported by the State." This support manifests in annual state allocations exceeding 1 billion Danish kroner (approximately $145 million USD as of 2023 exchange rates) for church operations, including clergy salaries and building maintenance, funded via general taxation. The provision underscores a framework where the church influences national ceremonies and holidays, such as mandatory state involvement in royal confirmations. Greece's 1975 (revised 2008), in Article 3, establishes the as the "prevailing religion," affirming its doctrinal unity with the and mandating state respect for Orthodox doctrines, including unaltered Holy Scriptures. Legal privileges include automatic Orthodox religious education in public schools (with options), state payment of approximately 200 million euros annually (as of 2022 data) toward clerical salaries for over 10,000 priests, and church exemptions from property taxes on religious sites. Article 3 also facilitates Orthodox canon law's role in family matters, such as marriage annulments. Malta's 1964 (revised 2016), Article 2(1), explicitly states: "The religion of Malta is the Roman Catholic Apostolic Religion," obligating the state to safeguard Catholic moral and spiritual interests. Subsection 2 grants the authority to teach which "must be respected," while Subsection 3 requires compulsory Roman Catholic religious instruction in all state schools, serving over 30,000 students annually as of 2023 enrollment figures. Additional elements include state funding for Catholic feast days and pilgrimages, with the church receiving about 10 million euros yearly (2022 figures) for administrative support, reflecting Catholicism's embedded role in civil rites like weddings. In the , the 's establishment lacks a single constitutional clause but derives from statutes like the 1701 Act of Settlement, requiring the to be a Protestant communicant and "," and the 1919 Church of England Assembly (Powers) Act, integrating ecclesiastical governance with parliamentary oversight. Twenty-six bishops sit ex officio in the , influencing legislation on moral issues, while state properties like cathedrals receive indirect support via heritage funding exceeding £100 million annually (2023 estimates). oaths bind the sovereign to preserve the Protestant faith, embedding confessional allegiance in the executive. These legal structures often incorporate residual elements like blasphemy prohibitions (e.g., 's Article 198 penal code until partial reforms in 2019) or trading restrictions rooted in Christian observance, though many have softened amid European human rights pressures. Empirical data from state budgets and enrollment statistics indicate sustained but declining practical influence, with below 10% in and as of 2022 surveys, highlighting tensions between confessional form and secular practice.

Distinctions from Theocracy and Secularism

A Christian state, often termed a confessional state, establishes one or more Christian denominations as official, integrating their doctrines into public institutions, legal frameworks, and national identity, while vesting ultimate political authority in civil rulers rather than clergy. This configuration preserves a distinction between ecclesiastical and temporal spheres, with the state supporting the church through funding, privileges, and alignment of laws with Christian ethics, but without subordinating civil governance to direct clerical oversight. In contrast, a entails rule by religious authorities or the direct application of superseding human legislation, as exemplified by the prior to 1870, where the Pope exercised both spiritual and temporal sovereignty, or contemporary , governed as an under papal rule since its 1929 establishment via the . Christian states avoid this fusion by limiting church influence to advisory or moral guidance, ensuring that magistrates enforce justice independently, a principle articulated in Reformed traditions where civil rulers are seen as ordained by to wield the sword apart from preaching the gospel. Relative to secularism, which mandates state neutrality toward religion—prohibiting official endorsements and enforcing separation as in France's 1905 law on the separation of church and state—a Christian state actively privileges Christianity in oaths of office, education curricula, and public ceremonies, fostering societal cohesion through shared faith without coercing private belief. This endorsement reflects empirical patterns where confessional arrangements historically correlated with lower religious conflict in homogeneous populations, such as Denmark's retention of the Evangelical Lutheran Church as state church under its 1849 constitution, amended in 1953 to affirm its role amid democratic governance. Secular models, conversely, prioritize ideological pluralism, often leading to privatization of religion, as observed in post-Enlightenment shifts where state disestablishment reduced public religious observance by 20-30% in metrics like church attendance across Western Europe from 1960 to 2000.

Types of Christian State Configurations

Christian states exhibit diverse configurations shaped by historical, theological, and political developments, ranging from tight integration of and civil authority to looser endorsements of as the official religion. These configurations can be broadly classified into classical patterns derived from Reformation-era thought and practice, including Catholic, Lutheran, Reformed, and Erastian models, each defining the respective roles of church and state in fostering a . In the Catholic model, the church holds spiritual supremacy over the state, with papal authority extending to temporal rulers, as articulated in medieval papal bulls like (1302), which asserted the pope's power to depose kings for the sake of unified . Historical examples include the , where church governance directly administered territory until 1870. Modern remnants persist in , a sovereign under papal rule since 1929, where governs both religious and civil matters for its 800 residents. The Lutheran model emphasizes two distinct kingdoms—spiritual (church) and temporal (state)—with the state responsible for external order and punishing vice, while the church focuses on gospel proclamation, yet the state often appoints bishops and enforces confessional uniformity to prevent disorder. This configuration, rooted in Luther's interpretation of , historically manifested in Scandinavian kingdoms, where became the state faith post-1536 . retains the Evangelical Lutheran Folk Church as established, with 72% of the population as members in 2023, receiving state funding equivalent to 0.7% of GDP and the as titular head. Similarly, until its 2017 constitutional , Norway's Lutheran Church held establishment status with parliamentary oversight of doctrine. In the Reformed model, church and state cooperate as parallel institutions under Christ's lordship, with the state tasked to promote true religion, suppress heresy, and protect the church's purity, as seen in John Calvin's (1541–1564), where consistories enforced moral discipline alongside civil law. This pattern influenced confessional covenants like Scotland's (1638), binding state policy to Presbyterian orthodoxy. Modern echoes appear in countries like , which amended its in to declare itself a "Christian nation," mandating alignment of laws with biblical principles while preserving multiparty democracy and church autonomy. , with Christianity as state religion since 301 CE, integrates the [Armenian Apostolic Church](/page/Armenian_Apostolic Church) into national identity through constitutional privileges, though without full theocratic control. Erastianism represents a state-supremacist configuration, where civil authority subordinates the church in affairs to maintain order, named after Thomas Erastus's 16th-century arguments against without state consent. The exemplifies this, established by the 1534 Act of Supremacy making the monarch Supreme Governor, with Parliament regulating doctrine via acts like the 39 Articles (1571); as of 2023, it claims 26 million baptized members but faces declining attendance below 1% weekly. Greece's configuration blends Orthodox confessionalism with state oversight, designating the as prevailing religion in its 1975 , funding clergy salaries (about €200 million annually) while the state appoints metropolitans in some regions. These models often overlap in practice, as in Malta's Catholic confessional framework under 1964 independence , where the state cooperates via concordats but guarantees religious freedom. Empirical data from 27 countries with official or favored show varying enforcement: strict in Vatican (100% Catholic adherence required for citizenship) versus nominal in , where Catholicism is official per 1949 but legalized in 2017 amid 70% Catholic identification. Such configurations historically correlated with social cohesion metrics, like lower crime rates in established church nations pre-secularization, though causal links require disentangling from cultural confounders.

Historical Development

Early Adoption in Antiquity

The Kingdom of became the first polity to adopt as its official in 301 AD, when King Tiridates III converted following the missionary efforts of , who had been imprisoned for his faith but released to evangelize the realm. This adoption predated similar developments in larger empires and involved royal decree integrating Christian practices into governance, including the destruction of pagan temples and establishment of ecclesiastical authority under Gregory as . Archaeological evidence, such as fourth-century church ruins, corroborates the early institutionalization of in , distinguishing it from mere elsewhere. In the , Emperor Constantine I's personal conversion around 312 AD, reportedly influenced by a vision before the Battle of Milvian Bridge, marked a pivotal shift, though initial policies emphasized rather than exclusivity. The , jointly issued by Constantine and in 313 AD, granted legal status to , restored confiscated church properties, and ended imperial , allowing public worship and episcopal courts but permitting other cults. This edict reflected pragmatic governance amid civil strife, as Christianity's growing adherents—estimated at 10-20% of the population by the early fourth century—offered social cohesion, yet Constantine delayed baptism until his deathbed in 337 AD and convened the Council of Nicaea in 325 AD to resolve doctrinal disputes like without mandating uniformity. Full establishment as the state religion occurred under Emperor via the on February 27, 380 AD, co-signed by and , which decreed —the Trinitarian orthodoxy affirmed at —as the sole legitimate imperial faith, proscribing heresies and pagan practices under threat of divine and civil penalties. This edict integrated church hierarchy into state administration, with bishops influencing legislation and Theodosius enforcing orthodoxy through councils like in 381 AD, effectively fusing Roman imperial authority with Christian doctrine amid declining . Subsequent laws under Theodosius closed temples and banned sacrifices by 391-392 AD, consolidating Christianity's dominance in a realm spanning , , and the . Concurrently, the Kingdom of Aksum in adopted around 340-356 AD under Ezana, who inscribed Christian symbols on coins and stelae after conversion by missionary , establishing an Orthodox church tied to imperial legitimacy and trade networks. This move paralleled Armenia's but occurred in a peripheral reliant on commerce, where supplanted indigenous faiths without immediate Roman influence. In Caucasian Iberia (modern Georgia), royal conversion circa 337 AD under Mirian III similarly elevated to state status, fostering alliances with against Persian . These early adoptions in antiquity demonstrate 's appeal to monarchs seeking ideological unity and legitimacy amid geopolitical pressures, predating its enforcement in the Roman core.

