Hubbry Logo
MuhammadMuhammadMain
Open search
Muhammad
Community hub
Muhammad
logo
14 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Contribute something
Muhammad
Muhammad
from Wikipedia

Key Information

Muhammad[a][b] (c. 570 – 8 June 632 CE)[c] was an Arab religious, military and political leader and the founder of Islam.[d] According to Islam, he was a prophet who was divinely inspired to preach and confirm the monotheistic teachings of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus, and other prophets. He is believed by Muslims to be the Seal of the Prophets, and along with the Quran, his teachings and normative examples form the basis for Islamic religious belief.

Muhammad was born in Mecca to the aristocratic Banu Hashim clan of the Quraysh. He was the son of Abdullah ibn Abd al-Muttalib and Amina bint Wahb. His father, Abdullah, the son of tribal leader Abd al-Muttalib ibn Hashim, died around the time Muhammad was born. His mother Amina died when he was six, leaving Muhammad an orphan. He was raised under the care of his grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, and paternal uncle, Abu Talib. In later years, he would periodically seclude himself in a mountain cave named Hira for several nights of prayer. When he was 40, in c. 610, Muhammad reported being visited by Gabriel in the cave and receiving his first revelation from God. In 613,[2] Muhammad started preaching these revelations publicly,[3] proclaiming that "God is One", that complete "submission" (Islām) to God (Allāh) is the right way of life (dīn),[4] and that he was a prophet and messenger of God, similar to other prophets in Islam.[5]

Muhammad's followers were initially few in number, and experienced persecution by Meccan polytheists for 13 years. To escape ongoing persecution, he sent some of his followers to Abyssinia in 615, before he and his followers migrated from Mecca to Medina (then known as Yathrib) later in 622. This event, the Hijrah, marks the beginning of the Islamic calendar, also known as the Hijri calendar. In Medina, Muhammad united the tribes under the Constitution of Medina. In December 629, after eight years of intermittent fighting with Meccan tribes, Muhammad gathered an army of 10,000 Muslim converts and marched on the city of Mecca. The conquest went largely uncontested, and Muhammad seized the city with minimal casualties. In 632, a few months after returning from the Farewell Pilgrimage, he fell ill and died. By the time of his death, most of the Arabian Peninsula had converted to Islam.

The revelations (waḥy) that Muhammad reported receiving until his death form the verses (āyah) of the Quran, upon which Islam is based, and are regarded by Muslims as the verbatim word of God and his final revelation. Besides the Quran, Muhammad's teachings and practices, found in transmitted reports, known as hadith, and in his biography (sīrah), are also upheld and used as sources of Islamic law. Apart from Islam, Muhammad has received praise in Sikhism as an inspirational figure, in the Druze faith as one of the seven main prophets, and in the Baháʼí Faith as a Manifestation of God.

Biographical sources

[edit]

Early biographies

[edit]
An early manuscript of Ibn Hisham's al-Sirah al-Nabawiyyah, believed to have been transmitted by his students shortly after his death in 833[6]: 61 

Important early sources for the life of Muhammad are authors from the 2nd and 3rd centuries AH (overlapping with the 8th and 9th centuries CE), whose works supplied additional biographical information to the Muslim traditions regarding his life.[7][8]

The earliest written sira (biographies of Muhammad and quotes attributed to him) is Ibn Ishaq's Life of God's Messenger written c. 767 (150 AH). Although the original work was lost, this sira survives as extensive excerpts in works by Ibn Hisham and to a lesser extent by al-Tabari.[9][10] However, Ibn Hisham wrote in the preface to his biography of Muhammad that he omitted matters from Ibn Ishaq's biography that "would distress certain people".[11] Another early historical source is the history of Muhammad's campaigns by al-Waqidi (d. 207 AH), and the work of Waqidi's secretary Ibn Sa'd al-Baghdadi (d. 230 AH).[8] Due to these early biographical efforts, more is known about Muhammad than almost any other founder of a major religion.[12] Many scholars accept these early biographies as authentic.[9] However, Waqidi's biography has been widely criticized by Islamic scholars for his methods, in particular his decision to omit his sources.[13] Recent studies have led scholars to distinguish between traditions touching legal matters and purely historical events. In the legal group, traditions could have been subject to invention while historic events, aside from exceptional cases, may have been subject only to "tendential shaping".[14] Other scholars have criticized the reliability of this method, suggesting that one cannot neatly divide traditions into purely legal and historical categories.[15]

Hadith

[edit]
Early manuscript of the Muwatta of Malik ibn Anas, dated within his lifetime c. 780[6]: 114 

Other important sources include the hadith collections, accounts of verbal and physical teachings and traditions attributed to Muhammad. Hadiths were compiled several generations after his death by Muslims including Muhammad al-Bukhari, Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj, Muhammad ibn Isa at-Tirmidhi, Abd ar-Rahman al-Nasai, Abu Dawood, Ibn Majah, Malik ibn Anas, al-Daraqutni.[16][17]

Muslim scholars have typically placed a greater emphasis on the hadith instead of the biographical literature, since hadith maintain a traditional chain of transmission (isnad); the lack of such a chain for the biographical literature makes it unverifiable in their eyes.[18] The hadiths generally present an idealized view of Muhammad.[19] Western scholars have expressed skepticism regarding the verifiability of these chains of transmission. It is widely believed by Western scholars that there was widespread fabrication of hadith during the early centuries of Islam to support certain theological and legal positions,[20][19] and it has been suggested that it is "very likely that a considerable number of hadiths that can be found in the hadith collections did not actually originate with the Prophet".[19] In addition, the meaning of a hadith may have drifted from its original telling to when it was finally written down, even if the chain of transmission is authentic.[15] Overall, some Western academics have cautiously viewed the hadith collections as accurate historical sources,[16] while the "dominant paradigm" in Western scholarship is to consider their reliability suspect.[20] Scholars such as Wilferd Madelung do not reject the hadith which have been compiled in later periods, but judge them in their historical context.[21]

Quran

[edit]

The Quran is the central religious text of Islam. Muslims believe it represents the word of God revealed to Muhammad by the archangel Gabriel.[22][23][24] The Quran is primarily addressed to a single "Messenger of God," identified as Muhammad in a number of verses. In contrast to the hundreds of references to earlier prophets such as Moses and Jesus, it contains comparatively little direct information about Muhammad himself,[25][26] or his companions.[27] The text also briefly refers to episodes from Muhammad's career, such as the migration of his followers to Yathrib and the Battle of Badr.[27]

Meccan years

[edit]

Early life

[edit]
Timeline of Muhammad's life
Important dates and locations in the life of Muhammad
Date Age Event
c. 570 Death of his father, Abdullah
c. 570 0 Possible date of birth: 12 or 17 Rabi al Awal: in Mecca, Arabia
c. 577 6 Death of his mother, Amina
c. 583 12–13 His grandfather transfers him to Syria
c. 595 24–25 Meets and marries Khadijah
c. 599 28–29 Birth of Zainab, his first daughter, followed by: Ruqayyah, Umm Kulthum, and Fatima Zahra
610 40 Qur'anic revelation begins in the Cave of Hira on the Jabal an-Nour, the "Mountain of Light" near Mecca. At age 40, Angel Jebreel (Gabriel) was said to appear to Muhammad on the mountain and call him "the Prophet of Allah"
Begins in secret to gather followers in Mecca
c. 613 43 Begins spreading message of Islam publicly to all Meccans
c. 614 43–44 Heavy persecution of Muslims begins
c. 615 44–45 Emigration of a group of Muslims to Ethiopia
c. 616 45–46 Banu Hashim clan boycott begins
619 49 Banu Hashim clan boycott ends
The year of sorrows: Khadija (his wife) and Abu Talib (his uncle) die
c. 620 49–50 Isra and Mi'raj (reported ascension to heaven to meet God)
622 51–52 Hijra, emigration to Medina (called Yathrib)
624 53–54 Battle of Badr
625 54–55 Battle of Uhud
627 56–57 Battle of the Trench (also known as the siege of Medina)
628 57–58 The Meccan tribe of Quraysh and the Muslim community in Medina sign a 10-year truce called the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah
630 59–60 Conquest of Mecca
632 61–62 Farewell pilgrimage, event of Ghadir Khumm, and death, in what is now Saudi Arabia
The birth of Muhammad in the 16th-century Siyer-i Nebi

Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Abd al-Muttalib ibn Hashim[28] was born in Mecca[29][1] c. 570,[1] and his birthday is believed to be in the month of Rabi' al-Awwal.[30] He belonged to the Banu Hashim clan of the Quraysh tribe, which was a dominant force in western Arabia.[31] While his clan was one of the more distinguished in the tribe, it seems to have experienced a lack of prosperity during his early years.[32][e] According to Muslim tradition, Muhammad was a hanif, someone who professed monotheism in pre-Islamic Arabia.[33] He is also claimed to have been a descendant of Ishmael, son of Abraham.[34]

The name Muhammad means "praiseworthy" in Arabic and it appears four times in the Quran.[35] He was also known as "al-Amin" (lit.'faithful') when he was young; however, historians differ as to whether it was given by people as a reflection of his nature[36] or was simply a given name from his parents, i.e., a masculine form of his mother's name "Amina".[37] Muhammad acquired the kunya of Abu al-Qasim later in his life after the birth of his son Qasim, who died two years afterwards.[38]

Islamic tradition states that Muhammad's birth year coincided with the Year of the Elephant, when Abraha, the Aksumite viceroy in the former Himyarite Kingdom, unsuccessfully attempted to conquer Mecca.[39] Recent studies, however, challenge this notion, as other evidence suggests that the expedition, if it had occurred, would have transpired substantially before Muhammad's birth.[40] Later Muslim scholars presumably linked Abraha's renowned name to the narrative of Muhammad's birth to elucidate the unclear passage about "the men of elephants" in Quran 105:1–5.[41][42] The Oxford Handbook of Late Antiquity deems the tale of Abraha's war elephant expedition as a myth.[43]

Muhammad's father, Abdullah, died almost six months before he was born.[44] Muhammad then stayed with his foster mother, Halima bint Abi Dhu'ayb, and her husband until he was two years old. At the age of six, Muhammad lost his biological mother Amina to illness and became an orphan.[45][46][47] For the next two years, until he was eight years old, Muhammad was under the guardianship of his paternal grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, until the latter's death. He then came under the care of his uncle, Abu Talib,[48] the new leader of the Banu Hashim.[48] Abu Talib's brothers assisted with Muhammad's learning – Hamza, the youngest, trained Muhammad in archery, swordsmanship, and martial arts. Another uncle, Abbas, provided Muhammad with a job leading caravans on the northern segment of the route to Syria.[49]

Young Muhammad meets the monk Bahira. From Jami al-Tawarikh by Rashid al-Din Hamadani in Tabriz, Persia, c. 1315.

The historical record of Mecca during Muhammad's early life is limited and fragmentary, making it difficult to distinguish between fact and legend.[50] Several Islamic narratives relate that Muhammad, as a child, went on a trading trip to Syria with his uncle Abu Talib and met a monk named Bahira, who is said to have then foretold his prophethood.[51] There are multiple versions of the story with details that contradict each other.[52] All accounts of Bahira and his meeting with Muhammad have been considered fictitious by modern historians[53] as well as by some medieval Muslim scholars such as al-Dhahabi.[54]

Sometime later in his life, Muhammad proposed marriage to his cousin and first love, Fakhitah bint Abi Talib. But likely owing to his poverty, his proposal was rejected by her father, Abu Talib, who chose a more illustrious suitor.[55][56] When Muhammad was 25, his fortunes turned around; his business reputation caught the attention of his 40-year-old distant relative Khadija, a wealthy businesswoman who had staked out a successful career as a merchant in the caravan trade industry. She asked him to take one of her caravans into Syria, after which she was so impressed by his competence in the expedition that she proposed marriage to him; Muhammad accepted her offer and remained monogamous with her until her death.[57][58][59]

Miniature from Rashid al-Din Hamadani's Jami al-Tawarikh, c. 1315, illustrating the story of Muhammad's role in re-setting the Black Stone in 605 (Ilkhanate period)[60]

In 605, the Quraysh decided to roof the Kaaba, which had previously consisted only of walls. A complete rebuild was needed to accommodate the new weight. Amid concerns about upsetting the deities, a man stepped forth with a pickaxe and exclaimed, "O goddess! Fear not! Our intentions are only for the best." With that, he began demolishing it. The anxious Meccans awaited divine retribution overnight, but his unharmed continuation the next day was seen as a sign of heavenly approval. According to a narrative collected by Ibn Ishaq, when it was time to reattach the Black Stone, a dispute arose over which clan should have the privilege. It was determined that the first person to step into the Kaaba's court would arbitrate. Muhammad took on this role, asking for a cloak. He placed the stone on it, guiding clan representatives to jointly elevate it to its position. He then personally secured it within the wall.[61][62]

Beginnings of the Quran

[edit]
The cave Hira in the mountain Jabal al-Nour where, according to Muslim belief, Muhammad received his first revelation

The financial security Muhammad enjoyed from Khadija, his wealthy wife, gave him plenty of free time to spend in solitude in the cave of Hira.[63][64] According to Islamic tradition, in 610, when he was 40 years old, the angel Gabriel appeared to him during his visit to the cave.[1] The angel showed him a cloth with Quranic verses on it and instructed him to read. When Muhammad confessed his illiteracy, Gabriel choked him forcefully, nearly suffocating him, and repeated the command. As Muhammad reiterated his inability to read, Gabriel choked him again in a similar manner. This sequence took place once more before Gabriel finally recited the verses, allowing Muhammad to memorize them.[65][66][67] These verses later constituted Quran 96:1-5.[68]

When Muhammad came to his senses, he felt scared; he started to think that after all of this spiritual struggle, he had been visited by a jinn, which made him no longer want to live. In desperation, Muhammad fled from the cave and began climbing up towards the top of the mountain to jump to his death. But when he reached the summit, he experienced another vision, this time seeing a mighty being that engulfed the horizon and stared back at Muhammad even when he turned to face a different direction. This was the spirit of revelation (rūḥ), which Muhammad later referred to as Gabriel; it was not a naturalistic angel, but rather a transcendent presence that resisted the ordinary limits of humanity and space.[69][70][71]

Frightened and unable to understand the experience, Muhammad hurriedly staggered down the mountain to his wife Khadija. By the time he got to her, he was already crawling on his hands and knees, shaking wildly and crying "Cover me!", as he thrust himself onto her lap. Khadija wrapped him in a cloak and tucked him in her arms until his fears dissipated. She had absolutely no doubts about his revelation; she insisted it was real and not a jinn.[69] Muhammad was also reassured by Khadija's Christian cousin Waraqah ibn Nawfal,[72] who jubilantly exclaimed "Holy! Holy! If you have spoken the truth to me, O Khadijah, there has come to him the great divinity who came to Moses aforetime, and lo, he is the prophet of his people."[73][74] Khadija instructed Muhammad to let her know if Gabriel returned. When he appeared during their private time, Khadija conducted tests by having Muhammad sit on her left thigh, right thigh, and lap, inquiring Muhammad if the being was still present each time. After Khadija removed her clothes with Muhammad on her lap, he reported that Gabriel left at that moment. Khadija thus told him to rejoice as she concluded it was not shayatin but an angel visiting him.[75][76][72]

Muhammad's demeanor during his moments of inspiration frequently led to allegations from his contemporaries that he was under the influence of a jinn, a soothsayer, or a magician, suggesting that his experiences during these events bore resemblance to those associated with such figures widely recognized in ancient Arabia. Nonetheless, these enigmatic seizure events might have served as persuasive evidence for his followers regarding the divine origin of his revelations. Some historians posit that the graphic descriptions of Muhammad's condition in these instances are likely genuine, as they are improbable to have been concocted by later Muslims.[77][78]

Image of Gabriel visiting Muhammad from the Siyer-i Nebi

Shortly after Waraqa's death, the revelations ceased for a period, causing Muhammad great distress and thoughts of suicide.[79] On one occasion, he reportedly climbed a mountain intending to jump off. However, upon reaching the peak, Gabriel appeared to him, affirming his status as the true Messenger of God. This encounter soothed Muhammad, and he returned home. Later, when there was another long break between revelations, he repeated this action, but Gabriel intervened similarly, calming him and causing him to return home.[80][81]

Muhammad was confident that he could distinguish his own thoughts from these messages.[82] The early Quranic revelations utilized approaches of cautioning non-believers with divine punishment, while promising rewards to believers. They conveyed potential consequences like famine and killing for those who rejected Muhammad's God and alluded to past and future calamities. The verses also stressed the imminent final judgment and the threat of hellfire for skeptics.[83] Due to the complexity of the experience, Muhammad was initially very reluctant to tell others about his revelations;[84] at first, he confided in only a few select family members and friends.[85] According to Muslim tradition, Muhammad's wife Khadija was the first to believe he was a prophet.[86] She was followed by Muhammad's ten-year-old cousin Ali ibn Abi Talib, close friend Abu Bakr, and adopted son Zayd.[86] As word of Muhammad's revelations continued to spread throughout the rest of his family, they became increasingly divided on the matter, with the youth and women generally believing in him, while most of the men in the elder generations were staunchly opposed.[87]

Opposition in Mecca

[edit]

Around 613, Muhammad began to preach to the public;[3][88] many of his first followers were women, freedmen, servants, slaves, and other members of the lower social class.[87] These converts keenly awaited each new revelation from Muhammad; when he recited it, they all would repeat after him and memorize it, and the literate ones recorded it in writing.[89] Muhammad also introduced rituals to his group which included prayer (salat) with physical postures that embodied complete surrender (islam) to God, and almsgiving (zakat) as a requirement of the Muslim community (ummah).[90] By this point, Muhammad's religious movement was known as tazakka ('purification').[91][92]

Initially, he had no serious opposition from the inhabitants of Mecca, who were indifferent to his proselytizing activities, but when he started to attack their beliefs, tensions arose.[93][94][95][96] The Quraysh challenged him to perform miracles, such as bringing forth springs of water, yet he declined, reasoning that the regularities of nature already served as sufficient proof of God's majesty. Some satirized his lack of success by wondering why God had not bestowed treasure upon him. Others called on him to visit Paradise and return with tangible parchment scrolls of the Quran. But Muhammad asserted that the Quran, in the form he conveyed it, was already an extraordinary proof.[97][98]

According to Amr ibn al-As, several of the Quraysh gathered at Hijr and discussed how they had never faced such serious problems as they were facing from Muhammad. They said that he had derided their culture, denigrated their ancestors, scorned their faith, shattered their community, and cursed their gods. Sometime later, Muhammad came, kissing the Black Stone and performing the ritual tawaf. As Muhammad passed by them, they reportedly said hurtful things to him. The same happened when he passed by them a second time. On his third pass, Muhammad stopped and said, "Will you listen to me, O Quraysh? By Him (God), who holds my life in His hand, I bring you slaughter." They fell silent and told him to go home, saying that he was not a violent man. The next day, a number of Quraysh approached him, asking if he had said what they had heard from their companions. He answered yes, and one of them seized him by his cloak. Abu Bakr intervened, tearfully saying, "Would you kill a man for saying God is my Lord?" And they left him.[99][100][101]

The Quraysh attempted to entice Muhammad to quit preaching by giving him admission to the merchants' inner circle as well as an advantageous marriage, but he refused both of the offers.[102] A delegation of them then, led by the leader of the Makhzum clan, known by the Muslims as Abu Jahl, went to Muhammad's uncle Abu Talib, head of the Hashim clan and Muhammad's caretaker, giving him an ultimatum to disown Muhammad:[103][104]