Medieval and Byzantine Eras

In the , spanning the medieval period from roughly the 6th to 15th centuries, served as the official , with emperors wielding supreme authority over both secular and ecclesiastical domains under the doctrine of . This arrangement, most pronounced between the 6th and 10th centuries, enabled rulers to appoint the of , summon ecumenical councils, and dictate theological policies to preserve doctrinal harmony essential for imperial cohesion. Emperors positioned themselves as God's representatives on earth, integrating Orthodox into governance, military campaigns, and legal reforms to legitimize their rule and unify diverse subjects. Emperor (r. 527–565) epitomized this fusion by issuing the from 529 to 534, a comprehensive codification of that embedded Christian ethical and theological tenets, such as prohibitions on and emphasis on divine , thereby sacralizing the legal framework and affirming the empire's identity as a Christian . Subsequent emperors, like those during the Iconoclastic Controversy (726–843), continued intervening in church matters, though such actions sometimes provoked resistance from clergy and populace, highlighting tensions inherent in caesaropapist governance. and administration thus prioritized Orthodox fidelity, with deviations often met by imperial persecution, as seen in the suppression of . In , after the Western Roman Empire's collapse in 476, emerging Germanic kingdoms adopted as their , forging alliances between monarchs and the church to consolidate power. (r. 481–511), king of the , converted to Catholicism circa 496, forsaking prevalent among other Germanic tribes, which secured ecclesiastical support from Gallo-Roman bishops and accelerated the of Frankish territories, numbering over 3,000 parishes by the . This conversion marked a pivotal shift, enabling the to dominate rivals and position their realm as orthodoxy's vanguard. The under (r. 768–814) advanced this model, expanding a Christian empire across modern , , and , with forced baptisms and efforts converting Saxon pagans during campaigns from 772 to 804. 's as emperor by on December 25, 800, in symbolized the symbiosis of imperial and papal authority, establishing a where Christian informed , such as the Capitulary of Herstal (779) mandating church attendance and tithes. Parallel to monarchical developments, the crystallized as a theocratic entity in 756, when , fulfilling oaths to , donated conquered Lombard territories—including , the , and —totaling over 13,000 square kilometers, granting the papacy direct temporal rule and autonomy from Byzantine overlordship. This underpinned papal sovereignty until the , with popes exercising legislative, judicial, and military powers grounded in Christian canon law. The , evolving from Carolingian precedents, was revived under Otto I (r. 936–973), who defeated Magyar incursions at the in 955 and received imperial coronation from on February 2, 962, in , thereby institutionalizing a confederation of Christian principalities under an emperor tasked with protecting the faith. Otto's Privilegium Ottonianum (962) regulated church-state relations, affirming imperial oversight of ecclesiastical appointments while pledging defense of the , thus embedding Christian orthodoxy into the empire's constitutional fabric across 300 bishoprics and abbeys.

Reformation and Enlightenment Transitions

The Protestant Reformation, sparked by Martin Luther's Ninety-Five Theses on October 31, 1517, initiated a series of transitions in European states from Catholic dominance to Protestant confessional establishments, fragmenting the prior unity of Western Christendom and empowering secular rulers to redefine religious policy. In northern Europe, monarchs leveraged the movement to assert control over church assets and doctrine; Denmark's Christian III, after prevailing in the Count's War (1534–1536), enacted legislation on October 30, 1536, declaring Lutheranism the official religion and subordinating the church to the crown, with Catholic bishops imprisoned or exiled. Sweden's Gustav I Vasa began confiscating church properties in the 1520s amid rebellion against Danish rule, culminating in Lutheranism's formal adoption as the state religion through the 1527 Västerås Diet and reinforced by the 1593 Confession of Faith at the Uppsala Synod. In England, Henry VIII's Act of Supremacy, passed by Parliament on November 3, 1534, repudiated papal authority and positioned the monarch as Supreme Head of the Church of England, enabling the dissolution of monasteries and redirection of ecclesiastical revenues to the state. These changes, driven by fiscal motives and doctrinal disputes over indulgences and papal supremacy, established Protestant state churches in Scandinavia, England, and select German principalities, where rulers enforced uniformity through laws mandating adherence and suppressing Catholic practices. The ensuing religious wars, including the (1546–1547) and the (1618–1648), which killed an estimated 4–8 million in , compelled diplomatic resolutions that institutionalized confessional diversity while preserving state control over religion. The (1555) codified cuius regio, eius religio ("whose realm, his religion"), permitting princes to select Catholicism or for their territories, excluding and Anabaptists. This principle was expanded in the (1648 treaties signed October 24), recognizing , granting private worship rights to minorities in some cases, and affirming territorial sovereignty, thereby transitioning to a system of sovereign Christian states with official denominations but reduced papal interference. Catholic realms like , , and the Habsburg domains countered with the , reinforcing their confessional status through the (1545–1563) and the , yet the overall effect was a balkanized map of Lutheran, Reformed, and Catholic state churches, each backed by royal edicts and armies to maintain orthodoxy. The Enlightenment era (c. 1650–1800) introduced rationalist critiques of confessional exclusivity, advocating toleration based on natural rights and empirical reason, which gradually undermined the coercive elements of Christian state churches without immediate abolition in most cases. John Locke's (1689) argued that civil government should not enforce inward belief, influencing pragmatic reforms like England's Toleration Act (1689), which exempted Protestant dissenters from penalties for nonconformity while preserving Anglican . In absolutist states, rulers adopted selective pluralism for stability; of (r. 1740–1786) permitted Catholic and Jewish rights in his Protestant domain, declaring in 1740 that "in my lands... all religions are equal." Habsburg Emperor Joseph II's (1781) extended to Protestants and Jews in Catholic territories, affecting over 100,000 individuals by easing guild and marriage restrictions. These policies reflected a causal shift toward viewing as a private matter conducive to , rather than a state-enforced monopoly, though full dis lagged—France's revolutionary (1790) nationalized church property and elected bishops, preluding separation, while Scandinavian and British churches endured with eroding privileges into the . The era's emphasis on and , as in Voltaire's campaigns against , fostered meta-awareness of confessional biases, paving for later secular constitutions, yet retained Christian states' role in moral education and legitimacy amid rising .

Theological and Philosophical Foundations

Biblical and Scriptural Basis

The scriptural foundation for integrating Christian principles into state governance draws primarily from the 's depiction of as a under God's direct and the New Testament's affirmation of as divinely ordained. In the , Israel's polity exemplified a theocratic structure where served as the supreme king, with civil laws derived explicitly from divine revelation through , as outlined in the covenant at Sinai (Exodus 19:5-6). This system mandated the enforcement of God's and ceremonial laws by judges and later kings, who were instructed to rule in accordance with to ensure national righteousness and prosperity, as seen in Deuteronomy 17:18-20, which required kings to copy and study the law to avoid deviation. Although transitioned to amid warnings of human kings' potential tyranny (1 Samuel 8:4-22), the enduring model emphasized that true stability arose from alignment with , with Proverbs 14:34 stating, "Righteousness exalts a , but is a reproach to any people." This framework portrayed the state not as autonomous but as an instrument for upholding God's ethical order against and . The builds on this by recognizing civil government's legitimacy while subordinating it to God's ultimate authority. Paul's explicitly teaches that "there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God," positioning rulers as "God's servant, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer" (:1-4). This passage underscores the magistrate's role in promoting good and punishing evil, bearing the sword as a divine mandate, which extends to maintaining social order through moral enforcement. Similarly, 1 Peter 2:13-14 instructs submission "to every human institution" for the Lord's sake, viewing authorities as sent to punish wrongdoers and praise good conduct. ' directive to "render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's" (Matthew 22:21) acknowledges a legitimate civic sphere but implies its boundaries under . These texts do not envision government as religiously neutral but as accountable to God-ordained standards, with 1 Timothy 2:1-2 urging prayers for kings to enable godly living in peace. Reformed theological interpretations, rooted in these passages, further argue that Christian magistrates bear a duty to suppress false religion and heresies to preserve societal virtue, as the civil sword applies to both moral tables of the Decalogue—encompassing worship of the true alongside interpersonal ethics. , for instance, asserted that magistrates must "punish those whom brings to their hands" for blasphemies, viewing inaction against as negligence of their God-given office. The (1646), chapter 23, codifies this by charging civil rulers to "suppress all blasphemies and heresies" and reform corruptions in worship, ensuring the state's role in fostering a Christian without usurping functions. Such views contrast with later voluntarist interpretations that limit government to the second table, contending that scriptural precedents—from Israel's suppression of Canaanite to apostolic calls for punitive justice—necessitate active promotion of for communal flourishing. Critics within broader evangelical circles argue these duties apply only under ideal conditions, but the texts' emphasis on rulers as divine agents implies a confessional orientation where , as revealed truth, informs legal norms to avert societal decay.

Natural Law, Social Order, and Causal Realism

In Christian theological foundations, constitutes the rational apprehension of divine order imprinted on human nature, serving as the basis for just governance and societal stability. articulates this in the (c. 1265–1274), describing as the eternal law's participation by rational beings, which inclines humans toward innate goods including , and child-rearing, acquisition of , and orderly communal life. These precepts, discernible through unaided reason yet perfected by , demand that human neither contradict nor exceed them, thereby ensuring legislation promotes the rather than arbitrary power. This natural law framework sustains social order by positing a teleological structure to human associations, where institutions like the family and polity exist to actualize inherent ends aligned with God's rational governance. Aquinas grounds social duties in these inclinations, viewing civil society as essential for mutual aid and virtue cultivation, with authority deriving legitimacy from service to the whole rather than coercion alone. In practice, Christian states historically derived legal norms from this order, as seen in medieval canon law's integration of natural principles to regulate contracts, property, and justice, fostering cohesion through shared moral realism over individualistic relativism. Causal realism complements this by affirming causation as an objective feature of , irreducible to mere patterns or human constructs, with effects tracing to structured powers including final ends oriented toward the divine. Aquinas adapts Aristotle's —material (substrate), formal (essence), efficient (agent), and final (purpose)—to Christian metaphysics, explaining social phenomena as outcomes of agents acting in accord with their God-given natures. Deviation from inclinations disrupts this chain, yielding disorder, while conformity yields flourishing; for instance, prioritizing familial procreation over transient pursuits correlates with demographic stability in historically regimes. Christian thus intervenes causally by reinforcing virtuous habits, recognizing that moral formation, not neutral proceduralism, underpins enduring order./01:_Chapters/1.05:_CHAPTER_4_AQUINASS_NATURAL_LAW_THEORY)

Critiques of Secular Alternatives from First Principles

Secular governance frameworks, by privileging human autonomy over divine ordinance, fail to establish a stable foundation for moral and legal order, as they derive authority from contingent social contracts or rational consensus rather than the immutable imprinted on creation. From foundational reasoning, any system must account for the teleological nature of human beings—ends oriented toward truth, goodness, and ultimate fulfillment—which abstracts away by treating persons as atomized individuals whose emerge from , prone to erosion when majorities shift. counters this by integrating , discernible through reason yet rooted in God's rational governance of the universe, ensuring laws align with human flourishing rather than mere preference aggregation. This deficiency manifests in secular states' inability to proscribe intrinsic evils without appealing to arbitrary utility, as seen in evolving definitions of that prioritize equality of outcomes over equity under objective standards. A core critique lies in secularism's inadequate , which presumes human rationality sufficient for without transcendent , overlooking the pervasive effects of disordered will and ignorance that undermine collective decision-making. First-principles analysis reveals that societies require not just procedural neutrality but substantive virtues—, temperance, —nurtured by alignment with the created order, where provides corrective revelation against reason's fallibility. Secular alternatives, in denying or equivalent constraints on human nature, foster illusions of progress through state intervention, inverting by centralizing power in bureaucracies that supplant familial and communal responsibilities. Historical precedents, such as the French Revolution's de-Christianization campaigns from onward, illustrate how severing from divine foundations invites totalitarian overreach, as authority vacuums invite to enforce cohesion absent shared moral priors. Furthermore, secularism's commitment to value-neutrality belies its own ideological commitments, imposing a materialist ontology that marginalizes metaphysical realities essential for causal coherence in . Reasoning from basics, effective must recognize in affairs—where actions yield foreseeable outcomes tied to ontological truths—yet secular frameworks often prioritize ideological experimentation over fidelity to ends, such as the procreative family structure evident in biological . rectifies this by subordinating state power to higher , preventing the instrumentalization of persons for abstract ideals, as critiqued in analyses of humanism's unsubstantiated elevation of dignity sans grounding. In practice, this leads to inconsistencies, like affirming bodily in some domains while mandating interventions in others, eroding when principles prove malleable to elite consensus rather than enduring verities.

Current and Former Christian States

European and North Atlantic Examples

maintains the Evangelical Lutheran Church as its established under Section 4 of the 1953 , which states it shall be supported by the state, with the obligated to belong to it. This configuration funds salaries and church operations through taxes, though regular attendance remains low at approximately 2-3% of the population weekly. Despite nominal membership exceeding 70%, the arrangement preserves Christianity's role in state ceremonies and national identity. In England, the holds established status, with the serving as Supreme Governor and 26 bishops sitting in the . This dates to the 16th-century settlements, entailing ary oversight of doctrine and state involvement in ecclesiastical appointments. The church conducts royal events and provides parish rights to baptisms, marriages, and burials, though active participation hovers below 2% weekly among adherents. Greece designates the Eastern Orthodox Church as the prevailing religion in Article 3 of its 1975 Constitution (revised 2008), acknowledging Jesus Christ as head and mandating respect for its doctrines. The state funds Orthodox clergy and education incorporates Orthodox theology, reflecting historical symbiosis since Byzantine times, with over 90% of Greeks identifying as Orthodox despite varying observance levels. Iceland's establishes the Evangelical Lutheran Church as the state church, protected and supported by the , which allocates about 0.1% of GDP to it via membership taxes. Covering roughly 60% of the population nominally, it integrates into civic life through national holidays and broadcasting, though weekly attendance is under 10%. Malta's 1964 Constitution declares the Roman Catholic Apostolic Religion as the in Article 2, granting the church authority in and moral matters while ensuring for other faiths. With over 90% Catholic adherence, the state funds Catholic schools and integrates religious instruction, underscoring Catholicism's foundational role post-independence. Among former examples, Norway disestablished its Lutheran Church of Norway in 2012 through constitutional amendments, ending state appointment of bishops and parliamentary representation while retaining funding and cultural privileges. Prior to this, the 1814 Constitution had enshrined Lutheranism as the public religion, reflecting confessional statehood until secular pressures prompted separation. Similar disestablishments occurred in Sweden (2000) and Finland (partial for Lutheran and Orthodox churches), shifting from formal ties to contractual state support amid declining religiosity. These transitions illustrate a pattern in Northern Europe where historical Christian establishments yield to pluralistic frameworks, yet legacies persist in legal holidays and social ethics.

Latin American and Caribbean Examples

maintains the Roman Catholic and Apostolic religion as the official , as stipulated in Article 75 of its 1949 Constitution (revised 2011), which mandates state contributions to the Church's maintenance while guaranteeing freedom of other worship forms. This arrangement, unique in the Americas, dates to the country's post-independence era and reflects Catholicism's enduring cultural and institutional dominance, with the state allocating approximately 13% of its budget to religious purposes, predominantly Catholic, as of recent audits. The with the , signed in 1954, further formalizes privileges such as tax exemptions and diplomatic status for the Church hierarchy. Historically, Latin American states emerging from Spanish and colonial rule in the early frequently enshrined Catholicism as the exclusive in their foundational constitutions, prohibiting public exercise of other faiths to preserve social cohesion amid struggles led by Catholic elites. This model, inherited from the system granting monarchs ecclesiastical oversight, persisted variably until liberal reforms and anticlerical movements prompted disestablishments, often tied to political upheavals; for example, in , President Perón's 1954 threats of full separation highlighted tensions but ultimately reinforced Church influence without immediate abolition. By the mid-20th century, secular constitutions in nations like (1917) and (1918) enforced strict separation, eroding formal ties amid rising and . In the Caribbean, no independent states currently uphold an established Christian church, though colonial legacies imposed Anglicanism as the official in British territories and Catholicism in French and Spanish holdings until post-emancipation reforms. constitutions from the onward, such as Jamaica's 1962 document, adopted secular frameworks emphasizing religious freedom, reflecting diverse ethnic influences and declining denominational monopolies despite Christianity's majority status (over 70% in most islands as of 2020 surveys). Historical missions, including Moravian and Methodist expansions post-1740, fostered Protestant pluralism but without state endorsement in sovereign entities.

Oceanic and African Examples

In Africa, the Kingdom of Aksum (encompassing modern-day northern and ) adopted as its in the mid-4th century under King Ezana, who inscribed crosses on coins and erected stelae bearing Christian symbols following his conversion around 330 AD, marking one of the earliest instances of official Christian adoption globally. This establishment endured through successive Ethiopian empires, with the serving as the dominant institution until the 1974 Marxist revolution under secularized the state, ending formal ties despite remaining the faith of approximately 43% of the population. In contemporary times, stands as the sole African to explicitly declare itself a Christian , with President proclaiming this status on December 29, 1991, citing the profession of by over 70% of citizens as a basis for governance guided by biblical principles. This declaration was enshrined in the preamble of the 1996 , though the document upholds religious freedom and prohibits discrimination, reflecting a orientation without coercive establishment. Among Oceanic nations, maintains —specifically the Congregational Church of Tuvalu—as its official , a status rooted in the 's endorsement of Protestant traditions dominant since arrivals in the , with over 90% of the population adhering to Christian denominations. amended its in June 2017 to affirm the state as "based on Christian principles and Samoan customs," formalizing a longstanding cultural integration of , which claims about 98% of the populace, amid efforts to reinforce social cohesion in a multi-denominational context. , with a 95% Christian majority, passed a in March 2025 declaring the nation a Christian , aiming to align with biblical values while navigating denominational diversity and opposition from some wary of implying a singular state church. These examples illustrate varied implementations, from entrenched historical monarchies to modern parliamentary affirmations, often balancing confessional identity with pluralism in post-colonial settings.