By God, we can no longer endure this vilification of our forefathers, this derision of our traditional values, this abuse of our gods. Either you stop Muhammad yourself, Abu Talib, or you must let us stop him. Since you yourself take the same position as we do, in opposition to what he's saying, we will rid you of him.[105][106]

Abu Talib politely dismissed them at first, thinking it was just a heated talk. But as Muhammad grew more vocal, Abu Talib requested Muhammad to not burden him beyond what he could bear, to which Muhammad wept and replied that he would not stop even if they put the sun in his right hand and the moon in his left. When he turned around, Abu Talib called him and said, "Come back nephew, say what you please, for by God I will never give you up on any account."[107][108]

Quraysh delegation to Yathrib

[edit]

The leaders of the Quraysh sent Nadr ibn al-Harith and Uqba ibn Abi Mu'ayt to Yathrib to seek the opinions of the Jewish rabbis regarding Muhammad. The rabbis advised them to ask Muhammad three questions: recount the tale of young men who ventured forth in the first age; narrate the story of a traveler who reached both the eastern and western ends of the earth; and provide details about the spirit. If Muhammad answered correctly, they stated, he would be a Prophet; otherwise, he would be a liar. When they returned to Mecca and asked Muhammad the questions, he told them he would provide the answers the next day. However, 15 days passed without a response from his God, leading to gossip among the Meccans and causing Muhammad distress. At some point later, the angel Gabriel came to Muhammad and provided him with the answers.[109][110]

In response to the first query, the Quran tells a story about a group of men sleeping in a cave (Quran 18:9–25), which scholars generally link to the legend of the Seven Sleepers of Ephesus. For the second query, the Quran speaks of Dhu al-Qarnayn, literally 'he of the two horns' (Quran 18:93–99), a tale that academics widely associate with the Alexander Romance.[111][112] As for the third query, concerning the nature of the spirit, the Quranic revelation asserted that it was beyond human comprehension. Neither the Jews who devised the questions nor the Quraysh who posed them to Muhammad converted to Islam upon receiving the answers.[110] Nadr and Uqba were later executed on Muhammad's orders after the Battle of Badr, while other captives were held for ransom. As Uqba pleaded, "But who will take care of my children, Muhammad?" Muhammad responded, "Hell!"[113]

Migration to Abyssinia and the incident of Satanic Verses

[edit]

In 615, Muhammad sent some of his followers to emigrate to the Abyssinian Kingdom of Aksum and found a small colony under the protection of the Christian Ethiopian emperor Aṣḥama ibn Abjar.[32] Among those who departed were Umm Habiba, the daughter of one of the Quraysh chiefs, Abu Sufyan, and her husband.[114] The Quraysh then sent two men to retrieve them. Because leatherwork at the time was highly prized in Abyssinia, they gathered a lot of skins and transported them there so they could distribute some to each of the kingdom's generals. But the king firmly rejected their request.[115]

While Tabari and Ibn Hisham mentioned only one migration to Abyssinia, there were two sets according to Ibn Sa'd. Of these two, the majority of the first group returned to Mecca before the event of Hijrah, while the majority of the second group remained in Abyssinia at the time and went directly to Medina after the event of Hijrah. These accounts agree that persecution played a major role in Muhammad sending them there. According to W. Montgomery Watt, the episodes were more complex than the traditional accounts suggest; he proposes that there were divisions within the embryonic Muslim community, and that they likely went there to trade in competition with the prominent merchant families of Mecca. In Urwa's letter preserved by Tabari, these emigrants returned after the conversion to Islam of a number of individuals in positions such as Hamza and Umar.[116]

Along with many others,[117] Tabari recorded that Muhammad was desperate, hoping for an accommodation with his tribe. So, while he was in the presence of a number of Quraysh, after delivering verses mentioning three of their favorite deities (Quran 53:19–20), Satan put upon his tongue two short verses: "These are the high flying ones / whose intercession is to be hoped for." This led to a general reconciliation between Muhammad and the Meccans, and the Muslims in Abyssinia began to return home. However, the next day, Muhammad retracted these verses at the behest of Gabriel, claiming that they had been cast by Satan to his tongue and God had abrogated them. Instead, verses that revile those goddesses were then revealed.[118][f][g] The returning Muslims thus had to make arrangements for clan protection before they could re-enter Mecca.[32][119]

According to the scholar Shahab Ahmed, the Satanic Verses incident was reported en masse and documented by nearly all of the major biographers of Muhammad during Islam's first two centuries,[120] which, according to these early sources, corresponds to Quran 22:52. Ahmed notes that with the rise of the hadith movement and systematic theology introducing new doctrines such as Ismah—the belief in Muhammad’s infallibility, which holds that he could not be deceived by Satan—the early community’s historical memory of the incident was reevaluated. By the 20th century, Muslim scholars unanimously rejected this incident.[117] On the other hand, most European biographers of Muhammad recognize the veracity of this incident of satanic verses on the basis of the criterion of embarrassment. Historian Alfred T. Welch proposes that the period of Muhammad's turning away from strict monotheism was likely far longer but was later encapsulated in a story that made it much shorter and implicated Satan as the culprit.[116]

In 616, an agreement was established whereby all other Quraysh clans were to enforce a ban on the Banu Hashim, prohibiting trade and marriage with them.[121][122] Nevertheless, Banu Hashim members could still move around Mecca freely. Despite facing increasing verbal abuse, Muhammad continued to navigate the streets and engage in public debates without being physically harmed.[123] At a later point, a faction within Quraysh, sympathizing with Banu Hashim, initiated efforts to end the sanctions, resulting in a general consensus in 619 to lift the ban.[124][116]

Attempt to establish himself in Ta'if

[edit]

In 619, Muhammad faced a period of sorrow. His wife, Khadija, a crucial source of his financial and emotional support, died.[125] In the same year, his uncle and guardian, Abu Talib, also died.[126][127] Despite Muhammad's persuasions to Abu Talib to embrace Islam on his deathbed, he clung to his polytheistic beliefs until the end.[128][127] Muhammad's other uncle, Abu Lahab, who succeeded the Banu Hashim clan leadership, was initially willing to provide Muhammad with protection. However, upon hearing from Muhammad that Abu Talib and Abd al-Muttalib were destined for hell due to not believing in Islam, he withdrew his support.[128][129]

Muhammad then went to Ta'if to try to establish himself in the city and gain aid and protection against the Meccans,[130][116][131] but he was met with a response: "If you are truly a prophet, what need do you have of our help? If God sent you as his messenger, why doesn't He protect you? And if Allah wished to send a prophet, couldn't He have found a better person than you, a weak and fatherless orphan?"[132] Realizing his efforts were in vain, Muhammad asked the people of Ta'if to keep the matter a secret, fearing that this would embolden the hostility of the Quraysh against him. However, instead of accepting his request, they pelted him with stones, injuring his limbs.[133] He eventually evaded this chaos and persecution by escaping to the garden of Utbah ibn Rabi'ah, a Meccan chief with a summer residence in Ta'if. Muhammad felt despair due to the unexpected rejection and hostility he received in the city; at this point, he realized he had no security or protection except from God, so he began praying. Shortly thereafter, Utbah's Christian slave Addas stopped by and offered grapes, which Muhammad accepted. By the end of the encounter, Addas felt overwhelmed and kissed Muhammad's head, hands, and feet in recognition of his prophethood.[134][135][136]

On Muhammad's return journey to Mecca, news of the events in Ta'if had reached the ears of Abu Jahl, and he said, "They did not allow him to enter Ta'if, so let us deny him entry to Mecca as well." Knowing the gravity of the situation, Muhammad asked a passing horseman to deliver a message to Akhnas ibn Shariq, a member of his mother's clan, requesting his protection so that he could enter in safety. But Akhnas declined, saying that he was only a confederate of the house of Quraysh. Muhammad then sent a message to Suhayl ibn Amir, who similarly declined on the basis of tribal principle. Finally, Muhammad dispatched someone to ask Mut'im ibn 'Adiy, the chief of the Banu Nawfal. Mut'im agreed, and after equipping himself, he rode out in the morning with his sons and nephews to accompany Muhammad to the city. When Abu Jahl saw him, he asked if Mut'im was simply giving him protection or if he had already converted to his religion. Mut'im replied, "Granting him protection, of course." Then Abu Jahl said, "We will protect whomever you protect."[137]

Isra' and Mi'raj

[edit]
Dome of the Rock, built during the reign of Abdul Malik. Anachronistically associated[h] with the Isra and Miraj marking the place where the Prophet Muhammad is believed to have ascended to heaven.[139] See also:Al-Aqsa Mosque.

It is at this low point in Muhammad's life that the accounts in the Sīrah lay out the famous Isra' and Mi'raj. Nowadays, Isra' is believed by Muslims to be the journey of Muhammad from Mecca to Jerusalem, while Mi'raj is from Jerusalem to the heavens.[140] There is considered no substantial basis for the Mi'raj in the Quran, as the Quran does not address it directly.[141]

Verse 17:1 of the Quran recounts Muhammad's night journey from a revered place of prayer to the most distant place of worship. The Kaaba, holy enclosure in Mecca, is widely accepted as the starting point, but there is disagreement among Islamic traditions as to what constitutes "the farthest place of worship". Some modern scholars maintain that the earliest tradition saw this faraway site as a celestial twin of the Kaaba, so that Muhammad's journey took him directly from Mecca through the heavens. A later tradition, however, refers to it as Bayt al-Maqdis, which is generally associated with Jerusalem. Over time, these different traditions merged to present the journey as one that began in Mecca, passed through Jerusalem, and then ascended to heaven.[142]

The dating of the events also differs from account to account. Ibn Sa'd recorded that Muhammad's Mi'raj took place first, from near the Kaaba to the heavens, on the 27th of Ramadan, 18 months before the Hijrah, while the Isra' from Mecca to Bayt al-Maqdis took place on the 17th night of the Last Rabi’ul before the Hijrah. As is well known, these two stories were later combined into one. In Ibn Hisham's account, the Isra' came first and then the Mi'raj, and he put these stories before the deaths of Khadija and Abu Talib. In contrast, al-Tabari included only the story of Muhammad's ascension from the sanctuary in Mecca to "the earthly heaven". Tabari placed this story at the beginning of Muhammad's public ministry, between his account of Khadija becoming "the first to believe in the Messenger of God" and his account of "the first male to believe in the Messenger of God".[140]

Migration to Medina

[edit]

As resistance to his proselytism in Mecca grew, Muhammad began to limit his efforts to non-Meccans who attended fairs or made pilgrimages.[143] During this period, Muhammad had an encounter with six individuals from the Banu Khazraj. These men had a history of raiding Jews in their locality, who in turn would warn them that a prophet would be sent to punish them. On hearing Muhammad's religious message, they said to each other, "This is the very prophet of whom the Jews warned us. Don't let them get to him before us!" Upon embracing Islam, they returned to Medina and shared their encounter, hoping that by having their people—the Khazraj and the Aws, who had been at odds for so long—accept Islam and adopt Muhammad as their leader, unity could be achieved between them.[144][145]

The next year, five of the earlier converts revisited Muhammad, bringing with them seven newcomers, three of whom were from the Banu Aws. At Aqaba, near Mecca, they pledged their loyalty to him.[144] Muhammad then entrusted Mus'ab ibn Umayr to join them on their return to Medina to promote Islam. Come June 622, a significant clandestine meeting was convened, again at Aqaba. In this gathering, seventy-five individuals from Medina (then Yathrib) attended, including two women, representing all the converts of the oases.[146] Muhammad asked them to protect him as they would protect their wives and children. They concurred and gave him their oath,[147] commonly referred to as the second pledge at al-Aqabah or the pledge of war. Paradise was Muhammad's promise to them in exchange for their loyalty.[148][149]

Subsequently, Muhammad called upon the Meccan Muslims to relocate to Medina.[146][150] This event is known as the Hijrah, literally meaning 'severing of kinship ties'.[151][152] The departures spanned approximately three months. To avoid arriving in Medina by himself with his followers remaining in Mecca, Muhammad chose not to go ahead and instead stayed back to watch over them and persuade those who were reluctant.[146] Some were held back by their families from leaving, but in the end, there were no Muslims left in Mecca.[153][154]

Islamic tradition recounts that in light of the unfolding events, Abu Jahl proposed a joint assassination of Muhammad by representatives of each clan. Having been informed about this by the angel Gabriel, Muhammad asked his cousin Ali to lie in his bed covered with his green hadrami mantle, assuring that it would safeguard him. That night, the group of planned assassins approached Muhammad's home to carry out the attack but changed their minds upon hearing the voices of Sawdah and some of Muhammad's daughters, since it was considered shameful to kill a man in front of the women in his family. They instead chose to wait until Muhammad left the house the next morning; one of the men peeked into a window and saw what he believed to be Muhammad (but was actually Ali dressed in Muhammad's cloak), though unbeknownst to them, Muhammad had previously escaped from the back of the residence. When Ali went outside to go for a walk the following morning, the men realized they had been fooled, and the Quraysh consequently offered a 100-camel bounty for the return of Muhammad's body, dead or alive.[155] After staying hidden for three days, Muhammad subsequently departed with Abu Bakr for Medina,[156] which at the time was still named Yathrib; the two men arrived in Medina on 4 September 622.[157] The Meccan Muslims who undertook the migration were then called the Muhajirun, while the Medinan Muslims were dubbed the Ansar.[158]

Medinan years

[edit]

Building the religious community in Medina

[edit]

A few days after settling in Medina, Muhammad negotiated for the purchase of a piece of land; upon this plot, the Muslims began constructing a building that would become Muhammad's residence as well as a community gathering place (masjid) for prayer (salat). Tree trunks were used as pillars to hold up the roof, and there was no fancy pulpit; instead, Muhammad stood on top of a small stool to speak to the congregation. The structure was completed after about seven months in April 623, becoming the first Muslim building and mosque; its northern wall had a stone marking the direction of prayer (qibla) which was Jerusalem at that time. Muhammad used the building to host public and political meetings, as well as a place for the poor to gather to receive alms, food, and care. Christians and Jews were also allowed to participate in community worship at the mosque. Initially, Muhammad's religion had no organized way to call the community to prayer in a coordinated manner. To resolve this, Muhammad had considered using a ram's horn (shofar) like the Jews or a wooden clapper like the Christians, but one of the Muslims in the community had a dream where a man in a green cloak told him that someone with a loud booming voice should announce the service by crying out "allahu akbar" ('God is greater') to remind Muslims of their top priority; when Muhammad heard about this dream, he agreed with the idea and selected Bilal, a former Abyssinian slave known for his loud voice.[159]

Constitution of Medina

[edit]

The text, referred to by contemporary popular Islamic writers as the Constitution of Medina, was a legal covenant or likely proclamation unilaterally written by Muhammad. Ibn Ishaq, following his narration of the Hijrah, maintains that Muhammad penned the text and divulges its content without relying on the Islamic corroboration system.[160] The appellation is generally deemed imprecise, as the text neither established a state nor enacted Quranic statutes,[161] but rather addressed tribal matters.[162] While scholars from both the West and the Muslim world agree on the text's authenticity, disagreements persist on whether it was a treaty or a unilateral proclamation by Muhammad,[i] the number of documents it comprised, the primary parties, the specific timing of its creation (or that of its constituent parts), whether it was drafted before or after Muhammad's removal of the three leading Jewish tribes of Medina, and the proper approach to translating it.[160][164]

In the text, Medina's Arab and Jewish tribes promised to live peacefully alongside the Muslims and to refrain from making a separate treaty with Mecca. It also guaranteed the Jews freedom of religion. In the agreement, everyone under its jurisdiction was required to defend and protect the oasis if attacked. Politically, the agreement helped Muhammad better understand which people were on his side.[165]

Beginning of armed conflict

[edit]

Following the emigration, the people of Mecca seized property of Muslim emigrants to Medina.[166] War would later break out between the people of Mecca and the Muslims. Muhammad delivered Quranic verses permitting Muslims to fight the Meccans.[167] According to the traditional account, on 11 February 624, while praying in the Masjid al-Qiblatayn in Medina, Muhammad received revelations from God that he should be facing Mecca rather than Jerusalem during prayer. Muhammad adjusted to the new direction, and his companions praying with him followed his lead, beginning the tradition of facing Mecca during prayer.[168]

Permission has been given to those who are being fought, because they were wronged. And indeed, Allah is competent to give them victory. Those who have been evicted from their homes without right—only because they say, "Our Lord is Allah." And were it not that Allah checks the people, some by means of others, there would have been demolished monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques in which the name of Allah is much mentioned. And Allah will surely support those who support Him. Indeed, Allah is Powerful and Exalted in Might.