Unique Cases: Vatican City and Microstates

, encompassing 0.44 square kilometers and home to roughly 800 residents mostly comprising clergy, religious orders, and lay workers, functions as an absolute theocratic under the Pope's supreme authority. Formalized as a sovereign entity via the signed on February 11, 1929, between the and , it resolves prior territorial disputes and guarantees the Holy See's independence to exercise spiritual jurisdiction over the global . Roman Catholicism constitutes the sole operative religion, with ecclesiastical law integral to governance; non-Catholics, including diplomats, are permitted but cannot proselytize or establish alternative worship sites. This structure embodies a direct fusion of church and state unparalleled elsewhere, prioritizing the Pope's dual role as temporal ruler and bishop of . European microstates such as and exemplify rare contemporary instances where Catholicism holds explicit constitutional status as the , distinguishing them from larger nations with disestablished churches. 's 1962 Constitution, in Article 9, affirms the Catholic, Apostolic, and Roman as the state's , mandating Catholic in public schools and reserving high ecclesiastical offices like the Archbishop's advisory role to the Prince. Covering 2.02 square kilometers with approximately 39,000 inhabitants, the principality enforces blasphemy laws until their repeal in recent years and integrates Catholic rites into official ceremonies, though freedom of worship is constitutionally protected for minorities. 's 1921 Constitution, Article 37, designates the Roman Catholic Church as the State Church with full state protection, while permitting other confessions to operate; the document invokes in its preamble, and Catholic fidelity guides the princely family's governance traditions. Spanning 160 square kilometers with about 39,000 residents, this setup supports state funding for Catholic institutions and reflects historical confessional allegiance amid . San Marino and Andorra, though lacking a declared , sustain institutional Catholic privileges that underscore their unique confessional legacies in governance. In , over 90% of the 34,000 population identifies as Catholic, with a 2008 ensuring Catholic religious instruction's parity in schools and state recognition of Catholic holidays; the republic's founding myth ties to , embedding Christian patrimony without formal establishment. Andorra's 1993 Constitution grants the Catholic Church special status per tradition, while one co-prince remains the of Urgell, affording the Church influence over the 468 square kilometer realm's 80,000 residents, including rights in certain matters and state subsidies for Catholic activities. These arrangements, rooted in medieval pacts, preserve Christianity's ceremonial and advisory roles despite secular legal frameworks and minority faiths' protections.

Established and National Churches

Current State Churches

In contemporary , a handful of nations retain established Christian churches, where specific denominations receive state recognition, financial support through taxation, and ceremonial roles in , though practical influence has waned amid . These arrangements trace to historical reforms but persist via constitutional provisions, often with the state collecting church taxes and bishops or holding reserved parliamentary seats. As of 2024, membership in these churches varies widely, from majorities in to nominal adherence elsewhere, reflecting cultural rather than devout affiliation in many cases. The holds established status uniquely in (not the broader ), with the British monarch as Supreme Governor since the Act of Supremacy in 1558, reconfirmed in subsequent legislation. Its 26 senior bishops, known as , occupy reserved seats in the , influencing legislation on moral and social issues. The church receives no direct state funding beyond historic endowments but benefits from state-maintained cathedrals and voluntary taxes via local authorities; approximately 14 million people, or 46% of 's population, were baptized members as of 2023, though active attendance hovers below 1%. Denmark's Evangelical Lutheran Church, or Folkekirken, functions as the state church under the 1849 Constitution, with the as nominal head and the state allocating about 0.7% of GDP in tax revenues—collected via a mandatory "" on members—for its operations. Parishes handle civil functions like burials, and the church conducts royal ceremonies; as of 2025, it claims 70.7% membership among 's 5.9 million people, yet weekly attendance is around 2-3%, indicating ceremonial rather than participatory dominance. Iceland's maintains status per the 1874 Constitution revision, with state funding covering 72% of its budget from national taxes and oversight by the ; the consecrates the president in a hybrid civil-religious rite. It serves 57% of Iceland's 387,000 residents as members in 2023, supporting social welfare amid low active participation. Finland recognizes two national churches—the Evangelical Lutheran Church (62% membership in 2024) and the Finnish Orthodox Church (1.1%)—with special constitutional status entailing state-collected voluntary taxes, reserved parliamentary influence, and military chaplaincy roles, though disestablishment discussions persist. The Lutheran church, with 3.5 million adherents, manages 90% of funerals and receives €100 million annually in state aid. Greece's Orthodox Church of Greece enjoys "prevailing religion" status under the 1975 Constitution (Article 3), with state payment of clergy salaries (about €250 million yearly) and property tax exemptions; autocephalous since 1833, it influences education and holidays for 90% of the 10.4 million population identifying as Orthodox, though synod elections involve government approval. Malta's Constitution (Article 2) designates Roman Catholicism as the state religion, obligating Catholic instruction in public schools (with opt-outs) and granting the church legal precedence in marriage and oaths; 83% of 542,000 Maltese identify as Catholic, with the state funding archdiocesan activities amid 92% nominal adherence but declining Mass attendance. Liechtenstein's Constitution (Article 37) affirms Roman Catholicism as the state church, providing full protection and subsidies; 70% of 39,000 residents are Catholic, with the prince's coronation oath referencing faith, though religious freedom is upheld. Beyond , Tuvalu's Congregational Christian Church of Tuvalu acts as the state church, dominating education, media, and oaths for 98% of 11,000 citizens, with constitutional nods to Christian principles despite formal separation claims.
CountryEstablished Church/DenominationKey PrivilegesMembership (% of Population, Recent)
(UK)Church of England (Anglican)Lords Spiritual seats; royal governance~46% baptized (2023)
Folkekirken (Evangelical Lutheran)Tax funding; civil roles70.7% (2025)
(Evangelical Lutheran)State budget allocation; ceremonies57% (2023)
Evangelical Lutheran & Orthodox ChurchesTax collection; state aid62% Lutheran (2024)
(Eastern Orthodox)Clergy salaries; educational influence~90% (nominal)
Roman Catholic ChurchSchool instruction; legal precedence83% (2023)
Roman Catholic ChurchSubsidies; constitutional protection70% (2020)
(Congregational Christian)Social/political dominance~98% (nominal)
These examples illustrate residual establishments yielding social cohesion metrics like lower divorce rates in Nordic cases, per empirical studies, without coercive enforcement.

Disestablished Churches and Their Legacies

The disestablishment of churches formerly linked to the state has occurred in several European contexts, severing formal ties such as mandatory tithes, state appointments of , and official religious privileges while often preserving informal cultural roles. In Ireland, the was disestablished effective January 1, 1871, under the , which transferred much of its property to the state for secular uses like and , yet the church adapted by reorganizing financially and emphasizing voluntary support, leading to a renewed sense of independence and mission as an Episcopal body. Similarly, in , the Anglican Church was disestablished on March 31, 1920, via the , which ended its integration with the and devolved governance to a new , allowing bishops to be elected by representative bodies rather than appointed by ; this shift, delayed by , enabled greater doctrinal flexibility and local control, with some contemporaries viewing it as a "" for fostering amid a predominantly Nonconformist population. In , the Evangelical Lutheran underwent disestablishment on January 1, 2000, through constitutional reforms that eliminated state oversight of doctrine, removed the monarch's role in selections, and equalized all denominations under the Religious Denominations Act, though the church retained administrative duties like registration until 1991 and continues to manage about 3,400 buildings and ceremonies such as state funerals. This separation coincided with accelerated membership decline—from 95% of the in 1930 to around 53% by 2023—but preserved its role in welfare services and cultural events, with lingering political influences evident in elections open to non-members. 's followed suit with constitutional amendments ratified in 2012 and full implementation by 2017, ending its status as the "folk church" enshrined since 1814, prohibiting government participation in and dean appointments, and framing as one of multiple recognized faiths; this prompted internal institutional work to redefine organizational identity, emphasizing autonomy while maintaining societal functions like and crisis response. Legacies of these disestablishments include sustained contributions to social cohesion and moral frameworks, even as formal privileges waned; for instance, the , now representing about 3% of Ireland's population, continues to operate schools and charitable institutions, drawing on endowments rebuilt post-1871 without state compulsion. In , the disestablished church administers over 1,000 parishes and plays ceremonial roles in national events, with its voluntary model correlating to stable numbers and community engagement despite secular pressures. Scandinavian cases reveal mixed outcomes: Sweden's church, post-2000, handles 80% of funerals and provides diaconal aid to over 100,000 annually, yet faces criticism for diluted theological focus amid high nominal affiliation (low active participation at under 2% weekly attendance). Norway's church, with 64% membership in 2023, adapted by enhancing democratic structures internally, preserving cultural influence on holidays and while navigating reduced state funding, which dropped from automatic allocations to negotiated grants. Across these, disestablishment facilitated adaptation to pluralism but did not halt broader secularization trends, as evidenced by consistent declines in religious practice predating and persisting after separation, underscoring causal factors like and over institutional status alone.