— Quran (22:39–40)

Muhammad ordered a number of raids to capture Meccan caravans, but only the 8th of them, the Raid on Nakhla, resulted in actual fighting and capture of booty and prisoners.[27] In March 624, Muhammad led some three hundred warriors in a raid on a Meccan merchant caravan. The Muslims set an ambush for the caravan at Badr.[169] Aware of the plan, the Meccan caravan eluded the Muslims. A Meccan force was sent to protect the caravan and went on to confront the Muslims upon receiving word that the caravan was safe.[170] Due to being outnumbered more than three to one, a spirit of fear ran throughout the Muslim camp; Muhammad tried to boost their morale by telling them he had a dream in which God promised to send 1,000 angels to fight with them.[171][172] From a tactical standpoint, Muhammad placed troops in front of all of the wells so the Quraysh would have to fight for water, and positioned other troops in such a way that would require the Quraysh to fight uphill while also facing the sun.[171] The Battle of Badr commenced, and the Muslims ultimately won, killing at least forty-five Meccans with fourteen Muslims dead. They also succeeded in killing many Meccan leaders, including Abu Jahl.[173] Seventy prisoners had been acquired, many of whom were ransomed.[174][175][176] Muhammad and his followers saw the victory as confirmation of their faith[32] and Muhammad ascribed the victory to the assistance of an invisible host of angels. The Quranic verses of this period, unlike the Meccan verses, dealt with practical problems of government and issues like the distribution of spoils.[177]

The victory strengthened Muhammad's position in Medina and dispelled earlier doubts among his followers.[178] As a result, the opposition to him became less vocal. Pagans who had not yet converted were very bitter about the advance of Islam. Two pagans, Asma bint Marwan of the Aws Manat tribe and Abu 'Afak of the 'Amr b. 'Awf tribe, had composed verses taunting and insulting the Muslims. They were killed by people belonging to their own or related clans, and Muhammad did not disapprove of the killings. This report, however, is considered by some to be a fabrication.[179] Most members of those tribes converted to Islam, and little pagan opposition remained.[180]

Muhammad expelled from Medina the Banu Qaynuqa, one of three main Jewish tribes,[32] but some historians contend that the expulsion happened after Muhammad's death.[181] According to al-Waqidi, after Abd Allah ibn Ubayy spoke for them, Muhammad refrained from executing them and commanded that they be exiled from Medina.[182] Following the Battle of Badr, Muhammad also made mutual-aid alliances with a number of Bedouin tribes to protect his community from attacks from the northern part of Hejaz.[32]

Conflicts with Jewish tribes

[edit]

Once the ransom arrangements for the Meccan captives were finalized, he initiated a siege on the Banu Qaynuqa,[183] regarded as the weakest and wealthiest of Medina's three main Jewish tribes.[184][185] Muslim sources provide different reasons for the siege, including an altercation involving Hamza and Ali in the Banu Qaynuqa market, and another version by Ibn Ishaq, which tells the story of a Muslim woman being pranked by a Qaynuqa goldsmith.[185][186] Regardless of the cause, the Banu Qaynuqa sought refuge in their fort, where Muhammad blockaded them, cutting off their access to food supplies. The Banu Qaynuqa requested help from their Arab allies, but the Arabs refused since they were supporters of Muhammad.[187] After roughly two weeks, the Banu Qaynuqa capitulated without engaging in combat.[184][185]

Following the surrender of the Qaynuqa, Muhammad was moving to execute the men of the tribe when Abdullah ibn Ubayy, a Muslim Khazraj chieftain who had been aided by the Qaynuqa in the past encouraged Muhammad to show leniency. In a narrated incident, Muhammad turned away from Ibn Ubayy, but undeterred, the chieftain grasped Muhammad's cloak, and refused to let go until Muhammad agreed to treat the tribe leniently. Despite being angered by the incident, Muhammad spared the Qaynuqa, stipulating that they must depart Medina within three days and relinquish their property to the Muslims, with a fifth (khums) being retained by Muhammad.[188][189]

Back in Medina, Ka'b ibn al-Ashraf, a wealthy half-Jewish man from Banu Nadir and staunch critic of Muhammad, had just returned from Mecca after producing poetry that mourned the death of the Quraysh at Badr and aroused them to retaliate.[190][191] When Muhammad learned of this incitement against the Muslims, he asked his followers, "Who is ready to kill Ka'b, who has hurt God and His apostle?"[192] Ibn Maslamah offered his services, explaining that the task would require deception. Muhammad did not contest this. He then gathered accomplices, including Ka'b's foster brother, Abu Naila. They pretended to complain about their post-conversion hardships, persuading Ka'b to lend them food. On the night of their meeting with Ka'b, they murdered him when he was caught off-guard.[193]

Meccan retaliation

[edit]
"The Prophet Muhammad and the Muslim Army at the Battle of Uhud", from the Siyer-i Nebi

In 625, the Quraysh, wearied by Muhammad's continuous attacks on their caravans, decided to take decisive action. Led by Abu Sufyan, they assembled an army to oppose Muhammad.[183][194] Upon being alerted by his scout about the impending threat, Muhammad convened a war council. Initially, he considered defending from the city center, but later decided to meet the enemy in open battle at Mount Uhud, following the insistence of the younger faction of his followers.[195] As they prepared to depart, the remaining Jewish allies of Abdullah ibn Ubayy offered their help, which Muhammad declined.[196] Despite being outnumbered, the Muslims initially held their ground but lost advantage when some archers disobeyed orders. As rumors of Muhammad's death spread, the Muslims started to flee, but he had only been injured and managed to escape with a group of loyal adherents. Satisfied they had restored their honor, the Meccans returned to Mecca.[183][197] Mass casualties suffered by the Muslims in the Battle of Uhud resulted in many wives and daughters being left without a male protector, so after the battle, Muhammad received revelation allowing Muslim men to have up to four wives each, marking the beginning of polygyny in Islam.[198]

Sometime later, Muhammad found himself needing to pay blood money to Banu Amir. He sought monetary help from the Jewish tribe of Banu Nadir,[199][200][201] and they agreed to his request.[200] However, while waiting, he departed from his companions and disappeared. When they found him at his home, according to Ibn Ishaq, Muhammad disclosed that he had received a divine revelation of a planned assassination attempt on him by the Banu Nadir, which involved dropping a boulder from a rooftop. Muhammad then initiated a siege on the tribe;[202][203] during this time he also commanded the felling and burning of their palm groves,[204] which was an unambiguous symbol of declaring war in Arabia.[205] After a fortnight or so, the Banu Nadir capitulated.[206] They were directed to vacate their land and permitted to carry only one camel-load of goods for every three people.[207] From the spoils, Muhammad claimed a fertile piece of land where barley sprouted amongst palm trees.[208]

Raid on the Banu Mustaliq

[edit]

Upon receiving a report that the Banu Mustaliq were planning an attack on Medina, Muhammad's troops executed a surprise attack on them at their watering place, causing them to flee rapidly. In the confrontation, the Muslims lost one man, while the enemy suffered ten casualties.[209] As part of their triumph, the Muslims seized 2,000 camels, 500 sheep and goats, and 200 women from the tribe.[210] The Muslim soldiers desired the captive women, but they also sought ransom money. They asked Muhammad about using coitus interruptus to prevent pregnancy, to which Muhammad replied, "You are not under any obligation to forbear from that..."[211][212] Later, envoys arrived in Medina to negotiate the ransom for the women and children. Despite having the choice, all of them chose to return to their country instead of staying.[211][212]

Battle of the Trench

[edit]

With the help of the exiled Banu Nadir, the Quraysh military leader Abu Sufyan mustered a force of 10,000 men. Muhammad prepared a force of about 3,000 men and adopted a form of defense unknown in Arabia at that time; the Muslims dug a trench wherever Medina lay open to cavalry attack. The idea is credited to a Persian convert to Islam, Salman the Persian. The siege of Medina began on 31 March 627 and lasted two weeks.[213] Abu Sufyan's troops were unprepared for the fortifications, and after an ineffectual siege, the coalition decided to return home.[214] The Quran discusses this battle in sura Al-Ahzab, in verses 33:9–27.[215] During the battle, the Jewish tribe of Banu Qurayza, located to the south of Medina, entered into negotiations with Meccan forces to revolt against Muhammad. Although the Meccan forces were swayed by suggestions that Muhammad was sure to be overwhelmed, they desired reassurance in case the confederacy was unable to destroy him. No agreement was reached after prolonged negotiations, partly due to sabotage attempts by Muhammad's scouts.[216] After the coalition's retreat, the Muslims accused the Banu Qurayza of treachery and besieged them in their forts for 25 days. The Banu Qurayza eventually surrendered; according to Ibn Ishaq, all the men apart from a few converts to Islam were beheaded, while the women and children were enslaved.[217][218] Walid N. Arafat and Barakat Ahmad have disputed the accuracy of Ibn Ishaq's narrative.[219] Arafat believes that Ibn Ishaq's Jewish sources, speaking over 100 years after the event, conflated this account with memories of earlier massacres in Jewish history; he notes that Ibn Ishaq was considered an unreliable historian by his contemporary Malik ibn Anas, and a transmitter of "odd tales" by the later Ibn Hajar.[220] Ahmad argues that only some of the tribe were killed, while some of the fighters were merely enslaved.[221][222] Watt finds Arafat's arguments "not entirely convincing", while Meir J. Kister has refuted the arguments of Arafat and Ahmad.[223]

In the siege of Medina, the Meccans exerted the available strength to destroy the Muslim community. The failure resulted in a significant loss of prestige; their trade with Syria vanished.[224] Following the Battle of the Trench, Muhammad made two expeditions to the north, both ended without any fighting.[32] While returning from one of these journeys (or some years earlier according to other early accounts), an accusation of adultery was made against Aisha, Muhammad's wife. Aisha was exonerated from accusations when Muhammad announced he had received a revelation confirming Aisha's innocence and directing that charges of adultery be supported by four eyewitnesses (sura 24, An-Nur).[225]

Invasion of the Banu Qurayza

[edit]

On the day the Quraysh forces and their allies withdrew, Muhammad, while bathing at his wife's abode, received a visit from the angel Gabriel, who instructed him to attack the Jewish tribe of Banu Qurayza.[226][227][228] Islamic sources recount that during the preceding Meccan siege, the Quraysh leader Abu Sufyan incited the Qurayza to attack the Muslims from their compound, but the Qurayza demanded the Quraysh to provide 70 hostages from among themselves to ascertain their commitment to their plans, as proposed by Muhammad's secret agent Nuaym ibn Masud. Abu Sufyan refused their requirement.[229] Nevertheless, later accounts claim that 11 Jewish individuals from the Qurayza were indeed agitated and acted against Muhammad, though the course of event may have been dramatized within the tradition.[230][227]

Citing the intrigue of the Qurayza, Muhammad besieged the tribe, though the tribe denied the charges.[231][232][233] However, there are sources that say the Banu Qurayza broke the treaty with Muhammad and assisted the enemies of Muslims during the Battle of the Trench.[234] As the situation turned against the Qurayza, the tribe proposed to leave their land with one loaded camel each, but Muhammad refused. They then offered to leave without taking anything, but this was rejected as well, with Muhammad insisting on their unconditional surrender.[235][231] The Qurayza subsequently requested to confer with one of their Aws allies who had embraced Islam, leading to the arrival of Abu Lubaba. When asked about Muhammad's intentions, he gestured towards his throat, indicating an imminent massacre. He immediately regretted his indiscretion and tied himself to one of the Mosque pillars as a form of penance.[236][235]

After a 25-day siege, the Banu Qurayza surrendered. The Muslims of Banu Aws entreated Muhammad for leniency, prompting him to suggest that one of their own should serve as the judge, which they accepted. Muhammad assigned the role to Sa'd ibn Mu'adh, a man nearing death from an infection in his wounds from the previous Meccan siege.[237][236][238] He pronounced that all the men should be put to death, their possessions to be distributed among Muslims, and their women and children to be taken as captives. Muhammad approved this pronouncement saying it aligned with the God's judgement.[236][237] Consequently, 600–900 men of Banu Qurayza were executed. The women and children were distributed as slaves, with some being transported to Najd to be sold. The proceeds were then utilized to purchase weapons and horses for the Muslims.[239]

Incidents with the Banu Fazara

[edit]

A few months after the conflict with the Banu Qurayza, Muhammad organized a caravan to conduct trade in Syria. Zayd ibn Haritha was tasked with guarding the convoy. When they journeyed through the territory of Banu Fazara, whom Zayd had raided in the past, the tribe seized the opportunity for revenge, attacking the caravan and injuring him. Upon his return to Medina, Muhammad ordered Zayd to lead a punitive operation against the Fazara in which their matriarch Umm Qirfa was captured and brutally executed.[240][241]

Treaty of Hudaybiyya

[edit]
The Kaaba in Mecca long held a major economic and religious role for the area. Seventeen months after Muhammad's arrival in Medina, it became the Muslim direction for prayer (qibla). The Kaaba has been rebuilt several times; the present structure, built in 1629, is a reconstruction of an earlier building dating to 683.[242]

Early in 628, following a dream of making an unopposed pilgrimage to Mecca, Muhammad embarked on the journey. He was dressed in his customary pilgrim attire and was accompanied by a group of followers.[243] Upon reaching Hudaybiyya, they encountered Quraysh emissaries who questioned their intentions. Muhammad explained they had come to venerate the Kaaba, not to fight.[244] He then sent Uthman, Abu Sufyan's second cousin, to negotiate with the Quraysh. As the negotiations were prolonged, rumors of Uthman's death began to spark, prompting Muhammad to call his followers to renew their oaths of loyalty. Uthman returned with news of a negotiation impasse. Muhammad remained persistent. In the end, the Quraysh sent Suhayl ibn Amr, an envoy with full negotiation powers. Following lengthy discussions, a treaty was finally enacted,[245] with terms:

  1. A ten-year truce was established between both parties.
  2. If a Qurayshite came to Muhammad's side without his guardian's allowance, he was to be returned to the Quraysh; yet, if a Muslim came to the Quraysh, he would not be surrendered to Muhammad.
  3. Any tribes interested in forming alliances with Muhammad or the Quraysh were free to do so. These alliances were also protected by the ten-year truce.
  4. Muslims were then required to depart back to Medina, however, they were permitted to make the Umrah pilgrimage in the coming year.[245][244]

Invasion of Khaybar

[edit]

Roughly ten weeks subsequent to his return from Hudaybiyya, Muhammad expressed his plan to invade Khaybar, a flourishing oasis about 75 miles (121 km) north of Medina. The city was populated by Jews, including those from the Banu Nadir, who had previously been expelled by Muhammad from Medina. With the prospect of rich spoils from the mission, numerous volunteers answered his call.[246][247] To keep their movements hidden, the Muslim military chose to march during the nighttime. As dawn arrived and the city folks stepped out of their fortifications to harvest their dates, they were taken aback by the sight of the advancing Muslim forces. Muhammad cried out, "Allahu Akbar! Khaybar is destroyed. For when we approach a people's land, a terrible morning awaits the warned ones."[248] After a strenuous battle lasting more than a month, the Muslims successfully captured the city.[249]

The spoils, inclusive of the wives of the slain warriors, were distributed among the Muslims.[250] The chief of the Jews, Kenana ibn al-Rabi, to whom the treasure of Banu al-Nadir was entrusted, denied knowing its whereabouts. After a Jew disclosed his habitual presence around a particular ruin, Muhammad ordered excavations, and the treasure was found. When questioned about the remaining wealth, Kenana refused to divulge it. He was then put through torture by Muhammad's decree and subsequently beheaded by Muhammad ibn Maslamah in revenge for his brother.[251][252] Muhammad took Kenana's wife, Safiyya bint Huyayy, as his own slave and later advised her to convert to Islam. She accepted and agreed to become Muhammad's wife.[253]

Following their defeat by the Muslims, some of the Jews proposed to Muhammad that they stay and serve as tenant farmers, given the Muslims' lack of expertise and labor force for date palm cultivation. They agreed to give half of the annual produce to the Muslims. Muhammad consented to this arrangement with the caveat that he could displace them at any time. While they were allowed to farm, he demanded the surrender of all gold or silver, executing those who secreted away their wealth.[254][255] Taking a cue from what transpired in Khaybar, the Jews in Fadak immediately sent an envoy to Muhammad and agreed to the same terms of relinquishing 50% of their annual harvest. However, since no combat occurred, the rank and file had no claim to a portion of the spoils. Consequently, all the loot became Muhammad's exclusive wealth.[256][257]

At the feast following the battle, the meal served to Muhammad was reportedly poisoned. His companion, Bishr, fell dead after consuming it, while Muhammad himself managed to vomit it out after tasting it.[256][258] The perpetrator was Zaynab bint al-Harith, a Jewish woman whose father, uncle, and husband had been killed by the Muslims.[252] When asked why she did it, she replied, "You know what you've done to my people... I said to myself: If he is truly a prophet, he will know about the poison. If he's merely a king, I'll be rid of him."[256][252] Muhammad suffered illness for a period due to the poison he ingested, and he endured sporadic pain from it until his death.[259][260]

Final years

[edit]

Conquest of Mecca

[edit]
A depiction from the Siyer-i Nebi of Muhammad advancing on Mecca, with his face veiled. The angels Gabriel, Michael, Israfil and Azrael, are also shown.

The truce of Hudaybiyyah was enforced for two years. The tribe of Banu Khuza'ah had good relations with Muhammad, whereas their enemies, the Banu Bakr, had allied with the Meccans. A clan of the Bakr made a night raid against the Khuza'ah, killing a few of them. The Meccans helped the Banu Bakr with weapons and, according to some sources, a few Meccans also took part in the fighting. After this event, Muhammad sent a message to Mecca with three conditions, asking them to accept one of them. These were: either the Meccans would pay blood money for the slain among the Khuza'ah tribe, they disavow themselves of the Banu Bakr, or they should declare the truce of Hudaybiyyah null.[261][262]

The Meccans replied that they accepted the last condition.[261] Soon they realized their mistake and sent Abu Sufyan to renew the Hudaybiyyah treaty, a request that was declined by Muhammad.

Muhammad began to prepare for a campaign.[263] In 630, Muhammad marched on Mecca with 10,000 Muslim converts. With minimal casualties, Muhammad seized control of Mecca.[264] He declared an amnesty for past offences, except for ten men and women who were "guilty of murder or other offences or had sparked off the war and disrupted the peace".[265] Some of these were later pardoned[266] Most Meccans converted to Islam and Muhammad proceeded to destroy all the statues of Arabian gods in and around the Kaaba.[267] According to reports collected by Ibn Ishaq and al-Azraqi, Muhammad personally spared paintings or frescos of Mary and Jesus, but other traditions suggest that all pictures were erased.[268] The Quran discusses the conquest of Mecca.[215][269]

Subduing the Hawazin and Thaqif and the expedition to Tabuk

[edit]
Conquests of Muhammad (green lines) and the Rashidun caliphs (black lines), with the Byzantine Empire (north and west) and Sasanian Empire (northeast) shown

Upon learning that Mecca had fallen to the Muslims, the Banu Hawazin gathered their entire tribe, including their families, to fight. They are estimated to have around 4,000 warriors.[270][271] Muhammad led 12,000 soldiers to raid them, but they surprised him at the valley of Hunayn.[272] The Muslims overpowered them and took their women, children and animals.[273] Muhammad then turned his attention to Taif, a city that was famous for its vineyards and gardens. He ordered them to be destroyed and besieged the city, which was surrounded by walls. After 15–20 days of failing to breach their defenses, he abandoned the attempts.[274][275]

When he divided the plentiful loot acquired at Hunayn among his soldiers, the rest of the Hawazin converted to Islam[276] and implored Muhammad to release their children and women, reminding him that he had been nursed by some of those women when he was a baby. He complied but held on to the rest of the plunder. Some of his men opposed giving away their portions, so he compensated them with six camels each from subsequent raids.[277] Muhammad distributed a big portion of the booty to the new converts from the Quraysh. Abu Sufyan and two of his sons, Mu'awiya and Yazid, got 100 camels individually.[278][279] The Ansar, who had fought bravely in the battle, but received close to nothing, were unhappy with this.[280][281] One of them remarked, "It is not with such gifts that one seeks God's face." Disturbed by this utterance, Muhammad retorted, "He changed color."[278]

Roughly 10 months after he captured Mecca, Muhammad took his army to attack the wealthy border provinces of Byzantine Syria. Several motives are proposed, including avenging the defeat at Mu'tah and earning vast booty.[282][283] Because of the drought and severe heat at that time, some of the Muslims refrained from participating. This led to the revelation of Quran 9:38 which rebuked those slackers.[284] When Muhammad and his army reached Tabuk, there were no hostile forces present.[285] However, he was able to force some of the local chiefs to accept his rule and pay jizya. A group under Khalid ibn Walid that he sent for a raid also managed to acquire some booty including 2,000 camels and 800 cattle.[286]

The Hawazin's acceptance of Islam resulted in Taif losing its last major ally.[287] After enduring a year of unrelenting thefts and attacks from the Muslims following the siege, the people of Taif, known as the Banu Thaqif, finally reached a tipping point and acknowledged that embracing Islam was the most sensible path for them.[288][289][290]

Farewell pilgrimage

[edit]
Anonymous illustration of al-Biruni's The Remaining Signs of Past Centuries, depicting Muhammad prohibiting Nasī' during the Farewell Pilgrimage, 17th-century Ottoman copy of a 14th-century (Ilkhanate) manuscript (Edinburgh codex)

On February 631, Muhammad received a revelation granting idolaters four months of grace, after which the Muslims would attack, kill, and plunder them wherever they met.[291][292]

During the 632 pilgrimage season, Muhammad personally led the ceremonies and gave a sermon. Among the key points highlighted are said to have been the prohibition of usury and vendettas related to past murders from the pre-Islamic era; the brotherhood of all Muslims; and the adoption of twelve lunar months without intercalation.[293][294]

Death

[edit]
The death of Muhammad depicted in the Siyer-i Nebi

After praying at the burial site in June 632, Muhammad suffered a dreadful headache that made him cry in pain.[295] He continued to spend the night with each of his wives one by one,[296] but he fainted in Maymunah's hut.[297] He requested his wives to allow him to stay in Aisha's hut. He could not walk there without leaning on Ali and Fadl ibn Abbas, as his legs were trembling. His wives and his uncle al-Abbas fed him an Abyssinian remedy when he was unconscious.[298] When he came to, he inquired about it, and they explained that they were afraid that such a severe fever was a result of pleurisy. He replied that God would not afflict him with such a vile disease, and ordered all the women to also take the remedy.[299] According to various sources, including Sahih al-Bukhari, Muhammad said that he felt his aorta being severed because of the food he ate at Khaybar.[300][260] On 8 June 632, Muhammad died.[301][302] In his last moments, he reportedly uttered:

O God, forgive me and have mercy on me; and let me join the highest companions.[303][304][305]

— Muhammad

Historian Alfred T. Welch, while presuming the illness to be ordinary Medinan fever, with death requiring a dangerous level of comorbidity, restrains his speculation to physical and mental fatigue.[306]

Tomb

[edit]
The Prophet's Mosque in Medina, with the Green Dome built over Muhammad's tomb in the center

Muhammad was buried where he died in Aisha's house.[32][307][308] During the reign of the Umayyad caliph al-Walid I, the Prophet's Mosque was expanded to include the site of Muhammad's tomb.[309] The Green Dome above the tomb was built by the Mamluk sultan Al Mansur Qalawun in the 13th century, although the green color was added in the 16th century, under the reign of Ottoman sultan Suleiman the Magnificent.[310] Among tombs adjacent to that of Muhammad are those of his companions (Sahabah), the first two Muslim caliphs Abu Bakr and Umar, and an empty one that Muslims believe awaits Jesus.[308][311][312]

When Saud bin Abdul-Aziz took Medina in 1805, Muhammad's tomb was stripped of its gold and jewel ornamentation. Adherents to Wahhabism, Saud's followers, destroyed nearly every tomb dome in Medina in order to prevent their veneration,[313] and the one of Muhammad is reported to have narrowly escaped.[314] Similar events took place in 1925, when the Saudi militias retook—and this time managed to keep—the city.[315][316][317] In the Wahhabi interpretation of Islam, burial is to take place in unmarked graves.[314] Although the practice is frowned upon by the Saudis, many pilgrims continue to practice a ziyarat—a ritual visit—to the tomb.[318][319]

Succession

[edit]
Expansion of the caliphate, 622–750 CE:
  Muhammad, 622–632 CE
  Rashidun caliphate, 632–661 CE
  Umayyad caliphate, 661–750 CE

With Muhammad's death, disagreement broke out over who his successor would be.[301][302] Umar ibn al-Khattab, a prominent companion of Muhammad, nominated Abu Bakr, Muhammad's friend and collaborator. With additional support, Abu Bakr was confirmed as the first caliph. This choice was disputed by some of Muhammad's companions, who held that Ali ibn Abi Talib, his cousin and son-in-law, had been designated the successor by Muhammad at Ghadir Khumm. Abu Bakr immediately moved to strike against the forces of the Byzantine Empire because of the previous defeat, although he first had to put down a rebellion by Arab tribes in an event that Muslim historians later referred to as the Ridda wars, or "Wars of Apostasy".[320]

The pre-Islamic Middle East was dominated by the Byzantine and Sasanian empires. The Roman–Persian Wars between the two had devastated the region, making the empires unpopular amongst local tribes. Furthermore, in the lands that would be conquered by Muslims, many Christians (Nestorians, Monophysites, Jacobites and Copts) were disaffected from the Eastern Orthodox Church which deemed them heretics. Within a decade Muslims conquered Mesopotamia, Byzantine Syria, Byzantine Egypt,[321] large parts of Persia, and established the Rashidun Caliphate.

Household

[edit]
The tomb of Muhammad is located in the quarters of his third wife, Aisha (Prophet's Mosque, Medina).

Muhammad's life is traditionally defined into two periods: pre-hijra in Mecca (570–622), and post-hijra in Medina (622–632). Muhammad is said to have had thirteen wives in total (although two have ambiguous accounts, Rayhana bint Zayd and Maria al-Qibtiyya, as wife or concubine[j][322]).

At the age of 25, Muhammad married the wealthy Khadija, who was 40 years old.[323] The marriage lasted for 25 years and was a happy one.[324] Muhammad did not enter into marriage with another woman during this marriage.[325][326] After Khadija's death, Khawla bint Hakim suggested to Muhammad that he should marry Sawdah bint Zam'ah, a Muslim widow, or Aisha, daughter of Umm Ruman and Abu Bakr of Mecca. Muhammad is said to have asked for arrangements to marry both.[225] According to classical sources, Muhammad married Aisha when she was 6–7 years old; the marriage was consummated later, when she was 9 years old and he was 53 years old.[327]

Muhammad performed household chores such as preparing food, sewing clothes, and repairing shoes. He is also said to have accustomed his wives to dialogue; he listened to their advice, and the wives debated and even argued with him.[328][329]

Khadija is said to have had four daughters with Muhammad (Ruqayya bint Muhammad, Umm Kulthum bint Muhammad, Zainab bint Muhammad, Fatimah Zahra) and two sons (Qasim ibn Muhammad and Abd Allah ibn Muhammad, who both died in childhood). All but one of his daughters, Fatimah, died before him.[330] Some Shia scholars contend that Fatimah was Muhammad's only daughter.[331] Maria al-Qibtiyya bore him a son named Ibrahim ibn Muhammad, who died at two years old.[330]

Nine of Muhammad's wives survived after him.[322] Aisha, who became known as Muhammad's favorite wife in Sunni tradition, survived him by decades and was instrumental in helping assemble the scattered sayings of Muhammad that form the hadith literature for the Sunni branch of Islam.[225]

Zayd ibn Haritha was a slave that Khadija gave to Muhammad. He was bought by her nephew Hakim ibn Hizam at the market in Ukaz.[332] Zayd then became the couple's adopted son, but was later disowned when Muhammad was about to marry Zayd's ex-wife, Zaynab bint Jahsh.[333] According to a BBC summary, "the Prophet Muhammad did not try to abolish slavery, and bought, sold, captured, and owned slaves himself. But he insisted that slave owners treat their slaves well and stressed the virtue of freeing slaves. Muhammad treated slaves as human beings and clearly held some in the highest esteem".[334]

Legacy

[edit]

Islamic tradition

[edit]

Following the attestation to the oneness of God, the belief in Muhammad's prophethood is the main aspect of the Islamic faith. Every Muslim proclaims in the Shahada: "I testify that there is no god but God, and I testify that Muhammad is a Messenger of God". The Shahada is the basic creed or tenet of Islam. Islamic belief is that ideally the Shahada is the first words a newborn will hear; children are taught it immediately and it will be recited upon death. Muslims repeat the shahadah in the call to prayer (adhan) and the prayer itself. Non-Muslims wishing to convert to Islam are required to recite the creed.[335]

Calligraphic rendering of "may God honor him and grant him peace", customarily added after Muhammad's name, encoded as a ligature at Unicode code point U+FDFA[336]

In Islamic belief, Muhammad is regarded as the last prophet sent by God.[337] Writings such as hadith and sira attribute several miracles or supernatural events to Muhammad.[338] One of these is the splitting of the Moon, which according to earliest available tafsir compilations is a literal splitting of the Moon.[339]

The sunnah represents the actions and sayings of Muhammad preserved in hadith and covers a broad array of activities and beliefs ranging from religious rituals, personal hygiene, and burial of the dead to the mystical questions involving the love between humans and God. The sunnah is considered a model of emulation for pious Muslims and has to a great degree influenced the Muslim culture. Many details of major Islamic rituals such as daily prayers, the fasting and the annual pilgrimage are only found in the sunnah and not the Quran.[340]

The Shahadah illustrated in Topkapı Palace, Istanbul, Turkey

Muslims have traditionally expressed love and veneration for Muhammad. Stories of Muhammad's life, his intercession and of his miracles have permeated popular Muslim thought and poetry (naʽat). Among Arabic odes to Muhammad, Qasidat al-Burda ("Poem of the Mantle") by the Egyptian Sufi al-Busiri (1211–1294) is particularly well-known, and widely held to possess a healing, spiritual power.[341] The Quran refers to Muhammad as "a mercy (rahmat) to the worlds".[342][32] The association of rain with mercy in Oriental countries has led to imagining Muhammad as a rain cloud dispensing blessings and stretching over lands, reviving the dead hearts, just as rain revives the seemingly dead earth.[k][32] Muhammad's birthday is celebrated as a major feast throughout the Muslim world, excluding Wahhabi-dominated Saudi Arabia where these public celebrations are discouraged.[343] When Muslims say or write the name of Muhammad, they usually follow it with the Arabic phrase ṣallā llahu ʿalayhi wa-sallam (may God honor him and grant him peace) or the English phrase peace be upon him.[344] In casual writing, the abbreviations SAW (for the Arabic phrase) or PBUH (for the English phrase) are sometimes used; in printed matter, a small calligraphic rendition is commonly used ().

Appearance and depictions

[edit]
Depiction of Muhammad at the Kaaba in Mecca from Siyer-i Nebi

Various sources present a probable description of Muhammad in the prime of his life. He was slightly above average in height, with a sturdy frame and wide chest. His neck was long, bearing a large head with a broad forehead. His eyes were described as dark and intense, accentuated by long, dark eyelashes. His hair, black and not entirely curly, hung over his ears. His long, dense beard stood out against his neatly trimmed mustache. His nose was long and aquiline, ending in a fine point. His teeth were well-spaced. His face was described as intelligent, and his clear skin had a line of hair from his neck to his navel. Despite a slight stoop, his stride was brisk and purposeful.[345] Muhammad's lip and cheek were ripped by a slingstone during the Battle of Uhud.[346][347] The wound was later cauterized, leaving a scar on his face.[348]

However, since the hadith prohibits the creation of images of sentient living beings, Islamic religious art mainly focuses on calligraphy.[349][350] Muslims generally avoid depictions of Muhammad, and instead decorate mosques with calligraphy, Quranic inscriptions, or geometrical designs.[349][351] Today, the interdiction against images of Muhammad—designed to prevent worship of Muhammad, rather than God—is much more strictly observed in Sunni Islam (85–90% of Muslims) and Ahmadiyya Islam (1%) than among Shias (10–15%).[352] While both Sunnis and Shias have created images of Muhammad in the past,[353] Islamic depictions of Muhammad are rare.[349] They have mostly been limited to the private and elite medium of the miniature, and since about 1500 most depictions show Muhammad with his face veiled, or symbolically represent him as a flame.[351][354]

Muhammad's entry into Mecca and the destruction of idols. Muhammad is shown as a flame in this manuscript. Found in Bazil's Hamla-i Haydari, Jammu and Kashmir, India, 1808.

The earliest extant depictions come from 13th century Anatolian Seljuk and Ilkhanid Persian miniatures, typically in literary genres describing the life and deeds of Muhammad.[354][355] During the Ilkhanid period, when Persia's Mongol rulers converted to Islam, competing Sunni and Shia groups used visual imagery, including images of Muhammad, to promote their particular interpretation of Islam's key events.[356] Influenced by the Buddhist tradition of representational religious art predating the Mongol elite's conversion, this innovation was unprecedented in the Islamic world, and accompanied by a "broader shift in Islamic artistic culture away from abstraction toward representation" in "mosques, on tapestries, silks, ceramics, and in glass and metalwork" besides books.[357] In the Persian lands, this tradition of realistic depictions lasted through the Timurid dynasty until the Safavids took power in the early 16th century.[356] The Safavaids, who made Shia Islam the state religion, initiated a departure from the traditional Ilkhanid and Timurid artistic style by covering Muhammad's face with a veil to obscure his features and at the same time represent his luminous essence.[358] Concomitantly, some of the unveiled images from earlier periods were defaced.[356][359][360] Later images were produced in Ottoman Turkey and elsewhere, but mosques were never decorated with images of Muhammad.[353] Illustrated accounts of the night journey (mi'raj) were particularly popular from the Ilkhanid period through the Safavid era.[361] During the 19th century, Iran saw a boom of printed and illustrated mi'raj books, with Muhammad's face veiled, aimed in particular at illiterates and children in the manner of graphic novels. Reproduced through lithography, these were essentially "printed manuscripts".[361] Today, millions of historical reproductions and modern images are available in some Muslim-majority countries, especially Turkey and Iran, on posters, postcards, and even in coffee-table books, but are unknown in most other parts of the Islamic world, and when encountered by Muslims from other countries, they can cause considerable consternation and offense.[353][354]

Islamic social reforms

[edit]

According to W. Montgomery Watt, religion for Muhammad was not a private and individual matter but "the total response of his personality to the total situation in which he found himself. He was responding [not only]... to the religious and intellectual aspects of the situation but also to the economic, social, and political pressures to which contemporary Mecca was subject."[362] Bernard Lewis says there are two important political traditions in Islam—Muhammad as a statesman in Medina, and Muhammad as a rebel in Mecca. In his view, Islam is a great change, akin to a revolution, when introduced to new societies.[363]

Historians generally agree that Islamic social changes in areas such as social security, family structure, slavery and the rights of women and children improved on the status quo of Arab society.[363][364] For example, according to Lewis, Islam "from the first denounced aristocratic privilege, rejected hierarchy, and adopted a formula of the career open to the talents".[363] Muhammad's message transformed society and moral orders of life in the Arabian Peninsula; society focused on the changes to perceived identity, worldview, and the hierarchy of values.[365][page needed] Economic reforms addressed the plight of the poor, which was becoming an issue in pre-Islamic Mecca.[366] The Quran requires payment of an alms tax (zakat) for the benefit of the poor; as Muhammad's power grew he demanded that tribes who wished to ally with him implement the zakat in particular.[367][368]

European appreciation

[edit]
Muhammad in La vie de Mahomet by M. Prideaux (1699). He holds a sword and a crescent while trampling on a globe, a cross, and the Ten Commandments.

Guillaume Postel was among the first to present a more positive view of Muhammad when he argued that Muhammad should be esteemed by Christians as a valid prophet.[32][369] Gottfried Leibniz praised Muhammad because "he did not deviate from the natural religion".[32] Henri de Boulainvilliers, in his Vie de Mahomed which was published posthumously in 1730, described Muhammad as a gifted political leader and a just lawmaker.[32] He presents him as a divinely inspired messenger whom God employed to confound the bickering Oriental Christians, to liberate the Orient from the despotic rule of the Romans and Persians, and to spread the knowledge of the unity of God from India to Spain.[370] Voltaire had a mixed opinion on Muhammad: in his play Le fanatisme, ou Mahomet le Prophète he vilifies Muhammad as a symbol of fanaticism, and in an essay in 1748 he calls him "a sublime and hearty charlatan". But in Voltaire's historical survey Essai sur les mœurs, he presents Muhammad as a legislator and conqueror and calls him an "enthusiast".[370] Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in his Social Contract (1762), "brushing aside hostile legends of Muhammad as a trickster and impostor, presents him as a sage legislator who wisely fused religious and political powers".[370] In Emmanuel Pastoret's 1787 Zoroaster, Confucius and Muhammad, he presents the lives of these three "great men", "the greatest legislators of the universe", and compares their careers as religious reformers and lawgivers. Pastoret rejects the common view that Muhammad is an impostor and argues that the Quran proffers "the most sublime truths of cult and morals"; it defines the unity of God with an "admirable concision". Pastoret writes that the common accusations of his immorality are unfounded: on the contrary, his law enjoins sobriety, generosity, and compassion on his followers: the "legislator of Arabia" was "a great man".[370] Napoleon Bonaparte admired Muhammad and Islam,[371] and described him as a model lawmaker and conqueror.[372] Thomas Carlyle in his book On Heroes, Hero-Worship, & the Heroic in History 1841 describes "Mahomet" as "A silent great soul; he was one of those who cannot but be in earnest".[373] Carlyle's interpretation has been widely cited by Muslim scholars as a demonstration that Western scholarship validates Muhammad's status as a great man in history.[374]

Ian Almond says that German Romantic writers generally held positive views of Muhammad: "Goethe's 'extraordinary' poet-prophet, Herder's nation builder (...) Schlegel's admiration for Islam as an aesthetic product, enviably authentic, radiantly holistic, played such a central role in his view of Mohammed as an exemplary world-fashioner that he even used it as a scale of judgement for the classical (the dithyramb, we are told, has to radiate pure beauty if it is to resemble 'a Koran of poetry')".[375] After quoting Heinrich Heine, who said in a letter to some friend that "I must admit that you, the great prophet of Mecca, are the greatest poet and that your Quran... will not easily escape my memory", John Tolan goes on to show how Jews in Europe in particular held more nuanced views about Muhammad and Islam, being an ethnoreligious minority feeling discriminated, they specifically lauded Al-Andalus, and thus, "writing about Islam was for Jews a way of indulging in a fantasy world, far from the persecution and pogroms of nineteenth-century Europe, where Jews could live in harmony with their non-Jewish neighbors".[376]

Recent writers such as William Montgomery Watt and Richard Bell dismiss the idea that Muhammad deliberately deceived his followers, arguing that Muhammad "was absolutely sincere and acted in complete good faith"[377] and Muhammad's readiness to endure hardship for his cause, with what seemed to be no rational basis for hope, shows his sincerity.[378] Watt, however, says that sincerity does not directly imply correctness: in contemporary terms, Muhammad might have mistaken his subconscious for divine revelation.[379] Watt and Bernard Lewis argue that viewing Muhammad as a self-seeking impostor makes it impossible to understand Islam's development.[380][381] Alford T. Welch holds that Muhammad was able to be so influential and successful because of his firm belief in his vocation.[32]

Criticism

[edit]

Criticism of Muhammad has existed since the 7th century, when Muhammad was decried by his non-Muslim Arab contemporaries for preaching monotheism, and by the Jewish tribes of Arabia for his perceived appropriation of Biblical narratives and figures and proclamation of himself as the "Seal of the Prophets".[382][383][384][385] In the Middle Ages, Western and Byzantine Christians labeled him a false prophet, the Antichrist, or portrayed him as a heretic.[386][384][387][385] Contemporary criticism involves questioning Muhammad's legitimacy as a prophet, his moral conduct, marriages, ownership of slaves, treatment of enemies, approach to doctrinal matters, and psychological well-being.[386][388][389][390]

Sufism

[edit]

The sunnah contributed much to the development of Islamic law, particularly from the end of the first Islamic century.[391] Muslim mystics, known as Sufis, who were seeking for the inner meaning of the Quran and the inner nature of Muhammad, viewed the prophet of Islam not only as a prophet but also as a perfect human being. All Sufi orders trace their chain of spiritual descent back to Muhammad.[392]

Other religions

[edit]

Muhammad Sahib is honored by Sikhs as one of the divine messengers sent to mankind, along with Moses, Jesus and others.[393] Guru Granth Sahib, the holiest book of Sikhism, states that a true Muslim who follows the faith of Muhammad would put aside the "delusion of death and life."[394] The founder of Sikhism, Guru Nanak, is specifically said to have praised Muhammad as a source of divine experience having a personal influence on his life, as stated in the janamsakhi of Bhai Bala.[395]

Followers of the Baháʼí Faith venerate Muhammad as one of a number of prophets or "Manifestations of God". He is thought to be the final manifestation, or seal of the Adamic cycle, but consider his teachings to have been superseded by those of Bahá'u'lláh, the founder of the Baháʼí faith, and the first manifestation of the current cycle.[396][397]

Druze tradition honors several "mentors" and "prophets",[398] and Muhammad is considered an important prophet of God in the Druze faith, being among the seven prophets who appeared in different periods of history.[399][400]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Muhammad (محمد) ibn Abdullah (Arabic: محمد بن عبد الله) (c. 570 – 8 June 632 CE) is traditionally regarded in as the final prophet and as the founder of the Muslim community; historians generally accept him as a 7th-century Arabian religious and political leader in western Arabia, while disputing many biographical details because most narratives about his life and reported revelations come from Islamic scripture and later biographical and hadith literature compiled after his death. Born into the tribe's Banu Hashim (بنو هاشم) clan, Islamic tradition reports that he experienced his first revelation around 610 CE while in seclusion in a cave near Mecca (مَكَّة), prompting him to preach against polytheism and social injustices, such as female infanticide reported in Islamic tradition as prevalent in pre-Islamic Arabia. Muhammad’s preaching in Mecca encountered opposition, and later Islamic accounts attribute this to religious, social, and economic tensions, including conflicts with leading Quraysh families. In 622 CE, Muhammad and his followers migrated to Yathrib (يثرب; later ), an event known as the and the starting point of the Islamic calendar; sources also attribute to this period the ‘,’ described in later tradition as an agreement regulating relations among Medinan groups, including Jewish tribes. Over subsequent years, Muhammad led or authorized a series of raids and battles—traditionally including (624) and the return to Mecca (630)—culminating in Meccan submission; Islamic biographical literature reports the removal of idols from the , though the precise details and numbers vary by source. After Muhammad’s death in Medina, disagreements within the early Muslim community over political and religious leadership—often framed in later sources as disputes about whether he had designated a successor—contributed to conflicts that, over time, crystallized into the ; these later traditions emphasize differing principles of authority, including consultation/communal selection and leadership claims associated with his family.