Empirical Outcomes and Achievements

Social Stability and Moral Frameworks

Christian moral frameworks in state-endorsed contexts have emphasized absolute ethical standards derived from biblical teachings, such as the Ten Commandments, which prohibit , , and , thereby establishing a foundation for consistent legal codes that deterred antisocial behavior and fostered communal trust. These principles promoted the sanctity of life and property rights, contrasting with pre-Christian pagan practices that often tolerated and vendettas, leading to a causal reduction in interpersonal violence as spread across from the onward. Sociologist contends that Christianity's doctrine of universal love and care for the vulnerable—evident in early Christian communities' support for widows, orphans, and plague victims—built resilient social networks that enhanced societal stability by increasing survival rates and mutual aid during crises, outcompeting pagan systems lacking such systematic compassion. Empirical data links religious adherence, often reinforced in Christian states through established churches, to lower rates and greater . A of studies on and found a consistent inverse relationship, with religious involvement—via mechanisms like enhanced and social bonds—reducing delinquency and adult criminality across diverse populations. In historical contexts, correlated with declining rates in ; for instance, pre-Christian Germanic tribes exhibited rates exceeding 100 per 100,000 annually, dropping significantly post-conversion as church-enforced oaths and penalties curbed feuds. Modern analyses of Christian-majority regions with state religious support, such as pre-secularization , show that church-promoted norms sustained lower and community cohesion, even as formal ties weakened. County-level data from the U.S., analogous to state-influenced religious contexts, indicate higher religious adherence directly associates with reduced reoffending, underscoring 's role in moral deterrence independent of secular enforcement. Regarding family stability, Christian states' endorsement of sacramental as indissoluble provided a bulwark against familial dissolution, historically yielding lower rates compared to non-Christian polities. In , where the Anglican Church served as established until partial reforms, biblical views on covenantal contributed to marital persistence rates exceeding 80% in the , predating modern welfare expansions. , a proxy for state-reinforced , remains the strongest predictor of marital happiness and stability, with regular practitioners 35% less likely to , as evidenced in longitudinal studies of religious households. In Nordic examples like and , which maintained Lutheran state churches into the late 20th century, legacy Christian norms supported family units despite rising ; pre-1960s rates hovered below 1 per 1,000, contrasting with post-secular spikes to 2-3 per 1,000, yet overall social trust and low illegitimacy persisted due to ingrained ethical frameworks. This suggests Christian legacies buffer against instability, promoting intergenerational stability through emphasis on paternal responsibility and child welfare, as seen in lower youth delinquency among religiously observant cohorts.

Economic and Cultural Contributions

In historical Christian states, such as the Byzantine Empire and medieval European kingdoms, the integration of Christianity with governance fostered economic stability by promoting ethical norms that reduced transaction costs and state enforcement needs; for instance, Christian doctrines emphasizing charity and mutual aid correlated with lower reliance on policing, as evidenced by Emperor Constantine's adoption of Christianity around 312 AD partly for its behavioral incentives that minimized social disorder. Monasteries under state-supported churches advanced agricultural techniques, including crop rotation and water mills, contributing to population growth and surplus production in regions like Carolingian Francia from the 8th to 10th centuries, where Benedictine orders disseminated these innovations across estates comprising up to one-third of arable land. The establishment of universities by the in Christian states laid foundational for economic advancement; between 1088 () and the 15th century, over 30 major universities in , including (c. 1096), (c. 1150), and (1209), were chartered under papal authority, training clergy, lawyers, and administrators who enabled complex trade networks, legal systems, and bureaucratic efficiency in realms like the . These institutions preserved and expanded knowledge from antiquity, facilitating proto-capitalist developments such as credit mechanisms pioneered by religious orders like the Knights Templar in 12th-century , which handled international banking for pilgrims and monarchs. Empirical analyses indicate that religious adherence, prevalent in such states, positively correlates with GDP growth rates, with studies across 150+ countries showing a 0.5-1% annual uplift from core Christian beliefs fostering and trust, though causality involves confounding factors like institutional inheritance. Culturally, Christian states sponsored monumental architecture and that defined epochs; Gothic cathedrals, such as (begun 1194) and (1163-1345), commissioned by monarchs and bishops in and , exemplified engineering feats with flying buttresses supporting vast stained-glass narratives of scripture, influencing urban development and precursors. Papal patronage in , a Christian state under the Holy See's influence, funded works like Michelangelo's frescoes (1508-1512), blending theology with humanism to advance perspective and anatomy in art. In music, state churches cultivated and ; composers like Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750), employed by Lutheran principalities in the , produced over 1,100 compositions rooted in Lutheran liturgy, establishing Western classical forms that persist in concert repertoires. Literature flourished under Christian state through scriptural and vernacular translations; the King James (1611), authorized by the , standardized English prose and influenced legal and poetic traditions in Britain, while Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy (c. 1320), composed in the Guelph-Ghibelline context of medieval , integrated Thomistic with epic narrative, shaping national literatures. These outputs, often state-endorsed, preserved classical texts in monastic scriptoria during the early medieval period, enabling the under (r. 768-814), where uniform scripts and curricula disseminated knowledge empire-wide.

Comparative Data on Governance Metrics

Countries with established Christian churches, such as , , and , consistently rank among the top performers in assessments, including low perceived , high government effectiveness, and robust . These metrics, drawn from the World Bank's (WGI) for 2023 and Transparency International's (CPI) for 2024, reflect percentile ranks where higher values indicate better performance relative to other countries. For instance, 's WGI control of corruption score places it in the 100th percentile, while its CPI score of 90 out of 100 ranks it first globally. Similar patterns hold for (CPI 88, rank 2) and (CPI 74, rank 12), where state-supported Lutheran churches coexist with strong institutional accountability. In contrast, and , with Orthodox and Catholic establishments respectively, score lower but still exceed the global CPI average of 43. 's CPI of 49 (rank 59) and 's 51 (rank 51) align with Mediterranean peers, potentially influenced by factors beyond religious establishment, such as economic pressures post-2008. The , with the as established in England, achieves a CPI of 71 (rank 20), underscoring effective governance amid partial disestablishment in and . , post-2012 disestablishment of the , maintains a CPI of 81 (tied rank 5), suggesting enduring cultural legacies from prior confessional ties.
CountryEstablished ChurchCPI 2024 Score (Rank)WGI Government Effectiveness 2023 (Percentile)WGI Rule of Law 2023 (Percentile)WGI Control of Corruption 2023 (Percentile)
Evangelical Lutheran90 (1)100100100
Evangelical Lutheran & Orthodox88 (2)99100100
(former)81 (5)999999
(Lutheran)74 (12)989898
71 (20)959495
Roman Catholic51 (51)888585
Greek Orthodox49 (59)767272
These outcomes challenge theoretical assertions that state religious involvement inherently undermines governance quality, as from Protestant-established states indicates causal links to ethical norms fostering transparency and stability, absent in more intrusive theocratic models. Social trust, bolstered by state-supported religious institutions, correlates positively with these metrics in Christian-majority contexts. Globally, such countries outperform the WGI medians (e.g., 50th across dimensions), attributing part of their success to historical Protestant influences emphasizing personal responsibility and institutional integrity.

Criticisms, Controversies, and Rebuttals

Secularist and Enlightenment Critiques

Enlightenment philosophers, emphasizing reason and individual liberty, frequently condemned the fusion of Christian doctrine with state authority as a barrier to human progress and personal freedom. , in his 1689 , asserted that civil government exists solely to secure temporal goods like property and safety, lacking jurisdiction over religious belief, which he deemed a matter of private conviction impervious to coercion. He warned that state-enforced religion inevitably breeds hypocrisy and persecution, drawing on the 1685 revocation of the , which displaced over 200,000 and fueled religious wars across Europe, totaling an estimated 8 million deaths from 1524 to 1648. Locke's critique stemmed from observations of Anglican dominance in and Calvinist rigidity in , where dissenters faced exile or execution, arguing such establishments corrupted both church and state by prioritizing uniformity over genuine piety. Voltaire, writing amid France's absolutist intertwined with Catholicism, lambasted the "alliance of throne and altar" for perpetuating and clerical tyranny, as detailed in his 1764 Philosophical Dictionary, where he ridiculed priests as exploiters wielding state-backed power to suppress inquiry. He advocated emulating England's post-1689 Toleration Act, which granted limited freedoms to non-Anglicans, viewing —the French church's subordination to —as a mechanism for arbitrary rule rather than moral guidance, evidenced by the church's role in upholding feudal privileges until the 1789 Revolution. Voltaire's deistic leanings, shaped by his 1717 imprisonment partly for satirical attacks on , framed Christian establishments as relics obstructing scientific advancement, citing delays in accepting due to ecclesiastical opposition, such as Galileo's 1633 condemnation. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, while proposing a minimal "civil religion" in his 1762 Social Contract to foster civic virtue, critiqued historical Christian states for clerical corruption and doctrinal divisiveness that undermined social cohesion. He argued that established churches, like the Catholic hierarchy in pre-Revolutionary , prioritized temporal power over spiritual ends, leading to intolerance exemplified by the 16th-century , which killed up to 30,000 . Rousseau's views reflected disillusionment with Geneva's Calvinist , where he was expelled in 1762 for Emile's naturalistic theology, positing that state religions stifled the general will by enforcing creeds incompatible with rational consensus. Later secularists extended these arguments, contending that Christian state religions inherently privilege one faith, eroding pluralism and rational governance. Thomas Paine, in his 1791–1792 The Age of Reason, denounced biblical foundations of establishments as irrational fables propounded by self-interested clergy, urging separation to avert theocratic tyranny observed in Spain's Inquisition, which executed over 3,000 and imprisoned tens of thousands from 1478 to 1834. Modern secular analyses, such as those in legal scholarship, maintain that state endorsement of Christianity imposes non-neutral moral codes, potentially discriminating against non-believers, as seen in historical U.S. blasphemy laws upheld until the 1950s, though often selectively enforced. These critiques, while rooted in empirical instances of abuse, frequently overlook contexts where Christian states, like medieval England, sponsored universities such as Oxford (founded 1096) that advanced learning under ecclesiastical patronage, suggesting selective emphasis driven by anti-religious presuppositions among many proponents.