Early Life and Background

Birth, Family, and Upbringing in Mecca

Muhammad (محمد) was born circa 570 CE in Mecca, a commercial hub in western Arabia controlled by the Quraysh tribe. The Quraysh gained influence through trade caravans and custodianship of the Kaaba shrine. He belonged to the Banu Hashim subclan, known for custodianship roles but modest wealth compared to other Quraysh groups. His father, Abdullah ibn Abd al-Muttalib (عبد الله بن عبد المطلب), a merchant, died before or shortly after the birth during a trading trip. His mother, Amina bint Wahb (آمنة بنت وهب) of the Banu Zuhrah (بنو زُهرة) clan, raised him initially with wet nurse Halima per Meccan custom of sending infants to Bedouin tribes for health. Traditions describe an "opening of the chest" incident—two figures purifying him—which alarmed Halima's family and led to his early return (Ibn Ishaq, Guillaume tr., pp. 71–72). Amina died when Muhammad was about six, during a trip to Medina. Orphaned young, Muhammad lived with his grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, a prominent Quraysh elder who included him in tribal ceremonies and protected clan interests until dying two years later, when Muhammad was eight. His uncle Abu Talib, Banu Hashim chief, then raised him as a son despite limited resources. Abu Talib provided shelter, protection, and involvement in caravan trade to Syria and Yemen, while upholding ancestral religion. Mecca's polytheistic setting featured tribal feuds, Kaaba idolatry, and an economy tied to pilgrimage and commerce. Islamic sources like the Quran, Hadith, and Ibn Ishaq's Sirah depict Muhammad as a Hanif: a monotheist following Abraham's pure faith, rejecting Quraysh polytheism, and seeking solitude in the Cave of Hira. In his early teens, he herded sheep; later, as a trader, he gained reputations for honesty, earning titles al-Amin (trustworthy) and al-Sadiq (truthful). These accounts stem mainly from eighth-century biographies like Ibn Ishaq's Sira. Scholars value them for general outlines but note limitations: compilation over a century later, oral transmission open to theological influence, and absence of seventh-century non-Islamic corroboration.

Pre-Prophetic Occupation and Marriage to Khadijah

In his youth, Muhammad ibn Abdullah worked as a shepherd for Meccan families, a common role that sustained him after early orphanhood. In his late teens or early twenties, he joined caravan trade under uncle Abu Talib (أَبُو طَالِب), traveling routes to Syria and building mercantile skills in Mecca's pilgrimage- and trade-based economy. His reliability earned him the Quraysh epithet al-Amin (الْأَمِين) (the trustworthy). Around age 25, circa 595 CE, Muhammad was hired by Khadijah bint Khuwaylid (خَدِيجَة بِنْت خُوَيْلِد), a wealthy Quraysh widow from the Banu Asad branch, to manage her Syria caravan due to his integrity. Khadijah, from a merchant family, had amassed wealth trading leather, textiles, and perfumes; widowed twice, she independently handled property and ventures in Mecca's market. Her status highlighted the agency of elite pre-Islamic Meccan women, including inheritance rights and marriage proposals. The trip's high profits impressed her; reportedly aged about 40, she proposed via intermediary, which Muhammad accepted after consulting Abu Talib (أَبُو طَالِب). Their union followed Quraysh customs without Muhammad's dowry, providing economic stability and lasting monogamously for 25 years until her death in 619 CE. They lived in Khadijah's Mecca home and had six children: sons al-Qasim (الْقَاسِم) (died in infancy) and, per some accounts like Ibn Ishaq, al-Tayyib and al-Tahir (or epithets for al-Abdullah, who died young); and daughters Zaynab, Ruqayyah, Umm Kulthum, and Fatima (فاطمة), who reached adulthood. Traditionally, all Muhammad's children except Fatimah (who died soon after him) predeceased him. Sources vary on Khadijah's marriage age, with modern analyses questioning the childbearing timeline. This marriage elevated Muhammad's social and financial position, allowing solitary reflection before prophethood.

Prophethood and Meccan Period

First Revelation and Initial Preaching

Around age 40, during Ramadan in 610 CE, Muhammad retreated to the Cave of Hira on Jabal al-Nour (Arabic: جبل النور) near Mecca for meditation. Islamic tradition holds that the angel Jibril (Gabriel) appeared, embraced him repeatedly with intense pressure—causing him to fear death—and commanded iqra (Arabic: اقْرَأْ, "recite" or "read"), revealing the first five verses of Surah Al-Alaq (Quran 96:1-5): "Recite in the name of your Lord who created, created man from a clinging substance. Recite, and your Lord is the most Generous—who taught by the pen, taught man that which he knew not." Distressed and illiterate, Muhammad protested his inability, but the angel persisted until the words were conveyed. He fled the cave, fearing he was majnūn (mad or possessed by jinn), as preserved in early accounts like Ibn Ishaq (Arabic: ابن إسحاق) (p. 106) and sahih narrations (Sahih al-Bukhari 1:1:3; Musnad Ahmad (Arabic: مسند أحمد) 6:223). Trembling, Muhammad returned home and confided in his wife Khadijah bint Khuwaylid (Arabic: خَدِيجَة بِنْتِ خُوَيْلِد), who reassured him of his character and took him to her cousin Waraqah ibn Nawfal, an elderly Christian scholar familiar with scriptures. Waraqah identified the angel as the one who visited Moses, predicted persecution, and affirmed Muhammad's prophethood, though he died soon after without further revelations. A brief pause in revelations followed, causing such distress that traditions describe Muhammad contemplating suicide from mountain peaks, averted by Jibril's visions, until Surah Ad-Duha (93:1-11) reassured him (Sahih al-Bukhari 9:87:111; Ibn Ishaq, p. 106). Later revelations induced somatic intensity, including heavy perspiration in cold weather, bell-like sounds, and terror, with Muhammad sometimes rushing home crying, "Cover me! Cover me!" (Sahih al-Bukhari 1:1:2, 1:1:3; Sahih Muslim 30:5763). These accounts stem mainly from 8th-century Muslim sources like Ibn Ishaq's sīra (d. 767 CE), transmitted orally earlier but compiled over a century later, inviting scholarly scrutiny for theological influence without contemporary non-Muslim corroboration. For the first three years, Muhammad preached privately to kin and close associates, stressing monotheism (tawhid (Arabic: توحيد)), rejection of polytheism, and social ethics. This yielded about 40 converts, including Khadijah (first), his young cousin Ali ibn Abi Talib, adopted son Zayd ibn Harithah, friend Abu Bakr ibn Abi Quhafah, and freed slave Bilal ibn Rabah. Commanded in Quran 74:1-5 to "arise and warn," this secretive da'wah avoided immediate backlash from Mecca's polytheistic Quraysh. A narration attributed to ʿAbd Allāh ibn Masʿūd in Musnad Ahmad describes an encounter after the ʿIshaʾ prayer in a Meccan valley during the prophethood period. Muhammad instructed Ibn Masʿūd to remain within a marked boundary while he went a short distance to recite Quran. Ibn Masʿūd observed tall, thin male figures resembling the Zutt (Arabic: الزطّ), initially unclothed but with genitals obscured, gathering around Muhammad as he recited. These figures approached Ibn Masʿūd, causing him fear, and remained until dawn before departing. Muhammad returned visibly fatigued, resting his head on Ibn Masʿūd’s lap. A subsequent appearance involved figures in white garments, interpreted as angels discussing a parable related to Islam. Parallel accounts appear in Sunan al-Tirmidhi (2861), often understood in tradition as jinn hearing the Quran, consistent with Surah al-Jinn. Around 613 CE, Quran 15:94 prompted public preaching. Muhammad ascended Safa Hill, summoning Quraysh clans to reject polytheism and affirm one God, asking, "If I told you that an army was behind this hill, would you believe me?" Initial curiosity turned to derision, led by figures like his uncle Abu Lahab. Converts grew modestly among slaves, youth, and women, reaching 70-100 by 615 CE; among these early converts was Muhammad's cousin Ubayd Allah ibn Jahsh (Arabic: عبيد الله بن جحش), who migrated to the Kingdom of Axum (Ge'ez: አክሱም) with other Muslims around 615 CE but later apostatized from Islam and converted to Christianity there, as reported in early biographical sources like Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (Arabic: سيرة رسول الله). but the message threatened Quraysh economic ties to Kaaba idols and tribal unity. Early traditions record the 'Gharaniq' (الغرانيق) incident, where Satan allegedly interjected idol-praising verses later abrogated (Quran 22:52), accepted by historians like al-Tabari and Ibn Ishaq but debated later (cf. Shahab Ahmed, Before Orthodoxy, 2017). These narratives rely on sīra traditions, with limited 7th-century external or archaeological evidence beyond post-632 CE attestations of Muhammad's existence.

Growing Opposition and Persecution of Early Muslims

As Muhammad began public preaching around 613 CE, denouncing polytheism central to Meccan society and commerce, opposition grew among the Quraysh elite. They perceived his monotheistic message as a threat to their religious authority, the Kaaba's pilgrimage economy, tribal prestige, and social cohesion, given its tendency to divide families and criticize ancestors and deities. Leaders like Abu Jahl (Amr ibn Hisham, عمرو بن هشام) and Abu Lahab (Muhammad's uncle) initially responded with verbal ridicule and social ostracism, then escalated to violence against vulnerable converts to force recantations. This resistance arose from the disruption of idol veneration, which sustained Quraysh trade and pilgrims, alongside fears of broader social upheaval. Persecution targeted slaves, women, and the poor among early converts, who lacked tribal protection, with masters using brutal tactics to compel apostasy. Bilal ibn Rabah (بلال بن رباح), an enslaved Abyssinian owned by Umayya ibn Khalaf, suffered torture such as exposure on hot sand under heavy stones while urged to renounce Islam; he remained steadfast until Abu Bakr ransomed him around 615 CE. Sumayyah bint Khayyat, an early convert with her husband Yasir, endured beatings and was ultimately impaled by Abu Jahl, becoming the first martyr in Islamic tradition around 615 CE. Early sources like Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah record these events as intimidation tactics met with converts' resilience, though historians caution against hagiographic elements in Muslim narratives. Unable to directly target Muhammad due to his uncle Abu Talib's protection, the Quraysh imposed a boycott in 616 CE on the Banu Hashim and allied Banu Muttalib clans, via a pact at the Kaaba banning marriages, trade, and interactions until Muhammad's surrender. The clans withdrew to the Shi'b Abi Talib (شعب أبي طالب) valley, facing three years of hardship including famine, infant deaths, and subsistence on scavenged leather; non-Muslims like Abu Talib endured it for tribal loyalty. The boycott ended around 619 CE when Meccan leaders, led by figures like Hisham ibn Amr, annulled it due to kinship ties, perceived injustice, termite damage to the pact (seen by some as divine), and growing internal opposition. The Muslim community still expanded to 70–100 members by 622 CE, aided by secret migrations to Abyssinia in 615 and 616 CE under the Christian ruler Negus Ashama ibn Abjar (النجاشي أصحمة بن أبجر), where Quraysh extradition attempts failed. Offers to Abu Talib—wealth or a substitute heir for abandoning Muhammad—were rejected, upholding tribal customs. Assassination plots eventually spurred the Hijra. Though drawn from pro-Islamic sources, these accounts reflect scholarly agreement on the polytheists' sense of existential threat, fostering Muslim resilience amid resistance.

Hijra and Medinan State-Building

Migration to Medina and Community Formation (622 CE)

In 622 CE, Muhammad led the Hijra, the mass migration of his followers from Mecca to Medina (then Yathrib), driven by intensifying persecution from Quraysh leaders who plotted his assassination after the deaths of protectors like Abu Talib. The emigration unfolded in stages from around May, involving roughly 150-200 early Muslims—primarily Muhajirun (emigrants)—who traveled covertly via coastal and desert routes to evade capture. They joined converts among the Aws and Khazraj tribes, who had pledged allegiance at Aqaba in 621 CE, arriving over several months. Muhammad departed last with Abu Bakr (أبو بكر), hiding in the Cave of Thawr south of Mecca for three days to escape search parties; tradition attributes concealment to a spiderweb and dove's nest at the entrance. Guided by non-Muslim Abdullah ibn Uraiqit along safe paths, with provisions from 'Amir ibn Fuhayra, they covered about 260 miles northward, reaching Quba—a suburb of Medina—in early September. At Quba on 8 Rabi' al-Awwal (circa September 622), Muhammad oversaw construction of Masjid Quba (مسجد قباء)—Islam's first mosque—using mud bricks and date-palm trunks. He stayed there 4 to 14 days while Ali ibn Abi Talib recovered remaining Meccan assets. Moving to central Medina, his she-camel Qaswa stopped at a burial ground, seen as divine choice for Masjid an-Nabawi, built with similar materials as a prayer hall and shelter. To integrate the groups, Muhammad introduced mu'akhat, pairing about 45-90 Muhajirun with Ansar (Medinan helpers) as "brothers in faith." This shared resources, inheritance (later modified by revelation), and defense, easing emigrants' hardships and promoting unity beyond tribes in the emerging ummah. Conducted in the mosque, it elevated Muhammad as arbiter, paving the way for the Constitution of Medina's confederation with local tribes, including Jewish ones, despite polytheist remnants.

Constitution of Medina and Relations with Tribes

The Constitution of Medina, drafted by Muhammad shortly after his arrival in Yathrib (later Medina) in September 622 CE, established a pact among Muslim emigrants (Muhajirun, المهاجرون), local Arab converts (Ansar), and major Jewish tribes, including Banu Qaynuqa (بنو قينقاع), Banu Nadir (بنو النضير), and Banu Qurayza (بنو قريظة). Preserved in fragments from early sources like Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah, it created a confederation focused on mutual defense, internal arbitration, and religious autonomy within a unified ummah (community). Comprising about 47 clauses, the document covered believers' community, Jewish alliances, and tribal duties, shifting from tribal feuds to centralized authority under Muhammad. Provisions declared Muslims and allies as "one community to the exclusion of other people," binding them against external threats while barring internal alliances with enemies. Jewish tribes kept religious freedom and arms-bearing rights for defense, shared blood money (diyah, دِيَة) duties, and committed to collective captive redemption; disputes went to God and Muhammad as arbitrator. The pact prohibited aiding Quraysh foes from Mecca and stressed loyalty to Medina as a sacred precinct (haram, حَرَم), forming a proto-state amid tribal rivalries. Scholars view it as authentic early agreements, though debates continue on phrasing and Jewish integration as equals or allies. Initial stability among Medina's groups gave way to tensions from Meccan pressures and alleged covenant breaches by Jewish clans. The Banu Qaynuqa, goldsmiths linked to Khazraj, were expelled in early 624 CE after Badr. Accounts cite their mockery of Muslims, an incident where a Jewish artisan pinned a Muslim woman's skirt leading to a killing, and refusal to submit, resulting in a 15-day siege and removal to Syria with few possessions. Islamic sources frame this as response to defense violations, reducing Jewish market influence. Tensions rose with Banu Nadir, agriculturists with fertile lands, expelled in August 625 CE post-Uhud. Muhammad accused them of assassination plots revealed divinely; after a two-week siege, they left for Khaybar or Syria without weapons or palms, whose seizure aided military funds per Qur'an 59:5-6. Sources describe preemptive action against Quraysh incitement and non-compliance, with expulsion numbers from 40 to 600 families. Banu Qurayza, smiths allied with Aws, faced severe consequences after the 627 CE Trench battle. They allegedly betrayed by negotiating with the 10,000-strong Quraysh coalition, offering rear access for dominance. Post-victory, a 25-day siege ended in surrender; arbiter Sa'd ibn Mu'adh judged combatants—traditionally 400-900 men executed per Torah invocation, women and children enslaved, property taken—though some scholars like W. N. Arafat suggest smaller scale for leaders. A hadith narrated by Aisha in Sunan Abi Dawud reports that one woman from Banu Qurayza was executed separately for committing a specific offense, despite the general enslavement of non-combatant women and children. Traditions portray Torah-based justice for wartime betrayal; non-Muslim views confirm historicity via early narratives despite severity. These events strengthened Muslim control, reallocating resources and neutralizing threats, though sira sources may idealize retrospectively.

Military Engagements and Conquests (622–632 CE)

#DateLocationEventOutcome
1March 624 CEBadr (near Medina)Battle of BadrDecisive Muslim victory over Quraysh forces (~14 Muslim deaths, ~70 Quraysh killed)
2March 625 CEUhud (near Medina)Battle of UhudTactical Meccan success but strategic stalemate for Muslims (~70 Muslim deaths, ~22–37 Meccan deaths)
3April 627 CEMedinaBattle of the TrenchDefensive Muslim victory against confederate alliance (minimal casualties: ~5–6 Muslims, ~3 enemies)
4Late 627 CEMedinaSiege of Banu QurayzaExecution of ~600–900 adult males, enslavement of others after surrender (no Muslim casualties in siege)
5May–June 628 CEKhaybar oasisConquest of KhaybarMuslim victory, establishment of tribute from Jewish tribes (~several dozen Jewish fighters killed)
6March 628 CEHudaybiyyah (near Mecca)Treaty of HudaybiyyahTen-year truce with Quraysh, enabling peaceful expansion (no casualties)
7January 630 CEMeccaConquest of MeccaLargely bloodless takeover, destruction of idols (~dozen casualties)
8October 630 CETabuk (northern Arabia)Expedition to TabukNo major battle; secured submissions and tribute from tribes (no battle casualties)

Key Battles: Badr, Uhud, and the Trench

The Battle of Badr, fought on 17 Ramadan 2 AH (March 13–17, 624 CE), was the first major clash between Medina's Muslims and Mecca's Quraysh. Muhammad commanded 313–317 fighters, including 82 Meccan emigrants, with limited equipment—2 horses and 70 shared camels—against Abu Sufyan's 950–1,000 men, who sought revenge for Muslim raids on caravans. By controlling Badr's wells and using high morale and tactics, including Muhammad's central charge, the Muslims secured victory: 70 Meccans killed (including Abu Jahl) and 70 captured, versus 14 Muslim deaths. Traditional accounts credit divine aid, but factors included terrain advantages and Meccan overconfidence. Sira sources like Ibn Ishaq, compiled over a century later, may exaggerate numbers for emphasis, yet the battle's occurrence and Muslim success are widely accepted. The Battle of Uhud on 7 Shawwal 3 AH (March 23, 625 CE) reversed this fortune, as the Quraysh sought vengeance with 3,000 troops under Abu Sufyan, including 200 cavalry and morale-boosting women led by Hind bint Utbah. Muhammad fielded 700–1,000 after tribal withdrawals. Muslims initially dominated, killing carriers like Talha ibn Abi Talha, but 50 archers left their post on Uhud's slopes for spoils, enabling Khalid ibn al-Walid's cavalry to flank them. Chaos ensued, wounding Muhammad slightly. Meccans claimed tactical success but strategic stalemate, with 70 Muslims (including Hamza) and 22–37 Meccans killed. Sources highlight archer disobedience and leadership lapses, emphasizing infantry's vulnerability without cavalry. In contrast, the Battle of the Trench (al-Khandaq, الخندق) in Shawwal 5 AH (April 627 CE) adopted defense against a 10,000-strong confederacy of Quraysh, Ghatafan, and Medina's Banu Qurayza tribe. Muhammad's 3,000 dug a 3–5 km trench (4.5–9 m deep and wide) around Medina's north, inspired by Salman al-Farsi, halting cavalry over two weeks. Harsh weather, shortages, and Nuaym ibn Masud's deception—spreading false betrayal reports—fractured the alliance, leading to withdrawal with minimal casualties (5–6 Muslims, 3 enemies). Narratives invoke a storm, but key elements were the trench's novelty, subversion, and coalition strains; inflated enemy numbers in sira persist, but the defensive triumph is corroborated as crucial for Medina's survival.

Later Expeditions, Treaty of Hudaybiyyah, and Conquest of Mecca

Following the Battle of the Trench in April 627 CE (5 AH), Muhammad authorized expeditions against remaining Jewish tribes in Medina and nearby oases, including the siege of the Banu Qurayza for about 25 days later that year. After their alleged treason during the siege, the tribe surrendered unconditionally. An arbitrator from the Aws tribe, Sa'd ibn Mu'adh, ruled that 600 to 900 adult males be executed, with women and children enslaved or ransomed, and property divided among Muslims—invoking Jewish law from the Tawrat, as preserved in classical sources (al-Tabari, Tarikh, Vol. 8, pp. 35-38; Ibn Hisham, Sira, vol. 2, p. 240). Muhammad approved the judgment as aligning with divine will (Sahih al-Bukhari 5:58:148). This event consolidated Muslim control over Medina by eliminating internal threats. In May 628 CE (Muharram 7 AH), Muhammad led about 1,600 men against the Jewish stronghold of Khaybar (خيبر), defeating its defenders after a siege and securing an annual tribute of half their produce in dates and grains. Further raids, or sariyyah (سرية), targeted Bedouin tribes like the Banu Lihyan and Ghatafan to enforce alliances or extract reparations, emphasizing submission to Medina's authority over forced conversion. In the context of such night raids against polytheist tribes, a hadith in Sahih Muslim reports that Muhammad, when asked about the killing of women and children, stated: "They are from them." These actions expanded Muhammad's influence across northern Arabia amid ongoing skirmishes. In March 628 CE (Dhu al-Qa'dah 6 AH), Muhammad set out from Medina with around 1,400 unarmed followers to perform umrah in Mecca, but Quraysh blocked them at Hudaybiyyah (حديبية), 20 kilometers from the city, due to security concerns. Negotiations, mediated by Suhayl ibn Amr (سهيل بن عمرو), yielded a treaty for a ten-year truce, cessation of hostilities, return of Meccan fugitives (excluding women who fled), no new alliances without consent, and permission for Muslims to perform umrah the next year for three days without arms. The document listed Muhammad as "Muhammad son of Abdullah," omitting his prophetic title—a concession some companions found humiliating but which enabled peaceful propagation of Islam. The truce facilitated rapid Muslim growth as tribes converted and shifted allegiances to Medina. The treaty broke in 630 CE (7 AH) when Quraysh allies, the Banu Bakr, attacked Muslim-allied Banu Khuza'ah (بنو خزاعة) near Hudaybiyyah, killing several despite the truce. Muhammad demanded reparations with a 10-day ultimatum, which Quraysh rejected, abrogating the pact. He then mobilized 10,000 men, including recent converts, and advanced on Mecca in December 629–January 630 CE (Ramadan 8 AH). The city fell with minimal resistance after Abu Sufyan converted and secured safe-conduct. Muhammad declared general amnesty, sparing most opponents except a few enemies, and entered the Kaaba (كعبة) to destroy its 360 idols by striking them with a stick while reciting, "Truth has come and falsehood has vanished. Truly falsehood is ever bound to vanish" (Quran 17:81) and "Truth has come and falsehood cannot create anything" (Quran 34:49), as narrated by Abdullah bin Masud in Sahih al-Bukhari (hadith 4720). This act transitioned Arabia from religious pluralism to monotheism. The largely bloodless conquest, with about a dozen casualties, subjugated Quraysh and unified the Hejaz under Islamic rule, prompting widespread tribal submissions. Later in 630 CE (Rajab 9 AH), Muhammad led the Expedition to Tabuk, mobilizing around 30,000 troops against rumored Byzantine threats in northern Arabia. No major battle occurred due to logistical challenges and the enemy's withdrawal, but the campaign secured tribute from local Christian and Jewish communities and enforced submissions from tribes. Quran 9:29, revealed during this expedition, commanded fighting those among the People of the Book who do not believe in Allah or the Last Day until they pay the jizyah willingly while humbled.

Personal Life and Character

Marriages, Concubines, and Family Dynamics

Muhammad's first marriage was to Khadijah bint Khuwaylid, a wealthy Meccan merchant widow approximately 40 years old, in 595 CE when he was 25; they remained monogamous for 25 years until her death in 619 CE shortly before the Hijra.

Children

Traditional accounts report Muhammad had seven children. From Khadijah (خديجة): sons Qasim, who died in infancy around 601 CE, and Abdullah, who died young (with variant traditions naming the second son al-Tayyib or al-Tahir, and Ibn Ishaq listing them separately); daughters Zaynab, Ruqayyah, Umm Kulthum, and Fatimah. From concubine Maria al-Qibtiyya (مارية القبطية): son Ibrahim, who died in infancy around 632 CE. Some Twelver Shia sources dispute whether Zaynab, Ruqayyah, and Umm Kulthum were biological daughters, maintaining only Fatimah was biological and the others were step-daughters from Khadijah's prior marriage—a sectarian divergence. Following Khadijah's death, Muhammad contracted multiple marriages, primarily after the Hijra in 622 CE, totaling 11 wives according to traditional accounts in Hadith collections like Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim; these were often widows or captives from tribal alliances, with exceptions like Aisha. The marriages served political and social functions, such as forging alliances with tribes or providing for war widows, though Quran 33:50-52 granted Muhammad exemptions from the four-wife limit imposed on other Muslim men (Quran 4:3).
WifeApprox. Birth YearApproximate Marriage DateDeath YearNotes
② Sawdah bint Zam'ah (سودة بنت زمعة)Unknown620 CEc. 644 CEWidow, elderly at marriage; first post-Khadijah union for companionship.
③ ʿĀʾisha bint Abī Bakr (عائشة بنت أبي بكر)c. 613–614 CEBetrothal 620 CE; consummation 623 CE678 CEDaughter of Abu Bakr; Hadith report her age as 6 at betrothal and 9 at consummation, though some modern analyses, representing a minority view, contest this based on alternative historical timelines.
④ Hafsa bint UmarUnknown625 CEc. 665–667 CEWidow of Khunays ibn Hudhayfa, killed at Badr; daughter of Umar.
⑤ Zaynab bint KhuzaymahUnknown625 CE626 CEWidow; died shortly after marriage in 626 CE.
⑥ Hind (Umm Salama) bint Abi UmayyahUnknown626 CEc. 678–679 CEWidow of Abu Salamah; mother of several children.
⑦ Zaynab bint Jahsh (زينب بنت جحش)Unknown627 CE641 CEDivorced wife of adopted son Zayd; marriage prompted Quran 33:37 abrogating adoption ties, cousin of Muhammad (daughter of Jahsh ibn Riyab and Umayma bint Abd al-Muttalib).
⑧ Juwayriyah bint al-Harith (جويرية بنت الحارث)Unknown628 CEc. 670 CECaptive from Banu Mustaliq; marriage led to her tribe's release.
⑨ Umm Habibah (Ramla) bint Abi Sufyan (أم حبيبة (رملة) بنت أبي سفيان)Unknown628 CEc. 664 CEWidow exiled in Abyssinia; daughter of Abu Sufyan, aiding Meccan reconciliation.
⑩ Safiyyah bint Huyayy (صفية بنت حيي)c. 610 CE628 CEc. 670 CEJewish captive from Khaybar, daughter of Huyayy ibn Akhtab (حيي بن أخطب), chief of Banu Nadir; husband killed at Khaybar; converted to Islam.
⑪ Maymunah bint al-Harith (مَيْمُونَة بِنْتِ الْحَارِث)Unknown629 CEc. 681 CEWidow; last marriage, during Umrah.
Muhammad also had concubines, including Maria al-Qibtiyya (مارية القبطية), a Coptic Christian gifted by the Egyptian ruler al-Muqawqis in 628 CE, who bore son Ibrahim (died 632 CE at 18 months); she is classified as a concubine rather than wife in major Sunni sources, lacking the "Mother of the Believers" status. Rayhana bint Zayd, a Jewish captive from Banu Qurayza in 627 CE, was another, with debated status as wife or concubine. Early biographical sources, such as Ibn Ishaq, report that she initially refused to convert to Islam before later accepting. These relationships aligned with pre-Islamic Arabian norms of concubinage from captives or gifts, regulated under "those your right hands possess" (Quran 4:24, 23:6). Family dynamics involved tensions from polygyny, including jealousy among wives, particularly toward younger Aisha and concubine Maria. A notable incident around 628 CE involved Hafsa discovering Muhammad with Maria in her quarters, leading the wives to confront him and prompting his temporary withdrawal and oath of abstention from them for twenty-nine days (Sahih al-Bukhari 5191 and 2468; Sahih Muslim 1479a-c). This event linked to the revelation of Surah al-Tahrim (Quran 66:1-5), rebuking their actions and reminding them of potential divorce. Hadith depict Aisha expressing rivalry, though Muhammad maintained equity in time allocation. These accounts, from Sahih al-Bukhari and Muslim, reflect traditional Sunni views but originate from oral chains compiled over a century later.

Reported Habits, Traits, and Interactions

Muhammad was reported to have been of medium height, with a sturdy build, broad shoulders, and a luminous, slightly flushed face of white complexion. Companions identified him as "this white (أبيض) man" in one narration (Sahih al-Bukhari 63) and described him as having a "white handsome face (وَجْهٌ أَبْيَضُ حَسَنٌ)" in another (Sahih Muslim 2340a). His black, slightly curly hair reached his earlobes or shoulders, complemented by a thick beard. These descriptions come primarily from companions like Anas ibn Malik in authentic collections such as Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim. His routine emphasized simplicity and devotion. He slept early after Isha prayer, rising in the latter third of the night for tahajjud prayers and supplications before resting until dawn. He instructed on responding to the call to prayer (adhan): narrated by 'Abdullah bin 'Amr, upon hearing the Muadhdhin, repeat after him, then send salat upon Muhammad, for Allah sends salat upon him tenfold; ask Allah to grant Muhammad Al-Wasilah, a unique rank in Paradise for one of His slaves—which he hoped to be—and whoever asks thus will have his intercession made lawful. Meals were modest—dates, barley, or milk—eaten sparingly with the right hand, beginning in Allah's name, and only from what was nearest. He fasted often outside Ramadan, especially Mondays and Thursdays, and sought forgiveness over seventy times daily. He slept on a simple mat, underscoring asceticism despite post-conquest opulence. Hadith describe traits of trustworthiness, modesty, patience, and justice, earning pre-prophetic titles Al-Amin (الأمين) and As-Sadiq (الصادق) among Meccans. These included emphasis on obedience to authority regardless of status, as in a narration where he stated, "You should listen to and obey your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian (black) slave whose head looks like a raisin," highlighting egalitarianism in leadership potential. Yet narrations also note domestic tensions, such as Aisha's jealousy over Maria the Copt. Companions reported exceptional vigor; a narration preserved in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī (ḥadīth no. 268), from Anas ibn Mālik through Qatāda, states that Muhammad would visit all of his wives in a single round during the day and night, when their number was eleven (or nine in another transmission), and when asked whether he possessed the strength for this, Anas replied that his companions believed he had been granted the strength of thirty men, equivalent to thirty men in sexual intercourse, viewed as divine favor. This narration is commonly cited in classical biographical and theological literature to illustrate perceptions of Muhammad’s physical vigor and exceptional endowment, themes that appear frequently in traditional descriptions of prophetic qualities (khaṣāʾiṣ al-nabī); the variation in reported numbers of wives is noted by scholars as an example of transmission differences within hadith literature, addressed through isnād comparison and contextual analysis. Hadith further illustrate his moral guidance in social and sexual matters; for instance, in Sunan Abū Dāwūd (no. 2156), Abū al-Dardāʾ narrates Muhammad's strong disapproval of sexual relations with a visibly pregnant captive woman by her owner, emphasizing concerns over lineage (nasab), inheritance, and the child's ambiguous legal status, nearly invoking a curse on the man. Another narration in Sahih Muslim (1403a), from Jābir ibn ʿAbd Allāh (جَابِر بْن عَبْدِ اللَّه), describes Muhammad advising companions that upon seeing a woman and feeling desire, one should go to his wife, as a woman may "advance and retreat in the form of a devil," to lawfully address urges in the heart. Additionally, during holy battles when companions without wives considered castration to avoid temptation, Muhammad forbade self-harm and permitted temporary marriage contracts, reciting Quran 5:87, as narrated by Abdullah in Sahih al-Bukhari (5075); Jabir ibn Abdullah further confirmed the practice of temporary marriage during the Prophet's lifetime in Sahih Muslim (1405c). He mended his clothes, helped with chores, and showed forbearance and humility. Mercy and forgiveness defined his character, though sternness appeared in wartime executions for treason or inciting hostility. A hadith states, "The best among you are those who have the best manners and character." In the Medinan period, a narration reported by ʿĀʾisha in Sahih al-Bukhari (3175) states that Muhammad was once affected by sorcery (siḥr), such that he came to imagine having done certain actions which, in fact, he had not done; this condition, attributed to a magic spell by Labid bin al-A'sam, was temporary and resolved by revelation, highlighting prophetic human vulnerability (bashariyyah) alongside protection from sin in revelation (ismah). A narration from ʿĀʾisha in Sahih Muslim (Book 32, Hadith 6285) describes two individuals angering Muhammad during a visit, prompting him to curse them; after their departure, ʿĀʾisha voiced concern over depriving them of goodness, to which he explained that any malediction against a believing Muslim is transformed by God into purification and reward for that person. This illustrates his proneness to emotional reactions tempered by divine mercy, as discussed in Islamic theology regarding prophetic temperament and authority. Interactions varied by context. With family, he displayed affection, playing with children like Hasan and dividing time equitably among wives, though tensions arose, as in Umar's advice to Hafsa about Aisha. Toward companions, he promoted brotherhood, consulting on matters like the Battle of the Trench and praising loyalty to figures like Abu Bakr and Umar. With enemies, he granted amnesty upon conquering Mecca in 630 CE, leading conversions such as Abu Sufyan's, but authorized executions for threats like Ka'b ibn al-Ashraf. He owned and traded slaves, for instance trading two black slaves to purchase a man who had pledged allegiance to him without knowledge of his enslaved status, and receiving a black slave named Mid'am as a gift during the Khaybar expedition; he also freed slaves personally and urged kindness toward them and the poor. These accounts from hadith and early sira like Ibn Ishaq's portray balance between compassion and authority, though later compilations may idealize the figure.