Religious Liberty and Minority Rights Debates

In Christian states featuring established or favored churches, debates over religious liberty and minority rights often hinge on the tension between symbolic or institutional endorsement of Christianity and guarantees of equal treatment for non-adherents. Critics from secular and human rights perspectives argue that such establishments foster implicit favoritism, correlating with elevated government restrictions on religious practices, as documented in Pew Research Center analyses where nations with official religions exhibit a median Government Restrictions Index (GRI) score of 4.8, higher than the 1.8 for religiously neutral states. This favoritism manifests in privileges like state funding, tax exemptions, or cultural dominance for the established denomination, potentially marginalizing minorities by signaling their secondary status and enabling policies that disproportionately burden alternative faiths. Specific cases illustrate these concerns. In Greece, the Greek Orthodox Church's status as the "prevailing religion" under the constitution grants it unique legal entity recognition and influence over education and public life, contributing to documented discrimination against Muslim minorities in Thrace, including interference in religious autonomy, physical violence, and barriers to mosque construction or imam appointments. The U.S. Department of State's 2023 International Religious Freedom Report notes ongoing verbal harassment and unequal treatment for Jehovah's Witnesses and evangelicals, attributing some issues to the Orthodox Church's societal influence. Similarly, Denmark's Evangelical Lutheran Church enjoys constitutional recognition and state support, yet policies such as the 2021 sermon translation mandate and restrictions on ritual slaughter or face coverings—framed as cultural assimilation—have been criticized for targeting Muslim minorities, despite Article 70's explicit freedom protections. Humanists International highlights these as part of a pattern of unequal regulations, though Denmark's GRI of 4.2 remains moderate globally. Proponents of establishment counter that it does not inherently erode liberties, emphasizing of coexistence with strong protections. In the , the Church of England's established status coexists with the and , which safeguard minority practices; the UK's GRI of 2.9 falls below the global average of 3.0, with minorities like and freely operating places of worship and schools. Nordic examples, including and (GRI 2.6), demonstrate low overall hostilities and high rankings in broader freedom indices, attributing any tensions to dynamics rather than church establishment per se. Advocates, drawing on historical precedents like post-Reformation in Protestant states, assert that Christianity's doctrinal emphasis on —evident in constitutional evolutions since the —facilitates pluralism without disestablishment, as state churches primarily preserve heritage rather than coerce belief. These states' track records, with minimal persecution and active minority communities, rebut claims of systemic incompatibility, though debates persist amid rising secular pressures and cultural integration challenges.

Internal Christian and Denominational Conflicts

In Christian states where a particular denomination was established by law, internal conflicts frequently arose from the suppression or marginalization of dissenting Christian groups, exacerbating theological divisions into violent confrontations intertwined with political ambitions. The Protestant Reformation, beginning in 1517, fragmented Western Christendom into Catholic and various Protestant camps, prompting rulers to enforce confessional uniformity to consolidate power, which in turn ignited civil strife. These denominational clashes, often termed Wars of Religion, resulted in millions of deaths across Europe between the 16th and 17th centuries, with religion serving as both a genuine doctrinal fault line and a proxy for territorial and dynastic rivalries. Empirical estimates attribute 5.5 to 18.5 million fatalities to these conflicts collectively, driven by battles, famines, and epidemics, underscoring the causal link between state-enforced orthodoxy and escalated intra-Christian violence. The (1562–1598) exemplify how monarchical support for Catholicism clashed with growing (Calvinist Protestant) communities, comprising about 10% of the population by the 1560s. Eight successive civil wars pitted Catholic leagues, backed by the , against forces under leaders like the Prince de Condé, with the state alternating between tolerance edicts and repression under weak regencies. The 1572 , initiated by Catherine de' Medici's faction, killed 2,000 to 3,000 in alone, sparking nationwide reprisals and prolonging the wars until Henry IV's in 1598 granted limited Protestant rights. Revocation of the edict in 1685 by led to further exodus and underground resistance, demonstrating how state revocation of denominational concessions reignited suppressed tensions. These conflicts weakened economically and demographically, with total deaths estimated in the hundreds of thousands, though precise figures remain debated due to incomplete records. The (1618–1648) in the began as a denominational revolt when Protestant Bohemian nobles defenestrated Catholic Habsburg officials, challenging the Catholic restoration efforts post- (1555), which had allowed rulers to impose their faith (). Escalating into a Europe-wide conflagration involving Lutheran, Calvinist, and Catholic states, the war saw interventions by Sweden's on the Protestant side and France's aiding Protestants against Habsburgs despite his Catholicism, revealing pragmatic state interests overlaying religious pretexts. Casualties reached 4.5 to 8 million, including 20% of the German population lost to war, disease, and starvation, with religious motivations fueling early phases but giving way to territorial grabs by the war's end in the (1648), which institutionalized multi-denominational coexistence within states. This treaty marked a causal shift toward state over , reducing but not eliminating future confessional clashes. In , the established Anglican Church under monarchs like James I and Charles I provoked conflicts with Puritan reformers and Presbyterians seeking doctrinal purity, culminating in the English Civil Wars (1642–1651). Parliamentarian forces, dominated by Calvinist-leaning Independents and Presbyterians, opposed Charles I's perceived Arminian (high-church Anglican) tendencies and his alliances with Scottish , who resisted episcopal governance. Religious grievances, including the 1637 Scottish riots, intertwined with absolutism debates, leading to Charles's execution in 1649 and Oliver Cromwell's Puritan Commonwealth, which suppressed Anglicans and radical sects like . The wars claimed around 200,000 lives in , about 4% of the population, with Restoration in 1660 reinstating Anglican supremacy but enacting penal laws against nonconformists until the Toleration Act of 1689. These episodes illustrate how internal denominational pressures within an established church could destabilize the state, prompting cycles of repression and partial liberalization. Such conflicts highlight a recurring pattern in Christian states: doctrinal enforcement by the ruling denomination bred resentment and among minorities, often amplified by state like inquisitions or forced conversions, though empirical analysis reveals that purely theological disputes alone rarely sustained violence without political catalysts. In Eastern Orthodox realms, like the Byzantine Empire's controversies (726–843), imperial decrees alternating between icon veneration and destruction sparked monastic and clerical revolts, but these were more contained than Western schisms. Overall, these intra-Christian struggles contributed to the gradual erosion of uniform confessional states, fostering pragmatic accommodations that prioritized civil order over theological absolutism.

Decline, Secularization, and Prospects

Historical Patterns of Erosion

The erosion of Christian state establishments in followed patterns of gradual legal and cultural diminishment, often accelerated by political upheavals, liberal reforms, and rising rather than abrupt collapses. Following the in 1648, which enshrined the principle, numerous states formalized confessional churches—such as Lutheran in and Anglican in Britain—granting them monopolistic privileges including tithes, state funding, and influence over education and law. However, by the late , Enlightenment critiques of ecclesiastical authority, exemplified in Voltaire's Philosophical Dictionary (1764) and the American Revolution's emphasis on religious liberty in the (1786), began undermining these structures by promoting separation as a safeguard against tyranny. In the 19th century, disestablishments clustered around nationalist and democratic movements, particularly where established churches represented minority or imported faiths amid shifting demographics. The Irish Church Act of 1869 disestablished the , ending its collection of tithes from a predominantly Catholic population and severing ties with the , as the Anglican church comprised only about 13% of Ireland's residents by 1861 data; this reform, driven by Liberal Prime Minister William Gladstone, reflected broader pressures from Irish Home Rule agitation and non-conformist Protestant critiques of privilege. Similarly, in , anticlerical Republicans, building on the Revolution's —which subordinated the to state control—culminated in the 1905 Law on the Separation of Churches and State, which revoked the 1801 , nationalized church property, and mandated state neutrality, amid scandals like the that fueled perceptions of clerical aligning with . These cases illustrate a causal where established churches' ties to unpopular ruling elites eroded support during democratization, leading to legislative severance of financial and jurisdictional links. The saw further erosion in Protestant strongholds, often through incremental reforms rather than revolution, as urbanization and compulsory diluted and cultural dominance. In , the was disestablished in 1920 via the Welsh Church Act of 1914 (effective post-World War I), transferring revenues to secular uses and reflecting Nonconformist majorities (over 70% of Welsh Protestants by 1900) who resented Anglican privileges imposed from . Scandinavian states, long exemplars of Lutheran establishment, underwent late disestablishments: Sweden's separated formally in 2000 after decades of reforms starting with 1951 dissenter laws allowing exit without joining another confession, driven by social democratic policies emphasizing equality over confessional monopoly. followed in 2012, amending its to end the Evangelical Lutheran Church's status while retaining some ceremonial roles, amid surveys showing only 10-20% active participation by the . This pattern highlights how state churches, lacking competitive , fostered complacency and vulnerability to secular welfare states that absorbed traditional church functions like , contributing to steeper declines compared to pluralistic contexts. Across these instances, empirical indicators of erosion included plummeting revenues—e.g., Irish Anglican collections fell 50% pre-1869—and legal privileges like mandatory rates, which dropped from near-universal in 19th-century to under 50% by mid-20th century, correlating with GDP growth and literacy rises that empowered individual choice over institutional allegiance. While some scholars attribute this to modernization's "" per Max Weber's , others note that establishments paradoxically hastened decline by stifling doctrinal vitality absent market-like pressures, as evidenced by higher vitality in disestablished U.S. denominations versus European monopolies. These patterns underscore causal realism: erosion stemmed not from inherent Christian flaws but from churches' entanglement with transient political power, rendering them targets during shifts toward liberal pluralism and state centralization.

Modern Pressures and Causal Factors

In contemporary Western societies with historical Christian establishments, such as and the , pressures on confessional structures arise from plummeting and affiliation rates, with Denmark reporting only 3% of the population attending services weekly as of 2020. These trends manifest in formal disestablishments, like Norway's in 2012, driven by public sentiment favoring neutrality amid low . Causal factors include generational replacement, where older cohorts with higher die off while younger ones exhibit lower belief and practice, as evidenced by in the U.S. and showing successive declines in intense since the 1970s. Socioeconomic modernization plays a pivotal role, with empirical studies linking rising prosperity, expanded welfare states, and higher education levels to reduced religious participation; for instance, the growth of state-provided in 20th-century correlated with a 20-30% drop in across Protestant nations. This diminishes religion's role in addressing existential insecurities, as individuals in affluent, secure environments prioritize over communal faith obligations. and legal further erode confessional privileges, with rulings pressuring states to accommodate non-Christian minorities, exemplified by challenges to symbols like crucifixes in public schools. Cultural shifts, including alienation from church teachings on social issues and institutional scandals—such as clerical cases exposed in the 2000s—have accelerated disaffiliation, with surveys indicating 20-40% of Western European Christians citing such factors for drifting away. from non-Christian regions contributes demographically, diluting Christian majorities; Europe's Muslim population rose from 4.9% in 2010 to projected 7-14% by 2050 under varying migration scenarios, straining confessional homogeneity. These pressures compound through a sequenced process: initial drops in public rituals, followed by diminished personal importance of , and eventual belief erosion, observed consistently in longitudinal data from 22 countries. While some analyses attribute persistence of nominal establishments to cultural inertia rather than active faith, the causal interplay of these elements underscores a structural retreat from Christian state integration.

Potential for Renewal and Adaptation

In , the government led by has actively pursued renewal of Christian institutional presence as part of a broader strategy to counteract demographic decline and cultural , renovating over 3,000 churches and constructing 200 new ones in the Carpathian Basin since assuming power in 2010. This effort aligns with the 2011 Fundamental Law's preamble, which affirms the founding of a Christian state by King Stephen I and commits to preserving national and amid migration and EU-imposed liberalization. Adaptation occurs through policies integrating Christian ethics into family support, education, and border security, fostering a model of "" that prioritizes endogenous population growth—evidenced by Hungary's fertility rate rising from 1.23 in 2010 to 1.59 in 2021—while navigating membership in secular-oriented institutions like the . Greece exemplifies adaptation in a longstanding confessional framework, where the retains constitutional status as the prevailing religion, with state funding for salaries (approximately €200 million annually as of 2022) and mandatory in schools emphasizing Orthodox heritage. Recent governments have resisted proposals for stricter separation, as seen in the 2019-2023 New Democracy administration scrapping earlier leftist plans to diminish church influence, thereby maintaining symbiotic church-state relations amid modernization pressures like EU standards. This approach adapts by incorporating Orthodox perspectives into and social policy, such as opposition to expansive liberalization, while accommodating pluralism through optional religious instruction opt-outs, preserving institutional vitality in a society where 81% identify as Orthodox per 2022 census data despite declining active practice. Nordic countries like and , following partial disestablishments (Norway in 2012, Denmark retaining a folk church structure), illustrate adaptive persistence of Christian cultural frameworks without formal mandates. Denmark's 2025 parliamentary debates over retaining Christian symbols in the and school curricula reflect efforts to counter atheism's rise, with 74% of affirming cultural Christianity's role in per recent surveys, even as active affiliation hovers at 20-30%. Prospects for renewal hinge on ; events like the ' Opwekking festival drew 60,000 attendees in 2025, predominantly under 30, signaling potential grassroots revival that could inform governance by emphasizing moral frameworks in welfare and policies. Broader European prospects involve transnational evangelical networks and conferences, such as the 2025 Revive Europe gathering in Krakow committing hundreds to , potentially bolstering political for Christian-influenced policies amid stabilizing metrics—e.g., Barna Group's 2025 data showing U.S. in rising 5% among young adults, with analogous Gen Z upticks in commitments doubling since 2020. However, causal factors like low fertility (below replacement in most states) and institutional biases toward limit scalability, requiring adaptation via alliances with conservative parties to embed principles like and without reverting to , as evidenced by Hungary's model yielding measurable social cohesion gains.