Core Teachings and Revelations

Monotheism, Prophethood, and Ethical Prescriptions

Muhammad's teachings centered on tawhid, the absolute oneness and uniqueness of God (Allah الله), as Islam's foundational doctrine. This rejected pre-Islamic Arab polytheism, which venerated intercessory deities as mediators to Allah. The primacy of tawhid for salvation is illustrated in a hadith narrated by Abu Dharr, in which Muhammad conveyed that whoever dies without associating partners with Allah will enter Paradise, even if guilty of theft, fornication, or drinking wine. Early Meccan revelations, such as Surah Al-Ikhlas (Quran 112), articulated it: "Say, He is Allah, [who is] One, Allah, the Eternal Refuge. He neither begets nor is born, nor is there to Him any equivalent." Tawhid extended to God's singularity in essence, attributes, worship, and lordship, prohibiting shirk—associating partners with the divine—as the gravest sin. The revelations also warned of judgment for disbelievers, including those from the People of the Book (Ahl al-Kitab أهل الكتاب) and polytheists who reject the message, as in Quran 98:6: "Indeed, those who disbelieve from the People of the Book and the polytheists will be in the Fire of Hell, to stay there forever. They are the worst of ˹all˺ beings." Quran 22:17 states: "Indeed, those who have believed and those who were Jews or the Sabeans or the Christians or the Magians and those who associated with Allah - Allah will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection. Indeed, Allah is, over all things, Witness." This exclusivity is further articulated in Quran 3:85: "And whoever desires other than Islam (إسلام) as religion - never will it be accepted from him, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers." Central to his message was prophethood: Muhammad received divine revelations from God via angel Gabriel, starting in 610 CE near Mecca. Compiled as the Quran, these positioned him as the final messenger after prophets like Abraham, Moses, and Jesus, designated the "Seal of the Prophets" in Quran 33:40: "Muhammad is not the father of [any] one of your men, but [he is] the Messenger of Allah and seal [khätam] of the prophets." He further described unique privileges granted to him, as narrated by Jabir bin Abdullah: The Prophet said, "I have been given five things which were not given to any one else before me. 1. Allah made me victorious by awe, (by His frightening my enemies) for a distance of one month's journey. 2. The earth has been made for me (and for my followers) a place for praying and a thing to perform Tayammum, therefore anyone of my followers can pray wherever the time of a prayer is due. 3. The booty has been made Halal (lawful) for me yet it was not lawful for anyone else before me. 4. I have been given the right of intercession (on the Day of Resurrection). 5. Every Prophet used to be sent to his nation only but I have been sent to all mankind." This finality signified the Quran's completeness, superseding prior scriptures altered by humans per Islamic doctrine, with Muhammad as the exemplar (uswa hasana) for emulating divine will. His prophetic teachings extended to eschatological events, including signs of the Hour. A hadith narrated by Abu Huraira reports Muhammad stating: "The Hour will not be established until the son of Mary (i.e. Jesus) descends amongst you as a just ruler, he will break the cross, kill the pigs, and abolish the jizya tax for dhimmis. Money will be in abundance so that nobody will accept it (as charitable gifts)." Another hadith, narrated by Abu Dhar, provides a prophetic interpretation of Quranic cosmology in Quran 36:38, describing the sun's daily course: The Prophet asked at sunset, "Do you know where the sun goes?" Upon reply that Allah and His Apostle know best, he said, "It goes till it prostrates itself underneath the Throne and takes the permission to rise again, and it is permitted... [but in the future] it will be about to prostrate itself but its prostration will not be accepted... and so it will rise in the west." Ethical prescriptions stemmed from Quranic injunctions and Muhammad's Sunnah, emphasizing individual accountability, social harmony in the believers' community (Ummah أمة) through fraternity (ukhuwah أخوة), and submission to God. Non-Muslim relations followed frameworks like dhimma (ذمة) or treaties, with revelations prescribing jihad—or struggle in the path of God—including combat against non-believers under specific conditions of opposition or refusal to submit. For example, Quran 9:29 states: "Fight those who do not believe in Allah and the Last Day, nor comply with what Allah and His Messenger have forbidden, nor embrace the religion of truth from among those who were given the Scripture, until they pay the tax, willingly submitting, fully humbled." It has been narrated on the authority of Abdullah b. 'Umar (عبد الله بن عمر) that the Messenger of Allah said: "I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, and they establish prayer, and pay Zakat and if they do it, their blood and property are guaranteed protection on my behalf except when justified by law, and their affairs rest with Allah." Similarly, Quran 9:123 instructs: "O believers! Fight the disbelievers around you and let them find firmness in you. And know that Allah is with those mindful ˹of Him˺." A hadith narrated by Abu Huraira reports Muhammad stating that the best deed is to believe in Allah and His Apostle, the next is to participate in Jihad in Allah's Cause, and the next is to perform Hajj Mubrur, accepted by Allah and performed with the intention of seeking His pleasure. Key virtues included honesty in trade (Quran 83:1-3; hadith: "The truthful, trustworthy merchant is with the prophets..."), charity (zakat زَكَاة) as a pillar requiring 2.5% of savings for the needy (Quran 2:177), and justice (adl عَدْل) even against kin (Quran 4:135). Benevolence (ihsan إحسان) extended to neighbors, animals, and slaves, despite status distinctions, while usury (riba رِبَا) was banned to curb exploitation (Quran 2:275-279). Prohibitions covered intoxication (Quran 5:90), gambling, adultery (Quran 17:32), and ritual impurity like janabah, as in the narration of Aisha washing the Prophet's garment before prayer (Sahih al-Bukhari 229). A hadith narrated by ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib reports that the Prophet Muḥammad said: “The eyes are the leather strap of the anus; therefore, whoever sleeps should perform ablution.” This supports the Islamic jurisprudential concept of ritual purity (Ṭahāra طَهَارَة) and the rules governing ablution (Wuḍūʾ), indicating that sleep invalidates ablution. A hadith narrated by Abū Hurayra reports that the Prophet instructed: when a person wakes from sleep and performs ablution (wuḍūʾ), he should rinse his nose by drawing water into it and blowing it out three times, “because Satan has stayed in the upper part of his nose during the night.” This report is commonly cited in classical Islamic jurisprudence to support the practice of nasal rinsing (istinshāq and istinthār) as part of ablution. Jurists generally interpreted the reference to Satan as emphasizing the spiritual dimension of ritual purity, reinforcing the idea that physical cleansing is connected to protection from spiritual impurity, rather than as a literal anatomical claim. Ethical prescriptions also included severe penalties for waging war against Allah and His Messenger and spreading corruption on earth, as in Quran 5:33: "Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment." Apostasy (riddah) was addressed in hadith reports attributed to Muhammad, who stated that the blood of a Muslim can be shed in cases including "the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims" (Sahih al-Bukhari 6878), and "Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him" (Sahih al-Bukhari 6922). Quran 88:23-24 warns that "he who turns away and disbelieves—Then Allah will punish him with the greatest punishment," understood as eschatological rather than prescribing earthly execution. These aimed to foster piety (taqwa تَقْوَى) as the measure of worth (Quran 49:13), applied contextually amid tribal norms.

Role in Quran Revelation and Early Islamic Law

According to Islamic tradition, Muhammad received the initial Quranic revelation in 610 CE in the Cave of Hira near Mecca, when the angel Gabriel commanded him to "Recite" the opening verses of Surah Al-Alaq (Quran 96:1-5). This began a 23-year process of piecemeal revelations until shortly before his death in 632 CE, with verses responding to specific circumstances, queries, or communal needs. An early example in classical tafsir involves the temporary inclusion and abrogation of intercessory verses for al-Lāt (اللات), al-ʿUzza (الْعُزَّى), and Manāt (الْمَنَاة) in Surah al-Najm (53:19–20), retracted per Qur’an 22:52 and preserved in multiple first–second century AH transmissions (e.g., Tafsīr al-Ṭabarī, Cambridge ed. vol. 27, pp. 53–68; Shahab Ahmed, Before Orthodoxy, Harvard 2017, pp. 26–97). Described as illiterate, Muhammad memorized and recited the revelations publicly. He employed about 40 scribes, including Zayd ibn Thabit and Ubayy ibn Ka'b, to record them on palm leaves, bones, and parchment. These were not compiled into a codex during his lifetime but preserved through Arabia's oral poetic tradition, with companions (huffaz) memorizing them for dissemination. The revelations covered theological, ethical, and select legal matters, such as inheritance (Quran 4:11-12), marriage (Quran 4:3-4, permitting up to four wives from free women or those whom your right hands possess—mā malakat aymānukum (مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَانُهُمْ)—referring to female slaves or captives obtained lawfully, as illustrated by a hadith on war captives permissible after their waiting period (iddah (عِدَّة))), and usury bans (Quran 2:275-279). For instance, upon the revelation of Quran 24:31 instructing women to draw their veils over their necks and bosoms, ladies cut their waist sheets at the edges and covered their heads and faces with those pieces, as narrated by Aisha via Safiya bint Shaiba in Sahih al-Bukhari 4759, demonstrating immediate application in early Islamic practice. Muhammad supplemented these through his pronouncements, actions, and decisions, establishing the Sunnah as reported in hadith. In Medina after 622 CE, as ummah leader, he adjudicated disputes among Muslims, Jews, and pagans, blending Quranic principles with adapted Arabian customs influenced by neighboring scriptural traditions. Examples include rulings on theft (amputation per Quran 5:38), retaliation (Qisas), and blood money (Diya), often aligning with pre-Islamic tribal and Jewish norms. These orally transmitted judgments set precedents emulated by companions like Abu Bakr and Umar, contributing to early ijma and Sharia. Early Islamic law under Muhammad prioritized flexibility, with abrogation (naskh, نَسْخ) updating norms—such as gradual alcohol prohibition (Quran 2:219 to 5:90)—and arbitration resolving conflicts, as in the Constitution of Medina. As interpreter and enforcer, he issued fatwas on prayer, fasting, and warfare, integrating revelation with governance. Later schools formalized these via qiyas, but his era emphasized adaptability to 7th-century Arabian society for communal order over rigid codes.

Death, Succession, and Immediate Legacy

Final Years, Illness, and Death

Following the Farewell Pilgrimage in March 632 CE, Muhammad returned to Medina, where delegations from Arabian tribes pledged allegiance, consolidating Islamic authority across the peninsula. He delivered sermons stressing unity and cautioning against pre-Islamic practices, as recorded in hadith. These efforts capped his leadership, with no major military campaigns after the Tabuk expedition in 630 CE. His final illness began in early June 632 CE, featuring severe fever, headaches, and weakness over about 14 days. Hadith link it to poisoning by Zaynab bint al-Harith (زينب بنت الحارث), retaliating for her family's execution at Khaybar in 628 CE; Muhammad told Aisha, "I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaybar, and at this time, I feel as if my aorta is being cut from that poison" (Sahih al-Bukhari 4428). Despite pain, he directed Abu Bakr to lead prayers, which Sunni scholars see as transferring ritual authority, though Shia dispute this as implying succession. Muhammad died on June 8, 632 CE, at age 63, in Aisha's chamber in Medina, his head in her lap; sources agree on the date, despite minor calendar variations. He was buried the next day in the same room, where his tomb remains. Hadith describe his last words affirming faith in Allah, while critics question the poisoning account due to reliance on later oral traditions susceptible to embellishment.

Conflicts over Succession and Early Schisms

Muhammad died on 8 June 632 CE in Medina without designating an explicit successor in the Quran or early hadith, leaving a leadership vacuum. While Ali ibn Abi Talib, his cousin and son-in-law, and Banu Hashim members performed funerary rites, Ansar leaders gathered at the Saqifa of Banu Sa'ida to select a leader from their ranks, fearing dominance by Meccan Muhajirun. Muhajirun leaders Abu Bakr al-Siddiq (أبو بكر الصديق), Umar ibn al-Khattab, and Abu Ubaydah ibn al-Jarrah arrived at the meeting of about 100 participants. Abu Bakr cited Quraysh precedence and his role leading prayers during Muhammad's illness to claim authority, rejecting Ansar proposals for dual leadership. After debate, Abu Bakr gained oaths as the first caliph, affirmed by Umar and Abu Ubaydah, prioritizing consensus against tribal risks. Ali and some companions, absent from Saqifa, initially withheld allegiance, seeing it as bypassing Muhammad's family and events like the Ghadir Khumm declaration. Tensions rose as Abu Bakr demanded allegiance and seized the Fadak estate, claimed by Fatima as inheritance; her protest and his reported disownment widened the divide. Ali delayed bay'ah for six months until after Fatima's death in late 632 or early 633 CE. Abu Bakr's rule faced Ridda Wars (632–633 CE), where tribes rebelled by halting zakat, asserting sovereignty post-Muhammad, or following false prophets like Musaylima. Suppressed by commanders like Khalid ibn al-Walid, these uprisings tested cohesion; Shi'a views link them to Saqifa resentment, while Sunni accounts see tribal opportunism. Saqifa sparked Islam's Sunni-Shi'a schism. Sunnis (85–90% of Muslims) validate Abu Bakr's shura-based election, extending to Rashidun caliphs Umar (r. 634–644 CE), Uthman (r. 644–656 CE), and Ali (r. 656–661 CE). Shi'a (shi'at Ali) assert divine authority through Ali's lineage as imams, deeming Saqifa a usurpation of ahl al-bayt rights; this minority grew via events like Uthman's murder and Ali's caliphate. Accounts from Ibn Ishaq (d. 767 CE) and al-Tabari (d. 923 CE) show biases—Sunni for unity, Shi'a for injustice—due to late compilation, oral roots, and politics, lacking neutral contemporaries. Early groups like Kharijites arose under Ali (e.g., post-657 CE Siffin), but the divide stems from elective versus hereditary authority disputes.

Historical Sources and Evidence

Primary Islamic Texts: Quran, Hadith, and Sira

The Quran, regarded by Muslims as God's verbatim word revealed to Muhammad over about 23 years (610–632 CE), forms the foundational primary text for Islamic doctrine. It includes references to Muhammad's life, prophethood, and interactions but offers limited biographical detail, emphasizing theological assertions over chronological narrative. Revelations were memorized by companions and recorded on materials like palm stalks, bones, and parchment, though no complete written compilation existed during Muhammad's lifetime. After his death in 632 CE and the Battle of Yamama (غزوة اليمامة) (632–633 CE), which killed many memorizers (huffaz), Caliph Abu Bakr tasked Zayd ibn Thabit with compiling the Quran into a single codex (suhuf) from oral and written sources, completed around 634 CE. Caliph Uthman later standardized it (circa 650–656 CE) into the Uthmanic codex to address dialectal recitation variations, distributing copies to major centers and destroying variants. Early manuscripts, such as the Birmingham folios (circa 568–645 CE), affirm textual stability, though scholarly assessments note the Quran's sparse historical content on Muhammad. Hadith literature comprises reports (ahadith) of Muhammad's sayings, actions, approvals, or descriptions, serving as a secondary source to interpret the Quran and his sunnah (practice). The most authoritative Sunni collections, the Sahihayn—Sahih al-Bukhari (compiler d. 870 CE) and Sahih Muslim (d. 875 CE)—emerged in the 9th century from oral transmission over two centuries, with written compilation intensifying in the 8th–9th centuries amid fabrication concerns. Bukhari selected about 7,397 sahih narrations from over 600,000 after scrutinizing chains (isnad, إسناد) and content (matn); Muslim chose around 12,000 from 300,000. Authentication assessed narrator reliability, chain continuity, and consistency, though critics note risks of projection or influence, as seen in variants and debates over weak (da'if) versus strong (sahih) hadith. Shi'i collections, like al-Kafi by al-Kulayni (d. 941 CE), prioritize narrations from Ali and the Imams, highlighting sectarian differences. Major Hadith collections include:
TraditionMajor Collections
Sunni1. Sahih al-Bukhari (صحيح البخاري) (Muhammad al-Bukhari, d. 870 CE) (~7,397)
2. Sahih Muslim (صحيح مسلم) (Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj, d. 875 CE) (~7,563 unique or ~12,000 with repetitions)
3. Sunan Abu Dawood (سنن أبي داود) (Abu Dawood al-Sijistani, d. 889 CE) (~4,800)
4. Jami' al-Tirmidhi (جامع الترمذي) (al-Tirmidhi, d. 892 CE) (~3,956)
5. Sunan al-Nasa'i (سنن النسائي) (al-Nasa'i, d. 915 CE) (~5,708)
6. Sunan Ibn Majah (سنن ابن ماجه) (Ibn Majah, d. 887 CE) (~4,341)
Shi'i1. Al-Kafi (الكافي) (al-Kulayni, d. 941 CE) (~16,000)
2. Man La Yahduruhu al-Faqih (من لا يحضره الفقيه) (Ibn Babawayh, d. 991 CE) (~6,000)
3. Tahdhib al-Ahkam (تهذيب الأحكام) (Shaykh al-Tusi, d. 1067 CE) (~13,590)
4. Al-Istibsar (الاستبصار) (Shaykh al-Tusi, d. 1067 CE) (~5,511)
Sira literature offers narrative biographies of Muhammad, using hadith, poetry, and Arabian lore to provide a chronological framework missing from the Quran. The earliest extant work, Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (circa 767 CE), compiles oral accounts of Muhammad's birth (circa 570 CE), Meccan period, Hijra (622 CE), and Medinan campaigns, but survives mainly in Ibn Hisham's edited recension (d. 833 CE), which omitted controversial elements. Ibn Ishaq gathered broadly but drew criticism from contemporaries like Malik ibn Anas for unverified reports, leading some to question its historicity despite its impact on later genres. Later works, such as Ibn Sa'd's Kitab al-Tabaqat al-Kabir (d. 845 CE), add companion details. Composed over 150 years after Muhammad, sira raises concerns of embellishment for didactic purposes; modern views stress cross-verification with non-Muslim sources. Together, Quran, hadith, and sira shape portrayals of Muhammad, though their transmission invites scrutiny of fidelity and intent in depicting 7th-century events. Major Sira works include:
Major Sira Works
1. Sirat Rasul Allah (سيرة رسول الله) (Muhammad ibn Ishaq, d. 767 CE)
2. Ibn Hisham's recension ('Abd al-Malik ibn Hisham, d. 833 CE)
3. Kitab al-Tabaqat al-Kabir (كتاب الطبقات الكبير) (Muhammad ibn Sa'd, d. 845 CE)
4. Kitab al-Maghazi (كتاب المغازي) (Muhammad ibn 'Umar al-Waqidi, d. 823 CE)

Non-Muslim Contemporary Accounts and Archaeological Corroboration

Seventh-century non-Muslim sources provide the earliest external references to Muhammad, appearing within decades of his 632 CE death and predating most Islamic biographical traditions. Primarily Syriac and Armenian Christian accounts of Arab conquests, they confirm a figure named Muhammad who unified tribes and launched campaigns against Byzantine and Sasanian territories. These texts depict him as a monotheistic preacher and martial leader, though details are sparse and shaped by polemics. A Syriac marginal note in a Gospel manuscript, dated around 636 CE, records Byzantine battles with "the Arabs of Muhammad" at Dathin in 634 CE, naming him as leader during Emperor Heraclius's reign and implying posthumous authority. The chronicle of Thomas the Presbyter, from circa 640 CE in northern Mesopotamia, describes a 634 CE clash near Gaza between Romans and "the Arabs of Muhammad" (Tayyāyē d-Mḥmt), linking his name to early conquests. The Armenian History of Sebeos, written circa 661 CE, gives the most detailed early non-Muslim view: Muhammad, a merchant among circumcised peoples, preached to the "sons of Ishmael" to reject idolatry, honor Abraham's God, and avoid carrion, wine, fornication, and lying. He unified tribes via religious teaching, banned infighting, promised land, and spurred post-death conquests in Palestine and Persia. This echoes Islamic unification narratives but interprets it as a Jewish-aligned covenant, reflecting Christian-Armenian concerns over Arab expansion. The Greek Doctrina Jacobi nuper baptizati (Διδασκαλία Ἰακώβου τοῦ νεοββτίστου), composed between 634 and 640 CE in Carthage, mentions a "prophet" among Saracens claiming paradise's keys and enforcing his message with a sword, amid Arab victories. Scholars identify this as Muhammad, based on the timing and circumcised prophet's conquest call for divine reward. Overall, these sources affirm Muhammad's catalytic role in Arab successes but stem from adversaries, emphasizing warfare over theology found in Islamic texts. Archaeology yields no direct evidence of Muhammad's life, like 570–632 CE inscriptions or artifacts, due to pre-conquest Arabia's oral, tribal society and scarce monumental records. Hijaz excavations show limited seventh-century finds, with trade continuity at sites like Qaryat al-Faw but no early Islamic markers until Umayyad times. Indirect corroboration appears in 630s–640s CE Greek and Coptic papyri from Egypt and Palestine, evidencing Arab administrative shifts and unified conquests. Early domed structures and outposts at Tiberias and Jerusalem match rapid gains by his successors, though tied to him via historical links, not inscriptions. The absence of early Islamic iconography or Qur'anic references—unlike Christian and Zoroastrian remains—stems from perishable materials and later Umayyad monumentalization.

Scholarly Assessments and Debates

Islamic Traditional Views versus Critical Analysis

In Islamic tradition, Muhammad is regarded as the final prophet and seal of the prophets, serving as uswa hasana (أسوة حسنة, an excellent example) for humanity in conduct, ethics, and devotion, as stated in Quran 33:21. Traditional sources depict him with impeccable moral character—mercy, forgiveness, justice, and humility—free from major sin (ismah (عِصْمَة)) and divinely guided, with his life implementing Quranic revelations. His biography from Sira and Hadith offers infallible guidance, portraying him as a statesman, warrior, and family man whose decisions, like granting amnesty during the 630 CE conquest of Mecca, reflect divine wisdom. Classical sources include self-critical debates on transmission, such as al-Tabari's variants and discussions of isnad reliability. In contrast, critical historical analysis questions the reliability of these portrayals, applying methods similar to biblical studies. The earliest Sira by Ibn Ishaq (d. 767 CE), predated by Musa ibn ʿUqba's Kitab al-Maghazi (كتاب المغازي) (d. ca. 758 CE), was compiled over 130 years after Muhammad's 632 CE death, relying on oral isnad chains that emphasize theological consistency over independent corroboration from non-Islamic sources or archaeology. These often include unverified miraculous elements, such as the Night Journey (Isra and Mi'raj (الإسراء والمعراج)) and the splitting of the moon—attributed to Muhammad in response to challenges from Meccan Quraysh (Quran 54:1; elaborated in hadith like Sahih al-Bukhari 4:56:831 and Sahih Muslim 1:280), where the moon reportedly divided into two parts then rejoined, viewed literally by traditional scholars and tafsirs as a miracle of prophethood, though some early interpretations treat it metaphorically or as eschatological—absent from contemporary non-Muslim records, global astronomical observations, or other civilizations' annals. Hadith collections, such as Sahih al-Bukhari (ca. 846 CE), face scrutiny for contradictions with pre-Islamic archaeology, non-Muslim accounts, and internal inconsistencies, suggesting possible fabrication to support doctrine—though scholars like Harald Motzki identify some authentic elements via isnad criticism. Mainstream scholarship affirms Muhammad's existence as a 7th-century Arabian preacher and leader, corroborated by sparse contemporary non-Muslim references like the 634 CE Doctrina Jacobi. However, debates continue on how much traditional narratives reflect history versus hagiographic idealization influenced by Abbasid-era agendas post-750 CE. Revisionist theories, such as in Patricia Crone and Michael Cook's Hagarism (1977), argue for retroactive construction to unify Arab conquests, though contested by early Quranic manuscripts like the Birmingham folios (568–645 CE). Critics note biases portraying Muhammad as flawless, potentially obscuring pragmatic decisions, such as executions at Badr (600–900) and Banu Qurayza (627 CE), framed traditionally as divinely sanctioned but assessed critically against tribal norms. This tension reflects differing epistemologies: traditional Islam prioritizes revelatory authority and communal transmission, while secular historiography requires corroboration from archaeology (e.g., scarce 7th-century Meccan inscriptions) and cross-cultural texts. It presents Muhammad as a charismatic reformer against Arabian polytheism rather than an unerring archetype, acknowledging his historical impact in rapid post-632 CE expansions without endorsing amplified legends. Corroborated events include the Hijra (622 CE) via calendar alignments and Syriac chronicles.

Questions of Historicity and Source Reliability

The historicity of Muhammad, traditionally dated to c. 570–632 CE as Islam's founder, is affirmed by most modern scholars, based on the rapid 7th-century Arab conquests and monotheistic movement implying a central prophetic figure. However, detailed elements like revelations, migrations, and battles face scrutiny due to no contemporaneous written records and the retrospective nature of surviving accounts. Evidence relies mainly on later Islamic compilations and sparse external references, with no archaeological artifacts directly tied to him or early Meccan events, prompting questions of narrative embellishment. Islamic sources—the Quran, Hadith, and Sira—form the traditional biography's core but raise reliability concerns from their timelines and purposes. The Quran, compiled soon after Muhammad's death under Caliph Uthman (r. 644–656 CE), offers no systematic life details, emphasizing theology with events inferred via later commentaries. Hadith, systematized in the 8th–9th centuries through transmission chains (isnads), include many reports but feature fabrications for doctrinal aims, as noted in classical critiques like Ibn al-Jawzi (ابن الجوزي) (d. 1201 CE). Sira texts, such as Ibn Ishaq's (d. 767 CE), rely on oral traditions recorded over a century later, mixing history with hagiography to support Islamic authority, resembling pious memoir over independently verified chronicle. Examples include the al-Zutt narration (Musnad Ahmad 3788; variant in Tirmidhi 2861), blending ethereal and ethnographic elements, and the Satanic Verses incident (Surah al-Najm 53:19–23), attested early across multiple chains despite doctrinal tensions, highlighting oral ambiguities and later standardization. Non-Muslim accounts from contemporaries or near-contemporaries offer limited corroboration, noting an Arab "prophet" without specifics on Muhammad. The Doctrina Jacobi (c. 634 CE) mentions a Saracen leader promising paradise amid conquests, possibly alluding to him; Sebeos's Armenian History (c. 661 CE) depicts a merchant uniting tribes under monotheism and anti-Jewish views. Greek and Syriac texts from the 630s–660s CE describe Arab leaders invoking divine favor, but polemically and without biographical depth, indicating external awareness of the movement's figure absent detailed knowledge. Explicit epigraphic mentions of "Muhammad" emerge only late 7th-century, as on the Dome of the Rock (691–692 CE). Archaeological evidence highlights gaps, especially for traditional Mecca and Medina. Pre-Islamic Mecca shows no signs of a major trade hub, lacking 6th–7th-century artifacts or inscriptions; ancient maps like Ptolemy's omit it, and restricted excavations yield little pre-8th-century material. Early mosques, such as in Kufa and Wasit (c. 670s CE), feature northward qiblas, suggesting later Mecca orientation. The scarcity of 7th-century Islamic relics, versus abundant records of Arab invasions, implies oral traditions addressed evidentiary voids, possibly shaped by Abbasid (post-750 CE) politics. Revisionist scholars argue traditional sources reflect 8th–9th-century constructs over 7th-century events, driven by imperial needs. Patricia Crone's Hagarism (1977) proposed origins in a Jewish-Arab alliance outside Arabia, citing trade and qibla discrepancies, later affirming existence but questioning details. Tom Holland's In the Shadow of the Sword (2012) notes contemporary "silence" and legendary growth akin to other figures. Fringe views question existence outright, but mainstream rejects mythicism given conquest evidence. These debates emphasize that without independent verification, theological sources may favor faith over precise history, paralleling other prophetic traditions.

Controversies and Modern Criticisms

Allegations of Violence, Slavery, and Warfare Ethics

In the early Medinan period, Muhammad authorized targeted killings of critics accused of inciting hostility against Muslims (المسلمون) through poetry and alliances with Meccan opponents. A key example is the 624 CE assassination of , a Jewish poet in Medina who mocked Muhammad and rallied Quraish after the Battle of Badr; Muhammad permitted the killing, executed by Muhammad bin Maslama via deception. Similar actions addressed other critics like Asma bint Marwan. Islamic tradition justifies these as defensive responses to threats against the Muslim community amid tribal conflicts. A major allegation concerns the 627 CE execution of the tribe after the Battle of the Trench. Accused of treason for negotiating with the besieging Meccan confederacy, the tribe surrendered; arbitrator Sa'd ibn Muʿādh decreed death for 600–900 adult males, invoking Torah penalties, with women and children enslaved and property confiscated. Muhammad confirmed the judgment, which was carried out in his presence (Sahih al-Bukhari 5:58:148; al-Ṭabarī (الطبري), Tārīkh vol. 8 pp. 35–38). Traditional accounts view this as judicial punishment for wartime betrayal, while critics emphasize its severity and question the scale or motives, seeing it as strategic elimination of threats rather than unprovoked massacre. Certain hadiths attributed to Muhammad describe an eschatological conflict in the end times, where Muslims will fight Jews, and stones and trees will call out to reveal Jews hiding behind them, except for the Gharqad tree (غرقد) (Sahih al-Bukhari 2926; Sahih Muslim 2922; cf. Sahih al-Bukhari 2925 variant). These prophetic statements in Islamic tradition have been cited in modern criticisms as indicative of hostility toward Jews. They are prominently quoted in Article 7 of the 1988 Hamas Covenant, which invokes this prophecy in describing an end-times battle against Jews, exemplifying their use by modern Islamist groups. Two hadiths in Sahih Muslim report Muhammad stating that on the Day of Resurrection, Muslims bearing sins as heavy as mountains would be forgiven, with Jews and Christians substituted in their place in Hell-Fire. One narration by Abu Burda (أبو بردة): "There would come people amongst the Muslims on the Day of Resurrection with as heavy sins as a mountain, and Allah (الله) would forgive them and He would place in their stead the Jews and the Christians." Another: "No Muslim would die but Allah (الله) would admit in his stead a Jew or a Christian in Hell-Fire." These attributions have drawn modern criticism for implying supersessionism or preferential eschatological treatment favoring Muslims over Jews and Christians. Quran 9:30 states: "The Jews say, 'Ezra is the son of Allah (الله),' while the Christians say, 'The Messiah is the son of Allah (الله).'" A related hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari describes Jews admitting on the Day of Judgment to worshiping Ezra as the son of God. This claim has been criticized by modern scholars for lacking historical evidence in Jewish sources or traditions, where Ezra is revered as a scribe and leader who restored the Torah after the Babylonian exile but not deified, in line with Judaism's strict monotheism. Other Quranic verses cited in modern criticisms of attitudes toward the People of the Scripture include 7:166, which states: "So when they were insolent about that which they had been forbidden, We said to them, 'Be apes, despised.'" Traditional exegesis links this to Jewish tribes punished for Sabbath-breaking. Similarly, Quran 5:59 states: "Say, 'O People of the Scripture, do you resent us except [for the fact] that we have believed in Allah (الله) and what was revealed to us and what was revealed before and because most of you are defiantly disobedient?'" Critics interpret these as reflecting supersessionist or confrontational tones toward Jews and Christians. Hadiths report Muhammad's intention to expel Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula, leaving only Muslims. Sahih Muslim 1767a narrates: "I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim." Jami' at-Tirmidhi 1606 records a similar statement: "If I live - if Allah (الله) wills - I will expel the Jews and the Christians from the Arabian Peninsula." Sahih al-Bukhari 3152 describes post-Khaibar considerations where Muhammad allowed Jews to remain on condition of labor and sharing produce, but Caliph Umar later enforced expulsion to Taima' and Ariha'. This policy is discussed in modern critiques as reflecting religious exclusivity in the region. Quran 9:5, known as the Sword Verse (آية السيف), states: "And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way." Critics interpret this as commanding violence against polytheists unless they convert, while scholarly debates emphasize its historical context as limited to treaty-breaking Arab polytheist tribes in 7th-century Arabia rather than a universal directive. A hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari 5686 narrates that when some people fell ill due to Medina's climate, Muhammad ordered them to follow his camels and drink their milk and urine (بول) as medicine; they recovered but then killed the shepherd and drove away the camels. Upon capture, Muhammad ordered their hands and feet cut off and eyes branded with heated iron. This incident has been cited in modern criticisms for prescribing urine as a medical remedy, viewed as unhygienic or superstitious, and for the severity of the punishments imposed. Such cross-amputations align with the Quranic prescription in 5:33-34 for those who wage war against Allah (الله) and His Messenger and strive upon earth to cause corruption: "Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah (الله) and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment, except for those who return [repenting] before you apprehend them. And know that Allah (الله) is Forgiving and Merciful." Muhammad's involvement with slavery reflected 7th-century Arabian norms, where wartime captives became property. The Quran allows sexual relations with female captives (4:24, 23:5–6), and Muhammad took concubines like and without marrying or manumitting them. Hadith accounts report Muhammad having intercourse with a female slave, which provoked tension with his wives Aishah and Hafsah, leading him to declare her forbidden to himself until Quran 66:1 was revealed addressing the matter. He owned and traded slaves, for instance trading two black slaves to purchase a slave who had pledged allegiance to him without his knowledge of the man's enslaved status (Sahih Muslim 1602), and receiving a black slave named Mid'am (مِدْعَمٌّ) as a gift during the Khaybar expedition (Sunan an-Nasa'i 3827), but freed some, such as facilitating manumissions after marrying Juwayriya bint al-Harith from the Banu Mustaliq raid. Quran 47:4 permits enslavement of non-Muslim captives in jihad (جهاد), with options for ransom or release, while encouraging emancipation (90:13). This perpetuated slavery through conquests, contrasting modern prohibitions—slavery persisted in some Muslim-majority countries until the mid-20th century, with abolition occurring in Saudi Arabia and Yemen in 1962, and in Oman in 1970—though Muhammad introduced regulations against abuse. Islamic sources credit Muhammad with warfare ethics prohibiting mutilation, treachery (except stratagems), and harm to non-combatants like women and children. Yet executions occurred, such as Qurayza men or select Badr prisoners, alongside ransoms elsewhere. Deception featured in raids like Nakhla (623 CE), which violated a sacred month and set precedents for ghazawat yielding spoils (Quran 8:41). Traditional defenses highlight contextual improvements over pre-Islamic practices, including feeding prisoners (76:8–9), while critics argue these prioritized victory in asymmetric warfare over universal restraint, with ongoing slave-taking challenging mercy claims. Hadith describe rewards for martyrs dying in the faith, including forgiveness, a place in paradise, protection from grave punishment, a crown of dignity, marriage to seventy-two wives from al-Hur al-'Ayn (الحور العين), and intercession for relatives (Jami' at-Tirmidhi 1663). Some modern critics cite such eschatological incentives as motivating participation in jihad and warfare. Source reliability varies, as hadith like Sahih Bukhari rely on transmission chains potentially subject to bias.

Issues of Polygamy, Child Marriage, and Gender Roles

Islamic tradition reports that Muhammad married multiple women, exceeding the 's limit of four wives for Muslim men ( 4:3). An exception for him appears in 33:50, allowing marriages beyond this restriction, including with women offering themselves or captives. Sira and hadith indicate he had 9 to 13 wives at various times, often widows or for political alliances, such as Hafsa bint Umar in 625 CE and Zaynab bint Jahsh around 627 CE. Aisha reportedly remarked that revelations hastened Muhammad's personal wishes (Sahih al-Bukhari 7:62:157). Traditional scholarship views these unions as divinely sanctioned and beneficial in a tribal society with warfare and female vulnerability. Modern critics, including secular scholars, see them as personal privileges inconsistent with Quranic equity, potentially enabling exploitation. Another reported practice was the allowance of temporary marriage (mutʿah (متعة)), permitted by Muhammad during his lifetime, particularly in contexts like military campaigns. Sahih Muslim 1405c narrates Jabir b. Abdullah stating that temporary marriage was practiced during the Prophet's time, as well as under Abu Bakr and Umar. Ibn Uraij reported: 'Ati' reported that Jabir b. Abdullah came to perform 'Umra, and we came to his abode, and the people asked him about different things, and then they made a mention of temporary marriage, whereupon he said: Yes, we had been benefiting ourselves by this temporary marriage during the lifetime of the Prophet (ﷺ) and during the time of Abu Bakr and 'Umar. Sahih al-Bukhari 5075 reports companions seeking permission for temporary contracts during battles when without wives, with Muhammad forbidding castration and allowing it while reciting 5:87. Sunni tradition holds that this permission was later abrogated. Critics interpret mutʿah as enabling short-term sexual relations sanctioned religiously, raising ethical concerns in modern views on marriage stability, while traditional accounts frame it as a pragmatic concession to prevent greater sins in exigencies. A key controversy involves Muhammad's marriage to (عائشة) bint Abi Bakr (عائشة بنت أبي بكر). Sahih al-Bukhari 5134 states he married her at age six and consummated the marriage at nine in Medina around 623 CE. Narrated Aisha: "The Prophet (ﷺ) engaged me when I was a girl of six (years). We went to Medina and stayed at the home of Bani-al-Harith bin Khazraj. Then I got ill and my hair fell down. Later on my hair grew (again) and my mother, Um Ruman, came to me while I was playing in a swing with some of my girl friends. She called me, and I went to her, not knowing what she wanted to do to me. She caught me by the hand and made me stand at the door of the house. I was breathless then, and when my breathing became Allright, she took some water and rubbed my face and head with it. Then she took me into the house. There in the house I saw some Ansari women who said, 'Best wishes and Allah's Blessing and a good luck.' Then she entrusted me to them and they prepared me (for the marriage). Unexpectedly Allah's Apostle came to me in the forenoon and my mother handed me over to him, and at that time I was a girl of nine years of age." (Sahih al-Bukhari 3894) Narrated 'Urwa: "The Prophet (ﷺ) wrote the (marriage contract) with `Aisha while she was six years old and consummated his marriage with her while she was nine years old and she remained with him for nine years (i.e. till his death)." (Sahih al-Bukhari 5158) This is corroborated in other Sunni hadith like Sahih Muslim, where (عائشة) is revered as a major hadith transmitter and scholar. Pre-Islamic norms allowed early betrothals for alliances. Classical sources note her youth at consummation, including playing with dolls (Sahih al-Bukhari 8:73:151). Some revisionist scholars propose she was 14-18 based on alternative timelines, but primary evidence supports the younger age. Additionally, 65:4 prescribes a three-month waiting period (iddah) for divorced or widowed women, stating "...and [also for] those who have not menstruated," which classical tafsirs traditionally interpret as applying to prepubescent girls, providing normative rules for young brides in early Islamic law. Critics label Aisha's marriage child marriage, citing risks of harm against modern standards. Proponents argue puberty defined adulthood in 7th-century Arabia, with no recorded harm to (عائشة), who lived productively to age 66; debates persist on exact age and general risks. Texts from Muhammad's era outline gender roles with male authority and provision. 4:34 states men are protectors of women due to superiority and spending, requiring righteous women to be obedient; for disloyalty, it prescribes admonition, bed separation, and light beating if needed. 2:223 likens wives to 'a place of sowing of seed' (tilth), allowing husbands to approach them 'however you wish' in marital relations while urging righteousness and fear of Allah. Hadith limit this to non-severe actions, as Muhammad advised against striking faces or severely (Sunan Abi Dawud 2142; Sahih Muslim 2328g). A hadith narrated by Umar ibn al-Khattab (عمر بن الخطاب) states: "The Prophet (ﷺ) said: A man will not be asked as to why he beat his wife" (Sunan Abi Dawud 2147). Critics cite instances like the case in Sahih al-Bukhari 5825, where a woman complained to (عائشة) of beating by her husband, showing a green spot on her skin caused by it, prompting (عائشة) to remark, "I have not seen any woman suffering as much as the believing women. Look! Her skin is greener than her clothes!" as evidence of harsher practice. Inheritance gives sons twice daughters' share ( 4:11), reflecting support duties. Financial testimony equates two women to one man ( 2:282), linked to a hadith on women's mental deficiency (Sahih al-Bukhari 3:48:826). A hadith narrated by Abu Sa`id al-Khudri (أبو سعيد الخدري) reports Muhammad addressing women during an Eid prayer: "O women! Give alms, as I have seen that the majority of the dwellers of Hell-fire (an-Nār, النَّار) were you (women)." When questioned, he attributed this to women cursing frequently, being ungrateful to husbands, and deficiencies in intelligence (e.g., two women's testimony equaling one man's) and religion (e.g., exemptions from prayer and fasting during menses) (Sahih al-Bukhari 304). Hadith also prohibit women leading mixed prayers. Critics from feminist views see subjugation devaluing women. Defenders argue these promote stability by matching roles to biological and social differences in strength and dependency. Hadith further describe paradise (Jannah, جنة) for believers including enhanced sexual performance equivalent to the strength of one hundred men (Jami' at-Tirmidhi 2536), which some critiques highlight as reflecting male-centric eschatological imagery. A hadith in Sahih Muslim 510a reports Muhammad stating that prayer is invalidated by the passing of an ass, a woman, or a black dog if no barrier equivalent to a saddle-back is present, and identifies the black dog as a devil. This has been subject to modern critique for equating women with animals in contexts of ritual interruption and for implications regarding black dogs. A debated hadith on adult breastfeeding for mahram status (Sahih Muslim 1453a) describes an exceptional case with Salim, treated as a singular concession without generalization in classical scholarship. This raises questions in ethnographic and feminist analyses tied to broader gender debates.

References

  1. Dec 5, 2022 · 1403/1982) stated, “The Prophet had 40 scribes before the revelation of the Qur'an came to completion.” 236. The Shia scholar Abū ʿAbdullāh al- ...
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
Contribute something
User Avatar
No comments yet.