References

  1. https://www.gotquestions.org/state-church.html
  2. https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/world-history/ancient-medieval/christianity/a/roman-culture
  3. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Christianity/Church-and-state
  4. https://www.worlddata.info/religions/state-religions.php
  5. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/what-countries-have-a-national-religion
  6. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Denmark_1953?lang=en
  7. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Greece_2008?lang=en
  8. https://www.servat.unibe.ch/icl/da00000_.html
  9. https://www.thedanishparliament.dk/democracy/the-constitutional-act
  10. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Malta_2016?lang=en
  11. https://religionmediacentre.org.uk/factsheets/factsheet-establishment-and-the-church-of-england/
  12. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/secularisation-of-the-confessional-state/CB29781D16CA5625B00734E428A795C7
  13. https://juicyecumenism.com/2021/05/27/integralism-theocracy-liberalism-protestantism/
  14. https://uscatholic.org/articles/201910/what-is-catholic-integralism/
  15. https://bredenhof.ca/2022/05/30/we-distinguish-church-and-state/
  16. https://advocate.jbu.edu/2021/05/06/why-i-a-christian-advocate-for-secularism
  17. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2007/12/03/religion-and-secularism-the-american-experience/
  18. https://directionjournal.org/5/3/classical-patterns-of-church-state.html
  19. https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05514a.htm
  20. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/10/03/many-countries-favor-specific-religions-officially-or-unofficially/
  21. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0147596716300737
  22. https://armenianprelacy.org/education/church-history/
  23. https://www.heritagedaily.com/2024/10/earliest-church-of-the-first-christian-nation-discovered-in-armenia/153677
  24. https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/edict-of-milan
  25. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Edict-of-Milan
  26. https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/edict-thessalonica
  27. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/religion-and-philosophy/theodosiuss-edicts-promote-christian-orthodoxy
  28. https://smarthistory.org/the-kingdom-of-aksum/
  29. https://mathewlyons.co.uk/2021/03/25/the-edict-of-thessalonica-theodosius-i-and-the-birth-of-the-christian-state/
  30. https://www.patheos.com/blogs/davearmstrong/2020/02/caesaropapism-in-orthodoxy-the-byzantine-empire.html
  31. https://scholarship.law.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2541&context=lawreview
  32. http://regentparents.regent.edu/acad/schlaw/student_life/studentorgs/lawreview/docs/issues/v11n1/11RegentULRev151.pdf
  33. https://www.tomrichey.net/blog/franks
  34. https://worldhistorymsgarcia.weebly.com/uploads/1/0/7/5/107511575/13.1-charlemagne_unites_germanic_kingdoms.pdf
  35. https://www.notgrass.com/pdf/exploring_world_history_unit14.pdf
  36. https://www.8thcentury.com/pepin-donates-aistulfs-toys/
  37. https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-history-archaeology-history-famous-people/otto-great-0021792
  38. https://www.christianity.com/church/church-history/timeline/1501-1600/lutheranism-made-official-in-denmark-11629962.html
  39. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283246184_The_Long_History_of_Lutheranism_in_Scandinavia_From_State_Religion_to_the_People%27s_Church
  40. https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/magazine/article/act-of-supremacy
  41. https://www.diplomacy.edu/blog/whats-all-the-fuss-about-the-westphalia-settlement/
  42. https://resources.saylor.org/wwwresources/archived/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/HIST103-3.2.1-ReformationPoliticalImpact-FINAL.pdf
  43. https://ausjlr.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Volume-4-Witte-with-Berman.pdf
  44. https://catdir.loc.gov/catdir/samples/cam032/99022488.pdf
  45. https://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1177&context=esi_working_papers
  46. https://www.galaxie.com/article/atj05-1-04
  47. https://learn.ligonier.org/devotionals/civil-obedience
  48. https://purelypresbyterian.com/2016/03/25/john-calvin-two-kingdoms-civil-enforcement-of-both-tables/
  49. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/civil-magistrate-presbyterians/
  50. https://www.desiringgod.org/interviews/does-romans-13-prohibit-all-civil-disobedience
  51. https://www.newadvent.org/summa/2094.htm
  52. https://iep.utm.edu/thomasaquinas-moral-philosophy/
  53. https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2021/08/77294/
  54. https://academic.oup.com/book/1621/chapter/141136546
  55. https://www.modernreformation.org/resources/articles/natural-law-and-christians-in-the-public-square
  56. https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2018/09/39297/
  57. https://aquinasonline.com/four-causes/
  58. https://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/aquinas/idea-four-causes/
  59. https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2022/08/83850/
  60. https://www.heritage.org/political-process/report/the-case-and-against-natural-law
  61. https://kirkcenter.org/reviews/natural-law-and-the-challenge-of-liberal-secularism/
  62. https://firstthings.com/does-natural-law-need-theology/
  63. https://www.hungarianconservative.com/articles/philosophy/the-myth-of-the-secular-state/
  64. https://www.wordonfire.org/articles/the-hollow-promises-of-secular-humanism/
  65. https://genealogiesofmodernity.org/journal/three-critiques-of-secularism
  66. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Denmark_1953
  67. https://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/posts/religion-in-denmark
  68. https://denmark.dk/people-and-culture/religion
  69. https://www.churchofengland.org/media/stories-and-features/what-does-it-mean-church-england-established-church
  70. https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/private-lives/religion/overview/church-and-religion/
  71. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Greece_2008
  72. https://talkabout.iclrs.org/2020/10/31/the-trinity-the-prevailing-religion-and-the-greek-constitution/
  73. https://www.government.is/topics/religion-and-non-religious-convictions/
  74. https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/iceland
  75. https://judiciary.mt/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/Freedom-of-Conscience-1.pdf
  76. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/church/news/2022-03/overview-of-the-church-in-malta-ahead-of-papal-visit.html
  77. https://www.christiancentury.org/article/2012-03/norways-state-church-headed-toward-dis-establishment
  78. https://www.secularism.org.uk/news/2012/05/norway-shows-the-way-by-separating-church-and-state
  79. https://www.concordatwatch.eu/nordic-countries--k34701
  80. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Costa_Rica_2011
  81. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/costa-rica
  82. https://teachersinstitute.yale.edu/curriculum/units/1982/5/82.05.07.x.html
  83. https://resolve.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/F1C81839B7578BA400B109F6B94971CA/9781139055192c12_p527-596_CBO.pdf/the-catholic-church-in-latin-america-1830-1930.pdf
  84. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2014/11/13/religion-in-latin-america/
  85. https://www.encyclopedia.com/environment/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/christianity-christianity-caribbean-region
  86. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2025/06/09/religion-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean/
  87. https://www.metmuseum.org/essays/african-christianity-in-ethiopia
  88. https://www.thecollector.com/ethiopian-christianity-facts/
  89. https://www.britannica.com/place/Ethiopia/Religion
  90. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/zambia-commemorates-30th-anniversary-of-declaration-as-christian-nation/2461153
  91. http://africajournal.ru/en/2021/09/15/christian-nation-in-zambia-from-proclamation-to-reset/
  92. https://thediplomat.com/2017/06/samoa-officially-becomes-a-christian-state/
  93. https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/papua-new-guinea-officially-declares
  94. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-17994868
  95. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/monaco
  96. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Liechtenstein_2011?lang=en
  97. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/san-marino
  98. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/andorra
  99. https://www.britannica.com/place/Denmark/Religion
  100. https://kirkjan.is/english/
  101. https://www.britannica.com/topic/National-Church-of-Iceland
  102. https://evl.fi/en/our-work/church-and-state/
  103. https://www.oikoumene.org/countries/finland
  104. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Church-of-Greece
  105. https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/malta
  106. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/liechtenstein
  107. https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/tuvalu
  108. https://www.churchofireland.org/our-faith/church-teaching/disestablishment
  109. https://dublin.anglican.org/about-us/disestablishment-150/disestablishment-a-brief-history
  110. https://www.manchesterhive.com/view/journals/bjrl/97/1/article-p145.pdf
  111. https://www.churchinwales.org.uk/en/news-and-events/100-years-serving-wales/
  112. https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2020/15-may/features/features/church-in-wales-separated-but-not-cut-off-from-old-privileges
  113. https://www.library.wales/fileadmin/docs_gwefan/new_structure/catalogues/specialist_catalogues/nlw_journal/cgr_erth_XXXVII_rhif3_2021_1.pdf
  114. https://www.acton.org/publications/transatlantic/2019/05/10/secularizing-church-sweden-politics-alone
  115. https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1973&context=lawreview
  116. https://evangelicalfocus.com/europe/13293/the-swedish-lutheran-church-is-no-longer-a-state-church-but-the-secularising-influence-of-politics-remains
  117. https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2025/22-august/news/world/swedish-church-embarks-on-three-mile-journey
  118. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/378616385_Leading_the_Church_through_Institutional_Change_Institutional_Work_during_the_Disestablishment_of_the_State_Church_in_Norway
  119. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0956522124000137
  120. http://vid.brage.unit.no/vid-xmlui/handle/11250/3213393?locale-attribute=en
  121. https://americanreformer.org/2025/06/did-established-churches-bring-about-european-secularism/
  122. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277169756_After_the_State_Church_A_Reflection_on_the_Relation_between_Theology_and_Religious_Studies_in_Contemporary_Sweden
  123. https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691027494/the-rise-of-christianity
  124. https://thejesusquestion.org/2013/01/20/the-rise-of-christianity-by-rodney-stark/
  125. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/religion/why/starktheology.html
  126. https://academic.oup.com/socrel/article/78/2/192/3089763
  127. https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1033&context=sociology_criminaljustice_fac_pubs
  128. https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/41333/chapter/352355230
  129. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7220049/
  130. https://www.heritage.org/civil-society/report/why-religion-matters-the-impact-religious-practice-social-stability
  131. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03468755.2017.1384661
  132. https://www.advokatsmart.no/news/divorce-statistics-for-scandinavia
  133. https://manhattan.institute/article/religion-the-forgotten-factor-in-cutting-youth-crime-and-saving-at-risk-urban-youth
  134. https://www.themontrealreview.com/2009/Economic-Origins-of-Roman-Christianity.php
  135. https://www.ifo.de/DocDL/cesifo1_wp8365.pdf
  136. https://catholiceducation.org/en/education/the-catholic-church-and-the-creation-of-the-university.html
  137. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w9682/w9682.pdf
  138. https://scholarship.law.bu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1439&context=faculty_scholarship
  139. https://lifespringschristianchurch.org/the-impact-of-christianity-on-western-civilization/
  140. https://exaudi.org/how-christianity-influenced-art-and-music/
  141. https://catholic.heritage-history.com/index.php?&s=study-info&f=saints_heroes&h=kingdoms&type=overview
  142. https://www.worldbank.org/en/publication/worldwide-governance-indicators
  143. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2024
  144. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/polp.12108
  145. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00323217221102826
  146. https://fiveable.me/introduction-christianity/unit-11/enlightenment-impact-christianity/study-guide/6zsrGckWJmdWf0qs
  147. https://www.kingswoodlearn.com/mod/page/view.php?id=399
  148. https://oercommons.org/courseware/lesson/87905/overview
  149. https://education.cfr.org/learn/reading/what-enlightenment-and-how-did-it-transform-politics
  150. https://revolution.chnm.org/exhibits/show/liberty--equality--fraternity/enlightenment-and-human-rights
  151. https://www.gotquestions.org/Enlightenment-Christianity.html
  152. https://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1176&context=facpubs
  153. https://academic.oup.com/book/38895/chapter/338046901
  154. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/greece
  155. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-report-on-international-religious-freedom/denmark
  156. https://fot.humanists.international/countries/europe-northern-europe/denmark/
  157. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/feature/religious-restrictions-around-the-world/
  158. https://nordics.info/nnl/show/artikel/religious-freedom-and-restrictions-in-the-nordic-countries
  159. https://www.britannica.com/event/Wars-of-Religion
  160. https://www.gotquestions.org/religious-wars.html
  161. https://courses.lumenlearning.com/atd-herkimer-westerncivilization/chapter/the-french-wars-of-religion/
  162. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/religion-and-philosophy/french-wars-religion
  163. https://www.britannica.com/event/Thirty-Years-War
  164. https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/learn/histories/the-english-civil-wars-history-and-stories/the-english-civil-wars/
  165. https://www.cromwellmuseum.org/cromwell/civil-war/causes-of-the-civil-war
  166. https://www.thecollector.com/english-civil-war-thirty-years-war/
  167. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/32-33/42/enacted
  168. https://www.worldhistory.org/article/2094/frances-1905-law-of-separation-of-church-and-state/
  169. https://museeprotestant.org/en/notice/the-law-of-1905/
  170. https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/evolutionofparliament/legislativescrutiny/parliamentandireland/overview/disestablishment/
  171. https://academic.oup.com/jcs/article/66/3/174/7514670
  172. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2018/05/29/being-christian-in-western-europe/
  173. https://www.theconservativereformer.com/articles/how-christian-nationalism-ended-in-scandinavia
  174. https://sociologicalscience.com/download/vol-5/november/SocSci_v5_694to710.pdf
  175. http://conference.nber.org/confer/2009/ERf09/Franck_Iannaccone.pdf
  176. https://www.uni-muenster.de/Religion-und-Politik/en/aktuelles/2025/Religion_in_der_Moderne_Neuauflage.shtml
  177. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-025-62452-z
  178. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2025/06/09/how-the-global-religious-landscape-changed-from-2010-to-2020/
  179. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12365078/
  180. https://academic.oup.com/socrel/article/86/2/141/7675863
  181. https://abouthungary.hu/news-in-brief/pm-orban-we-want-a-christian-europe-because-we-believe-it-is-the-only-one-that-has-a-future
  182. https://hungarytoday.hu/a-christian-europe-is-the-only-way-forward-says-viktor-orban/
  183. https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-report-on-international-religious-freedom/hungary
  184. https://www.icwa.org/in-greece-orthodoxy-remains-at-the-heart-of-village-life/
  185. https://publicorthodoxy.org/2024/04/02/the-fear-of-tomorrow-in-religious-education-in-greece/
  186. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304796424_Religion_in_Contemporary_Greece_-_A_Modern_Experience
  187. https://cne.news/article/4698-denmark-is-fighting-over-its-christian-heritage
  188. https://theworld.org/stories/2025/07/24/in-one-of-the-worlds-most-secular-countries-some-gen-z-christians-are-finding-faith-again-but-not-at-church
  189. https://evangelicalfocus.com/europe/29820/hundreds-commit-to-evangelism-and-prayer-for-revival-at-revive-europe-conference-in-krakow
  190. https://www.barna.com/research/belief-in-jesus-rises/
  191. https://www.pensions.org/news-and-events/articles/christianity-at-a-crossroads-decline-slows%253B-could-renewal-lie-ahead-
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.